The Marrow of Human Experience
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Utah State University DigitalCommons@USU All USU Press Publications USU Press 2006 The Marrow of Human Experience William A. Wilson Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.usu.edu/usupress_pubs Part of the Folklore Commons, and the History of Religion Commons Recommended Citation Wilson, W. A., Rudy, J. T., & Call, D. (2006). The marrow of human experience: Essays on folklore. Logan, UT: Utah State University Press. This Book is brought to you for free and open access by the USU Press at DigitalCommons@USU. It has been accepted for inclusion in All USU Press Publications by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@USU. For more information, please contact [email protected]. The Marrow of Human Experience ESSAYS ON FOLKLORE William A. Wilson Edited by Jill Terry Rudy The Marrow of Human Experience The Marrow of Human Experience ! Essays on Folklore By William A. Wilson Edited by Jill Terry Rudy with the assistance of Diane Call Utah State University Press Logan, UT Copyright © 2006 Utah State University Press All rights reserved Utah State University Press Logan, Utah 84322–7800 www.usu.edu/usupress/ Manufactured in the United States of America Printed on acid-free paper Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Wilson, William Albert. The marrow of human experience : essays on folklore / by William A. Wilson ; edited by Jill Terry Rudy with the assistance of Diane Call. p. cm. Includes index. ISBN-13: 978-0-87421-653-0 (pbk.) ISBN- 0-87421-545-5 (e-book) ISBN-10: 0-87421-653-2 (pbk. : alk. paper) 1. Folklore and nationalism. 2. National characteristcs. 3. Folklore--Finland. 4. Mormons--Folklore. I. Rudy, Jill Terry, 1963- II. Call, Diane. III. Title. GR41.5.W55 2006 398.2094897--dc22 2006021243 Contents Acknowledgments vi Introduction 1 Jill Terry Rudy The Importance of Folklore The Deeper Necessity: Folklore and the Humanities 9 Building Bridges: Folklore in the Academy 23 Arts and Cultural Policy 32 “Something There Is That Doesn’t Love a Wall” 44 The Folk Speak: Everyday Life in Pioneer Oral Narratives 62 Documenting Folklore 81 Folklore and National Identity Herder, Folklore, and Romantic Nationalism 107 Sibelius, the Kalevala, and Karelianism 124 Folklore, Nationalism, and the Challenge of the Future 142 Finns in a New World: A Folkloristic Perspective 150 Folklore, Religion, and Who We Are The Concept of the West and Other Hindrances to the Study of Mormon Folklore 169 The Study of Mormon Folklore: An Uncertain Mirror for Truth 182 On Being Human: The Folklore of Mormon Missionaries 201 The Seriousness of Mormon Humor 221 Freeways, Parking Lots, and Ice Cream Stands: Three Nephites in Contemporary Mormon Culture 236 “Teach Me All That I Must Do”: The Practice of Mormon Religion 253 Personal Narratives: The Family Novel 261 A Daughter’s Biography of William A. Wilson 283 Denise Wilson Jamsa William A. Wilson’s Published Works 293 Works Cited 299 Contributors of Introductions to Essays 311 Index 315 Acknowledgments he editor would like to acknowledge the Brigham Young University Eng- lish Department for the semesters of research assistance that Diane Call Tprovided this project and for the encouragement of endearing colleagues. Many thanks to Diane herself for her organizational skill and her persistence. I also thank the contributors for their introductions and enthusiastic responses to my requests to write them. I hope again someday to work on a project that is so warmly received by its participants. Additionally, I appreciate the many colleagues who would have been willing to write introductions if room had allowed. The readers for Utah State University Press, including Barre Toelken, made helpful suggestions that improved the fi nal version, and John Alley provided the perfect organizing scheme for the essays and great patience in guiding me through my initial publishing foray. I have read manuscripts and proofs of this book at dance rehearsals, baseball games, and late into the night and thank Bill, Katelyn, Matthew, and Spencer Rudy for not minding. My gratitude to Bert Wilson is eter- nal, and for everyone who knows him, the work in this book displays our debts, always, to Hannele. Introduction often misplace certain William A. “Bert” Wilson articles and then fi nd them in unexpected locations. When researching Mormon folklore, I may need “On IBeing Human” and fi nally fi nd the article in a folder marked “Defi nitions of Folklore” or “Folklore and the Humanities.” The article might be tucked in the folder I use for the Introduction to Folklore course or even in the folder for my advanced writing class. The process gets repeated for the “Deeper Necessity” ar- ticle, the “Herder” article, and others. For this very personal reason, I have wanted a book compiling Bert Wilson’s essays. I want a good variety of his writings in one easily accessible and