Redacted: Public Version

Before the COPYRIGHT ROYALTY JUDGES Washington, D.C.

In the Matter of ) ) Distribution of ) Docket No. 14-CRB-OO 10-CD 2010-2013 2010-2013 ) Cable Royalty Funds )

In the Matter of ) ) Distribution of ) Docket No. 14-CRB-0011-SD 2010-2013 2010-2013 ) ....;;...Sa_t__ el __ li_te_R_o_y_al__.ty ...... F_u_n_d_s _____)

MULTIGROUP CLAIMANTS' OPPOSITION TO JOINT SPORTS CLAIMANTS' MOTION TO DISALLOW THE MULTIGROUP CLAIMANTS' CLAIMS AGAINST THE SPORTS CATEGORY

Brian D. Boydston, Esq. California State Bar No. 155614 PICK & BOYDSTON, LLP 10786 Le Conte Ave. Los Angeles, California 90024 Telephone: (213) 624-1996 Facsimile: (213) 624-9073 Email: [email protected]

Attorneys for Multigroup Claimants Redacted: Public Version

TABLE OF CONTENTS

INTRODUCTION•..•.•.....•.....•...... •.•....•.....••....••.••. 4

A. THE JUDGES SHOULD NOT DISMISS THE PROGRAM CLAIMS OF FIFA OR, IF DISMISSED, MUST BE PREPARED TO REINSTATE SUCH PROGRAM CLAIMS PENDING THE DECISION OF THE NINTH CIRCUIT FEDERAL COURT OF APPEALS ..•..•.•.•...... •..•.•.•••••..•.•.•.•....•••.•...... 5

1. MULTIGROUP CLAIMANTS IS REQUIRED TO MAKE CLAIM FOR FIFA PROGRAMMING PENDING THE OUTCOME OF A DISPUTE BEFORE THE NINTH CIRCUIT FEDERAL COURT OF APPEALS •.....•...•.•....••.•••....••.••..•••..••.•••.5

2. FIFA PROGRAMMING HAS BEEN SUFFICIENTLY IDENTIFIED...••.•••••••.•.•••••.•.•..••••..•.•.••.••..•. 8

3. MULTIGROUP CLAIMANTS HAS SUFFICIENTLY DEMONSTRATED THE EXISTENCE OF PROGRAMMING IN THE "SPORTS PROGRAMMING" CATEGORY, AND ALREADY AGREED TO WITHDRAW ANY MISCATEGORIZED PROGRAMMING..••.••.•.....•...... •.••...••.••....•.. 10

B. THERE IS NO LEGAL BASIS TO DISMISS MULTIGROUP CLAIMANTS' CLAIM TO CFL PROGRAMMING....•..•••.•... 12

1. CFL'S NOTICE OF TERMINATION IS SUBJECT TO A POST­ TERM COLLECTION RIGHT, WHICH THE CFL EXPRESSLY RECOGNIZED BY EXECUTION OF AN "ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF REPRESENTATION'' ...... ••....•.•...... ••.....••..12

2 Redacted: Public Version

2. IN THE SPORTS PROGRAMMING CATEGORY, MULTIGROUP CLAIMANTS HAS ONLY MADE CLAIM FOR THE RETRANSMISSION OF U.S.-ORIGINATED BROADCASTS OF CFL PROG RAMMING. . • . . • . • ...... • • . . . . • . • ...... • . . • • . . 14

3. THE JSC ASSERT THERE HA VE BEEN NO QUALIFYING RETRANSMISSIONS OF CFL PROGRAMMING BASED ON THE REVIEW OF A TWO PRESS RELEASES BY ONE OF THE JSC LEGAL COUNSEL...••....••.•...... •.•....•.•..•.... 15

C. THERE IS NO LEGAL BASIS TO DISMISS MULTIGROUP CLAIMANTS' CLAIM TO TV AZTECA PROGRAMMING...•.•. 18

1. MULTIGROUP CLAIMANTS RIGHTS ARE DERIVED THROUGH AZTECA INTERNATIONAL CORPORATION..•.• 18

2. TV AZTECA'S CLAIMS HAVE BEEN PRESERVED BY THIRD PARTIES, AND TV AZTECA APPEARS ON THE SLP PETITIONS TO PARTICIPATE.•...... •...... •.•...•.•.... 22

3. MULTIGROUP CLAIMANTS PRODUCED EXTENSIVE DOCUMENTATION IDENTIFYING THE TV AZTECA PROGRAMMING.•.•..•.•.....••.•..•.•.•.....•••••••..•• 24

4. THE PROGRAMMING LISTS PROVIDED BY TV AZTECA EXPRESSLY SEGREGATES THE PROGRAMS INTO THE PHASE I CATEGORIES APPLICABLE TO THESE PROCEEDINGS•.....••....•...... ••...... •...• 28

CONCLUSION...... •.•.•....•...... •....•.•.••..••....••.•• 28

3 Redacted: Public Version

INTRODUCTION

By its motion, the Joint Sports Claimants ("JSC") ask the Judges to disallow the claims asserted by Multigroup Claimants ("MC") in this proceeding regarding

(1) the Federation Internationale de Football Association ("FIFA"), (2) Canadian

Football League Properties, Limited ("CFL"), and (3) TV Azteca S.A. de C.V.

("TV Azteca").

The motion should be denied in its entirety. The issue of MC' s entitlement to collect royalties on behalf of FIFA is presently pending before the Ninth Circuit

Court of Appeal, with oral argument thereon scheduled for November 8, 2016.

The CRB should not dismiss such claims until that issue is decided.

With regard to the CFL, contrary to the JSC 's aspersions, Independent

Producers Group ("IPG"), MC's assignor, has a fully authorized post termination collection right to collect royalties on behalf of the CFL. As such, there are no grounds to disallow such claims. By CFL' s execution of an Acknowledgment of

Representation, CFL has affirmed such fact.

With regard to TV Azteca, MC's right to collect royalties on behalf of TV

Azteca (as assigned by IPG) post dates that of any other claimants herein, making

MC the proper claimant of TV Azteca royalties, and the JSC's claims regarding

MC's alleged failure to produce TV Azteca documentation regarding the nature of

its programming are demonstrably false and ignore such exact documentation

4 Redacted: Public Version produced by MC to the JSC herein {specifically, Item 10 to MC's production to the

·1sc).

Therefore, the JSC's motion should be denied in its entirety.

ARGUMENT

A. THE JUDGES SHOULD NOT DISMISS THE PROGRAM CLAIMS OF FIFA OR, IF DISMISSED, MUST BE PREPARED TO REINSTATE SUCH PROGRAM CLAIMS PENDING THE DECISION OF THE NINTH CIRCUIT FEDERAL COURT OF APPEALS.

1. MULTIGROUP CLAIMANTS IS REQUIRED TO MAKE CLAIM FOR FIFA PROGRAMMING PENDING THE OUTCOME OF A DISPUTE BEFORE THE NINTH CIRCUIT FEDERAL COURT OF APPEALS.

The JSC argue that MC lacks authority to represent FIFA in this proceeding, citing to the Judge's rulings in 2000-2003 cable proceeding, and the consolidated

2004-2009 cable and 1999-2009 satellite proceeding (the "Consolidated

Proceeding"). The JSC further note that they frequently asked for information from MC regarding the FIFA claim, and requested that MC either dismiss MC's claims regarding FIFA or produce documents establishing an additional basis for

MC's authority.

As the JSC note, MC did not respond to those multiple requests. This was for the obvious reason that the JSC first attempted to engage in one sided discovery in advance of discovery in these proceedings. Further, once discovery commenced, the JSC further attempted to unilaterally engage in the submission of

5 Redacted: Public Version requests for information that were, effectively, interrogatories. JSC motion at pp.

4, 7. JSC is well aware that MC was not obligated to engage in all these forms of unauthorized discovery, but nonetheless makes issue of it in its motion, suggesting that there is some significance to IPG's refusal to be engaged by the JSC. In any event, in its prior pleadings and correspondence the JSC had already demonstrated its familiarity with the pending litigation between Independent Producers Group

("IPG") and FIFA, a matter expressly addressed between MC's counsel and the

JSC counsel, and there was nothing to produce other than the same documentation that has been produced in prior proceedings by IPG. That documentation was produced by MC herein as well.

MC' s ability to represent FIFA in these proceedings depends upon a civil matter presently pending before the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, specifically, an appeal by IPG of a ruling by the Central District of California in which IPG' s lawsuit alleging a right to represent FIFA in these proceedings was dismissed for lack of personal jurisdiction over FIFA. If IPG' s appeal is granted, which could occur imminently, it will necessarily be based on the enforceability of the agreement that was produced to the JSC in these and prior proceedings.1 lfIPG's appeal is granted based on FIFA' s agreement that IPG is exclusively entitled to

1 Whether FIFA entered into an agreement is dispositive of the issue of personal jurisdiction because it would reflect assent to a written agreement which established jurisdiction over disputes in the Central District of California.

6 Redacted: Public Version collect retransmission royalties attributable to FIFA programming then, presumably, the Judges would honor the decision and allow IPG to pursue the collection of FIFA royalties. In fact, given the limitations on the Judges' authority to adjudicate contractual disputes, the ruling of the federal court would be controlling.

The JSC cite to earlier rulings by the Judges in prior proceedings, and contend that based upon those rulings IPG has no right to collect royalties due

FIFA. However, those rulings were not made in the face of a ruling from a federal court finding that IPG is entitled to collect such royalties. MC is, in fact, in a precarious situation of being "damned if it does, damned if it doesn't", because failure to assert the claims presently will result in the irretrievable forfeiture of such claims, while assertion of the claims subjects MC to an accusation of having asserted a claim for which prior rulings found that the program claims should be dismissed.

In light of these circumstances, the Judges should not grant the JSC' s motion on this issue at this time. If the Judges were to grant the JSC motion as to FIFA pending the determination of the Ninth Circuit, the Judges should be prepared to reinstate the FIFA programming claims if the Ninth Circuit rules favorably for

IPG.

7 Redacted: Public Version

2. FIFA PROGRAMMING HAS BEEN SUFFICIENTLY IDENTIFIED.

The JSC next argue that the FIFA programming for which MC makes claims herein has not been identified by FIFA as FIFA-owned programming. Indeed, given the contractual dispute between IPG and FIFA, FIFA has been an

"uncooperative claimant" despite having entered into a contract with IPG to collect these royalties (hence the action before the Ninth Circuit). Under the circumstances, IPG has done what it must and independently researched FIFA' s programming which applies to these proceedings, and any bright line ruling that precludes the consideration of verifiable facts if they are not directly from the mouth of the underlying claimant, would seem unreasonable.

IPG' s research has yielded a wealth of public documentation indicating what all parties seem to understand, i.e., that FIFA is the organizer and owner of World

Cup Soccer and other FIFA-sponsored soccer events. In fact, not one piece of publicly accessible information suggests the contrary, and MC has even produced non-obligatory copyright registrations by FIFA which establish FIFA' s ownership of the programming for which MC seeks royalties in these proceedings. See

Exhibit Bat pp. 2027-2146. Those documents were produced in these proceedings, the 2000-2003 Cable proceedings, and the Consolidated Proceedings.

Such documents, some of which were created and filed by FIFA itself, clearly establish FIFA's ownership of the programming at issue. Moreover, after four

8 Redacted: Public Version years of such issue being presented to the JSC, the JSC has presented no evidence to establish (or even suggest) another owner ofsuch programming, or another party entitled to make claim therefor. That is, no evidence exists to establish any actual or potential conflicting claimant or claim exists.

Moreover, judicial precedent finds a presumption that sports leagues are entitled to receive the retransmission royalties distributed in these proceedings:

"There is a clear course of action by the Congress, and the broadcasting representatives, which compels the award of cable royalties for sports programming to the sports leagues, in the absence of contractual arrangements specifically providing that such royalties shall be distributed to broadcaster claimants."

1978 Cable Royalty Distribution Determination, Docket No. CRT-79-1, 45 Fed.

Reg. 63026, 63034-63035 (Sept. 23, 1980). Notably, this was a position affirmatively advocated by the JSC in the 1978 cable proceedings. Id. In prior proceedings the JSC has already stipulated with IPG that FIFA was the organizer of the World Cup. Applying such principal, therefore, results in the inescapable conclusion that FIFA is the proper claimant. Further, while the JSC refer to a comment in the Judges' prior order observing that language within IPG/FIFA correspondence gave rise to an issue regarding whether FIFA owned the World

Cup Soccer broadcasts, the Judges' ruling expressly stated that "the Judges do not decide whether FIFA owned the copyright to the telecasts of the Soccer Programs

9 Redacted: Public Version for which IPG seeks royalties."2 Case no. No. 2008-2 CRB CD 2000-2003 (Phase

II) Memorandum Opinion and Order Following Preliminary Hearing on Validity ofClaims at :th. 14 (Mar. 21, 2013).

3. MULTIGROUP CLAIMANTS HAS SUFFICIENTLY DEMONSTRATED THE EXISTENCE OF PROGRAMMING IN THE "SPORTS PROGRAMMING" CATEGORY, AND ALREADY AGREED TO WITHDRAW ANY MISCATEGORIZED PROGRAMMING.

