Steve Hayden CivilWarTokens.com PO Box 1863 Goose Creek SC 29445

FIRST CLASS

Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

STEVE HAYDEN PO Box1863 Goose Creek SC 29445 (843) 973-4556 (Voice Mail or FAX) - Email [email protected] Web Site CivilWarTokens.com Please note new address MAILBID SALE - #46 Closing April 22nd 2018 Sunday (online) First Lot at 7:00 PM EST until Last Lot just before 11:30 PM EST

TERMS OF SALE:

1.There are NO buyer's fees in this sale. What you bid is the most you will pay.

2. Bids are reduced to one increment over the second highest bid. Bidding increments are: for bids up to $50 the increment is $2, from $50 to $100 the increment is $5, from $100 to $250 the increment is $10, from $250 to $500 the increment is $25, from $500 to $1,000 the increment is $50, from $1,000 to $2,500 the increment is $100, from $2,500 to $5,000 the increment is $250, from $5,000 to $10,000 the increment is $500, from $10,000 to $25,000 the increment is $1,000 and over $25,000 the increment is $2,500.

3. Postage and insurance will be added to all invoices with a minimum charge of $1.00 per item. Free shipping to those who pay by check. When you get your invoice simply send a check for the total before shipping.

4. Invoices for delivery within South Carolina must pay 8% for South Carolina sales tax unless a resale number is supplied. Bidders from other states are responsible for paying any sales / use tax that may be required.

5. This sale has Live Online Bidding. You can view and bid on all lots online at civilwartokens.com. If you plan to bid online you will need to register so don’t delay. As always let us know if you have any difficulty. Although the auction is staggered many lots will close within seconds so plan ahead and bid accordingly.

6. If you choose, you may still bid by Mail, Fax, Phone and Email but those bids should be received at least one day before the closing date of the sale to assure they are properly recorded. We will enter these bids and act as your agent. These bids will be reflected in the online bidding with the User Name “xxmailbid”. If you bid in this manner please do not also bid online.

7. Bids for each lot can be entered at any time until that item closes as noted in online description with possible bidding extensions as noted below. There are no hidden reserves; the opening bid is the consignor’s reserve.

8. Closing time for a lot is automatically extended for 3 minutes if that lot receives a bid within its last 3 minutes. This continues in 3 minute increments until no further bids are received for that item. If you bid with 4 minutes left the closing will still be in 4 minutes. But if you bid with 2 minutes left the closing will be in 5 minutes. And if you bid with one second left the closing will be in 3 minutes and one second.

9. Estimates which appear after the description are only a guide and lots will often be sold above and below those amounts.

10. You may FAX your bids to our regular number. When we are out of the office our phone will be set to receive FAX's or voice mail. Again these bids should be received at least one day before the closing date of the sale to assure they are properly recorded.

11. Returns will be accepted on any lots incorrectly described, however, since the majority of this material is consigned all sales will be considered final 14 days after lot delivery.

12. The auctioneer reserves the right to reject any bid or withdraw any lot.

13. Placing a bid in this sale constitutes acceptance of the above terms.

My web site civilwartokens.com, has Enlarged Photos of EVERY LOT. Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Patriotic Tokens 1 - 1/359 b R8 PCGS MS64 30% Bright with a thin planchet crack visible at 12 o'clock on reverse only. 1863 Turban Head Not One Cent struck in Brass. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 20°, 46.1 grains, 19.5 mm. (200-300) 2 - 1/391 z R8 NGC MS62 1863 IOU 1 Cent struck in Zinc. These Zinc tokens were formerly listed as Lead with the "g" designation but it has been determined the Zinc is a more appropriate classification. Aside from a few New York City merchants most Zinc tokens were struck for collectors and did not hold up well in storage often developing a white layer of corrosion; this is a happy exception. 1863 Turban Head IOU 1 Cent struck in Zinc what used to be called Lead. The sixth example we have seen offered. From the Robert Williams collection. (200-300) 3 - 3/373 b R6 NGC AU55 1863 The Union For Ever struck in Brass by Koehler of Baltimore. Two very scarce dies, nicer than the Raw AU Details example that brought $443 in our December 2017 sale. From the Robert Williams collection. (400-500) 4 - 7A/317 a R3 NGC MS64 BN 10% Red. Typical worn die state. 1863 Army & Navy. Rare this nice. (100-150) 5 - 9/406 a R6 PCGS AU55 1863 Turban Head Proclaim Liberty Through Out The Land with odd fellows three chain links. Very scarce Indiana Primitive reverse die only used in this variety, rare this nice. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 42.8 grains, 19.3 mm. (400-500) 6 - 11/298 a R1 PCGS MS64 BN Trace Red. 1863 Army & Navy. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections from Leslie Heilbronner 1973. Data: 19 mm. (75-100) 7 - 17/388 a R2 NGC MS64 BN Trace Red and nicely toned. 1863 Millions For Defense Not One Cent For Tribute. From the Mark Glazer collection purchased from Eagle Eye. (100-150) 8 - 18/337 a R6 NGC MS63 RB Trace Red mostly on the reverse with usual large obverse die crack. 1863 Our Navy. Rare in Uncirculated condition, we sold a Raw MS62 for $110 in our July 2009 sale. From Eagle Eye. (150-200) 9 - 23/306 a R2 NGC MS63 BN 1863 Army & Navy. (50-75) 10 - 23/306 b R5 NGC MS63 Toned, struck from worn and rusted dies as usual. 1863 Army & Navy struck in Brass. Very scarce variety rarely seen this nice. (100-150) 11 - 23/306 j R8 NGC MS63 60% Bright, struck from worn and rusted dies as usual. 1863 Army & Navy struck in German Silver. Rare variety, the first we have offered in one of our sales. (300-400) 12 - 30A/277A b R10 NGC VF35 1863 Childs Liberty Head Union 1861 with Childs Eagle struck in Brass. Two Unique dies in the Patriotic series. From the Mark Glazer and Larkin Wilson collections, the Glazer pedigree is so noted on the NGC holder. (4000-6000) 13 - 35/265 a R4 NGC XF45 BN Union 1864. (25-50) 14 - 35/265 a R4 NGC AU55 BN Union 1864. Very scarce this nice. (50-75) 15 - 43/387 a R4 NGC MS64 BN 10% Red or more. 1863 Millions For Defense Not One Cent For Tribute signed by maker Louis Leichtweis. Scarce reverse, tiny stars instead of Beaver, a slightly more Red Raw MS63 sold for $220 in our August 2015 sale. From the Steve Tanner collection. (200-300) 16 - 45/350 a R2 NGC MS64 BN 10% Red with usual late die state for this die combination with the obverse die overly polished or lapped resulting in loss of details. Obverse weakly struck as usual on this combination. Scarce variety particularly this nice. From my May 2004 auction where it brought $27.51. (50-75) 17 - 51/334 a R1 NGC MS64 RD 90% Red. Indian Princess Our Army. Unusual with the Full Red designation. From the Robert Williams collection. (150-200) 18 - 51/334 d R7 NGC MS65 Trace Bright all on the reverse with attractive toning. Our Army struck in Copper Nickel. We sold a brighter NGC MS64 example in our March 2008 sale for $495. From the Ken Bauer collection. (400-500) 19 - 54/430 a R3 NGC MS64 RB 20% Red more so on the reverse. From worn and rusted reverse die as usual. Penny Saved Is A Penny Earned. Very scarce this nice. (100-150)

