Surnames and National Identity in Turkey and Iran
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Pisma Humanistyczne Zeszyt XIV z 2016 z ISSN 1506-9567 Pisma Humanistyczne Humanistyczne Pisma XIV IDENTITY Between unity and distinctiveness Pisma Humanistyczne Zeszyt XIV z 2016 z ISSN 1506-9567 Humanistic Scripts Volume XIV z 2016 z ISSN 1506-9567 IDENTITY Between unity and distinctiveness Scientific Council Chairman prof. zw. dr hab. Wiesław Kaczanowicz (Univeristy of Silesia in Katowice) Members dr Mirosław Czerwiński (Univeristy of Silesia in Katowice) dr hab. prof. UW Jarosław Czubaty (University of Warsaw) prof. Stéphane Guerard (Université Lille Nord de France) dr hab. prof. UŚ Mariusz Kolczyński (Univeristy of Silesia in Katowice) dr hab. Irma Kozina (Univeristy of Silesia in Katowice) dr hab. prof. UŚ Dariusz Kubok (Univeristy of Silesia in Katowice) prof. zw. dr hab. Janusz Mucha (AGH University of Science and Technology) dr hab. prof. UŚ Dariusz Nawrot (Univeristy of Silesia in Katowice) dr hab. Sławomir Raube (University of Białystok) prof. Reinhold Sackmann (Martin-Luther-Universität Halle-Wittenberg) prof. dr hab. Robert Wiszniowski (University of Wrocław) dr hab. Piotr Wróblewski (Univeristy of Silesia in Katowice) Editorial Staff mgr Tomasz Okraska (editor in chief) mgr Justyna Łapaj (deputy editor-in-chief, thematic editor: political science) mgr Maria Michniowska (thematic editor: sociology) mgr Agata Muszyńska (thematic editor: history) mgr Tomasz Pawlik (thematic editor: philosophy) mgr Iwona Bijak (Polish language editor) mgr Kamil Ciborowski (English language editor) mgr Emilia Woźniczko (technical editor) Reviewers Prof. dr hab. Anna Barska (University of Opole), dr hab. Agnieszka Chudzicka-Czupała (Univeristy of Silesia in Katowice), dr hab. Tomasz Czakon (Univeristy of Silesia in Ka- towice), dr Paweł Ćwikła (Univeristy of Silesia in Katowice), dr hab. Sylwester Fertacz (Univeristy of Silesia in Katowice), dr hab. Agnieszka Kasińska-Metryka (The Jan Ko- chanowski University (JKU) in Kielce), dr hab. Norbert Kasparek (University of Warmia and Mazury in Olsztyn), dr hab. Andrzej Kasperek (Univeristy of Silesia in Katowi- ce), dr Stefan Kesting (University of Leeds), dr Rafał Klepka (Pedagogical University of Kraków), dr Barbara Lewicka (Univeristy of Silesia in Katowice), dr hab. Sławomir Łodziński (University of Warsaw), dr Agnieszka Łukasik-Turecka (The John Paul II Ca- tholic University of Lublin), dr Piotr Machura (Univeristy of Silesia in Katowice) dr hab. Ewa Marciniak (University of Warsaw), dr hab. Jerzy Mizgalski (Jan Dlugosz University in Czestochowa), dr hab. Maria Nawojczyk (AGH University of Science and Technology), dr hab. Adam Perłakowski (Jagiellonian University), dr hab. Dorota Piontek (Adam Mickiewicz University in Poznań), prof. dr hab. Joanna Rostropowicz (University of Gdańsk), prof. Rosemarie Sackmann (Julius-Maximilians-Universität Würzburg), dr Agnieszka Skorupa (Univeristy of Silesia in Katowice), dr hab. Andrzej Słaboń (Kraków University of Economics), dr hab. Jacek Surzyn (Univeristy of Silesia in Katowi- ce), dr hab. Magdalena Szpunar (AGH University of Science and Technology), dr hab. Anna Śliz (University of Opole), dr hab. Piotr Świercz (Jesuit University Ignatianum in Krakow), dr hab. Dobrosława Wężowicz-Ziółkowska (Univeristy of Silesia in Katowice), dr hab. Robert Wiszniowski (University of Wrocław), dr hab. Barbara Wiśniewska Paź (University of Wrocław), dr hab. Renata Włoch (University of Warsaw), dr hab. Filip Wolański (University of Wrocław), dr Adam Zamojski (The Jan Kochanowski University (JKU) in Kielce). www.pismahumanistyczne-wns.us.edu.pl [email protected] Graphic on the cover www.colorado.edu Typesetting JAK – studio graficzne www.jakstudio.pl This book was published under the auspices of Faculty of Social Sciences, University of Silesia in Katowice Copyright © 2016 JAK – studio graficzne The original version of the journal: paper ISSN 1506-9567 Edition 120 copies Contents Editorial ........................................................................................................................................ 9 Weronika Wojtanowska Morality and the Problem of Personal Identity ...................................................................... 11 Anna Ciechomska Cultural aspects of infrahumanization .................................................................................. 21 Zbigniew Przybyłka We and our Enemy. The self-perception of the Romans through their imagination of the Carthaginians ................................................................................................................. 51 Paweł Matejek The identity of the poet and the mystic. Contribution to research into the poetic imagination of Juliusz Słowacki .............................................................................................. 