Steve Hayden Civilwartokens.Com PO Box 1863 Goose Creek SC 29445

Steve Hayden CivilWarTokens.com PO Box 1863 Goose Creek SC 29445

FIRST CLASS

Mail Bid Sale #47 Closing December 15th 2019 and December 16th 2019

STEVE HAYDEN PO Box1863 Goose Creek SC 29445 (843) 973-4556 (Voice Mail or FAX) - Email [email protected] Web Site CivilWarTokens.com MAILBID SALE - #47 Session ONE Lots 1 to 410 Closing December 15th 2019 Sunday (online) Session TWO Lots 411 to 800 Closing December 16th 2019 Monday (online) First Lot at 7:00 PM EST each day

TERMS OF SALE:

1.There are NO buyer's fees in this sale. What you bid is the most you will pay.

2. Bids are reduced to one increment over the second highest bid. Bidding increments are: for bids up to $100 the increment is $5, from $100 to $250 the increment is $10, from $250 to $500 the increment is $25, from $500 to $1,000 the increment is $50, from $1,000 to $2,500 the increment is $100, from $2,500 to $5,000 the increment is $250, from $5,000 to $10,000 the increment is $500, from $10,000 to $25,000 the increment is $1,000 and over $25,000 the increment is $2,500.

3. Postage and insurance will be added to all invoices with a minimum charge of $1.00 per item. Free shipping to those who pay by check, simply send a check for the total before shipping.

4. Invoices for delivery within South Carolina must pay 8% for South Carolina sales tax unless a resale number is supplied. Bidders from other states are responsible for paying any sales / use tax that may be required.

5. This sale has Live Online Bidding. You can view and bid on all lots online at civilwartokens.com. If you plan to bid online you will need to register so don’t delay. As always let us know if you have any difficulty. Although the auction is staggered many lots will close within seconds so plan ahead and bid accordingly.

6. If you choose, you may still bid by Mail, Fax, Phone and Email but those bids should be received at least one day before the closing date of the sale to assure they are properly recorded. We will enter these bids and act as your agent. These bids will be reflected in the online bidding with the User Name “xxmailbid”.

7. Bids for each lot can be entered at any time until that item closes as noted in online description with possible bidding extensions as noted below. There are no hidden reserves; the opening bid is the consignor’s reserve.

8. Closing times for all lots are automatically extended for 15 seconds if a bid is received within the last 15 seconds. This will continue until no more bids are received on that lot. Items will close sequentially by lot number.

9. Estimates which appear after the description are only a guide and lots will often be sold above and below those amounts.

10. Returns will be accepted on any lots incorrectly described, however, since the majority of this material is consigned all sales will be considered final 14 days after lot delivery.

11. The auctioneer reserves the right to reject any bid or withdraw any lot.

12. Items can be paid by check or Paypal. Free shipping to those who pay by check, simply send a check for the total before shipping

13. Placing a bid in this sale constitutes acceptance of the above terms.

My web site civilwartokens.com, has Enlarged Photos of EVERY LOT.

th th Steve Hayden - Mail Bid Sale #47 - Closing Sunday December 15 and Monday December 16 2019 Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Patriotic Tokens Session One - lots 1 to 410 begin closing at 7PM Eastern Time Sunday December 15th including all Civil War Patriotics, Sutlers and Store Cards. 1 - 1/391 b R4 Raw AU+ 1863 Turban Head IOU 1 Cent struck in Brass. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 50.6 grains, 19 mm. (25-50) 2 - 1/391 e R7 Raw UNC Details 20% Bright with light stain. 1863 IOU 1 Cent struck in White Metal. (200-300)

003 006 020 3 - 2/270 b R9 Raw AU Details With a few hairlines from an old cleaning and small patches of porosity. 1864 Union Forever struck in Brass. Two very scarce dies used only in the Patriotic series. Quite rare in Brass, just the second example we have seen offered. A Raw UNC Detail with hairlines bought $575 in our December 2017 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. (400-500) 4 - 6A/269 a R4 Raw MS63 20% Red mainly on the reverse with typical shallow obverse strike for this die. Scarce obverse die and variety, quite rare in Uncirculated condition. From the Dave Bowers, Steve Tanenbaum and Herman Aqua collections. (100-150) 5 - 6B/308 a R4 Raw EF 1863 Turban Head Army & Navy. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 190°, 62.5 grains, 19.7 mm. (25-50) 6 - 7/ 7 a R8 Raw EF 1863 Turban Head obverse brockage. (500-750) 7 - 7A/317 a R2 Raw VF Turban Head 1863 Army & Navy. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 10°, 43.4 grains, 18.6 mm. (0-25) 8 - 8/309 a R3 Raw EF Turban Head 1863 Army & Navy. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 170°, 52.4 grains, 18.9 mm. (25-50) 9 - 8B/309 a R2 Raw AU Turban Head 1863 Army & Navy. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 44.5 grains, 19 mm. (25-50) 10 - 8C/313 a R3 Raw EF Turban Head 1863 Army & Navy. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 150°, 44.7 grains, 18.9 mm. (25-50) 11 - 9/407 a R5 Raw AU+ Proclaim Liberty Through Out The Land Lincoln 1863. Indiana Primitive by maker Higgins of Mishawaka Indiana. From the Tampa collection. (150-200) 12 - 9/431 a R6 Raw AU Straight planchet clip mint error. 1863 Value Me As You Pleas spelling error. Indiana Primitive by maker Higgins of Mishawaka Indiana. Rare this nice, an EF brought $120 in our June 2013 sale. From the Tampa collection. (100-150) 13 - 12/297 a R2 Raw MS64 Nicely toned. 1863 Army & Navy. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 0°, 51.4 grains, 19 mm. (75-100) 14 - 14/297 a R5 Raw MS62 10% Red. 1863 Army & Navy. Very scarce obverse die, particularly this nice. A Raw AU+ example sold for $95 in our December 2017 sale. (150-200) 15 - 16/301 a R4 Raw VF+ Turban Head 1863 Army & Navy. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 330°, 40.7 grains, 19 mm. (25-50) 16 - 16/353 a R7 Raw VF+ Turban Head 1863 with flags, cannons and drum. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 250°, 40.4 grains, 19.2 mm. (75-100) 17 - 20/303 b R6 Raw AU Details Two small stains and rim bump. 1863 Army & Navy struck in Brass. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 170°, 49.7 grains, 19.4 mm. (50-75) 18 - 25/418 a R4 Raw MS63 1863 Peace Forever with NORTH and SOUTH shaking hands. From the Dave Bowers, Steve Tanenbaum and Robert Williams collections. Data: 19.3 mm. (75-100) 19 - 27/365 a R3 Raw VF 1863 Not One Cent. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 180°, 57 grains, 19.4 mm. (25-50) 20 - 30/280 j R9 Raw EF Details With a few small marks on each side. Childs Liberty head 1863 with eagle on reverse struck in German Silver. From Chicago Illinois die sinker Childs each die is a single use and single composition in the Patriotic series. Thought to be one of just two known. From the Mark Glazer and Larkin Wilson collections. (4000-6000) 21 - 34/279 a R9 Raw VF Details With a number of light marks. 1863 Union with eagle. Struck by Childs of Chicago on a broad 22mm planchet, apparently the norm for this very rare die combination. The fourth example we have seen offered, all well worn and a variety missing from the Tanenbaum collection. A Raw FINE+ brought $400 in our October 2011 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 90°, 52 grains, 21.8 mm. (400-500) 22 - 46/335 a R2 Raw UNC Details 20% Red mainly on the reverse, nice luster and attractive but slightly bent, likely at the mint with no other signs of damage. Liberty 1864 Our Army. (25-50) 23 - 51/342 j R7 Raw MS63 70% Bright with very nice cartwheel luster. Date weak as usual for this die combination. Indian Princess Union For Ever 1864 struck in German Silver. From the Mark Bendett collection. (300-400) 24 - 51/334 ao Unlisted Raw AU Details With reverse punch mark. Some original mint red still remains. Indian Princess Our Army. Impressive and unlisted Flip Over Double Struck mint error. Much undertype detail is visible on each side, most spectacularly on the obverse. (300-400) 25 - 54/342 ao R9 Raw VF Indian Princess Union For Ever 1864. Flip Over Double Stuck mint error. Not much undertype is visible except for the bold 1864 date above the head, it alone is quite dramatic. (100-150) 26 - 56/161 a R5 Raw VF 1864 Indian Princess Our Army with two scarce dies. (75-100) 27 - 60/346 a R5 Raw MS63 Trace Red with nice toning. 1863 Indian Head with Constitution and the Union. Two very scarce dies. From the Robert Williams collection. (300-400) 28 - 66/370 a R2 Raw VF 1863 Not One Cent. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 135°, 42.8 grains, 18.9 mm. (25-50) 29 - 66/370 a R2 Raw MS63 Trace Red. 1863 Not One Cent. A common variety but quite scarce in AU and this is just the second Uncirculated example we have seen offered. An AU realized $45.10 in our October 2001 sale. From the Dave Bowers, Steve Tanenbaum and Leslie Heilbronner collections. (50-75)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com th th Steve Hayden - Mail Bid Sale #47 - Closing Sunday December 15 and Monday December 16 2019 Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Patriotic Tokens 30 - 68/359 e R8 Raw AU+ 30% Bright. 1863 Not One Cent struck in White Metal. Rare die combination in any combination. From the Tampa collection. (150-200) 31 - 68A/371 a R3 Raw EF Weak and uneven strike. 1863 Not One Cent. This obverse is the current plate specimen in the new Patriotic book. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 200°, 63.7 grains, 19.3 mm. (25-50)

032 033 034 32 - 71/183 i R9 Raw UNC Details 20% Bright with nearly full original Tin Plating but also some light hairlines. 1863 Indian Head with small Buffalo on reverse struck in Tin Plated Copper. One of the classic rarities with extremely rare reverse die. From the Mark Glazer and Fayerweather collections. (3000-4000) 33 - 71/467 a R9 Raw AU Details Retoned from cleaning. 1863 Indian Head, The Federal Government a National Currency, Free Trade And Human Rights. The obverse die is very rare with this being its most frequently encountered combination. The popular reverse die is rare in its own right. A Raw EF+ brought $1,500 in our February 2014 auction. From the Mark Glazer collection. (1500-2000) 34 - 73/ 74 a R8 Raw UNC Details With a scrape on reverse cheek. 1863 Indian Head doubleheader. Despite the rarity rating this is just the second example we have seen offered publicly. Exceedingly rare reverse die only available in this die combination in the Patriotic series. From the Mark Glazer, Larkin Wilson, Joe Kuehnert, Jon Harris, George Fuld and Virgil Brand collections. (2000-3000)

035 048 062 35 - 84/148 a R7 Raw EF Indian Head with all stars and no date with an unknown bearded gentleman on the reverse. It has been speculated that this is John Stanton himself. From an image, supplied by the current president of the firm's current incarnation Long-Stanton Manufacturing, we think that is a distinct possibility. That period picture of the token maker shows a strong resemblance including a balding head and beard. A raw EF brought $1,105.50 in our June 2005 sale. From the Dick Punchard collection. (750-1000) 36 - 91/373 a R7 Raw EF Details With some short scratches around the E in Cent. Indian Head 1863 Not One Cent. Exceedingly rare reverse die only used on this variety in Patriotic series and not used at all as a Store Card. From the Robert Williams collection earlier from our web site in March 2013 at $500. (500-750) 37 - 93/362 a R2 Raw MS63 Trace Red with weak date as usual. 1863 Indian Head Not One Cent signed H on the obverse for die sinker Charles D. Horter and signed on the reverse JGW thought to be the initials of engraver James Wilson or of Horter's neighbor and book seller John G. Wells. It is fairly unusual to have the combination of two differently signed dies. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 180°, 40.6 grains, 19 mm. (50-75) 38 - 94/363 a R6 Raw VF+ Better than average strike for variety. 1863 Indian Head Not One Cent. Two scarce dies. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 70°, 43.8 grains, 19.3 mm. (100-150) 39 - 96/144 a R9 Raw MS64 40% Red and sharply struck. 1864 Indian Head signed Key Phila on head band with Ulysses Grant on reverse. Listed in the new Patriotic book as Possibly Non-Contemporary as the Grant die may date to after the Civil War. Very rare, just the third we have seen offered. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 10°, 54.7 grains, 19 mm. (500-750) 40 - 96/144 b R9 Raw MS62 Trace Bright, feathers weak opposite Grant's high relief bust. 1864 Indian Head signed Key Phila on head band with Ulysses Grant on reverse struck in Brass. Listed in the new Patriotic book as Possibly Non-Contemporary as the Grant die may date to after the Civil War. Very rare, just the third we have seen offered. From the Dave Bowers collection earlier from Walt Korzick. (400-500) 41 - 98/291 a R5 Raw EF 1863 Union and Liberty Indian Head One Country. (50-75) 42 - 101/263 a R7 Raw VF 1861 Indian Head obverse Our Card reverse. Dies by Escherich with wonderfully crude die work and nearly always seen in low grade often with problems, this example being well above average in that respect. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 170°, 54.6 grains, 19.8 mm. (500-750) 43 - 103/293 a R6 Raw VF+ Normal weak reverse. Indian head No North, No South, No East, No West, One Country. Very scarce die variety. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 57.2 grains, 19 mm. (50-75) 44 - 103/375 a R4 Raw AU Indian Head 1863 Not One Cent. Much nicer than normally seen. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 200°, 58.3 grains, 19 mm. (50-75) 45 - 104/263 a R5 Raw EF Details With a few obverse planchet flaws as struck. Indian head Our Cent crudely made by Escherich of Chicago. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 190°, 67.3 grains, 18.7 mm. (75-100) 46 - 107/108 d R7 Raw MS63 120% Bright, typical late reverse die state with large die cud. Double headed 1863 George Washington token struck in Copper Nickel. From the Dick Punchard collection. (400-500) 47 - 112/396 a R1 Raw AU Details Short scratch on Washington's cheek. 1863 George Washington with Wilson's Medal reverse. (0-25) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com th th Steve Hayden - Mail Bid Sale #47 - Closing Sunday December 15 and Monday December 16 2019 Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Patriotic Tokens 48 - 115/115A f R8 Raw MS62 10% Bright. George and Martha Washington struck in Silver with Plain edge. Two very scarce dies, an NGC AU50 sold for $876 in our December 2016 auction. (1000-1500) 49 - 115/530 g R8 Raw AU With nearly full original Copper plating. George Washington Don't Tread On Me reverse die with oddly coiled snake. Struck in Lead with Copper plating as usually seen on pieces above VF. This example and 115A/530 were likely made by a different die sinker using the Lovett obverse die (115 and 115A) as patterns (similar to Higgins of Indiana Primitive fame). They have again been listed in the new Patriotic book. We sold a similar example that brought $913 in our April 2000 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 170°, 82 grains, 20.5 mm. (1000-1500) 50 - 117/420 a R1 Raw MS63 Struck from worn dies with die rust, cracks and cud mint error above Washington's head. 1863 George Washington Exchange. A variety that is available in a number of different die states. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 170°, 46.7 grains, 19.3 mm. (50-75) 51 - 119/398 a R1 Raw MS63 George Washington with shield within star. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 180°, 46.2 grains, 19.5 mm. (75-100) 52 - 120/255 b R7 Raw MS63 30% Bright. 1863 George Washington with Knickerbocker Currency reverse struck in Brass. Scarce obverse die. From the Dick Punchard collection. (400-500) 53 - 124/294 a R7 Raw EF Small lamination area at L of Lincoln. Abraham Lincoln President 1864 Freedom struck in Copper. Very scarce obverse die many times rarer than the 125, a Raw EF+ example brought $430 in our August 2015 auction. From the Robert Williams collection. (400-500) 54 - 125/294 d R7 Raw MS63 Trace Bright. Abraham Lincoln President 1864 Freedom struck in Copper Nickel. From the Dick Punchard and Cindy Grellman Wibker collections. (400-500) 55 - 127/248 b R3 Raw EF 1864 Abraham Lincoln OK struck in Brass. (100-150) 56 - 129/347 e R7 Raw UNC Details Holed for suspension and used as a campaign badge with original loop. 1864 Abraham Lincoln with shield and flags struck in White Metal. The vast majority of this variety come holed. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 0°, 39.4 grains, 18 mm. (300-400) 57 - 129/349 e R8 Raw MS62 Trace Bright. Abraham Lincoln 1864 with Cannons, Flags and Drums struck in White Metal. A Raw MS64 brought $825 in our December 2010 sale. From the Robert Williams collection. (500-750) 58 - 133/458 b R5 Raw VF Holed as usual. Lincoln and Liberty Good For Another Heat with ax in log. Dewitt AL 1864-43 From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 350°, 27.8 grains, 19.3 mm. (100-150) 59 - 135/440 a R2 Raw MS63 10% Red with bisecting obverse die crack. For Our Country A Common Cause Now and For Ever with Andrew Jackson. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 170°, 45.1 grains, 18.6 mm. (50-75) 60 - 137/395 a R1 Raw AU+ Trace Red. Andrew Jackson This Medal Price One Cent. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 180°, 41.9 grains, 19.3 mm. (25-50) 61 - 138/256 a R4 Raw AU Obverse double struck. General George McClellan with Horrors Of War reverse. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 0°, 58.7 grains, 19.9 mm. (50-75) 62 - 142/0 e Die Trial R10 Raw MS63 20% Bright. Large irregular 27mm uniface die trial. George McClellan obverse die trial well centered on a large planchet, quite impressive. The planchet appears to have been made of scrap metal that had been used to test small numbers and eagle punches. We sold another similar Raw MS64 die trial for this die on a larger round planchet for $1,301 in our December 2017 sale. From the Mark Glazer and John J. Ford collections. (1000-1500) 63 - 142/347 e R8 Raw MS62 40% Bright and nearly Proof Like. General McClellan with Union shield and flags within wreath struck in White Metal. This variety often comes holed, this example fortunately escaped that fate. From the Robert Williams collection. (400-500) 64 - 144/282 a R9 Raw UNC Details 20% Red with some spots. Ulysses Grant with Flying Eagle 1863 struck in Copper. Listed in the new Patriotic book as Possibly Non-Contemporary as the Grant die may date to after the Civil War. Very rare, just the first we have seen offered. The reverse die is particularly rare and depicts an eagle or some other bird with oddly turned neck the result for poor artistry or an attempt at social commentary. The most affordable example of this die was a Raw EF+ 129/282 e that brought $706 in our June 2013 sale. This may bring less due to its Possibly Non- Contemporary status. From the Robert Williams collection. (500-750) 65 - 144/349 b Unlisted Raw UNC Details With a few small spots. US Grant with cannons, flags, rifles and drums struck in Brass with a reeded edge. This obverse die had been listed as non-contemporary but has been included again in the latest edition of the Patriotic book as possibly non- contemporary. This die combination is currently unlisted in any composition and although the reverse die was used in 1864 any future listing will likely also be listed as possibly non-contemporary. Very rare and just the second example we have recorded. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 350°, 51.9 grains, 18.4 mm. (300-400)

066 067 068 66 - 147/228 a R7 Raw UNC Details 60% Red but with hairlines on both sides. 1861 I Am Ready Wide Awakes and All Seeing Eye reverse struck in Copper. Very rare reverse die. Only the fifth example we have seen offered. A Raw MS64 sold for $2,500 in our June 2013 sale. From the Virgil Brand collection. (1000-1500)

67 - 152/0 a R10 Raw UNC Details Nicely toned with 10% Red. Reverse is blank without rim and has three oak leaf shaped counterstamps joined at the tips in center. The one and only Patriotic used of the 1861 Benjamin Franklin die and apparently the Plate token for the 1982 4th edition, the 1993 4th revised and even the 2005 5th edition of the Patriotic book. However it was dropped from the listings in the 1993 4th revised edition without explanation and has not returned since with even its photo being excluded from the newest 6th edition. Our guess is because this piece, likely Unique, has not been readily available for study for many years and was assumed to be a fabrication. This example, however, would appear to be full weight and thickness with no sign of tampering, though the reverse shows some natural roughness consistent with an unstruck planchet. The oak leaves often have a military association but the configuration of these counterstamps is unique and remains a mystery. A very important rediscovery. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 61 grains, 19.1 mm. (3000-4000) 68 - 153/0 ao R7 Raw MS62 Trace Red on 1847 Large Cent VF. Benjamin Franklin struck over the obverse of an 1847 Large Cent. From StacksBowers November 2015 sale where it brought $1,423. (1500-2000)

069 070 077 69 - 153/0 fo1 Unlisted Raw AU Trace Bright struck of an 1838 Mexican Four Real coin VF or better. Benjamin Franklin struck over the obverse of an 1838 Mexican 4 Real unlisted as such and listed as Unique over a Silver coin (1799 Dollar). A Raw MS63 example over the much more available Large Cent dated 1841 brought $1,400 in our October 2011 sale. From the John J. Ford collection, earlier our February 2014 auction where it realized $900. (1500-2000) 70 - 153/519B e R9 Raw MS63 40% Bright. Benjamin Franklin die trial uniface on a 22mm nearly square White Metal planchet, unlisted as such. When encountered die 153 is almost always counterstamped into a US large cent, this is most likely Unique. From our June 2013 auction where it realized $1,350. (1500-2000) 71 - 154/417 a R7 Raw EF Stephen A. Douglas America. Rare die combination, we sold another Raw EF for $155 in our December 2016 auction. (150-200) 72 - 155/431 a R4 Raw EF+ Union 1863 Indiana Primitive with Value Me As You Peas reverse. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 150°, 46.4 grains, 19.3 mm. (100-150) 73 - 159/469 a R7 Raw VF Typical strike and die state. 1863 Flying Eagle with Dry Goods And Groceries reverse. Two rare single use Patriotic dies. A raw VF+ Details with a few light marks brought $350 in our August 2015 auction. From the Robert Williams collection. (300-400) 74 - 162/338 a R5 Raw VF With rough planchet as almost always seen with this die combination. Our Army Our Navy with eagle. Rare die combination. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 0°, 34.3 grains, 18.7 mm. (75-100) 75 - 165/431 a R5 Raw EF Eagle on Shield with Value Me As You Pleas. The obverse is Higgin's Indiana Primitive version of Scovill's Union shield die 163. Popular spelling error of Please. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 10°, 42.3 grains, 19.3 mm. (100-150) 76 - 168/311 a R1 Raw AU Cannon and cannon balls 1863 Army & Navy. (75-100) 77 - 171/428 a R7 Raw UNC Details With obverse stain and small rim nicks. The Peacemaker cannon 1863 with C. L. R. reverse die. Obverse is signed GG for George J. Glaubrecht. Both dies are rare and popular, particularly the Cannon. Most examples of this variety have problems and overall this is one of the most attractive we have seen. A Raw EF Details with obverse scratches sold for $1,250 in our December 2016 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 200°, 50.9 grains, 19.3 mm. (1500-2000)

078 092 094 78 - 177/177 a R8 Raw MS63 10% Red mostly on the normally struck side. First In Peace, First In War 1863 with George Washington on horseback with reverse a full mirror brockage mint error. We sold a Raw MS63 Trace Red example for $900 in our January 2016 auction. (1000-1500) 79 - 178/266 e R8 Raw MS62 50% Bright with weak date as usual for this die combination. The Federal Union It Must And Shall Be Preserved 1863 struck in White Metal. From the Mark Bendett collection. (200-300) 80 - 195/378 a R3 Raw AU Late die state with many fine obverse die cracks. United States Of America 1863 Not One Cent. Reverse die signed L. Roloff. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 200°, 51.7 grains, 19.4 mm. (50-75) 81 - 217/479 e R7 Raw MS62 40% Bright. National Union League of the United States 1863 with Long May It Wave flag reverse. We sold an NGC MS62 on eBay for $548.88 in March 2019. From the Robert Williams collection. (500-750) 82 - 238/405 a R3 Raw VF+ Our Little Monitor The Constitution Must And Shall Be Preserved. Scarce Indiana Primitive version of the Our Little Monitor obverse die. (150-200) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com th th Steve Hayden - Mail Bid Sale #47 - Closing Sunday December 15 and Monday December 16 2019 Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Patriotic Tokens 83 - 244/0 a R9 Raw AU Remembrance of 1863 struck in Copper with a blank reverse. This is the prototypical blank reverse type created when two planchets are struck at the same time resulting in two different blanks each with a wavy raw planchet roughness on the blank portion. We have always thought it would be interesting to be able to match up two blanks that were struck at the same time, they should fit together like hand and glove. In this case a blank 381 die is also listed making the logical intended combination 244/381. We suspect fate has eliminated the possible reunion of most blank reverses, however, with this piece hope still lives. From the Dave Bowers collection earlier from Walt Korzick. (1000-1500) 84 - 252/271 d R6 Raw MS62 Trace Bright. Masonic Union For Ever with square and compass struck in Copper Nickel. This is one of the few die combinations produced in Copper Nickel for circulation with most of the known examples EF and below. From the Tampa collection. (200-300) 85 - 285/383 a R7 Raw EF 1863 Not One Cent with eagle and Union shield. Two rare Patriotic dies from die sinker Alexander Gleason of Hillsdale Michigan. Another EF brought $633.60 in our December 2000 sale. From the Dick Punchard collection. (750-1000) 86 - 305/350 a R8 Raw EF Details Retoning from cleaning. Army & Navy with Cannons, Flags and Drum. Very rare obverse die, a Raw VF realized $525.80 in our May 2001 sale. From the Robert Williams collection. (500-750) 87 - 360/436 e R8 Raw MS62 20% Bright a bit unevenly struck. Not One Cent United Country struck in White Metal. Rare die combination. From the Mark Bendett collection. (300-400) 88 - 427/480A b R8 Raw VF Union C 1863 with Eureka Good For 10. Two rare dies particularly the reverse and many have some sort of problem, mainly stray counterstamps. We sold a Raw VF+ in our December 2016 auction which realized $1,000. (750-1000) 89 - 444/452A a R9 Raw VF Details Retoning from cleaning. An arrangement of fruit surrounded by stars while the reverse features 10 CENTS also surrounded by stars struck in Copper with a Reeded edge. Both dies are quite rare in the Patriotic series with this die combination the only use for 452A. An NGC AU50 example of the similarly rare R9 Brass variety sold for $2,100 in our April 2018 auction. (1000-1500) 90 - 453A/464C b R9 Raw EF Details A bit porous. 15 Cents with No and 5 counterstamped on reverse struck in Brass with a Reeded edge. Two very rare dies, the reverse being a single use and the current Fuld plate specimen. Both the obverse and reverse are the plate specimen in the Bowers book. From the Mark Glazer collection. (1000-1500) 91 - 454B/464D a R10 Raw EF 50 Cents with No and 10 counterstamped on reverse struck in Copper with a Plain edge. Two very rare dies, the reverse being Unique and a single use. The reverse is the current Fuld plate specimen for die 464D while the obverse 454B is the plate specimen in the Bowers book. From the Mark Glazer collection. (1500-2000) 92 - 474/475 a R7 Raw EF+ Milk Check One Quart Milk. Two rare Indiana Primitive dies neither of which were used in the Store Card series or any other combination. (1000-1500) 93 - 481/482 g R8 Raw AU 10% Bright and fairly nice for the composition. Two running dogs with 1844 dated Hope and anchor struck in Lead. It is now official that these were made during the Civil War in late 1864 or early 1865 for the Rhode Island Numismatic Society and have been relisted in the current edition of the Patriotic book. From the Dave Bowers, Charles Litman and Don Miller collections. (750-1000) 94 - 481/483 d R8 Raw MS63 40% Bright. Eagle holding shield with anchor design with 1844 dated Hope and anchor struck in Copper Nickel. It is now official that these were made during the Civil War in late 1864 or early 1865 for the Rhode Island Numismatic Society and have been relisted in the current edition of the Patriotic book. From the Dave Bowers collection. (1000-1500) 95 - 481/485 g R8 Raw EF Details With light marks in the soft metal. Leaping deer or moose with large antlers and 1844 dated Hope and anchor struck in Lead. It is now official that these were made during the Civil War in late 1864 or early 1865 for the Rhode Island Numismatic Society and have been relisted in the current edition of the Patriotic book. From the Dave Bowers collection. (500-750) 96 - 481/486 a R8 Raw UNC Details But weakly struck with some light stains. Vermont Militia with soldier with 1844 dated Hope and anchor struck in Copper. It is now official that these were made during the Civil War in late 1864 or early 1865 for the Rhode Island Numismatic Society and have been relisted in the current edition of the Patriotic book. From the Dave Bowers and Robert Blum collections. (750-1000) 97 - 481/488 g R8 Raw AU Details With light marks in the soft metal. Wolfhound and 1844 dated Hope and anchor struck in Lead. It is now official that these were made during the Civil War in late 1864 or early 1865 for the Rhode Island Numismatic Society and have been relisted in the current edition of the Patriotic book. From the Dave Bowers, Charles Litman and Don Miller collections. (500-750) 98 - 481/489 e Unlisted Raw EF Two game birds and 1844 dated Hope and anchor struck in White Metal and Unlisted as such. It is now official that these were made during the Civil War in late 1864 or early 1865 for the Rhode Island Numismatic Society and have been relisted in the current edition of the Patriotic book. From the Dave Bowers collection. (750-1000) 99 - 481/492 g R8 Raw AU Details With light marks in the soft metal. Three grouse and 1844 dated Hope and anchor struck in Lead. It is now official that these were made during the Civil War in late 1864 or early 1865 for the Rhode Island Numismatic Society and have been relisted in the current edition of the Patriotic book. From the Dave Bowers and Cindy Grellman Wibker collections. (400-500)