020 034 035 20 - 57/185 do R9 NGC MS62 Struck over an 1859 Indian Head Cent with much detail plainly visible. 1862 Indian Head with Bull reverse struck in Copper Nickel over a US Cent. Very rare die in the Patriotic series, only used on this and the Copper variety of the same die combination and though it is called R8, it is also likely a R9. From the Mark Glazer collection and so noted on the NGC holder. Picture on page of the current Patriotic book. (6000-8000) 21 - 57/467 a R7 NGC MS63 RB 30% Red with very nice cartwheel luster. The Federal Government, A National Currency, Free Trade and Human Rights 1862. Two rare and underrated dies, just the fifth example of this variety we have seen offered and not included in the Tanenbaum collection. An EF+ sold for $1,020.54 in our November 2004 sale. From the Mark Glazer and Jack Detwiler collections, the Glazer pedigree is so noted on the NGC holder though called 57/473 in error. (2000-3000) 22 - 58/58 a R10 NGC AU55 BN Single Die Doubleheader. 1863 Indian Head signed L. Roloff large 24mm Single Die Doubleheader struck in Copper and believed to be Unique. One of the rarest types of Civil War tokens and a specialty of Patriotic token collector Mark Glazer who assembled the largest collection of these by far. These are normally thought to be the work of idle hands at the manufacturer. A token was struck uniface against another blank planchet or smooth surface then flipped over and struck again in the same manner. This usually results in the side first struck being somewhat squashed or distorted as on this example. They can also result from an odd set of striking errors which would normally result in the same type of appearance. We sold a NGC XF45 example of the equally rare 87/87 in our July 2014 sale that realized $1,485 in spirited bidding. From the Mark Glazer collection and so noted on the NGC holder. (1500-2000) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Patriotic Tokens 23 - 60/346 a R5 NGC MS65 BN Trace Red more so on the reverse with attractive toning. 1863 Indian Head with Constitution and the Union. Two very scarce dies. (300-400) 24 - 69/369 a R3 NGC MS65 BN 1863 Not One Cent. (75-100) 25 - 71/467 a R9 PCGS MS62 BN Or nearly so. 1863 Indian Head, The Federal Government a National Currency, Free Trade And Human Rights. The obverse die is very rare with this being its most frequently encountered combination. The popular reverse die is rare in its own right. A Raw EF+ brought $1,500 in our February 2014 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 110°, 55.5 grains, 19.1 mm. (2000-3000) 26 - 71A/76A d R10 NGC MS63 20% Bright and well struck. 1863 and 1864 John Stanton Indian Head Doubleheader struck in Copper Nickel and believed to be Unique. Both dies are exceedingly rare in the Patriotic series. The 71A die is only known in one other variety 71A/76 in Brass also unique while the 76A is also only in one other variety 76A/522 in Copper an R9. We sold the only 76A/522 a we have seen offered a Raw MS63 in our February 2014 sale that realized $3,500. From the Mark Glazer and Steve Tanenbaum collections earlier from Sol Kaplan and Paul Koppenhaver. The Tanenbaum pedigree is so noted on the NGC holder. (4000-6000) 27 - 81/351 a R2 NGC MS62 RB 20% Red. 1863 Indian head flags, drum and crossed cannons. (50-75) 28 - 86/357 a R2 NGC MS63 BN 1863 Not One Cent. (50-75) 29 - 91/303 a R3 PCGS MS64 RB 20% Red. 1863 Indian Head Army & Navy. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 190°, 51.5 grains, 19.3 mm. (100-150) 30 - 91/432 b R8 PCGS MS65 20% Bright. 1863 Indian Head No Compromise With Traitors struck in Brass. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 135°, 63.8 grains, 19.3 mm. (500-750) 31 - 91/435 j R7 PCGS MS63 10% Bright, typically weakly struck for this composition. 1863 United We Stand Divided We Fall struck in German Silver. Scarce reverse die. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 350°, 48.4 grains, 19.4 mm. (300-400) 32 - 92/198 b R9 PCGS MS65 10% Bright and nicely toned. 1863 Indian Head United States of America with eagle on shield struck in Brass. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 0°, 47.3 grains, 18.9 mm. (500-750) 33 - 95/368 do R8 PCGS MS65 30% Bright, struck over an 1862 Cent. Distinctive 1863 Indian Head Not One Cent struck in Copper Nickel. The first example of this Over Cent we have seen offered, a variety missing from the Tanenbaum collection. Steve Tanenbaum loved Over Cents and other coins trying to add as many as possible to his collection, so his not owning one says quite a lot. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 150°, 71.3 grains, 19.4 mm. (1000-1500) 34 - 96/129 a R9 PCGS MS63 RB 20% Red, a bit weakly struck opposite Lincoln's bust. 1864 Abraham Lincoln with 1864 Indian Head reverse struck in Copper. Rare die combination that when found is frequently weakly struck. An NGC MS64 RB brought $875 in our December 2016 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 200°, 45.2 grains, 19.1 mm. (750-1000) 35 - 97/389 do R8 PCGS MS64 10% Bright. Struck on 1857 Flying Eagle Cent with very strong detail of the undertype visible without magnification. Millions For Contractors Fort Lafayette Not One Cent For The Widows. A very impressive piece indeed. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 69.9 grains, 19.3 mm. (1500-2000) 36 - 98/291 a R5 PCGS MS64 RB 60% Red with reverse die clashed as often seen. 1863 Union and Liberty Indian Head One Country. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 315°, 45.7 grains, 19.2 mm. (200-300) 37 - 99/292 a R3 PCGS MS64 BN Trace Red, reverse weak at center as usual. Union And Liberty 1863 One Country. Very rarely seen in any degree of Uncirculated. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 200°, 40.7 grains, 19.8 mm. (200-300) 38 - 100/341 a R7 PCGS MS64 BN Trace Red. United We Stand 1863 Union For Ever with shield. Very scarce obverse die, an NGC MS64 RB brought $264 in our June 2011 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 170°, 35.7 grains, 18.6 mm. (300-400) 39 - 102A/345A a R10 PCGS MS63 BN Trace Red. 1863 Indian Head with Union shield reverse. Two extremely rare Patriotic dies, though currently listed as Unique two examples are known. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections, earlier from Rich Rossa November 1999. (6000-8000) 40 - 104/521 a R9 PCGS MS62 BN Quite sharp, smooth and problem free for this variety. Indian Head Copper Mine Token struck by A. W. Escherich of Chicago Illinois. Rare variety with rare reverse die though overrated at R9. One of the most detailed examples we have seen offered. A weakly struck EF sold for $550 in our June 2005 sale, while a well struck and likely finest known AU+ brought $1,855 in our July 2012 sale. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections. From our July 2012 sale where it was a Raw AU+ and realized $1,855. (2000-3000) 41 - 105/198 b R8 PCGS MS64 10% Bright. George Washington within star United States of America 1863 struck in Brass. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 350°, 46.7 grains, 19.3 mm. (500-750) 42 - 105/360 b R9 PCGS MS64 10% Bright. George Washington within star Not One Cent struck in Brass. Very rare die combination. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 180°, 44.6 grains, 19.2 mm. (500-750) 43 - 105/436 a R9 PCGS MS65 BN Trace Red. George Washington within star United Country struck in Copper. Copper has traditionally been the most sought after composition for collector strikes that come in a variety of compositions. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 0°, 40.2 grains, 19 mm. (750-1000)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Patriotic Tokens

044 051 052 44 - 106/432 a R7 PCGS MS66 RB 80% Red with great cartwheel luster. George Washington No Compromise With Traitors struck in Copper. This die combination is usually encountered circulated, in Copper Nickel and struck over a Store Card. A rarity in Copper particularly this nice. A Raw MS64 realized $458.70 in our July 2007 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 0°, 58.5 grains, 20.2 mm. (750-1000) 45 - 107/108 d R8 PCGS MS64 10% Red, typical late reverse die state for this composition with large die cud. Double headed 1863 George Washington token struck in Copper Nickel. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 180°, 63.5 grains, 19.7 mm. (500-750) 46 - 107/432 e R9 PCGS MS63 30% Bright. 1863 George Washington No Compromise With Traitors struck in White Metal. The first example we have seen in this composition. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 160°, 36.8 grains, 19.6 mm. (400-500) 47 - 108/201 d R9 PCGS MS63 Trace Bright, well struck for variety from an early obverse die state. 1863 George Washington Our Union with shield struck in Copper Nickel. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 180°, 61.1 grains, 18.8 mm. (400-500) 48 - 110/442 a R1 PCGS MS65 BN Trace Red with very nice luster. 1863 George Washington New York. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 170°, 50.9 grains, 19.6 mm. (100-150) 49 - 111/271 j R9 PCGS MS63 Trace Bright with typical very weak strike for this die combination in general and in this composition in particular. 1863 George Washington Union For Ever struck in German Silver. A very rare variety. From the Dave Bowers collection from C&D Gale. Data: 190°, 47.4 grains, 19.5 mm. (200-300) 50 - 111/340 a R3 PCGS MS65 BN 10% Red with nice toning. 1863 George Washington with shield, flags and a Liberty cap. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 270°, 45.3 grains, 18.7 mm. (100-150) 51 - 113/114A a R8 PCGS MS66 RB 70% Red and nearly Proof Like. Pater Patrie George Washington doubleheader struck in Copper. Rare dies. We sold a Raw MS63 30% Red for $700 in our December 2017 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 180°, 74.5 grains, 20.6 mm. (1500-2000) 52 - 114/432 f R9 PCGS MS63 Nicely toned. George Washington No Compromise With Traitors struck in Silver. Obverse die punch by George H. Lovett, very rare its only known use in any series. GW-652, Copper called very rare in Musante with Silver not listed. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 180°, 81.6 grains, 20.7 mm. (6000-8000) 53 - 115/115A b R9 PCGS MS65 20% Bright. George and Martha Washington struck in Brass with a Plain edge. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 0°, 53.5 grains, 20.5 mm. (500-750)

054 055 062 54 - 115B/115C f R9 PCGS MS64 Nicely toned and nearly Proof Like. George Washington 1792 Martha Washington 1792 struck in Silver with a Plain edge. The finest by far of just three examples we have seen offered. We sold a Raw MS62 example of the equally reverse Copper variety in our December 2017 auction that realized $1,116. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 20°, 76.6 grains, 20.6 mm. (1500-2000) 55 - 116/477 e R9 PCGS MS62 30% Bright. George Washington with Procese reverse struck in White Metal on a planchet of normal thickness. Rare and enigmatic reverse...a prize to anyone who knows its meaning. The reverse is normally seen paired with 349 on a thick White Metal planchet. It too is rare and listed as R9, though a bit overrated. We sold a Raw AU Details with tiny rim bump of the 349/477 that brought $477 in our December 2017 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 10°, 47.8 grains, 18 mm. (1500-2000) 56 - 117/420 a R1 PCGS MS64 BN 10% Red. 1863 George Washington Exchange. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 180°, 54.2 grains, 19.3 mm. (100-150) 57 - 118/418 a R2 PCGS MS64 BN 10% Red. 1863 George Washington Peace For Ever with shaking hands labeled North and South. The shaking hands reverse is often not fully struck with the North, South or both missing from the shirt cuffs. This is far above average. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 135°, 42.1 grains, 19.2 mm. (100-150) 58 - 119/360 do Unlisted PCGS MS65 50% Bright with nice toning, struck over an Indian Cent with the Indian's profile easily visible on reverse but little other detail is apparent. George Washington 1863 with Not One Cent reverse struck in Copper Nickel. Unlisted struck over an Indian Head cent. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 180°, 66.3 grains, 19.7 mm. (1000-1500) 59 - 120/255 b R7 PCGS MS64 10% Bright mostly on the reverse. 1863 George Washington with Knickerbocker Currency reverse struck in Brass. Scarce obverse die. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 0°, 42.2 grains, 20.1 mm. (500-750) 60 - 120/256 d R9 PCGS MS65 50% Bright. 1863 George Washington Horrors of War Blessings of Peace struck in Copper Nickel. Just the second example we have seen offered. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 315°, 63.8 grains, 19.9 mm. (750-1000)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Patriotic Tokens 61 - 120/434 b R8 PCGS MS64 40% Bright. 1863 George Washington United States Copper struck in Brass. We sold an NGC MS64 RB example of the R9 Copper variety for $500 in our December 2008 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 315°, 43.9 grains, 20.3 mm. (500-750) 62 - 120/434 fo R9 PCGS MS63 Struck on 1841-O Seated Dime with much detail including date easily visible without magnification. 1863 George Washington United States Copper struck in Silver. As a class, Over Dimes are many times rarer than Over Cents, a rare opportunity as a very impressive example. From the Dave Bowers, Cindy Grellman Wibker and Ron Guth collections. Data: 315°, 36.3 grains, 19.4 mm. (4000-6000) 63 - 120/434 j R9 PCGS MS64 20% Bright, weakly struck at centers typical of this composition. 1863 George Washington United States Copper struck in German Silver. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 315°, 39.2 grains, 20 mm. (300-400)

