Camp Marketing Consultancy
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Camp Marketing Consultancy Power Dimensions of Economic Freedom. Law Int l Express Int l Express e e Understanding artificial acceleration - systematic concentration – targeted financial misappropriation iCore 9 Gulftown Desktop & Xeon Westmere EP 5600 Series 2 way Economic assessment calculated on Intel through press signal that is RICO Collusion by Model “Science is basically concerned with investigating how and why things are as they are. Science, in fact, is organized knowledge about the world, not organized knowledge about itself”. Stafford Beer, University of Manchester; Decision & Control, 1966 Mike Bruzzone, Camp Marketing Consultancy, [email protected], 415/250-4652 FTC Submission 7/23/2012 Camp Marketing Consultancy “The latest wave of new competition laws is taking place in countries where the domestic economy has some similarities to the United States when Competition law was first enacted. Many of these countries, like the United States of the 1890’s, have economies that are dominated by large firms. In the transitional economies, the giant firms tend to be leftovers from colonial governments, state enterprise formed by socialist governments, or government favoritism based on Crony capitalism. Regardless of the reasons for the dominance of these oversized firms they will not survive if they are disciplined by competitive market forces. As a result some of these firms are likely to fail when faced by market competition and competition laws, others will have to change dramatically in order to survive. The question of what institutions are necessary to create a market economy has provoked a great deal of discussion that is reflected in academic and popular literature. Although there is no definitive list of legal and social institutions that are necessary to have a market economy, there is consensus that the following are elements that are found virtually in all modern economies”. Private property rights including the right to sell and buy property; Money which is accepted as payment for property and services; Contract rights for the sale or purchase of goods and services; Rules that permit lending or borrowing money or private property; Rules that permit the management of entities the right to operate businesses without the consent of the owners of the business for individual transactions; Rules that permit the issuance of debt obligations that are secured solely by the value of specified private property or business entities; Trust between market participants; Open competitive environment free from subterfuge and sub group network control; and An honest effective judicial system which enforces contract, competition, individual and property rights that are not respected by market participants. Kenneth Davidson, Free Markets and Competition Laws, December 2011 Mike Bruzzone, Camp Marketing Consultancy, [email protected] FTC Submission 7/23/2012 Camp Marketing Consultancy – Gulftown iCore 9 Desktop & Xeon 2 way Server 3.33 GHz X6 Core 12 MB L3 3ddr3-1333 130w 3/10 3.47 GHz X4 Core 12 MB L3 3ddr3 -1333 130w 3/10 Westmere EP 1600 3.47 GHz X6 Core 12 MB L3 3ddr3-1333 133w 2/11 3.60 GHz X4 Core 12 MB L3 3ddr3-1333 130w 2/11 1550 1500 2.93 GHz X6 Core 12 MB L3 3ddr3-1333 95w 3/10 “People need a way of linking their 1450 HEXA MONOPOLY 3.07 GHz X4 Core 12 MB L3 3ddr3-1333 95w 3/10 3.07 GHz X6 Core 12 MB L3 3ddr3-1333 95w 2/11 productive lives to society”. 