Status of the Osprey in Southeastern Montana Before and After the Construction of Reservoirs

Home , Fort Custer (Montana), Musselshell River

STATUS OF THE OSPREY IN SOUTHEASTERN MONTANA BEFORE AND AFTER THE CONSTRUCTION OF RESERVOIRS

JON E. SWENSON, Montana Departmentof Fish, Wildlife, and Parks, Box 36, Rosebud, Montana 59347

Ospreys (Pandion l•aliaetus)readily colonizesuitable habitat created by manmadeimpoundments. Henny et al. (1978a) found that about47 percent of the Ospreysin Oregon, and a greaterpercentage of thosein the interiorof the state, nest along reservoirs.In northern California, about 20 percent of the Ospreysnest along reservoirs,including 49 percent in the interior of the region (Henny et al. 1978b). Henny et al. (1978a,b) suspectedthat Osprey numbers had increased in both areas due to the construction of the reservoirs. Also, Henny and Noltemeier (1975) and Henny et al. (1978b) have describedsituations where Ospreys or their progeny, nesting on natural lakes, have colonizednearby reservoirs as nestsites became less available at the natural lakes. Childress and Eng (1979) documented an increased Ospreypopulation with the constructionof shallowimpoundments in an ex- istingreservoir. However, the establishmentof a breedingOsprey population in an area wherebreeding Ospreys were not previouslyfound hasapparently not been documented.This paper documentssuch a situation.

STUDY AREA AND METHODS The study area (Figure 1) comprisessoutheastern Montana, bounded on the northby the MissouriRiver (exceptthat the entireFort PeckReservoir on the MissouriRiver was included), on the southby Wyoming,on the westby the Bighorn River and the north-flowingportion of the MusselshellRiver, and on the east by North and South Dakota. This area containsno natural lakes, exceptfor oxbowson major rivers.Three mainstreamreservoirs have been constructed in this area: Fort Peck Reservoir (1,000 km 2) on the MissouriRiver in 1939, Tongue River Reservoir(14 km2) on the Tongue River in 1940 and Bighorn Lake or YellowtailReservoir (70 km2) on the BighornRiver in 1965. Other reservoirsare primarilysmall livestock reservoirs. On three areasstudied by Smith (1953) in southeasternMontana, livestockreservoirs occurred at a densityof 0.1 per km• and 124 reservoirs variedin sizefrom 0.04 to 7.7 ha, averaging1.3 ha. SoutheasternMontana is dominatedby Big Sagebrush(Artemi$ia tri½len- tara)steppe, but some grass-dominatedsteppes and PonderosaPine (Pinus pon½lerosa)forests and savannasare present.Plains Cottonwood (?opulu$ ½leltoi½le$)predominates along larger rivers and isscattered along most major creeks. Determinationof the former and presentstatus of Ospreyswas based primarilyon a literaturesearch. Several ornithologists visited the areaprior to 1910. Althoughcoverage was not usuallyintensive, activities were concen- WesternBirds 12:47-51, 1981 47 OSPREY IN MONTANA

tratedalong the watercourses,where Ospreys would be mostexpected. In- creasedenergy development since 1970 hasresulted in manywildlife studies in southeasternMontana. The resultsof these studies,discussions with other biologistsin the areaand my ownobservations were used to assessthe present statusof Ospreys.

RESULTS

HISTORICAL STATUS Lewisand Clarkdid not mentionthe Ospreyin theiraccounts of birdsseen along the Missouriand Yellowstonerivers in 1805 and 1806 in easternMon- tana and North Dakota, but they did recordthem from southwesternMon- tana (Reidand Gannon1927, Walcheck1976). Earlynaturalists did not mention seeing the Osprey during their explorations of the lower Yellowstone,Bighorn and Musselshell rivers (Allen 1874, McChesney 1879, Mearns1904). Cooper(1868) did not see Ospreys near the muddy waters of the MissouriRiver below Fort Benton, which is upstreamfrom my study area, whereas they were common on the rivers and their tributariesfrom therewestward. Thorne (1895) did notrecord Ospreys near Miles City, on the YellowstoneRiver, from 1888 to 1892. Cameron (1907) lived and traveledextensively in southeasternMontana during an 18-yearperiod aroundthe turn of the century,but did not observeOspreys.

FortPeckRes. /

200 km ,

'•e•'•heørn •on gueR. • •'•'•'! Res.

Figure1. Ospreystudy area in southeasternMontana. The lettersindicate the citiesof Billings(B) and Miles City (MC). The mapped area is shaded on the map of Montana. 48 OSPREY IN MONTANA

Apparently, the only early referencesto Ospreysin this general area are the earlyfall recordsof Jonesand Dawson(1900), who observedthe species from a train alongthe YellowstoneRiver betweenBillings and MilesCity on 13 August 1900, and Visher (1911), who saw one on 2 September1910 along the Little MissouriRiver in northwesternSouth Dakota. These birds may have been migrantssince fall migrationgenerally occurs from mid- Septemberto mid-Octoberin southeasternMontana (Hinz 1977).

