Submissions to the Napier City Council FREEDOM CAMPING BYLAW 2016
Submission numbers 101 - 197
101 Karrie Stephens 102 Katina Skepetais 103 David McKinnie 104 Robyn McKinnie 105 Kirstin Daly Taylor 106 Michael Taylor 107 Kyra Garrity 108 Philip and Leanne Brodie 109 Charlie and Margaret Lee 110 Mary Wise 111 Max Speakman 112 Bev Bates 113 Jan Roff 114 Malcolm Beets 115 Norma Beets 116 Peter Gay 117 Pene Wisdom Westshore RDA 118 David Plowman 119 Paul Harper 120 Hayley Powell 121 Robert Adams 122 Roger C Mosley Davcon Construction 123 Sharon Mackie 124 Stan Estcourt 125 Timothy Adams 126 Togia Lui-Fakaotimanava 127 Trevor Lilley 128 Valerie Norton 129 Warrick Smith 130 Warren Hack 131 Aaron Shuker 132 Andrew Robinson 133 Ann Mackie 134 Chelsea Henare 135 Daniel McKinnie 137 John Hart 138 Joy and Roger Forsyth 139 Kathy McQuade 140 Kelly Millea
141 Lloyd and Barbara Stokes 142 Lynne Tarplett 143 Margaret and Ivan Palleson 144 Rhys Putland 145 Richard Millea 146 Tamra Robinson 147 Trevor Mackie 148 Trudie Bosson 149 Vern Wilson 150 Georgia Harper 151 Denis Bosson 152 Vicki Skepetaris 153 Cathy MacDonald 154 Emma Beer 155 Fergus Brown Holiday Accommodation Parks Assn of NZ 156 Jason Trow 157 Jeremy Bayliss Westshore Beach Inn 158 Noel Roff 159 Graham Pedler 160 Wendy Pedler 161 Glenys Plowman 162 Robert Bird 163 Michelle Sayers 164 Richard Karn Westshore Residents & Development Association 165 Errol Lilley 166 Carmyn Shuker 167 Donna Smith 168 Linda Murray 169 Ray and Carol Seymour 170 Gary Stoneley All Points Camping Club of NZ 171 Craig Goodier 172 Dorothy Pilkington 173 James Imlach NZ Motor Caravan Association 174 Roger Wallis NZMCA Rally - Lower North Island Rally attendees 175 Roger Wallis NZMCA - HB area committee 176 Ron Carswell 177 Dennis Pilkington 178 Shaun Harvey NZ Transport Agency 179 Lisa Pohatu Hawkes Bay Housing Coalition 180 Kevin Gosling Westshore Residents and Development Association 181 Jeremy Bayliss 182 Petrina Denton 183 Jane Nicholls 184 Jeannette Cameron 185 Jelle Elzinga 186 Rob Kimble 187 Mark Thomas 188 Ann Bowes 189 Paul Laursen and Sandra Godfrey 190 Mark Brewer 191 Ken and Jo Nightingale 192 Andrew and Haley Price 193 Craig Daly 194 Elisabeth Beachen Quayside Residents Association 195 Jane Sutton 196 Mary O'Sullivan 197 Maria Van der Linden Quayside Apartments to{
A .
OrY COUNCiL Tel^"^a DMLfu. '
. . . . .I' Co CT . Y All submissions nlust be in writii19 You ITi, ,y attach a more detailed submission If yoii wish
Name: 1<'0. r r cc. *S+'F A OAJ Organisation:
Title/Position:
Postal address:
Daytime contact details:
I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick) Yes 7'610 If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time.
Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s), or i you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary
Ib ,^^.^, 141w "'t ,^,,^0, '~:I '*^IR^,'+ ^ *,*Iu\ +!^-yyo}ub ' ' ' "+ F ah " ^ a"'ru, ^ at, ,^I, r,C ^^",,,?I, furyvpi, \, ,,, ^:I a. .*'~ OUI USt 61. CLh61 CONCA IAI09 116Yt. g@ACI\ 1:10?{-. VVQI
111C Cea. ,.\ I^. I 1< A. A at cI\a kiln PI'~ IVtry flu. .,/y\ OCG@,,* C12aIOC ""'~ CMP A, I, T, \to c dye 61 k t A, ? +A 6L+ a re fi^, OLA I I woL, lid. Like. OAK. ^.><-?@of IT) 54.4_ fir'4 @. 61 0 rvL~ C 4.1v^^ I 1:1 pr o Iu ^^ 4< I IA r EQ IC^r*#74.1 4-7 e ^-.? Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Reti. In to: this form CPIus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council . You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission will be in duded in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public.
CICSl g date for submissions is 12pm, Friday 28 Octo^pr 2016
231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 f +6468357574 Doc ID: 30680\ WWW. napie, .amLnz e info @napier. govt. nz 10^
A .
coyCOUNqL Tel^"^a ochusfr, '
. .
. Do
All submissions nlust be In wi'It Ing You indy attach a more dotnil@d submission If you wi. ;h
Name: X^^;/^- 5^^'/^"/^S' Organisation:
Title/Position:
Postal address:
Daytime contact details:
I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick) Yes No
If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time.
Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s), or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. I .^',//^^^,'^,// I^c: ,;' on^ I, e, ,,^,,^ 12^,,,^,,,.^, ,,"' j. j.I S^;" ,-/;^..,-,"^-/;^..,-," ,>"^ 6^. I, ' '/,,/;',I,'le$,^, , , ,^,^^^, ,37 ,37 , c Of,^;^^',^of, """-""'A<;17'".""' 0 I"'4.1',^~~ '<1/7' f/; ,^I::' f::.. . I' j. I^,,, ,,, '^;,,, I, ,,;,, """"~";;,;? P'c?/;,,^^,./;',/ ,,, 115, ,,,., ,,, Submissions must be made either in writing. by way of Ret, Im to= this form CPIus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submission search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council . You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do not have to attend this meeting . Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public.
CICSl g date for subm, 5510ns is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016
231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +64683575, s f +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 WWW. nanie, .gnu. "z e info cornpier. govt. nz t^^
A .
dry ColiNOL Lib"demoAh"*,'
. 00 'e C' . . Do 00
All subm $5 ons nlust be in writing You niay attach a more detailed submission If You wigh
Name; Do. ^^*c\ \t\c\, ,,,,, ,,.. .
Organisation
Title/Position:
Postal address:
Daytime contact details
I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick) ^,, ,^:I;
If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time.
Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. \ s^*^^^.,,", ^\^e '^. 0^I, ^ - C . '0^\I. *^,^s p+^^*~!,^\^^^,!, -^^<6. ^^^.,',^ co^' ^ ' \::, A&^e. .,,* C),.^0^^ co*^ " ^ I \ ,,^^^.,*\c\ \^^^. \o s, ^. e, , . ,.,, 0\-.^0^, a^^ ^^^ tesc^e, ~*\*,*^ I 0.12. C^I^::^
Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Return to: this form (plus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govL. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a tim NAPIER 4142 You do not have to attend this meeting . Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public.
CICSl g date for subm, ssions is 12pm. Friday 28 October 2016
231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +646835 ,a, s f +6468357574 Doc ID: 30680\ WWW"ap, or. gout. "z e info. ariapier. govLnz to^--
A .
orY COUNCIL 76IC. ^ DAI, "in'
. . . 00 '
. Do A
All submissions must be In wiltii\g You in, ,y attach a more detailed submission If yon WISH
Name: ^0\.^\^ ,{\cj< \fir\ te. . Organisation:
Title/Position:
Postal address:
Daytime contact e ai s:
wis to speak at the hearing (please tick) Yes No
If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time.
Summary of Submission Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary.
\ ^...*^.^^^9, .', *^I-^,,. 9.0^I^ ^"': C. . B ^IQ^., I^, oY. *^^to. j ^';~<,<01o con^^^*,\ci, ,^-- ,,..,, ' 11' ' I \ ,,..,,_*\^\ \ \^e. . I^^ ,,,.. s:"'. , . ,^^^,^,^-,*'0 .\^, 1 *, ^e. s .cie. ,--,\*c^I CAI GoS I
Submissions must be made either in writing. by way of Return to: this form CPIus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council . You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 . You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public.
CICSl g date for submissions is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016
231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 f +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 WWW. ,, apie, .govL"z e info. ariapier. govLnz OS
A .
OrY couNOL 76 form^ OAh^'
. . o0 '
. 00 .. All Submissions rimst be in writing You 111.1y ,*ttactia 111<)re 01.1, ,1/@d submi. *5101, If will wish
Name: 1<, I, I, ^. 0 ^:-, j 72t-I03}-- Organisation:
Title/Position:
Postal address:
Daytime contact I
,
I wish to speak at the hearing CPIease tick): us INo
If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time.
Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. ' "' A1',^v+ ,I^.,, 2. ,I V I"'~"'~""' ^ t^, ^-Q, ^ I~""b*I j. J, .,, o0"I ^.~^o
Submissions must be made either in writing by wayof Ret. ,in to: this form CPIus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #free^ropingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public.
Closing date for ubm, 5510ns I 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016
231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 f +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 Up10, .900Lnz e info. d, napier. govLnz ^^b
A .
errv COLINciL 76 fun, ^eru DAI, urn'
. . o 00 e . . ,,
All submi:, 510n^ must be in writing You IT, ,, y attdcti a inure do. tulipd ,,,, bini, "5,101, If yoii \vi!, h
hame 1/4 I 6114'^;"C '7A, 't/o0'72 Organisation: I^... a A. --, 4.1 n. . I, Title/Position:
Postal address:
Daytime contact c
I wish to speak at the hearing CPIease tick) Yes o
If you wish to speak at the hearing. we will contact you to arrange a time.
Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if
you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. , 7 ^\~ ,'^'^-- "" I"dy", '^"";7 ^"" ~ I'I " "' "' I', Co, 69~,*, 0, ,'4*?^^ 4/6~ ,o. 6, /, yZ^, a^,^ ^,,,, , 1.1 ""4, . I'^!. ^.',-^c.^",~^C. . ,^,,, . of of A1 A1 A a-,*,6. ,.,, I- ,.^.. , A. ,,., ,/^"A A. I, ,..,,_,, '"""' c^I' 11""11, I" ' "' by^7^^,"7,. ,4, A, /-v~'^---,,,,<,,,7'"' C IP\ <3^^,
Submissions must be made either in writing bywayof Return to: this form (plus supporting documents if required). or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: titredomcampirigbylaw Napier City Coundl . You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission vrill be in duded in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public.
Closing date for subm, 5910ns Is ,2pm, Frid y 28 OCRober 20.6
231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 , +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 napio, .gout. "z e info@napier. govLnz ^^t"
A .
OrY CouNOL 76 K""dam o Mom'
. . . 00 '
. Do A
All submission nunst be in .Nutii19. You 111dy attach inure 1.1, *tied submission If will \vi!, h
Name: 13 A. A^,, a
Organisation: , 17 I, Title/Position:
Postal address:
Daytime contact details:
^ ^ ,>^ wish to speak at the hearing p ease tick): C. .,./ Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. . C^,I""""""""':^""' ' ,1'4 <:1:1,1''""~'~'''"'~I ^^--@^;.,~~;'A-^-^ ,. C, ' LCD' '"""""""""' ,^'^,"'."' '7""" I . ,^>/'^-Q"'^,^/^^^.,^^.. ^^:' ~^,^,^._. I ^ ,I^^?""" 49"{ ""0 ',""',,,,,, ';: ,-\ . <;11:2=? . . thisSubmissions form CPIus supporting must be documents made either if required), in writing or FREEposT bywayof 172273 Return Ize^0.3 to: 14? ,^,"'\ 06^;E> . online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freecomco, coingbylaw Napier City Conndl You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission will be in duded in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. ^~-,./ Closing date for subm, ssl@n is 12pm, Friday 28 OCRober 20's 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4nO t +6468357579 f +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 apio, .govLnz e infouinapier. govLnz ^0^ A . errv couNOL 76 ^"tiara Din"in' . . o0 . . Do All submiss ons must be in writing You IT, dy attach a 1114, re o1.1, ,lied ^,, binissioii If yini \vi. ,h Name: I6, ', IP ,---I, ,.-, A^. ^ ,-^ ^{*^... A I , Organisation: Title/Position: Postal address: Daytime eontact details: wish to speak at the hearing CPIease IC : es No If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or I you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. I^- 5' "I' ,?%,^ 2.0j6 (, A -^ ^ 16, ,,^, I^,^^,* 748^748^, Z^:"" ;'^:^! co^,,\ ;;,';""^i:,, ':;' ,U:^I;;-, "I"", '^:::!,"'/2;,^-^ '";;,?;:^/,,,/ of I ,^,,; ,t^,*);, I ,, Iru, . Submissions must be made either in writing, bywayof ReL, ,in to: this form CPIus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword#treado^, IPingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a tim NAPIER 4142 You do not have to attend this meeting Your submission vJill be in duded in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. CICSl g date for subm, sslons is 12pm, Frid y 28 Oatober 20.6 I^^^" 231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +6468s5 ,^,^ f +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 PIOr. coVL"Z e info. dinapier. govLnz to9 A . dry COUNCiL 16 for^ra o A1, urn' . . .. . u C, . Do All submissions nlust be in writii\g You may attach a more detailed submission If you wish Name; C;^,^2 , ,11" 1:1, ,36, Organisation: ^::? ~/t^ Title/Position: Postal address: Daytime contact details: I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick): Yes o If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission= Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if ,^!.-"*;^^;^ , ,, , ^!:-'^:,,,,., '^',^,;^;:: o"';. $"#,^ ' I ,^^-,I """' I^~ 'I '""" ' ' C:'^::',,,,,' C:,^,' ",^:> """"'^,"'~'i^',' ;^Z, . I'^21^v ' '' I1''"^;'i^" 1'1 "'^~ '77\, ^:^'I^^^'. C^.,^ Submissions must be made either in writing. by way of Return to: this form (plus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do riot have to attend this meeting , Your submission will be included in the agenda for the ,,,/, I ^,^.. meeting which is available to the public. I Closing date for submissions is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 f +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 un^napicrgovt"z e info ulnapier. govLnz 1/10 A . dry COUNciL 76 Jim^ ON, Win' . . . . . SI n of e 00 ' .t C nC, . Do C N All submiss ons nlust be 111 Nritii19 You in, ,y attach a more detailed submission If you wish Name: Organisation: ,^-:;;> '^'I *^* ,_ Title/Position: Postal address: Daytime contact details: wis to speak at the hearing (please tick) Y, , <,^3' If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if my, nn"**:hare:::'ng:an"*^;:;:;;;'^:^";;;j:;"""^*^+mm^^". ,,,,,,,,, ' ""'' ""~^~^' "" ' "; """" ^^^,: ' '~ "P, "::! ;:,"" of. ,,, "'I . ", ";'I^.-e,^., .^.^ .e,.e, - ', ,Q^-,^--,^~j^.,.,, Q^,~^--, v^....," I, I, ^ ^"' ^-,^-,^.^/^-,^-, ^,,^_, 7^-^/ 7^.,/ .>^A .>^A .>^:: ,^^.; ,^-^; " ,^;^,^,^;^.,, ,^^-,^ ^^I'^^I' ,,,,,, , ,,, Ss .. Submissions must be made either in writing. by way of Return to: this form CPIus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 in dude a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. CICSl g date for submissions Is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 , +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 w, ,". nap, or. 00.3"z e info ariapier. govtnz 111 A . errY couNOL 76I^alum ONnuiri o 00 * . Do All submissions rill, st be In writing You lift, y attach a ITiore di. trilled submission If will \vi!, h Name: Nick\ ':^I"'"' Organisation: Title/Position: Postal address Daytirne contact debits I wish to speak at the hearing CPIease tick): es No If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. I S, ,\.^100^I tv, ^_ ,^^:^11, I:;^'c:^..@0N*^ C-@,~, I:=^^^ , I'll? IQ, v ^16I^e^.,, ' :>I :I^ v, ::,.,.~, e^.., i^,^, IQ^,^ 1< FC}^^^--;I^c^-c^^,^^I^*^s c-, y YI^0, I^0, i^.,^IFc, , <9c. ^.,, , ^,^* Co, ,,,, IC, I \. 30.1\,^ \\Y^, \ o ^<,^ {'^ ^.,!0^ cctv^ip\ '~'S p ,0\--^ , \,>. '^e^I I ~^ ^ ,2>\,\c^^^^ ^\ C>\I ^.. 61 S ~ Submissions must be made either in writing, bywayof Return to: this form (plus supporting documents if required). or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampirigbylaw Napier City Council . You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do not have to attend this meeting Your submission vJill be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. Closing date for subm, sslo s is 12pm, Friday 28 October 20.6 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 f +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 PIO, .gouLnz e infodinapier. govLnz Inz OCT 20/6 A . coy COUNCiL Tel^,""a Danim' o0 ' Do All submissions nlust be in writii\g You in. *y attach a more detailed submission If yoii wish Name; I^"^v' ':^", 41^S Organisation: Title/Position: Postal address: Daytime contact details: ^ I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick): Yes I. If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. 11 I 61^. ';^^)16 I ^^'V . a2. .,,,. I ^,., 16'^.^/^ ^-/c Z:,^", I ^,^ ^,. I ^,^^", C^^4, , I'41^' , ^.^,. , ^, 6.2 I 6.1^^ I''"', "" ^/) */ Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Return to: this form CPIus supporting documents if required). or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a tim NAPIER 4142 You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. Closing date for submissions is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 Private Bag 6010. Napier 4142 f +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 WWW. napier. 900L"z e info. ariapier. govt. nz 141^ A . dry CollNOL Ib K, "^a o A1^' . . Do All subm ss ons must be In writii\g. You may attach a more detailed submission If yoii wi"h Name: '^;, "'^^. ^^^;' Organisation: Title/Position: Postal address: Daytime contact details: I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick) Yes No If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. I^^^\^~I^^~\-~""' ~ ~ 'I;^ "'._ I;^^^^ ^ 6"':~,,.,:.^,,,, I-,,,,.,! ^,^, G, c, *':.","',, ,, ,,. '~\,,.,*^":&.,~, ,,, ,\ \,>,,\, I,U*, ,, ,,. 11;;^,^%,,,,,*,''"' \^^A ',\ ,,,,~ C^^ ^^^j^-^ , ,,,.:!^,.,,,$:^-^;^..::.., ^,'. ^:'or, ^.,*e, 'A 04'0~ ' "'^ J^ " "' ''j""""' ' It;!:,'t.^;I:'^;'\^. :!";..^:^^-, I ::'^:;-, It: ':'~!^:I";^,,,.,-A04^,.I, .:In, .I j;:,, "~ -*^ Afi^,:::i, , ,,*,, j, ^-^-,^-- Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Return to: this form CPIus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govL. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a tim NAPIER 4142 You do not have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. CICSl g date for submissions is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +646835 ,=,:, f +6468357574 I Doc ID: 306801 winLnOpiC, .covL"z e info. @napier. govLnz 11'1A ^^... A . dry conNcjL 76 fontom DAI, "in' . SS, 00 . Do All submissions must be in wilting You indy attach a more detailed submission If You wish Name: in tel, boo \.. ^v^ 'B^ IE. . ^;::\":,. Organisation: Title/Position: Postal address: Daytime contact details: I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick) Yes KINo If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. I~ S \,,\ <, 196 t^c \I+I;^. 2.01C, F1Q. E. G---D owl <-Q. MY\^'INj '^;^'y ',^" 19 R. 0 *7- I !5 , '7~, rug \= R, S:^-^I '57 0 mm <. G\ I~A ^ \ \-\ Q, ^ ' L\> E:E;^' ^,, \\ 0 ^<_E^. 13<;:: e, , c. -V^, <;^. IE^._,;> E ^^* ,, E. V'V\ C-- '^\^:. e\t*^ 1'<:^. R. I^_ C\N O C. .ly'\<^, N ^ 0^.. s g, -T Not^:"C\^^-I;::I^,^\ O c__I^ e\ I\) ::^^f"(.\ <, 12\^ R*^^ ^.\^^,\c, '::^' ,00 &.\. L-'O I_\ ^\^:. ,; "O S ^:f^. 1:7^,(E:.. G^..^> o t*\ C, ^., *, ? ^ ^*\ ^:, ^"R. 0 \\ I 13,1'7I^10 *N f'^GE:. E^.{\)I^. I\)71f^\- ^'\~I^---^;:. f\S , Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Return to: this form (plus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govL. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbyla*v Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a tim NAPIER 4142 You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. Closing date for submissions is ,2pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hatings Street, Napier 4/10 , +646835 ,a, , f +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 un, .nap, @r. covL"z e info. ariapier. govLnz 115 A . OrY COLINciL 7616"", eru DAI, urn' . 00 ' . . Do 00 All submiss ons ntust be in wilting You ITiay attach a more detailed submission If yon wish Name; I\) o Q. ,v\ A (2>E. G. \ S Organisation: ..^ ~ Title/Position: Postal address: Daytime contact details: I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick): Yes 9.1qb If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. I^:: <;; 0 ? e@, 2. .'<'~ '^:"^^\^: ?.. Q *IQ ';""!Z. G. ^-. OCN, C. A Iv, P * ribG. ('^,^ ^_,'I-*,. 3 q (2.0 *,\. ^ {^,, \t ^ ,~> <^- '^""$2-GE. 0 ^, V\ CAIV^{'I A's Ca. At LA) ESt S ^*012-,^: C. \.!. pt-t's GE. S (;=, e. etc\.\ ^2_^. s e. cz. Q ,^:. N\ C. CG^,\^ Qf^*:a. ^=, F^.,*90 (>,-f I\, 0 \2. <^. I. :=. cz. ,\> oc-G_I^,- ,\a See^ CPI 12. .RF^CZ~\<~ , c L. ~^0^>.., I->. I. ..\\,, e. , 7.0 sei^::' F'{ase:oe, An <1, \ ,,*, ^ , ,,, q. ^ ^ 12.0\..^-. I=!> \ ~c a. Jo t r~, Re:. s * I> ^:,^r \ eii. ... I'Ita Gets Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Return to: this form (plus supporting documents if required). or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4.42 You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. Closing date for submissions is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +646835 ,a, , Private Bag 6010, Napier 4142 f +6468357574 Doc ID: 30680i WWW. nanie, .go"Lnz e info conapier. govLnz I^6 A . errYC^, NOL 76 fonder a a Mum' . . 00 ' . Do All submibsion, , rillist be in writing You 11, ay attach a inure dpi, ,lied ,, 1.1^missioii If yoti wit, h ,, am ,^:^.-., ^^;^./ Organisation: 1, ^'<2. -J^""' ^;^, v^ y^/ Title/Position: Postal address: Daytirne coatac wish to speak at the hearing p ease tick): es N, / If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. I Summary of Submission: I Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. . I e^^::'/0, ,^;2. ^11^:24^^;;^^-- ^C. .^..~ _7 I ,c:^ ,\ , I^;';^;/^^.*-,~- o<12. Submissions must be made either in writing bywayof Reti, in to= this form CPIus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword#freedomcornpirigbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a tim NAPIER 4142 You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission will be in duded in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. Closing date for subm, 5510ns Is ,2pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +646835 ,=,^ Private Bag 6010, Napier 4142 f +5468357574 Doc ID: 306801 ap, a, .govL"z e info@napier. govLnz ,, I ' I^.. A . Cm COLINCiL 7.1^^ CMufr, ' o0 . Do All submissions nlust be ill-^97^119 u indy attach a mole dPtailed submission If yon wish Name; Organisation: ^ 'O Title/Position: Postal address: Daytime contact details: I wish to speak at the hearing \I. ,, ease LICKJ: Yes ^;10 If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if " ;^.//;^I~ 77;, ,^Z I^, 61^,>,,.,,,, Cj, ,c?^:_ y'' I^';;;, ,, "'e, ,,,,,,*,,.,,. I 17),.. c ^^,,,,, . ,0.'>^C' ,_ 4'^";^"' ,"' , 1";";;;:^:";47',,,I'^^' 7^/^2 7^/^z A^,^;;'^^'6';^:.-\^;^, ~""A^,,^ine;^;::.^,^,^;^~/, ',,'i t;:J,*, ' ' '/91^6' 70, ,^>, I" -' , ' '~"',;,, Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Return to: this form (plus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. CIOsl g date for submissions is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 ^ . 