Resettlement Plan
Land Acquisition and Resettlement Plan for Rohri Document Stage: Final Project Number: 37192 November 2007
PAK: Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program – Tranche 2
Prepared by National Transmission and Despatch Company
The land acquisition and resettlement plan is a document of the borrower. The views expressed herein do not necessarily represent those of ADB’s Board of Directors, Management, or staff, and may be preliminary in nature.
ASIAN DEVELOPMENT BANK
ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF PAKISTAN
Pakistan: Power Transmission Enhancement Program (ADB TA No. 4665-PAK and Loan No. 2178)
TRANCHE 2
Subproject No. 7
New Rohri 220kV Sub-Station and Associated Transmission Lines
Short Land Acquisition and Resettlement Plan
November 30, 2007
NATIONAL TRANSMISSION AND DESPACH COMPANY (NTDC)
GOVERNMENT OF PAKISTAN Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Program ------
ii Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Table of Contents Abbreviations Definition of Terms Executive Summary
1.H INTRODUCTION...... H1
1.1H BACKGROUND...... 1H
2.H PROJECT COMPENSATION AND REHABILITATION FRAMEWORK...... H3
2.1H PAKISTAN’S LAW AND REGULATIONS ON LAND ACQUISITION AND RESETTLEMENT...... 3H
2.2H COMPARISON OF PAKISTAN LAND ACQUISITION ACT AND ADB RESETTLEMENT POLICY ...... 4H
2.3H REMEDIAL MEASURES TO BRIDGE THE GAP ...... 5H
2.4H 2.5 LEGISLATION RELEVANT TO LAND CLASSIFICATION ...... 5H
2.7H ELIGIBILITY ...... 7H
2.8H STRATEGY FOR COMPENSATION OF LAND AFFECTED BY TOWERS ...... 7H
2.9H COMPENSATION ENTITLEMENTS ...... 8H
2.10H ASSESSMENT OF COMPENSATION UNIT VALUES...... 9H
3.H ASSESSMENT OF IMPACTS ...... H10
3.1H INTRODUCTION ...... H10
3.1.1H Resettlement Field Survey ...... H10
3.1.2H Minimistaion of Impacts...... H10
3.2H IMPACTS OF POWER PLANTS AND SUB-STATION ...... H10
3.3H IMPACTS OF THE TRANSMISSION LINE ...... H11
3.4H IMPACTS ON AFFECTED HOUSEHOLDS ...... H15
3.4.1H General...... H15
4.H SOCIO-ECONOMIC PROFILE OF AFFECTED PEOPLE...... H17
4.1H CENSUS OF AFFECTED HOUSEHOLDS ...... H17
4.2H DATA ON HEADS OF AFFECTED HOUSEHOLDS ...... H18
4.3H DATA ON AFFECTED HOUSEHOLDS AND POPULATION ...... H18
5.H INSTITUTIONAL ARRANGEMENTS ...... H21
5.1H NATIONAL TRANSMISSION AND DISPATCH COMPANY ...... H21
5.2H DISTRICT GOVERNMENT ...... H22
5.3H OTHER AGENCIES AND INSTITUTIONS...... H23
5.4H RESPONSIBILITY FOR INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL MONITORING ...... H24
6.H CONSULTATION AND DISCLOSURE...... H25
6.1H CONSULTATION UNDERTAKEN FOR THE LARP...... H25
6.2H COMPENSATION OPTIONS DISCUSSED...... H26
7.H GRIEVANCE REDRESS PROCESS ...... H27
8.H BUDGET FOR LAND AND ASSET ACQUISITION ...... H28
8.1H BASIS FOR COMPENSATION...... H28
8.2H DETERMINING THE RATES FOR COMPENSATION ...... H28
8.3H BUDGET FOR LAND AND ASSET ACQUISITION ...... H31
9.H IMPLEMENTATION SCHEDULE ...... H33
10.H MONITORING AND EVALUATION...... H34
10.1H INTERNAL MONITORING ...... H34
10.2H EXTERNAL MONITORING ...... H35
10.3H INDICATORS FOR MONITORING AND EVALUATION...... H35
10.4H RESETTLEMENT DATABASE ...... H35
10.5H REPORTING REQUIREMENTS ...... H36
LARP New Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page i
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Appendices Appendix 1 – Summary of Resettlement Field Survey Appendix 2 – List of People Consulted Appendix 3 – Draft Public Information Brochure
LARP New Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page ii
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Abbreviations ADB Asian Development Bank AHs Affected households AHs Affected people CBO Community Based Organization CCPP Combined Cycle Power Plant DOR District Officer Revenues EMA External Monitoring Agency GRC Grievance Redress Committee GSC Grid System Construction (department of NTDC) IOL Inventory of Losses IPDF Indigenous Peoples Development Framework IPDP Indigenous Peoples Development Plan IPP Independent Power Producer (Private Sector Power Producer) kanal unit of land measurement: 1 kanal = 20 marlas (8 kanal = 1 acre) kV kilo-Volt (Unit of Power) LAA Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (amended) LAC Land Acquisition Collector LARF Land Acquisition and Resettlement Framework LARP Land Acquisition and Resettlement Plan LARU Land Acquisition and Resettlement Unit (NTDC) marla smallest unit of land measurement: 1 marla = 272.25 ft2 (= 25.31 m2) MOWP Ministry of Power and Water MRM Management Review Meeting NGO Non-governmental organization NTDC National Transmission and Dispatch Company PD Project Director of NTDC PIB Public Information Booklet PMU Project Management Unit PPTA Project Preparatory Technical Assistance RFS Resettlement Field Surveys ROW Right-of-way Rs. Pakistani Rupees (currency): Rs. 60.90 = US$1.00 SLARP Short Land Acquisition and Resettlement Plan SST Site Selection Board TL Transmission Line TOR Terms of Reference WAPDA Water and Power Development Authority
LARP New Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page iii
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Definition of Terms Affected persons/households (APs/AHs) mean all the people affected by land acquisition, relocation, or loss of incomes and includes any person, household (referred to as project affected family or affected household [AH]), firms, or public or private institutions. APs therefore include; i) persons affected directly by the safety corridor, right-of-way, tower or pole foundations or construction work area; (ii) persons whose agricultural land or other productive assets such as trees or crops are affected; (iii) persons whose businesses are affected and who might experience loss of income due to the project impact; (iv) persons who lose work/employment as a result of project impact; and (v) people who lose access to community resources/property as a result of the project. Compensation means payment in cash or kind for an asset to be acquired or affected by a project at replacement cost at current market value. Cut-off-date means the date after which people will NOT be considered eligible for compensation i.e. they are not included in the list of APs/AHs as defined by the census. Normally, the cut-off date is the date of the detailed measurement survey. Encroachers mean those people who move into the project area after the cut-off date and are therefore not eligible for compensation or other rehabilitation measures provided by the project. Entitlement means the range of measures comprising cash or in-kind compensation, relocation cost, income rehabilitation assistance, transfer assistance, income/livelihood restoration which are due to AHs, depending on the type and degree nature of their losses to restore their social and economic base. Inventory of losses means the pre-appraisal inventory of assets as a preliminary record of affected or lost assets. Land acquisition means the process whereby a person is compelled by a public agency to alienate all or part of the land s/he owns or possesses, to the ownership and possession of the agency for public purposes, in return for fair compensation. The land acquisition and resettlement plan is known as a LARP. Non-titled means those who have no recognizable rights or claims to the land that they are occupying and includes people using private or state land without permission, permit or grant i.e. those people without legal title to land and/or structures occupied or used by them. ADB’s policy explicitly states that such people cannot be denied compensation. Poor means those falling below the official national poverty line (equivalent to 2,350 calories per day) of Rs 848.79 per person per month (2004). Replacement cost means the method of valuing assets to replace the loss at current market value, or its nearest equivalent, and is the amount of cash or kind needed to replace an asset in its existing condition, without deduction of transaction costs or for any material salvaged. Resettlement Field Survey means the detailed inventory of losses that is completed after detailed design and marking of project boundaries on the ground, socioeconomic data on the affected households/families, and stakeholder consultations. Sharecropper means the same as tenant cultivator or tenant farmer, and is a person who cultivates land they do not own for an agreed proportion of crop or harvest. Significant impact means 200 people or more will experience major impacts, which are defined as; (i) being physically displaced from housing, or (ii) losing ten per cent or more of their productive assets (income generating). Vulnerable means any people who might suffer disproportionately or face the risk of being marginalized from the effects of resettlement and includes; (i) female-headed households with dependents; (ii) disabled household heads; (iii) poor households (within the meaning given previously); (iv) landless; (v) elderly households with no means of support; (vi) households without security of tenure; (vii) ethnic minorities; and (viii) marginal farmers (with landholdings of five acres or less).
LARP New Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page iv
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Executive Summary 1. The Subproject. The Rohri subproject (No. 7 of tranche 2) has been designed to disperse the electricity to be produced by two independent power producers (IPPs) at Dharkai and Ghotki respectively, through a new 220kV sub-station and onwards transmission to the existing 220kV sub-station at Shikarpur. This subproject will be implemented under Tranche 2 of the Power Transmission Enhancement Program of NTDC. It includes the construction of a new 220 kV sub-station at Rohri, Sukkur District (Sindh Province) and 145.7 km of 220 kV transmission line passing through three districts Ghotki, Sukkur and Shikarpur. The new 220kV sub-station will require the permanent acquisition of a total of 19 ha (47 acre) of land in Ponath village, in Rohri Tehsil, Sukkur District. Of the total, 16.2 ha (40 acres) area is privately owned by six households (100 persons), while the remaining 2.8 ha (7 acres) is owned by the provincial government. While the land is cultivable it was abandoned by the six owners about a decade ago in the hope of its sale to potential industrialists (prompted by the establishment of flour mills on adjacent land). The NTDC has already initiated the process for acquiring this land from the owners through the Executive District Officer (Revenue), District Sukkur, who has initiated negotiations with the six landowners on the basis of current market rates. 2. Resettlement Impacts. The subproject as a whole (sub-station and transmission lines) will affect 244 households (AHs) with a total population of 2,800 affected persons (APs). As mention above six AHs are associated with the sub-station. The new 145.7 km transmission line will traverse lands of some 51 villages. It will temporarily affect agricultural crops and trees of a total of 238 households (2,700 APs). For the 145.7 km long transmission lines, a total of 461 towers will be constructed. The majority of the towers are straight towers and in some cases, to avoid or reduce impacts, angular towers will be installed. Of the 461 towers, 371 towers will be constructed on private productive farmlands, while the remaining 90 towers will be constructed on unproductive land belonging to private owners (53 towers) and the local government (37 towers). Besides agricultural crops, a total of 684 trees (544 fruit trees and 140 wood trees) will be removed from the 30m wide corridor of impact. While moe than 200 people will ne affected by the subproject, the resettlement impacts are temporary and minor (i.e. no AHs will be displaced and no AHs will lose > 10% of their income generating assets. In accordance with this minor impact this Short LARP has been prepared. Compensation and rehabilitation assistance for the subproject impacts will be provided in accordance to with the following Compensation Eligibility and Entitlements (see Table 1). Table 1 – Entitlement Matrix
Affected Asset Specification Compensation Entitlements People Arable Land Access is not Farmer/Titleholder No Land compensation provided that land is rehabilitated/restored to restricted and former quality following completion of works. Compensation, in cash, for existing or current all damaged crops and trees as per item below land use will Leaseholder No Land compensation provided that the land is rehabilitated/restored to remain (registered or not) former quality following completion of works. Compensation, in cash, for unchanged all damaged crops and trees as per item below Sharecroppers Compensation, in cash or kind, for all damaged crops/trees as per item (registered or not) below Agricultural Compensation, in cash or kind, for all damaged crops/trees as per item workers below Squatters Compensation, in cash, for all damaged crops/trees as per item below
LARP New Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page v
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Asset Specification Affected People Compensation Entitlements Land for land compensation with plots of equal value and productivity to the plots lost; or cash for affected land at replacement cost based on Farmer/Titleholder market value plus 15% compulsory acquisition surcharge and free of taxes, registration, and transfer costs
Renewal of lease in plots of equal value/productivity of plots lost, or Cash All adverse Leaseholder equivalent to market value of gross yield of affected land for the remaining effects on land (registered or not) lease years (up to a maximum of 3 years). use independent of severity of Sharecroppers Cash compensation equal to market value of lost harvest share once impact (registered or not) (temporary impact) or twice (permanent impact) Arable Land where Agricultural Cash indemnity equal to salary (including portions in kind) for remaining access is workers part of agricultural year. restricted 1 rehabilitation allowance equal to market value of 1 gross harvest Squatters and/or land (additional to crop compensation) for land use loss. use will be 1 severe impact allowance equal to market value of gross harvest of Farmer/Titleholder affected Additional for affected land for 1 year (inclusive of winter and summer crop and Leaseholder severe impacts additional to standard crop compensation) (>10% of land Sharecroppers 1 severe impact allowance equal to market value of harvest share loss) (registered or not) (additional to standard crop compensation) 1 severe impact allowance equal to market value of gross harvest of the Squatters affected land for 1 year (inclusive of winter and summer crop and additional to standard crop compensation) Land x land through provision of plots comparable in value/location to plot Titleholder lost; or cash for affected land at full replacement cost free of taxes, Residential/ registration, transfer costs plus 15% compulsory acquisition surcharge. Commercial Renter, 1-3 months allowance Land Leaseholder Accommodation in a government resettlement area or a self-relocation Squatters allowance All relevant AHs, Cash compensation at replacement rate for affected structure/other fixed Houses and incl. squatters assets free of salvaged materials, depreciation or transaction costs. For Structures partial impacts full cash assistance to restore remaining structure. All AHs, incl. Crop compensation in cash at full market rate for one harvest (either squatters winter or summer) by default for impacts caused by tower bases and Crops Crops affected perimeter, stringing and access. All other crop losses will be compensated at market rates based on actual losses. All AHs, incl. Trees Trees affected squatters Cash compensation shall reflect income replacement
All AHs, incl. Business owner: (i) Cash compensation equal to 1 year income, if loss squatters permanent; (ii) cash compensation for the period of business interruption, Business loss of business if loss is temporary. Employment or employment Worker/employee: lost wages indemnity for the business interruption period up to a 3 months maximum. All AHs so Transport, Provision of sufficient allowance to cover transport expenses and Relocation affected transition costs livelihood expenses for one month.
Rehabilitation/substitution of affected structures/utilities (i.e. mosques, Community roads, schools etc. Vulnerable AH below poverty Employment priority in project-related jobs. AH line
LARP New Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page vi
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
3. Significance of Impact. As there is no restriction on access to, or use of, land, the impacts will be temporary. The impact on crops and trees is such that AHs will not experience a loss of 10% or more of their productive assets (income generating). There are no houses, shops or community structures affected. Thus, none of the 244 AHs will experience significant impacts. Therefore the overall resettlement impact is considered minor (non-significant). 4. Indigenous People Issues. All AHs are Muslim and ethnically Sindhi. There are neither tribal nor minority people amongst the AHs, and all affected land is held in private or government ownership (i.e. not tribally owned or communally held land). The ADB’s Policy on Indigenous People, as specified in the Indigenous Peoples Development Framework (IPDF) prepared for the program is not triggered, and therefore neither an IPDP nor special action is required for this subproject. 5. Participatory Land Acquisition Process. The program’s LARF has been translated into Urdu and disclosed according to ADB’s public communications policy, and it has also been uploaded to ADB’s website. Consultation has been undertaken through a series of meetings with local government agencies, AHs, as well as wider community group meetings of both men and women. The RFS was a participatory process, with the head of household assisting in the identification and calculation of losses. Further consultations will be required during the implementation of the LARP. 6. Grievance Redress Mechanism. There is also a process established to deal with any issues or concerns raised on any aspect of the LARP or compensation process. The verbal or written grievances of AHs will be heard by the district level Land Acquisition Coordinating Committees, which will be established to assist NTDC implement the LARP. 7. Cost of Plan. The total land acquisition and resettlement cost for the Rohri sub- project (220kV Sub-Station and associated transmission lines) is estimated at Rs. 343 million (US$ 5.6 million), which the NTDC will set aside and use it in complete implementation of this LARP prior to awarding of civil works contracts under this subproject. Table 2: Estimated Resettlement Cost New Rohri Subproject
No. Resettlement Activity No. Unit Total Rs.
A. Asset Compensation - - 267,737,076
A.1 Permanent Land Acqusion 47 Acres 227,362,500
A.2 Trees 684 tree 13,697,822
A.3 Agricultural Crops - - 26,676,754
B. Other Activities (TA & Training) - - 3,398,208
C. Administration Costs (15%) 0.15 lumpsum 40,670,293
D. Sub-total (A+B+C) - - 311,805,577
E. Contingency (10%) 0.10 lumpsum 31,180,558
TOTAL (Pak. Rs) 342,986,134
TOTAL (US$) 5,631,956
* US$ 1.00 = Pak. Rs. 60.90
LARP New Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page vii
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
1. INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background
1. The Government of Pakistan has requested financing from the Asian Development Bank (ADB) for implementing the Power Transmission Enhancement Investment Program (the program) to be executed through a Multi-tranche Financial Facility (MFF) divided into four tranches. The Ministry of Water and Power and the National Transmission and Dispatch Company (NTDC) are the Executing Agency (EA) and the Implementing Agency (IA), respectively. Each tranche will constitute a project which, in turn, will be divided into several sub-projects involving the construction/upgrading of sub-stations and the installation of power transmission lines. 2. The Rohri sub-project (Subproject No. 7 in tranche 2 of this MFF) includes a new 220kV sub-station (19 ha) and a total length of 145.7 km of 220kV transmission line Daharki – Ghotki – Rohri – Shikarpur transmission lines. This Short Land Acquisition and Resettlement Plan (LARP) has been prepared for the Rohri sub-project by NTDC to fit the Land Acquisition and Resettlement Framework (LARF) prepared for the program as a whole. As such the Subproject will fit the following LAR-related implementation conditions: • Signing of contracts awards for the Subproject’s civil works will be contingent to the preparation of a LARP fitting the LARF and ADB relevant polices; and • ADB issuance of notice to proceed for the implementation of the subproject’s civil works will be contingent to the full implementation of the compensation and rehabilitation programs detailed in this LARP. 3. This LARP is based on final line alignments and tower positions and fully fits the provisions of the LARF already prepared. As required by the LAR-related conditionalities for the program the LARF has been reviewed but it was not modified as the subprojects under tranche 2 require the same LAR approach as the subprojects under tranche 1. 4. As noted in the LARF and based on ADB’s OM section F2/OP & BP (2003) impacts are considered severe when >200 APs are resettled or suffer >10% loss of productive assets (income generating) and a subproject is classified as category “A” for which a full LARP is to be prepared. Conversely, when losses are minor or non- significant i.e <200 APs are to be resettled or lose <10% of productive assets, a subproject is classified as category “B” and only a short LARP is to be prepared. Although the number of APs is more than 200, none are to be resettled and the impact on each AH is minor, therefore this sub-project is classified as category ‘’B’’ and this document has been prepared following the short LARP format. 5. The following sections of this Short LARP detail: (i) the principles and eligibility/entitlement criteria for compensation or rehabilitation of AHs and APs; (ii) the LARP institutional organization; (iii) the various LARP implementation mechanisms (AH information disclosure, participation & consultation, grievance redress and monitoring); and, (iv) time schedules and budgets.
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 1
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
1.2 Description of the Sub-project 6. The sub-project is designed to disperse and distribute power made available from the Daharki and Gotki independent power producers (IPPs), the IPPs are to be based on natural gas located in the sub-project area. The Mari and Engro IPP power plants are based on low quality gas located in the Mari gas fields. 7. The two power plants are to be interconnected by means of a 220kV double circuit transmission line to the new 220kV Rohri sub-station. The Rohri-sub station is further connected to the existing 220kV Shikarpur sub-station by means of a double circuit 220 kV transmission line and to the 132 kV Gambit sub-station by means of a double circuit 132kV transmission line (which is not a part of this subproject). Rohri sub- station will be installed with three new 260 MVA 220/132kV power transformers. The interconnection concept is illustrated in Figure 1.
Figure 1: The Interconnection of Rohri Transmission Network
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 2
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
2. PROJECT COMPENSATION AND REHABILITATION FRAMEWORK
8. This section compares the Pakistani laws and regulations on land acquisition and resettlement with the requirements of the ADB Policy on Involuntary Resettlement and details summarizes the main components of the policy framework prepared specifically for the project to ensure that ADB’s policy on involuntary resettlement is complied with (refer to Section 2.4).
2.1 Pakistan’s Law and Regulations on Land Acquisition and Resettlement
9. The 1894 Land Acquisition Act (LAA) with its successive amendments is the main law regulating land acquisition for public purpose. The LAA has been variously interpreted by local governments, and some province has augmented the LAA by issuing provincial legislations. The LAA and its Implementation Rules require that following an impacts assessment/valuation effort, land and crops are compensated in cash at market rate to titled landowners and registered land tenants/users, respectively. The LAA mandates that land valuation is to be based on the latest 5-3 years average registered land sale rates, though, in several recent cases the median rate over the past year, or even the current rates, have been applied. Due to widespread land under-valuation by the Revenue Department, current market rates are now frequently used with an added 15 per cent Compulsory Acquisition Surcharge as provided in the LAA. 10. Based on the LAA, only legal owners and tenants registered with the Land Revenue Department or possessing formal lease agreements, are eligible for compensation or livelihood support. The rights of the non-titled, are however addressed under the 1986 Punjab Jinnah Abadis for Non-proprietors in Rural Areas Act which recognize to squatters the right to receive rehabilitation in form of a replacement plot. It is to be noted that this right has been sometimes extended in practice to include some form of rehabilitation in cash or in forms different from land. Projects such as Chotiari Dam, Ghazi Barotha Hydropower, and National Highways Improvement, have awarded compensation and assistance to unregistered tenants and other forms of AH (sharecroppers/squatters). 11. It must also be noted that the LAA does not automatically mandate for specific rehabilitation/assistance provisions benefiting the poor, vulnerable groups, or severely affected AHs, nor does it automatically provide for rehabilitation of income/livelihood losses or resettlement costs. This however is often done in many projects in the form of ad hoc arrangements based on negotiations between a specific EA and the AHs. 12. As noted above, exceptions to the rule are intrinsic to the fact that the law is both elastic and broadly interpreted at provincial level depending on operational requirements, local needs, and socio-economic circumstances. Recourse is often taken to ad hoc arrangements, agreements and understandings for resettlement in difficult situations. The above is also influenced by the fact that an amendment of the LAA has been considered necessary by the Ministry of Environment. Accordingly, a National Resettlement Policy (NRP) and a Resettlement Ordinance have been drafted to broaden LAA provisions and current practices so as to widen the scope of eligibility and tightening up loopholes (i.e. regarding definitions of malpractices, cut- off dates, political influence on routing, etc.). But both these documents are still awaiting government’s approval for implementation.
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 3
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
2.2 ADB’s Involuntary Resettlement Policy 13. The ADB Policy on Involuntary Resettlement is based on the following principles: • Involuntary resettlement is to be avoided or at least minimized. • Compensation must ensure the maintenance of the AHs’ pre-project living standards. • Compensation is required for any AH who as a result of a project has their access to, or use of, land restricted. • AHs should be fully informed and consulted on LAR compensation options. • AHs’ socio-cultural institutions should be supported/used as much as possible. • Compensation will be carried out with equal consideration of women and men. • Lack of formal legal land title should not be a hindrance to rehabilitation. • Particular attention should be paid to households headed by women and other vulnerable groups, such as indigenous people and ethnic minorities, and appropriate assistance should be provided to help them improve their status. • LAR should be conceived and executed as a part of the project, and the full costs of compensation should be included in project costs and benefits. • Compensation/rehabilitation assistance will be paid prior to ground leveling and demolition.
2.2 Comparison of Pakistan Land Acquisition Act and ADB Resettlement Policy
14. Table 2.1 below outlines the differences between Pakistani Law and ADB policy. Table 2.1 Pakistan and ADB Land Acquisition Policies
Pakistan’s Land Acquisition Act ADB Involuntary Resettlement Policy
Lack of title should not be a bar to compensation Land compensation only for titled landowners or and/or rehabilitation. Non-title-holders are to be holders of customary rights. rehabilitated.
Crop losses compensation provided only to Crop compensation are provided to landowners and registered landowners and lease/sharecrop tenants sharecrop/lease tenants according to their shares (Non-registered are often deprived). whether they are registered or not
Tree losses are compensated o the basis of officially Tree losses are compensated according to actual fixed rates by the Forest and Horticulture worth of affected trees based on market rates. departments
Land valuation based on the median registered land Land valuation is to be based on current replacement transfer rate over the previous 3 years. (market ) value.
Valuation of built-up structures is based on current Structures valuation based on official rates, with market value/cost of new construction of the depreciation deducted from the structure gross value. structure
Land Acquisition Collector (LAC) is the only pre- Complaints and grievances are resolved informally litigation final authority to decide disputes and through community participation in the Grievance address complaints regarding quantification and Redress Committees (GRC), local governments, assessment of compensation for the affected lands NGO and/or local-level community based and other assets organizations
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 4
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
2.3 Remedial Measures to Bridge the Gap
15. In principle, Pakistan Law and ADB Policy adhere not only to the objective of AH compensation, but also to the objective of rehabilitation. However, Pakistan law is unclear on how rehabilitation is to be achieved and in practice the provision of rehabilitation is left to ad hoc arrangements taken by local governments and specific project proponents. To clarify these issues and reconcile eventual gaps between
Pakistan Law and ADB Policy, the EA prepared the LARF for the program F1, ensuring compensation at replacement cost of all items, the rehabilitation of informal settlers, and the provision of subsidies or allowances for AHs that may be relocated, suffer business losses, or may be severely affected.
2.4 2.5 Legislation Relevant to Land Classification
16. In terms of application of the LARF prepared for the program, identifying the type of land affected is an important step in determining eligibility for compensation for land. Jurisdiction rather than use classifies land. Rural land includes irrigated land and un- irrigated land and is governed by the Land Revenue Act (1967) which must be read in conjunction with the LAA and other legislation that may also apply, including for example the Punjab Alienation of Land Act (1900), Colonization of Government Lands Act (1912) and the various Land Reform Regulations. Rural land falls under the jurisdiction of revenue districts. 17. Land, other than rural land, is urban and including all permutations there-under such as residential, commercial, built upon and buildable, and is governed by various regulations and ordinances including the People’s Local Government Ordinance (1972) for each province, Cantonments Act (1924), and Land Control Act (1952). Urban land falls under the jurisdiction of municipal and local government authorities. 18. While there are broad definitions of rural and urban land in the People’s Local Government Ordinances, such classifications are not immutable and have been, and are, changed by the Collector of Revenues and provincial governments over time. In general it is either the People’s Local Government Ordinances or the Land Revenue Act that determines the classification of land, however there are some cases where both applies and other cases where different legislation altogether can dictate jurisdiction and classification over land. Hence there is neither a universal classification nor legislation pertaining to the land that will be potentially affected under the program. 2.6 Compensation Eligibility and Entitlements for the Project 19. Land acquisition tasks under the program, and for this Daharki - Shikarpur subproject, will be implemented according to a compensation eligibility and entitlements framework in line with both Pakistan’s law/ regulation and ADB Policy. 20. A summary entitlements matrix is included in Table 2.2 below.
1 The program’s LARF has been endorsed by NTDC and has been uploaded on ADB’s website.
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 5
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Table 2.2: Compensation and Entitlement Matrix
Asset Specification Affected People Compensation Entitlements No Land compensation provided that land is rehabilitated/restored to Farmer/Titleholder former quality following completion of works. Compensation, in cash, for all damaged crops and trees as per item below Access is not No Land compensation provided that the land is rehabilitated/restored Leaseholder restricted and to former quality following completion of works. Compensation, in existing or (registered or not) Arable Land cash, for all damaged crops and trees as per item below current land use Sharecroppers Compensation, in cash or kind, for all damaged crops/trees as per will remain (registered or not) item below unchanged Compensation, in cash or kind, for all damaged crops/trees as per Agricultural workers item below Squatters Compensation, in cash, for all damaged crops/trees as per item below Land for land compensation with plots of equal value and productivity to the plots lost; or cash for affected land at replacement cost based Farmer/Titleholder on market value plus 15% compulsory acquisition surcharge and free of taxes, registration, and transfer costs All adverse Renewal of lease in plots of equal value/productivity of plots lost, or Leaseholder effects on land Cash equivalent to market value of gross yield of affected land for the (registered or not) use remaining lease years (up to a maximum of 3 years). independent of Sharecroppers Cash compensation equal to market value of lost harvest share once severity of (temporary impact) or twice (permanent impact) impact (registered or not) Arable Land Cash indemnity equal to salary (including portions in kind) for Agricultural workers where access remaining part of agricultural year. is restricted 1 rehabilitation allowance equal to market value of 1 gross harvest and/or land Squatters (additional to crop compensation) for land use loss. use will be 1 severe impact allowance equal to market value of gross harvest of affected Farmer/Titleholder Additional for affected land for 1 year (inclusive of winter and summer crop and Leaseholder severe impacts additional to standard crop compensation) (>10% of land Sharecroppers loss) 1 severe impact allowance equal to market value of harvest share (registered or not) (additional to standard crop compensation) 1 severe impact allowance equal to market value of gross harvest of Squatters the affected land for 1 year (inclusive of winter and summer crop and additional to standard crop compensation) Land x land through provision of plots comparable in value/location to plot lost; or cash for affected land at full replacement cost free of Titleholder taxes, registration, transfer costs plus 15% compulsory acquisition Residential/ surcharge. Commercial Renter, Land 1-3 months allowance Leaseholder Accommodation in a government resettlement area or a self-relocation Squatters allowance All relevant AHs, incl Cash compensation at replacement rate for affected structure/other Houses and squatters fixed assets free of salvaged materials, depreciation or transaction Structures costs. Partial impacts full cash assistance to restore structure. Crop compensation in cash at full market rate for one harvest (either winter or summer) by default for impacts caused by tower bases and Crops Crops affected All AHs, incl squatters perimeter, stringing and access. All other crop losses will be compensated at market rates based on actual losses. Trees Trees affected All AHs, incl squatters Cash compensation shall reflect income replacement Business owner: (i) Cash compensation equal to 1 year income, if loss Business Loss of business permanent; (ii) cash compensation for the period of business All AHs, incl squatters Employment or employment interruption, if loss temporary. Worker/employee: lost wages indemnity for the business interruption period up to a max. of 3 months Transport, Provision of sufficient allowance to cover transport expenses and Relocation All AHs so affected transition costs livelihood expenses for one month. Rehabilitation/substitution of affected structures/utilities (i.e. mosques, Community roads, schools etc. Vulnerable AH below poverty line Employment priority in project-related jobs. AH
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 6
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
2.7 Eligibility
21. AHs entitled for compensation or rehabilitation provisions under the program are: • All AHs affected by restricted access to, or use of, land whether they have legal title/traditional land rights or not; • Tenants and sharecroppers whether registered or not; • Owners of buildings, crops, plants, or other objects attached to the land; and • AHs losing business, income, and salaries. 22. Compensation eligibility will be limited by a cut-off date to be set for each subproject on the last date of the Resettlement Field Surveys (RFS). AHs who settle in the affected areas after the cut-off date will not be eligible for compensation. They will, however, be given sufficient advance notice, requested to vacate premises and dismantle affected structures prior to project implementation. Their dismantled structures will not be confiscated and they will not pay any fine or sanction. Forced eviction will only be considered after all other efforts are exhausted. 23. Cut-off Date: Compensation eligibility will be limited by a cut-off date fixed at the 5th September 2007 for the Rohri subproject, which was the last day of the RFS. AHs that settle in the affected areas and/or make changes in the land use patterns after this cut-off date will not be eligible for compensation. They will, however, be given sufficient advance notice requesting them to vacate premises/corridor and dismantle all affected structures and other establishments (if any) prior to project implementation. They will be allowed to reuse their salvaged material for free and they will not be asked to pay any fine for making those change. Forced eviction will only be considered after all other efforts are exhausted.
2.8 Strategy for Compensation of Land Affected by Towers
24. Besides the amended LAA, the NTDC has adopted the Telegraph Act (1885) (as amended) for the construction and maintenance of power transmission lines. The latter Act was originally framed for the construction of telegraphic poles during the British Era and later inherited by Pakistan upon independence. This Act was subsequently adopted by WAPDA for electric poles and supply lines, and eventually passed to NTDC. However, telegraphic or electric poles cover a much smaller area of land compared with transmission towers which have the potential to affect crops and grazing shrubs. The NTDC makes utmost efforts to minimize resettlement impacts, alternatively NTDC compensates affected farmers for their crop losses. 25. Thus, based on current Pakistani Law and NTDC’s practice, the land under the towers is not acquired permanently and therefore compensation is not required for land. For this Program, however, it was agreed between NTDC and ADB that the land under the tower will be acquired but would only require compensation in the case where (i) in rural areas, the tower hinders access to the land under the tower for cultivation; and/or, (ii) in urban/residential areas, the tower restricts use of the land for housing development. Based on this principle it was established that the strategy for compensation of land affected by tower construction will be different for urban/residential land (and its potential for housing development) and agricultural land. In the case of urban/residential areas, the land under towers will be considered as being permanently affected and therefore it will be acquired and compensated in full. In the case of rural areas and agricultural land, as long as the towers provide sufficient clearance to allow the continuation of crop cultivation, the land will be considered to be temporarily affected (for the duration of tower installation and stringing of the lines) and therefore will not be acquired nor compensated. However,
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 7
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
for towers with low-bars which would restrict the farmer’s access for cultivation activities, the land will be acquired permanently and compensated accordingly. 26. The construction of towers on agricultural land however will still require the provision of compensation for crops and loss of trees, for the area under the tower plus a small perimeter surrounding it (an access and working area). The area included in the perimeter has been assessed as 900 m2 for 220 kV towers and 2,500 m2 for 500 kV towers. Furthermore, as the construction of towers involves a 3-tier process, namely: (i) preparation of the foundation; (ii) erection of the tower; and, (iii) stringing of the power cables, and this process has the potential to affect three crops, and thus, compensation for three crops will be paid to the affected farmers.
2.9 Compensation Entitlements
27. Entitlement provisions for AHs cover such impacts as land losses, house and buildings losses, crops and trees losses, a relocation subsidy, rehabilitation measures, and a business losses allowance based on tax declarations and/or lump sums. These entitlements are detailed below: • Agricultural land impacts will be compensated based on whether an AH’s access to, or use of, their land is restricted. For AHs whose access to, and use of, agricultural land is not restricted i.e. they can continue to cultivate the land, compensation will be for removed or damaged crops and trees. For AHs whose access to, or use of, agricultural land is restricted i.e. they cannot continue to cultivate the land, compensation will be at replacement value in: (i) cash at current market rates plus a 15% compulsory acquisition surcharge (CAS), or (ii) through replacement land equal in value/productivity to the plot lost. When >10% of an AH’s income or agricultural land is affected, AHs (owners, leaseholders and sharecroppers) will get an additional allowance for severe impacts equal to the market value of a year’s gross yield of the land lost (inclusive of winter and summer harvest). Eventual transaction taxes/fees will either be paid by NTDC or waived by local governments. Market rates will be assessed through a survey of prevalent land prices, carried out by local government financing institutions. • Residential/commercial land will be compensated at replacement value by either (i) land for land, or (ii) cash at current market rates free of any deductions. Renters/leaseholders will receive an allowance corresponding to 3 months’ rent. • Houses, buildings, structures will be compensated in cash at replacement cost free of depreciation, salvaged materials, and transaction costs deductions. The compensation for houses/buildings will include the cost of lost water and electricity connections. • Crops: Cash compensation at current market rates for the net harvest actually lost being as it may the winter, the summer crop, or both. Crop compensation will be paid both to landowners and tenants based on their specific sharecropping agreements. • Trees: Cash compensation shall reflect income replacement (Section 2.10). • Businesses: compensation for permanent business losses will be in cash for a 1-year income based on tax declaration or, if unavailable, based on the official minimum salary; compensation for temporary business will be cash for the period of income interruption based on tax declaration or, if unavailable, official minimum salary.
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 8
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
• Business workers and employees: Indemnity for lost wages for the period of business interruption up to a maximum of 3 months. • Agricultural land leaseholders, sharecroppers, and workers: Where the access to, or use of, the land is restricted; affected leaseholders will receive either a renewal of the lease in other plots or cash corresponding to the yearly yield of land lost for remaining years of the lease up to a maximum of 3 years. Sharecroppers will receive their share of harvest at market rates (if impact is temporary) or if the land is lost permanently additional compensation for 1 crop. Agricultural workers, with contracts interrupted, will get an indemnity in cash corresponding to their salary in cash and kind for the remaining part of the agricultural year (inclusive of both winter and summer crops). • Relocation subsidy: AHs forced to relocate will receive a relocation subsidy sufficient to cover transport costs and living expenses for 1 month. • House renters: House renters who have leased a house for residential purposes will be provided with a cash grant of 3 months’ rent at the prevailing market rate in the area and will be assisted in identifying alternative accommodation. • Community structures and public utilities: Will be fully replaced or rehabilitated so as to satisfy their pre-project functions. • Vulnerable people livelihood: Vulnerable people (AHs below the poverty line) will be given priority in employment in project-related jobs.
2.10 Assessment of Compensation Unit Values
28. The methodology for assessing unit compensation values of different items is as illustrated as follows: • Land shall be valued at replacement cost based on actual land sale price survey in the year before the impact survey. No deductions for taxes/transaction costs will be applied. • Houses/buildings will be valued at replacement value based on cost of materials, type of construction, labor, transport and other construction costs. No deductions will be applied for depreciation, salvaged materials and transaction costs. • Annual crops will be valued at net market rates at the farm gate for the first year crop. In the eventuality that more than one-year compensation is due to the AHs the crops after the first will be compensated at gross market value. • Fruit trees will be valued based on age category (a. seedling; b. not yet productive; c. productive). Productive trees will be valued at gross market value of 1 year income x the number of years needed to grow a new tree with the productive potential of the lost tree.
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 9
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
3. ASSESSMENT OF IMPACTS
3.1 Introduction
3.1.1 Resettlement Field Survey
29. As a general strategy, the identification and layout of the site and a technical drawing showing line profile with complete tower spotting have been made as pre-requisites for carrying out the resettlement surveys. The resettlement survey involved impact assessment by quantifying and costing the affected lands and other assets (crops, trees, etc.) through a participatory approach, socio-economic data on AHs, and 2 consultation with the men and women of AHs and the affected communities. F 30. The RFS team, comprising one resettlement specialist, two male and two female field surveyors, along with the technical surveyor conducted the fieldwork in the subproject area between 01st and 5th Sepetmber 2007. Thus, 5th September 2007 has been fixed as the cut-off-date for this subproject. No subsequent changes made in land use pattern or construction of any structure will be entertained for any compensation or assistance under this subproject.
3.1.2 Minimistaion of Impacts
31. The NTDC usually takes all possible steps to safeguard against and minimize the likely adverse impacts on the local communities in the design and implementation of its power transmission enhancement subprojects, involving construction of Sub- Stations and Transmission Lines. Accordingly, the following specific actions were applied to avoid and minimize the likely resettlement impacts of this Rohri 220kV Subproject: • To avoid impacts of land acquisition on the local farming community NTDC has located the new 220kV Sub-Station partly on the state owned land. The selected 47 acre land includes 7 acres of state land and 40 acres of private land. • The alignments of the transmission lines were altered slightly at a number of places to avoid both the compact housing areas and scattered farm-houses; and, three four orchards. 32. As a result, no built-up structures are affected. The transmission lines traverse the open lands (including mostly agricultural and some un-productive/abandoned lands) where only the agricultural crops and trees will be affected by the Subproject execution.
