Symposium 13 Regulation of Photosynthetic Gene Expression 315

Unique central carbon metabolic pathways and novel enzymes in phototrophic revealed by integrative genomics, 13C-based metabolomics and fluxomics

Kuo-Hsiang Tanga,b, Xueyang Fengc, Anindita Bandyopadhyaya, Himadri B. Pakrasia,c, Yinjie J. Tangc, Robert E. Blankenshipa,b,*

Departments of aBiology, bChemistry, cEnergy, Environment, and Chemical Engineering, Washington University in St. Louis, St. Louis, Missouri 63130, USA *Corresponding author. Tel. No. 1-314-935-7971; Fax No. 1-314-935-4432; E-mail: [email protected].

Abstract: Photosynthesis is the process to convert solar energy to biomass and biofuels, which are the only major solar energy storage means on Earth. To satisfy the increased demand for sustainable energy sources, it is essential to understand the process of solar energy storage, that is, the carbon metabolism in photosynthetic organisms. It has been well-recognized that one bottleneck of photosynthesis is carbon assimilation. In this report, we summarize our recent studies on the carbon metabolism pathways of several types of photosynthetic bacteria, including aerobic anoxygenic phototrophic proteobacteria, , heliobacteria and , using physiological studies, transcriptomics, enzyme assays, 13C-based metabolomics and fluxomics. Our studies have revealed several unique and/or significant central carbon metabolic pathways and novel enzymes that operate in these , quantified CO2 assimilation pathways operative during mixotrophic cultivation conditions, and also suggested evolutionary links between photosynthetic and non-photosynthetic organisms.

Keywords: CO2 fixation; Citramalate pathway; Entner-Doudoroff pathway; Metabolomics; Reductive TCA cycle; (Re)-citrate synthase

Introduction microorganisms is of substantial interest. In this review, we briefly summarize our recent studies on Solar energy is the most abundant, albeit dilute, the carbon metabolism mechanisms of aerobic sustainable energy source on Earth, and anoxygenic phototrophic proteobacteria, green sulfur photosynthesis is a process that converts solar energy bacteria, heliobacteria and cyanobacteria using into biofuels and biomass (Blankenship, 2002). physiological studies, transcriptomics, enzyme assays, However, the photosynthetic efficiency for bimass 13C-based metabolomics and fluxomics. Our studies production in higher plants is at maximum only 4-6% have revealed several unique carbon metabolic (Zhu et al., 2010). As the demand for sustainable pathways and enzymes that operate in these energy has expanded significantly, it is important to phototrophs. Possible evolutionary links between improve the efficiency of photosynthesis. It has been photosynthetic and non-photosynthetic organisms are determined that carbon assimilation is one important suggested. bottleneck of photosynthesis, so it is necessary to understand carbon metabolism pathways in photosynthetic organisms. In contrast to the rich Materials and Methods information reported for biomedically relevant microbes, much less knowledge has been obtained for Physiological studies and integrative genomics. the metabolism of photosynthetic bacteria. Many The methods for bacterial growth, physiological photosynthetic microorgnisms live in environments studies, gene expression profiles via quantitative real- that higher plants cannot survive in, so an time PCR (QRT-PCR) (Tang et al., 2009b) and understanding of the metabolism of these enzyme assays of Roseobacter denitrificans (Tang et 316 Photosynthesis: Research for Food, Fuel and Future—15th International Conference on Photosynthesis al., 2009a), Chlorobaculum tepidum (Tang & Results and Discussion Blankenship, 2010; Tang et al., 2010a), Heliobacterium modesticaldum (Tang et al., 2010b) Using multiple approaches, we have identified and Cyanothece sp. ATCC 51142 (Feng et al., 2010a; several unique pathways and novel enzymes in several Wu et al., 2010) are described elsewhere. photosynthetic bacteria. Here we report some unique 13C-isotopic labeling and flux analysis. 13C- and/or significant central carbon metabolic pathways labeled glucose, pyruvate, acetate or bicarbonate was and novel enzymes; details can be found in our recent used as the sole carbon source in cell cultures, and the published studies (Feng et al., 2010a; Feng et al., labeled protein-based amino acids were extracted 2010b; Tang & Blankenship, 2010; Tang et al., 2009a; from cell pellets, hydrolyzed, derivitized and analyzed Tang et al., 2010a; Tang et al., 2010b; Wu et al., by GC/MS (Figure 1). For flux analysis, fluxes cannot 2010). be calculated directly from labeling data, but their accurate determination was achieved through a (1) The Entner-Doudoroff pathway. heuristic recursive procedure: the known metabolic The Embden-Meyerhof-Parnas (EMP) pathway reactions, atomic transitions, metabolite labeling, and (glycolysis), Entner-Doudoroff (ED) pathway and extracellular fluxes are combined to produce an error pentose phosphate pathway are three major function ε (the difference between the measured carbohydrate metabolic pathways. While the majority isotopomer data and the predicted isotopomer data of organisms use the EMP pathway for digesting from assumed fluxes), and then a search algorithm is glucose, some microorganisms, most of which are applied to determine the actual fluxes by minimizing aerobes, have been reported to use the ED pathway the error function (equation 1): (Conway, 1992; Fuhrer et al., 2005). Our studies indicate that the aerobic anoxygenic phototrophic

