NATIONAL HOLOCAUST MEMORIAL & LEARNING CENTRE PROOF OF EVIDENCE (APPENDICES) HERITAGE TOWN AND COUNTRY PLANNING ACT 1990 CALL-IN INQUIRY DR CHRIS MIELE IHBC MRTPI APPLICATION REFERENCE: 19/00114/FULL SEPTEMBER 2020 Page 1 of 54 APPENDICES APPENDIX 1.0 CM LIST OF PUBLICATIONS APPENDIX 2.0 VISUAL MATERIAL APPENDIX 3.0 EXTRACT FROM SUPREME COURT VOLUME APPENDIX 4.0 COMMENTS ON DR GERHOLD’S SUBMISSION 2 Page 2 of 54 APPENDIX 01 CM LIST OF PUBLICATIONS 4 Page 3 of 54 ■ “The Battle for Westminster Hall”, Architectural Published Works History (British Society of Architectural Historians) ■ ‘The Mystery of Ashpitel’s Notebook, Georgian vol. 41 (1998), pp. 220-244. Group Journal, 2016. ■ ‘Robert Adam, Marlborough House and Mrs ■ ‘E A Freeman and the Culture of Gothic Revival’ in Fitzherbert: “The First Architect of the World in Bremner and Conlin, Making History (OUP, 2016) Brighton”’, Sussex Archaeological Collections, vol. ■ ‘Scenes of Clerical Life: the Young Scott’, in G G 136 (1998), pp. 149-175. Scott RA, ed by P Barnwell (Shaun Tyas, ■ “Real Antiquity and the Ancient Object”, in The forthcoming). Study of the Past in the Victorian Age, ed. V Brand, ■ ‘Community Heritage’ and other Victorian Myths: intro. By Chris Brooks, Oxbow Monographs no. 73 Reflections on the English Experience’, ed. Melanie (1998), pp. 103-125. Hall, The History of Preservation: International ■ Morris on Architecture, ed by C Miele (Sheffield, Perspectives (Ashurst, 2013). 1997). A collection of William Morris’ lectures on ■ Forgotten, Lost and Restored, joint author building and architecture, with a critical (Hackney Society, 2012). introduction and annotations. ■ ‘Gothic Sign. Gothic Realia: Reflections on the Holy ■ “The First Conservation Militants”, in Preserving Sepulchre’, in Architectural History, 2010. the Past, ed M Hunter (Stroud, Gloucs., 1996), pp. ■ ‘Architectural Representation’, Celebrating a 17- 37. Century of the Victorian Society: 2010. ■ “Art or Craft? Morris& Co Revisited”, The Victorian ■ The Anatomy of Georgian Villa, Danson House, Society Annual, 1996, pp. 15-21. author (English Heritage 2009). ■ “The Conservationist”, in William Morris, ed by ■ The Supreme Court of the United Kingdom: Linda Parry(Victoria & Albert Museum, Exhibition History, Art, Architecture (Hardcover) , editor and Catalogue, 1996), pp. 72-90. contributor (2010). ■ “Their Interest and Habit. Professionalism and the ■ From William Morris: Conservation and the Arts Restoration of Medieval Churches”, in A Saint and and Crafts Cult of Authenticity, editor and C Brooks (Manchester, 1995), pp 151-171. contributor (2005) ■ “A Small Knot of Cultivated People: The Ideologies ■ “English Antiquity: Saxonism and the Construction of Protection”, The Art Journal (American College of National Architectural Identities”. In Art Association: special issue on Conservation and Architecture and Englishness, Con. Proceedings Art History), vol. 54 (Summer 1995), pp. 73-80. Society of Architectural Historians. (2005),ed. I. ■ “The Restoration of the West Front of Rochester Dungavell and D. Crellin. Cathedral: Antiquarianism, Historicism and the ■ Designing the World: Engineering, Architecture Restoration of Medieval Buildings”, The and the Royal Navy”, Architectural History (Jrof the Archaeological Journal, vol. 151 (1994), pp. 400- Society of Architectural Historians, UK),vol. 49, 419. 