231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 , +6468357579 , +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 WWW. napic, .gnuLnz e info on apier. govt. nz 14^ A . OrY COUNCiL 76 I^""herd o Mum' Do All submissions must be in Nriting You ni, *y attach a more detailed submission If you wish Name: :b A .^ 7> ?,. o NA\, C\,* I 'rganisation: Title/Position: Postal address: Postcode: Daytime contact details: Phone: Email: I I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick): Yes If. 10 If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. I ' ^{ j**,"' ,-!L^ 2-o10 ^""^-"-,'~\- C~--v * \ { Q^J ""'~",,,. '~"I ""^;Ie r\of, '~~'I~'!' (, s , -^,;, 61.IAI, ,,,,,,,0, -.'Y ,, t^,,..*!, : ' . ':!:j """' \ ^,, v"" ' ' (';:::::.,-_ ^' "' 1:1\\ ,.,_ ('~^.",*,,,^ C",~~?'~I ,~\-"^^-J* ^ (^\,',~^' this form CPIus supporting documents if required). or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. Closing date for submissions is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +646835 ,a, s , +6468357574 w. winapie, .00vk. "z e info. @nanier. govtnz Doc ID: 306801 1/9 A . errYCOLINOL 7b foul^am DAI. urn' . . 00 ' . Do All submissions rimst be ill ,NIItii\q You nit, y at Idc!I a inure dpi, ,i1@11 ,it, bini, ,s, on If you \vi:, h Name: ' 00" IC, ., 2-"' Organisation: Title/Position: Postal address: Daytime eontact details: I wish to speak at the hearing CPIease tick): es o If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. I ,, Submissions must be made either in writingI by wayof. Re*,, in to: this form CPIus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govLnz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keywordL#freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council . You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a tim NAPIER 4142 You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission vJill be in duded in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. CICSi g date for subm, sslens is ,2pm, Friday a October 2016 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 f +646 8357574 Doc ID: 306801 napi@,. goutnz e info. @napie, ;govLnz I^o A . errYcoui*aL 76 Km"",,~ DAI, witi . . 00 ' . Do . All submi%\ on. must be n ,NIItiiIQ You tidy atI'dI a more of. 1,111@d ^I, binis:, 10/11f you wish Name: ?^v\^ \ Organisation: a^1:3, \^^ Title/Position: Postal address: Daytirrie contact details: I wish to speak at the hearing ,I, .case LICKj: es No If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. \ S ^^OF6^ \\^ ^gjl^^ ^ < ^Q ^, Q^^ QQ, (,^^ \ ,\ q ,o ::^"'t;:^(^^::I^":^^,^ """"" """' Submissions must be made either in writing bywayof ReL, ,rin to: this form CPIus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword #frePclnmcon:pingbylaw Napier City council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a tim NAPIER 4142 You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission vJiil be in duded in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. Closing date for submissions is 12pm, Friday 28 Oatober 2016 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 t +646835 rs, s , +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 apio, .govt"z e infodinapier. govtnz A . . CITYCOUNCIL 76 Kuruiihera o Ahuriri o G SIO o All submissions must be in writing. You may attach a more detailed submission if Jou wish Name I^ - I, *-,,+- 61 o1 I". S' Organisation Title/Position: Postal address: Daytime contact details: I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick): Yes No If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arra a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s), or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. I $64 , off I. ^a '>. o1 +-/2,101a*. 6'6, ^,,, ,\ I, .,/ 11'0 ,"I I, ^ 11^,!"~ (',, v^ , h PI }' \, U'? ff'\^^^ 2, j, J^ 128'9<7j/e. C ID^/'k ,I ^, I C 'I",*, r$ @\+ I, "011^ t/,, O 24, ,, 5 4161 lit. . ' ',,'," 41 I 1<^ +0 8, z Ile^46~, 101 ,. L. I I'. re, ., ^ Ie, I '~\ yes GII, ,1:01 o1,841S Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Return to: this form (plus supporti g documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a tim NAPIER 4142 You do not have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. dosing date for submissions is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 f +6468357574 WWW.Private napiO, Bag .govt. 6010. nz Napier 414' I e info@napier. govt. nz Doc ID: 306801 ^'Z^--- A . errv couNOL Ib bridero o Mum' . . 00 ' . Do All submissions rill, st be in writing You IT, dy attach a Inure o1.1, ,lied ,,., binissioiiif you wish, Name:am, IY\(^. I^0(*612. . < "AllQiCe-1 or^am^atto". 01<\/OA) Coy\,. Tl^.,\CT\ 0, ^ ^. Title/Position: I^I , Postal address: Daytime eontact d wish to spea a ne nearing p ease tick): es o If you wish to speak at the hearing. we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. 11. . ;U ^,^, ,",~~ +'I'Q. ^..*^I '^ ^"','^^-(I O^,^,, Co*^,^, 11^ V9 by ^ O VV ? ^:^ I^ i\^ I\ ^^^ {"^^..^01 ^ ,"^ CGI ,^^ p' ^ V^^ or\ V*, C'^13 A ^~"^Q ^.-^0, ^^\,'^ " S^,, 'V"" I 1" 'C I9"C\ I^ 1" '~" "' NO '""' ", ' C^,.,, '~, 5'100, Co I 17 0( ^~ I^,, ^_. \,-^t)^..\I d I ^,^. ^ I^^ I^^^,^ee. .. o1 0^. Co ,*, 11, ^* I^^ p ^:.>v A, I\.^^ , v* ,^e, $ Tcl^^\ ^, I o1 ,^2.05 . Ret, Irn to= . Submissions must be made either in writing; bywayof. FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword #freed rimcamp. ingbylaw Napier City Council . You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a tim NAPIER 4142 You do riot have to attend this meeting . Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. Closing date for subm, 5510ns 18 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 f +6468357574 Private Bag 6010,1.1apier 4142 Doc ID: 30680i pier gnu*. nz e info. dnapier. govLnz 11^ A . dry cor, NQL 76 fun^DAI, ,"fri . . o0 , . Do All submissions rillist be ill NritiiIq. You 171.1y attocti a In ore out, jihad ,,,, bini:. 5101i If yoii \vi. ,F Name: 6 I, '^\ r6"' VV\ o Ok_I <3. - Organisation: Title/Position: Postal address: Daytime contact details: I wish to speak at the hearing If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if i':^^;^I:^^'^1't:^.":^^',^:*^::;^,";Y^on;^;:,::;;*j^"*""'I;::;'^'i^>+-, 1.10^+I^I I^~"',^I,{^"6:36^I. , ^, to"'^;"^, c o ", PI, 0^ ^! 0^+-,wit, we.!;^,::;;, s\SVC/e. g'' , ,,,,.... :^ eO^0^:1,71, ^,,^, ,,, I"I, A. ^^ . '. Ijoy \,., 0^*Id I'I^I^e. "" ,. +0 {'^6.1<^^63. {^'eta^:!ore in c^.,^pi^^ ^ ladiyo^^I, ^-lad I in 186-1cleYjho I oreo. s . Submissions must be made either in writing. by way of Ret, ,rn to: this form (plus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPiER 4142 You do not have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the ager^a for the meeting which is available to the public. CICSi g date for submissions is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 f +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 or. gnuL"a e Info. @napi@r. govLnz ^^Z, ^ 2 0 OCT 20 6 A . errYCOLINOL fo I^,^ra o Mum' . o0 . uc . . Do . All submiss ons ntust be In writii19 You indy attach a more dotail@d submission If yoi, wi ,h Name: '1:>+A \.", ^;:. S+ LA t+ Organisation: Title/Position: Postal address: Daytime contact details: I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick): Yes No If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). o you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. ""'I';::1'1^:*;in "::IY^:*;, ' ''on'Y^q' ' """"'^ \J, am IIJ, 1:1, Gomit*, "~:*,,^,_^,^,,',,, ^-*;I Iwit'f!*^^;. byw Cam, 'am!*^,^, ,^*,I, :^litlit ,,,, ^^^.^J-^ ^mm ^,_,',,,,.,,,, ,,, "", :;,^^""~ '* , * "' ' "11^:I0 .^;-^,-- ^ ^XI^ ,, c_.*\^. I ,*!^^,\ '--'\; ^^;: ^" ' " ^!I I^~,*^^I:;~\ ^...,,,, I^A^^-' ^ c^,^v, ^,'.- ^;^^ ^ ,^" byC_. '_~I'co-Y^, by 11:' P~^, C}"^!:" ^I - Ivi^ ^^ ^dI ' ,ll*!I,* ^:)! N. ^^:tit, ^-cat. .,,^^~tat ^^I''l;::-;~}^;11, , ^.^ ^,-*,^,^! ,I ,**:if-^^^ I^^, ^Q^,^^_ t ^Q ^-^^- Submissions must be made either in writing. by way of Return to: this form CPIus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council By!aw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council . You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 in dude a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. Closing date for submissions is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 f +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 WWW. napic, .co, Lnz e info ariapier. govLnz I^s A . CITYCOUNCIL 76 Koujihera o Ahurirt .I o'0 ' All submissions must be in writing. You may attach a more detailed submission if IOU wish. Name: Tjj"\ ant! Organisation: Title/Position: Postal address: Daytime contact details: I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick): Yes o If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s), you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. Z's I+ 4-1...... CG. I^ ^, I do \\, C. ^.. @.+ B caO I, or V4- 110 Parl^ A. ^11. C n O\),.- o1+herv\ O S U\ k. .:t. . I*\,. Sec ^', c^!ooh. Co. . bit \ I\ 11, -,^16 Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Return to: this form (plus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submission search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Counc'I You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do not have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meet'rig which is available to the public Closing date for submissions is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 f +6468357574 WWW.Private "apier. Bag govt. 6010. nz Napier 41'' I e info@napier. govt. nz Doc ID: 306801 12^ A . errYcouNciL Ib fun"ham DAI, "in' . . . s tte. o0.'e Ou c, . O A PI All submissions nlust be in writing You indy attach a mole detailed submissioii If yon wi, ;h Name; ^,'\^. '^'OC. -^-,'\ \. L^^.~ ^"'?.\ Title/Position: Postal address: Daytime contact details: I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick) Yes IN. If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s), or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. "' ""^, eoc\" \\^^. ?, 016 F"^^. e, ^, w^ Cow^^\A, ^, 'I\,^^", ^^,^\ Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Return to: this form (plus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govL. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do not have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. Closing date for subm, sslons Is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +646835 ,a, , Private Bag 6010, Napier 4142 , +6468357574 Doc ID: 30680i WWW. nap, @,. coULnZ e info @napier. govLnz 11^^ A . errYcot!NOL 76 Kan^ DAI, "tr, ' , . o0 . . Do . All submissions nlust bP n writii19 You IT. .*y attach a inure di. I'm@11 ,, uhmiss, o11 If VCIii \vi, ,h Name: <7^ty A^ Organisation: Title/Position: ,.,, ,,+. V'^6'^^ A, , Postal address: Daytirrre eontact details: I wish to speak at the hearing If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission= Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if 13"*\';';*I%'^;^:*\;;I^A, *.,, I'ofI^^I ,*^^/... ^^'' """~ ,--.^,^~,*,. ( ^!c^___.( ^! L.Ql+ ,L. -^^^---^^--^ ,^^.' ^_^^_ 0, ,^^,^^,,, ^^-^^^^^_ Q^Q "\""~,^.,,? C"I', ,j;^,:14< ,*, I^,,~"" I ,.<' o, Y^ O, ".- PC^^0^It, {^ Q- Submissions must be made either in writing bywayof Ret, ,in to: this form (plus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword#freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. Closing date for subm, sslons is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 t +646835 ra, s f +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 apio, .gout"z e infodinapier. govtnz {,^8 A . dry couNciL Tel^""jam DAI, urn' . . b o 00 , g . Do . All submissions must be in writing. You may attach a more detailed submission if yoi, wish Name; U' 16-11-<1 11^/^ 11n AI 11 Organisation: Title/Position: Postal address: Daytime contact details: I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick): Yes o If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s), o you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. 17n^:,%"4*'~"""""12^^';,,I^;'j:,,,:;%/""4^;--;^*'it;. ;^ ^ ' ''"""'% ,,-/:^^, <1 ,,,.^:;:"^...?^,,.,, ,, I"" 74^I,I"' I' "' , ^";, I ,,A^;##;*.*{..,I_,./,^,-^,/#' 1/, 1^by/'%' 19 .L^^- 4^,,^/,^-/^ ,4^,,^/,9^.^^ "' """""" ^-^,^I^--/^;^/;'/^-,'^-^-^I^"/'!;;t ' ' """"~ Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Return to: this form CPIus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. CIOslng date for ubm, 5510ns Is 12pm, Frida 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 , +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 WWW. napiCr coVL"Z e info @napier. govt. nz I9 Oar 20/6 A . dryco!. INOL T , . o0 . . Do . All submissions must be ill writing You lit, y attdc, I a In ore dot, Iil@tl ^I'llmissioi, if you wnh Name I, ^I I'^ I^.. I^. I C 1< Sly'^ I~T H Organisation Title/Position: Postal address Daytime contact details I wish to speak at the hearing CPIease tick) Yes ^./ If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time Sum", ary of Submission= Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary I ^>UPf"01<'i~ 71.1e. 2.0 16 FiZ. 6:. t^^0^)NI Of^{Ylf'11^ G I^,^4I_.^^I\\ PI^. OHi^3^} 711^\Q, F(^.. 6. .^., D O or\ CFiMPl, \I G^ I^^^' 0:6S. 75 ^IC>I^.^:. ^, 5.1^10-1 11^. 6S^iZ. .oe. , I IQC. S O I^^E. c IE:0<^. F^, SE. Do iV\ CF\ J\'I 96.12, s O I^, C f:\ {Yi P I I\! G, O F F^ N L-} 1< I *.\ 0 S H o t. > L. - 11^^ 1358 PR. 01.1 I G, ITE. .D I I\! I^ CG U1'^I^^. I^I\! 12.65I 06. I, ^T11.1L 1.1 1:2. ef; S Submissions must be made either in writing. by way of RetL, in to: this form CPIus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Cound! Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 in dude a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do not have to attend this meeting Your submission vJill be included in the ager^a for the meeting which is available to the public CICSlng te for ubm, 5510ns is 12pm, Frida 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 per. gout"z e info@napier. govLnz Doc ID: 306801 ,\< IF. .! f\I>01Ti^> r^ 70 Ti~Ie I:\I^,, o0<:. Summ A1^..'1 ill' (^><>0^, 0 I::\ <. 50 L_11<^E. To 1<1\jou>. I::..> A . errYcoliNOL 76 hmma DML, fit . . 00 ' . Do , All submib!, Ions must be in writing You IT, ,, y attach a limit',, dpi, ,ileti SI, bin!$5,011 If You \, 11!, h Name: nat, , I)^.,,,, ^//,/ c, ^- Organisation: Title/Position: Postal address Daytime contact details Pho Cine I wish to speak at the hearing CPIease tick): Yes No If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if ~71Z"s'^^; 14 -/ 161^; 1:' ;^;I'- ,-^9^-,- "^."',^.. s, I^~,, In^^ I-^,:,?---c ,,/; ,c ;^:@ s ^ :/^^~e^, . Submissions must be made either in writing. bywayof Return to: this form Closing date for subm, 5510ns Is 12pm, Friday 28 OCRober 2016 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 f +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 PIO, .gout"Z e info. ulnapier. govLnz I^{ I9 0e 2016 A . dryc^, NOL 76K^, era DML"in . . . 00 ^ . Do A All submissions lint, st be in writiiIq You Irk, y attoc, I a in o1'0 uphill@ri hullmi^, 10/1 If yoii wi. ;t, Name: Organisation: 61^""!!I;I^I'-11^,., Title/Position: Postal address: Daytime contact details: WIS o speak at the hearing (please IC es o If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if I + I^I^I ^ , Submissions must be made either in writing. by way of Rerun to= this form CICSl date for submissions is 12pm, Friday 28 October 20.6 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 f +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 , gout. "z e info. @napier. govLnz 132- A . dry COUNCjL 76 furthera DAI, urn' 00 ' C Do 6 All submissions nlust be in wt'It 11/9 You nit*y attach a more detailed submission If yoii wigh I Name; 4A/0^CLI I^^81^5@, V Organisation: Title/Position: Postal address: Daytime contact details: I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick) Yes ^<8, , If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission= Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. I $0, PP@/ar 71.1, 2016 ,^"'feeoo, ,, I C, 4^//PC, 8,104, ,, 1'20/1/317iA/C; I'llZE'6,017 C, 4, ,-1/1,0< 11- Grey7f//o126 ^;"6.4C// 1265Ei^2u6, 12-,"/ '^^4, u I^^,{.!< ,^;' Ch';^VCC5 47 11,107Z. 7H6, Z, (! O '61/12 $134 61/12 124 { at' I 41,901 CD Z_i 1< 6 72, - 16^ 17^^'6t^914 6,444I',;U4 11^<0 at 81 rea , It;'6'5 , DCA, ^'inc ^-,(-- Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Return to: this form CPIus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a tim NAPIER 4142 You do not have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. CICSl"g date for submissions is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +646835 ,a, , , +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 WWWnapie, .govr"z e info. @napiergovLnz 13^ A . dry COUNciL Tel^""kiri DAI, win' Do All submiss ons must be n wiltiiIg You nidy attach a more detailed submission If you wi, h Name: I~ 4\ r\ f'\ 0. <^k. :I G~ Organisation: Title/Position: Postal address: Daytime contact details: I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick) Yes No If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s), or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. ~^:- s, .,,,,,^- +!-^., 201t, , F1"^.<, 10"*, C:0. ,,, p;fj:! ID, 11Q, ,^ ?*",.., b^ +,'*:; \",^. ao, A c, Q. ,rip, ,,, 0\' ^-*>^,^! ^!-^,^, '^;^^,.,*-*'^^s. ^,",^,., i'^ ~,. e^A'i'^..* ^.~I <..,~a. ~ .as c. \ I\>Of 11\err, 0 Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Return to: this form CPIus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. Closing date for submissions Is 12pm, Frida 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 f +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 WWWnap, @, 90.3"z e info conapier. govLnz OG 06 ^^.., A . dry CdiNCiL Ib Kan"hem o thrum' o .. , . Do All submiss ons nlust be in writing You may attach a more detailed submissioi, If you wish Name; CLV\!z. . tS ^i-""~ Organisation: Title/Position: Postal address: Postcode: Daytime contact details: I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick): Yes No If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. I; ^^.-^^if^'^^:I^I. .\e::I;:^, C;by, , ,, to, '""''"^;itI.C^>t, V\C^_. Q ."'^:!^A o. 1'*Q. .. . . C:,,^.;?,'j;^,_.',^;!^. C, }~ C -\~,\IV^!CL. o1.1'^"^^CIO, ' <22^o1^,.^::^. ^.-^ <:20^, I , VIPl. :I I^). . co slot^:!^ toe . "p of@ OV\ s, ' ,,,' ^^-~eQ^^.I ^^,, to, . ,^::^^,,,^:',;Ier, ::^::;;^.; ,,,.,, to, ' this form CPIus supporting documents if required). or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a tim NAPIER 4142 You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. Closing date for submissions Is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 , +6468357574 WWWnopic, .gout"z e info conapier. govLnz Doc ID: 306801 , ^g, A . dry ConNQL Tel^^ON, Win' . 00 All submiss ons niust be in writing You may attach a more detailed submissioi, If You wi^h Name; ^TI I Gt NICjc_\j\I N I"' Organisation: Title/Position: Postal address: Daytime contact details: I wish to speak at the hearing CPIease tick): Yes I, . If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission= Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. I 5,199:,^I^T fH6 Z. 016 Fee600!\'\ Ci^melt^ic 13^OILi\I\) f'^o1/16m!\IC\ I' ^. 6eOOM Cam RINDC. j^'i~ v^)61ST~SHOt^61 8.61'^ctl i'-I^56^VC, NICL6v\I\) f"^I^IC AllO C\\)NG, 6:5, A, r A10t<.f^) Oc^ci .S C^ Ct\^^'^^1< , I IAIo. ic0 o1\CG To .s^;'6 PiZ-^;-600AA Ct\WIPii\)Q \'^>\. Ills, IT60 11\) \^ 6.5^\ 061\iT I^'IC {'it^-^'1'15 Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Return to: this form CPIus supporting documents if required). or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govL. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a tim NAPIER 4142 You do not have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. CICSl g date for subm, sslons is 12pm, Frida 28 October 20.6 231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 , +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 won, nanie, gnur. "z e info ariapier. govLnz I^^ A . . CITYCOUNCIL 7^ Kounihera o Ahuriri . . . . . 00 . . . . . Do A . A 00 All ubmissions must b. in writing You may atta h a more detailed ubmi ion if you wish Name 0'01\I\ kfQI, Organisation: Title/Position: Postal address: I postcode I~~r'- Daytime contact details: Phone: Email I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick): Yes If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision - ^^I Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Return to: this form (plus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council By law Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do not have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. Closing date for submissions is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 f +6468357574 WWW. napier. govt. nz e info@napier. govt. nz Doc ID: 306801 ,. . A . errYcoliNOL 76 Kan^a 6th"in' . . . SI .. . . Do All submissions must be in writing You may attach a mole demil@d submission If yon wish Name; Organisation: ' 0{,,, ,,, ,,,, I '\;:z-^;'j"' Title/Position: Postal address: Daytime contact details: I wish to speak at the hearing CPIease tick): Yes No If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or i you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet i necessary. <>^<, 0\^^I^ ^,^. 0< {^e. . ^ "' <''^8.6*^^Q)^^^\ *e, I C\ (2<, 015;=.. ^*,,*;:;::;::^^'; ,,,, e- ':1' ,,,,,,: 0 ";\, ,,... ,.,,{.,,,.=. ';:2, :1:1 <^,,., "^ ;z_,,...,,,e, ,^,, V \ a_v^:>.,,, '^;^.**,., \.^{., ofz. q- <7^^ ^::::^^..,_.,, '^::^ - L^>*^^^^^ I O':> ^; Submissions must be made either in writing. by way of Return to: this form CPIus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council . You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 in dude a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do not have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. Closing date for submissions I 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +646835 ,a, , f +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 WWW. napie, govL"z e info On apier. govLnz I^9 A . errY couNOL 76 fun, had Darnam, ' . o0 ' . 00 All submibsicn\ must be in writing You IT. ,*y attach a 11,010 dpi, ,lied ,,,, hintssioii If you \vi. ,h "^am \<'c^.\\\ '~' "":::)^~q^""- I Organisatjor, Postal addre Daytime con I wish to speak at the hearing CPIease tick): Yes No If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate cle rly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state yo r reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. I ~,,* \0, ^ :^,,._. \, ^,,,, _ I^*'::;,,, C^ co ^C^'I ^,^*0\^\\^;\ ^^^. a^ ; ,\ ^2. *^^^.