DATA REPORT Sustainable Urban Transport Index (SUTI) for Asian Cities
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
DATA REPORT Sustainable Urban Transport Index (SUTI) for Asian Cities Dr. Muhammad Nanang Prayudyanto Ahmad Faris Saffan Sunarya, MSc. Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific Workshop on Sustainable Urban Transport Index Colombo, 30-31 October 2017 Indonesia Greater Jakarta GRDP US$ 108.7 mio Contribution to National: 18.48% Name of The City Area (Km2) Population (in Density Projection of million) (Pop/km2) 20 years Growth (%) JAKARTA (CITY) 662,33 10 ,08 15231,9 0,86 BOGOR REGENCY 2997,13 5,1 1705,8 1,22 BEKASI REGENCY 1269,51 2,81 2219,8 1,22 BOGOR (CITY) 111,73 1,03 9269,9 1,49 BEKASI (CITY) 213,58 2,54 11914,3 1,49 DEPOK (CITY) 199,44 1,89 9500,5 1,49 TANGERANG REGENCY 1011,86 3,13 3101,4 1,59 TANGERANG (CITY) 153,93 2,02 13163,6 1,99 SOUTH TANGERANG 147,19 1,45 9876,0 1,99 SELATAN (CITY) TOTAL 6766,7 30,1 Greater Jakarta Population trend in Metropolitan core and sub-urban areas Seoul MA 10 Bangkok MR 25 8 Total Total 20 6 15 SeoulCore-area City 4 Core-area 10 Suburb 2 population, million million population, population, 5 million million population, population, Suburb Population, million million Population, Population, Population, million million Population, Population, 0 0 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 20 Metro Manila* 25 Jabotabek 20 15 Total Total 15 10 M. ManilaCore Suburb 10 5 suburb 5 Core population, million million population, population, population, million million population, population, population, million million population, population, 0 million million population, population, 0 1980 1990 2000 1980 1990 2000 *Study Area of MMUTIS Decentralization of population? 3 Sustainable Urban Transport Index 01 02 03 04 05 Extent to which Modal share of Convenient access Public transport Traffic fatalities per transport plans active and public to public transport quality and 100.000 inhabitants cover public transport in service reliability transport, commuting intermodal facilities and infrastructure for active modes 06 07 08 09 10 Affordability – Operational costs Investment in Air quality (pm10 Greenhouse gas travel costs as part of the public public concentration) emissions of Income transport System transportation . systems . INDICATOR 1 Extent to which transport plans cover public transport, intermodal facilities and infrastructure for active modes SCORE NO COVERAGE 0 No goals -- No designation -- No budget 1 3 LIMITED CYCLING PUBLIC 1 Vague goal -- Little designation seen in plans -- NETWORK TRANSPORT Small or unclear budget MIDDLE 2 Qualitative goals -- Some designation in 1-2 WALKING INTERMODAL major areas/corridors -- Some budget NETWORK TRANSFER 2 FACILITIES 4 EXTENSIVE 3 Quantitative goals -- Much designation across city -- increased realistic budget LEADING 4 Ambitious goals -- Full designation across city - - Major secured new funding Indicative Scoring Criteria for Greater Jakarta Score 0 1 2 3 4 No coverage Limited Middle Extensive Leading I) WALKING Vague goal Qualitative goals Quantitative goals Ambitious goals NETWORKS No goals Little designation seen in Some designation in 1-2 Much designation across Full designation across No designation No plans major areas/corridors city city budget Small or unclear budget Some budget increased realistic Major secured new budget funding II) CYCLING Vague goal Qualitative goals Quantitative goals Ambitious goals NETWORKS No goals Little designation seen in Some designation in 1-2 Much designation across Full designation across No designation No plans major areas/corridors city city budget Small or unclear budget Some budget Increased Major secured new realistic budget funding III) INTERMODAL Vague goal Qualitative goals Quantitative goals Ambitious goals TRANSFER No goals Little designation seen in Some designation in 1-2 Much designation across Full designation across No designation No plans major areas/corridors city city FACILITIES budget Small or unclear budget Some budget Increased Major secured new realistic budget funding IV) PUBLIC Vague goal Qualitative goals Quantitative goals Ambitious goals TRANSPORT No goals Little designation seen in Some designation in 1-2 Much designation across Full designation across No designation No plans major areas/corridors city city budget Small or unclear budget Some budget Increased Major secured new realistic budget funding Walking Facilities Improvement 1. Walking Networks: KPI pedestrian access 2. Much designation (Jakarta, Kota Bekasi, Kota Bogor, Kota Tangerang, etc) 3. Budget: increased realistic budget Pedestrian Facilities Construction and Campaign 80 km pedestrian facilities in DKI Jakarta has been constructed in 2017. 