DOCSLIB.ORG

Thompson, Mark S. (2009) the Rise of the Scientific Soldier As Seen Through the Performance of the Corps of Royal Engineers During the Early 19Th Century

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Thompson, Mark S. (2009) the Rise of the Scientific Soldier As Seen Through the Performance of the Corps of Royal Engineers During the Early 19Th Century Thompson, Mark S. (2009) The Rise of the Scientific Soldier as Seen Through the Performance of the Corps of Royal Engineers During the Early 19th Century. Doctoral thesis, University of Sunderland. Downloaded from: http://sure.sunderland.ac.uk/id/eprint/3559/ Usage guidelines Please refer to the usage guidelines at http://sure.sunderland.ac.uk/policies.html or alternatively contact [email protected]. THE RISE OF THE SCIENTIFIC SOLDIER AS SEEN THROUGH THE PERFORMANCE OF THE CORPS OF ROYAL ENGINEERS DURING THE EARLY 19TH CENTURY. Mark S. Thompson. A thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements of the University of Sunderland for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. February 2009 TABLE OF CONTENTS. Table of Contents.................................................................................................ii Tables and Figures. ............................................................................................iii List of Appendices...............................................................................................iv Abbreviations .....................................................................................................v Abstract ....................................................................................................vi Acknowledgements............................................................................................vii SECTION 1. INTRODUCTION......................................................................... 1 1.1. Context .................................................................................................. 1 1.2. The Military in the Age of Enlightenment............................................... 3 1.3. Historiography of military engineering during the Peninsular War......... 9 1.4. Structure of Thesis............................................................................... 15 SECTION 2. HISTORICAL AND POLITICAL CONTEXT............................... 17 2.1. Britain in the Long 18th Century ........................................................... 17 2.2. The British Government during the Napoleonic Wars ......................... 19 2.3. Military responsibilities outside of the Cabinet..................................... 28 2.4. The Board of Ordnance ....................................................................... 31 SECTION 3. THE RISE OF THE SCIENTIFIC SOLDIER.............................. 36 3.1 Overview............................................................................................... 36 3.2. Education, Training and the rise of the Scientific Soldier. ................... 37 3.3. Analysis of Royal Engineers Officers.................................................. 78 3.4. Careers of the Engineer officers.......................................................... 89 3.5. Conclusion from Section 3................................................................. 116 SECTION 4 – OPERATIONAL PERFORMANCE .......................................... 118 4.1. Overview of Section 4........................................................................ 118 4.2. Sieges in the Peninsula ..................................................................... 119 4.3. Torres Vedras and other defences .................................................... 205 4.4. River and Road Communications...................................................... 208 4.5. Surveying and Reconnaissance ........................................................ 214 4.6. Activity with the Army on Operations................................................. 218 4.7. Relationship with the Royal Staff Corps ........................................... 223 4.8. Improvements in Training and Experience ........................................ 224 4.9. Review of performance during the Peninsular War. .......................... 229 SECTION 5. AFTER THE PENINSULAR WAR........................................... 232 5.1. Introduction........................................................................................ 232 5.2. 1814-15, Holland, America and Waterloo.......................................... 232 5.3. From the Napoleonic to Crimean wars .............................................. 235 5.4. The Army’s response to education .................................................... 238 SECTION 6. CONCLUSIONS...................................................................... 240 BIBLIOGRAPHY ............................................................................................. 248 APPENDICES ................................................................................................ 