3.2 Impacts of Power Plants and Sub-station
33. The two power plants being constructed at Dharaki and Ghotki by the two IPPs are not included in this ADB-funded sub-project. However, as those are the associated components of the whole scheme, both sites were visited, necessary information collected and consultations held with the former landowners. According to the information obtained from the IPPs and former landowners, lands for both the sites have already been purchased by the respective IPPs.
2 Socio-economic survey findings are presented in Section 4 and Consultations and Disclosure in Section 6.
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 10
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
34. Both sites were purchased through bilateral negotiations and on voluntary sale basis, based on current market prices of lands in both the localities. The former landowners confirmed their satisfaction with the amounts and time of payment for their lands, which they have already received in both the cases. Thus, the NTDC’s LARF is not 3 triggered in either case. F 35. The new 220kV Rohri sub-station will require permanent acquisition of a total 19 ha (47 acre) of land in Ponath village, of which 16.2 ha (40 acres) area is privately owned by six households and the remaining 2.8 ha (7 acres) is owned by the provincial government. While the selected land is cultivable it was abandoned by the owners about a decade ago in the hope of sale to potential industrialists, prompted by the establishment of flour mills on adjacent land. 36. The NTDC has initiated the process of acquiring the identified land from the six landowners through the Executive District Officer-Revenue (EDO-R) of Sukkur district, who has notified the landowners under Section 4 of LAA, using eminent domain for pledging the land in favor of NTDC. Initially, the amount of compensation was assessed was rejected by the affected landowners. They demanded the current market rate of Rs 3.6 million. As a result of tripartite negotiations among the NTDC, EDO-R and the six landowners, the landowners’ demand for current market rate of their affected land has already been accepted by NTDC and the issue is settled now.
3.3 Impacts of the Transmission Line
3.3.1 General Description 37. As specified in Section 2, the strategy for the compensation of land affected by tower construction will be different for urban/residential land and rural (agricultural) land. In the case of urban or residential land the land under the tower will be considered as being permanently affected and therefore it will be acquired and compensated in full. In the case of agricultural land, as long as towers provide sufficient clearance to allow crop cultivation, the land will be considered as temporarily affected and therefore will not be acquired nor compensated. The construction of towers on agricultural land will require compensation for crops and trees lost from the area under the tower and also in a small perimeter surrounding it. The area included in this perimeter has been assessed to be 900 m2 for a 220 kV tower. Crop cultivation within the corridor can continue after the stringing of lines has taken place. During stringing operations it is expected that one harvest will be lost. 38. The transmission lines of this subproject will consist of the following: Line A: Double circuit line (30.5 km; 100 towers) connecting FFC PP (Dharaki) to ENGRO PP (Ghotki). Line B: Double circuit line (58.5 km; 194 towers) connecting ENGRO PP (Ghotki) to New Rohri 220kV Sub-Station. Line AB: Double circuit line (0.75 km; 2 towers) connecting Line A to Line B. Line C: Double circuit line (42.8 km; 165 towers) connecting the New Rohri 220kV Sub-Station to the existing Shikarpur 220kV Sub-Station. 39. The transmission line will traverse, for the most part, intensively irrigated private farmlands (79%) and uncultivated government owned and privately owned lands (21%) as shown in Table 3.1. No land will be acquired permanently for the transmission lines. Nevertheless, its construction and installation works will affect private seasonal agricultural crops (see Appendix 1: Working Tables).
3 For further details, please refer to Due Diligence Reports on each power plant already submitted to ADB in October 2007.
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 11
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Table 3.1: Types of Land Traversed by Transmission Line
Length of Line (m) Percentage Transmission Line Private Cultivated Govt/ Private Total Length (Lines) Land Uncult. Land A: Daharki- Ghotki 26,600 3,892 30,492 20.93 B: Ghotki- Rohri 44,702 13,819 58,521 40.17 AB: Connecting line A- B 745 - 745 0.51 C: Rohri-Shikarpur 42,810 13,121 55,931 38.39 Totals: 114,857 30,832 145,689 100.0 Percentage (Lands): 78.8 21.1 100.0 --
40. Major most crops grown in the area are wheat in the Rabi season (winter-spring) cotton and Rice in the Kharif season (summer-autumn). This dominant cropping pattern of wheat-cotton and rice rotation covers 98% of the farmland, while sugarcane, maize/fodder and vegetables are grown on the remaining lands (only 2%). Thus, the subproject’s impact assessment has been made on the basis of wheat, cotton and rice crop loss. 41. In addition, there are four large fruit orchards, which were avoided successfully in the technical design. However, scattered fruit and wood trees are found mostly on farm boundaries. The fruit trees species found there are date palm and mango. Among the wood tree species, Shisham (sisso), Eucalyptus and Mulberry are most common, followed by Sharen and Kikar (acasia nicolta), exotic species such as poplar and eucalypts are not common. The NTDC’s technical survey and design team made utmost efforts avoid affecting even indidividual trees, and as a result, only 684 trees will need to be removed from the 30m wide corridor. 3.3.2 Impacts of the Towers 42. The new 220kV transmission line will require the construction of a total 461 towers. No private or public land will be acquired permanently, as none of the new towers will be constructed in an established urban or a developing housing area, and sufficient clearance between the lowest tower bars and the ground will be provided to ensure access by tractors and allow affected farmers continued and unencumbered use of their land. 43. The farmland under and around towers will, however, be affected temporarily by the loss of crops and trees during a 3-tier process of tower construction, namely: (i) construction of foundations, (ii) erection of towers, and (iii) stringing of power cables. The whole process is usually completed in a period of 12 to 18 months, thereby causing crop losses for up to three cropping seasons. Accordingly, cash compensation will be paid to the affected farmers for the loss of agricultural crops for three seasons.
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 12
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
44. Of the total 461 towers, 371 towers will be located on private productive farmlands, while the remaining 90 towers will be located on unproductive private and government land (53 and 37 towers, respectively). As explained in Section 2.8, for tower installation, crops and trees in an area not only under the tower, but also in a small perimeter surrounding it as the access, working and storage areas, will be affected during the construction works, which is assessed at an average size of 900 m2 per tower. 45. Accordingly, as shown in Table 3.2, the 371 towers will affect a total 333,900 m2 (33.39 ha) of crops, and 90 towers will be constructed on 81,000 m2 (8.1 ha) of uncultivated government or private land. As a result, a total of 189 farming AHs will be temporarily affected by the construction of the 371 towers on private land. There are no AHs or Aps affected by the towers to be constructed on uncultivated land. Table 3.2: Impacts of Towers on Private Farmland
Number of No. of Affected Cropped Area Transmission Line AHs Towers m2 ha A: Daharki- Ghotki 59 88 79,200 7.92 B: Ghotki- Rohri 70 151 135,900 13.59 AB: Connecting line A- B 1 2 1,800 0.18 C: Rohri- Shikarpur 59 130 117,000 11.7 Totals: 189 371 333,900 33.39
3.3.3 Impacts of the Lines 46. The sections of the transmission lines falling in-between the towers (the corridor) will cause damage or loss of crops in farmland by the stringing of power cables. This final activity is usually carried out rapidly at one stretch of time and completed in one cropping season, for which one-time crop compensation will be paid to the affected farmers. No crop compensation will be paid for the line reaches traversing over uncultivated and/or unused land, whether private or public. Cash compensation will also be paid to AHs for the loss or removal of their trees falling within 30m wide corridor. No built-up structures will be affected by this sub-project, and thus, no compensation and/or financial assistance for this purpose will need to be paid to anybody in the subproject area. 47. Tables 3.3, 3.4 and 3.5 show the total length of the corridor (excluding lands under the towers) as 103.73 km, with a total affected area of 311.18 ha. Some 78.6% of the corridor traverses private farmlands and as a result, some 237 AHs will be affected temporarily only by the stringing activity in the corridor, and will be paid a one-time compensation for the loss of their crops and trees. Table 3.3: Line Corridor by Type of Land Affected
Length of TL Corridor (m) Affected Area (m2) Uncultivated Uncultivated Private Private Transmission Line Govt/ Private Govt/ Private Farmlands Farmlands Land Land A: Daharki- Ghotki 23,960 3,532 718,800 105,960 B: Ghotki- Rohri 40,172 12,529 1,205,160 375,870 AB: Connecting line A- B 685 - 20,550 - C: Rohri- Shikarpur 38,910 12,071 1,167,300 362,130 Total 103,727 28,132 3,111,810 843,960
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 13
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Table 3.4: Impacts of Line Corridor* on Private Farmland
Total Length Affected Cropped Area Transmission Line No. of AHs (m) m2 ha A: Daharki- Ghotki 67 23,960 718,800 71.88 B: Ghotki- Rohri 95 40,172 1,205,160 120.52 AB: Connecting line A- B 1 685 20,550 2.06 C: Rohri- Shikarpur 78 38,910 1,167,300 116.73 Sum-Total 241* 103,727 3,111,810 311.18 Actual Total 238 - - - * There are a total of 238 AHs, but the sum-total (241 AHs) is higher because one AH is affected by by two lines (A & B), and another AH has farmland affected by three lines (A, B & AB).
Table 3.5: Area of Land Temporarily Affected by Line by District
Type of Affected Private Crops by District (ha) Transmission Line Ghotki Sukkur Shikarpur Total A: Daharki- Ghotki ( 88 Towers) 79.80 - - 79.80 B: Ghotki- Rohri (151 Towers) 83.48 50.62 - 134.10 AB: Connecting line A- B (2 Towers) 2.24 - - 2.24 C: Rohri- Shikarpur (130 Towers) - 57.30 71.13 128.43 Total Area (371 towers): 165.52 107.92 71.13 344.57 Percentage: 48.04 31.32 20.64 100.00
3.3.4 Other Impacts and Impacts Summary 48. In addition to crop loss, trees will be removed from the 30m wide corridor. As shown in Table 3.6, some 112 AH will lose 684 trees (544 fruit trees and 140 wood trees). Most of the affected trees are found in the scattered or clustered forms on farmland, especially on the field boundaries, and three fruit orchards are found partly affected. 49. Compensation for affected trees will be paid once, on initial removal. The compensation for fruit trees is assessed on the basis current market price of average fruit production for the number of years required for fruiting maturity of the respective fruit trees. The affected fruit trees, date palms and mango, have an average 10 years long maturity period, and accordingly the compensation will be paid for the fruit produced in 10 years. For affected wood trees, the compensation amount is based on current market rate of the wood. Table 3.7: Affected Fruit and Wood Trees
No. and type of trees Line Section Fruit Trees Wood Trees Date Mango Shisham Kiker Others Total A: Daharki- Ghotki 0 2 7 11 7 27 B: Ghotki- Rohri 9 0 36 25 25 95 AB: Connecting Line 0 0 0 0 0 0 C: Rohri- Shikarpur 513 20 14 10 5 562 D: Rohri Sub-station 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total: 522 22 57 46 37 684
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 14
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
50. In summary, 238 AHs will be affected by the construction of the transmission lines. Of them, 189 AHs will be affected by both the towers and the line corridor, while the remaining 49 AHs will be affected by the corridor only during the stringing activity (Table 3.7). The 189 AHs will be compensated for three crops; two crops affected by construction and erection of the towers, and a third crop damaged or lost during the stringing activity. The 49 AHs who will experience crop damage or loss as a result of the stringing activity only will be paid compensation for one crop. Table 3.7: Total Affected Crops by Type of Land
Affected Private Crops (ha) Uncultivated Lands (ha) Transmission Line Total Tower Corridor Total Tower Corridor A: Daharki- Ghotki 79.80 7.92 71.88 0.0 0.0 0.0 B: Ghotki- Rohri 134.11 13.59 120.52 0.0 0.0 0.0 AB: Connecting line A- B 2.24 0.18 2.06 0.0 0.0 0.0 C: Rohri- Shikarpur 128.43 11.70 116.73 0.0 0.0 0.0 Total: 344.58 33.39 311.18 0.0 0.0 0.0
51. Besides the loss of crops and trees, no houses or built-up structures are affected by the whole Subproject, with a 30m wide corridor for the construction and stringing of the transmission lines. Similarly, there are no community property resources (land, structures, etc.), nor any business activities will affected by the construction of the towers and/or stringing of transmission line cables. Moreover, there are no vulnerable people among the toal 244 AHs, as they are all found above the national poverty line and mostly live in a joint/extended family system to mutually share in the responsibilities and benefits which serve as a safety net against external economic shocks. And finally, the overall impacts on the local communities will not be severe by any recognized standards.
3.4 Impacts on Affected Households
3.4.1 General
52. As stated above, the acquisition of land for the construction of the new 220 kV sub- station will affect six households and also require land from the provincial Government. Of the total site most (40 acres) is privately owned land and cultivated land and the remaining land (7 acres) is government owned and uncultivated. 53. Construction of the new 145.69 km long 220kV transmission line will traverse mainly intensively irrigated farmlands in Ghotki, Sukkur and Shikarpur districts, with a total of 238 AHs temporarily affected by crop losses and removal of trees (see Table 3.8).
Table 3.8: Affected Households by Towers and Line Corridor
No. of AHs Total Total No. Transmission Line Length of Towers + TL TL Corridor of Towers Total Line (km) Corridor only A: Daharki- Ghotki 23.960 88 59 18 67 B: Ghotki- Rohri 40.172 151 70 25 95 AB: Connecting Line 0.685 2 1 0 1 C: Rohri- Shikarpur 38.910 130 59 19 78 Total 103.727 371 189 62 241
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 15
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
54. Thus, in addition to the Provincial Government of Punjab, the owner of the selected site to be purchased by NTDC, the construction and stringing of transmission line will affect 238 AHs with a total of 2,870 APs in three districts, as given in Table 3.9. Table 3.9: Location and Number of Affected Households (Rohri Sub Project)
No. of AHs by District Households Affected by Ghotki Sukkur Shikarpur Total A: Daharki- Ghotki ( 88 Towers) 67 - - 67 B: Ghotki- Rohri (151 Towers) 53 42 - 95 AB: Connecting line A- B (2 Towers) 1 - - 1 C: Rohri- Shikarpur (130 Towers) 29 49 78 D: Rohri Sub-station - 6 - 6 Total (371 Towers): 121 77 49 247
Note – total number of AHs is greater than actual number because two AHs are affected by more than one section of line.
3.4.2 Significance of Impacts 55. The impact of loss of crops will be insignificant on all 244 AH, as all of them are relatively large farmers with highly fertile farmlands, and none of them will lose >10% of his total crop income (Table 3.10). The 30m wide strip of land will be acquired temporarily as a working corridor for installation of the new towers and stringing of the power lines. 56. The transmission line and towers will affect only agricultural crops and trees, and none of the affected households (AHs) will be impacted by restricted access to, or use of, their farmlands. Cotton, Rice and wheat crops will be affected on a total of 360.78 ha of private lands and 684 trees will be removed from a 30m wide corridor of the transmission lines. The overall crop loss impact is insignificant as it averages at 6.97 per cent and ranges from 0.8 per cent to 9.79 per cent, and remains consistently below 10 per cent for all the affected households. Table 3.8: Proportion of Crop Loss by Section of Line
Percentage of Crop Loss (%) Transmission Line No. of AHs Minimum Maximum Average A: Daharki- Ghotki 67 4.9 9.35 7.64 B: Ghotki- Rohri 95 0.8 9.79 7.55 AB: Connecting Line 1 2.77 2.77 2.77 C: Rohri- Shikarpur 78 2.32 9.16 6.38 D: Rohri Sub-station 6 5.63 7.99 6.87 Total: 247 0.8 9.79 6.97
57. Moreover, none of the 247 AHs are vulnerable (or include individually vulnerable 4 people), as their incomes are such that they are above the national poverty line F , and they live predominantly in a joint/extended family system which serves as a safety net against external economic shocks. None of the 64 AHs were found to be headed by a widow or or a disabled person as such persons. Finally, the overall community impact (i.e. village level) will be negligible to just minor.
4 See Table A-6 (Per Capita Incomes), In Appendix 1: Working Tables, for details on Incomes of all the affected households.
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 16
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
4. SOCIO-ECONOMIC PROFILE OF AFFECTED PEOPLE
4.1 Census of Affected Households
4.1.1 Field Methodology 58. The field methodology included carrying out Resettlement Field Surveys, including a 100% Census of AHs, accompanied by community consultation (refer to Section 6). The survey was complted on the 5th September. The survey included questions about the socio-economic characteristics of AHs in order to obtain necessary information about their livelihoods and conditions. 4.1.2 General Information on Affected Households 59. The sub-station will affect six private landowners with land acquisition, and the double circuit transmission lines will affect 238 households by crops and tree losses. The transmission lines traverse over the lands of three districts in the Sindh Province, namely, Ghotki, Sukkur and Shikarpur districts. 60. As a result, 244 AHs with a total population of 2,870 affected people (APs) who will temporarily suffer insignificantly by the loss of crops and trees (see Table 4.1).
Table 4.1: Affected Households & Population by Location
Line Section No. of AHs* Total APs A: Daharki- Ghotki 67 621 B: Ghotki- Rohri 95 1019 AB: Connecting line 1 26 C: Rohri – Shikarpur 78 1104 D: Rohri Sub-station 6 100 Sum-Total: 247 2,870 Actual Total: 244 2,800
* The actual total number of AHs is 244 and population 2,800 persons, but the sum-totals are higher because of overlapping - one AH is affected by two lines (A & B) and another one AH by three lines (A, B & AB).
61. All participants in the survey were the heads of household. All the 244 AHs are Muslim and ethnically and linguistically Sindhi. In terms of social groups, there are seven major castes of original Sindhis, as described in the following table.
Table 4.2: Social Group of Affected Households
Social Group Section of Transmission Line (%) A B AB C D Chachar 17 13 - 3 - Laghari 22 18 - 12 - Jam 14 16 - 8 - Khosa 11 13 - 22 - Shar - - - 18 - Lashari 19 14 - 6 - Jatoi 14 17 - 23 - Others 3 9 100 8 100
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 17
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
4.1.3 Indigenous People 62. None of the AHs are tribal or minority members and all affected land is held in private ownership (i.e. no tribal or communal ownership). Similarly, none of AHs were found to be vulnerable (had by either females, disabled/aged persons or poor). 63. Therefore the standard provisions of the LARF and this LARP are sufficient to ensure an effective compensation process and the requirements of ADB Policy on Indigenous People are complied with. The ADB’s policy, as specified in the Indigenous Peoples Development Framework (IPDF) prepared for this project is not triggered, and therefore neither an IPDP nor special action is required for this subproject.
4.2 Data on Heads of Affected Households
64. All heads of household are male, 229 out of 244 (94 %) AHs are headed by married men while 13 (6%) are widowed men and only two AHs were heade by unmarried men, in all married cases the spouse lives in the same household (i.e. none are separated). 65. One hundred and forty two (58%) household head are between 41 and 60 years old, 83 (34%) are between 61 and 75 years old, while only nineteen head of affected households (eight per cent) are young, aged between 36 and 40 years. There are no elderly AHs (older than 75 years). 66. In terms of literacy and education, one hundred and seven (44 per cent) of survey participants stated they are literate (can read and write in Urdu), Thirty two or thirteen per cent of household heads are illiterate or can not even read and write, sixty three (26 %) of household heads have a primary education and twenty nine (12 %) have a secondary education. Only thirteen or five per cent have attained a higher education (including vocational, business or teachers training college).
4.3 Data on Affected Households and Population
4.3.1 Households 67. Households in the subproject area are large, with an average size of 11 people per household, indicating a dominant trend towards joint and extended family system. The smallest household is made up of five persons and the largest household consists of 34 people (refer to Table 4.2) Table 4.2: Average Size of Affected Households
Household Size (Number of Persons) Line Section No. AHs Minimum Maximum Average A 67 5 26 9.27 B 95 5 28 10.73 AB 1 26 26 26 C 78 6 33 14.15 D 6 9 34 16.67 Total 247 5 34 11.62
68. Tables 4.3 to 4.5 provide details on household size, and their age and gender compositions.
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 18
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Table 4.3: Gender Composition of Affected Households
Total No. of APs Line Section No. of AHs Male APs Female APs Total APs A 67 302 319 621 B 95 487 532 1019 AB 1 17 9 26 C 78 548 556 1104 D 6 43 57 100 Total 247 1397 1473 2870
69. As seen in Table 4.4, adults account for just over half of the AP population (57%) and older adults account for 2%, together these APs take care of the household economy. The children and youth account for the remaining 38% of APs Table 4.4: Age and Gender Composition of AHs
Total No. of APs Age Group Age in Years Male APs Female APs Total APs % Children Up to 15 87 92 683 23.80 Youth 16 – 25 69 72 488 17.01 Adults 26 – 60 235 228 1628 56.72 Older adults Above 60 10 12 71 2.47 Total All Ages 1397 1473 2870 100.0
4.3.2 Housing 70. None of the AHs live in simple dwellings (constructed of thatch, sack, bamboo, clay or earth). All respondents stated that they live in houses constructed of brick and concrete, and some even highly expensive large concrete houses, this was also confirmed by observations during the RFS. This indicates that they are economically well-off. 4.3.3 Livelihood and Incomes 71. As all AHs rely on farming most, if not all of their income, the tenure of agricultural land is an important factor in terms of security and sustainability of livelihood. Among the AHs, all the land owners in the RFS stated they are the registered land owners, there are also eight sharecroppers amongst the AHs. There are no AHs that rent or lease agricultural land, no households that claim ownership, and no squatters. With the excetion of the eigth sharecroppers, the AHs are landowner farmers. Table 4.6 shows that the total farm size of almost all the affected households is relatively large, as its overall average stands at 23.69 ha and ranges from 2.04 ha to 376.5 ha. Table 4.6: Farm Size of Affected Households
No. AHs Total Farm Size (ha) Line Section (Actual: 244) Minimum Maximum Average A (TL) 67 2.04 112.8 15.58 B (TL) 95 2.4 152.8 21.69 AB (TL) 1 112.8 112.8 112.8 C (TL) 78 3.5 376.5 30.76 D (sub-station) 6 12.2 87.7 39.27 Sum-Total: 247 2.04 376.5 23.69
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 19
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
72. As shown in Tables 4.7 and 4.8, agriculture is the sector that accounts for 67% of APs engaged in livelihood, of which men account for 71% of agriculturalists. Agriculture also accounts for 81% of the income earned by APs. The next largest livelihood sector is waged employment which accounts for 20% of the AP workforce and of which two-thrids are men, this sector acciunts for 7% of the income earned by APs. Small business and trade accounts for 13% of working APs and again two- thrids are male, and contributes 11% of the income eanred by APs. Table 4.7: Sector-Wise Average Incomes by Gender of Affected Households
Income Involvement of APs by Gender (No.) Sector (%) Sector Men Women Overall Agriculture 268 109 377 66.5 Business 47 29 76 13.4 Employment 71 43 114 20.1 Total 361 181 567 100.00
Table 4.8: Sector-Wise Average Incomes by Gender of Affected Households
Income Average Income of APs by Gender (Rs) Sector (%) Sector Men Women Overall Agriculture 39,167 779 39,946 81.3 Business 5,046 566 5,613 11.4 Employment 2,289 1,240 3,530 7.1 Total 46,502 2,587 49,089 100.0 4.3.4 Poverty Level 73. The poverty line is estimated to be 849 Rs per person per month, based on the data provided in the RFS, there are no AHs that fall on or below the poverty line. Average per capita monthly incomes are Rs 1,329, with a minimum of 865 Rs/person/month and a maximum of 15,938 Rs/person/month. Table 4.9: Monthly per Capita Income of Affected Households
No. of AHs Monthly Per Capita Income (Rs) Line Section Minimum Maximum Average A 67 864.17 2,450.42 1,084.16 B 95 859.81 3,082.26 1246.78 AB 1 2450.42 2,450.42 2450.42 C 78 858.06 15,937.6 1,428 D (sub-station) 6 1080.46 4,143.65 1,835 Total 247 958.00 2,188.00 1,461.00 4.3.5 Literacy 74. Table 4.10 shows an overall literacy rate of APs of 39%, with the literacy rate of male APs (59%) being more than twice that of female APs (21%). Table 4.10: Literacy by Age and Gender of APs
Total No. of APs Literacy Level Male Female Overall Total No. of APs 1397 1473 2870 Literate APs (No.) 832 306 1138 Iliterate APs (No.) 565 1167 1732 Literacy Rate (%) 59.56 20.77 39.65
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 20
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
5. INSTITUTIONAL ARRANGEMENTS
75. The compensation and rehabilitation program described in this LARP involves a number of agencies including; NTDC as the implementing agency, the Sindh Board of Revenue, the Ministry of Environment, NGOs, Provincial Government of Sindh, and the district governments of Daharki, Sukkur and Shikarpur, as detailed below.
Figure 5.1: Organization of District Land Acquisition Collector Office
Environmental Protection Ag. LAR STEERING COMMITTEE
LOCAL GOVERNMENT PROVINCE NTDC
Board of revenue Other Departments Land compensation PMU District Nazim
District Coordination Office (DCO) District Departments PIU - Land Acquisition Collector(LAC) Thesil Nazim
LAR COORDINATION COMMITTEE Other Compensation Union Councils
Complaints and Grievances
Administrative Function
Coordination function APs
Finance Direction
5.1 National Transmission and Dispatch Company
76. NTDC has overall responsibility for the preparation, implementation and financing of all tasks set out in this LARP as well as inter-agency coordination. NTDC will exercise its functions through a centrally based Project Management Unit (PMU) which will be responsible for general project execution, and at subproject level through Project Implementation Units (PIUs) which will be tasked with day-to-day project activities.
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 21
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
77. Within the PMU, LARP tasks will be managed by a specific group; the Land Acquisition and Resettlement Unit (LARU), which will update this LARP (including surveys, asset valuation, community consultation, and approvals), and internally monitor LARP implementation. 78. In the implementation of these tasks LARU will receive specific technical assistance from: • Resettlement Specialist under the Design and Supervision Consultant team, who will assist in LARU in land acquisition planning, LARP implementation, internal monitoring, and imparting training to the NTDC and district governments on impact assessment and entitlements, and ADB policy/LARF requirements; • An impact assessment/valuation team hired as required to assist in on-site preparation of surveys, base-line information gathering and AH consultation; and • external monitoring agency (EMA) to be hired to conduct periodic monitoring and third party validation of LARP implementation (see Section 5.4).
5.2 District Government
79. District governments have jurisdiction for land administration, valuation and acquisition. At the provincial level these functions rest with the Board of Revenue while at district level they rest with the District Collector Office (DCO) and the Land Acquisition Collector (LAC) within the DCO. A number of minor agents, most notably the Patwari, (the keeper of land records), carry out specific roles such as titles identification and verification (see Figure 5.2). Functions pertaining to compensation of assets different from land (i.e buildings, crops and trees) or income rehabilitation also fall on local governments, more specifically the relevant District Department.
Figure 5.2: Organization of District Land Acquisition Collector Office
EDO-R / LAC Executive District Officer (Revenue) (Land Acquisition Collector)
Tesildar / Naib Tehsildar Land Acquisition Officers (LAO)
Girdawar / Qanungo Land Surveyor (Land Records)
Patwari Assistant Land Surveyor (Land Records)
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 22
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
5.3 Other Agencies and Institutions
80. As various agencies will need to be carefully coordinated so as to obtain effective, smooth and timely LARP implementation, a land acquisition steering committee (LASC) will be directly assigned to NTDC-PMU by the Punjab Board of Revenue and district level coordination committees.The LASC will be established at provincial level and will include NTDC’s General Manager; Provincial Chairman of Planning & Development Department, or Additional Chief Secretary; Chairman Punjab Board of Revenue; Director General Punjab-EPA; and, Project Director (PD) NTDC-PMU (Figure 5.3). 81. The LASC will meet periodically to ensure proper and timely formation of the district level coordination committees to facilitate the LARP approval and implementation processes.
Figure 5.3: Organization of Land Acquisition Steering Committee
Project Director PMU, NTDC
Chairman, P&DD / Chairman, Provincial Additional Chief Provincial Board of Director General, Project Director, Secretary Revenue EPA PMU, NTDC (Principle Member) (Member) (Member) (Member-Secretary)
82. A Land Acquisition Coordination Committee (LACC) will be formed in Rohri Town to assist with the updating and implementation of the LARP (in particular execution of surveys, valuation of assets, AH consultation, and local approval of LARP provisions). The committee formation will be initiated by the NTDC-PMU, including representatives of PIU, LARU, Tehsildars of the concerned districts and Union Council Nazims representing the AHs (Figure 5.4). 83. One of the areas where LCC functions will be to offer the affected communities with a channel and a support group for addressing complaints and grievances. In this function the LCC will hear the complaint, and if found justified will support its lodging at the PMU, and as further described in Section 7. 84. This LARP will require review and clearance by the Punjab Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) as part of Government’s Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) approval procedures, as well as approval by ADB (the division that assess compliance with safeguard policies - RSES, ADB Headquarters in Manila, Philippines).
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 23
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Figure 5.4: Organization of Land Acquisition Coordination Committee
Executive District Officer (Revenue) / Land Acquisition Collector (LAC) (Chairman)
District Officer Tehsildar Union Council Deputy Director, (Revenue) (Revenue Officer) Nazim/s PIU, NTDC (Principle Member) (Member) (Member/s) (Member-Secretary)
5.4 Responsibility for Internal and External Monitoring
85. Land acquisition tasks under the project will be subjected to both internal and external monitoring. Internal monitoring will be conducted by NTDC-PMU, assisted by the design and supervision consultant. External monitoring responsibilities will be assigned to an external monitoring agency (EMA: a Consultant or NGO) to be engaged by PMU, NTDC according to the Terms of Reference (TOR) that have been approved by ADB. This aspect of the LARP implementation has been further elaborated in Section 10 (Monitoring and Evaluation).
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 24
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
6. CONSULTATION AND DISCLOSURE
6.1 Consultation Undertaken for the LARP
86. The consultative process undertaken for the preparation of the LARP has included not only AHs, but also representatives of local governments in the subproject area, and members of local people’s organizations (e.g., CBCs, women’s organizations, peasant worker’s organizations). Special attention was paid to identify the needs of vulnerable groups (such as the poor, women, and elderly), to ensure that their views have been considered in the formulation of the LARP. 87. Consultation with stakeholders at the different stages of the subproject is required by ADB’s Policy on Involuntary Resettlement and as provided for in the LARF. To start with, consultations with the AHs were conducted as part of inventory taking of affected lands and other assets. The communities’ and especially the AHs’ responses to the proposed subproject were found to be positive. 88. Along with the participatory RFS and interviewing of AHs, semi-structured discussions aiming at community awareness and consultations regarding the project’s likely impacts were also held with the small groups of men and women, including AHs, other stake holders and notables of the area along the proposed transmission line. Sixteen group discussions and consultations were held (groups of men and women) in three villages. The total number of participants was 71; including 36 men and 35 women, as shown in the table below and as set out in Appendix 2. Table 6.1: Participants in Group Discussions and Consultations
No. of Groups No. of Participants Village Men Women Total Men Women Total Eadan Lashari 1 1 2 10 10 20 Arror 1 1 2 8 8 16 Goth Ibrahim 1 1 2 9 7 16 Goth Ch Rasheed 1 1 2 9 9 18 Nandi Patni 1 1 2 10 9 19 Bagarge 1 1 2 7 7 14 Lukhy 1 1 2 11 7 18 Lodra 1 1 2 7 8 15 Total 8 8 16 71 65 136
89. The concerns raised during the consultation sessions, namely, the adequacy and timeliness of the compensation payments, safety measures, etc., have been addressed by NTDC by making payment of crop and tree compensations to all the 247 AHs at least one month (30 days) prior to the temporary use of their farmlands (before starting the civil works), and instructing the Contractor/s to take all possible safety measures during the entire the Subproject execution period, especially during the construction and stringing activities.
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 25
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
90. The local communities’ responses (awareness, perceptions and preferences) to the Jarwar- Sadiqabad subproject and resettlement related matters are summarized as follows: • This subproject is necessary under the current local conditions. • Crop and tree compensation should be fair and timely • Skill and unskilled labor should be used locally. • Electricity should be provided to the affected villages which are still without electricity.
6.2 Compensation Options Discussed
91. In addition to the focus group discussions and consultative meetings described above, the DMS included a questionnaire with several questions regarding AHs’ preferences for compensation and rehabilitation options. This information has been and will be used to assist in determining the support measures required by AHs. 92. The first compensation priority of all AHs is for cash, rather than land or a combination of cash and land. When asked why they preferred cash compensation, half of all AHs stated the reason was to assist with daily living expenses as they will loose their livelihood in the shape of crops. 93. In summary, the compensation and resettlement options discussed and agreed upon during the consultation meetings included: • Relocation - not applicable; • Assistance - not applicable; • Compensation – the majority of AH representatives look forward to receiving a “fair” and “timely” compensation for their lost/affected crops and trees. By “fair”, they meant the application of prevalent open market rates, or “replacement value” for their crop production and wood trees. By “timely”, they meant prior to the temporary use of their lands and sustaining any damage to or removal of their crops and trees, as provided for in the LARF; and • Job opportunities - the more disadvantaged people in the villages requested that NTDC assist them with job opportunities with the contractors, on a priority basis, during project implementation.
6.3 LARP Disclosure 94. An English version of the program’s LARF has already been uploaded to ADB’s website and an Urdu version has been made available through NTDC’s headquarters and PIUs in Subproject areas (second tranche). 95. In line with ADB’s public communications policy, this LARP in English will also be posted on the ADB website, while its translation in Urdu will be disclosed to the AHs at the Dera Ghazi Khan PIU office and posted on the ADB website. 96. In addition, a public information booklet in Urdu, summarizing compensation provisions will be sent to all AHs (a draft booklet in English has been prepared as provided in Appendix 3).
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 26
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
7. GRIEVANCE REDRESS PROCESS
94. A grievance mechanism will be available to allow an AH appealing any disagreeable decision, practice or activity arising from land or other assets compensation. AHs will be fully informed of their rights and of the procedures for addressing complaints whether verbally or in writing during consultation, survey, and time of compensation. 95. Care will always be taken to prevent grievances rather than going through a redress process. This can be obtained through careful LAR design and implementation, by ensuring full participation and consultation with the AHs, and by establishing extensive communication and coordination between the community, the PMU, the LAC and local governments in general. 96. As finances will move differently for (i) land (for land use or access impacts) and (ii) other items compensation or rehabilitation (in the first case funds will move from NTDC through the District Collector Office to the AHs, while in the second funds will go directly from NTDC to the AHs. The complaint and grievances will be addressed through two different processes as described in Table 7.1.
Table 7.1: Grievance Resolution Process Land & Crop Compensation Issues Other Compensation or Project Issues 1. First, complaints resolution will be 1. First, complaints resolution will be attempted at village level through the involvement of attempted at village level through the involvement of the LARU, NGO and informal mediators. the LARU, NGO and informal mediators. 2. If still unsettled, a grievance can then be 2. If still unsettled, a grievance can be lodged lodged to the LAC who has 30 days to decide on the to the PIU/LARU, which will have 30 days to respond. case. 3. If no solution was reached a grievance can 3. If no solution was reached a grievance can be lodged with support of the LCC to the PMU. The AH be lodged with support of the LCC to the PMU. The AH must lodge the complaint within 1 month of lodging the must lodge the complaint within 1 month of lodging the original complaint with the LAC and must produce original complaint with the LAC and must produce documents supporting his/her claim. The PMU will documents supporting his/her claim. The PMU will provide the decision within 21 days of registering the provide the decision within 21 days of registering the complaint. The PMU decision must be in compliance complaint. The PMU decision must be in compliance with this LARF provisions. with this LARF provisions.
4. Should the grievance redress system fail to 4. Should the grievance redress system fail to satisfy the AH, they can further submit their case to the satisfy the AH, they can further submit their case to the appropriate court of law as per the process set out in appropriate court of law as per the process set out in Sections 18 to 22 of the LAA (1894). Sections 18 to 22 of the LAA (1894).
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 27
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
8. BUDGET FOR LAND AND ASSET ACQUISITION
8.1 Basis for Compensation
97. Compensation for projects requiring land acquisition can often differ between the borrower and ADB (and other providers of official development assistance). To comply with ADB’s Policy on Involuntary Resettlement, rates used to compensate for lost land and assets must be replacement cost at current market value, in order to meet the policy objective of “at least” restoring people’s livelihoods and ensuring that people affected by a project are not left worse off. 98. According to the project’s LARF, replacement cost is the amount of cash or kind needed to replace an asset in its existing or better condition, and is the value determined as compensation for the current market price without depreciation or deduction of the costs of any transaction or for any material salvaged. The processes for establishing the rates used for the New 220kV Rohri subproject followed the methodology of LARF.
8.2 Determining the Rates for Compensation
99. Based on the foregoing requirements and the LARF provisions, the methodology for assessing unit compensation values of the different items is described as follows: • Basic annual crop compensation was valued at net farm-gate market rates. If additional crops compensation is due it will be calculated at market value minus inputs. As noted earlier, compensation for crops affected by tower bases and perimeters is three-crop and for stringing of the lines is for one- crop; and • Fruit trees were valued based on age and productivity category (a. seedling; b. not yet productive; c. productive). Productive fruit trees were valued at gross market value of one year’s income multiplied by the number of years needed to grow a new tree with the productive potential of the lost tree. Wood trees were valued based on type, size, and age (dimensions rather than productivity). AHs are entitled to keep the wood (as salvaged material) without any deductions from the amount of compensation. 100. The valuation survey registered recent current crop and tree sales at markets and was based on AH and community consultation (including relevant local government agencies). The conclusion of the survey is that in most cases the actual transaction values are higher than the values officially documented and registered. The results of RFS are provided in the tables below. Table 8.1: Average Crop Incomes in Rohri Sub-project Area
Affected Crop Average Net Income (Rs/sq meters.) No. Type of Crop Ghotki Sukkur Shikarpur Average 1 Cotton (Kharif Season) 7.12 6.98 6.82 6.97 2 Wheat (Rabi Season) 5.60 5.42 5.31 5.44 3 Rice (Kharif Season) 7.43 7.54 7.62 7.53 Sum Total: 20.15 19.94 19.75 19.95 Average 6.72 6.65 6.58 6.65 Average (Cotton/ Wheat): 6.36 6.20 6.07 6.21 Average ( Rice/ Wheat): 6.52 6.48 6.47 6.49
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 28
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
101. In the affected area two crops - rice and cotton - are cultivated in Kharif season and wheat in rabi Season. For the purpose of compensation average of the price of wheat and rice or wheat and cotton is used and the area under rice and cotton is shown in table 8.2 below:
Table 8.2: Area Affected by Towers and Lines by Crop
Area (m2) Crops Towers Line Cotton/ Wheat 213,300 2,099,700 Rice/ Wheat 114,300 1,131,200
102. The affected fruit and wood tree compensations were assessed as shown in the following four tables (Tables 8.3 to 8.6).
Table 8.3: Categorization and Income Replacement of Affected Fruit Trees (Rohri) Name of Categorization No. of Fruit Potential for Fruiting Income Affected Maturity Age Harvests Period Annual Replacement No. Fruit Tree Level (Years) Year (Years) Income (Rs) Value (Rs.) 1 Date Palm Immature Up to 10 0 18 2,675 48,150 Mature-1 10 - 22 1 12 2,450 29,400 Mature-2 above 22 1 6 1,725 10,350 2 Mango Immature Up to 10 0 15 2,650 39,750 Mature-1 10 - 20 1 10 2,250 22,500 Mature-2 above 20 1 5 1,725 8,625
Table 8.4: Number and Compensation of Affected Fruit Trees (Rohri)
Name of Affected Fruit Tree (No.) Compensation Total Price Line Line Line No. Fruit Tree Category A B AB Line C D. Grid Total Rate (Rs.) (Rs.)