k 2 (AAP) proteobacterium Roseobacter denitrificans j  M  N (v )   i i n  (eq. 1)  (vn )    predominantly uses the ED pathway for metabolizing i1  i  sugars (Figure 2), and that their EMP pathway is Subject to: S • vn = 0 inactive (Tang et al., 2009a). Similar results were also

reported in two other AAP bacteria using 13C- where S is the stoichiometry matrix for all unknown metabolomics and fluxomics (Furch et al., 2009) as fluxes, v are the unknown fluxes to be optimized in n well as some purple bacteria (such as the program, M is the measured isotopomer data, N is i i capsulatus and ) under the corresponding model-predicted isotopomer data, certain growth conditions (Conrad & Schlegel, 1977; and δ is the corresponding standard deviation of the i Fuhrer et al., 2005). All of the cultured AAPs are measured isotopomer data. The unknown metabolic and require organic carbon for fluxes are calculated to minimize ε (Feng et al., 2010b; growth. It has not been established if the ED pathway Pingitore et al., 2007; Wahl et al., 2004). is active in all of the purple bacteria, and is also not

entirely clear why those bacteria use the ED pathway, which has a lower thermodynamic efficiency compared to the EMP pathway. It is possible that those bacteria may use a high glucose metabolic rate to compensate the thermodynamic inefficiency of the ED pathway (Molenaar et al., 2009).

(2) (Re)-citrate synthase. The majority of studied organisms synthesize citrate from acetyl-CoA and oxaloacetate by (Si)- citrate synthase ((Si)-CS) for initiating the TCA cycle. Our studies showed that the anoxygenic heliobacterium Heliobacterium modesticaldum uses

(Re)-citrate synthase ((Re)-CS), an alternative Fig. 1. 13C-based metabolomics and fluxomics biosynthetic pathway, to produce citrate (Tang et al., Symposium 13 Regulation of Photosynthetic Gene Expression 317

2010a). Activity of (Si)-CS has not been detected oxidative TCA cycle, in which the reducing (Tang et al., 2010b) and the gene encoding (Si)-CS equivalents (i.e. NADH) are generated (Figure 4), has not been annotated in the H. modesticaldum although all of the genes, except one, in the reductive genome (Sattley & Blankenship, 2009; Sattley et al., TCA cycle have been annotated in H. modesticaldum 2008). As indicated in Figure 3, the acetyl group from genome (Sattley et al., 2008) and the enzymatic acetyl-CoA is attached to the pro-S or pro-R arm of activity of encoded proteins in the TCA cycle have citrate by (Si)-CS or (Re)-CS, respectively. been detected in H. modesticaldum (Tang et al., 2010b). Our studies may shed light on the proposed photosynthetic cyclic electron transport pathway in the heliobacteria (Kramer et al., 1997).

