Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 7.8.2004 10:34am page i
Fluorine in Organic Chemistry
Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Richard D. Chambers © 2004 Blackwell Publishing Ltd. ISBN: 978-1-405-10787-7 Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 7.8.2004 10:34am page iii
Fluorine in Organic Chemistry
Richard D. Chambers FRS Emeritus Professor of Chemistry University of Durham, UK Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 7.8.2004 10:34am page iv
ß 2004 by Blackwell Publishing Ltd
Editorial offices: Blackwell Publishing Ltd, 9600 Garsington Road, Oxford OX4 2DQ, UK Tel: þ44 (0)1865 776868 Blackwell Publishing Asia Pty Ltd, 550 Swanston Street, Carlton, Victoria 3053, Australia Tel: þ61 (0)3 8359 1011
ISBN 1-4051-0787-1
Published in the USA and Canada (only) by CRC Press LLC, 2000 Corporate Blvd., N.W., Boca Raton, FL 33431, USA Orders from the USA and Canada (only) to CRC Press LLC
USA and Canada only: ISBN 0-8493-1790-8
The right of the Author to be identified as the Author of this Work has been asserted in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988.
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, except as permitted by the UK Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, without the prior permission of the publisher.
This book contains information obtained from authentic and highly regarded sources. Reprinted material is quoted with permission, and sources are indicated. Reasonable efforts have been made to publish reliable data and information, but the author and the publisher cannot assume responsibility for the validity of all materials or for the consequences of their use.
Trademark notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation, without intent to infringe.
First published 2004
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data is available
A catalogue record for this title is available from the British Library
Set in 10/12.5 pt Times by Kolam Information Services Pvt. Ltd, Pondicherry, India Printed and bound in India by Gopsons Papers Ltd, Noida
The publisher’s policy is to use permanent paper from mills that operate a sustainable forestry policy, and which has been manufactured from pulp processed using acid-free and elementary chlorine-free practices. Furthermore, the publisher ensures that the text paper and cover board used have met acceptable environmental accreditation standards.
For further information on Blackwell Publishing, visit our website: www.blackwellpublishing.com Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 7.8.2004 10:34am page v
To my wife Anne and our grandchildren, Daniel, Benjamin, Alexandra, and Jack, who give us so much pleasure Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 7:05pm page vii
Contents
Foreword xv by Professor George A. Olah Preface xvii
1 GENERAL DISCUSSION OF ORGANIC FLUORINE CHEMISTRY 1 I General introduction 1 A Properties 1 B Historical development 2 II Industrial applications 3 A Introduction 3 B Compounds and materials of high thermal and chemical stability 3 1 Inert fluids 4 2 Polymers 5 C Biological applications 5 1 Volatile anaesthetics 6 2 Pharmaceuticals 7 3 Imaging techniques 7 4 Plant protection agents 9 D Biotransformations of fluorinated compounds 9 E Applications of unique properties 12 1 Surfactants 12 2 Textile treatments 12 3 Dyes 12 III Electronic effects in fluorocarbon systems 13 A Saturated systems 14 B Unsaturated systems 14 C Positively charged species 15 D Negatively charged species 15 E Free radicals 16 IV Nomenclature 16 A Systems of nomenclature 17 B Haloalkanes 18 References 19
vii Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 7:05pm page viii
viii Contents
2 PREPARATION OF HIGHLY FLUORINATED COMPOUNDS 23 I Introduction 23 A Source of fluorine 23 II Fluorination with metal fluorides 23 A Swarts reaction and related processes (halogen exchange using HF) 24 1 Haloalkanes 25 2 Influence of substituent groups 26 B Alkali metal fluorides 27 1 Source of fluoride ion 28 2 Displacements at saturated carbon 29 3 Displacements involving unsaturated carbon 30 Alkene derivatives 30 Aromatic compounds 31 C High-valency metal fluorides 31 1 Cobalt trifluoride and metal tetrafluorocobaltates 32 III Electrochemical fluorination (ECF) 33 IV Fluorination with elemental fluorine 35 A Fluorine generation 35 B Reactions 35 C Control of fluorination 36 1 Dilution with inert gases 36 D Fluorinated carbon 39 E Fluorination of compounds containing functional groups 39 V Halogen fluorides 40 References 41
3 PARTIAL OR SELECTIVE FLUORINATION 47 I Introduction 47 II Displacement of halogen by fluoride ion 47 A Silver fluoride 47 B Alkali metal fluorides 47 C Other sources of fluoride ion 49 D Miscellaneous reagents 50 III Replacement of hydrogen by fluorine 51 A Elemental fluorine 51 1 Elemental fluorine as an electrophile 52 B Electrophilic fluorinating agents containing O–F bonds 56 C Electrophilic fluorinating agents containing N–F bonds 58 D Xenon difluoride 60 E Miscellaneous 60 IV Fluorination of oxygen-containing functional groups 62 A Replacement of hydroxyl groups by fluorine 62 1 Pyridinium poly(hydrogen fluoride) – Olah’s reagent 62 2 Diethylaminosulphur trifluoride (DAST) and related reagents 63 3 Fluoroalkylamine reagents (FARs) 65 Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 7:05pm page ix
Contents ix
B Replacement of ester and related groups by fluorine 66 C Fluorination of carbonyl and related compounds 66 1 Sulphur tetrafluoride and derivatives 66 D Cleavage of ethers and epoxides 69 V Fluorination of sulphur-containing functional groups 71 VI Fluorination of nitrogen-containing functional groups 73 A Fluorodediazotisation 73 B Ring opening of azirines and aziridines 74 C Miscellaneous 75 VII Addition to alkenes and alkynes 76 A Addition of hydrogen fluoride 76 B Direct addition of fluorine 77 C Indirect addition of fluorine 79 D Halofluorination 80 E Addition of fluorine and oxygen groups 82 F Other additions 82 References 83
4 THE INFLUENCE OF FLUORINE OR FLUOROCARBON GROUPS ON SOME REACTION CENTRES 91 I Introduction 91 II Steric effects 91 III Electronic effects of polyfluoroalkyl groups 92 A Saturated systems 92 1 Strengths of Acids 92 2 Bases 93 B Unsaturated systems 94 1 Apparent resonance effects 94 2 Inductive and field effects 97 IV The perfluoroalkyl effect 97 V Strengths of unsaturated fluoro-acids and -bases 98 VI Fluorocarbocations 99 A Effect of fluorine as a substituent in the ring on electrophilic aromatic substitution 99 B Electrophilic additions to fluoroalkenes 101 C Relatively stable fluorinated carbocations 102 1 Fluoromethyl cations 104 D Effect of fluorine atoms not directly conjugated with the carbocation centre 105 VII Fluorocarbanions 107 A Fluorine atoms attached to the carbanion centre 108 B Fluorine atoms and fluoroalkyl substituents adjacent to the carbanion centre 111 C Stable perfluorinated carbanions 112 Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 7:05pm page x
x Contents
D Acidities of fluorobenzenes and derivatives 113 E Acidities of fluoroalkenes 115 VIII Fluoro radicals 115 A Fluorine atoms and fluoroalkyl groups attached to the radical centre 115 B Stable perfluorinated radicals 117 C Polarity of radicals 117 References 118
5 NUCLEOPHILIC DISPLACEMENT OF HALOGEN FROM FLUOROCARBON SYSTEMS 122 I Substituent effects of fluorine or fluorocarbon groups on the SN2 process 122 A Electrophilic perfluoroalkylation 126 II Fluoride ion as a leaving group 128 A Displacement of fluorine from saturated carbon – SN2 processes 128 1 Acid catalysis 129 2 Influence of heteroatoms on fluorine displacement 131 B Displacement of fluorine and halogen from unsaturated carbon – addition–elimination mechanism 131 1 Substitution in fluoroalkenes 132 2 Substitution in aromatic compounds 133 References 135
6 ELIMINATION REACTIONS 137 I b-Elimination of hydrogen halides 137 A Effect of the leaving halogen 137 B Substituent effects 138 C Regiochemistry 139 D Conformational effects 140 E Elimination from polyfluorinated cyclic systems 142 II b-Elimination of metal fluorides 144 III a-Eliminations: generation and reactivity of fluorocarbenes and polyfluoroalkylcarbenes 147 A Fluorocarbenes 147 1 From haloforms 147 2 From halo-ketones and –acids 149 3 From organometallic compounds 149 4 From organophosphorous compounds 151 5 Pyrolysis and fragmentation reactions 151 B Polyfluoroalkylcarbenes 154 C Structure and reactivity of fluorocarbenes and polyfluoroalkylcarbenes 156 Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 7:05pm page xi
Contents xi
1 Fluorocarbenes 156 2 Polyfluoroalkylcarbenes 158 References 159
7 POLYFLUOROALKANES, POLYFLUOROALKENES, POLYFLUOROALKYNES AND DERIVATIVES 162 I Perfluoroalkanes and perfluorocycloalkanes 162 A Structure and bonding 162 1 Carbon–fluorine bonds 162 2 Carbon–carbon bonds 162 B Physical properties 163 C Reactions 163 1 Hydrolysis 163 2 Defluorination and functionalisation 164 3 Fragmentation 166 D Fluorous biphase techniques 166 II Perfluoroalkenes 167 A Stability, structure and bonding 167 B Synthesis 169 C Nucleophilic attack 171 1 Orientation of addition and relative reactivities 172 2 Reactivity and regiochemistry of nucleophilic attack 172 3 Products formed 176 0 4 Substitution with rearrangement – SN2 processes 176 5 Cycloalkenes 183 6 Fluoride-ion-induced reactions 185 7 Addition reactions 186 8 Fluoride-ion-catalysed rearrangements of fluoroalkenes 187 9 Fluoride-ion-induced oligomerisation reactions 188 10 Perfluorocycloalkenes 190 D Electrophilic attack 191 E Free-radical additions 196 1 Orientation of addition and rates of reaction 197 2 Telomerisation 202 3 Polymerisation 203 F Cycloadditions 205 1 Formation of four-membered rings 205 2 Formation of six-membered rings – Diels–Alder reactions 209 3 Formation of five-membered rings – 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition reactions 212 4 Cycloadditions involving heteroatoms 214 G Polyfluorinated conjugated dienes 214 1 Synthesis 214 2 Reactions 216 3 Perfluoroallenes 218 Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 7:05pm page xii
xii Contents