2006. ■ Hoxton (Hackney Society Publication, ■ “Conservation”, in The Oxford Dictionary of London,1993). Architecture, 2005. ■ “Conservation and the Development Process”, Accepted but not published Journal of Architectural Conservation, July 2005. ■ ‘Morris Architectural Vision’, in The William Morris ■ “Danson House Restored”, Country Life, Reader, ed.F.Bovs (Ashgate, 2019). 24 March 2005. ■ “The Value of Conservation Plans?”, IHBC Submitted for Publication Review Yearbook, 2005. ■ ‘Between Architecture and Archaeology: the Scott- ■ “Love, Marriage and the Painted Georgian Freeman Debate’. Interior”, English Heritage Collections Review, ■ ‘GG Scott, Gottfried, Semper and the Hamburg (2001). Nikolaikirche’. ■ “Re-presenting the Church Militant. The Camden ■ ‘The Great Architectural “Awakening”: Glibert Scott Society and the Round Church”, in A Church As It and Pugin’. Should Be, ed C Webster and J Elliott(Stamford, ■ ‘Towards a History of Vernacular Revival’ from the 2000), pp 257-294. Journal of the Vernacular Architecture Group (ex. ■ “Victorian Internationalism”, in The Gothic Revival. Plenary session paper). Religion, Architecture and Style in Western ■ ‘The London “City Model”: Technology and Europe, 1815-1914, ed J de Maeyer and L Planning in a Historic World City 2017 Conference Verpoest (Leuven/Louvain, Belgium, 2000), pp. Paper, Glasgow. 209-220. ■ ‘Arts and Crafts Conservation’ in The Oxford ■ London Suburbs, gen ed. C Miele, technical ed. Dictionary of Vernacular Architecture (Oxford, the Kit Wedd, introduced by A Saint. Also contributor University Press, 2020 – forthcoming). to first chapter: ‘From Aristocratic Ideal to ■ ‘Conservation and Architecture’ in A. Mason et al., Middle- Class Idyll’, (English Heritage, 1999), eds., William Morris (Thames and Hudson with the Victoria & Albert Museum, 2021 – pp. 31-60. forthcoming). ■ ‘Icon of Victorian Modernity’ in Country Life, vol. 193, 2, 1999. Page 4 of 54 APPENDIX 02 VISUAL MATERIAL 6 Page 5 of 54 61 31 60 HERITAGE ASSET PLAN Application Site 21 13 Conservation Areas 86 B. Westminster Abbey and 79 Parliament Square (WCC) 108 C. Smith Square (WCC) Listed Buildings Grade I 35 39 1. Victoria Tower Lodge and Gates to Black Rod Garden 2. Statuary group of The Burghers of Calais 63 13. The Jewel House (Or Tower) of The Palace of Westminster and Former Dock Retaining Walls to Moat Around Jewel House 14. Houses of Parliament and The 1 Palace of Westminster C 21. Abbey Precinct Wall Grade II* 97 22. Buxton Memorial Fountain, Victoria Tower Gardens 31. 6-9, Smith Square SW1 35. The Church Commissioners 106 39. Knife Edge Two Piece Sculpture Grade II 60. Abbey (Canons’) Garden 61. 10-12, Little College Street SW1 and Lampstandard Numbered G1 110 63. Norwest House 2 79. 