Finally, the JSC argue that MC has failed to establish that the FIFA programs are properly within the Sports Category as "[l]ive broadcasts of professional and college team sports", and ask that all ofMC's claims regarding

FIFA programming be disallowed. However, as an initial matter, the JSC over- reach as they only identify a handful of programs whose titles are not sufficiently specific to confirm that they are "live team sports" (e.g., the JSC reference "Copa

America: La Inauguracion" (America Cup: The Opening)), ignoring the majority

2 It bears noting that the language referenced by the Judges, i.e., a statement by FIFA' s legal counsel, actually acknowledges that copyright to the soccer broadcasts initially vested with FIFA, and would have to be assigned to broadcasters in order for broadcasters to have a right to retransmission royalties. Exhibit C, at Exh. B thereto (M. Dale affidavit). Regardless, and what was not excerpted in the Judges footnote 14 reference, was FIFA' s simultaneous statement that "FIFA does not presently know the answer to [the question of whether FIFA granted a license/assignment to broadcasters]." Id. As is also memorialized therein was FIFA's ostensible refusal to even review its agreements with broadcasters. Id. FIFA, therefore, had not asserted a position one way or the other, careful to not expose itself to a breach of contract claim by acknowledging its entitlement to the retransmission royalties derived from its soccer broadcasts.

10 Redacted: Public Version of programs for which the name clearly identifies broadcasts of "live team sports", such as "World Cup Soccer", "South America World Cup Qualifier" etc.

Moreover, the JSC take liberties with its own description of FIFA programming as, for example, describing "Copa America: La Inauguracion" as the opening ceremony, when it could as easily be the opening match. In its responses to follow up discovery, MC has stated to the JSC that if evidence exists which indicates that any of the FIFA programming is not properly within the Sports category, MC would withdraw its claims regarding such programming, yet the JSC has pointed to no such evidence.

Moreover, the Judges have ruled that ambiguous program titles in the Sports category are sufficient for the JSC's claims. Specifically, in these proceedings MC moved to compel the JSC to produce evidence of JSC broadcasts to better define the JSC's claims for programs identified merely as "NBA Basketball", etc., and the

Judges held that such ambiguous identification was sufficient. See Order

Regarding Multigroup Claimants 'First Motion to Compel Production of

Documents by Joint Sports Claimants at pp. 5-6 (Sept. 14, 2016). As such, the

Judges should not tum around now and disallow MC claims for FIFA programming based on a comparable ambiguity of titles.

11 Redacted: Public Version

B. THERE IS NO LEGAL BASIS TO DISMISS MULTIGROUP CLAIMANTS' CLAIM TO CFL PROGRAMMING.

1. CFL'S NOTICE OF TERMINATION IS SUBJECT TO A POST­ TERM COLLECTION RIGHT, WHICH THE CFL EXPRESSLY RECOGNIZED BY EXECUTION OF AN "ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF REPRESENTATION".

With regard to MC's claims regarding the CFL, the JSC argue that the CFL has terminated its agreement with IPG. That is true, and only occurred on July 29,

2016, i.e., after responses to initial and follow-up discovery had already been made. Consequently, MC produced the notice of termination as part of a supplemental production to the JSC. See Kientzle decl., Exh. 14.

As the JSC are fully aware, the IPG agreement with the CFL, like all such

IPG agreements, contains a perpetual post-Term right to collect royalties generated during the "Term",3 and the CFL fully expects MC to make such post-Term collections (on behalf of IPG). In fact, while the JSC feigns that it cannot understand why the CFL would do so, the CFL executed an "Acknowledgement of

Representation" after submission of its notice of termination. See Kientzle decl.

Exh. 15. By that acknowledgement the CFL explicitly confirmed IPG's continuing authority to seek retransmission royalties on its behalf, a representation perfectly consistent with IPG's post-Term collection right, and completely at odds with the

3 See Kientzle decl. at Exh. 13, para. 1 (IPG/CFL agreement): "The foregoing authorization shall apply to Distribution Proceeds applicable to the Term, irrespective ofwhen such Distribution Proceeds are payable."

12 Redacted: Public Version

JSC's asserted interpretation of the IPG/CFL agreement. Such acknowledgement by the CFL removes any reasonable doubt as to IPG's post-Term collection right, as the CFL obviously would not be executing such a document immediately after its notice of termination ifthe CFL did not recognize the post-Term collection right.

To support its interpretation of the IPG/CFL agreement, the JSC point to a ruling by the Judges in the Consolidated Proceeding whereby the Judges disallowed IPG's claims on behalf of Adler Media, Inc. However, the form of the contract regarding Adler was entirely different that the IPG/CFL contract, one which the Judges apparently did not recognize a post-Term collection right. The

IPG/CFL contract clearly identifies IPG's post-Term collection right, and denying that right would forfeit the CFL' s claims, something the CFL obviously does not wish to do.

In this instance, the JSC advocate that the Judges disregard the clear meaning of the IPG/CFL agreement, and disregard IPG's post-Term collection right. The Judges have done so in the past, but not when the claimant has subsequently executed an "Acknowledgment of Representation". While MC (and

IPG) take issue with this approach of interpreting IPG's contracts, i.e., a presumption that the forwarding of a notice of termination means that no post­

Tenn collection right survives the agreement, IPG observes that the Judges cannot

13 Redacted: Public Version reasonably apply such a "rule" to the exclusion of the intent of the parties. Such intent is reflected by execution of an "Acknowledgment of Representation" after the forwarding of a notice of termination, so no reasonable grounds would exist for the Judges to supplant all contracting parties' intentions with their own rule of application.

2. IN THE SPORTS PROGRAMMING CATEGORY, MULTIGROUP CLAIMANTS HAS ONLY MADE CLAIM FOR THE RETRANSMISSION OF U.S.-ORIGINATED BROADCASTS OF CFL PROGRAMMING.

MC produced a spreadsheet to the JSC in discovery herein regarding its claims. With regard to the CFL, MC identified a territorial restriction of"U.S. only" to its CFL claims, because MC was only making claim (in the sports programming category) on behalf of the CFL for U .S.-originated broadcasts (see the reproduction of the relevant portion of the spreadsheet on page 12 of the JSC' s brief). Because the CFL is a Canadian entity, Canadian-originated broadcasts would fall under the "Canadian Claimants" category. No disagreement therefore exists between the JSC's interpretation of which retransmissions MC is entitled to make claim, and for which retransmission MC has reported it is making claim.

14 Redacted: Public Version

3. THE JSC ASSERT THERE HA VE BEEN NO QUALIFYING RETRANSMISSIONS OF CFL PROGRAMMING BASED ON THE REVIEW OF A TWO PRESS RELEASES BY ONE OF THE JSC LEGAL COUNSEL.

In the course of discovery, IPG sought from the JSC and was denied evidence of JSC broadcasts of its programming. The JSC objected and refused to produce such data, and the Judges agreed. See Order Regarding Multigroup

Claimants' First Motion to Compel Production ofDocuments by Joint Sports

Claimants at fn. 8 (Sept. 14, 2016). In their order, the Judges expressly stated:

"Broadcast-by-broadcast identification of programming is not necessary for purposes of testing the validity and categorization of claims, and the Judges will not require JSC to produce such detailed information."

Id. Notwithstanding, such is exactly what the JSC assert MC has failed to produce, and now must produce in order to validate its claim to CFL programming.

Notwithstanding, although the JSC assert that it requested specific broadcast information from MC in discovery, it did not, and for such reason does not direct the Judges to any such discovery request. Rather, the JSC sent MC an argumentative letter asking for information (e.g., interrogatory-like requests) and

asking for concession on a variety of points, rather than simply identifying its

follow-up document requests. See Exh. 8 to Kientzle Deel. MC was under no obligation to engage with the JSC, was forced to filter out of such letter what

follow-up document requests were actually being made, and for such reason MC

15 Redacted: Public Version qualified its responses with a general objection that MC was required to unilaterally articulate what documents were being requested by the JSC. See Exh.

9 to Kientzle Deel., General Objection no. 12 (MC discovery responses). MC identified those document requests in MC's responses, and clearly did not identify or perceive a request for CFL programming broadcast information. Id. No challenge that MC was unresponsive was made, nor ever has been made by the

JSC, formally or informally. As such, not only was the JSC not entitled to receive the documents it complains were not received, the JSC did not even request such documents.

In any event, the entirety of the JSC challenge is based on two press releases read online and presented by one of the JSC legal counsel, Michael Kientzle.

Initially, the items do not even state that CFL broadcasts will be exclusively broadcast by NBC Sports Network, as Mr. Kientzle suggests. Moreover, Mr.

Kientzle has no apparent expertise or knowledge regarding CFL programming and its broadcasts, nor even articulates that he does. He is entirely unqualified to testify as to the aggregate of CFL programming or where it was broadcast during calendar years 2012 and 2013. Literally, the JSC seek the dismissal of all CFL programming based on two mischaracterized press releases. 4

4 Regardless, it is curious that the JSC would seek dismissal of claims for which it asserts no retransmitted broadcasts exists. If there are no CFL programming

16 Redacted: Public Version

Presuming that the JSC actually did request CFL programming broadcast information, which it did not, and presuming that MC was obligated to produce such documents, which is was not (based on the Judges' ruling), in order to support its argument the JSC cite to the requirement that a single example of a retransmitted broadcast be identified. JSC motion at pp. 13-14. Clearly, it doesn't take an expert in royalty distribution proceedings to recognize that the cited language refers to the filing requirements for "July claims", and absent the JSC establishing that IPG failed to sufficiently file its "July claim", the JSC argument is irrelevant. 5

In sum, the JSC have provided no basis for which to dismiss the program claims attributable to CFL.

broadcasts that are compensable, no royalties will be allocated, so much ado about nothing.

5 Ironically, the JSC refer to IPG's challenge to several SDC claims in the 2000- 2003 proceedings, whereby IPG affirmatively established several instances in which the retransmission example cited in several SDC claims did not occur on the identified date, on the identified station, or at all. Despite such fact, the Judges denied all ofIPG's challenges to such claims. Memorandum Opinion and Order Following Preliminary Hearing on Validity ofClaims at fu. 14 (Mar. 21, 2013). Such ruling, by all appearances, is precedent for the JSC's inability to even make the challenge it has made herein. Why the JSC would have cited to such precedent is entirely unclear.

17 Redacted: Public Version

C. THERE IS NO LEGAL BASIS TO DISMISS MULTIGROUP CLAIMANTS' CLAIM TO TV AZTECA PROGRAMMING.

1. MULTIGROUP CLAIMANTS RIGHTS ARE DERIVED THROUGH AZTECA INTERNATIONAL CORPORATION.

The JSC challenge MC's right to collect royalties on behalf of TV Azteca on the grounds that MC has not produced an agreement directly between TV Azteca and IPG. However, as the JSC acknowledge, IPG entered into written agreements with Azteca International Corporation ("AIC").

IPG (and its successor SLP) entered into a representation agreement (and amendment thereto) with AIC for the collection of retransmission royalties on

January 21, 2015 and June 9, 2016. See Kientzle Deel. at Exhs. 19, 20.

As set forth in the opening provisions of the January 21, 2015 representation agreement:

1. Authorization: AIC holds the rights to use and exploit TV Azteca, S.A.B. de C. V. 's programming in the U.S. ("TV Azteca") and it is a subsidiary of TV Azteca. AIC hereby grants and assigns IPG the non-transferrable, non-assignable, non-sublicensable right to any and all cable and satellite retransmission royalties distributed in the territory of the United States ... attributable to all audiovisual works owned and/or distributed by AIC (the "Programs").

Kientzle Deel. at Exh. 19 (emphasis added). Further, under paragraph 8 thereto:

AIC's Representations and Warranties: AIC warrants that AIC retains the exclusive authority to the Distribution Proceeds, and has not previously conveyed the right to collect the Distribution Proceeds to any third party.

18 Redacted: Public Version

As the foregoing makes clear, AI C is a subsidiary of TV Azteca, and retains the exclusive right to TV Azteca's programming in the U.S., and the exclusive authority to the retransmission royalties attributable to TV Azteca programming.

Thereafter, the June 9, 2016 amendment to the initial agreement expressly acknowledges that IPG' s rights under the agreement have been assigned to SLP. 6

As set forth in the JSC motion, SLP subsequently transferred its interest in these proceedings to MC. AIC oho TV Azteca has provided IPG with extensive lists of the programming for which IPG to make claim in these proceedings. Exhibit D.

By contrast, zero communications between TV Azteca and the MPAA, or the

MPAA's represented agents, has been produced.

Notwithstanding, the JSC asserts that the TV Azteca claims were held by

Fintage and then EGEDA, and that the MPAA, not IPG or MC, represents

EGEDA. However, any authority ofFintage to represent TV Azteca ended no later than March 1, 2013, because of the termination of the Fintage/TV Azteca agreement. Kientzle decl., Exh. 22 at Exh. B thereto. However, according to prior rulings of the Judges making the "last in time" conveyance controlling, Fintage's rights arguably ended as early as February 22, 2011, when EGEDA entered into an agreement with TV Azteca. Id. In tum, EGEDA's right to make claim on behalf

6 See opening recitals: "WHEREAS, SLP assumed the Agreement and agreed to perform all obligations of Independent Producers Group ("IPG") under the Agreement after January 21, 2015". Kientzle Deel. at Exh. 20.

19 Redacted: Public Version of TV Azteca ended no later than January 21, 2015, when an authorized representative of TV Azteca, AIC, granted such rights to IPG (then SLP). Kientzle decl., Exh. 19.