1400 3.20 GHz X4 Core 12 MB L3 3ddr3-1333 95w 2/11 1350 QUAD MONOPOLY HEXA ECONOMIC 2 Konosuke Matsushita 1300 1250 2.80 GHz X6 Core 12 MB L3 3ddr3-1333 95w 3/10 1200 1150 1100 3.33 GHz 6 iCore 12 MB L3 3ddr3-1333 130w 3/10 $1095 1050 3.47 GHz 6 iCore 12 MB L3 3ddr3-1333 130w 2/11 2.67 GHz X6 Core 12 MB L3 3ddr3-1333 95w 3/10 Xeon 5600 1000 2.27 GHz X6 Core 12 MB L3 3ddr3-1333 60w 3/10 Hexa Core 2.00 GHz X6 Core 12 MB L3 3ddr3-1333 60w 3/10 950 iCore 9 & FULL RUN EFFICIENT FULL RUN 900 Xeon 3600 3.20 GHz 6 iCore 12 MB L3 3ddr3-1066 130w 7/10 PRODUCTION POINT AWP = $888 850 5600 Hexa AMC = $799 2.67 GHz X4 Core 12 MB L3 3ddr3-1066 80w 3/10 800 2.93 GHz X4 Core 12 MB L3 3ddr3-1333 130w 2/11 2.53 GHz X6 Core xx MB L3 3ddr3-1333 80w 2/11 750 QUAD AWP $721 700 Xeon 5600 $716 650 Quad Core 600 3.33 GHz 6 iCore 12 MB L3 3ddr3-1066 130w 6/11 550 2.13 GHz X4 Core 12 MB L3 3ddr3-1066 40w 3/10, 2.53 GHz X4 Core 12 MB L3 3ddr3-1066 80w 3/10, 2.4 GHz X6 Core 12 MB xx L3 ddr3-1333 80w 3/10 1.87 GHz X4 Core 12 MB L3 3ddr3-1066 40w 3/10 5600 Quad AMC = $542 500 iCore 9 AMC = $477 450 1.87 GHz X4 Core 12 MB L3 3ddr3-1066 40w 3/10 400 2.40 GHz X4 Core 12 MB L3 3ddr3-1066 80w 3/10 350 300 2.27 GHz X4 Core 8 MB L3 3ddr3-1066 80w 2/11 250 2.13 GHz X4 Core 8 MB L3 3ddr3-1066 80w 2/11 200 1.60 GHz X4 Core 4 MB L3 3ddr3-1066 80w 2/11 ATC = $227 150 100 AFC = $121 250K 500K 750K 1M 1.25M 1.5M 1.75M 2M 2.25M 2.5M 2.75M 3M 3.25M 3.5M Mike Bruzzone, Camp Marketing Consultancy, [email protected] FTC Submission 7/23/2012 Camp Marketing Consultancy – Gulftown iCore 9 Desktop & Xeon 2 way Server Westmere EP $363,919,165 Hexa Core 1600 Monopoly Price Overcharge assessment. economic refined on increase overcharge price monopoly QUAD Xeon Note 1550 1500 Infra marginal Exact Units > $1442 1450 HEXA MONOPOLY 1400 $603,211,809 Quad Core 1350 QUAD MONOPOLY HEXA ECONOMIC 2 Monopoly Price Overcharge 1300 Infra marginal Exact Units > $1330 1250 HEXA ECONOMIC 1 1200 1150 QUAD ECONOMIC 1 1100 HEXA AWP =$1077 $1095 1050 $1056 Xeon 5600 1000 $999 Hexa Core 950 iCore 9 & $940 900 Xeon 3600 FULL RUN EFFICIENT PRODUCTION POINT FULL RUN AWP = $888 850 5600 Hexa AMC = $799 800 SHUT DOWN POINT 750 $733 QUAD COMPETITIVE QUAD AWP $721 700 Xeon 5600 $716 650 Quad Core 600 $583 550 SHUT DOWN POINT 5600 Quad AMC = $542 500 SHUT DOWN POINT iCore 9 AMC = $477 450 400 350 300 15,690,157 Units Priced < In Quarter MC; 42% of Xeon Run 250 200 ATC = $227 150 100 AFC = $121 250K 500K 750K 1M 1.25M 1.5M 1.75M 2M 2.25M 2.5M 2.75M 3M 3.25M 3.5M Mike Bruzzone, Camp Marketing Consultancy, [email protected] FTC Submission 7/23/2012 Camp Marketing Consultancy – Gulftown iCore 9 Desktop & Xeon 2 way Server Westmere EP 1600 1550 1500 1450 1400 1350 1300 1250 1200 1150 1100 1050 Xeon 5600 1000 Hexa Core 950 iCore 9 & 900 Xeon 3600 FULL RUN AWP = $888 850 800 750 700 Xeon 5600 650 