100 101 103 100 - 492/492 b Unlisted Raw EF Three grouse hunting scene, the center portion of Rhode Island Numismatic Society series die 492 struck in Brass on a very thin 19mm planchet rather than the normal 29mm. The reverse is an apparent full brockage mint error but also could be related to the Button die that inspired or actually struck the token series. It is interesting to note that the shared die in the series 481 is also known in 19mm size muled with "Lincoln" Redeemed die 134. A fascinating piece. From the Matt Westphal collection. (750-1000)

101 - 498/499 Iron R8 Raw VF+ Very well struck for issue. The First Ironclad 1862 Made From the Armor Plate Of The Merrimac. The Iron from the Merrimac was not recovered until well after the Civil War and consequently it has been delisted as a contemporary Civil War token, however it is still collected along with the series as an important war relic. Superior to the Raw VF example that brought $1,550 in our December 2016 sale. (2000-3000) 102 - 509A/510A b R8 Raw AU Details Cleaned with hairlines. John Bell of Tennessee with Presidents House, reverse struck in Brass. DeWitt JBELL 1860-11. (300-400) 103 - 509B/510B b R9 Raw AU Holed for suspension as usual. For President John Bell of Tennessee, Presidents House struck in Brass with Plain edge. Exceedingly rare obverse die, long considered the key to the Presidents House series. Finer than the current Fuld Plate token which is also the Bower's book Plate token. (2000-3000)

104 105 107 104 - 511/517 b R6 Raw MS62 Trace Bright. Wealth of the South No Submission to the North struck in Brass. Rare reverse die only used in this die combination it is very rare above EF and usually seen holed. (1500-2000) 105 - 511/513 a R8 Raw AU+ Wealth of the South muled with Our Rights, The Constitution and the Union struck in Copper. Very popular pro South token. We sold a Raw UNC Details with some spots for $1,250 in our December 2017 sale. (1000-1500) 106 - 520/521 a R7 Raw VF Details Slightly porous with normal uneven strike with light marks. Liberty 1860 Copper Mine Token. Crude token struck by die sinker Escherich of Chicago. From the Dave Bowers collection earlier from our July 2012 sale where it brought $525. (500-750) Civil War Sutler Tokens 107 - IL-41-5B R8 Raw MS64 40% Bright. J. C. Benton, Forty First Regiment Illinois Volunteers Good For Five Cents In Goods At The Sutlers Store. Struck in Brass with a Plain edge. Formerly IL I-5B. (1500-2000) 108 - IL-97-05B R6 Raw EF S. Whited & Co. Sutlers 97th Illinois Volunteers Good For 5 Cents In Goods. Another Raw EF sold for $400 in our August 2015 sale. Formerly IL P-5B. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 350°, 39.5 grains, 16.9 mm. (400-500) 109 - IL-97-10Ca R6 Raw VF+ S. Whited & Co. Sutlers, 97th Illinois Volunteers Good For 10 Cent 1862. Another VF+ sold for $400 in our July 2014. Formerly IL Q-10C. From the Dave Bowers collection, earlier from C&D Gale 1998. (400-500) 110 - IL-97-10Ca R6 Raw VF+ Small struck through grease flaw at the L in Vol. S. Whited & Co. Sutlers, 97th Illinois Volunteers Good For 10 Cent 1862. Another VF+ sold for $400 in our July 2014. Formerly IL Q-10C. From the Dave Bowers collection. (400-500) 111 - IN-36-05Bb R8 Raw UNC Details Small obverse spot. G. Davidson 5 Cents, 36th Indiana Volunteers. A raw MS63 realized $1,100 in our December 2010 auction. Formerly IN G-05Ba. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 300°, 16 grains, 19.1 mm. (500-750)

112 114 115 112 - IN-69-05B R9 Raw VF+ Wm. Snow Sutler, 69th Indiana Volunteers 5 Cents In Goods by manufacturing John Stanton. Very rare two variety sutler with both listed as R9. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 90°, 11.1 grains, 16.6 mm. (1000-1500) 113 - IN-84b-25B R9 Raw EF G. S. Maddy & Co. 84th Regiment Indiana Volunteer Infantry. Rare sutler an EF+ sold for $750 in our February 2014 sale. Formally IN Q-25B. From the Dave Bowers collection, earlier from Bowers and Merena March 2001. (750-1000) 114 - KY-21-05C R8 Raw MS63 Or a bit better with traces of original red and small reverse planchet flaw. 21st Kentucky Volunteer Infantry Good For 5 Cents 1863 with flying eagle. Rare sutler. Formerly KY A-5C. From PCAC's March 1999 sale. (1000-1500) 115 - KY-21-25C R9 Raw MS63 Trace Red all on the obverse. 21st Kentucky Volunteer Infantry 1863. Very rare denomination and rare non maverick state. We sold a Raw EF Details with reverse punch mark for $400 in our March 2010 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1391A. Data: 30°, 58.4 grains, 19.2 mm. (1500-2000)

116 117 118 116 - NH-14-05C R9 Raw VF W. A. Farr 14th New Hampshire Volunteers Good For 5 Cents. Struck in Copper and signed by Koehler of Baltimore. Very rare, the rarest denomination from a rare single sutler state. We sold a Tanenbaum specimen, a Raw EF with very light obverse stain, for $2,250 on our web site in August 2014. Formerly NH A-5C. From the Dave Bowers collection. (2000-3000) 117 - NH-14-10B R8 Raw EF+ W. A. Farr 14th New Hampshire Volunteers Good For 10 Cents. Struck in Brass and signed by Koehler of Baltimore. The second rarest denomination from a rare single sutler state. We sold a Raw EF with some weakness of strike for $750.20 in our April 2000 auction. Formerly NH A-10B. From the Dave Bowers and James Curto collections. (1500-2000) 118 - NH-14-25N R7 Raw EF+ W. A. Farr 14th New Hampshire Volunteers Good For 25 Cents. Struck in Nickel and signed by Koehler of Baltimore. The most available denomination from a rare single sutler state but even at R7 nearly all seen are low grade and often damaged. This is likely one of the finest known, we sold a Raw VF Detail a bit porous for $500 in our December 2017 auction. Formerly NH A-25N. From the Dave Bowers collection earlier from Steve Tanenbaum. (1500-2000) 119 - NY-1-10B R6 Raw AU J. J. Benson Sutler 1st Mounted Rifles. Formerly NY A-10B. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 48.3 grains, 20.5 mm. (300-400) 120 - OH-62-10B R8 Raw VF+ Slightly wavy planchet. Hosmer & Crowther Sutler Check 10 Cents 62 Reg. O. V. M. with John Stanton Die Sinker reverse struck in Brass. Former OH AA-10B. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 45°, 14.1 grains, 18.8 mm. (400-500) 121 - OH-81a-05C R7 Raw MS63 10% Red more so on the obverse. J. W. Cruikshank 81st Regiment Ohio Volunteer Infantry with Civil War token reverse die 1290 that features a sea monster of some type. This is the obverse die that was later altered to eliminate the 81st designation and make an interesting pair. We sold a PCGS MS62 BN example for $600 in our January 2016 sale. Formerly OH AG-5C. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1290. Data: 340°, 64 grains, 19.2 mm. (750-1000) 122 - OH-81b-25C R8 Raw VF+ J. W. Cruikshank Ohio Volunteer Infantry. Interesting variety with the "81" removed from the original die by adding an ornament. Apparently Cruikshank served as sutler for another regiment after the 81st. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1127. Data: 150°, 19.2 mm. (300-400) 123 - OH-81b-25C R8 Raw FINE+ J. W. Cruikshank Ohio Volunteer Infantry. Interesting variety with the "81" removed from the original die by adding an ornament. Apparently Cruikshank served as sutler for another regiment after the 81st. From the Dave Bowers, Steve Tanenbaum and Niles Schultz collections. (500-750)

124 133 137 124 - US-119-C R9 Raw MS62 Trace Red. J. M. Longwell Sutler 119 U.S.C.I. Very popular sutler as it was one of just a handful that serviced Black soldiers, in this case the 119th United States Colored Infantry. Formerly NL-R-C. From the Dave Bowers, Steve Tanenbaum and Herman Aqua collections, earlier from our February 2014 sale where it realized $2,300. (3000-4000) 125 - UI-D-05Bb R8 Raw EF Wm. H. Jones, Sutler Check Redeemed in Goods to Soldiers Only 5 Cents struck in Brass. Wm. H. Jones ran United States Sutler Store at 45 Cabot Street in Newport, Kentucky from at least 1867 to 1869, though it is still not known what military unit he may have been associated with during the war, if any. Always seen very well worn, this may be the finest known. Formerly NL K-5Bb. From the Dave Bowers, Steve Tanenbaum and Herman Aqua collections. Data: 19.5 mm. (500-750) 126 - UI-D-05Bb R8 Raw VF+ Wm. H. Jones, Sutler Check Redeemed in Goods to Soldiers Only 5 Cents struck in Brass. Wm. H. Jones ran United States Sutler Store at 45 Cabot Street in Newport, Kentucky from at least 1867 to 1869, though it is still not known what military unit he may have been associated with during the war, if any. Formerly NL K-5Bb. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 315°, 35.7 grains, 19.5 mm. (500-750) 127 - UI-D-10Bb R9 Raw VF Wm. H. Jones, Sutler Check Redeemed in Goods to Soldiers Only struck in Brass. Wm. H. Jones ran United States Sutler Store at 45 Cabot Street in Newport, Kentucky from at least 1867 to 1869, though it is still not known what military unit he may have been associated with during the war, if any. Formerly NL K-10Bb and the Plate Specimen for both the obverse and reverse die in the current Sutler Token book. From the Dave Bowers, Steve Tanenbaum and David Schenkman collections. (500-750) 128 - UI-D-25Bb R9 Raw VG Details A bit porous with some scratches. Wm. H. Jones, Sutler Check Redeemed in Goods to Soldiers Only struck in Brass. Wm. H. Jones ran United States Sutler Store at 45 Cabot Street in Newport, Kentucky from at least 1867 to 1869, though it is still not known what military unit he may have been associated with during the war, if any. Very rare, Dave Schenkman noted he had not seen an example in the 1st Edition of the Sutler Token book and to our knowledge this is the only example. Formerly NL K-25Bb. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections. This is the current Plate Specimen for the reverse. (300-400) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com th th Steve Hayden - Mail Bid Sale #47 - Closing Sunday December 15 and Monday December 16 2019 Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Sutler Tokens 129 - UI-D-50Ba R8 Raw VF Details Small reverse punch mark. Wm. H. Jones, Sutler Check Redeemed in Goods to Soldiers Only 50 Cents struck in Brass. Wm. H. Jones ran United States Sutler Store at 45 Cabot Street in Newport, Kentucky from at least 1867 to 1869, though it is still not known what military unit he may have been associated with during the war, if any. Formerly NL K-50Ba. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 20°, 36.4 grains, 19.2 mm. (300-400) 130 - UI-D-50Bb R8 Raw VF+ With small grease filled die at E in Check. Wm. H. Jones, Sutler Check Redeemed in Goods to Soldiers Only struck in Brass. Wm. H. Jones ran United States Sutler Store at 45 Cabot Street in Newport, Kentucky from at least 1867 to 1869, though it is still not known what military unit he may have been associated with during the war, if any. This is the current Plate Specimen in the Sutler Token book for obverse and reverse. NL K-50Bb. From the Dave Bowers, Steve Tanenbaum and David Schenkman collections. (500-750) Civil War Store Cards 131 - CT035A-1a R3 Raw MS62 Nicely toned. E. W. Atwood Dealer in Books, Bridgeport Connecticut. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1002. Data: 30°, 52.4 grains, 19.3 mm. (50-75) 132 - CT035A-2a R3 Raw AU E. W. Atwood Books, Bridgeport Connecticut with US Capitol Building on reverse. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1237. Data: 20°, 49.2 grains, 19.3 mm. (25-50) 133 - CT250A-1b(fp) R8 Raw AU Details With obverse stains. Arch Saloon No. 10 O. Rudd Montville Connecticut with Lincoln Redeemed reverse die struck in Silvered brass and has a unique Crosshatch Reeded Edge. Formerly attributed to Willimantic and has been moved in the new Store Card book to Montville where Orrin Rudd was a saloon keeper. A very rare town. We sold an NGC AU for $1,800 in our January 2015 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1147. Data: 180°, 47.3 grains, 21.1 mm. (1000-1500) 134 - CT345aA-1a R1 Raw MS63 10% Red with nice luster and toning. City Of New York I. O. U. One Cent. Current research and the new Store Card book place the base of operations for The City Of New York steamship in Norwich Connecticut. From the Tampa collection. (100-150) 135 - CT345aA-1ao Unlisted Raw AU City Of New York I. O. U. One Cent. A flip over double strike, unlisted as such. This can now be added to the long listed of unusual over strikes made for this merchant. (300-400) 136 - CT345aA-1e R9 Raw AU+ 30% Bright. An unusual piece seemingly struck on a slightly smaller than normal planchet resulting in an irregular edge and associated weakness. City Of New York I. O. U. One Cent struck in White Metal. A very rare variety from a merchant with a number of rare and unusual items. (150-200) 137 - DC500A-1h R9 Raw MS63 Henry A. Hall 308 Pa. Av. Washington DC Buy Rubber Goods Of struck in Maroon Hard Rubber. Now attributed to the Civil War era and included in the new Store Card book. Rare single merchant state. A Raw AU+ realized $1,800 in our July 2012 auction. From our August 2014 sale where it realized $1,500. (2000-3000)

138 151 166 138 - ID350A-1a R7 Raw FINE+ Miners Brewery & Bakery, Idaho City Idaho 1865. Rare single variety. The Miners Brewery burned to the ground before the end of the Civil War. A Raw VF sold for $1,320 in our March 2003 sale. From the Bob Adams and Henry South collections earlier from Chuck Kirtley's May 1987 sale. (1000-1500) 139 - IL095B-3a R9 Raw AU Details Holed, a bit dark and counterstamped 10 on reverse. D. Ford Watch Maker And Jeweler, Cairo Illinois struck in Copper. Very rare variety for use as a Watch Check. Called reverse die 0 in the current Store Card book but probably should be 1427D. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 0. Data: 49.6 grains, 19.4 mm. (150-200) 140 - Possible Cairo Illinois Civil War Token Raw FINE Details Obverse planchet roughness. Wm. H. Schutter 10 Cents Cairo struck in Brass with reeded edge and Liberty Head reverse. Schutter was in Business in Cairo from before the Civil War until the late 1870's and is currently listed in the Possible Civil War Store Card section of the new book. Issue after the Civil War is precluded by the existence of an example in the September 1863 Edward Cogan sale of the J. P. Leavitt collection Lot Number 1660. Rulau IL Cr 4. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 350°, 27.2 grains, 17.8 mm. (150-200) 141 - IL150 H-1a R6 Raw EF+ J. J. Brown's Grocery, Chicago. Very scarce merchant. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1368. Data: 190°, 48.7 grains, 19.5 mm. (75-100) 142 - IL150 J- 6a R6 Raw AU Childs Die Sinker & Engraver, Chicago Illinois 1861 Union with eagle. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1208. Data: 210°, 54.1 grains, 19.5 mm. (50-75) 143 - IL150 J-11a R7 Raw AU Details Obverse nick and some planchet flaws. Childs Die Sinker & Engraver, Chicago Illinois 1861. Late reverse die state with a high shear die crack. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1115. Data: 190°, 49.6 grains, 19.5 mm. (50-75) 144 - IL150 M-1a R3 Raw EF R. H. Countiss Grocer & Tea Dealer, Chicago Illinois. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1368. Data: 0°, 53.7 grains, 19.6 mm. (25-50) 145 - IL150 N-2a R4 Raw AU+ Dodd's Elgin Dairy Pure Milk Chicago 1861. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1111. Data: 180°, 47.4 grains, 19.5 mm. (75-100) 146 - IL150 O-1a R7 Raw UNC Details Nicely toned with reverse verdigris stain. D. Dryer & Co. Groceries & Provisions, Chicago with crude Indian Head Business Card reverse. Rare merchant and exceedingly rare in Uncirculated condition, we sold a Raw AU in our March 2002 auction that brought $705. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1080. Data: 0°, 47.4 grains, 19.6 mm. (750-1000) 147 - IL150 Q-1a R6 Raw AU Edwards Fine Watches & Jewelry, Chicago. Very scarce merchant, an EF+ sold for $90 in our October 2011 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1368. Data: 200°, 51.6 grains, 19.5 mm. (100-150) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com th th Steve Hayden - Mail Bid Sale #47 - Closing Sunday December 15 and Monday December 16 2019 Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 148 - IL150 X-1a R4 Raw VF+ P. Gaffney Grocer & Tea Dealer, Chicago. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1368. Data: 190°, 50.8 grains, 19.5 mm. (25-50) 149 - IL150AE-1a R7 Raw EF+ W. A. Hendrie Watches, Clocks & Jewelry, Chicago Illinois. Rare merchant, a VF sold for $72.60 in our March 2003 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1368. Data: 190°, 55.7 grains, 19.5 mm. (100-150) 150 - IL150AI-1b R8 Raw EF O. Kendall's Sons & Co. Bread Good For One Loaf 1863 Chicago Illinois. Another Raw EF from our January 2016 auction sold for $140. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1094. Data: 160°, 34.5 grains, 19.8 mm. (150-200) 151 - IL150AIa-1b R9 Raw AU Details Light staining. Klare & Friedrick's Billiard Hall struck in Brass with pool cues and balls pictured. Formerly listed as SNL-2a, should have been listed as Brass not Copper as all known examples are Brass. Current research shows that this business was located in Chicago during the war and it has now been listed as such in the new 3rd edition of the Civil War Store Card book. One of just four examples we have seen offered. We sold a Raw EF Detail with a few very light marks for $1,300 in our June 2013 sale. (1000-1500) 152 - IL150AJ-1a R4 Raw VF+ F. A. Leavitt Family Grocery, Chicago. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1368. Data: 190°, 64.3 grains, 19.5 mm. (25-50) 153 - IL150AJ-2a R6 Raw VF+ F. A. Leavitt Family Groceries, Crockery & c. Chicago. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1368. Data: 10°, 54.7 grains, 19.5 mm. (50-75) 154 - IL150AK-3b R8 Raw MS63 20% Bright. Marsh & Miner Military Clothiers, Chicago struck in Brass. From the Tampa collection. (200-300) 155 - IL150AL-1a R6 Raw EF A. Meyer Rag Store, Chicago Illinois with Business Card Indian Head reverse 1080. Very scarce merchant, another Raw EF brought $210 in our August 2015 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1080. Data: 90°, 60.5 grains, 19.5 mm. (200-300) 156 - IL150AU-1a R4 Raw VF+ W. R. Prentice Family Grocery, Chicago. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1368. Data: 61.8 grains, 19.5 mm. (25-50) 157 - IL150AX-1a R5 Raw AU+ With some minor planchet flaws. H. Regensburg, Bakery, Chicago Illinois. Scarce merchant and very rare in AU or better, an EF+ realized $55.50 in our June 2013 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1080. Data: 200°, 49.5 grains, 19.8 mm. (100-150) 158 - IL150BB-5a R8 Raw VF Details But poorly struck particularly on the obverse, not an uncommon occurrence with this merchant and variety. J. F. Siechler Boarding Haus, Chicago. Rare variety. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1072. Data: 190°, 51.6 grains, 19.8 mm. (50-75) 159 - IL150BC-6a R7 Raw EF C. & S. Stein Dry Goods Store, Chicago Illinois with 1860 dated reverse. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1356. Data: 0°, 49.9 grains, 19.6 mm. (50-75) 160 - IL150BE-1a R6 Raw AU+ 20% Bright with nearly full Silvering. W. Treleaven Gold Pen Maker, Chicago Illinois. Unlisted Silver Plated and looks to be original with light toning. Very scarce single variety merchant, an EF sold for $100 in our March 2003 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1368. Data: 10°, 56.8 grains, 19.6 mm. (150-200) 161 - IL200A-1a R5 Raw AU Details Small reverse spots. I. L. Ellwood, DeKalb Illinois. Manufactured by Bridgens of New York with George Washington reverse die. A VF+ sold for $155 in our July 2009 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1137. Data: 0°, 44.3 grains, 20.3 mm. (150-200) 162 - IL300A-1a NC Raw AU C. Van Dorn Largest & Cheapest Store, Fairview Illinois. Delisted in the current Store Card book as Non- Contemporary as Van Dord is thought to have operated his store from 1867 to 1873 after the end of the Civil War. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 135°, 36.7 grains, 20 mm. (100-150) 163 - IL320A-4a R7 Raw EF+ D. S. Bogar Farmers Store, Freeport Illinois. Rare variety, particularly this nice. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1209. Data: 52.3 grains, 20 mm. (100-150) 164 - IL320B-1a R5 Raw VF D. S. Brewster Butter, Eggs & c., Freeport Illinois Union 1863. Very scarce merchant. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1209. Data: 50.6 grains, 19.9 mm. (75-100) 165 - IL472A-1a R6 Raw VF Ellsworth & Halsey Ladies Ware, Lacon Illinois. Very scarce single merchant town. (200-300) 166 - IL535A-1b R9 Raw AU+ T. Adcock's Billiard Saloon Bar Check Union 1863 struck in Brass. Very rare merchant from Macomb, a very rare town. We sold a Raw MS63 with 20% Bright luster in our August 2015 auction that realized $7,100 in very active bidding. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1205. Data: 170°, 52.8 grains, 20 mm. (3000-4000) 167 - IL692A- 1a R4 Raw AU+ Trace Red with some light obverse planchet flaws. Yankee Robinson The Great Comedian with pictorial of Robinson in top hat with rifle. Robinson operated a traveling Circus and is listed under Peoria Illinois where his base of operations was located at the time these Civil War tokens were issued. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 100°, 62.9 grains, 19.1 mm. (50-75) 168 - IL692A- 1b R9 Raw MS63 30% Bright. Yankee Robinson The Great Comedian with pictorial of Robinson in top hat with rifle struck in Brass. Robinson operated a traveling Circus and is listed under Peoria Illinois where his base of operations was located at the time these Civil War tokens were issued. Very rare variety, the first we have offered though we do have records of two other being offered, one possibly this very example. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 315°, 50.1 grains, 19.1 mm. (300-400) 169 - IL692A- 2m R8 Raw EF Yankee Robinson The Great Comedian with pictorial of Robinson in top hat with rifle struck in Tin shell with incused image on reverse. Though listed in the current book as a Brockage they were likely made as intended and are not mint errors. Robinson operated a traveling Circus and is listed under Peoria Illinois where his base of operations was located at the time these Civil War tokens were issued. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 11.5 grains, 19.9 mm. (150-200) 170 - IL692A- 3a R4 Raw MS62 Yankee Robinson The Great Comedian 1863 with pictorial of Robinson in top hat with rifle. Robinson operated a traveling Circus and traditionally was listed under Cincinnati Ohio. In the third edition of the Store Card book he has been relocated to Peoria Illinois where his base of operations was located at the time these Civil War tokens were issued. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 80°, 54.5 grains, 19.2 mm. (150-200) 171 - IL692A- 3b R8 Raw MS63 10% Bright. Yankee Robinson The Great Comedian 1863 with pictorial of Robinson in top hat with rifle struck in Brass. Robinson operated a traveling Circus and traditionally was listed under Cincinnati Ohio. In the third edition of the Store Card book he has been relocated to Peoria Illinois where his base of operations was located at the time these Civil War tokens were issued. Very rare variety, the first we have offered though we do have records of one other being offered, one possibly this very example. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 135°, 55.9 grains, 19.3 mm. (300-400) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com th th Steve Hayden - Mail Bid Sale #47 - Closing Sunday December 15 and Monday December 16 2019 Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards

172 197 202 172 - IL692A- 3i R10 Raw MS65 60% Bright with full Tin Plating. Yankee Robinson The Great Comedian 1863 with pictorial of Robinson in top hat with rifle struck in Tin Plate. Very rare and currently thought to be Unique. Robinson operated a traveling Circus and traditionally was listed under Cincinnati Ohio. In the third edition of the Store Card book he has been relocated to Peoria Illinois where his base of operations was located at the time these Civil War tokens were issued. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 135°, 54.7 grains, 19.2 mm. (1000-1500) 173 - IL692A- 9a R4 Raw AU+ Yankee Robinson Big Show Triad 1863 with Indian Head. Robinson operated a traveling Circus listed under Peoria Illinois where his base of operations was located at the time these Civil War tokens were issued. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1028. Data: 225°, 62.4 grains, 19 mm. (75-100) 174 - IL692A-11a R8 Raw EF Yankee Robinson Big Show Triad. Robinson operated a traveling Circus based in Peoria Illinois. Rare variety with reverse die 1045 and Indian Head surrounded by star and without a date. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1045. Data: 10°, 57 grains, 19.1 mm. (50-75) 175 - IL692A-16a R3 Raw AU+ Yankee Robinson's Big Show Triad 1869 with portrait. Robinson operated a traveling Circus based in Peoria Illinois. Late die state with large die crack from hand to rim with other smaller cracks. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 270°, 59.4 grains, 19.4 mm. (50-75) 176 - IL692A-16a R3 Raw MS62 Yankee Robinson's Big Show Triad 1869 with portrait. Robinson operated a traveling Circus based in Peoria Illinois. Late die state with large die crack from hand to rim with other smaller cracks. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 100°, 55.9 grains, 19.4 mm. (100-150) 177 - IL692A-16a R3 Raw UNC Details Retoning from cleaning. Yankee Robinson's Big Show Triad 1869 with portrait. Robinson operated a traveling Circus based in Peoria Illinois. Late die state with large die crack from hand to rim with other smaller cracks. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 100°, 56.4 grains, 19.4 mm. (25-50) 178 - IN135A-1a R7 Raw VF Details With obverse dig. Cox & Landers Dry Goods, Clothing, Boots & Shoes, Brooklyn Indiana 1864. Rare town with this variety nearly always appearing in very low grade, often with damage. We sold a Raw FINE with a number of light scratches in our April 2000 sale that brought $243.10. This was the Plate Specimen for the second edition of the store card book. From the Bob Adams, Ed Rosen and George Fuld collections. (300-400) 179 - IN140A-4i R7 Raw MS62 40% Bright with nearly full Tin Plating. H. Linck Dry Goods, Groceries & Hardware, Brookville Indiana struck in Tin Plate. Underrated variety, the only Uncirculated example we have seen offered. From the Bob Adams, Dave Bowers, Wayne Stafford, Steve Tanenbaum and Don Schramm collections, earlier from our December 2008 sale where it realized $350. (400-500) 180 - IN175A-1a R6 Raw MS64 60% Red. Gaffney & McDonnell Groceries, Liquors, Cigars & c., Columbia City Indiana The Army & Navy Union 1863. From the Nick Bruno collection, earlier from our January 2015 sale where it brought $331. (400-500) 181 - IN230C-1a R7 Raw EF Details A bit porous. S. A. Russell Merchant, Danville Indiana 1864. Rare merchant from this scarce town. From the Bob Adams collection, earlier from our July 2007 sale where it sold for $165. (150-200) 182 - IN250A-1a R7 Raw FINE+ A. Jenkins Dealer In Dry Goods & Groceries, Dublin Indiana 1863. Very rare town, a Raw VF brought strong $975 in our July 2012 auction. From the Bob Adams collection. (500-750) 183 - IN290B-1a R5 Raw MS63 10% Red. Anderson & Evans Grocers, Ft. Wayne Indiana. Very scarce in Uncirculated condition. (200-300) 184 - IN350B-2a R7 Raw MS62 Trace Red with light planchet flaw across reverse. Hascall, Alderman & Brown Dry Goods, Goshen Indiana 1861. Rare variety from a very scarce merchant, particularly in Uncirculated condition. We sold a Raw VF+ for $110 in our July 2007 auction. (300-400) 185 - IN365A-1a R6 Raw FINE Details With two small reverse rim bumps. Baldwin & Sweet Dealers All Kinds Of Groceries, Greensboro Indiana with Masonic symbol. Rare single variety town. (200-300) 186 - IN460E-5a R8 Raw MS63 30% Red. M. H. Good Wholesale & Retail Dry Goods, Indianapolis Indiana 1864. Rare variety, still just one of three we have seen offered. From the Steve Tanenbaum, Don Schramm and Ray Haggenjos collections, earlier from our July 2012 sale where it brought $240. (300-400) 187 - IN495A-1a R6 Raw VF Details Old scratch on reverse. Robt. Cooder Dry Goods & Groceries, Jonesboro Indiana 1864. Rare town, a Raw EF sold for $429 in our 2003 auction. From the Bob Adams collection, earlier from C & D Gale. (150-200) 188 - IN530B-3a R7 Raw VF+ J. Faller & Son Watchmakers, LaPorte Indiana. Very rare variety. A Raw EF with clip brought $165 in our July 2009 auction. (150-200) 189 - IN550J-1a R7 Raw MS62 20% Red. C. J. Vail Dry Goods, Ligonier Indiana. Very scarce merchant , particularly this nice, an MS62 brought $190 in our December 2008 sale. From the John Dettinger collection, earlier from our July 2012 sale where it brought $190. (200-300) 190 - IN570A-1a R7 Raw MS63 40% original red mint luster. Booth & Sturges Dealers In Boots and Shoes, Logansport Indiana 1864 with boot. Rare single variety merchant and just the third Uncirculated example we have seen offered. We sold another Raw MS63 for $665 in our June 2013 auction. (500-750) 191 - IN600A-1a R7 Raw FINE+ Elliott & Swain Dry Goods, Groceries, Hardware & c., Mechanicsburg Indiana 1863. Rare merchant. From the Bob Adams collection, earlier from our July 2007 auction where it brought $255. (150-200) 192 - IN630A- 2a R4 Raw MS63 H. D. Higgins Optician and Manufacturer of Barometers, Mishawaka Indiana. Popular reverse die 1327 featuring pictorial of monocle and glasses. (400-500) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com th th Steve Hayden - Mail Bid Sale #47 - Closing Sunday December 15 and Monday December 16 2019 Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 193 - IN630A- 6b R7 Raw AU Well struck for issue. H. D. Higgins Jeweler, Mishawaka struck in Brass. Rare, a dark and porous VF sold for $300 in our December 2008 sale. From the Dave Bowers, Steve Tanenbaum, Ed Rosen and George Fuld collections. (400-500) 194 - IN630A-10b R7 Raw EF+ H. D. Higgins Optician, Mishawaka 1863 struck in Brass. Very rarely seen without problems or over VF. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections, earlier from the Western Reserve Historical Society sold by Spinks America October 1998. (150-200) 195 - IN630B-1a R3 Raw AU B. Holcomb Stone Ware, Mishawaka Indiana. From the Dave Bowers collection, earlier from our July 2012 sale. (75-100) 196 - IN690A-5a R8 Raw VF+ M. L. Powell Dealer In Stoves, New Castle Indiana. Very scarce single merchant town. From the Bob Adams, Ed Rosen and George Fuld collections. (150-200) 197 - IN710A-1a R9 Raw AU Details With some light staining on the obverse that makes it appear to be silvered. A. M. Davis Drugs, New Paris Indiana. Rare single merchant town and very rare variety. We sold a raw VF Details with a few reverse marks for $980 in our February 2014 auction. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections, earlier from Dave Schenkman in 1998. (1000-1500) 198 - IN740B-6a R2 Raw MS63 10% Red with small planchet clip. J. S. Queeby Dry Goods & Notions, Peru Indiana with unusual star and wreath reverse die 1384. (100-150) 199 - IN830A-2a R9 Raw EF Or a bit better. J. F. Johnson News Dealer, Seymour Indiana. Very rare town. This variety was called R7 and should have been moved to R8 but now it is a bit over rated at R9. From the Bob Adams collections, earlier from our December 2010 sale where it sold for $561. (500-750) 200 - IN860E-2a R4 Raw EF J. C. Knoblock Baker, South Bend Indiana. From the Bob Adams and Ed Rosen collections. (75-100) 201 - IN950A-4b R7 Raw EF Details With denomination cancelled by a line as seen on other examples. D. Carlile Oysters, Confectionery and Cigars, Warsaw Indiana with Good For 25 Cents Payable In Bank Bills reverse struck in Brass. Scarce town and rare merchant, we sold a raw VF Details with a small rim bump and more severe chisel punch cancellation through denomination for $209 in our July 2006 auction. From the Bob Adams and Henry South collections earlier from Bowers & Merena's March 1985 sale. (200-300) 202 - IA150A-1a R6 Raw AU Reynolds & Co. New York Store, Cedar Rapids Iowa. Rare town and state particularly above EF. From the Bob Adams collection. (1000-1500)