III Fluoroalkynes and (fluoroalkyl)alkynes 218 A Introduction and synthesis 218 B Reactions 222 1 Perfluoro-2-butyne 222 Formation of polymers and oligomers 222 Reactions with nucleophiles 223 Fluoride-ion-induced reactions 223 Cycloadditions 224 Free-radical additions 226 References 227
8 FUNCTIONAL COMPOUNDS CONTAINING OXYGEN, SULPHUR OR NITROGEN AND THEIR DERIVATIVES 236 I Oxygen derivatives 236 A Carboxylic acids 236 1 Synthesis 236 2 Properties and derivatives 238 3 Trifluoroacetic acid 240 4 Perfluoroacetic anhydride 241 5 Peroxytrifluoroacetic acid 242 B Aldehydes and ketones 243 1 Synthesis 243 2 Reactions 243 Addition to C5O 246 Reactions with fluoride ion 251 C Perfluoro-alcohols 254 1 Monohydric alcohols 254 2 Dihydric alcohols 255 3 Alkoxides 257 D Fluoroxy compounds 258 E Perfluoro-oxiranes (epoxides) 259 F Peroxides 264 II Sulphur derivatives 265 A Perfluoroalkanesulphonic acids 265 B Sulphides and polysulphides 270 C Sulphur(IV) and sulphur(VI) derivatives 272 D Thiocarbonyl compounds 272 III Nitrogen derivatives 275 A Amines 275 B N–O compounds 277 1 Nitrosoalkanes 277 2 Bistrifluoromethyl nitroxide 278 C Aza-alkenes 278 D Azo compounds 284 E Diazo compounds and diazirines 284 References 287 Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 7:05pm page xiii
Contents xiii
9 POLYFLUOROAROMATIC COMPOUNDS 296 I Synthesis 296 A General considerations 296 B Saturation/re-aromatisation 297 C Substitution processes 298 1 Replacement of H by F 298 þ 2 Replacement of 2N2 by F: the Balz–Schiemann reaction 300 3 Replacement of 2OH or 2SH by F 300 4 Replacement of Cl by F 300 II Properties and reactions 306 A General 306 B Nucleophilic aromatic substitution 307 1 Benzenoid compounds 307 Orientation and reactivity 310 Mechanism 311 2 Heterocyclic compounds 315 Pyridines and related nitrogen heterocyclic (azabenzenoid) compounds 315 Polysubstitution 320 Acid-induced processes 321 3 Fluoride-ion-induced reactions 325 Polyfluoroalkylation 325 Other systems 332 4 Cyclisation reactions 332 C Reactions with electrophilic reagents 336 D Free-radical attack 338 1 Carbene and nitrene additions 338 E Reactive intermediates 341 1 Organometallics 341 Lithium and magnesium derivatives 342 Copper compounds 346 2 Arynes 346 3 Free radicals 349 4 Valence isomers 351 Nitrogen derivatives 353 References 358
10 ORGANOMETALLIC COMPOUNDS 365 I General methods and synthesis 365 A From iodides, bromides and hydro compounds 365 1 Perfluoroalkyl derivatives 365 2 Derivatives of unsaturated systems 366 Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 7:05pm page xiv
xiv Contents
B From unsaturated fluorocarbons 367 1 Fluoride-ion-initiated reactions 367 II Lithium and magnesium 368 A From saturated compounds 368 B From alkenes 369 C From trifluoropropyne 370 D From polyfluoro-aromatic compounds 371 III Zinc and mercury 371 A Zinc 371 B Mercury 373 1 Perfluoroalkyl derivatives 373 2 Unsaturated derivatives 374 3 Cleavage by electrophiles 375 IV Boron and aluminium 376 A Boron 376 1 Perfluoroalkyl derivatives 376 2 Unsaturated derivatives 377 B Aluminium 380 V Silicon and tin 381 A Silicon 381 B Tin 385 VI Transition metals 387 A Copper 388 B Other metals 388 References 395
Index 399 Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 7:06pm page xv
Foreword by Professor George A. Olah Nobel Laureate
Chambers’ book Fluorine in Organic Chemistry was published 30 years ago and became a classic of the field. A revised and updated edition is a significant and authoritative contribution by one of the leaders of organic fluorine chemistry. Organic fluorine chemistry has grown enormously in significance and scope in the intervening three decades, not in small measure by the contribution of the author and his colleagues. The new edition will be of great value and help not only to those interested in fluorine chemistry, but also to the wider chemical community. When considering a new edition of a ‘classic’ of chemical literature, it is most appropriate to maintain broadly the layout and aims of the original book, concentrating on methodology, mechanism and the unique chemistry of highly fluorinated compounds. Understandably, therefore, it is outside the scope to discuss medicinal and biochemical aspects. Readers interested in these topics are advised to use the extensive reviews that are available elsewhere.
xv Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 7:06pm page xvii
Preface
This book is a revision and update of one that was first published in 1973, followed by two small reprintings. The original was prompted by Professor George Olah, during a year that I spent as a Visiting Lecturer in Cleveland. My aim for the original edition was to present an overview of organofluorine chemistry, in a way that corresponded with modern organic chemistry. Of course this involved including a mechanistic basis of the subject, which was still evolving at the time; to my knowledge, this was the first broad attempt to do so. The original book appears to have served a useful purpose because, for a number of years now, friends in the field have encouraged me to write an update. In the intervening years since the first edition the subject has grown enormously, and any idea of a single-author comprehensive volume would now be a preposterous under- taking. Consequently, I have concentrated attention on illustrating the principles of the subject, and especially those concerning highly fluorinated compounds, where the chem- istry is quite unusual. Inevitably, important areas are omitted: for example the impact of fluorine as a label in biochemistry, which is outside my expertise. However, I hope that there are enough key references to important areas that I have neglected. Inevitably, my choice of illustrative examples is subjective and I apologise in advance for all the beautiful examples that have not been included. The considerable task of producing the manuscript would not have been completed without the continued help of a long-term friend and collaborator, Dr. John Hutchinson, to whom I am deeply indebted. Also, my sincere thanks to the Leverhulme Trust for an Emeritus Fellowship, during the tenure of which the book was written. Thanks also to my colleague, Dr Graham Sandford, for invaluable help and discussions, and to Dr Darren Holling, Rachel Slater and Chris Hargreaves for reading the manuscript. Last, but not least, thanks to my wife Anne for her continued forbearance. Dick Chambers
xvii Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 6:39pm page 1
Chapter 1 General Discussion of Organic Fluorine Chemistry
I GENERAL INTRODUCTION One of the major activities of chemists in industry and academia is the search for ‘special- effect’ chemicals, i.e. systems with new chemistry and with novel properties that can be exploited by industry. There are, of course, many ways of creating novel systems but the introduction of carbon–fluorine bonds into organic compounds has led to spectacular industrial developments, together with an exciting field of organic chemistry and bio- chemistry. Fluorine is unique in that it is possible to replace hydrogen by fluorine in organic compounds without gross distortion of the geometry of the system but, surprisingly, compounds containing carbon–fluorine bonds are rare in nature [1, 2]. In principle, therefore, we could introduce carbon–fluorine bonds singly, or multiply, so that there is the potential for a vast extension to organic chemistry, providing that the appropriate methodology can be developed. Consequently, the study of systems containing carbon– fluorine bonds has become a very important area of research and the subject already constitutes a major branch of organic chemistry, while imposing a strenuous test on our fundamental theories and mechanisms. Moreover, as we shall see later in this chapter, the applications of fluorine-containing organic compounds span virtually the whole range of the chemical and life-science industries and it is quite clear that wherever organic chemistry, biochemistry and chemical industry progress, fluorine-containing compounds will have an important role to play. Surprisingly, this situation is still not reflected in current general textbooks; the reasons can be traced partly to the very rapid growth of the subject, as well as the difficulty that all workers experience in reaching a wider audience. Therefore, it is hoped that this book will help by presenting an outline of fluorine chemistry on a broadly mechanistic basis. This volume stems from an earlier book [3] on the subject; its aim remains to provide an overview through highlighting a variety of topics but with no attempt to provide comprehensive coverage of the literature. Where appropriate, books and reviews will be cited and the author therefore acknowledges the many sources, referred to either here or in the following text, to which this book is intended to be complementary [4–39].
A Properties Fluorocarbon systems, in general, present no peculiar handling difficulties and the familiar and powerful techniques of isolation, purification and identification in organic
Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Richard D. Chambers 1 © 2004 Blackwell Publishing Ltd. ISBN: 978-1-405-10787-7 Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 6:39pm page 2
2 Chapter 1 chemistry are applicable in every way. In fact, fluorocarbons themselves are characterised by high thermal stability and, indeed, elemental fluorine is so very reactive because it forms such strong bonds with other elements, including carbon. Volatilities of hydrocar- bons and corresponding fluorocarbons are surprisingly similar, despite the increased molecular weight of the latter, and indicate a general feature that intermolecular bonding forces are reduced in the perfluorocarbon systems. A final, and by no means least important, similarity between hydrocarbon and fluorocarbon chemistry is that, like hydrogen-1, fluorine-19 has a nuclear spin quantum number of 1/2 and so nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy plays a powerful role in characterisation [40]. Indeed, the only tool that is not easily available for fluorine is the observation of fluorine isotope effects, because the longest-lived isotope is F-18, with a half-life of only 109 minutes [41] although, even with this limitation, applications as a mechanistic probe have been reported [42].