^^^\-^^~'^^ \ 0*^ Q , ^..^^. ^,,.. . I ^:;:^\\ s^^^,,^.*,,^,!'*^ -\\-,,._ 2. .c^I^^^, ^^;^^c^^,^-^^ C^^^,(\., \, *,, \,~ Submissions must be made either in writing byway of RetL, in to: this form CPIus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword #freedomcon:pingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission will be in duded in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. Closing date for subm, 5510ns Is 12pm. Friday 28 OCRober 20.6 231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 f +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 WWWnOpio, .gout"z e info. @napier. govLnz ^+^ 27 OCT 20/6 API . CITYCOUNCIL I^ Kounihero o Ahurin . . . . 00 ' . . . . Do A . . . All submis ions inu t be in writing You in a atta h a in or d tailed submi SIon if you wi h Name: 1 Title/Position: Postal address: Postcode Daytime contact details: Phone Email: I wish to speak at the hearing CPIease tick): Yes Ii^. If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision - Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Return to: this form (plus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City COLIncil By law Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You Inay speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do not have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public Closing date for submissions is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 f +6468357574 WWW. napier. govt. nz e info@napier. govt. nz Doc ID: 306801 ^^'I A . errYCOLINCL 76 fondua DAI, urn' o 00 ' . Do All submis, - on^ must be in .Nuking You ri, ay at tacti a Inure chit, tiled *, ubmiss, o11 If yoii \, 11, ;h Name: A joy of ^ I^ 0-,,' I, byQ. S. +o 1 Title/Position: Postal address: Daytime eontact details: I wish to speak at the hearing CPIease IC es N0 1' If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. . IN^'^., Calc O~ a^ 0. ,;^^S'{ C, ^ *I' ';\. ' CICSl g date for subm, 5510ns is 12pm, Friday 28 OCRober 2016 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4nO t +646835 ra, s f +6468357574 Doc ID: 30680\ WWW. nap, @,. govr"z e info. of napier. govLnz I^z. A . dry COLINOL 7b for^ o Must, ' o . o0 , . Do All subm 5510/1s must be in writing You n, ,, y attdc, I, , inure dpi, *ilc-d submissioiiif yoii \vi. ,h by' ' Y^^^ ' I^ ^* '^ 16 11"" Organisation: Title/Position: Postal address Daytime eontai I wish to speak at the hearing CPIease tick): Yes N If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet f necessary. I-I' ,,,,,,,,',,,',,""' ,,, I-- \,,,, +I^^ I ;:.;!^o, * ,,,I, rip'I, " 'II '"" ' ""'^:""', I, ^ ' ;":^ ,, ^,,,J, ,,I, 1.1 I, ~^I , Ite-O o """,^^ ^, I' C,I "^ ,_ , ,, '~-tit;;/ 'J^::;, r ' '\ I)*I, /' Submissions must be made either in writing bywayof Realm to= this form CPIus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword#freedomcornpingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do not have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. CIOsi date for subm, ssi@ne Is 12pm, Frid y 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 Private Bag 6010. Napier 4142 f +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 PI ,. 900LnZ e info. @napier. govLnz If^ A . errYcouNOL 7.1^"^a DML"in' . 00 ' . Do All submissicrIs must be In writing You nit, y attach a inc, re chit, ,ite, d ^L, bini, ,5101, If you \vi!, h Name: ,*,?\ - f', c IQ o ,, Organisation: Title/Position: Postal address: Daytime eontact details: Email: wish to speak at the hearing CPIease tic es No If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission Please identify what your Issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. ~"' "'~'/;^ ,71^/ V'<._*, ^. ^* I^ ;^'~^_A^C, ,,** ^.. ,,..,,,/;^*, ^,,., ,<, by, Q pH^I~,IZ. c,/^.,,^ "', I',\:,, '""'^:-""'..,^'**-. *' ' j~.~/""', C, ,\-.,/..,., a, ,"j" '^,'.^. ' " ^Y '^:' ' ^. "'~r, ^~ ^:. ''4, 64.4, {^.*-sI, ^;;S-*;,<" ,!:._ -4*-* 4.11. t- 4-<, 5.0^C. ,-,, v{: ,< Q, ' ^ Submissions must be made either in writing bywayof Ret. ,rin to= this form CPIus supporting documents if required). or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword #freecomcampingbylaw Napier City Coundl You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission vJill be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public, I, ,04" '~ CICSlng date for ubm, sslo s is 12pm, Frid y 28 OCRober 2016 ^:?., <:' . I':;:,-6<. C. ^,--*-.^ 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 t +6468357S79 f +6468357574 Doc ID: 30680T PIO, .goutnZ e infodnapier. govtnz ^^^( A . errYcoLiNOL ^ 16N, ^ DAI, urn' . . U SS, Do ,,,,,,,,*~^";~\;j~~,,Organisation: Title/Position: Postal address: Daytime contact details: I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick): Yes No If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission= ;^"*;;;::;;^;,,;---^^^^-^^/^,%:'"';^^;,;^-^^;'\^4 I^',,,-^'^"'^ I^;^,/^,^ ^;..,,,,,,,,',,,,,, ,, ^: ,, ,,/ 12^,,,,/ ,,,,,,, , . ,,,,,,,- ---- '-~ ^;;""'},,-, i;,^,^,?/ Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Return to: this form CPIus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a tim NAPIER 4142 You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. Closing date for submissions is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +646835 Jars , +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 WWWnO"Or gout. nZ e Info ariapier. govt. nz N, .I . CITYCOUNCIL 76 Kaunihero o Ahurin ...... . . . Do A . A 00 All ubmissions inu t be in writ!rig You may attach a more detailed ubmi SIon If uw h Name: I^. I CV\0101 in I I Ie. .q Organisation: Title/Position: Postal address: Postcode: Daytime contact details: Phone Email I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick): Yes o If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Return to: this form (plus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council By law Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to ari'ange a time NAPIER 4142 You do not have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. Closing date for submissions is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 f +6468357574 WWW. napier. govt. nz e info@napier. govt. nz Doc ID: 306801 ^+b A . dry COUNcjL Ib budaa o Mom. ' . . . SIO ' . o1. C' C Do , .. All submissions nlust be In writii\g You may attach a more detailed submissioi, If yon wish Name; fH/!{Z7{ " """ Organisation: Title/Position: Postal address: Daytime contact details: I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick) Yes No If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if . Its , ,I ,.,,_(!,I ^,,-(!, ,/-.'I" 61' 61- ^;:)~ 1''an'toha;"";'I, ,;' I ,,,_(!,, gad;,,,,.,,, on, ,/,--I .,,,,,,,,, arat, ,1-^ ,,,, ,, ~ .. A ^.^, 11 ^ . ^ . ,. f" <1\ or Submissions must be made either in writing. by way of Return to: this form CPIus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. CICSl g date for submissions is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 t +646835 ,a, , f +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 WWW. napie, .govL"z e info cinepiergovLnz I^^" A . dry COUNCjL Tel^""kern ochusfr, ' . . o0 ' . I . Do 00 All submiss ons must be 111 Nritii19 You indy attach a in or'e datail@d submissio, , If yoii wi, ,h Name; fife 70 I I'/'Q c// G. ' Organisation: Title/Position: Postal address: Daytime contact e an s I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick) Yes INo If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission= Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. ^. 5/4/'14-/ 7'1^2 ;221^' freed"@,^ COM1, ,-?I by/q&v. ' I;, o1.16,11n, ^, 14.2 e of'd, ,,? C Q "?I@/14.7 q I Ile 61:5 I@I I^'e' Q' C. I, If'eS G, ~ 11C: , 11';<1e^,, I^"/ ^,,^"' <1^" ^, e^ q, " IU;, All@,,, C;', Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Return to: this form CPIus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govL. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a tim NAPIER 4142 You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. CICSl"g date for submissions is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +646835 ,a, s f +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 WWWnOplC, goVLnZ e info, @napier. govtnz .o ^ A . dry COLINciL 7b balun DAI, win' . 00 . Do . All submissions must be in wilting Yuu may ,, tmc!I a more upt, *lien funmi, ;:, 10/1 If yoii with Name: IPI. vi^>IC' '^./:~?:SSL, ,}~) Organisation: Title/Position: Postal address: Daytime contact details I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick): If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. I s, -*^()^^\ +I^... ^^^6 F1-^,!d^^ c. ^*-^0^'^,^ I, yl^,^^ (,^--'::I^I^,'":^ ^;-^.,!.^^ coy^^,?^h. ^, ^\ COQ. s\ ^.--.^,-<... 15^,^^^ (Z^s^z^L, <..., Ad. -^..,,,^ (?a^.-,, ,^h, ). cy^,^*"^^s ^\ ^)or^V^. r^ 0, ^,,^^ <;;^?,^ Co, ~^^,^^"C^, I ",^,,^.,,^,\ In^^ ^ s^,-^-. Q, -^^.^!0, ^-^ c. ^.",,, 9^',^,^ ^y^V^;^t\^,^ ,' A I. e. 's, I v\\;#\^ o v<.. 0\'^,, . Submissions must be made either in writing. by way of Return to: this form (plus supporting documents if required). or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council . You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do not have to attend this meeting . Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public Closing date for subm, salons is 12pm, Frid y 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 f +64 G 8357574 Doc ID: 306801 amieLgO"t. nz e info. @1napier. govLnz I+9 A . CITY COLINCIL foI^^ DAI, urn' Do All submissions nlust be in writing You may attach a more detailed submission If You wish Name; ^^AN tA// I. . ,$ 011 Organisation: Title/Position: Postal address: Daytime contact details: I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick): Yes o If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. 41',.,,^::,I^^..^/.,,4,;^142;^;^/-^ ^-^;/;,/y, ^ . 41-7,17^^,,^^ ,,,,,. ^^-^I, ,,,^^ 11/1, I^^^^//:^'^^"^:;^'/ I^^',,,, ;ty,^, ,^.,.. 2'j"^:;^^/,,,,-I:.^;fy,:^;,,,^#^:,,-^;,* , ,,,---,,^, 12^;,,^,^ '1:4 ,;;''""^^//^^"'^101 by of 1:11^ ,^, z^,,, I, ^;^""'t^. I ^ ^ I^. ^,,,;(^,,;( ,,,,.,,,,' ^""' Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Return to: this form (plus supporting documents if required). or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. Closing date for subm, sslons Is ,2pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 f +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 win, napie, .gnuL"z e info ulnapier. govLnz I^(' ON^ ^;^ A . . CITYCOUNCiL 76 Kuruiihera o Ahoyiri All submissions must be in writing. You may attach a more detailed submission if IOU wish. Name: , Or , , 01. orcQ, ,/ Organisation . Title/Position: Postal address Daytime contact details: I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick): Yes No If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to a ge a time Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s), or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. Q, . I. 2. . I , ," 'W\ In I^,., . . . ., T' . ,, , .I. .., .. f. I\ . , ,, I^^, o. 0 .. . ,,! Of f C o\ Cor 10., <.. , , . ., 0.1 A. A +O . ',, Do, . in In to , . e. c, ., \,. . o Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Return to: this form (plus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council By aw Review Submission search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Counc'I You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a tim NAPIER 4142 You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public elosing date for submissions is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 f +6468357574 WWW.Private napie, Bag .govt. 6010. nz Napier 41'' I e info@napier. govt. nz Doc ID: 306801 1<^^ A . dry COLINciL Tab"^a QinW*,' . o0 ' . . Do . All submissions in11st be in ,NIItiiig You IT, ,, y attach ,. morn dPt, *lied submission if yoi, \vi^h Name: O G~ ^ S^ C;^^, o SE^.^5. <> Organisation: Title/Position: Postal address: Daytime contact details I wish to speak at the hearing CPIease tick) Yes o If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will con you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission= Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. I ^.,^~ T~^16 20\(=, ^:'^I <:9^(^;>\^^.* ^^,^,)/*,\^-> , \\\^^, CC\,~'C. ^"'^lee^I C, ^~\?\I^^.. elf \.^.>^^.^\~102^, ^^^<.^\ ^.^. S^,^.\_Ie, \-t C^,\^ ?CFz^. ^._ c. 1.1^IC, G, :^^ err \~^^'^--!^..> o<^,CS^ ^:^^\^- C*^,^r^ , > \-,-'~ \^> I *^.. e. ^""c^ ^:^,--- ^"^.^^.DCDc, * ce, ^\, I=^I, \^C, 92. c^\\^^:I^.T^:;^> It\,> ^.^, S. \<'^G.,\. T\F'\\ ,=\(ZE. ^I^>, , Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Return to= this form CPIus supporting documents if required). or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council . You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 . You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. CICSl g date for submissions is 12pm, Frid y 28 October 20.6 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 t +6468357S79 f +6468357574 onto. goutnz e info a napier. govLnz Doc ID: 306801 I^ Is 2, A . errYCOLINOL 16 I^^ oar, ^' . . 00 ' o . . A . Do . . . All submiss ns nlust be n Nritii19 You may attach a more detailed ubmiss o1, If you wi h Name; \! c. ,**^^ ^:,,,.,,^.^-*^.-^"""'"""' Organisation: Title/Position: Postal address: tcode: Daytime contact details: Phon, Email I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick): Yes V'No If you wish to speak at the hearing. we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary ~:^. ^g=:>t ^.;:-- ,\c::"'CL, \ r^ 5.1:,,^.,--- ,. 1'\ c. ^,:.:;^-, ^^,..,,!1, <;;^::;ti--- - '^" ~"~' ~^=, \;- .,,,, """'^1:1>, 3 \"'~'=$..\ K L , ~ , ^. SE^::=.\ ' Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Return to: this form CPIus supporting documents if required). or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a tim NAPIER 4142 You do not have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. CIOsl g date for submissions Is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 Private Bag 6010. Napier 4142 , +6468357574 napt@,. gouL"z e info @napier. govt. nz Doc ID: 30680T ^ 15^ A . coyCOUNCiL 76^archera a AllL"fri . 00 * . Do All subm 55 on, , n, I'St be In writing, You n, ay ,, ttac*I a inclre, apt, ,it ti an brimsEiioii If nil jin Name: C11 T*. I^' in^'C. .^OIL, ','? "'~' Organisation: Title/Position: Postal address: Postcode: Daytime contact details Phone: Email: I wish to speak at the hearing CPIease tick): Lye^ No If you wish to speak at the hearing, we vJill contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. ',:;^^"'^,:::,^""' """"::! ^::;;^!^::^, I^,^.!,,, ,,,,..,,, ,.. Me Led, ^ Pay!^. *.. ^!:. e. .. c/,@ ,^. 0, Pbn S Cat I^^^ . Z ,*@, I'll. IjL, , ^ s^., ,^I {!,,&,*,^ ^:--^^,/'"*,-, ,,^,^/,^^- s, ^:" or, ^. ,,@ 91, I, ,,--,,-- r.r. .^..^. SQL,SQL, ^.-s.^.-s. 71.471.4 4.11^^.^ A12. ,"..?c,,"..?c, ,.,?,.,? @17^-;,,^,@17^-;^,,, I^^^ C;^ . Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Ret n to: I" this form CPIus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council 1'10 . You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do riot have to attend this meeting . Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 * +6468357579 Private Bag 6010. Napier 4142 f +6468357574 e infodinapi@rgovt. nz Doc ID: 306801 ? ""/ --f · 90 �,,,, lr fi"/10 _,,,1 7 1 //f"" efJ./J? ""3/1 o/ s:>= -p.vpv · U?/,,-;J (,-<0r?/J "ff I -p�,MI '* 4m t�9!> a/1/ � /'r:"/5 '?f/S �/� """'('7=/f . "": 't.,I � '!' m •<71'"' �"17.,n:J r.,m.) �,,.u 711 Io =n /,,,7rw Sf./O(V/ ./3'!!0 t-!t 10,2712016 NZMCA : Freedom Camping 157 Freedom Camping .^ New Zealand is blessed with an abundance of secluded and scenic spots ideal for freedom camping. In order to maintain the privileges of freedom camping, and ensure the protection of our environment, it is important everyone camps responsibly and observes local freedom camping-related rules. WHERE CAN I FREEDOM CAMP IN I^IE Tl-^BS-COROMANDEL ER^? Some Council's are creating new bylaws under the Freedom Camping Act 2011. In July 2012, the NZMCA commissioned public law firm, Chen Palmer, to prepare a guidance document to assist Councns and other interested parties in better undestanding the requirements of the Act. As a result of this gtiide a few Council's have deferred their decisions to pass new bylaws, pending further information. For further inform, ,tion on the Freedom Camping Act 2011 please select the link below: Model Freedom Cam in B law Nov 13 - this document was prepared by NZMCA and public law experts, Chen Palmer, and in consultation with Local Government New Zealand, Department of Conservation and Department of Internal Affairs. The Freedom Cam in Act 2011 How to uide or b laws under the F eedom Cam In Act 2011 (prepared by Chen Palmer) U dated uidance for local authorities (prepared by LGNZ and D/A) Re ort o the ocal Governmen & Environment Select Committee on the reedom Cam in Bill (prepared by Doc and D/A) Cons rvation Teas where Freedom C in n is rohibited or restr cted (Doc website) f you are unsure where you can freedom camp refer to your Travel Directory or enquire here: https://WWW. minca. org. rizffreedom-camping/ 10/27/2016 NZMCA : Freedom Camping I^" Department of Conservation Valor Is:^ ^ Infornebon re Papa At""ib"t Responsible freedom camping can be achieved in a er med self contained vehicle as these vehicles have the necessary facilities onboard to contain all the occupants waste for a minimum of three days. Many Councils are permiting freedom camping in certified self contained vehicles only A certified self contained vehicle must display a warrant on the front windscreen and, to assist enforcement officers, may display a sticker on the .^ . rear window or bumper to verify its status under the NZ Standard for Self Containment of Motor Caravans and Caravans, NZS 5465:2001. . , The certification documentation was reviewed in March 2012 - for further information on the desi n lease CLICK HERE. https:/haww. rizmca. org. nzffreedom-campingI 1st Kiin Anstey From: NCC Website Request - Submission Freedom Camping Bylaw Name * Emma Beer Postal I^l Address * Daytime Contact phone * Email Address * If you wish No to speak at the Hearing we will contact you to arrange a time. Hearings will be scheduled after the consultation period. I wish to speak at the Hearing (please tick): * Type Submission or attach below I support the bylaw prohibiting freedom camping at Westshore Beach Reserve. Westshore Beach Reserve is a special place to notjust Napier residents, but also visitors' Westshore Beach Reserve has it all, a childrens' playground, flat beach access for launching boats, kayaks and jet skis, picnic spots, large flat areas for launching kites or for family and group impromptu cricket and rugby games and of course a safe swimming beach. It is the fact that such activites have a home that helps to give Westshore, and Napier, that community feeling that so many people live in and visit the region for. Since the introduction of the 2014 Freedom Camping though, th's feeling of joy and community togetherness has massively declined There has been a dramatic reduction in day visitors for several reasons. Firstly, they can't get into the car park because it is full of campervans; as such access to the reserve and the beach has been greatly hindered. Secondly, many visitors feel intimidated by the sheer size and number of the motorhomes, with many commenting that they felt like they are intruding on a camping ground. This intimidation is not limited to visitors, and many local residents also feel they cannot use parts of their own community because of the number of people camping here. Freedom Camping is something special to New Zealand, and offers tourists a chance to explore different parts of our wonderful country in a different way. However, this should not be done at the expense of rate paying locals. There are places within Napier which would lend themselves nicely to freedom campers, which would not have such a drastic and negative impact on the community. is for this reason that I am supporting the bylaw prohibiting freedom camping at Westshore Beach Reserve. , I , 11^",'^' *. 26 October 2016 holidoL, IPOrks ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND Freedom Cain ping BYlaw Submission Napier City Council Private Bag 6010 Napier 4142 Submission: Proposed Freedom Camping By law 201.6 Submission on behalf of Holiday Accommodation Parks Association of New Zealand We support the recommendations to include prohibiting freedom camping at Westshore Beach Reserve and MCLean Park, removing the Northern Ocean Spa carpark as a restricted site and providing clarification on how long self-contained vehicles are allowed to stay in reserve carparks (that are not prohibited or restricted areas) We also support Councils intention to use a combination of options 2,3 and 4 to address the issues associated with freedom campers. We recommend that . Freedom camping is prohibited in all urban areas. . Outside of urban areas freedom camping is restricted to self-contained vehicles which meet NZS5465. Background Holiday Accommodation Parks Association of NZ Inc. (HAPNZ) Established in 1955 as the Camp and Cabin Association, HAPNZ is the industry association that represents the commercial holiday park sector in New Zealand There are 420 commercial holiday parks in New Zealand that annually provide in excess of 7.4 million guest nights 33% of which are international visitors HAPNZ has 300 member parks and over 90 trade members. HAPNZis a full member of the Tourism Industry Association (TIANZ) and all HAPNZ members are affiliate members of TIANZ. HAPNZ is a national partner of the New Zealand Cycle Trail, a full me in ber of the Backpacker, Youth and Adventure Tourism Association (BYATA) and an allied member of the Tourism Export Council of New Zealand. While staying at Holiday Parks, visitors contribute around $1 billion in direct expenditure to New Zealand's economy each year. Approximately $594 million, or 59% of this expenditure, is contributed by domestic visitors and the remaining $405 million, or 41%, by international visitors' Expenditu re by international visitors also contributes directly to New Zealand's export ea mings ''''' " ','. I. ,!I. ,!. I_j, .._,..'., -r' ,.:. I. ,I=,!:;, ,L, -,,:. F(.,,,, -'-: *,'..;-:* 11. ,it. ,; ; . . -.- I-, , ph +,;-,- ?*:: t's, fax +G* -! 2*S, ?,, email ;,"t*!,*:;*.,-,,!;*. c, .fir ;I::: ;*:\'.' :'. e::*;lit;,:;*:: '* :';;:;;* **.:*, ~:;3',, n c- ! 'f ,\" ", 3 !;1:1* I :,;;*C:: ;**j*ill. *C-,:Z \ \ . 