Russia Turned Upside Down
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
RUSSIA TURNED UPSIDE DOWN ot Marx, but Machiavel- atavistic to the socialist view as li, has clearly been Mik Nationalism, it can simply fold up its hail Gorbachev's special tent and, at least in the shape of its study. The history of leader, attempt to retain office in these 20th-century politics has new conditions, in what did it consist? rarely afforded such a What was it all about? spectacle of political opportunism as he For this was no principled split or has displayed in these past weeks. Here assumption of a new direction - like is a man, born into a communist family, that among the Italian socialists after whose advance was at all times under the war, or for the German SPD at Bad the party's protective aura, who had had Godesburg in 1959, or in the British no other job than to work within its Labour Party when it produced the SDP ranks, who rose to be its leader and in 1980. These moments were properly remained so... until, using the powers of marked - in polemic, debate, bitterness his post as head of state, which leader lasting decades, all the paraphernalia of ship of the party had obtained for him, a proper fraternal dispute. There had he banned it. seemed to be something over which to In doing so, he cancelled the political argue. Yet the cancellation of the Com existence and in many cases the careers munist Party of the Soviet Union took of millions. To be sure, many were glad place with the stroke of a pen, 24 hours to be so liberated: many, perhaps the after the party's general secretary majority, held their cards from inertia, came back from internal captivity say or a residual fear of losing the few ing that the most urgent task he had in privileges they might have. But others mind was the party's democratization had been looking for some kind of trans and renewal. It took place while the formation, for a conscious working party still had about 15m members, at through of what communism could now least on paper; when it was still, in a become, how it should rid itself of the formal if neither in a legal or actual incubus of its own past, how it could sense, the ruling party of the Soviet take responsibility, at last, for the chaos Union. it did so much to create. They had beenj looking, in fact, for exoneration through Times change, of course. The CPSU was a Good Works. Gorbachev simply dropped dinosaur waiting to crash to the ground, them in the trash can, then got up the all hollow bones and wasting cells. It. next morning and went about his daily was stopping more vigorous forms of At a stroke, the major work - lightened, no doubt, by being life from reaching the vegetation. It shorn of the duties of being Stalin's was an idea whose time was up. But for politicians shaping the successor. all that, should it not have been given a He has since sat on a US chat show with more decent - or for that matter inde future of the Union are Boris Yeltsin, who had handed in Len- cent - send off? It has been so hole in nin's banner a little earler and actually the corner - save for the brilliant suddenly ex-communists. with rather more ceremony, and public act of taking Feliz Dzerzhinsky listened to his now close colleague in off his plinth before the headquarters of John Lloyd wonders where arms say that communism had been an the KGB he created and the further, the country is heading, and unmitigated disaster, without offering less telegenic, removals of such lumina the least protest. Nothing, it seemed, ries as Kalinin and Sverdlov from their does socialism have no part remained of a dedication to the party central Moscow bases. Nothing has which was the content of hundreds of been set in train which would purge it to play? speeches, thousands of obeisances to from society - all that has been done is the Gods of the ideology, hundreds of to knock it down and cover it up. thousands of routine acts of furthering lmost every major politi the party's grasp for all of his adult, and cian in power today, who even part of his childhood, life. aspires to recreate what Among the many marvels we have was the Soviet Union or seen in recent weeks in the Soviet Union Awho aspires to further its disintegra is the sight of a man who appears to give tion, was a communist, and often until the lie to any assumption that living and recently a leading one. For much of working for a political faith especially their adult lives they conducted their one as all embracing and ideologically political careers according to its rules - butressed as communism - was in the even if, as Eduard Shevardnadze claims end more than simply a calculation in his recent memoirs, or as Boris Yelt about power. Here, in the holy of social sin claimed in his, they were determi ist holies, we see that the same betrayal nedly iconoclastic and liberal, this was of a faith is possible as that which has not the impression others always had of been undertaken by most, if not all, of them. the western leaders of socialism in its The party intellectuals who have worthwhile democratic version: Mitte- now come to power, like Gavril Popov, rand, Gonzales, Hawke, Kinnock and the Moscow mayor, were indeed on the their circles. If, before a movement as reformist side - but reformism was 12 MARXISM TODAY OCTOBER 1991 until recently encapsulable in a relat decision taken by Popov on August 29 to worth preserving which pointed out ively rigid framework, with the reform shut down the museum by October 1 of that there had been exploitation: he did ists guarding their own idelogical fron this year, and move its displays to the not specify how far he thought him tiers, none of them very far over to the exhibition of the Russian Revolution in relevant today. Bikennin, a courtly man right. Now, they are the preachers of Tverskaya Street a few hundred yards who helped persuade Gorbachev to quit market and democratic principles of a away. Most of those taking part were the party because he believed, with quality so pure, so urgent, that western middle-aged or elderly; the basic Yakovlev, that the party had hopelessly liberals and social democrats chide themes of all the arguments was the compromised itself during the coup, is them, when they come to town for the view that the Popov decision was unde to replace Kommunist with a new ma Grand Tour, on their naivety: not every mocratic, against the opposing belief gazine from October, to be called Svo- thing on our side is wonderful, you that the communists had it coming. One bodnoye Misl - 'Free Thought'. Again, know! We have our problems, our poor, old man engaged in a long sarcastic quite a jump - even for one who, as he our injustices! (To which the answer, monologue at the expense of past CPSU had, consistently kept Kommunist on especially from those who do know leaders; around him, three old women, the side of the reformers since taking something about the West, is - give us with only a few teeth between them, the editorial chair in 1987. your problems, because to us they look jabbed at him angrily with their fingers, It is not, in fact, likely that the Move like solutions.) invoking 'our' party, 'our' Lenin, 'our' ment for Democratic Reform will be On a Sunday in the middle of this country. able to display much of a leftist ideolo month (September) I went to visit the t had something of the air of a gical stance - since it is not very likely main Lenin museum, which flanks an madhouse, or at least of the that it will be more than a top people's ' entrance to Red Square (on 'Historical eccentricity of those who were lifeboat out of the party. None of the Lane')- It is the largest exhibition of powerless and half-daft. Those intellectuals among the movements' I Leninalia in the world: it has many of whIo were left to pick up the baton for founders - Yakovlev himself, Nikolai 'The rich, his letters, books, even clothes, the Ilyich were not the men in the Volgas, Petrakov and Stanislav Shatalin, two the new chairs he sat on, even the fireplace from let alone in the Zils, who had owed hihi radical economists - have any vestige business the house in London in which he and his their ideological cover for so many of socialist belief left as far as can be wife lived. It has the Rolls Royce he years. It was those who were too silly or seen. Yakovlev spent some time before class, are not used in the last years of his power, with too stubborn or too possessed or too actually quitting the party musing attractive to the information that the car passed into angered to give him up, who did not aloud about whether bolshevism was Western the possession of the Crimean Fish realise that the modern style was to worse than nazism, coming to the con intellectuals, Workers party committee in the 1930s. pass by on the other side, to confine any clusion, on tv, that 'nothing is worse In every room there is a portrait of expression of former allegiance to him than bolshevism'. Neither Petrakov nor or indeed to Lenin, usually in heroic or heuristic or to a brief, humorous shrug; who were Shatalin have any time for even mildly Soviet declamatory mode: one shows him help still out there fighting.