Locale-Specific Sugar Packet Opening by Lesser Antillean Bullfinches In
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
J. Field Ornithol. 73(1):82±85, 2002 Locale-speci®c sugar packet opening by Lesser Antillean Bull®nches in Barbados Simon M. Reader,1,3,4 Daniel Nover,2 and Louis Lefebvre2 1 Bellairs Institute of McGill University, Barbados, West Indies 2 McGill University, MontreÂal, Canada Received 8 January 2001; accepted 11 April 2001 ABSTRACT. Lesser Antillean Bull®nches Loxigilla noctis were observed opening packets of sugar on the grounds of a hotel on the west coast of Barbados. We presented closed sugar packets at 40 sites in 10 areas on the west coast, near the site where opening was originally observed, to determine whether the foraging behavior was locale- speci®c. Bull®nches only touched, opened, and fed from sugar packets at the original opening site, suggesting that the behavior pattern was speci®c to that location. SINOPSIS. Individuos de Loxigilla noctis abren paquetes de azuÂcar en una aÂrea localizada de Bar- bados Se observaron individuos de Loxigilla noctis abriendo paquetes de azuÂcar en un hotel de la costa oeste de Barbados. Para determinar si este patroÂn de forrajeo era especõ®co de esta zona, colocamos paquetes de azuÂcar en 40 sitios repartidos entre 10 localidades de la costa cercanas al lugar donde observamos la conducta. Las aves de la zona del hotel fueron las uÂnicas que abrieron los paquetes y se alimentaron del azuÂcar, lo que sugiere que el patroÂn de conducta es especõ®co de la zona. Key words: behavioral ¯exibility, foraging techniques, innovation, opportunism, social learning Lesser Antillean Bull®nches are omnivorous, (grid reference 5547 5922), in the parish of St. feeding on fruits, seeds, insects, and routinely James, Barbados. A bull®nch fed from a small visiting scraps of food left by humans (Pinchon hole in the ¯at side of a single-serving packet 1964; Evans 1990; Dolman et al. 1996). Bull- of white sugar (5.5 3 3.7 cm), removing the ®nches will readily feed on dissolved sugar and packet into a nearby bush after feeding for ca. fruit juice (Pinchon 1964; Webster and Lefebv- 60 s. It was not possible to determine the sex re 2000), including leftover cocktails and syrup of the individual involved, since male bull®nch- bottles, and have also been observed feeding es on Barbados have a similar plumage to fe- from open sugar bowls (S.M. Reader, pers. males, in contrast to the rest of the eastern Ca- obs.). In 2000, bull®nches on Barbados were ribbean (Bond 1985; Evans 1990). To deter- observed opening an unusual food source, mine whether bull®nches were responsible for sealed paper packets of sugar. We describe here packet opening, a single packet (obtained from our observations of the behavior pattern, and the hotel) was placed approximately 1 m from experiments to determine whether the behavior two observers. A bull®nch approached the pattern is locale-speci®c. Field observations of packet within 30 s, and began pecking at the opening behavior in birds are of particular in- ¯at packet surface. After ca. 20 s, the ®nch had terest because they add ecological validity to the made a hole and began feeding on the sugar, many captive tests that utilize opening of an occasionally widening the hole by pushing in apparatus. the beak. The packet was removed for exami- The feeding behavior was ®rst observed in nation, and a second packet placed 0.3 m from the mid afternoon (14:45±15:45) on 16 May the observers. The packet was moved by a bull- 2000 in the grounds of the Colony Club hotel ®nch to a distance of 1 m after a period of 5± 10 min, where the ®nch repeatedly turned the 3 Current address: Department of Biology, McGill packet over, but did not make pecking attempts University, 1205 avenue Docteur Pen®eld, MontreÂal, and eventually abandoned the packet. A second QueÂbec, H3A 1B1, Canada. bull®nch, distinguishable from the previously 4 Corresponding author. Email: ,simon.reader@ observed birds by virtue of its smaller size, ap- mcgill.ca. proached and opened the packet by pecking at 82 Vol. 73, No. 1 Bull®nch Locale-speci®c Foraging Behavior 83 the ¯at surface. A larger bull®nch subsequently morning, the grounds of the Colony Club ho- fed from this hole. Examination of the opened tel, the north of the Coral Reef Club hotel (grid packets revealed a hole in each of ca. 5 3 2 reference 5551 5913), the south of the Coral mm, of similar appearance to holes made by Reef Club (5547 5910), the west of Bellairs bull®nches in ripe fruit such as banana. Research Institute (5555 5905), and to the In total, four observations were made of bull- north of St. James' Church (5570 5888). In the ®nches feeding from sugar packets on 16 May, afternoon of the following day, we tested at the with at least two different individuals observed following sites: the south of St. James' Church opening the packets. One observation was (5571 5881), the east of Bellairs (5567 5906), made of an individual feeding from a packet the east of the Coral Reef Club (5555 5911), opened by another. To our knowledge, this is the Colony Club, and the west edge of the the ®rst recorded observation of this behavior Balmford estate to the north of the Colony pattern. Lefebvre et al. (1997, 1998) collected Club (5542 5932). Grid references are the stan- over 1800 reports of foraging innovation in dard metric system for plotting precise locations birds from the published literature, and the in Barbados and many other nations (including only remotely similar cases we found in this Canada, Great Britain, and Australia). Grid ref- database were Passeriformes and Piciformes ex- erences are typically split into three parts: the ploiting hummingbird nectar feeders (Taylor 100 km square in which they lie, the easting (a 1972; Fisk 1973; Leck 1974; Fisher 1975; Mar- measure of longitude, read from the horizontal tin 1977; Stokes and Stokes 1984, 1985; Beach map edge), and the northing (a measure of lat- 1988). On 24 May 2000 further observations itude). Barbados is covered by one 100 km map of packet opening were made at the Colony square, so the ®rst part of the grid reference is Club hotel. Initially, brown colored packets of not required. The furthest study area was 500 raw sugar were placed at the site, but after 35 m from the Colony Club sites. min of observation only one ®nch had ap- At each of these 10 areas, two observers with proached the packets and made a failed attempt synchronized stopwatches conducted tests at to open them. We then placed the white pack- four sites simultaneously, so that if opening was ets of white sugar used by the hotel on the observed at more than one site we could deter- ground. Bull®nches were observed picking up, mine how many birds were involved. Conduct- opening, and carrying the packets away. Bana- ing the four tests consecutively in the same area naquits (Coereba ¯aveola) picked up the packets would risk attracting the same bird to each site and fed on sugar which had fallen out of an in turn, producing a false picture of the open- opened packet, and a Zenaida Dove (Zenaida ing activity in each area. It was unlikely that aurita) pecked at the same packet that a ®nch the same ®nches were observed in different had recently contacted, as well as feeding on study areas, since ®nches show very high site sugar it knocked out of an already opened ®delity (Webster and Lefebvre 2001), and on packet. each day the study areas were at least 50 m To determine whether the sugar packet open- apart and visually isolated from one another. All ing behavior was locale-speci®c or part of the the test sites were open to the public, but were usual bull®nch behavioral repertoire, we con- chosen to be as free from disturbance and hu- ducted a simple ®eld experiment. We placed man traf®c as possible. packets of sugar at a total of 40 sites, in 10 In the experiments, ®nches only contacted different areas in St. James, Barbados, and and opened sugar packets at the Colony Club watched for any bird activity. We obtained sug- sites. In the morning session, rapid opening was ar packets of a similar design and color to those observed at one site at the Colony Club. A used at the Colony Club hotel from Barbados ®nch picked up a packet after 148 s, carried it Hotel Foods, St. Michael. We placed ®ve pack- ca. 3 m, and opened and fed from the packet ets in a row ca. 35 cm long at a variety of sites 156 s after the beginning of the trial. After 295 where ®nches had been recently observed. We s a second ®nch chased away the opener and observed each site for 20 min, from at least 5 fed from the hole, and several other displace- m. We conducted half the observations in the ment incidents were observed. At another Col- morning and half in the afternoon to control ony Club site a ®nch touched, but did not for time of day. The study areas were, in the open, a packet. In the afternoon testing ses- J. Field Ornithol. 84 S. M. Reader et al. Winter 2002 sions, ®nches were observed contacting the bull®nches may be socially learned by individ- packets at one site at the Colony Club study uals taking advantage of the innovation of other area, but no opening events were observed birds. In Blue Tits (Parus caeruleus) a novel for- within 20 min (though a ®nch did open a pack- aging behavior, nectar robbing from the ¯owers et 56 s after the end of one trial).