064 066 074 64 - 121/531 b R9 PCGS MS64 Trace Bright with nice toning. George Washington President Good For One Glass Of Soda struck in Brass. Extremely rare dies, just the fourth example we have recorded in all compositions and the only one in Brass. We sold an NGC MS63 BN example of the Copper variety for $2,500 in our December 2016 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 71.1 grains, 23.9 mm. (3000-4000) 65 - 124/201 b R9 PCGS MS65 Trace Bright with nice toning. 1864 Abraham Lincoln with Our Union shield reverse struck in Brass. Very scarce obverse die, rare die combination. We sold a nice NGC MS63 example in White Metal that brought $1,025 in our December 2016 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 190°, 51.8 grains, 19 mm. (1500-2000) 66 - 125/160 f R9 PCGS MS65 10% Bright with attractive toning. Abm. Lincoln President 1864 with Mossin and Marr Liberty For All eagle on cannon struck in Silver. Very rare die combination in any composition and the first we have seen in Silver. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 180°, 19.9 mm. (2000-3000) 67 - 125/248 a R6 PCGS MS64 BN Trace Red, very well struck for this die combination. Abm. Lincoln President 1864 OK. Popular token, a Raw EF+ brought $212.12 in our December 2016 auction. Dewitt AL 1864-47. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 190°, 40 grains, 18.9 mm. (500-750) 68 - 125/294 a R7 NGC MS63 BN Abraham Lincoln President 1864 Freedom. We sold a Raw MS63 for $375 in our September 2010 auction. (400-500) 69 - 126/432 b R9 NGC MS64 10% Bright all on the obverse with reverse a bit weak opposite Lincoln's head. Lincoln The Right Man In The Right Place 1864 with No Compromise with Traitors reverse struck in Brass. Very rare die combination in any composition. From the Tampa, Steve Tanenbaum, Dave Bowers and Andrew Zabriskie collections earlier from Sotheby's June 1999. The NGC holder is labeled Bowers Reference Set. Data: 33.1 grains. (1000-1500) 70 - 127/160 a R9 PCGS MS66 BN Trace Red with nice toning. Abraham 1864 Lincoln Liberty For All with eagle perched on cannon. The fourth example of this rare Lincoln variety that we have seen offered. A Raw MS64 RB sold for $750 in our December 2012 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 200°, 39.7 grains, 19.8 mm. (1500-2000) 71 - 127/177 j R4 PCGS AU55 Trace Bright. 1864 Lincoln First In War, First In Peace 1863 struck in German Silver. Note the two different dates used. A Raw VF sold for $100 in our January 2017 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 180°, 47.6 grains, 19.6 mm. (200-300) 72 - 127/201 d R9 PCGS MS65 40% Bright, sharply struck and nearly Proof Like obverse. Abraham Lincoln 1864 with Our Union shield 1864 struck in Copper Nickel. We sold a Raw MS64 that realized $500 in our December 2012 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 200°, 61.1 grains, 19.4 mm. (750-1000) 73 - 127/248 a R4 PCGS MS65 RB 30% Red with nice cartwheel luster. 1864 Abraham Lincoln OK. We sold an NGC MS65 RB for $427.90 in our June 2011 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 200°, 38.4 grains, 19.1 mm. (500-750) 74 - 127/253 a R9 NGC MS64 RB 10% Red with attractive toning. 1864 Abraham Lincoln mule with Exceedingly rare 1864 Yngenio Ecuador die. The reverse die was originally used to make tokens in the US for use in Cuba but was muled during the war with six different Civil War token dies each exceedingly rare. We sold a 253/295 mp in NGC MS63 for $3,050 in our January 2016 auction. This with Lincoln rather than simple Free Dom is likely worth more. From the Mark Glazer collection and so noted on the NGC holder. (4000-6000) 75 - 127/294 d R9 NGC MS65 40% Bright and sharply struck. 1864 Lincoln Freedom struck in Copper Nickel. Rare die combination, a Raw MS65 brought $990 in our July 2007 sale. From the Tampa collection. (1000-1500)

076 078 079 76 - 127/428 d R9 PCGS MS66 70% Bright and nearly Proof Like. 1864 Abraham Lincoln with the rare C.L.R. reverse die struck in Copper Nickel. A Raw Nice Uncirculated from our March 2002 sale realized $1,063. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 200°, 62 grains, 19.7 mm. (1500-2000) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Patriotic Tokens 77 - 128/289 fp R7 NGC MS65 10% Bright and nicely toned. Lincoln and Union 1864 struck in Silvered Brass. From the Tampa collection. (500-750) 78 - 129/130 a R10 NGC MS65 RB 20% Red, very attractive toning and nearly Proof Like surfaces. Broadstruck and very impressive. 1864 Abraham Lincoln Unique double header. Each of the other three compositions of this die combination are also Unique. We sold the Brass example an NGC MS67 for $3,500 on our web site in December 2014. From the Mark Glazer collection and so noted on the NGC holder. (3000-4000) 79 - 129/282 e R9 PCGS MS64 80% Bright and nearly Proof Like. Abraham Lincoln 1864 with a crude broken neck eagle dated 1863 struck in White Metal. Very rare variety and reverse die, a Raw EF+ brought $706 in our June 2013 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 340°, 38.9 grains, 18.1 mm. (1500-2000) 80 - 131A/349A a R8 NGC MS62 BN 1864 Abraham Lincoln Our Country Our Flag Now & Forever struck in Copper. Two rare dies and normally seen only in Brass. We sold a Raw MS63 RB example that realized $1,300 in our March 2010 auction. From the Tampa collection. (1000-1500)

081 082 083 81 - 132/149 ao R9 PCGS MS64 BN Trace Red struck over another Patriotic token 51/334 with much detail showing particularly Our Army across Johnson's face. For President Abraham Lincoln / For Vice President Andrew Johnson. Popular token signed RL under each bust. Very popular token with dramatic error. An NGC MS64 example of the normal R5 variety realized $575 in our February 2014 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 30°, 35.1 grains, 19.1 mm. (750-1000) 82 - 134/184 d R9 PCGS MS65 50% Bright sharply struck with very nice cartwheel luster on the obverse. Lincoln Redeemed and Hunting Dogs struck in Copper Nickel. Two very rare and popular dies and the first example of this variety we have seen offered. An NGC MS64 BR sold for $4,800 in our August 2015 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 160°, 60.3 grains, 20.4 mm. (6000-8000) 83 - 134/283 d R9 PCGS MS65+ 60% Bright sharply struck with great cartwheel luster on the obverse and flashy reverse. Lincoln Redeemed and Eagle and Anchor struck in Copper Nickel. Very rare and popular dies. A Raw MS64 example in German Silver sold for $2,800 in our June 2013 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 180°, 63.6 grains, 20.2 mm. (4000-6000)

084 089 094 84 - 135/199 fo R10 PCGS MS63 Trace Bright, struck on 1843 Seated Dime. For Our Country A Common Cause with Andrew Jackson and eagle on shield 1863 struck in Silver. As a class Over Dimes are much rarer than Over Cents. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 90°, 39.5 grains, 19 mm. (3000-4000) 85 - 136/397 a R1 PCGS MS65 BN Trace Red. Typical, somewhat soft strike and great cartwheel luster and toning. Beware "Copperhead" 1863 with coiled snake. Always popular, an NGC MS65 sold for $571 in our February 2014 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. (500-750) 86 - 138/255 a R2 PCGS MS64 BN Trace Red all on the obverse. George McClellan Knickerbocker Currency. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 10°, 57 grains, 19.5 mm. (150-200) 87 - 138/434 a R1 PCGS MS65 BN 10% Red with nice luster. George McClellan United States Copper. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 350°, 49.5 grains, 19.6 mm. (150-200) 88 - 141/307 b R8 PCGS MS65 BN 20% Bright. Crude General George B. McClellan Army & Navy struck in Brass. Very rare in this composition, we sold a Raw VF+ example that brought $75 in our October 1999 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 20°, 44.3 grains, 19.5 mm. (400-500) 89 - 142/282 f R9 PCGS MS64 10% Bright with attractive toning particularly on reverse. General McClellan with 1863 Eagle reverse struck in Silver. The eagle is in flight despite what appears to be a broken neck. Very rare reverse die in any composition. Just the second example we have seen offered of this die combination though it is listed in five compositions. From the Dave Bowers collection from Rich Hartzog. Data: 0°, 54.8 grains, 18.4 mm. (1500-2000) 90 - 142/349 a R9 NGC AU58 BN Holed for suspension. General McClellan with 1864 dated display of cannons, flags and drums. Very rare reverse die and die combination, just the third we have seen offered. From the Mark Glazer collection earlier from Benj Fauver. (300-400) 91 - 142/349 e R9 PCGS MS63 60% Bright and nearly Proof Like. General McClellan with 1864 dated display of cannons, flags and drums struck in White Metal. Very rare reverse die and die combination, just the third we have seen offered in this composition. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 20°, 49.3 grains, 18.1 mm. (750-1000) 92 - 143/261 b R7 PCGS MS65 10% Bright with sharp strike from early die state. This Medal of G. B. McClellan Price One Cent struck in Brass. Quite rare in this composition, we sold an AU+ Details with stain for $76 in our October 1999 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 200°, 62 grains, 19.3 mm. (400-500) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Patriotic Tokens 93 - 146/184 j R8 PCGS MS63 40% Bright but poorly struck at centers as often seen with this composition. Ambrose Burnside 1864 with very popular Hunting Dogs struck in German Silver. A fascinating reverse die so much so that the late Civil War token dealer Bret Palser literally made it his calling card. From the Dave Bowers collection. Called 146/283 j on PCGS holder. Data: 200°, 34 grains, 20.1 mm. (2000-3000) 94 - 146/283 d R9 PCGS MS65 60% Bright. 1864 Ambrose Burnsides with Eagle and Anchor struck in Copper Nickel. This Eagle and Anchor die like its more famous Hunting Dogs cousin has horizontal lines that add to the luster and beauty of the design. We sold a Raw MS61 example in White Metal for $1,250 in our January 2016 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 180°, 60 grains, 20.5 mm. (3000-4000)