203 205 211 203 - KS550A-1b R8 Raw EF Details A bit porous. A. Cohen Clothing, Leavenworth Kansas struck in Brass. Kansas is one of the rarest states in the entire Civil War series. A Raw VF Details with slight residue traces brought $2,420 in our March 2003 auction. From the Bob Adams and Henry South collections, earlier from PCAC's June 1987 sale. (2000-3000) 204 - KY640B-2a R8 Raw AU+ Newport & Covington Bridge Company 1863. Rare merchant. From the Bob Adams and Ed Rosen collections, earlier from our June 2005. (400-500) 205 - LA670A-1do R7 Raw VF On a very smooth AG 1860 Indian Cent. J. B. SCHILLER counterstamped on obverse and X above Cent on the reverse of an 1860 Indian Cent. J. B. Schiller, New Orleans Louisiana issued as a ten cent piece during the Union's Naval blockade of New Orleans before it fell on May 1, 1862 thus becoming the United States only known siege money. Schiller, who was a liquor importer and coffee house proprietor, also issued scrip notes dated April 3, 1862 in twenty five and fifty cent denominations and it is probably this token was issued at the same time. The counterstamp is bold as usual but the cent is unusually well worn, perhaps carried for years as a pocket piece souvenir. The very smooth light tan cent helps the counterstamp detail stand out all the more. Rare single variety state, we sold a Raw VF Details on a dark VG with verdigris that brought $2,465 in our March 2008 sale. (3000-4000) 206 - MD060 R-1b R9 Raw EF Details Slightly porous. M. K. 1863, Baltimore with reverse die 1003. Now listed as Baltimore in the new edition of the Store Card book. Very rare merchant, we sold a Raw EF in our February 2014 sale which brought $414. (300-400) 207 - MD060 W-1b R7 Raw EF+ Mount Vernon Club, Baltimore Maryland 1863. Rarely seen this nice. (750-1000) 208 - MA200A-4a R8 Raw EF Details Some verdigris residues primarily on the edge. Dunn & Co. Oyster House 1864, Charlestown Massachusetts. Current research indicates that Dunn was actually from Charlestown rather than Boston as previously thought, formerly listed as MA115B-4a. The only use of this rare obverse die with equally rare reverse die 1415. An EF brought $450 in our February 2014 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1415. Data: 180°, 42.1 grains, 19.1 mm. (300-400) 209 - MA530A-1b R8 Raw MS63 20% Bright. Great Fair in Aid of the US Sanitary Commission, Nantucket Massachusetts August 1864 struck in Brass with George Washington. Very popular token issued to raise money to benefit soldiers during the Civil War. Very rare in anything other than Copper, we sold a Raw AU+ example that brought $385 in July 2009. From the Bob Adams collection, earlier from John Coker June 2008. (500-750) 210 - MI005B-3a R8 Raw AU+ Or a bit better and attractively toned but with an uneven strike resulting in a few very weak letters. Buck & Farrar, Adrian Michigan with rare Child's 1861 Arm & Hammer reverse die 1390. A very rare variety, one of just four we have seen offered. Difficult to get nice and missing from the Tanenbaum collection. An AU realized $203 in our August 1997 sale. From the Tom Reed collection, earlier from our July 2014 sale where it sold for $180. (300-400) 211 - MI040A-1do R7 Raw MS63 Trace Bright struck over an 1861 Cent with much undertype detail on each side. Philip Bach Dry Goods, Ann Arbor Michigan 1863 struck in Copper Nickel over an 1861 Cent. From the Mark Bendett collection. (1000-1500)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com th th Steve Hayden - Mail Bid Sale #47 - Closing Sunday December 15 and Monday December 16 2019 Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 212 - MI045A-5a Unlisted Raw EF+ F. J. & J. Palmer's Woolen Factory, Atlas Genesee County Michigan. Unlisted die variety, likely an R7, with 1023A reverse die. This variety has been known for 20 years or so but was traditionally called 1039A because of denticle similarity. This die is now called 1023A to more accurately fit into the last star and feather diagnostic template. A Raw EF brought $220 in our July 2012 sale. From the Bob Adams and Henry South collections, earlier from Al Jakira's June 1989 sale. (200-300)

213 214 222 213 - MI060aA-6a R9 Raw AU Wm. Brooks Hardware, Battle Creek Michigan and Elkhart Indiana. Very rare and formerly unlisted die combination with Indiana Primitive reverse die 1161. We sold a Raw VF in our July 2006 auction that realized $1,372.60. From the Dave Bowers, Steve Tanenbaum and Richard Coslet collections, June 1979. (1500-2000) 214 - MI060B-1a R8 Raw AU+ J. B. Leonard Boot & Shoe Maker, Battle Creek Michigan. Rare merchant and one of the key merchants in a set of the products of Hillsdale diesinker Alexander Gleason. An NGC MS61 BN sold for $1,187.77 in our December 2008 sale. From the Wayne Stafford and Don Thoms collections. (1000-1500) 215 - MI180B-3a R9 Raw MS63 10% Red and nicely toned. R. & J. T. Peter Druggist, Clarkston Michigan 1864 struck in Copper. Very rare variety. From the Tampa collection. (300-400) 216 - MI200B-4a R4 Raw AU G. W. Goodell Drugs , Medicines & c., Corunna Michigan 1863. From the Bob Adams collection. (75-100) 217 - MI225 L-2a1 Unlisted Raw EF+ F. A. Burkhart Butcher, Detroit Michigan 1863 struck with a Plain edge and unlisted as such. We have the pleasure of having access to Steve Tanenbaum's last Store Card book where he recorded his collection along with other notes. He had this piece recorded in his book and marked as R10 Unique. Unfortunately it never was forwarded for the new edition. Steve sold this and many other pieces in his collection when he scaled back to one per die combination to pursue other collection interests. From the Dave Bowers, Steve Tanenbaum and Richard Seipelt collections. (300-400) 218 - MI225 N-4a R3 Raw AU+ Campbell Linn & Co. Scotch Store Dry Goods and Millinery, Detroit. From the Dave Bowers collection. (50-75) 219 - MI225 X-1a1 Unlisted Raw AU+ E. A. Drury Grocer, Detroit Michigan 1863 struck with a Plain edge and unlisted as such. We have the pleasure of having access to Steve Tanenbaum's last Store Card book where he recorded his collection along with other notes. He had this piece recorded in his book and marked as R10 Unique. Unfortunately it never was forwarded for the new edition. Steve sold this and many other pieces in his collection when he scaled back to one per die combination to pursue other collection interests. From the Dave Bowers, Steve Tanenbaum and D. Brock collections, earlier from Walt Korzick. (400-500) 220 - MI225 Y-3a R6 Raw MS64 60% Red with light planchet cutting mark near rim. Francis Eccard Tobacconist, Detroit Michigan 1863. (200-300) 221 - MI225AFa-10a2 R6 Raw EF Counterstamped F. GIES on reverse. F. Gies & Bro's Fire & Water Proof Roofing, Detroit. A number of pieces from this merchant were counterstamped F. Gies, presumably to correct the spelling on Geiss and Gies tokens although in this case the name was spelled correctly on the token. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1043. Data: 60°, 56 grains, 19.3 mm. (50-75) 222 - MI225AV-2a R9 Raw MS64 Trace Red with very attractive toning. Martin Bro's Cheap Boot & Shoe Store, Detroit Michigan 1864. Rare merchant, a Raw AU Details retoned example of the equally rare -1b variety sold for $373.56 in our June 2005 sale, and a PCGS MS65 RD example of this variety sold for $900 in our April 2018 auction. (1000-1500) 223 - MI225BE-7a R9 Raw MS64 20% Red mostly on the obverse. G. C. Pond Grocery & Provision Dealer, Detroit Michigan 1864. Rare merchant and very rare variety, we sold an NGC MS64 RB example of the more available R8 -2a variety for $240 in our July 2012. From the Tampa collection. (300-400)

224 230 240 224 - MI250E-1a R8 Raw FINE+ D. Pond Grocer and Confectioner, Dowagiac Michigan 1863. One of the rarest merchants in the entire series, just the seventh example of either variety we have seen offered. A Raw AU Details with stain brought $1,500 in our October 2011 sale. (1000-1500) 225 - MI280D-1a1 Unlisted Raw VF John McKay Oyster, Fruit & Fish Depot, East Saginaw Michigan with a Plain edge and unlisted as such. We have the pleasure of having access to Steve Tanenbaum's last Store Card book where he recorded his collection along with other notes. On a hunch we checked for the listing even though he was not recorded on the pedigree. He did have the variety listed and noted as R10 but there was no grade to indicate it was ever part of his collection, as was his habit. From the Dave Bowers collection. (300-400) 226 - MI280G-1a R7 Raw VF Details But with square hole. Charles Turner Dealer in Furs & Skins, East Saginaw Michigan 1863. Rare merchant, a raw EF brought $757.77 in our March 2008 sale. (100-150) 227 - MI370K-2a R6 Raw EF+ A. Roberts & Son Dry Goods, Groceries, Crockery & c., Grand Rapids. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1365. Data: 64.5 grains, 20.2 mm. (50-75) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com th th Steve Hayden - Mail Bid Sale #47 - Closing Sunday December 15 and Monday December 16 2019 Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 228 - MI370K-3a R7 Raw EF+ A. Roberts & Son Dry Goods, Grand Rapids. Rare reverse die, an EF sold for $209 in our April 2000 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1366. Data: 20°, 66.4 grains, 20.1 mm. (150-200) 229 - MI440A-2a R6 Raw EF+ D. C. Hawley Groceries & Provisions, Hastings Michigan 1863. From the Bob Adams collection earlier from us via price list. (75-100) 230 - MI450A-1a R9 Raw VF+ J. O. Ames Books & Stationery, Hillsdale Michigan 1863. Extremely rare merchant and one of the keys to a Michigan merchant set. This is the only Copper example from this merchant we have seen offered. From the Tom Reed and Steve Tanenbaum collections, earlier from our January 2015 sale where it brought $1,400, even earlier from Tony Terranova in 2005. (1500-2000) 231 - MI450B-2a R6 Raw MS62 10% Red. O.S. Betts Dealer In Watches, Jewelry & Silverware, Hillsdale Michigan. Struck by hometown die sinker Alexander Gleason. Very scarce merchant and very rare in Uncirculated condition. From the Tampa collection. (300-400) 232 - MI450C-3b R9 Raw VF+ Card, Pierce & Co. Agricultural Implements, Hillsdale Michigan. Rare merchant and very rare, formerly unlisted, variety. An EF+ example of the more available R8 -3a variety brought $220 in our March 2008 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1186. Data: 52 grains, 19.8 mm. (200-300) 233 - MI450E-1b R7 Raw MS61 Trace Bright and nicely toned. French & Parsons Druggists, Hillsdale Michigan struck in Brass. Rare merchant, particularly this nice. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1111. Data: 190°, 44.8 grains, 19.5 mm. (300-400) 234 - MI450H-2a R7 Raw MS63 With nice luster. E. C. Keating Grocer and Produce Dealer, Hillsdale Michigan 1863. Rare merchant, very rare in Uncirculated condition. From the Tampa collection. (400-500) 235 - MI450L-4a R7 Raw AU+ Mott & Bro. Druggists and Grocers, Hillsdale Michigan. Rare and unusual mule of Childs of Chicago obverse die with a Gleason of Hillsdale reverse die. The obverse die was apparently retained by the Childs customer and later pressed into service again by the hometown Gleason mint. This is the most available Childs / Gleason mule but very rarely are any of them seen in this condition. A Raw VF Details with residues brought $275 in our December 2008 sale. From the Wayne Stafford and Don Thoms collections. (400-500) 236 - MI450M-2a R6 Raw EF+ Samm & Kuhlke Grocers, Hillsdale Michigan. Very scarce merchant. From the Wayne Stafford collection earlier from our May 2004 sale where it brought $221. (200-300) 237 - MI450O-2a R4 Raw MS64 20% Red. Geo. W. Underwood Druggist & Grocer, Hillsdale Michigan 1861. Very rare in Uncirculated condition, the Tanenbaum NGC MS63 BN sold on our web site for $300 in November 2013. (300-400) 238 - MI480C-1a R9 Raw VF Details But porous. Gillett & Niles Druggists, Hudson Michigan. Very rare merchant though variety is now a bit overrated at R9 when it likely should have stayed at R8. From the Tom Reed. (200-300) 239 - MI525C- 5a R5 Raw MS62 Jackson Hall X Clusive Trade In Groceries, Jackson Michigan 1863. From the Bob Adams collection. (50-75) 240 - MI577A-1b R7 Raw AU Trace Bright. A. Burleson Dry Goods, Groceries, Boots & Shoes, Litchfield Michigan 1863 struck in Brass. Very rare single merchant town. From the Bob Adams collection, earlier from our December 2012 sale where it realized $1,025. (1000-1500) 241 - MI580A-3a R8 Raw UNC Details Trace Red but very unevenly struck with missing letters. W. R. Blaisdell, Lowell Michigan. Rare merchant and very rare variety, one of just five examples we have seen offered in thirty years. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1205. Data: 52 grains, 19.8 mm. (500-750) 242 - MI587C-1b R7 Raw VF Details A bit porous. L. F. Heath Watch Maker And Photographer, Lyons Michigan struck in Brass with Pocket Watch reverse die 1321. From the Bob Adams collection earlier from us August 2008. (150-200) 243 - MI660A-1b R9 Raw AU+ 20% Bright. J. M. Page & Co. Hardware, Morenci Michigan struck in Brass. Very scarce merchant struck by Gleason of Hillsdale, very rare in Uncirculated condition. Very rare variety. (300-400) 244 - MI680A-1a R5 Raw EF Details Slightly porous. E. C. Morse Dry Goods, Groceries & c., Mussey Michigan 1863. Very scarce single merchant town. From the Bob Adams collection. (75-100) 245 - MI745D-2a R5 Raw VF Details Rim bump. J. D. Sherman Groceries & Provisions, Paw Paw Michigan 1863. Very scarce town. (50-75) 246 - MI845A-1a R6 Raw EF Wm. Binder Dry Goods Groceries, Saginaw City Michigan 1863. Very scarce town. From the Bob Adams and Henry South collections, earlier New London sale May 1979. (200-300)

247 251 253 247 - MI845B-1a R8 Raw VF With a few light marks. Epting & Eaton Drugs and Medicines, Saginaw City Michigan 1863. Very rare merchant, a raw VF brought $1,600 in our December 2010 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1095. Data: 180°, 48.3 grains, 19.8 mm. (1500-2000) 248 - MI915A-1a R5 Raw MS63 G. W. Stephenson General Merchant, Drugs and Medicines, St. Johns Michigan with mortar and pestle. From the Tampa collection. (300-400) 249 - MI920A-1a R7 Raw EF Details Retoned from cleaning. Fisher & Hendryx Druggists, Tecumseh Michigan. Rare merchant. (200-300) 250 - MI920B-4a R9 Raw EF+ Dr. E. Hause Dentist, Tecumseh Michigan 1863. Very rare variety, just the fourth known to us. We sold a Raw FINE+ Detail dark and porous example in our October 1998 sale that realized $100.10. (300-400) 251 - MN680A-2b R8 Raw MS63 30% Bright. A. W. E. Red Wing Minnesota America struck in Brass. A very rare single merchant town and the key to a Minnesota town or merchant set. A Raw MS63 example of the equally rare -2a variety sold for $3,000 in our January 2015 auction and an NGC MS65 example of this variety sold for $4,250 off our web site in December 2013. (3000-4000)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com th th Steve Hayden - Mail Bid Sale #47 - Closing Sunday December 15 and Monday December 16 2019 Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 252 - MN760B-1a R6 Raw EF+ Wheeler & Wilson Sewing Machines, St. Paul Minnesota with popular sewing machine reverse die 1298. From the Bob Adams collection earlier from our June 2011 catalog sale where it sold for $704. (750-1000) 253 - MO910A-3a R6 Raw MS63 Trace Red with very attractive toning. Drovers Hotel, St. Louis Missouri 1863 popular token with steers head pictured. A raw EF+ sold for $388.88 in our November 2004 sale. (750-1000) 254 - NJ555B-1do R7 Raw AU Struck over an 1863 Cent. Much of the Cent's reverse detail is easily visible but little of the obverse detail, including the date, is visible without careful study. Charles Kolb Restaurant, Newark New Jersey struck over an 1863 Indian Head Cent. (500-750) 255 - NY010A- 4b R7 Raw MS62 20% Bright. Benjamin & Herrick Fruit Dealers, Albany New York struck in Brass. From the Nick Bruno collection earlier from one of our fixed price lists. (100-150) 256 - NY010A- 9d R8 Raw MS62 30% Bright. Struck from a later obverse die state showing rust as usual for this die combination. Benjamin & Herrick, Albany New York struck in Copper Nickel with very scarce United We Stand Divided We Fall reverse die 1276. From the Nick Bruno collection earlier from one of our fixed price lists. (200-300) 257 - NY010D-1a1 R10 Raw EF+ New York City Rail Road Express Trains Leave Albany and Buffalo. Flip Over Double Struck in error with much undertype detail visible on each side, particularly the Leaves Albany side. (300-400)

258 272 274 258 - NY105D-3a R8 Raw EF+ F. J. Bieler, Buffalo New York. Rare Indian Head Business Card reverse die 1081, it’s only used in either the Store Card or Patriotic series. One of just five known. We sold a Raw VF+ Details retoning from cleaning example in our December 2010 auction that realized $2,200. (2000-3000) 259 - NY105G-3a R6 Raw EF Howes Scale, Buffalo New York. Very scarce merchant. From the Bob Adams collection. (100-150) 260 - NY105H-2a R7 Raw MS64 20% Red. W. G. Fox Oysters, Fruit & Liquors, Buffalo New York 1863. From the Nick Bruno collection earlier from our March 2003 sale. (300-400) 261 - NY105M-1a R6 Raw AU Details With light obverse stain. Reilly's Bazaar, Buffalo New York. Rare single variety merchant. (150-200) 262 - NY105O-1a R5 Raw MS62 20% Red with attractive luster and toning. Rowe & Co. Oyster & Foreign Fruit Depot, Buffalo New York 1863. From the Nick Bruno collection earlier from our July 2006 sale. (150-200) 263 - NY105S-1a R5 Raw EF+ Webster & Co. Grocers, Buffalo New York 1863 with crude Indian Head reverse. (50-75) 264 - NY145B-1e R8 Raw AU Trace Bright. G. L. Bowne, Cooperstown New York struck in White Metal. Very rare variety, still the only example we have seen offered. From the Nick Bruno and Byron Kanzinger collections, earlier from our October 2011 sale where it realized $277.96. (200-300) 265 - NY630 C-13a R9 Raw AU+ Trace Red with extensive reverse die cracks. C. Bahr, New York. One of just three known. From the Nick Bruno collection. (150-200) 266 - NY630 D-1a R1 Raw MS63 10% Red. H. J. Bang Restaurant, New York with grapes and grape vine. From the Dave Bowers collection. (75-100) 267 - NY630 I-1a R3 Raw MS63 50% Red. Jas. Brennan US Postage Stamps, New York with McClellan reverse. A similar example brought $160.35 in our December 2012 sale. From the Nick Bruno collection, earlier from our December 2005 sale where it brought $107 and even earlier from our October 2002 auction. (150-200) 268 - NY630 J-2b R7 Raw MS63 40% Bright. Bridgens Metal Tokens & Store Cards, New York struck in Brass with George Washington reverse die 1137. From the Nick Bruno collection. (200-300) 269 - NY630 L- 3e1 R8 Raw MS60 50% Bright but poorly struck with typical reverse die crack and some light marks. Broas Bros., New York Army & Navy struck in White Metal. From the Nick Bruno collection. (150-200) 270 - NY630 N-2b R9 Raw MS62 20% Bright with traces of what appears to be original silvering, unlisted as such. M. S. Brown Eureka, New York struck in Brass. Quite rare and still one of only two examples we have seen offered. From the Nick Bruno collection, earlier from our December 2012 sale. (150-200) 271 - NY630 T-1a R2 Raw MS64 30% Red and well struck for variety. J. J. Diehl Undertaker, New York with coffin pictured. Unusually nice for this issue. (200-300) 272 - NY630 W-1do R8 Raw MS63 30% Bright. Felix Kosher Dining Saloon, New York struck over an 1863 Copper Nickel Indian Cent with much of the under type visible. Very popular token with Kosher spelled out in Hebrew. From the Roger Merritt collection. (1000-1500) 273 - NY630AB-5b R7 Raw MS63 50% Bright. A. Gavron Sausages New York with Money Makes The Mare Go reverse struck in Brass. From the Nick Bruno collection, earlier from our September 2010 sale. (150-200) 274 - NY630AIa-1b Unlisted Raw MS64 30% Bright. Havens Hatter 202 Broadway New York A Hat Bought For 10 Cts Less Than The Regular Price Marked By Presenting This One Check. Struck in Brass with Plain edge 24mm. Unlisted in anything other than White Metal (Lead) in Fuld, Rulau, Miller or Adams. Current research indicates this merchant was only in business during the Civil War and the White Metal variety has been added to the new edition of the Civil War Store Card book. From the Don Boller collection. (750-1000) 275 - NY630AIa-1e R6 Raw MS63 60% Bright. Havens Hatter 202 Broadway New York A Hat Bought For 10 Cts Less Than The Regular Price Marked By Presenting This One Check. Struck in White Metal with Plain edge 24mm. Formerly listed as Miller NY 302, current research indicates it was used during the Civil War and has been added to the new edition of the Civil War Store Card book. A Raw MS62 brought $406 in our August 2015 auction. From the Don Boller collection. (500-750) 276 - NY630AM-1a R2 Raw VF+ Christoph Karl, New York 1863. A very dramatic Double Struck mint error with major shift between the two off center strikes including two bold dates. Said to be ex. Virgil Brand collection. (200-300) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com th th Steve Hayden - Mail Bid Sale #47 - Closing Sunday December 15 and Monday December 16 2019 Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 277 - NY630AM-1e R8 Raw MS62 50% Bright struck in White Metal on a 2.4mm thick planchet. Flip over double strike mint error. On the reverse 42 and CHR visible with some study while the Germania base line and even part of date is visible on the obverse. Christoph Karl New York with Seated Germania reverse die 1164 struck in White Metal. From the Nick Bruno and Dave Bowers collection, earlier from our July 2009 sale. (300-400) 278 - NY630AP-12j R8 Raw MS63 50% Bright. H. M. Lane Lamps Kerosene Oil, New York struck in German Silver. We sold a similar Raw example in July 2007 that realized $192.50. (200-300) 279 - NY630BB-14d R8 Raw MS62 20% Bright struck on a filed down planchet with no undertype visible but likely a Copper Nickel Cent. Monk's Metal Signs, New York struck in Copper-Nickel with George Washington obverse. From the Nick Bruno collection, earlier from our June 2013 auction. (150-200) 280 - NY630BB-14e R9 Raw MS62 30% Bright struck on a very large untrimmed 24mm planchet. Monk's Metal Signs, New York struck in White Metal with George Washington obverse. A very impressive mint error. From the Nick Bruno collection, earlier from our January 2016 sale where it brought $350. (400-500) 281 - NY630BG-5b R7 Raw MS63 50% Bright with tiny rim clip. John Quinn Grocer, New York with Money Makes The Mare Go struck in Brass. From the Nick Bruno collection, earlier from our December 2012 auction. (150-200) 282 - NY630BQ-1j R8 Raw MS62 Trace Bright. Ph. J. Seiter's New York with bulls head with horns struck in German Silver. Very rare variety. From the Mark Bendett collection. (200-300) 283 - NY630BV- 3a R8 Raw MS63 40% Red. Story & Southworth, New York with Indian Head reverse die 1017 struck in Copper. From the Nick Bruno collection, earlier from our October 2010 auction. (200-300) 284 - NY630BV-17j R8 Raw MS63 60% Bright but weakly struck at centers as often seen with this die and composition. Story & Southworth, New York with Turban Head reverse die 1000 struck in German Silver. Very rare variety, one of just two we have seen offered. From the Nick Bruno collection, earlier from our July 2014 auction. (200-300) 285 - NY630BX-2b R8 Raw MS62 With traces of original Bright luster. Wm. Thierbach Grocer, New York struck in Brass. Very rare variety from a merchant who issued virtually all his tokens in Zinc (what we used to call Lead). From the Nick Bruno collection, earlier from our August 2001 sale where it realized $199.10. (200-300) 286 - NY630CE-1a R4 Raw MS63 10% Red. John Watson Union Tea Store, New York. From the Bob Adams collection. (75-100) 287 - NY760A-1d R5 Raw MS62 10% Bright. Eastman National Business College, Poughkeepsie New York struck in Copper Nickel. From the Nick Bruno collection. (300-400)