258 ii TABLES AND FIGURES. Table 3a. Size of the Royal Military Academy. ................................................. 40 Table 3b. Occupation of fathers of Royal Engineer officers. ............................ 80 Table 3c. Breakdown of obtaining first commission.......................................... 82 Table 3d. Actual and Establishment levels in the Royal Engineers. .............. 91 Table 3e. Royal Engineer Officers by Location. ............................................... 92 Table 3f. Newly Commissioned Engineer Officers............................................ 92 Table 3g. Officer numbers summary................................................................. 93 Table 3h. Officers killed and wounded in the Peninsula ................................... 95 Table 3i. Time taken to reach Lieutenant-Colonel In the Army....................... 101 Table 3j. Royal Engineer Officers by seniority, Part A.................................... 102 Table 3k. Royal Engineer Officers by seniority, Part B................................... 104 Table 4a. Casualties at sieges and major battles. .......................................... 120 Table 4b. Comparison of sieges and blockades............................................. 121 Table 4c. Sieges : Reasons for surrender to the French. ............................... 122 Figure 4.1. Map of Badajoz............................................................................. 124 Table 4e. Timeline for first siege of Badajoz................................................... 125 Table 4f. Timeline for second siege of Badajoz.............................................. 145 Table 4g. Comparison of the ordnance at the start of the sieges of Badajoz. 147 Table 4h. Guns available each morning of the 2nd siege of Badajoz. ............. 148 Table 4i. Timeline for siege of Ciudad Rodrigo............................................... 154 Table 4j. Timeline for third siege of Badajoz................................................... 163 Table 4k. Timeline for siege of Burgos. .......................................................... 177 Table 4l. Timeline for first siege of San Sebastian. ........................................ 184 Table 4m. Timeline for second siege of San Sebastian. ................................ 195 Table 4n. Summary of outcomes of sieges. ................................................... 201 Figure 4.2. The notebooks of G.I.P. West. R.E. and C.R. Scott. R.S.C. ........ 225 iii LIST OF APPENDICES Appendix A Royal Military Academy syllabus, 1792. Appendix B Royal Engineer operational experience prior to the Peninsular War Appendix C Royal Engineers in the Peninsula by month Appendix D Pay and Allowances Appendix E Royal Engineer commissions by year, 1758-1822 Appendix F Time taken to reach Lieut.-Colonel in the Royal Engineers Appendix G Alphabetical list of officers of the Royal Engineers 1808-15 Appendix H List of officers of the Royal Engineers 1808-15 by seniority Appendix I Key Engineer Officers during the period 1808-1815 Appendix J Time taken to reach brevet army ranks Appendix K Sieges during the Peninsular War Appendix L Glossary of engineering terms Appendix M British river crossings during the Peninsular War iv ABBREVIATIONS Abbreviation Description ADC Aide-de-Camp ADD British Library Manuscripts BL British Library CRE Commanding Royal Engineer. EIC East India Company IGF Inspector General of Fortifications. The most senior Royal Engineer. NAM National Army Museum QMG Quarter-Master-General RA Royal Artillery RE Royal Engineer REM Royal Engineers Museum RMA Royal Military Artificers RSC Royal Staff Corps RSM Royal Sappers and Miners WD Wellington’s Despatches. 1st Edition unless stated otherwise. WO War Office papers, National Archives. WSD Wellington’s Supplementary Despatches v ABSTRACT The second half of the 18th century saw the formation of the first establishments to provide formal training to officers prior to receiving their first commission. The first school, the Royal Military Academy, was formed in 1741 by the Board of Ordnance to train Artillery and Engineer Officers. It was 1800 before the army formed a similar establishment and the building blocks were in place for the creation of the Scientific Soldier. This thesis will look at the formation of the Royal Military Academy and look at the training that officers received with a focus on those officers destined to serve during the Peninsular War. The complementary roles and training of the Royal Military Artificers and the eventual formation of the School of Military Engineering will be described. A thorough review will then be undertaken of the officers in the Royal Engineers, the numbers, their background, the locations they served in and the tasks they carried out. A new review of the sieges during the war will be completed using unpublished material. The other roles undertaken by the Royal Engineers in the
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Thompson, Mark S. (2009) the Rise of the Scientific Soldier As Seen Through the Performance of the Corps of Royal Engineers During the Early 19Th Century