2 An average of just 23% of daily expenditure by Holiday Park visitors goes toward holiday park accommodation costs. The balance, which totals approximately $769 million annually, is typically spent outside of Holiday Parks in areas such as hospitality (cafes, restaurants, bars), activities and attractions, transport (rental vehicles, fuel, buses, taxis), retail goods and services, a rid entertainment. Holiday Accommodation Parks Association Position of Freedom Camping As an Association we support freedom camping in New Zealand in appropriate locations. We believe that Councils where necessary should develop bylaws that state: . Freedom camping is prohibited in urban areas. . Outside of urban areas freedom camping is restricted to self-contained vehicles which meet NZS5465. There is no such thing as free camping -there is a cost whether it is to local ratepayers, Doc or tax payers. We fully support the concept that the user should pay. As part of local communities our members take an active part in the development of policies and bylaws which apply to freedom camping. Our members provide feedback on suggested freedom camping areas. In some cases we will support freedom camping areas and in others we will oppose them; these decisions will be linked to the appropriateness of the location and the mood of the community. We do not consider urban locations as being appropriate for free camping. While we do not seek special protection for our members from the bylaws it is sensible that some buffer around commercial Holiday Parks be put in place. This can assist in discouraging the unlawful use of facilities e. g. showers toilets and dump stations, which occur at many parks, but also remove the inevitable tension that will arise from campers overnighting for free in close proximity to commercial holiday parks. HAPNZ has been an active participant in the NZ Responsible Camping Forum and fully supports the key messages and information that has been agreed and promoted by group members. We believe that strong, consistent national messages, backed by comprehensive regional information will help remove much of the tension that has existed over vehicle-based camping and result in better experiences for campervan holiday-makers and communities. Hawkes Bay Regional Expenditure Information The following table shows that in the Year ended August 2016,233,952 guest nights were spent in commercial holiday parks in the Hawkes Bay RTO region. The table shows that these holiday park guests spent $33,996,431 in the region with only 21% of this amount spent on accommodation. , I , 3 Hawkes Bay International/Domes tit Guest Ni hts DailyS end Annualspend Holiday Park Guest Nights YE August 2016 27% 63,167 5184 % Sri, 683,376 International 733,952 73% 170,785 S130 65 $22, aL3p55 Domestic $33,996,431 Tatal DAILY EXPENDITURE PER PERSON HAWKES BAY RTO VE AUGUST 20L6 Domes11. Visitors International Visitors Domestic Visitors International Visitors Total E" enditure ALL. in modal Inn 2773% 1772% $6,187,539 $2,069,984 58,257,523 Snacks/Bruceries 1906% 12/2% $4,252,546 S1.4 15,573 $5,668,119 Adjvity/admission lees lD 62% 2658% $2,370,495 $ a. re5.923 $5,476.419 Transpnr, 240% 1589% $534,557 $1,856,479 $2.391.036 Cafes/restaurants ID 52% B 70% $2,348,293 $1,016,358 $3,364.651 Petrol/Iud 1688% 9.75% $3,767,516 $1,139,533 $4,907,050 Ba, ,/nightclubs I75% 159% $389,390 SL86.343 $575,732 Gambling l 46% O 09% $326,199 S10,107 $336,306 Internet 0.34% O 86% $75,145 $100,436 $175.58L Other PRPendilure 924% 670% $2,061,374 $782,640 $2,844,014 Total 100.00% LOUDO% 22.31.3,055 11,683,376 $33,996,431 S, u, .. Stairs, ILE New Ze, bnd. Commercial ALL, mm, d. I"n Survey. Year endn, Au, u, 12.16 Angus a A, ,,.. I". HUI, .y P. rk Vi, ",, E, penditu, e 20/4/15. April2015 Campervan/motorhome/sleepervan Fleet The rental campervan fleet is estimated at 5,500 vehicles. In addition to these rental vehicles many Young international visitors purchase private vans and other vehicles and travel the country for periods up to six months. The NZMCA members own in excess of 40,000 vehicles Urban Areas Many TLA's are choosing to prohibit freedom camping within Urban Areas and we would encourage council to take this approach in the BYlaw. It is not appropriate for visitors to be sleeping in vehicles overnight in residential urban areas Nori - Self-contained Vehicles Over the past Year there has been a shift to restricting freedom cain ping to vehicles which are fully self-contained which meet the New Zealand Standard NZS5465. We encourage Councilto adopt this as a region wide condition. Enforcement It is essential that no matter what decisions as are made regarding the Freedom Camping BYlaw that Council provides sufficient resources to enforce them. As has been seen in Queenstown Lakes District Council area, the enforcement can provide sufficient funds to cover all enforcement costs In conclusion . We support the recommendations to include prohibiting freedom camping at Westshore Beach Reserve and MCLean Park, removing the Northern Ocean Spa carpark as a restricted site and providing clarification on how long self-contained vehicles are allowed to stay in reserve carparks (that are not prohibited or restricted areas). . We support Councils intention to use a combination of options 2,3 and 4 to address the issues associated with freedom campers. . Freedom camping should be prohibited in all urban areas. \*, \ 4 . Freedom Camping in non-Self-contained vehicles should be prohibited unless in in designated sites with toilet facilities . Non self-contained vehicles should be encouraged to use holiday parks, Doc camp sites designated sites with toilet facilities. \ Fergus G Brown Chief Executive 15 NAPIER CITYCOUNCIL 76 Kuruiihero o Ahuriri . U. isSI. n to t e apte it oun I . . Do .I . A . . All submissions must be in writing. You may attach a more detailed submission if you wish I Z. .~ 10 16 - Name !c^ , ,,.,, I ,2.0 c, , Organisation: 12-1 s. , Title/Position Postal address: POSLcuu, Daytime contact details: Phone Email I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick) Yes No If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision \ , I ,,, 5, z 1:11 , I I, ,* ,^I I I I Av avV I" ,.. 42, , ^cj I Iv. /' < 4.7 6-12, , - 2. ..@/6 I; ,,, , ^ 1:1 , I , ., I I:, , , C ~ ,,,/ I 07 C I , e. .. , A , "' ' "" ' C*, C" 1"" 1167 -) Iv 14 I , "' IPI'145 , S , I Av' ,'S t. .v 12" , @. Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of ,,*:, :- ?"' '"' " I^' ,, of^, A, ,,' this form (plus supporting documents if required), or Return011 :, I'I I"C.' I^' O it^-74,11.If . online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council By law Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak h support of your submission. Please Pr'vate Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do not have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public I* . Closing date for submissions is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 f +6468357574 WWW. napier. govt. nz e info@napier. govt. nz Doc ID: 306801 ISO A . dry ColiNOL 76 I^", mm o Mum' . .. 00 . . . . Do A . All submissions nlust be n writing You indy attach a more detailed submission If you wi ,h Name; <1^V^y"tj (^ Z^;> I C:; I Organisation: A1A Title/Position: .-/\.., 119. - . Postal address: Postcode: Daytime contact details: Phone Email: I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick): Yes No If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision CICSl g date for submissions is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastlngs Street, Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 , +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 WWWJ, apie, .govL"z e info @napier. govLnz Is^ A . errYcouNciL fob"^a DAI, mm, ' . . . . o1. OUn I Do A O All submissions niust be 111 wilting You in, *y attach a more demil@d submission If yon wish Name: 1706'^_ I^^^ Organisation: Title/Position: Postal address: Postcode: Daytime contact details: Phone: Email; I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick): Yes No If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. I^::if;^-4:<^^:^^In;^';^.',^;I^,,^;^/in^j!a, ^^?^-;^,;;;:,^#:-^^,^;,^^^;^^-- *:^^:^, I^^-,,^';, 9^.^^^^-- I , ~'_ , I f""" If, ,!^' ^^' ^/:I^I'-^^..,^;!^-'^:",^!;^'^^^; 4^";'?./^'{' this form CPIus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govL. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council . You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. Closing date for ubmisslons is 12pm. Friday 28 October 20 , 231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +646835 ,a, , , +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 wuw"api@,. 900L"z e info ariapier. govt. nz Is^I Kiin Anstey From: NCC Website Request - Submission Freedom Camping Bylaw Name * Graham Pedler Name of NA Organisation Title/Position Ratepayer Postal I^I Address * Daytime Contact phone * Email Address * If you wish No to speak at the Hearing we will contact you to arrange a time. Hearings will be scheduled after the consultation period. I wish to speak at the Hearing I (please tick): * Type Submission or attach below I note that a bylaw under I I (2)(I)(11)(ill)may be made to protect the area, protect the health and safety of people who may visit the area and to protect access to the area I further note that freedom campers must be self contained. I have noticed over the past 6 months 2 incidences of tents being set up and consistent use of the public toilet facilities by freedom campers who are far from self contained. This can hardly be consistent with protecting the area The current prime areas used by freedom campers are totally monopolised by them during the warmer seasons to the exclusion of many rate paying Napier families. These areas are the best for family access to the beach. Hardly fair considering the fact that freedom campers make no contribution to the mainenance of the area or the toilet facilities I further note the the NZ Bill of rights needs to be considered irisofar as it may infringe on the rights of freedom campers. The are approximately I87 rate paving residents in Fergusson Drive and The Esplanade who by my estimate contribute $600-700,000 in rates used in part to maintain our reserves and facilities. Freedom Campers make no contribution to our reserves or facilities but expect the right to (almost) camp where they like for free Where do the rights of Westshore and Napier ratepayers rank in relation to freedom campers I therefore fully support the proposed bylaw prohibiting freedom campers from areas specified 2 O e T 2016 160 A . CITY COLINCIL 7EI^,^ergoAhwir, ' . . 00 ^ . .. A All , Jimi: skills rim. t 13, * in writing. You n ,Iy ,, tt, *c, , a 11/01'e- 11* 1.1i!CLI lit. I, !, libic, 11 If 1,011 \\, I ,I~, Name; f;:dc, .. Organisation: Title/Position: ~ Postal address: Postcode: aytime contact details: Phone: Email: I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick): No If you wish to speak at the hearing, we vJill con arrange a line. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly \. Jhether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet If necessary. Q(Q0/02_ I ^.!!Q, ^' 40 0'!!0. d, o01 *^^^!!0, vii^;,^^ IQ'^ . Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Return to: this form CPIus supporting documents if required). or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council By law Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do riot have to attend this meeting . Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. Closing date for subm, 5510 s is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 f +6468357574 Doc ID: 506801 WWW. napi@,. goVt nz e info. @1napicrgovLnz I^, o We ridv Pedler 18 October 2016 Submission to the Napier City Council FREEDOM CAMPING BYLAW 2016 I fully support the 2016 Freedom Camping bylaw prohibiting Treeoom camping at Westshore Beach and other areas the Council have designated as a no vehicle or camping zone. Infoct I support prohibiting freedom camping in all or any residential areas. I bought a property and moved to The Esplanade in March and was astounded by the number of freedom campers parked up. I dread to think what it is like in summer. I note they must be self contained vehicles capable of meeting all sanitary needs of the occupants without requiring external services. My property is almost adjacent to the toilet block and I witness every morning a steady stream of campers using these facilities. I also witness them taking their dogs on the beach and not picking up their dog faeces. This is a real concern as I believe a serious health & safety hazard as children and adults play and picnic along this coastline. I coinmend the Council for addressing the concerns of the residents and others with issues raised, such as providing unfettered access to the beach for Napier residence who regularly use this area as their recreational playground. Wind surfers, canoeists, swimmers, cyclists, children on trikes, scooters, picnickers. I feel the extra pressure on this location from freedom campers is having an adverse effect in this public space and interfering with the natural environment. Under the New Zealand Bill of Rights all citizens have the same rights, but I feel that some rights have to be considered greater than others' The permanent residents and tax paying citizens of Napier who makeup and take pride in their neighbourhoods and community surely must have greater rights than the rights of transient campers who contribute verylittle to our community. Weridy dler I^I A . errYCOtiNOL Tel^""rein 6th win' . 00 . . Do All submissions must be n NIItii19 You n ay attach a more detailed submissioit If You wish Name: ,., 46.4 I ? 40, ., AAA. ^ Organisation: Title/Position: Postal address: Postcode: Daytime contact e ai s: Phone: Email: I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick): Yes INo If you wish to speak at the hearing. we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission= Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. I JA. , ,.! 41. < ,a. .e\(, I"^,-,-,',~~ G"~~! ' (- (A~^ ,,*v^::_, ^:,, I, ,., c",.~, ,\ 51' ~~^I^^-, t. ,, ^,,*!,"~ I v^,\ ,!* \ \,^ \" FC"L Co. ,_{ ; ,^ ,e I, , \, ,\.,,* I, \ ^t, ,^ ^, 91 "\. a. ,<.^J ^+.~ a* ,~LeJ A ,,~~, I JL. ^.+3. '9\<. a, <,@.. ~ ^., I, ^'0'^ A^. 4 .^k. J e VC^ Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of mm, ^;^ "'\ " ' '~*"", ' this form CPIus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govLnz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a tim NAPIER 4142 You do not have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. Closing date for submissions is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Huskings Street, Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 , +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 w"w. "apic, .gnuL"z e info@napier. govLnz I ^2_, A . OrY COLINciL 76 ^", dam OAha*,' . o0 ' . Do All submissions rill, st be in writi You indy attach a more d"1,111ed submission if yoii wi. ih Name: (^6,100"'I" ^) , Cc/ . Organisation: Title/Position: Postal address Postcode' Daytime contact details: Phone: Email: I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick) @/ If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s), or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. ".,,, ""~ ,,,,_ ::,"";^I" *, c, ,,, :::,,,,,:,, ,,^^ ~*(t, 11, i;. I.c "'I:,;,,,,,^:,,:.,,,,^,,,,.,,,,,,,,,,, ,,,,,,,,,,, ,*,.,*,. ,, C ,z*\^,^ I^^,~ o. 3 \^A. --,,,.\~ c^,*^^,! ^,^I, --"*N I, , j^;.^t~. I, ^ I, ,*, \^\\^*".,*^ "q, ' "", ^"3- , ( ":^;^-' ^,,, ,, \,^^ t'L, ^ ,e^,*,* --,.^I, ., ^ ^ ^{o 619'7<^. pv **,,, ,v ^+, &, .*.,!,> I, ,.,^ , 4"' ^ *.^(.,,'^ '*'~ C, ,\:,\1, "' .6^-';j^ ,,!,*,.<,.\ "'**" ,, v\-., : ,:1'.\~ v'c ,,,*,. ',:',", by, j, ^,.'" "' " ' Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Return to= this form CPIus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govL. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissi search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do not have to attend this meeting . Your submission will be included in the ager^a for the meeting which is available to the public. 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 Private Bag 6010, Napier 4142 f +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 e info. "napior. govt. nz I^3 A . my COLINcjL Telto"^ DAI, win' . o0 'e Ci C Do Y All submiss ons must be n writing You nidy attach a more detailed ubmissioi, If You wi ,h Name: tvi. * cve>^ ^a. ^,^. Organisation: Title/Position: cots Postal address: Postcode: Daytime contact details: Phone: Email: I wish to speak at the hearing CPIease tick): Yes No If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. "", * $;> ^,.. t e\;ge'\; C-' C- CSCS 06 *4. ,e_<\.,,.,_ tv^.^> ^.^,~-,;\.,^. ^"*~ 'beers I. S \, Geec\I, >;a^.. e", ,,.,,, *:,,,... Q\ e. ~, o c, ~\. a>. s~* .*, ,3*,,,,\,,, \he. , ~TV\ CICSl"g date for submissions is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 f +6468357574 Doc ID: 30680T WWW. nani@,. gnuL"z e info @repier. govLnz I , , I^^- The Westshore Residents' & Development Association support the proposed 201.6 Freedom Camping bylaw This submission is for the benefit of submitters who cannot understand why the small limestone car park at Westshore Beach, opposite Domain Rd, is proposed to become a prohibited area for overnight freedom camping. The Freedom Camping Act 2011 states very clearly that a Council can make a bylaw that controls freedom camping where access to a public parking area is hindered by freedom camping vehicles Because freedom campers can park at this limestone car park for 3 nights in a row, they tend to stay put for up to 3 days and 3 nights, because if they move they may lose their possie, especially if it is in the front row nearest the beach Last summer, the limestone car park was effective Iy a camping ground, not a public car park, as depicted in the following photos * \* ~., ^ . , I \ ,*,,*. ,, . ;..,** , '~' ,,-*~~"' ~.*~' . @. * \a, F, ' \.. ., & . ...., , < , * . , , ,,~f * ,,,! , .;*!. ,, , , 141, ,1. --1<;*; 81.11. . I, '-. I a. I. , ,, , 1 4. , *, It;;. .+, ~v' .\\ Y, :^^ 4:1^ ,,. : !!^' ' """ ~ jab .. *. ^ *, ^ a'~ ^,;a a ,,= I .. , 14, ,^ '* ^ t. ~.- 4^I. 9~ ., ~. a _ *..... :^:^;;^: ,t. .~-. Try ^ 9 naga. .In~'\5.1...*,, ,,^. -, * -,. - .:*, , ^;. ,* * 3 * __ A ;* 593.1 ^ " .-:,"* to~ -*, Pi ,. ^$'^:"^\'-' ' - , ,,;11 if**,**:, f;**^'**, . - 2 S ,, * *. ,,-=* ~ - ~. airi *- , -. ,;':'f ./;..* * J ^ .\ , zz. qj';, IP!;..\;' a, ":,***. a .~ ,~ \ I~~- ~' ^,- *, TCP9 ^ A e ~. ~ .* *;/* * * .^...- A 4 ill:I , * 41 "~*" '~~ \ , " NJ* O a ;' * .'~ ...,.'.,..~ -* * * I *: -_,,.. ,*, ,",. - * ,..,.,, , ..,.,. , -,~-,. -...... L ^^- " "~' 114, * *~~ \~.~ - *::'"'~ , , \ I , ,, , , ,^^I , 165 A . CITYCOLINQL 76 I^",", eru o Mum' . . Cl Do A . All submiss ons must be n wt 111ng You n ay attach a more detailed ubmission If yoii wi ,h Name; ^-@^^ e Organisation: I A I_^ Title/Position: Postal address: Postsode: Daytime contact details: Phone: Email: I wish to speak at the hearing CPIease tick): Yes I^^. If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. I~"*> J <: u lopc;!zT' <',^ .;2^i I E;,, ^"^.,^;,^ ,=,,-y* <1^^yo , \^,"1,^""^:,,,,, I I~^.,^V ^', 2^,^^;:'^ 2^^^:-^:^^~,^,,, , I^^^ ^T'V'e,,,,, ^;,^,^^:.^; j^. 0, Do, ^~ ^~ ^'e ^'^e '\,\ I, 77 cf ^:^"~f^^:^""^^:^^^,.^^^,^:'^^^^,- ^t^:;^^^ IC,I^ "'I^., ^^, Ic!.^:/v, 11. .""- _^^, ' " <1^,, v\Ivi^z. vj^^, , ,I ^,A, 23'pry^^ 23'I'^ I^t2CO^i6':"' ^^,^. 7^j5^'- '~^'0~ -T", I^ ^';I^., c+^/v, ^i:^,^,Ivi^z. ,,^,,,, {,,Return v^^ to: ^tz, ,,;, j, i^-- -T", Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of this form CPIus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council . You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 . You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. CICSlng date for submissions Is 12pm. Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 f +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 win, nap, or gov. .nz e info ariapier. govtnz I^^; or 206 A . dry corn^L Teito^era OMR"it . o0 ' . Do All submissions must be in writing You ITi. ,y fittacti a more d*. t, 11/@d *,,, I'm 1555/01, If yo, , \vi. ;h Name: Organisation: ^;;;;^^,^*,,,,,,,., Title/Position: Postal address: Postcode Daytime contact details: priorio: Email: I wish to speak at the hearing CPIease tick): Yes No If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. ,^.,,^s;^^v^^-^,I^^11';;^^v^^:I^:"";I^\$;;^t'I"*^:..^'^';^^^I^ ,,,,,,,^,, I^^^:^'^^I\\\f^^^^^.^^^^ ^;^,*:16I::j:;:11, ^I, , ' ^;\,,., ,,. * I,^;:,^, ,,,,,^,\ ,"'^'41 it^_,,,,;^-^^ ^ ^ ,,,,,^b^,*';!^:;;j;,b: 'I\v^:^,,PI^^\^^'v^,^.,^,^^;^..0:;^^t^j,,^.,^,. z ^^^^v\0:;^^;^,{ ^:I^*',^^^^ V~^^^^I^^,^^^;-^I^:^^ ,^^^;^0. ;:":::;:'-:^nit:;; ^.^\,, I!^;^,^:^;,,' I^:^ 0*.:^\o012. ^^v~^^.,^^^,, ^^'I^'^^^,,.^'SI^,;^^^, '~I, I^11 ,^, <31V^~^;^,^+ re, 1^,,^,,^ ^icy^{';:^, ^^"^^'^;;^"^I^\^^;;^t^"',,IQ, ,,,,,!t, ""'+Y:,-'\,'0'0^;^^:t'^;;\:^--"1^^,,' j^,,^\' ^I::"'^11. ^.^I' ^!^^^I^^ ,*" ,,;"'IA^Z. thisonline form by going (plus to WWW. supporting napier. goVt. documents nZ and entering if required).the Napjer City or Cound! FREEPOST Bylaw Re ^^, 17227' Su missions ^:^I \"' *>, "" ' "" search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier city Council bot ^\ ,?,\I 10;^.- . You may speak in support of your submission. Please private Bag 6010 toad'include ' 'ay"im'a daytime mm' phone mm'er number fo' us for to us amng' to arrange ' mm' a ".time VC^Z. NAPjER ,Y\ ^ 4142 AV\^ " >' ' You do not have to attend this meeting \:> IC^.^> 1" Y^^ Yournesting submission which will i^ be ^^^had^ included toin theth^ ageTxia p, bli. for. C the O ^, CICSl g d to for subm, 5510ns is 12pm, Frida 28 October 2016 . ;^ ~ * ,:I~ .* 231 Hastingst +6468357579Street, Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 . f +6468357574 IQ, .govL"ze info. dnapiergo e info. dnapiergo Doc I : 30680 0 167 t g OeT 2016 A . dryCO!. INCIL 76 fonthaa DAI. win' . . o0 ' . Do All submissions rill, st be in writing You ITi, ,y attach a more tit, t, jihad submission If you wish Name: '. Dor~o t\>e\ '^:>'~' '~'~"' Organisation: Title/Position: Postal address: Postcode: Daytime contact details: Phone: Email: I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick): Yes N. / If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. ":^' ,^-^-*t. eo:'\ ^'t-~e, ^z. .0 ( (;' I^':;:^^0 co. ,,, 0. 10 ,.,., ,_..,,,..,,,,,,..I 0 I4. \<^,. VCi ,. 3 ,' \~e..-~~ .Q. 0~.\^. cv\ Co. 0tv*(? 10e. \ 0 -. ^*,'Co c. i:;:^.,!,^. \O e o. c!:!.~."'- e . , o!^-,Q. ,,,^<::,^ ^<::,^ '~ '::\,,:,!...!I, ' '0^-^*^^.