095 097 099 95 - 146/472 b R9 PCGS MS63 30% Bright with typical weakness opposite Burnsides' head. 1864 General Burnsides Rhode Island First In The Field muled with 1837 East Boston Hard Times token reverse struck in Brass. For whatever reason this variety appears to be even rarer than the following with this being the first we have recorded. A Raw MS62 example in German Silver sold for $1,000 in our July 2009 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 180°, 38.5 grains, 18.9 mm. (1000-1500) 96 - 146/472 d R9 PCGS MS65 50% Bright, sharply struck on an apparently filed down planchet though no undertype is visible. 1864 General Burnsides Rhode Island First In The Field muled with 1837 East Boston Hard Times token reverse struck in Copper-Nickel. A Raw MS63 example in our July 2009 auction sold for $1,650. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 180°, 55 grains, 18.8 mm. (2000-3000) 97 - 147/227 fp R6 PCGS MS64 Trace Bright toned with full Silver Plating. Am I Ready 1861 The Union Must & Shall be Preserved signed L for John D. Lovett. Popular large size 31mm token with a soldier wearing a star studded shirt with neckerchief and Pilgrim style wide brim hat. A Raw AU+ brought $1,503 in our December 2017 sale. Listed in the Anti-Confederate section of DeWitt / Sullivan as C 1861-6. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 180°, 170.5 grains, 30.5 mm. (2000-3000) 98 - 151/430 a R1 PCGS MS65 BN Trace Red nicely toned. Benjamin Franklin Penny Saved Is A Penny Earned. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 10°, 48.2 grains, 19.6 mm. (150-200) 99 - 153/282 e R9 PCGS MS63 40% Bright and nearly Proof Like. Benjamin Franklin 1863 with unusual eagle flying with broken neck struck in White Metal. Both dies are rare, one of just five examples we have seen offered. We sold a Raw MS63 in our December 2017 sale that brought $2,750. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 340°, 38.8 grains, 18.2 mm. (3000-4000) 100 - 154/218 a R5 NGC XF40 BN Stephen A. Douglas with Naked Amazon Warrior reverse. A Raw EF+ realized $192 in our December 2017 auction. From the Mark Glazer collection. (200-300) 101 - 154/218 a R5 PCGS MS63 BN Stephen A. Douglas with Naked Amazon Warrior reverse. A Raw AU realized $241 in our August 2016 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 180°, 60.4 grains, 19.8 mm. (400-500)

102 104 106 102 - 154A/469A a R9 NGC AU55 BN Stephen Douglas S.A.D. obverse with Dry Goods Groceries & Provisions reverse die. This variety is listed as R9 but we do not know of another example which would make the reverse die Unique in the Patriotic series. From the Mark Glazer, Larkin Wilson, Joe Kuehnert and Ken Trobaugh collections, the Glazer pedigree is so noted on the NGC holder. (6000-8000) 103 - 155/431 a R4 NGC MS62 BN Union 1863 Indiana Primitive with Value Me As You Peas reverse. (200-300) 104 - 156/524 a R8 PCGS MS65 BN Trace Red all on the reverse. 1863 Flying Eagle with Sewing Machines Neatly Repaired 1863 reverse. Two rare Patriotic dies. A Raw AU+ brought $500 in our December 2017 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 280°, 55.2 grains, 19.3 mm. (1500-2000) 105 - 159/469 a R8 PCGS MS63 BN Well struck for die combination with typical late obverse die state with small rim cuds. 1863 Flying Eagle with Dry Goods And Groceries reverse. Two rare single use dies in the Patriotic series. An EF+ sold for $750 in our February 2014 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 45°, 56 grains, 19.4 mm. (2000-3000) 106 - 160/218 d R8 PCGS MS66 50% Bright. Liberty For All 1864 with eagle perched on cannon paired with a Naked Amazon Warrior dated 1863 struck in Copper Nickel. From the Dave Bowers collection. Called 160/218 do on PCGS's holder, seemingly in error. Data: 180°, 65.6 grains, 19.5 mm. (1500-2000) 107 - 160/417 e R8 PCGS MS64 20% Bright. Liberty For All 1864 with eagle perched on cannon struck in White Metal by Mossin and Marr of Milwaukee. A very popular token a Raw AU+ example of the R4 Copper variety realized $220 in our January 2016 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 180°, 47.7 grains, 19.9 mm. (500-750)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Patriotic Tokens 108 - 163/352 a R2 PCGS MS64 RB 20% Red. Union Army & Navy with shield and crossed cannons. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 0°, 49.3 grains, 19.2 mm. (100-150) 109 - 164/312 a R1 PCGS MS64 BN 20% Red. Eagle on Union shield Army & Navy. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 0°, 49 grains, 19.2 mm. (100-150) 110 - 166/432 a R6 PCGS MS65 RB 20% Red well struck with nice toning. Union shield with eagle and No Compromise With Traitors reverse. Very scarce obverse die. Rare this nice, we sold a Raw MS64 that brought $382 in our February 2014 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 315°, 44.8 grains, 18.9 mm. (500-750) 111 - 167/318 a R5 NGC MS64 BN 10% Red with nice toning. Union 1863 Army & Navy. Two scarce dies. Another NGC MS64 BN brought $580 in our December 2016 sale. From the Robert Williams collection. (400-500) 112 - 168/311 b R4 PCGS MS65 10% Bright. Cannon and cannon balls 1863 Army & Navy. Very rarely seen in Brass and quite underrated. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 330°, 43 grains, 19.2 mm. (300-400) 113 - 169/213 b R3 PCGS MS64 10% Bright. Popular Peace Maker cannon 1863 struck in Brass and rare as such. From the Dave Bowers collection from C&D Gale. Data: 120°, 45.7 grains, 19.2 mm. (400-500) 114 - 172/429 a R5 PCGS MS63 BN Military Necessity with crossed cannons. Rare this nice, we sold a Raw MS63 in our February 2014 sale that realized $335. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 260°, 56.2 grains, 19.5 mm. (400-500) 115 - 173/272 a R1 NGC MS64 BN First In War First In Peace 1863 with Washington on horseback. (75-100) 116 - 175/400 a R3 NGC MS65 BN Sharply struck and nicely centered. First In War, First In Peace 1863. The Union Must And Shall Be Preserved Jackson. The Indiana Primitive version of Scovill's 174 die. Exceptional condition for one of these crude tokens. We sold a nice Raw AU for $130 in our December 2017 sale. From the Tampa collection. (400-500)

117 124 148 117 - 177/177 a R8 NGC MS63 BN Well struck with nice toning. First In Peace, First In War 1863 with George Washington on horseback with full mirror brockage mint error reverse. We sold a Raw MS63 Trace Red example for $900 in our January 2016 auction. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection earlier from Dave Schenkman February 1980. The Tanenbaum pedigree is noted on the NGC holder. (1500-2000) 118 - 178/267 a R1 NGC AU58 BN The Federal Union It Must And Shall Be Preserved 1863. NGC holder calls 178/226 in error. (25-50) 119 - 187/214 g (apl) R8 PCGS AU58 Trace Red with 95% of original Copper plating remaining. Plain edge. Time is Money Exigency 1863 The Flag of Our Union struck in Copper Plated Lead. Rare obverse die that is normally seen in the store card series. Almost certainly a contemporary counterfeit made to circulate during the war. From the Dave Bowers collection. Called 187/476 g Copper-Plated Lead on PCGS's holder in error. Data: 0°, 61.3 grains, 19.1 mm. (500-750) 120 - 188/435 b R8 NGC MS65 20% Bright mostly on the obverse. Industry 1864 with bees and beehive struck in Brass with United We Stand Divided We Fall reverse. Very scarce reverse die. We sold a Raw MS63 for $425 in our July 2007 sale. From the Tampa and Henry South collections. The Henry South pedigree is noted on the NGC holder. (500-750) 121 - 199/440 e R9 PCGS MS62 10% Bright, poorly struck from misaligned dies with the reverse off center 10% or so. 1863 Eagle on shield with Now And For Ever reverse struck in White Metal. A very unusual die combination made all the more unusual in that it only is known in White Metal. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 110°, 50.3 grains, 19.5 mm. (300-400) 122 - 203/413 b R4 PCGS MS64 Or nearly so with 20% Bright luster. The Flag Of Our Union If Anyone Attempts To Tear It Down Shoot Him On The Spot Dix struck in Brass. Rarely seen in this composition. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections. (150-200) 123 - 204/413 a R5 PCGS MS64 BN Trace Red nicely toned. The Flag Of Our Union If Anyone Attempts To Tear It Down Shoot Him On The Spot Dix struck in Copper. Very scarce single use obverse die. A Raw EF realized $170.50 in our March 2010 sale. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections earlier from Leslie Heilbronner 1973. (400-500) 124 - 205/411 a R9 PCGS MS64 BN 10% Red with attractive toning. The Flag Of Our Union If Anyone Attempts To Tear It Down Shoot Him On The Spot Dix. Exceedingly rare reverse die, easily recognizable by recut T and H of "THE" on reverse. Not only was this die only used for one variety in the Patriotic series, it was not used at all in the store card series. This is the finest of just five examples we have seen offered. An NGC MS63 BN sold for $2,650 in our December 2016 sale. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections from Walt Korzick June 1975. (4000-6000) 125 - 209/412 b R4 PCGS MS63 Trace Bright. The Flag Of Our Union If Anyone Attempts To Tear It Down Shoot Him On The Spot Dix struck in Brass. Rarely seen in this composition. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections from Gary Pipher 1975. (150-200) 126 - 209/414 b Unlisted PCGS MS65 20% Bright. The Flag Of Our Union If Anyone Attempts To Tear It Down Shoot Him On The Spoot Dix struck in Brass. Popular SPOOT spelling error, unlisted in this composition. From the Dave Bowers collection. (300-400) 127 - 210/323 a R1 PCGS MS64 RB 40% Red. The Flag Of Our Union 1863 Army and Navy. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections. (100-150) 128 - 210/416 b R3 PCGS MS63 50% Bright. The Flag Of Our Union If Anyone Attempts To Tear It Down Shoot Him On The Spot Dix struck in Brass. Rarely seen in this composition. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections from Bill Panitch December 1980. (150-200) 129 - 211/400 a R4 PCGS MS65 BN 10% Red with nice toning and very strong cartwheel luster. Higgins Indiana Primitive version of The Flag Of Our Union 1863 with The Union Must And Shall Be Preserved Jackson. The nicest example we have offered in quite some time, an NGC MS65 BN brought $425 in our September 2010 sale. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections earlier from Richard Coslet June 1979. (400-500) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Patriotic Tokens 130 - 212/415 a R2 PCGS MS65 BN Trace Red and nicely toned. The Flag Of Our Union If Anyone Attempts To Tear It Down Shoot Him On The Spot Dix struck in Copper. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections. (150-200) 131 - 212/415 b Unlisted PCGS MS65 50% Bright. The Flag Of Our Union If Anyone Attempts To Tear It Down Shoot Him On The Spot Dix struck in Brass. Unlisted and the first I have seen offered in this composition. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections. (200-300) 132 - 214/416 a R1 PCGS MS65 BN 10% Red with very nice luster. The Flag Of Our Union If Anyone Attempts To Tear It Down Shoot Him On The Spot Dix struck in Copper. From the Dave Bowers, Steve Tanenbaum and Cindy Grellman Wibker collections. (150-200) 133 - 219/320 a R1 PCGS MS65 RB 40% Red and nicely toned. The Federal Union It Must And Shall Be Preserved Army And Navy. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections purchased at the 1973 ANA. (150-200) 134 - 219/323 a R2 PCGS MS64 RB 20% Red with nice luster. The Federal Union It Must And Shall Be Preserved Army And Navy. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections earlier from Leslie Heilbronner 1973. (100-150) 135 - 220/322 b R7 PCGS MS65 60% Bright. The Federal Union It Must And Shall Be Preserved Army And Navy struck in Brass. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections from Gary Pipher 1974. (150-200) 136 - 221/324 b Unlisted PCGS MS64 60% Bright. The Federal Union It Must And Shall Be Preserved Army And Navy struck in Brass and Unlisted in that composition. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections from Jon Harris at the 1973 ANA. (200-300) 137 - 222/325 b R3 PCGS MS64 20% Bright. The Federal Union It Must And Shall Be Preserved Army And Navy struck in Brass. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections earlier from Leslie Heilbronner 1973. (100-150) 138 - 223/328 a R2 PCGS MS65 BN 10% Red mainly on the obverse. The Federal Union It Must And Shall Be Preserved Army And Navy. From the Dave Bowers, Steve Tanenbaum and Cindy Grellman Wibker collections. (150-200) 139 - 224/326 a R1 PCGS MS65 BN 10% Red. The Federal Union It Must And Shall Be Preserved Army And Navy. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections earlier from Leslie Heilbronner 1973. (100-150) 140 - 225/327 a R1 PCGS MS65 RB 50% Red. The Federal Union It Must And Shall Be Preserved Army And Navy. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections from J. J. Teaparty March 1973. (100-150) 141 - 225A/327 a R3 PCGS MS65 RB 40% Red. The Federal Union It Must And Shall Be Preserved Army And Navy. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections. (100-150) 142 - 226/321 b R8 PCGS MS64 10% Bright more so on the reverse. The Federal Union It Must And Shall Be Preserved Army And Navy struck in Brass. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections earlier from Leslie Heilbronner 1973. (150-200) 143 - 230/352B a R2 NGC MS64 RB 30% Red more so on the obverse. Our Country with crossed Union cannons. (100-150) 144 - 238/402 a R4 NGC AU55 BN Trace Red with some light reverse planchet flaws as made. The Indiana Primitive version of Our Little Monitor. Very scarce obverse and reverse die. A Raw EF+ also with some light flaws sold for $300 in our February 2014 auction. (500-750) 145 - 238/405 a R3 NGC AU58 BN Our Little Monitor The Constitution Must And Shall Be Preserved. Scarce Indiana Primitive version of the Our Little Monitor obverse die. From the Tampa collection. (300-400) 146 - 241/338 d R9 NGC MS63 40% Bright. 1864 Monitor Our Navy struck in Copper Nickel. A less bright raw MS63 sold for $467.50 in our December 2006 sale. From the Robert Williams collection. (500-750) 147 - 256/433 a R3 NGC MS65 RB 40% Red. Horrors of War, Blessings of Peace Union For Ever. A raw MS63 with more red sold for $220 in our August 2015 auction. From the Robert Williams collection. (300-400) 148 - 260/447 b R7 NGC MS62 20% Bright. Constitution 1861 Concession Before Secession struck in Brass. An NGC MS62 BN example of the R7 - 1a variety sold for $750 in our January 2016 sale. From the Robert Williams collection. (750-1000)