B Historical development It could be argued that fluorocarbon chemistry began with Moissan in 1890 when he claimed to have isolated tetrafluoromethane from the reaction of fluorine with carbon, but these results were in error [43, 44]. Swarts, a Belgian chemist, began his studies on the preparation of fluorocarbon compounds [45] by exchange reactions around 1890 and for about 25 years from 1900 he was virtually the only worker publishing in the field. He continued until about 1938, and during that time he contributed a great deal in outlining methods of preparation for a large number of partly fluorinated compounds. It was on the foundation of Swarts’s work that Midgley and Henne [46] in 1930 were able to apply fluoromethanes and ethanes as refrigerants, and this development gave the subject some financial impetus for progress. Tetrafluoromethane was the first perfluor- ocarbon to be isolated pure; it was reported in 1926 by Lebeau and Damiens [47] but not properly characterised by them until 1930 [48] and, in the same year, by Ruff and Keim [49]. Swarts made trifluoroacetic acid [50] as early as 1922 and in 1931 reported that the electrolysis of an aqueous solution of the latter gave pure perfluoroethane [51]. Nevertheless, the first liquid perfluorocarbons were not characterised until 1937, when Simons and Block found that mercury promotes reaction between carbon and fluorine [52]; they were able to isolate CF4,C2F6,C3F8,C4F10 (two isomers), cyclo-C6F12 and C6F14. It was established that these compounds are very thermally and chemically stable and this led to suggestions by Simons that these materials might be resistant to UF6, which was found to be the case. There then ensued a period of very rapid development in the synthesis of fluorocarbon materials, the goal being stable lubricants and gaskets for use in 235 the gaseous diffusion plant for concentrating the U isotope, using UF6. These wartime developments have been published in various collected forms [53–55]. Tetrafluoroethene was obtained by Ruff and Bretschneider in 1933, who decomposed tetrafluoromethane in an electric arc [56] while Locke et al. [57] developed a synthesis in 1934, which involved zinc dehalogenation of CF2Cl2CF2Cl. Then the formation of polytetrafluoroethene [58] was discovered in 1938 and in the same period chlorotrifluoroethene was found to polymerise to give a very stable inert transparent polymer. The wartime efforts involved development of these and other new materials. Nevertheless, even at the end of the Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 6:39pm page 3
General Discussion of Organic Fluorine Chemistry 3 wartime work the subject was not well developed as an area of organic chemistry. However, its potential was recognised by a number of workers and, since then, progress has been extremely rapid. In the 1950s much progress was made on the chemistry of functional derivatives and a whole new fluorocarbon organometallic chemistry began to emerge. A major and greatly under-appreciated development of the period was the introduction of fluorinated anaesthetics which, being non-flammable, revolutionised anaesthesia. Also during this period was the development of fluorinated elastomers which, together with other fluorinated materials, were critical in the development of supersonic and space flight. It is clear, therefore, that this infant subject made crucial contributions to some of the most exciting scientific developments of the 20th century. The period from 1960 onwards saw perfluoroaromatic chemistry rapidly unfold, selective methods for fluorination develop, and fluorinated compounds play an increas- ingly important role in the pharmaceutical and plant-protection industries. Indeed, there have been so many interesting developments in the subject since the original edition [3] that it will be impossible to do justice to this era in one small volume. Remarkably, it has been reported that organofluorine compounds constitute 6–7% of all new com- pounds recorded in Chemical Abstracts up to 1990 and 7–8% of all chemical patents up to 1997 contain fluorinated compounds. This in itself is an outstanding output for the relatively limited number of workers in the field worldwide and is a tribute to their dedication [59].
II INDUSTRIAL APPLICATIONS A Introduction Even in 1992, it was estimated that business involving the sale of compounds containing carbon–fluorine bonds was worth around US$50 billion per annum [60] and it has certainly increased since then. In this chapter, only a short survey of the major industrial applications of fluorinated molecules is possible and the reader is directed to a number of books and reviews [17, 20, 29, 61–65] for further details.
B Compounds and materials of high thermal and chemical stability [29] The greater strength of the carbon–fluorine over the carbon–hydrogen bond leads to considerably enhanced thermal stability for perfluorocarbon systems over their hydrocar- bon analogues, and stability towards oxidation is dramatic. Moreover, the large number of non-bonding p-electrons, which virtually shield the carbon backbone from attack in a perfluorocarbon, must contribute significantly to these properties and, at the same time, produce novel surface effects. Furthermore, perfluorinated systems are quite inert to microbiological attack and so, combining these observations, it is reasonable to conclude that perfluorocarbon surfaces provide the ultimate in organic materials for protection against chemical and atmospheric corrosion. A further unique property of perfluorocar- bons is that they are both water- and hydrocarbon-repellent and the implications for fabric treatment are obvious. Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 6:39pm page 4
4 Chapter 1
1 Inert fluids The chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) were introduced over 60 years ago as refrigerants [46] to replace gases such as ammonia and sulphur dioxide. In 1974, at the peak of production, 900 000 tonnes of CFCs, principally CF2Cl2 (CFC-12), CFCl3 (CFC-11) and CHFCl2 (CFC-22), were manufactured mainly for use as refrigerants, aerosols and foam blowing agents. However, it was eventually recognised that the inertness of volatile CFCs is itself a problem because they survive unchanged up to the stratosphere, where they dissociate under short-wavelength solar ultraviolet radiation, releasing chlorine atoms which then catalyse the decomposition of ozone to oxygen [66, 67]. Consequently, the Montreal Protocol, which was introduced in 1987 and revised in 1990 and 1992, caused the complete phase-out of production and use of the CFC range of compounds. This legisla- tion forced refrigerant manufacturers to identify alternative ranges of non-toxic, stable chemicals which, additionally, possess low ozone depletion potentials (ODPs) and low global warming potentials (GWPs) to meet customer needs and regulatory requirements. Hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs), being free of chorine atoms, have ODPs of zero, making these products ideal systems for replacing CFCs. One of the major unsung achievements of the chemical industry has been the rapid development to large-scale production of these substitutes for CFCs; for example, CF3CFH2 (HFC-134a) is an acceptable substitute for CF2Cl2 (CFC-12) in refrigeration applications. Bromofluorocarbons possess outstanding fire-extinguishing ability: CF3Br has been used for automatic systems where the use of water is as potentially damaging as a fire, for instance in art galleries and in libraries, or in aircraft where highly efficient non-toxic agents are required. However, on an atom-to-atom basis bromine atoms are estimated to be 40 times more effective at destroying ozone than chlorine atoms, and therefore the Montreal Protocol required the complete phase-out of bromofluorocarbon use in 1994. Alternative ‘in-kind’ replacements [68] of these halon fire extinguishers are being de- veloped and currently CHF3 (DuPont) and CF3CFHCF3 (Great Lakes), amongst others, are on the market [69], but at the time of writing the problem of finding replacements for bromofluorocarbons for application as fire-fighting agents in aircraft is largely unsolved. Perfluorocarbon fluids, such as the Flutect range (F2 Chemicals Ltd), find many uses in the electronics industry. For instance, the complete immersion of electronic compon- ents in a bath of perfluorocarbon fluid can efficiently cool overheated circuits and, by a similar process, the airtight packaging around highly valuable and sensitive equipment can be tested in complete safety for leaks. Since perfluorocarbons are inert to microbiological attack, many potential medical uses of these fluids have been investigated. The report by Clark in 1966 that perfluorocarbons can dissolve significant amounts of oxygen [70] prompted the exciting suggestion that such fluids could be used as ‘artificial blood’ [71] and the now-classic photograph of a rat breathing under liquid perfluorocarbon has been reproduced countless times. Perfluorocar- bons are immiscible with blood and do not dissolve the essential mineral nutrients required. Consequently, emulsions of perfluorocarbons with an aqueous buffer solution containing various surfactants have been formulated as potential blood substitutes. Although products have been approved and marketed, there is no commercially successful emulsion. The need to extend the liquid range of perfluorinated systems to very high molecular weights was satisfied by the important introduction of perfluoropolyethers (PFPEs) [72] Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 6:39pm page 5
General Discussion of Organic Fluorine Chemistry 5 as high-boiling inert fluids, such as Krytoxt (DuPont), Fomblint (Ausimont) and Demnumt (Daikin), for use in demanding environments and for long-term reliability (Figure 1.1). These fluids have the longest liquid range known [73], remaining in fluid form from 1008 C to 3508 C and, consequently, are used for the lubrication of many diverse precision instruments, from the mechanisms of luxury watches to the moving parts of geostationary satellites and even for computer discs.