^^e. ':"' ,,.,,,,,,!;;;., ,.!^ ,^ c ?^,.,, c?^--^, 0 ^^-^ 0, ,_,0^~ ,,, c^.,^:'^,;^ ,,.,,,.,,,, ^-,-,-:";;^;^';"';C^ "'^^^^!...!I, '^ \^,^.. . ,.,^^.!,.,^0\-!;;;.! , , ,,,\, .,.\^ (_-\^"^,"'I\ "' Submissions must be made either in writing. by way of Return to: this form CPIus supporting documents if required>, or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. gownz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Coundl You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a tim NAPIER 4142 You do not have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agentla for the meeting which is available to the public. CICSl g date for subm, sslo"s is 12pm, Frida a Odeber 2016 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 *--:^::',., 0_.,^;':^::,I:^6 ,,-^^0"'11^:;"':I:^ ^,^. ^,,^.^,^^ <~'~ *,, 0 ^AC:^ ^.^, I\^ ,,,,,,.. " ^::^: ^-,\^^, ^, 0\^;^--^.-- ^ ,:;^^ s. ^^^ ^^^e, , ,,,._,,,,+, \^'. I ~'^:^-- ^~0-.\e. Qo. ,; q;: ^ c, ,^;^,.. ^,-, ~^;, .^.,,',^,,',*, <^. ,,*,,,, 16n A . OrY COLINciL IbI@^ 6th win' . . . Do 00 All submiss!ons niust be in writii\g You nidy attach a more detailed submission If yon wish Name; Organisation: I~\, a. c^. IV\'11/"'O Title/Position: Postal address: Postcode: Daytime contact details: Phone: Email; I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick): Yes No If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or i -^:^;;;:;^:,^,*^I^^;:ill';;^;:;"^(^;;^:;^;-:;;-^^,,,, b,':'*,^-9~"-"" ,, fy, ' ^'~,..\*,^""^-,' 910^*o1. d, . of^^_.,,,,,^!,^ ,t~'0!- I ^^I ^"0 ^.. a", ^.^- 61cc^;^^,, ^:^^,^,^^ ^0 ^. ^- 6, ^;^"""11"" g. ,. b^^.^fy^' '*\/^^^' I '^.. v!'~^,--\*^^- Y6^^,' ^' ^7'^"~^" "'j^,,,!^" ofO. * of'~""'^,~ ~ """"" C^.'-^' ""' 0~"'""" ', ^,*,',^^I, 0-^"I'^,,"^^., ,^. y^..^^3 @^^ ;,^^ 0. .. A^^~^"'*4^. ^^^4. ., . Submissions,, ,^^I, ,0-^!"I^^,, in t be made ,^;,,^^, either ,^. in y^,..^.^3writing, by @^^way of ;,^^ e urn 0. : .. A^^,,!^,.'*,^, ,,,,,,..., . this form (plus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council . You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 in dude a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. CICSl g date for submisslons is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 , +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 WWW. "an IC, gayLnZ e info. @napier. govLnz * 161 I^!API^^ CTFVCOUNCiL ^ I Ib foulff, era DAI, Ith' .... - ....-,~- -. ~ I ' ,, ...... -..~..~.. .~, ^ I' ... , ...... , . ^...... ~ ,.....,...... ,...... ^ .,,.,...... :., V',...... Name: ^. Cox@I 54 rvv=, cJ r . R, *.,, , Orqanisation: 1:26s^do, d. Title/Position: Postal address: Postcode: Daytime contact details: Phone: Email: I vrish to speak at the hearing CPIease tick): Yes No If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Return to: this form CPIus supporting documents if required>. or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to vJww. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council Private Bag 6010 You may speak in support of your submission. Please & include a daytime phone number Tor us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. . . . -^. . . . - ...... - ~....~~--... ~ ... . . ,...... 231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 f +64 G 8357574 Private Bag 6010, Napier 4142 Doc ID: 306801 .*., , , . . e info;at napier. govL. nz , , , 10 o Kiin Anstey From: NCC Website Request - Submission Freedom Camping Bylaw Name * Cary Stoneley Name of All Points Camping Club of New Zealand Organisation Title/Position President Postal 11:!I Address * Daytime Contact phone * Email Address * If you wish No to speak at the Hearing we will contact you to arrange a time. Hearings will be scheduled after the consultation period. I wish to speak at the Hearing I , . ~ \, o * (please tick): * Type Submission or attach below Firstly I would like to compliment Your working party on putting together such an easy to understand and fair draft freedom camping bylaw. This is a model by which many other local authorities could learn You have correctly recognised that freedom camping is not an exclusive term applying solely to those in self contained vehicles. All Points Camping NZ was formed in December 2015 to support and represent inclusive Iy, NZ family and active campers including those who use tents and trailer campers and have been marginal ised over the past few Years, These are our future campers and include our vulnerable Youth, our lower income families. Camping has significant health and social benefits and we should be encouraging opportunities for this. It is notjust overseas tourists and and motor homers that we should be welcoming and acknowledging I would like to refer to the following clauses which I believe are incorrect "5.3 Freedom Camping is restricted in areas identified in Schedule Two: Restricted Area for Freedom Camping (non- self-contained vehicles). Vehicles are restricted to a maximum of three consecutive night stays and freedom campers must comply with the conditions listed In 6.1. " clause 5.2 refers to certified self contained whereas clause 5.3 refers to non-Self contained vehicles. A vehicle may be fully self contained but not certified. Therefore in context clause 5.3 should state "(nori certified self contained vehicles) to be correct in law or clause 5.2 should be amended Note: many campers are self contained, for example pop top campers, Australian style OZTENT, OZTrail campers. these are becoming very popular in NZ but will often not meet the technical requirements of being certified self contained' Clause 7.2. "Sealed or unsealed parking areas forming part of any grassed reserve are excluded from this prohibition in 71 (with the exception of Westshore Beach Reserve, or MCLean Park where freedom camping is prohibited both within the area and any associated parking areas) but freedom campers must still comply with the conditions listed in 5.1. " is open to misinterpretation and confusion For example the prohibited area, grassed reserve, of Tamatea would allow freedom camping in the adjacent sealed area - carpark. the carpark itself is however prohibited In such cases of freedom camping on the sealed or unsealed area, per clause 2, on interpretation it would be open to all freedom campers notjust those self contained. 2 ,, e' I 1.0 , As a last submission I would like council to be aware that space needs to be made available and accessible to our campers, notjust those with the financial means for a self contained vehicle. Our poorest and most vulnerable chidren are the ones who most need the educational and social experiences of camping. The council needs to ensure that opportunities exist (the door is not shut) for families and organisations to be able to camp out, close to home. Most families cannot afford Camping ground prices and use tents and trailers. Tourists cycling through NZ, motorcyclists with tents, families, rooftop campers - Make this an inclusive bylaw and a bylaw for the future. Please return email a COPY of this submission WWW. all o1ntscam in nz. or 3 10 ^ NAPIERCITYCOUNCIL ^ ^ 76 Kounihera o Ahuri, i S b '55'0n t. ..'. rC t . nc . R EDO ,IvlPING ,Y AW20, . All submissions must be in writing. You may attach a more detailed submission if you wish Name: ,::;^:^/;41 ,,,,,., D I, 3:12 Organisation Title/Position: Postal address: Postcode Daytime contact details Phone Email I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick) Yes No If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s), or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary ^::^..<. ,;' C^^/( 11' ^^,/- , c/:::,, I^^, C I^^^!c. 2. , cC- 11 .. N6. ,/ I . ^"' 1144 IZ) 4, " I ^ o I Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Return to: this form (plus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council By law Review Submissions search keyword; #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do not have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public Closing date for submissions is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 f +6468357574 WWW. napier. govt. nz e Info@napier. govt nz Doc ID: 306801 171 Submission on Freedom camping bylaw 2016 Napier City Council Thank you for the opportunity to comment on the proposed freedom camping bylaw. I agree with the proposed changes to the freedom camping bylaw, in particular the addition of Westshore Beach Reserve, and northern Ocean Spa Carpark as prohibited areas. However, I believe the rules may be better implemented with several minor changes, as described below: Issue I : Freedom camping at Perfume Point restricts access for other users. The issue with the current regime is that freedom camping at Perfume Point causes restricted access for many visitors to this carpark. Observations over the past years indicate that, prior to freedom camping being allowed here, many people would park here and then walk on the beach or pathways, fish, or enjoy the area in some other way. In addition, there were a great number of people who would park facing east or west, and remain in their vehicle to enjoy the view. My family often did this with our 92 year old father who is not very mobile. Being able to park and watch the surfers, yachts or the ships entering or leaving the port is an enjoyable activity, and can only be achieved at this carpark. Over the past summer, when freedom camping became a much more common activity, there were many occasions where most of the car parks were taken up with large campervans, or the vans were parked in such a way to take up more than one spot. I rioted that many camper vans stayed for several days and nights, obviously reluctant to give up the prime spot they had picked. Even with just several large vans, it is not possible to park between two camper vans and enjoy the view, as it is similar to parking in a tunnel. I've included a few photos to show the parking behaviour at perfume point, where on many occasions the campervans park in such a manner to take up several spots: . ... . .. Note this camper used a Ievdling block to Another blatant disregard for ensure a level bed. This camper remained other car park users, This in this location for several days camper is taking up 4 spots This camper took up 4 spots for several days in a row Figure I : Photos showing typical freedom camping parking problems at Perfume Point. ,A, , I note also that there may be a perception that campervans simply arrive late at night, and vacate the space in the morning. This may be the case in some areas, however, observations indicate that in places like Perfume Point, many campers arrive and stay for several days, then when they vacate the spot, another camper comes along and fills the spot. This results in a continuous occupation of the spots, which then prevents other people from accessing the area. The current freedom camping area is shown below, and includes all parking spaces in the carpark. Figure 2: Current Freedom Camping permitted area at Perfume Point I believe rules which enable of freedom campers to use the entire carpark results in a conflict with condition 6.1 (e) of the Napier City Council Freedom Camping Bylaw 2016, which states campers must. .. ensure parking of vehicle does not restrict access to public areas. .. I note that the Freedom Camping Act 2011 (Section 11(2)(a)(iii) - see below) allows a local authority to make a bylaw to protect access to the area. \u) UCLULLu;s uLc ,uL. ,L auuLu, ,, y o1cas uL uns uusuLL, u, Lc^, u, , bay, ,cic uccuu, u L, "uruL (2) A local authority may make a bylaw under subsection. (1) only if it is satisfied that- (a) the bylaw is necessary' for I or more of the follo\\, ing purposes: (i) to protect the area: (ii) to protect the health and safety of people who may visit the area: (in) to protect access to the area; and The allowing of freedom campers to park in the entire car park has certainly restricted the access for many people who frequent this carpark. 10 As an alternative, I believe a solution to this would be to allow freedom camping at the 14 carparks facing the south, as shown in the following figure. Legend Freedom camping permitted Freedom camping prohibited Figure 3: Alternative Proposal for Freedom Camping at Perfume Point This would enable freedom camping to continue to take place without restricting other users' access to the carpark and beach. I understand there may be difficulty in enforcing such a rule, however, with adequate signage this may be overcome. Other councils enable such a rule to be easily understood by the use of two signs each stating "Freedom camping allowed in parking spaces between these signs", with appropriate arrows indicating the direction to the companion sign. Suggestion to resolve issue I : Restrict freedom camping to the selected south facing spots at Perfume Point. I, 0 ) Issue 2: Length of Stay Section 6.1 (9) of the Napier City Council Freedom Camping Bylaw 2016 states no person may freedom camp for more than 10 nights in any calendar month. I believe imposing a maximum stay is a good practice to encourage freedom campers to enjoy the area, but to also not overstay their welcome, and to vacate the space and allow others to enjoy similar benefits. However, the current proposed bylaw could result in people staying for 20 days in a row (10 days at the end of one month, then 10 days at the beginning of the next month). I believe this length is inconsistent with Local Government New Zealand (LGNZ) recommendations, which in their example shown below, suggests a 3 night maximum in any 4 week period. The decision to use a calendar month as opposed to a 4 week period results in the consecutive length of stay effective Iy being able to be doubled from what is intended. Excerpt from Local Government New Zealand Model Freedom Camping Bylaw This Model Freedom Camping Bylaw has been developed in consultation with the Department of Internal Affairs, the Department of Conservation and Local Government New Zealand, who are all generally supportive of the Model By law. MODEL FREEDOM CAMPING BYLAW Examples of restrictions 'nclude: . That freedom camping is restricted to self-contained vehicles. . That freedom camping is restrbted 10 a maximum of three consecutive nights in any four week period. . That freedom camping is restricted to designated carparks within a particular area only. . That freedom camping in a non-Self-contained vehicle or a tent is permitted within I00 in of a public toilet. Suggestion to resolve issue 2: Use the wording "no person may freedom camp for more than 70 nights in any 4 week period". 10 I Issue 3: Presentation colour in Maps The prohibited areas and the permitted areas are the same red colour in the maps presented in the Napier City Council Freedom Camping Bylaw 2016. This could be confusing to some people. , ,\ . \ ^ I ., {. * ... \.*-,^ . . ,,t ,> .I , ,. . , ,., , ,,, , ,,::;;^^""' "^;$,,, , ;. ~fit . ..' ~,$,.-.,-**:.S, ,,', I,, .:*$$*::~;;. ^^,\.',";.'#:* ' .:;:*:.. <::;$**' ^f;*::$:'^;\::;> \*:::"' e,' ' 'J . * I ~ I*"$:>*V \'*^\::a. , . \..;* ' ' ~^ I : . > ,F--43:.:;$>:3$,;.: >;: .. ., , . ., . . -v-'\I '>'+::"* * - , , If .^.\4, ?$$';';:^^., :::.;'^:^* ,^!b*; ' I;;: .;"" ';^:, ' ^:.'* ' . '-.:*'e} ' I - * I , ',">'ff, !. "' I , *.. .. .'*/ ; .I ,^ ~. . *" I ., a . , *4 . * " * ~ ~I , . , ^ J, a 'I ,& e, Figure 4: Left map: Marewa - Prohibited Right Map: Ellison St. - Permitted Many people cut and paste maps from publications, which could easily result in the maps being misinterpreted since the wording may not be included. Simply making the permitted areas green (or at least some colour other than red) would clearly differentiate the permitted areas. An example from another council is shown below, which uses yellow for permitted and red for prohibited. ^!,- ". ~.." ^." ~.,,.-., ~.... . ~.. co, " a. ,. ^ " "".~ ..^:"~ =.."" =='.*... -^ as!==. e^,.,.,,.._..*.-' EU" EQ We"In"on .,.~. ~.~,.."~. P~~ co. c~~ ~~ .--2. .,~ ^*~.. d, ^. " ~ ~-~ as'=^. Figure 5: Example showing different colours for permitted vs. prohibited areas. Suggestion to resolve issue 3: Use different colours on the maps. , I , I \ 2-- Kiin Anstey From: NCC Website Request - Submission Freedom Camping Bylaw Name * Dorothy Pilkington Postal I^I Address * Daytime Contact phone * Email Address * If you wish Yes to speak at the Hearing we will contact you to arrange a time. Hearings will be scheduled after the consultation period. I wish to speak at the Hearing (please tick): * I ,* \ Type Submission or attach below 01. ,' I support the removal in the proposed revision of the bylaw of the two areas currently designated as freedom camping areas at Westshore. However, I am very disappointed that as currently proposed, the revision of the bylaw will impose a total prohibition on freedom camping at Westshore, because both the Westshore foreshore reserve and the Meeanee Quay reserve are listed as prohibited areas To clarify my viewpoint, I am a member of the committee of the Westshore Residents' and Development Association, which as a body, last Year requested that Council look again at the freedom camping bylaw because of concern communicated to the WRDA by residents in the vicinity of the designated sites on The Esplanade. Throughout the process that has evolved since then I have consistently argued that it is not in the best interests of the future of Westshore, to coin PIetely prohibit self-contained freedom cain ping. Other committee members have favoured total prohibition on the grounds that - We don't have to have a freedom camping site at Westshore and that - Freedom camping should not be allowed in urban areas Whether or not freedom camping should be allowed in urban areas is beyond the scope of the bylaw review, and I will not, therefore make any comment, other than to note in the report on the proposed review of Napier s freedom camping bylaw tabled at a meeting of Council's Regulatory Committee on 7 September, it is specifically stated that Napier is a popular destination on the freedom camping circuit, and freedom campers are described as "a high value tourist market that is set to increase over time" In regard to whether or not a freedom camping site should be located at Westshore, I note that the bylaw review sets out more specific clarification of where non self-contained freedom camping is and is not permitted in the city. As it has been the litter problems and other inconsiderate behaviour of those in non self-contained vehicles that have triggered the wish to be totally rid of freedom campers at Westshore, this clarification should resolve these issues However, it was not litter or behavior generally that led to the complaints voiced by residents of The Esplanade in regard to the public carpark designated as a self-contained freedom camping site at that location. Their stated problem was that it had become, ipso facto, inaccessible to other members of the general public, particularly (but not only) during the summer months when the area wasjampacked with motor homes. 2 ,v I 102, , . I consider that prohibiting the self-contained freedom camping vehicles from all of Westshore is an unnecessarily extreme solution to this problem. In the September report Council officers describe Westshore as an area of Napier that is of "special recreational, environmental, and social significance, high in amenity values" and it is, as also highlighted in the report, one of only a very few swimmable beaches in Napier. Westshore is attractive to visitors, as evidenced by the number of motels, the holiday park, and the hotel already providing accommodation in the suburb. Freedom campers are another significant sector of that visitor market and it makes no sense not to provide for them at Westshore. I also question the prohibition of self-contained freedom camping on the grounds of whether Council will be able to provide the level of resourcing necessary to carry out surveillance to enforce that prohibition. In the September report it is stated that "monitoring of freedom camping to ensure compliance requires daily surveillance because of the transient nature of campers. " Last summer, the perception of Westshore residents was that the surveillance was inadequate. In addition, the September sound the warning that the creation of a new prohibited area at Westshore is likely to lead to an increase in after hours calls that trigger Armouguard callouts. I would like to see an alternative site provided for self-contained freedom campers only, of a similarly modest size to the one on The Esplanade, at some other suitable location in Westshore I note that in the September report to the Regulatory Committee it is envisioned that the proposed revision of the bylaw "is not an end point, with further freedom camping options to be explored in the future" and that "Council intends to monitor the situation and assess the suitability of other sites that could be used to accommodate self- contained vehicles within the city. " I therefore request that, in consultation with residents and the WRDA, Council continue to seek out and designate an area to cater only for self-contained freedom camping at Westshore. As a final comment, I have also read recently that in some other parts of New Zealand, residents who live near to freedom camping areas are consulted on an annual basis to ensure that they have not experienced any problems arising from the activity of freedom camping during the past I2 months. I see this as a very positive move, and one that would reassure the residents of Westshore that they are not having a problem activity dumped on them without any defined channel of communication with Council. 3 ID^ 7:7 .. A ...... 