Finnish Studies
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
JOURNAL OF INNISH TUDIES F S From Cultural Knowledge to Cultural Heritage: Finnish Archives and Their Reflections of the People Guest Editors Pia Olsson and Eija Stark Theme Issue of the Journal of Finnish Studies Volume 18 Number 1 October 2014 ISSN 1206-6516 ISBN 978-1-937875-96-1 JOURNAL OF FINNISH STUDIES EDITORIAL AND BUSINESS OFFICE Journal of Finnish Studies, Department of English, 1901 University Avenue, Evans 458 (P.O. Box 2146), Sam Houston State University, Huntsville, TX 77341-2146, USA Tel. 1.936.294.1402; Fax 1.936.294.1408 SUBSCRIPTIONS, ADVERTISING, AND INQUIRIES Contact Business Office (see above & below). EDITORIAL STAFF Helena Halmari, Editor-in-Chief, Sam Houston State University; [email protected] Hanna Snellman, Co-Editor, University of Helsinki; [email protected] Scott Kaukonen, Assoc. Editor, Sam Houston State University; [email protected] Hilary Joy Virtanen, Asst. Editor, Finlandia University; hilary.virtanen@finlandia. edu Sheila Embleton, Book Review Editor, York University; [email protected] EDITORIAL BOARD Börje Vähämäki, Founding Editor, JoFS, Professor Emeritus, University of Toronto Raimo Anttila, Professor Emeritus, University of California, Los Angeles Michael Branch, Professor Emeritus, University of London Thomas DuBois, Professor, University of Wisconsin Sheila Embleton, Distinguished Research Professor, York University Aili Flint, Emerita Senior Lecturer, Associate Research Scholar, Columbia University Richard Impola, Professor Emeritus, New Paltz, New York Daniel Karvonen, Senior Lecturer, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis Andrew Nestingen, Associate Professor, University of Washington, Seattle Jyrki Nummi, Professor, Department of Finnish Literature, University of Helsinki Juha Pentikäinen, Professor, Institute for Northern Culture, University of Lapland Douglas Robinson, Professor, Dean, Hong Kong Baptist University Oiva Saarinen, Professor Emeritus, Laurentian University, Sudbury George Schoolfield, Professor Emeritus, Yale University Beth L. Virtanen, Professor, South University Online Keijo Virtanen, Professor, University of Turku Marianne Wargelin, Independent Scholar, Minneapolis SUBSCRIPTION RATES 2014-15 (2 ISSUES PER YEAR) Individuals: US $40 Institutions: US $50 Europe €40 Europe €50 ADVERTISEMENTS (BLACK & WHITE ONLY) Half page $50/€50 Full page $100/€100 Inside back cover $200/€200 Outside back cover $250/€250 MORE INFORMATION Contact Business Office, or http://www.shsu.edu/~eng_www/finnishstudies/ ©2014 Journal of Finnish Studies Cover: The Isojoki coat of arms, designed by Pentti Vakkamaa, accessed at en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isojoki. Cover design: Scott Kaukonen. TABLE OF CONTENTS Helena Halmari: Editorial 1 Pia Olsson and Eija Stark: Making Cultural Heritage in Finland: The Production of and Challenge to Tradition 3 Risto Blomster and Kati Mikkola: Inclusion and Exclusion of Roma in the Category of Finnish Folklore: The Collections of the Finnish Literature Society from the 1800s to the 2000s 11 Eija Stark: Folk Views on the Rural Upper Class and Questions of Historical Contextualization of Finnish Proverbs (1885–1950) 46 Pia Olsson: “Good Factual Knowledge” for Future Generations: Questionnaire Activity Defining Traditional Culture 65 Niina Hämäläinen: Why is Aino not Described as a Black Maiden? Reflections on the Textual Presentations by Elias Lönnrot in the Kalevala and the Kanteletar 91 Kivi’s Nummisuutarit: A Polemic Exchange Douglas Robinson: Partly Sunny: A Critical Edition of Kivi’s Greatest Play 130 Jyrki Nummi: Partly Funny: Enters Il Dottore 153 Book Reviews Golubev, Alexey, and Irina Takala. 2014. The Search for a Socialist El Dorado: Finnish Immigration to Soviet Karelia from the United States and Canada in the 1930s. Reviewed by Paul Lubotina. 167 Goss, Glenda Dawn. 2009. Sibelius: A Composer’s Life and the Awakening of Finland. Reviewed by Timo Virtanen. 171 Heikkilä, Elli, Manon Danker, Emilio José Gómez Ciriano, Hugh McLaughlin, and Henny Reubsaet, eds. 2011. Working Together for Better Integration: Immigrants, Police and Social Work. Reviewed by Mitchel P. Roth. 178 Heimo, Anne, Tuomas Hovi, and Maria Vasenkari, eds. 2012. Pyhä Urho: Fakeloresta folkloreksi/St. Urho: From Fakelore to Folklore. Reviewed by Elo-Hanna Seljamaa. 180 Lindström, Varpu. 2012. Letters from an Immigrant Teenager: Letters from Varpu in Canada to Kaisa in Finland, 1963-65. Reviewed by Nancy Mattson. 185 Muir, Simo, and Hana Worthen, eds. 2013. Finland’s Holocaust: Silences of History. Reviewed by Paul Lubotina. 191 Olsson, Pia. 2011. Women in Distress: Self-understanding among 20th-century Finnish Rural Women. Reviewed by Pirjo Korkiakangas. 197 Roinila, Mika. 2012. Finland-Swedes in Michigan. Reviewed by Peter Kivisto. 