149 152 154 149 - 286A/287 d R9 PCGS MS65 60% Bright. Silver Mine Token with Gold Weight reverse struck in Copper Nickel. We sold a raw MS64 example for $2,000 in our July 2012 auction. From the Dave Bowers, Steve Tanenbaum, Joe Kuehnert, Rich Rossa, Ken Trobaugh and George Fuld collections. (3000-4000) 150 - 332/336 a R4 NGC MS62 RB 30% Red. Our Army / Our Navy. Scarce die combination, particularly this nice. (100-150) 151 - 332/336 d R7 NGC MS64 60% Bright. Likely struck on a filed down US Copper Nickel Cent with file marks visible on and near rims, though no undertype is visible. Our Army / Our Navy struck in Copper Nickel. A somewhat underrated variety. From the Robert Williams collection. (300-400) 152 - 425/425 a R9 NGC MS64 BN 10% Red. Single Die Doubleheader. 1863 within wreath Single Die Doubleheader. One of the rarest types of Civil War tokens. These are normally thought to be the work of idle hands at the manufacturer. A token was struck uniface against another blank planchet or smooth surface then flipped over and struck again in the same manner. This usually results in the side first struck being somewhat squashed or distorted as on this example. They can also result from an odd set of striking errors which would normally result in the same type of appearance. Very rare die in the Patriotic series. We sold an NGC XF45 example of the equally rare but of a much more common die 87 in our July 2014 sale that realized $1,485 in spirited bidding. From the Mark Glazer and Larkin Wilson collections, the Glazer pedigree is so noted on the NGC holder. (2000-3000)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Patriotic Tokens 153 - 427/480A a R9 NGC AU55 BN Sharply struck with none of the problems that often plague this issue. A raw VF+ example of the -1b variety sold for $1,000 in our December 2016 sale. Union C 1863 with Eureka Good For 10. Two rare dies particularly the reverse. Very rarely seen above VF and many have some sort of problem, mainly stray counterstamps. We sold a similar raw piece in our August 2015 auction which realized $450. From the Tampa and Steve Tanenbaum collections. (1000-1500) 154 - 444/452A b R9 NGC AU50 BN An arrangement of fruit surrounded by stars while the reverse features 10 CENTS also surrounded by stars struck in Brass. The only use of die 452A in the Patriotic series and quite rare. The plate for this die in the current Fuld Patriotic book is actually a picture of store card. The picture was borrowed from plates used in Fuld's Store Card book as close study of the two will indicate. When we last offered this example nearly 20 years ago it caused quite a stir and brought $7,001 with spirited bidding in our April 2000 auction. Another example or two have turned up since, so it likely will not bring that much but it is still the finest know. From the Mark Glazer, Larkin Wilson and George Fuld collections, the Glazer pedigree is so noted on the NGC holder. (3000-4000)

155 157 168 155 - 474/475 a R8 NGC MS63 BN Milk Check One Quart Milk. Two rare Indiana Primitive dies neither of which were used in the Store Card series. A MS62 brown with small planchet flaw realized $3,300 in our December 2008 auction. From the Tampa collection earlier from our December 2008 sale where it realized $3,300. (3000-4000) 156 - 520/521 a R7 NGC AU53 BN An unusually high grade example, a bit unevenly struck as often seen on this variety. Liberty 1860 Copper Mine Token. Crude Escherich token often seen uneven, clipped with marks and scratches. This is much better than average. A raw VF slightly porous with uneven strike and light marks brought $525 in our July 2012 auction. From the John J. Ford collection Stack's Bowers August 2013 where it realized $763.75. The Ford pedigree is noted on the NGC holder. (500-750) Civil War Sutler Tokens 157 - IL-51-5B R8 PCGS MS64 30% Bright. H. Lester 51st Illinois Volunteers Good For 5 Cents In Goods At Sutlers Store 1861 with Arm and Hammer reverse struck in Brass. Formerly IL K-5B. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1390. (1500-2000) 158 - IL-97-10Cc R8 PCGS MS64 BN S. Whited & Co. Sutlers, 97th Illinois Volunteers Good For 10 Cent with Store Card reverse die featuring 10 within circle of stars struck in Copper. Formerly IL S-10C. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1393. Data: 60°, 62.7 grains, 19.1 mm. (1000-1500) 159 - IL-MB-50B R8 PCGS AU58 H. Rice Sutler M'Clernands Brigade Illinois Volunteers 50 Cents In Goods. Formerly IL T-50B. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 90°, 34 grains, 25.3 mm. (500-750) 160 - IN-16-05Ba R9 PCGS MS62 Sutler Check 16th Indiana Volunteers 5 Cents in Goods. Rare sutler, a Raw VF example brought $900 in our July 2014 auction. Formerly IN D-5Ba. (2000-3000) 161 - IN-36-05Ba R8 PCGS AU58 Or a bit better. Trace Bright. G. Davidson 5 Cents, 36th Indiana Volunteers. Formerly IN G-05Ba. From the Tampa collection. (500-750) 162 - IN-71-10B R9 NGC MS62 Trace Bright and nicely struck. W.W. Sibley & Co. Sutler 71st Regiment Indiana Volunteers. Very rare Sutler, a Raw EF example of the R8 -5B variety sold for $1,127.50 in our July 2006 sale. From the Rick Irons, Steve Tanenbaum and Dave Schenkman collections. This is the Plate Specimen for both the first and second editions of the book on Sutler tokens. (3000-4000) 163 - IT-FS-05Bb R10 NGC AU55 Sutler Check Redeemed by Rice & Byers 5 Cents Fort Still, Indian Territory. Unlisted variety in First Edition. Though listed as Unique in the Second Edition, this is the fourth example we have recorded, two of which are badly damaged. This example sold for $1,350 on our June 2015 fixed price list. From the Rick Irons and Terry Brenner collections. (1500-2000) 164 - KY-1-05B R8 PCGS MS65 40% Bright. Simmonds Battery, J. M. Kerr Sutler 5 Cents struck in Brass. This Sutler is now attributed to the First Kentucky Independent Battery. A Raw MS63 sold for $900 in our July 2014. Formerly NL M-5B. From the Dave Bowers, Steve Tanenbaum, Byron Hoke and Henry Chapman collections. Reverse Die: 1391. (1000-1500) 165 - KY-1-10C R8 PCGS MS65 RB 60% Red. Simmonds Battery, J. M. Kerr Sutler 10 Cents struck in Copper. This Sutler is now attributed to the First Kentucky Independent Battery. An NGC MS63 BN sold for $753.15 in our January 2016. Formerly NL M-10C. From the Dave Bowers, Steve Tanenbaum and Dave Schenkman collections. Reverse Die: 1394. (1000-1500) 166 - KY-1-25C R7 PCGS MS65 RB 50% Red. Simmonds Battery, J. M. Kerr Sutler 25 Cents struck in Copper. This Sutler is now attributed to the First Kentucky Independent Battery. A Raw MS63 sold for $600 in our January 2017. Formerly NL M-25C. From the Dave Bowers collection from PCAC March 1999. Reverse Die: 1399. (1000-1500) 167 - KY-1-50Ca R8 PCGS MS64 RB 60% Red. Simmonds Battery, J. M. Kerr Sutler 50 Cents struck in Copper. This Sutler is now attributed to the First Kentucky Independent Battery. A Raw AU sold for $406 in our March 2010. Formerly NL M-50Ca. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1404. (1000-1500) 168 - KY-1-CNa R10 PCGS MS65 40% Bright. Simmonds Battery, J. M. Kerr Sutler 1864 struck in Copper Nickel and thought to be Unique. This Sutler is now attributed to the First Kentucky Independent Battery. Formerly NL N-CN. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections from Paul Koppenhaver and Sol Kaplan. Reverse Die: 1047. (3000-4000)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Sutler Tokens