F CF3
O OCF2CF2CF2 OCF2 OCF2CF2 n nm F F n
Krytox® (DuPont) Demnum® (Daikin) Fomblin® (Ausimont)
Lubricants, coatings Lubricants, vacuum pump oils
Figure 1.1
2 Polymers [73a] Since the first synthesis of polychlorotrifluoroethene and the discovery of polytetrafluor- oethene (PTFE) in the late 1930s, the global production of fluoropolymers has grown to over 60 000 tonnes per annum. Fluoropolymers possess a unique combination of proper- ties [74–76] which ensure a wide range and continually growing number of applications for these materials. The fabled ‘non-stick’ properties of PTFE may be attributed to the abundance of non-bonding electron pairs and the coefficient of friction has been related to that of wet ice on wet ice. Some examples of commercial fluoropolymers are listed in Table 1.1 along with just some of the many applications. The remarkable feature of this area is that materials such as Vitont (DuPont) and related elastomers, which were once regarded as esoteric and appropriate in cost only for ‘space flight’ and related applications, have now entered widely into the automobile industry. Lumiflont (Asahi Glass Co., Japan), a high-performance paint which is fam- ously used on the Hikari ‘bullet trains’ in Japan, and various coatings for protection of concrete and stone building materials have also emerged. The gradual public realisation that the higher cost of high-performance products makes longer-term economic sense is the driving force behind the continued growth of this industry. Perfluorinated ionomer membranes [77], such as Nafiont (DuPont) and Flemiont (Daikin), are increasingly being used as cell-dividing membranes for chlor-alkali cells, replacing the mercury cells that have, understandably, led to so much public concern.
C Biological applications [29, 61, 62] The physiological properties of many biologically significant molecules can be modu- lated if fluorine or fluorinated groups are incorporated into their structure [24, 78]; factors affecting the change in biological activity of a substrate upon fluorination are complex [79]. Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 6:39pm page 6
6 Chapter 1
Table 1.1 Applications of fluoropolymers
Polymer Monomer(s) Applications
PTFE CF2=CF2 Cookware coatings; Goretext (W.R. Gore Co.) waterproof clothing; electrical insulators; medical uses such as artificial blood vessels.
FEP CF2=CF2 + CF3CF=CF2 Fabrication by conventional melt processing; wire and cable insulators; heat-sealable film, tubing.
PFA CF2=CF2 + RFOCF=CF2 Injection-moulded parts for use in aggressive environments. FF Teflon AFt (DuPont) Optically clear, used in corrosive CF2=CF2+ OO environments where glass is unsuitable, e.g. in computer chip CF3 CF3 manufacture.
Cytopt (Asahi) CF2=CFO(CF2)nCF=CF2 Optically clear, used in corrosive environments, e.g. computer chip manufacture.
PCTFE CF2=CFCl Gaskets, seals, oils, coatings, transparent inert covers.
PVDF CF2=CH2 Weather-resistant coatings; cable insulation; piezo-electric devices. PVF CH2=CHF Coatings, flexible films. t VitonA (DuPont)CF2=CH2 + CF3CF=CF2 Elastomers used for sealants, O- rings, fuel-resistant seals for F aircraft and automobiles.
CF2 3 CF2ϭCF2 + F2CϭC Nafiont (DuPont) Membranes in chlor-alkali cells. (OCF2CF)nϪ O
Flemiont (Daikin) CF2CF2X
Nafion, X ¼ CO2H Flemion, X ¼ SO2H
1 Volatile anaesthetics Prior to 1956, the most common anaesthetics included diethyl ether and chloroethane, with the associated risks. Fluothanet (ICI) was the first widely used fluorine-containing volatile anaesthetic [80], and such was its success that it has been estimated that 70–80% of all anaesthesias carried out in 1980 were performed using this substance. However, Isofluranet, Sevofluranet and Desfluranet are now commercially available alternatives in the general quest for less readily metabolised systems and faster recovery times of the patients (Figure 1.2).
CF3CHClBr CF3CHClOCHF2 (CF3)2CHOCH2FCF3CHFOCHF2 Fluothane® Isoflurane® Sevoflurane® Desflurane®
Figure 1.2 Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 6:39pm page 7
General Discussion of Organic Fluorine Chemistry 7
2 Pharmaceuticals Fluorinated corticosteroids were the first successful commercial products where useful modification of biological activity was achieved by introduction of a carbon–fluorine bond. Subsequently, the interest of the pharmaceutical industry in this approach has grown substantially and many new fluorine-containing products are available or are in advanced screening stages. Simplistically, an orally administered drug must: (a) be absorbed through the gut into the bloodstream, (b) then pass through a series of phospholipid membranes (transport) before reaching the correct site of action, and (c) bind and produce the desired effect at the appropriate enzyme site. Following this stage, the drug should be metabolised neither too quickly, nor into toxic by-products. The incorporation of fluorine into a biologically active molecule may modulate all of these functions as well as the more obvious effects of enhancing the acidity or reducing the base strength of appropriate proximate functional groups. Size is not the dominant factor, although steric requirements in biology are not so easy to establish, and a range of factors arising from fluorine substitution are at work [81– 83] and will continue to be evaluated for some considerable time. Fluorine or trifluoromethyl substituents generally enhance the lipophilicity of an aromatic sub- strate and so increase the rate of transport of the drug to the active site. A contributing factor could be, for example, the change in acidity of the drug upon fluorination, thus enhancing the solubility. Whatever the relative importance of the contributing factors, introduction of a fluorine atom at the C-6 site in the antibacterial fluoroquinolone drugs, e.g. Ciproflaxint (Bayer), increases the rate of cell penetration by up to 70 times. Fluorine substitution in drugs may affect binding in two ways [61]. First, it is often possible to vary the dipole moment (e.g. using two fluorine substituents that are ortho, meta or para in a phenyl group); secondly, it is possible that fluorine may be displaced from the bound drug, leading to covalent binding, in a process referred to as ‘suicide inhibition’. The anti-metabolite 5-fluorouracil (5-FU) is almost certainly effective in part through this process. A further significant effect of introducing fluorine is the resulting enhanced resistance to metabolic oxidation and therefore to potentially toxic by-products, thus increasing both the effective lifetime and the safety of a drug. Some examples of fluorinated pharmaceuticals currently on the healthcare market are given in Figure 1.3. Both Ciprofloxacint (Bayer), a member of the 6-fluoroquinolone antibacterial agent range, and the controversial ‘sunshine drug’ Prozact (Eli Lilley), the leading member of a new family of selective serotonin re-uptake inhibitor (SSRI) antidepressants, are in the world top 20 best-selling pharmaceuticals and achieve annual sales in the region of US$1 billion each.
3 Imaging techniques The isotope fluorine-18 has a half-life of 109 minutes and decays by positron emission; therefore molecules containing this isotope can be monitored by positron emission tomography (PET), which is a technique that is especially useful for non-invasive in vivo study of metabolic processes [41]. For example, 2-fluorodeoxyglucose is transported into cells in the same manner as glucose but, after rapid phosphorylation, further metab- olism is inhibited because of the fluorine, thus effectively trapping the radiolabelled Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 6:39pm page 8
8 Chapter 1
O
O H CF3 N H F N O N O O N HO H
5-Fluorouracil OH (anti-cancer) Trifluridine® (anti-viral)
N N OH N O N N N F CO2H
F N N N H F Fluconazole® Ciprofloxacin® (anti-fungal) (antibacterial)
O CH OH H 2 OH ON HO CH3 CH3
F C 3 F O
Prozac® Betamethasone® (anti-depressant) (anti-inflammatory)
Figure 1.3 Examples of drugs containing fluorine molecule in a cell. Uptake of fluorine-18 gives a direct measure of the rate of glucose metabolism in the part of the body under study. Similarly, 18F-DOPA acts as a tracer for DOPA, which is a neurotransmitter in the brain, and the PET study of the complex metabolism and biodistribution of DOPA is hoped to provide a quantitative measure of the dopaminergic neurons in the brain [84] (Figure 1.4). Non-invasive monitoring of therapeutic agents can also be performed by 19F magnetic resonance imaging (MRI); the negligible natural fluorine background and the high sensitivity of 19F NMR spectroscopy has made possible the study of the in vivo action and metabolic pathways of fluorine-containing drugs. For instance, 19F MRI has demon- strated that 5-fluorouracil is metabolised to NH2CH2CHFCOOH. Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 6:39pm page 9
General Discussion of Organic Fluorine Chemistry 9
HO F CO2H O HO OH NH2 HO HO F OH 18F-2-Fluorodeoxyglucose 18F-6-Fluoro-DOPA (PET Scanning Agent) (NMR Scanning Agent)
Figure 1.4 Perfluorooctyl bromide is being used very successfully to enhance the contrast between healthy and diseased tissue in 1H MRI procedures and as a general imaging agent for X-ray and other forms of examination of soft tissue.
4 Plant protection agents [62] Environmental concerns have imposed massive constraints on plant protection products, and the impressive progress towards lower dose levels for effective control is another of the unrecognised success stories of the chemical industry. Fluorinated molecules have played an important role in these developments, leading to a range of successful herbi- cides, insecticides and fungicides [85]. Trifluralin (Dow), a herbicide used principally for the control of grassy weeds in a wide range of crops, has been in use for over 25 years and peak sales in the mid 1980s reached US$400 million per annum. Fusiladet is another widely successful herbicide used for the control of weeds in broad-leaf crops at low dosage rates. The pyrethroid derivative Cyhalothrint is a successful insecticide and the fungicide sector contains five significant products with fluorine incorporated in the substrate. Flutriafolt is used for protecting cereal crops and Flutolanilt is used mainly in the Far East for controlling crop diseases (Figure 1.5).