200 Contributors 203 EDITORIAL It is my pleasure to present the newest theme issue of the Journal of Finnish Studies to our subscribers and readers around the world. Pia Olsson and Eija Stark, the guest editors of From Cultural Knowledge to Cultural Heritage: Finnish Archives and Their Reflections of the People, have compiled a fascinating collection that focuses on the ac- quisition and storage of cultural knowledge intended for archives in Finland—and how this cultural knowledge becomes our cultural heritage. These essays reveal that the facts now contained in the Finnish historical ar- chives have been collected and selected by people who themselves were living in times and places very different from our present. While applauding the collectors of these materials from our societal past, these essays also contest some aspects of the process. The collectors’ decisions to include certain materials in the archives and to exclude others were made based on their own times and not on ours. In the four articles that constitute the core of this collection, the readers will learn, for example, about the representation (or better, non-representation) of the Roma in Finnish archives. One also gains insights into the old Finnish upper class through an investigation of proverbs. In addition, we learn how questionnaires were designed and deployed in the collection of these archival materials over long periods of Finland’s history. Likewise important is the analysis of Elias Lönnrot’s proce- dures for collecting textual representations of the figure of Aino in the Kalevala and the Kanteletar. In sum, this issue encourages the reader to question, to contest, to chal- lenge, and—not to take its topics for granted. It reminds me of the title of a poetry collection by my colleague, Professor Nick Lantz: We Don’t Know We Don’t Know (Minneapolis: Graywolf Press, 2010). Lantz builds his poems on questions—some- times funny and comfortable ones, sometimes dark and disturbing ones. In similar fashion, the authors of this issue ask some questions that we can easily answer, but they also ask those questions that make us, the consumers of the Finnish cultural 1 Journal of Finnish Studies heritage, ponder: how is it that we know what we know—and is there something that we don’t know we don’t know. In this issue, we also offer to our readers a large number of books reviews. And we include a polemic exchange between two of our editorial board mem- bers, Dr. Douglas Robinson (Hong Kong Baptist University) and Dr. Jyrki Nummi (University of Helsinki), who engage in a heated discussion about the new critical edition of Kivi’s Nummisuutarit, edited by Nummi and his colleagues. Enjoy. Helena Halmari 2 MAKING CULTURAL HERITAGE IN FINLAND: THE PRODUCTION OF AND CHALLENGE TO TRADITION Pia Olsson, University of Helsinki Eija Stark, University of Helsinki 1 In Finland, as in many other countries, archives and museums are places where frag- ments of the past are stored. This collection of articles focuses on the historical pro- cesses in which these fragments, such as folklore items and life histories, have been gathered and judged worthy to be preserved. These collections, and the information they contain, are part of the knowledge upon which we base our understanding of the past in Finnish society and of the individuals who lived in it. Nonetheless, the extensive amount of information and the multiple sources of data available in modern times force us to question and contest the nature of this knowledge. Who defines what kind of information is important to collect and pre- serve? What is acceptable and unacceptable in different periods and contexts? How do the different social hierarchies of knowledge affect our worldview? These are the questions addressed, from the perspective of cultural knowledge, in this volume of the Journal of Finnish Studies. We are not the first to approach these questions. Human knowledge is based on information received from sources one can trust. People’s understanding of their own culture has always been more diverse than the representations preserved in traditional archives and museums. The articles of this volume focus on how cultural knowledge was produced in late nineteenth and early twentieth-century Finnish society. All authors discuss perspectives on knowledge as it concerns common people, and they all consider information management from historical perspectives. 1 The theme of this volume of the Journal of Finnish Studies evolved in the project financed by the Kone Foundation in 2011. Kati Mikkola and Eija Stark made their contributions to the volume in conjunction with a project financed by the Academy of Finland. 3 Journal of Finnish Studies Information related to ethnography and folklore has been collected in archives and museums in Finland (as