79 Julita Biniewska The Culture Identity of the Younger Russian Emigrants in Paris ....................................... 99 Szymon Pietrzykowski Holocaust, Israeli Statehood and Jewish Identity: International Reception of the Eichmann Trial (1961-1962) .............................................. 117 Monika Habdas Creating and developing the collective state identity in Israeli society ............................. 159 Anna Szombierska Surnames and National Identity in Turkey and Iran .......................................................... 175 Hanna Wiczanowska The “Satanic Verses” affair and its influence on the mutual relationship between Western and Islamic civilization ............................................................................................ 193 Maria Banaś Outsiders in the light of Goffman’s Dramaturgical Model (on the Example of Margaret Atwood’s Novel “The Year of the Flood”) .................................................. 215 Natalia Rytelewska The identity of the post-industrial cities on the example of Gdansk, Lodz and Katowice ... 231 Paweł Pistelok, Elżbieta Ziobro The new center of Katowice – towards the spatial identity of the city. A few reflections from the research ......................................................................................... 249 Editorial Dear Readers, The question of identity is one of the most fundamental problems for the delibera- tions of humanities and social sciences. Identity can be viewed both in individual and collective perspective. The question asking ‘who are we?’ is equally important to ‘who are we not?’. One’s self is always accompanied by the other and identity is always related to otherness. More interestingly, the identity once defined is not the identity defined for ever. In Conversations With Benedetto Vecchi, Zygmunt Bauman claims that belonging and identity “are not cut in rock, that they are not secured by a lifelong guarantee, that they are eminently negotiable and revocable; and that one’s own decisions, the steps one takes, the way one acts – and the determination to stick by all that – are crucial factors of both. In other words, the thought of ‘having an identity’ will not occur to people as long, as ‘belonging’ remains their fate, a condition with no alternative”. Our journal is published in Silesia – the region of strong and differing identi- ties. Over the course of it’s history, Silesia belonged, partially or fully, to Bohemia, Poland, Habsburg Monarchy and Germany. This heritage still matters very much for the inhabitants of the region. A lot of them could relate to a story Bauman tells about the representatives in the census who were not able to get answer for the question concerning nationality. What they heard was just ‘we live here’ or ‘we belong here’. Finally, the authority succumbed to the people and decided to add ‘the locals’ to the list of answers. We cordially invite you to study the twelve perspectives on the problem of iden- tity presented by our Authors! Editorial Staff Weronika Wojtanowska Morality and the Problem of Personal Identity Introduction The problem of personal identity touches a variety of problems, mainly philo- sophical ones, but also of psychological, sociological or anthropological nature. As a metaphysical issue, it is a subject of discussions within the continental as well as the Anglo-American tradition. The disagreement in this matter encompasses different views about the existence of personal identity, its proper understanding, foundations, and importance. On the basis of selected theories that are the representatives of substance-based ego concept, reductionist conception or narrative approach, the article addresses the issues of ontological foundations of identity with relation to the questions concerning morality and ethics1. However, the paper does not attempt to resolve the problem of the ontological foundations of identity. Its objective is not supporting one of the theories that are presented below, i.e. the substance-based, relational or narrative conception. It focuses on selected issues regarding moral implications of accepting particular con- ceptions of personal identity. It pays special attention to the views, which deny the ex- istence of personal identity in its traditional form, as by this denial they challenge the natural notion of the nature of morality and prudence as well as the relations between them. In the article it will be argued that the view that is refuting the substance-based concept of personal identity entails a redefinition and modification of justification not only for prudence but morality as well. 1 Ethics is understood here as a theoretical foundation of morality (actual moral practices). 12 Weronika Wojtanowska 1. Substance-based