D Biotransformations of fluorinated compounds As the occurrence of fluoride ion is so widespread, it is particularly surprising that compounds containing carbon–fluorine bonds are rarely found in nature [1, 2]. Potassium monofluoroacetate occurs in several tropical and sub-tropical plants located in the southern hemisphere, such as Dichapetalum cymosum (South Africa, very toxic to animals) and Oxylobium parviform (Australia). Some plants, such as soya bean (Glycine max), are able to synthesise fluoroacetate when grown in fluoride-rich soil. A shrub occurring in Sierra Leone, Dichapetalum toxicarium (ratsbane), is also poisonous, par- ticularly the seeds, and this has been attributed to the occurrence of v-fluoro-oleic acid,
CH2FðCH2Þ7CH5CHðCH2Þ7COOH [86]. Nucleocidin, an adenine-containing antibiotic, has been isolated from the fermentation broths of a micro-organism Streptomyces calvus [1]. The fact that only 12 compounds containing C–F bonds have been found in nature so far [87] leads to the questions of (a) whether this is a consequence of the difficulty of forming C–F bonds in the first place, and (b) whether subsequent enzymic transform- ations in plants and animals are inhibited by the presence of C–F bonds. Fluorine, as fluoride ion, although extremely abundant, is present in largely insoluble salts. Moreover, fluoride ion is extensively hydrated because of the strength of hydrogen bonding, and in Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 6:39pm page 10
10 Chapter 1
n N Pr2 O O2N NO2 F C O 3 OnBu Me N O CF3
Trifluralin® Fusilade® OCN O F3C O
Cl
Cyhalothrin®
OH
F CF3 O
i N F N O Pr NN H
Flutriafol® Flutolanil®
Figure 1.5 Examples of plant-protecting agents containing fluorine the hydrated state it is relatively unreactive as a nucleophile. It seems likely, therefore, that the dearth of C–F bonds in nature is essentially due to a combination of these effects, which inhibit C–F bond formation. However, an exception to this situation is the formation of the toxin fluoroacetate, which inhibits the Krebs cycle. Moreover, O’Hagan and co-workers have successfully identified the first fluorinase enzyme, in the bacterium Streptomyces cattleya, which catalyses the formation of a C–F bond [88] (Figure 1.6). These results then raise the issue of how the fluoride becomes an active nucleophile in this system: at this stage, the most likely scenario is that fluoride ion is drawn into lipophilic sites on the enzyme and effectively de-solvated, to make it more reactive. Exciting prospects for the future are indicated by the identification of this fluorinase system [88]. In contrast, there are now many examples in the literature to indicate that, when presented with organic compounds already labelled with fluorine, enzymes may be tolerant to the presence of fluorine, depending on the number of C–F bonds and their location [89, 90]. For example, baker’s yeast may lead to significant asymmetric reduc- tion of carbonyl (Figure 1.7). Likewise, various kinetic resolutions of fluorinated compounds have been achieved, e.g. the acetate of 1,1,1-trifluoro-2-octanol has been transformed into (R)-1,1,1-trifluoro- 2-octanol (Figure 1.8). Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 6:39pm page 11
General Discussion of Organic Fluorine Chemistry 11
− + O H3N NH NH ½88 O 2 2 N − N N F N Fluorinase F N Me S+ N N N O O
HO OH HO OH
S-adenosylmethionine 5'-FDA
O O + OH NAD H F F
Fluoroacetate Fluoroacetaldehyde
Figure 1.6
OH ½89 CH2FCOPh 58%
FH2C Ph
R (90% ee)
Figure 1.7
OCOMe OH OCOMe ½89 Lipase MY
F3CCH2CO2Et F3CCH2CO2Et F3CCH2CO2Et
(R) 96% ee
Figure 1.8
The use of CHF [91] and CF2 [92] groups as oxygen mimics has been explored and fluoromethylenephosphonates, as phosphate mimics [93], have been employed as binding agents for a promising approach to catalytic antibodies [94] although inevitably these sites must be more sterically demanding than oxygen. Of course a fluorine atom itself is isoelectronic with an oxygen anion and, not surprisingly, fluorinated carbohydrates have been widely explored [22, 95], as have fluorinated amino-acids and peptides [31, 96]. Indeed, fluorine is advocated as a tool for exploring the conformations of amides and peptides [97]. The presence of fluorine, with the opportunity of observation by 19F NMR, free from the often complex 1H signals, can be an extremely useful probe. Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 6:39pm page 12
12 Chapter 1
It should be clear from this cursory discussion, and the publications referred to, that the roles of fluorine in drug design and in applications to biochemistry are very large and burgeoning topics that are hugely important.
E Applications of unique properties 1 Surfactants [29] The low surface energy possessed by highly fluorinated compounds has allowed the development of fluorine-containing surfactants that are especially effective in very low concentrations [98–100]. Surfactants based on straight fluorocarbon chains are the most efficient known, and a terminal trifluoromethyl group is essential to this efficiency. Fluorinated surfactants are used in fire-fighting foams, as emulsifiers for polymerisations and as additives to paints. Cationic, anionic and non-ionic surfactants containing per- fluorinated groups have been marketed; examples of each are given in Figure 1.9.
F3CCF3
F3C O C8F17SO2NH(CH2)3NMe3 I C2F5 C2F5 SO3 Na Cationic Anionic
C8F17CH2CH2O(CH2CH2O)nH
Non-ionic
Figure 1.9 Fluorinated surfactants
2 Textile treatments [29] Polyacrylates bearing pendant perfluoroalkyl groups are extremely difficult to wet, due to the very low surface energy of the partially fluorinated polymer. When surfaces of materials are coated with such polymers, their oil and water repellencies are greatly enhanced and this has been used to great effect in the textile-finishing area. Products such as Zepelt (DuPont) are used for coating fabrics, as furniture sprays, and as carpet and leather finishing agents. However, the highly successful Scotchgardt (3M) was removed from the marketplace following concerns about the appearance of perfluoro-octyl sulphonic acid in various blood samples, albeit in extremely low concentrations. How- ever, the extreme stability of the acid could lead to a build-up in biological systems. Techniques for plasma polymerisation have been progressed significantly in recent years [101] and direct formation of fluorocarbon coatings on surfaces, including textiles, holds much promise.
3 Dyes [29] Fibre-reactive dyes are water-soluble dyes containing a chromophore that is attached to a reactive group which then may be attacked by fibres containing nucleophiles to form a Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 6:39pm page 13
General Discussion of Organic Fluorine Chemistry 13 dye–fibre bond. Fluorinated heterocycles, such as pyrimidines or triazines, are the most widely used ‘carrier systems’ for dye chromophores since the fluorine on the heterocyclic ring may be attacked by hydroxyl groups on the cellulose or cotton fibre surface, as outlined below (Figure 1.10) (see Chapter 9 for a discussion of nucleophilic aromatic
NH-Dye NH-Dye
Cl Cl Cl N Dye-NH2 N Cotton-OH N F F F N N Cotton O N
Figure 1.10 substitution of fluorine). The incorporation of trifluoromethyl groups into a chromophore can give the dye increased light fastness and improved clarity. A similar approach to conferring oil-repellency on cellulose surfaces has been de- scribed using perfluoro(isopropyl-s-triazine)s [102]. For various reasons, the superior properties of most liquid-crystalline materials con- tained in LCD displays depend critically on the presence of fluorinated substructures [103]. In particular, perfluorinated groups have displaced cyano groups for their role in inducing polarity.
III ELECTRONIC EFFECTS IN FLUOROCARBON SYSTEMS The electronic properties and size of fluorine relative to hydrogen and chlorine are set out in Table 1.2; at this point it is worthwhile to examine some of the possible consequences of these differences for the chemistry of fluorocarbon systems. In this way it can be emphasised, at the outset, how far-reaching these effects will be and, at the same time, it sets the scene for a rational approach to the chemistry. First, the large ionisation energy of fluorine implies that species involving electron- deficient fluorine might be less common than those involving hydrogen or chlorine. The ionisation energy of chlorine is, in fact, less than that of hydrogen and chloronium ions
Table 1.2 Electronic properties
H F Cl Ref.
Electronic configuration 1s1 ...2s22p5 ...3s23p53d0 – Electronegativity (Pauling)ÀÁ 2.20 3.98 3.16 [104] a Ionisation energyÀÁ kJmol 1 1312 1681 1251 [104] Electron affinity kJmol 1 b 74.0 332.6 348.5 [104] Bond energiesÀÁ of C2Xin 446.4 546.0 305.0 [19] 1 CX4 kJmol BondÀÁ energies of X2X 434 157 242 [105] kJmol 1 Bond lengths of C2Xc (A˚ ) 1.091 1.319 1.767 [19] van der Waals radius (A˚ ) 1.20 1.47 1.75 [104] Preference as a leaving group Hþ F Cl – a Xþ þ e ! X b X þ e ! X c Covalent radii in CX4 Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 6:39pm page 14
14 Chapter 1
2Clþ2 (as well as 2Brþ2 or 2Iþ2) are now well established [106], whereas the analogous fluoronium species 2Fþ2 have not been observed. It is particularly interesting that the electron affinity of fluorine is actually less than that of chlorine because, here, we have the first indication of repulsion between unshared electron pairs raising the energy of the system, and it is likely that this factor accounts for the lower bond strength of F2F than Cl2Cl bonds; it will become apparent that electron-pair repulsions are very import- ant in fluorocarbon chemistry. Overall we can expect profound differences between hydrocarbon and fluorocarbon systems arising from, in particular: (a) electronegativity differences, (b) the existence of unshared electron pairs associated with fluorine, (c) the tendency for displacement of fluorine as F from unsaturated fluorocarbons, (d) the higher bond strength of C2F than C2H and, to a lesser extent, (e) the larger size of fluorine than hydrogen [107]. Differences between fluorocarbon and chlorocarbon systems are likely to be influenced by (a) the larger steric requirements of chlorine, (b) the lower bond strength of C2Cl than C2F, and (c) the greater availability of 3d orbitals of chlorine. We can now outline, in a collective fashion, some electronic effects of fluorine that act, or have been suggested to act, in a fluorocarbon system but no attempt is made to discuss the detail of these effects at this point.