In prior proceedings, IPG challenged that in circumstances in which a claimant had granted the same rights to both IPG and another party, the "first in time rule" prevailed, further noting that allowing a "last in time" rule to apply ignored IPG's contractual entitlement to a perpetual post-Term right to collect royalties generated during the "Term", i.e., IPG' s post-term right to collect

"irrespective ofwhen such Distribution Proceeds are payable." The MPAA disputed this application, and the Judges agreed with the MPAA.7 On this basis alone, the Judges awarded program claims attributable to such parties as BBC

Worldwide Americas and Pacific Family Entertainment, despite the circumstance that IPG's contractual engagement predated the MPAA's, and no notice of termination (i.e., termination of the "Term") was provided to IPG until the filing of the MPAA's motion to strike claims (or ever, in the case of Pacific Family

Entertainment; see infra). See infra; see Memorandum Opinion And Ruling On

Validity And Categorization Of Claims, Docket Nos. 2012-6 CRB CD 2004-2009

7 In fact, and perhaps not anticipating its application to the program claims of TV Azteca, the MPAA reiterates its advocacy of such rule in its motion to strike claims, and cites to the Judges' ruling thereon. MPAA motion at p. 23, and fn. 76 (citing Final Distribution Order, 78 Fed. Reg. 64989 (Oct. 30, 2013).

20 Redacted: Public Version

(Phase II) and 2012-7 CRB SD 1999-2009 (Phase II) at Exh. A-1, pp. 4, 25 (March

13, 2015) (the "Memorandum Opinion").

In the current situation with TV Azteca, the agreements that stand as the authority for MC to make claim for TV Azteca programming all post-date the agreements on which the MPAA relies and, contrary to the MPAA (whom the JSC argues represents TV Azteca programming), IPG' s agreement is directly with an entity that is actually related to TV Azteca, its U.S. subsidiary that controls U.S. distribution rights. Applying the "last in time" rule that the Judges have ruled applies, MC's entitlement to make claim to TV Azteca programming is superior to that of the MPAA's (vis-a-vis any third party). Application of the contrary rule of law would necessarily contradict the Judges' prior rulings.

Aside from the immediate issue, the JSC have uncovered a disturbing fact not known by IPG or MC: that in November of 2012, TV Azteca terminated its agreement with Fintage, who had assigned its rights to the MPAA. To be specific, despite the fact that TV Azteca had terminated its agreement with Fintage in 2012, the MPAA never disclosed such fact or produced such termination letter to

IPG in the 2000-2003 Cable proceedings or the Consolidated Proceedings.

The MPAA represented in discovery in those proceedings that it had

produced to IPG copies of all documents regarding the MPAA's right to make

claim for TV Azteca royalties. (See Exhibit 316 (at Exhibit 6 thereof) to "MPAA

21 Redacted: Public Version

Opposition to IPG Motion to Strike MPAA Claims" in the 2004-2009 Cable and

1999-2009 Satellite proceedings.) Clearly, the MPAA failed to produce a termination document relevant to those proceedings. Not only can the unproduced letter of termination not be used by the to attack IPG's claim, it is a basis for dismissing any entitlement of the MPAA to TV Azteca programming.

2. TV AZTECA'S CLAIMS HAVE BEEN PRESERVED BY THIRD PARTIES, AND TV AZTECA APPEARS ON THE SLP PETITIONS TO PARTICIPATE.

The JSC is correct that IPG did not file "July claims" identifying TV Azteca.

Notwithstanding, TV Azteca was identified as a claimant appearing on the joint claims filed by Fintage Publishing and Collection, B.V. ("Fintage") for calendar years 2010-2013, and the joint claims filed by EGEDA for calendar years 2012-

2013.8

The JSC is also correct that "AIC" was not identified on the petitions to participate filed by Spanish Language Producers ("SLP"). This is for the obvious reason that the identified claimant on the aforementioned "July claims" was not

8 Of immediate note is the fact that TV Azteca terminated its agreement with Fintage by letter of November 12, 2012, with termination "effective March l, 2013" (see Kientzle Deel., Exh. 22 at Exh. B thereto).

It is also curious that EGEDA submits that it entered into an agreement with TV Azteca dated February 22, 2011, but then did not include TV Azteca on its joint claims until 2012, even though it ostensibly had the exclusive authority to include TV Azteca in its filings for 2010 (occurring in July 2011). Id.

22 Redacted: Public Version

AIC, but rather "TV Azteca S.A. de C.V.". Consequently, "TV Azteca S.A. de

C.V." appears on SLP's petitions to participate.

Nevertheless, SLP did file petitions to participate naming TV Azteca. Still, the JSC challenge the legitimacy of this filing, claiming that IPG's transfer of authority to SLP was conditional on there being a Spanish Language Programming

"Phase I" category. Kientzle decl., Exh. 5. Yet the JSC disingenuously ignore the very next sentence of the IPG/SLP transfer, which expressly states that in the event there is no Spanish Language category, the rights are transferred to MC. Id.

The JSC then state that these claims are invalid because "authority to represent a claimant must exist at the time a petition is filed" and SLP was not assigned the TV Azteca rights by IPG until after petitions had been filed. First of all, the JSC's assertion is entirely incorrect, as IPG had the authority to represent

TV Azteca when the SLP petition was filed and had already transferred its interest to SLP. Further, and anticipating the JSC to next argue that AIC did not approve of the IPG/SLP transfer, AIC did approve such transfer at the time of its occurrence. Exhibit E. Further, later documentation executed by AIC

acknowledges the already-existing IPG/SLP transfer within its recitals. Kientzle

decl., Exh. 20. Further, even though the amendment agreement between AIC, IPG,

and SLP has no assignment restriction, AIC is expressly aware of its representation

in these proceedings by MC, and has executed a document making clear that it

23 Redacted: Public Version consents to SLP' s assignment to MC of obligations incun·ed under its agreement with IPG. Exhibit F.

Next, the JSC question the validity of the IPG-SLP assignment because Raul

Galaz executed it on behalf of SLP. Raul Galaz did execute on behalf of SLP, but there is no reason that such fact invalidates the agreement as Raul Galaz was an authorized representative of SLP, and no evidence exists to the contrary.

3. MULTIGROUP CLAIMANTS PRODUCED EXTENSIVE DOCUMENTATION IDENTIFYING THE TV AZTECA PROGRAMMING.

The JSC then falsely claim that MC failed to produce any documentation indicating that TV Azteca is entitled to claim these royalties for the programs identified herein. That is simply and demonstrably untrue: as "Item 10" to its production of documents to the JSC, MC produced documentation from AIC in the form of seven Excel spreadsheets prepared by AIC in which AIC categorized its programming pursuant to the CRB 's Phase I category definitions, including the

Sports category, along with email correspondence from AIC on the subject. See

Exhibit E. As such, the JSC are simply mistaken in their allegation.

Next, the JSC complain that MC did not produce in discovery documents sufficient to establish that TV Azteca is the owner of the sports programming to which it makes claim. However, the JSC misapply both the requirements of discovery, and the Judges' rulings regarding the "presumption of validity".

24 Redacted: Public Version

First, as the JSC motion reveals, no request for documents between TV

Azteca and any sports club was requested by the JSC. Rather, the JSC made a combination interrogatory/document request, and the document request generically covered all documents on which MC was relying. Such documents, correspondence from AIC oho TV Azteca, was produced to the JSC. Exhibit E.

Second, following the Judges prior rulings on discovery, MC did not even have an obligation to inquire from TV Azteca regarding agreements it might have had with any specific sports clubs. MC appreciates the JSC's frustration with such rule of application, and MC (and IPG) have regularly challenged the legitimacy and prudence of a discovery rule that does not require either the production or even inquiry of entitlement along the entire chain-of-title. Nonetheless, that is the rule of application that the Judges have followed, and MC therefore had no reason or purpose to make further inquiry with TV Azteca regarding such matter.

Third, the "presumption of validity" applicable to the claims of TV Azteca dictates that its claims must be taken at face value as legitimate unless and until contradictory evidence of ownership or entitlement is presented by the JSC.

Unlike MC's challenge upon the JSC, wherein MC relies on copyright registrations and the JSC's own admissions regarding the owners of sports broadcasts claimed by the JSC, the JSC have presented no piece of evidence contradicting TV

Azteca's claim to its sports programming. Further, and although the JSC premises

25 Redacted: Public Version its argument on the false statement that TV Azteca has presented no information regarding its program claims, such assertion is patently false. As noted, MC produced correspondence from AI C identifying all of its programming, and identifying such programming according to the Phase I category definitions relied on by the Judges. Exhibit E.

Notably, the JSC address the presumption that sports leagues are entitled to receive the retransmission royalties distributed in these proceedings. However, as even the cited authority holds, such presumption exists only in the absence of contractual arrangements specifically providing that such royalties shall be distributed to broadcaster claimants. 1978 Cable Royalty Distribution

Determination, Docket No. CRT-79-1, 45 Fed. Reg. 63026, 63034-63035 (Sept.

23, 1980). By its claim, TV Azteca tacitly asserts that such agreements exist, and the fact that there is there is no basis to challenge the "presumption of validity" accorded to TV Azteca by such claim means that such claim stands. If the JSC has presented any evidence to the contrary, e.g., contradictory copyright registrations, etc., then the presumption might have been overcome and the burden of proof

shifted, but the JSC have presented no countervailing evidence, at all.9

9 Moreover, MC has been led to believe from online review that at least certain of the soccer sports clubs for which TV Azteca makes claim are owned by TV Aztec a.

26 Redacted: Public Version

The JSC's final point is equally at odds with reality. First, the JSC complain again that MC did not respond to the JSC's informal one-way discovery demands via rambling discovery letters to MC (attached as Exhibits 8 and 9 to the Kientzle

Declaration). Obviously, MC had no obligation to respond to such correspondence and instead waited to do so in the formal (and not one-way) discovery process herein. Second, while the JSC contend that those requests included requests that

MC produce documents which indicated the nature of the TV Azteca sports programming, actually they did not. Third, as set forth above, TV Azteca had prepared the seven Excel spreadsheets which categorized its programming and MC produced them and their attendant emails as Item 10 to MC's discovery responses to the JSC' s discovery requests.

Therefore, the JSC's statement that MC "should have produced a document containing a representation from TV Azteca itself that each TV Azteca Program involves the live telecast of a soccer match", is factually incorrect, because MC produced that precise thing in Item 10 of its responses to the JSC's discovery requests.

27 Redacted: Public Version

4. THE PROGRAMMING LISTS PROVIDED BY TV AZTECA EXPRESSLY SEGREGATES THE PROGRAMS INTO THE PHASE I CATEGORIES APPLICABLE TO THESE PROCEEDINGS.

On what basis the JSC assert that MC did not identify the appropriate Phase

I category for TV Azteca programming is befuddling. MC produced correspondence from TV Azteca which attached seven separate spreadsheets, each of which identified the categories of TV Azteca programming, including by means more specific than would apply in these proceedings. Exhibit E. Either the JSC has misplaced the TV Azteca correspondence, or is being disingenuous.

CONCLUSION

For the reasons set forth herein, the JSC motion should be denied in its entirety.

Dated: October 28, 2016 ---Isl------Brian D. Boydston, Esq. California State Bar No. 155614

PICK & BOYDSTON, LLP 10786 Le Conte Ave. Los Angeles, California 90024 Telephone: (213) 624-1996 Facsimile: (213) 624-9073 Email: [email protected]

Attorneys for Multigroup Claimants

28 Redacted: Public Version

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I hereby certify that on this 31st day of October 2016, a copy of the foregoing was sent by electronic mail to the parties listed on the attached Service

List.

------Isl Brian D. Boydston, Esq.

SETTLING DEVOTIONAL CLAIMANTS

Matthew MacLean, Esq. PILSBURY WINTHROP SHAW PITTMAN LLP 1200 Seventeenth Street NW Washington, DC 20036

Matthew .maclean@pillsbury law .com

NATIONAL ASSOCIATION of BROADCASTERS

John I. Stewart Crowell & Moring LLP 1001 Pennsylvania Avenue NW Washington, DC 20004 Email: [email protected]

CANADIAN CLAIMANTS GROUP

L. Kendall Satterfield, Esq. FINKELSTEIN THOMPSON LLP 1077 30th Street, NW Washington, DC 20007

29 Redacted: Public Version [email protected]

LARSON & GATSON LLP 200 S. Robles Ave., Suite 530 Pasadena, CA 91101 Victor [email protected]

JOINT SPORTS CLAIMANTS

Robert Alan Garrett ARNOLD AND PORTER LLP 601 Massachusetts Ave., NW Washington, DC 20001 Email: [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]

Thomas J. Ostertag OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF BASEBALL 245 Park Avenue New York, NY 10167 Email: [email protected]

Phillip R. Hochberg, Esq. LAW OFFICES OF PHILLIP R. HOCHBERG 12505 Park Potomac A venue, 6th Floor Potomac, 1vID 20854 [email protected]

Ritchie T. Thomas, Esq. SQUISRE, SANDERS & DEMPSEY LLP 1201 Pennsylvania Ave., NW Washington, DC 20004 Email: [email protected]; [email protected]

MPAA-REPRESENTED PROGRAM SUPPLIERS

Gregory 0. Olaniran, Esq.

30 Redacted: Public Version

MITCHELL SILBERBERG & KNUPP LLP 1818 n Street N.W., 8th Floor Washington, DC 20036 Email: [email protected]; [email protected]

MUSIC CLAIMANTS

AMERICAN SOCIETY OF COMPOSERS, AUTHORS, AND PUBLISHERS

Samuel Mosenkis AS CAP One American Plaza New York, NY 10023 Email: [email protected]; [email protected]

BROADCAST MUSIC, INC.

