A Mechanism Giving a Finite Value to the Speed of Light, and Some Experimental Consequences
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by HAL-IN2P3 A mechanism giving a finite value to the speed of light, and some experimental consequences M. Urban, F. Couchot, X. Sarazin To cite this version: M. Urban, F. Couchot, X. Sarazin. A mechanism giving a finite value to the speed of light, and some experimental consequences. LAL 11-289. Submitted to Eur. Phys. J. B. 2012. <in2p3-00639073v2> HAL Id: in2p3-00639073 http://hal.in2p3.fr/in2p3-00639073v2 Submitted on 13 Sep 2012 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access L'archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- destin´eeau d´ep^otet `ala diffusion de documents entific research documents, whether they are pub- scientifiques de niveau recherche, publi´esou non, lished or not. The documents may come from ´emanant des ´etablissements d'enseignement et de teaching and research institutions in France or recherche fran¸caisou ´etrangers,des laboratoires abroad, or from public or private research centers. publics ou priv´es. EPJ manuscript No. (will be inserted by the editor) A model of quantum vacuum as the origin of the speed of light Marcel Urban, Fran¸cois Couchot and Xavier Sarazin LAL, Univ Paris-Sud, CNRS/IN2P3, Orsay, France Received: September 12, 2012 / Revised version: date Abstract. We show that the vacuum permeability µ0 and permittivity ǫ0 may originate from the magneti- zation and the polarization of continuously appearing and disappearing fermion pairs. We then show that if we simply model the propagation of the photon in vacuum as a series of transient captures within these ephemeral pairs, we can derive a finite photon velocity. Requiring that this velocity is equal to the speed of light constraints our model of vacuum. Within this approach, the propagation of a photon is a statistical process at scales much larger than the Planck scale. Therefore we expect its time of flight to fluctuate. We propose an experimental test of this prediction. PACS. PACS-key discribing text of that key – PACS-key discribing text of that key 1 Introduction particle-antiparticle pairs). We consider neither intermedi- ate bosons nor supersymmetric particles. All known species The vacuum permeability µ0, the vacuum permittivity ǫ0, of charged fermions are taken into account: the three fam- and the speed of light in vacuum c are widely considered ilies of charged leptons e, µ and τ and the three families of as being fundamental constants and their values, escaping quarks (u, d), (c, s) and (t, b), including their three color any physical explanation, are commonly assumed to be states. This gives a total of 21 pair species, noted i. invariant in space and time. In this paper, we propose a An ephemeral fermion pair is assumed to be the prod- mechanism based upon a ”natural” quantum vacuum de- uct of the fusion of two virtual photons of the vacuum. scription which leads to sensible estimations of these three Thus its total electric charge and total color are null. We electromagnetic constants. A consequence of this descrip- suppose also that the spins of the two fermions of a pair tion is that µ0, ǫ0 and c are not fundamental constants are antiparallel, and that they are on their mass shell. but observable parameters of the quantum vacuum: they The only quantity which is not conserved is therefore the can vary if the vacuum properties vary in space or in time. energy and this is the reason for the limited lifetime of A similar analysis of the quantum vacuum, as the phys- the pairs. We assume that first order properties can be ical origin of the electromagnetism constants, has been deduced assuming that pairs are created with an average proposed independently by Leuchs, Villar and Sanchez- energy, not taking into account a full probability density Soto [1]. Although the two mechanisms are different, the of the pairs kinetic energy. Likewise, we will neglect the original idea is the same: the physical electromagnetic con- total momentum of the pair. stants emerge naturally from the quantum theory. The average energy Wi of a pair is taken proportional 2 The paper is organized as follows. First we describe our to its rest mass energy 2mic : model of the quantum vacuum filled with continuously ap- 2 pearing and disappearing fermion pairs. We show how µ0 Wi = KW 2mic (1) and ǫ0 originate respectively from the magnetization and the electric polarization of these pairs. We then derive the where KW is a constant, assumed to be independent