A Saturated systems (1) Inductive (through s-bonds) and field (through space) effects arise from a highly polar bond ( Is), resulting in electron withdrawal to fluorine (Figure 1.11).
d + d CF
Figure 1.11 (2) ‘Double bond–no bond resonance’ (and equivalent molecular orbital descriptions) has been suggested to be involved ( R) (Figure 1.12).
FFC F CF
Figure 1.12 This may be described in molecular orbital terms as interaction of s-electrons in C2F with low-lying s -orbitals in the other C2F bonds.
B Unsaturated systems
(1) Inductive ( Is) effects act as in saturated systems. (2) Inductive and field effects result in the polarisation of p-electrons ( Ip) (Figure 1.13).
F d -d + CC
Figure 1.13 Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 6:39pm page 15
General Discussion of Organic Fluorine Chemistry 15
(3) Coulombic or Pauli repulsion occurs between electron pairs on fluorine and p-electrons (þIp) (Figure 1.14).
F δ+ δ− CC
Figure 1.14 Thus, there is a dichotomy in behaviour of fluorine because effects 1 and 2 lead to electron withdrawal whereas 3 leads to return of electron density from fluorine. (4) ‘No-bond resonance’ ( R) is illustrated in Figure 1.15.
CF3 F C CCϭ FCCϭ F
Figure 1.15
C Positively charged species
(1) Inductive electron withdrawal ( Is) would tend to destabilise a carbocation (Figure 1.16).
CCF C F
1.16A 1.16B
Figure 1.16 (2) Mesomeric interaction (þM) of an unshared pair with the empty orbital on carbon, if operating, would lead to stabilisation (Figure 1.17).
+ + C F CF
1.17A
Figure 1.17 Later discussion will show that fluorine directly attached to a carbocation centre, as in 1.16A and 1.17A, overall is clearly a stabilising influence, but the effect of fluorine more remote from the centre, as in 1.16B, is strongly destabilising.
D Negatively charged species
(1) Inductive electron withdrawal ( Is) would lead to stabilisation (Figure 1.18).
CCCF F
1.18A 1.18B
Figure 1.18 Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 6:39pm page 16
16 Chapter 1
(2) Repulsion between adjacent electron pairs (þIp) would be destabilising (Figure 1.19).
CF
1.19A
Figure 1.19 It will become apparent that fluorine not directly attached to the carbanionic carbon 1.18B is strongly stabilising but, when directly attached as in 1.18A and 1.19A, it has either a moderate stabilising effect compared with hydrogen, or it definitely destabilises, depending on the stereochemistry of the carbanion. (3) A ‘negative hyperconjugation’ has been proposed (Figure 1.20). F F CCFCCϭ F F F
Figure 1.20 Again, in MO terms, this would be described as interaction of the filled p-orbital on carbon with s -orbitals associated with C2F bonds.
E Free radicals
(1) Inductive electron withdrawal ( Is) will affect the polar characteristics, and hence reactivity, of a radical (Figure 1.21).
d + d - C F
Figure 1.21
(2) All substituents replacing hydrogen should lower the potential energy of a free radical; this may be represented as a resonance stabilisation (Figure 1.22).
CF CF
Figure 1.22 Even from the foregoing crude but useful generalisations, it will be appreciated how unusual the chemistry of fluorocarbon compounds is.
IV NOMENCLATURE [108, 109] The nomenclature of fluorocarbon derivatives is based on regarding them as derivatives of the corresponding hydrocarbon compounds. Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 6:39pm page 17
General Discussion of Organic Fluorine Chemistry 17
A Systems of nomenclature The number of fluorine atoms is indicated in the name and the positions are indicated by numerals or Greek letters according to normal conventions, for example as in Figure 1.23. FF
CF3 O
CF3 FF Hexafluoroacetone 1,1,4,4-Tetrafluorocyclohexane
Figure 1.23 To avoid cumbersome use of numbers, when the number of hydrogen atoms in a molecule is four or less and the ratio of hydrogen to halogen atoms is not more than 1:3, then the position of the hydrogen atoms is designated, for example, as in Figure 1.24.
CF3CFHCF3 2H-heptafluoropropane
CHClFCF2CF3 1H-1-chlorohexafluoropropane
Figure 1.24 Another system frequently used involves adding a prefix ‘perfluoro’ before the name of the corresponding hydrocarbon analogue. This indicates that all hydrogen atoms that are not part of a recognised functional group are replaced by fluorine, for example as in Figure 1.25.
CF3
F (CF ) C-OH 3 3 F N
Perfluorocyclobutane Perfluoro-t-butanol Perfluoro(4-methylpyridine)
Figure 1.25 For cyclic systems, a capital F in the centre of the ring is used frequently to denote that all unmarked bonds are to fluorine, for example as in Figure 1.26.
F Perfluorocyclohexane
Figure 1.26 There are ambiguities and limitations to the use of the ‘perfluoro’ prefix; it should not be used for some substituted derivatives, for example see Figure 1.27.
Cl
F 1,2-dichlorohexafluorocyclobutane
Cl
Figure 1.27 Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 6:39pm page 18
18 Chapter 1
A simple method for indicating the geometry of stereoisomers is indicated in Figure 1.28.
H H F F
H H
1H, 2H / - perfluorocyclohexane 1H, / 2H - perfluorocyclohexane
Figure 1.28 For highly fluorinated systems the ‘perfluoro’ system is often much less cumbersome and immediately more meaningful than the numerical system and, for this reason, it will often be used in this book. Both systems can be used, together with parentheses, to refer to individual groups (Figure 1.29).
C6H5CF2CF2CF2CF2CF3 (Perfluoro-n-pentyl)benzene
C6H5CF2CF2CFHCF2CF3 (3H-decafluoro-n-pentyl)benzene
Figure 1.29
In many cases, the abbreviations RF and ArF are used to represent perfluoroalkyl and perfluoroaryl groups respectively. A further system of nomenclature has been authorised by the ACS, whereby a capital F preceding the name of a substrate indicates perfluorination, for example as in Figure 1.30.
CF3CF2COOH F-propanoic acid F F-benzene
Figure 1.30
B Haloalkanes [109] A perverse system of nomenclature exists for the CFC, HCFC and HFC groups of compounds and, whatever objections to it may be made, it seems to be here to stay. Therefore, to avoid much frustration it is advisable to become acquainted with the rules. A series of three numbers are used (or two if the first is zero) that indicate, in order, the following: Number of carbon atoms minus one (C 1) Number of hydrogen atoms plus one (H þ 1) Number of fluorine atoms (F) Chlorine atoms are not included and, for bromine derivatives, B is added, followed by the number of bromine atoms. Also, a cyclic system has the numbers prefixed by C, for example: Tetrachlorodifluoroethane C2Cl4F2 112 Trichlorofluoromethane CCl3F11 Perfluorocyclobutane C4F8 C318 Dibromodifluoromethane CBr2F2 12B2 Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 6:39pm page 19
General Discussion of Organic Fluorine Chemistry 19
For positional isomers, the deviation from symmetrical fluorine substitution is denoted by a letter, for example: CF2H2CF2H 134 CF32CFH2 134a
REFERENCES 1 D.B. Harper and D. O’Hagan, Nat. Prod. Rep., 1994, 11, 123. 2 D.B. Harper and D. O’Hagan, J. Fluorine Chem., 2000, 100, 127. 3 R.D. Chambers, Fluorine in Organic Chemistry, John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1973. 4 M. Stacey, J.C. Tatlow, A.G. Sharpe, et al. (eds), Advances in Fluorine Chemistry, Vols 1–7, Butterworth, London, 1960–1973. 5 P. Tarrant (ed.), Fluorine Chemistry Reviews, Vols 1–8, Dekker, New York, 1967–1977. 6 M. Howe-Grant (ed.), Kirk-Othmer Encyclopedia of Chemical Technology, 4th edition, Vol. 11, Organic Fluorine Compounds, John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1994. 7 M. Howe-Grant (ed.), Fluorine Chemistry: A Comprehensive Treatment, John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1995. 8 A.E. Pavlath and A.L. Leffler, Aromatic Fluorine Compounds, Reinhold, New York, 1962. 9 A.J. Rudge, The Manufacture and Use of Fluorine and its Compounds, Oxford University Press, London, 1962. 10 W.A. Sheppard and C.M. Sharts, Organic Fluorine Chemistry, Benjamin, New York, 1969. 11 S. Patai (ed.), The Chemistry of the Carbon–Halogen Bond, John Wiley and Sons, London, 1973. 12 L.A. Wall, Fluoropolymers, Wiley-Interscience, New York, 1973. 13 R. Filler, Biochemistry Involving Carbon–Fluorine Bonds, American Chemical Society, Washington DC, 1976. 14 J.W. Root, Fluorine-containing Free Radicals, American Chemical Society, Washington DC, 1978. 15 R.D. Chambers and S.R. James in Halo Compounds, ed. J.F. Stoddart, Pergamon, Oxford, 1979, p. 493. 16 R. Filler and Y. Kobayashi (eds), Biomedical Aspects of Fluorine Chemistry, Elsevier Bio- medical Press, Amsterdam, 1982. 17 R. E. Banks (ed.), Preparation, Properties and Industrial Applications of Organofluorine Compounds, Ellis Horwood, Chichester, 1982. 18 I.L. Knunyants and G.G. Yakobson, Synthesis of Fluoro-organic Compounds, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1985. 19 B.E. Smart in Fluorinated Organic Molecules, ed. J.F. Liebman and A. Greenberg, VCH Publishers, Deerfield Beach, 1986, p. 141. 20 R.E. Banks, D.W.A. Sharp and J.C. Tatlow (eds), Fluorine: The First One Hundred Years, Elsevier Sequoia, New York, 1986. 21 J.F. Liebman, A. Greenberg and W.R. Dolbier (eds), Fluorine Containing Molecules, Struc- ture, Reactivity, Synthesis and Applications, VCH Publishers, New York, 1988. 22 N.F. Taylor (ed.), Fluorinated Carbohydrates: Chemical and Biochemical Aspects, American Chemical Society, Washington DC, 1988. 23 L. German and S. Zemskov (eds), New Fluorinating Agents in Organic Synthesis, Springer- Verlag, Berlin, 1989. 24 J.T. Welch and S. Eswarakrishnan, Fluorine in Bioorganic Chemistry, John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1991. 25 J.T. Welch (ed.), Selective Fluorination in Organic and Bioorganic Chemistry, American Chemical Society, Washington, DC, 1991. 26 K.L. Kirk, Biochemistry of Halogenated Organic Compounds, Plenum, New York, 1991. Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 6:39pm page 20