288 293 295 288 - NY845A-1b R6 Raw AU+ 10% Bright and some nice toning. D. Skidmore Hotel, Seneca Falls New York single merchant town struck in Brass. This token is a favorite of many since it has an eagle holding a cigar in its beak signifying what the token was Good For. We sold a Raw AU Details with stain for $412.50 in our October 2002 catalog sale. (500-750) 289 - NY890B- 9b R2 Raw VF Oliver Boutwell, Troy New York. This particular die combination comes more than occasionally as a Flip Over Double Strike while this is the first example we can remember with a conventional Double Strike mint error. There is good detail on the first strike, particularly on the reverse. Interestingly the obverse strike is rotated less than 45 degrees while the reverse is rotated approximately 180 degrees. (50-75) 290 - OH005A-2b R7 Raw MS61 Trace Bright. Stoner & Shroyer Dry Goods, Adamsville Ohio struck in Brass with George Washington reverse die 1134. We sold a Raw example way back in March 2003 simply graded as UNC Trace Bright that sold for $476.30. From the Dave Bowers collection. (300-400) 291 - OH005A-3e R8 Raw MS62 50% Bright. Stoner & Shroyer Dry Goods, Adamsville Ohio struck in White Metal with rare Lincoln reverse die 1146. (500-750) 292 - OH060D-6a R8 Raw EF+ E. B. Winans & Co. Drugs and Medicines, Bellaire Ohio Union 1863. Very scarce merchant and very rare variety. From the Bob Adams collection. (150-200) 293 - OH070A-1a R8 Raw VF Details Porous with nice strike for issue. O. C. Metcalf Dry Goods, Belmont Ohio 1864. Very rare single variety town that when seen is usually in very low grade and or damaged. A Raw VF Details a bit porous with tiny reverse dig brought $1,554.24 in our January 2015 auction. (1000-1500) 294 - OH074A- 4a R9 Raw MS63 D. E. Stearns Grindstones, Berea Ohio. Very rare variety with 1863 Indian Head die 1018, only the second we have seen offered. (200-300) 295 - OH160A-2b R9 Raw MS63 50% Bright more so on the obverse. John Bohm, Chillicothe Ohio 5 Cents. Rare merchant, extremely rare this nice. From the Charles Thobaben collection. (750-1000) 296 - OH165 O-7a R6 Raw MS64 30% Red. C. H. Bennett Steam Bakery, Cincinnati Ohio with wheat sheaf pictured. From the Bob Adams collection. (150-200) 297 - OH165 P-5a R9 Raw AU+ Frank Beresford Meat Market, Cincinnati Ohio with Masonic square and compass. Rare mint error struck with a blank reverse, created when two blank planchets are struck together before striking resulting in two blank reverse tokens. This is exactly how a blank reverse should look. The only example of this variety we have seen offered. From the Dave Bowers collection, earlier from us via private treaty. (400-500) 298 - OH165AN-4a R9 Raw MS64 10% Red. Fenton & Beck Daily Market, Cincinnati Ohio 1863. Very rare variety. From the David Zimmerman collection. (300-400) 299 - OH165AW-10a R7 Raw MS63 40% Red. Charles Flach Dealer In Provisions, Cincinnati 1863. A rare variety, particularly this nice. (100-150) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com th th Steve Hayden - Mail Bid Sale #47 - Closing Sunday December 15 and Monday December 16 2019 Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 300 - OH165CV-1a R5 Raw MS62 H. Kreber Grocer, Columbia Between Rowe & Mill, Cincinnati Ohio with eagle on shield. From the Bob Adams collection. (75-100) 301 - OH165CY- 44b R9 Raw MS62 Trace Bright. W. K. Lanphear Die Sinker, Cincinnati struck in Brass with custom Boots, Shoes and Yankee Notions stock reverse die. From the David Zimmerman collection. (150-200)

302 329 341 302 - OH165CY- 65b R9 Raw MS63 40% Bright. W. K. Lanphear Manufacturer of Metallic Cards, Cincinnati with Sign of the Lion reverse die 1280 struck in Brass. Very rare, just the third example we have seen offered. From the Mark Bendett collection. (400-500) 303 - OH165CY- 69b R9 Raw MS64 30% Bright with some nice toning. W. K. Lanphear Die Sinker, Cincinnati Ohio 1863 with stove reverse die 1300 struck in Brass. From the David Zimmerman collection. (200-300) 304 - OH165DC-2a R4 Raw AU+ H. Lazaress Dealer In Rags & Metals, Cincinnati 1863. (25-50) 305 - OH165DJ- 1a R6 Raw EF Marsh & Miner Vest Manufacturers, Cincinnati Ohio 1862. From the Bob Adams collection. (50-75) 306 - OH165DV-6a R9 Raw MS64 Trace Red and very attractively toned. J. T. Moore Fruit Dealer, Cincinnati Ohio 1864 struck in Copper. Very rare variety. From the David Zimmerman collection. (300-400) 307 - OH165EB-8a Unlisted Raw UNC Details With linear obverse planchet flaw and other obverse planchet roughness. H. Niebuhr Wine & Beer Saloon 223 Central Avenue, Cincinnati Ohio. A very unusual mint error having the incused image of the reverse of an Indian Cent. The obverse is unimpaired aside from the planchet anomalies and there is no sign of a struck reverse beneath the incused reverse. This merchant has a number of odd mint errors including a -6a full obverse brockage and -7a a reverse Cent brockage over the normal 1295 die both listed as Unique. There is a different example of the present token without the planchet flaws that brought $400 in our March 1998 sale. (400-500) 308 - OH165EK-4a R9 Raw MS63 Trace Red. Philip 16 Walnut Street, Cincinnati Ohio 1864. Very rare variety. From the Tampa collection. (200-300) 309 - OH165ET-2a R6 Raw MS62 J. Reis & Co. Meat Store, Cincinnati Ohio with Masonic reverse. Rare merchant, we sold a Raw AU in our August 2015 sale that brought $191.25. (300-400) 310 - OH165FT-4a R4 Raw EF Details Light obverse scratch. S. & L. Smith Grocers, Cincinnati Ohio 1863. From the Bob Adams collection. (25-50) 311 - OH165FX- 9a R9 Raw MS63 John Stanton Manufacturer of Store Cards, Cincinnati with Prairie Flower Indian Princess reverse die and struck with a plain edge. Very rare variety, the first we have seen offered. (150-200) 312 - OH165FZ-1a R5 Raw EF C. Sutton's New Grocery Store, Cincinnati. Scarce merchant. From the Bob Adams collection. (50-75) 313 - OH165GE-4b R7 Raw MS63 20% Bright. Jacob Vogel Butcher, Cincinnati Ohio 1863 struck in Brass. (200-300) 314 - OH165GJ-2a R7 Raw VF+ W. W. Wert Auction and Commission Boot and Shoes, Cincinnati Ohio 1863. From the Bob Adams collection. (50-75) 315 - OH165GL-4a R6 Raw AU+ A. B. Wilson Staple & Fancy Grocer, Cincinnati Ohio 1863. From the Bob Adams collection. (50-75) 316 - OH165GY-32e R10 Raw AU Details With some Tin Pest. John E. Zeltner National Hall 5 struck in White Metal 18mm. A common merchant with many varieties with all but this one struck by home town die sinker John Stanton. Very rare and while no longer believed to be Unique this is just the third known. (100-150) 317 - OH175H-2a R4 Raw VF+ J. H. & A. S. Gorham Crackers and Confectionery, Cleveland Ohio 1863. From the Bob Adams collection. (50-75) 318 - OH175K-2a R10 Raw UNC Details Reverse was cleaned during its decades of display in a Marquette Michigan bank. C. L. Marvin Stove & Grate Depot, Cleveland 1863 struck in Copper with Mercury Head reverse die 1125. Unique and newly listed die combination. It is interesting to note that in the field of Civil War tokens significant new discoveries can be found after 150 years of active collecting. Before the sale in 2013 this merchant was known as a single variety merchant only available with an eagle reverse, a very obvious difference compared to slightly different Indian Head designs. From the Dave Bowers and Louis Kaufman collections. (750-1000) 319 - OH175S- 8b R9 Raw MS63 30% Bright. Geo. Worthington Hardware, Cleveland featuring a large pad lock struck in Brass with Lanphear reverse die. Very rare variety, just the second we have seen offered. From the Charles Thobaben collection. (400-500) 320 - OH230B-1a R5 Raw VF+ J. Durst Grocer, Dayton Ohio 1863. (50-75) 321 - OH320A-1a R5 Raw VF+ Bartlett & Rigby Dry Goods & Groceries, Fredericktown Ohio 1864. Very scarce single merchant town. From the Bob Adams and Dennis Haskett collections. (100-150) 322 - OH330D-1a R6 Raw VF+ Emrich & Co. Clothing, Fremont Ohio 1863. Very scarce merchant. From the Bob Adams collection. (75-100) 323 - OH330F-1b R8 Raw MS62 10% Bright. D. W. Krebs & Co. Clothing, Freemont Ohio 1863 struck in Brass. Very rare variety from very scarce merchant and scarce town. From the Charles Thobaben collection. (400-500) 324 - OH360B-5a R10 Raw MS64 20% Red with some nice toning. T. P. Turpen Grocer & Tobacco, Greenville Ohio 1864. Very rare variety from rare merchant. Currently listed as Unique but this is now the second known. While this 1047 reverse die is generally thought to be a collectors strike there are notable exceptions, the most extreme example is IL692A-13a where we have recorded six circulated examples some quite heavily worn and / or damaged. We bring this up because the only other example of this variety we are aware of was a holed VF in the Steve Tanenbaum collection. (500-750) 325 - OH440A-4a R5 Raw EF J. Armbruster Grocer, Lancaster Ohio 1863. Scarce town. From the Bob Adams collection. (50-75) 326 - OH445A-4a R6 Raw VF+ Geo. D. Riegel Dry Goods and Groceries, Laurelville Ohio Union 1864. From the Bob Adams collection. (50-75) 327 - OH505B-4b R8 Raw MS62 30% Bright. F. B. Orr Dealer In Hardware, Iron & Nails, Mansfield Ohio with Union For Ever reverse struck in Brass. Despite the rarity rating this is the only example we have seen offered. From the Dave Bowers collection. (200-300) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com th th Steve Hayden - Mail Bid Sale #47 - Closing Sunday December 15 and Monday December 16 2019 Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 328 - OH540A-1b R8 Raw EF Details But porous. H. Burritt Drugs, Medicines, Oils and Dye Stuffs, Maumee City Ohio with Mortar and Pestle reverse die struck in Brass. Very rare variety from a very scarce town, we sold an EF Details with hairline scratches that brought $145 in our December 2016 auction. From the Bob Adams collection. (150-200) 329 - OH557A-1a R7 Raw MS64 60% Red. John Frank One Half Pint Of Milk struck in Copper. Long attributed to Cincinnati Ohio as OH165AY-1a, current research has placed the Frank dairy in Mill Creek Township of rural Hamilton County, Ohio and it is so listed in the new Store Card book. We sold an NGC MS64 example of the somewhat rare R8 -2b variety for $950 in our January 2016 sale. From the Mark Bendett collection, removed from an ANACS holder as OH165AY-1a MS64 RB. (1000-1500) 330 - OH570B-2a R6 Raw VF+ E. Levy Dry Goods, Clothing, Boots, Shoes & c., Morrow Ohio 1863. Rare town and merchant, a Raw VF Details with light marks brought $125 in our October 2011 sale. From the Q. David Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1178. Data: 315°, 55.1 grains, 19.2 mm. (150-200) 331 - OH597A-1a R5 Raw EF Hall & Frymire Dealer in Stoves, Navarre Ohio 1863 with stove labeled Peace Maker on reverse. From the Bob Adams collection, earlier from one of our fixed price offerings March 2005. (75-100) 332 - OH670A-1a R9 Raw VF Details A bit porous. P. Timmins Provisions, Norwalk Ohio. Very rare variety from a very scarce town. From the Bob Adams collection earlier from eBay June 2008. (75-100) 333 - OH690A-1a R5 Raw EF R. H. Birge Drugs And Medicines, Oberlin Ohio. Rare single variety merchant, an EF realized $171.14 in our March 2008 sale. From the Bob Adams collection. (150-200) 334 - OH725B-1a R6 Raw EF D. Kreps Agricultural Implements, Perrysburg Ohio. Very scarce merchant and town. A Raw EF Details with light marks brought $123.20 in our March 2010 auction. From the Bob Adams and Ed Rosen collections. (150-200) 335 - OH755A-1a R5 Raw EF L. Wiles Dry Goods, Putnam Ohio 1863. Very scarce single merchant town. From the Bob Adams and Dennis Haskett collections. (150-200) 336 - OH770A-3i R9 Raw AU+ 10% Bright with 80% or more original Tin Plating remaining. B. L. Crew Dry Goods and Grocers, Richmond Ohio struck in Tin Plated copper. Reverse die 1045 is one of just a handful of dies which are more than occasionally encounter in Tin Plate, others being 1037, 1192, 1288, 1046 and of course stalwart 1042. Tin Plate on these dies are almost always collector strikes while 1045 seems to be used almost exclusively made for circulation. The finest of just two known. Very scarce town, a Raw EF+ example of the R5 -3a variety sold for $100 in our August 2015 sale. From Paul Koppenhaver's June 1987 sale. (300-400) 337 - OH830B-1a R5 Raw AU Kaufmann & Co. Cigars & Liquors, Springfield Ohio 1863. Very scarce merchant. From the Bob Adams collection. (150-200) 338 - OH835B-2a R5 Raw VF J. H. Bristor, Steubenville Ohio 1863 with padlock reverse die 1326. From the Bob Adams collection. (50-75) 339 - OH880D-2a R5 Raw EF Details Porous. Julian & Co. Watch Makers & Jewelers, Troy Ohio 1863 with pocket watch reverse die 1320. From the Bob Adams collection. (50-75) 340 - OH895A-1a R8 Raw MS63 20% Red. C. McCarty Washington House, Urbana Ohio 1864 struck in Copper. Now considered as Non Contemporary as announcements for the recently opened business were placed in December 1866 issues of the Urbana Union newspaper. Very rare merchant and town. Before this revelation we sold an R10 example of -2d in our December 2008 sale that realized $6,000. More recently fellow Urbana Non Contemporary Fisler & Chance have been bringing in the $200 range on eBay. It will be interesting to see what this rare, non maverick token with an 1864 dated reverse die will bring. NC OH-N. From the Charles Thobaben collection. (400-500) 341 - OH900A-1a R5 Raw MS63 40% Red. A. Jacobs Ready Made Clothing, Van Wert Ohio with Top Hat reverse. Very scarce single variety town, a Raw AU brought $825 on a (300-400) estimate in an epic battle during our December 2017 auction. From the Bob Adams and Dennis Haskett collections. (750-1000) 342 - OH905C-1b1 R7 Raw VF Details Reverse dark and a bit porous. Memento Of The Sanitary Fair Of Wapakoneta Ohio. Rare merchant and the key to a Sanitary Fair set. These fairs were held across the North to raise money to aid soldiers. (400-500) 343 - OH910A-1a R3 Raw EF+ Robbins' Photographic Albums, Warren Ohio. From the Bob Adams, Ed Rosen, Don Schramm and Arthur Fritz collections. (50-75) 344 - OH915B-1a R5 Raw EF Details Light obverse scratch. Wm. Lawrence Clothier and Photographic Artist, Wellsville Ohio 1863. Very scarce merchant and town. From the Bob Adams collection. (100-150) 345 - OH925A-1a R5 Raw VF C. M. Coffin Dealer in Dry Goods, West Newton Ohio 1863. From the Bob Adams collection. (75-100)

346 348 355 346 - OH935A-6a R9 Raw UNC Details 30% Red obverse but reverse was cleaned during its decades of display in a Marquette Michigan bank. Mrs. Owens & Taylor Millinery, Wilmington Ohio 1863 with Mercury Head reverse. Rare female merchant usually seen only in very low grades often with much detail missing at the periphery. Only the second example we have recorded, a raw AU Details with light stains brought $467.50 in our July 2007 auction. From the Dave Bowers and Louis Kaufman collections. (1000-1500) 347 - OH935B-1a R5 Raw MS64 10% Red. H. Perrin Hardware, Groceries & c., Wilmington Ohio 1863. Very scarce merchant from a very scarce town. A Raw EF+ sold for $162 in our June 2013 auction. From the Charles Thobaben collection. (400-500) 348 - OH935C-1a R5 Raw MS64 30% Red. Wm. Preston Cheap Cash Store, Wilmington Ohio with Sign Of The 8 reverse die 1347. An NGC MS63 RB sold for $565 in our January 2015 sale. (500-750) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com th th Steve Hayden - Mail Bid Sale #47 - Closing Sunday December 15 and Monday December 16 2019 Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 349 - OH975E-1a R5 Raw MS63 20% Red. J. S. Duden Dealer in Groceries and Provisions, Wooster Ohio 1863. Very scarce single variety merchant. Very rare in Uncirculated condition. From the Charles Thobaben collection. (150-200) 350 - PA013E-7a R5 Raw EF R. & W. Jenkinson Tobacconists, Allegheny City Pennsylvania 1863. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1033. Data: 20°, 55.6 grains, 19 mm. (50-75) 351 - PA013F-6a R4 Raw UNC Details Staining mainly on the reverse. John Sherer Tobacco Dealer, Alleghany City Pennsylvania. With tobacco related reverse including scales, humidor and box labeled Cigars. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1331. Data: 53.6 grains, 19.3 mm. (50-75) 352 - PA360A-1do R5 Raw VF well struck counterstamp and VG Cent. W. Bell For Bargain Dry Goods, Erie Pennsylvania. Struck on the planed down reverse of an 1859 Copper-Nickel Cent as are all we have seen. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 68.6 grains, 19.2 mm. (100-150) 353 - PA750B-1d R5 Raw MS63 20% Bright. M. B. Allebach Watch Maker & Jeweler, Philadelphia struck in Copper Nickel. From the Tampa collection. (200-300) 354 - PA750E-5a R9 Raw AU+ M. F. Beirn Magnolia Hotel, Philadelphia. Obverse die of -2a with 1093 reverse. The more common -1a obverse not pictured in Fuld does not have a period after Hotel and has a period rather than a line under the T in the second St. Known for some time they appear to be quite rare, this very example sold for $102.76 in our January 2015 sale. (100-150) 355 - PA750H-1b R8 Raw AU Details But dark and porous. Chestnut & Walnut Passenger Railroad Company One Fare struck in Brass with 1861 dated Benjamin Franklin reverse die 1148. Very rare merchant and while far from the finest known it still has very presentable detail, high R8. The current plate token is the NGC AU58 from the Alan Bleviss collection that realized $6,325 in Stack's September 2009 sale. From our December 2016 sale where it went unsold with a reserve of $1,800. (1500-2000) 356 - PA750Ja-1a R5 Raw AU+ Fox's Casino, Philadelphia Pennsylvania. Very scarce this nice. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 10°, 46.4 grains, 20 mm. (100-150) 357 - PA750K-1a NC Raw AU J. Henry Gercke 1206 Pine Street, Philadelphia Pennsylvania with George Washington reverse die. The address on the token was first occupied by Gercke in 1872 and is therefore listed as Post Civil War in the Non-Contemporary section of the new Civil War Store Card book. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1133. Data: 340°, 49.3 grains, 19.1 mm. (100-150) 358 - PA750L-1a R2 Raw MS63 Trace Red. Great Central Fair Philadelphia June 1864 with George Washington reverse. One of the more famous Sanitary Fairs held to raise money to aid soldiers. From the Dave Bowers and John Dettinger collection. (75-100) 359 - PA750L-1f R3 Raw AU+ Great Central Fair Philadelphia June 1864 struck in Silver and used to raise money to help the soldiers fighting in the war. Another AU+ sold for $121 in our September 2010 auction. From the Dave Bowers and John Dettinger collection. (150-200) 360 - PA750M-2a R5 Raw EF North Military Hall, Philadelphia Pennsylvania with very scarce reverse die 1380. Much scarcer than the -1a and -3a varieties. From the Dave Bowers collection. (50-75) 361 - PA750N-1e R9 Raw UNC Details 10% Bright with some light marks. A. Lambert, Philadelphia Pennsylvania struck in White Metal. Very rare and all we have recorded have been worn or had problems. (300-400) 362 - PA750O-2b R6 Raw EF H. Mulligan Watches and Jewelry, Philadelphia Pennsylvania struck in Brass with portrait of the owner. (100-150) 363 - PA750P-3j R5 Raw EF+ F. P. Rogers, Philadelphia Pennsylvania struck in German Silver with Milk Can pictured. (100-150)

364 379 380 364 - PA750V-2a R9 Raw EF Details Verdigris residue. N. & G. Taylor Co., Philadelphia Pennsylvania 1863. Very rare obverse die with portrait of George Washington. This is the finer of just two known, the other being damaged. GW-561A Baker 580F. From the Steve Tanenbaum, Ray Byrne, Jon Harris and George Fuld collections. (1500-2000) 365 - PA750V-4b R7 Raw EF N. & G. Taylor 1862, Philadelphia with George Washington. Much scarcer than the -3b or even the -5e variety. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 160°, 255.9 grains, 38.6 mm. (200-300) 366 - PA750V-5e R7 Raw EF+ Trace Bright. N. & G. Taylor Co. Stamped & Japanned Ware Metals. Another large size token with George Washington, this struck in White Metal. An AU with a couple light marks realized $195.57 in our July 2009 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 200°, 226.8 grains, 38.4 mm. (200-300) 367 - PA750V-7a Unlisted Raw EF Details Appears to be a copper plated lead copy. Uniformly and finely porous with smooth edge that has marks and some lighter colored metal showing through. N. & G. Taylor Co. Stamped & Japanned Ware Metals, Philadelphia Pennsylvania. Large 37mm token with George Washington and very rare reverse die without the word Files. Unlisted in Copper, Unique in Brass and perhaps only two or three known in White Metal. Hard to imagine how or why this copy was created given the extreme rarity of the reverse die, a puzzle from a merchant with a number of very rare and interesting pieces. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 200°, 229 grains, 38.2 mm. (100-150) 368 - PA765G-1a R5 Raw EF+ D. A. Hall & Co. Tea Dealers, Pittsburgh Pennsylvania. From the Alan Bleviss collection. (75-100) 369 - PA765J-1a R4 Raw AU Details Trace Red but retoned from old cleaning. A. Ludewig Snuff and Cigars, Pittsburgh Pennsylvania with detailed pictorial of man in fancy clothes. Very popular. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 84.3 grains, 21.8 mm. (100-150) 370 - PA765K-2b R9 Raw AU Light planchet streak across the reverse. J. W. McCarthy Bill Poster, Pittsburgh Pennsylvania 1863 struck in Brass. Very rare variety, still the only example we have recorded. From our December 2017 sale where it realized $275. (300-400) 371 - PA765N- 5a R7 Raw MS63 10% Red. Pekin Tea Store, Pittsburgh Pennsylvania. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1030. Data: 315°, 56 grains, 19.1 mm. (100-150) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com th th Steve Hayden - Mail Bid Sale #47 - Closing Sunday December 15 and Monday December 16 2019 Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 372 - PA765O-1a R5 Raw EF+ A. C. Pentz, Pittsburgh Pennsylvania. Rare without the 2 in address canceled. (50-75) 373 - PA765P- 8a R5 Raw AU Struck from rusted reverse die as normally seen. Pittock's News Depot, Pittsburg with popular Sea Serpent reverse die 1290. An AU+ example brought $150 in our January 2016 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1290. Data: 64.1 grains, 19.2 mm. (150-200) 374 - PA765P-29a R8 Raw MS62 Trace Red. John W. Pittock Opposite Post Office, Pittsburgh Pennsylvania. Just the fifth example we have seen offered. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1042. Data: 100°, 62.2 grains, 19 mm. (100-150) 375 - PA765R-2a R3 Raw MS63 Trace Red and nicely toned, struck from a later reverse die state with rim cud. Pittsburgh Dry Goods United We Stand Divided We Fall. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1408. Data: 46.1 grains, 19.3 mm. (75-100) 376 - PA765R-3a R2 Raw VF Details A bit porous. Pittsburgh Dry Goods United We Stand Divided We Fall. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1409. Data: 42 grains, 19.2 mm. (0-25) 377 - RI700F-1a R6 Raw EF Details Somewhat unevenly struck with some small planchet flaws both as usual. Struck on a thicker than normal 2.3mm planchet. H. Y. Lefevre Empire Saloon, Providence with popular reverse die 1294 featuring large beer tankard. This crude token, with backwards N's, S's and even a backwards 1. (75-100) 378 - RI700I-1b R9 Raw UNC Details 20% Bright with light hairlines from old cleaning. F. W. Shattuck Burnside Fruit Store, Providence Rhode Island struck in Brass. Rare merchant. From our January 2015 sale where it realized $240. (500-750) 379 - TN180A-5a R8 Raw EF+ N. O. Underwood Good For 5 Cents, Dedham Tennessee 1863. Rare town and state. From the Bob Adams collection. (750-1000) 380 - TN430A-1b R7 Raw EF With straight planchet clip mint error. Barry & McDaniel Premium Confectioners, Knoxville Tennessee Good For One Glass Arctic Soda Water struck in Brass. Very rare single merchant town. We sold a Raw AU example in our October 2011 auction that brought $2,350. (1500-2000)

381 382 383 381 - TN600B- 8a R8 Raw MS62 Elliott, Vinson & Co., Memphis Tennessee Our Rights, The Constitution And The Union struck in Copper. From the Bob Adams collection. (1000-1500) 382 - TN690C-5a R9 Raw VF Details A bit porous. D. L. Lapsley & Co., Nashville Tennessee 25 struck in Copper. Very rare town and merchant and one of only a handful of Civil War tokens known to have been issued by African-Americans. Per the Store Card book the merchants were Barbers and Daniel L. Lapsley in particular was heavily involved in politics during Reconstruction and the early Civil Rights movement. By the 1870 census he was listed as a justice of the peace. We sold an NGC MS63 example of the R9 -1a variety for $4,400 in our June 2011 sale. From the Bob Adams collection. (1500-2000) 383 - WI030A-1e R8 Raw MS62 30% Bright. Parsons & Barlow, Appleton Wisconsin 1864 Liberty For All with eagle struck in White Metal. From the Bob Adams collection. (750-1000) 384 - WI250C-1b R9 Raw UNC Details With two small obverse spot at rim. A. Kimboll Dealer in Hardware, Green Bay Wisconsin 1863 struck in Brass. From the Mike Tramte collection. (300-400)

385 404 423 385 - WI250D-1b R10 Raw UNC Details Reverse retoning from cleaning with hairlines. Philipp Klaus Yankee Notions and Toys, Green Bay Wisconsin 1863 struck in Brass and thought to be Unique. From the Mike Tramte collection. (400-500) 386 - WI270A-1a R5 Raw EF J. Siegel Dry Goods & Groceries, Hales Corner Wisconsin 1863. Scarce single variety town. From the Bob Adams collection. (75-100) 387 - WI300G-1b R6 Raw AU Details 10% Bright with some light staining. H. L. Smith Iron, Hardware, Wagon Stuff, Janesville Wisconsin 1861 struck in Brass with padlock pictured. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1111. Data: 46.6 grains, 19.6 mm. (150-200) 388 - WI410F-1a R5 Raw VF+ J. J. Lawrence Crockery & Glassware, Madison Wisconsin. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1222. Data: 240°, 62.4 grains, 19.4 mm. (50-75) 389 - WI410I-1a R6 Raw EF George V. Ott Tannery Manufacturer & Dealer In Leather Hides, Madison Wisconsin. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1205. Data: 53.4 grains, 19.8 mm. (75-100) 390 - WI410J-1a R6 Raw VF Ramsay & Campbell, Madison Wisconsin. Very scarce merchant with anvil reverse die. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1332. Data: 61.1 grains, 19.4 mm. (50-75) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com th th Steve Hayden - Mail Bid Sale #47 - Closing Sunday December 15 and Monday December 16 2019 Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 391 - WI435A-1a R7 Raw VF+ I. Livingston Dry Goods Marshall Wisconsin 1863. Rare merchant from a very scarce town. We sold a Raw VF for $160 in our December 2012 auction. From the Bob Adams and Chet Krause collections earlier from Kurt Krueger's May 2009 sale where it brought $172.50. (200-300) 392 - WI510 B-1a R5 Raw VF Details Some planchet flaws. Ch. Bast Wisconsin Brewery, Milwaukee Wisconsin 1863 with beer barrel and Star of David pictured. Signed Mossin & Marr, unusual as most of their signed work is labeled simply Marr. A raw EF Details with light marks brought $90 in our February 2014 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 350°, 58.4 grains, 20.1 mm. (75-100) 393 - WI510 L-1a R3 Raw MS63 Trace Red. Wm. Frankfurth, Milwaukee Wisconsin 1863 with tools on reverse including a saw labeled Don't Despair. From the Q. David Bowers collection. Data: 61.5 grains, 20.1 mm. (150-200) 394 - WI510 P-2a R6 Raw EF C. Hambach, Milwaukee Wisconsin. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1194. Data: 55.8 grains, 19.7 mm. (75-100) 395 - WI510 T-1a R7 Raw EF Kirby Longworthy & Co. Threshing Machine Works, Milwaukee Wisconsin 1863. Rare merchant. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1108. Data: 160°, 52.1 grains, 19.8 mm. (150-200) 396 - WI510 X-2a R6 Raw VF Louis Kurz Pictorial Lithographer, Milwaukee Wisconsin. With Naked Amazon reverse die 1220 signed Marr. A Raw VF with small stains brought $71.50 in our March 2010 sale. (100-150) 397 - WI510AC-1a R5 Raw EF F. Mitzlaff Grocer, Milwaukee Wisconsin. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1194. Data: 61.6 grains, 19.7 mm. (50-75) 398 - WI510AE-1a1 R5 Raw VF+ Carl Paeschke Provisions, Milwaukee with Reeded Edge. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 180°, 52.8 grains, 19.6 mm. (50-75) 399 - WI510AP-6a1 R9 Raw EF H. Upmeyer Jeweler, Milwaukee Wisconsin with very rare S.A.D. (Stephen A. Douglas) reverse die 1156. Somewhat overrated variety and we have yet to personally examine the R8 Plain Edge variety; perhaps the rarities should be reversed. A Raw VF+ sold for $300 in our August 2015 auction. (300-400) 400 - WI530A-1a R6 Raw UNC Details With some very light obverse hairlines. Frankenberg & Keller Hardware, Newburg Wisconsin. Very scarce town and quite rare in Uncirculated condition. A raw VF+ brought $175 in our September 2010 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1194. Data: 64.1 grains, 19.6 mm. (200-300) 401 - WI550B-1a R8 Raw VF Details Small stains. J. Remington Sons Dry Goods & Groceries, North Prairie Wisconsin Union 1863. A Raw EF Details with light marks on each side sold for $376 in our December 2017 auction. From the Q. David Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1106. Data: 170°, 52.4 grains, 19.8 mm. (400-500) 402 - WI620A-1a R6 Raw EF City Hotel Nearest Hotel to the Steam Boat Landing, G. Bock Proprietor Oshkosh Wisconsin. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 200°, 58.8 grains, 19.6 mm. (150-200) 403 - WI620O-1a R6 Raw AU+ With raised reverse die marks as often seen. Allen Vosburg & Co. Steinway's Pianos, Oshkosh. Rare merchant. We sold a Raw VF Details with residue traces for $150 in our December 2008 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 53.4 grains, 19.2 mm. (300-400) 404 - WI700A-1a R8 Raw UNC Details 20% Red with edge nick under the date, likely mint caused. J. I. Case & Co. Thrashing Machine Manufacturers, Racine Wisconsin Union 1863 with Eagle struck in Copper. Very rare variety and obverse die. Only the third example we have seen offered. We sold an NGC MS64 RB in our March 2008 catalog sale that realized $1,925. From the Dave Bowers and George Fuld collections. (500-750) 405 - WI890A-1a R6 Raw VF+ Eaton & Barns, Tomah Wisconsin 1864. Very scarce single variety merchant. From the Bob Adams collection. (100-150) 406 - WI920A-1a R5 Raw EF Tiny planchet clip mint error. H. Bellack Dry Goods, Groceries & Provisions, Watertown Wisconsin 1863 with Flying Eagle. (75-100) 407 - WI920L-1a R5 Raw VF Theodore Racek Restaurant, Watertown Wisconsin with beer mug reverse die 1295. (50-75) 408 - WI930C-1a R6 Raw AU H. W. Sherman Dry Goods, Hats, Caps And Groceries, Waukesha Wisconsin with boot on the reverse. Very scarce town. From the Bob Adams and John Dettinger collections. (300-400) 409 - WI960A-1a R5 Raw EF Gallt & Cole Dry Goods, Groceries, Boots & Shoes, Whitewater Wisconsin 1861. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1111. Data: 51.6 grains, 19.5 mm. (50-75) 410 - LU S-5a R9 Raw MS64 Trace Red. Town Branch Store Redeemable in Goods 25 Cents. Long thought to be from East Saginaw Michigan as MI280F-5a and now in limbo. Lexington Kentucky has been suggested in part due to the similarity of the larger unlisted piece to Keiningham variety -2b which is also 22mm with 10 Cents reverse die that is quite distinctive. A Raw MS62 example of the equally rare R9 -1a variety realized $425 in our August 2015 auction. From the Steve Tanenbaum, Cindy Grellman Wibker and Ken Trobaugh collections. (500-750)