Fig. 4. The proposed central carbon flow in heliobacteria. Fig. 2. The EMP pathway versus the ED pathway. (3) Citramalate pathway. Many organisms synthesize isoleucine through the threonine-deaminase dependent pathway, whereas we discovered that several photosynthetic bacteria, including R. denitrificans (Tang et al., 2009a), Chlorobaculum tepidum (Feng et al., 2010b), H. modesticaldum (Tang et al., 2010a) and Cyanothece sp. ATCC 51142 (Wu et al., 2010), use the

citramalate-dependent pathway to synthesize Fig. 3. The reactions catalyzed by (Si)- versus (Re)-CS. isoleucine (Figure 5). Together with an active citramalate pathway reported in several non- Previous studies indicate that several photosynthetic bacteria (Feng et al., 2009; Risso et al., species exclusively use (Re)-CS to synthesize citrate 2008), it is suggested that the citramalate-dependent (Li et al., 2007). These reports, together with our pathway is much more widespread than previously work on heliobacteria, suggest a possible evolutionary recognized (Howell et al., 1999). Compared to the link between heliobacteria and Clostridia, both of threonine-dependent pathway, it is more efficient to which are anaerobic gram-(+) bacteria. Also, our produce 2-ketobutyrate through the citramalate studies on H. modesticaldum and a previous report on pathway. 2-ketobutyrate is an intermediate in the Heliobacterium strain HY-3 (Pickett et al., 1994) isoleucine biosynthesis pathway, for butanol and indicate that both heliobacteria use the oxidative propanol production (Figure 5) (Atsumi & Liao, (forward) TCA cycle to synthesize glutamate. 2008). Additionally, our studies demonstrate that the carbon flux is mostly carried out through the incomplete 318 Photosynthesis: Research for Food, Fuel and Future—15th International Conference on Photosynthesis

strong carbon flow in their oxidative TCA cycle (Tang et al., 2009a; Tang et al., 2010a; Tang et al., 2010b), so the production of oxaloacetate (OAA) from carboxylation of pyruvate and of phosphoenolpyruvate (PEP) is essential for the oxidative TCA cycle when it is running low. Also,

while CO2-enhanced phototrophic growth of H. modesticaldum has not been detected using pyruvate

as the sole organic carbon source, CO2-enhanced growth has been observed in acetate-grown cultures

(Tang et al., 2010b). The CO2-enhanced phototrophic growth is most likely due to conversion of acetyl-CoA to pyruvate (Figure 4). Further, an active anaplerotic pathway in C. tepidum confirmed by us is essential for efficient assimilation of pyruvate (mainly via the reductive TCA cycle) and acetate (via both oxidative and reductive TCA cycles) during mixotrophic growth of GSBs (Feng et al., 2010b; Tang & Blankenship, Fig. 5. The Val, Ile and Leu biosynthetic pathways 2010), although GSBs require the autotrophic reductive TCA cycle for growth. (4) Alternative CO2-assimilation pathways. Several autotrophic CO2-assimilation pathways have been identified in microorganisms, including the Acknowledgements Calvin-Benson -Bassham (CBB) cycle, the reductive TCA cycle (Arnon-Buchanan-Evans cycle), the This work was supported by Exobiology Program reductive acetyl-CoA pathway (Wood-Ljungdahl of NASA Grant NNX08AP62G (R.E.B.), National pathway), the 3-hydroxy-propionate cycle and the 3- Science Foundation Career Grant MCB0954016 hydroxypropionate/4-hydroxy-butyrate cycle (Thauer, (Y.J.T.) and Department of Energy Grant DE-FC02- 2007). Some photosynthetic bacteria are known to 07ER64694 (H.B.P. and Y.J.T.). employ the CBB cycle (purple non-sulfur bacteria and cyanobacteria), the reductive TCA cycle (the green sulfur bacteria, GSBs) and the 3-hydroxypropionate References cycle (). Our studies indicate that the cyanobacterium Cyanothece 51142 grows Atsumi, S., Liao, J.C. (2008) Directed evolution of photoautotrophically in the presence of glucose or Methanococcus jannaschii citramalate synthase pyruvate, and photoheterotrophically with minimal for biosynthesis of 1-propanol and 1-butanol by