20 Chapter 1
27 G.A. Olah, R.D. Chambers and G.K.S. Prakash (eds), Synthetic Fluorine Chemistry, Wiley-Interscience, New York, 1992. 28 M. Hudlicky, Chemistry of Organic Fluorine Compounds, 2nd revised edition, Ellis Horwood, Chichester, 1992. 29 R.E. Banks, B.E. Smart and J.C. Tatlow (eds), Organofluorine Chemistry. Principles and Commercial Applications, Plenum, New York, 1994. 30 T. Hayashi and V.A. Soloshonok, Tetrahedron: Asymm., 1994, 5, 955. 31 V.P. Kukhar and V.A. Soloshonok, Fluorine-containing Amino Acids, John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1995. 32 M. Hudlicky and A.E. Pavlath (eds), Chemistry of Organic Fluorine Compounds II, American Chemical Society, Washington DC, 1995. 33 T.L. Gilchrist (ed.), Comprehensive Organic Functional Group Transformations, Vol. 6, Elsevier Science, Oxford, 1995. 34 B.E. Smart, Chem. Rev., 1996, 96, 1555. 35 G. Resnati and V.A. Soloshonok, Tetrahedron, 1996, 52, 1. 36 B. Baasner, H. Hegemann and J.C. Tatlow (eds), Houben-Weyl: Methods of Organic Chemis- try, Vols E10a–E10c, Organo-fluorine Compounds, Georg Thieme, Stuttgart, 1999. 37 J.H. Clark, D. Wails, and T.W. Bastock, Aromatic Fluorination, CRC Press, Boca Raton, 1996. 38 R.D. Chambers (ed.), Organofluorine Chemistry. Fluorinated Alkenes and Reactive Intermedi- ates, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1997. 39 R.D. Chambers (ed.), Organofluorine Chemistry: Techniques and Synthons, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1997. 40 W.S. Brey and M.L. Brey in Fluorine-19 NMR, ed. D.M. Grant and R.K. Harris, John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1996, p. 2063. 41 M.R. Kilbourn, Fluorine-18 Labeling of Radiopharmaceuticals, National Academy Press, Washington DC, 1990. 42 O. Matsson, S. Axelsson, A. Hussenius and P. Ryberg, Acta. Chem. Scand., 1999, 53, 670. 43 H. Moissan, Compt. Rend., 1890, 110, 276. 44 H. Moissan, Le Fluor et ses Compose´s, Steinheil, Paris, 1900. 45 F. Swarts, Bull. Acad. Roy. Belg., 1892, 24, 474. 46 T. Midgley and A.L. Henne, Ind. Eng. Chem., 1930, 22, 542. 47 P. Lebeau and A. Damiens, Compt. Rend., 1926, 182, 1340. 48 P. Lebeau and A. Damiens, Compt. Rend., 1930, 191, 939. 49 O. Ruff and R. Keim, Z. Anorg. Allg. Chem., 1930, 192, 249. 50 F. Swarts, Bull. Acad. Roy. Belg., 1922, 8, 343. 51 F. Swarts, Bull. Acad. Roy. Belg., 1931, 17, 27. 52 J.H. Simons and L.P. Block, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1937, 59, 1407. 53 J.H. Simons (ed.), Fluorine Chemistry, Vol. 1, Academic Press, New York, 1950. 54 J.H. Simons (ed.), Fluorine Chemistry, Vol. 2, Academic Press, New York, 1954. 55 C. Slesser and S.R. Schram (eds), Preparation, Properties and Technology of Fluorine and Organic Fluoro Compounds, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1951. 56 O. Ruff and O. Bretschneider, Z. Anorg. Allg. Chem., 1933, 210, 173. 57 E.G. Locke, W.R. Brode and A.L. Henne, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1934, 56, 1726. 58 R.J. Plunkett, US Pat. 2 230 654 (1941); Chem. Abstr., 1941, 35, 3365. 59 H. Schofield, J. Fluorine Chem., 1999, 100, 7. 60 S. Rozen in Synthetic Fluorine Chemistry, ed. G.A. Olah, R.D. Chambers and G.K.S. Prakash, John Wiley, New York, 1992, p. 143. 61 R.E. Banks and K.C. Lowe, Fluorine in Medicine in the 21st Century, UMIST Chemserve, Manchester, 1994. 62 R.E. Banks, Fluorine in Agriculture, Fluorine Technology Ltd, Manchester, 1994. 63 R.E. Banks, Fluorocarbons and their Derivatives, MacDonald, London, 1970. Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 6:39pm page 21
General Discussion of Organic Fluorine Chemistry 21
64 R.L. Powell in Houben-Weyl: Methods of Organic Chemistry, Vol. E10a, ed. B. Baasner, H. Hegemann and J.C. Tatlow, Georg Thieme, Stuttgart, 1999, p. 59. 65 M. Silvester, Speciality Chemicals, 1991, 392. 66 M.J. Molina, Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. Engl., 1996, 35, 1778. 67 F.S. Rowland, Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. Engl., 1996, 35, 1786. 68 C.S. Todd, The Use of Halons in the United Kingdom and the Scope for Substitution, HMSO, London, 1991. 69 R.E. Banks, J. Fluorine Chem., 1994, 67, 193. 70 L.C. Clark and F. Gollan, Science, 1966, 152, 1755. 71 J.G. Riess, Chem. Rev., 2001, 101, 2797. 72 R.M. Flynn in Kirk-Othmer Encyclopedia of Chemical Technology, Vol. 11, ed. M. Howe- Grant, John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1994, p. 525. 73 R.J. Lagow, T.R. Bierschenk, T.J. Juhlke and H. Kawa in Synthetic Fluorine Chemistry, ed. G.A. Olah, R.D. Chambers and G.K.S. Prakash, John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1992, p. 97. 73a G. Hougham (ed.) Fluoropolymers, Academic/Plenum Publishers, New York, 1999. 74 D.P. Carlson and W. Schmeigel in Ullmanns Encyclopedia of Industrial Chemistry, Vol. A11, VCH Publishers, Weinheim, 1988, p. 393. 75 R.F. Brady, Chem. Britain, 1990, 26, 427. 76 C.A. Sperati in Properties of Fluoropolymers, ed. J. Brandrup and E.H. Immergut, Wiley, New York, 1975. 77 A. Eisenberg and H.L. Yeager, Perfluorinated Ionomer Membranes, American Chemical Society, Washington DC, 1982. 78 V.A. Soloshonok (ed.), Enantiocontrolled Synthesis of Fluoro-organic Biomedical Targets, John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1999. 79 M. Schlosser in Enantiocontrolled Synthesis of Fluoro-organic Biomedical Targets, ed. V.A. Soloshonok, John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1999, p. 613. 80 D.F. Halpern in Anaesthetics Review, ed. R.E. Banks and K.C. Lowe, UMIST Chemserve, Manchester, 1994, Paper 15. 81 B.E. Smart, J. Fluorine Chem., 2001, 109, 3. 82 D. O’Hagan and H.S. Rzepa, J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun., 1997, 645. 83 D. Seebach, Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. Engl., 1990, 29, 1320. 84 M.R. Kilbourn in Fluorine-18 in Nuclear Medicine, ed. R.E. Banks, UMIST Chemserve, Manchester, 1994. 85 S.B. Walker, Fluorine Compounds as Agrochemicals, Fluorochem Ltd, Glossop, 1989. 86 S.R.A. Peters and R.J. Hall, J. Biochem. Pharmacol., 1959, 2, 25. 87 D. O’Hagan and D.B. Harper, Nat. Prod. Rep., 1994, 11, 123. 88 D. O’Hagan, C. Schaffrath, S.L. Cobb, J.T.G. Hamilton and C.D. Murphy, Nature, 2002, 416, 279. 89 T. Kitazume and T. Yamazaki in Organofluorine Chemistry. Techniques and Synthons, ed. R.D. Chambers, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1997, p. 91. 90 T. Fujisawa and M. Shimizu in Enantiocontrolled Synthesis of Fluoro-organic Biomedical Targets, ed. V.A. Soloshonok, John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1999, p. 307. 91 T.F. Herpin, W.B. Motherwell and M.J. Tozer, Tetrahedron: Asymm., 1994, 5, 2265. 92 D.M. LeGrand and S.M. Roberts, J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun., 1993, 1284. 93 D.B. Berkowitz and M. Bose, J. Fluorine Chem., 2001, 112, 13. 94 S. Cesaro-Tadic, D. Lagos, A. Honegger, J.H. Rickard, L.J. Partridge, G.M. Blackburn and A. Pluecktun, Nat. Biotechnol., 2003, 21, 679. 95 B. Novo and G. Resnati in Enantiocontrolled Synthesis of Fluoro-organic Biomedical Targets, ed. V.A. Soloshonok, John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1999, p. 349. 96 K. Uneyama in Enantiocontrolled Synthesis of Fluoro-organic Biomedical Targets, ed. V.A. Soloshonok, John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1999, p. 391. 97 C.R.S. Briggs, D. O’Hagan, J.A.K. Howard and D. Yufit, J. Fluorine Chem., 2003, 119, 9. Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 6:39pm page 22
22 Chapter 1
98 K. Shinoda, M. Hato and T. Hayaski, J. Phys. Chem., 1972, 76, 909. 99 H. Kuneida and K. Shinoda, J. Phys. Chem., 1976, 80, 2468. 100 W. Guo, T.A. Brown and B.M. Fung, J. Phys. Chem., 1991, 95, 1829. 101 J.P. Badyal, Chem. Britain, 2001, 37, 45. 102 R.D. Chambers, C. Magron, G. Sandford, J.A.K. Howard and D.S. Yufit, J. Fluorine Chem., 1999, 97, 69. 103 P. Kirsch and M. Bremer, Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. Engl., 2000, 39, 4216. 104 B.E. Smart in Organofluorine Chemistry. Principles and Commercial Applications, ed. R.E. Banks, B.E. Smart and J.C. Tatlow, Plenum, New York, 1994, p. 57. 105 N.N. Greenwood and A. Earnshaw, Chemistry of the Elements, Pergamon, Oxford, 1989. 106 G.A. Olah, Halonium Ions, Wiley-Interscience, New York, 1975. 107 C.G. Beguin in Enantiocontrolled Synthesis of Fluoro-organic Biomedical Targets, ed. V.A. Soloshonok, John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1999, p. 601. 108 R.E. Banks and J.C. Tatlow in Organofluorine Chemistry. Principles and Commercial Applications, ed. R.E. Banks, B.E. Smart and J.C. Tatlow, Plenum, New York, 1994, p. 1. 109 R.E. Banks in Houben-Weyl: Methods of Organic Chemistry, Vol. E10a, ed. B. Baasner, H. Hegemann and J.C. Tatlow, Georg Thieme, Stuttgart, 1999, p. 12. Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 6:41pm page 23
Chapter 2 Preparation of Highly Fluorinated Compounds
I INTRODUCTION Two different approaches have been adopted here in describing fluorination reactions: the production of highly fluorinated systems is discussed in this chapter on the basis of a comparison of methods, whereas selective fluorinations are described in Chapter 3 in terms of the conversion of functional groups. If we wish to produce highly fluorinated systems, then the starting materials are usually hydrocarbons, polychloro compounds or, of course, highly fluorinated ‘building-blocks’ for conversion to other compounds.