transportable collection. More seriously, and less selfi shly, I requested to work on this essay collection with Bert so others could receive and study the work of an excellent teacher and champion of folklore studies and the humanities. The essays won’t convey exactly what it was like to be in his classroom, what it was like to experience the vari- ety of personal experiences, lectures, slide shows, guest speakers, fi lms, and other multimedia displays he used to present folklore in all its varieties to his students. But these writings will introduce new and ongoing students of folklore to useful defi nitions and functions of folklore study. They may guide readers who know little of this fi eld, as well as seasoned folklorists, to recognize and remember the imperatives of traditional expression—the powerful needs to create, to know, and to commune within the realms of change, continuity, and a common humanity. These essays in folklore will immerse their readers in Bert’s passion for folklore as a way to negotiate recurring human needs, to recognize the values and concerns of particular groups, and to understand what it means to be human. making this collection When studying folklore, it seems important to indicate that the creation and shar- ing of knowledge takes place through face-to-face contacts as well as by reading and writing. I studied folklore with Bert as a master’s student at Brigham Young University and heard him give several of the invited lectures on Mormon narrative traditions now included here. As a folklore doctoral student at Indiana Univer- sity, I discovered that he had a wider infl uence than Mormon folklore when my 1 2 The Marrow of Human Experience professors expressed their appreciation for his work on Finnish nationalism and folklore in the academy. Knowing of the regard for Bert and his contributions to the fi eld, I more fully understood the scope and impact of his work. When we be- gan to make this essay collection, I invited his scholarly peers and former students, whom he always treats as peers, to contribute introductory notes to the essays so readers could more easily see this impact. By gathering in one collection Bert’s words from four decades of work, we can better understand his vision of folklore studies that builds bridges across academic disciplines and unites such seemingly diverse areas of specialty as romantic nationalism and Mormon folklore. It is fi tting that Michael Owen Jones wrote in his introductory note to “On Being Human” that “All of us are infl uenced by the writing of others.” The format of this book is based on Jones’s essay collection, Exploring Folk Art: Twenty Years of Thought on Craft, Work, and Aesthetics. In his collection Jones included introduc- tory headnotes explaining the personal and disciplinary context of his writings, and I enjoyed reading the notes as much as reading his articles. Contributors have been enthusiastic and thoughtful in providing their introductory responses to the essays and commenting on their relationship with Bert and his ideas. Some con- tributors refer to Bert informally by his fi rst name, while others use his last name; either name is a sign of esteem and respect. As mentioned in most of the intro- ductions and especially in the biographical sketch by his daughter Denise Jamsa, Bert Wilson is recognized as a community builder; therefore, it is particularly ap- propriate in his essay collection to include the voices of others interacting with his life and work. Many other colleagues and former students could have provided commentary on Bert’s infl uence, but the mirror I have held is infl uenced by my relationships with Bert and these contributors at this particular time. Selecting essays to include has been a delight; deciding which essays to elimi- nate from the collection has been diffi cult. I made initial selections, invited the writers to contribute introductory notes, and grouped the essays somewhat the- matically by folklore and the academy, folklore and religion, and folklore and Finn- ish nationalism. The initial order of sections and essays was improved by the care- ful reading of John Alley, our USU Press editor. On more than one occasion with Bert, I have compared the process of essay selection to compiling a “greatest hits” collection, suggesting that creating another volume later could be an option. Bert has preferred instead to winnow some previously published articles and include some unpublished papers in order to consider this as his standard. He consistently has chosen to add more recent works, preferring to present how his ideas have developed and matured rather than simply using the collection as a documentary of past thought. For example, later in the manuscript process he announced that he wanted to replace “Fact amid the Legends” with the more recent “The Folk Speak,” explaining that the two pieces expressed similar ideas but he liked the later iteration better.