CO2 assimilation when nitrate and glycerol are Escherichia coli. Appl Environ Microbiol, 74, supplied (Feng et al., 2010a). Furthermore, our flux 7802-7808 analysis show that C. tepidum can fix about ~3.6 (or Blankenship, R.E. (2002) Molecular mechanisms of

~6.0) mole CO2 per mole acetate (or pyruvate) under photosynthesis. Blackwell Science Ltd, Oxford mixotrophic conditions (Feng et al., 2010b). Conrad, R., Schlegel H.G. (1977) Different

Alternatively, the CO2-anaplerotic pathway is known degradation pathways for glucose and fructose in to be essential in the energy metabolism of many Rhodopseudomonas capsulata. Arch Microbiol, chemoheterotrophic organisms, and the deficiency of 112, 39-48 enzymes in the anaplerotic pathways leads to Conway, T. (1992) The Entner-Doudoroff pathway: accumulation of lipids, lack of gluconeogenesis, and history, physiology and molecular biology. FEMS Microbiol Rev, 9, 1-27 other effects. Our studies demonstrate that the CO2- anaplerotic pathways are active in R. denitrificans, H. Feng, X., Bandyopadhyay, A., Berla, B., Page, L., Wu, modesticaldum and C. tepidum. The first two bacteria B., Pakrasi, H.B., Tang, Y.J. (2010a) Mixotrophic are obligate photoheterotrophs and our studies suggest and photoheterotrophic metabolism in Cyanothece Symposium 13 Regulation of Photosynthetic Gene Expression 319