PRESENT STATUS The Ospreyis a rare breedingbird in southeasternMontana. Only 11 pairs are known to nest there. Nine of thesepairs nest along Fort Peck Reservoir (CharlesM. RussellNational Wildlife Refuge files, 1980). One nestis present on the upper end of Tongue River Reservoir(Knapp 1977) and, although there are no known nestson BighornLake (Steve Swedbergpers. comm. 1981), one may occurnear YellowtailDam, basedon the repeatedobserva- tions of Ospreys there during two summers (R. Stevenson pers. comm. 1975). One activeOsprey nest was also located on a largelivestock reservoir 8 km westof Jordan (B. Hildebrandpers. comm. 1980). No Ospreynests were found by Hinz (1977) during his intensive2-year studyof the aquatic birdsof the lower YellowstoneRiver and, to my knowledge,there are no Osprey nestsalong any riversin southeasternMontana. In adjacentNorth Dakota, Stewart (1975) reported only three known nestinglocalities for Ospreys;all were alongreservoirs and all were recordedafter 1951.

DISCUSSION The paucityof Ospreyobservations during the breedingseason by early naturalistsand the presentlack of Ospreysnesting along rivers strongly sug- gestthat the speciesdid not nestin southeasternMontana prior to the constructionof reservoirs.In contrast,Ospreys occurred historically in western Montana (Betts1916, Saunders1921) and now nest there alongnatural lakes, riversand reservoirs(Childress and Eng 1979, MacCarterand Mac- Carter1979, Swenson1979). Earlyobservers noted that the Ospreywas not found on the lower MissouriRiver where the water was muddy (Cooper 1868, Grinnell 1876). The turbidwater, which is stillpresent in the riversof southeasternMontana, probablywould makefishing too difficultto allowthe Ospreysto raiseyoung. Hinz (1977) notedthat migrationof Ospreysalong the lower YellowstoneRiver occurredwhen turbidityand flow were low, which supportsthis contention. Ospreysnest in the boreallakes region of centralCanada (Houstonet al. 1977) and someof thesebirds probably migrate through southeastern Mon- tana. Ospreysfrom western Montana probablydo not migratethrough southeasternMontana, because the speciesdoes not appearto wanderwide- ly to the east or west duringmigration (Henny and Van Velzen 1972, Ken- nedy 1973, Melquist et al. 1978). Since not all 2-year-old Ospreys (subadults)return to their natal vicinity (Henny and Van Velzen 1972), subadultsfrom central Canadian populations were probably "short-stopped"

49 OSPREY IN MONTANA at favorable reservoirsin southeasternMontana and originallypopulated them. The reducedturbidity of the water and the creationof still, shallow areas in the large reservoirsprobably created suitable foraging habitat (Childressand Eng 1979). The very small population (probably 15-20 pairs) of Ospreys in southeastern Montana indicates that few of the reservoirs are suitable for Ospreysand that the area is marginalOsprey habitat. But it appearsthat the creation of these reservoirs has resulted in the establishment of a small breedingpopulation of Ospreyswhere one did not existpreviously. These resultsadd strengthto the conclusionof Henny et al. (1978a,b) that reservoir constructionhas increasedthe numbersand distributionof Ospreysin the western United States.

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I am gratefulto Mike Hedrick for providingme with the Osprey census data from the Charles M. RussellNational Wildlife Refuge, and to Bernie Hildebrandand Rich Stevensonfor allowingme to cite their Ospreyobserva- tions. I also thank Robert L. Eng, Kurt L. Alt and P. David Skaar for their constructivecomments on this manuscript.

LITERATURE CITED

Allen, J.A. 1874. Noteson the naturalhistory of portionsof Dakotaand Montanater- ritories. Proc. Boston Soc. Nat. Hist. 17:33-91. Betts, N.D. 1916. Birds seen in the valley of the South Fork of the Flathead River, Montana. Condor 18:161-163. Cameron, E.S• 1907. The birds of Custer and Dawson counties,Montana, Auk 24:241-270. Childress,D.A. and R.L. Eng. 1979. Dust abatementproject with wildlife enhance- ment on Canyon Ferry Reservoir,Montana. Pages 282-288 in G.A. Swanson, tech. coordin., The mitigationsymposium: a national workshopon mitigating lossesof fish and wildlife habitats.U.S. For. Serv. Gen. Tech. Rep. RM-65. Cooper, J.G. 1868. The fauna of Montana Territory. Am. Nat. 2:596-600. Grinnell, G.B. 1876. Birds. Pages72-92 in W. Ludlow, Report of a reconnaissance from Carrot, Montana Territory, on the Upper Missouri,to the YellowstoneNa- tional Park, and return, made in the summer of 1875. U.S. War Dep., Gov. Print. Off., Washington, D.C. Henny, C.J., J.A. Collinsand W.J. Deibert. 1978a. Osprey distribution,abundance, and status in western North America: II. The Oregon population. Murrelet 59:14-25. Henny, C.J., D.J. Dunaway,R.D. Malletteand J.R. Koplin. 1978b. Ospreydistribu- tion, abundance, and statusin western North America: I. The northern Califor- nia population. NorthwestSci. 52:261-271. Henny, C.J. and A.P. Noltemeier.1975. Ospreynesting populations in the coastal Carolinas. Am. Birds 29:1073-1079. Henny, C.J. and W.T. Van Vetzen. 1972. Migrationpatterns and winteringlocalities of American Ospreys.J. Wildl. Manage. 36:1133-1141.