1 Date Palm Immature 0 0 0 48 0 48 48,150 2,311,200
Mature-1 0 0 0 289 0 289 29,400 8,496,600
Mature-2 0 9 0 176 0 185 10,350 1,914,750
Sub-total (a): Date-Palm 0 9 0 513 0 522 - 12,722,550
2 Mango Immature 0 0 0 5 0 5 39,750 198,750
Mature-1 1 0 0 8 0 9 22,500 202,500
Mature-2 1 0 0 7 0 8 8,625 69,000
Sub-total (b): Mango 2 0 0 20 0 22 - 470,250
TOTAL: 2 9 0 533 0 544 - 13,192,800
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 29
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Table 8.5: Relative Sizes of Affected Wood Trees by Maximum Heights and Girths (Rohri)
Name of Small Medium Large No. Wood Tree Height (m) Girth (m) Height (m) Girth (m) Height (m) Girth (m) 1 Shisham up to 3.8 up to 0.5 3.9 - 7.6 0.5 - 0.9 7.7 & above 1.0 & above 2 Kikar up to 4.6 up to 0.3 4.6 - 9.1 0.4 - 0.5 9.1 & above 0.5 & above 3 Eucalyptus up to 3.0 up to 0.5 3.1 - 6.1 0.5 - 0.9 6.1 & above 1.0 & above 4 Mulberry up to 3.0 up to 0.5 3.1 - 6.1 0.5 - 0.9 6.1 & above 1.0 & above 5 Sirin/Saras up to 3.8 up to 0.5 3.9 - 7.6 0.5 - 0.9 7.7 & above 1.0 & above
Table 8.6: Number and Compensation of Affected Wood Trees (Rohri)
Name of Relative Affected Wood Tree (No.) Market Rate Total Price No. Wood Tree Size Line A Line B Line AB Line C D. Grid Total (Rs.) (Rs.)
1 Shisham Small 3 18 0 9 0 30 4,200 126,000
Medium 2 13 0 3 0 18 6,500 117,000
Large 2 5 0 2 0 9 8,975 80,775
Sub-total (a): Shisham 7 36 0 14 0 57 - 323,775 Kikar 2 (Acasia) Small 4 9 0 7 0 20 3,550 71,000
Medium 3 11 0 0 0 14 4,800 67,200
Large 4 5 0 3 0 12 6,300 75,600
Sub-total (b): Kikar 11 25 0 10 0 46 - 213,800
3 Eucalyptus Small 1 1 0 0 0 2 2,450 4,900
Medium 0 0 0 1 0 1 4,500 4,500
Large 0 2 0 0 0 2 6,500 13,000
Sub-total (c): Eucalyptus 1 3 0 1 0 5 - 22,400
4 Mulberry Small 0 1 0 0 0 1 2,200 2,200
Medium 0 0 0 0 0 0 4,350 -
Large 1 2 0 0 0 3 6,400 19,200
Sub-total (d): Mulberry 1 3 0 0 0 4 - 21,400
5 Others Small 2 7 0 3 0 12 2,000 24,000
Medium 0 10 0 0 0 10 4,500 45,000
Large 3 2 0 1 0 6 6,200 37,200
Sub-total (e): Others 5 19 0 4 0 28 - 106,200
TOTAL: 20 67 0 25 0 140 - 687,575
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 30
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
8.3 Budget for Land and Asset Acquisition
103. This LARP includes the cost of compensation, rehabilitation and other restoration/assistance entitlements of the 243 private AHs and land compensation of govt. land, with a breakdown by crops and trees, and other associated costs. The cost estimate has been based on the rates derived through consultation and survey as described in Section 8.2. The rates for compensation and cash entitlements for rehabilitation as well as allowances payable to AHs will be adjusted annually, based on the actual annual inflation rate. NTDC, with the LACs, will determine the annual inflation rates and adjust all cash entitlements. Compensation for land, crops and trees is Rs. 264,747,129. 104. The administrative charges have been estimated as 15 per cent of the total of compensation for land, crops and trees, and allowances. These charges are to cover the costs of implementing the plan (producing and distributing the PIB, holding individual and group consultations and public meetings as required, verifying the DMS, revising the LARP if required (to reflect any minor changes), organizing and arranging for the compensation payments through the LACCs), and internal monitoring of the plan and its implementation. 105. A contingency of 10 per cent of the subtotal of the compensation and administrative charges has been included in the cost estimate. Funds for compensation and implementation of the LARP will be from the Government (counterpart funds) via NTDC, budgetary requirements for economic restoration, as part of resettlement budget will also come from the counterpart funds and shall be identified as allowances. The EMA will be financed as a project loan cost as a component of the project support fund. As shown in Table 8.7, the total cost of LARP implementation, will be 313.10 million Rs (US$5.14 million).
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 31
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Table 8.7: Estimated of Rohri LARP No. Resettlement Activity No. Unit Rs./Unit Total Rs. A. Asset Compensation: - - - 264,747,129 A.1 Land Compensation (Acquisition for GS): 19 ha 11,799,474 224,190,000 Land Price based on Rs. 3.6 million per Acre 19 ha 8,905,263 169,200,000 Compulsary Acquisition Surcharge (@25%) 0.25 - 169,200,000 42,300,000 Taxes and Stamp Papers, etc. (@7.5%) 0.075 - 169,200,000 12,690,000 A.2 Trees: 684 tree - 13,880,375 A.2.1 Fruit Trees: 544 tree - 13,192,800 Date Palm 522 tree 24,373 12,722,550 Mango 22 tree 21,375 470,250 A.2.2 Wood Trees: 140 tree - 687,575 Shisham (sisso) 57 tree 5,680 323,775 Kikar (acasia nicolta) 46 tree 4,648 213,800 Other (Eucalyptus, Mulberry, etc.) 37 tree 4,054 150,000 A.3 Crops: - - - 26,676,754 Cotton/Wheat - Towers (x 3 Crops) 213,300 m2 6.24 3,992,976 Cotton/Wheat - TL Corridor (1 Crop) 2,099,700 m2 6.24 13,102,128 Rice/Wheat - Towers (x 3 Crops) 114,300 m2 6.50 2,228,850 Rice/Wheat - TL Corridor (1 Crop) 1,131,200 m2 6.50 7,352,800 B. Other Activities -- - 4,670,560 Rehabilitation of Affected B.1 Lands/Structures 3,617,600 m2 0.60 2,170,560 B.2 Resettlement Specialist (impl.) 6.00 pers/mo 300,000 1,800,000 B.3 External monitoring 2.00 pers/mo 300,000 600,000 B.4 Training of NTDC staff (incl. materials) 1.00 lumpsum 100,000 100,000 C. Administration Costs (15% of A) 0.15 lumpsum264,747,129 39,712,069 D. Subtotal (A+B+C) -- - 309,129,758 E. Contingency (10% of C) 0.10 lumpsum 39,712,069 3,971,207 Total Amount in Pak. Rupees: -- - 313,100,965 Total Amount in US Dollars (@ Rs. 60.90): - - - 5,141,231
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 32
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
9. IMPLEMENTATION SCHEDULE
106. The overall program will be implemented over a five to six year period with the first tranche of subprojects scheduled to commence upon loan approval. Implementation of resettlement and related activities will take place after the project supervision consultant has mobilized, who will work closely with, and assist, the NTDC in all resettlement and related activities. 107. Civil works contractors will not be issued a notice of possession of site for any section of construction works unless NTDC has (i) satisfactorily completed, in accordance with the approved LARP and all compensation payments have been made, and (ii) ensured that the rehabilitation assistance is in place and the area required for civil works is free of all encumbrances. 108. The LARP implementation schedule, shown below, envisages the following sequence of activities; some of these steps will overlap in their timing and some will be repeated throughout the project schedule.
Table 9.1: Implementation Schedule for Rohri Subproject
Responsibility 2007 Year 2008 Year 2009
Jul- Oct- Jan- Apr- LARP Activity/Task Primary Secondary Completed Sep Dec Mar Jun
LARF Disclosure - Brochure in Urdu PMU LARU LARF Revision (if necessary) PMU LARU/RS NTDC- Request to Govt. of Punjab for NOC/Land Transfer Govt PMU Request to DRO for initiating process PMU LARU/RS Negotiations with Forest Deartment and Punjab Board of Preparation DRO/LAC LARU/RS Revenue LARP disclosure - Brochure in Urdu PMU ADB Site Demarcation of Affected Lands PMU LARU/RS Mobilize project supervision consultant Govt NTDC LARP revision (if necessary) PMU LARU/RS Information dissemination regarding compensation payment NTDC- LARU/RS & evacuation dates PMU Submit revised LARP to EPA/ADB. LARP approval prior to Govt/ADB NTDC Award of Contracts for civil works. Adjust compensation rates & rehabilitation costs for inflation NTDC- DRO/LAC (if necessary) PMU
Implementation Delivery of compensation. Payments to made prior to the DRO/LAC LARU/RS start of Civil Works LARP monitoring (internal, and mobilization of EMA & NTDC- EMA baseline survey) PMU Grievance Redress Process LACC LARU/RS Possession of land for starting works DRO/LAC PMU/NTDC Contractor mobilized, civil works commenced Contractor Consultant Final payment of crop compensation PMU LARU/RS Construction LARP monitoring; post-evaluation report submitted EMA NTDC/ADB
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 33
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
10. MONITORING AND EVALUATION
109. Monitoring and evaluation (M&E) are critical activities in involuntary resettlement caused by various infrastructure development projects, like this power transmission enhancement project. Monitoring involves periodic checking to ascertain whether activities are progressing as per schedule while evaluation is essentially a summing up, at the end of the project, assessment of actual achievement in comparison to those aimed at during the implementation. RP implementation will be monitored both internally as well as externally. 110. The NTDC/PMU through LARU will be responsible for internal monitoring through its field office. The Resettlement Specialist will provide necessary technical assistance in implementing and monitoring the resettlement activities. In addition, a part-time Consultant will be responsible for independent external monitoring and evaluation of the resettlement activities.
10.1 Internal Monitoring
111. The Short LARP includes indicators and benchmarks for achievement of the objectives under the resettlement program, which can be categorized as follows: • Process indicators, which include project inputs, expenditures, staff deployment; • Output indicators are results in terms of numbers of affected persons compensated for their affected assets (land, crops and/or trees), and, • Impact indicators related to the long-term effect of the project on people’s lives in the project-affected area. 112. The first two types of indicators, related to process and immediate outputs and results, will be monitored internally by LARU. This information will be collected from the project site and assimilated in the form of a monthly progress report to assess the progress and results of LARP implementation, and adjust the work program, where necessary, in case of any delays, disputes and/or other problems. Specific activities under LARP implementation that will be monitored are the following: • Information campaign and consultation with AHs on a continued basis; • Status of land acquisition/purchase and payment of crop/tree compensations; • Status of restoration of damaged community infrastructure (water pipelines, irrigation channels / watercourses, drains, roads, streets, etc.) • Grievances redress activities 113. The LARU will be responsible for monitoring the day-to-day resettlement activities of the subproject. The socio-economic census and land acquisition data will provide the necessary benchmark for field level monitoring, to be carried out through: • Review of IOL/Census information for all AHs; • Consultation and informal interviews with AHs; • In-depth case studies; • Informal sample survey of AHs; • Key informant interviews; and • Community public meetings.
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 34
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
114. A performance data sheet will be developed to monitor the project at the field level. Quarterly reports will be received from the field offices and LAC/GSC will be responsible for overall project level monitoring.
10.2 External Monitoring
115. As mentioned earlier, an Individual Consultant, a Consulting firm, or an NGO will be engaged on part-time basis to carry out independent monitoring and evaluation of the LARP implementation (see TORs in Appendix 4). Independent evaluation will be undertaken on a bi-annual basis till the end of the Project. The Consultant will be selected by the NTDC/PMU, with advice and concurrence of ADB. S/he will review the status of the resettlement implementation in light of the targets, budget and duration that had been laid down in this short LARP. The key tasks during external monitoring include: • Review and verify internal monitoring reports prepared by LARU; • Identification and selection of impact indicators; • Impact assessment through formal & informal surveys with the affected persons; • Consultations with AHs, officials, community leaders for review report; and • Assessment of the resettlement efficiency, impact and sustainability, and drawing lessons for future resettlement policy formulation and planning.
10.3 Indicators for Monitoring and Evaluation
116. The following will be considered as the basis for indicators in monitoring and evaluation of the subproject’s LARP: • Socio-economic conditions of the AHs in the post-resettlement period; • Communications and reactions from AHs on entitlements, compensation, options, alternative developments and relocation timetables etc.; • Changes in housing and income levels; • Valuation of property; • Grievance procedures; • Disbursement of compensation; and • Level of satisfaction of AHs in the post resettlement period.
10.4 Resettlement Database
117. All information concerning resettlement issues related to land acquisition, socio- economic information of the acquired land; inventory of crop and tree losses by individual AHs, compensation and entitlements and payments will be collected by LARU and the Consultants through their concerned field offices and computerized by the LARU, at EHV-GSC office in Lahore. This database will form the basis of information for implementation, monitoring and reporting purposes and facilitate efficient resettlement management.
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 35
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
10.5 Reporting Requirements
118. The LARU responsible for supervision and implementation of LARP will prepare monthly progress reports on resettlement activities and submit them to the ADB for review. The Resettlement Specialist will also monitor LARP implementation independently and submit quarterly reports to PMU, NTDC and ADB. These quarterly reports will also highlight the bottlenecks and recommend ways and means to improve such problematic situations. The external Consultant will submit bi-annual review reports directly to ADB and determine whether or not resettlement goals have been achieved, more importantly whether livelihoods and living standards have been restored/enhanced and suggest suitable recommendations for improvement. S/he will also provide a copy of the same report to NTDC Headquarters for information and successive action.
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 36
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
ANNEX 1
Table A-1: Land Affected by Construction of New 220kV Rohri Sub-station and Associated Transmission Lines (Subproject No. 9, Tranche 2)
Temporary Affected Private Land (Crop Compensation: Towers: 3 Crops; TL Corridor: 1 Crop) Affected Government Land
No Compensation
Total Productive Tower Land for Towers (m2) Tower Nos. TL Corridor (30m wide) Land (Public Infrastructure: Length x 30m Width)
No. Productive Non (From-To) Length (m) Productive Non Sq. Meters Hectares Land Productive Land (m2) Productive Land Distance Meters (m2) Description Length Area (m2) Area (ha)
A: Dahrki - Ghotki Line :
1 900.00 - PP - 1 30.00 15.00 450.00 - 1,350 0.14 - - - -
2 900.00 - 1 - 2 320.00 285.50 8,565.00 - 9,465 0.95 Track 4.50 135 0.01
3 900.00 - 2 - 3 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
4 900.00 - 3 - 4 320.00 285.50 8,565.00 - 9,465 0.95 Track 4.50 135 0.01
5 900.00 - 4 - 5 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
6 900.00 - 5 - 6 290.00 260.00 7,800.00 - 8,700 0.87 - - - -
7 900.00 - 6 - 7 300.00 270.00 8,100.00 - 9,000 0.90 - - - -
8 900.00 - 7 - 8 270.00 240.00 7,200.00 - 8,100 0.81 - - - -
9 900.00 - 8 - 9 300.00 270.00 8,100.00 - 9,000 0.90 - - - -
10 900.00 - 9 -10 340.00 302.00 9,060.00 - 9,960 1.00 Road 8.00 240 0.02
11 900.00 - 10-11 250.00 212.00 6,360.00 - 7,260 0.73 Road 8.00 240 0.02
12 900.00 - 11-12 330.00 300.00 9,000.00 - 9,900 0.99 - - - -
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 37
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Temporary Affected Private Land (Crop Compensation: Towers: 3 Crops; TL Corridor: 1 Crop) Affected Government Land
No Compensation
Total Productive Tower Land for Towers (m2) Tower Nos. TL Corridor (30m wide) Land (Public Infrastructure: Length x 30m Width)
No. Productive Non (From-To) Length (m) Productive Non Sq. Meters Hectares Land Productive Land (m2) Productive Land Distance Meters (m2) Description Length Area (m2) Area (ha)
13 900.00 - 12-13 330.00 300.00 9,000.00 - 9,900 0.99 - - - -
14 900.00 - 13-14 320.00 285.00 8,550.00 - 9,450 0.95 Track 5.00 150 0.02
15 900.00 - 14-15 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
16 900.00 - 15-16 320.00 285.50 8,565.00 - 9,465 0.95 Track 4.50 135 0.01
17 900.00 - 16-17 320.00 285.50 8,565.00 - 9,465 0.95 Track 4.50 135 0.01
18 900.00 - 17-18 310.00 280.00 8,400.00 - 9,300 0.93 - - -
19 900.00 - 18-19 330.00 288.00 8,640.00 - 9,540 0.95 Road 12.00 360 0.04
20 900.00 - 19-20 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
21 900.00 - 20-21 270.00 240.00 7,200.00 - 8,100 0.81 - - - -
22 900.00 - 21-22 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
23 900.00 - 22-23 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
24 900.00 - 23-24 270.00 222.00 6,660.00 - 7,560 0.76 Canal + Road 18.00 540 0.05
25 900.00 - 24-25 270.00 240.00 7,200.00 - 8,100 0.81 - - - -
26 - - 25-26 310.00 135.00 4,050.00 - 4,050 0.41 Forest 175.00 5,250 0.53
27 - - 26-27 320.00 - - - - - Forest 320.00 9,600 0.96
28 - - 27-28 320.00 - - - - - Forest 320.00 9,600 0.96
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 38
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Temporary Affected Private Land (Crop Compensation: Towers: 3 Crops; TL Corridor: 1 Crop) Affected Government Land
No Compensation
Total Productive Tower Land for Towers (m2) Tower Nos. TL Corridor (30m wide) Land (Public Infrastructure: Length x 30m Width)
No. Productive Non (From-To) Length (m) Productive Non Sq. Meters Hectares Land Productive Land (m2) Productive Land Distance Meters (m2) Description Length Area (m2) Area (ha)
29 - - 28-29 320.00 - - - - - Forest 320.00 9,600 0.96
30 900.00 - 29-30 320.00 265.00 7,950.00 - 8,850 0.89 Forest 25.00 750 0.08
31 900.00 - 30-31 320.00 286.50 8,595.00 - 9,495 0.95 Track 3.50 105 0.01
32 900.00 - 31-32 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
33 900.00 - 32-33 320.00 286.00 8,580.00 - 9,480 0.95 Track 4.00 120 0.01
34 900.00 - 33-34 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
35 900.00 - 34-35 320.00 285.50 8,565.00 - 9,465 0.95 Track 4.50 135 0.01
36 900.00 - 35-36 320.00 285.50 8,565.00 - 9,465 0.95 Track 4.50 135 0.01
37 900.00 - 36-37 320.00 285.50 8,565.00 - 9,465 0.95 Track 4.50 135 0.01
38 900.00 - 37-38 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
39 900.00 - 38-39 325.00 295.00 8,850.00 - 9,750 0.98 - - - -
40 900.00 - 39-40 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
41 900.00 - 40-41 330.00 300.00 9,000.00 - 9,900 0.99 - - - -
42 900.00 - 41-42 320.00 284.00 8,520.00 - 9,420 0.94 Track 6.00 180 0.02
43 900.00 - 42-43 320.00 272.00 8,160.00 - 9,060 0.91 Canal + Track 18.00 540 0.05
44 900.00 - 43-44 320.00 276.00 8,280.00 - 9,180 0.92 Road + Track 14.00 420 0.04
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 39
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Temporary Affected Private Land (Crop Compensation: Towers: 3 Crops; TL Corridor: 1 Crop) Affected Government Land
No Compensation
Total Productive Tower Land for Towers (m2) Tower Nos. TL Corridor (30m wide) Land (Public Infrastructure: Length x 30m Width)
No. Productive Non (From-To) Length (m) Productive Non Sq. Meters Hectares Land Productive Land (m2) Productive Land Distance Meters (m2) Description Length Area (m2) Area (ha)
45 900.00 - 44-45 350.00 316.00 9,480.00 - 10,380 1.04 Track 4.00 120 0.01
46 900.00 - 45-46 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
47 900.00 - 46-47 330.00 300.00 9,000.00 - 9,900 0.99 - - - -
48 900.00 - 47-48 290.00 260.00 7,800.00 - 8,700 0.87 - - - -
49 900.00 - 48-49 300.00 265.50 7,965.00 - 8,865 0.89 Track 4.50 135 0.01
50 900.00 - 49-50 270.00 240.00 7,200.00 - 8,100 0.81 - - - -
51 900.00 - 50-51 310.00 280.00 8,400.00 - 9,300 0.93 - - - -
52 900.00 - 51-52 270.00 235.50 7,065.00 - 7,965 0.80 Track 4.50 135 0.01
53 900.00 - 52-53 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
54 900.00 - 53-54 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
55 900.00 - 54-55 320.00 285.50 8,565.00 - 9,465 0.95 Track 4.50 135 0.01
56 900.00 - 55-56 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
57 900.00 - 56-57 310.00 280.00 8,400.00 - 9,300 0.93 - - - -
58 900.00 - 57-58 310.00 280.00 8,400.00 - 9,300 0.93 - - - -
59 900.00 - 58-59 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
60 900.00 - 59-60 320.00 280.00 8,400.00 - 9,300 0.93 Road 10.00 300 0.03
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 40
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Temporary Affected Private Land (Crop Compensation: Towers: 3 Crops; TL Corridor: 1 Crop) Affected Government Land
No Compensation
Total Productive Tower Land for Towers (m2) Tower Nos. TL Corridor (30m wide) Land (Public Infrastructure: Length x 30m Width)
No. Productive Non (From-To) Length (m) Productive Non Sq. Meters Hectares Land Productive Land (m2) Productive Land Distance Meters (m2) Description Length Area (m2) Area (ha)
61 900.00 - 60-61 320.00 282.00 8,460.00 - 9,360 0.94 Road 8.00 240 0.02
62 900.00 - 61-62 300.00 270.00 8,100.00 - 9,000 0.90 - - - -
63 900.00 - 62-63 310.00 272.00 8,160.00 - 9,060 0.91 Road 8.00 240 0.02
64 900.00 - 63-64 290.00 260.00 7,800.00 - 8,700 0.87 - - - -
65 900.00 - 64-65 300.00 270.00 8,100.00 - 9,000 0.90 - - - -
66 900.00 - 65-66 270.00 240.00 7,200.00 - 8,100 0.81 - - - -
67 900.00 - 66-67 310.00 280.00 8,400.00 - 9,300 0.93 - - - -
68 900.00 - 67-68 320.00 285.50 8,565.00 - 9,465 0.95 Track 4.50 135 0.01
69 900.00 - 68-69 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
70 900.00 - 69-70 320.00 285.50 8,565.00 - 9,465 0.95 Track 4.50 135 0.01
71 900.00 - 70-71 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
72 900.00 - 71-72 320.00 286.00 8,580.00 - 9,480 0.95 Track 4.00 120 0.01
73 900.00 - 72-73 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
74 900.00 - 73-74 270.00 225.00 6,750.00 - 7,650 0.77 Road + Track 15.00 450 0.05
75 900.00 - 74-75 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
76 900.00 - 75-76 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 41
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Temporary Affected Private Land (Crop Compensation: Towers: 3 Crops; TL Corridor: 1 Crop) Affected Government Land
No Compensation
Total Productive Tower Land for Towers (m2) Tower Nos. TL Corridor (30m wide) Land (Public Infrastructure: Length x 30m Width)
No. Productive Non (From-To) Length (m) Productive Non Sq. Meters Hectares Land Productive Land (m2) Productive Land Distance Meters (m2) Description Length Area (m2) Area (ha)
77 900.00 - 76-77 320.00 282.00 8,460.00 - 9,360 0.94 Road 8.00 240 0.02
78 - 900 77-78 270.00 240.00 6,450.00 750 6,450 0.65 - - - -
79 - 900 78-79 320.00 284.00 - 8,520 - - Track 6.00 180 0.02
80 - 900 79-80 310.00 280.00 - 8,400 ------
81 - 900 80-81 300.00 270.00 - 8,100 ------
82 900.00 - 81-82 270.00 240.00 2,100.00 5,100 3,000 0.30 - - - -
83 - 900 82-83 300.00 270.00 2,700.00 5,400 2,700 0.27 - - - -
84 - 900 83-84 270.00 232.00 - 6,960 - - Road 8.00 240 0.02
85 - 900 84-85 330.00 300.00 - 9,000 ------
86 - 900 85-86 290.00 255.50 - 7,665 - - Track 4.50 135 0.01
87 - 900 86-87 183.21 153.21 - 4,596 ------
88 900.00 - 87-88 300.00 270.00 7,500.00 600 8,400 0.84 - - - -
89 900.00 - 88-89 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
90 900.00 - 89-90 290.00 260.00 7,800.00 - 8,700 0.87 - - - -
91 900.00 - 90-91 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
92 900.00 - 91-92 270.00 240.00 7,200.00 - 8,100 0.81 - - - -
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 42
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Temporary Affected Private Land (Crop Compensation: Towers: 3 Crops; TL Corridor: 1 Crop) Affected Government Land
No Compensation
Total Productive Tower Land for Towers (m2) Tower Nos. TL Corridor (30m wide) Land (Public Infrastructure: Length x 30m Width)
No. Productive Non (From-To) Length (m) Productive Non Sq. Meters Hectares Land Productive Land (m2) Productive Land Distance Meters (m2) Description Length Area (m2) Area (ha)
93 900.00 - 92-93 290.00 260.00 7,800.00 - 8,700 0.87 - - - -
94 900.00 - 93-94 320.00 285.50 8,565.00 - 9,465 0.95 Track 4.50 135 0.01
95 900.00 - 94-95 310.00 188.00 5,640.00 - 6,540 0.65 Highway+Railway 92.00 2,760 0.28
96 900.00 - 95-96 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
97 900.00 - 96-97 310.00 280.00 8,400.00 - 9,300 0.93 - - - -
98 900.00 - 97-98 229.12 199.12 5,973.60 - 6,874 0.69 - - - -
99 900.00 - 98-99 270.00 240.00 7,200.00 - 8,100 0.81 - - - -
100 900.00 - 99-100 290.00 260.00 7,800.00 - 8,700 0.87 - - - -
900.00 - 100 - PP 85.00 70.00 2,100.00 - 3,000 0.30 - - - -
100 79,200 8,100 sub-total (a): 30,492 26,130 718,804 65,091 798,004 79.80 - 1,483 44,475 4.45
B: Ghotki- New Rohri Line :
1 900 - PP-1 85.00 70.00 2,100.00 - 3,000 0.30 - - - -
2 900 - 1 - 2 270.00 240.00 7,200.00 - 8,100 0.81 - - - -
3 900 - 2 - 3 300.00 270.00 8,100.00 - 9,000 0.90 - - - -
4 900 - 3 - 4 320.00 198.00 5,940.00 - 6,840 0.68 Highway+Railway 92.00 2,760 0.28
5 900 - 4 - 5 250.00 220.00 6,600.00 - 7,500 0.75 - - - -
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 43
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Temporary Affected Private Land (Crop Compensation: Towers: 3 Crops; TL Corridor: 1 Crop) Affected Government Land
No Compensation
Total Productive Tower Land for Towers (m2) Tower Nos. TL Corridor (30m wide) Land (Public Infrastructure: Length x 30m Width)
No. Productive Non (From-To) Length (m) Productive Non Sq. Meters Hectares Land Productive Land (m2) Productive Land Distance Meters (m2) Description Length Area (m2) Area (ha)
6 900 - 5 - 6 270.00 240.00 7,200.00 - 8,100 0.81 - - - -
7 900 - 6 - 7 305.00 275.00 8,250.00 - 9,150 0.92 - - - -
8 900 - 7 - 8 310.00 280.00 8,400.00 - 9,300 0.93 - - - -
9 900 - 8 - 9 310.00 280.00 8,400.00 - 9,300 0.93 - - - -
10 900 - 9 -10 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
11 900 - 10-11 310.00 280.00 8,400.00 - 9,300 0.93 - - - -
12 900 - 11-12 280.00 250.00 7,500.00 - 8,400 0.84 - - - -
13 900 - 12-13 280.00 250.00 7,500.00 - 8,400 0.84 - - - -
14 900 - 13-14 270.00 240.00 7,200.00 - 8,100 0.81 - - - -
15 900 - 14-15 285.00 255.00 7,650.00 - 8,550 0.86 - - - -
16 900 - 15-16 270.00 240.00 7,200.00 - 8,100 0.81 - - - -
17 900 - 16-17 241.00 211.00 6,330.00 - 7,230 0.72 - - - -
18 900 - 17-18 320.00 282.00 8,460.00 - 9,360 0.94 Road 8.00 240 0.02
19 900 - 18-19 330.00 295.50 8,865.00 - 9,765 0.98 Track 4.50 135 0.01
20 900 - 19-20 330.00 300.00 9,000.00 - 9,900 0.99 - - - -
21 900 - 20-21 280.00 250.00 7,500.00 - 8,400 0.84 - - - -
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 44
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Temporary Affected Private Land (Crop Compensation: Towers: 3 Crops; TL Corridor: 1 Crop) Affected Government Land
No Compensation
Total Productive Tower Land for Towers (m2) Tower Nos. TL Corridor (30m wide) Land (Public Infrastructure: Length x 30m Width)
No. Productive Non (From-To) Length (m) Productive Non Sq. Meters Hectares Land Productive Land (m2) Productive Land Distance Meters (m2) Description Length Area (m2) Area (ha)
22 900 - 21-22 270.00 232.00 6,960.00 - 7,860 0.79 Road 8.00 240 0.02
23 900 - 22-23 310.00 280.00 8,400.00 - 9,300 0.93 - - - -
24 900 - 23-24 270.00 235.00 7,050.00 - 7,950 0.80 Track 5.00 150 0.02
25 900 - 24-25 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
26 900 - 25-26 310.00 280.00 8,400.00 - 9,300 0.93 - - - -
27 900 - 26-27 290.00 260.00 7,800.00 - 8,700 0.87 - - - -
28 900 - 27-28 270.00 240.00 7,200.00 - 8,100 0.81 - - - -
29 900 - 28-29 270.00 240.00 7,200.00 - 8,100 0.81 - - - -
30 900 - 29-30 270.00 235.50 7,065.00 - 7,965 0.80 Track 4.50 135 0.01
31 900 - 30-31 290.00 260.00 7,800.00 - 8,700 0.87 - - - -
32 900 - 31-32 305.00 275.00 8,250.00 - 9,150 0.92 - - - -
33 900 - 32-33 295.00 265.00 7,950.00 - 8,850 0.89 - - - -
34 900 - 33-34 270.00 222.00 6,660.00 - 7,560 0.76 Canal + Road 18.00 540 0.05
35 900 - 34-35 310.00 280.00 8,400.00 - 9,300 0.93 - - - -
36 900 - 35-36 310.00 280.00 8,400.00 - 9,300 0.93 - - - -
37 900 - 36-37 310.00 280.00 8,400.00 - 9,300 0.93 - - - -
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 45
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Temporary Affected Private Land (Crop Compensation: Towers: 3 Crops; TL Corridor: 1 Crop) Affected Government Land
No Compensation
Total Productive Tower Land for Towers (m2) Tower Nos. TL Corridor (30m wide) Land (Public Infrastructure: Length x 30m Width)
No. Productive Non (From-To) Length (m) Productive Non Sq. Meters Hectares Land Productive Land (m2) Productive Land Distance Meters (m2) Description Length Area (m2) Area (ha)
38 900 - 37-38 300.00 262.00 7,860.00 - 8,760 0.88 Road 8.00 240 0.02
39 900 - 38-39 310.00 280.00 8,400.00 - 9,300 0.93 - - - -
40 900 - 39-40 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
41 900 - 40-41 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
42 900 - 41-42 300.00 270.00 8,100.00 - 9,000 0.90 - - - -
43 900 - 42-43 300.00 270.00 8,100.00 - 9,000 0.90 - - - -
44 900 - 43-44 270.00 240.00 7,200.00 - 8,100 0.81 - - - -
45 900 - 44-45 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
46 900 - 45-46 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
47 900 - 46-47 320.00 282.00 8,460.00 - 9,360 0.94 Road 8.00 240 0.02
48 - - 47-48 270.00 250.00 7,500.00 - 7,500 0.75 Forest 20.00 600 0.06
49 - - 48-49 300.00 - - - - - Forest 300.00 9,000 0.90
50 - - 49-50 320.00 - - - - - Forest 320.00 9,600 0.96
51 - - 50-51 310.00 - - - - - Forest 310.00 9,300 0.93
52 - - 51-52 300.00 - - - - - Forest 300.00 9,000 0.90
53 - - 52-53 310.00 - - - - - Forest 310.00 9,300 0.93
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 46
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Temporary Affected Private Land (Crop Compensation: Towers: 3 Crops; TL Corridor: 1 Crop) Affected Government Land
No Compensation
Total Productive Tower Land for Towers (m2) Tower Nos. TL Corridor (30m wide) Land (Public Infrastructure: Length x 30m Width)
No. Productive Non (From-To) Length (m) Productive Non Sq. Meters Hectares Land Productive Land (m2) Productive Land Distance Meters (m2) Description Length Area (m2) Area (ha)