sp. ATCC 51142 under continuous light. sulfurreducens. J Bacteriol, 190, 2266-2274 Microbiology, 156, 2566-2574 Sattley, W.M., Blankenship, R.E. (2009) Insights into Feng, X., Mouttaki, H., Lin, L., Huang, R., Wu, B., heliobacterial photosynthesis and physiology from Hemme, C.L., He, Z., Zhang, B., Hicks, L.M., Xu, the genome of Heliobacterium modesticaldum. J., Zhou, J., Tang, Y.J. (2009) Characterization of Photosynth. Res the central metabolic pathways in Sattley, W.M., Madigan, M.T., Swingley, W.D., Thermoanaerobacter sp. X514 via isotopomer- Cheung, P.C., Clocksin, K.M., Conrad, A.L., assisted metabolite analysis. Appl. Environ. Dejesa, L.C., Honchak, B.M., Jung, D.O., Microbiol., 75, 5001-5008 Karbach, L.E., Kurdoglu, A., Lahiri, S., Mastrian, Feng, X., Tang, K.H., Blankenship, R.E., Tang, Y.J. S.D., Page, L.E., Taylor, H.L., Wang, Z.T., (2010b) Metabolic flux analysis of the Raymond, J., Chen, M., Blankenship, R.E., mixotrophic metabolisms in the green sulfur Touchman, J.W. (2008) The genome of bacterium Chlorobaculum tepidum. J Biol Chem, Heliobacterium modesticaldum, a phototrophic 285, 39544-39550 representative of the containing the Fuhrer, T., Fischer, E. , Sauer, U. (2005) simplest photosynthetic apparatus. J Bacteriol, 190, Experimental identification and quantification of 4687-4696 glucose metabolism in seven bacterial species. J Tang, K.H., Blankenship, R.E. (2010) Both forward Bacteriol, 187, 1581-1590. and reverse TCA cycles operate in green sulfur Furch, T., Preusse, M., Tomasch, J., Zech, H., bacteria. J Biol Chem, 285, 35848-35854 Wagner-Dobler, I., Rabus, R. & Wittmann, C. Tang, K.H., Feng, X., Tang, Y.J., Blankenship, R.E. (2009) Metabolic fluxes in the central carbon (2009a) Carbohydrate metabolism and carbon metabolism of Dinoroseobacter shibae and fixation in Roseobacter denitrificans OCh114. Phaeobacter gallaeciensis, two members of the PLoS One, 4, e7233 marine Roseobacter clade. BMC Microbiol, 9, 209 Tang, K.H., Feng, X., Zhuang, W.Q., Alvarez-Cohen, Howell, D.M., Xu, H., White, R.H. (1999) (R)- L., Blankenship, R.E., Tang, Y.J. (2010a) Carbon citramalate synthase in methanogenic archaea. J flow of heliobacteria is related more to clostridia Bacteriol, 181, 331-333 than to the green sulfur bacteria. J Biol Chem, 285, Kramer, D.M., Schoepp, B., Liebl, U., Nitschke, W. 35104-35112 (1997) Cyclic electron transfer in Heliobacillus Tang, K.H., Wen, J., Li, X., Blankenship, R.E. (2009b) mobilis involving a menaquinol-oxidizing Role of the AcsF protein in Chloroflexus cytochrome bc complex and an RCI-type reaction aurantiacus. J Bacteriol, 191, 3580-3587 center. Biochemistry, 36, 4203-4211 Tang, K.H., Yue, H., Blankenship, R.E. (2010b) Li, F., Hagemeier, C.H., Seedorf, H., Gottschalk, G., Energy metabolism of Heliobacterium Thauer, R.K. (2007) Re-citrate synthase from modesticaldum during phototrophic and Clostridium kluyveri is phylogenetically related to chemotrophic growth. BMC Microbiol, 10, 150 homocitrate synthase and isopropylmalate Thauer, R.K. (2007) Microbiology. A fifth pathway of synthase rather than to Si-citrate synthase. J carbon fixation. Science, 318, 1732-1733 Bacteriol, 189, 4299-4304 Wahl, S.A., Dauner, M., Wiechert, W. (2004) New Molenaar, D., van Berlo, R., de Ridder, D., Teusink, tools for mass isotopomer data evaluation in (13)C B. (2009) Shifts in growth strategies reflect flux analysis: mass isotope correction, data tradeoffs in cellular economics. Mol Syst Biol, 5, consistency checking, and precursor relationships. 323 Biotechnol Bioeng, 85, 259-268 Pickett, M.W., Williamson, M.P., Kelly, D.J. (1994) Wu, B., Zhang, B., Feng, X., Rubens, J.R., Huang, R., An enzyme and 13C-NMR of carbon metabolism Hicks, L.M., Pakrasi, H.B., Tang, Y.J. (2010) in heliobacteria. Photosynth. Res., 41, 75-88 Alternative isoleucine synthesis pathway in Pingitore, F., Tang, Y., Kruppa, G.H., Keasling, J.D. cyanobacterial species. Microbiology, 156, 596- (2007) Analysis of amino acid isotopomers using 602 FT-ICR MS. Anal Chem, 79, 2483-2490 Zhu, X.G., Long, S.P., Ort, D.R. (2010) Improving Risso, C., Van Dien, S.J., Orloff, A., Lovley, D.R., photosynthetic efficiency for greater yield. Annu Coppi, M.V. (2008) Elucidation of an alternate Rev Plant Biol, 61, 235-261. isoleucine biosynthesis pathway in Geobacter