END OF SESSION ONE

Counterstamped Coins Session Two - lots 411 to 800 begin closing at 7PM Eastern Time Monday December 16th including all Counterstamps, Hard Times, Merchant, Political and Shell Cards. 411 - 123 W. 22. SY. / - N.Y. - on obverse of a 1908 Billiken Good Luck token Raw EF Token VF. This token was issued by the Billiken Company of Chicago Illinois with a copyright of 1908 and features the interesting Good Luck charm doll Billiken. The meaning or residents of the New York City address are not known. (25-50) 412 - BARTON. VT on obverse of 1863 English Half Penny Raw EF Coin FINE. Likely associated with a business of some sort located in Barton Vermont. (25-50) 413 - BOSTON / NOV 9 / 1872 on obverse of 1872 Raw VF Coin VF. The date on this piece is the date of the Great Boston Fire that destroyed 65 acres of downtown Boston including 776 buildings. (0-25) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com th th Steve Hayden - Mail Bid Sale #47 - Closing Sunday December 15 and Monday December 16 2019 Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Counterstamped Coins 414 - BOWMAN on obverse of Seated Quarter Raw VF Coin AG. This stamp is sometimes self identified to Ottawa Illinois photographer W. E. Bowman and were apparently done in the late 1870's. Rulau IL-Ot 5a this lone stamp only listed on a Bust Dime. (75-100) 415 - G. BAYNTON / MILTON, MS. on obverse of an 1843 Large Cent Raw VF Details Coin FINE but dark and porous. Most likely Milton Massachusetts rather than Milton Mississippi. From the Dave Bowers collection. (200-300) 416 - J. L. BARNES / SALOON / BRYAN TEX on the obverse of a Seated Half Dollar Raw FINE Coin AG. This scarce and popular Saloon counterstamp dates from the late 1870's. Rulau TX-By 3 (300-400) 417 - A. S. CLACKNER / ROCHESTER, NY / PATTENT / SEPT. 19. 1865 on reverse of 1863 Patriotic Civil War token Raw EF Token EF, reverse planed down. Andrew S. Clackner is listed in the 1875 Rochester directory as a Jeweler located at 291 State. The patent, 49978, is related to Watches. (150-200) 418 - ALEXANDER CLARK / MAKER / 139 FENCHURCH ST. LONDON ON REVERSE OF 1887 British Half Penny Raw VF Coin VG. This firm was active under this name and address circa 1891-1898 manufacturing a variety of silver and silver plate items. From Bowers and Merena's March 1987 sale. (50-75) 419 - D. CARLILE on obverse of 1858-O Half Dollar Raw VF Coin VG. A research opportunity. (50-75) 420 - J. CUMMINGS. / SPRINGFIELD. / MASS. on both sides of 1857 Canada Bank token Raw VG Details Coin VG holed, portions of the stamp are missing on each side but complete in total. Apparently the stamp of John Cummings, a gunsmith in the 1840's and 1850's (50-75) 421 - CONSULT / DR. DARBY / BOSTON on obverse of a 1772 Two Real Raw VF Coin VG. Rulau lists this as the stamp of Dr. Ralph H. Darby an apothecary / physician and attributes it to 1854-55. Rulau Mass 34A. From Bowers & Merena's March 1987. (300-400) 422 - W. P. DAVIS / ENGIN, CALENDER / & / TILE / MACHINE / MANF'R / NO. BLOOMFIELD, N.Y. on obverse of 1863 Cent Raw VF Coin VG with some stray marks on reverse. William P. Davis operated a machine manufacturing business in North Bloomfield and later Rochester New York beginning in the 1880's. Rulau NY NB 2. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections, earlier from Paul Koppenhaver June 1978. (100-150) 423 - GANT on obverse of 1853 $2½ Gold Piece Raw VF Coin EF. We know nothing about the issuer but any counterstamp on a US Gold coin is very rare. (500-750) 424 - USE / G.G.G. / & / G.G.G.G on the obverse of an 1837 Cent Raw VF Coin FINE. This enigmatic token has now been attributed to Exeter New Hampshire as Goodwin's Grand Greasejuice a hair tonic and Goodwin's Grand Glittering Globules a breath perfume form the 1850's. Rulau NH 151 From the Dave Bowers collection. (100-150) 425 - USE / G.G.G. / & / G.G.G.G on the obverse of an 1847 Cent Raw VF Coin FINE. This enigmatic token has now been attributed to Exeter New Hampshire as Goodwin's Grand Greasejuice a hair tonic and Goodwin's Grand Glittering Globules a breath perfume form the 1850's. Rulau NH 151 (100-150) 426 - USE / G.G.G. / & / G.G.G.G on the obverse of an 1853 Cent Raw EF Coin VF Details a bit flattened near rim at 2 o'clock. This enigmatic token has now been attributed to Exeter New Hampshire as Goodwin's Grand Greasejuice a hair tonic and Goodwin's Grand Glittering Globules a breath perfume form the 1850's. Rulau NH 151 From the Dave Bowers collection. (50-75) 427 - USE / G.G.G. / & / G.G.G.G on the obverse of an 1853 Quarter Raw VF Coin VG. This enigmatic token has now been attributed to Exeter New Hampshire as Goodwin's Grand Greasejuice a hair tonic and Goodwin's Grand Glittering Globules a breath perfume form the 1850's. Rulau NH 153 From the Dave Bowers collection. (150-200) 428 - USE / G.G.G. on the obverse of an 1854 Dime Raw VF Coin VG. Goodwin's Grand Greasejuice was a hair tonic originating in Exeter New Hampshire. Rulau NY 163 From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections. (100-150)

429 441 445 429 - Wm GRUMBINE / COACH / MAKER / HAVOVER Pa on obverse of 1772 Two Real Raw VF Details Coin VG holed. Per Russell Rulau, William Grumbine was one of roughly 25 coachmakers in Hanover at the time. Collectively they employed over 2,000 people. Another coachmaker, G. W. Welsh, also from Hanover, issued counterstamps. The vast majority of both issues are on silver two reals. Rulau Pa 701. From the Cliff Wainwright, John Linhoss and Bob Ulrich collections. Brunk Plate specimen. (500-750) 430 - (Anchor) HOPE SILVER Co on the obverse of 1888 Cent Raw VF Coin VG. This was the hallmark for silver-plated items by G. W. Parks Company of Providence Rhode Island, active from 1904 to 1915. From the Q. David Bowers collection earlier from our January 2016 sale where it brought $95.75. (100-150) 431 - C. HORN / GROCER / 304 W. 16 ST. / N.Y. on obverse of 1862 Cent. Raw VF Coin VG. Rulau places this New York City merchant squarely in the Civil War era citing 1863 and 1864 directory evidence, however, the current Store Card book disputes this and places it in its Do Not List Section. Very rare merchant regardless being one of just three known on a Copper Nickel Cent with two additional pieces known on Large Cents. This is the Plate Specimen for both Brunk and Rulau. Rulau NY 2204. From the Q. David Bowers, Steve Tanenbaum and Roy Van Ormer collections, earlier from Bowers & Merena's September 1985 sale. (200-300) 432 - H. P. on reverse of 1829 Cent with star, three balls and bowling pin Raw VF Coin GOOD. A very intriguing piece that certainly has a story to tell. If anyone figures it out, we would love to know…even after the sale. From the Cliff Wainwright collection. (100-150) 433 - HATCH'S / RESTAURANT / Cor Main & 3rd Sts. / LAX, WIS. On obverse of an 1868 Shield Nickel Raw VF Coin VG. E. A. Hatch is listed in the 1876 directory as the proprietor of the Aldine Restaurant, Billiard Hall and Sample Room at the corner of Third and Main Streets in La Crosse Wisconsin. We sold a similar example on a 1870 Nickel in our December 2008 sale that brought $110. (150-200) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com th th Steve Hayden - Mail Bid Sale #47 - Closing Sunday December 15 and Monday December 16 2019 Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Counterstamped Coins 434 - HOPE FILE WORKS on obverse of 1871 Nickel Raw VF Coin VG, stamped twice to complete the single line punch. A Hope File Works is listed at 161 Lockwood Providence Rhode Island in 1877 and 1878 directories. (75-100) 435 - HUNT & MOORE on obverse of 1864-L Cent Raw EF Coin EF+. Long a stubborn maverick, a prior owner has suggested a country store in Marlboro Massachusetts. We were unable to verify this with some simple internet searching. Rulau unlisted undertype. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections. (100-150) 436 - J. HAYNES / CONCORD / N. H. on obverse of 1869 Boston token Raw VF Token EF. Struck on National Peace Jubilee token. The Jubilee was held in Boston Massachusetts on June 17th 1869. (100-150) 437 - D. F. JACOBS in raised letter in a rectangular punch on the obverse of an 1834 Hard Times token Raw VG Token FINE, stamp is struck twice making some letters difficult to read. Kovels' American Silver Marks lists a D. Jacobs as a Charleston South Carolina silversmith circa 1852. (100-150) 438 - JENNIE / HUBBS on obverse of 1866 Cent Raw VF Coin VG. The steamship Jennie Hubbs was built by David Gibson and Company Cincinnati Ohio in 1863. During November 1866 she sank at the falls of Ohio River near Clarksville Indiana. From the Cliff Wainwright collection. (100-150) 439 - A. KLINGER / JEWELER / ELKHART IND on reverse of 1852 Large Cent Raw EF Coin VG. A. Klinger was listed as a watchmaker and jeweler in the 1858-59 Indiana state business directory. An impressive stamp accompanied. Rulau Ind 100C. We sold a similar example on an 1848 Cent that realized $264 in our December 2010 sale. From the Cliff Wainwright collection. (200-300) 440 - KNIGHT'S / 15 BEAVER St / ALBANY on obverse of 1854 Quarter Raw VF Coin FINE. Thos. S. Knight is listed as running a restaurant at 15 Beaver in the 1856 Albany New York city directory. (200-300) 441 - (Bust of General Lafayette) on the obverse of an 1836 Large Cent Raw EF Coin FINE. (Bust of General Lafayette) on the obverse of an 1836 Large Cent. From the Q. David Bowers and John J. Ford collections, earlier Stack's Bowers August 2013. (1500-2000) 442 - ADMIT / TO THE / MODEL ARTIST'S / 127 GRAND ST. / NEAR B.WAY. on 178? Spanish Two Real Raw VF Details Coin AG with reverse scratches. Model Artist's performed at the Franklin Museum at 127 Grand Street New York City managed by George Lea. The troop, described as Madame Warton's, consisted of twenty-seven young ladies who posed nude or seminude. The company staged scenes from classic paintings to lend an air of respectability to the show. Miller 583. (300-400) 443 - D. MUNSON in raised letters in a rectangular punch on obverse of an 1788 Two Real Raw EF Coin GOOD. Yet to be identified but based on known stamped coins it appears to be from the late 1830's to early 1840's, leading Russell Rulau to list as a maverick Hard Times token, HT-541C. Usually seen on Large Cents, this stamp is very rare on Two Reals. (150-200) 444 - J. H. METZ'S / HOTEL / N.E. COR. JEFFn AV. & FED. St on obverse of 1859 Cent Raw EF Coin EF. A tavern in Philadelphia Pennsylvania was located at the NE corner of Jefferson Avenue and Federal Street in the 1860's. A very impressive counterstamp of possible Civil War vintage. From the Q. David Bowers collection, earlier from PCAC's May 1985 sale. (300-400) 445 - MESCHUTT'S / METROPOLITIAN / COFFEE ROOM / 433. Bd. WAY on the obverse of 1857 Half and D. REARDON twice on reverse Raw VF Coin VF. Issued by Frederick Meschutt, Rulau dates this popular stamp to 1855. Unlisted in Rulau on any US coin other than Large Cent. Unlisted in Adams. Miller NY 558 From the Dave Bowers collection from Steve Tanenbaum and PCAC December 1976. (750-1000) 446 - MESCHUTT'S / METROPOLITIAN / COFFEE ROOM / 433. Bd. WAY on the reverse of 1821 Cent Raw VF Coin GOOD. Issued by Frederick Meschutt, Rulau dates this popular stamp to 1855. Unlisted in Adams. Miller NY 558A From the Dave Bowers collection from our July 2014 sale where it realized $220. (300-400) 447 - MILLER HOUSE on the obverse of an 1876 Seated Quarter Raw VF Coin AG. Cohoes New York and Ironton Ohio have been suggested as possible attributions for this counterstamp that was likely issued in the late 1870's or early 1880's. From the Q. David Bowers and John J. Ford collections, earlier Stack's Bowers August 2013. (300-400) 448 - N. Y. N. H. & / H. R. R. on the obverse and 1 on reverse of 1891 Cent Raw VF Coin EF. Rulau lists a similar piece (NY NY 214) as New York, New Haven & Hartford Railroad and dates to 1897. There are a number of similar stamps for various railroads, all quite rare. They are all likely tests of presses of metal seals used to secure railroad freight cars. From the Dave Bowers collection from Steve Tanenbaum. (100-150) 449 - OIL / OF / ICE on the obverse of an 1853 Cent Raw VF Coin FINE+. Issued by a yet to be identified maker of early Patent Medicine. Unlike other counterstamps of this type, this stamp is much more available on small rather than large cents. Rulau MV 230 From the Dave Bowers collection. (100-150) 450 - HABILITADO / POR / F. / PINTO / M twice on obverse of 1861 Cent Raw EF Coin VF. Thought to have been issued in the 1870's by Francisco Pinto owner of a coffee plantation in San Jose Costa Rica. The stamps are quite rare but when seen are invariably on Copper Nickel Indian Head Cent of the type issued from 1860 to 1864. The dates are almost always obliterated by the stamp but on this one enough of the final digit is visible to confirm it is an 1861 and important as such. An unusually nice example. Rulau SJS 98, Brunk P-511 From the Dave Bowers collection. (400-500) 451 - J. L. POLHEMUS / (Mortar & Pestle) / DRUGGISTS / 190 J. ST. COR 7th / SACRAMENTO CAL. on the obverse of an 1855 Quarter Raw VF Coin AG. Popular early California druggist counterstamp. Rulau CA 1A. (300-400) 452 - PARISIAN / VARIETIES / 16. St & B'WAY. N. Y. on obverse of 1875 Half Dollar Raw EF Coin FINE. According to Rulau Parisian Varieties was an erotic show of nubile young ladies in 1875 and 1876. Very nice stamp and coin. Rulau NY NY230 Miller 627. (150-200) 453 - Phila. Oyster House. on obverse of 1873 English Florin Raw VF Coin VG. This piece has traditionally been listed under Philadelphia Pennsylvania based on circumstantial evidence, but we note a Philadelphia Oyster House at 513 Eleventh St. NW Washington DC in a 1892 District of Columbia directory. Rulau Pa Ph 1060. From the Cliff Wainwright, John Linhoss and Bob Ulrich collections. Brunk Plate specimen. (200-300) 454 - W. F. / PASCO on obverse of 1863 Yankee Robinson Civil War token Raw VF Token VF, the stamp of the initials are upside down in relation to the surname. Possibly from Fillmore New York during the early 1900's. From the Byron Kanzinger collection. (25-50) 455 - H. L. RAY on obverse of 1850's Grand Rapids Michigan token Raw VF Details Token VF with some marks and residues. A research opportunity. (25-50) 456 - H. REES in a curved punch on the obverse of an 1828 Large Cent Raw VF Coin AG. Rees was a Philadelphia blacksmith in the late 1830's and is assigned the Hard Times token identification HT 415B. From the Dave Bowers reference collection. (50-75) 457 - H. REES in a curved punch on the obverse of an 1830 Large Cent Raw VF Coin AG. Rees was a Philadelphia blacksmith in the late 1830's and is assigned the Hard Times token identification HT 415B. From the Dave Bowers reference collection. (50-75) 458 - J. H. ROOT on obverse of 1822 Cent Raw VF Coin VG Details dark. Joel H. Root was a clock maker from Bristol Connecticut in the 1850s. Rulau Ct Bt 25. From the Dave Bowers collection. (150-200) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com th th Steve Hayden - Mail Bid Sale #47 - Closing Sunday December 15 and Monday December 16 2019 Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Counterstamped Coins 459 - J. RUSSELL & Co. on the obverse of an 1832 Large Cent Raw VF Coin VG. Rulau lists John Russell as a maker of knives and tools from Greenfield Massachusetts. Rulau MA 663 the same smaller punch as the last. From the Dave Bowers reference collection. (75-100) 460 - RUDOLPH on the obverse of an 1854 Quarter Raw VF Coin FINE. J. F. Rudolph was a druggist in Nevada City California in the late 1850's. Rulau CA 118. (75-100) 461 - S. RORK. on both sides of an 1855 Seated Quarter Raw VF Coin VG with a light mark. No information is known of the issuer, a mystery to be solved. From the Q. David Bowers and John J. Ford collections, earlier Stack's Bowers August 2013. (50-75) 462 - ( ). STEPHENSON CO / (P)AT OCT 17 187( ) / (n)EW YORK on both sides of 1860 Cent Raw FINE Coin VG with stamp too big for coin. The description is a composite of both sides. Probably the stamp of John Stephenson Company a street car and omnibus maker at 47 East 27th Street in New York. The company was founded in 1831 as the John Stephenson Car Company and changed its name to John Stephenson Company in 1867 and lasting many decades. A listing, admittedly incomplete, of patents of the firm does not list this date, however, it does show they were very active in the 1870's. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections. (75-100) 463 - DR. / SHATTUCK'S / WATER CURE / WATERFORD / ME. On the obverse of an 1833? Cent Raw VF Coin AG+. Dr. William P. Shattuck was a physician specializing in cold water cures. ME 5 From the Dave Bowers collection. (300-400) 464 - DR. / SHATTUCK'S / WATER CURE / WATERFORD / ME. On the obverse of an 1853 Quarter Raw VF Coin EF Details with some hairlines. Dr. William P. Shattuck was a physician specializing in cold water cures. ME 6 From the Dave Bowers collection from Bob Mitchell in the 1980s. (200-300)

465 483 486 465 - DR. / SHATTUCK'S / WATER CURE / WATERFORD / ME. On the obverse of an 1859-O Half Raw VF Coin GOOD+. Dr. William P. Shattuck was a physician specializing in cold water cures. This scarce counterstamp when seen is normally on a Large Cent or Quarter with the Half Dollars particularly rare, one of just five known. A particularly nice 1858-O brought $1,057.50 in Stack's August 2013 auction. Rulau ME 6A From the Dave Bowers collection. (750-1000) 466 - O. H. SHORT on the reverse of an 1854 Seated Quarter Raw VF Coin VG. From the Q. David Bowers and John J. Ford collections, earlier Stack's Bowers August 2013. (50-75) 467 - SAGE'S / CANDY / COIN on obverse of 1874 Quarter Raw EF Coin FINE. According to Russell Rulau these were issued by Buffalo New York patent medicine seller R. V. Pierce who sold under the names Dr. Pierce and Dr. Sage. A popular stamp. Rulau NY Bf 18. From the Cliff Wainwright collection. (150-200) 468 - STONE & BALL / SYRACUSE / N.Y. on obverse of 1853 Quarter Raw VF Coin GOOD+. Seymour Stone and Calvin Ball were silversmiths who operated in Syracuse from 1853 to 1869. Rulau NY 1027E. (50-75) 469 - STONE & BALL / SYRACUSE / N.Y. on obverse of 1854 Quarter Raw VF Coin FINE. Seymour Stone and Calvin Ball were silversmiths who operated in Syracuse from 1853 to 1869. Rulau NY 1027E. (100-150) 470 - W. A. S. & CO on obverse of 1863 Cent Raw VF Coin FINE. A maverick awaiting attribution. Should be Civil War era or very near. From the Q. David Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections, earlier from Paul Cunningham in 1976. (0-25) 471 - J. M. TAYLOR / BROKER / CHATHAM St / COR. JAMES. N.Y. on obverse of a 1775 Two Real Raw VF Coin VG. Taylor was located at 169 Chatham during 1854. Rulau NY 889G. (100-150) 472 - J. M. TAYLOR / BROKER / CHATHAM St / COR. JAMES. N.Y. on the obverse of an 1854 Arrows Seated Quarter Raw EF Coin VF. Considerably scarcer than the normally seen 1853 host coin. Rulau 889C From the Q. David Bowers and John J. Ford collections, earlier Stack's Bowers August 2013. (200-300) 473 - C. F. ULRICH in a rectangle on reverse of 1865 Three Cent piece Raw EF Coin VG. Conrad F. Ulrich was the master engraver for the Winchester Repeating Arms Company New Haven Connecticut in the 1870's. This very stamp is seen on some of his intricately engraved rifles. (300-400) 474 - VOTE THE LAND / FREE on obverse of 1841 Cent Raw EF Coin VF. Popular political token believed to have been issued by the Free Soil party and their candidate ex President Martin Van Buren in 1848. He gathered nearly 300,000 votes but no electoral votes. We sold a similar example for $325 in our December 2017 auction. Dewitt MVB 1848-3 From the Cliff Wainwright and Dave Bowers collections. (300-400) 475 - C. WARNER on obverse of 1817 Cent in a raised letter punch Raw VF Coin GOOD. Caleb Warner was a silversmith in Portsmouth New Hampshire circa 1824-1830. Rulau Early NH 9 From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections. (200-300) 476 - DR. G. G. WILKINS. Curved on both sides of a French Colonies 5 Centimes Raw VF Coin AG+ with some pitting. George Wilkins was a dentist in Pittsfield New Hampshire. NH 111T From the Dave Bowers collection from Roy Van Ormer April 1985. (100-150) 477 - DR. G. G. WILKINS. Curved on obverse of 1838 English Three Pence Raw EF Coin FINE Details with some light scratches. George Wilkins was a dentist in Pittsfield New Hampshire. NH 111N From the Dave Bowers collection from Paul Koppenhaver. (150-200) 478 - DR. G. G. WILKINS. Curved on the obverse of a 1858 Cent Raw EF Coin FINE+. George Wilkins was a dentist in Pittsfield New Hampshire. Rulau NH 107. From the Q. David Bowers collection. (75-100) 479 - DR. G. G. WILKINS. Curved on the obverse of a 1863 Civil War token Raw EF Coin VF Details with punch mark on both sides. George Wilkins was a dentist in Pittsfield New Hampshire. This stamp is usually seen on Large Cents and Flying Eagle Cents, all those on US tokens are quite rare. Rulau NH 113C From the Dave Bowers collection from Roy Van Ormer April 1985. (50-75)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com th th Steve Hayden - Mail Bid Sale #47 - Closing Sunday December 15 and Monday December 16 2019 Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Counterstamped Coins 480 - DR. G. G. WILKINS. Curved on the obverse of a Hard Times token Raw VF Coin FINE. George Wilkins was a dentist in Pittsfield New Hampshire. This stamp is usually seen on Large Cents and Flying Eagle Cents, all those on US tokens are quite rare. This over a Merchant Exchange New York City Hard Times token. Rulau NH 111 From the Dave Bowers collection, earlier from PCAC July 1992. (150-200) 481 - DR. G. G. WILKINS. Curved on the obverse of an 1813 Canadian token Raw VF Coin FINE Detail porous. George Wilkins was a dentist in Pittsfield New Hampshire. This stamp is usually seen on Large Cents and Flying Eagle Cents, all those on Canadian tokens are quite rare. Rulau NH 111B From the Dave Bowers collection from Steve Tanenbaum January 1987. (75-100) 482 - DR. G. G. WILKINS. PITTSFIELD.N.H. on obverse of 1840 Cent with G. W. GREENE on reverse Raw VF Coin GOOD. An important piece not often seen with the addition of city and state counterstamp with the added bonus of an additional merchant stamp. We sold an example with only the Wilkins stamps on an 1862 English Half Penny that realized $309.10 in our April 1999 auction. Rulau NH 114 From the Dave Bowers collection from Steve Tanenbaum. (300-400) 483 - DR. G. G. WILKINS. PITTSFIELD.N.H. on obverse of 1859 Canadian Cent Raw EF Coin FINE. An important piece not often seen with the addition of city and state counterstamp. We sold an example on an 1862 English Half Penny that realized $309.10 in our April 1999 auction. Rulau NH 114C From the Dave Bowers collection from Rossa & Tanenbaum January 1987. (400-500) 484 - DR. G. G. WILKINS. PITTSFIELD.N.H. on obverse of 1864 New Brunswick Cent Raw VF Coin VF Details a bit porous. An important piece not often seen with the addition of city and state counterstamp. We sold an example on an 1862 English Half Penny that realized $309.10 in our April 1999 auction. Rulau Unlisted. From the Dave Bowers collection from Roy Van Ormer April 1985. (300-400) 485 - O. R. Whitcomb engraved on obverse of 1800 Two Real Raw VF Coin VG. Rulau lists this as a maverick in the Early American section of his Standard Catalog but refers to an Oliver Whitcomb of Belfast Maine circa 1830. Rulau Early Mav 59E. From the Russell Rulau collection. (50-75) 486 - FREE TICKET TO / YANKEE / ROBINSONS / QUADRUPLE - SHOW on the obverse of an 1855 Half Dollar Raw FINE+ Coin FINE. This traveling Circus also issued a large number of Civil War tokens. From the Q. David Bowers collection. (500-750) Hard Times Tokens

487 488 489 487 - LOW 4 / HT-6 R2 Raw AU+ Very well struck. Andrew Jackson Our Hero In War & In Peace, Reelected 1832. From the Robert Williams collection. (750-1000) 488 - LOW 5A / HT-8 R6 Raw AU Small planchet clip. Andrew Jackson the Gallant & Successful Defender of New Orleans 1833. This is the scarcer variety with different spacing and no period after N in N. Orleans. Another Raw AU brought $880 in our December 2010 auction. From the Robert Williams collection. (1000-1500) 489 - LOW 7 / HT-15 R6 Raw EF Details Retoned from cleaning. The Glorious Whig Victory Of 1834 Fellow Citizens, Save Your Constitution. We sold a Raw VF Details with flattened rim for $876 in our December 2017 sale. (1500-2000) 490 - LOW 8 / HT-9 R1 Raw MS64 Trace Red with nice luster and color. My Substitute For The US Bank with running boar pictured. From the Steve Turns collection, earlier from Tom Reynolds December 1999. (300-400) 491 - LOW 9 / HT-10 R3 Raw AU+ 30% Bright. Jackson with Running Boar 1834 struck in Brass. Rare this nice. From the Robert Williams collection. (400-500) 492 - LOW 9B / HT-10A R3 Raw AU 10% Bright with 50% or more original Silvering. Jackson with Running Boar 1834 struck in Silvered Brass. We sold a similar piece in our December 2017 sale that brought $255. From the Maurice Shepherd and Gilbert Steinberg collections, earlier from Bowers and Merena's November 2002 sale where it realized $161. (300-400)