    Thompson, Mark S. (2009) The Rise of the Scientific Soldier as Seen Through the Performance of the Corps of Royal Engineers During the Early 19th Century. Doctoral thesis, University of Sunderland. Downloaded from: http://sure.sunderland.ac.uk/3559/ Usage guidelines Please refer to the usage guidelines at http://sure.sunderland.ac.uk/policies.html or alternatively contact [email protected]. THE RISE OF THE SCIENTIFIC SOLDIER AS SEEN THROUGH THE PERFORMANCE OF THE CORPS OF ROYAL ENGINEERS DURING THE EARLY 19TH CENTURY. Mark S. Thompson. A thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements of the University of Sunderland for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. February 2009 TABLE OF CONTENTS. Table of Contents.................................................................................................ii Tables and Figures. ............................................................................................iii List of Appendices...............................................................................................iv Abbreviations .....................................................................................................v Abstract ....................................................................................................vi Acknowledgements............................................................................................vii SECTION 1. INTRODUCTION......................................................................... 1 1.1. Context .................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • The Royal Engineers Journal
    _ _I_·_ 1__ I _ _ _ __ ___ The Royal Engineers Journal. Sir Charles Paley . Lieut.-Col. P. H. Keay 77 Maintenance of Landing Grounds . A. Lewis-Dale, Esq. 598 The Combined Display, Royal Tournament, 1930 Bt. Lieut.-Col. N. T. Fitzpatrik 618 Restoration of Whitby Water Supply . Lieut. C. E. Montagu 624 Notes on the Engineers in the U.S. Army . "Ponocrates" 629 A Subaltern in the Indian Mutiny, Part I . Bt. CoL C. B. Thackeray 683 The Kelantan Section of the East Coast Railway, F.M.S.R. Lieut. Ll. Wansbrough-Jones 647 The Reconstruction of Tidworth Bridge by the 17th Field Company, R.E., in April, 1930 . Lient. W. B. Sallitt 657 The Abor Military and Political Mission, 1912-13. Part m. Capt. P. G. Huddlestcn 667 Engineer Units of the Officers' Training Corps . Major D. Portway 676 Some Out-of-the-Way Places .Lieut.-CoL L. E. Hopkins 680 " Pinking" . Capt. K. A. Lindsay 684 Office Organization in a Small Unit . Lieut. A. J. Knott 691 The L.G.O.C. Omnibus Repair Workshop at Chiswick Park Bt. Major G. MacLeod Ross 698 Sir Theo d'O Lite and the Dragon .Capt. J. C. T. Willis 702 Memoirs.-Wing-Commander Bernard Edward Smythies, Lieut.-Col. Sir John Norton-Griffiths . 705 Sixty Years Ago. 0 Troop-Retirement Scheme. 712 Books. Magazines. Correspondence. 714 VOL. XLIV. DECEMBER, 1930. CHATHAM: Tun INSTITUTION OF ROYAL ENGINZZBS. TZLEPHONZ: CHATHAM, 2669. AGZNTS AND PRINTERS: MACZAYS LTD. All it tt EXPAMET EXPANDED METAL Specialities "EXPAMET" STEEL SHEET REINFORCEMENT FOR CONCRETE. "EXPAMET" and "BB" LATHINGS FOR PLASTERWORK.
    [Show full text]
  • Military Aspects of Hydrogeology: an Introduction and Overview
    Downloaded from http://sp.lyellcollection.org/ by guest on September 28, 2021 Military aspects of hydrogeology: an introduction and overview JOHN D. MATHER* & EDWARD P. F. ROSE Department of Earth Sciences, Royal Holloway, University of London, Egham, Surrey TW20 0EX, UK *Corresponding author (e-mail: [email protected]) Abstract: The military aspects of hydrogeology can be categorized into five main fields: the use of groundwater to provide a water supply for combatants and to sustain the infrastructure and defence establishments supporting them; the influence of near-surface water as a hazard affecting mobility, tunnelling and the placing and detection of mines; contamination arising from the testing, use and disposal of munitions and hazardous chemicals; training, research and technology transfer; and groundwater use as a potential source of conflict. In both World Wars, US and German forces were able to deploy trained hydrogeologists to address such problems, but the prevailing attitude to applied geology in Britain led to the use of only a few, talented individuals, who gained relevant experience as their military service progressed. Prior to World War II, existing techniques were generally adapted for military use. Significant advances were made in some fields, notably in the use of Norton tube wells (widely known as Abyssinian wells after their successful use in the Abyssinian War of 1867/1868) and in the development of groundwater prospect maps. Since 1945, the need for advice in specific military sectors, including vehicle mobility, explosive threat detection and hydrological forecasting, has resulted in the growth of a group of individuals who can rightly regard themselves as military hydrogeologists.