54 - - 53-54 290.00 - - - - - Forest 290.00 8,700 0.87
55 - - 54-55 300.00 - - - - - Forest 300.00 9,000 0.90
56 - - 55-56 290.00 - - - - - Forest 290.00 8,700 0.87
57 - - 56-57 300.00 - - - - - Forest 300.00 9,000 0.90
58 - - 57-58 290.00 - - - - - Forest 290.00 8,700 0.87
59 - - 58-59 300.00 - - - - - Forest 300.00 9,000 0.90
60 - - 59-60 270.00 - - - - - Forest 270.00 8,100 0.81
61 - - 60-61 320.00 - - - - - Forest 320.00 9,600 0.96
62 900 - 61-62 320.00 12.00 360.00 - 1,260 0.13 - 278.00 8,340 0.83
63 900 - 62-63 310.00 270.00 5,850.00 2,250 6,750 0.68 Canal 10.00 300 0.03
64 900 - 63-64 300.00 266.00 4,500.00 3,480 5,400 0.54 Track 4.00 120 0.01
65 900 - 64-65 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
66 900 - 65-66 290.00 260.00 7,800.00 - 8,700 0.87 - - - -
67 900 - 66-67 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
68 900 - 67-68 300.00 270.00 8,100.00 - 9,000 0.90 - - - -
69 900 - 68-69 290.00 260.00 7,800.00 - 8,700 0.87 - - - -
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 47
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Temporary Affected Private Land (Crop Compensation: Towers: 3 Crops; TL Corridor: 1 Crop) Affected Government Land
No Compensation
Total Productive Tower Land for Towers (m2) Tower Nos. TL Corridor (30m wide) Land (Public Infrastructure: Length x 30m Width)
No. Productive Non (From-To) Length (m) Productive Non Sq. Meters Hectares Land Productive Land (m2) Productive Land Distance Meters (m2) Description Length Area (m2) Area (ha)
70 900 - 69-70 290.00 260.00 7,800.00 - 8,700 0.87 - - - -
71 - 900 70-71 270.00 115.00 3,450.00 - 3,450 0.35 Forest 125.00 3,750 0.38
72 - - 71-72 290.00 - - - - - Forest 290.00 8,700 0.87
73 - - 72-73 300.00 - - - - - Forest 300.00 9,000 0.90
74 - - 73-74 300.00 - - - - - Forest 300.00 9,000 0.90
75 - - 74-75 290.00 - - - - - Forest 290.00 8,700 0.87
76 - - 75-76 280.00 - - - - - Forest 280.00 8,400 0.84
77 - - 76-77 300.00 - - - - - Forest 300.00 9,000 0.90
78 - - 77-78 270.00 - - - - - Forest 270.00 8,100 0.81
79 - - 78-79 300.00 - - - - - Forest 300.00 9,000 0.90
80 - - 79-80 320.00 - - - - - Forest 320.00 9,600 0.96
81 - - 80-81 320.00 - - - - - Forest 320.00 9,600 0.96
82 - - 81-82 320.00 - - - - - Forest 320.00 9,600 0.96
83 - - 82-83 320.00 - - - - - Forest 320.00 9,600 0.96
84 900 - 83-84 320.00 50.00 1,500.00 - 2,400 0.24 - 240.00 7,200 0.72
85 900 - 84-85 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 48
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Temporary Affected Private Land (Crop Compensation: Towers: 3 Crops; TL Corridor: 1 Crop) Affected Government Land
No Compensation
Total Productive Tower Land for Towers (m2) Tower Nos. TL Corridor (30m wide) Land (Public Infrastructure: Length x 30m Width)
No. Productive Non (From-To) Length (m) Productive Non Sq. Meters Hectares Land Productive Land (m2) Productive Land Distance Meters (m2) Description Length Area (m2) Area (ha)
86 900 - 85-86 320.00 284.00 1,500.00 7,020 2,400 0.24 Paved Track 6.00 180 0.02
87 900 - 86-87 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
88 900 - 87-88 290.00 260.00 7,800.00 - 8,700 0.87 - - - -
89 900 - 88-89 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
90 900 - 89-90 320.00 290.00 5,610.00 3,090 6,510 0.65 - - - -
91 900 - 90-91 320.00 285.50 8,565.00 - 9,465 0.95 Track 4.50 135 0.01
92 900 - 91-92 315.00 285.00 8,550.00 - 9,450 0.95 - - - -
93 900 - 92-93 320.00 290.00 5,850.00 2,850 6,750 0.68 - - - -
94 900 - 93-94 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
95 900 - 94-95 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
96 900 - 95-96 320.00 285.50 6,150.00 2,415 7,050 0.71 Track 4.50 135 0.01
97 900 - 96-97 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
98 900 - 97-98 290.00 260.00 7,800.00 - 8,700 0.87 - - - -
99 900 - 98-99 320.00 280.00 8,400.00 - 9,300 0.93 Road 10.00 300 0.03
100 900 - 99-100 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
101 900 - 100-101 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 49
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Temporary Affected Private Land (Crop Compensation: Towers: 3 Crops; TL Corridor: 1 Crop) Affected Government Land
No Compensation
Total Productive Tower Land for Towers (m2) Tower Nos. TL Corridor (30m wide) Land (Public Infrastructure: Length x 30m Width)
No. Productive Non (From-To) Length (m) Productive Non Sq. Meters Hectares Land Productive Land (m2) Productive Land Distance Meters (m2) Description Length Area (m2) Area (ha)
102 900 - 101-102 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
103 900 - 102-103 320.00 285.00 8,550.00 - 9,450 0.95 Track 5.00 150 0.02
104 900 - 103-104 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
105 900 - 104-105 290.00 260.00 7,800.00 - 8,700 0.87 - - - -
106 900 - 105-106 290.00 260.00 7,800.00 - 8,700 0.87 - - - -
107 900 - 106-107 310.00 280.00 5,460.00 2,940 6,360 0.64 - - - -
108 900 - 107-108 310.00 272.00 8,160.00 - 9,060 0.91 Road 8.00 240 0.02
109 900 - 108-109 270.00 240.00 7,200.00 - 8,100 0.81 - - - -
110 900 - 109-110 320.00 290.00 5,250.00 3,450 6,150 0.62 - - - -
111 900 - 110-111 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
112 900 - 111-112 320.00 285.00 8,550.00 - 9,450 0.95 Track 5.00 150 0.02
113 900 - 112-113 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
114 900 - 113-114 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
115 900 - 114-115 320.00 290.00 4,950.00 3,750 5,850 0.59 - - - -
116 900 - 115-116 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
117 900 - 116-117 330.00 300.00 9,000.00 - 9,900 0.99 - - - -
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 50
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Temporary Affected Private Land (Crop Compensation: Towers: 3 Crops; TL Corridor: 1 Crop) Affected Government Land
No Compensation
Total Productive Tower Land for Towers (m2) Tower Nos. TL Corridor (30m wide) Land (Public Infrastructure: Length x 30m Width)
No. Productive Non (From-To) Length (m) Productive Non Sq. Meters Hectares Land Productive Land (m2) Productive Land Distance Meters (m2) Description Length Area (m2) Area (ha)
118 900 - 117-118 330.00 300.00 6,300.00 2,700 7,200 0.72 - - - -
119 900 - 118-119 330.00 300.00 9,000.00 - 9,900 0.99 - - - -
120 900 - 119-120 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
121 900 - 120-121 320.00 282.00 8,460.00 - 9,360 0.94 Road 8.00 240 0.02
122 900 - 121-122 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
123 900 - 122-123 310.00 280.00 8,400.00 - 9,300 0.93 - - - -
124 900 - 123-124 270.00 240.00 7,200.00 - 8,100 0.81 - - - -
125 900 - 124-125 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
126 900 - 125-126 270.00 240.00 7,200.00 - 8,100 0.81 - - - -
127 900 - 126-127 270.00 240.00 7,200.00 - 8,100 0.81 - - - -
128 900 - 127-128 265.00 235.00 7,050.00 - 7,950 0.80 - - - -
129 900 - 128-129 290.00 260.00 7,800.00 - 8,700 0.87 - - - -
130 0 900 129-130 300.00 270.00 6,900.00 1,200 6,900 0.69 - - - -
131 0 900 130-131 235.00 205.00 - 6,150 ------
132 0 900 131-132 320.00 290.00 - 8,700 ------
133 0 900 132-133 330.00 300.00 - 9,000 ------
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 51
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Temporary Affected Private Land (Crop Compensation: Towers: 3 Crops; TL Corridor: 1 Crop) Affected Government Land
No Compensation
Total Productive Tower Land for Towers (m2) Tower Nos. TL Corridor (30m wide) Land (Public Infrastructure: Length x 30m Width)
No. Productive Non (From-To) Length (m) Productive Non Sq. Meters Hectares Land Productive Land (m2) Productive Land Distance Meters (m2) Description Length Area (m2) Area (ha)
134 0 900 133-134 330.00 300.00 - 9,000 ------
135 0 900 134-135 330.00 300.00 - 9,000 ------
136 900 - 135-136 330.00 300.00 8,100.00 900 9,000 0.90 - - - -
137 900 - 136-137 330.00 278.00 8,340.00 - 9,240 0.92 Canal + Road 22.00 660 0.07
138 900 - 137-138 270.00 240.00 7,200.00 - 8,100 0.81 - - - -
139 900 - 138-139 320.00 290.00 6,600.00 2,100 7,500 0.75 - - - -
140 900 - 139-140 270.00 240.00 7,200.00 - 8,100 0.81 - - - -
141 900 - 140-141 290.00 260.00 7,800.00 - 8,700 0.87 - - - -
142 900 - 141-142 280.00 250.00 7,500.00 - 8,400 0.84 - - - -
143 900 - 142-143 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
144 900 - 143-144 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
145 900 - 144-145 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
146 900 - 145-146 320.00 286.00 7,680.00 900 8,580 0.86 Track 4.00 120 0.01
147 900 - 146-147 310.00 275.50 8,265.00 - 9,165 0.92 Track 4.50 135 0.01
148 900 - 147-148 270.00 240.00 7,200.00 - 8,100 0.81 - - - -
149 900 - 148-149 285.00 255.00 7,650.00 - 8,550 0.86 - - - -
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 52
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Temporary Affected Private Land (Crop Compensation: Towers: 3 Crops; TL Corridor: 1 Crop) Affected Government Land
No Compensation
Total Productive Tower Land for Towers (m2) Tower Nos. TL Corridor (30m wide) Land (Public Infrastructure: Length x 30m Width)
No. Productive Non (From-To) Length (m) Productive Non Sq. Meters Hectares Land Productive Land (m2) Productive Land Distance Meters (m2) Description Length Area (m2) Area (ha)
150 900 - 149-150 270.00 240.00 7,200.00 - 8,100 0.81 - - - -
151 900 - 150-151 310.00 280.00 8,400.00 - 9,300 0.93 - - - -
152 900 - 151-152 320.00 290.00 7,200.00 1,500 8,100 0.81 - - - -
153 900 - 152-153 300.00 265.50 7,965.00 - 8,865 0.89 Track 4.50 135 0.01
154 900 - 153-154 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
155 900 - 154-155 270.00 240.00 7,200.00 - 8,100 0.81 - - - -
156 900 - 155-156 270.00 240.00 7,200.00 - 8,100 0.81 - - - -
157 900 - 156-157 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
158 900 - 157-158 320.00 285.50 8,565.00 - 9,465 0.95 Track 4.50 135 0.01
159 900 - 158-159 270.00 240.00 7,200.00 - 8,100 0.81 - - - -
160 900 - 159-160 270.00 240.00 7,200.00 - 8,100 0.81 - - - -
161 900 - 160-161 270.00 240.00 7,200.00 - 8,100 0.81 - - - -
162 900 - 161-162 300.00 270.00 8,100.00 - 9,000 0.90 - - - -
163 900 - 162-163 300.00 270.00 8,100.00 - 9,000 0.90 - - - -
164 900 - 163-164 305.00 275.00 8,250.00 - 9,150 0.92 - - - -
165 900 - 164-165 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 53
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Temporary Affected Private Land (Crop Compensation: Towers: 3 Crops; TL Corridor: 1 Crop) Affected Government Land
No Compensation
Total Productive Tower Land for Towers (m2) Tower Nos. TL Corridor (30m wide) Land (Public Infrastructure: Length x 30m Width)
No. Productive Non (From-To) Length (m) Productive Non Sq. Meters Hectares Land Productive Land (m2) Productive Land Distance Meters (m2) Description Length Area (m2) Area (ha)
166 900 - 165-166 320.00 290.00 6,885.00 1,815 7,785 0.78 - - - -
167 900 - 166-167 320.00 290.00 5,850.00 2,850 6,750 0.68 - - - -
168 900 - 167-168 320.00 285.50 8,565.00 - 9,465 0.95 Track 4.50 135 0.01
169 900 - 168-169 320.00 286.00 8,580.00 - 9,480 0.95 Track 4.00 120 0.01
170 900 - 169-170 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
171 900 - 170-171 265.00 235.00 7,050.00 - 7,950 0.80 - - - -
172 900 - 171-172 270.00 240.00 7,200.00 - 8,100 0.81 - - - -
173 900 - 172-173 295.00 258.00 7,740.00 - 8,640 0.86 Paved Track 7.00 210 0.02
174 0 900 173-174 320.00 290.00 7,050.00 1,650 7,050 0.71 - - - -
175 0 900 174-175 270.00 240.00 - 7,200 ------
176 0 900 175-176 270.00 240.00 - 7,200 ------
177 0 900 176-177 325.00 295.00 - 8,850 ------
178 0 900 177-178 320.00 290.00 - 8,700 ------
179 0 900 178-179 320.00 290.00 - 8,700 ------
180 900 - 179-180 320.00 290.00 6,300.00 2,400 7,200 0.72 - - - -
181 900 - 180-181 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 54
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Temporary Affected Private Land (Crop Compensation: Towers: 3 Crops; TL Corridor: 1 Crop) Affected Government Land
No Compensation
Total Productive Tower Land for Towers (m2) Tower Nos. TL Corridor (30m wide) Land (Public Infrastructure: Length x 30m Width)
No. Productive Non (From-To) Length (m) Productive Non Sq. Meters Hectares Land Productive Land (m2) Productive Land Distance Meters (m2) Description Length Area (m2) Area (ha)
182 900 - 181-182 230.00 200.00 6,000.00 - 6,900 0.69 - - - -
183 900 - 182-183 270.00 235.50 7,065.00 - 7,965 0.80 Track 4.50 135 0.01
184 0 900 183-184 270.00 240.00 5,460.00 1,740 5,460 0.55 - - - -
185 0 900 184-185 285.00 255.00 - 7,650 ------
186 900 - 185-186 320.00 282.00 7,200.00 1,260 8,100 0.81 Road 8.00 240 0.02
187 900 - 186-187 320.00 285.50 8,565.00 - 9,465 0.95 Track 4.50 135 0.01
188 900 - 187-188 270.00 240.00 7,200.00 - 8,100 0.81 - - - -
189 900 - 188-189 315.00 277.00 8,310.00 - 9,210 0.92 Paved Track 8.00 240 0.02
190 900 - 189-190 280.00 250.00 7,500.00 - 8,400 0.84 - - - -
191 900 - 190-191 315.00 285.00 8,550.00 - 9,450 0.95 - - - -
192 900 - 191-192 300.00 270.00 8,100.00 - 9,000 0.90 - - - -
193 0 900 192-193 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 8,700 0.87 - - - -
194 0 900 193-194 320.00 202.00 6,060.00 - 6,060 0.61 Drain + Road 88.00 2,640 0.26
- - 194 - Grid 210.00 195.00 5,850.00 - 5,850 0.59 - - - -
194 135,900 15,300 sub-total (b): 58,521 44,919 1,205,160 142,410 1,341,060 134.11 - 8,562 256,860 25.69
AB: Connecting Line A to B:
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 55
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Temporary Affected Private Land (Crop Compensation: Towers: 3 Crops; TL Corridor: 1 Crop) Affected Government Land
No Compensation
Total Productive Tower Land for Towers (m2) Tower Nos. TL Corridor (30m wide) Land (Public Infrastructure: Length x 30m Width)
No. Productive Non (From-To) Length (m) Productive Non Sq. Meters Hectares Land Productive Land (m2) Productive Land Distance Meters (m2) Description Length Area (m2) Area (ha)
1 900 - Lane A -1 210.00 195.00 5,850.00 - 6,750 0.68 -
2 900 - 1-2 325.00 295.00 8,850.00 - 9,750 0.98 - - - -
- - - 2 - Lane B 210.00 195.00 5,850.00 - 5,850 0.59 -
2 1,800 - sub-total (ab): 745 685 20,550 - 22,350 2.24 - - - -
C: New RohrI - Shikarpur Line
1 - 900 Grid- 1 60.00 45.00 - 1,350 ------
2 - 900 1 - 2 370.00 340.00 - 10,200 ------
3 - 900 2 - 3 345.00 315.00 - 9,450 ------
4 - 900 3 - 4 340.00 305.50 - 9,165 - - Track 4.50 135 0.01
5 - 900 4 - 5 350.00 320.00 - 9,600 ------
6 - 900 5 - 6 355.00 325.00 - 9,750 ------
7 900.00 - 6 - 7 349.00 319.00 - 9,570 900 0.09 - - - -
8 900.00 - 7 - 8 367.00 337.00 10,110.00 - 11,010 1.10 - - - -
9 900.00 - 8 - 9 345.00 315.00 9,450.00 - 10,350 1.04 - - - -
10 900.00 - 9-10 355.00 325.00 9,750.00 - 10,650 1.07 - - - -
11 900.00 - 10-11 380.00 344.00 10,320.00 - 11,220 1.12 Village Road 6.00 180 0.02
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 56
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Temporary Affected Private Land (Crop Compensation: Towers: 3 Crops; TL Corridor: 1 Crop) Affected Government Land
No Compensation
Total Productive Tower Land for Towers (m2) Tower Nos. TL Corridor (30m wide) Land (Public Infrastructure: Length x 30m Width)
No. Productive Non (From-To) Length (m) Productive Non Sq. Meters Hectares Land Productive Land (m2) Productive Land Distance Meters (m2) Description Length Area (m2) Area (ha)
12 900.00 - 11-12 260.00 218.00 6,540.00 - 7,440 0.74 Minor Canal 12.00 360 0.04
13 900.00 - 12-13 273.50 243.50 7,305.00 - 8,205 0.82 - -
14 - 900 13-14 380.00 240.00 - 7,200 - - Road+ Railway 110.00 3,300 0.33
15 - 900 14-15 365.00 335.00 - 10,050 - - - -
16 - 900 15-16 355.00 325.00 - 9,750 - - - -
17 900.00 - 16-17 349.00 319.00 - 9,570 900 0.09 - -
18 900.00 - 17-18 356.00 326.00 9,780.00 - 10,680 1.07 - -
19 900.00 - 18-19 320.89 286.39 3,300.00 5,292 4,200 0.42 Kacha track 4.50 135 0.01
20 - - 19-20 270.00 40.00 1,200.00 - 1,200 0.12 Road+ Canal 230.00 6,900 0.69
21 - - 20-21 285.00 - - - - - Road+ Canal 285.00 8,550 0.86
22 - - 21-22 267.95 152.95 - 4,589 - - Road 85.00 2,550 0.26
23 900.00 - 22-23 181.25 87.25 - 2,618 900 0.09 Road 64.00 1,920 0.19
24 900.00 - 23-24 320.00 284.00 8,520.00 - 9,420 0.94 Village Road 6.00 180 0.02
25 - 900 24-25 330.00 70.00 2,100.00 - 2,100 0.21 Canal+ProtectBnd 230.00 6,900 0.69
26 - - 25-26 327.00 - - - - - River 327.00 9,810 0.98
27 - - 26-27 360.00 - - - - - River 360.00 10,800 1.08
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 57
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Temporary Affected Private Land (Crop Compensation: Towers: 3 Crops; TL Corridor: 1 Crop) Affected Government Land
No Compensation
Total Productive Tower Land for Towers (m2) Tower Nos. TL Corridor (30m wide) Land (Public Infrastructure: Length x 30m Width)
No. Productive Non (From-To) Length (m) Productive Non Sq. Meters Hectares Land Productive Land (m2) Productive Land Distance Meters (m2) Description Length Area (m2) Area (ha)
28 - - 27-28 355.00 - - - - - River 355.00 10,650 1.07
29 - - 28-29 350.00 - - - - - River 350.00 10,500 1.05
30 - 900 29-30 360.00 330.00 - 9,900 - - - -
31 - 900 30-31 350.00 320.00 - 9,600 - - - -
32 - 900 31-32 355.00 325.00 - 9,750 - - - -
33 900.00 - 32-33 357.00 327.00 2,100.00 7,710 3,000 0.30 - -
34 900.00 - 33-34 363.00 243.00 2,100.00 5,190 3,000 0.30 Protective Bund 90.00 2,700 0.27
35 900.00 - 34-35 360.00 330.00 8,100.00 1,800 9,000 0.90 - -
36 900.00 - 35-36 385.00 355.00 10,650.00 - 11,550 1.16 - -
37 900.00 - 36-37 387.00 357.00 10,710.00 - 11,610 1.16 - -
38 900.00 - 37-38 370.00 340.00 10,200.00 - 11,100 1.11 - -
39 900.00 - 38-39 380.00 345.50 10,365.00 - 11,265 1.13 Kacha track 4.50 135 0.01
40 900.00 - 39-40 375.00 345.00 10,350.00 - 11,250 1.13 - -
41 900.00 - 40-41 380.00 350.00 10,500.00 - 11,400 1.14 - -
42 900.00 - 41-42 375.00 345.00 10,350.00 - 11,250 1.13 - -
43 900.00 - 42-43 385.00 355.00 10,650.00 - 11,550 1.16 - -
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 58
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Temporary Affected Private Land (Crop Compensation: Towers: 3 Crops; TL Corridor: 1 Crop) Affected Government Land
No Compensation
Total Productive Tower Land for Towers (m2) Tower Nos. TL Corridor (30m wide) Land (Public Infrastructure: Length x 30m Width)
No. Productive Non (From-To) Length (m) Productive Non Sq. Meters Hectares Land Productive Land (m2) Productive Land Distance Meters (m2) Description Length Area (m2) Area (ha)
44 900.00 - 43-44 380.00 345.50 10,365.00 - 11,265 1.13 Kacha track 4.50 135 0.01
45 900.00 - 44-45 370.00 340.00 10,200.00 - 11,100 1.11 - -
46 900.00 - 45-46 365.00 335.00 10,050.00 - 10,950 1.10 - -
47 900.00 - 46-47 369.00 339.00 10,170.00 - 11,070 1.11 - -
48 900.00 - 47-48 370.00 335.50 10,065.00 - 10,965 1.10 Kacha track 4.50 135 0.01
49 900.00 - 48-49 350.00 320.00 9,600.00 - 10,500 1.05 - -
50 900.00 - 49-50 355.00 320.50 9,615.00 - 10,515 1.05 Kacha track 4.50 135 0.01
51 900.00 - 50-51 360.00 330.00 9,900.00 - 10,800 1.08 - -
52 900.00 - 51-52 350.00 320.00 9,600.00 - 10,500 1.05 - -
53 900.00 - 52-53 365.00 335.00 10,050.00 - 10,950 1.10 - -
54 900.00 - 53-54 367.00 337.00 10,110.00 - 11,010 1.10 - -
55 900.00 - 54-55 368.00 338.00 10,140.00 - 11,040 1.10 - -
56 900.00 - 55-56 355.00 325.00 9,750.00 - 10,650 1.07 - -
57 900.00 - 56-57 356.00 326.00 9,780.00 - 10,680 1.07 - -
58 900.00 - 57-58 350.00 320.00 9,600.00 - 10,500 1.05 - -
59 900.00 - 58-59 349.00 319.00 9,570.00 - 10,470 1.05 - -
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 59
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Temporary Affected Private Land (Crop Compensation: Towers: 3 Crops; TL Corridor: 1 Crop) Affected Government Land
No Compensation
Total Productive Tower Land for Towers (m2) Tower Nos. TL Corridor (30m wide) Land (Public Infrastructure: Length x 30m Width)
No. Productive Non (From-To) Length (m) Productive Non Sq. Meters Hectares Land Productive Land (m2) Productive Land Distance Meters (m2) Description Length Area (m2) Area (ha)
60 900.00 - 59-60 355.00 325.00 9,750.00 - 10,650 1.07 - -
61 900.00 - 60-61 356.00 326.00 9,780.00 - 10,680 1.07 - -
62 900.00 - 61-62 357.00 327.00 9,810.00 - 10,710 1.07 - -
63 900.00 - 62-63 358.00 323.50 9,705.00 - 10,605 1.06 Kacha track 4.50 135 0.01
64 900.00 - 63-64 359.00 329.00 9,870.00 - 10,770 1.08 - -
65 - 900 64-65 360.00 330.00 7,650.00 2,250 7,650 0.77 - -
66 - 900 65-66 345.00 315.00 - 9,450 - - - -
67 900.00 - 66-67 350.00 296.00 1,950.00 6,930 2,850 0.29 Road+ Canal 24.00 720 0.07
68 900.00 - 67-68 250.00 70.00 2,100.00 - 3,000 0.30 Canal 150.00 4,500 0.45
69 - - 68-69 255.00 60.00 1,800.00 - 1,800 0.18 Canal 195.00 5,850 0.59
70 900.00 - 69-70 250.00 220.00 6,600.00 - 7,500 0.75 - -
71 900.00 - 70-71 252.00 222.00 6,660.00 - 7,560 0.76 - - -
72 900.00 - 71-72 360.00 322.00 9,660.00 - 10,560 1.06 Road 8.00 240 0.02
73 900.00 - 72-73 350.00 320.00 9,600.00 - 10,500 1.05 - -
74 900.00 - 73-74 367.00 337.00 10,110.00 - 11,010 1.10 - -
75 900.00 - 74-75 368.00 338.00 10,140.00 - 11,040 1.10 - -
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 60
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Temporary Affected Private Land (Crop Compensation: Towers: 3 Crops; TL Corridor: 1 Crop) Affected Government Land
No Compensation
Total Productive Tower Land for Towers (m2) Tower Nos. TL Corridor (30m wide) Land (Public Infrastructure: Length x 30m Width)
No. Productive Non (From-To) Length (m) Productive Non Sq. Meters Hectares Land Productive Land (m2) Productive Land Distance Meters (m2) Description Length Area (m2) Area (ha)
76 900.00 - 75-76 380.00 350.00 10,500.00 - 11,400 1.14 - -
77 - 900 76-77 370.00 340.00 8,700.00 1,500 8,700 0.87 - -
78 - 900 77-78 365.00 335.00 - 10,050 - - - -
79 - 900 78-79 380.00 350.00 - 10,500 - - - -
80 - 900 79-80 390.00 360.00 - 10,800 - - - -
81 - 900 80-81 359.00 324.50 8,400.00 1,335 8,400 0.84 Kacha track 4.50 135 0.01
82 - 900 81-82 380.00 350.00 10,500.00 - 10,500 1.05 - -
83 900.00 - 82-83 370.00 340.00 10,200.00 - 11,100 1.11 - -
84 900.00 - 83-84 360.00 330.00 9,900.00 - 10,800 1.08 - -
85 900.00 - 84-85 300.00 262.00 7,860.00 - 8,760 0.88 Road 8.00 240 0.02
86 900.00 - 85-86 310.00 280.00 8,400.00 - 9,300 0.93 - -
87 900.00 - 86-87 290.00 260.00 7,800.00 - 8,700 0.87 - -
88 900.00 - 87-88 310.00 280.00 4,500.00 3,900 5,400 0.54 - -
89 - 900 88-89 355.00 325.00 - 9,750 - - - -
90 - 900 89-90 330.00 300.00 - 9,000 - - - -
91 - 900 90-91 330.00 300.00 - 9,000 - - - -
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 61
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Temporary Affected Private Land (Crop Compensation: Towers: 3 Crops; TL Corridor: 1 Crop) Affected Government Land
No Compensation
Total Productive Tower Land for Towers (m2) Tower Nos. TL Corridor (30m wide) Land (Public Infrastructure: Length x 30m Width)
No. Productive Non (From-To) Length (m) Productive Non Sq. Meters Hectares Land Productive Land (m2) Productive Land Distance Meters (m2) Description Length Area (m2) Area (ha)
92 - 900 91-92 330.00 300.00 - 9,000 - - - -
93 - 900 92-93 335.00 305.00 - 9,150 - - - -
94 900.00 - 93-94 337.00 286.00 7,680.00 900 8,580 0.86 Drain+ Road 21.00 630 0.06
95 900.00 - 94-95 338.00 308.00 9,240.00 - 10,140 1.01 - -
96 900.00 - 95-96 340.00 310.00 9,300.00 - 10,200 1.02 - -
97 900.00 - 96-97 320.00 282.00 8,460.00 - 9,360 0.94 Road 8.00 240 0.02
98 900.00 - 97-98 340.00 310.00 9,300.00 - 10,200 1.02 - -
99 900.00 - 98-99 345.00 315.00 9,450.00 - 10,350 1.04 - -
100 900.00 - 99-100 342.00 312.00 9,360.00 - 10,260 1.03 - -
101 900.00 - 100-101 354.00 324.00 9,720.00 - 10,620 1.06 - - -
102 900.00 - 101-102 331.00 - - - 900 0.09 2Roads+Railway 301.00 9,030 0.90
103 900.00 - 102-103 330.00 300.00 9,000.00 - 9,900 0.99 - - - -
104 900.00 - 103-104 332.00 302.00 9,060.00 - 9,960 1.00 - - -
105 900.00 - 104-105 330.00 300.00 9,000.00 - 9,900 0.99 - - - -
106 900.00 - 105-106 340.00 282.00 8,460.00 - 9,360 0.94 2 roads+ Miner 28.00 840 0.08
107 900.00 - 106-107 338.00 308.00 9,240.00 - 10,140 1.01 - - - -
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 62
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Temporary Affected Private Land (Crop Compensation: Towers: 3 Crops; TL Corridor: 1 Crop) Affected Government Land
No Compensation
Total Productive Tower Land for Towers (m2) Tower Nos. TL Corridor (30m wide) Land (Public Infrastructure: Length x 30m Width)
No. Productive Non (From-To) Length (m) Productive Non Sq. Meters Hectares Land Productive Land (m2) Productive Land Distance Meters (m2) Description Length Area (m2) Area (ha)
108 900.00 - 107-108 342.00 312.00 9,360.00 - 10,260 1.03 - - - -
109 900.00 - 108-109 340.00 310.00 9,300.00 - 10,200 1.02 - - - -
110 900.00 - 109-110 341.00 302.00 9,060.00 - 9,960 1.00 Track+ Bund 9.00 270 0.03
111 900.00 - 110-111 343.00 313.00 9,390.00 - 10,290 1.03 - - - -
112 900.00 - 111-112 341.00 299.00 8,970.00 - 9,870 0.99 Minor Canal 12.00 360 0.04
113 900.00 - 112-113 344.00 314.00 9,420.00 - 10,320 1.03 - - - -
114 900.00 - 113-114 345.00 307.00 9,210.00 - 10,110 1.01 Road 8.00 240 0.02
115 900.00 - 114-115 350.00 320.00 9,600.00 - 10,500 1.05 - - - -
116 900.00 - 115-116 352.00 322.00 9,660.00 - 10,560 1.06 - - - -
117 - 900 116-117 320.00 278.00 8,010.00 330 8,010 0.80 Road 12.00 360 0.04
118 900.00 - 117-118 340.00 310.00 8,400.00 900 9,300 0.93 - - - -
119 900.00 - 118-119 360.00 312.00 9,360.00 - 10,260 1.03 Canal 18.00 540 0.05
120 900.00 - 119-120 326.00 296.00 8,880.00 - 9,780 0.98 - - - -
121 900.00 - 120-121 327.00 289.00 8,670.00 - 9,570 0.96 Minor Canal 8.00 240 0.02
122 900.00 - 121-122 300.00 265.50 7,965.00 - 8,865 0.89 Kacha track 4.50 135 0.01
123 900.00 - 122-123 280.00 250.00 7,500.00 - 8,400 0.84 - - - -
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 63
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Temporary Affected Private Land (Crop Compensation: Towers: 3 Crops; TL Corridor: 1 Crop) Affected Government Land
No Compensation
Total Productive Tower Land for Towers (m2) Tower Nos. TL Corridor (30m wide) Land (Public Infrastructure: Length x 30m Width)
No. Productive Non (From-To) Length (m) Productive Non Sq. Meters Hectares Land Productive Land (m2) Productive Land Distance Meters (m2) Description Length Area (m2) Area (ha)
124 900.00 - 123-124 300.00 270.00 8,100.00 - 9,000 0.90 - - - -
125 900.00 - 124-125 290.00 260.00 7,800.00 - 8,700 0.87 - - - -
126 900.00 - 125-126 300.00 270.00 8,100.00 - 9,000 0.90 - - - -
127 900.00 - 126-127 340.00 278.00 4,020.00 4,320 4,920 0.49 Canal+ Minor 32.00 960 0.10
128 900.00 - 127-128 346.00 308.00 9,240.00 - 10,140 1.01 Road 8.00 240 0.02
129 900.00 - 128-129 352.00 322.00 9,660.00 - 10,560 1.06 - - - -
130 900.00 - 129-130 346.00 316.00 9,480.00 - 10,380 1.04 - - - -
131 900.00 - 130-131 350.00 320.00 9,600.00 - 10,500 1.05 - - - -
132 900.00 - 131-132 340.00 299.00 8,970.00 - 9,870 0.99 2 Tracks 11.00 330 0.03
133 900.00 - 132-133 360.00 330.00 9,900.00 - 10,800 1.08 - - - -
134 900.00 - 133-134 363.00 321.00 9,630.00 - 10,530 1.05 Canal 12.00 360 0.04
135 900.00 - 134-135 366.00 336.00 10,080.00 - 10,980 1.10 - - - -
136 900.00 - 135-136 363.00 333.00 9,990.00 - 10,890 1.09 - - - -
137 900.00 - 136-137 360.00 330.00 9,900.00 - 10,800 1.08 - - - -
138 900.00 - 137-138 370.00 312.00 9,360.00 - 10,260 1.03 Road+ Canal 28.00 840 0.08
139 900.00 - 138-139 368.00 338.00 10,140.00 - 11,040 1.10 - - - -
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 64
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Temporary Affected Private Land (Crop Compensation: Towers: 3 Crops; TL Corridor: 1 Crop) Affected Government Land
No Compensation
Total Productive Tower Land for Towers (m2) Tower Nos. TL Corridor (30m wide) Land (Public Infrastructure: Length x 30m Width)
No. Productive Non (From-To) Length (m) Productive Non Sq. Meters Hectares Land Productive Land (m2) Productive Land Distance Meters (m2) Description Length Area (m2) Area (ha)
140 900.00 - 139-140 359.54 311.54 9,346.20 - 10,246 1.02 Drain 18.00 540 0.05
141 900.00 - 140-141 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
142 900.00 - 141-142 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
143 900.00 - 142-143 300.00 270.00 8,100.00 - 9,000 0.90 - - - -
144 900.00 - 143-144 330.00 265.00 7,950.00 - 8,850 0.89 GT Road+ Drain 35.00 1,050 0.11
145 900.00 - 144-145 280.00 250.00 7,500.00 - 8,400 0.84 - - - -
146 900.00 - 145-146 300.00 270.00 8,100.00 - 9,000 0.90 - - - -
147 900.00 - 146-147 310.00 280.00 8,400.00 - 9,300 0.93 - - - -
148 900.00 - 147-148 300.00 262.00 7,860.00 - 8,760 0.88 Road 8.00 240 0.02
149 900.00 - 148-149 300.00 252.00 7,560.00 - 8,460 0.85 Drain 18.00 540 0.05
150 900.00 - 149-150 310.00 280.00 8,400.00 - 9,300 0.93 - - - -
151 900.00 - 150-151 209.00 179.00 5,370.00 - 6,270 0.63 - - - -
152 900.00 - 151-152 320.00 290.00 8,700.00 - 9,600 0.96 - - - -
153 900.00 - 152-153 327.00 291.00 8,730.00 - 9,630 0.96 Road 6.00 180 0.02
154 900.00 - 153-154 325.00 295.00 8,850.00 - 9,750 0.98 - - - -
155 900.00 - 154-155 330.00 295.50 8,865.00 - 9,765 0.98 Kacha track 4.50 135 0.01
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 65
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Temporary Affected Private Land (Crop Compensation: Towers: 3 Crops; TL Corridor: 1 Crop) Affected Government Land
No Compensation
Total Productive Tower Land for Towers (m2) Tower Nos. TL Corridor (30m wide) Land (Public Infrastructure: Length x 30m Width)
No. Productive Non (From-To) Length (m) Productive Non Sq. Meters Hectares Land Productive Land (m2) Productive Land Distance Meters (m2) Description Length Area (m2) Area (ha)
156 900.00 - 155-156 336.68 306.68 9,200.40 - 10,100 1.01 - - - -
157 900.00 - 156-157 345.00 315.00 9,450.00 - 10,350 1.04 - - - -
158 900.00 - 157-158 345.00 315.00 9,450.00 - 10,350 1.04 - - - -
159 900.00 - 158-159 350.00 320.00 9,600.00 - 10,500 1.05 - - - -
160 900.00 - 159-160 358.00 306.00 9,180.00 - 10,080 1.01 Canal+ Road 22.00 660 0.07
161 900.00 - 160-161 360.00 330.00 9,900.00 - 10,800 1.08 - - - -
162 900.00 - 161-162 355.00 325.00 9,750.00 - 10,650 1.07 - - - -
163 900.00 - 162-163 365.35 335.35 10,060.50 - 10,961 1.10 - - - -
164 900.00 - 163-164 360.00 318.00 9,540.00 - 10,440 1.04 Road 12.00 360 0.04
165 900.00 - 164-165 350.00 320.00 9,600.00 - 10,500 1.05 - - - -
Grid - - 165- Grid 65.00 50.00 1,500.00 - 1,500 0.15 - - -
165 117,000 24,300 sub-total (c): 55,931 47,616 1,167,317 261,168 1,284,317 128.43 - 3,575 107,250 11
461 333,900 47,700 TOTAL 145,689 119,350 3,111,831 468,669 3,445,731 345 - 13,620 408,585 41
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 66
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Permanent Land Affected By New Rohri Sub-station Land Cost for New Rohri Sub-station:
Total Cost Length Width Area Govt Land Private Land Ha Acres Rs./Acre (Rs.)