from photon velocity in vacuum by modeling its propagation the fermion type. We take KW as a free parameter, greater as a series of interactions with the pairs. Finally, we pre- than unity. The value of KW could be calculated if we dict statistical fluctuations of the transit time of photons knew the energy spectrum of the virtual photons together across a fixed vacuum path. with their probability to create fermion pairs. The pairs lifetime τi is given by the Heisenberg uncer- tainty principle (Wiτi = ¯h/2). So 2 An effective description of the quantum 1 ¯h vacuum τi = 2 (2) KW 4mic The vacuum is assumed to be filled with continuously ap- We assume that the ephemeral fermion pairs densities pearing and disappearing charged fermion pairs (ephemeral Ni are driven by the Pauli Exclusion Principle. Two pairs 2 Marcel Urban, Fran¸cois Couchot, Xavier Sarazin: A model of quantum vacuum as the origin of the speed of light containing two identical fermions in the same spin state Since the total spin of the pair is zero, and since fermion cannot show up at the same time at the same place. How- and antifermion have opposite charges, each pair carries ever at a given location we may find 21 charged fermion twice the magnetic moment of one fermion. pairs since different fermions can superpose spatially. In If no external magnetic field is present, the magnetic solid state physics the successful determination of Fermi moments point randomly in any direction resulting in a energies[2] implies that one electron spin state occupies a null global average magnetic moment. In the presence of hyper volume h3. We assume that concerning the Pauli an external magnetic field B, the coupling energy of the principle, the ephemeral fermions are similar to the real i-type pair to this field is 2µ B cos θ, where θ is the angle − i ones. Noting ∆xi the spacing between identical i-type between the magnetic moment and the magnetic field B. fermions and pi their average momentum, the one dimen- The energy of the pair is modified by this term and the sion hyper volume is pi∆xi and dividing by h should give pair lifetime is therefore a function of the orientation of the number of states which we take as one per spin de- its magnetic moment with respect to the applied magnetic gree of freedom. The relation between pi and ∆xi reads field: pi∆xi/h = 1, or ∆xi = 2π¯h/pi. We can express ∆x as a function of W if we suppose ¯h/2 i i τi(θ) = . (7) the relativity to hold for the ephemeral pairs Wi 2µiB cos θ − 2π¯hc λ ∆x = = Ci (3) The pairs having their magnetic moment aligned with i 2 2 2 2 the field last a bit longer than the anti-aligned pairs. The (Wi/2) (mic ) KW 1 − − resulting average magnetic moment of a pair is there- Mi where λCi = h/p(mic) is the Compton lengthp associated to fore different from zero. It is aligned with the applied field. fermion i. Its value is obtained integrating over θ with a weight pro- The pair density is defined as: portional to the pairs lifetime: 3 2 π 1 KW 1 0 2µi cos θ τi(θ) 2π sin θ dθ Ni 3 = − (4) i = π . (8) ≈ ∆x λC i p i ! M R 0 τi(θ) 2π sin θ dθ Each pair can be produced only in the two fermion- To first order in B,R one gets: antifermion spin combinations up-down and down-up. We define Ni as the density of pairs for a given spin combina- 2 4µi tion. i B. (9) M ≃ 3Wi Finally, we use the notation Qi = qi/e, where qi is the i-type fermion electric charge and e the modulus of the The magnetic moment per unit volume produced by electron charge. the i-type fermions is Mi = 2Ni i , since one takes into account the two spin states perM cell. The contribution µ˜0,i of the i-type fermions to the vacuum permeability 3 The vacuum permeability is thus given by B =µ ˜0,iMi or 1/µ˜0,i = Mi/B. Each species of fermions increases the induced magnetization When a torus of a material is energized through a winding and therefore the magnetic moment. By summing over carrying a current I, the resulting magnetic flux density all pair species, one gets the estimation of the vacuum B is expressed as: permeability: B = µ0nI + µ0M. (5) 1 M 8N µ2 = i = i i (10) where n is the number of turns per unit of length and nI µ˜0 B 3W i i i is the magnetic intensity in A/m. M is the corresponding X X magnetization induced in the material and is the sum of Using Eq. (1), (4) and (6) and summing over all pair the induced magnetic moments divided by the correspond- types, one obtains ing volume. In an experiment where the current I is kept a constant and where we lower the quantity of matter in 3 KW 24π ¯h the torus, B decreases.