    [Show full text]
  • Rsme Matters
    G N I R E E N I G N E Y R A T I L I M rsme F O L O O H C S L A Y matters O R E ISSUE 3 : NOVEMBER 2009 H T M O R F S W E N Inside: Learning Lessons in Afghanistan Working together to train our soldiers for operations NOVEMBER 2009 03 rsme matters Contents Features Introduction ............................................4 6 8 New CO for 1 RSME ...............................4 Safety Update .........................................5 Open Day ................................................6 The Class of 2009 – Sapper Volunteers ..................................8 OPEN DAY THE CLASS OF 2009 – Thousands of people crowded into SAPPER VOLUNTEERS Army Show and Trade Village ...............10 Brompton Barracks for the RSME RSME Matters has enlisted the help Open Day. The afternoon was a of 6 willing volunteer sappers and Look at Life ...........................................11 great success with both the arena will follow them from the basic B3 events and the display areas Combat Engineering training through Medway Recce .....................................11 proving equally popular... their trade training and on into the Read more on page 6 field army... Read more on page 8 Construction Update: ...........................12 Eco Greenhouse ...................................13 Learning Lessons in Afghanistan .........14 11 Padre Pat Aldred ..................................16 Veterans at Chatham and Memorial Service ...........................16 Top Bucket 2009 ..................................17 Sky High for Charity .............................18
    [Show full text]
  • The Junior British Army Officer: Experience and Identity, 1793-1815
    The Junior British Army Officer: Experience and Identity, 1793-1815 by David Lachlan Huf, B.A. (Hons) School of Humanities (History) Submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy, Arts University of Tasmania, June 2017 ii Declaration of Originality This thesis contains no material which has been accepted for a degree or diploma by the University or any other institution, except by way of background information and duly acknowledged in the thesis, and to the best of my knowledge and belief, no material previously published or written by another person except where due acknowledgement is made in the test of the thesis, nor does this thesis contain any material that infringes copyright. Signed ………………… Date 07/06/2017 Declaration of Authority to Access This thesis is not to be made available for loan or copying for two years following the date this statement was signed. Following that time, the thesis may be made available for loan and limited copying and communication in accordance with the Copyright Act 1968. Signed ………………… Date 07/06/2017 iii Acknowledgements This thesis is the culmination of an eight-year association with the University of Tasmania, where I started studying as an undergraduate in 2009. The number of people and institutions who I owe the deepest gratitude to during my time with the university and especially during the completion of my thesis is vast. In Gavin Daly and Anthony Page, I am privileged to have two supervisors who are so accomplished in eighteenth-century British history, and the history of the French Revolutionary and Napoleonic era.
    [Show full text]
  • 5C Defence Heritage – Napoleonic
    EB 11.15c PROJECT: Shepway Heritage Strategy DOCUMENT NAME: Theme 5c: Defence Heritage - Napoleonic Version Status Prepared by Date V01 INTERNAL DRAFT B Found 13/10/16 Comments – First draft of text. No illustrations. Needs current activities added and opportunities updated. Version Status Prepared by Date V02 Version Status Prepared by Date V03 Version Status Prepared by Date V03 Version Status Prepared by Date V04 Version Status Prepared by Date V05 5c Defence Heritage – Napoleonic 1 Summary Shepway contains an exceptionally significant collection of Napoleonic period fortifications. Notable works of this period include the great programme of Martello building, construction of the Grand Redoubt at Dymchurch and the cutting of the Royal Military Canal. The collection of Napoleonic period defences in Shepway District form a group of sites of outstanding importance. 2 Overview 2.1 Background The French Revolution of 1789 and the deposition of Louis XVI of France sent shockwaves across the whole of Europe and ultimately saw war spread across Europe and the overseas colonies. Throughout this period Britain was engaged almost continuously in wars with France, ending ultimately with the defeat of Napoleon. The outbreak of the Revolutionary Wars (1793-1802) and subsequent Napoleonic Wars (1803 – 1815) saw an extensive system of new defences built in stages across the district. At the start of this period Britain was primarily a maritime nation, with only a small standing army. Naval supremacy was Britain’s traditional first line of defence; by controlling the channel and blockading the French fleet in its ports the Admiralty was confident that it could protect Britain from invasion.
    [Show full text]
  • The Royal Engineers Journal
    The Royal Engineers Journal VOL. LVIII SEPTEMBER, 1944 5Ii *A CONTENTS The S.M.E. Comes to Chatham . Lt.-Col. F. S.,Garwood 149 Vive L'Entente Cordiale . Col. H. B.. Harrison lss The Sudan Defence Force Goes to War . Brig. iA. J. Knoit 157 Still More War Books . J.E.E. 171 Musings on Roads (Part I) . Col. E. SGt. G. Kirke 976 A Private View .A.R.A.I. 181 A Minor Bridging Episode . Brig. H. de L. Panet 182 Post-War Army Housing Buccaneer 109 R.E. Work for the Mechanization of the Army (Part II) . 195 Memoirs. Books. Magazines. Correspondence. 199 1 1 II Published Quarterly by THE INSTITUTION OF ROYAL ENGINEERS CHATHAM, KENT Telephone: Chatham 2669 AGENTS and PRINTERS: W. & J. MACKAY & CO., LTD., CHATHAM. LONDON AGENTS: HUGH REES, LTD., 47, PALL MALL, S.W.I. INSTITUTION OF RE OFFICE COPY DO NOT REMOVE II _ NOFRANGO PROCESS (Patented) Is very briefly a cement sand rendering on a fabric. It is useful for the cheap and quick construction of boundary walls, swimming pools, drinking troughs, sheds, permanent camouflage, and where other materials are not easily available can be used for-general purpose building. NOFRANGO bungalows or houses are com- pletely waterproof, do not absorb moisture, are clean, sanitary, comfortable. For instructions and the fabric, apply: THE CEMENTATION CO. LTD. BENTLEY WORKS DONCASTER Telephone: Doncaster Telegrams: Cementation 54177-8-9. Doncaster. ADVERTISEMENTS i 1 1BH 0 2 - 31 ;14 m ·00 -5U, 5 I L. L,~' b > THE VICTAULIC COMPANY LTD. Brook House, 113 Park Lane, London, W.1.