Quad Core 600 550 500 450 400 350 ATC = $227 300 250 200 150 100 AFC = $121 250K 500K 750K 1M 1.25M 1.5M 1.75M 2M 2.25M 2.5M 2.75M 3M 3.25M 3.5M Mike Bruzzone, Camp Marketing Consultancy, [email protected] FTC Submission 7/23/2012 Camp Marketing Consultancy – Gulftown Xeon 2 way Server Westmere EP É 1600 1550 1500 1450 TR 1400 Qty 1350 1300 Revenue Contribution or ▲TR 1250 1200 1150 1100 1050 1000 950 900 FULL RUN EFFICIENT PRODUCTION POINT FULL RUN 850 AWP = $888 800 750 700 650 600 550 500 450 400 350 300 250 200 ATC = $227 150 100 AFC = $121 1M 2M 3M 4M 5M 6M 7M Mike Bruzzone, Camp Marketing Consultancy, [email protected] FTC Submission 7/23/2012 Camp Marketing Consultancy x86 PC Industry Structure 1993 - 99 -- 2012 Unnatural Entry Barriers D M E Industrial Espionage V O E N T I L O Tools O R R P P FABS N A S Pentium 4 3.06 GHz M O Core Logic Pricing - 11/29/02 E Intel P Horizontal Dealer Combination #1 Intel OEMS N T N L E I Broker Price $699 PC & MB OEMs Intel S E T Y Inside N Intel Price $637 Big End Customers M N L I F Rebate E Are Intel PC dealers Peripheral OEMs R reselling their CPU T surplus sans their Horizontal Surplus Reseller Combination #2 Brokers & Integrators T Attractor Intel Inside rebate? L I C OS & Network ISV E N H P Applications ISVs R E A R ISV Infrastructure Allies S US v Intel; FTC Dockets 9288 through 9341 S B N Education O O I N Government Possibility Layer C Conspiracy to Conceal T D E D Nat’l Distribution & Sales Channels T Local Integrators, VARs, Hardware & Software Consultants E L M U T R L O Corporate IT , Pilot Projects, Sophisticated Users E N C E Nat’l & Local Industry Analysts O Intel v. Competitive T N O R P T Nat’l & Local Financial Analysts P Stock Price Manipulation E I O O Engineering & OEM Trade Press R E C L P L E Segment Specific Press U K Y U B A Intel A Business Editors & News Writers L S I D T S Inside Horizontal Major & Minor Nat’l PC & Consumer Products Press H T D E Media Dealing I R E Local Business Press S O Fee Combination #3 R N Local PC Press & Broadcast R Extractor G Mass Market Consumers RECEIVERS S “In science there is only one mortal sin; telling a lie” - Journal of International Affairs, 1967 Mike Bruzzone, Camp Marketing Consultancy, [email protected], 415/250-54652 FTC 3/99, FTC/NAAG 8/2000, NAAG 11/02 Camp Marketing Consultancy Quantities by all types of Frequency Grades within Quarter É MR=MC Q1 Q2 Q3 6 Core Qty Q4 Q5 Q6 MR=MC TR Revenue Contribution or ▲TR Dumping < AVC Product Grades 1 2 3 4 5 iCore 9 Performance Desktop & Xeon 3600 Speed Splits 2,438,004 Units 970 3.2 980 3.33 $2,174,531,822 Revenue 950 3.33 AWP = $892 990 3.47 AMR = $404 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 AMC = $487 Qtrs 23% 3.20 Consolidated Speed Split Tied Charge Back Price Fix 51% 3.33 26% 3.47 $217,453,182 3.20 GHz 3.33 GHz 3.47 GHz iCore 9 Model 2 on Press Signal Qtrs 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Mike Bruzzone, Camp Marketing Consultancy, [email protected] FTC Submission 7/23/2012 Camp Marketing Consultancy KEY: Every horizontal line represents by quarter quantities of speed grades offered in that quarter; turn chart and read vertically.