<<

15/9/2014

UNITED UTILITIES DRAFT WATER RESOURCES MANAGEMENT PLAN

WEST RESOURCE ZONE

EXAMINATION IN PUBLIC

DOCUMENTS LIST

GENERAL DOCUMENTS GEN1 Briefing from Defra for the Inspector running the Inquiry into United Utilities Draft Water Resources Management Plan GEN2 Letter from Defra to United Utilities dated 2 April 2014 in response to their letter of 11 November 2013 (CD1.5) GEN3 Letter from Defra to United Utilities dated 16 June 2014 regarding the timetable and arrangements for the Examination in Public of the Draft Water Resources Management Plan GEN4 Inspector’s Initial Question to United Utilities dated 24 June 2014 GEN5 Agenda for the 16 September 2014 Hearing GEN5a Revised agenda for the 16 September 2014 Hearing GEN6 Agenda for the 17 September 2014 Hearing GEN7 Letter from the Programme Officer to all respondents dated 21 July 2014 GEN8 Email exchange between the and the Programme Officer regarding clarification Agenda item 9

CORE DOCUMENTS Provided by United Utilities CD1.1 Strategic Environmental Assessment of United Utilities Draft Water Resources Management Plan, February 2008 CD1.2 Draft Water Resources Management Plan 2013 CD1.3 United Utilities Habitats Regulations Assessment of Water Resources Management Plan, March 2013 CD1.4 Addendum to United Utilities Habitats Regulations Assessment of Water Resources Management Plan, November 2013 CD1.5 Letter from United Utilities to Defra dated 11 November 2013, regarding the Statement of Response and a Revised Draft Water Resources Management Plan CD1.6 Revised Draft Water Resources Management Plan, November 2013 CD1.7a Strategic Environmental Assessment of United Utilities Draft Water Resources Management Plan, March 2013 CD1.7b Strategic Environmental Assessment of United Utilities Draft Water Resources Management Plan, Environmental Report Addendum, November 2013 CD1.8 2013 Draft Water Resources Management Plan – Statement of Response CD1.9 Environment Agency Advice Report on United Utilities Statement of Response, 17 January 2014 CD1.10 Revised Draft Drought Plan 2014 CD1.11 - sections 76 to 76c CD1.12 Update on Ennerdale Abstraction Reductions 2013-2016 – June 2014 CD1.13 Annual Water Resources Review April 2013 to March 2014 CD1.14a Environmental Damage (Prevention and Remediation) Regulations 2009, Regulation 14(2) Notice – 19 December 2012 CD1.14b Environmental Damage (Prevention and Remediation) Regulations 2009, Regulation 14(2) Notice – 21 May 2013 CD1.14c Environmental Damage (Prevention and Remediation) Regulations 2009, Regulation 14(2) Notice – 28 April 2014

1

15/9/2014

CD1.15 Environmental Monitoring of the River Ehen freshwater mussel population in 2012 CD1.16 Peer Reviewed Report on the 2012 River Ehen freshwater mussel surveys CD1.17a Stress Testing of the Freshwater Mussel in the River Ehen, Summary of Results on 29 January 2013 CD1.17b Stress Testing of the Freshwater Mussel in the River Ehen, Summary of Results on 26/27 March 2013 CD1.17c Stress Testing of the Freshwater Mussel in the River Ehen, Summary of Results on 15 April 2013 CD1.17d Stress Testing of the Freshwater Mussel in the River Ehen, Summary of Results on 30/31 May 2013 CD1.17e Stress Testing of the Freshwater Mussel in the River Ehen, Summary of Results on 25-28 July 2013 CD1.17f Stress Testing of the Freshwater Mussel in the River Ehen, Summary of Results on 8-9 November 2013 CD1.17g Stress Testing of the Freshwater Mussel in the River Ehen, Summary of Results on 15-19 March 2014 CD1.18 Health Screen of Pearl Mussels, Centre for Environment, Fisheries & Aquaculture Science, 20 May 2013 CD1.19 The National Rivers Authority and North West Water Limited - Management Agreement relating to Ennerdale, 18 May 1992 CD1.20 Water Resources Act 1991 (1991 c 57)/Part II Water Resources Management (ss 19-81)/20 Water resources management schemes CD1.21 Final Water Resources Management Plan, September 2009 CD1.22a Copeland DMZ, Engineering Level 2 Report, Issue Ref. 412 – West Cumbria Strategy: Kielder Option CD1.22b Copeland DMZ, Engineering Level 2 Report, Issue Ref. 412 – West Cumbria Strategy: Local Sources CD1.22c Copeland DMZ, Engineering Level 2 Report, Issue Ref. 412 – West Cumbria Strategy: Local Sources (Superworks) CD1.23 West Cumbria Strategy – Accelerated Stretch Schedule – 2 June 2014 CD1.24 Narrative to Project schedule (“Accelerated Stretch Schedule”) 2nd June 2014 CD1.25 Water Resources Planning Guideline, August 2013 CD1.26 Proposed package of compensatory measures for adverse effects on the River Ehen SAC, 28 February 2014 CD1.27a Pipeline Solutions CD1.27b Map – West Cumbria Pipeline Project CD1.28 Newby Bridge Weir – Directions for Operation of the Fishery Sluice – Agreement between the Environment Agency and United Utilities Water Plc CD1.29 Additional context for Company response to Inspectors questions, July 2014 CD1.30 Revised draft Water Resources Management Plan Technical Report Options Appraisal, United Utilities, November 2013