Joseph DiMona BROADCAST MUSIC, INC. 7 World Trade Center 250 Greenwich Street New York, NY 10007-0030 Email: [email protected]

Michael J. Remington, Esq. DRINKER BIDDLE & REATH LLP 1500 K Street, NW - Suite 1100 Washington, DC 20005 Email: [email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]

NATIONAL PUBLIC RADIO

Gregory A. Lewis NATIONAL PUBLIC RADIO 1111 North Capitol Street, NE Washington, DC 20002 Email: [email protected]

31 Redacted: Public Version

SESAC,INC.

John C. Beiter, Esq. SHACKELFORD, BOWEN, ZUMWALT & HAYES 4 7 Music Square East Nashville, TN 37203 Email: [email protected]

Christos P. Badavas SESAC 152 West 57th Street, 57th Floor New York, NY 10019 Email: [email protected]

BROADCASTER CLAIMANTS GROUP

John I. Stewart, Esq. Ann Mace CROWELL & MORING LLP 1001 Pennsylvania Ave., NW Washington, DC 20004-2595 Email: [email protected]

Richie T. Thomas, Esq. SQUIRE PATTON BOGGS 2550 M Street Northwest Washington, D.C., 20037 Email: [email protected]

32 EXHIBIT A Before the COPYRIGHT ROYALTY JUDGES Washington, D.C.

In the Matter of ) ) Distribution of ) Docket No. 14-CRB-0010-CD 2010-2013 2010-2013 ) _C_ab_le__ R_oy_a_lt~y_F_un_d_s ______)

In the Matter of ) ) Distribution of ) Docket No. 14-CRB-OO 11-SD 2010-2013 2010-2013 ) .;.;;..Sa.;;.;...;t...... ,el..._li;.;;..;;te;....;;R;...;;;..o;;;...,.jy'-"-'a;,::..;;lt..,,_y..;;;..,F-=u;;;.;;;.nd;;..;..=s:;....__ __)

DECLARATION OF RAUL GALAZ IN SUPPORT OF MULTIGROUP CLAIMANTS' OPPOSITION TO JSC MOTION TO DISALLOW THE MULTIGROUP CLAIMANTS' CLAIMS AGAINST THE SPORTS CATEGORY

I, Raul Galaz, swear under penalty of perjury, that the following is true and correct:

1. I am over twenty-one years of age, am of sound mind and suffer from no legal disabilities. I am fully competent to testify to the matters set forth in this declaration. I have personal knowledge of all the facts stated herein and am in all respects qualified to assert the same. The contents of this declaration are true and correct.

Multigroup Claimants exhibits. 2. Attached hereto as Exhibit B is a true and correct copy of documents produced to the Joint Sports Claimants ("JSC") in this proceeding, including documents relating to the claims of FIFA, appearing at bate-stamp nos. 2027-2146.

3. Attached hereto as Exhibit C is a true and correct copy of the

Affidavit of Margaret Dale, legal counsel to FIFA.

4. Attached hereto as Exhibit D is a true and correct copy of an email dated April 1, 2016, from Fabiola Rivas to IPG, identifying the program claims of TV Azteca.

5. Attached hereto as Exhibit E is a true and correct copy of a letter dated January 21, 2015 from IPG to Azteca International Corporation, indicating AIC's consent to IPG's transfer of interests to Spanish Language

Producers ("SLP").

6. Attached hereto as Exhibit F is a true and correct copy of a letter dated October 22, 2016 from SLP to Azteca International Corporation, indicating AIC's consent to SLP's transfer of interests to Multigroup

Claimants.

DATED: October 31, 2016

By: ____Isl ______Raul Galaz

2 EXHIBITB REDACTED

SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER IN DOCKET NO. 2008-2 CRB CD 2000-2003 (Phase II) EXHIBITC Before the COPYRIGHT ROY ALTY JUDGES Washington, D.C.

) In the Matter of ) ) Docket No. 2008-2 CRB CD 2000-2003 Distribution of the 2000, 2001, ) 2002, and 2003 Cable Royal ) Funds )

AFFIDAVIT OF MARGARET A. DALE

STATEOFNEWYORK) ) ) ss: COUNTY OF NEW YORK )

MARGARET A. DALE, being duly sworn, deposes and says:

1. I am a member of the Bar of the State of New York, and a partner at Proskauer

Rose LLP, resident in the New York office. I submit this affidavit to place certain facts before the Copyright Royalty Judges in the above-captioned proceeding.

2. Proskauer represents Federation Internationale de Football Association ("FIFA").

On August 1, 2012, at the direction of FIFA' s Senior Legal Counsel, Sanjiv Arora, I wrote to inform the Copyright Royalty Board that Worldwide Subsidy Group LLC dba Independent

Producers Group does not represent FIFA, and that FIFA is not represented by Pick & Boydston,

LLP, attorneys for Independent Producers Group, in connection with these proceedings. A copy of my August 1, 2012 letter is attached hereto as Exhibit A.

32387201 3. Attached hereto as Exhibit B is a true and correct copy of an email string between myself and Mr. Raul Galaz, who I understand works for Worldwide Subsidy Group LLC dba

Independent Producers Group.

Sworn to before me this 21st day of September, 2012

1~lic~jJJµ-

BEVERLY WALKER Notary Public, State of New York No. 01WA4683190 Qualified lfl Suffo1k County Certificate Flied In New York County Commission Expires Oct. 31, 2014

-2- EXHIBIT A Pro ska uer» Proskauer Rose LLP Eleven Times Square New York. NY 10036-8299

Margaret A Dale August 1, 2012 Member of the Farm d 212.969.3315 BY USPS EXPRESS MAIL r 212.sae.2soo mdale@proskauer com Copyright Royalty Board www.proskauer com P.0. Box 70977 Southwest Station Washington, DC 20024-0977

Re: Docket No. 2008-2 CRB CD 2000-2003 - Federation Internationale de Football Association

Dear Copyright Royalty Judges:

This firm represents Federation Internationale de Football Association (4'FIF A"). At the direction of our client's Senior Legal Counsel, Sanjiv Arora, we are writing to inform the Copyright Royalty Board that Worldwide Subsidy Group LLC dba Independent Producers Group does not represent FIFA in the Distribution of the 2000-2003 Cable Royalty Funds, Docket No. 2008-2 CRB CD 2000-2003. Furthermore, FIFA is not represented by Pick & Boydston, LLP, attorneys for Independent Producers Group, in connection with these proceedings.

Enclosed please find five copies of this letter, an electronic PDF copy of this letter on a CD, and proof of service of the individuals identified in the service list.

Please contact the undersigned if you have any questions regarding this matter.

Sincerely yours, ~ Margaret A. Dale (N. Y. Bar No. 2318004)

Enclosures cc: Service list

Becjlllg I Boca Raton I Boston I Chicago I Hong Kong I London I Los Angetes I New Orleans I New Yor1< I Newark I Pans I SAo Paulo I Washington, DC CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I hereby certify that on this 1st day of August, 2012, I caused a copy of the foregoing letter to be sent by Federal Express overnight mail to the individuals listed below:

Independent Producers Group Broadcast Music, Inc. Brian D. Boydston Michael J. Remington PICK & BOYDSTON, LLP Jeffrey J. Lopez 617 S. Olive Street, Suite 400 Philip J. Cardinale Los Angeles, CA 90014 DRINKER, BIDDLE & REATH LLP 1500 K Street, N.W., Ste. 1100 Public Television Washing ton, DC 2-0005 Ronald G. Dove, Jr. Lindsey Tonsager Marvin L. Berenson COVINGTON & BURLING Joseph J. DiMona 1201 Pennsylvania Avenue, N. W. BROADCAST MUSIC, INC. Washington, DC 20004-2401 7 World Trade Center 250 Greenwich Street Gene Ashe New York, NY 10007-0042 Marc Magnum Public Broadcasting Service SESAC. Inc. 2100 Crystal Drive John C. Beiter Arlington, VA 22202-3785 ZUMWALT, ALMON &HAYES PLLC 1014 16th Avenue South MP AA-Represented Program Suppliers Nashville, TN 37212 Gregory 0. Olaniran Lucy Holmes Plovnick National Association of Broadcasters MITCHELL SILVERBERG John I. Stewart, Jr. &KNUPPLLP Jennifer H. Burdman 1818 N. Street, N.W., gth Floor Ann Mace Washington, DC 20036 CROWELL & MORING, LLP 1001 Pennsylvania Avenue, N. W. American Society of Composers. Authors Washington, DC 20004-2595 and Publishers Joan M. McGivem SamuellVlosenlcis AS CAP One Lincoln Plaza New York, NY 10023 Joint Sports Claimants Robert Alan Garrett Stephen K. Marsh Marco Palmieri ARNOLD & PORTER LLP 555 Twelfth Street, N.W. Washington, DC 20004-1206

Canadian Claimants Group L. Kendall Satterfield FINKELSTEIN THOMSON LLP I 050 30th Street, N. W. Washington, DC 20007

Victor Cosentino LARSON & GASTON LLP 200 S. Los Robles Avenue, Suite 530 Pasadena, CA 91101

Devotional Claimants Arnold P. Lutzker Allison L. Rapp Jeanette Carmadella LUTZKER & LUTZKER LLP 1233 20th Street, NW, Suite 703 Washington, DC 20036

Clifford M. HaiTington Jack McKay Paul Cicelski Alison B. Rousseau PILLSBURY WINTHROP SHAW PITTMANLLP _2300 N. Street, N.W. Washington, DC 20037-1128 EXHIBITB Page 1 of 5

Toner, Barbara

From: Dale, Margaret A. Sent: Monday, July 30, 2012 2:59 PM To: 'Raul Galaz' Cc: '[email protected]'; Weinstein, Lawrence I. Subject: RE: FIFA broadcasts Mr. Galaz, I am not aware of any communications prior to the July 31, 2001 email either. Margaret Dale

From: Raul Galaz [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Monday, July 30, 2012 2:53 PM To: Dale, Margaret A. Cc: [email protected]; Weinstein, Lawrence I. Subject: Fwd: FIFA broadcasts

Dear Ms. Dale, my apologies, but I neglected to ask you about one of your comments. Specifically, you seem to choose your words very carefully that FIFA has no communications in its possession "following" the July 31, 2001 email from FIFA to WSG. Mr. Arora informed me that FIFA had no communications that precede or follow the July 31, 2001 email that would provide greater context to the July 31 email. Are you suggesting something other than that? If so, then please share such communications with us.

Thank you, and I look forward to your response.

Raul Galaz Worldwide Subsidy Group

--Original Message- From: Raul Galaz To: mdale Cc: brianb ; LWeinstein Sent: Mon, Jul 30, 2012 1:24 pm Subject: Re: FIFA broadcasts

Dear Ms. Dale, clearly, we are at an impasse, as WSG considers a communication stating 11FIFA Is interested in testing the services of the Worldwide Subsidy Group in the administration of retransmission royalties. Please go ahead with the necessary steps and keep us informed about the proceedings and the outcome" to mean exactly that, i.e., WSG should take the necessary steps and keep FIFA Informed about the proceedings. You and your client ascribe no meaning to this communication. As we explained previously, the only proceedings that have arisen are the proceedings with which we are currently involved, which took more than a decade to commence, and WSG promptly contacted FIFA regarding such proceedings.

As for my criminal conviction, you are only partially correct. All of my crimes, large and small, were addressed in my sole criminal conviction, and admitted by myself when I came forward to governmental authorities before ever being contacted by them. Moreover, this news was already addressed with FIFA almost a year ago, and Ff FA was given the option of dealing with someone other than myself. Consequently, I am not certain why you are raising the matter at this time. The crime does not involve FIFA. and does not involve Worldwide Subsidy Group LLC. As such, while you may consider it to have a bearing on my personal credibility, it really has nothing to do with FIFA's contractual obligations, or WSG's entitlements.

You may certainly take whatever actions you believe are warranted in order to protect your client's interests. In many ways, it creates a cleaner record for review, and makes clear that WSG has taken all

9/21/2012 Page 2of5

actions it reasonably could take in order to collect the subject royalties.

Thank you for your attention to this matter.

Raul Galaz Worldwide Subsidy Group

---Original Message----- From: Dale, Margaret A. To: Raul Galaz Cc: brianb ; Weinstein, Lawrence I. ; Dale, Margaret A. Sent: Mon, Jul 30, 2012 12:16 pm Subject: RE: FIFA broadcasts

Dear Mr. Galaz,

We disagree with your two points. A single email from July 31, 2001 hardly qualifies as a "direction to act" with respect to the current proceeding, or any other for that matter. We are not aware of any communications between Worldwide Subsidy Group and FIFA after this email. and there exists no executed contract between your company and FIFA. Furthermore, on June 20, 2002, you pleaded guilty to one count of mail fraud In federal court in Washington DC. That felony conviction involved a falsification of royalty claims. Additionally, following this fraud, you were found by another court to have entered into an illegal money-laundering contract to place illicit royalty proceeds in an offshore bank account. As we have said before, FIFA has not and does not authorize you, Worldwide Subsidy Group, and/or Independent Producers Group to represent it before the Copyright Royalty Board. We intend to alert the Copyright Royalty Board to this fact.

