I Love You: a Theory of Love
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
I LOVE YOU 1 FRANCESCO ALBERONI I LOVE YOU (A THEORY OF LOVE ) I LOVE YOU 2 CHAPTER ONE LOVE AND THE COUPLE A science of love There are many kinds of love, like a mother’s, a brother or sister’s, or a friend’s. But here we will be talking about the passionate, erotic kind of love which exists between lovers, between a husband and wife, i.e. the love binding a couple together - the kind of love that makes us say “I love you”. We will be trying to understand how it begins, what forms it takes, how it develops, what problems it may meet, and why it ends or endures. It is the kind of love that can grow slowly out of friendship or explode at first sight. It can be a passing infatuation burning itself out in a few days or months, or it can last for years, even a lifetime. It can be made of torrid sexuality or sweet tenderness, it may never I LOVE YOU 3 develop beyond unsatisfied passion or it may bloom into marriage. It can turn into an idyll or a conflict, fade away into routine, or carry along with it all the vibrance and freshness of its early stages. A person who loves and wishes that love to be returned will ponder over innumerable questions, knowing that passion, jealousy, dreams, ideals, eroticism and love can either make life wonderful or turn it into hell. Gestures that make us happy or words that plunge us into despair come from very few human beings indeed, only those to whom we are intensely and inextricably bound.i The greatest triumph can be poisoned by a cruel word or lack of attention from the one we love. What can the answer be to such questions? There is as yet no theory, no science of love, non “eros-ology” we can today turn to! Yet being a couple has acquired great importance in the modern world. Once upon a time there was the extended family, which included a whole circle of relations. Nowadays people marry because “they like each other”, because “they are in love”. They stay together while they continue to find each other attractive, and feel they are still in love. If “they no longer love each other”, however, having children no I LOVE YOU 4 longer holds as sufficient reason for staying together - so only the bond of love between man and woman remains to hold the union together. It is a bond that unites two individuals who are consequently far freer, richer and maturer. Each has a personal set of connections, a separate job, and autonomous political and religious ideas. The couple is therefore a dynamic unit, a creative melting pot where two personalities come together, form an alliance, talk things over and complement each other, in order to confront a world which has become more and more complicated. Love is the driving force behind this tension and this union. But what does being in love mean? What is the meaning of “I love you”?ii Some people say they are always falling in love or never fall out of it. Others hold that falling in love is a fairly rare occurrence in a single lifetime. And then during a moment of confidence a person will happen to confess to having had numerous love affairs but only one great love. Many meanings indeed lie behind the words falling in love, love, caring, affection, tenderness, passion and sexual attraction. Our aim is to put some order into this untidy state of affairs by creating the basis for a real science of love. We intend to set up a survey and to categorize the various forms of love so as I LOVE YOU 5 to make it easier for readers to recognize their own experiences, understand what processes gave rise to them, and what possible lines of development there may be. We are offering a map, an explanation, a guide. The bonds of love Love bonds can be classified as strong, medium or weak. Strong bonds are those that are formed in infancy between a child and its parents, and between brothers and sisters. Strong bonds are exclusive, for nobody can take the place of a mother, a father, or a child. These bonds withstand any alteration in character or appearance. Sons and daughters continue to love their mother even when she is old, ugly or ailing. Mothers and fathers continue to love their children even if they become delinquents, drug addicts, or even if they have been disfigured and marred by illness. The only force that is capable of establishing a strong bond outside infancy and outside family ties is falling in love. Two people with no previous knowledge of each other fall in love and become mutually indispensable, as in a I LOVE YOU 6 child/parent relationship. This is indeed a truly fascinating phenomenon! Medium bonds are those we develop with intimate friends, the people we trust, the people we confide in. Friendship is free and disinterested, without any of the jealousy or envy that can even surface between siblings. Nevertheless, even the closest friendships are vulnerable. If a friend deceives or betrays us something is gone forever, and though we can forgive, the rapport never recovers its former splendour. If we quarrel with mothers, fathers, brothers or sisters, the bond resists the test, and after a while all is forgiven and forgotten. This just does not happen in the case of friendship. A violent argument, insults, threats and affronts leave wounds that are unlikely to heal. We can prefer friends to brothers or sisters, trusting them more than our siblings, but friendship is ultimately a bond in the second category. It is vulnerable to abuse, and when it breaks down it has gone forever. Lastly there is the category of weak bonds. These are set up with colleagues, neighbours and holiday friends. Many forms of sexual attraction, even intense ones, go to form weak bonds. We can like a person or be overcome by a great passionate desire, but it only takes a rude word or I LOVE YOU 7 vulgar gesture to make us stop wanting to be with them. Sometimes, once the sex act is over, all we want to do is to get away. The fact that a bond is weak does not mean that we forget the relationship. On the contrary, we may remember it with pleasure for the rest of our lives. Certain erotic experiences leave an indelible impression and we remember the intense glances, the desire and the frantic contact between bodies. We remember with a touch of nostalgia something which might have developed into something. Between two people who have made love there remains a rarefied bond of confidence and trust, or even of complicity, which comes close to friendship. A weak bond relationship means only that we do not feel the need to remain with that person, that their presence is not missed. The two of us do not make up a compact unit, an “us” united by faith, love, duty or destiny. Where to start Where shall we start our research on the love binding two people together? Since a couple forms a stable relationship which lasts in time, we must begin by looking at strong bonds. If you ask I LOVE YOU 8 people why they got married they will say “Because I was in love”. We must therefore examine first of all the act of falling in love. Yet looking through magazines and articles dealing with love and the couple, we see no studies or reports on falling in love. Prevalent is the Freud-based idea that love grows slowly out of erotic attraction satisfied.iii It all begins with an exchange of glances. If the other person responds in the same way, bodies start to come into contact: hands touch and then clasp. Then comes the first kiss and the first rendezvous. When all goes well, intercourse may follow, with complete physical fusion. A little later will come tenderness, passion and intimacy. Because according to this way of thinking, the better the understanding and the better the mutual satisfaction, the stronger the love. At last the partner will seem indispensable and we feel lost without him or her. At this point we are in love. In other words, falling in love would seem to be a gradual process, born out of reciprocal satisfaction. This idea of falling in love is, however, contradicted by what really happens since it usually explodes rapidly after a gradual and uncertain beginning. In English and in French, in fact, the expressions fall in love and tomber I LOVE YOU 9 amoureux are used. It often happens that two people feel love before any sexual encounter, feel desire before getting to know each other well, and the one may go after the other even without there being any reciprocal response.iv Passionate love does not grow gradually because of mutual sexual satisfaction. It explodes unexpectedly between two strangers and draws them irresistibly towards each other. It is not limited to sexual desire alone, nor to tenderness. It is something different. It is a new state of emotions - unknown, unexpected and inebriating. It is at the beginning of a relationship that love is at its most intense and passionate. If anything, it declines with the passing of time, familiarity and intimacy. The process is the exact opposite of what should happen according to the Freud-based idea of gradual reinforcement. To understand the love process we should not start from low down the scale with sexual attraction and then gradually move up.