Meter Meter Sq Meters Hacters Hacters Hacters 19 47 3,600,000 169,200,000
463.5 410 190035 19.00 2.81 16.19 CAS: 25% 42,300,000
Compensn: 211,500,000
Tax+: 7.5% 15,862,500
Total Cost: 227,362,500
US$: 3,733,374
Overall Cost per Acre (Rs.) 4,837,500
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 67
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Table A-2: List of Affected Farmers by New 220kV Rohri Sub-station and Associated Transmission Lines (Subproject No. 9, Tranch 2)
Name of Parent Tower (30mx30m) T. Line (30m Wide) Total Affected Area Name of Affected Farmer No. (HHH) Village/Hamlet Village Tower No. Number Area (m2) Length (m) Area (m2) Sq. Meters Hectares
A: Dahrki - Ghotki Line : 1 Qasim Lashari Goth Sultan Khan Rarki 1 - 2 2 1800 311 9,330 11,130 1.11
2 Haji Muhammad Bachal Goth Sultan Khan Rarki 3 - 4 2 1800 602 18,060 19,860 1.99
3 Jamal Din Goth Sultan Khan Rarki 5 - 6 2 1800 510 15,300 17,100 1.71
4 Khan Muhammad Lashari Goth Sultan Khan Rarki 7 1 900 250 7,500 8,400 0.84
5 Allah Diwaya Goth Sultan Khan Rarki 8 1 900 280 8,400 9,300 0.93
6 Ghulam Farid Pitali Goth Sultan Khan Rarki 9 1 900 350 10,500 11,400 1.14
7 Shafi Muhammad Goth Sultan Khan Rarki 10 1 900 298 8,940 9,840 0.98
8 Hai Qadir Bux Goth Shafi Muhammad Rarki 11 1 900 318 9,540 10,440 1.04
9 Ali Gohar Goth Shafi Muhammad Rarki 12 1 900 350 10,500 11,400 1.14
10 Farid Lashari Goth Shafi Muhammad Rarki 13 - 15 3 2700 802 24,060 26,760 2.68
11 Jamal Din Goth Shafi Muhammad Rarki 16 1 900 342 10,260 11,160 1.12
12 Waseer Muhammad Goth Shafi Muhammad Rarki 16 - 17 0 0 60 1,800 1,800 0.18
13 Muhammad Usman Goth Shafi Muhammad Rarki 17 1 900 212 6,360 7,260 0.73
14 Mansoor Goth Shafi Muhammad Rarki 17 - 18 0 0 80 2,400 2,400 0.24
15 Mola Bux Goth Shafi Muhammad Rarki 17 - 18 0 0 80 2,400 2,400 0.24
16 Haiji Ali Shair Goth Shafi Muhammad Rarki 18 1 900 170 5,100 6,000 0.60
17 Ali Murad Goth Khuda Bux Daharki 19 1 900 298 8,940 9,840 0.98
18 Khuda Bux Goth Khuda Bux Daharki 19 - 20 0 0 150 4,500 4,500 0.45
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 68
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Name of Parent Tower (30mx30m) T. Line (30m Wide) Total Affected Area Name of Affected Farmer No. (HHH) Village/Hamlet Village Tower No. Number Area (m2) Length (m) Area (m2) Sq. Meters Hectares
19 Dodo Khan Goth Khuda Bux Daharki 20 1 900 60 1,800 2,700 0.27
20 Haider Khan Goth Khuda Bux Daharki 21 1 900 340 10,200 11,100 1.11
21 Islam shair Goth Khuda Bux Daharki 22 - 23 2 1800 520 15,600 17,400 1.74
22 Haji Bangal Khan Goth Khuda Bux Daharki 24 - 25 2 1800 358 10,740 12,540 1.25
23 Adil Laghari Goth Adil Laghari Daharki 30 1 900 72 2,160 3,060 0.31
24 Ali Muhammad Khan Buzdar Goth Adil Laghari Daharki 31 - 32 2 1800 652 19,560 21,360 2.14
25 Asghar Buzdar Goth Adil Laghari Daharki 33 1 900 292 8,760 9,660 0.97
26 Akbar Malik Goth Adil Laghari Daharki 34 1 900 310 9,300 10,200 1.02
27 Nasir Ahmad Goth Adil Laghari Daharki 35 1 900 322 9,660 10,560 1.06
28 Punhar Khan Goth Adil Laghari Daharki 36 - 38 3 2700 914 27,420 30,120 3.01
29 Atta Hussain Goth Adil Laghari Daharki 39 1 900 355 10,650 11,550 1.16
30 Shah Nawaz Goth M Amjad Daharki 40 - 41 2 1800 680 20,400 22,200 2.22
31 Munir Ahmad Goth M Amjad Daharki 42 1 900 282 8,460 9,360 0.94
32 Muhammad Khan Goth M Amjad Daharki 43 1 900 284 8,520 9,420 0.94
33 Abdul Haq Goth M Amjad Daharki 44 1 900 240 7,200 8,100 0.81
34 Muhammad Amjad Goth M Amjad Daharki 45 - 47 3 2700 782 23,460 26,160 2.62
35 Pholo Khan Goth M Amjad Daharki 48 1 900 295 8,850 9,750 0.98
36 Imdad Hussain Goth M Amjad Daharki 49 1 900 312 9,360 10,260 1.03
37 Abdul Latif Goth M Amjad Daharki 50 1 900 290 8,700 9,600 0.96
38 Ali Gohar Goth M Amjad Daharki 51 - 53 3 2700 737 22,110 24,810 2.48
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 69
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Name of Parent Tower (30mx30m) T. Line (30m Wide) Total Affected Area Name of Affected Farmer No. (HHH) Village/Hamlet Village Tower No. Number Area (m2) Length (m) Area (m2) Sq. Meters Hectares
39 Abdul Wahid Goth Bux Ali Mahar Berari Mathelo 54 1 900 270 8,100 9,000 0.90
40 Bux Ali Mahar Goth Bux Ali Mahar Berari Mathelo 55 1 900 332 9,960 10,860 1.09
41 Raja Khan Goth Bux Ali Mahar Berari Mathelo 56 - 59 4 3600 875 26,250 29,850 2.99
42 Mian Rung Ali Khan Goth Bux Ali Mahar Berari Mathelo 60 1 900 328 9,840 10,740 1.07
43 Sajan Matajo Goth Bux Ali Mahar Berari Mathelo 61 1 900 268 8,040 8,940 0.89
44 Khuda Bux Goth Ali Haider Berari Mathelo 62 1 900 315 9,450 10,350 1.04
45 Mian Ali Haider Goth Ali Haider Berari Mathelo 63 1 900 238 7,140 8,040 0.80
46 Aziz ur Rahman Goth Ali Haider Berari Mathelo 64 1 900 305 9,150 10,050 1.01
47 Muhammad Usman Goth Ali Haider Berari Mathelo 64 - 65 0 0 145 4,350 4,350 0.44
48 Panjo Khan Goth Ali Haider Berari Mathelo 65 1 900 130 3,900 4,800 0.48
49 Jamo Goth Ali Haider Berari Mathelo 66 1 900 300 9,000 9,900 0.99
50 Muhammad Panjo Goth Ali Haider Berari Mathelo 67 1 900 355 10,650 11,550 1.16
51 Ata Bux Goth Ali Haider Berari Mathelo 68 1 900 277 8,310 9,210 0.92
52 Usman Ahmad Goth Ali Haider Berari Mathelo 69 1 900 310 9,300 10,200 1.02
53 Mirza Khan Goth Ali Haider Dildar Mahar 70 1 900 302 9,060 9,960 1.00
54 Abdul Rahim Abdul Baqir Dildar Mahar 71 1 900 310 9,300 10,200 1.02
55 Abdul Baqir Abdul Baqir Dildar Mahar 72 1 900 297 8,910 9,810 0.98
56 Raja Abdul Baqir Dildar Mahar 72 - 73 0 0 95 2,850 2,850 0.29
57 Abdul Rahim Abdul Baqir Dildar Mahar 72 - 73 0 0 50 1,500 1,500 0.15
58 Shah Muhammad Abdul Baqir Dildar Mahar 73 1 900 120 3,600 4,500 0.45
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 70
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Name of Parent Tower (30mx30m) T. Line (30m Wide) Total Affected Area Name of Affected Farmer No. (HHH) Village/Hamlet Village Tower No. Number Area (m2) Length (m) Area (m2) Sq. Meters Hectares
59 Yunas Shah Latif Shah Dildar Mahar 74 1 900 310 9,300 10,200 1.02
60 Jam Mahar Latif Shah Dildar Mahar 75 1 900 340 10,200 11,100 1.11
61 Ali Muhammad Dildar Mahar Dildar Mahar 76 1 900 355 10,650 11,550 1.16
62 Bunal Ali Shah Dildar Mahar Dildar Mahar 77 1 900 210.5 6,315 7,215 0.72
63 Abdullah Ali Bux Mehar Labano 82 1 900 160 4,800 5,700 0.57
64 Ch Asghar ch Asghar Labano 88 - 96 9 8100 2410 72,300 80,400 8.04
65 Nabi Bux Goth Ch Rasheed Umar Daro 97 1 900 300 9,000 9,900 0.99
66 Muhammad Yaseen Goth Ch Rasheed Umar Daro 97 - 98 0 0 50 1,500 1,500 0.15
67 Ch Rasheed Ahmad Goth Ch Rasheed Umar Daro 98 - 100 3 2700 643 19,290 21,990 2.20
Sub-Total (a): Line A: 87 78,300 23,961 718,815 797,115 79.71 B: Ghotki- New Rohri Line : 1 Ch Rasheed Ahmad Goth Ch Rasheed Umar Daro 1 - 2 2 1800 32 960 2,760 0.28
2 Nabi Bux Goth Ch Rasheed Umar Daro 2 - 3 0 0 90 2,700 2,700 0.27
3 Bachal Khan Goth Ch Rasheed Umar Daro 2 - 3 0 0 110 3,300 3,300 0.33
4 Haji Qasim Goth Ch Rasheed Umar Daro 3 1 900 60 1,800 2,700 0.27
5 Nizam Deen Goth Ch Rasheed Umar Daro 3 - 4 0 0 150 4,500 4,500 0.45
6 Ch Asghar Labano Parari 4 - 10 7 6300 1298 38,940 45,240 4.52
7 Muhammad Yaseen Labano Parari 11 1 900 280 8,400 9,300 0.93
8 Mushtaq Ahmad Labano Parari 12 1 900 260 7,800 8,700 0.87
9 Akbar Ali Labano Parari 13 - 14 2 1800 575 17,250 19,050 1.91
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 71
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Name of Parent Tower (30mx30m) T. Line (30m Wide) Total Affected Area Name of Affected Farmer No. (HHH) Village/Hamlet Village Tower No. Number Area (m2) Length (m) Area (m2) Sq. Meters Hectares
10 Karam Ali Goth Nazir Parari 14 - 15 0 0 50 1,500 1,500 0.15
11 Mumtaz Shaikh Goth Nazir Parari 15 1 900 270 8,100 9,000 0.90
12 Nazir Ahmad Goth Nazir Parari 16 - 18 3 2700 824 24,720 27,420 2.74
13 Rustam Ali Bhirialo Parari 19 - 20 2 1800 542 16,260 18,060 1.81
14 Araz Muhammad Bhirialo Parari 20 - 21 0 0 110 3,300 3,300 0.33
15 Bahadur Wasir Bhirialo Parari 20 - 21 0 0 125 3,750 3,750 0.38
16 Muhammad Yunas Goth Peer Bux Parari 21 - 22 2 1800 515 15,450 17,250 1.73
17 Atta ullah Goth Peer Bux Parari 22 -23 0 0 110 3,300 3,300 0.33
18 Ali Bux Goth Peer Bux Parari 22 - 23 0 0 90 2,700 2,700 0.27
19 Ch Akram Goth Sargodha Parari 23 - 32 10 9000 1897 56,910 65,910 6.59
20 Rustam Khan (Tanent) Goth Sargodha Parari 23 - 24 2 1800 328 9,840 11,640 1.16
21 Ali Hassan Khan (Tanent) Goth Sargodha Parari 25 1 900 310 9,300 10,200 1.02
22 Shah Nawaz Khan (Tanent) Goth Sargodha Parari 26 - 27 2 1800 372 11,160 12,960 1.30
23 Yunas (Tanent) Goth Sargodha Parari 27 - 28 0 0 90 2,700 2,700 0.27
24 M Yusaf (Tanent) Goth Sargodha Parari 28 - 29 2 1800 330 9,900 11,700 1.17
25 Tariq Hussain (Tanent) Goth Sargodha Parari 30 1 900 298 8,940 9,840 0.98
26 Abdul Khaliq (Tanent) Goth Sargodha Parari 31 - 32 2 1800 422 12,660 14,460 1.45
27 Ghulam Ali Juma Bhatoo Parari 32 - 33 0 0 110 3,300 3,300 0.33
28 Nasrullah Juma Bhatoo Parari 33 1 900 210 6,300 7,200 0.72
29 Rahmat Ali Juma Bhatoo Parari 33 - 34 0 0 160 4,800 4,800 0.48
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 72
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Name of Parent Tower (30mx30m) T. Line (30m Wide) Total Affected Area Name of Affected Farmer No. (HHH) Village/Hamlet Village Tower No. Number Area (m2) Length (m) Area (m2) Sq. Meters Hectares
30 Muhammad Mussa Juma Bhatoo Parari 34 1 900 128 3,840 4,740 0.47
31 Deen Muhammad Juma Bhatoo Parari 35 1 900 312 9,360 10,260 1.03
32 Muhammad Sabul Juma Bhatoo Parari 36 1 900 191 5,730 6,630 0.66
33 Ahmad Khan Goth Ameer Khan Adan Pur 37 1 900 224 6,720 7,620 0.76
34 Rasool Bux Goth Ameer Khan Adan Pur 37 - 38 0 0 150 4,500 4,500 0.45
35 Abdul Shakoor Goth Ameer Khan Adan Pur 38 1 900 118 3,540 4,440 0.44
36 Muhammad Qasim Goth Ameer Khan Adan Pur 38 - 39 0 0 60 1,800 1,800 0.18
37 Abdul Latif Goth Ibrahim Adan Pur 38 - 39 0 0 30 900 900 0.09
38 Abdul Rasheed Goth Ibrahim Adan Pur 38 - 39 0 0 60 1,800 1,800 0.18
39 Muhammad Wazir Goth Ibrahim Adan Pur 38 - 39 0 0 65 1,950 1,950 0.20
40 Abdul Aziz Goth Ibrahim Adan Pur 39 1 900 105 3,150 4,050 0.41
41 Fiaz Muhammad Goth Ibrahim Adan Pur 39 - 40 0 0 35 1,050 1,050 0.11
42 Shair Muhammad Goth Ibrahim Adan Pur 39 - 40 0 0 65 1,950 1,950 0.20
43 Muhammad Hassan Goth Ibrahim Adan Pur 39 - 40 0 0 80 2,400 2,400 0.24
44 Muhammad Sadiq Goth Ibrahim Adan Pur 39 - 40 0 0 70 2,100 2,100 0.21
45 Muhammad Ayaz Goth Khan M Adan Pur 40 - 41 2 1800 315 9,450 11,250 1.13
46 Haji Khan Goth Khan M Adan Pur 42 - 44 3 2700 778 23,340 26,040 2.60
47 Yar Muhammad Dari Toghan Dari Toghan 45 - 47 3 2700 742 22,260 24,960 2.50
48 Noor Hassan Dari Toghan Dari Toghan 62 1 900 195 5,850 6,750 0.68
49 Nasrullah Dari Toghan Dari Toghan 63 - 64 2 1800 228 6,840 8,640 0.86
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 73
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Name of Parent Tower (30mx30m) T. Line (30m Wide) Total Affected Area Name of Affected Farmer No. (HHH) Village/Hamlet Village Tower No. Number Area (m2) Length (m) Area (m2) Sq. Meters Hectares
50 Shahzada Dari Toghan Dari Toghan 65 1 900 322 9,660 10,560 1.06
51 Aman Ullah Dari Toghan Dari Toghan 66 - 67 2 1800 612 18,360 20,160 2.02
52 Sijad hussain Dari Toghan Dari Toghan 67 - 68 0 0 94 2,820 2,820 0.28
53 Nazir Hussain Dari Toghan Dari Toghan 68 1 900 250 7,500 8,400 0.84
54 Hussain Bux Dari Toghan Dari Toghan 69 - 70 2 1800 532 15,960 17,760 1.78
55 Abdul Khaliq Dad Goth Bullah Pannu Aqil 70 - 71 0 0 210 6,300 6,300 0.63
56 Arab Bullah Goth Bullah Pannu Aqil 84 - 86 3 2700 984 29,520 32,220 3.22
57 Jam Saif Ullah Goth Kata Khan Pannu Aqil 87 - 98 12 10800 3872 116,160 126,960 12.70
58 Baig Kata Goth Kata Khan Pannu Aqil 99 1 900 325 9,750 10,650 1.07
59 Satar Jonajo Goth Kata Khan Pannu Aqil 100 1 900 612 18,360 19,260 1.93
60 Kutab Junajo Goth Kata Khan Pannu Aqil 101 - 104 4 3600 822 24,660 28,260 2.83
61 Malik Agla Khan Sultan Pur Pannu Aqil 105 - 106 2 1800 582 17,460 19,260 1.93
62 Muhammad Sharif Sultan Pur Pannu Aqil 107 - 109 3 2700 796 23,880 26,580 2.66
63 Sana Ullah Sultan Pur Pannu Aqil 110 1 900 318 9,540 10,440 1.04
64 Abdul Sitar Sultan Pur Pannu Aqil 111 1 900 330 9,900 10,800 1.08
65 Kul Baig Sultan Pur Pannu Aqil 112 - 113 2 1800 592 17,760 19,560 1.96
66 Pahalwan Sammar Sultan Pur Pannu Aqil 114 - 118 5 4500 1321 39,630 44,130 4.41
67 Ram Talla Barath Junnas 118 - 119 0 0 110 3,300 3,300 0.33
68 Anwar Summar Barath Junnas 119 - 120 2 1800 530 15,900 17,700 1.77
69 Muhammad Bux Barath Junnas 121 - 122 2 1800 522 15,660 17,460 1.75
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 74
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Name of Parent Tower (30mx30m) T. Line (30m Wide) Total Affected Area Name of Affected Farmer No. (HHH) Village/Hamlet Village Tower No. Number Area (m2) Length (m) Area (m2) Sq. Meters Hectares
70 Ibrahim Barath Junnas 123 - 124 2 1800 498 14,940 16,740 1.67
71 Mahram Khan Fazal Mangi Hingoro 125 - 126 2 1800 518 15,540 17,340 1.73
72 Dhani Bux Fazal Mangi Hingoro 127 1 900 240 7,200 8,100 0.81
73 Ubaid Ullah Fazal Mangi Hingoro 128 1 900 315 9,450 10,350 1.04
74 Imam Bux Fazal Mangi Hingoro 129 1 900 380 11,400 12,300 1.23
75 Ghulam Haider Nirch Hingoro 136 1 900 240 7,200 8,100 0.81
76 Allah Jorio Nirch Hingoro 137 1 900 340 10,200 11,100 1.11
77 Muhammad Bux Nirch Hingoro 138 1 900 250 7,500 8,400 0.84
78 Muhammad Nawab Nirch Hingoro 138 - 139 0 0 80 2,400 2,400 0.24
79 Abdul Raheem Nirch Hingoro 139 1 900 158 4,740 5,640 0.56
80 Ali Khan Nirch Hingoro 140 1 900 300 9,000 9,900 0.99
81 Raza Muhammad Jagirani Jan Abad Dubar 141 - 147 7 6300 1922 57,660 63,960 6.40
82 Muhammad Khan (Tanent) Jan Abad Dubar 141 - 147 7 6300 1922 57,660 63,960 6.40
83 Muhammad Rasheed Jatoi Jan Abad Dubar 148 - 156 9 8100 2314 69,420 77,520 7.75
84 Ghulam Nabi (Tanent) Jan Abad Dubar 148 - 156 9 8100 2314 69,420 77,520 7.75
85 Abdul Sami Jan Abad Dubar 157 - 161 5 4500 1362 40,860 45,360 4.54
86 Aziz Ullah Khoso Goth Abdul Razaq Panwar 162 - 167 6 5400 1622 48,660 54,060 5.41
87 Abdul Razaq Khoso Goth Abdul Razaq Panwar 168 - 169 2 1800 720 21,600 23,400 2.34
88 Khan Muhammad Goth Abdul Razaq Panwar 170 1 900 177 5,310 6,210 0.62
89 Muhammad Juman Goth Abdul Razaq Panwar 171 1 900 282 8,460 9,360 0.94
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 75
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Name of Parent Tower (30mx30m) T. Line (30m Wide) Total Affected Area Name of Affected Farmer No. (HHH) Village/Hamlet Village Tower No. Number Area (m2) Length (m) Area (m2) Sq. Meters Hectares
90 Sardar Ali Goth Abdul Razaq Panwar 171 - 172 0 0 80 2,400 2,400 0.24
91 Shafqat Mirani Goth Mirani Ponath 172 - 173 2 1800 515 15,450 17,250 1.73
92 Muhammad Ali Khoso Goth Mirani Ponath 180 - 181 2 1800 550 16,500 18,300 1.83
93 Haqim Labano Goth Mirani Ponath 182 - 183 2 1800 590 17,700 19,500 1.95
94 Lal Muhammad Mangi Goth Lal Muhammad Ponath 186 - 188 3 2700 292 8,760 11,460 1.15
95 Muhammad Bux Goth Lal Muhammad Ponath 189 - 192 4 3600 872 26,160 29,760 2.98
Sub-Total (b): District Line B: 177 159,300 46,558 1,396,740 1,556,040 155.60 AB: Connecting Line A to B: 1 Ch Asghar Labano Parari 1 - 2 2 1800 980 29,400 31,200 3.12
Sub-Total (ab): Line AB: 2 1,800 980 29,400 31,200 3.12 C: New RohrI - Shikarpur Line 1 Nasir Ahmad Nandi Patni Patni 7 1 900 210.00 6,300 7,200 0.72
2 M Nazal Dandan Nandi Patni Patni 7 - 8 0 0 127.00 3,810 3,810 0.38
3 Ghulam Muhammad Nandi Patni Patni 8 1 900 110.00 3,300 4,200 0.42
4 Bashir Ahmad Nandi Patni Patni 8 - 9 0 0 60.00 1,800 1,800 0.18
5 Gobar Faqir Nandi Patni Patni 8 - 9 0 0 145.00 4,350 4,350 0.44
6 Ali Nawaz Nandi Patni Patni 9 1 900 65.00 1,950 2,850 0.29
7 Faiz Muhammad Chandio Nandi Patni Patni 9 - 10 0 0 115.00 3,450 3,450 0.35
8 Mukhtar Ahmad Nandi Patni Patni 10 1 900 145.00 4,350 5,250 0.53
9 Ghulam Ali Nandi Patni Patni 11 + 12 2 1800 245.00 7,350 9,150 0.92
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 76
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Name of Parent Tower (30mx30m) T. Line (30m Wide) Total Affected Area Name of Affected Farmer No. (HHH) Village/Hamlet Village Tower No. Number Area (m2) Length (m) Area (m2) Sq. Meters Hectares
10 Ali Dino Nandi Patni Patni 13 1 900 216.50 6,495 7,395 0.74
11 Shafi Muhammad Trandro Meer Patni 17 1 900 280.00 8,400 9,300 0.93 Muhammad Hasan 12 Ahmad Ali Trandro Meer Patni 18 1 900 246.00 7,380 8,280 0.83 Muhammad Hasan 13 Wali Muhammad Trandro Meer Patni 18 - 19 0 0 60.00 1,800 1,800 0.18 Muhammad Hasan 14 Shabir Ahmad Khoso Trandro Meer Patni 19 1 900 66.00 1,980 2,880 0.29 Muhammad Hasan 15 Haji Akbar Civil Jail Coloney Sukkur 23 1 900 210.00 6,300 7,200 0.72
16 Sikander Civil Jail Coloney Sukkur 24 1 900 272.00 8,160 9,060 0.91
17 Ali Nawaz Civil Jail Coloney Sukkur 24 - 25 0 0 512.00 15,360 15,360 1.54
18 Sardu Goth Ali Shair Long Jatoi 33 1 900 70.00 2,100 3,000 0.30
19 Shafi Muhammad Jatoi Goth Ali Shair Long Jatoi 34 - 38 5 4500 1,179.00 35,370 39,870 3.99
20 Ali Shair (Tanent) Goth Ali Shair Long Jatoi 34 - 38 5 4500 1,180.00 35,400 39,900 3.99
21 Long Jatoi Long Jatoi Long Jatoi 39 - 45 7 6300 1,925.00 57,750 64,050 6.41
22 Jahangir Jatoi Goth Khuda Bux Long Jatoi 46 - 58 13 11700 4,281.00 128,430 140,130 14.01
23 Jamal Khan Kharos Bagarge Bagarge 59 - 64 6 5400 2,314.50 69,435 74,835 7.48
24 Haji Yar Muhammad Bagarge Bagarge 66 - 67 0 0 216.00 6,480 6,480 0.65
25 Muhammad Paral Bagarge Bagarge 67 1 900 80.00 2,400 3,300 0.33
26 Faqir Yar Muhammad Bagarge Bagarge 68 1 900 130.00 3,900 4,800 0.48
27 Muhammad Bux Mahar Bagarge Bagarge 69 - 70 0 0 150.00 4,500 4,500 0.45
28 Faiz Muhammad Labano Bagarge Bagarge 70 1 900 170.00 5,100 6,000 0.60
29 Nabi bux Bagarge Bagarge 71 1 900 152.00 4,560 5,460 0.55
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 77
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Name of Parent Tower (30mx30m) T. Line (30m Wide) Total Affected Area Name of Affected Farmer No. (HHH) Village/Hamlet Village Tower No. Number Area (m2) Length (m) Area (m2) Sq. Meters Hectares
30 Anwar Khan Tamachani Tamachani 72 - 76 5 4500 1,522.00 45,660 50,160 5.02
31 Wali Muhammad Qalandar Bux Maca 80 - 81 0 0 280.00 8,400 8,400 0.84
32 Peer Bux Qalandar Bux Maca 81 - 82 0 0 172.00 5,160 5,160 0.52
33 Sumar Muhammad Qalandar Bux Maca 81 - 82 0 0 178.00 5,340 5,340 0.53
34 Yar Muhammad Qalandar Bux Maca 82 - 83 0 0 180.00 5,400 5,400 0.54
35 Khuda Bux Qalandar Bux Maca 82 - 83 0 0 160.00 4,800 4,800 0.48
36 Ismail Merani Qalandar Bux Maca 83 1 900 276.00 8,280 9,180 0.92
37 Ghulam Qadir Qalandar Bux Maca 83 -84 0 0 290.00 8,700 8,700 0.87
38 Sadina Qalandar Bux Maca 84 1 900 150.00 4,500 5,400 0.54
39 Zamir Qalandar Bux Maca 85 1 900 142.00 4,260 5,160 0.52
40 Lal Bux Qalandar Bux Maca 85 - 86 0 0 140.00 4,200 4,200 0.42
41 Muhammad Zamir Qalandar Bux Maca 86 1 900 170.00 5,100 6,000 0.60
42 Yar Muhammad Qalandar Bux Maca 87 1 900 280.00 8,400 9,300 0.93
43 Elahi Bux Qalandar Bux Maca 88 1 900 100.00 3,000 3,900 0.39
44 Bacha Maca Maca 94 1 900 310.00 9,300 10,200 1.02
45 Ghulam Shabir Maca Maca 95 - 96 2 1800 604.00 18,120 19,920 1.99
46 Ghulam Hussain Maca Maca 97 1 900 252.00 7,560 8,460 0.85
47 Manzoor Hussain Maca Maca 98 1 900 370.00 11,100 12,000 1.20
48 Haji Maca Maca Maca 99 1 900 285.00 8,550 9,450 0.95
49 Noor Khan Lukhy Station Lukhy 100 1 900 346.00 10,380 11,280 1.13
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 78
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Name of Parent Tower (30mx30m) T. Line (30m Wide) Total Affected Area Name of Affected Farmer No. (HHH) Village/Hamlet Village Tower No. Number Area (m2) Length (m) Area (m2) Sq. Meters Hectares
50 Anwar Bhato Lukhy Station Lukhy 101 1 900 290.00 8,700 9,600 0.96
51 Nazir Ahmad Shaikh Lukhy Station Lukhy 102 - 104 3 2,700 712.00 21,360 24,060 2.41
52 Munawar Khan Lukhy Station Lukhy 105 1 900 190.00 5,700 6,600 0.66
53 Haji Abdul Aziz Lukhy Station Lukhy 105 - 106 0 - 160.00 4,800 4,800 0.48
54 Abdul Sami Khan Goth Malik Lukhy 106 1 900 280.00 8,400 9,300 0.93
55 Gulshan Barohi Goth Malik Lukhy 107 1 900 260.00 7,800 8,700 0.87
56 Ghos Bux Mahar Goth Malik Lukhy 108 - 110 3 2,700 919.00 27,570 30,270 3.03
57 Shahzada Goth Malik Lukhy 111 - 113 3 2,700 858.00 25,740 28,440 2.84
58 Rahmat Ullah Barohi Goth Jawah Habib Kot 114 1 900 273.00 8,190 9,090 0.91
59 Jabal Khan Goth Jawah Habib Kot 115 1 900 305.00 9,150 10,050 1.01
60 Phulapotar Goth Jawah Habib Kot 115 - 116 0 - 152.00 4,560 4,560 0.46
61 Dr Ibrahim Goth Jawah Habib Kot 116 1 900 310.00 9,300 10,200 1.02
62 Abdul Hakim Goth Jawah Habib Kot 118 - 120 3 2,700 1,027.00 30,810 33,510 3.35
63 Muhammad Yusaf Goth Jawah Habib Kot 121 -122 2 1,800 673.30 20,199 21,999 2.20
64 Qamer Deen Goth Atta M Habib Kot 123 - 124 2 1,800 401.00 12,030 13,830 1.38
65 Sachal Goth Atta M Habib Kot 125 - 126 2 1,800 510.00 15,300 17,100 1.71
66 Naz Muhammad Goth Atta M Habib Kot 126 -127 0 - 134.00 4,020 4,020 0.40
67 Ali Akbar Goth Ali Akbar Habib Kot 127 1 900 256.00 7,680 8,580 0.86
68 Tanseer Bhoto Goth Ali Akbar Habib Kot 128 1 900 308.00 9,240 10,140 1.01
69 Abdullah Barohi Goth Ali Akbar Habib Kot 129 1 900 186.00 5,580 6,480 0.65
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 79
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Name of Parent Tower (30mx30m) T. Line (30m Wide) Total Affected Area Name of Affected Farmer No. (HHH) Village/Hamlet Village Tower No. Number Area (m2) Length (m) Area (m2) Sq. Meters Hectares
70 Guy Khan Bolani Goth Ali Akbar Habib Kot 130 - 133 4 3,600 1,165.00 34,950 38,550 3.86
71 Abdul Rahman Sumro Goth Ali Akbar Habib Kot 134 1 900 310.00 9,300 10,200 1.02
72 Irfan Ahmad Goth Ali Akbar Habib Kot 135 1 900 336.00 10,080 10,980 1.10
73 Muhammad Tafu Goth Haji Talib Khan Shikarpur 136 - 137 2 1,800 708.00 21,240 23,040 2.30
74 Waliat Lar Baloch Goth Shair M Lodran !37 - 138 0 - 60.00 1,800 1,800 0.18
75 Haji Faqir Muhammad Goth Shair M Lodran 138 - 159 22 19,800 6,171.00 185,130 204,930 20.49
76 Abdullah Mughal (Tanent) Goth Shair M Lodran 138 - 159 23 20,700 6,172.00 185,160 205,860 20.59
77 Noor Deen Khan Goth Shair M Lodran 160 - 163 4 3,600 1,369.00 41,070 44,670 4.47
78 Abdul Rahman Jafri Goth Shair M Lodran 164 - 165 2 1,800 628.00 18,840 20,640 2.06
Sub-Total (c): Line C: 158 142,200 46,262 1,387,869 1,530,069 153.01 D: New Rohri Sub-station 1 Qadir Bux Ponath Ponath - - - - - 12,140 1.21
2 Ali Gohar Ponath Ponath - - - - - 8,094 0.81
3 Faqir Muhammad Ponath Ponath - - - - - 52,604 5.26
4 Ghulam Akbar Ponath Ponath - - - - - 28,325 2.83
5 Ghulam Akbar S/O Qadir Bux Ponath Ponath - - - - - 44,511 4.45
6 Javaid Shah Ponath Ponath - - - - - 16,186 1.62
Sub-Total (d) Sub-station: - - - - 161,860 16.19
TOTAL: A+B+C+D* 424 381,600 117,761 3,532,824 4,076,284 407.63
* Total number of towers and land in this sheet differes from the Affected land sheet because land of tanents is increased in this sheet.
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 80
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Table A-3: Percentage Affected Land by New 220kV Rohri Sub-station and Associated Transmission Lines
Name of Parent Total Affected Land
No. Name of Affected Farmer (HHH) Village/Hamlet Village Land (ha) Hectares Percentage
A: Dahrki - Ghotki Line :
1 Qasim Lashari Goth Sultan Khan Rarki 14.62 1.11 7.59
2 Haji Muhammad Bachal Goth Sultan Khan Rarki 24.67 1.99 8.07
3 Jamal Din Goth Sultan Khan Rarki 21.32 1.71 8.02
4 Khan Muhammad Lashari Goth Sultan Khan Rarki 11.24 0.84 7.47
5 Allah Diwaya Goth Sultan Khan Rarki 12.80 0.93 7.27
6 Ghulam Farid Pitali Goth Sultan Khan Rarki 13.46 1.14 8.47
7 Shafi Muhammad Goth Sultan Khan Rarki 11.24 0.98 8.72
8 Hai Qadir Bux Goth Shafi Muhammad Rarki 14.42 1.04 7.21
9 Ali Gohar Goth Shafi Muhammad Rarki 13.24 1.14 8.61
10 Farid Lashari Goth Shafi Muhammad Rarki 34.64 2.68 7.74
11 Jamal Din Goth Shafi Muhammad Rarki 14.60 1.12 7.67
12 Waseer Muhammad Goth Shafi Muhammad Rarki 3.67 0.18 4.90
13 Muhammad Usman Goth Shafi Muhammad Rarki 12.80 0.73 5.70
14 Mansoor Goth Shafi Muhammad Rarki 3.34 0.24 7.19
15 Mola Bux Goth Shafi Muhammad Rarki 3.20 0.24 7.50
16 Haiji Ali Shair Goth Shafi Muhammad Rarki 7.60 0.60 7.89
17 Ali Murad Goth Khuda Bux Daharki 12.24 0.98 8.01
18 Khuda Bux Goth Khuda Bux Daharki 6.20 0.45 7.26
19 Dodo Khan Goth Khuda Bux Daharki 3.78 0.27 7.14
20 Haider Khan Goth Khuda Bux Daharki 14.32 1.11 7.75
21 Islam shair Goth Khuda Bux Daharki 24.40 1.74 7.13
22 Haji Bangal Khan Goth Khuda Bux Daharki 14.80 1.25 8.45
23 Adil Laghari Goth Adil Laghari Daharki 4.80 0.31 6.46
24 Ali Muhammad Khan Buzdar Goth Adil Laghari Daharki 28.70 2.14 7.46
25 Asghar Buzdar Goth Adil Laghari Daharki 13.40 0.97 7.24
26 Akbar Malik Goth Adil Laghari Daharki 12.45 1.02 8.19
27 Nasir Ahmad Goth Adil Laghari Daharki 13.40 1.06 7.91
28 Punhar Khan Goth Adil Laghari Daharki 34.50 3.01 8.72
29 Atta Hussain Goth Adil Laghari Daharki 12.40 1.16 9.35
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 81
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Name of Parent Total Affected Land
No. Name of Affected Farmer (HHH) Village/Hamlet Village Land (ha) Hectares Percentage
30 Shah Nawaz Goth M Amjad Daharki 28.60 2.22 7.76
31 Munir Ahmad Goth M Amjad Daharki 12.86 0.94 7.31
32 Muhammad Khan Goth M Amjad Daharki 12.34 0.94 7.62
33 Abdul Haq Goth M Amjad Daharki 11.40 0.81 7.11
34 Muhammad Amjad Goth M Amjad Daharki 32.78 2.62 7.99
35 Pholo Khan Goth M Amjad Daharki 14.34 0.98 6.83
36 Imdad Hussain Goth M Amjad Daharki 13.42 1.03 7.68
37 Abdul Latif Goth M Amjad Daharki 12.40 0.96 7.74
38 Ali Gohar Goth M Amjad Daharki 32.40 2.48 7.65
39 Abdul Wahid Goth Bux Ali Mahar Berari Mathelo 11.65 0.90 7.73
40 Bux Ali Mahar Goth Bux Ali Mahar Berari Mathelo 12.34 1.09 8.83
41 Raja Khan Goth Bux Ali Mahar Berari Mathelo 34.80 2.99 8.59
42 Mian Rung Ali Khan Goth Bux Ali Mahar Berari Mathelo 12.84 1.07 8.33
43 Sajan Matajo Goth Bux Ali Mahar Berari Mathelo 12.45 0.89 7.15
44 Khuda Bux Goth Ali Haider Berari Mathelo 12.80 1.04 8.13
45 Mian Ali Haider Goth Ali Haider Berari Mathelo 11.24 0.80 7.12
46 Aziz ur Rahman Goth Ali Haider Berari Mathelo 13.45 1.01 7.51
47 Muhammad Usman Goth Ali Haider Berari Mathelo 6.43 0.44 6.84
48 Panjo Khan Goth Ali Haider Berari Mathelo 6.80 0.48 7.06
49 Jamo Goth Ali Haider Berari Mathelo 13.24 0.99 7.48
50 Muhammad Panjo Goth Ali Haider Berari Mathelo 14.24 1.16 8.15
51 Ata Bux Goth Ali Haider Berari Mathelo 11.60 0.92 7.93
52 Usman Ahmad Goth Ali Haider Berari Mathelo 12.40 1.02 8.23
53 Mirza Khan Goth Ali Haider Dildar Mahar 14.24 1.00 7.02
54 Abdul Rahim Abdul Baqir Dildar Mahar 11.60 1.02 8.79
55 Abdul Baqir Abdul Baqir Dildar Mahar 14.60 0.98 6.71
56 Raja Abdul Baqir Dildar Mahar 3.87 0.29 7.49
57 Abdul Rahim Abdul Baqir Dildar Mahar 2.04 0.15 7.35
58 Shah Muhammad Abdul Baqir Dildar Mahar 5.40 0.45 8.33
59 Yunas Shah Latif Shah Dildar Mahar 12.40 1.02 8.23
60 Jam Mahar Latif Shah Dildar Mahar 14.60 1.11 7.60
61 Ali Muhammad Dildar Mahar Dildar Mahar 14.34 1.16 8.09
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 82
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Name of Parent Total Affected Land
No. Name of Affected Farmer (HHH) Village/Hamlet Village Land (ha) Hectares Percentage
62 Bunal Ali Shah Dildar Mahar Dildar Mahar 9.60 0.72 7.50
63 Abdullah Ali Bux Mehar Labano 7.40 0.57 7.70
64 Ch Asghar ch Asghar Labano 112.80 8.04 7.13
65 Nabi Bux Goth Ch Rasheed Umar Daro 14.60 0.99 6.78
66 Muhammad Yaseen Goth Ch Rasheed Umar Daro 2.80 0.15 5.36
67 Ch Rasheed Ahmad Goth Ch Rasheed Umar Daro 34.80 2.20 6.32
Sub-Total (a): Line A: 1044.16 79.77 7.64
Average Per Affected Farmer (N=67): 15.58 1.19 7.64
B: Ghotki- New Rohri Line :
1 Ch Rasheed Ahmad Goth Ch Rasheed Umar Daro 34.80 0.28 0.80
2 Nabi Bux Goth Ch Rasheed Umar Daro 6.40 0.27 4.22
3 Bachal Khan Goth Ch Rasheed Umar Daro 3.80 0.33 8.68
4 Haji Qasim Goth Ch Rasheed Umar Daro 3.80 0.27 7.11
5 Nizam Deen Goth Ch Rasheed Umar Daro 6.80 0.45 6.62
6 Ch Asghar Labano Parari 112.80 4.52 4.01
7 Muhammad Yaseen Labano Parari 12.70 0.93 7.32
8 Mushtaq Ahmad Labano Parari 11.60 0.87 7.50
9 Akbar Ali Labano Parari 24.60 1.91 7.76
10 Karam Ali Goth Nazir Parari 2.76 0.15 5.43
11 Mumtaz Shaikh Goth Nazir Parari 12.60 0.90 7.14
12 Nazir Ahmad Goth Nazir Parari 27.98 2.74 9.79
13 Rustam Ali Bhirialo Parari 22.40 1.81 8.08
14 Araz Muhammad Bhirialo Parari 4.60 0.33 7.17
15 Bahadur Wasir Bhirialo Parari 4.60 0.38 8.26
16 Muhammad Yunas Goth Peer Bux Parari 25.34 1.73 6.83
17 Atta ullah Goth Peer Bux Parari 4.20 0.33 7.86
18 Ali Bux Goth Peer Bux Parari 4.60 0.27 5.87
19 Ch Akram Goth Sargodha Parari 78.42 6.59 8.40
20 Rustam Khan (Tanent) Goth Sargodha Parari 14.67 1.16 7.91
21 Ali Hassan Khan (Tanent) Goth Sargodha Parari 12.20 1.02 8.36
22 Shah Nawaz Khan (Tanent) Goth Sargodha Parari 15.82 1.30 8.22
23 Yunas (Tanent) Goth Sargodha Parari 4.60 0.27 5.87
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 83
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Name of Parent Total Affected Land
No. Name of Affected Farmer (HHH) Village/Hamlet Village Land (ha) Hectares Percentage
24 M Yusaf (Tanent) Goth Sargodha Parari 15.80 1.17 7.41
25 Tariq Hussain (Tanent) Goth Sargodha Parari 12.30 0.98 7.97
26 Abdul Khaliq (Tanent) Goth Sargodha Parari 17.40 1.45 8.33
27 Ghulam Ali Juma Bhatoo Parari 4.20 0.33 7.86
28 Nasrullah Juma Bhatoo Parari 9.80 0.72 7.35
29 Rahmat Ali Juma Bhatoo Parari 6.70 0.48 7.16
30 Muhammad Mussa Juma Bhatoo Parari 5.60 0.47 8.39
31 Deen Muhammad Juma Bhatoo Parari 14.60 1.03 7.05
32 Muhammad Sabul Juma Bhatoo Parari 7.90 0.66 8.35
33 Ahmad Khan Goth Ameer Khan Adan Pur 13.00 0.76 5.85
34 Rasool Bux Goth Ameer Khan Adan Pur 6.70 0.45 6.72
35 Abdul Shakoor Goth Ameer Khan Adan Pur 7.80 0.44 5.64
36 Muhammad Qasim Goth Ameer Khan Adan Pur 4.60 0.18 3.91
37 Abdul Latif Goth Ibrahim Adan Pur 2.60 0.09 3.46
38 Abdul Rasheed Goth Ibrahim Adan Pur 5.70 0.18 3.16
39 Muhammad Wazir Goth Ibrahim Adan Pur 6.80 0.20 2.94
40 Abdul Aziz Goth Ibrahim Adan Pur 6.30 0.41 6.51
41 Fiaz Muhammad Goth Ibrahim Adan Pur 2.40 0.11 4.58
42 Shair Muhammad Goth Ibrahim Adan Pur 2.70 0.20 7.41
43 Muhammad Hassan Goth Ibrahim Adan Pur 3.80 0.24 6.32
44 Muhammad Sadiq Goth Ibrahim Adan Pur 3.20 0.21 6.56
45 Muhammad Ayaz Goth Khan M Adan Pur 14.60 1.13 7.74
46 Haji Khan Goth Khan M Adan Pur 31.80 2.60 8.18
47 Yar Muhammad Dari Toghan Dari Toghan 33.70 2.50 7.42
48 Noor Hassan Dari Toghan Dari Toghan 7.20 0.68 9.44
49 Nasrullah Dari Toghan Dari Toghan 11.70 0.86 7.35
50 Shahzada Dari Toghan Dari Toghan 21.80 1.06 4.86
51 Aman Ullah Dari Toghan Dari Toghan 32.70 2.02 6.18
52 Sijad hussain Dari Toghan Dari Toghan 3.80 0.28 7.37
53 Nazir Hussain Dari Toghan Dari Toghan 12.60 0.84 6.67
54 Hussain Bux Dari Toghan Dari Toghan 19.70 1.78 9.04
55 Abdul Khaliq Dad Goth Bullah Pannu Aqil 8.40 0.63 7.50
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 84
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Name of Parent Total Affected Land
No. Name of Affected Farmer (HHH) Village/Hamlet Village Land (ha) Hectares Percentage
56 Arab Bullah Goth Bullah Pannu Aqil 48.80 3.22 6.60
57 Jam Saif Ullah Goth Kata Khan Pannu Aqil 152.80 12.70 8.31
58 Baig Kata Goth Kata Khan Pannu Aqil 14.20 1.07 7.54
59 Satar Jonajo Goth Kata Khan Pannu Aqil 22.70 1.93 8.50
60 Kutab Junajo Goth Kata Khan Pannu Aqil 33.20 2.83 8.52
61 Malik Agla Khan Sultan Pur Pannu Aqil 23.10 1.93 8.35
62 Muhammad Sharif Sultan Pur Pannu Aqil 28.00 2.66 9.50
63 Sana Ullah Sultan Pur Pannu Aqil 12.40 1.04 8.39
64 Abdul Sitar Sultan Pur Pannu Aqil 13.70 1.08 7.88
65 Kul Baig Sultan Pur Pannu Aqil 24.90 1.96 7.87
66 Pahalwan Sammar Sultan Pur Pannu Aqil 52.80 4.41 8.35
67 Ram Talla Barath Junnas 4.60 0.33 7.17
68 Anwar Summar Barath Junnas 22.40 1.77 7.90
69 Muhammad Bux Barath Junnas 21.00 1.75 8.33
70 Ibrahim Barath Junnas 18.40 1.67 9.08
71 Mahram Khan Fazal Mangi Hingoro 25.20 1.73 6.87
72 Dhani Bux Fazal Mangi Hingoro 11.20 0.81 7.23
73 Ubaid Ullah Fazal Mangi Hingoro 12.00 1.04 8.67
74 Imam Bux Fazal Mangi Hingoro 15.70 1.23 7.83
75 Ghulam Haider Nirch Hingoro 11.50 0.81 7.04
76 Allah Jorio Nirch Hingoro 13.70 1.11 8.10
77 Muhammad Bux Nirch Hingoro 11.70 0.84 7.18
78 Muhammad Nawab Nirch Hingoro 4.50 0.24 5.33
79 Abdul Raheem Nirch Hingoro 6.70 0.56 8.36
80 Ali Khan Nirch Hingoro 11.40 0.99 8.68
81 Raza Muhammad Jagirani Jan Abad Dubar 82.00 6.40 7.80
82 Muhammad Khan (Tanent) Jan Abad Dubar 71.40 6.40 8.96
83 Muhammad Rasheed Jatoi Jan Abad Dubar 98.50 7.75 7.87
84 Ghulam Nabi (Tanent) Jan Abad Dubar 98.50 7.75 7.87
85 Abdul Sami Jan Abad Dubar 52.40 4.54 8.66
86 Aziz Ullah Khoso Goth Abdul Razaq Panwar 64.80 5.41 8.35
87 Abdul Razaq Khoso Goth Abdul Razaq Panwar 27.00 2.34 8.67
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 85
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Name of Parent Total Affected Land
No. Name of Affected Farmer (HHH) Village/Hamlet Village Land (ha) Hectares Percentage
88 Khan Muhammad Goth Abdul Razaq Panwar 7.80 0.62 7.95
89 Muhammad Juman Goth Abdul Razaq Panwar 11.00 0.94 8.55
90 Sardar Ali Goth Abdul Razaq Panwar 3.50 0.24 6.86
91 Shafqat Mirani Goth Mirani Ponath 19.40 1.73 8.92
92 Muhammad Ali Khoso Goth Mirani Ponath 24.50 1.83 7.47
93 Haqim Labano Goth Mirani Ponath 23.80 1.95 8.19
94 Lal Muhammad Mangi Goth Lal Muhammad Ponath 14.30 1.15 8.04
95 Muhammad Bux Goth Lal Muhammad Ponath 35.40 2.98 8.42
Sub-Total (b): Line B: 2060.89 155.69 7.55
Average Per Affected Farmer (N=95): 21.69 1.64 7.55
AB: Connecting Line A to B:
1 Ch Asghar Labano Parari 112.80 3.12 2.77
Sub-Total (ab): Line AB: 112.80 3.12 2.77
Average Per Affected Farmer (N=1): 112.80 3.12 2.77
C: New RohrI - Shikarpur Line
1 Nasir Ahmad Nandi Patni Patni 15.50 0.72 4.65
2 M Nazal Dandan Nandi Patni Patni 10.15 0.38 3.74
3 Ghulam Muhammad Nandi Patni Patni 8.10 0.42 5.19
4 Bashir Ahmad Nandi Patni Patni 5.15 0.18 3.50
5 Gobar Faqir Nandi Patni Patni 8.75 0.44 5.03
6 Ali Nawaz Nandi Patni Patni 3.55 0.29 8.17
7 Faiz Muhammad Chandio Nandi Patni Patni 4.80 0.35 7.29
8 Mukhtar Ahmad Nandi Patni Patni 8.50 0.53 6.24
9 Ghulam Ali Nandi Patni Patni 15.00 0.92 6.13
10 Ali Dino Nandi Patni Patni 12.85 0.74 5.76
11 Shafi Muhammad Trandro Meer Muhammad Hasan Patni 11.00 0.93 8.45
12 Ahmad Ali Trandro Meer Muhammad Hasan Patni 25.50 0.83 3.25
13 Wali Muhammad Trandro Meer Muhammad Hasan Patni 5.50 0.18 3.27
14 Shabir Ahmad Khoso Trandro Meer Muhammad Hasan Patni 12.50 0.29 2.32
15 Haji Akbar Civil Jail Coloney Sukkur 20.25 0.72 3.56
16 Sikander Civil Jail Coloney Sukkur 15.00 0.91 6.07
17 Ali Nawaz Civil Jail Coloney Sukkur 30.00 1.54 5.13
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 86
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Name of Parent Total Affected Land
No. Name of Affected Farmer (HHH) Village/Hamlet Village Land (ha) Hectares Percentage
18 Sardu Goth Ali Shair Long Jatoi 7.50 0.30 4.00
19 Shafi Muhammad Jatoi Goth Ali Shair Long Jatoi 74.00 3.99 5.39
20 Ali Shair (Tanent) Goth Ali Shair Long Jatoi 45.00 3.99 8.87
21 Long Jatoi Long Jatoi Long Jatoi 70.00 6.41 9.16
22 Jahangir Jatoi Goth Khuda Bux Long Jatoi 256.00 14.01 5.47
23 Jamal Khan Kharos Bagarge Bagarge 85.75 7.48 8.72
24 Haji Yar Muhammad Bagarge Bagarge 8.50 0.65 7.65
25 Muhammad Paral Bagarge Bagarge 5.60 0.33 5.89
26 Faqir Yar Muhammad Bagarge Bagarge 6.10 0.48 7.87
27 Muhammad Bux Mahar Bagarge Bagarge 7.45 0.45 6.04
28 Faiz Muhammad Labano Bagarge Bagarge 7.20 0.60 8.33
29 Nabi bux Bagarge Bagarge 6.08 0.55 9.05
30 Anwar Khan Tamachani Tamachani 58.88 5.02 8.53
31 Wali Muhammad Qalandar Bux Maca 10.40 0.84 8.08
32 Peer Bux Qalandar Bux Maca 8.10 0.52 6.42
33 Sumar Muhammad Qalandar Bux Maca 7.80 0.53 6.79
34 Yar Muhammad Qalandar Bux Maca 12.00 0.54 4.50
35 Khuda Bux Qalandar Bux Maca 8.25 0.48 5.82
36 Ismail Merani Qalandar Bux Maca 16.50 0.92 5.58
37 Ghulam Qadir Qalandar Bux Maca 11.40 0.87 7.63
38 Sadina Qalandar Bux Maca 8.41 0.54 6.42
39 Zamir Qalandar Bux Maca 8.70 0.52 5.98
40 Lal Bux Qalandar Bux Maca 6.02 0.42 6.98
41 Muhammad Zamir Qalandar Bux Maca 7.42 0.60 8.09
42 Yar Muhammad Qalandar Bux Maca 37.25 0.93 2.50
43 Elahi Bux Qalandar Bux Maca 15.18 0.39 2.57
44 Bacha Maca Maca 17.80 1.02 5.73
45 Ghulam Shabir Maca Maca 32.80 1.99 6.07
46 Ghulam Hussain Maca Maca 12.85 0.85 6.61
47 Manzoor Hussain Maca Maca 15.60 1.20 7.69
48 Haji Maca Maca Maca 10.45 0.95 9.09
49 Noor Khan Lukhy Station Lukhy 12.75 1.13 8.86
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 87
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Name of Parent Total Affected Land
No. Name of Affected Farmer (HHH) Village/Hamlet Village Land (ha) Hectares Percentage
50 Anwar Bhato Lukhy Station Lukhy 11.81 0.96 8.13
51 Nazir Ahmad Shaikh Lukhy Station Lukhy 36.60 2.41 6.58
52 Munawar Khan Lukhy Station Lukhy 9.82 0.66 6.72
53 Haji Abdul Aziz Lukhy Station Lukhy 6.60 0.48 7.27
54 Abdul Sami Khan Goth Malik Lukhy 16.80 0.93 5.54
55 Gulshan Barohi Goth Malik Lukhy 13.50 0.87 6.44
56 Ghos Bux Mahar Goth Malik Lukhy 48.20 3.03 6.29
57 Shahzada Goth Malik Lukhy 38.70 2.84 7.34
58 Rahmat Ullah Barohi Goth Jawah Habib Kot 11.80 0.91 7.71
59 Jabal Khan Goth Jawah Habib Kot 21.50 1.01 4.70
60 Phulapotar Goth Jawah Habib Kot 7.41 0.46 6.21
61 Dr Ibrahim Goth Jawah Habib Kot 17.20 1.02 5.93
62 Abdul Hakim Goth Jawah Habib Kot 47.90 3.35 6.99
63 Muhammad Yusaf Goth Jawah Habib Kot 41.60 2.20 5.29
64 Qamer Deen Goth Atta M Habib Kot 14.30 1.38 9.65
65 Sachal Goth Atta M Habib Kot 27.21 1.71 6.28
66 Naz Muhammad Goth Atta M Habib Kot 8.40 0.40 4.76
67 Ali Akbar Goth Ali Akbar Habib Kot 13.11 0.86 6.56
68 Tanseer Bhoto Goth Ali Akbar Habib Kot 17.50 1.01 5.77
69 Abdullah Barohi Goth Ali Akbar Habib Kot 8.80 0.65 7.39
70 Guy Khan Bolani Goth Ali Akbar Habib Kot 52.40 3.86 7.37
71 Abdul Rahman Sumro Goth Ali Akbar Habib Kot 13.70 1.02 7.45
72 Irfan Ahmad Goth Ali Akbar Habib Kot 14.60 1.10 7.53
73 Muhammad Tafu Goth Haji Talib Khan Shikarpur 27.23 2.30 8.45
74 Waliat Lar Baloch Goth Shair M Lodran 3.50 0.18 5.14
75 Haji Faqir Muhammad Goth Shair M Lodran 376.50 20.49 5.44
76 Abdullah Mughal (Tanent) Goth Shair M Lodran 289.00 20.49 7.09
77 Noor Deen Khan Goth Shair M Lodran 58.80 4.47 7.60
78 Abdul Rahman Jafri Goth Shair M Lodran 34.78 2.06 5.92
Sub-Total (c): Line C: 2399.11 152.98 6.38
Average Per Affected Farmer (N=78): 30.76 1.96 6.38
D: New Rohri Sub-station
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 88
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Name of Parent Total Affected Land
No. Name of Affected Farmer (HHH) Village/Hamlet Village Land (ha) Hectares Percentage
1 Qadir Bux Ponath Ponath 21.50 1.21 5.63
2 Ali Gohar Ponath Ponath 12.20 0.81 6.64
3 Faqir Muhammad Ponath Ponath 87.70 5.26 6.00
4 Ghulam Akbar Ponath Ponath 35.40 2.83 7.99
5 Ghulam Akbar S/O Qadir Bux Ponath Ponath 56.80 4.45 7.83
6 Javaid Shah Ponath Ponath 22.00 1.62 7.36
Sub-Total (d): Sub-station: 235.60 16.18 6.87
Average Per Affected Farmer (N=6): 39.27 2.70 6.87
TOTAL: A+B+C+D* 5852.56 407.74 6.97
Average Per Affected Farmer (N=247): 23.69 1.65 6.97
* Iin this table total land is more than the table of Affected Land because land under the control of tanets is also included in this table.