Sincerely, Margaret Dale

From: Raul Galaz [marlto:[email protected] Sent: Tuesday, July 17, 2012 11:06 AM To: Dale, Margaret A. Cc: [email protected]; Weinstein, Lawrence I.; Kleiman, Zachary Subject: Re: FIFA broadcasts

Dear Ms. Dale, two points:

1) has anyone on your side of the table looked at the Excel file that was forwarded? There are 168 program broadcasts, of 150-180 minutes in length, described as "World Cup Soccer", from "Seoul, South Korea" (and the other locations at which the 2002 World Cup Soccer matches were located), on the exact dates that those matches occurred. These program broadcasts do not just reflect commentary. Rather, they are the live transmissions of the matches. There are another 101 broadcasts of programming entitled "World Cup Soccer: Highlights" for which the average broadcast Is over two hours in length, with lengths of up to 338 minutes, on the same dates. That would be a lot of "commentary0 without footage.

With all due respect, it is not reasonable to suggest that these broadcasts do not reflect the live broadcasts, or do not otherwise include footage of the matches. It is also not reasonable to suggest that FIFA could not, If It so chose, review the contracts with the limited number of broadcasters that broadcast the matches. In fact, there might even be a single distributor contract. As reflected by the Excel file, the stations airing these broadcasts include only six broadcasters, CBET, CBLT, CBMT, CBUT, CBWT, CKWS. [fhere are also two single broadcasts in 2003 of World Cup Soccer matches from Lyon, France, however we will Ignore them for the time being.] In any event, and as I mentioned in a prior email to you, Sanjlv Arora explicitly described to me the continuing copyright ownership of FIFA in the program footage, which fact is substantiated even in filings with the U.S. Copyright Office.

2) I understand your issue with the failure to locate a signed copy of the agreement that was sent to FIFA. That bothers me as well. However, there is no issue that FIFA representatives instructed WSG to make the filings that were covered by the document proposed by WSG for signature. That much can be established. It therefore gives rise to the issue of what significance you and your client are giving to the instruction that can be established to exist? WSG acted on at least 9/21/2012 Page 3of5

that instruction (and perhaps a signed contract, yet to be located), has performed all it was required to do under that instruction, and now stands capable of recovering a significant royalty to FIFA pursuant to the very proceedings referenced in FIFA's email. Is it your client's position that there is no significance to the instruction of FIFA that 11 FIFA is interested In testing the services of the Worldwide Subsidy Group in the administration of retransmission royalties. Please go ahead with the necessary steps and keep us informed about the proceedings and the outcome"?

We are genuinely trying to be encouraging and cooperative here, but if your client is intent on giving no credence to the July 31, 2001 direction to act, and will make no effort to even check the handful of contracts relating to the specified broadcasts, then there really is little for us to discuss, and this becomes a legal matter. As we have also attempted to explain, of the two choices before FIFA, the one by which it receives royalties with a modicum of effort seems the most rational. I realize that you cannot compel your client to do anything, however if I were in your position (and I have been), I would be strongly urging your client to cooperate.

Raul Galaz Worldwide Subsidy Group

---Original Message---- From: Dale, Margaret A. To: Raul Galaz Cc: brianb ; Weinstein, Lawrence I. ; Kleiman, Zachary Sent: Tue, Jul 17, 2012 8:43 am Subject: RE: FIFA broadcasts

Dear Mr. Galaz,

FIFA cannot say for certain that any FIFA copyright is contained within the programs for which re 4 transmission royalties are being sought as FIFA has not viewed those programs. For example, If the program is a panel of sports experts discussing the game with no footage, then FIFA certainly has no copyright to it.

More importantly, as previously stated, FIFA has not located an agreement authorizing WSG to represent FIFA before the Copyright Royalty Board in connection with the retransmission royalties. Further, we understand that WSG Itself is not in possession of such an agreement. Under the circumstances, FIFA does not Intend to provide further information concerning its agreements with broadcasters.

Sincerely,

Margaret Dale

From: Raul Galaz [mallto:[email protected]] Sent: Tuesday, July 10, 2012 12:28 PM To: Dale, Margaret A. Cc: [email protected]; Weinstein, Lawrence I.; Kleiman, Zachary Subject: Re: FIFA broadcasts

Dear Ms. Dale,

I am presuming that you reviewed the broadcast data that we sent. Armed with the information that we have provided about the specific broadcasters of the World Cup soccer matches, is FIFA currently attempting to review contracts with those broadcasters to see what information exists within those contracts?

When I spoke with Sanjiv Arora a few months ago, he explained the process by which the World Cup "IP" (intellectual property) was "licensed" to various broadcasters for live broadcast, and then replay rights allowed for a subsequent limited period of time (I think he said two years, typically). Mr. Arora's description makes clear what we are seeking confirmation of, i.e., that FIFA retains perpetual ownership of the underlying footage copyright.

Raul Galaz

-Original Message-- From: Dale, Margaret A. To: Raul Galaz 9/21/2012 Page 4of5

Cc: Weinstein, Lawrence I. ; brianb ; Kleiman, Zachary Sent: Tue, Jul 10, 2012 8:29 am Subject: RE: FIFA broadcasts

Dear Mr. Galaz, Thank you for your email. We have seen the excel spreadsheet that you attached. However, that spreadsheet does not answer the fundamental question of whether FIFA retained the copyright to the content for the 2002 WorldCup or If the copyright was part of the license /assignment to the broadcasters. FIFA does not presently know the answer to that question and Is not prepared to represent, or permit anyone else to represent, that It Is entitled to retransmission royalties for the period In question. Further, as we discussed, FIFA has not been able to locate an agreement between it and WSG authorizing WSG to represent FIFA before the Copyright Royalty Board in connection with the retransmission royalties. Under these circumstances, FIFA Is not In a position to provide the information that you request. Sincerely, Margaret Dale

From: Raul Galaz [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Monday, July 09, 2012 4:01 PM To: Kleiman, Zachary; Dale, Margaret A. Cc: Weinstein, Lawrence I.;[email protected] Subject: FIFA broadcasts

Zack and Margaret,

I just had my first opportunity to look at the slew of emails that I received today, including an email forwarded from WSG's legal counsel that had your email addresses.

On the subject of what we were speaking about this morning, attached is the Excel spreadsheet that we previously provided to FIFA demonstrating the retransmitted broadcasts that have generated a retransmission royalty. As I noted, these are all Canadian or Mexican-originated broadcasts, because the U.S.-originated World Cup broadcasts were a network feed (NBC, If I recall), and network broadcasts do not qualify for cable retransmission royalties, only satellite retransmission royalties (the proceedings of which have not yet commenced).

Raul Galaz Worldwide Subsidy Group

********************************************************** To ensure compliance with requirements imposed by U.S. Treasury Regulations, Proskauer Rose LLP informs you that any U.S. tax advice contained in this communication (including any attachments) was not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, for the purpose of (i) avoiding penalties under the Internal Revenue Code or (ii) promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any transaction or matter addressed herein.

********************************************************* This message and its attachments are sent from a law firm and may contain information that is confidential and protected by privilege from disclosure. If you are not the intended recipient, you are prohibited from printing, copying, forwarding or saving them. Please delete the message and attachments without printing, copying, forwarding or saving them, and notify the sender immediately.

======;======~======~======

********************************************************** To ensure compliance with requirements imposed by U.S.

9/21/2012 Page 5of5

Treasury Regulations, Proskauer Rose LLP informs you that any U.S. tax advice contained in this communication (including any attachments) was not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, for the purpose of (i) avoiding penalties under the Internal Revenue Code or (ii) promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any transaction or matter addressed herein.

********************************************************* This message and its attachments are sent from a law firm and may contain information that is confidential and protected by privilege from disclosure. If you are not the intended recipient, you are prohibited from printing, copying, forwarding or saving them. Please delete the message and attachments without printing, copying, forwarding or saving them, and notify the sender inunediately. ======

********************************************************** To ensure compliance with requirements imposed by U.S. Treasury Regulations, Proskauer Rose LLP informs you that any U.S. tax advice contained in this communication (including any attachments) was not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, for the purpose of (i) avoiding penalties under the Internal Revenue Code or (ii) promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any transaction or matter addressed herein.

********************************************************* This message and its attachments are sent from a law firm and may contain information that is confidential and protected by privilege from disclosure. If you are not the intended recipient, you are prohibited from printing, copying, forwarding or saving them. Please delete the message and attachments without printing, copying, forwarding or saving them, and notify the sender immediately.

======~======;=~=~======

9/21/2012 EXHIBITD From: frivas To: Raul Galaz Cc: hmedal Subject: Re: Azteca Date: Fri, Apr 1, 2016 5:57 pm Attachments: Transmision Aztecs America 2008 OK rev 3.xlsx (20K), Transmisi6n Aztecs America 2009-0K rev 3.xlsx {18K), Transmisi6n Aztecs America 2010 OK - Rev 3.xlsx (16K). Transmisi6n Azteca America 2011- 0K- rev 3.xlsx (20K}, Transmisi6n Azteca America 2012 OK- rev 3.xlsx (16K), Transmisi6n Azteca America 2013 OK- rev 3.xlsx (16K), Transmisi6n Azteca America 2014- 0K - Rev 3.xlsx (14K)

Hi Raul,

Enclosed are the revised files. Please let me know if you have any questions or comments.

Best, Fabiola

Fabiola Rivas In-House Counsel Azteca Office: (818) 241-5400 [email protected]

This message is intended only for the use of the Addressee and may contain information that is PRIVILEGED and CONFIDENTIAL. If you are not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any dissemination of this communication is strictly prohibited. If you have received this commw1ication in error, please erase all copies of the message and its attachments and notif)' us immediately. Thank You. 2008 LUNES - VIERNES PROGRAMA CLASIFICACION La vida es una canclon Unitario novelas La vida es una cancion rep Unitario novelas Lo que callamos las mujeres Unitario novelas Lo que calla mos las mujeres rep Unitario novelas Cam bio de vida Unitario novelas Cam bio de vida rep Unitario novelas HechosAM Noticias Noticlero Azteca America 1er edici6n Noticias Noticiero Azteca America Noticias Noticleros Hechos noticas Entre tres Noticas Shala hi Noticias Animal nocturno Noticias Reporte 13 Noticias En contexto Noticias Entrevlsta con Sarmiento Notidas Asignaci6n especial Noticias Que buena onda rep Entretenimiento Puro loco Entretenimiento Puro loco rep Entretenimiento Aycaramba Entretenimiento Te cache Entretenlmiento Te cache rep Entretenimiento Taxi libre Entretenimiento El que no cae resbala Entretenimiento El que no cae resbala rep Entretenimiento Diflcil de creer Entretenimiento Extra normal Entretenlmlento Extranormal rep Entretenimlento Ventaneando America Espectaculos Ventaneando America rep Espectaculos

1 Historias engarzadas Espectiiculos Hist.orlas engarzadas rep Espectaculos Con un nudo en la garganta Espectaculos Con un nudo en la garganta rep Espectaculos La historia detras del mito rep Espectaculos La historia detras del mito Espectaculos Vaqueva Espectaculos Famosos en jaque Espectaculos Famosos en jaque rep Espectaculos vidas al Limite Espectaculos Especial Show de Niurka Espectaculos Marat6n vidas al Hmite Espectaculos Betlezas indomable Novela Bellezas indomable rep No vela Mientras haya vida Novela Mientras haya vida rep Novel a Catalina y Sebastfan No vela Catalina y Sebastian rep Novel a Senora Novel a

2 Maravillas de Mexico Entretenimiento Al extremo Entretenimiento Al extremo rep Entretenimiento Camino a la fama Entretenlmiento Camino a la fama rep Entretenirniento Lo quela gente cuenta Entretenimiento Que buena onda Entretenimiento Que buena onda rep Entretenimlento Se vale soiiar Entretenimiento Se vale sofiar rep Entretenimiento Asesinos Entretenlmiento Platicando con Alazraki Noticias Frente a frente Noticias Escandalos de cosas de la vida Entretenimiento Escandalos de cosas de la vida rep Entretenlmiento Vidas al Limite rep Entretenimiento lnfarto Entretenimiento Bucaneros lnfantil Cybercuates lnfantil Lo que callamos las mujeres Edici6n Especial Unitario novelas Los 25mas Espectaculos Extranormal de impacto Entretenimiento

DE PORTES Futbol soccer -Jaguares Deportes Futbol soccer -Santos Deportes Futbol soccer -Puebla Deportes Futbol soccer -Pachuca Deportes Futbol soccer- Cruz azul Deportes Futbol soccer· U.A. de G Deportes Futbol soccer· Veracruz Deportes Antesala deportiva Deportes Entretenlmiento Analisis de liguilla Deportes Entretenimiento Deportv America rep Deportes Entretenimiento La Liga Futbol Mexicano · Cruz azul Deportes

3 la Liga Futbol Mexicano - Puebla Deportes La Liga Futbol Mexicano - Santos Deportes La Liga Futbol Mexicano - Pachuca Deportes La Liga Futbol Mexicano - Veracruz Deportes la Liga Futbol Mexicano - U.A. de G Deportes Previo Deportes La Liga Futbol Mexicano Final ida - Cruz azul Deportes ESPECIALES Bienvenido 2008 Tv especial Especial Espectaculos Ventaneando Que viva la liga Espectaculos Simplemente Yahir Espectciculos Ventaneando america Bienvenido el Cucucy Espectaculos Especial Ventaneando Espectaculos Especial Viva el Cruz Azul Deportes Entretenimiento 50 super goles La liga clausura 2008 Deportes Entretenimiento Lo mejor de la liga de Clausura 2008 Deportes Entretenimiento Especial Posada Ventaneando rep Espectaculos Los grandes momentos de la Liga Deportes Entretenlmiento Especial Lo mas diflcil de creer 2008 parte 1 Entretenimiento Especial Vidas al Hmite Espectaculos Lo que el ai'io se llev6 Espectaculos Cruz azul de final a final Deportes Entretenimiento Festival Azteca Music Entretenimiento Anuario Ventaneando Espectaculos Rostros 2008 Noticias