    [Show full text]
  • The Properties and Uses of Roman Cement
    Construction History Vol. 18. 2002 The Properties and Uses of Roman Cement Lawrance Hurst INTRODUCTION Dunng at least the first half of the nmeteenth century mortar meant a rmxture of llme and sand, cement meant Roman cement, and concrete at least In terms of bulldlngs was a mxture of fine and coarse aggregate with llme Roman cement, which was patented by James Parker ln 1796, was an Important addition to the constructor's armoury It was an hydraullc blnder, which set in the presence of water, a set qulckly, and was waterproof Previously only some of these charactenstlcs could be obtalned by the addltlon of a puzzola~caddltlve to llme It IS not now generally appreclated that most Roman cements set In a matter of mlnutes, so it was not a stralght replacement of hme as used In mortar, render or concrete, nor could lt be replaced ln all respects by Portland cement New techmques needed to be developed for uslng lt and novel applications were found for lt, such as Charles Fowler's tlle creaslng for floors and roofs Its use conhnued after ~t had been largely superseded by Portland cement because of lts qulck settlng, its waterproofing propertles and ~tssupenor adheslon to Iron and steel compared with nlneteenth century Portland cements Ths paper cites contemporary references from the nlneteenth and early twentieth century, supplemented by personal observat~ons,to show how Roman cement was applled and used, and for what purposes The references suggest that lt was used more wldely than IS generally recognlsed today. The paper concentrates on bond, waterproofing, mortar, concrete and s~mlaruses, because Frank Kelsall12and Ian Bnstow3have wntten on stucco and render The paper relates to work ln the Unlted Klngdom but it IS thought that cements w~thslmlar propertles were used in the malnland of Europe and in Amenca.
    [Show full text]
  • The Peninsular War Letters of Lancelot Machell RE
    The Napoleon Series Reviews Machell, Lancelot. The Peninsular War Letters of Lancelot Machell RE. Mark S. Thompson (ed.). Published by Mark S. Thompson, 2017. 132 pages. Paperback. ISBN# 9781517647308. $12 Considering the pivotal role that the Royal Engineers played in the Peninsular War, there are relatively few memoirs, diaries, and letters published in the past 200 years by them. Mark Thompson, who has written extensively on the Royal Engineers in the Peninsular War, including the definitive book on them: Wellington’s Engineers: Military Engineering in the Peninsular War 1808 - 1814. He also published The Peninsular War Diary of Edmund Mulcaster RE, 1808 - 1810. His latest book is also about the Royal Engineers, but contains the letters of an officer who was in the Royal Corps of Sappers and Miners. This is the only primary source I know of written by an officer who was in that Corps during the Napoleonic Wars. Lancelot Machell was born in 1792 and was a cadet at the Royal Military Academy at Woolwich when the first letter was written. He was commissioned on 21 July 1810 and by 1811 was assigned to Plymouth Dock. While there he was under the command of Captain Charles Pasley, an innovative Royal Engineer, who served as his mentor. In October 1812 he was ordered to the Peninsula. He was killed in action on 25 July 1813 at the siege of San Sebastian. During these years he wrote many letters home describing his daily life, both at school, in garrison, and on campaign. There are several things that makes this book stand out: - The author goes into detail on his studies at the Royal Military Academy in preparation of becoming a Royal Engineer.