27 October 2016 BYlaw Review Su binissions Napier City Council Private Bag 6010 NAPIER 4142 Emailed to: info na ier. ovt. nz SUBMISSION ON THE NAPIER CITY DRAFT FREEDOM CAMPING BYLAW 2016 Introduction The New Zealand Motor Caravan Association Inc. (the NZMCA) appreciates the opportunity to submit on the draft freedom camping bylaw (the by law). Formed in 1956, the NZMCA today represents over 68,500 individual New Zealanders who enjoy travelling our country at leisure in the purpose built motorhomes and caravans. The NZMCA is a strong advocate for freedom camping in certified self-contained (CSC) vehicles and recently commissioned a partial review of the NZ Standard for Self-Containment (NZS 5465), with support from Local Government and the Department of Conservation. Freedom camping is an important, traditional activity for our large and rapidly growing membership base. For this reason the NZMCA invests significant resources each Year protecting the privilege to freedom camp, while giving back to communities and encouraging decision-makers to pass fair and reasonable bylaws. A summary of the NZMCA's efforts and contribution to communities is attached Since Napier received motorhome friendly accreditation last year, we have enjoyed furthering our strategic partnership with council and other local event organisers by promoting Napier as a friendly destination to NZMCA members and other responsible tourists travelling in certified self- contained (CSC) motorhomes. We acknowledge the council is also reviewing its strategies and investigating further opportunities to support responsible freedom cain ping in Napier, thank you. For its part, the NZMCA has provided Napier with free tourism advertising on the understanding council decisions will both enable and support responsible camping in (at least) self-contained vehicles, without undue or disproportionate restrictions around freedom camping. In terms of this bylaw review, while we respect the council has a duty to respond to community concerns we, , 173 2 like everyone else, also expect considered decisions will be made in line with the guiding legislation, including the councils commitment to the motorhome friendly programme. Please note that if it appears the council- or any local authority for that matter -is attempting to subvert the spirit and intent of the Freedom Camping Act 20TT (FCA), or is endeavoring to use the Act for improper purposes (e. g. prohibiting freedom camping to surreptitiously protect property values or private views over public land), the NZMCA will consider taking matters further. Executive summar While we continue to support the main thrust of the bylaw, we support the proposal ID_12^rL_gnu{ We recommend: I. Amending the definition of 'certified self-contained vehicle' to reflect the proposed changes to NZS 5465:2001; 2 Delete sub-clause 9.1(e) as this provision is uncertain; 3. Amend Map 8 - prohibiting freedom camping along Westshore Beach Reserve; and 4. Amend Map 9 - prohibiting freedom camping in and around MCLean Park. Benefits of maintainin a ermissive b law Economic benefits Motor caravanning is worth over $650 million to New Zealand's economy and the latest research reinforces how significant the industry is to local economies. For example; . An independent report' published in October 2012 found campervan hirers in the year 201.1 spent on average $1.95 per day during their travels. Tourism Industry Aotearoa pu blically su pported these findings stating campers were contributing to communities throughout New Zealand, supporting local business andjobs, and their spending was not limited to tourism operators rather spread across a wide range of businesses in the coin m u nity; . In February/March 2014 the Central Otago District Council surveyed 1,000 campers at popular freedom camping spots across their district. According to their results: the average camper spent $9T a day while visiting the district, 78% were domestic visitors, and 64% over 60 Years of age. The Council's Parks and Recreation Manager, Mathew Begg, noted that this spend was quite significant to their community'- I Understanding the Value Created by Campervan Tourists in New Zealand, COVEC (NZ Market Research Company) 2 htt WWW. odt. conz re ions central-ota 0 3093/7 freedom-cain ers- o0d-s enders [accessed 16 July 2014] I?3 A survey carried out in March/April2012 at Ferry Road, Taupo (a restricted freedom camping area) showed the average motorhome visitor spent $401 per visit. Also of note, over 1.00 local businesses signed a petition to the Taupo District Council supporting the preservation of freedom camping at this site; and Results from a 2012 survey by CB Marketing Consultants, Nelson showed the average NZMCA couple spent $117.00 per day in local businesses while visiting the small town of Murchison. The domestic market is undergoing a significant growth phase with the NZMCA forecasting over 80,000 individual members in the next 2-3 years' That equates to approximately 50% more domestic motorhomes on the road by the year 2020. NZMCA members travel throughout the Year, especially over the off-peak season, and therefore provide much needed economic benefits to small business communities outside the peak holiday periods. SOCiol benefits Places that permit CSC freedom camping generally suffer less from vandalism and other undesirable social behavior as self-contained campers provide free security forthe area. Many community clubs and associations nationwide have formed reciprocal relationships with the NZMCA allowing our members to park overnight for the security it provides to their facilities. This positive benefit from allowing responsible freedom camping is frequently overlooked. Environmento1benefits In addition to the benefits associated with CSC freedom camping, NZMCA members value the places they stay and take special care to look after and improve them. Members regularly volunteer their time with local organisations and authorities to tidy up sites, pick up litter, and plant vegetation. Again, this positive benefit is frequently overlooked. Definition of a 'certified self-contained vehicle' A few local authorities have encountered problems with small 'sleepervans' purporting to be CSC. Usually the portable toilet provided is not easily accessible within the vehicle and in many cases the vehicle occupants have no intent on using them. Although these vehicles may technicalIy comply with the toilet requirements stipulated under section 6.1 of NZS 5465, the NZMCA believes the set up and e tr'cted use of the toilet ails to achieve the overriding intent of the CSC Standard. This view is shared by other stakeholders. The NZMCA acknowledges this problem is not widespread and is confined to a relatively small group of low-end sleepervans. However, with the projected growth in tourism and anticipated increase in freedom campers next summer, the NZMCA firmly believes the industry and local government need to take proactive action now. Therefore, with the support of Local Government New Zealand, the NZMCA has commissioned Standards New Zealand (SNZ) to review NZS 5465 . 103 4 with a view to, inter alia, 'raising the bar' around the minimum requirements for on-board portable toilets. In the meantime, the NZMCA has adopted the proposed amendments internally. According to SNZ, the impending review of NZS 5465 may take up to 1.1 months from beginning to end. The project is expected to conclude during winter 2017. Therefore, this bylaw review provides council with an opportunity to adopt the anticipated changes now in order to manage the aforementioned problems over summer (as other local authorities have done). We therefore recommend amending the definition of 'certified self-contained vehicle' as follows: Certffied seff-contoined vehicle me ons o vehicle designed ond builtfor the purpose of coinpi'rig which hos the copobility of meeting the objutionory Grid sonitory needs of occuponts of thot rehitle for o minimum of three doys without requi7^^g ony extemolservices or di^chorging ony woste ond coinpfies with New Zeolond Stondord 5465:2001, OS evidenced by the disploy of o current seff-contoinment worront I^sued under New Zeo/ond Stondord Self Contoinment of Motor Corovons ond Corovons, NZS 5465:2001. For the ovoidonce of doubt, the vehjtje shojibe equipped with o toilet thot is odequotely restroined or secured when trove 11^^g. The toilet sholl be reodily us obje within the vehitle incluchng sufficient heod ond elbow room ot o11 times, even with the bed mode up. Furthermore, to clarify the NZMCA's position on freedom camping, although the Association is a strong advocate for responsible freedom camping in CSC vehicles, where necessary we are not opposed to local authorities developing bylaws that accominodate other freedom cain pers, e. g those travelling in non-Self-contained vehicles and/or tents. CIOsin an area to freedom cain in Clause 9.1 of the bylaw enables the Chief Executive to temporarily close or restrict freedom camping in any area or part of any area where the closure or restriction is considered necessary to (inter alia) : (e) protect residents from signjfitont odverse effects OSsocioted with freedom coinping in publ^t spoces. While we support in principle local authorities empowering themselves with provisions similar to 9. T, sub-clause 9.1(e) is vague and would potentially enable the council to close an area(s) to freedom camping for reasons that fall outside the scope of the FCA. For example, the council may be inclined to use 9.1(e) if/when residents feel their property values or private views over public land are being significantly affected by freedom campers. The council may rely on these arguments to justify closing an area to freedom camping. We submit this would be unlawful behaviour and recommend deleting sub-clause 9.11e) from the bylaw. Westshore Beach Recreation Reserve We acknowledge the restricted car park area is a controversial issue. However, council reports suggest that it is necessary to prohibit all forms of freedom camping across the entire reserve in order to protect access, and notes the car park (representing a very small portion of the entire " 102^^ 5 reserve) can be congested with motorhomes and other visitors during peak times of the Year. We have received additional reports from other local sources noting only some (certainly not all) Westshore residents are opposed to freedom camping at the car park. These residents are primarily concerned with vehicles blocking their private sea views; despite the fact the specific area of concern is a formed public car park. From the evidence received to date, we disagree outright prohibition along the entire reserve is necessary. We also disagree outright prohibition is the most appropriate and proportionate response to the perceived problem. We do, however, agree there is a need to review and potentially tighten up the existing restrictions at this site in order to protect access to the area. With that in mind we recommend the following alternative solutions, which the NZMCA will elaborate on at the bylaw hearing: . Restrict the number of permitted freedom camping parking spaces at the Westshore Beach car park during peak periods only, orthroughout the Yearif necessary. Currently there are no such restrictions in place, which may alleviate existing congestion issues . Work with the NZMCA to expand the car park area, noting reserve land immediately south of the formed car park is included in the existing bylaw (although no vehicle access is available). The vacant reserve land offers a large overflow area (at least 4x the current car parking area) that could be utilised during peak periods to help protect access for all legitimate visitors, including motorhomers as either day visitors or freedom campers. . If this car park must be prohibited then prohibit that area only and continue to allow restricted freedom camping at other vehicle-accessible sites along the reserve. The councilwould rely on the proposed default rules under sections 5 to 7 of the bylaw to manage the activity. This approach may resolve the issues expressed by some Westshore residents; continue to enable some responsible freedom camping along the reserve; and minimise the influx of campers during peak periods by not advertising the site as a 'designated area' The NZMCA is recommending alternative solutions in an attempt to resolve the issue amicably for all interested parties. While we do agree outright prohibition along the reserve is necessary, we it may be appropriate to alter the existing restrictions with a view to enabling more controlled, uriadvertised freedom camping. If, however, the council prohibits the entire Westshore Reserve as is proposed, the NZMCA will have little choice but to take matters further. MCLean Park As noted in the Sop and the Regulatory Committee Agenda, dated 07 September 2016, the council recommends prohibiting MCLean Park, all associated car parks and surrounding streets, to protect public vehicle access during rugby and cricket matches. The agenda also notes the Hawke's Bay Rugby Union and Central District Cricket Association lease the car parks from council. , 103 6 Firstly, from the information made available to the public, the NZMCA does not agree that it is both necessary and appropriate to prohibit freedom camping around MCLean Park in order to protect car park access during rugby and cricket events. If necessary, the council can rely on sub- clause 9.1(d) to temporarily prohibit freedom camping during planned events, and outside of these events continue to permit restricted freedom camping as per the default provisions under sections 5 to 7 of the bylaw. Secondly, if the councilleases car parks to the rugby union and cricket association, then the council no longer has management or controloverthose car parks. The car parks are no longer considered local authority areas for the pu rposes of the FCA. For this reason alone it would be inappropriate for the council to regulate freedom camping over leased car park areas. The NZMCA requests the opportunity to speak at the hearing and will require a projector. Yours faithfully THE NEW ZEALAND MOTOR CARAVAN ASSOCIATION INC. C. ^ James jinlach BSC. MRP (Hons) National Policy and Planning Manager 0272985648I ames nzmca. or .nz Postal: P. O Box 72147I Papakura 12244 ^,,^ BYlaw Review Submissions Napier City Council Private Bag 6010 Napier 4142 Submission on Napier City Draft Freedom Camping Bylaw 201.6 The Hawkes Bay Area committee of the New Zealand Motor Caravan Association (NZMCA) appreciate the opportunity to submit to the draft freedom camping bylaw. The Hawkes Bay area has some 1500 members residing within the region most of whom enjoy the benefit of being able to enjoy the freedom camping activity that "Certified self-contained motor caravans" are able to provide under NZS 5465. With Napier now recognised as motorhome friendly our local resident members have enjoyed the ability to park at local recreational reserves as do many members from all over New Zealand when visiting the city. Summary We support the bylaw but only support the proposal in part only. We recommend the following I Amend the description of certified self-contained vehicle to match the intended amendment to NZS 5465. 2 Remove clause 9.1. e as this clause is extremely broad and uncertain in definition. 3 Amend map 8 prohibiting freedom camping within Westshore Reserve. 4 Amend map 9 prohibiting freedom camping at MCIean Park. Certified self-contained vehicle With proposed changes to the NZS 5465 to restrict the use of toilets in smaller vans where there is insufficient room to access and operate the toilet with a bed permanently made up, these smallvans will no longer qualify for Certification. Closing areas to freedom camping We feel that the clause 9.1 e is very loose to interpretation and that it could be used in circumstances that would be opposed to the Freedom Camping Act. Westshore Reserve Area. With regard to the Westshore Reserve this is very large area and we believe that a lot more area could be opened up for vehicle parking with MotorhomesICampervans restricted to no more than six vehicles in any one area parked up at the same time, re parking could be spread over a much wider area of the reserve in three or four different locations. This would result in reducing the pressure on the existing parking area. MCIean Park To MCIean Park we object to the possible loss of parking in this area, we would be understanding of the need for council to restrict on occasions due to large sporting events. However if we are to loose any parking in this area we would respectfully request that council find a replacement area of similar capacity within the city. We thank You for the opportunity to make a submission and request time for one of our committee members to speak to our submission at the Hearing. Roger Wallis Hawkes Bay NZMCA Area Chairperson 122 Arataki Rd Havelock North 4/30 Ph 0274454787 arither xtra. conz I') 5 BYlaw Review Submissions Napier City Council Private Bag 6010 Napier 4142 Submission on the Napier City Draft Freedom camping By law 201.6 Introduction The attendees of the New Zealand Motor Caravan Association Inc. Annual "Lower North Island Rally" held at Fielding over Labour weekend 2016 thank council for the opportunity to submit on the draft freedom camping bylaw. The provinces represented at this rally included Wellington, Mariawatu, Wariganui, Wairarapa and Hawkes Bay as well as visitors from other regions. Many of these people are regular visitors to Napier & have enjoyed the welcome from the city as a motorhome friendly destination. Summary We support the bylaw but can only support the proposal in part only. We recommend: I Amend map 8 Prohibiting freedom camping on Westshore Beach Reserve. 2 Amend map 9 Prohibiting freedom camping at MCIean Park. 3 Amend definition of "Certified Self Contained vehicle" to match the changes proposed to the NZS 5465:2001: self-containment standard. 4 Remove clause 9.1 e) this clause is vague and uncertain and council could invoke this clause in an unfair situation outside of the intention of the Freedom camping Act. Westshore Beach Reserve The members felt that the proposed prohibition was a step too far from what is presently allowed, there are several other areas within the reserve that could be utilised for freedom camping in smaller groups, which would alleviate the concentration of motorhomes in the northern carpark a rea. MCLean Park Members do not agree that this area should be closed to freedom campers however they do accept that council could require to temporarily restrict freedom camping during large events. I request the option to speak at the hearing for and on behalf of the listed attendees attached. For and on behalf of Attendees of Lower North Island NZMCA Rally. Roger Wallis 122 Arataki Rd Havelock North 4/30 Ph 0274454787 , ../ , ID ^, Kim Anstey From: NCC Website Request - Submission Freedom Camping Bylaw Name * Ron CARSWELL Name of in dependant Organisation Postal PI Address * Daytime Contact phone * Email Address * If you wish Yes to speak at the Hearing we will contact you to arrange a time. Hearings will be scheduled after the consultation period. I wish to speak at the Hearing I \ \. * \ 11/1, * (please tick): * Type Submission or attach below I consider Napier made a gigantic step forward with the implementation of the 2014 (amended 2015) Freedom Camping BYlaw. I am most grateful and thank you for it. It is a privilege to Freedom Camp, which I am sure is appreciated by the vast majority of us The establishment of an area for non certified campers to park overnight near the South Boundary to the City, was a visionary move by Council and to be complimented on - I do not have any issue with removing the Northern end of Ocean Spa Car Park or Westshore Toilet Block Park from the 'Permitted" park over list. - I am however, greatly concerned at the proposal to remove other areas from the approved "Permitted" park list, especially so, as no alternatives are being offered I cannot agree with Council advisor comment as to reasons to close Westshore "Permitted" park. I can only imagine at the thought process that came to bear on the three criteria to enable Council to ban Freedom Camping in the Area using the guidelines of the Freedom Camping Act That is IIto protect the area. 21 To protect the health and safety of those who visit the area. 31 To protect access to the area. Given the dimension of the Westshore Reserve, the multiple entrances along its length and its under utilised grassed areas I find it difficult to understand that points I, 2 or 3 can reasonably be justified as a reason to close the area off. To protect a view is not an option under the Resource Management Act. - I would like to suggest that the area at Westshore Beach Reserve Car Park, map 4a of the Freedom Camping BYlaw 2015 be kept open and further opened to the dimensions approved in that map. Some of the area to be designated Freedom Camper only parks. For example a maximum of 20 certified self contained vehicles. This particular site meets several criteria in my view I I Good and safe access off a low traffic flow street. 21 Ground slopes down from street level so minimal view obstruction for the few affected residents, and that covering a very small arc in the overall picture. 31 Excellent separation from houses, street and cycleway 41 situated away from the main swimming and child play area. 51 Easily accessed from the Public Dump Point in Domain Road 2 , . I' ,, 17^ 61 Within walking distance of the Westshore shops. - I also suggest the inclusion of the centre parks only, not the whole area, (approximately 8 spaces) in the car park at Nelson Street, Ahuriri Estuary (North of the Sport Fishing Club) which would be suitable for motorhomes up to 12 metres in length. The Pohutukawa trees at the entrance would screen vehicles from the road and also the apartments across the street. - I do not consider any other alterations to the existing bylaw are crucial at this point in time and that the whole process requires a settling down period to really be able to evaluate its effectiveness and any perceived flaws. Perhaps with Central Government considering Tourism and Freedom Camping at this point in time maybe we should be waiting for their thoughtsjguidance on the matter - Meanwhile, Policing the main parking areas and issuing fines where appropriate will very quickly sort any non complying Campers. - To suggest visiting travellers use a Camp Ground or the NZMCA site at Eriksen Road I believe is NOT consistent with the intent of the Freedom Camping Act . a '. ;: ' Attach a File 2016 submission f_c_na Iercc. .docx I 5.46 KB Docx . . 