FIN DE SEMANA

Cybercuates INFANTIL Bucaneros INFANTIL Ay caramba Entretenimiento Ya cay6 Entretenimiento Famosos en jaque Espectaculos lnfarto Entretenimiento

4 infarto rep Entretenimiento Que buena onda Espectaculos Que buena onda rep Espectaculos Frente a frente Noticias Por fin el fin Entretenlmiento Por fin el fin rep Entretenimiento Los 25mas Espectaculos Los 25 mas rep Espectaculos La historia detras del mito Espectaculos La historia detras del mito rep Espectaculos Los ganadores de la gente Espectaculos El asesino Entretenimiento El asesino rep Entretenimiento Vidas la Ifmite Entretenimiento Asignacion especial Noticias Asignacion especial rep Noticias No te lo pierdas Entretenimiento Shala la Noticias Platicando con Alazraki Notlcias Lo mejor de Venga la alegrla Entretenlmiento Pura loco Entretenimiento Puro loco rep Entretenimiento Historias engarzadas Espectaculos historias engarzadas rep Espectaculos Entretres Noticias Azteca music Entretenimiento Frente a frente rep Noticias Platicando con Alazraki rep Noticias Si te la sabes cantala Entretenimiento (.Te la sabes cantala? Entretenimiento Sexo fuerte Unitario novela Diflcil decreer Entretenimiento Dificil de creer rep Entretenimfento Extra normal Entretenlmiento Extranormal rep Entretenimiento

5 Previo La Academia ultima generaci6n Entretenlmiento La Academia ultima generaci6n de Mexico Conclerto Entretenlmlento Loque la gente cuenta Entretenimiento HitM3 Espectaculos La vida es una canci6n Unitario novela Taxi libre Entretenimiento El que no cae resbala "Edici6n dominical" Entretenirniento El que no cae resbala "Edicion dominical" rep Entretenimlento Vaqueva Espectaculos Hoy tetoca Espectaculos Te cache Entretenimiento Te cache rep Entretenimiento Top ten Espectaculos Marat6n Lo que la gente cuenta Unitario novela Marat6n vidas al If mite Espectaculos Marat6n Va que va Espectaculos Vidas al limite Espectaculos Festival Azteca Entreteni miento

DE PORTES Futbol soccer -Jaguares Deportes Futbol soccer -Santos Deportes Futbol soccer -Puebla Oeportes futbol soccer -Pachuca Deportes Futbol soccer -Cruz azul Deportes Futbol soccer-Veracruz Oeportes Futbol soccer- U.A. de G Deportes Antesala Futbolistica Deportes Entretenimiento Antesala Deportiva Deportes Entretenimiento Antesala rep Deportes Entretenimiento Futbolfama Espectaculos Futbol fama rep Espectaculos Futbol soccer rep Deportes Futbol soccer semifinal Deportes Futbol soccer final ida Deportes

6 Futbol soccer Final vuelta Deportes Deportv America Deportes Entretenimiento Deportv America rep Deportes Entretenimiento Boxeo Azteca Deportes Futbol internacional Tecos vs Boca juniors Deportes Futbol internacional Dallas vs America Deportes La Liga Futbol Mexicano - Cruz azul Deportes La Liga Futbol Mexicano - Puebla Deportes La Uga Futbol Mexicano - Santos Deportes La Liga Futbol Mexicano - Pachuca Deportes La Liga Futbol Mexicano - Veracruz Deportes La Liga Futbol Mexicano - U.A. de G Deportes La Liga Futbol Mexicano - Jaguares Deportes La Liga Futbol Mexicano - Monarcas Deportes La Uga Futbol Mexicano - Indios Deportes La Liga Futbol Mexicano - Jaguares rep Deportes La Liga Futbol Mexicano - Puebla rep Deportes La Uga Futbol Mexicano - Cruz azul rep Deportes La Liga Futbol Mexicano - Santos rep Deportes La Liga Futbol Mexicano - Pachuca rep Deportes La Liga Futbol Mexicano -Veracruz rep Deportes La Uga Futbol Mexicano - U.A. de G rep Deportes Adrenalina Deportiva Deportes Entretenimiento

ESPECIALES Especial HE Espectaculos Resumen Mientras haya vida Novelas Especial Viva Santos Deportes Entretenimiento Cr6nicas de un campeon "Santos" Deportes Entretenimiento so super goles La llga clausura 2008 Deportes Entretenimiento Especial lo mejor de Futbol Tecate Deportes Entretenimiento Casting partel La Academia Entretenimiento Casting parte 2 La Academia Entretenimiento Casting parte 3 La Academia Entretenimiento

7 casting parte 4 La Academia Entretenimiento Especial Expo Mexico Especial Azteca Music 1 Espectaculos Especial Azteca Music 2 Espectaculos Especial Azteca Music 3 Espectaculos Especial Azteca Music 4 Espectaculos Especial Ventaneando 1 Espectaculos Especial Ventaneando 2 Espectaculos Especial Ventaneando 3 Espectaculos Especial Ventaneando 4 Espectaculos Especial calendario Niurka 2009 Espectaculos Especial el show de Niurka Espectaculos Especial lo que no vio del show de Niurka Espectaculos Especial lo que no vio del show de Niurka rep Espectaculos Especial Al Extreme Entretenimiento Especial Posada Ventaneando Espectaculos Especial Pastorela Ventaneando Espectaculos Especial La Academia ultima generacion Espectaculos Los Heroes de la liga 2008 Deportes Entretenimiento Los 100 golazos de la liga Azteca Deportes Entretenim iento

8 2009 LUNES - VIERNES PROGRAMA CLASIFICACl6N Te cache Entretenimiento Te cache rep Entretenimiento La vida es una canci6n Unitarlo novelas La vida es ina cancion rep Unitario novelas Loque callamos las mujeres Unitario novelas Lo que callamos las mujeres rep Unitario novelas Cambio de vida Unitario novelas Cambio de vida rep Unitario novelas Loque callamos las mujeres Edici6n especial Unitario novelas Loque callamos las mujeres Edici6n especial rep Unitario novelas El milagro de los Santos Unitario novelas El milagro de las Santos rep Unitario novelas La historia detras del mito Espectaculos La historia detras del mito rep Espectaculos Dificil de creer Entretenimiento Diflcil decreer rep Entretenimiento Especial Dificil decreer Entretenimiento Especial Dfflcil de creer rep Entretenimiento Extra normal Entretenlmiento Extranormal rep Entretenimiento Extranormal de impacto Entretenlmiento Extranormal de irnpacto Entretenimiento Ventaneando America Espectaculos Ventaneando America rep Espectaculos Historias engarzadas Espectaculos Historias engan:adas rep Espectaculos Notlclero Azteca America ler edid6n Noticias Noticiero Azteca America Noticias Noticiero Azteca America rep Noticias Noticiero Nacional Noticias Noticiero nacional rep Noticlas

1 catallna y Sebastfan Novel a Catalina y Sebastian rep Novel a Senora Novela Seiiora rep Novela Azul tequila Novel a Azul tequila rep Novel a Port! Novel a Por ti rep Novel a Va queva Espectaculos Va que va rep Espectaculos Los 25 mas Espectaculos Vidas al Llrnite Espectaculos

2 Maravillas de Mexico Entretenimiento Al extrema Entretenimiento Al extremo rep Entretenimiento Se vale soiiar Entretenimiento Se vale sonar rep Entretenimiento Escandalos de cosas de la vida Entretenimiento Escandalos de cosas de la vida rep Entretenimiento Extranormal de impacto Entretenimiento Hoy tetoca Entretenimiento Hoy te toca rep Entretenimiento A la mexicana Entretenimiento A la mexicana rep Entretenimlento Demente Entretenimlento Laura de todos Entretenimiento Ya cay6 rep Entretenimiento Taxi libre rep Entretenimiento Ay Caramba rep Entretenimiento Fiesta Azteca a 200 anos del bicentenario Entretenimiento La Academia al limite Entretenimiento La Academia al lrmlte rep Entretenimlento

DE PORTES Deportv America rep Deportes Entretenimiento La Uga Futbol Mexicano - Cruz azul Deportes La Liga Futbol Mexicano - Puebla Deportes La Liga Futbol Mexicano - Jaguares Deportes La Llga Futbol Mexicano - Indios Deportes Antesala deportiva Deport es Entretenimiento Futbol Mexicano Primera A Merida vs Tijuana Deportes Tomeo La cuna def futbol Pachuca vs Queretataro Deport es Que viva Mexico de un solo sofpe Jorge Travieso vs Simphwe Nongqayi Deport es Box Azteca

ESPECIALES Especial Las doce campanadas Entretenimiento

3 Toma de posesl6n de Barack Obama Notlclas Especial Laura Bozzo, sin mledo a la verdad rep Entretenlmiento Que viva Mexico de un solo golpe Deportes Especial Jenni Rivera en Historias Engarzadas parte 1 Entretenlmlento Especial Virgen de Guadalupe Entretenimfento Especial La Academia: Sorpresa de Navidad Entretenimiento Especial Lo mas diffcil de creer 2008 parte 2 Entretenimiento Especial Vidas al Limlte Espectaculos Especial Analisis La Liguilla Deportes Entretenimiento Especial detras de camaras El gran desflo Entrete nimiento Especial cr6nica del campe6n Deportes Entretenimiento Especial Dia del padre Espectaculos Especial Laura Bozzo, sin miedo a la verdad Entretenimlento Especial Heroes y villanos Espectaculos Especial La Liga Azteca Deportes Especial Alfombra roja El gran desafio Entretenimlento Bpecial Lo que no se vfo de el Gran desaflo de estrellas Entretenlmlento Especial La Academia La Gala Entretenlmiento Especial Festival Azteca Music Dia de Muertos Entretenimlento Extranormal de lmpacto Edici6n especial Dfa de Muertos Entretenimiento Especial Camino a Sudafrica Entretenimiento Entretenimiento Especial El juego de las Estrellas Deportes Entretenimiento Especial El juego de la fuerza Deportes Entretenim iento Especial El juego del peligro Deportes Entretenimiento Especial El Campe6n Deportes Entretenimiento Pastorela Ventaneando Espectaculos Alfombra Naranja Entretenimiento Especial Al Extremo 2009 Entretenimlento Especial Los mejores goles 2009 Deportes Entretenimiento Especial Lo mas escalofriante de Extranormal de impacto Entretenimiento Anuario Ventaneando Espectaculos Especial Deportv America Deportes Entretenimiento Especial Deportv America Deportes Entretenimiento Lo que el aiio se llevo Entretenimiento

4 FIN DE SEMANA PROGRAMA CLASIFICACl6N Taxi libre Entretenimiento Taxi libre rep Entretenimiento Ya cav6 Entretenimiento Ya cayo rep Entretenimiento Asgaard INFANTIL Asgaard nueva temporada INFANTIL Bucaneros INFANTIL Diffcil de creer Entretenimiento Diflcil de creer rep Entretenimiento Dificil de creer fin de semana Entretenimiento Te cache Entretenimiento Te cache rep Entretenimiento Va queva Espectaculos Va queva rep Espectaculos Extranormal Entretenimiento Extranormal rep Entretenimiento Hoy tetoca Espectaculos Hoy te toca rep Espectaculos Historias engarzadas Espectaculos historias engarzadas rep Espectaculos Top ten Espectaculos HitM3 Espectaculos El que no cae resbala Espectaculos El que no cae resbala Edicion Domlnical Espectaculos El que no cae resbala Edicion Dominica! rep Espectaculos Los 25mas Espectaculos los 25 mas rep Espectaculos Los 25 mas fin de semana Espectaculos Famosos en jaque Espectaculos Famosos en jaque rep Espectaculos Loque la gente cuenta Entretenimiento Lo que la gente cuenta rep Entretenimiento

5 Historia detras de! mlto Espectaculos Historia detras del mito rep Espectaculos Extranormal de impactro Entretenimiento Festival Azteca Music Entretenimlento Vidas al l(mite Espectaculos Vidas al lfmite Fin de semana Espectaculos M arat6n Va que Va Espectaculos El show de Niurka 2009 Espectaculos Cambio de vida rep Unitario novelas Se vale sonar rep Entretenimiento Al extremo fin de semana Entretenimiento Al extremo fin de semana rep Entretenimiento Ay caramba Entretenimiento El gran desaffo Entretenimiento Sabados A la mexicana Entretenimiento Demente Entretenimiento A la mexicana Entretenimiento A la mexicana rep Entretenimlento La Academia Entretenimiento Ellos vs Elias Entretenimiento Ya cay6 renovado Entretenimiento

DE PORTES Antesala Deportiva Deportes Entretenimiento Antesala Deportiva rep Deportes Entretenimiento Oeportv America Deportes Entretenimiento oeportv America rep Oeportes Entretenimiento Box Azteca Deportes La Liga Futbol Mexicano - Monarcas Deportes La liga Futbol Mexicano - Jaguares Oeportes La Llga Futbol Mexicano - Cruz: azul Deportes La Liga Futbol Mexicano - Puebla Deportes La Liga Futbol Mexicano - Indios Deportes La Liga Futbol Mexicano - Cruz: azul rep Deportes La Liga Futbol Mexicano - Indios rep Deportes