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 89
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Table A-4: Type and Area of Crops Affected New 220kV Rohri Sub-station and Associated Transmission Lines 2
Name of Parent Crops/ Orchards (Hactares)
No. Name of Affected Farmer (HHH) Village/Hamlet Village Total Area Cotton Rice Orchards
District Sukkur :
A: Dahrki - Ghotki Line :
1 Qasim Lashari Goth Sultan Khan Rarki 1.11 1.11 - -
2 Haji Muhammad Bachal Goth Sultan Khan Rarki 1.99 1.99 - -
3 Jamal Din Goth Sultan Khan Rarki 1.71 1.71 - -
4 Khan Muhammad Lashari Goth Sultan Khan Rarki 0.84 0.84 - -
5 Allah Diwaya Goth Sultan Khan Rarki 0.93 0.93 - -
6 Ghulam Farid Pitali Goth Sultan Khan Rarki 1.14 1.14 - -
7 Shafi Muhammad Goth Sultan Khan Rarki 0.98 0.98 - -
8 Hai Qadir Bux Goth Shafi Muhammad Rarki 1.04 1.04 - -
9 Ali Gohar Goth Shafi Muhammad Rarki 1.14 1.14 - -
10 Farid Lashari Goth Shafi Muhammad Rarki 2.68 2.68 - -
11 Jamal Din Goth Shafi Muhammad Rarki 1.12 1.12 - -
12 Waseer Muhammad Goth Shafi Muhammad Rarki 0.18 0.18 - -
13 Muhammad Usman Goth Shafi Muhammad Rarki 0.73 0.73 - -
14 Mansoor Goth Shafi Muhammad Rarki 0.24 0.24 - -
15 Mola Bux Goth Shafi Muhammad Rarki 0.24 0.24 - -
16 Haiji Ali Shair Goth Shafi Muhammad Rarki 0.60 0.60 - -
17 Ali Murad Goth Khuda Bux Daharki 0.98 0.98 - -
18 Khuda Bux Goth Khuda Bux Daharki 0.45 0.45 - -
19 Dodo Khan Goth Khuda Bux Daharki 0.27 0.27 - -
20 Haider Khan Goth Khuda Bux Daharki 1.11 1.11 - -
21 Islam shair Goth Khuda Bux Daharki 1.74 1.74 - -
22 Haji Bangal Khan Goth Khuda Bux Daharki 1.25 1.25 - -
23 Adil Laghari Goth Adil Laghari Daharki 0.31 0.31 - -
24 Ali Muhammad Khan Buzdar Goth Adil Laghari Daharki 2.14 1.34 0.80 -
25 Asghar Buzdar Goth Adil Laghari Daharki 0.97 0.97 - -
26 Akbar Malik Goth Adil Laghari Daharki 1.02 1.02 - -
27 Nasir Ahmad Goth Adil Laghari Daharki 1.06 1.06 - -
28 Punhar Khan Goth Adil Laghari Daharki 3.01 3.01 - -
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 90
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Name of Parent Crops/ Orchards (Hactares)
No. Name of Affected Farmer (HHH) Village/Hamlet Village Total Area Cotton Rice Orchards
29 Atta Hussain Goth Adil Laghari Daharki 1.16 1.16 - -
30 Shah Nawaz Goth M Amjad Daharki 2.22 2.22 - -
31 Munir Ahmad Goth M Amjad Daharki 0.94 0.94 - -
32 Muhammad Khan Goth M Amjad Daharki 0.94 0.94 - -
33 Abdul Haq Goth M Amjad Daharki 0.81 0.81 - -
34 Muhammad Amjad Goth M Amjad Daharki 2.62 2.62 - -
35 Pholo Khan Goth M Amjad Daharki 0.98 0.98 - -
36 Imdad Hussain Goth M Amjad Daharki 1.03 1.03 - -
37 Abdul Latif Goth M Amjad Daharki 0.96 0.96 - -
38 Ali Gohar Goth M Amjad Daharki 2.48 2.48 - -
39 Abdul Wahid Goth Bux Ali Mahar Berari Mathelo 0.90 0.90 - -
40 Bux Ali Mahar Goth Bux Ali Mahar Berari Mathelo 1.09 1.09 - -
41 Raja Khan Goth Bux Ali Mahar Berari Mathelo 2.99 2.99 - -
42 Mian Rung Ali Khan Goth Bux Ali Mahar Berari Mathelo 1.07 1.07 - -
43 Sajan Matajo Goth Bux Ali Mahar Berari Mathelo 0.89 0.89 - -
44 Khuda Bux Goth Ali Haider Berari Mathelo 1.04 - 1.04 -
45 Mian Ali Haider Goth Ali Haider Berari Mathelo 0.80 - 0.80 -
46 Aziz ur Rahman Goth Ali Haider Berari Mathelo 1.01 - 1.01 -
47 Muhammad Usman Goth Ali Haider Berari Mathelo 0.44 - 0.44 -
48 Panjo Khan Goth Ali Haider Berari Mathelo 0.48 - 0.48 -
49 Jamo Goth Ali Haider Berari Mathelo 0.99 - 0.99 -
50 Muhammad Panjo Goth Ali Haider Berari Mathelo 1.16 - 1.16 -
51 Ata Bux Goth Ali Haider Berari Mathelo 0.92 - 0.92 -
52 Usman Ahmad Goth Ali Haider Berari Mathelo 1.02 - 1.02 -
53 Mirza Khan Goth Ali Haider Dildar Mahar 1.00 - 1.00 -
54 Abdul Rahim Abdul Baqir Dildar Mahar 1.02 1.02 - -
55 Abdul Baqir Abdul Baqir Dildar Mahar 0.98 0.98 - -
56 Raja Abdul Baqir Dildar Mahar 0.29 0.29 - -
57 Abdul Rahim Abdul Baqir Dildar Mahar 0.15 0.15 - -
58 Shah Muhammad Abdul Baqir Dildar Mahar 0.45 0.45 - -
59 Yunas Shah Latif Shah Dildar Mahar 1.02 1.02 - -
60 LARP Jam Rohri Mahar 220kV Subproject_ Final Latif Draft_ Shah November 2007 Dildar Mahar 1.11 1.11 - -
Page 91
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Name of Parent Crops/ Orchards (Hactares)
No. Name of Affected Farmer (HHH) Village/Hamlet Village Total Area Cotton Rice Orchards
61 Ali Muhammad Dildar Mahar Dildar Mahar 1.16 1.16 - -
62 Bunal Ali Shah Dildar Mahar Dildar Mahar 0.72 0.72 - -
63 Abdullah Ali Bux Mehar Labano 0.57 0.57 - -
64 Ch Asghar ch Asghar Labano 8.04 5.54 2.50 -
65 Nabi Bux Goth Ch Rasheed Umar Daro 0.99 0.99 - -
66 Muhammad Yaseen Goth Ch Rasheed Umar Daro 0.15 0.15 - -
67 Ch Rasheed Ahmad Goth Ch Rasheed Umar Daro 2.20 - 2.20 -
Sub-Total (a): Line A: 79.77 65.41 14.36 0.00
Percentage 100.00 82.00 18.00 -
B: Ghotki- New Rohri Line :
1 Ch Rasheed Ahmad Goth Ch Rasheed Umar Daro 0.28 0.28 - -
2 Nabi Bux Goth Ch Rasheed Umar Daro 0.27 0.27 - -
3 Bachal Khan Goth Ch Rasheed Umar Daro 0.33 0.33 - -
4 Haji Qasim Goth Ch Rasheed Umar Daro 0.27 0.27 - -
5 Nizam Deen Goth Ch Rasheed Umar Daro 0.45 0.45 - -
6 Ch Asghar Labano Parari 4.52 - 4.52 -
7 Muhammad Yaseen Labano Parari 0.93 - 0.93 -
8 Mushtaq Ahmad Labano Parari 0.87 - 0.87 -
9 Akbar Ali Labano Parari 1.91 - 1.91 -
10 Karam Ali Goth Nazir Parari 0.15 - 0.15 -
11 Mumtaz Shaikh Goth Nazir Parari 0.90 - 0.90 -
12 Nazir Ahmad Goth Nazir Parari 2.74 2.74 - -
13 Rustam Ali Bhirialo Parari 1.81 1.81 - -
14 Araz Muhammad Bhirialo Parari 0.33 0.33 - -
15 Bahadur Wasir Bhirialo Parari 0.38 0.38 - -
16 Muhammad Yunas Goth Peer Bux Parari 1.73 1.73 - -
17 Atta ullah Goth Peer Bux Parari 0.33 0.33 - -
18 Ali Bux Goth Peer Bux Parari 0.27 0.27 - -
19 Ch Akram Goth Sargodha Parari 6.59 6.59 - -
20 Rustam Khan (Tanent) Goth Sargodha Parari - - - -
21 Ali Hassan Khan (Tanent) Goth Sargodha Parari - - - -
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 92
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Name of Parent Crops/ Orchards (Hactares)
No. Name of Affected Farmer (HHH) Village/Hamlet Village Total Area Cotton Rice Orchards
22 Shah Nawaz Khan (Tanent) Goth Sargodha Parari - - - -
23 Yunas (Tanent) Goth Sargodha Parari - - - -
24 M Yusaf (Tanent) Goth Sargodha Parari - - - -
25 Tariq Hussain (Tanent) Goth Sargodha Parari - - - -
26 Abdul Khaliq (Tanent) Goth Sargodha Parari - - - -
27 Ghulam Ali Juma Bhatoo Parari 0.33 0.33 - -
28 Nasrullah Juma Bhatoo Parari 0.72 0.72 - -
29 Rahmat Ali Juma Bhatoo Parari 0.48 0.48 - -
30 Muhammad Mussa Juma Bhatoo Parari 0.47 0.47 - -
31 Deen Muhammad Juma Bhatoo Parari 1.03 1.03 - -
32 Muhammad Sabul Juma Bhatoo Parari 0.66 0.66 - -
33 Ahmad Khan Goth Ameer Khan Adan Pur 0.76 0.76 - -
34 Rasool Bux Goth Ameer Khan Adan Pur 0.45 0.45 - -
35 Abdul Shakoor Goth Ameer Khan Adan Pur 0.44 0.44 - -
36 Muhammad Qasim Goth Ameer Khan Adan Pur 0.18 0.18 - -
37 Abdul Latif Goth Ibrahim Adan Pur 0.09 0.09 - -
38 Abdul Rasheed Goth Ibrahim Adan Pur 0.18 0.18 - -
39 Muhammad Wazir Goth Ibrahim Adan Pur 0.20 0.20 - -
40 Abdul Aziz Goth Ibrahim Adan Pur 0.41 0.41 - -
41 Fiaz Muhammad Goth Ibrahim Adan Pur 0.11 0.11 - -
42 Shair Muhammad Goth Ibrahim Adan Pur 0.20 0.20 - -
43 Muhammad Hassan Goth Ibrahim Adan Pur 0.24 0.24 - -
44 Muhammad Sadiq Goth Ibrahim Adan Pur 0.21 0.21 - -
45 Muhammad Ayaz Goth Khan M Adan Pur 1.13 1.13 - -
46 Haji Khan Goth Khan M Adan Pur 2.60 2.60 - -
47 Yar Muhammad Dari Toghan Dari Toghan 2.50 2.50 - -
48 Noor Hassan Dari Toghan Dari Toghan 0.68 0.68 - -
49 Nasrullah Dari Toghan Dari Toghan 0.86 0.86 - -
50 Shahzada Dari Toghan Dari Toghan 1.06 1.06 - -
51 Aman Ullah Dari Toghan Dari Toghan 2.02 - 2.02 -
52 Sijad hussain Dari Toghan Dari Toghan 0.28 - 0.28 -
53 LARP Nazir Rohri Hussain 220kV Subproject_ Final Dari Draft_ Toghan November 2007 Dari Toghan 0.84 - 0.84 -
Page 93
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Name of Parent Crops/ Orchards (Hactares)
No. Name of Affected Farmer (HHH) Village/Hamlet Village Total Area Cotton Rice Orchards
54 Hussain Bux Dari Toghan Dari Toghan 1.78 1.78 - -
55 Abdul Khaliq Dad Goth Bullah Pannu Aqil 0.63 0.63 - -
56 Arab Bullah Goth Bullah Pannu Aqil 3.22 3.22 - -
57 Jam Saif Ullah Goth Kata Khan Pannu Aqil 12.70 12.70 - -
58 Baig Kata Goth Kata Khan Pannu Aqil 1.07 1.07 - -
59 Satar Jonajo Goth Kata Khan Pannu Aqil 1.93 1.93 - -
60 Kutab Junajo Goth Kata Khan Pannu Aqil 2.83 2.83 - -
61 Malik Agla Khan Sultan Pur Pannu Aqil 1.93 1.93 - -
62 Muhammad Sharif Sultan Pur Pannu Aqil 2.66 2.66 - -
63 Sana Ullah Sultan Pur Pannu Aqil 1.04 1.04 - -
64 Abdul Sitar Sultan Pur Pannu Aqil 1.08 1.08 - -
65 Kul Baig Sultan Pur Pannu Aqil 1.96 1.96 - -
66 Pahalwan Sammar Sultan Pur Pannu Aqil 4.41 4.41 - -
67 Ram Talla Barath Junnas 0.33 0.33 - -
68 Anwar Summar Barath Junnas 1.77 1.77 - -
69 Muhammad Bux Barath Junnas 1.75 1.75 - -
70 Ibrahim Barath Junnas 1.67 1.67 - -
71 Mahram Khan Fazal Mangi Hingoro 1.73 1.73 - -
72 Dhani Bux Fazal Mangi Hingoro 0.81 0.81 - -
73 Ubaid Ullah Fazal Mangi Hingoro 1.04 1.04 - -
74 Imam Bux Fazal Mangi Hingoro 1.23 1.23 - -
75 Ghulam Haider Nirch Hingoro 0.81 0.81 - -
76 Allah Jorio Nirch Hingoro 1.11 1.11 - -
77 Muhammad Bux Nirch Hingoro 0.84 0.84 - -
78 Muhammad Nawab Nirch Hingoro 0.24 0.24 - -
79 Abdul Raheem Nirch Hingoro 0.56 0.56 - -
80 Ali Khan Nirch Hingoro 0.99 0.99 - -
81 Raza Muhammad Jagirani Jan Abad Dubar 6.40 6.40 - -
82 Muhammad Khan (Tanent) Jan Abad Dubar - - - -
83 Muhammad Rasheed Jatoi Jan Abad Dubar 7.75 7.75 - -
84 Ghulam Nabi (Tanent) Jan Abad Dubar - - - -
85 LARP Abdul Rohri Sami 220kV Subproject_ Final Jan Draft_ Abad November 2007 Dubar 4.54 4.54 - -
Page 94
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Name of Parent Crops/ Orchards (Hactares)
No. Name of Affected Farmer (HHH) Village/Hamlet Village Total Area Cotton Rice Orchards
86 Aziz Ullah Khoso Goth Abdul Razaq Panwar 5.41 5.41 - -
87 Abdul Razaq Khoso Goth Abdul Razaq Panwar 2.34 2.34 - -
88 Khan Muhammad Goth Abdul Razaq Panwar 0.62 0.62 - -
89 Muhammad Juman Goth Abdul Razaq Panwar 0.94 0.94 - -
90 Sardar Ali Goth Abdul Razaq Panwar 0.24 0.24 - -
91 Shafqat Mirani Goth Mirani Ponath 1.73 1.73 - -
92 Muhammad Ali Khoso Goth Mirani Ponath 1.83 1.83 - -
93 Haqim Labano Goth Mirani Ponath 1.95 1.95 - -
94 Lal Muhammad Mangi Goth Lal Muhammad Ponath 1.15 1.15 - -
95 Muhammad Bux Goth Lal Muhammad Ponath 2.98 2.98 - -
Sub-Total (b): Line B: 134.19 121.77 12.42 0.00
Percentage 100.00 90.74 9.26 -
AB: Connecting Line A to B:
1 Ch Asghar Labano Parari 3.12 3.12 - -
Sub-Total (ab): Line AB: 3.12 3.12 0.00 0.00
Percentage 100.00 100.00 - -
C: New RohrI - Shikarpur Line
1 Nasir Ahmad Nandi Patni Patni 0.72 - - 0.72
2 M Nazal Dandan Nandi Patni Patni 0.38 - - 0.38
3 Ghulam Muhammad Nandi Patni Patni 0.42 - - 0.42
4 Bashir Ahmad Nandi Patni Patni 0.18 - - 0.18
5 Gobar Faqir Nandi Patni Patni 0.44 - - 0.44
6 Ali Nawaz Nandi Patni Patni 0.29 - - 0.29
7 Faiz Muhammad Chandio Nandi Patni Patni 0.35 0.35 - -
8 Mukhtar Ahmad Nandi Patni Patni 0.53 0.53 - -
9 Ghulam Ali Nandi Patni Patni 0.92 0.92 - -
10 Ali Dino Nandi Patni Patni 0.74 0.74 - -
11 Shafi Muhammad Trandro Meer Muhammad Hasan Patni 0.93 0.93 - -
12 Ahmad Ali Trandro Meer Muhammad Hasan Patni 0.83 0.31 0.52
13 Wali Muhammad Trandro Meer Muhammad Hasan Patni 0.18 - 0.18
14 Shabir Ahmad Khoso Trandro Meer Muhammad Hasan Patni 0.29 - 0.08 0.21
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 95
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Name of Parent Crops/ Orchards (Hactares)
No. Name of Affected Farmer (HHH) Village/Hamlet Village Total Area Cotton Rice Orchards
15 Haji Akbar Civil Jail Coloney Sukkur 0.72 - 0.72
16 Sikander Civil Jail Coloney Sukkur 0.91 - 0.91
17 Ali Nawaz Civil Jail Coloney Sukkur 1.54 0.90 - 0.64
18 Sardu Goth Ali Shair Long Jatoi 0.30 - 0.30
19 Shafi Muhammad Jatoi Goth Ali Shair Long Jatoi 3.99 3.99 -
20 Ali Shair (Tanent) Goth Ali Shair Long Jatoi - - -
21 Long Jatoi Long Jatoi Long Jatoi 6.41 6.41 -
22 Jahangir Jatoi Goth Khuda Bux Long Jatoi 14.01 6.21 7.80 -
23 Jamal Khan Kharos Bagarge Bagarge 7.48 2.28 5.20 -
24 Haji Yar Muhammad Bagarge Bagarge 0.65 0.65 -
25 Muhammad Paral Bagarge Bagarge 0.33 0.33 -
26 Faqir Yar Muhammad Bagarge Bagarge 0.48 0.48 -
27 Muhammad Bux Mahar Bagarge Bagarge 0.45 0.45 -
28 Faiz Muhammad Labano Bagarge Bagarge 0.60 0.60 -
29 Nabi bux Bagarge Bagarge 0.55 0.55 -
30 Anwar Khan Tamachani Tamachani 5.02 5.02 -
31 Wali Muhammad Qalandar Bux Maca 0.84 0.84 -
32 Peer Bux Qalandar Bux Maca 0.52 0.52 -
33 Sumar Muhammad Qalandar Bux Maca 0.53 0.53 -
34 Yar Muhammad Qalandar Bux Maca 0.54 0.54 -
35 Khuda Bux Qalandar Bux Maca 0.48 0.48 -
36 Ismail Merani Qalandar Bux Maca 0.92 0.92 -
37 Ghulam Qadir Qalandar Bux Maca 0.87 0.87 -
38 Sadina Qalandar Bux Maca 0.54 0.54 -
39 Zamir Qalandar Bux Maca 0.52 0.52 -
40 Lal Bux Qalandar Bux Maca 0.42 0.42 -
41 Muhammad Zamir Qalandar Bux Maca 0.60 0.60 -
42 Yar Muhammad Qalandar Bux Maca 0.93 0.93 -
43 Elahi Bux Qalandar Bux Maca 0.39 0.39 -
44 Bacha Maca Maca 1.02 1.02 -
45 Ghulam Shabir Maca Maca 1.99 1.01 0.98 -
46 LARPGhulam Rohri Hussain 220kV Subproject_ Final Maca Draft_ November 2007 Maca 0.85 0.42 0.43 -
Page 96
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Name of Parent Crops/ Orchards (Hactares)
No. Name of Affected Farmer (HHH) Village/Hamlet Village Total Area Cotton Rice Orchards
47 Manzoor Hussain Maca Maca 1.20 1.20 - -
48 Haji Maca Maca Maca 0.95 0.95 - -
49 Noor Khan Lukhy Station Lukhy 1.13 1.13 -
50 Anwar Bhato Lukhy Station Lukhy 0.96 0.96 -
51 Nazir Ahmad Shaikh Lukhy Station Lukhy 2.41 1.11 1.30 -
52 Munawar Khan Lukhy Station Lukhy 0.66 0.66 -
53 Haji Abdul Aziz Lukhy Station Lukhy 0.48 0.48 -
54 Abdul Sami Khan Goth Malik Lukhy 0.93 0.93 -
55 Gulshan Barohi Goth Malik Lukhy 0.87 0.87 -
56 Ghos Bux Mahar Goth Malik Lukhy 3.03 0.53 2.50 -
57 Shahzada Goth Malik Lukhy 2.84 2.84 -
58 Rahmat Ullah Barohi Goth Jawah Habib Kot 0.91 0.91 -
59 Jabal Khan Goth Jawah Habib Kot 1.01 1.01 - -
60 Phulapotar Goth Jawah Habib Kot 0.46 0.46 -
61 Dr Ibrahim Goth Jawah Habib Kot 1.02 1.02 -
62 Abdul Hakim Goth Jawah Habib Kot 3.35 3.35 -
63 Muhammad Yusaf Goth Jawah Habib Kot 2.20 2.20 -
64 Qamer Deen Goth Atta M Habib Kot 1.38 1.38 -
65 Sachal Goth Atta M Habib Kot 1.71 1.71 -
66 Naz Muhammad Goth Atta M Habib Kot 0.40 0.40 -
67 Ali Akbar Goth Ali Akbar Habib Kot 0.86 0.86 -
68 Tanseer Bhoto Goth Ali Akbar Habib Kot 1.01 1.01 -
69 Abdullah Barohi Goth Ali Akbar Habib Kot 0.65 0.65 -
70 Guy Khan Bolani Goth Ali Akbar Habib Kot 3.86 1.24 2.62 -
71 Abdul Rahman Sumro Goth Ali Akbar Habib Kot 1.02 1.02 -
72 Irfan Ahmad Goth Ali Akbar Habib Kot 1.10 1.10 -
73 Muhammad Tafu Goth Haji Talib Khan Shikarpur 2.30 2.30 -
74 Waliat Lar Baloch Goth Shair M Lodran 0.18 0.18 -
75 Haji Faqir Muhammad Goth Shair M Lodran 20.49 4.49 16.00 -
76 Abdullah Mughal (Tanent) Goth Shair M Lodran - - -
77 Noor Deen Khan Goth Shair M Lodran 4.47 4.47 -
78 LARP Abdul Rohri Rahman 220kV Jafri Subproject_ Final Goth Draft_ Shair NovemberM 2007 Lodran 2.06 2.06 -
Page 97
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Name of Parent Crops/ Orchards (Hactares)
No. Name of Affected Farmer (HHH) Village/Hamlet Village Total Area Cotton Rice Orchards
Sub-Total (C): Line C New Rohri- Shikarpur 128.50 24.82 97.77 5.91
Percentage 100.00 19.32 76.09 4.60
D: New Rohri Sub-station
1 Qadir Bux Ponath Ponath 1.21 1.21 - -
2 Ali Gohar Ponath Ponath 0.81 0.81 - -
3 Faqir Muhammad Ponath Ponath 5.26 5.26 - -
4 Ghulam Akbar Ponath Ponath 2.83 2.83 - -
5 Ghulam Akbar S/O Qadir Bux Ponath Ponath 4.45 4.45 - -
6 Javaid Shah Ponath Ponath 1.62 1.62 - -
Sub-Total (d): Sub-station: 16.18 16.18 0.00 0.00
Percentage 100.00 100.00 - -
SUM TOTAL (a+b): 361.76 231.30 124.55 5.91
Percentage 100.00 63.94 34.43 1.63
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 98
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Table A-5: Trees Affected by New 220kV Rohri Sub-station and Associated TLs (Within 30m Wide Corridor - Right of Way)
Tower Nos. Fruit Trees Wood Trees*
(From-To) Dates Mango Shisham Kikar Others Total No.
A: Dahrki - Ghotki Line :
PP - 1 - - - - - 0
1 - 2 - - - - - 0
2 - 3 - - - - - 0
3 - 4 - - - - - 0
4 - 5 - - - - - 0
5 - 6 - - - - - 0
6 - 7 - - - - 2 2
7 - 8 - - - - - 0
8 - 9 - - - - - 0
9 -10 - - - 1 1 2
10-11 - - - - - 0
11-12 - - - 1 - 1
12-13 - - - - - 0
13-14 - - - - - 0
14-15 - - - - - 0
15-16 - - - - - 0
16-17 - - - - - 0
17-18 - - - 1 - 1
18-19 - - - - - 0
19-20 - - - - - 0
20-21 - - - - 2 2
21-22 - - - - - 0
22-23 - - - - - 0
23-24 - - - - - 0
24-25 - - - - - 0
25-26 - - - - - 0
26-27 - - - - - 0
27-28 - - - - - 0
28-29 - - - - - 0
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 99
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Tower Nos. Fruit Trees Wood Trees*
(From-To) Dates Mango Shisham Kikar Others Total No.
29-30 - - - - - 0
30-31 - - - - - 0
31-32 - - - - - 0
32-33 - - 1 - - 1
33-34 - - - - - 0
34-35 - - - - - 0
35-36 - - - - - 0
36-37 - - 2 - - 2
37-38 - - - - - 0
38-39 - - - - - 0
39-40 - - 1 - - 1
40-41 - - - - - 0
41-42 - - - - - 0
42-43 - - - - - 0
43-44 - - - - - 0
44-45 - - - 1 - 1
45-46 - - - - - 0
46-47 - - - - - 0
47-48 - - - - - 0
48-49 - - - - - 0
49-50 - - - - - 0
50-51 - - - - - 0
51-52 - - - - - 0
52-53 - - - - - 0
53-54 - - - - - 0
54-55 - 2 - - - 2
55-56 - - - - - 0
56-57 - - - 2 - 2
57-58 - - - - 0
58-59 - - - - 0
59-60 - - - - 0
60-61 - - - - 0
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 100
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Tower Nos. Fruit Trees Wood Trees*
(From-To) Dates Mango Shisham Kikar Others Total No.
61-62 - - - - 0
62-63 - - - - 0
63-64 - - - - 0
64-65 - - - - 0
65-66 - - - - 0
66-67 - - - - 0
67-68 - - - - 0
68-69 - - - - 0
69-70 - - - - 0
70-71 - - - 1 - 1
71-72 - - - - - 0
72-73 - - - - - 0
73-74 - - 1 - - 1
74-75 - - - - - 0
75-76 - - - - - 0
76-77 - - - - - 0
77-78 - - - - - 0
78-79 - - - - - 0
79-80 - - - - - 0
80-81 - - - - - 0
81-82 - - 1 1 - 2
82-83 - - - - - 0
83-84 - - - - - 0
84-85 - - - - - 0
85-86 - - - - - 0
86-87 - - - - - 0
87-88 - - - - - 0
88-89 - - - - - 0
89-90 - - - 2 - 2
90-91 - - - - - 0
91-92 - - 1 - - 1
92-93 - - - - - 0
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 101
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Tower Nos. Fruit Trees Wood Trees*
(From-To) Dates Mango Shisham Kikar Others Total No.
93-94 - - - - - 0
94-95 - - - - - 0
95-96 - - - - - 0
96-97 - - - - - 0
97-98 - - - 1 1 2
98-99 - - - - 1 1
99-100 - - - - - 0
100 - PP
Sub-Total (a) 0 2 7 11 7 27
Percentage - 7.41 25.93 40.74 25.93 100.00
B: Ghotki- New Rohri Line :
PP-1 - - 2 - - 2
1 - 2 - - - - 1 1
2 - 3 - - 1 - 1 2
3 - 4 - - 2 - - 2
4 - 5 - - - - - 0
5 - 6 - - - - - 0
6 - 7 - - - - - 0
7 - 8 - - - - - 0
8 - 9 - - - - - 0
9 -10 - - - - - 0
10-11 - - - - - 0
11-12 - - 1 - - 1
12-13 - - - - - 0
13-14 - - - - - 0
14-15 - - - - - 0
15-16 - - - - - 0
16-17 - - - - - 0
17-18 - - - - - 0
18-19 - - 2 3 - 5
19-20 - - 2 2 1 5
20-21 - - - 1 - 1
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 102
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Tower Nos. Fruit Trees Wood Trees*
(From-To) Dates Mango Shisham Kikar Others Total No.
21-22 - - 2 - - 2
22-23 - - - - - 0
23-24 - - 3 - - 3
24-25 - - 1 - 2 3
25-26 - - - 1 - 1
26-27 - - - 1 - 1
27-28 - - - - - 0
28-29 - - - - - 0
29-30 - - - - - 0
30-31 - - - - - 0
31-32 - - - - - 0
32-33 - - - - - 0
33-34 - - - - - 0
34-35 - - 1 - 3 4
35-36 - - 1 - - 1
36-37 - - - - - 0
37-38 - - - 1 - 1
38-39 - - - 2 - 2
39-40 - - - - - 0
40-41 - - - - - 0
41-42 - - - - - 0
42-43 - - - - - 0
43-44 - - - - - 0
44-45 - - - - - 0
45-46 - - - - - 0
46-47 - - - 1 - 1
47-48 - - - - - 0
48-49 - - - - - 0
49-50 - - - - - 0
50-51 - - - - - 0
51-52 - - - - - 0
52-53 - - - - - 0
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 103
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Tower Nos. Fruit Trees Wood Trees*
(From-To) Dates Mango Shisham Kikar Others Total No.
53-54 - - - - - 0
54-55 - - - - - 0
55-56 - - - - - 0
56-57 - - - - - 0
57-58 - - - - - 0
58-59 - - - - - 0
59-60 - - - - - 0
60-61 - - - - - 0
61-62 - - - 1 1
62-63 - - 1 - 1 2
63-64 - - 1 - - 1
64-65 - - - - 2 2
65-66 - - - - 1 1
66-67 - - 1 - - 1
67-68 - - - - - 0
68-69 - - 2 - - 2
69-70 - - 1 2 3
70-71 - - - - - 0
71-72 - - - - - 0
72-73 - - - - - 0
73-74 - - - - - 0
74-75 - - - - - 0
75-76 - - - - - 0
76-77 - - - - - 0
77-78 - - - - - 0
78-79 - - - - - 0
79-80 - - - - - 0
80-81 - - - - - 0
81-82 - - - - - 0
82-83 - - - - - 0
83-84 - - 1 - - 1
84-85 - - - - - 0
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 104
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Tower Nos. Fruit Trees Wood Trees*
(From-To) Dates Mango Shisham Kikar Others Total No.