    [Show full text]
  • Diletta&Nbsp;D'andrea&Nbsp
    Diletta D’Andrea (University of Messina) Gould Francis Leckie and the ‘insular strategy’ of Great Britain in the Mediterranean, 1800-15 Foreword Once the British government decided to intervene against the French expansion in Europe, Great Britain occupied a series of islands in the Mediterranean. With the possession of Corsica (1794-96), Elba (1796), Malta (from 1800) and the Ionian Islands (1809), as well as with that sort of British protectorate over Sicily which sanctioned the ‘English Decade’ 1806-1815 in the island, Great Britain began to exercise a new political influence and a strong trading power in that crucial area. These insular positions in the Mediterranean became ‘ political workshops ’, where significant political and constitutional experiences were carried out on the model of British institutions, for example through the Constitution of Anglo-Corsican Kingdom in 1794, the Sicilian Constitution in 1812, the British Crown Colony in Malta in 1813, the Constitution of the United States of the Ionian Islands in 1817. The insular strategy, which during the First and Second Coalition (1793- 1802) had brought Great Britain to occupy for brief periods of time Corsica and Elba, and then to keep firmly the possession of Malta, entered into a new perspective in 1805 when the war led by the Third Coalition against Napoleonic France began. In 1806, in fact, British government sent out its army and navy to protect Sicily from a possible French invasion and to help the Bourbons to re-conquer their peninsular dominions. From 1806 to 1815, Sicily proved both a military basis and a commercial post of great value for the British in the Mediterranean.
    [Show full text]
  • The Qawasim and British Control of the Arabian Gulf Mubarak Al-Otabi
    The Qawasim and British Control of the Arabian Gulf Mubarak Al-Otabi Thesis presented for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy University of Salford International Studies Unit 1989 Author's Note While every effort has been made to standardise proper and place names, it will be appreciated that these have undergone variation in transliteration since the middle of the eighteenth century; where archaisms occur, as in contemporary writings, reports and journals, these have been retained so as not to lose the period flavour they lend to the narrative TABLE OF CONTENTS Chapter Title Page 1 The situation in the Gulf in the 1 first half of the eighteenth century 2 The emergence of the Qawasim as 23 a new political power in the Gulf 3 The Wahabi movement and its effect 38 on the political history of the area (1800-1818) 4 Franco-British rivalry in the Gulf 58 (1798-1810) 5 Qawasim activity in the Gulf 107 6 The 1819 expedition and the pacifico‘lin 127 of the Gulf 7 Conclusions 164 Appendices A. The government of India 168 B. Treaty concluded between the 173 Honourable East India Company and His Highness the Imaum of Muskat, 12 October 1798 . C. Further treaty between the 176 Honourable East India Company and His Highness the Imaum of Muskat, 18 January 1800 D. General treaty with the Arab 178 tribes of the Persian Gulf, 1820 Bibliography 182 SUMMARY THE QAWASIM AND BRITISH CONTROL OF THE ARABIAN GULF For 150 years after 1820, Oman and the littoral sheikhdoms of the Arabian Gulf were known respectively as Trucial Oman and the Trucial States.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Chapter 1 Ik Brunel and William Gravatt
    CHAPTER 1 I.K. BRUNEL AND WILLIAM GRAVATT: THEIR TRAINING AND EARLY CAREERS This chapter brings together evidence relating to the formative years and early careers of I.K. Brunel and William Gravatt, beginning with a review of their education and training up to August 1826 when Marc Brunel engaged Gravatt to assist his son in the Thames Tunnel. Their work together in the tunnel is examined next, and the chapter concludes with an investigation of their activities during the period from the shut-down of the tunnel in August 1828 through to the passage of the Great Western Railway Bill in August 1835. According to the generally accepted version of events, Brunel's precocious talent for technical and mathematical subjects was enthusiastically encouraged by Marc. At the age of 14 he was sent to France for three years, where he studied at the College of Caen and the Lycée Henri Quatre in Paris in preparation for sitting the entrance examination of the prestigious École Polytechnique. When his attempt to gain entry to the Polytechnique was thwarted on the grounds of his nationality, he became a pupil of Louis Breguet.1 Jean-Francois Belhoste of the École Pratique des Hautes Études, Paris, has recently challenged some aspects of this version of events.2 He reviewed the evidence from a French perspective and has questioned the plausibility of Brunel having studied for a regulation-bound examination to enter the École Polytechnique only to discover at the last minute that there were conditions of nationality to be met. He has suggested that it is more likely that Brunel returned to England in consequence of Marc's embittered feelings towards the members of the Corps des Ponts et Chaussees, who were all graduates of the École Polytechnique and whom Marc had found to be obstructive in his attempts to renew his professional and business contacts in France in the early 1820s.
    [Show full text]