6 La Liga Futbol Mexicano - Puebla rep Oeportes Futbol Mexicano Primera A Merida vs Tijuana Deportes Torneo La cuna del futbol Pachuca vs Atlante Deportes Campean Azteca Deportes Entretenimiento Previo lnauguraci6n Estadio Santos Laguna Deportes Entretenimiento

7 2010

. - . - -· __ Lunes a Viernes La vida es una canci6n Unitaria - Navelas La Historia detras del mito Ventaneando America Por ti Novel a Diffcil de creer Entretenimiento A Carmba Entretenimiento A la Mexicana Entretenimiento Taxi libre Entretenimiento lnfantil lnfantil Escandalas de Cosas de la Vida Entretenimiento Cambia de Vida Unitario - Novelas El mila ro de los santos Unitario - Novelas Los 25 + Vidas al Limite Extranormal de Im acto Entretenimiento Historias de la vida real Unitario - Navelas Laura de todos Entretenimiento Lo ue callamos las mu·eres Edici6n Es ecial Unitario - Novelas Al Extremo Entretenimiento Naticiero Nacianal Naticias La Loba Novela orada Entretenimiento Entretenimiento Entretenimiento De ortes Entreten imiento Vamonos al Baile Entretenimiento La academia Bicentenario "La Casa" Entretenimiento Entretenimiento Novela Casas de la Vida Entreten imiento .... . Sabado y Domingo Se vale sonar Entretenimiento Te cache Entretenimiento Famosos en Ja ue Es ectaculos Festival Azteca Music Entretenimiento Entretenimiento

Vidas al Umite "Fin de Semana" Extranormal de Im acto "Fin de Semana" Entretenimiento Al Extrema "Fin de Semana" Entretenimiento Demente Entretenimiento As aard Entreten imiento Los 25 + "Fin de semana" El ue no cae resbala Ya ca 6 renovado Entretenimiento De ortes Entreteniemiento Entreten imiento

La Li a Futbol Mexicano - Puebla La Li a Futbol Mexicano - Ja uares De ortes La L i a Futbol Mexicano - Santos De ortes La Li a Futbol Mexicano - Monarcas De ortes La Li a Futbol Mexicano - Cruz Azul De ortes La Li a Futbol Mexicano - Necaxa De ortes Futbol Mexicano Primera A Fnal Li a de Ascenso De ortes Box Azteca De ortes Corazon Gru ero Entretenimiento La academia Bicentenario Entretenimiento Entretenimiento Es ectaculos

Especiales .

Al Extrema Extra Entretenimiento Es ecial 14 de febrero - Amores de Alto Ries o Es ectaculos

2 Al Extrema Extra Fin de Semana Entretenlmlento Esoecial Caso Paulette oarte 1 Noticias Esoeclal Caso Paulette oarte 2 Noticias Especial Seaunda Ooortunidad Entretenimiento Especial Rumbo al Mundial Deoortes Entreten iemiento Especial Celia Lora Homicidio lmprudencial Entretenimiento Esoecial Analisis de la Li!luilla Deoortes Entreteniemiento Esoecial CamPe6n 2010 Deoortes Entreteniemlento Especial Laura de todos Guarderia ABC Entretenimiento Especial Diff cil de Creer desde Africa Entretenimiento Especial del Archivo de Pati Chapoy: Cr6nica de una reconcialiaci6n AB Quintanilla y Cruz Martinez Esoectaculos Especial del Archivo de Pati Chapoy: Pablo Montero sobreviviendo asf mismo Esoectaculos Esoecial del Arch!vo de Pati Chaoov: Ernesto Alonso, una herenc!a de Telenovela Esoectaculos Esoecial del Archivo de Pati Chaoov: Rickv Martin el destaoe de un secrete Esoectaculos Especial del Archivo de Pati Chaoov: Joan Sebastian dinastfa traoica Espectaculos Esoecial rumba a la academia Bicentenario Entretenimiento Esoecial Los secretes de la casa de la Academia Entretenimiento Gran Escecial Bicentenario Entretenimlento Esoecial Ines Saenz. en la lfnea de Qolpeo Entretenimiento Especial Chile el oran rescate Noticias Esnecial Historias de Terror de los Famosos Entretenimlento Especial Fashion Grupero Esoectaculos Especial Muevete de Noche Entretenimiento Esoecial Famosas al desnudo Esoectaculos Escandalos v tragedias del deporte Esoectaculos Esoecial los meiores aoles 2010 Deoortes Entreteniemiento Especial Box Azteca 2010 Deportes Entreteniemiento Especial El camoe6n Torneo de Aoertura Deportes Entreteniemiento Esoecial el fen6meno de la academia Entretenimiento Especial musical La Academia Entretenimiento Anuario Ventaneando Esoectaculos Especial lo mas escalofriante de Extranormal de lmpacto Entretenimiento Posada Ventaneando Esoectaculos

3 CAM BIO DE VIDA ( R) Unitario I Novela El milagro de los Santos ( R } Unitario / Novela La Vida es una canci6n ( R ) Unitario I Novela CAMBIO DE VIDA Unitarlo I Novela la Vida es una canci6n Unitario I Novela El milagro de los Santos Unitario I Novela Lo que Callamos las mujeres Unitario I Novela La verdad de mi vida Unitario I Novela Vivir as( Unitario I Novela

Cybercuates lnfantil

La Historia Detras del Mito ( R ) Espectaculos La Historia Detras del Mito Espectaculos Laura de todos Espectaculos Historlas Engarzadas Espectaculos Ventaneando America Espectaculos Los 25 Mas Espectaculos Vidas al Limite Espectaculos Va queva Espectaculos Ventaneando America ( R ) Espectaculos

Ay Caramba Taxi Libre ( R ) Entretenimiento A la mexicana ( R) Entretenimiento Taxi Libre ( R ) Entretenimiento Extra normal de lmpacto Entretenimiento Diffcil de Creer Entretenimiento

1 Ya cay6 Entretenlmiento Cosas de la Vida Entretenimiento Al Extremo Entretenimiento Se vale sonar Entretenimiento Te Cache Entretenimiento La hora de la verdad Entretenimiento Generaci6n 2011 Entretenimiento

Muejr Comprada Novel a Cielo Rojo Novela Ni una vez mas Novela Montecristo Novel a

Noticiero Nacional Azteca america Noticias Noticiero Nacional Azteca america ( R ) Noticias

La Liga Futbol Mexicano Necaxa I Monarcas I Cruz Azul / Jaguares/ Tijuana (Viernes) DEPORTES Liga de Ascenso Futbol Mexicano DE PORTES Partido Amistoso Pumas vs Morelia DEPORTES Box Azteca Mexico de un solo galpe DEPORTES Oeporte Caliente DEPORTES Entretenimiento Copa Mesoamericana DEPORTES

·· sa~ado v oomingio

CAM BIO DE VIDA ( R) Unitario I Novela Lo que la Gente Cuenta Unitario I Novela

Cybercuates lnfantil

Se vale sonar Entretenimiento Taxi Libre Entretenimiento

2 Ya Cayo Entretenlmiento Te Cache Entretenirniento Aycaramba Entretenimiento A la mexicana Entretenimiento Vamonos al Barie Entretenimiento Extranormal de lmpacto Entretenimiento Drenaje Profundo Entretenimiento Al Extrema fin de semana Entretenimiento Diffcil de creer Entretenimiento Cosas de la vida Entretenimiento Especial Cosas de la Vida Entretenimiento Al caer la noche Entretenimiento Academia 2011 Entretenimiento

Historias Engarzadas Espeetaculos Historias detras del mito Espectaculos HitM3 Espectaculos Los 2Smas Espectaculos Va queva Espectaculos Famosos en Jaque Espectaculos Vidas al lfmite Espectaculos Historia Detras del mlto ( R ) Espectaculos

Antesala Deportlva Deportes Entretenimiento La Liga Futbol Mexicano Cruz Azul / Puebla/ Tijuana I Jaguares/ Monarcas Deportes Deportv America Deportes Entretenimiento Box Azteca Deportes Partido Amistoso America vs Morelia Deportes

... . . ·· •...... ,....

_,.,.._ .. . ., . ·~.-·•-: _...... • • -H ... .. ·' -~p~CIPJ.ES ···~

3 Ella es Niurka Entretenlmiento Especial yo amo Meleo Entretenimiento Especial lnvitados aodemia 2011 Entretenimiento Lo mejor de Al Extrelo Parte 1 Entreten imiento Lo mas escalofrianteExtranormal de lmpacto Entreten lmiento Lo mejor de Al Extre-io Parte 2 Entretenimiento Especial Alto Riesgo Entretenimiento Especial dia del padl! Entretenlmiento Especial la Academh:2011 Entretenlmiento Especial Al Extrema Entretenlmiento

Famosas al Desnudc Espectaculos Especial def Altar a Is juzgados Espectaculos Fashion Grupero Espectaculos Amores de la patadc: Espectaculos Especial Selene la nn a del texmex Espectaculos Especial Musical Esinoza Paz Espectaculos Fans al Acecho Espectaculos Del arc:hivo de Pati Clapoy Espectaculos De Campana en Carr.:>ana Espectaculos Posada Ventaneand Espectaculos Especial 12 canpanalas Espectaculos Tratetoria al Exito Espectaculos Trayectoria Grupera Espectaculos

Revive la pasi6n de t'isto Noticlas Boda Real Noticias Boda Real Kate Midleton Noticias La boda real el resunen Noticias Especial Expediente~in LaDEN Noticias Los arc:hivos del 201 Parte 1 Notlcias Los archivos del 201 Parte 2 Noticias Especial Asesinos Sefales parte 1 Noticias

4 Especial Asesinos Seriales parte 2 Noticias Especial Mafianltas a la Viegen Noticlas Especial Catastrofe Japan Noticias Especial Juan Pablo II Noticias Cobertura especial Beatification Noticlas Especial Caso Monterrey Noticlas El Grito Noticlas

Especial Goles lnternacionales Deportes Entretenimiento Especia I Box Azteca Deportes Especial el campe6n Deportes Entretenimiento Tragedias del deporte Deportes Especial Juan Manuel Marquez Deportes Entretenimiento Especial Rumbo a la Ligullia Deportes Entretenimiento Especial mejores momentos del futbol en el mundo Deportes Entretenimiento Rumbo a la final de la liguilla Deportes Entretenimiento El campe6n Deportes Entretenimiento Especial Dallas, Yarda SO Deportes Entretenimiento fco nos Deportivos Deportes Entretenimiento De cara a la apertura 2011 Deportes Entretenimiento Premios y Escandalos del deporte Deportes Entretenimiento Rempe Marquez... rumba a su pelea Parte 1 Deportes Entretenimiento Rompe Marquez... rumbo a su pelea Parte 2 Deportes Entretenimiento Rompe Marquez ... rumbo a su pelea Parte 3 Deportes Entretenlmiento

5 2012 Lunes a Viernes

Cybercuates lnfantil Se Vale Sonar Espectaculos Te Cache Entretenimiento Cambia de Vida Unitarios - Novelas La Historia Oetras del Mito Espectaculos la Verdad de mi Vida Espectaculos Cielo Rojo Novelas La Vida es una Candon Unitarios - Novelas Noticiero Nacional Azteca America Noticieros Va Cay6 Renovado Entretenimiento El Milagro de las Santos Unltarios - Novelas Ventaneando America Espectaculos Cosas de la Vida Entretenimiento Al Extremo Entretenimiento Deporte Caliente Deportes Entretenimiento Historlas Engarzadas Entretenimlento Vidas al Limite Espectaculos Los 25 Mas Entretenimiento Va queVa Entretenimiento Extra normal Entretenimiento Lo Que callamos las Mujeres Unitarios - Novelas La Liga Futbol Mexicano Monarcas Deportes Fut Azteca Copa MX Deportes Buenas Noches America con Fernando Arau Espectaculos Cuentame tu Historia con Martha Susana Espectaculos Yo me Quierio Casar lY tu? Entretenimiento iAy Carambal Entretenimiento El Pelado de la Noche Espectaculos

1 Emperatiz Novelas Ni Una Vez Mas Unitarios - Novelas Echale Primo Entretenlmiento Trayectorla al Exito Espectaculos Quiero Ser Grupero Entretenimiento la Isla Reality Shows lo que Callamos las Mujeres Edlcl6n Especial Unitarlos - Novelas Los Rey Novelas

Sabado y Domingo Cybercuates lnfantil Te Cache Entretenimiento la Historia Detras del Mito "Fin de Semana" Espectaculos Ya Cay6 Renovado Entretenimiento Ya Cay6 Entretenimiento Cosas de la Vida Entretenimlento Al Extrema "Fin de Semana" Entretenimiento Historias Engarzadas "Fin de Semana" Espectaculos Vidas al Limite "Fin de Semana" Espectaculos Los 25 Mas "Fines de Semana" Entretenimiento Va que Va "Fines de Semana" Entretenimiento Extranormal de lmpacto Entretenimiento Taxi Libre Entretenimiento iAy Caramba I Entretenimiento A la Mexicana Entretenimiento Dificil de Creer Entretenimiento Hit M3 Espectaculos Antesala Oeportiva Deportes Entretenimiento lo que la Gente Cuenta Unitarios - Novelas BoxAzteca Deportes Escandalos Gruperos Espectaculos Deportv America Deportes Entretenimiento Trayectoria al Exito Espectaculos