24 km by Provincial and 56 km by Cities (5 Sub Provinces) Total budget: Rp. 412 bill. (± US$ 40 mio) Cycling Network 1. Cycling Networks: MoT and MPW Regulations on Pedestrian Facilities 2. Some designation (Jakarta, Kota Bogor, Kota Tangerang, etc) 3. Budget: some budget Intermodal Transfer Facilities Vending Machine 1. Intermodal at Railway Station Transfer: KPI P&R at Bogor Distance and Commuter Railway Station location in station and terminals 2. Much designation (Commuter Railway Stations P&R, Electronic Payment, BRT shelters, etc) Parking 3. Budget: increased at Railway Station realistic budget Development of Mass Public Transport System in Greater Jakarta: 2017 : Airport Railway 2017 : Elevated BRT 13rd Corridor in Jakarta (Tendean – Ciledug). Public 2018 : LRT Jabodetabek (Cawang – Cibubur) and LRT DKI Jakarta (Gading Nias – Transport Velodrome). 2019 : LRT Jabodetabek (Cawang – Bekasi Timur and Cawang – Dukuh Atas). 1. Public Transport: 2019 : MRT (Lebak Bulus – Bundaran HI). RITJ, PTM, Source: GJTA, 2017 Permenhub 54/2013 2. Full designation LRT Jabodetabek across cities (Trans Jabodetabek, JR Tunnel of Jakarta MRT Connection, JA Co, LRT, MRT, Commuter, Long distance rail, Ferry 3. Budget: major secured new funding INTEGRATED PUBLIC TRANSPORT NETWORK FOR GREATER JAKARTA Source: GJTA, 2016 GJTA, Source: INDICATOR 2 Modal Share of Active and Public Transport in Commuting Mode Economic Status Daily Trips Share Mode Share Lower income 8.314.748 16% Private cars and motorcycle ownership Motorcycle person grows inevitably as a natural effort by Medium Income 17.801.390 34% 53% trips each individual to fulfill their mobility needs. High Income 2.007.651 4% Lower income 1.211.348 2% low parking prices and subsidized fuel costs have affected the people’s decision to Car person trips Medium Income 7.233.139 14% 20% choose a private vehicle. High Income 2.056.607 4% Currently, Jakarta has two kinds of rapid Lower income 5.323.158 10% transit system : Transjakarta BRT and Public transport Commuter Rail (KRL) Medium Income 8.466.125 16% 27% person trips High Income 637.535 1% The KRL train headway is less convenient than TransJakarta because its frequent service Total Trips 53.051.701 100% 100% is only every 5-20 minutes per train Source: Japtrapis, 2012 Public Transport Masterplan Rail total : 159 km, 127 stations, 2 Operators 2 m trips/day 40% PT 60% Total PT Trips LRT : 29 km, 43 stations ~ 6 m/day 3.1 m trips/day 0.9 m trips/day Buses : 350 routes, 3700 buses, 4000 route- km, 2 Operators Taxis : 25,000 (7 Operators) Public Transport Modal Share Source: Japtrapis (JICA-MoT, 2012) 15 INDICATOR 3 Convenient Access to Public Transport Service Total Districts Serviced Assumed Serviced Population Area Kota Jakarta Utara 95 1,221,704.77 Kota Jakarta Timur 156 2,456,764.88 Kota Jakarta Selatan 144 2,049,088.43 Kota Jakarta Barat 112 2,222,822.38 Kota Jakarta Pusat 51 948,160.34 Bogor 164 899,878.47 Kota Bogor 60 604,988.31 Kota Depok 93 1,062,996.60 Tangerang 105 206,458.31 Kota Tangerang 87 1,054,938.09 Kota Tangerang Selatan 80 840,183.19 Bekasi 82 559,526.51 Kota Bekasi 73 1,180,666.94 Total 15,308,177.23 Ratio to total Greater Jakarta 51% population (%) INDICATOR 4 INDICATOR -4 Public transport quality and reliability INDICATOR -4 INDICATOR Source: GJTA Primary Survey, 2017 Source: Japtrapis, 2012 Source: GJTA Primary Survey, 2017 INDICATOR 5 INDICATOR -5 Traffic fatalities per 100.000 inhabitants 1,200 Seriously Material Loss 1,000 Year No of Accidents Fatalities Injured Injured (Rp. Mio) 2010 8,235 1,048 3,473 5,820 17,744 800 2011 8,079 1,008 2,820 6,312 18,102 y = -49.279x + 100000 2012 8,020 912 2,938 6,153 21,885 600 R² = 0.6049 2013 6,498 676 2,925 4,711 23,794 fatalities 2014 6,574 605 3,088 568 23,149 400 Source: Traffic Police, 2015 200 Fatalities by Mode - 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 INDICATOR -5 INDICATOR Fatalities Jakarta (Polda Metro as Jabodetabek minus Kab. Bogor and Kab. Tangerang) Car Truck No. of fatalities= 605. Population= 30 mio. Bus Motorcycle Traffic Fatalities per 100.000= Statistical Bureau from Jakarta Metro Police (2015) 605/(30.000.000/100.000)= 2.1 INDICATOR 6 INDICATOR -6 Affordability – travel costs as part of Income Average Daily Spending by Mode Bus : Rp. 30,271 (around $ 2.33) Private Car : Rp. 121,049 ($ 9.31) Taxi : Rp. 89,574 ($ 6.89) Rail : Rp. 30,712 ($ 2.36) Motor Cycle : Rp. 26,931 ($ 2.07) Average : Rp. 53,453 ($ 4.11) Monthly transport expenditure is $4.11x25 days= $ 102.75 Greater Jakarta Transport Authority Survey, 2017 INDICATOR -6 INDICATOR Average Monthly Income Jakarta : $ 14,727 West Java : $ 2,538 Banten : $ 3,115 The transport cost from monthly income Average : $ 6,793 = $ 102.75/ $ 566 Average monthly income: $ 566 = 18.2%. Statistical Bureau, 2016 INDICATOR -7 INDICATOR 7 Operational costs of the public transport System The study from BPTJ (2017) from 29 routes of large buses in Greater Jakarta shows that : 6 routes of Trans Jakarta are subsidised by Jakarta govt. the tariff of Rp. 3,500 is under the operating cost of Rp. 11,000 9 routes operates by private that tariff is same as operation cost, mostly operate by PT.