169 178 181 169 - KY-21-05C R8 PCGS MS65 BN Trace Red with attractive toning. 21st Kentucky Volunteer Infantry Good For 5 Cents 1863 with flying eagle. Rare sutler. Formerly KY A-5C. From the Dave Bowers, Steve Tanenbaum, Dave Schenkman and George Fuld collections. Reverse Die: 1166. (1500-2000) 170 - MD A-15 B R8 NGC AU55 Or nearly so. G. Gilpin Sutler Cumberland Maryland 2nd Regiment P. H. B. (Potomac Home Brigade) 15 Cents In Goods. Very rare state and sutler, a Raw VF+ realized $3,400 in our July 2014 sale. From the Tampa collection. (3000-4000) 171 - MA-19-100Ba R8 NGC AU55 With a light toning stain on the obverse and more serious one on the blank reverse. Edward Pearl Sutler, 19th Massachusetts Volunteer Infantry. A rare Sutler. The denomination is spelled out ONE unlike the other varieties. It is thought to represent One Dollar, a rare denomination only used by a handful of other issuers. From the Rick Irons and Raymond Bunt collections earlier from Steve Tanenbaum. (1000-1500) 172 - NY- 13-25B R10 NGC AU55 G. H. Benedict was a sutler for the 13th New York Heavy Artillery. Rare sutler, a VF sold for $1,000 in our March 2010 sale. This is the discovery specimen and was thought to be a Unique variety when the second edition was publish. Since that time an additional example has been recorded. A Raw VF example of the much more available -5B variety sold for $1,000 in our March 2010 sale. From the Rick Irons and Steve Tanenbaum collections. This is the Plate Specimen in the Second Edition of the Sutler token book. (3000-4000) 173 - NT-1-25C R7 PCGS AU58 P. Hoddy & Co. First Nebraska Regiment 25 Cents In Goods with John Stanton back stamp. Rare state, a Raw EF Details with many light marks sold for $500 in our February 2014 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 270°, 25.9 grains, 21.7 mm. (1500-2000) 174 - OH-04a-10B R7 PCGS MS63 20% Bright mostly on the obverse. E. W. Hamlin Sutler 4th Regiment Ohio Volunteer Cavalry Good For 10 Cents In Goods. We sold a Raw AU+ for $450 in our June 2013 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection from Walt Korzick February 1998. (1000-1500) 175 - OH-23-25C R7 PCGS MS64 RB 40% Red. G. W. Forbes Sutler 23rd Ohio 25 Cents 1863. We sold a Raw UNC Details with short scratch in our April 2012 internet only auction that brought $575. Formerly OH N-25C. From the Dave Bowers collection from us September 2001. Reverse Die: 1082. (1500-2000) 176 - OH-55a-05C R8 PCGS MS63 BN Trace Red and nicely toned. J. B. Spitzer Sutler, 55th Ohio Volunteer Infantry 5 Cents with anchor reverse die. We sold an NGC MS63 BN in our December 2016 auction for $953.75. Formerly OH V-5C. From the Dave Bowers collection from us via Want List. Reverse Die: 1346. Data: 50.6 grains, 19.3 mm. (1000-1500) 177 - OH-55a-10CN R10 PCGS MS65 50% Bright. J. B. Spitzer Sutler, 55th Ohio Volunteer Infantry 10 Cents 1863 The Army & Navy with shield struck in Copper Nickel and thought to be Unique. Formerly OH V-10CN. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections from Paul Koppenhaver and Sol Kaplan. This is the current Fuld Plate specimen for this die combination. Reverse Die: 1226. (3000-4000) 178 - OH-55a-25C R7 PCGS MS64 RB 50% Red. J. B. Spitzer Sutler, 55th Ohio Volunteer Infantry 25 Cents 1863 with flying eagle. Formerly OH V-25C. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections. Reverse Die: 1168. (1000-1500) 179 - OH-55a-50C R8 PCGS MS65 BN Trace Red. J. B. Spitzer Sutler, 55th Ohio Volunteer Infantry 50 Cents with Mercury head. We sold a Raw MS63 RB in our October 2012 auction for $1,075. Formerly OH V-50C. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1122. Data: 20°, 53 grains, 19.5 mm. (1000-1500) 180 - OH-61-10B R8 PCGS MS63 61st Regiment Ohio Volunteers USA 10 Cents with John Stanton Die Sinker reverse struck in Brass. This is the current Sutler book plate token. Rare in Uncirculated condition. Formerly OH Z-5B. From the Dave Bowers collection from Walt Korzick February 1998. (1000-1500) 181 - OH-81a-10CN R10 PCGS MS65 50% Bright. J. W. Cruikshank 81st Regiment Ohio Volunteer Infantry 10 Cents with Beer Mug reverse struck in Copper Nickel and thought to be Unique. Formerly OH AF-10CN. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections from Paul Koppenhaver and Sol Kaplan. This is the current Fuld Plate specimen for this die combination. Reverse Die: 1295. (3000-4000) 182 - OH-81a-25C R7 PCGS MS64 BN 10% Red. J. W. Cruikshank 81st Regiment Ohio Volunteer Infantry 25 Cents with eagle on shield reverse. Formerly OH AF-25C. From the Dave Bowers and Raymond Bunt collections. Reverse Die: 1176. (1000-1500) 183 - PA-12-05B R9 NGC F15 A nice, well struck and problem free example. L. Lang Sutler 12th Pennsylvania Cavalry Regiment Good 5. Exceedingly rare Sutler, we sold a Raw VF+ Details example of the R9 -10B variety with tiny digs that brought $1,000 in our February 2014 sale. From the Rick Irons, Steve Tanenbaum, Byron Hoke and Henry Chapman collections. (1000-1500) 184 - PA-28-25B R8 NGC AU55 C. & S. Sutler 28th Regiment Pennsylvania Volunteers 25 Cent denomination struck in Brass with a blank reverse. Rare sutler, particularly this nice and likely the finest known of this issuer. We sold a Raw EF example of the -5B variety in our December 2017 sale for $700. Formerly PA H-25B. From the Rick Irons and Terry Brenner collections. This is the Plate Specimen for the Second Edition. (1500-2000)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Sutler Tokens

185 189 190 185 - PA-54-3B R5 PCGS MS64 20% Bright. J. A. Garman Sutler 54th Pennsylvania Volunteers 3 Cents. This is the smallest denomination for this prolific issuer. There is an example known with just a 2 stamped which is presumed to have been intended as 25. Formerly PA I-003B. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 330°, 30.2 grains, 18.4 mm. (500-750) 186 - PA-72-10B R8 NGC AU58 10% Bright. A. W. H. Baxter's Fire Zouaves Sutler's 10 Ticket. The Pennsylvania 72nd Volunteers were popularly known as Baxter's Fire Zouaves because its soldiers were drawn from Philadelphia Fire Companies. They were organized and led by DeWitt Clinton Baxter and wore the unusual Zouave style uniforms with short jackets, baggy trousers and ornamental headgear. Seemingly nicer than the other NGC AU58 that realized $900 in our July 2014 auction. Formerly NL H-10B. From the John J. Ford collection Stack's Bowers August 2013. The Ford pedigree is noted on the NGC holder. (1000-1500) 187 - VA-2a-5C R8 PCGS UNC Details Scratch. J. L. O'Neal 2nd Virginia Cavalry 5 Cents with Stanton back stamp struck in Copper. Formerly VA C-5C. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 315°, 11.7 grains, 16.6 mm. (750-1000) 188 - WI-11-10Ba R7 PCGS AU55 Sid Wright Good For 10 Cents In Goods At Sutlers Store, 11th Regiment Wisconsin Volunteers. Very rare state, a Raw VF Details with short scratches brought $770 in our March 2010 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection from us via Want List. Data: 180°, 56.1 grains, 21.8 mm. (1500-2000) Civil War Store Cards

189 - AL425A- 5a R8 PCGS MS63 BN White & Swann, Huntsville Alabama struck in Copper. Very rare and desirable southern state. Just the second example in our data base. An NGC MS64 example of the -1a variety realized $4,800 in our December 2016 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1397. Data: 110°, 52.8 grains, 19.1 mm. (6000-8000) 190 - AL425A- 9e R9 PCGS MS62 20% Bright. White & Swann, Huntsville Alabama struck in White Metal. Very rare and desirable southern state. An NGC MS64 example of the -1a variety realized $4,800 in our December 2016 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1403. Data: 340°, 60.7 grains, 19.2 mm. (4000-6000) 191 - CT035B-1a R1 PCGS MS65 BN 10% Red sharp strike. A. W. Wallace's Variety Bakery, Bridgeport Connecticut. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1201. Data: 0°, 49.1 grains, 19.1 mm. (150-200)