5O OSPREY IN MONTANA

Hinz, T.C. 1977. The effect of altered streamflow on migratory birds of the Yellowstone River Basin, Montana. Montana Dep. Nat. Resour. & Conserv., Yellowstone Impact Stud. Tech. Rep. No. 7. Houston, C.S., J.M. Gerrard, D.W.A. Whitfield, H.A. Stelfox and W.J. Maher. 1977. Ospreynesting records in Saskatchewan.Blue Jay 35:38-41. Jones, L. and W.L. Dawson. 1900. A summer reconnaissancein the West. Wilson Bull. No. 33. Kennedy,R.S. 1973. Noteson the migrationof juvenileOspreys from Marylandand Virginia. Bird-Banding44:180-186. Knapp, S.J. 1977. Birney-Deckerwildlife study, final report. Montana Dep. Fish & Game, unpubl. rep. MacCarter, D.L. and D.S. MacCarter. 1979. Ten-year nesting statusof Ospreys at Flathead Lake, Montana. Murrelet 60:42-49. McChesney,C.E. 1879. Report on the mammalsand birdsof the generalregion of the Big Horn River and Mountains of Montana Territory. U.S. House of Representatives,Ex. Doc. 1, Part 2:2371-2395. Mearns, E.A. 1904. Birds of Fort Custer, Montana. Condor 6:20-21. Melquist,W.E., D.R. Johnsonand W.D. Carrier. 1978. Migrationpatterns of northern Idaho and eastern WashingtonOspreys. Bird-Banding49:234-236. Reid, R. and C.G. Gannon. 1927. Birdsand mammalsobserved by Lewis and Clark in North Dakota. Holt Printing Co., Grand Forks, North Dakota. Saunders, A.A. 1921. A distributional list of the birds of Montana. Pac. Coast Avif. 14. Smith, R.H. 1953. A study of waterfowl productionon artificialreservoirs in eastern Montana. J. Wildl. Manage. 17:276-291. Stewart, R.E. 1975. Breedingbirds of North Dakota. Tri-Coll. Cent. Environ. Stud., Fargo, North Dakota. Swenson,J.E. 1979. Factorsaffecting status and reproductionof Ospreysin Yellow- stone National Park. J. Wildl. Manage. 43:595-601. Thorne, P.M. 1895. List of birds observedin the vicinityof Fort Keogh, Montana, from July, 1888, to September, 1892. Auk 12:211-219. Visher, S.S. 1911. Annotatedlist of the birdsof HardingCounty, northwesternSouth Dakota. Auk 28:5-16. Walcheck, K. 1976. Montana wildlife 170 yearsago. Montana Outdoors 7(4):15-30.

Accepted 3 August 1981

51 N••Amust forsouthwestern birders-- Annotated ...... Checkhst of ...... the Birds of

•,•,•.•' • •:_• %o• SecondEdition • Rewsed &Expanded _ • •,, • •_ ,,• •,,,•o• Gale Monson

9: ,•'•.•.•'•.•A-- • Allan Phahps

270pages 4¾•x 7V• •perback $5.95

Here's a field companionspecifically designed for use in the mountainsand des- erts of the Grand Canyon state. Gale Mortson and Allan Phillips have encom- passed 475 species--including subspecies--in this volume, in accordance with the birds' known status through 1980. Detailed records and range descriptions offer informationunmatched in field guides, allowing you to better determine the identityand statusof any bird you may find in Arizona. Use this checklistin conjunctionwith ....

The Birds of Arizona Allan Phi/lips, Joe Marshall, & Gale Mortson

,•. AR_iZO\ A Features 126 distribution maps, 12 color plates by George MikschSutton, and 51 color photographs by Eliot Porter."The presentationand selection ß of material are excellent." (Audubon Magazine) 212 pages, 9 x 12, $27.50 clothbound(0-8165-0012-6)

Specialoffer-- Bibliographyof ArizonaOrnithology, $1.00 THE UNIVERSITY OF ARIZONA PRESS BOX 3698Z, TUCSON,, ARIZONA 85722