2 Cine Espectacular del Sabado Entretenimiento Asesinos Seriales Entretenlmlento la Liga Futbol Mexicano Cruz Azul Deportes la liga Futbol Mexicano Puebla Deportes la Liga Futbol Mexicano Jaguares Deportes La liga Futbol Mexicano Tijuana Deportes La liga Futbol Mexicano Cruz Azul Deportes Box Azteca Ford Deportes Tatiana Entretenimiento Especial Eurocopa Deportes Entretenimiento Futbol Mexicano Liga de Ascenso Toros Neza Deportes Fut Azteca Ascenso MX Toros Neza Deportes la Academia 10 afios Entretenimiento la Bitacora La Isla Entretenimiento Venga el Domingo Entretenimiento La Vida es una Candon Unitarios - Novelas Bucaneros lnfantil

Especiales

Especial Julio Cesar Chavez JR Deportes Entretenimiento Desfile Conmemorativo 150 ai'ios de la batalla de Puebla Noticieros futbol Mexicano liga de Ascenso Correcaminos Deportes Especial El Camino del Campe6n Deportes Entretenimiento Especial Espinoza Paz Espectaculos Especial Vicente Fernandez Espectaculos Especial Ricky Martin Espectaculos Especial Shakira Espectaculos Especial Mana Espectaculos Especial Alejandro Fernadez Espectaculos Especial Tigres del Norte Espectaculos Especial Mexico Decide 2.012 Noticieros Especial Joyas Gruperas Espectaculos Especial Joan Sebastian Espectaculos

3 Especial Alejandra Guzman Espectaculos Especial Juan Gabriel Espectaculos Especial Convenciones Noticias Especial Vo Amo a Mexico Entretenimiento El Grito (15 de Septiembre} Noticias Mafianitas a La Virgen Marfa Noticias Posada Ventaneando Espectaculos Especial Jenni Rivera, El Adios a una Diva Espectaculos Especial Profecias Mayas Entretenimiento Especial las Revelaciones Entretenimiento Especial Anuario Ventaneando Espectaculos Especial Navidad La Academia Reality Shows Lo mas lnsolito de! 2012 Noticias Especial Noticias Noticias

4 2013

· Lunes a Viernes Te cache Entretenimiento Cambio de Vida Entretenimiento A la Mexicana Entretenimiento Taxi libre Entretenimiento A la Mexicana Entretenimiento Se vale sonar Entretenimiento Historias En arzadas Vidas al Umite Los 25+ Va ue Va La Historia detras del mito Los Re Novelas Cosas de la Vida Entretenimiento Ventaneando America Es ectaculos Lo ue callamos las mu·eres Unitario - Novelas Noticiero Nacional Azteca America Noticias Entretenimlento Unitario - Novelas Unitario - Novelas Al Extreme Entretenimiento Extranormal Entretenimiento Entretenimiento ortes ortes ortes La otra cara del alma Novelas EL Cofi Breik Entretenimiento Entre nos Entretenimiento Entretenimiento Novelas De ortes

1 La loba Novelas Al caer la noche Entretenimiento Hit M3 R Ventaneando America R De orti s Entretenimiento Partido Amistoso La Isla "El realit " Entretenimiento La Historia detras del Mita "Edici6n Es ecial" Es ectaculos Corazon en Condominio Novelas De ortes Entretenimiento Demente Entretenimiento El Coffee Break Entretenirniento Historias de la Vida real Unitario - Novelas Noticiero Azteca America West Coast Noticias Noticiero Azteca America West Coast R Noticias Noticiero Nacional Azteca America R Noticias Dificil de creer R Entretenimiento

· Sabado Oomin o

Se vale sonar Entretenimiento Cambia de Vida Unitario - Novelas C bercuates lnfantil Bucaneros lnfantil Taxi libre Entretenimiento Ya ca 6 Entretenimiento Te cache Entretenimiento Al Mexicana Entretenimiento La vida es una canci6n Unitario - Novelas Es ectaculos Entretenimiento

La Historia detras del Mita ectaculos Historias En arzadas ectaculos

2 Antesala deoortiva Deportes Entretenimiento Box Azteca Deoortes Al Extrema "Fin de Semana" Entretenimiento Los 25 + Espectaculos Oeportv America Deport es Entretenimiento Extranormal de lmpacto Entretenimiento Lo que la qente cuenta Entretenimiento Box Azteca Ford Deoortes La Liqa Futbol Mexicano - Puebla Deportes La Liga Futbol Mexicano - Cruz Azul Deportes La vida es una canci6n ( R ) Unitario - Novelas Se vale sonar ( R ) Entreten imiento Gambio de Vida ( R ) Unitario - Novelas Va que Va "Fin de semana" Espectaculos La Historia detras del Mita "Fin de semana" Esoectaculos Historias Enqarzadas "Fin de semana" Esoectaculos La Liqa Futbol Mexicano - Santos Deportes La Liqa Futbol Mexicano - Monarcas Deportes El Milaqro de los Santos ( R ) Unitario - Novelas Ventaneando America ( R ) Espectaculos Asesinos Seriales ( R ) Entreten imiento Asesinos Seriales Entretenimiento Venqa el Dominqo 1 Entretenimiento Venqa el Dominqo 2 Entretenimiento La Academia Kids Entretenimiento Fut Azteca Guerra de Campeones Deoortes Sanqre de Campeones Deportes Entretenimiento Confesiones del mas alla Entretenimiento Lo meior de antesala deportiva Deportes Entretenimiento

11:.1 Mt; I

Especial 12 Campanadas Espectaculos Especial - Julio Preciado Esoectaculos

3 Juauet6n Entretenimiento Toma posesi6n presidenclal Noticias Esta

4 2014 Lunes a Viernes Cybercuates lnfantil Ya Cay6 Renovado Entretenimiento Entre Nos Entretenimiento El Coffee Break Entretenimiento La Verdad de mi Vida Unitario - Novelas La Loba Novelas Cosas de la Vida Entretenimiento El Milagro de los Santos Unitario - Novelas Lo Que Callamos las Mujeres Unitario - Novelas Noticiero Nadonal Azteca America Noticieros Dificil de Creer Entretenimiento Ventaneando America Espectaculos Corazon en Condominio Novelas La Vida es una Canci6n Unitario - Novelas Al Extremo Entretenimiento Extra normal Entretenimiento Loque la Gente Cuenta Unitario - Novelas Deperte Caliente Deportes Entretenimiento Fut Azteca liga MX Monarcas Deportes Fut Azteca Liga MX Queretaro Deportes Fut Azteca Liga MX Tijuana Deportes Fut Azteca Llga. MX Santos Deportes HechosAM Noticieros Venga la Alegrfa Entretenimiento Cuando Seas Mia Novel as La Tenlente Entretenlmiento Hombre Tenias que Ser Novelas Noticiero Nacional Azteca Edici6n Nocturna Noticieros Siempre Tuya Acapulco Novel as

1 Destine Novelas Amanecer Carioca Deportes Entretenimiento Vive Brasil Deportes Entretenimiento Camb!o de Vida Unitario - Novelas Vidas Robadas Novelas A Cada Quien su Santo Unitario- Novelas Fut Azteca Super Copa MX Monarcas Deportes Prohibido Amar Novelas Las Bravo Novelas Secretos del Alma Novel as Hechos Nacional Tarde Noticieros Hechos Nacional Neche Noticieros

Sabado y Domingo

Cambia de Vida Unitario - Novelas Cybercuates lnfantil Te Cache Entretenimiento El Milagro de los Santos Unitario - Novelas Lucha Azteca Deportes Al Extremo 11 Fin de Semana" Entretenimiento Historias Engarzadas Espectaculos La Historia Detras del Mito Espectaculos Tras las rejas Espectaculos BoxAzteca Deportes Venga el Domingo 1 Entretenimiento Venga el Domingo 2 Entretenimiento HitM3 Espectaculos Los 25 Mas Entretenimiento Extranormal de lmpacto Entretenimiento Lo que la Gente Cuenta Unitario - Novelas Deportv America Deportes Entretenimiento Fut Azteca Liga MX Puebla Oeportes Box Azteca Ford Deportes

2 Top Ten Entretenimiento Marcaje Personal Deportes Pinche Pancho Entretenlmiento Pasion Deportiva Deportes Entretenimiento Campean Azteca Deportes Entretenimfento Ti em po de Gel es Deport es Entretenimiento Deportips Deportes Entretenimiento La Vida es una Canci6n Unitario • Novelas Fut Azteca Liga de Ascenso Leones Negros Deportes Dificil de Creer Entretenimiento Extra normal Entretenimiento Vive Brasil Deportes Entretenimiento Fut Azteca Super Copa MX Tigres Deportes La Isla Entretenimiento Al Extrema Edid6n Especial Entretenimiento Fut Azteca Liga MX Santos Deportes la Academia Kids Entretenimiento Hasta Maiiana es Lunes Espectaculos Deportv Deportes Entretenimiento Conexi6n Espectaculos Fut Azteca Liga de Ascenso Coras Tepic Deportes Mananltas a la Virgen Noticias Mas Alla del Deporte Deportes Entretenimiento

Especial es

Especial Escandalos y Tragedias del Deporte Deportes Entretenimiento Estado de la Union Noticias Siempre Tuya Acapulco "Resumen" Novelas Especial El campe6n Deportes Entretenimiento Especial La Isla Entretenimiento Especial is de Septiembre "Estamos con Mexico" Estamos Contigo Noticias Especial Extranormal Dfa de Muertos Entretenimiento Especial Al Extremo Inocencia Ultrajada Entretenimiento

3 Especial La Academia Kids Navidefio Entretenimiento Especial Navidad Azteca Entretenimiento Posada Ventaneando Espectaculos Especial Deportv Deportes Entretenimiento Lo Mejo Al Extremo Parte 1 Entretenimiento Lo Mejo Al Extremo Parte 2 Entretenimiento Los Mejores Momentos de Venga la Alegrfa Entretenimiento Especial Navidad La Academia de Venga la Alegrfa "El Recalentado" Entretenimiento Especial lo mejor del afio de tiempo de gales Parte 1 Deportes Entretenimiento Especial La Academia Kids Afio Nuevo Entretenimiento Lo Mejor de Extranormal Entretenimiento

4 tI JJHIHXH January 21, 2015

VIA E-MAIL AND OVERNIGHT COURIER Azteca International Corporation Horacio Medal, VP and Chief Legal Officer 113 9 Grand Central Ave Glendale, CA 9120 l

Re: Consent to Assignment ofRepresentation Agreement Authorizalion (the "Agreement".) dated .Janum:y 21. 2015 between Independent Produe-·ers Group ("I PG") and A;tcca International Corporation (''A.IC").

Dear Mr. Medal:

This letter is to confirm AIC's consent to IPG's assignment to the Spanish Language Producers (4'SLP") of the Agreement (the '~Assignment"). SLP, as well as IPG, shall be held responsible for all rights, liabilities and obligations under the Agreement.

This Assignment is neither a modification of nor an amendment to the Agreement. All capitalized terms in this letter will have the meaning given to them on the Agreement.

Please confirm your consent to the foregoing by sibrning this letter bellow, emailing a copy of the signed letter to my attention at [email protected], and mailing the original signed copy to me at Pick & Boydston~ 10786 Le Conte Ave.: Los Angeles. California 90024.

Sincerely~ Independent Producers Group ... -····-·-'"'"'"·;:a ~·-- ---~~=~·~ ··-··· I Name: Raul Galaz /\ i \ Title: Representative ! \ ,

Consentecj o,11ie 2\s; day of January, 2015 .

./ \. " Azteea lnte1t3J \~rporation

I I ··· ... \ Name: Horacib \Medal-~. /-, I : Ti9e:.1WP and p1ief Legal Officer ·.... /· \

,(.··.._~' ·-,. .~l ...... ,,· B). . . ).~.A ..J-~ ·., ... ~· ·... · 1 ~ ... _..i.., Martiri-Sfei«isprecher " Chief Operations Officer d JJ8JHX3 October 22, 2016

VIA E-MAIL Azteca lnternationa I Corporation Horacio Medal, VP and Chief Legal Officer 1139 Grand Central Ave Glendale. CA 9120 I

Re: Consenl to Assignment ofReprcsentalion Agreement {!he "Agreement'') dated .!amuu:)' 21. 2015 between Spanish Language Producers ("SLP "J r:mccessor in inlerest lo independent Producers Group "/PG") and AzlecCJ lnlernational ( 'orporat ion ("A JC··).

Dear Mr. Medal:

This letter is SLP's request to obtain Al Cs consent to assignment of the Agreement to the Multigroup Claimants (•'MC") (the ··Assignment"). MC. as well as IPG and SLP. shaH be held responsible for all rights. liabilities and obJigations under the Agreement.

This Assignment is neither a modification of nor an amendment to the Agreement. All capitalized terms in this letter will have the meaning given to them on the Agreement.

Please confirm your consent to the foregoing by signing this letter beJlow, emailing a copy of the signed letter to my attention at world\t\.. idesg@aol.<;om. and mailing the original signed copy to me at Pick & Boydston. LLP, 10786 Le Conte Ave .. Los Angeles, CA 90024.

Sincerely. Spanish Language Producers

.-··""- Name: Title: Representative

Name: 1-loraci Titlc:.)P and Chief Legal Officer r.-"'· f . ,\ • - B~: ~ 'iSL i. 01 }" ' I _.-\--J M~eidsprecher \ Chief Operations Officer