85-86 - - - 2 - 2
86-87 - - - - - 0
87-88 - - - - - 0
88-89 - - - - - 0
89-90 - - - - - 0
90-91 - - 1 - - 1
91-92 - - - - - 0
92-93 - - - - - 0
93-94 - - - - - 0
94-95 - - - 1 - 1
95-96 - - - - - 0
96-97 - - - - - 0
97-98 - - 1 - - 1
98-99 - - 2 1 - 3
99-100 - - - - - 0
100-101 - - - - - 0
101-102 - - - - - 0
102-103 - - - - - 0
103-104 - - - - - 0
104-105 - - - - - 0
105-106 - - - 2 - 2
106-107 - - - - - 0
107-108 - - - - - 0
108-109 - - - - - 0
109-110 - - - - - 0
110-111 - - - - - 0
111-112 - - - - - 0
112-113 - - - - - 0
113-114 - - - - - 0
114-115 - - 2 - - 2
115-116 - - 1 - - 1
116-117 2 - - - - 2
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 105
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Tower Nos. Fruit Trees Wood Trees*
(From-To) Dates Mango Shisham Kikar Others Total No.
117-118 - - 1 - - 1
118-119 - - - - - 0
119-120 - - - - - 0
120-121 - - - - - 0
121-122 - - - - - 0
122-123 - - - - - 0
123-124 - - - - - 0
124-125 - - - - - 0
125-126 - - - 2 - 2
126-127 - - - - - 0
127-128 - - 1 - - 1
128-129 - - 1 - - 1
129-130 - - - - - 0
130-131 - - - - - 0
131-132 - - - - - 0
132-133 - - - - - 0
133-134 - - - - - 0
134-135 - - - - - 0
135-136 - - - - 2 2
136-137 - - - - - 0
137-138 - - - - - 0
138-139 - - - - 1 1
139-140 - - - - - 0
140-141 - - - - - 0
141-142 - - - - - 0
142-143 - - - - - 0
143-144 - - - - - 0
144-145 - - - - - 0
145-146 - - - - - 0
146-147 - - - - - 0
147-148 - - - - - 0
148-149 - - - - - 0
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 106
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Tower Nos. Fruit Trees Wood Trees*
(From-To) Dates Mango Shisham Kikar Others Total No.
149-150 - - - - - 0
150-151 - - - - - 0
151-152 - - - - - 0
152-153 1 - - - - 1
153-154 - - - - - 0
154-155 - - - - - 0
155-156 - - - - - 0
156-157 - - - - - 0
157-158 - - - - 2 2
158-159 - - - - 1 1
159-160 - - - - - 0
160-161 - - - - - 0
161-162 - - - - - 0
162-163 - - - - 1 1
163-164 - - - - - 0
164-165 - - - - 1 1
165-166 - - - - - 0
166-167 - - - - 1 1
167-168 - - 2 - - 2
168-169 - - - 2 - 2
169-170 - - - - - 0
170-171 - - - - - 0
171-172 - - - - - 0
172-173 - - - 1 - 1
173-174 - - - - - 0
174-175 - - - - - 0
175-176 - - - - - 0
176-177 - - - - - 0
177-178 - - - - - 0
178-179 - - - - - 0
179-180 - - - - - 0
180-181 - - - - - 0
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 107
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Tower Nos. Fruit Trees Wood Trees*
(From-To) Dates Mango Shisham Kikar Others Total No.
181-182 - - - - - 0
182-183 - - - - - 0
183-184 - - - - - 0
184-185 - - - - - 0
185-186 - - - - 2 2
186-187 - - - - - 0
187-188 - - - - - 0
188-189 - - - - - 0
189-190 6 - - - - 6
190-191 - - - - - 0
191-192 - - - - - 0
192-193 - - - - - 0
193-194 - - - - - 0
194 - Grid
Sub-Total (b) 9 0 36 25 25 95
Percentage 9.47 - 37.89 26.32 26.32 100.00
AB: Connecting Line A to B:
Lane A -1 - - - - - 0
1-2 - - - - - 0
2 - Lane B - - - - - 0
Sub-Total (ab) 0 0 0 0 0 0
Percentage ------
C: New RohrI - Shikarpur Line
Grid- 1 - - - - - 0
1 - 2 - - - - - 0
2 - 3 - - - - - 0
3 - 4 - - - - - 0
4 - 5 - - - - - 0
5 - 6 - - - - - 0
6 - 7 3 - - - - 3
7 - 8 11 - - - - 11
8 - 9 8 - - - - 8
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 108
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Tower Nos. Fruit Trees Wood Trees*
(From-To) Dates Mango Shisham Kikar Others Total No.
9 -10 4 - - - - 4
10-11 - - - - 1 1
11-12 - - - - - 0
12-13 - - - - - 0
13-14 - - - - - 0
14-15 - - - - - 0
15-16 - - - - - 0
16-17 25 - - - - 25
17-18 356 - - - - 356
18-19 12 - - - - 12
19-20 - - - - - 0
20-21 - - - - - 0
21-22 - - - - - 0
22-23 12 - - - - 12
23-24 60 20 - - - 80
24-25 - - - - - 0
25-26 - - - - - 0
26-27 - - - - - 0
27-28 - - - - - 0
28-29 - - - - - 0
29-30 - - - - - 0
30-31 - - - - - 0
31-32 - - - - - 0
32-33 - - - - - 0
33-34 15 - - - - 15
34-35 - - - - - 0
35-36 - - - - - 0
36-37 - - - - - 0
37-38 - - - - - 0
38-39 - - - - - 0
39-40 - - - - - 0
40-41 - - - - - 0
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 109
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Tower Nos. Fruit Trees Wood Trees*
(From-To) Dates Mango Shisham Kikar Others Total No.
41-42 - - - - - 0
42-43 - - - - - 0
43-44 - - - - - 0
44-45 - - - - - 0
45-46 - - - - - 0
46-47 - - - - - 0
47-48 - - 1 - 1 2
48-49 - - - - - 0
49-50 - - - - - 0
50-51 - - - - - 0
51-52 - - - - - 0
52-53 - - - - - 0
53-54 - - - - - 0
54-55 - - - 1 - 1
55-56 - - - - - 0
56-57 - - - - - 0
57-58 - - - - - 0
58-59 - - - - - 0
59-60 - - - - - 0
60-61 - - - - - 0
61-62 - - - - - 0
62-63 - - - 1 - 1
63-64 - - - - - 0
64-65 - - - - - 0
65-66 - - 1 - - 1
66-67 - - 1 - - 1
67-68 - - - - - 0
68-69 - - - - - 0
69-70 - - - 1 - 1
70-71 - - - - - 0
71-72 - - - - - 0
72-73 - - - - - 0
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 110
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Tower Nos. Fruit Trees Wood Trees*
(From-To) Dates Mango Shisham Kikar Others Total No.
73-74 - - - - - 0
74-75 - - - - - 0
75-76 - - - - - 0
76-77 - - - - - 0
77-78 - - 1 - - 1
78-79 - - - - - 0
79-80 - - - - - 0
80-81 - - - - - 0
81-82 - - - - - 0
82-83 - - - - - 0
83-84 - - - - - 0
84-85 - - - - - 0
85-86 - - - - - 0
86-87 - - 1 - - 1
87-88 - - - - - 0
88-89 - - - - - 0
89-90 - - - - - 0
90-91 - - - - - 0
91-92 - - - - - 0
92-93 - - - - - 0
93-94 - - - - - 0
94-95 - - - - - 0
95-96 - - - - - 0
96-97 - - - - - 0
97-98 - - - - - 0
98-99 - - - - - 0
99-100 - - - - - 0
100-101 - - 1 - - 1
101-102 - - - - - 0
102-103 - - - - - 0
103-104 - - - - - 0
104-105 1 - - - - 1
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 111
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Tower Nos. Fruit Trees Wood Trees*
(From-To) Dates Mango Shisham Kikar Others Total No.
105-106 - - - - - 0
106-107 - - - - - 0
107-108 - - - - - 0
108-109 - - - - - 0
109-110 - - - - - 0
110-111 - - - 1 - 1
111-112 - - - - - 0
112-113 - - - - - 0
113-114 - - - - - 0
114-115 - - - - 1 1
115-116 - - - - - 0
116-117 - - - - - 0
117-118 1 - - - - 1
118-119 - - - - - 0
119-120 - - - - - 0
120-121 - - 1 - - 1
121-122 - - - - - 0
122-123 - - - 1 - 1
123-124 - - - - - 0
124-125 - - - - - 0
125-126 - - - - - 0
126-127 4 - - - - 4
127-128 - - - - 1 1
128-129 - - - - - 0
129-130 - - - - - 0
130-131 - - - - - 0
131-132 - - - - - 0
132-133 - - - - - 0
133-134 - - - - - 0
134-135 - - 1 - - 1
135-136 - - - - - 0
136-137 - - - - - 0
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 112
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Tower Nos. Fruit Trees Wood Trees*
(From-To) Dates Mango Shisham Kikar Others Total No.
137-138 - - - - - 0
138-139 - - - 2 - 2
139-140 - - - - - 0
140-141 - - - - - 0
141-142 - - - - - 0
142-143 - - - - - 0
143-144 - - - - 1 1
144-145 1 - 2 - - 3
145-146 - - - - - 0
146-147 - - - - - 0
147-148 - - - 1 - 1
148-149 - - - - - 0
149-150 - - 1 - - 1
150-151 - - - - - 0
151-152 - - - - - 0
152-153 - - - 1 - 1
153-154 - - - - - 0
154-155 - - - - - 0
155-156 - - - - - 0
156-157 - - - - - 0
157-158 - - - - - 0
158-159 - - - - - 0
159-160 - - 2 - - 2
160-161 - - - - - 0
161-162 - - - 1 - 1
162-163 - - - - - 0
163-164 - - 1 - - 1
164-165 - - - - - 0
165- Grid
Sub-Total (c) 513 20 14 10 5 562
Percentage 91.28 3.56 2.49 1.78 0.89 100.00
D: New Rohri Sub-station
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 113
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Tower Nos. Fruit Trees Wood Trees*
(From-To) Dates Mango Shisham Kikar Others Total No.
------0
------0
Sub-Total (d) 0 0 0 0 0 0
Percentage 0 0 0 0 0 0
G TOTAL : 522 22 57 46 37 684
Percentage 76.32 3.22 8.33 6.73 5.41 100.00
* Botanical Names: Shisham = Sisso; Sirin = Albizia Lebbek; Kikar = Acacia Nicolta; Toot = Mulberry.
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 114
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Table A-6: List of Affected Farmers by New 220kV Rohri Sub-station and Associated Transmission Lines (Subproject No. 9, Tranche 2)
Affected Person (AH) Annual Household Income by Sectors and Gender (Rs. "000")
Agriculture AH Employment Small Business (Net) Total Income (Rs. "000")
No. Name of Household Head Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Overall
A: Dahrki - Ghotki Line :
1 Qasim Lashari - - 53.87 - 99.09 - 152.96 - 152.96
2 Haji Muhammad Bachal - - - - 167.21 - 167.21 - 167.21
3 Jamal Din - - - - 144.50 - 144.50 - 144.50
4 Khan Muhammad Lashari - - - - 76.18 - 76.18 - 76018
5 Allah Diwaya - - - - 86.76 - 86.76 - 86.76
6 Ghulam Farid Pitali - - - - 91.23 - 91.23 - 91.23
7 Shafi Muhammad - - - - 76.18 - 76.18 - 76.18
8 Hai Qadir Bux - - - - 97.74 - 97.74 - 97.74
9 Ali Gohar - - - - 89.74 34.66 89.74 34.66 124.40
10 Farid Lashari - - - - 234.78 - 234.78 - 234.78
11 Jamal Din - - - - 98.96 - 98.96 - 98.96
12 Waseer Muhammad - - 62.80 - 24.87 - 87.67 - 87.67
13 Muhammad Usman - - - - 86.76 - 86.76 - 86.76
14 Mansoor 42.60 - 22.80 - 22.64 - 88.04 - 88.04
15 Mola Bux - - 53.60 - 21.69 - 75.29 - 75.29
16 Haiji Ali Shair - 48.80 - - 51.51 - 51.51 48.80 100.31
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 115
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Affected Person (AH) Annual Household Income by Sectors and Gender (Rs. "000")
Agriculture AH Employment Small Business (Net) Total Income (Rs. "000")
No. Name of Household Head Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Overall
17 Ali Murad - - - - 82.96 - 82.96 - 82.96
18 Khuda Bux 47.60 - - - 42.02 - 89.62 - 89.62
19 Dodo Khan - - 54.60 - 25.62 - 80.22 - 80.22
20 Haider Khan - - - - 97.06 - 97.06 - 97.06
21 Islam shair - - - - 165.38 - 165.38 - 165.38
22 Haji Bangal Khan - - - - 100.31 - 100.31 - 100.31
23 Adil Laghari - - 48.80 - 32.53 - 81.33 - 81.33
24 Ali Muhammad Khan Buzdar - - - - 194.52 - 194.52 - 194.52
25 Asghar Buzdar - - - - 90.82 - 90.82 - 90.82
26 Akbar Malik - - - - 84.38 - 84.38 - 84.38
27 Nasir Ahmad - - - - 90.82 - 90.82 - 90.82
28 Punhar Khan - - - - 233.83 - 233.83 - 233.83
29 Atta Hussain - - - - 84.04 - 84.04 - 84.04
30 Shah Nawaz - - - - 193.84 - 193.84 - 193.84
31 Munir Ahmad - - - - 87.16 - 87.16 - 87.16
32 Muhammad Khan - - - 33.60 83.64 - 83.64 33.60 117.24
33 Abdul Haq 58.45 - - - 77.27 - 135.72 - 135.72
34 Muhammad Amjad - - - - 222.18 - 222.18 - 222.18
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 116
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Affected Person (AH) Annual Household Income by Sectors and Gender (Rs. "000")
Agriculture AH Employment Small Business (Net) Total Income (Rs. "000")
No. Name of Household Head Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Overall
35 Pholo Khan - - - - 97.19 - 97.19 - 97.19
36 Imdad Hussain - - - - 90.96 - 90.96 - 90.96
37 Abdul Latif - - 36.00 - 84.04 - 120.04 - 120.04
38 Ali Gohar - - - - 219.60 - 219.60 - 219.60
39 Abdul Wahid - 38.00 - - 78.96 - 78.96 38.00 116.96
40 Bux Ali Mahar - - 45.87 - 83.64 - 129.51 - 129.51
41 Raja Khan - - - - 235.87 46.00 235.87 46.00 281.87
42 Mian Rung Ali Khan - - - - 87.03 - 87.03 - 87.03
43 Sajan Matajo - - - - 84.38 - 84.38 - 84.38
44 Khuda Bux - - - - 86.76 - 86.76 - 86.76
45 Mian Ali Haider - - - - 76.18 - 76.18 - 76.18
46 Aziz ur Rahman - - - - 91.16 - 91.16 - 91.16
47 Muhammad Usman - - 52.00 - 43.58 - 95.58 - 95.58
48 Panjo Khan - - 38.90 - 46.09 - 84.99 - 84.99
49 Jamo 46.80 - - - 89.74 - 136.54 - 136.54
50 Muhammad Panjo - - - - 96.52 48.00 96.52 48.00 144.52
51 Ata Bux - - - - 78.62 - 78.62 - 78.62
52 Usman Ahmad - - - - 84.04 - 84.04 - 84.04
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 117
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Affected Person (AH) Annual Household Income by Sectors and Gender (Rs. "000")
Agriculture AH Employment Small Business (Net) Total Income (Rs. "000")
No. Name of Household Head Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Overall
53 Mirza Khan - - - - 96.52 - 96.52 - 96.52
54 Abdul Rahim - - - - 78.62 - 78.62 - 78.62
55 Abdul Baqir - - - - 98.96 - 98.96 - 98.96
56 Raja - - 56.80 - 26.23 - 83.03 - 83.03
57 Abdul Rahim 92.40 - - - 13.83 - 106.23 - 106.23
58 Shah Muhammad - - 58.70 - 36.60 - 95.30 - 95.30
59 Yunas Shah - - - - 84.04 - 84.04 - 84.04
60 Jam Mahar - - - - 98.96 - 98.96 - 98.96
61 Ali Muhammad - - - - 97.19 - 97.19 - 97.19
62 Bunal Ali Shah - - - 34.00 65.07 - 65.07 34.00 99.07
63 Abdullah 48.80 - - - 50.16 - 98.96 - 98.96
64 Ch Asghar - - - - 764.53 - 764.53 - 764.53
65 Nabi Bux - - - - 98.96 - 98.96 - 98.96
66 Muhammad Yaseen - - 56.80 - 18.98 - 75.78 - 75.78
67 Ch Rasheed Ahmad - - - - 235.87 - 235.87 - 235.87
Sub-Total (a): Line A: 336.65 86.80 641.54 67.60 7,077.10 128.66 8,055.29 283.06 8,338.35
Percentage 79.5 20.5 90.5 9.5 98.2 1.8 96.6 3.4 100.0
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 118
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Affected Person (AH) Annual Household Income by Sectors and Gender (Rs. "000")
Agriculture AH Employment Small Business (Net) Total Income (Rs. "000")
No. Name of Household Head Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Overall
B: Ghotki- New Rohri Line :
1 Ch Rasheed Ahmad - - - - 235.87 - 235.87 - 235.87
2 Nabi Bux - - 34.80 - 43.38 - 78.18 - 78.18
3 Bachal Khan 56.80 - - - 25.76 - 82.56 - 82.56
4 Haji Qasim - - 48.90 - 25.76 - 74.66 - 74.66
5 Nizam Deen - 38.80 - - 46.09 - 46.09 38.80 84.89
6 Ch Asghar - - - - 764.53 - 764.53 - 764.53
7 Muhammad Yaseen - - - - 86.08 - 86.08 - 86.08
8 Mushtaq Ahmad - - - - 78.62 - 78.62 - 78.62
9 Akbar Ali - - - - 166.73 - 166.73 - 166.73
10 Karam Ali - 38.70 54.80 - 18.71 - 73.51 38.70 112.21
11 Mumtaz Shaikh - - - - 85.40 - 85.40 - 85.40
12 Nazir Ahmad - - - - 189.64 - 189.64 - 189.64
13 Rustam Ali - - - - 151.82 - 151.82 - 151.82
14 Araz Muhammad - - 47.80 - 31.18 56.00 78.98 56.00 134.98
15 Bahadur Wasir 52.80 - - - 35.14 - 87.94 - 87.94
16 Muhammad Yunas - - - - 171.75 - 171.75 - 171.75
17 Atta ullah - - 52.40 - 28.47 - 80.87 - 80.87
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 119
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Affected Person (AH) Annual Household Income by Sectors and Gender (Rs. "000")
Agriculture AH Employment Small Business (Net) Total Income (Rs. "000")
No. Name of Household Head Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Overall
18 Ali Bux - - 56.80 - 31.18 - 87.98 - 87.98
19 Ch Akram - - - - 531.51 - 531.51 - 531.51
20 Rustam Khan (Tanent) - - - - 99.43 - 99.43 - 99.43
21 Ali Hassan Khan (Tanent) - - - - 82.69 - 82.69 - 82.69
22 Shah Nawaz Khan (Tanent) - - - - 107.22 - 107.22 - 107.22
23 Yunas (Tanent) 84.50 - - - 31.18 - 115.68 - 115.68
24 M Yusaf (Tanent) - - - - 107.09 - 107.09 - 107.09
25 Tariq Hussain (Tanent) - - - - 83.37 - 83.37 - 83.37
26 Abdul Khaliq (Tanent) - - - - 117.93 - 117.93 - 117.93
27 Ghulam Ali - 32.44 46.80 - 28.47 - 75.27 32.44 107.71
28 Nasrullah - - - - 66.42 - 66.42 - 66.42
29 Rahmat Ali 48.90 - - - 45.41 - 94.31 - 94.31
30 Muhammad Mussa - - 36.40 - 37.96 - 74.36 - 74.36
31 Deen Muhammad - - - - 98.96 - 98.96 - 98.96
32 Muhammad Sabul - - - - 53.54 12.80 53.54 12.80 66.34
33 Ahmad Khan - - - - 88.11 - 88.11 - 88.11
34 Rasool Bux - - 24.00 - 45.41 - 69.41 - 69.41
35 Abdul Shakoor - - - 24.60 52.87 - 52.87 24.60 77.47
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 120
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Affected Person (AH) Annual Household Income by Sectors and Gender (Rs. "000")
Agriculture AH Employment Small Business (Net) Total Income (Rs. "000")
No. Name of Household Head Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Overall
36 Muhammad Qasim 46.00 - - - 31.18 - 77.18 - 77.18
37 Abdul Latif - - 45.67 - 17.62 - 63.29 - 63.29
38 Abdul Rasheed - 32.00 34.00 - 38.63 - 72.63 32.00 104.63
39 Muhammad Wazir 28.00 - 32.00 - 46.09 - 106.09 - 106.09
40 Abdul Aziz - - 34.00 - 42.70 - 76.70 - 76.70
41 Fiaz Muhammad - - 42.60 - 16.27 - 58.87 - 58.87
42 Shair Muhammad 32.40 - - 46.30 18.30 - 50.70 46.30 97.00
43 Muhammad Hassan - - 42.40 - 25.76 - 68.16 - 68.16
44 Muhammad Sadiq - - 58.24 - 21.69 - 79.93 - 79.93
45 Muhammad Ayaz - - - - 98.96 - 98.96 - 98.96
46 Haji Khan - - - - 215.53 - 215.53 - 215.53
47 Yar Muhammad - - 46.00 - 228.41 - 274.41 - 274.41
48 Noor Hassan - - 52.80 - 48.80 - 101.60 - 101.60
49 Nasrullah 54.80 - - - 79.30 - 134.10 - 134.10
50 Shahzada - - - - 147.76 - 147.76 - 147.76
51 Aman Ullah - - - - 221.63 - 221.63 - 221.63
52 Sijad hussain - - 36.44 32.00 25.76 35.00 62.20 67.00 129.20
53 Nazir Hussain - - - - 85.40 - 85.40 - 85.40
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 121
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Affected Person (AH) Annual Household Income by Sectors and Gender (Rs. "000")
Agriculture AH Employment Small Business (Net) Total Income (Rs. "000")
No. Name of Household Head Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Overall
54 Hussain Bux - - - - 133.52 - 133.52 - 133.52
55 Abdul Khaliq Dad - - - - 56.93 - 56.93 - 56.93
56 Arab Bullah - - 48.70 - 330.76 - 379.46 - 379.46
57 Jam Saif Ullah - - - - 1,035.64 - 1,035.64 - 1,035.64
58 Baig Kata 49.60 - - - 96.24 - 145.84 - 145.84
59 Satar Jonajo - - - - 153.86 - 153.86 - 153.86
60 Kutab Junajo - - - - 225.02 - 225.02 - 225.02
61 Malik Agla Khan - - - - 156.57 - 156.57 - 156.57
62 Muhammad Sharif 34.00 - 46.00 - 189.78 - 269.78 - 269.78
63 Sana Ullah - - - - 84.04 - 84.04 - 84.04
64 Abdul Sitar - - - - 92.86 - 92.86 - 92.86
65 Kul Baig - - - - 168.77 - 168.77 - 168.77
66 Pahalwan Sammar - - - - 357.87 - 357.87 - 357.87
67 Ram Talla - - 49.80 - 31.18 - 80.98 - 80.98
68 Anwar Summar - 52.00 - - 151.82 - 151.82 52.00 203.82
69 Muhammad Bux - - - - 142.33 - 142.33 - 142.33
70 Ibrahim - - - - 124.71 - 124.71 - 124.71
71 Mahram Khan - - - - 170.80 - 170.80 - 170.80
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 122
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Affected Person (AH) Annual Household Income by Sectors and Gender (Rs. "000")
Agriculture AH Employment Small Business (Net) Total Income (Rs. "000")
No. Name of Household Head Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Overall
72 Dhani Bux - - - - 75.91 - 75.91 - 75.91
73 Ubaid Ullah - - - - 81.33 - 81.33 - 81.33
74 Imam Bux - - - - 106.41 - 106.41 - 106.41
75 Ghulam Haider - - - - 77.94 22.50 77.94 22.50 100.44
76 Allah Jorio - - - - 92.86 - 92.86 - 92.86
77 Muhammad Bux 48.80 - - - 79.30 - 128.10 - 128.10
78 Muhammad Nawab - - 52.00 - 30.50 - 82.50 - 82.50
79 Abdul Raheem - - 48.80 - 45.41 - 94.21 - 94.21
80 Ali Khan - - - - 77.27 - 77.27 - 77.27
81 Raza Muhammad Jagirani - - - - 555.78 - 555.78 - 555.78
82 Muhammad Khan (Tanent) - - 48.70 - 232.40 - 281.10 - 281.10
83 Muhammad Rasheed Jatoi - - - 34.00 667.61 46.00 667.61 80.00 747.61
84 Ghulam Nabi (Tanent) 38.00 - - - 343.60 - 381.60 - 381.60
85 Abdul Sami - - - - 355.16 - 355.16 - 355.16
86 Aziz Ullah Khoso - - 52.40 - 439.20 - 491.60 - 491.60
87 Abdul Razaq Khoso - - - - 183.00 - 183.00 - 183.00
88 Khan Muhammad - - 48.70 - 52.87 - 101.57 - 101.57
89 Muhammad Juman - 42.00 - - 74.56 - 74.56 42.00 116.56
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 123
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Affected Person (AH) Annual Household Income by Sectors and Gender (Rs. "000")
Agriculture AH Employment Small Business (Net) Total Income (Rs. "000")
No. Name of Household Head Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Overall
90 Sardar Ali - 48.86 72.80 - 23.72 - 96.52 48.86 145.38
91 Shafqat Mirani - - - - 131.49 - 131.49 - 131.49
92 Muhammad Ali Khoso - - - - 166.06 - 166.06 - 166.06
93 Haqim Labano - - - - 161.31 - 161.31 - 161.31
94 Lal Muhammad Mangi 34.00 - - - 96.92 - 130.92 - 130.92
95 Muhammad Bux - 284.80 1,294.75 136.90 239.93 172.30 1,534.68 594.00 2,128.68
Sub-Total (b): Line B: 608.60 569.60 2,589.50 273.80 13,396.71 344.60 16,594.81 1,188.00 17,782.81
Percentage 51.7 48.3 90.4 9.6 97.5 2.5 93.3 6.7 100.0
AB: Connecting Line A to B:
1 Ch Asghar - - - - 764.53 - 764.53 - 764.53
Sub-Total (ab): Line AB: 0 0 0 0 764.53 0 764.53 0 764.53
Percentage #DIV/0! #DIV/0! #DIV/0! #DIV/0! 100.0 - 100.0 - 100.0
C: New RohrI - Shikarpur Line
1 Nasir Ahmad 32.0 - 58.0 - 239.67 - 329.7 - 329.7
2 M Nazal Dandan - 42.5 - - 75.33 - 75.3 42.5 117.8
3 Ghulam Muhammad - - - - 109.56 - 109.6 - 109.6
4 Bashir Ahmad - - - - 87.67 - 87.7 - 87.7
5 Gobar Faqir - - - - 75.33 - 75.3 - 75.3
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 124
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Affected Person (AH) Annual Household Income by Sectors and Gender (Rs. "000")
Agriculture AH Employment Small Business (Net) Total Income (Rs. "000")
No. Name of Household Head Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Overall
6 Ali Nawaz - - 32.0 - 58.33 - 90.3 - 90.3
7 Faiz Muhammad Chandio - - 48.7 18.0 35.67 - 84.4 18.0 102.4
8 Mukhtar Ahmad - 34.0 - - 63.00 - 63.0 34.0 97.0
9 Ghulam Ali - - 56.0 - 111.33 34.80 167.3 34.8 202.1
10 Ali Dino - - 12.0 - 95.33 - 107.3 - 107.3
11 Shafi Muhammad 64.0 - - - 81.56 - 145.6 - 145.6
12 Ahmad Ali 63.0 - 28.0 - 396.33 - 487.3 - 487.3
13 Wali Muhammad 45.8 42.0 - - 89.00 - 134.8 42.0 176.8
14 Shabir Ahmad Khoso - - - - 192.11 - 192.1 - 192.1
15 Haji Akbar - - 36.0 - 380.11 - 416.1 - 416.1
16 Sikander - - 46.0 - 252.78 - 298.8 - 298.8
17 Ali Nawaz - - 78.0 32.0 506.22 - 584.2 32.0 616.2
18 Sardu - - - - 93.00 - 93.0 - 93.0
19 Shafi Muhammad Jatoi - - 38.0 - 549.00 - 587.0 - 587.0
20 Ali Shair (Tanent) - - - - 109.67 - 109.7 - 109.7
21 Long Jatoi - - 33.0 - 519.33 - 552.3 - 552.3
22 Jahangir Jatoi - - 39.0 - 788.11 - 827.1 - 827.1
23 Jamal Khan Kharos - - 65.0 16.0 636.22 - 701.2 16.0 717.2
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 125
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Affected Person (AH) Annual Household Income by Sectors and Gender (Rs. "000")
Agriculture AH Employment Small Business (Net) Total Income (Rs. "000")
No. Name of Household Head Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Overall
24 Haji Yar Muhammad 38.6 - - - 63.11 - 101.7 - 101.7
25 Muhammad Paral 38.0 - - - 41.56 45.60 79.6 45.6 125.2
26 Faqir Yar Muhammad 42.5 - - - 45.22 - 87.7 - 87.7
27 Muhammad Bux Mahar - 34.0 - - 55.22 - 55.2 34.0 89.2
28 Faiz Muhammad Labano - 32.0 - - 53.44 - 53.4 32.0 85.4
29 Nabi bux - 48.0 - - 45.11 - 45.1 48.0 93.1
30 Anwar Khan - - 82.0 42.0 436.89 - 518.9 42.0 560.9
31 Wali Muhammad - - 28.0 - 77.11 - 105.1 - 105.1
32 Peer Bux 48.0 - - - 60.11 - 108.1 - 108.1
33 Sumar Muhammad - 36.0 - - 57.89 - 57.9 36.0 93.9
34 Yar Muhammad - - - - 89.00 - 89.0 - 89.0
35 Khuda Bux 46.0 - - - 61.22 - 107.2 - 107.2
36 Ismail Merani - - 92.0 - 122.44 - 214.4 - 214.4
37 Ghulam Qadir - 48.0 - - 84.56 - 84.6 48.0 132.6
38 Sadina 65.8 - - - 62.44 - 128.2 - 128.2
39 Zamir 35.7 - - - 64.56 - 100.2 - 100.2
40 Lal Bux - - - - 44.67 48.00 44.7 48.0 92.7
41 Muhammad Zamir 32.0 - - - 55.00 - 87.0 - 87.0
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 126
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Affected Person (AH) Annual Household Income by Sectors and Gender (Rs. "000")
Agriculture AH Employment Small Business (Net) Total Income (Rs. "000")
No. Name of Household Head Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Overall
42 Yar Muhammad - - - - 276.33 - 276.3 - 276.3
43 Elahi Bux - - 45.0 - 112.67 - 157.7 - 157.7
44 Bacha - - 32.0 - 132.11 - 164.1 - 164.1
45 Ghulam Shabir - - 63.0 - 243.33 - 306.3 - 306.3
46 Ghulam Hussain - - - - 95.33 - 95.3 - 95.3
47 Manzoor Hussain - - 24.0 - 115.78 - 139.8 - 139.8
48 Haji Maca 23.0 - - - 77.56 - 100.6 - 100.6
49 Noor Khan - - 12.0 - 94.56 - 106.6 - 106.6
50 Anwar Bhato - - - - 87.67 - 87.7 - 87.7
51 Nazir Ahmad Shaikh - - 38.0 - 271.56 - 309.6 - 309.6
52 Munawar Khan - 28.0 - - 72.89 - 72.9 28.0 100.9
53 Haji Abdul Aziz 48.6 - - - 49.00 - 97.6 - 97.6
54 Abdul Sami Khan - - 78.0 - 124.67 - 202.7 - 202.7
55 Gulshan Barohi 68.0 - - - 100.11 - 168.1 - 168.1
56 Ghos Bux Mahar - - - - 357.66 - 357.7 - 357.7
57 Shahzada - - - - 287.11 - 287.1 - 287.1
58 Rahmat Ullah Barohi 87.0 - - - 87.56 32.56 174.6 32.6 207.1
59 Jabal Khan 65.0 62.0 45.6 - 159.56 - 270.2 62.0 332.2
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 127
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Affected Person (AH) Annual Household Income by Sectors and Gender (Rs. "000")
Agriculture AH Employment Small Business (Net) Total Income (Rs. "000")
No. Name of Household Head Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Overall
60 Phulapotar - - 38.0 18.5 55.00 - 93.0 18.5 111.5
61 Dr Ibrahim - - 38.0 - 127.56 - 165.6 - 165.6
62 Abdul Hakim - - 92.0 - 355.33 - 447.3 - 447.3
63 Muhammad Yusaf 34.0 - 81.0 - 308.67 - 423.7 - 423.7
64 Qamer Deen 67.0 - - - 106.11 - 173.1 - 173.1
65 Sachal - - - 42.0 201.89 - 201.9 42.0 243.9
66 Naz Muhammad - - - 22.0 62.33 - 62.3 22.0 84.3
67 Ali Akbar - - - - 97.22 - 97.2 - 97.2
68 Tanseer Bhoto - - - - 128.89 - 128.9 - 128.9
69 Abdullah Barohi 65.0 - - - 65.33 - 130.3 - 130.3
70 Guy Khan Bolani - 42.0 - - 388.76 42.00 388.8 84.0 472.8
71 Abdul Rahman Sumro - - 33.0 - 101.67 - 134.7 - 134.7
72 Irfan Ahmad - - 45.0 - 108.33 - 153.3 - 153.3
73 Muhammad Tafu 87.0 - - - 202.00 - 289.0 - 289.0
74 Waliat Lar Baloch 42.6 - 29.0 35.0 26.00 - 97.6 35.0 132.6
75 Haji Faqir Muhammad 78.8 84.0 104.0 - 2793.22 - 2,976.0 84.0 3,060.0
76 Abdullah Mughal (Tanent) - - 34.0 - 699.67 - 733.7 - 733.7
77 Noor Deen Khan - - 24.0 - 436.22 46.60 460.2 46.6 506.8
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 128
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Affected Person (AH) Annual Household Income by Sectors and Gender (Rs. "000")
Agriculture AH Employment Small Business (Net) Total Income (Rs. "000")
No. Name of Household Head Men Women Men Women Men Women Men Women Overall
78 Abdul Rahman Jafri - - - - 258.00 - 258.0 - 258.0
Sub-Total (c): Line C: 1,217.4 532.5 1,627.3 225.5 16331.87 249.6 19,176.5 1,007.6 20,184.1
Sector-Wise Percentage (Men:Wmn): 69.6 30.4 87.8 12.2 98.49 1.5 95.0 5.0 100.0
D: New Rohri Sub-station
1 Qadir Bux 72.50 - 98.00 - 145.72 - 316.22 - 316.22
2 Ali Gohar - - 34.00 - 82.69 - 116.69 - 116.69
3 Faqir Muhammad - 52.00 - - 594.41 - 594.41 52.00 646.41
4 Ghulam Akbar - - - - 239.93 - 239.93 - 239.93
5 Ghulam Akbar S/O Qadir Bux - - 56.00 - 384.98 56.55 440.98 56.55 497.53
6 Javaid Shah 54.00 - - - 149.11 - 203.11 - 203.11
Sub-Total (d): Sub-station: 126.50 52.00 188.00 - 1596.84 56.55 1,911.34 108.55 2,019.89
Percentage 70.9 29.1 100.0 - 96.6 3.4 94.6 5.4 100.0
OVERALL TOTAL: 2,289.1 1,240.9 5,046.3 566.9 39,167.1 779.4 46,502.5 2,587.2 49,089.7
Sector-Wise Percentage (Men:Wmn): 64.8 35.2 89.9 10.1 98.0 2.0 94.7 5.3 100.0
Sector Totals / Averages: 3,530.0 55.16 5,613.2 87.71 39,946.4 624.2 49,089.7 767.0
Sector Percentages: 7.19 11.43 81.37 100.00
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 129
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Annex Y: Per Capita Income of Affected Farmers by New 220kV Rohri Subproject
HH Size Total Income Per Capita Income (Rs./Person) No. Affected Farmer (HHH) (Persons) (Rs./Year) Annual Monthly Daily A: Dahrki - Ghotki Line : 1 Qasim Lashari 12 152960 12,746.67 1,062.22 34.92 2 Haji Muhammad Bachal 12 167210 13,934.17 1,161.18 38.18 3 Jamal Din 8 144500 18,062.50 1,505.21 49.49 4 Khan Muhammad Lashari 6 76180 12,696.67 1,058.06 34.79 5 Allah Diwaya 8 86760 10,845.00 903.75 29.71 6 Ghulam Farid Pitali 7 91230 13,032.86 1,086.07 35.71 7 Shafi Muhammad 5 76180 15,236.00 1,269.67 41.74 8 Hai Qadir Bux 9 97740 10,860.00 905.00 29.75 9 Ali Gohar 11 124400 11,309.09 942.42 30.98 10 Farid Lashari 21 234780 11,180.00 931.67 30.63 11 Jamal Din 9 98960 10,995.56 916.30 30.12 12 Waseer Muhammad 8 87670 10,958.75 913.23 30.02 13 Muhammad Usman 8 86760 10,845.00 903.75 29.71 14 Mansoor 8 88040 11,005.00 917.08 30.15 15 Mola Bux 5 75290 15,058.00 1,254.83 41.25 16 Haiji Ali Shair 9 100310 11,145.56 928.80 30.54 17 Ali Murad 8 82960 10,370.00 864.17 28.41 18 Khuda Bux 8 89620 11,202.50 933.54 30.69 19 Dodo Khan 7 80220 11,460.00 955.00 31.40 20 Haider Khan 8 97060 12,132.50 1,011.04 33.24 21 Islam shair 14 165380 11,812.86 984.40 32.36 22 Haji Bangal Khan 10 100310 10,031.00 835.92 27.48 23 Adil Laghari 7 81330 11,618.57 968.21 31.83 24 Ali Muhammad Khan Buzdar 13 194520 14,963.08 1,246.92 40.99 25 Asghar Buzdar 7 90820 12,974.29 1,081.19 35.55 26 Akbar Malik 5 84380 16,876.00 1,406.33 46.24 27 Nasir Ahmad 7 90820 12,974.29 1,081.19 35.55 28 Punhar Khan 14 233830 16,702.14 1,391.85 45.76 29 Atta Hussain 8 84040 10,505.00 875.42 28.78 30 Shah Nawaz 15 193840 12,922.67 1,076.89 35.40 31 Munir Ahmad 8 87160 10,895.00 907.92 29.85 32 Muhammad Khan 7 117240 16,748.57 1,395.71 45.89 33 Abdul Haq 11 135720 12,338.18 1,028.18 33.80 34 Muhammad Amjad 16 222180 13,886.25 1,157.19 38.04 35 Pholo Khan 8 97190 12,148.75 1,012.40 33.28 36 Imdad Hussain 8 90960 11,370.00 947.50 31.15 37 Abdul Latif 11 120040 10,912.73 909.39 29.90 38 Ali Gohar 19 219600 11,557.89 963.16 31.67 39 Abdul Wahid 7 116960 16,708.57 1,392.38 45.78 40 Bux Ali Mahar 8 129510 16,188.75 1,349.06 44.35 41 Raja Khan 15 281870 18,791.33 1,565.94 51.48 42 Mian Rung Ali Khan 7 87030 12,432.86 1,036.07 34.06 43 Sajan Matajo 8 84380 10,547.50 878.96 28.90 44 Khuda Bux 6 86760 14,460.00 1,205.00 39.62 45 Mian Ali Haider 5 76180 15,236.00 1,269.67 41.74 46 Aziz ur Rahman 7 91160 13,022.86 1,085.24 35.68
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 130
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
HH Size Total Income Per Capita Income (Rs./Person) No. Affected Farmer (HHH) (Persons) (Rs./Year) Annual Monthly Daily 47 Muhammad Usman 8 95580 11,947.50 995.63 32.73 48 Panjo Khan 7 84990 12,141.43 1,011.79 33.26 49 Jamo 11 136540 12,412.73 1,034.39 34.01 50 Muhammad Panjo 10 144520 14,452.00 1,204.33 39.59 51 Ata Bux 6 78620 13,103.33 1,091.94 35.90 52 Usman Ahmad 8 84040 10,505.00 875.42 28.78 53 Mirza Khan 7 96520 13,788.57 1,149.05 37.78 54 Abdul Rahim 6 78620 13,103.33 1,091.94 35.90 55 Abdul Baqir 8 98960 12,370.00 1,030.83 33.89 56 Raja 8 83030 10,378.75 864.90 28.43 57 Abdul Rahim 9 106230 11,803.33 983.61 32.34 58 Shah Muhammad 8 95300 11,912.50 992.71 32.64 59 Yunas Shah 7 84040 12,005.71 1,000.48 32.89 60 Jam Mahar 7 98960 14,137.14 1,178.10 38.73 61 Ali Muhammad 6 97190 16,198.33 1,349.86 44.38 62 Bunal Ali Shah 9 99070 11,007.78 917.31 30.16 63 Abdullah 8 98960 12,370.00 1,030.83 33.89 64 Ch Asghar 26 764530 29,405.00 2,450.42 80.56 65 Nabi Bux 9 98960 10,995.56 916.30 30.12 66 Muhammad Yaseen 7 75780 10,825.71 902.14 29.66 67 Ch Rasheed Ahmad 18 235870 13,103.89 1,091.99 35.90 Sub-Total (a): Line A: 621 8,338,350 871,669 72,639 2,388 Average 9 124,452.99 13,009.98 1,084.16 35.64 B: Ghotki- New Rohri Line : 1 Ch Rasheed Ahmad 18 235870 13,103.89 1,091.99 35.90 2 Nabi Bux 6 78180 13,030.00 1,085.83 35.70 3 Bachal Khan 7 82560 11,794.29 982.86 32.31 4 Haji Qasim 5 74660 14,932.00 1,244.33 40.91 5 Nizam Deen 7 84890 12,127.14 1,010.60 33.23 6 Ch Asghar 26 764530 29,405.00 2,450.42 80.56 7 Muhammad Yaseen 8 86080 10,760.00 896.67 29.48 8 Mushtaq Ahmad 7 78620 11,231.43 935.95 30.77 9 Akbar Ali 11 166730 15,157.27 1,263.11 41.53 10 Karam Ali 10 112210 11,221.00 935.08 30.74 11 Mumtaz Shaikh 8 85400 10,675.00 889.58 29.25 12 Nazir Ahmad 16 189640 11,852.50 987.71 32.47 13 Rustam Ali 11 151820 13,801.82 1,150.15 37.81 14 Araz Muhammad 12 134980 11,248.33 937.36 30.82 15 Bahadur Wasir 7 87940 12,562.86 1,046.90 34.42 16 Muhammad Yunas 9 171750 19,083.33 1,590.28 52.28 17 Atta ullah 7 80870 11,552.86 962.74 31.65 18 Ali Bux 6 87980 14,663.33 1,221.94 40.17 19 Ch Akram 23 531510 23,109.13 1,925.76 63.31 20 Rustam Khan (Tanent) 8 99430 12,428.75 1,035.73 34.05 21 Ali Hassan Khan (Tanent) 7 82690 11,812.86 984.40 32.36 22 Shah Nawaz Khan (Tanent) 9 107220 11,913.33 992.78 32.64 23 Yunas (Tanent) 6 115680 19,280.00 1,606.67 52.82 24 M Yusaf (Tanent) 8 107090 13,386.25 1,115.52 36.67 25 Tariq Hussain (Tanent) 7 83370 11,910.00 992.50 32.63
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 131
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