493 514 525 493 - LOW 11A / HT12A R6 Raw EF+ 10% Bright with 50% or more original Silvering. Rarer broad shoulders Andrew Jackson with running Boar 1834 struck in Silvered Brass. We sold a similar example for $880 in our July 2007 auction. (1000-1500) 494 - LOW 12 / HT-25 R1 Raw EF The Constitution As I Understand It Roman Firmness LLD 1834 A Plain System Void Of Pomp. Popular satirical Political token. Dewitt CE 1834-14. (75-100) 495 - LOW 13 / HT-26 R4 Raw EF Details Deep scratch and other light marks. William Seward Our Next Governor. Very scarce variety. A Raw VF Details with light scratches brought $321.20 in our June 2011 sale. (150-200) 496 - LOW 18 / HT-32 R1 Raw AU+ I Follow in the Foot Steps of My Illustrious Predecessor with a running donkey or jackass. Executive Experiment 1837 Fiscal Agent with turtle carrying Sub Treasury strong box. A similar example sold for $111 in our December 2017 auction. (100-150) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com th th Steve Hayden - Mail Bid Sale #47 - Closing Sunday December 15 and Monday December 16 2019 Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Hard Times Tokens 497 - LOW 19 / HT-33 R1 Raw MS63 10% Red. Turtle carrying Sub Treasury with Jackass on reverse. From the Steve Turns collection, earlier from Robert Vlack November 1999. (200-300) 498 - LOW 20 / HT-34 R1 Raw MS62 I Follow in the Foot Steps of My Illustrious Predecessor with a running donkey or jackass. From the Robert Williams collection. (150-200) 499 - LOW 21 / HT-35 R2 Raw AU 1837 Liberty head Millions For Defense Not One Cent For Tribute. Rarely seen this nice and without problems. From the Robert Williams collection. (500-750) 500 - LOW 29 / HT-44 R3 Raw AU Weak opposite head as usual. 1837 Millions For Defense with large crude and slightly mean looking Liberty head. Rare this nice and by far the nicest we have auctioned. From the Robert Williams collection. (500-750) 501 - LOW 31 / HT-46 R2 Raw UNC Details 10% Red more so on the reverse with a small stain under Liberty's chin. Millions For Defense Not One Cent For Tribute. From the Robert Williams collection. (50-75) 502 - LOW 45 / HT-56 R1 Raw MS63 Trace Red with a bit more on the obverse and a tiny rim clip mint error. Phoenix rising from flames Substitute For Shin Plasters. A similar raw example brought $260 in our February 2014 auction. (300-400) 503 - LOW 46 / HT-57 R1 Raw MS62 Trace Red all on the reverse. Substitute For Shin Plasters 1837 with Phoenix rising from the flames. (200-300) 504 - LOW 49 / HT-73 R2 Raw AU Details Retoned from cleaning. Half Cent Worth Of Pure Copper 1837. Listed in the Half Cent section of the Red Book and always popular. (100-150) 505 - LOW 51 / HT-70 R1 Raw MS62 Nice luster with small stain. The Constitution As I Understand It Roman Firmness Veto with Jackass labeled LLD. (150-200) 506 - LOW 53 / HT-72 R2 Raw AU+ Very nice for issue with considerable luster. The Constitution As I Understand It Roman Firmness Veto with Jackass labeled LLD. A cruder version of the normally encountered variety, likely from a different maker. From the Steve Turns collection, earlier from Superior June 1998. (400-500) 507 - LOW 54 / HT-81 R1 Raw EF Well struck for issue. Very popular 1838 Anti Slavery token that pictures a woman in chains with the legend Am I Not A Woman And A Sister. From the Robert Williams collection. (300-400) 508 - LOW 55 / HT-63 R1 Raw AU+ Very nice for issue. Popular Loco Foco Benton Experiment Mint Drop 1838. Another Raw AU+ brought $413 in our December 2012 auction. From the Robert Williams collection. (400-500) 509 - LOW 58 / HT-16 R1 Raw AU+ With nice luster. Webster Credit Current 1841 with ship labeled Constitution sailing on calm seas. (100-150) 510 - LOW 60 / HT-18 R1 Raw VF Van Buren Metallic Currency with ship labeled Experiment being hit by storm. (25-50) 511 - LOW 62 / HT-20 R1 Raw AU+ Well struck. Van Buren Metallic Current 1837 with ship labeled Experiment crashing on the rocks in a lightning storm. (100-150) 512 - LOW 67 / HT-68 R1 Raw MS62 Specie Payments Suspended May Tenth 1837. (150-200) 513 - LOW 67 / HT-68 R1 Raw MS63 Trace Red with nice toning. Specie Payments Suspended May Tenth 1837. From the Dave Bowers collection. (300-400) 514 - LOW 70 / HT-59 R7 Raw AU Details But porous as nearly always seen on all the Bushnell pieces. Struck over what appears to be a 1780's Connecticut Copper though only the branch-hand and sprig are visible. Weight is 119.2 grains. 1841 Millions For Defense Not One Cent For Tribute. Extremely rare with likely no more than six known. From the Robert Shallowitz, Dave Menchell, John Ford and F. C. C. Boyd collections, earlier for our June 2013 sale where it realized $2,300 and still earlier from Stack's June 2004 sale where it also brought $2,300. (2000-3000) 515 - LOW 81 / HT-200 R4 Raw VF Details Light scratches mainly on the reverse. Howell Work's Garden, Allaire New Jersey. (150-200) 516 - LOW 84 / HT-158 R1 Raw AU+ With nice cartwheel luster. S. B. Schenck 1834 Planing Machine Attleboro, Massachusetts. (100-150) 517 - LOW 92 / HT-353 R1 Raw EF Typical strike and crudeness. Bucklin's Book Keeping, Troy New York 1835. From the Robert Williams collection. (100-150) 518 - LOW 92 / HT-353 R1 Raw FINE+ With a few light marks. Bucklin's Book Keeping, Troy New York 1835. From the Don Boller collection in our July 2012 sale. (25-50) 519 - LOW 93 / HT-355 R4 Raw EF Typical late die state with consequent uneven strike. 1835 Bucklin's Book Keeping, Troy New York signed TRUE ALB under date. Very scarce, variety particularly this nice without problems. We sold a Raw VF Details with light marks that realized $350 in our January 2016 auction. (750-1000) 520 - LOW 95 / HT-291 R1 Raw MS62 Well struck. Merchants Exchange Wall Street New York Millions for Defense Not One Cent for Tribute. Very scarce this nice. (150-200) 521 - LOW 97 / HT-293 R1 Raw MS64 20% Red more so on the reverse. Merchants Exchange Wall Street, New York. From the Robert Williams collection. (200-300) 522 - LOW 98 / HT-294 R1 Raw AU With nice cartwheel luster. Merchants Exchange New York Joint Stock Exchange Wall Street. (75-100) 523 - LOW 99 / HT-216 R1 Raw MS62 . Walsh's General Store, Lansingburgh New York with plow pictured. (200-300) 524 - LOW 103 / HT-154 R3 Raw AU+ R. & W. Robinson Sporting Buttons, Attleboro Massachusetts. Very scarce variety, another Raw AU+ sold for $176 in our December 2012 sale. (200-300) 525 - LOW 105 / HT-156 R4 Raw MS62 With nice luster. R. & W. Robinson Military Buttons American Institute, New York. By far the scarcest of the Low 103 to 105 series, particularly in EF or better. We sold a Raw MS63 in our July 2009 auction that brought $660. From the Robert Williams collection. (500-750) 526 - LOW 107 / HT-219 R1 Raw MS63 10% Red. Henry Anderson Mammoth Boot, New York 1837 picturing a large boot. A less red Raw MS63 brought $255 in our February 2014 auction. From the Robert Williams collection. (300-400) 527 - LOW 110 / HT-239 R1 Raw MS62 Centre Market Accommodations, New York. Very scarce this nice. (150-200) 528 - LOW 111 / HT-240 R1 Raw MS62 20% Red. Centre Market Accommodations, New York. Scarce this nice. Another MS62 brought $210 in our February 2014 sale. From the Steve Turns collection, earlier from Steve Tanenbaum March 2000. (200-300) 529 - LOW 114 / HT-249 R2 Raw MS62 Very well struck for this variety. J. H. Dayton's Union Steam Washing for Hotels and Private Families New York 1837. Rare in Uncirculated, particularly well struck. We sold a very well struck NGC AU50 in our January 2015 sale that realized $235.22. (400-500) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com th th Steve Hayden - Mail Bid Sale #47 - Closing Sunday December 15 and Monday December 16 2019 Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Hard Times Tokens

530 543 544 530 - LOW 117 / HT-262 R3 Raw AU Feuchtwanger's Composition 1837 Three Cents, New York. A PCGS AU55 sold for $2,300 in our December 2016 auction. (1500-2000) 531 - LOW 120 3-E / HT-268 R3 Raw AU+ Feuchtwanger's Composition 1837 One Cent, New York. From the Robert Williams collection. (300-400) 532 - LOW 120 5-G / HT-268 R2 Raw AU Planchet streak mostly on the obverse. Feuchtwanger's Composition One Cent 1837 struck in German Silver. From the Robert Williams collection. (300-400) 533 - LOW 120 6-I / HT-268 R1 Raw AU Feuchtwanger's One Cent 1837 struck in German Silver. From the Robert Williams collection. (200-300) 534 - LOW 125 / HT-289 R2 Raw MS62 S. Maycock Everpointed Pencil Case, New York. Very rare in Uncirculated condition, a Raw MS62 with 10% Red sold for $300 in our March 2010 sale. From the Robert Williams collection. (300-400) 535 - LOW 126 / HT-290 R1 Raw MS64 10% Red and nicely toned. S. Maycock & Co. Everpointed Pencil Case, New York with 1837 Eagle. Rarely seen this nice, we sold a Raw MS62 with 10% Red for $192.50 in our May 2004 auction. (500-750) 536 - LOW 135 / HT-314 R1 Raw AU Smiths Clock Time Is Money, New York. (200-300) 537 - LOW 148 / HT-204 R1 Raw MS61 Nice luster with some small stains and natural planchet flaws. T. Duseaman Butcher, Belleville New Jersey. Popular token with both US and Canadian collectors due to the Bouquet Sou reverse. Very rare in Uncirculated condition. A Raw AU brought $200 in our October 2011 sale. Breton 670. From the Doug Robins collection. (300-400) 538 - LOW 180 / HT-205A R4 Raw AU+ Bergen Iron Works Store, Lakewood New Jersey. Struck in Copper and much rarer than the Brass variety, particularly this nice. A well struck EF+ brought $351 in our December 2017 auction. From the Robert Williams collection. (400-500) 539 - LOW 192 / HT-79 R2 Raw EF+ Sharply struck. Henry Clay United We Stand. Very unusually well struck for variety with not just complete WE but a sharp WE, even with a die sinkers centering dot visible between the W and E. Dewitt HC 1840-1. From the Robert Williams collection. (400-500) 540 - LOW 239 / HT-247 R6 Raw EF Day, Newell & Day Manufacturer of Locks, Bolts & Hinges, New York signed W&B NY for Wright and Bale. Very scarce variety, a Raw FINE+ sold for $407 in our July 2007 sale. (750-1000) 541 - LOW 245F / HT-258C R7 Raw AU Details 10% Bright with 30% original Gilt plating and short scratch above Liberty. Doremus, Suydam & Nixon, New York struck in Gilt Brass with reeded edge. From the Robert Williams and Don Boller collections, earlier from our July 2012 sale where it realized $366. (400-500) 542 - LOW 255 / HT-278 R4 Raw EF Details Retoned from cleaning. Dr. J. G. Hewett Bone Setter Practice Confined to Dislocations, Sprains, Contractions, Rheumatism, White Swellings, Weakness of the Limbs and etc., New York. Very scarce and popular variety that almost always comes well worn and often with problems, whereas the following is usually seen in Uncirculated condition. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections. (300-400) 543 - LOW 256 / HT-279 R3 Raw MS64 50% Red. Dr. J. G. Hewett Bone Setter Practice Confined to Dislocations, Sprains, Contractions, Rheumatism, White Swellings, Weakness of the Limbs and etc., New York. Interestingly this variety is almost always found in Uncirculated condition while Low 255 / HT-278 is almost always found in worn condition. From the Robert Williams collection, earlier from our March 2008 sale where it realized $673.20. The collector has since been removed from its prior NGC holder. (750-1000) 544 - LOW 260 / HT-285A R6 Raw AU 10% Bright with 20% of gilt remaining. Wm. G. Jones Union Coal Office, New York. Rare variety and merchant. From the Robert Williams and Don Boller collections, earlier from our July 2012 sale where it realized $926.60. (1000-1500) 545 - LOW 261 / HT-286 R2 Raw EF+ Or a bit better but a bit weak near rims as usual. H. Law Baker English Bread, Twist & Fancy Cakes, New York. From the Robert Williams and Ron Ward collections, earlier from our July 2012 auction where it brought $285 and even earlier from Rod Burress in 1995. (300-400) 546 - LOW 262 / HT-287 R5 Raw EF Well struck for issue. Leverett & Thomas Circular Saws, New York. Very scarce merchant, particularly this nice. From the Robert Williams collection. (400-500) 547 - LOW 271 / HT-363 R1 Raw EF J. & C. Peck Tin Machines, Troy New York with one of their machines pictured. From the Robert Williams collection. (100-150) 548 - LOW 279 / HT-318 R6 Raw VF+ Squire & Merritt Ship Chandlers and Rope Makers, New York. This is die combination 1-A with a Plain edge and no address counterstamp. Much scarcer than the counterstamped variety. From the Robert Williams collection. (200-300) 549 - LOW 285 / HT-332 R5 Raw AU Details Retoned from cleaning. Hy Suydam & Wm Boyd Hosiery 187 Pearl St., New York. A Raw EF Details with some light staining brought $550 in our July 2012 sale. From the Robert Williams collection, earlier from our December 2006 auction where it brought $305 still earlier from PCAC's December 1989 auction. (750-1000)

550 556 561 550 - LOW 287 / HT-336 R2 Raw MS63 Trace Red. Van Nostrand & Dwight Book Sellers, 146 Nassau St., New York, NY struck with Reeded edge. Underrated variety, a Raw MS62 sold for $425 in our September 2014 sale. From the Robert Williams collection. (500-750) 551 - LOW 291 / HT-102 R2 Raw AU+ Fobes & Barlow Veneers, New Haven Connecticut. From the Robert Williams collection. (200-300) 552 - LOW 300 / HT-181 R1 Raw VF+ John J. Adams Brushes, Taunton Massachusetts with running boar pictured. (50-75) 553 - LOW 305 / HT-101 R3 Raw EF Details With a couple of light reverse hairlines. Davenport Combs and Perfumery, New Haven Connecticut. Underrated merchant, an EF brought $467.50 in our June 2011 auction. From the Robert Williams and Richard Crosby collections, earlier from our July 2012 sale where it realized $266. (300-400) 554 - LOW 310 / HT-254 R6 Raw UNC Details With scattered light marks and short scratches. Doremus, Suydam & Nixon, New York with 309 Pearl Street address signed W. & B. N.Y. in Gilt Copper with Plain edge. Very rare location for this merchant with most examples quite worn with problems. From the Maurice Shepherd, earlier from Chuck Kirtley December 1998 sale. (750-1000) 555 - LOW 321 / HT-295 R2 Raw MS63 20% Red. James G. Moffet Brass Founder, New York with charmingly crude die work featuring a backwards N and S in E Pluribus Unum. A Raw MS62 sold for $270 in our August 2015 sale. From the Steve Turns collection, earlier from us privately in February 2000. (400-500) 556 - LOW 323 / HT-297 R2 Raw MS62 James G. Moffet Brass Founder, New York with charmingly crude die work featuring backwards N's and S's and Pluribus spelled incorrectly. Much scarcer than the proceeding, particularly in Uncirculated condition. From the John Ford collection, earlier from F. C. C. Boyd May 1957 (400-500) 557 - LOW 324 / HT-212 R5 Raw EF Very well struck for merchant. Patterson Bros., Buffalo New York with Padlock and Anvil. This is the much scarcer Plain edge variety, a Raw VF Details with a few light marks sold for $165 in our March 2008 auction. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection, earlier from Leslie Heilbronner January 1974. (300-400) 558 - LOW 324A / HT-212A R2 Raw VF Patterson Brothers, Buffalo New York featuring an anvil and padlock. (25-50) 559 - LOW 327 / HT-170 R7 Raw VF Nicely struck for variety and slightly off center as often seen on a 29.5mm planchet. William Rutter Songs and Ballads Boston Massachusetts. Rare variety usually seen in lower grades and/or damaged, this example is a happy exception. Nearly as nice as the Raw VF+ example that brought $711 in our January 2016 auction. (500-750) 560 - LOW 328 / HT-171 R1 Raw MS62 Alfred D. Willard, Boston Massachusetts with vintage comb pictured. From the Robert Williams collection. (150-200) 561 - LOW 344 / HT-118 R7 Raw AU Gasquet Parish & Co., New Orleans Louisiana. Very rare merchant. A Raw EF Details lightly cleaned example realized $2,000 in our July 2006 sale. More recently a stained and scratched EF45 sold for $3,055 and an NGC UNC Details Improperly Cleaned with seemingly other problems brought $4,700 both in Stack's August 2013 offering of the Ford collection. (4000-6000)

562 563 564 562 - LOW 360 / HT-280 R7 Raw EF Benjamin Hooks 276 Broome Street Corner Allen St. with bust of Benjamin Franklin signed Bale on reverse. Benjamin Hooks is listed as a Hatter at 276 Broome Street in the 1840 edition of Longworth's City Directory. A nice problem free example worthy of a premium bid. An NGC AU55 sold for $6,452.50 in StacksBowers August 2013 auction. (4000-6000) 563 - LOW 365 / HT-339 R8 Raw AU Richard Williams Union Hall New York Good For Refreshment At The Bar with Odd Fellow heart in hand symbol on obverse and signed Bale on reverse. Despite Ford having three examples this is a very rare merchant. We can only account for six. This piece compares quite favorably to the NGC AU55 Dice-Hicks specimen that realized $4,230 in Stacks Bowers March 2016 sale. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections from Robert Vlack October 1983. (3000-4000) 564 - LOW 372A / HT-301 R7 Raw EF Sharp but dark with green verdigris spots. N-York & Harlaem Railroad Company struck in Copper and signed by Bale and Smith. Very rare token. Overall superior to the Rulau plate token as it has a rather large punch mark affecting both sides. From the Robert Williams collection, earlier from our July 2012 auction where it realized $2,390. (3000-4000) 565 - LOW 383 / HT-410 R4 Raw VF Details Porous and cleaned. Samuel & Joseph Harvey Cutlery, Philadelphia Pennsylvania. (75-100)

566 567 571 566 - LOW 384A / HT-421A R5 Raw MS63 Proof Like. James Watson, Philadelphia Pennsylvania struck in Gilt Brass with reeded edge. From the Robert Williams collection, earlier from our July 2012 sale where it brought $1,250. (1500-2000) 567 - LOW 385 / HT-411 R6 Raw AU+ 40% Bright. This example is Gilt with 90% of plating remaining and unlisted as such. Hooper, Martin & Smith Hardware & Cutlery 113 Market Street, Philadelphia Pennsylvania. Rare merchant, particularly this nice. From the Robert Williams collection, earlier from our July 2012 auction where it brought $900. (1000-1500) 568 - LOW 386B / HT-417B R7 Raw EF Trace Bright more than 10% original Gilt remaining. Smith & Brothers Cutlery, Philadelphia. From the Robert Williams collection, earlier from our June 2013 sale where it realized $354. (400-500) 569 - LOW 389A / HT-215C Unlisted Raw UNC Details With a number of light scratches many of which may be in fact planchet scratches. L. Robinson Rifle Trimmings And Gunnery, Chittenango New York struck in Copper Nickel with a Plain edge. While the die combination is known in both Copper and White Metal, this is neither. A Raw AU Detail example with Tin Pest of the much more available White Metal variety brought $600 in our December 2017 sale. From the John J. Ford collection. (750-1000) 570 - LOW 392 / HT-337 R3 Raw AU C. H. Webb Congress Hall Hotel, New York struck in Copper. A Raw EF+ sold for $232 in our December 2012 sale. From the Robert Williams collection. (300-400) 571 - LOW 398A / HT-385A R6 Raw MS63 40% Bright with full Gilt Plating. Isaac Barton & Co., Philadelphia Pennsylvania. Very scarce variety with Gilt Plating and reeded edge, rare in Uncirculated condition with this likely the finest known. From the Robert Williams collection, earlier from our July 2012 sale where it brought $2,176 in competitive bidding. (2000-3000)

572 578 580 572 - LOW 400B / HT-141 R4 Raw EF Coin EF+ with nice even counterstamp. HOUCK'S / PANACEA / BALTIMORE in raised letters within an oblong depression on the obverse of an 1832 Half Dollar. From the Tony Terranova collection, earlier from Stack's March 2006 sale where it brought $1,380. (1000-1500) 573 - HT-213 R5 Raw AU W. A. Thomson, Buffalo New York popular large size token picturing a large anvil and hammer. One of the nicest examples we have seen offered. Unlisted in Low. (400-500) 574 - HT-214 R4 Raw AU Details Some very light scratches above the anvil. W. A. Thomson, Buffalo New York picturing a large anvil and Tea Pot. Unlisted in Low. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (100-150) 575 - HT-415B R4 Raw EF Coin FINE. H. REES on the obverse of an 1831 Large Cent. Rees was a Philadelphia blacksmith in the late 1830's. From the Dave Bowers reference collection. (75-100) 576 - HT-571A R8 Raw EF H. Disston Philadelphia Pennsylvania with blank reverse. Henry Disston saw maker in Philadelphia in the early 1840's. Very rare merchant. (500-750) 577 - HT-815 R4 Raw AU Details Holed for suspension with some hairlines from cleaning. Maj. Genl W. H. Harrison The Peoples Choice In The Year 1840. A Raw AU+ sold for $90 in our January 2016 sale. DeWitt WHH 1840-50. (50-75) 578 - HT-Unlisted Raw FINE+ J. C. Kelsey G 6 ¼ Cts struck in Brass, 18mm. Unlisted Hard Times era merchant very similar to the listed S. Feather Norristown Pennsylvania and J. Nicolls Philadelphia. All three have the mysterious G proceeding the denomination and all three were issued in the relatively odd 6 ¼ denomination (half bit) the S. Feather also being known as 12 ½. This piece is still not attributed to a specific business though Steve Tanenbaum noted "1830 Census Huntington" PA? on his holder. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection from Richard Rossa February 2006. (1000-1500) 579 - HT-Unlisted Raw VF S B 3 Cts. with eagle on reverse struck in Lead, 16mm. Unlisted Hard Time era token with eagle reverse very similar to HT-310 San Souci and HT-310E "PB" maverick. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection, earlier from PCAC's December 2004 sale where it sold for $747.50. (300-400) 580 - HT-Unlisted Raw VF+ Forrest House with eagle on reverse struck in Lead, 16mm. Unlisted Hard Time era token with eagle reverse very similar to HT-310 San Souci and HT-310E "PB" maverick. Steve Tanenbaum notes "34 Spring St NYC 1835" on his holder though it is a bit smudged and could be 24 Spring Street. From the Steve Tanenbaum and Lionel Rudduck collections, earlier from Bowers & Merena. (500-750) 581 - HT-Unlisted Raw VG I M C with eagle on reverse struck in Brass, 17mm. Unlisted Hard Times era token with eagle meant for a much larger token. From the Steve Tanenbaum and Charles Litman collections. (300-400)

592 597 603 592 - MILLER DE 2 Raw EF J. Randel Jr. C. & D. Canal 1825, Delaware. Randel was the chief engineer for the Chesapeake and Delaware Canal. Very rare and missing from the Ford, and nearly every other, collection. Rulau-E Del 2. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection, earlier from Paul Koppenhaver February 2005. (750-1000) 593 - MILLER IL 1 Raw MS63 20% Bright with straight planchet clip. John Plane & Co. 1856, Belvidere Illinois with anvil and stove pictured. Struck in Brass with a plain edge. Rare mint error, straight planchet clip. (150-200) 594 - MILLER IL 8N Raw VF+ 1846 surrounded by stars and leaves with a watch face on the reverse struck in Copper with a Plain edge. Some interesting speculation; could the star and leaf punches on this token be meant to represent Biela's Comet which was scheduled to arrive in 1846. Seen approaching in late 1845 it was observed the comet had split, with two portions then visible. Though it has not been seen since 1852 it is thought to have caused subsequent meteor showers. In what seems too strange to be a coincidence, in 1883 Ignatius Donnelly speculated that just such a meteor shower remnant of Biela's Comet caused the Great Chicago fire of 1871. That fire occurred at half past nine on the evening of October 8th when "at apparently the same moment, at points hundreds of kilometers apart, in three different states, Wisconsin, Michigan, and Illinois, fires of the most peculiar and devastating kind broke out." This token of course is thought to have been made and used in Chicago during 1846 but has long remained a mystery. Rare and quite intriguing. We sold a Raw VF in our December 2017 sale that realized $177.75. Rulau Ill 100. From Bowers & Merena's November 1990 sale. (200-300) 595 - MILLER IL 40 Raw EF Peter Stumps, Chicago Illinois struck in Brass with a Reeded edge. Popular token featuring a vintage Fireman's Hat thought to have been issued in 1859. We sold a Raw MS63 that brought $275 in our January 2016 auction. (75-100) 596 - RULAU IL-El 9 Raw AU+ 30% Bright. Made By The National Elgin Watch Co. Chicago Exposition 1873, Elgin Illinois struck in White Metal, Plain edge with exposition building and detailed clock face pictured. (50-75) 597 - MILLER LA Unlisted Raw FINE Details Holed. Metairie Jockey Club Members Medal Not Transferable 1851 struck in Silver with Plain edge. The Metairie Jockey Club was in Metairie Louisiana and not New York City as listed in Rulau as NY A562. Not pictured in Rulau and Steve Tanenbaum believed there were no more than three known. He had a somewhat nicer example, also holed, that is now in the Steve Hayden collection. From the Steve Hayden and Charles Litman collections. (1500-2000) 598 - MILLER MD 67 Raw MS62 10% Bright with full Silvering. Chas. W. Hamill & Co. 1880, Baltimore Maryland signed F. X. Kohler and struck in Silvered White Metal with Plain edge. Popular with Morgan Dollar style Liberty head. Rulau MD-Ba 46. (100-150)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com th th Steve Hayden - Mail Bid Sale #47 - Closing Sunday December 15 and Monday December 16 2019 Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Merchant Tokens 599 - RULAU MA Bo 14 Raw AU+ 10% Bright. Henry W. Burr & Co. Rubber Goods 37 Milk St., Boston Massachusetts struck in White Metal with Plain edge, 31mm. Thought to be Unique in this composition as it is usually struck in Hard Rubber. Burr was in business at 37 Milk Street from 1863 to 1866 and consequently it is listed in the Possible Civil War Store Card section of the current Civil War token book. From the Steve Tanenbaum and Dave Shenkman collections, earlier from Paul Koppenhaver's October 1977 sale. (500-750) 600 - MILLER MA 30 Raw FINE Struck on a smaller than adequate 28mm planchet, as were all, resulting in most letters being at least partially missing. Currier & Greeley, Boston Mass Not One Cent But Just As Good struck in Copper with Plain edge. The reverse pictured in Rulau under MA 30 and MA 31-32 are different. This has the MA 31-32 reverse unlike what Rulau describes. Very rare. An NGC EF40 with similar weakness, though in different areas, brought $411.25 in August 2013. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection, earlier from Paul Koppenhaver's February 1979 sale. (150-200) 601 - MILLER MA 55 Raw AU Jos. H. Merriam Medalist Die Sinker And Cutter, Boston Massachusetts struck in Copper 27mm with Plain edge with George Washington reverse die signed M for Merriam. Baker 560 GW-685. (75-100) 602 - MILLER MA 57 Raw MS63 30% Bright and nearly Proof Like. Jos. H. Merriam Medalist Die Sinker And Cutter, Boston Massachusetts struck in White Metal with Plain edge with George Washington reverse die signed M for Merriam. From the Dave Bowers and Fred Reed collections. (200-300) 603 - MILLER MA 59 Raw MS65 50% Red and nearly Proof Like. Jos. H. Merriam Die Sinker Boston Massachusetts with Daniel Webster reverse struck in Copper with Plain edge 31mm. Rare in any composition, a Raw MS63 in White Metal realized $331 in our August 2015 sale. Rulau Ma Bo 65. (500-750) 604 - MILLER MA 90 Raw EF H. B. Stanwood & Co. Diamonds, Boston Massachusetts struck in Brass with Reeded edge. (25-50) 605 - RULAU Ma Bos 119A Raw MS62 20% Red. White Brothers & Company Willow Calf, Boston Massachusetts struck in Copper with Plain edge. Unholed and almost unheard of as such. (25-50) 606 - RULAU MA 526 Raw FINE Details Holed with marks, scratches and Tin Pest. Hamilton & Capin China Glass Crockery and Solar Lamps, Springfield Massachusetts with 1851 Crystal Palace reverse struck in White Metal with Plain edge, 31mm. Very rare merchant not listed in Adams, Miller or Storer. We sold a Raw EF in our June 2012 sale that realized $150. (25-50) 607 - RULAU NJ AC 3 Raw MS63 40% Bright. Applegate's Palace of Flying Animals, Atlantic City New Jersey struck in Brass with Plain edge. Rarely seen this nice. Formerly thought to be Philadelphia and listed by Miller as PA 23. (150-200) 608 - MILLER NJ 12 Raw VF+ Warrick & Stanger 1872, Glassboro New Jersey struck in Brass with Plain Edge. Unlisted merchant in Rulau. (25-50) 609 - MILLER NY 34A Raw EF Holed for suspension as usual. A. D. Sharpe Dry Goods, Jamestown New York with Grover Cleveland on reverse struck in Brass with Plain edge, 15mm. Unlisted in Adams this merchant also issued a very similar token with Blaine on reverse instead of 1884 political rival Cleveland. (100-150) 610 - MILLER NY 67 Raw VF+ 80% original Copper plating remaining. Samuel N. Black Electrotype, New York dated 1860 with obverse similar to a Braided Hair Large Cent struck in Copper Plated Lead with Plain edge. (25-50) 611 - RULAU NY NY 42 Raw MS63 D. S. Brown & Co. Fine Soaps, New York struck in Wood with Plain edge and eagle on reverse, 26mm and very thick at 8mm. A very unusual token unlisted in Adams and Miller. (50-75)