A Source of fluorine Fluorine is widely distributed in nature [1] and it is estimated that, among the elements, fluorine is about thirteenth in abundance. Phosphate rock, which is processed on a multimillion-ton scale as raw material for the fertiliser industry, contains as much as 3.8% of fluorine and is a very rich source of the element. However, the fluorine recovered from this process as fluorosilicic acid is still not a commercially competitive source of fluorine compared with fluorspar (CaF2), although reserves of the latter are said to be limited and it is expected that use of fluoride in phosphate rocks will eventually be increased. For industry, the source of fluorine is essentially anhydrous hydrogen fluoride [2], which is made commercially by distillation (b.p. 19.58 C) from a mixture of fluorspar and concentrated sulphuric acid. The liquid fumes in air and great care must be taken to avoid its contact with the skin, otherwise unpleasant burns are obtained which are difficult to heal and often require a subcutaneous injection of calcium gluconate [3, 4]. Synthesis of highly fluorinated compounds, starting from hydrogen fluoride, is therefore achieved by a variety of techniques: directly by reaction of an organic compound with hydrogen fluoride or by electrolysing solutions of certain compounds in HF, or indirectly by reactions with elemental fluorine or with metallic fluorides (Figure 2.1).
II FLUORINATION WITH METAL FLUORIDES [5] There is a considerable literature [6–8] on this group of reactions, embracing an extremely wide variety of experimental conditions, and the patent literature abounds with reports of different ‘catalyst’ systems. It is possible to group some of these reactions partly on a basis of mechanism if some rather broad generalisations are made about the mechanistic pathways. The aim here is to assist in the choice of the type of reagent but it is not
Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Richard D. Chambers 23 © 2004 Blackwell Publishing Ltd. ISBN: 978-1-405-10787-7 Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 6:41pm page 24
24 Chapter 2
H2SO4 KF.2HF CaF2 anhydrous HF F2 m.p. ca. 100 C
Metal Fluorides Transition Metal Fluorides
Figure 2.1 intended to imply that detailed mechanisms are understood, nor should the classifications be regarded as rigid. There are three main groups, as described below.
A Swarts reaction and related processes (halogen exchange using HF) These reactions are based on hydrogen fluoride and involve, essentially, a nucleophilic displacement of halogen (for convenience, in the sense intended throughout this book, this term usually excludes fluorine). However, only the most reactive halides such as allylic and benzylic ones can be fluorinated by anhydrous HF alone [9] (Figure 2.2). HF, 40 C PhCF PhCCl3 3 70% ½9
HF, rt Ph3CCl Ph3CF 62%
CCl3 CF3 HF, catalyst 80% 300−500 C Cl N Cl N
Figure 2.2 Hydrogen fluoride acts both as a Friedel–Crafts catalyst and a fluorinating agent in a one-step preparation of trifluoromethylated aromatics [10] (Figure 2.3).
CF3 ½10 5hr, 100 C + CCl4 + HF 92%
Figure 2.3 Halogen exchange at less activated sites requires a Lewis acid catalyst and an important part of the function of the catalyst, usually a metal fluoride or a chromium species, is to assist the removal of halogen as halide ion. Therefore, these reactions could be considered to involve carbocationic intermediates (Figure 2.4).
F CCl + MFx C MFxCl CF
Figure 2.4 Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 6:41pm page 25
Preparation of Highly Fluorinated Compounds 25
It is more likely, however, that four-centre reactions occur since the metal fluorides can be used either alone or in catalytic amounts in the presence of anhydrous hydrogen fluoride. This latter process was developed by Swarts and it now usually bears his name (Figure 2.5).
Cl δ + δ − F CCl + MFx C MFx-1 CF
F
Figure 2.5
Generally, reactions performed in the liquid phase utilise hydrogen fluoride in combin- ation with antimony fluoride catalysts and their efficiency stems from the greater strength of the bond from antimony to chlorine than to fluorine. Pentavalent antimony catalysts, such as SbF5 and SbF3Cl2, are more efficient than trivalent species because they are extremely strong Lewis acids. Carbocations are formed in the presence of antimony pentahalides and, indeed, one of the now-classic techniques developed by Olah and his co-workers for the generation of relatively stable carbocations involves the reaction of an organic halide with antimony pentafluoride, in solvents such as sulphur dioxide, at low temperature [11]. On the industrial scale, reactions are performed in the vapour phase and chromium(III)-based catalysts are extensively used in the production of hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs). In general, in this group of fluorination reactions, reactivities of the substrates and the nature of the products obtained can be accounted for in terms of the corresponding carbocation intermediates.
1 Haloalkanes For many years chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) were manufactured in huge quantities by Swarts-type processes but, after the introduction of the Montreal Protocol legislation, these compounds were superseded by non-ozone depleting HFCs (see Chapter 1). Fortunately, much of the chemistry developed for the manufacture of the CFCs can be adapted for the production of HFCs [7, 12–15]. Generally, conversion of 2CCl3 groups to 2CFCl2 can be easily accomplished, reflecting both the stabilisation of the intermediate carbocations by chlorine and the relief in steric strain associated with replacement of chlorine by fluorine. Further fluorination of the 2CFCl2 group is possible but becomes progressively more difficult [3] due to the decrease in the donating ability of the chlorine. Fluorination of 2CFCl2 groups can also be achieved but RFCH2Cl moieties (where RF ¼ perfluoroalkyl) are generally very difficult to fluorinate due to the lower stability of the derived carbocation intermediates. These effects can all be seen in the two most important industrial routes to HFC-134a, now a leading refrigerant, in which chromium(III) catalysts are used in conjunction with HF for the halogen exchange steps [15] (Figure 2.6). Chambers: Fluorine in Organic Chemistry Final Proof 4.8.2004 6:41pm page 26
26 Chapter 2
HF HF CCl2=CHCl CF2ClCClH2 ½15 CF3CH2Cl Cr(III) Cr(III)
HF
CF3CH2F HFC 134a
HF AlCl3 CCl3-CCl3 CF ClCFCl CF CCl Cr(III) 2 2 3 3
Cr(III) HF
H2 / Pd
CF3CH2F CF3CFCl2 HFC 134a
Figure 2.6
2 Influence of substituent groups Groups such as alkyl [16] and aryl [17], double bonds [18], oxygen [19] and sulphur [20] (that are known to stabilise carbocations), when attached to the carbon centres that are undergoing halogen exchange, activate the process (Figure 2.7). i PhCCl2CCl3 PhCF2CCl3 + PhCFClCCl3 ½17 60% 6% i, SbF3 / SbCl5, 150 C
i CCl CClCCl 2 3 CF3CCl CCl2 + CF2ClCCl CCl2 ½18
43% 28% i, SbF3, 150 C
i CH3CCl2CH3 CH3CF2CH3 + CH3CFClCH3 ½16
85% 10% i, SbF3 / SbCl5, rt
i CCl3CF2OCH3 84% ½19 CCl3CCl2OCH3
i, SbF3, reflux
i CF −S−CH CCl3 S CH3 3 3 73% ½20