HH Size Total Income Per Capita Income (Rs./Person) No. Affected Farmer (HHH) (Persons) (Rs./Year) Annual Monthly Daily 26 Abdul Khaliq (Tanent) 10 117930 11,793.00 982.75 32.31 27 Ghulam Ali 9 107710 11,967.78 997.31 32.79 28 Nasrullah 6 66420 11,070.00 922.50 30.33 29 Rahmat Ali 7 94310 13,472.86 1,122.74 36.91 30 Muhammad Mussa 7 74360 10,622.86 885.24 29.10 31 Deen Muhammad 8 98960 12,370.00 1,030.83 33.89 32 Muhammad Sabul 6 66340 11,056.67 921.39 30.29 33 Ahmad Khan 7 88110 12,587.14 1,048.93 34.49 34 Rasool Bux 5 69410 13,882.00 1,156.83 38.03 35 Abdul Shakoor 7 77470 11,067.14 922.26 30.32 36 Muhammad Qasim 7 77180 11,025.71 918.81 30.21 37 Abdul Latif 6 63290 10,548.33 879.03 28.90 38 Abdul Rasheed 9 104630 11,625.56 968.80 31.85 39 Muhammad Wazir 9 106090 11,787.78 982.31 32.30 40 Abdul Aziz 7 76700 10,957.14 913.10 30.02 41 Fiaz Muhammad 5 58870 11,774.00 981.17 32.26 42 Shair Muhammad 8 97000 12,125.00 1,010.42 33.22 43 Muhammad Hassan 5 68160 13,632.00 1,136.00 37.35 44 Muhammad Sadiq 6 79930 13,321.67 1,110.14 36.50 45 Muhammad Ayaz 8 98960 12,370.00 1,030.83 33.89 46 Haji Khan 17 215530 12,678.24 1,056.52 34.73 47 Yar Muhammad 18 274410 15,245.00 1,270.42 41.77 48 Noor Hassan 8 101600 12,700.00 1,058.33 34.79 49 Nasrullah 9 134100 14,900.00 1,241.67 40.82 50 Shahzada 10 147760 14,776.00 1,231.33 40.48 51 Aman Ullah 16 221630 13,851.88 1,154.32 37.95 52 Sijad hussain 10 129200 12,920.00 1,076.67 35.40 53 Nazir Hussain 8 85400 10,675.00 889.58 29.25 54 Hussain Bux 9 133520 14,835.56 1,236.30 40.65 55 Abdul Khaliq Dad 5 56930 11,386.00 948.83 31.19 56 Arab Bullah 21 379460 18,069.52 1,505.79 49.51 57 Jam Saif Ullah 28 1035640 36,987.14 3,082.26 101.33 58 Baig Kata 8 145840 18,230.00 1,519.17 49.95 59 Satar Jonajo 12 153860 12,821.67 1,068.47 35.13 60 Kutab Junajo 18 225020 12,501.11 1,041.76 34.25 61 Malik Agla Khan 13 156570 12,043.85 1,003.65 33.00 62 Muhammad Sharif 19 269780 14,198.95 1,183.25 38.90 63 Sana Ullah 7 84040 12,005.71 1,000.48 32.89 64 Abdul Sitar 6 92860 15,476.67 1,289.72 42.40 65 Kul Baig 13 168770 12,982.31 1,081.86 35.57 66 Pahalwan Sammar 19 357870 18,835.26 1,569.61 51.60 67 Ram Talla 7 80980 11,568.57 964.05 31.69 68 Anwar Summar 16 203820 12,738.75 1,061.56 34.90 69 Muhammad Bux 9 142330 15,814.44 1,317.87 43.33 70 Ibrahim 10 124710 12,471.00 1,039.25 34.17 71 Mahram Khan 13 170800 13,138.46 1,094.87 36.00 72 Dhani Bux 6 75910 12,651.67 1,054.31 34.66 73 Ubaid Ullah 7 81330 11,618.57 968.21 31.83 74 Imam Bux 9 106410 11,823.33 985.28 32.39
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 132
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
HH Size Total Income Per Capita Income (Rs./Person) No. Affected Farmer (HHH) (Persons) (Rs./Year) Annual Monthly Daily 75 Ghulam Haider 8 100440 12,555.00 1,046.25 34.40 76 Allah Jorio 9 92860 10,317.78 859.81 28.27 77 Muhammad Bux 8 128100 16,012.50 1,334.38 43.87 78 Muhammad Nawab 7 82500 11,785.71 982.14 32.29 79 Abdul Raheem 7 94210 13,458.57 1,121.55 36.87 80 Ali Khan 6 77270 12,878.33 1,073.19 35.28 81 Raza Muhammad Jagirani 18 555780 30,876.67 2,573.06 84.59 82 Muhammad Khan (Tanent) 21 281100 13,385.71 1,115.48 36.67 83 Muhammad Rasheed Jatoi 24 747610 31,150.42 2,595.87 85.34 84 Ghulam Nabi (Tanent) 21 381600 18,171.43 1,514.29 49.78 85 Abdul Sami 18 355160 19,731.11 1,644.26 54.06 86 Aziz Ullah Khoso 17 491600 28,917.65 2,409.80 79.23 87 Abdul Razaq Khoso 14 183000 13,071.43 1,089.29 35.81 88 Khan Muhammad 9 101570 11,285.56 940.46 30.92 89 Muhammad Juman 9 116560 12,951.11 1,079.26 35.48 90 Sardar Ali 11 145380 13,216.36 1,101.36 36.21 91 Shafqat Mirani 12 131490 10,957.50 913.13 30.02 92 Muhammad Ali Khoso 13 166060 12,773.85 1,064.49 35.00 93 Haqim Labano 12 161310 13,442.50 1,120.21 36.83 94 Lal Muhammad Mangi 10 130920 13,092.00 1,091.00 35.87 95 Muhammad Bux 23 2075880 90,255.65 7,521.30 247.28 Sub-Total (b): Line B: 1,019 17,730,010 1,421,330 118,444 3,894 Average: 10.73 186,631.68 14,961.37 1,246.78 40.99 AB: Connecting Line A to B: 1 Ch Asghar 26 764,530.00 29,405.00 2,450.42 80.56 Sub-Total (ab): Line AB: 26 764,530.00 29,405.00 2,450.42 80.56 Average: 26 764,530.00 29,405.00 2,450.42 80.56 C: New RohrI - Shikarpur Line 1 Nasir Ahmad 28 329670 11,773.93 981.16 32.26 2 M Nazal Dandan 11 117830 10,711.82 892.65 29.35 3 Ghulam Muhammad 10 109560 10,956.00 913.00 30.02 4 Bashir Ahmad 8 87670 10,958.75 913.23 30.02 5 Gobar Faqir 7 75330 10,761.43 896.79 29.48 6 Ali Nawaz 8 90330 11,291.25 940.94 30.93 7 Faiz Muhammad Chandio 9 102370 11,374.44 947.87 31.16 8 Mukhtar Ahmad 9 97000 10,777.78 898.15 29.53 9 Ghulam Ali 15 202130 13,475.33 1,122.94 36.92 10 Ali Dino 10 107330 10,733.00 894.42 29.41 11 Shafi Muhammad 13 145560 11,196.92 933.08 30.68 12 Ahmad Ali 27 487330 18,049.26 1,504.10 49.45 13 Wali Muhammad 15 176800 11,786.67 982.22 32.29 14 Shabir Ahmad Khoso 16 192110 12,006.88 1,000.57 32.90 15 Haji Akbar 25 416110 16,644.40 1,387.03 45.60 16 Sikander 21 298780 14,227.62 1,185.63 38.98 17 Ali Nawaz 29 616220 21,248.97 1,770.75 58.22 18 Sardu 8 93000 11,625.00 968.75 31.85 19 Shafi Muhammad Jatoi 31 587000 18,935.48 1,577.96 51.88 20 Ali Shair (Tanent) 10 109670 10,967.00 913.92 30.05 21 Long Jatoi 24 552330 23,013.75 1,917.81 63.05 LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 133
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
HH Size Total Income Per Capita Income (Rs./Person) No. Affected Farmer (HHH) (Persons) (Rs./Year) Annual Monthly Daily 22 Jahangir Jatoi 32 827110 25,847.19 2,153.93 70.81 23 Jamal Khan Kharos 33 717220 21,733.94 1,811.16 59.55 24 Haji Yar Muhammad 9 101710 11,301.11 941.76 30.96 25 Muhammad Paral 12 125160 10,430.00 869.17 28.58 26 Faqir Yar Muhammad 8 87720 10,965.00 913.75 30.04 27 Muhammad Bux Mahar 8 89220 11,152.50 929.38 30.55 28 Faiz Muhammad Labano 8 85440 10,680.00 890.00 29.26 29 Nabi bux 9 93110 10,345.56 862.13 28.34 30 Anwar Khan 26 560890 21,572.69 1,797.72 59.10 31 Wali Muhammad 9 105110 11,678.89 973.24 32.00 32 Peer Bux 10 108110 10,811.00 900.92 29.62 33 Sumar Muhammad 8 93890 11,736.25 978.02 32.15 34 Yar Muhammad 8 89000 11,125.00 927.08 30.48 35 Khuda Bux 10 107220 10,722.00 893.50 29.38 36 Ismail Merani 16 214440 13,402.50 1,116.88 36.72 37 Ghulam Qadir 12 132560 11,046.67 920.56 30.26 38 Sadina 12 128240 10,686.67 890.56 29.28 39 Zamir 9 100230 11,136.67 928.06 30.51 40 Lal Bux 9 92670 10,296.67 858.06 28.21 41 Muhammad Zamir 8 87000 10,875.00 906.25 29.79 42 Yar Muhammad 16 276330 17,270.63 1,439.22 47.32 43 Elahi Bux 14 157670 11,262.14 938.51 30.86 44 Bacha 14 164110 11,722.14 976.85 32.12 45 Ghulam Shabir 20 306330 15,316.50 1,276.38 41.96 46 Ghulam Hussain 9 95330 10,592.22 882.69 29.02 47 Manzoor Hussain 13 139780 10,752.31 896.03 29.46 48 Haji Maca 9 100560 11,173.33 931.11 30.61 49 Noor Khan 9 106560 11,840.00 986.67 32.44 50 Anwar Bhato 8 87670 10,958.75 913.23 30.02 51 Nazir Ahmad Shaikh 19 309560 16,292.63 1,357.72 44.64 52 Munawar Khan 9 100890 11,210.00 934.17 30.71 53 Haji Abdul Aziz 9 G97600 10,844.44 903.70 29.71 54 Abdul Sami Khan 13 202670 15,590.00 1,299.17 42.71 55 Gulshan Barohi 13 168110 12,931.54 1,077.63 35.43 56 Ghos Bux Mahar 20 357660 17,883.00 1,490.25 48.99 57 Shahzada 17 287110 16,888.82 1,407.40 46.27 58 Rahmat Ullah Barohi 19 207120 10,901.05 908.42 29.87 59 Jabal Khan 27 332160 12,302.22 1,025.19 33.70 60 Phulapotar 10 111500 11,150.00 929.17 30.55 61 Dr Ibrahim 15 165560 11,037.33 919.78 30.24 62 Abdul Hakim 32 447330 13,979.06 1,164.92 38.30 63 Muhammad Yusaf 22 423670 19,257.73 1,604.81 52.76 64 Qamer Deen 10 173110 17,311.00 1,442.58 47.43 65 Sachal 15 243890 16,259.33 1,354.94 44.55 66 Naz Muhammad 8 84330 10,541.25 878.44 28.88 67 Ali Akbar 9 97220 10,802.22 900.19 29.60 68 Tanseer Bhoto 11 128890 11,717.27 976.44 32.10 69 Abdullah Barohi 12 130330 10,860.83 905.07 29.76 70 Guy Khan Bolani 6 472760 78,793.33 6,566.11 215.87
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 134
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
HH Size Total Income Per Capita Income (Rs./Person) No. Affected Farmer (HHH) (Persons) (Rs./Year) Annual Monthly Daily 71 Abdul Rahman Sumro 11 134670 12,242.73 1,020.23 33.54 72 Irfan Ahmad 10 153330 15,333.00 1,277.75 42.01 73 Muhammad Tafu 12 289000 24,083.33 2,006.94 65.98 74 Waliat Lar Baloch 11 132600 12,054.55 1,004.55 33.03 75 Haji Faqir Muhammad 16 3060020 191,251.25 15,937.60 523.98 76 Abdullah Mughal (Tanent) 19 733670 38,614.21 3,217.85 105.79 77 Noor Deen Khan 16 506820 31,676.25 2,639.69 86.78 78 Abdul Rahman Jafri 11 258000 23,454.55 1,954.55 64.26 Sub-Total (c): Line C: 1,104 20,184,100 1,336,212 111,351 3,661 Average: 14.15 258,770.51 17,130.92 1,427.58 46.93 D: New Rohri Sub-station 1 Qadir Bux 21 316220 15,058.10 1,254.84 41.26 2 Ali Gohar 9 116690 12,965.56 1,080.46 35.52 3 Faqir Muhammad 13 646410 49,723.85 4,143.65 136.23 4 Ghulam Akbar 14 239930 17,137.86 1,428.15 46.95 5 Ghulam Akbar S/O Qadir Bux 34 497530 14,633.24 1,219.44 40.09 6 Javaid Shah 9 203110 22,567.78 1,880.65 61.83 Sub-Total (d): Sub-station: 100 2,019,890 132,086 11,007 362 Average: 16.67 336648 22014 1835 60 OVERALL TOTAL: 2,870 49,036,880 3,790,702 315,892 10,385 OVERALL AVERAGE 11.62 198529.88 15346.97 1278.91 42.05
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007
Page 135
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
APPENDIX 2: LIST OF PARTICIPANTS IN GROUP DISCUSSIONS/CONSULTATION SESSIONS
Men's Groups Women's Groups N o. Name Status AH No. Name Status AH Village 1: Eaden Lashari Village 1: Eaden Lashari Group 1: 1st Jully 2007 Group 1: 1st Jully 2007 Shafi Mohammed S/O Mohammed 1 Ramzan Landowner AH 1 Laiqa Bibi House-Wife AH 2 Ghulam Fareed Pitafi Landowner AH 2 Parveen Akhtar House-Wife AH 3 Haji Qadir Bux S/O Eaden Lashari Landowner AH 3 Shazia Shabbir Teacher AH 4 Hakeem Khan Lashari Landowner AH 4 Huma Riaz Paramedic - 5 Fareed Ahmed Leghari Landowner AH 5 Afshan Begum Student AH 6 Mohammed Qasim Leghari Shopkeeper AH 6 Muniba Habib Teacher AH 7 Allah Wasayo Lashari Sharecropper - 7 Safeera Maqbool House-Wife AH 8 Jamal Ahmed Leghari Lease Tenant - 8 Hafeeza Bashir House-Wife - 9 Allah Diwayo Lashari Landowner AH 9 Munazza Ara NGO Worker AH 10 Abdul Raheem Manghan Teacher - 10 Imtiaz Bibi House-Wife - Village 2: Aror Village 2: Aror Group 2: 3rd Jully 2007 Group 2: 3rd Jully 2007 11 Qadir Baksh Landowner AH 11 Ghulam Roqia House-Wife AH 12 Ghulam Akbar Landowner AH 12 Hifza Bibi House-Wife AH 13 Abdul Rashid LO +Advocate AH 13 Mahnaz Bibi Teacher - 14 Ali Gohar Landowner AH 14 Rehana Student - 15 Faqir Muhammad Landowner AH 15 Shazia Paramedic AH 16 Javaid Shah Landowner AH 16 Afsar Begum House-Wife AH 17 Husain Bux Shopkeeper - 17 Maryam Bibi Tailor + HW - 18 Ahmad Den Labour - 18 Robina Rashid Teacher AH Village 3: Goth Ibrahim Village 3: Goth Ibrahim Group 3: 28th June 2007 Group 3: 28th June 2007 19 Abdl Latif Landowner AH 19 Shahnaz Teacher - 20 Abdul Raheem Landowner AH 20 Gulnaz House-Wife AH 21 Wazir Machi Landowner AH 21 Sadia House-Wife - 22 Abdul Aziz Landowner AH 22 Safia House-Wife AH 23 Faiz Muhammad Teacher - 23 Noreen Teacher AH 24 Shair Muhammad Student AH 24 Nazia House-Wife AH 25 Muhammad Hassan Sharecropper - 25 Saima Teacher AH 26 Rahem Dad Labour - Village 4: Goth Ch. Rasheed 27 Waqar Hussain Landowner AH Group 4: 27th June 2007 Village 4: Goth Ch. Rasheed 26 Zahida Bibi House-Wife AH Group 4: 27th June 2007 27 Shabnam Teacher AH 28 Mohammad Yaseen Landowner AH 28 Rahima Bibi House-Wife - 29 Imran Ali Landowner AH 29 Nabiha Ara Student AH 30 Ghulam Mustafa LO + Tenant AH 30 Sahira Student - 31 Asghar Ali LO + Tenant AH 31 Ummi Kulsoom Teacher - 32 Muhammad Sachal Landowner AH 32 Samina Mid Wife AH 33 Muhammad Akbar Student - 33 Shamim Teacher AH 34 Irfan Ali Lease Tenant - 34 Shakila Labour - 35 Muhammad Tahir Shopkeeper - - - - - 36 Mumtaz Ahmad Teacher - - - - -
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 136
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Village 5: Nandi Patni Village 5: Nandi Patni Group 5: 25th Aug 2007 Group 5: 25th Aug 2007 37 Ghulam Muhammad Landowner AH 35 Ghulam Ruqaia House-Wife AH 38 Bashir Ahmad Landowner AH 36 Aysha House-Wife AH 39 Nasir Ahmad Landowner AH 37 Madi Bibi House-Wife AH 40 Ali Deno Landowner AH 38 Bibi Halima Teacher AH 41 Ghulam Ali Landowner AH 39 Hajira House-Wife - 42 Faiz Mohammad Landowner AH 40 Mariam Teacher - 43 Khalid Ahmad Driver - 41 Sadea Student - 44 Iftikhar Ahmad Shopkeeper - 42 Saima Akbar Student - 45 Muhammad Akbar Khan Labour - 43 Sajida Govt. Servent - 46 Mukhtar Ahmad Chandio Shopkeeper - - - - - Village 6: Bagarge Village 6: Bagarge Group 6: 27th Aug 2007 Group 6: 27th Aug 2007 47 Jahangir Jatoi Landowner AH 44 Kubra House-Wife AH 48 Jamal Khan Landowner AH 45 Hameeda Bibi House-Wife AH 49 Yar Muhammad Landowner AH 46 Kanza House-Wife AH 50 Ibrahim Khoso Tanent AH 47 Kainat Student - 51 Wazir muhammad Tanent AH 48 Kainat Bibi Mid wife - 52 Faqir Muhammad Driver - 49 Hafsa Batool House-Wife AH 53 Abdul Qadir Driver - 50 Maryam Bibi Tailor - Village 7: Luckhy Village 7: Luckhy Group 7: 30th Aug 2007 Group 7: 30th Aug 2007 54 Ghulam Hussain Landowner AH 51 Zubada Naeem House-Wife AH 55 Noor Khan Landowner AH 52 Wahida Parween House-Wife AH 56 Haji Maica Landowner AH 53 Shamim Begum House-Wife AH 57 Anwar Bhato Landowner AH 54 Parween Khtoon Teacher - 58 Ahmad Shaikh Landowner - 55 Amina Begum Teacher - 59 Ghulam Muhammad Landowner - 56 Afzal Khatoon Student - 60 Mumtaz Ahmad Sharecropper - 57 Anisa Begum Student AH 61 ilam Deen Labour - - - - - 62 Anwar Ahmad Teacher - Village 8: Lodra 63 Fazal Dad Govt. Servent - Group 8: 2nd Sep 2007 64 Mohammad Khan Landowner - 58 Shahina Batool House-Wife AH Village 8: Lodra 59 Karima Mai House-Wife AH Group 8: 2nd Sep 2007 60 Shamim Akhtar House-Wife AH 65 Noor deen Khan Landowner AH 61 Shakira Bibi Student - 66 Muhammad Jafar Landowner AH 62 Shakira Student - 67 Ghulam Hussan Tanent AH 63 Naheda Nasreen House-Wife - 68 Hashim Khan Tanent AH 64 Mania Bibi Student - 69 Muhammad Murid Shopkeeper AH 65 Malkani Labour - 70 Fahim Ahmad Labour - - - - - 71 Fazal Karim Labour - - - - -
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 137
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
APPENDIX 3 – DRAFT PUBLIC INFORMATION BROCHURE
Pakistan Power Transmission Enhancement Program New 220kV Rohri Sub-station and Associated Transmission Lines Subproject
National Transmission and Dispatch Company Government of Pakistan
September 2007
Land Acquisition and Resettlement Impacts Compensation/Rehabilitation: Information Booklet
A. GENERAL 1. The National Transmission and Dispatch Company (NTDC) is intending to take a loan from the Asian Development Bank (ADB) to implement the Power Transmission Enhancement Program (PTEP) aiming at upgrading and extending the transmission network to expanding the capacity and coverage of the network. The project will be implemented over five to six years, and will include a number of tranches or groups of subprojects. 2. The first tranche included some 21 subprojects including three new sub-stations, expansion of existing sub-stations, and installation of associated transmission lines; 18 of the subprojects will not cause any resettlement impacts as they entail transformers being installed within an existing sub-station site and no works beyond the existing sub-station site boundaries. There are four subprojects (including this New 220kV Rohri Sub-station and Associated Transmission Lines Subproject) that required permanent land acquisition for the sub-station, and temporary crop and tree losses for during the construction (Foundation and erection of towers and stringing of power cables) of the associated transmission lines, namely: (A) Dharaki – Ghotki; (B) Ghotki – Rohri; and, (AB) Connecting Line from A to B. 3. The Mari Power Plant at Dharaki will be constructed by the Foundation Power Company of the Fauji Foundation and the Engo Power Plant will be constructed Ghotki by the Engo Fertilizer Company, Dharaki, as independent power generation units in Sind Province. Both the IPPs have already purchased lands for setting up their power plants at their respective sites, on a voluntary sale basis against the prevalent market prices in the respective areas. They have both already initiated land leveling and initial foundation works, to be followed shortly by the construction works, and eventually by the installation of generators, and the associated equipment and the transmission lines. The New 220kV Rohri subproject will will supply additional power from the two power plants to the New Rohri Sub-station and the existing 220kV sub-station at Shikarpur and enhance its capacity for the entire Northern Sindh region. 4. The subproject will be implemented in the area where you live starting later in 2007 and will affect crops and trees in your communities. To compensate and/or rehabilitate these losses the provisions of relevant Pakistan laws and of the ADB
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 138
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Policy on Involuntary Resettlement will be adopted. This has included the preparation of a Land Acquisition and Resettlement Framework (LARF) setting out the basic compensation/rehabilitation provisions for the PTEP and a Land Acquisition and Resettlement Plan (LARP) providing data on impacts and affected families and indicating in detail how the impacts will be compensated or rehabilitated has been prepared for each subproject that requires temporary disturbance to land and subsequent compensation for crops and trees . 5. Both the LARF and the LARP in Urdu language will be available for perusal to anyone interested at the Project Implementation Unit in Rahim Yar Khan district. This booklet summarizing the provisions of the LARF and the LARP for the New Jarwar – Sadiqabad 132 kV Transmission Line Subproject is given to all the families whose land, trees and crops and incomes are affected by this subproject. The objective of this booklet is to inform them of the essential compensation and rehabilitation policy for the New Jarwar – Sadiqabad 132 kV Transmission Line Subproject and of a number of basic issues relative to the implementation of the compensation and rehabilitation program.
B. PRINCIPLES FOR COMPENSATION AND/OR REHABILITATION OF AFFECTED FAMILIES Principles for the compensation/rehabilitation of affected people (AHs) by the New Jarwar – Sadiqabad 132 kV Transmission Line Subproject are: 1. Land acquisition will be avoided and acquisition will only occur where access to, or use of, an AH’s land is affected; 2. Compensation will guarantee the maintenance of the AHs pre-project living standards; 3. AHs will be fully informed/consulted on compensation options; 4. AHs’ socio-cultural institutions will be supported and used; 5. Land acquisition provisions will equally apply to women and men; 6. Lack of formal title will not impede rehabilitation of families losing land; 7. Particular attention will be paid to women-headed households and vulnerable groups; 8. Land acquisition budgets will be included in project costs; and 9. Compensation will be fully provided prior to ground leveling and demolition.
C. COMPENSATION AND REHABILITATION ELIGIBILITY AND ENTITLEMENTS All families residing in affected areas and holding affected assets or incomes before the eligibility cut-off date for the project 21st August 2007 (the date of the end of the impact survey) will be entitled to compensation and/or rehabilitation for their losses. This provision includes legal owners, sharecroppers and leaseholders and squatters as detailed in table 1 below.
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 139
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Table 1 - Eligibility and Entitlements Matrix
Asset Specification Affected Compensation Entitlements People Arable Land Access is not Farmer, No compensation for land provided that the land is rehabilitated/restored restricted and Titleholder to its former quality following completion of works; existing or Compensation, in cash, for all damaged crops and trees as per item current land below use will remain Leaseholder No compensation for land provided that the land is rehabilitated/restored unchanged (registered or to its former quality following completion of works; not) Compensation, in cash, for all damaged crops and trees as per item below Sharecroppers Compensation, in cash or kind, for all damaged crops and trees as per (registered or item below not) Agri. workers Compensation, in cash or kind, for all damaged crops and trees as per item below Squatters Compensation, in cash, for all damaged crops and trees as per item below All adverse Land for land compensation with plots of equal value and productivity to Arable Land effects on land Farmer, the plots lost; or; where access use Titleholder Cash compensation for affected land at replacement cost based on is restricted independent of market value b free of taxes, registration, and transfer costs plus 15% and/or land severity of Compulsory Acquisition Surcharge use will be impact Leaseholder Renewal of lease in other plots of equal value/productivity of plots lost, affected (registered or or Cash equivalent to market value of gross yield of affected land for the not) remaining lease years (up to a maximum of 3 years).
Sharecroppers Cash compensation equal to the market value of the lost harvest share (registered or once (temporary impact) or twice (permanent impact) not) Agricultural Cash indemnity corresponding to their salary (including portions in kind) workers losing for the remaining part of the agricultural year. their contract Squatters 1 rehabilitation allowance equal to market value of 1 gross harvest (in addition to crop compensation) for land use loss. Additional Farmer, 1 severe impact allowance equal to market value of gross harvest of the provisions for Titleholder affected land for 1 year (inclusive of winter and summer crop and severe Leaseholder additional to standard crop compensation) impacts Sharecroppers 1 severe impact allowance equal to market value of share of harvest lost (More than (registered or (additional to standard crop compensation) 10% of land not) loss) Squatters 1 severe impact allowance equal to market value of gross harvest of the affected land for 1 year (inclusive of winter and summer crop and additional to standard crop compensation) Residential/ Titleholder Land for land compensation through provision of a plots comparable in Commercial value/location to plot lost or cash compensation for affected land at full Land replacement cost free of taxes, registration, and transfer costs Renter, 1-3 months allowance Leaseholder Squatters Accommodation in a government resettlement area or a self-relocation allowance Houses and All relevant AHs Cash compensation at replacement rates for affected structure and Structures (incl. squatters) other fixed assets. In case of partial impacts full cash assistance to restore remaining structure. Crops Crops affected All AHs (incl. Cash compensation at full market rate for the net harvest actually lost squatters (winter or summer crop or both as it is the case) Trees Trees affected All AHs (incl. Cash compensation shall reflect income replacement squatters)
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 140
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Asset Specification Affected Compensation Entitlements People Business Temporary or All AHs Business owner: (i) Cash compensation equal to one year income, if Employment permanent (incl. squatters) loss is permanent; (ii) cash compensation for the period of business loss of interruption, if loss is temporary. business or Worker/employees: Indemnity for lost wages for the period of business employment interruption up to a maximum of 3 months. Relocation Transport and All AHs affected Provision of sufficient allowance to cover transport expenses and transitional by relocation livelihood expenses for one month. For those subproject the allowance livelihood has been set at PRs. 5.000 costs Community Rehabilitation/substitution of the affected structures/utilities (i.e. assets mosques, footbridges, roads, schools, health centers, etc..) Vulnerable AH below Employment priority in project-related jobs. AH livelihood poverty line
D. Compensation Assessment for Affected Crops and Trees The following five tables (Tables A-2 to A-6) provide the bases for assessment of compensations for the affected agricultural crops and fruit and wood trees.
Table A-1: Categorization and Income Replacement of Affected Fruit Trees (Rohri) Name of Categorization No. of Fruit Potential for Fruiting Income Affected Maturity Age Harvests Period Annual Replacement No. Fruit Tree Level (Years) Year (Years) Income (Rs) Value (Rs.) 1 Date Palm Immature Up to 10 0 18 2,675 48,150 Mature-1 10 - 22 1 12 2,450 29,400 Mature-2 above 22 1 6 1,725 10,350 2 Mango Immature Up to 10 0 15 2,650 39,750 Mature-1 10 – 20 1 10 2,250 22,500 Mature-2 above 20 1 5 1,725 8,625
Table A-2: Number and Compensation of Affected Fruit Trees (Rohri)
Name of Affected Fruit Tree (No.) Compensation Total Price Line Line Line No. Fruit Tree Category A B AB Line C D. Grid Total Rate (Rs.) (Rs.)
1 Date Palm Immature 0 0 0 48 0 48 48,150 2,311,200
Mature-1 0 0 0 289 0 289 29,400 8,496,600
Mature-2 0 9 0 176 0 185 10,350 1,914,750
Sub-total (a): Date-Palm 0 9 0 513 0 522 - 12,722,550
2 Mango Immature 0 0 0 5 0 5 39,750 198,750
Mature-1 1 0 0 8 0 9 22,500 202,500
Mature-2 1 0 0 7 0 8 8,625 69,000
Sub-total (b): Mango 2 0 0 20 0 22 - 470,250
TOTAL: 2 9 0 533 0 544 - 13,192,800
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 141
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Table A-3: Relative Sizes of Affected Wood Trees by Maximum Heights and Girths (Rohri)
Name of Small Medium Large No. Wood Tree Height (m) Girth (m) Height (m) Girth (m) Height (m) Girth (m) 1 Shisham up to 3.8 up to 0.5 3.9 - 7.6 0.5 - 0.9 7.7 & above 1.0 & above 2 Kikar up to 4.6 up to 0.3 4.6 - 9.1 0.4 - 0.5 9.1 & above 0.5 & above 3 Eucalyptus up to 3.0 up to 0.5 3.1 - 6.1 0.5 - 0.9 6.1 & above 1.0 & above 4 Mulberry up to 3.0 up to 0.5 3.1 - 6.1 0.5 - 0.9 6.1 & above 1.0 & above 5 Sirin/Saras up to 3.8 up to 0.5 3.9 - 7.6 0.5 - 0.9 7.7 & above 1.0 & above
Table A-4: Number and Compensation of Affected Wood Trees (Rohri)
Name of Relative Affected Wood Tree (No.) Market Rate Total Price No. Wood Tree Size Line A Line B Line AB Line C D. Grid Total (Rs.) (Rs.)
1 Shisham Small 3 18 0 9 0 30 4,200 126,000
Medium 2 13 0 3 0 18 6,500 117,000
Large 2 5 0 2 0 9 8,975 80,775
Sub-total (a): Shisham 7 36 0 14 0 57 - 323,775 Kikar 2 (Acasia) Small 4 9 0 7 0 20 3,550 71,000
Medium 3 11 0 0 0 14 4,800 67,200
Large 4 5 0 3 0 12 6,300 75,600
Sub-total (b): Kikar 11 25 0 10 0 46 - 213,800
3 Eucalyptus Small 1 1 0 0 0 2 2,450 4,900
Medium 0 0 0 1 0 1 4,500 4,500
Large 0 2 0 0 0 2 6,500 13,000
Sub-total (c): Eucalyptus 1 3 0 1 0 5 - 22,400
4 Mulberry Small 0 1 0 0 0 1 2,200 2,200
Medium 0 0 0 0 0 0 4,350 -
Large 1 2 0 0 0 3 6,400 19,200
Sub-total (d): Mulberry 1 3 0 0 0 4 - 21,400
5 Others Small 2 7 0 3 0 12 2,000 24,000
Medium 0 10 0 0 0 10 4,500 45,000
Large 3 2 0 1 0 6 6,200 37,200
Sub-total (e): Others 5 19 0 4 0 28 - 106,200
TOTAL: 20 67 0 25 0 140 - 687,575
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 142
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
E. SOME BASIC QUESTIONS RELATED TO THE IMPACTS COMPENSATION AND REHABILITATION PROGRAM FOR THE PROJECT
Question 1 - Do we need to have a land title in order to be compensated or rehabilitated?
Answer: No. Lack of formal legal rights (title) to land does not prevent AHs from receiving at least rehabilitation assistance. All AHs who were occupying or using the affected land at the time of the cut-off date (see above) will be entitled to compensation or at least rehabilitation under the project. Users of land with title or traditional rights (or who can prove they are legally using the land) who are affected by restricted access to, or use if, the land will be entitled to compensation for land and any assets on the land affected. Users of land who do not have title or traditional rights to land will be provided full compensation for any structures, crops or trees on land affected by the project and if their access to, or use of, the land is affected, will receive rehabilitation for land losses either in form of replacement land (if available) or in form of a cash allowance for land-use loss.
Question 2 - Does compensation apply to my house or structures?
Answer: Yes. Houses and any other structures (small shops, animal sheds, etc) that will be affected by the project shall be compensated at replacement cost so that owners can build another structure of the same size and standard.
Question 3 - What about my crops and trees?
Answer: Your affected crops and trees will also be compensated at current market value. Compensation for crops will be based on the anticipated harvest at market value, while compensation for trees will be based on the type, age and productivity of each tree affected.
Question 4 - Does the above mean that anybody in your community can claim compensation or rehabilitation?
Answer: No. The entitled affected families are only those who where residing in project affected areas and had affected assets at the time the impacts assessment and the affected people census was carried out. The cut-off-date for eligibility for this subproject is 14th January 2007 when the impact survey and the affected people census was completed. Anybody who encroaches into the area after the cut-off-date will not be entitled to compensation or any other form of resettlement assistance.
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 143
Power Transmission Enhancement Program
Question 5 - Do we need to vacate and clear the affected properties immediately after they have been identified as needed by the project?
Answer: No. Clearing the affected areas will only take place AFTER the compensation or rehabilitation for affected land or other lost assets and the appropriate subsidies have been provided to you. After the day in which compensation and rehabilitation was delivered to you, you will then have 1 month to clear the land. If you have not done so after a month the project will be allowed to enter your ex-property and clear the land for you.
Question 6 - If there is any disagreement regarding the way the compensation policy set up in the LARP has been implemented or any other issue relative to the compensation and rehabilitation program for the project do we have the right to complain, and if so how and where?
Answer: Yes. Any AH may file a complaint or grievance. AHs will first lodge a complaint with the land acquisition collector and the project implementation unit in Rohri district. If unanswered within 15 days, the complaint can then be lodged to NTDC’s project management unit in Lahore. Finally if the grievance is still not settled within 1 month, the AH can seek redress at the appropriate court. The village administrations and the Land Acquisition Coordination Committee (LACC) composed by senior members of the AH communities and by their elected representatives will assist the AH in these cases. The concerned land acquisition coordination committees will properly document all complaints and resolutions. AHs will be exempted from all taxes, administrative and legal fees associated with resolving the dispute.
Question 7 - Who can we contact for more information about the project?
Answer: For further information about the project as a whole, and/or the LARP for Rohri Subproject, or if you would like to receive a full copy of the Land Acquisition and Resettlement Framework (2006) for the project, please contact as the follows:
NATIONAL TRANSMISSION AND DISPATCH COMPANY Address: WAPDA House, Lahore Phone Number: +92-42-9202414 Contact person: M. Tahir Khan (Manager MTP)
LARP Rohri 220kV Subproject_ Final Draft_ November 2007 Page 144