3 Inn DQ, Y\I\\ S ,,, ,,.,,^,, f Submission to the Napier City Council Freedom Camping Bylaw 201.6 Clarification Required: Section 5.1 (by of the proposed bylaw states that the period of stay shall be no longer that one consecutive night. On the other hand section 5.2 and 5.3 refer to vehicles being restricted to to a maximum of three consecutive night stays. This apparent contradiction is confusing. Which is correct or how can it be better explained? Other Issues: I MY uderstanding is that residents of The Esplanade in Westshore are concerned that camper vans parked on the foreshore restrict their sea view as do other related activities such as hanging out laundry. I note that these concerns are not covered by the bylaw and hence do not provide a valid objection to freedom camping in that area. 2 The proposed bylaw appears to significantly restrict the number of areas available for freeedom camping in Napier. Given that there appear to be some legitimate concerns about carpark and access congestion caused by freedom campers the proposal to reduce the number of available sites is therefore likely to increase congestion in the remaining areas. On this basis it seems unrealistic to reduce the area available for freedom camping and the aim should be to provide alternative or additional sites to the areas where it is proposed to prohibit freedom camping. It seems unresonable to completely prohibit freedom camping in Westshore which is a popular swimming, picnicing and recreation area for residents and visitors' My suggestion is that additional or alternative freedom camping areas could be created in the beach reserve in selected areas between Fenwick Street and James Street. In these area the beach reserve is below the level of the street which should avoid camper vans causing any estiction to the sea view. A further altenative below street level would be the BOYdstown area o Meeanee Q y. Conclusions: I am seeking clarifaication of the wording of sections 5.1,5.2 and 5.3 of the proposed by law. I am concerned that cutting down the available areas for freedom camping will only cuse greater congestion in remaining areas. The proposed bylaw therefore needs to provide for alternative or additional freedom camping areas particularly in the Westshore area. 10^ NZ TRANSPORT AGENCY Levels, 43 Ashley Street PO Box 1947 WAKA KOTAHl ^7 Palmerston North Central Palmerston North 4440 New Zealand 28, hjuly 2013 T 6469536396 F 6469536203 Senior Policy Planner WWW. nzta. govt. nz Napier City Council FREEPOST 172273 PRIVATE BAG 6010 NAPIER Dear Sir I Madam, Proposed Napier City Freedom Camping Bylaw 2016 Thank You for the opportunity to submit on the Proposed Napier City Freedom Camping Bylaw 2016 The Transport Agency has some concern that closing down existing sites within the 50km/h zones t may result in an increased number of vehicle movements heading to those sites which remain available especially those on high volume sections of lookm/h road including Marine Parade, State Highway 2 where the added risk of large vehicles would be a particular concern Such problems could also arise on other parts of the network, where volumes and speed are higher. The Transport Agency would be supportive of urng that access standards to existing sites are adequate to ens re that the safety and efficiency of the highway network is maintained. If you have any further questions, please do not hesitate to contact me on (06) 9536671 or s haun. harvev@nzta. qovt. nz Yj s sincerely Shaun Harvey Senior Planning visor (Acting) 17^ To whom it may concern RE: Submission on the propsed changes to its freedom camping bylaw The Hawke's Bay Housing Coalition thank you for the opportunity to submit on the proposed changes to freedom camping bylaw. The Hawke's Bay Housing Coalition is a very broad range of agencies involved in supporting the region to achieve healthy housing for all. This coalition works to a strategy with the aim to deliver "appropriate, healthy, affordable homes in Hawke's Bay through leadership, advocacy and action". With housing becoming increasingly uriaffordable, the coalition also aims to address issues and support work for those people that currently have issues in being housed. The aim of this submission is to provide feedback about the proposed changes to freedom camping and the impact this will have on our most vulnerable people who are homeless and who utilise freedom camping spaces. The New Zealand definition of homelessness has been defined by four categories. The proposed by law change impacts on the definition category of "without shelter" which means, no shelter or makeshift shelter and examples include; living on the street and inhabiting improvised dwellings, such as shacks or cars'. There is no official count of how many homeless people reside in Hawke's Bay. Following a community hui in Napier on August 2015 a cross-sector group was formed to address issues and concerns around homelessness in Napier. The research idenitfied there are 18-20 people 'sleeping rough' in Napier CBD, others sleep in cars and tents, or in temporary accommodation such as camping grounds with the numbers increasing'. The Ministry of Social Development assess families for social housing need and for June 2016 Social Housing Register waiting list for Napier, indicates that there are 95 people in Priority A and 34 people in Priority B. With increasing numbers of homelessness in Napier, freedom camping sites can be viewed as being a safe place to sleep for people who are without shelter with access to toilets. Agencies that help the homeless are noting anecodotally that those people without shelter congregate at freedom camping sites. We want to raise the awareness of the homelessness highlighting that there are multiple agencies working together to address this issue. We acknowledge the regulatory capacity and monitoring that occurs from the Napier City Council at the freedom camping sites. BY reducing the number of sites made available to freedom camping will place additional pressure on the remaining sites, and in particular along the Marine Parade. This could reduce access to a **safe" option for those using temporary accommodation. We recommend usage be monitored to ensure local and visitor needs are being met continue. Also support strategies to reduce local demand for Napier people without shelter. Reducing the places available will increase the density of people in remaining areas and will place an additional strain on toilets and rubbish in these areas. \^*^ ^Q\'\. ,^\^^... C6^\^ ^^^(^^^^ ,,,,,,,,, Lisa Pohatu "'I I S Secretary Hawke's Bay Housing Coalition ' Homelessness in New Zealand (2014). Pantmentary Library Research Paper. ' http://WWW. napier. govt. nz/assets/Documents/Outreach-Research-ReportFinal. pdf , . I^o * Kiin Anste From: NCC Website Request - Submission Freedom Camping Bylaw Name * Kevin Cosling Title/Position Napier city resident Postal Address * I^I Daytime Contact Phone * Email Address * If you wish to speak at the Hearing we will Yes contact you to arrange a time. Hearings will be scheduled after the consultation period. I wish to speak at the Hearing (please tick): * Type Submission or attach below I suggest in ( MAP 8 AREA ) the low lying land opposite the school on Ferguson ave may be an alternative location that perhaps goes some way to accommodating the concerns of all parties. !^I A . coy CouNQL 7b rea^ o Mum' . 00 . . . . . All submissions nlust be In writii19. You indy attach a more detailed submission If you wish Name; '^' ^-,^,,^^j e4^^ ^-^-^ Organisation: ' We, / I-- A, " ^^^:0< IA1\~ Title/Position: ^.^, ,^ 21 Postal address: Postcode: Daytime contact details: Phone: Email; I wish to speak at the hearing CPIease tick): Yes No If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. ^,,,L, ;;,^';,^-/4. ^^4,, b ,,.' '*,"j, ,^I^'^^^--^ '^;:^,. ^;j'!^ "'I ^?:^^*^^----,^if;,-""(^;z",/: ' '!:^^"I"~""' ' """"'""" I, "'^""""/"^.^', ""'^ IP '/I:^ ""~ ^";;,,,..* ," ^I"'j, ^,.,"* f' ,,,,, 1.42,d^^,,"~^' /,,' ,"^^:^/ "^^ I,,, ^^;'.I^, I ^;',^32^,--^'." " '," - !^;'^^^",,,,,, I^ ^/- >",,// I^~." ^," 14.2 ~^/,- '^" ^;" "' I^^,,^'by"'~' ' "', I '/d^^,,/0 I " I" ^ I, ^,,^^,,^ ^ ^{ ^^:^/ I^^,--/^^,"'.,'",, ,,",, I, ^'^--^:^' I II^32^,.- I^^"' I---' ^:^";^:" 4-,, I^^/->","/ ^,-,^^^' j"' 11:1^^,{"'^;^,";:^-''," 14'2"" ,,-4, "",,-," '""I^^,, I^^,, ' I^^,, Submissionsmm *mm to^us must copy.be made ,*^ng either common*^ in writing. ^* byam^,^,,, way of or Return ER^^,.^^ to: In.mm, .,?'!/ ^ ^: ^;11 I, ,g, ' ^ ,/// ' ,2^/;'^'@" online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nZ and entering the Napjer City Council Bylaw Review Subm' ons search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 . You do riot have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. Closing date for submissions is 12pm, Friday 28 October 20.6 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 t +6468357S79 , +6468357574 Doc ID: 306801 WWW"apic, .gnuL"z e info. dnapier. govLnz It;L Kiin Anstey From: NCC Website Request - Submission Freedom Camping Bylaw Name * Petrina Denton Name of Individual Organisation Postal I^~I Address * Daytime Contact phone * Email ,I, Address * If you wish No to speak at the Hearing we will contact you to arrange a time. Hearings will be scheduled after the consultation period. I wish to speak at the Hearing I It)'- (please tick): * Type Submission or attach below Cary and I are NZMCA members and regular visitors to the Bay for cycling and shopping. We are just on our way back to our home in Dannevirke after another 48 hour stint in Westshore for 2 days of cycling. This is a central point for us to cycle to the city and beyond and the next day the Wetlands. I thoroughly enjoy the down time watching the port activity and the wildlife while Cary fishes. The highlight this trip was watching 2 Killer Whales for an hour exploring the inner sanctum of the Westshore harbour. Magical. This trip we spent $390 at Supercheap, New World, Aquarium Cafe, Caltex and bulk Bird Seed all in a 48 hour period so we do spend when we are here. We always consider the residents and do not hang washing etc out. We consider our stay there a priviledge not a right. In our opinion the Council have it right at the moment with a 2 night limit. We are happy to move on to another access point for the cycle way after 2 days. If You do block W estshore from us I would be bitterly disappointed but would understand. What I ask in return is for You to open a larger site down the Awatoto end with a sea view where we are not obstructing residents views. We do not want to be in a position of leaving the Bay off our cycle destinations as we feel part of the Bay and spend many happy hours there. Thank You for taking the time to allow us to have our say 2 I^3 Kim Anstey From: NCC Website Request - Submission Freedom Camping Bylaw Name * lane Nicholls Postal I^l Address * _. ~. JL~. nt ,., -- .-, .... ,,,,, .. up"' " 10 Daytime Contact phone * Email Address * If you wish to speak at the Hearing we will contact you to arrange a time. Hearings will be scheduled after the consultation period. I wish to speak at the Hearing (please tick): * I I^,?) Type Submission or attach below As local residents of Napier and members of the Motor Caravan Associaton we were very disappointed to hear that the Westshore self contained camping area could possibly close. That would be a great shame for Napier visitors and tourists. And also the Westshore shopping village. We have stayed there frequently and along with many others enjoy the peace and being close to the sea. Most campervaners are very respectful of the places they stay, we have never encountered disrespect or lack of consideration to others. The only rudeness we experienced was from a resident who was 'hurling abuse from her balconyjust as we arrived. .and completely uncalled for There is a real need for a good camper van site in Westshore, and we feel there is considerable potential to design a unique and welcoming place, that could include more tree planting We see no reason to reduce the number of nights if we wish Napier to be motor home friendly city. Hope You will give this serious consideration. Yours Sincerely Jane Nicholls William ISOn. 2 . I^4 Kiin Anstey From: NCC Website Request - Submission Freedom Camping Bylaw Name * leannette Cameron Title/Position Mrs Postal IP~I Address * Daytime "~- - Contact phone * Email Address * If you wish No to speak at the Hearing we will contact you to arrange a time. Hearings will be scheduled after the consultation period. I wish to speak at the Hearing (please tick): * I Type Submission or attach below ^^c^ We do not believe the Freedom Campers should be stopped from using the beach reserve area. Our beaches are for everyone and in the context of the size of the whole reserve this is a very small parking area. And herein lies part of the problem...... there are not enough suitable sized parking areas. If You want to protect the area what is the difference what type of vehicle You have parked there, freedom campers or cars? People picnic all along the reserve and in front of our house at number 24 The Esplanade and park in different places along the Esplanade, notjust in that one area. We would have thought the safest area to swim in would be down by the Surf Club, where there is parking and life guards. When a member of The Westshore Residents' & Development Assoc visited a while ago to ask us to sign a petition banning these freedom campers, not one word was mentioned about the points made about protecting the area etc, it was all about the people living in the homes over the road looking at these vans. What is the difference. .... cars or vans. We have people park over from us all the time...... that is what using the beach areas is about. 2 I^5 Kiin Anstey From: NCC Website Request - Submission Freedom Camping Bylaw Name * Ielle Elzinga Postal 11^~I Address * F -.. -\. UIUllU Daytime ... Contact phone * Email -, Address * If you wish No to speak at the Hearing we will contact you to arrange a time. Hearings will be scheduled after the consultation period. I wish to speak at the Hearing (please tick): * I^^ Type Submission or attach below As a Napier-based motorhome owner who sometimes makes use of the Westshore Beach Reserve to spend a night or two to recreate at the parking area at present designated as an area where campers are permitted to stay for three consecutive nights I object to a blanket prohibition on camping for the entire length of the Westshore Beach Reserve. The parking area near Domain Road is not in close proximity to residents who should not unduly suffer from motorhomes parking there. I consider a blanket prohibition of freedom camping along the entire length of the Westshore Beach Reserve, as an unreasonable limitation of my right to enjoy this area in the way that it has in he past been able to be enjoyed 2 I ^, ^ Kiin Anstey From: NCC Website Request - Submission Freedom Camping Bylaw Name * Rob Kiinble Name of n/a Organisation Postal 1:1_, Address * Daytime Contact phone * Email Address * If you wish No to speak at the Hearing we will contact you to arrange a time. Hearings will be scheduled after the consultation period. I wish to speak at the Hearing ^^.^ (please tick): * Type Submission or attach below I do NOT support the closing of the Westshore and the parking alongside Ocean Spa. Napier has attracted numerous people to visit Napier, andjudging by the number of motorhomes I have seen, the financial benefits to Napier in general, but particularly to petrol stations, supermarkets, cafe's and retailers must be substantial. Leaving only the smallest parking at Perfume Point seems to be the incorrect decision Also, the council need to appreciate the difference between fully self-contained (SCC) and certified overnight parkers and the smaller rental vehicles, many of which are not SCC certified. In my view these campers add a little extra security at night, especially at Perfume Point, where prior to campers being allowed to park there, the toilets were being vandalised I agree that motorhomes should not be parked wherever they block ratepayer's views of the sea, but that's not the case at the parking along Marine Parade of Perfume Point, and I doubt other then the largest of motorhomes would block views at Westshore. With ovei' 60,000 members of the Motorhome Cub, who are, in the main, totally law abiding and aware of regulations and restictions, Napier should encourage these members to visit and spend money and time here. Parking during working hours can be handled as a separate issue, but at night, most of the existing Freedom camping areas are deserted. And let's be fair, why does the council want to restrict campervans from parking in these areas, they pay Road Users charge ( most are diesel vehicles), rego fees, etc. etc. so why should they be restricted where they can park - essentially they enjoy the same rights as every vehicle on the road. Instead of closing the parkings to overnight parking, why not seize the opportunity of raising a bit of extra revenue for Napier by introducing a small overnight parking fee, say around $5 - $10 per night. All I ask is Napier is not portrayed in the same negative view that the Coromandel was when they enforced anti freedom parking laws which were subsequently overturned. Many campers, myself included, did not travel to the Coromandel due to their unfair policies at that time. 2 I^, Kiin Anstey From: NCC Website Request - Submission Freedom Camping Bylaw Name * Mark Thomas Postal PI Address * Daytime Contact phone * Email Address * If you wish No to speak at the Hearing we will contact you to arrange a time. Hearings will be scheduled after the consultation period. I wish to speak at the Hearing (please tick): * It, , Type Submission or attach below I am a Hastings resident and I don't support the changes as prescribed in the document however I do support controls so freedom camping is managed. I support freedom camping in principle I attended the Art Deco weekend as a freedom camper and was amazed at how well the weekend was organised. I noticed that hotels and motels appeared sold out so that freedom camping was not adversely affecting accommodation bookings and I noticed the vibrancy and volumes the freedom campers brought, plus the entertainment venues were very well attended and a very positive experience was had. I came away believing Napier was was a progressive city, working with freedom campers rather than against it. Restricting freedom camping will restrict these items and turn people away, They won't be happy given that Napier has so far appeared very progressive on this issue. However I do respect that freedom campers can be troublesome, but don't support the idea of having a few troublemakers leading to an adverse experience for everyone else and restrictions being imposed. Instead of restricting freedom camping, I would be supportive of retaining Napier's progressive and supportive stance- but of introducing fairly hefty immediate fines, bans, tows and penalties being placed on troublemakers to ban and discourage them from attending and very clear notices and policing to support that. The issues come from only the big events, where security for such occurances could be budgetted for and funded by the fines and penalties imposed. This would keep troublemakers out of the picture, but retain the positives of encouraging freedom camping Thank You for taking into account this submission Mark Thomas. 2 I. , AVI, I B. we^ 18^ Freedom Camping Submission by Ann Bowes. We live on Te Awa Avenue directly opposite the Southern camping area on State Highway 2. We have many concerns as we are looking out in this direction from our living room. Do we have to witness a tragedy before the powers that be do something to alleviate these problems? My submission is that it is urgent that plans for further spaces are in place immediately, considering the overcrowding in the previous summer season. Points to consider are; Right turning traffic when coining from Hastings. Now that we have the wires each side of the road there is nowhere for following traffic to go when there is a queue in the middle of the road. There has been a pile up here some time ago and we are surprised that there haven't been more. On Sunday (23/10/16) two large vans went past the entrance heading south. They backed up against the look traffic in order to turn in and they had two nights taking up 4 spaces. I understand that traffic flow on State Highway 2 does not come under Napier City Counciljurisdiction but the camping area has been set up by them. Overcrowding. On Tuesday morning (25/10/16) the campers were already parked in the driveway. Last summer there were often cars parked both sides of the driveway right out and including parking on the road. If there is an emergency no large vehicle would have access. These people are not in camper vans but in old converted people movers. They have their mattress on top of a shelf and they cook with a small gas cooker on top of the bedding with the back doorlifted. Many of the vans arrive around 10.00pm which Ithink must be after the last check by security and these are the ones that park wherever they can. We have had up to 70 vehicles in a park designed for 35 spaces and they are using two toilets. We see men urinating behind the toilet block, in the grassed area and we imagine the bushes are also being used as toilets. 3 Day Rule. So far this is not being adhered to at all. We recognise people who have flouted this rule since the area opened. Why put up a notice informing about fines when they all know nothing happens? Why a Sea View? The Motor Caravan association has a paddock behind the golf course in Eriksen Road. Is there a similar area available to be easily developed immediately for this use? Cost to Napier Ratepayers. The toilet block was constructed to give facilities for this camping area. The capital cost of the block and then the truck arriving regularly (every second day in summer) are a drain on the ratepayers. Apart from the major construction cost the emptying fee will be approximately $400 each time for the foreseeable future. I^ ^ Closing of other camping spaces. I am aware that there are other popular areas about to be closed and to my knowledge there no definite plans to replace them which will lead to further overcrowding. I submit that it is urgent that there is attention to the following points 1.1 Turning traffic from State Highway 2. 21 Overcrowding 31 Rules for length of stay 41 No need for a sea view. 51 Cost to Ratepayers. 61 Closing of other camping areas. I^\ *, I"'^::. I^!APIEI^ .^? ,, CF~\!J:- ;'\, CITYCOUNCIL It:^, 76 KOUJIihera o Alluriri e::. f. Submission 1:0 I'.^'re Nowier City Council Fill=!;D, C 1-111 CAI\, Ply' ^3I. ..:-Y!. A\A1 2.16 All submissions must be in writing. You may attach a more detailed submission if you wish I~ I I Name t ., , f. ; I I 16rganisation: I'~'c vf\ \O Q-*LLC ' \ 0- 'i" J. ^- ; \ .-, ., ^ -* * . Title/Position ^ . .--. . : I, I . . ; ^ -' _ ,,..;I;;, . . , .-.. Postal address: I, ! Postcode Daytime contact details: IPhone IEmai" I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick): Yes ^* q; A, , ,^-. ct^,\* ^", *' , **_ \^111 If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. ;;>^13 \,.. 