7 Lampstandards Numbered G4, 5 14 and 6 and G9, 10, 11 and 12 86. Lampstandard Numbered G1 on 22 Corner of Smith Square 96. River Embankment From The Houses of Parliment to Lambeth Bridge World Heritage Site 106. Palace of Westminster, Westminster Abbey and St. Margaret’s Church 96 Scheduled Monuments 108. The Jewel Tower Registered Park and Gardens 110. Victoria Tower Gardens B Contains OS data © Crown copyright and database right 2020 MONTAGU EVANS CHARTERED SURVEYORS LOCATION: DATE: SCALE: FIGURE: NORTH 5 BOLTON STREET, Holocaust Memorial - Victoria Tower Gardens April 2020 NOT TO SCALE LONDON W1J 8BA T: 020 7493 4002 WWW.MONTAGU-EVANS.CO.UK PHASING PLAN 1: 1867-1881: River embankment, creation of a parade ground and then a roughly square garden, shown on 1895 OS 2: 1910-1914: Gardens extended, Plotted Scale - Licence number 100022432 Ordnance Survey new layout. Burghers of Calais first installed near present location of Mrs Emmeline Pankhurst 1:1250 Plotted Scale - Licence number 100022432 Ordnance Survey © Crown Copyright 2020. All Rights Reserved. 3: 1931: Part of park covered . Paper Size - with huts to accommodate civil servants A3 4: 1923: Horseferry playground 1:1250 laid out. Near the south was the Spicer Memorial. © Crown Copyright 2020. All Rights Reserved. Paper Size - 5: 1933: Lambeth Bridge rebuilt, taking in the south of the park for footings 6: 1930: Emmeline Pankhurst A3 Memorial installed within the middle of the park 7: 1956-1959: Park remodelled after bomb damage repairs completed. Three listed memorials moved to their current locations. New semi-circular paths added with juncture at the newly relocated Buxton Memorial 8: 2003: Restoration and new plinth for the Burghers of Calais. Moved 4m south to present location. 9: 2015: Horseferry Playground restored, Spicer Memorial moved north to present position. Contains OS data © Crown copyright and database right 2020 MONTAGU EVANS CHARTERED SURVEYORS LOCATION: DATE: SCALE: FIGURE: NORTH 5 BOLTON STREET, Holocaust Memorial - Victoria Tower Gardens April 2020 NOT TO SCALE LONDON W1J 8BA T: 020 7493 4002 WWW.MONTAGU-EVANS.CO.UK DR CHRIS MIELE PROOF OF EVIDENCE: BUILT HERITAGE MATTERS APPENDIX 2: VISUAL DOSSIER NatioNal Holocaust MeMorial aNdlearNiNgceNtre april 2020 ii ©MoNtagu evaNs LLP 2020 1.0 HISTORIC iMAGES oF tHe SITE aNd eNVIRONs NatioNal Holocaust MeMorial aNd learNiNg ceNtre 4 HISTORIC iMAGES oF tHe SITE aNd eNVIRONs 1.0 HISTORIC iMAGES oF tHe SITE aNd eNVIRONs Figure 1.2 Rocque’s Map of 1746 Figure 1.1 Aga’s Map of 1578 © MoNtagu evaNs LLP 2020 | NatioNal Holocaust MeMorial aNd learNiNg ceNtre HISTORIC iMAGES oF tHe SITE aNd eNVIRONs 5 Figure 1.3 1851 Plan showing the narrow yard Figure 1.4 1860s or 1870s plan of the Houses of Parliament dr Chris Miele prooF oF evideNce: Built Heritage Matters | april 2020 6 HISTORIC iMAGES oF tHe SITE aNd eNVIRONs Figure 1.5 William Strudwick’s Plan of the 1860s Landmark Historical Map County: LONDON Published Date(s): 1875-1879 Originally plotted at: 1:2,500 Figure 1.6 1875 First Edition OS © MoNtagu evaNs LLP 2020 | NatioNal Holocaust MeMorial aNd learNiNg ceNtre HISTORIC iMAGES oF tHe SITE aNd eNVIRONs 7 Landmark Historical Map County: LONDON Published Date(s): 1896 Originally plotted at: 1:2,500 Figure 1.8 1895 Second Edition OS Figure 1.7 1882 photograph of the gardens dr Chris Miele prooF oF evideNce: Built Heritage Matters | april 2020 8 HISTORIC iMAGES oF tHe SITE