192 193 211 192 - CT250A-1b(fp) R8 NGC MS62 Trace Bright with full Silvering. Arch Saloon No. 10 O. Rudd Montville Connecticut with Lincoln Redeemed. Reverse die struck in Silvered brass and has the odd cross hatching on the edge as noted in new Store Card book. Formerly attributed to Willimantic and has been moved in the new Store Card book to Montville where Orrind Rudd was a saloon keeper. A very rare town and one of the finest known. We sold another NGC MS62 for $2,650 in our January 2016 sale. (2000-3000) 193 - CT560A-1a R4 PCGS MS64 BN Nice toning. New York Store, Waterbury Connecticut. Popular token with Postage Currency reverse. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 330°, 43.5 grains, 19.1 mm. (300-400) 194 - CT560A-2a R4 PCGS MS65 BN Trace Red. New York Store Millinery and Fancy Goods, Waterbury Connecticut 1863. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 90°, 46 grains, 19.2 mm. (300-400) 195 - IL025B-1j R9 PCGS MS63 50% Bright. Gates & Trask Dealers In Watches, Jewelry & Silverware, Aurora, Illinois struck in German Silver. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1368. Data: 0°, 61.5 grains, 19.6 mm. (500-750) 196 - IL065A-2d R8 PCGS MS65 40% Bright. S. P. Sedgwick & Co. Variety Goods, Bloomington Illinois struck in Copper Nickel with Lincoln reverse die. We sold an NGC MS65 RB example of the Copper variety for $660 in our December 2008 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1145. Data: 190°, 60.9 grains, 19.4 mm. (750-1000) 197 - IL095B-3d R10 PCGS MS64 60% Bright and very sharp. D. Ford Watch Maker And Jeweler, Cairo Illinois struck in Copper Nickel and thought to be Unique. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 65 grains, 19.4 mm. (1000-1500) 198 - IL140B-2a R5 PCGS AU58 B. A. Wade & Co. Dealer In Dry Goods Groceries & C., Chemung Illinois. An EF brought $206.81 in our May 2004 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1357. Data: 160°, 46.4 grains, 19.5 mm. (300-400) 199 - IL150 B-1j R8 PCGS MS64 40% Bright. Barker & Illsley Hardware, Chicago Illinois struck in German Silver. Just the second example we have seen offered. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1368. Data: 0°, 61.9 grains, 19.7 mm. (500-750) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 200 - IL150 G-1a R6 PCGS MS62 BN Ira Brown Book Dealer 61 West Kinzie St., Chicago Illinois 1863. Very scarce merchant particularly this nice. This is one of just three Uncirculated examples we have recorded. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1096. Data: 0°, 47.7 grains, 19.7 mm. (150-200) 201 - IL150 J-18j R6 PCGS MS62 10% Bright. Childs' Manufacturer of Advertising Coin, Chicago Illinois struck in German Silver. One of very few Civil War tokens in this composition that actually circulated; rarely seen this nice. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1203. Data: 180°, 44.3 grains, 19.8 mm. (300-400) 202 - IL150 J-22a R8 PCGS MS66 BN 10% Red. 1861 Childs Manufacturer, Chicago Illinois with Suit of clothing reverse die. Only the second example we have recorded. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1338. Data: 350°, 49.6 grains, 19.5 mm. (500-750) 203 - IL150 P-2a R7 PCGS AU53 F. N. Dubois Die Sinker, Chicago Illinois. One of the rarest Chicago merchants. A Raw FINE+ realized $211.20 in our March 1997 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1368. Data: 0°, 56 grains, 19.6 mm. (500-750) 204 - IL150 R-1a R4 PCGS MS62 BN A. W. Escherich, Chicago Illinois 1861 Business Card with Indian Head. Escherich operated as a die sinker during the war and produced a number of crude tokens. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1080. Data: 45°, 47.5 grains, 19.5 mm. (200-300) 205 - IL150 S-1a R3 PCGS MS64 BN 10% Red. Flaggs Cheap Store Boots & Shoes, Chicago Illinois. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1368. Data: 0°, 63.3 grains, 19.7 mm. (100-150) 206 - IL150 V-2a R3 PCGS MS64 BN Nice toning and luster. Freedman & Goodkind Dry Goods & Millinery, Chicago Illinois 1861 Business Card. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1118. Data: 180°, 52.7 grains, 19.4 mm. (150-200) 207 - IL150 W-1j R8 PCGS MS64 60% Bright. Freedman, Goodkind & Co. Dry Goods, Chicago Illinois struck in German Silver. One of just two examples we have seen offered. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1368. Data: 0°, 59.6 grains, 19.6 mm. (500-750) 208 - IL150 Z-1a R4 PCGS MS64 RB 50% Red. G. E. Gerts & Co. Brush Factory, Chicago Illinois. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1368. Data: 0°, 61.5 grains, 19.7 mm. (150-200) 209 - IL150AA-3a R8 PCGS MS65 BN 10% Red. Haas & Powell Butchers, Chicago Illinois Union 1861 with eagle. Rare variety, the third example we have recorded. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1207. Data: 200°, 51.1 grains, 19.6 mm. (400-500) 210 - IL150AG-3a R8 PCGS MS64 BN Trace Red more so on the reverse. S. A. Ingram Watches And Clocks, Chicago Illinois 1863. Very rare merchant. We sold a nice part red Uncirculated example for $1,001 in our October 2001 sale in a time before we assigned numerical grades. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1274. Data: 180°, 57 grains, 19.2 mm. (2000-3000) 211 - IL150AG-4f R9 PCGS MS65 With attractive toning and nearly Proof Like surfaces. S. A. Ingram Watches and Clocks, Chicago Illinois muled with J. A. Hughes Metallic Cards Cincinnati Ohio struck in Silver. A very rare muling of two very rare merchants, Hughes being essentially uncollectable. We sold a Raw UNC Details with cleaned reverse example of the Unique Copper variety in our August 2015 sale that realized $1,879. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 0°, 67.4 grains, 19.2 mm. (3000-4000)

212 215 220 212 - IL150AG-5f R9 PCGS MS65 With very attractive toning. S. A. Ingram Watches and Clocks, Chicago Illinois with Phoenician head reverse struck in Silver. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1131. Data: 180°, 69.2 grains, 18.9 mm. (2000-3000) 213 - IL150AI-3b R6 PCGS MS64 Trace Bright and nicely struck for variety. O. Kendall's Sons & Co. Bread Good For One Loaf, Chicago Illinois struck in Brass with very scarce 1861 Arm and Hammer reverse die 1390. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1390. Data: 180°, 38.8 grains, 19.6 mm. (400-500) 214 - IL150AK-4d R10 PCGS MS64 40% Bright. Marsh & Miner Military Clothiers, Chicago Illinois 1864 struck in Copper Nickel and thought to be Unique. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1047. Data: 315°, 63.4 grains, 19.2 mm. (1000-1500) 215 - IL150AN-1b R10 PCGS MS62 Trace Bright and well struck. G.R. Meyer Good For 5 Cts with Mansion on a hill reverse featuring house surrounded by trees and a tall flagpole with a tiny horse drawn carriage riding past all behind a plank sidewalk and picket fence. Rare merchant Unique in Brass, we sold an NGC AU55 example of the R8 -1a variety on eBay for $2,250 in October 2017. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 330°, 45.5 grains, 19.4 mm. (4000-6000) 216 - IL150AQ-1a R5 PCGS MS64 BN 10% Red. Oppenheimer & Metzger Jewelry & Watch Materials, Chicago Illinois. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1368. Data: 190°, 51.9 grains, 19.6 mm. (200-300) 217 - IL150AR-1b R7 PCGS AU53 Wm. Ostendorf Good For One Glass Beer, Chicago Illinois. Rare single variety merchant, a Raw VF+ sold for $255 in our June 2013 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 30°, 54.4 grains, 19.5 mm. (400-500) 218 - IL150AS-1a R5 PCGS MS65 BN Attractive toning. Passage Certificates From Liverpool To Chicago, Bank Drafts For 1£ And Upwards On The Royal Bank Of Ireland 1861. Very popular token. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 170°, 47.7 grains, 19.6 mm. (400-500) 219 - IL150AT-6a R6 PCGS MS65 RB 40% Red. W. G. Peck Grocer, Chicago Illinois 1861. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1116. Data: 160°, 49.9 grains, 19.4 mm. (200-300) 220 - IL150AY-1a R3 PCGS MS64 BN Nice toning. Great West Market Fresh & Salt Meats, Chicago. Popular 1286 reverse die featuring Bull holding flags in his mouth. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1286. Data: 0°, 50.7 grains, 19.5 mm. (400-500)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 221 - IL150AZ-1a R9 PCGS MS65 BN 10% Red mostly on the reverse with nicely toned obverse. F. E. Rigby Wall Papers, Chicago Illinois 1861. Rare variety, just the fourth we have recorded. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1111. Data: 200°, 52.4 grains, 19.5 mm. (300-400) 222 - IL150BC-5a R7 PCGS MS65 BN 20% Red. C. & S. Stein Dry Goods Store, Chicago Illinois Union 1861. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1207. Data: 0°, 52.1 grains, 19.6 mm. (200-300)