612 614 650 612 - MILLER NY 189 Raw MS64 40% Red all on the Collector side. John Curtis mule of Great Eastern ship entering New York harbor with popular 1859 dated Antiquary reverse with collector studying coins with a magnifying glass struck in Copper with Reeded edge. (400-500) 613 - MILLER NY 210 Raw EF With full Copper plating. Philip A. Dougherty Good For 6 Cents dated 1859 with obverse similar to an Indian Head Cent. (100-150) 614 - MILLER NY 239 Raw MS62 30% Bright. Female Preventive Or Morsonic Amulet struck in White Metal 35mm Plain edge. Unlike the more commonly known Boyd's Battery who's wearer was promised purified blood, this Amulet was apparently worn or carried by a pregnant woman to assure a male (More Sons) rather than a female birth. This piece is White Metal while most others were made in three layers, two brass with a lead or other white metal center. Perhaps that unusual composition was needed to generate the needed magnetic or electric fields required to perform the advertised task. Possibly made for collectors or as a die trial, exceedingly rare and one of the classic rarities in the Merchant token series that is only represented in Rulau with line drawings. We sold a Raw MS62 of the Brass sandwich type in our March 2008 sale for $3,300. From John Ford and F. C. C. Boyd collections March 1958, earlier from our December 2017 sale where it realized $1,300. (1500-2000) 615 - MILLER NY 295A Raw VF+ A. W. Hardie Draper and Taylor, New York struck in Brass with a Plain edge. Rulau lists as quite rare at R8 and dates it to the 1826-27 time period. We have yet to see the R7 Reeded edge variety. A Raw EF Detail dark and porous example sold for $100 in our December 2012 sale. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection, earlier from Chili Coin Company October 1976. (150-200) 616 - MILLER NY 308 Raw MS62 30% Bright. E. Hill Dealer In Coins, Medals, Minerals, Autographs, Engravings, Old Curiosities & c. New York 1860 struck in White Metal with Plain edge and George Washington reverse. Baker 542 From the Dave Bowers and David Litrenta collections. (150-200) 617 - MILLER NY 308 Raw MS62 30% Bright. E. Hill Dealer In Coins, Medals, Minerals, Autographs, Engravings, Old Curiosities & c. New York 1860 struck in White Metal with Plain edge and George Washington reverse. Baker 542 From the Dave Bowers collection. (150-200)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com th th Steve Hayden - Mail Bid Sale #47 - Closing Sunday December 15 and Monday December 16 2019 Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Merchant Tokens 618 - MILLER NY 316 Raw MS62 20% Bright. E. Hill Dealer In Coins, Medals, Minerals, Autographs, Engravings, Old Curiosities & c. New York 1860 struck in White Metal with Plain edge and stage actor Edwin Forrest on reverse. From the Dave Bowers and David Litrenta collections. (100-150) 619 - MILLER NY 316 Raw UNC Details 20% Bright with a patch of Tin Pest on the obverse. E. Hill Dealer In Coins, Medals, Minerals, Autographs, Engravings, Old Curiosities & c. New York 1860 struck in White Metal with Plain edge and stage actor Edwin Forrest on reverse. From the Dave Bowers collection. (50-75) 620 - MILLER NY 324 Raw MS64 50% Bright and nearly Proof Like. E. Hill Dealer In Coins, Medals, Minerals, Autographs, Engravings, Old Curiosities & c. New York 1860 struck in White Metal with Reeded edge. Reverse shows Cupid riding a spouting Sea Monster. An NGC MS62 brought $285 in our February 2014 auction. From the Dave Bowers and David Litrenta collections. (300-400) 621 - MILLER NY 340 Raw MS62 20% Bright. E. Hill Dealer In Coins, Medals, Minerals, Autographs, Engravings, Old Curiosities & c. New York 1860 struck in White Metal with Plain edge and Virtue Liberty & Independence reverse. From the Dave Bowers and David Litrenta collections. (150-200) 622 - MILLER NY 357 Raw MS62 Trace Red. Charles D. Horter Die Sinker and Engraver, New York with detailed view of his establishment on reverse struck in Copper with Plain edge. Very scarce and not pictured in Rulau. An AU+ sold for $186 in our June 2013 auction. From the Dave Bowers and David Litrenta collections. (200-300) 623 - MILLER NY 359 Raw AU+ Houghton, Merrell & Co., New York struck in Brass with Plain edge and Umbrellas and Parasol reverse. Underrated merchant difficult to get above EF or without problems. An EF with light scratch brought $47 in our February 2014 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. (75-100) 624 - MILLER NY 383 Raw MS65 50% Bright. Jennings, Wheeler & Co., 43 Chambers St., New York with clasped hands struck in Brass with Reeded edge. A raw MS64 realized $120 in our July 2014 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. (150-200) 625 - MILLER NY 383 Raw MS63 30% Bright. Jennings, Wheeler & Co., 43 Chambers St., New York with clasped hands struck in Brass with Reeded edge. From the Dave Bowers collection. (75-100) 626 - MILLER NY 388 Raw MS63 30% Bright. Jennings, Wheeler & Co., 45 & 47 Chambers St., New York with nice pictorial map of North America labeled Clothing For The U. States and Free Trade For This Continent below. Struck in Brass with Plain edge. (50-75) 627 - MILLER NY 388A Raw MS63 20% Bright. Jennings, Wheeler & Co., 45 & 47 Chambers St., New York with nice pictorial map of North America labeled Clothing For The U. States and Free Trade For This Continent below. Struck in Brass with Reeded edge. From the Dave Bowers and David Litrenta collections. (100-150) 628 - MILLER NY 418 Raw UNC Details 10% Bright with somewhat rough surfaces as usual. M. Leask Real Lace, New York struck in White Metal with Plain edge. Struck in a very soft White Metal and consequently very difficult to obtain in nice condition. One of the finest known for this variety. (50-75) 629 - MILLER NY 487 Raw MS62 10% Bright. Geo. H. Lovett Medal Die-Sinker, New York with reverse of Cupid being followed by Sea Serpent struck in Brass with Reeded edge. Much rarer than the White Metal examples for this die combination. From the Dave Bowers collection. (150-200) 630 - MILLER NY 502 Raw MS63 20% Bright. J. D. Lovett Wedding & Visiting Cards, Seals, Dies, Jewelry Engraved with New Congress Hall 1860 struck in Brass with Reeded edge. An MS62 brought $120 in our December 2012 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. (200-300) 631 - MILLER NY 503 Raw MS62 30% Bright. J. D. Lovett Engraver, New York muling with 1860 dated Congress Hall reverse struck in Brass with Reeded edge. Obverse has seal press pictured with head of a Lion. An example in MS62 sold for $277.20 in our July 2009 auction. From the Dave Bowers and David Litrenta collections. (300-400) 632 - MILLER NY 506 Raw MS63 40% Bright. R. Lovett Stone Seal Engraver & Medalist, New York with attractive Benjamin Franklin portrait on reverse struck in Brass with Plain edge. Very scarce and popular. Another Raw MS63 example brought $180 in our December 2017 sale. (200-300) 633 - MILLER NY 510 Raw MS62 30% Bright. E. Lyon Magnetic Powder & Pills For Insects & Rats, 424 Broadway New York struck in Brass with Reeded edge smaller 22mm size. From the Dave Bowers and David Litrenta collections. (50-75) 634 - MILLER NY 515 Raw MS65 70% Red with obverse nearly Proof Like. Malcolm & Gaul British, French and American Dry Goods, New York struck in Copper with Plain edge. From the Dave Bowers and David Litrenta collections. (200-300) 635 - MILLER NY 516 Raw MS65 60% Bright. Malcolm & Gaul British, French and American Dry Goods, New York struck in Brass with Reeded edge. From the Dave Bowers and David Litrenta collections. (150-200) 636 - MILLER NY 517 Raw MS64 20% Bright, toned with nearly full Silvering and nearly Proof Like obverse. Malcolm & Gaul British, French and American Dry Goods, New York struck in Silvered Brass with Plain edge. This variety appears to be much scarcer than NY 515 or NY 516. From the Dave Bowers and David Litrenta collections. (100-150) 637 - MILLER NY 537A Raw EF+ Merritt & Langley Dey Street House Dining Saloon 2 shillings and 9 Pence struck in German Silver with Plain edge. Underrated merchant. From the Dave Bowers and David Litrenta collections. (75-100) 638 - MILLER NY 552 Raw EF Merritt & Langley Dey Street House Dining Saloon, 54 & 56 Dey St. New York 2 Shillings 6 Pence struck in German Silver with Plain edge. Underrated merchant. From the Dave Bowers and David Litrenta collections. (75-100) 639 - MILLER NY 560B Raw FINE+ A bit unevenly struck as usual. Meschutt's Metropolitan Coffee Room 433 Broadway New York City incused on a White Metal Plain edge planchet with denomination 15 (Pence) stamped on both sides along with a star figure. This denomination is Unlisted and those known to us now includes 3, 9, 15, 18, 1/- and 1/9 with the later two indicating Shillings and Pence. It is interesting to note than 15 could just as well have been 1/3 and likewise 18 as 1/6 not to mention 1/- as 12. Perhaps there was a method to this seeming madness. From the John Ford collection, earlier from Paul Koppenhaver's June 1978 sale. (150-200) 640 - MILLER NY 589 Raw VF+ Moss' Hotel, New York with 6d (6 Pence) on reverse struck in Brass with Plain edge. From the Dave Bowers and David Litrenta collections. (75-100) 641 - MILLER NY 600 Raw EF+ Moss' Hotel, New York 3 Shillings 3 Pence struck in Brass with Plain edge. From the Dave Bowers and David Litrenta collections. (50-75) 642 - MILLER NY 601A Raw VF Moss' Hotel, New York with 3 / 6 on each side for 3 Shillings 6 Pence with no merchant name struck in Brass with Plain edge. From the Dave Bowers and David Litrenta collections. (50-75)

653 663 670 653 - MILLER NY 820C Raw MS64 40% Bright and nearly Proof Like. F. B. Smith & Hartmann Die Sinkers, New York with Indian Chief in feathered headdress on one side and The Great Trotting Stallion George M. Patchen on the reverse struck in Brass with a Reeded edge on a 3mm thick planchet as usual. Very attractive and popular token. A raw MS62 sold for $259.99 in our August 2015 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. (400-500) 654 - MILLER NY 826F Raw MS63 20% Red. Smithsonian House 606 Broadway muled with A. D. Thompson Dining Saloon struck in Copper with a Plain edge. Quite scarce. From the Dave Bowers and David Litrenta collections. (150-200) 655 - MILLER NY 833 Raw MS63 20% Red. Lewis L. Squire & Sons Ship Chandlers, New York struck in Copper on a thick 2+mm Plain edge planchet. We sold a similar Raw example for $125 in our July 2012 auction. From the Dave Bowers and David Litrenta collections. (100-150) 656 - MILLER NY 840A - P Raw EF Jos. Stiner & Co. Established 1840 ½ denomination all incused with P counterstamp. Much scarcer than the ¼ denominations. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection. (50-75) 657 - MILLER NY 847 Raw AU Strasburger & Nunn Importers New York Spiel Marke struck in Brass with Reeded edge 34mm. Unlisted by Rulau. A scarce piece with reverse design of a Gold Double Eagle. From the Dave Bowers and David Litrenta collections. (75-100) 658 - MILLER NY 863 Raw MS62 20% Red. Sweeny's Hotel with Smithsonian House reverse struck in Copper with Plain edge, 26mm as usual rather than 30mm suggested in Rulau. A Raw MS62 brought $90 in our June 2013 sale. From the Dave Bowers and David Litrenta collections. (100-150) 659 - MILLER NY 921A Raw AU Trace Bright with 70% Silvering remaining. Tredwell Kissam & Co. Looking Glasses, New York struck in Silvered Brass with a Reeded edge. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection. (150-200) 660 - MILLER NY 949 Raw EF Details Holed. H. B. West's Famous Trained Dogs, New York with obverse image of two dogs Tray & Troy pulling a man in a carriage struck in Brass with a Reeded edge. (0-25) 661 - MILLER NY 949A Raw MS64 20% Bright more so on the reverse, lightly toned on the obverse. H. B. West's Famous Trained Dogs, New York struck in Silver Plated Brass with Plain edge and two dogs pulling man in a carriage on the obverse. Very popular and this variety is quite scarce. We sold a raw MS62 for $110 in our August 2015 auction. From the Dave Bowers and David Litrenta collections. (200-300) 662 - MILLER NY 954 Raw EF Details Holed with a few light marks. Willis & Brothers Hardware Cutlery & Earthenware China, 215 Pearl St, New York struck in White Metal (Tin) with a Reeded edge. Rulau dates this token to 1829 to 1833 based on an 276 Pearl Street address not on the token. Our research indicates they were at the 215 Pearl Street address subsequently from 1834 to 1838 putting them squarely in the Hard Times period. Called Very Rare by Adams and Miller with this being the Rulau plate specimen. We know of no other example. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection, earlier from Bowers & Merena's March 2000 sale. (400-500)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com th th Steve Hayden - Mail Bid Sale #47 - Closing Sunday December 15 and Monday December 16 2019 Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Merchant Tokens 663 - MILLER NY 961 Raw VF+ C. Wolfe, Spies & Clark Military Store, New York with George Washington struck in Brass with Plain edge. Long considered a classic rarity in the early merchant token series. From the Steve Tanenbaum and Gilbert Steinberg collections, earlier from Stack's May 1992 sale. (750-1000) 664 - MILLER NY 964 Raw VF Wood's Minstrels Warranted Pure Silver Intrinsic Value 25 Cts., New York struck in Silver with a Plain edge. One of very few circulating Silver tokens ever made in the US. (50-75) 665 - MILLER NY 969 Raw MS64 70% Red. Woodgate & Co. Wines, New York 1860 Represtd By J. N. T. Levick struck in Copper with a Reeded edge. From the Dave Bowers and David Litrenta collections. (200-300) 666 - MILLER NY 969 Raw MS63 30% Red. Woodgate & Co. Wines, New York 1860 Represtd By J. N. T. Levick struck in Copper with a Reeded edge. From the Dave Bowers collection. (150-200) 667 - MILLER NY 970 Raw MS62 30% Bright. Woodgate & Co. Wines, New York 1860 Represtd By J. N. T. Levick struck in Brass with a Reeded edge. From the Dave Bowers collection. (150-200) 668 - MILLER NY 973 Raw MS63 40% Bright. Woodgate & Co. Brandies New York 1860 struck in Brass with Reeded edge and George Washington reverse. Baker 593B From the Dave Bowers and David Litrenta collections. (200-300) 669 - MILLER NY 998 Raw MS62 10% Bright mainly on the Virtue side. Woodgate & Co. Brandies New York 1860 struck in Brass with Plain edge and Virtue Liberty & Independence reverse. From the Dave Bowers collection. (150-200) 670 - MILLER NY 1008 Raw MS64 40% Red. M. L. Marshall's Variety Store 1860, Oswego New York with man fly fishing along a mountain stream struck in Copper with Plain edge. From the Dave Bowers and David Litrenta collections. (500-750) 671 - MILLER NY 1009 Raw MS64 20% Bright. M. L. Marshall's Variety Store 1860, Oswego New York with man fly fishing along a mountain stream struck in Brass with Plain edge. From the Dave Bowers collection. (400-500) 672 - MILLER NY 1010 Raw MS60 40% Bright with some minor Tin Pest. M. L. Marshall's Variety Store 1860, Oswego New York with man fly fishing along a mountain stream struck in White Metal with Plain edge. From the Dave Bowers collection. (200-300) 673 - MILLER NY 1019 Raw MS60 10% Bright. Olcott & Brother Locomotive Head Lights, Rochester New York struck in Brass with Reeded edge and railroad headlamp pictured. From the Dave Bowers collection. (75-100) 674 - MILLER NY 1021 Raw MS62 10% Bright and nearly full Silvering. Olcott & Brother Locomotive Head Lights, Rochester New York struck in Silvered Brass with Reeded edge and railroad headlamp pictured. From the Dave Bowers collection. (75-100) 675 - MILLER NY 1022 Raw AU+ 40% Bright. Frederick Starr Sheet Music, Rochester New York State Fair 1851 struck in Brass with Plain edge and piano pictured. Very scarce this nice. (50-75) 676 - MILLER NY 1024 Raw MS62 20% Bright. William R. Brown, Saratoga Springs New York struck in Brass with a Reeded edge. Rare in Uncirculated condition. From the Dave Bowers collection. (100-150) 677 - MILLER NY 1029 Raw MS64 40% Red. A. C. Yates Clothing Store, Syracuse New York struck in Copper with Plain edge and a well dressed portly old man in spectacles holding a store placard on the obverse. From the Dave Bowers and David Litrenta collections. (150-200) 678 - MILLER NY 1061A Raw MS63 10% Red. S.W. Chubbuck Telegraph, Chemical & Philosophical Apparatus, Utica New York struck in Copper with a Reeded edge. Popular token that has a key to the Morse Code alphabet. On this die variety, lines four and five of the key are curved rather than straight. From the Dave Bowers and David Litrenta collections. (300-400) 679 - MILLER NY 1064 Raw MS62 10% Bright. T. L. Kingsley & Son Great Wardrobe Clothing, Utica New York struck in Brass with a Reeded edge. From the Dave Bowers collection. (50-75) 680 - MILLER NY 1068 Raw EF C. A. M. Smith, Windsor New York One Cent with the look of the reverse of a US Large Cent struck in Copper with Plain edge. From the Dave Bowers collection. (75-100) 681 - MILLER OH 10½ Raw EF+ F. Eckstein Jr. One Glass Soda, Cincinnati with fountain pictured struck in Copper with a Plain edge. From the Dave Bowers and David Litrenta collections. (75-100) 682 - MILLER OH 11 Raw MS64 70% Bright. S. C. Erwin Hatter, Cincinnati Ohio struck in Brass with Plain edge and top hat pictured. From the Dave Bowers and David Litrenta collections. (75-100) 683 - RULAU OH 72 Raw AU+ Trace Bright. W. J. M. Gordon One Glass Of Soda Or Blue Lick Water Western Row & Eighth, Cincinnati Ohio struck in German Silver with a Reeded edge. To date we have recorded equal numbers of Plain and Reeded tokens for this merchant. Formerly Miller PA 181. From the Dave Bowers and David Litrenta collections. (150-200) 684 - RULAU OH 73 Raw AU T. B. Harris One Glass Of Soda Or Blue Lick Water 4th & Main, Cincinnati Ohio struck in German Silver with a Plain edge. For whatever reason, this merchant seems to be much rarer than the other three of this type. We sold a VF+ for $135 in our July 2012 auction. Formerly Miller PA 193. From the Dave Bowers and David Litrenta collections. (150-200) 685 - MILLER PA 59 Raw EF Details With a few light rim nicks. Browning Brothers Druggists, Philadelphia struck in Brass with Plain edge. (25-50) 686 - MILLER PA 176 Raw MS62 20% Bright. J. H. Gercke Watches, Clocks, Jewelry, Philadelphia Pennsylvania struck in White Metal with Independence Hall reverse die. Rulau Pa Ph 102. (75-100) 687 - MILLER PA 195 Raw MS63 30% Bright. Saml Hart & Co. Club House Cards, Philadelphia Pennsylvania struck in Silvered Brass with Reeded edge. From the Dave Bowers collection from Rich Rossa July 1997. (75-100)

688 711 730 688 - MILLER PA 203W Unlisted Raw VF+ Industrial Works Philadelphia Pennsylvania with George Washington reverse die struck in Copper Plain edge 22.5mm. Completely unlisted and presumably issued by the Bement & Dougherty Industrial Works that operated in Philadelphia during the 1860s. Steve Tanenbaum, the tokens former owner, thought this to be Unique and a Civil War token. The reverse die is the obverse of Baker 280 / GW-813. That token has Civil War Patriotic die 349A featuring cannons and flags. Despite this, Musante followed Rulau and Fuld to date as circa 1870. Additionally, the merchant is ambiguous enough to defy concrete attribution. Finally, if it is Bement & Dougherty they were in business outside of the War years. Regardless a very important unlisted Washingtonia merchant token, quite possibly Unique. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection. (400-500) 689 - MILLER PA 217 Raw MS64 30% Red all on the obverse. W. Idler Dealer In Coins & Medals, Philadelphia. Made to resemble a 1659 Lord Baltimore Penny struck in Copper with Plain edge. A raw MS64 brought $213 in our February 2014 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. (200-300) 690 - MILLER PA 217 Raw MS65 30% Red mostly on the reverse. W. Idler Dealer In Coins & Medals, Philadelphia. Made to resemble a 1659 Lord Baltimore Penny struck in Copper with Plain edge. An MS64 brought $213 in our February 2014 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. (300-400) 691 - MILLER PA 217A Raw UNC Details 50% Bright with full Gilt Plating with light hairlines from cleaning. W. Idler Dealer In Coins & Medals, Philadelphia. Made to resemble a 1659 Lord Baltimore Penny struck in Gilt Copper with Plain edge. Unlisted in this composition. From the Dave Bowers collection. (150-200) 692 - MILLER PA 228H Raw UNC Details Hairlined. W. Idler Dealer In Coins & Medals 111 N. 9th St., Philadelphia Dealer in Coins, Minerals, Shells, Antiques & c. with the obverse resembling obverse of a 1659 Lord Baltimore Penny struck in Brass with reeded edge. Apparently quite rare and unlisted in Adams and Miller. From the Dave Bowers collection from PCAC July 1997. (100-150) 693 - MILLER PA 229 Raw MS61 Trace Bright. W. Idler Dealer In Coins, Minerals, Shells, Antiques, 111 N. 9th St., Philadelphia with George Washington reverse struck in Brass with a Plain edge. Baker 545B From the Dave Bowers collection from Rich Rossa July 1997. (100-150) 694 - MILLER PA 229 Raw MS63 20% Bright. W. Idler Dealer In Coins, Minerals, Shells, Antiques, 111 N. 9th St., Philadelphia with George Washington reverse struck in Brass with a Plain edge. Baker 545B From the Dave Bowers collection from Rich Rossa July 1997. (150-200) 695 - MILLER PA 230 Raw MS61 20% Bright and nearly Proof Like. W. Idler Dealer In Coins, Minerals, Shells, Antiques, 111 N. 9th St., Philadelphia struck in White Metal with Plain Edge and George Washington reverse. This variety comes in both Silvered and Non Silvered White Metal. So far by our count the Silvered appears scarcer. Baker 545D From the Dave Bowers collection from Rich Rossa July 1997. (100-150) 696 - MILLER PA 230A Raw UNC Details Trace Red with nice toning but a few small verdigris spots. W. Idler Dealer In Coins, Minerals, Shells, Antiques, Philadelphia with George Washington reverse struck in Copper with a Plain. Baker 545A From the Dave Bowers collection from Rich Rossa July 1997. (75-100) 697 - MILLER PA 230A Raw MS62 W. Idler Dealer In Coins, Minerals, Shells, Antiques, Philadelphia with George Washington reverse struck in Copper with a Plain. Baker 545A From the Dave Bowers collection from Rich Rossa July 1997. (150-200) 698 - MILLER PA 230B Raw MS63 30% Bright. W. Idler Dealer In Coins, Minerals, Shells, Antiques, 111 N. 9th St., Philadelphia with George Washington reverse struck in Nickel with a Plain edge. Baker 545C From the Dave Bowers collection from Rich Rossa July 1997. (200-300) 699 - MILLER PA 230D Raw MS63 30% Red. W. Idler Dealer In Coins, Minerals, Shells, Antiques, 111 N. 9th St., Philadelphia with Continental Paper Money, Autographs, Engravings & c. Bought and Sold reverse struck in Copper with a Plain edge. From the Dave Bowers collection from B&M June 2000. (200-300) 700 - MILLER PA 230F Raw MS63 40% Bright. W. Idler Dealer In Coins, Minerals, Shells, Antiques, 111 N. 9th St., Philadelphia with Continental Paper Money, Autographs, Engravings & c. Bought and Sold reverse struck in Brass with Plain edge. An MS64 realized $277.20 in our September 2010 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. (200-300) 701 - MILLER PA 230H Raw MS62 10% Bright with attractive toning. W. Idler Dealer In Coins, Minerals, Shells, Antiques, 111 N. 9th St., Philadelphia with Continental Paper Money, Autographs, Engravings & c. Bought and Sold reverse struck in Silvered White Metal with Plain edge. A Raw MS64 realized $357.50 in our December 2010 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection from C&D Gale August 1997. (200-300) 702 - MILLER PA 327A Raw EF+ William W. Long Shuffle Board, Billiards & Bowling, Philadelphia struck in Copper with Plain edge. A very interesting token with rebus spelling out Brilliant across the reverse. This merchant comes with two different obverse and reverse dies. This token has the obverse pictured in Rulau while the other obverse has a period after Long and the right compass point points to the S in St. This token has the unlisted second reverse without a period after Hotel and Bowling and no space between Bagatelle & Shuffle. This combination would appear to be the most available combination. (50-75) 703 - MILLER PA 334 Raw MS62 30% Red mainly on the obverse. Robert Lovett Jr. Die Sinker, Philadelphia Pennsylvania struck in Copper with Plain edge and Stephen Girard reverse. From the Dave Bowers collection from Steve Tanenbaum July 1997. (100-150) 704 - MILLER PA 344N Raw UNC Details With some staining on the ship side. Constitution and Guerriere 1812 Free Trade and Sailors Rights Lovett's Series No. 3 Philadelphia struck in Copper with a Reeded edge. From the Dave Bowers collection from Alan Weinberg June 1997. (50-75) 705 - MILLER PA 348 Raw MS63 30% Bright. R. Lovett Jr. Die Sinker, Philadelphia Pennsylvania struck in German Silver with Plain edge and St. George slaying dragon on reverse and a portrait of Franklin? on the obverse. From the Dave Bowers collection from Rich Rossa July 1997. (100-150) 706 - MILLER PA 351A Raw MS64 Trace Red R. Lovett Jr. Die Sinker, Philadelphia Pennsylvania struck in Copper with a Plain edge and St. George slaying dragon on reverse. Rulau lists PA351A as coming with both Plain and Reeded edges but we have yet to see a Reeded example. A raw MS62 sold for $195 in our February 2014 auction. (200-300)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com th th Steve Hayden - Mail Bid Sale #47 - Closing Sunday December 15 and Monday December 16 2019 Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Merchant Tokens 707 - MILLER PA 353 Raw AU+ Trace Red. R. Lovett Jr. Engraver & Die Sinker 1860, Philadelphia struck in Copper with Plain edge. Popular token due to its association with and similarity to the Confederate Cent made just one year later by the same firm. From the Dave Bowers collection from Rich Rossa July 1997. (100-150) 708 - MILLER PA 355 Raw MS62 10% Bright. R. Lovett Jr. Engraver & Die Sinker 1860, Philadelphia struck in Copper-Nickel with Plain edge. Popular token due to its association with the Confederate Cent made just one year later by the same firm. Though the most available composition for this die combination it enjoys added demand as it more closely mimics the Confederate Cent. An MS62 brought $190 in our February 2014. From the Dave Bowers collection from Rich Rossa July 1997. (200-300) 709 - MILLER PA 355 Raw VF Details With a number of small rim bumps. R. Lovett Jr. Engraver & Die Sinker 1860, Philadelphia struck in Copper- Nickel with Plain edge. Popular token due to its association with the Confederate Cent made just one year later by the same firm. Though the most available composition for this die combination it enjoys added demand as it more closely mimics the Confederate Cent. From the Dave Bowers collection from Rich Rossa July 1997. (25-50) 710 - MILLER PA 363 Raw MS63 40% Bright. Mason & Co. 1870 Coin & Stamp Dealer 139 No. 9th St., Philadelphia struck in White Metal with Plain edge. George Washington reverse, a later use of Civil War Patriotic die 116 and Store Card die 1134. Reported to be one of only 100 struck. A raw MS63 example of the similarly scarce Copper variety brought $160 in our February 2014 sale. Rulau Pa Ph 290, Fuld NC-16e, Baker 559D and GW-760. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 70°, 34.5 grains, 18.2 mm. (150-200) 711 - MILLER PA 366A Raw MS64 20% Bright. Mason & Co. 1870 Coin & Stamp Dealer 139 No. 9th St., Philadelphia struck in Brass with Plain edge and 1864 dated Abraham Lincoln. The reverse is a later use of Civil War Patriotic die 129 and Store Card die 1146. Unlisted in Adams and listed in Miller but without composition. Said to be one of just two struck in this composition. Rulau Pa Ph 296, King 638, Cunningham 5-860B. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 52.9 grains, 18.2 mm. (400-500) 712 - MILLER PA 492 Raw AU Details But stained with a corrosion patch. John Stilz & Son Finest Clothing House, Philadelphia struck in White Metal with popular Libertas Americana reverse. Rulau PA Ph 760 From the Dave Bowers reference collection. (50-75) 713 - MILLER PA 508 Raw MS64 Nearly Proof Like with nice toning. A. B. Taylor Druggist & Apothecary The Best Preparations For Teeth, Philadelphia struck in Copper with a Plain edge. A raw MS63 sold for $152 in our February 2014 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 350°, 55.9 grains, 19.1 mm. (150-200) 714 - MILLER PA 510 Raw MS64 Obverse nearly Proof Like. A. B. Taylor Druggist & Apothecary, Philadelphia Pennsylvania with Drugs and Medicines reverse struck in Copper with Plain edge. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 350°, 54.1 grains, 19.2 mm. (200-300) 715 - MILLER SC 10 Raw VF+ W. W. Wilbur Auction & Commission Merchant 1846, Charleston South Carolina struck in Copper with Plain Edge. Obverse 3 with Going At Only A Penny and reverse B with short bushy tree. Popular token featuring an auctioneer holding gavel. Thought to be one of the many auction houses that sold slaves during this period. Much rarer in Copper than the Brass version of this die combination. We sold a Raw VF+ example in Copper that brought $265 in our July 2012 sale. (300-400) 716 - RULAU TN Me 25 Raw EF Hotel Luehrmann 2½, Memphis Tennessee struck in German Silver with a Plain edge, 16mm. (50-75) 717 - MILLER TN 32 Raw AU Details With some light staining on the obverse and a few small rim bumps on the reverse. M. H. Miller & Co. Hatters, Memphis Tennessee with Liberty Head reverse struck in Brass with Reeded edge. (50-75) 718 - MILLER TN 54 Raw MS64 50% Bright with nearly full Silvering. Francisco & Whitman Hatters, Nashville Tennessee with top hat and eagle pictured, struck in Silvered Brass with Plain edge. Much scarcer than the Copper or Brass examples of this die combination. (150-200) 719 - RULAU TN Na 10 Raw VF Hotel Nashville 2½, Nashville Tennessee with six chain links struck in German Silver with Plain edge, 16mm. (25-50) 720 - MILLER TN 59A Raw EF Details But a bit porous and cleaned. H. & I. Kirkman Hardware and Cutlery, Nashville Tennessee struck in Brass with a Plain edge and anvil, rifle, hoe, trowel and chains pictured. A very rare early Tennessee token, Rulau thought this token was issued between 1828 and 1832 based on its fabric as he was unable to obtain directory evidence. Possibly a Hard Time era token, see HT-98 for a very similar obverse design. We sold a Raw VG/AG for $120 in our December 2017 sale while a Raw VF brought $1,870 in Bowers & Merena's November 1990 auction. From the John Ford collection. (500-750) 721 - RULAU VA 103 Raw AU+ With full date. Marshall House 1859, Richmond Virginia struck in Copper with a Plain edge. Popular token issued for the hotel where Colonel Ellsworth was shot and killed for removing a Confederate flag in 1861. (300-400) 722 - MILLER VA 15 Raw MS62 40% Bright. S. H. Marks & Co. Wholesale and Retail Confectioners, Petersburg Virginia struck in White Metal with a Plain edge and Libertas Americana reverse. The Raw MS63 example in Brass sold for $500 in our December 2017 auction. Rulau VA Pe 1. (300-400) 723 - MILLER WI 10 Raw EF A. B. Van Cott, Racine Wisconsin with pocket watch reverse struck in Copper with a Plain edge. We consider this to be the normal 2.2mm thin planchet. Much scarcer than the Brass version of this die combination. (25-50) 724 - MILLER WI 14 Raw AU A. B. Van Cott, Racine Wisconsin struck in Copper with Plain edge. Popular spelling error, Racim for Racine. Rarely seen this nice. (75-100) 725 - RULAU MV 601A Raw VF Eureka 1867 10 Cents struck in Brass with a Reeded edge. A later use of Civil War token die 1394. The Eureka Hotel in San Francisco California has been suggested but this merchant remains a mystery despite issuing tokens in the following denominations 5, 10, 15, 20, 25, 30, 50, 60, 100, 500 and 10 Dollars with some in Copper and some in Brass, some Plain edge and some Reeded edge and some even with more than one die for the same denomination. All are quite rare. Fuld NC-12b with unlisted reverse. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 49.4 grains, 19.2 mm. (50-75) Political Tokens 726 - AJACK 1824-4 BR Raw AU Details With some obverse staining and light hairlines. Genl Andrew Jackson (around bust left) // The Nation's Good (within wreath). Brass 24mm. (150-200) 727 - AJACK 1824-4 BR Raw FINE Details Holed for suspension. Genl Andrew Jackson (around bust left) // The Nation's Good (within wreath). Brass 24mm. (75-100) 728 - AJACK 1824-5 BR Raw VF+ Genl Andrew Jackson (around bust left) // The Nation's Pride (within wreath). Apparently considerably scarcer than AJACK 1824-4. Brass 24mm. (150-200)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com th th Steve Hayden - Mail Bid Sale #47 - Closing Sunday December 15 and Monday December 16 2019 Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Political Tokens 729 - SL 1859-1 WM Raw VG Slavery The Sum Of All Villainies Marching Along John Brown (around bust of Brown quarter right) // Resistance To Tyranny Is Obedience To God Give Me Liberty Or Give Me Death John Brown 1859 (around Brown being hung on gallows). White Metal 32mm Plain edge. A Raw AU+ Details with light staining brought $700 in my March 2010 sale. (150-200) 730 - AL 1860-12 CU Raw MS62 20% Red mostly on the reverse. Abraham Lincoln (round bust right) // The Peoples Choice 1860 Lincoln & Hamlin Freedom & Protection (with crossed fence rails). Dies by William H. Key. Copper 38mm. Rarely offered, we sold a Raw MS62 holed example that brought $869.69 in our July 2009 auction. From Heritage's May 2017 sale where it brought $750 (1000-1500)