CD1.31 HRA Stage 3 Alternative Option Appraisal, Grontmij, July 2013 live draft CD1.32 Overwater Abstraction Licence (Licence number 2775006S018), issued 27 June 2014 CD1.33 Letter from Steve Mogford, United Utilities, to Steve Moore, Environment Agency, 16 October 2013 CD1.34 Summary of IROPI notification to Secretary of State CD1.35 Final Drought Plan 2014, United Utilities, July 2014 (pages 67, 161, 162) CD1.36 Revised draft Water Resources Management Plan Technical Report Yield and Supply Capability, United Utilities, November 2013 CD1.37 Derwent and West Cumbria abstraction licensing strategy, Environment Agency, February 2013

2

15/9/2014

CD1.38 Eden and Esk abstraction licensing strategy, Environment Agency, February 2013 CD1.39 Habitats and Wild Birds Directives: guidance on the application of article 6(4) Alternative solutions, imperative reasons of overriding public interest (IROPI) and compensatory measures, Defra, December 2012 CD1.40 River Ehen compensatory measures update, United Utilities, June 2014 CD1.41 Thirlmere pipeline project risk register CD1.42 Letter from Environment Agency 10th January 2014 CD1.43 Drought Plan Habitats Regulations Assessment Stage 3 Alternative Option Appraisal report, August 2014, Final draft for Examination in Public CD1.44 Life in UK Rivers publication: Skinner, A,Young M & Hastie L (2003). Ecology of the Freshwater Mussel. Conserving Natura 2000 Rivers Ecology Series No. 2 English Nature, Peterborough CD1.45 An investigation into relationships between velocity, bed shear stress and flow requirements in the River Ehen, Atkins, May 2014 CD1.46 Study to age the population of freshwater mussels (Margaritifera margaritifera) in the River Ehen, Cumbria, Malacological Services (2013) CD1.47 Detailed Baseline Geomorphological Assessment of the River Ehen, Jacobs, December 2012 CD1.48 Nutrients and algae in the Upper River Ehen and their implications for freshwater mussels, Bowburn Consultancy (2013) CD1.49 Drinking Water Inspectorate guidance to water companies on the application of Regulation 15 of the Water Supply (Water Quality) Regulations 2000 – October 2012 Provided by the Environment Agency CD2.1 River Ehen SAC: SAC Site Action Plan Addendum Ennerdale abstraction licence No. 2774003008, December 2013 CD2.2 Notes regarding the redaction of The Habitats Directive Review of Consents, River Ehen SAC Site Action Plan Addendum, for Ennerdale Abstraction licence No 2774003008. December 2013 – July 2014 CD2.3 North West River Basin District: Challenges and choices - Summary of significant water management issues. A consultation, June 2013 CD2.4 Letter dated 9 October 2013 from the Environment Agency to United Utilities regarding water supply-demand options for West Cumbria CD2.5 Appendix 1 – Mussel life cycle CD2.6 River basin management planning: Challenges and choices consultation Response document. 2014 CD2.7 Letter dated 7 May 2014 from the Environment Agency to Ltd regarding plans for water abstraction in support of current and future activities at Sellafield. CD2.8 Minutes of meeting - UU draft Water Resources Management Plan (dWRMP) 12th July 2013 CD2.9 Water resources planning guidelines, June 2012

PRE-EXAMINATION SUBMISSIONS EA1 Response by the Environment Agency to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan EA2 Email from the Environment Agency to dated 28 January 2014 NE1 Response by Natural England to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan OF1 Response by Ofwat to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan OF2 Email from Ofwat to Defra dated 23 January 2014 FLD1 Response by Friends of the Lake District to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan

3

15/9/2014

WLC1 Response by Windermere Lake Cruises Limited to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan WLU1 Response by Windermere Lake User Forum to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan HET1 Response by Holker Estate Trust to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan CCW1 Response by the Consumer Council for Water to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan CCW2 Response by the Consumer Council for Water to the notification by United Utilities of the Examination NDC1 Response by The Nuclear Decommissioning Authority and Sellafield Ltd to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan BEC1 Response by Britain’s Energy Coast to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan WCRT1 Response by West Cumbria Rivers Trust to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan REDFA1 Response by River Eden and District Fisheries Association to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan DOA1 Response by Derwent Owners’ Association to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan CFAG1 Response by Cleator Flood Action Group to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan KFAG1 Response by Keswick Flood Action Group to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan BCC1 Response by Butterfly Conservation Cumbria to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan BUG1 Response by Buglife to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan LDNPA1 Response by Lake District National Park Authority to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan MCC1 Response by Manchester City Council to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan ABC1 Response by Allerdale Borough Council to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan SBPC Response by St Bees Parish Council to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan SJCWP1 Response by St John’s, Castlerigg and Wythburn Parishes PM1 Response by P McCartney to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan DM1 Response by D Millington to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan JB1 Response by Joseph Bowman to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan RDS1 Response by Rod Donington-Smith to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan OB1 Response by Oliver Barratt MBE to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan GPS1 Response by G P Smith to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan GCB1 Response by Graham Chaplin-Brice to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan MES1 Response by Miss E Steele to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan NRW1 Response by Natural Resources Wales to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan NRW2 Response by Natural Resources Wales to the Strategic Environmental Assessment of the Draft Water Resources Management Plan CRT1 Response by the Canal & River Trust to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan

4

15/9/2014

WT1 Response by the Wildlife Trust and the Wildlife Trust for , Manchester & North to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan PWS1 Response by Peel Water Services Ltd to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan GAF1 Response by Garstang Against Fracking to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan GARD1 Response by the Group Against Reservoir Development to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan SLDC1 Response by South Lakeland District Council to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan PDNPA1 Response by the Peak District National Park Authority to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan SHC1 Response by St Helens Council to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan CWCC1 Response by Cheshire West & Chester Council to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan AGMA1 Response by the Combined Authority / Association of Greater Manchester Authorities to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan WCBC1 Response by Wrexham County Borough Council to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan DB1 Response by Derek Booth to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan AB1 Response by Averil Booth to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan MR1 Response by Melanie Rideout to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan BP1 Response by Barbara Prescott to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan LP1 Response by Lynne Pattinson to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan JH1 Response by John Hobson to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan DP1 Response by Dawid Ptak to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan NW1 Response by Neil White to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan MDB1 Response by Mr D Barber to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan BAR1 Response by David Barker to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan JC1 Response by James Carr to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan HM1 Response by Heather Moore to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan BACH1 Response by Mr & Mrs Bach to the Draft Water Resources Management Plan WTC1 Response by Windermere Town Council to the notification by United Utilities of the Examination MAWD1 Response by Mr & Mrs Mawdsley to the notification by United Utilities of the Examination BPC1 Response by Blindbothel Parish Council to the notification by United Utilities of the Examination

EXAMINATION SUBMISSIONS United Utilities UU1 United Utilities’ response to the Inspector’s Initial Questions UU2 Statement of Common Ground between United Utilities and Natural England, August 2014 UU3 Statement of Common Ground between United Utilities and the Environment Agency, August 2014 UU4 Statement by United Utilities for the Examination in Public UU4a Errata to statement by United Utilities for the Examination in Public UU5 Further Common Ground between United Utilities and the Environment Agency, 12 September 2014 UU6 Supporting slides for 2nd September EiP Meeting (EA/NE/UU) Environment Agency EA3 Environment Agency’s response to the Inspector’s Initial Questions

5

15/9/2014

EA4 Statement by the Environment Agency for the Examination in Public EA5 Flow data for the River Ehen - 2010 to current day EA6 Ranges of project completion dates, United Utilities Natural England NE2 Statement by Natural England for the Examination in Public NE2a Appendix 1 to written representation by Natural England NE2b Appendix 2 to written representation by Natural England NE2c Appendix 3 to written representation by Natural England Ofwat OF3 Written representation by Ofwat OF4 Email from Ofwat dated 1 September 2014 Friends of the Lake District FLD2 Written representation by Friends of the Lake District Sellafield Ltd. SL1 Written representation by Sellafield Ltd. United Utilities Customer Challenge Group CCG1 Written representation by United Utilities Customer Challenge Group

6