13el, -t;I\' --^^--^---^-.--^-.-^-^^-^^ ------Summary of Submission: -^ "- ^^^- '., '...,~.-.\.,- ..-, *'*--.,,,,^,-,-~._^,)\\e. ,._^. '\~*, C t ' ~\ "-- ' <'0 ; ..,, , I .-. ;: "~ " ~~""' "" ' ' "' ' ' ' ' ' ' *.. .,. I.. ~ -.,..: ,~ . . I ------^^-----.^----.------^-----^-----^^- - I~~~~ ~ ~ ~' ~ ~~^'~':~~~' ~~~I ------.--^------ ,, ,.- . ', ' . *_ ', ...,:,, . Submissions must be made either in wi'it ing, by way of Return to: this form (plus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council By law Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 " You do not have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public Closing chic for SIIhmissi, ns is 12,111, Puma\, 2:3 tiett>be!' 2,116 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 a t+6468357579 Private Bag 6010, Napior 4142 I f +6468357574 I'-, VJ\, I. .1,111G*.,!five. 'I2 e info@napier. govt. nz Doc ID: 306801 , ,.. I, ' A ;I \ ; . II .. : : I , . , , \ I* . , , J , . ' ~' .,, , . '/ I~ ' 'L'~--'I' \.;'>,.} , 1.1 : , * <. 1 L, - " 4.4 I ~> ~. \.., * * ' ,"'.'I !,/. r7; " 'f~* , \ , *-:.- I 11 I , I- , I * **, ' "' A \\ * ./' ' ' \-* . I I :*,*., *~ ."\ ,' if " , FF ~'~' ';'* I, , , , ,;! , ; \ . , , ,-, ,, ,* I. , ':' . , \, t 11 .*?I \, 7 ;,,,?,,-,,"7. -'? ',It'{!,,/\,.,/ I I I~~' . . I",.,, *,, :',./ * , , , ., , A, \ ^.., ~ ....,- A a. , *I, ,/ -.* I \~ ,.~ ,; "-, *\/ . ~. **: ,. I . , ~ , Iu' , ',' I I, ,%I , I^6 o'? ^:;;,? NAP I I;;:I^ CF'\:11, ^'> CITYCOUNCiL CF^^, e::y> Te Kouninero o Ahuriri Submission to he A1^pier City (COLIncil F1'>!:=DC1-/I CAMPk C 11\/I_/^, V\/ 2.16 All submissions must be in writing. You may at tacit a in o1. e detailed submission if you wish. I, Name ;.' ~} 16rganisation: Title/Position Postal address , . Postcode Daytime contact details: I Phone: I Emai" -\ I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick): Yes I NO I \.^ If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. 11:;identifyr ~ ~~ -~~'-- what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision \ e' ~^ , , \I'*., C C, ',,.*.( C ', t I ,~'1, <1< ,,~. \ , I. _ If t. 11 C ~T~ - - ><,! , ,'\ ; \.:.,, I'~ -~- -\ , ,. ' JR ,,-..\ I\i~;\"c~I' I. \' ' >C. ,.,', I ,..!,, _: I C*, *:~ , I~\*"* ,':', F;_FA, A*, ,_I', I . . ,I '. I-- I I".~ \ '~~' I ! _, -----L. ,'.\'- " '~' ' ' I-;, I'tt;\ ~,- I-!c, '~' I L;, \, . Submissions must be made either in writing. by way of Return to: this form (plus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council By law Review Submissions search 1 Cios:rig date for s;.;Elmissions is 12/3m, I', it;a\, 28 Oct4J!}e!' 2016 231 Hastings Street. Napiei' 4/10 I t +6468357579 Private Bag 6010. Napier 4142 I f +6468357574 WWW. lapis;IgoVI. '13 e illfo@napier. govt. nz Doc ID: 306801 I^ I rf> * ? NAP!I^^ CF^^.., It'., CITYCOUNCIL 1<^>> e:>,? 76 Koujiihera o Alluriri Submission {o I' ^"'Ie 1101pier City Council F1>.!;DC1-*/I CliffiPi!\' ;3I--:V!_ Ally 20/6 All submissions In ust be in wi'iting. You may attach a mole detailed submission if yoLi wish .,- , , ,.- Name !. .~ \/,. ~, * \ I I 16rganisation: Title/Position: Postal address: I Postcode Daytime contact details: Phone: Email I wislT to speak at the hearing (please ticl<): Yes No - If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time Summary of Submission: you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. r~ , J J f , ,- II -' I'., I, .. I ' ._ ~ ,\ *.~",\ ,\ t. , , ,'-~~*.', , . '. *,', *..' __; it\- .\ ~ f *,.* ,,** : . , I I'. I , . , C *-- >,, """"' *I re~,' ~>,. , I*. * if, ,. .,^ >* . . '*.' , ..~.. I- t , I I I , I. I I ,, 1< , 'I' " ' L=L} * * *' .. , '.,, "i , J I, ..~,. -\ \,- A \-,. \ ,, I. I \ I'- , I' :_-** , },>< \ ,.* \ .. L. *-~ - I*,: ,\!/ '.. ,-.,.,'- I, I *"' ' I 11 *- : *,, I\. ' \ , I, ', I. . I'-'/I'*, " , , ,c,.'* ~, It A ,**,, ' L* ~~,/", I ,, ,; -^ *" I I " ' I-.. *** *, . -~/, ; \: .;~'- * ;/~ ** , , ,.- , * ~. .. .,: . * ..- V * <.' *.. ~ -,: '^=:\__:_., . j * . , ^ J , I -. I, .- ,, ;t- .. I\4: .. A I'; :(,~ - ^. . , \r. * 4'4_** . .,\ , ,_ .,. , .,, I- I~, ,-^. , . Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Return to: this form (plus supporting documents if I'equired), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council By law Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council . You may speak in support of your submission. Please PI'ivate Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 . You do not have to attend this meeting . Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public Cms;!;g clefte f4}r saw^^isei, t's is 12nm, Fukiay 28 47ct0*!31' 2016 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 ' t +6468357579 h f +6468357574 Private Bag 6010. Napier 4142 ., If. ,vJUJ. 'lapisY. 94>Vt. ', a e info@napier. govt. nz ,,^. ,.\ , '*-~*. ~' Doc ID: 306801 .. , I^I . . .* .Jt~ ,-" ..^, , ..- **-- , , ! . \ \; ~:- . .. ,, .- ,. ^ '~;,- . I , , ; , , .. ,, ~ , ; ,.., ,' .,- I .- . ^\- ; : . ; , --. . , , ~ _ *., ,.. f ,: . .~ ~ , , ~ - ....\ , ; ,.. \.. , t , : , \ ,;' I~ , . . ^ ;-. ,. -./ .; . I ~..,:, . I ,.. * . .^ f , . -: . * , 1'12- JP ':;I I' I^^!APIE^ 62 ,,,,, ;^3 CITYCOUNCIL ^:.> "^'I 76 Kaunihero o Ahuriri Submission to he I\/^pier City COLI, ^atI Fiji:I:DC 1-11 C/^IvjpI I\^13 .,\/I A\A1 ??16 All submissions must be in writing. You may attach a more detailed submission if you wish. Name !.* Organisation Title/Position: ^,. Postal address: I Postcode Daytime contact details: I phone: IE, ail' I wish to speal< at the hearing (please tick): Yes .- No ~- -.- . If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate cleai'Iy whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s), or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary ~ 01':.\A?0*~'t~Go *,,, . Submissions must be made either in writing. by way of Return to: this form (plus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council By law Review Submissions search 1 Closing date for submissions is 12p;n, I;:rida\; 28 Oct(}!1161' 2016 231 Hastings Street, Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 Private Bag 6010. Napier 4142 I f +6468357574 ,,,!v. "'J. 'iai, ICr. g, ,vi . 12 I e info@napier. govt. nz Doc ID: 306801 I--~I ? Yi 11vi Q S >713I*) \7", a, - '11/1 1'0 V ^V\' I L I'! \:200 J. ,\ ?',,(24^" ;\IN ,?, *.; I^/-21\VB ;;" 07'0'I\, I ILL I ~I;, L?-I, ~),,.. Ij177 a n I) *'vt 0 , 13 (>Y-I > S I -HJ- ? I A1 I I' ' 'IL. - I ' ,':, I~LL. 'p I~^A I A \ ~I I~\'71\{F?',> _find <1.7*! 3.9~law, 31-\ PI O UNe\A1 41. L0I\11 ',"LA\=., 0I'.?.!\'\ ~) \7, '~\}31\2;.. A: ---...,=) F1 ,, <,, .z' A v\-~\ 71^-~" 16. J-- -b ~",.~- ? !\e--\ ~;? P O ~,!.:=\ I, C; 0-3 ? \, fj <1! I\23\ j, ~ ,*\,,-'-I, _I, vin_, _:=,, 0 ,Z?, j ?'~D- ,^' ' .a*'\/ OF;;~ .93I* o 1:0'TIP? ^' '" a AV\'1 O\~a\I "'QJ, 3 ' 17:<:0 UV \,' , '\,\/ Q 0,231}. 03 N I VJ--- I~' 00 6''1. ^, S to ON ;^, 2.1 :51- ' \-I r\} I ~ ' LLD. 0 I, -\ ~ 0 _2_Fly S\ S I I\ _L- - IVO{_I I, ^^_L. 1'15 I\, GP fj I\! I~ LL. I ,,, I-\,,','I 931 >._21' _^^'I a)~VJ-*}.;^,,, V I, I'll I'D'0' " ';3\) ~', b'I\) Q \?ia, } 01"'0' .IDOL, Do ?, I\\O I~. 10 <}^.~L D '," d IV I A 'L!_ !\ V~D "7'' ' b's ^; 'd'+I S I H I ^ t bl Iq~s Kiin Anstey From: NCC Website Request - Submission Freedom Camping Bylaw Name * Craig Daly Postal I^'~I Address * 53 Nelson Quay Napier 4/10 New Zealand Daytime 8335/50 Contact phone * Email crai andsa@ mail. coin Address * If you wish Yes to speak at the Hearing we will contact you to arrange a time. Hearings will be scheduled after the consultation period. I wish to speak at the Hearing (please tick): * \ I I^^ I, 13 Type Submission or attach below The bylaw proposes to prohibit freedom camping for the whole of the Westshore seafront and to also remove the Northern Ocean Spa carpark as a freedom camping site, but to leave the Perfume Point carpark as a designated site. This will only divert all the current Westshore and Northern Ocean Spa freedom campers to then use the already highly occupied (by Motorhomes) Perfume Point site The issues identified by Council to back the bylaw change are:- I - Protection of the area 2 - Health and Safety 3 - Protection of access to popular areas These also all apply to the Perfume Point site. In fact they are even MORE pertinent to the Perfume Point site than the Westshore and the Northern Ocean Spa carpark sites. This is because Perfume Point site is:- - a place of recreational, social and significant to Napier - Provides access to "Ahuriri Beach" - Provides access for surfers to Rangatira Reef - A VERY popular picnic spot and also a site where citizens and workers of Napier Lunch and eat dinner - A site where peoplejust come and park to enjoy the unique views which no other sites have - Used for sporting events, drink stops, watching and controlling sea events - Is a premium site, but is restricted in size and hence should be reserved for residents and citizens of Napier (and Hawkes Bay) and not be overtaken by Freedom Campers. Attached photos are Photo I showing Motorhome bus taking up 6 carparks Photo 2 showing Motorhome blocking footpath Photo 3 showing Motorhome taking up multiple parks and make using the footpath uncomfortable SUMMARY - The proposed bylaw will result in the Perfume Point carpark (Napier's Premium seaside carpark) being overwhelmed with motorhomes and its use being denied to the people of Napier. Therefore the first site that should have freedom camping prohibited in Napier is Perfume Point 1.1 =:=" - Attach a File e rf u in e 01nt hotos_I 2 _3. docx I o1 2.12 KB - Docx . a :;*-.-- Attach a File erfume_ o1nt hotos I_2__31. docx I o12.12 KB - Docx 2 OCT 2016 Iq4-- NAPIER CITYCOUNCIL 7^ Kaunihera o Ahuriri S b is ion of heNa ie Cit Co cil E 01^I G All submissions must be in writing. You may attach a more detailed submission if you wish. Name E I I ^ ,^.^o2\\\ =I^aQ. C. \^ e A 2. . ( 1<1.5ICUir, ^/ , , Organisation ^,~ . .-=>L -~. ~ - Title/Position Q'Aq^^I_/.,, ,. I_^, Q, 171,PTO^Q. ^""' ( 95 ~ ' ~' ~I Postal address . ^^^ I' , ^" .. .^. postcode: IF I I O Daytime contact details Phon, 'I Eru I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick) I"^^ No If you wish to speak at the hearing. we will contact you to arrange a time Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s). or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary 62. a. c^.^'0. c.\.\a c;\ ^,\\e. e. ^!.^ OF ^^^e. \^.^\S CAI>e. o Re Q. s, +!rig ^\OS, ^,,_^!_s_,^;,_s. t^I^I^.<,~ I'e. ^\:AC\:2.01 _ Qre. 9.5_IDCe. $2, -\\-\.:,, @96\\^.!0\e. .+. s> Se. ^ - cor~,\0. \;^, I. F;'^,. e, .^!.^_Ify. ^ C, .Q. "6_{=1<.. t' \/Q. Y\S~ Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Return to: this form (plus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council By law Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a tim NAPIER 4142 You do not have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public Closing date for submissions is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 , +6468357574 WWW. napier. govt. nz e Info@napier. govt. nz Doc ID: 306801 I^^- The residents of the Quayside Apartments situated in Nelson Quay, Ahuriri, are opposed to the proposed closure by the NCC of 3 of the 5 Napier restricted areas presently available to Self- contained Freedom Campervans. ( See below ) This proposal takes no consideration of the impact on the Perfume Point Carpark, which has already suffered a " More than minor change to the environment " under the present Bylaw. : Five Self Contained sites for Freedom Cain in in Na ier I Northern Ocean Spa Car Park 2 Perfume Point Car Park 3 Westshore Beach Reserve Car Park North 4 Westshore Beach Reserve Car Park South Ellison Street Car Park on Marine Parade During last summer, afte, constant overcrowding of the Perfume Point site by large campervans and buses, a complaint was made to the then Ahuriri Ward Coundllor, Mark Herbert, requesting that something be done to restore the original usage of the site to cars during the day. He replied that the problem was created by the Government and that NCC had no ability to redress the situation anywhere. This was patently untrue in view of the present Bylaw change being tabled. We submit the following points from the NCC documentation. Some quoted are as relevant to Perfume Point Carpark as they are to Westshore. STATEMENT of PROPOSAL Item I Protect the area Perfume Point carpark, Quote : is a place of recreational, social and environmental significance to Napier Historically it is a scenic beauty viewing point which encompasses views to West , North and North East, and the marked sealed carpark is utilised by the rate-paying public of Napier, and by tourists, who swim on the nearby East Pier Beach, fish from the rocks, picnic on the reserve, watch the yachting ,boating or other water activities, orjust enjoy a wonderful vista of sea and hills. Item 2 Protect the health and safety of people who may visit the area. The public toilet block on Perfume Point carpark should be safely available to users of the walkway adjacent, to swimmers for changing, and for anyone in need! It is frequently blocked after use by Campervan owners to do their personal washing. Note: There is no Effluent Discharge Tank available at Perfume Point. The size of the Campervans often exceeds the marked carparks and access on the footpaths is impeded for wheelchair users, and there is danger for small children or the elderly with the overhang of the vehicles. The size of the Campervans and Buses frequently means that they occupy 3 or 4 marked parking spaces. * I^+ * The road entry and egress to the Carpark and its proximity to the East Pier Hotel constitutes a traffic hazard when both sides of the road and round the corner are completely parked up because of functions at the Conference Facility requiring more space than the Hotel carpark provides. This is also a hazard during summer when vehicles plus boat trailers are also lining both sides of the approaches on a blind corner. Item 3 Protection of access to popular areas. Perfume Point, Quote "is a special area to both daytime visitors and local residents. At the moment the continual presence of freedom campers over the popular summertime peak season is restricting people's enjoyment of this area. Thereforeitis appropriate for Councilto introduce restrictions on freedom camping in this area to manage these issues We would like to submit the following option for the NCC to consider in relation to the Perfume Point Carpark and the proposed FREEDOM CAMPING BYLAW 201.6 That Freedom Camping as a Restricted Area on the Perfume Point Carpark during Daylight Saving Summertime be between 8pm and 9am only ; and during the rest of the year Spin and 9am only. Campervans be required to adhere to all NCC rules regarding parking re within marked spaces and riot overhanging footpaths for public safety. Owners also to use their on board toilet facilities. NAPIER I^5 errYcouNciL I^ Kawuliera o Ahwir, ' . . All submissions must be in writing. You may attach a in o1'e detailed submission if you wish. I Name: Jo. n e. 5 <,"++0 I, I Organisation: I Title/position: I Postal address: ,- Postcode: I Daytime contact details: I Phone Email: I wish to speak at the hearing (please tick): Yes No If you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s), or i you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary. ^.".<;^^a. ,, co"^^ I^^ A ^+ I^^;'^:^in f6 ',+ Of POS I^ I 6 low 6 .I e- ^ 006.5 lion' 16.5+r. c+ Q. cce. sJ +-0 '- L, ,10/1c c^reQS I ^1<3, ^t, se ^; ^^! ,^. I'h, ^.. cl-, e^!^ ,S +of^^ tvi 6.0 ^ 61 lid' 10 I'^ 0 '+0 J OS*^*^A {0 ~IL^^J-, IL, , J ^"' Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Return to: this form CPIus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council By!aw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAP!ER 4142 You do not have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public Closing date for submissions is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 Private Bag 6010. Napier 4142 ,+6468357574 WWW napier. govt. nz e info@napier. govt. nz Doc ID: 306801 I^5 Jane Sutton 28/10/20L66:57 AM Freedom Camping bylaw 6.1. .e - Does riot restrict access to public areas. I am opposed to certain areas being allowed for freedom camping - Westshore, Perfume Point and Marine Parade Ocean Spa end. We appear to give freedom campers choices to park in our most popular public leisure areas without any contribution to their upkeep. I do riot however want to see them having to pay to park up, but would rather them be able to park for free on the outskirts - one area which seems ideal and working well is at the end of the Marine Parade by the children's pump park and then further on to the next parking area, and gets used regularly - great!! ! I have observed over the past couple of years an invasion of camper vans. I am not opposed to freedom campers on the outskirts of Napier, but at key areas where the general public enjoy public spaces, that is where I draw the line. Last summer at perfume point which is a small parking area - numerous camper vans and buses would clog the area deeming it, at times, unsafe as driving views were restricted. This area is a high volume area for walkers and cyclists, young families enjoying the views of the bay and seating areas and the elderly who can enjoy a short walk and sit. Many times the buses/vans obstruct the pathways, as they park over the path, because their vehicles are too long for the carpark space. Some vans/buses take up more than one carpark. I have witnessed a couple parked up with their bus, and in the next space set up their picnic table and cooking stove and blithely eating their meal - do they contribute to Napier's economy in any way? I took photos of one incident recently - I wanted to take my elderly mum out, who cannot walk far and parked at Perfume Point - a bus was two parks away but the park next to us was also being used by them, as they had their steps set up, to come and go from the bus - on the other side was a picnic chair in front of what I assumed was their private car. Their dog was tied up and enjoying the bushes along with its feeding bowl. What I found most offensive was the fact they had placed another picnic chair in front of the bus and were reading their book, right on the pathway, blatanly or obliviously blocking access to all who were wanting to use the cycle/walkway. Everyone had to walk around them or onto the grass. Why they couldn't move it a short distance onto the grass I don't know. This was at lunchtime on a Sunday afternoon, where many of the public were enjoying the walkways. Could they riot park in the fishing carpark and walk along the cycle/walkways as we all do??? And then move on to the end of the Marine Parade?? I look forward to hearing the results of this and hope Ijoin with many others, who would like to see these most popular areas FREE to all. Kind regards o Jane Sutton d See photos atta ed I"'Ime I^S I^> t A + c, ,^c IC?I' UVO- I v\/"'Cj ' I Qjl^mule +^e^, Lot ^ +I^!,, 4---, ^^ PICn*C CF\a, / is i A {'{o0.1 - 30'1^ 0\J 0,1<" OA I^ 0^ I I^ my' 4:1 I', I I D, I^ ^21' * ^,, o 14,061<'/ b ct. S ^"" V\I I 11, I\I I ^:212.bot^I at, IN . . ^-- s+^!.^s I, , Cor^11 I A CAO^ O^*\ 0 ^ b**5 , ^ 1'14; NAPIER CITYCOUNCIL 76 Kaunihero o Ahuriri . . U in!SSIO . . o1e ' . urici! FR E. CM , PIN a W20 . All submissions must be in writing. You may attach a more detailed submission if you wish Name: 17"\ I\-/ if^uC/C! OA/V Organisation I"", Title/Position: Postal address: Postcoc , Daytime contact details Phc Eine wish to speak at the hearing (please tick) Yes No f you wish to speak at the hearing, we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s), or I you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet i necessary. b, ^"' IYl vC_ /,/ <7 I:^' /^"625^"^^;;: 177^ I'i^/29^.'I 0-^- ~ ^-.., t^:" ^2.0 IC^a 111 f'e=^ 12^'c, 111 ^. I^^^/ ^- 77 717-/ S~~ 11'1^:65:29 I-S" C \,, IZ/2.6, v Ie^^' C--' S60 123 I-O <, 2'7C. ,5:1~ Juli"'O I 'V ' 1:2='- C^::-IC 1'1itz I"/,'^ 4.1<, I' < I^" I I<""' C__ Ac In .E^'o. 12. ,^//, , I:.../9~^;;::" ^.- ';^, 1'1'~/E^.,^^-/^-- s I')--<._.. , -c o fc, ~^' C, \/ ^ I^' c. ,^; *^:I S^, A"^', 9^,,^ ^<'z^-,:?0 ^ c. ^-- ^, I ^.<.^" I'D IH' I .S:~~ IV\ I"\--/< C='7 1. <)- I^" , ^^' 7~'I^a. _, e~1"/ IC Co ?-~"') <'C','~ 7>'0 A1 . Submissions must be made either in writing, by way of Return to: this form (plus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council Bylaw Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council . You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 . You do not have to attend this meeting . Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public. Closing date for submissions Is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 , +6468357574 Doc ID: 30680\ WWW. napier. govt. nz e info@napier. govt. nz 19> NA IER CITYCOUNCIL 76 Kaunihera o Ahwiri . . . . . Is SIo o ' . o1er g. I . Do , .N a A o1. All submissions must be in writing. You may attach a more detailed submission If you wish. Name: *. <11. . ~ v ^ L'. o<^.,., IF, . ^ . . Organisation ^V , ,, \ Title/Position ,\^;^',,~, ^.,_^ ' Postal address: , 00 ^^..,,.}, ^,/ in I\)+:^.,,-'~~~ ~T~~ Postcode Daytime contact details: Phone Email wish to speak at the hearing (please tick): Yes No f you wish to speak at the hearing. we will contact you to arrange a time. Summary of Submission: Please identify what your issue is. Indicate clearly whether you support or oppose the specific provision(s), or if you want to have them changed and state your reasons. Continue on a separate sheet if necessary \ ., ^. A , 00 R 3"'\ 0 0 \;'^,^b.,^!^^ F^^,^,!..^ C^. , ' Q. . PI,,-,, o ,, ^^ , ee, , 0 12_911.5^.,:j, try\ Q. ^.. \ ' , \ ^ 0\c^^... I libc e, .c. '^;. ,^. ' \^_ . ' I^ - ' ^ ^,^^Ie. ,-- I +^ '^s ' -+^.,,\, T' ^* " ,^Q_ 1.16, ~. ^^;:*;;^.^^^Submissions must ^^;I^{^;^^^',^^^!:!^^t;^*;^I^^I^^^,,^"""","" be made either in writing, by way of Return to: ""' I Q-Y\^i-e. .r's"a^. " SI this form (plus supporting documents if required), or FREEPOST 172273 online by going to WWW. napier. govt. nz and entering the Napier City Council By law Review Submissions search keyword: #freedomcampingbylaw Napier City Council You may speak in support of your submission. Please Private Bag 6010 include a daytime phone number for us to arrange a time NAPIER 4142 You do not have to attend this meeting Your submission will be included in the agenda for the meeting which is available to the public Closing date for submissions is 12pm, Friday 28 October 2016 231 Hastings Street. Napier 4/10 t +6468357579 , +6468357574 WWW.Private napier. Bag govt.6010. nz Napier 414' I e info@napier. govt. nz Doc ID: 306801