731 740 744 731 - AL 1860-34 WM Raw MS63 40% Bright a bit unevenly strike. Abraham Lincoln Republican Candidate For President 1860 (around bust right signed J.D.L. for John D. Lovett) // The Union Must And Shall Be Preserved (around all-seeing eye). Struck in White Metal with a Reeded edge, 31mm. From the Dave Bowers collection from Rossa & Tannenbaum June 1999. (1000-1500) 732 - AL 1860-41 BR Raw EF Details Small rim bump. Hon. Abraham Lincoln. 1860 (around bust right) // The Railsplitter Of The West (over scene of Lincoln and helper splitting log). Always popular. Brass 28mm. (150-200) 733 - AL 1860-52 BR Raw VF+ Abm: Lincoln, Rep. Candidate For President 1860 (around bust right signed R. L. Phila for Robert Lovett Jr.) // Protection To American Industry Free Homes For Free Men. Struck in Brass 27mm. (150-200) 734 - AL 1860-52 BR Raw EF Details Lacquer residue. Abm: Lincoln, Rep. Candidate For President 1860 (around bust right signed R. L. Phila for Robert Lovett Jr.) // Protection To American Industry Free Homes For Free Men. Struck in Brass 27mm. (100-150) 735 - AL 1860-59 BR Raw AU Millions For Freedom 1860 Not One Cent For Slavery // Success To Republican Principles (around eagle). Brass 24mm. Always popular anti slavery token, a VF+ sold for $86 in our February 2014 auction. (150-200) 736 - AL 1860-59 BR Raw UNC Details Small spot. Millions For Freedom 1860 Not One Cent For Slavery // Success To Republican Principles (around eagle). Brass 24mm. Always popular anti slavery token, a VF+ sold for $86 in our February 2014 auction. (150-200) 737 - AL 1860-59 BR Raw AU+ Millions For Freedom 1860 Not One Cent For Slavery // Success To Republican Principles (around eagle). Brass 24mm. Always popular anti slavery token, a VF+ sold for $86 in our February 2014 auction. (150-200) 738 - AL 1860-70 BR Raw EF Details With scratches and spot on obverse. Abram Lincoln Free Land, Free Speech & Free Men (around bust facing forward) // Union Of The States (above eagle). Nice portrait, the only 1860 Lincoln token not in profile. Brass 22mm. A Raw EF sold for $201 in our July 2009 sale. (100-150) 739 - AL 1860-96 Ferro Raw AU Details Case is nice. Lincoln photo is nice except for chip in left field and scratch extending from nose with some rust near edge. Hamlin photo is dark with a chip on the back on neck. Lincoln 1860 (around ferrotype picture of Lincoln facing slightly left) // Hannibal Hamlin 1860 (around ferrotype picture of Hamlin facing slightly right). Solid Brass 25mm. (300-400) 740 - C 1861-13 Slvd BR Raw AU+ With 50% Original Silvering mostly on the obverse. Anti-Confederate Jefferson Davis 1861. (around man hanging from gallows) // Death To Traitors. Silvered Brass 25mm. Quite popular due to the dramatic subject. We sold a raw EF Details with some light marks and minor reverse stains for $760 in our January 2016 auction. (1500-2000) 741 - C 1861-13 BR Raw AU Details Holed for suspension. Anti-Confederate Jefferson Davis 1861. (around man hanging from gallows) // Death To Traitors. Brass 25mm. Quite popular due to the dramatic subject. We sold a raw EF Details with some light marks and minor reverse stains for $760 in our January 2016 auction. (500-750) 742 - UL 1862-2 WM Raw EF Details Holed for suspension as usual with a few light marks. Union League July 4th 1776 1863 Philadelphia (around shield and scroll) // Organized Philadelphia December 27th 1862. White Metal 33mm. (150-200) 743 - UL 1862-3 WM Raw AU Details With small obverse rim bump. Holed for suspension. Union League July 4th 1776 1863 Philadelphia (around shield and scroll) // Organized December 27th 1862. White Metal 34mm. A similar Raw AU holed with light marks brought $190 in our June 2013 sale. (200-300) 744 - AL 1864-10 Slvd BR Raw MS64 40% Bright with nearly full Silvering. Abraham Lincoln For President 1864 (around bust right) // US (on shield with eagle, flags, etc. surrounding). Silver Plated Brass 31mm. A Raw MS63 nearly as bright sold for $376 in our January 2016 auction. (400-500) 745 - AL 1864-12 WM Raw AU Details With a few marks in the field left of Lincoln's face. Lincoln Abraham 1864 (around bust left) // The Peoples Choice For President (within shield surrounded by flags and Liberty cap). White Metal 31mm. Dies by George H. Lovett. (300-400) 746 - GMcC 1864-18 Slvd BR Raw AU Details With a few obverse spots. Geo. B. McClellan For President 1864 (around military bust left) // (eagle on drum surrounded by flags). Silvered Brass 30mm. A Raw EF+ example in Brass with tiny stain brought $93.50 in our July 2009 auction. (100-150) 747 - GMcC 1864-25 BR Raw AU+ 30% Bright. George B. McClellan (around bust left signed G. H.) // The Union Must And Shall Be Preserved (around eagle). One of at least two sub varieties of this DeWitt number, this with the left wing pointing to the T in Must and the following lot where the wing points to the S in Must. This appears to be the one pictured in Sullivan. Brass 25mm. (100-150) 748 - GMcC 1864-25 BR Raw EF+ George B. McClellan (around bust left signed G. H.) // The Union Must And Shall Be Preserved (around eagle). One of at least two sub varieties of this DeWitt number, the prior lot with the left wing pointing to the T in Must and this where the wing points to the S in Must. This appears to be the one Unlisted in Sullivan. Brass 25mm. (75-100) 749 - GMcC 1864-30 CU Raw AU+ Maj. Gen. G. B. McClellan, Peninsular Campaign (around military bust left) // (Blank for use as Soldier's ID Tag). Copper 20mm. (150-200)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com th th Steve Hayden - Mail Bid Sale #47 - Closing Sunday December 15 and Monday December 16 2019 Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Political Tokens 750 - GMcC 1864-30 BR Raw UNC Details Cleaned and holed for suspension. Maj. Gen. G. B. McClellan, Peninsular Campaign (around military bust left) // (Blank for use as Soldier's ID Tag). Brass 20mm. (100-150) 751 - USG 1864-1 BR Raw AU+ With traces of Bright luster. Lieut. Gen. Ulysses S. Grant U.S.A. 1864 (around bust left) // US (in oval surrounded by eagle, flags, cannon and balls). Brass 32mm. A very nice example of a very scarce token and the only 1864 die combination listed for General Grant in Sullivan. We sold a Raw UNC Details with spot example in our June 2013 auction that realized $150. (150-200) 752 - WTS 1864 Unlisted BR Raw AU Details Stained mostly on obverse. Maj. Gen. Wm. T. Sherman U.S.A. (around bust left) / (eagle on drum surrounded by flags). Brass 30mm. Though not generally considered a political campaign token it is a nice match in style and reverse die to AL 1864-11, GMcC 1864-18 and JF 1864-4. (100-150) 753 - USG 1868-10 Slvd WM Raw AU Holed for suspension. Lieu. Gen. U. S. Grant (around military bust right) // Capture Of Richmond April 3d 1865 (surrounded by stars). Silvered White Metal 32mm. (100-150) 754 - USG 1868-23 Slvd BR Raw MS64 10% Bright with nice toning. Grant & Colfax 1868 (around busts left signed J.E.E. for J. E. Ellis engraver) // "Let Us Have Peace" (within wreath). Silvered Brass 28mm Plain edge. Very scarce. From our December 2017 sale where it realized $210. (200-300) 755 - USG 1868-30 CU Raw EF Details Some rim bumps. Holed for suspension. General U.S. Grant 1868 (around bust facing right with J. E. E. on truncation) // I Promise To Fight It Out On This Line If It Takes All Summer (around wreath). Copper 28mm (25-50) 756 - USG 1868-31 BR Raw AU+ 10% Bright holed for suspension. General U.S. Grant 1868 (around bust facing right signed J. E. Ellis on truncation) // I Promise To Fight It Out On This Line If It Takes All Summer (around wreath). Brass 28mm Plain edge. From our December 2017 sale where it realized $56.15. (50-75) 757 - USG 1868-47 Slvd BR Shell Raw MS64 60% Bright with full silvering. (Military bust left) // I Propose To Fight It Out On This Line 1868 / Grant (around and within wreath). Silvered Brass shell 35mm complete with integral loop at top and silk ribbon. Extraordinary condition for such a delicate item. From our December 2017 sale where it realized $250. (300-400) 758 - USG 1868-49 Slvd BR Shell Raw MS63 40% Bright. General U. S. Grant 1868 (around military bust right signed J. Eyman) // Schuyler Colfax 1868 (around bust left). Silvered Brass shell 32mm complete with integral loop at top. Another very choice example. From our December 2017 sale where it realized $210. (200-300) 759 - USG 1868-50 Slvd BR Shell Raw MS63 20% Bright. General U. S. Grant 1868 (around military bust right signed J. Eyman) // The Peoples Choice For President. Silvered Brass shell 32mm complete with integral loop at top and silk ribbon. Another very choice example. From our December 2017 sale where it realized $265. (300-400) 760 - HS 1868-14 Slvd BR Shell Raw MS63 10% Bright with attractive toning. Seymour Horatio Seymour 1868 (around bust left signed EYM. F. for engraver J. Eyman of New York) // Frank P. Blair. Jr. 1868 (around bust right both sides signed EYM. F.). Silvered Brass Shell 32mm with integral loop. From our December 2017 sale where it realized $180. (200-300) 761 - JGB 1884-03 CU Raw MS63 Blaine Logan (around busts facing) // Republican Candidates Protection To American Industry 1884. Copper 35mm Plain edge. From our December 2017 sale where it realized $160. (200-300) 762 - BH 1892-01 AL Raw MS63 50% Bright. Republican Presidential Nominees 1892 For President For Vice President (around busts) // Landing Of Columbus In America October 12th 1492 Pat's Dec 1 1891 (around Columbus landing scene). Aluminum 45mm Plain edge. Eglit 82. From our December 2017 sale where it realized $61. (50-75) Miscellaneous by Topic 763 - Baker 76C Raw MS63 50% Bright. George Washington General of the American Armies struck in Brass with a Plain edge. GW-748 From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 34 grains, 18.1 mm. (100-150)

764 775 776 764 - Baker 638 R8 Raw MS63 George Washington Perseverance 5 Extends a Hearty Welcome. Thought to be a US Mint Medal issued in the 1861-1867 time period for the Perseverance Hose Company Number 5 of Philadelphia Pennsylvania. Julian lists the Abraham Lincoln version, CM-25, stating 100 were struck in Silver only, during 1867 to commemorate Lincoln's visit to the fire company in 1861. Musante lists this version in Copper and Nickel, dates them to circa 1865, calls both Very Rare and was even forced to use composite photos. Formerly listed as a Civil War Patriotic Token, 122/462, but delisted due to the 1867 date in Julian related to the Lincoln version. Very rare and collectible in many fields. GW-762, Julian CM-25A. From the Dave Bowers collection. (500-750) 765 - Bolen JAB-26 CU Raw MS63 20% Red. Thomas Jefferson Equal And Exact Justice To All Men struck in Copper 25mm on 2.7mm thick planchet and as such an Original from 1867 and one of just 14 struck. (400-500) 766 - Lincoln 25 Mystery Raw MS62 20% Bright. Abraham Lincoln 25 In God We Trust (around bearded bust right) // United States Of America For Ever Inseparable 1864 (around eagle). A somewhat mysterious token. It would appear to be a political campaign item from 1864 but was not listed in DeWitt or Sullivan while almost certainly known to them. It has 25 under Lincoln's bust that could be a denomination. The size is right for a Quarter and it is struck in Coin Turn rotation rather than Metal Turn. Consequently, some have suggested it is a proposed coin pattern. Whatever it is this is one of the nicest examples we can recall seeing. White Metal 25mm. King 878 Cunningham 15-550W. From Craig Whitford's November 2000 sale. (400-500)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com th th Steve Hayden - Mail Bid Sale #47 - Closing Sunday December 15 and Monday December 16 2019 Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Miscellaneous by Topic 767 - Lincoln 25 Mystery Raw VF Holed for suspension. Abraham Lincoln In God We Trust (around bearded bust right) // United States Of America For Ever Inseparable 1864 (around eagle). A somewhat mysterious token. It would appear to be a political campaign item from 1864 but was not listed in DeWitt or Sullivan while almost certainly known to them. This particular example lacks the 25 under Lincoln's bust that could be a denomination. The size is right for a Quarter and it is struck in Coin Turn rotation rather than Metal Turn. Consequently, some have suggested it is a proposed coin pattern. This is the only example we have seen without the 25 and while there are no obvious signs of removal there are marks in the area along with heavy wear making it difficult to tell if the 25 was ever present. White Metal 25mm. Similar to King 878 and Cunningham 15-550W but without 25. (100-150) 768 - Sage's Historical Muling No. 2/3 Raw MS63 60% Bright and nearly Proof Like. Sage's Historical Tokens No.2 City Hall obverse with Obverse of No. 3 Faneuil Hall struck in Brass with Reeded edge 31mm. Bowers calls this muling Very rare in Brass, somewhat nicer than a Brass muling of obverses 3/4 sold for $425 in our December 2017 auction. From the Q. David Bowers collection. Data: 0°, 168.9 grains, 31.1 mm. (400-500) 769 - Sage's Historical Tokens No. 8 Raw MS63 30% Red. The Old Hasbrook House Newburg NY, Washington's Head Quarters 1782-3. Signed G.H.L. on obverse for maker George H. Lovett. Copper 31mm Plain edge. From the John Lewis collection earlier our March 1998 sale. (150-200) 770 - Sage's Masonic Medalets No. 1 Raw MS64 60% Red and nearly Proof Like. Old Masonic Hall Broadway NY Copper with a plain edge 31mm. Later die state with long cud on rim, indicating this is an 1870's restrike. From the Q. David Bowers and Johnson collections earlier from Bowers & Merena 2002. Data: 0°, 207.3 grains, 31.3 mm. (75-100) 771 - Sherman Corps Badge Raw VG Details With some dents, holed for suspension. Maj. Gen. W. T. Sherman (around bust right within wreath) // (Corps symbols: Star, Acorn, Cartridge Bow and Arrow). White Metal 31mm. The reverse carries the symbols for the 12th, 14th, 15th and 17th Union Army Corps. (25-50) 772 - Shell Card Stamford Connecticut Raw MS63 Shell side 90% Bright. Taylor Brothers Grocers, China, Crockery And Glass-Ware, Quintard's Block Stamford Conn. This is the Bowers plate specimen. Bowers CT-430. From the Q. David Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections. (300-400) 773 - Shell Card Peoria Illinois 1868 Yankee Robinson Raw AU Details Shell side 50% Bright holed. Yankee Robinson's Consolidated Shows A Stream Of Gold And Glitter Over A Mile Long. Popular traveling circus item. Bowers IL-778 Green Card. From the Q. David Bowers collection. (150-200) 774 - Shell Card Madison Indiana Mirror Raw VF+ Nice mirror. Alling, Lodge & Co. Dealers in Hardware & Cutlery, Madison Ind. This is the Bowers plate specimen. Bowers IN-448 From the Q. David Bowers collection. (150-200) 775 - Shell Card Baltimore Maryland 1867 Raw MS63 Shell side 30% Bright. Robinson, Lord & Co. Wooden Ware Baltimore. Large 38mm imitation of an 1867 $20 Gold Coin. This is the Bowers plate specimen. Bowers MD-460. From the Q. David Bowers, Steve Tanenbaum and George Fuld collections. (400-500) 776 - Shell Card Marquette Michigan 1870 Raw MS62 60% Bright. Schott & Co. Ready Made Clothing National Bank Building Marquette L. S. Mich. Marquette is a port on Lake Superior in the state’s Upper Peninsula and this is the only shell card for that part of the state. This is the Bowers plate specimen. Bowers MI-590. From the Q. David Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections. (500-750) 777 - Shell Card Concord New Hampshire 1868 Raw AU+ Shell side 20% Bright. M. B. Clough's Boot & Shoe Store, Concord NH. This is the Bowers plate specimen. Bowers NH-250. From the Q. David Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections earlier from Chuck Kirtley sale 42. (200-300) 778 - Shell Card Dover New Hampshire 1868 Raw EF Details Dents primarily on the Liberty Head side. Purinton & Ham Hats, Caps and Furs, Dover NH. Bowers NH-350. From the Q. David Bowers collection. (75-100) 779 - Shell Card Dover New Hampshire 1868 Raw MS62 40% Bright. Purinton & Ham Hats, Caps and Furs, Dover NH. This is the Bowers plate specimen. Bowers NH-350. From the Q. David Bowers collection. (300-400) 780 - Shell Card Dover New Hampshire 1868 Raw UNC Details 30% Bright with some minor staining where Gilt plating is missing and a number of small dents. Purinton & Ham Hats, Caps and Furs, Dover NH. Bowers NH-355. From the Q. David Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections, earlier from Bill Panitch January 1970. (150-200) 781 - Shell Card Dover New Hampshire 1868 Raw MS62 50% Bright with some lacquer residue. Purinton & Ham Hats, Caps and Furs, Dover NH. This is the Bowers plate specimen. Bowers NH-355. From the Q. David Bowers collection. (300-400) 782 - Shell Card Dover New Hampshire Mirror Raw MS63 Shell side 50% Bright with nice mirror. Purinton & Ham Hats, Caps & Ladies Furs, Dover NH. This is the Bowers plate specimen. Bowers NH-360. From the Q. David Bowers collection. (200-300) 783 - Shell Card Manchester New Hampshire Mirror Raw AU+ Shell side 30% Bright with some of Gilt plating missing. Nice mirror pin cushion. S. S. Carr Druggist & Apothecary, Manchester NH. This is the Bowers plate specimen. Bowers NH-500. From the Q. David Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections. (200-300) 784 - Shell Card Manchester New Hampshire Mirror Raw FINE Details Mirror cracked with some silvering missing or disturbed. Pickering's City Furnishing House 994 Elm St. Manchester Pat. June 16, 1868 pin cushion mirror. Per an 1875 Manchester NH town history the proprietor was J. W. C. Pickering. Bowers Unlisted. From the Q. David Bowers collection, earlier our January 2016 sale where it brought $155. (200-300)

785 792 794 785 - Shell Card New York City Circus Raw MS62 40% Bright. W. C. Coup's New United Monster Shows. This is the Bowers plate specimen. Bowers NY-4260. From the Q. David Bowers collection. (400-500)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com th th Steve Hayden - Mail Bid Sale #47 - Closing Sunday December 15 and Monday December 16 2019 Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Miscellaneous by Topic 786 - Shell Card New York City Vichy Raw EF+ Vichy Spa and Mineral Water, Paris. Apparently a French version of the New York City shell card issued by Eisner and Mendelson Co.. The shell card appears to be from the same maker as the US version which is believed to have been issued in the 1890's. The shell side is very similar to Bowers NY-4900. An interesting "go along" that should inspire some additional research. From the Q. David Bowers collection. (50-75) 787 - Shell Card New York City Newark New Jersey 1868 Raw MS62 Shell side 10% Bright. Wm. O. Headley & Son Manufacturers of Trunks New York, Factory Newark New Jersey. This is the Bowers plate specimen. Bowers NY-6340. From the Q. David Bowers collection. (300-400) 788 - Shell Card Utica New York 1867 Raw MS62 Shell side Trace Bright with 20% original silvering. T. L Kingsley & Son Great Wardrobe, Utica New York. Kingsley issued Hard Rubber and Merchant tokens as well. This is the Bowers plate specimen. Bowers NY-9540. From the Q. David Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections. (300-400) 789 - Shell Card Cincinnati Ohio Die Sinker Sayre Raw MS63 60% Bright. Jos. J. Sayre Stencils Cor. 4th & Walnut Cincinnati Ohio 1868. This is the Bowers plate specimen. Bowers OH-1362 From the Dave Bowers collection. (300-400) 790 - Shell Card Cincinnati Ohio 1868 Raw MS63 80% Bright. Pye, Clothier Hats & Furs 5th & Vine, Cincinnati Ohio. This is the Bowers plate specimen, though in person it is much superior to the plate where minor lacquer residues are greatly exaggerated. Bowers OH-1302. From the Q. David Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections. (400-500) 791 - Shell Card Cincinnati Ohio 1868 Raw MS63 60% Bright. S. K. Stephens & Co. Excelsior Tobacco Factory, Cin. O.. This is the Bowers plate specimen. Bowers OH-1460. From the Q. David Bowers collection. (300-400) 792 - Shell Card Zanesville Ohio 1867 Raw MS63 Shell side 20% Bright. Grant & Black Dealers In Dry Goods & Carpets, Zanesville Ohio. 38mm replica 1867 Silver Dollar. The Bowers plate specimen. Bowers OH-2060. From the Q. David Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections. (300-400) 793 - Shell Card Philadelphia Pennsylvania Tintype Portrait Raw UNC Details Shell side 30% Bright with a few small dents on the portrait side. Applegate's Patent Pocket Portraits Phila.. This is the Bowers plate specimen. Bowers PA-2020. From the Q. David Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collection, earlier from Dave Schenkman February 1981. (150-200) 794 - Shell Card Philadelphia Pennsylvania 1868 Raw MS63 Shell side 80% Bright. F. Rahter's Great Zingari Bitters, Philadelphia. Bitters bottle labeled IXL Zingari Bitters on the card. This is the Bowers plate specimen. Bowers PA-4060. From the Q. David Bowers collection. (400-500) 795 - Shell Card Philadelphia Pennsylvania Applegate's Photographer Raw AU+ Apple (gate) Pocket Portrait with tintype photograph on reverse. This is the Bowers plate specimen. An interesting piece featuring a rebus of an apple behind a gate. If that wasn't easy enough they added the label Apple to the fruit above the gate. Bowers PA-2040 From the Dave Bowers collection. (300-400) 796 - Shell Card Philadelphia Pennsylvania George Washington Raw MS63 50% Bright. Cousty's East - End Grocery, Established 1809. Dealer in Finest Grades Of Teas And Fancy Groceries, Wines, Liquors & Segars, 118 South 2d St. Philadelphia. Bowers PA-2820 From the Dave Bowers collection. (300-400)

797 798 800 797 - Shell Card Philadelphia Pennsylvania Maison Fertile Brothel 1868 Raw AU 10% Bright. Wm. H. Harrison Maison Fertile 403 Merchant St., and the Maison Doree 8 S. Broad St. Philadelphia Pennsylvania 1868. Thought to have operated as a house of prostitution. This is the Bowers plate specimen. Bowers PA-3420 From the Dave Bowers collection. (500-750) 798 - Shell Card Providence Rhode Island 1868 Raw MS62 Shell side 50% Bright. Elsbree & Valleau Dealers In Hats, Caps, Furs and Gentlemen's Furnishing Goods, Providence RI. One of just a handful of Shell Cards known from this state. This is the Bowers plate specimen. Bowers RI-320. From the Q. David Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections. (400-500) 799 - Shell Card Brandon Vermont 1876 Raw MS63 Shell side 10% Bright with 10% original silvering. The Improve Howe Scales 1876 Trade Dollar. There is a blank space on the card side to record the weight of a participant, 111 lbs in this case. One of the most often encountered Shell Cards though still quite rare by coin standards. Bowers VT-200. (200-300) 800 - Spence's Tree of Liberty Condor token Raw MS64 40% Red 1796 British Condor token Middlesex 883b with Plain edge. Obverse has four men dancing around maypole labeled Tree of Liberty with a man's head atop pole, possibly that of Prime Minister William Pitt. The reverse has seated female labeled Rouse Britannia with cap in the wind. From the Dave Bowers collection, earlier Stack's July 2008 where it realized $431.25. (500-750)

END OF SESSION TWO

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com