223 224 229 223 - IL150BG-1a R4 PCGS MS66 BN Trace Red attractive toning. C. Winsauer Gunsmith, Chicago with very scare reverse die 1345 featuring rifles, pistols and accessories. Popular token, a Raw MS64 RB sold for $563 in our July 2012 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1345. Data: 0°, 49.1 grains, 19.3 mm. (750-1000) 224 - IL210A-2a R9 PCGS MS66 Nicely toned. Ed Weibezahm Dealer In Groceries & Dry Goods, Dixon Illinois 1861 with Arm and Hammer reverse. Rare town, a Raw VF example of the much more available -1a variety sold for $297 in our July 2009 sale. Just the second example of this variety we have recorded. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1390. Data: 160°, 54.7 grains, 19.8 mm. (1500-2000) 225 - IL225A-1a R3 PCGS MS65 BN 10% Red attractive toning. H. L. Mosely, Durand Illinois. Scarce single merchant town. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 45.8 grains, 19.4 mm. (200-300) 226 - IL540A-1a R4 PCGS MS66 RB 40% Red. H. G. Skinner Groceries & Provisions, Marengo Illinois. Very scarce in Uncirculated condition, we sold a Raw MS63 in our August 2015 sale that realized $191.81. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1357. Data: 210°, 55.8 grains, 19.9 mm. (500-750) 227 - IL615A-1i R9 PCGS MS66 40% Bright with full Tin plating. Robert Naper Dry Goods Groceries & c., Naperville Illinois 1864 struck in Tin Plate. Very scarce single merchant town and the only example of this variety we have seen offered. A Raw VF example of the much more available R6 - 1a variety sold for $260 in our December 2012 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1046. Data: 135°, 53 grains, 19 mm. (1500-2000) 228 - IL692A- 1a R4 PCGS MS64 RB 20% Red. Yankee Robinson The Great Comedian with pictorial of Robinson in top hat with rifle. Robinson operated a traveling Circus and is listed under Peoria Illinois where his base of operations was located at the time these Civil War tokens were issued. From the Dave Bowers, Steve Tanenbaum, James Holtel, George Fuld and Don Schramm collections. (200-300) 229 - IL692A- 3a R4 PCGS MS66 RB 60% Red. Yankee Robinson The Great Comedian 1863 with pictorial of Robinson in top hat with rifle. Robinson operated a traveling Circus and traditionally was listed under Cincinnati Ohio. In the third edition of the Store Card book he has been relocated to Peoria Illinois where his base of operations was located at the time these Civil War tokens were issued. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections from Francis Cady. (400-500) 230 - IL692A- 9a R4 PCGS MS62 BN Yankee Robinson Big Show Triad 1863 with Indian Head. Robinson operated a traveling Circus listed under Peoria Illinois where his base of operations was located at the time these Civil War tokens were issued. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections from Rich Hartzog. Reverse Die: 1028. (100-150) 231 - IL692A-10a R5 PCGS MS65 BN 10% Red with nice luster. Yankee Robinson Big Show Triad 1863 with Indian Head. Robinson operated a traveling Circus listed under Peoria Illinois where his base of operations was located at the time these Civil War tokens were issued. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections from Francis Cady. Reverse Die: 1034. (150-200) 232 - IL692A-11a R8 PCGS MS64 BN Yankee Robinson Big Show Triad. Robinson operated a traveling Circus based in Peoria Illinois. Rare variety with reverse die 1045 and Indian Head surrounded by star and without a date. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections from Richard McFerran. Reverse Die: 1045. (200-300) 233 - IL692A-13a R7 PCGS UNC Details Scratch. Yankee Robinson Big Show Triad 1864 with Indian Head. Robinson operated a traveling Circus based in Peoria Illinois. One of the very few uses of reverse die 1047 that actually circulated. From the Dave Bowers collection. No attribution listed on PCGS holder. Reverse Die: 1047. (75-100) 234 - IL692A-14a R4 PCGS MS65 BN Trace Red nicely toned. Big Show Triad 1869 dated with Yankee Robinson portrait. From the Dave Bowers, Steve Tanenbaum and Henry South collections. (200-300) 235 - IL692A-15d R10 PCGS MS64 30% Bright. Yankee Robinson portrait 1863 with Indian Head struck in Copper Nickel and thought to be Unique. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections from Paul Koppenhaver. Reverse Die: 1018. (1000-1500) 236 - IL692A-16a R3 PCGS MS64 BN Attractive toning and very nice cartwheel luster. Yankee Robinson's Big Show Triad 1869 with portrait. From the Dave Bowers, Steve Tanenbaum, Henry South and George Fuld collections. (200-300) 237 - IL692A-17d R10 PCGS MS66 40% Bright. Yankee Robinson's Big Show Triad 1869 with 1864 Indian Head struck in Copper Nickel and thought to be Unique. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections from Paul Koppenhaver and Sol Kaplan. Reverse Die: 1047. (1000-1500) 238 - IL692A-18d R10 PCGS MS65 20% Bright. Yankee Robinson The Great Comedian Big Show 1869 struck in Copper Nickel and believed to be Unique. The 3rd edition appears to be incorrect or this is Unlisted. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections from PCAC. (1000-1500) 239 - IN020A-2a R7 NGC MS63 BN Trace Red with nice toning. J. P. Barnes, Anderson Indiana with anchor reverse die. Likely the finest known. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection and so noted on the holder earlier from Ron Vore December 1978. Reverse Die: 1346. (300-400)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 240 - IN260B-2a R9 PCGS AU55 A nice problem free example. J. Davenport & Son Dealers In Dry Goods, Elkhart Indiana 1863. Very rare Indiana Primitive merchant and variety. A Raw EF with tiny clip realized $750 in our February 2014 sale. From the Dave Bowers, Steve Tanenbaum, Don Schramm and Ray Haggenjos collections. Reverse Die: 1161. (1500-2000) 241 - IN260C-1a R6 PCGS MS63 BN Trace Red well centered and well struck. C. T. Greene & Co. Grocers & Provision Dealers, Elkhart Indiana 1863. Very scarce Indiana Primitive merchant very rare in Uncirculated condition. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections from the Western Reserve Museum sale by Spinks America October 1998. Reverse Die: 1003. (750-1000) 242 - IN495A-2a R8 NGC MS64 RB 20% Red and nicely toned. Robt. Cooder Dry Goods & Groceries, Jonesboro Indiana 1864. Rare town, particularly this nice. Another NGC MS64 RB example sold for $1,550 in our December 2008 auction. Reverse Die: 1047. (1500-2000) 243 - IN500H-1a R8 NGC MS63 BN 20% Red. J. H. Gotsch Dealer in Clocks, Watches & Jewelry, Kendallville Indiana. A very rare merchant, from our August 2015 sale where it was a Raw MS62 and sold for $350. Reverse Die: 1321. (500-750) 244 - IN530B-1a R7 PCGS MS63 BN J. Faller & Son Watchmakers and Jewelers, LaPorte Indiana 1863. Popular Indiana Primitive very difficult to find above VF. From the Dave Bowers, Steve Tanenbaum, Ed Rosen and George Fuld collections. Reverse Die: 1003. (500-750)

245 246 247 245 - IN530B-4a R9 PCGS MS64 BN Very attractive toning. J. Faller & Son Watchmakers and Jewelers, LaPorte Indiana. Very rare and previously unlisted obverse die, the finest of just three we have seen offered. We sold a Raw VF+ for $1,265 in our March 2008 sale. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections from Chuck Kirtley. This is the current Fuld Plate specimen for this die. Reverse Die: 1165. (2000-3000) 246 - IN630A- 4b R7 PCGS MS64 10% Bright mainly on the obverse. H. D. Higgins Jeweler, Optician and Manufacturer of Barometers, Mishawaka Indiana struck in Brass. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections from the Western Reserve Museum sale by Spinks America October 1998. Reverse Die: 1003. (750-1000) 247 - IN630A- 5a R3 PCGS MS65 BN 10% Red with nice toning and luster. H. D. Higgins Optician, Mishawaka. Popular token with reverse die 1328 with Periscopic Spectacles. From the Dave Bowers, Steve Tanenbaum, Don Schramm and Ray Haggenjos collections. Reverse Die: 1328. (750-1000) 248 - IN710A-2a R7 PCGS MS63 RB 50% Red more so on the obverse. A. M. Davis Dry Goods, Groceries, Crockery, Drugs & c., New Paris Indiana 1863. Rare single merchant town, a Raw EF brought $1,075 in our July 2012 auction. This is the only Uncirculated example from this town we have seen offered. Once owned by Steve Tanenbaum, he believed it was struck over another token and this piece is the reason for the R10 -2ao variety is listed. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections earlier from Richard Coslet June 1979. Reverse Die: 1161. (3000-4000)

249 251 252 249 - IN860B-2a R8 PCGS MS63 BN Trace Red on the obverse and nicely toned. Blowney & Johnson Composition Roofing, South Bend Indiana. Indiana Primitive. The only Uncirculated example from this merchant we have seen offered. A Raw EF+ brought $302.50 in our December 2012 auction. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections earlier from William Fayerweather and Herman Aqua December 1974. Reverse Die: 1202. (1000-1500) 250 - IN915A-1a R6 PCGS MS64 RB 20% Red with nice cartwheel luster. Bartholomew & McClelland Dry Goods, Boots, Shoes & c., Valparaiso Indiana 1863. Scarce Indiana Primitive single merchant town. The first example from the town we have seen offered in Uncirculated condition. A Raw EF brought $180 in our June 2013 auction. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collections earlier from Richard Coslet June 1979. Reverse Die: 1234. (750-1000) 251 - IA150A-3a R8 NGC MS64 RB 40% Red. Reynolds & Co. New York Store, Cedar Rapids Iowa Union 1863. Rare town and state particularly above EF and the only example of this variety we have seen offered publicly. An NGC MS64 RB of the more available R6 -1a variety brought $2,325 in our August 2015 auction. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection though not noted on holder. Reverse Die: 1205. (3000-4000) 252 - IA560A-1a R7 NGC MS66 RB 60% Red more so on the obverse. Wm. Flemming & Bro. Lumber, Lansing Iowa. Very scarce state and town particularly this nice. We sold an NGC MS65 RB in our December 2008 auction that brought $2,062.50. Called incorrectly IA560A-3a on NGC's holder. Reverse Die: 1037. (3000-4000)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards

253 255 262 253 - KS550A-1a R6 NGC MS63 RB 30% Red more so on the obverse. A. Cohen Clothing, Leavenworth Kansas. Kansas is one of the rarest states in the entire Civil War series. An NGC AU58 sold for $3,850 in our August 2015 sale. Reverse Die: 1085. (6000-8000) 254 - KY150C-1a R4 NGC MS63 BN A bit unevenly struck as often seen. J. Dolman Stocking Manufacturer, Covington Kentucky. Reverse Die: 1278. (400-500) 255 - KY510F-1b R9 NGC MS64 60% Bright and quite attractive. M. Egelhoff, Louisville Kentucky with maker H. Miller reverse die featuring a hand holding beer mug. An exceedingly rare merchant, Michael Egelhoff is listed as a Grocer at 642 East Main Street. The only example we have handled, missing from Alan Bleviss Sale and most other major collections. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection and the current Fuld Plate specimen, both so noted on the holder. Reverse Die: 1431. (2000-3000) 256 - ME100A-2a R3 NGC MS62 BN Sharply struck. R. S. Torrey Bee Hive, Bangor Maine. Scarce single merchant state. A Raw AU+ brought $276 in our August 2015 sale. (300-400) 257 - MD060C-1b R9 NGC AU50 CLA 5, Baltimore Maryland counterstamped with shield in wreath. From the Tampa and Steve Tanenbaum collections though not noted on NGC's holder. The current Fuld Plate Specimen. Reverse Die: 1352A. (400-500) 258 - MD060 H-2b R9 NGC VF30 F. B. 5, Baltimore Maryland with 1863 French Liberty head reverse. From the Tampa and Steve Tanenbaum collections though not noted on NGC's holder. The current Fuld Plate Specimen. Called incorrectly MD060H-1b on NGC's holder. Reverse Die: 1001. (400-500) 259 - MD060 T-1b R10 NGC VF35 Or a bit better. A L counterstamped on a 1863 Patriotic Civil War token 3/273 b, Baltimore Maryland. Steve Tanenbaum loved this series of counterstamped Maryland tokens and had the definitive collection and many of the pieces were used to illustrate the merchants in the new book. From the Tampa and Steve Tanenbaum collections though not noted on NGC's holder. Reverse Die: 1246A. (400-500) 260 - MD060AK-1b R6 NGC MS62 Trace Bright. Shakespeare Club Baltimore Maryland 1863. Always popular as the only Baltimore Civil War merchant to list the city's name. Rarely seen this nice, we sold a VF+ example for $522.50 in our April 2000 sale. From the Tampa and Steve Tanenbaum collections from George Fuld the Tanenbaum and Fuld pedigrees are noted on NGC's holder. Reverse Die: 1001. (1000-1500) 261 - MA115A-1e R7 PCGS MS62 10% Bright. Comer's Commercial College, Boston Massachusetts struck in White Metal. Quite rare in Mint State. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 300°, 49.7 grains, 19.2 mm. (750-1000) 262 - MA115E-1a R4 PCGS MS64 BN With nice toning and cartwheel luster particularly on the reverse. Jos. H. Merriam Die Sinker, Boston Massachusetts with very popular Good For A Scent reverse die featuring a dogs head. The NGC MS62 BN in our January 2015 sale realized $1,815. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1284. Data: 61 grains, 19 mm. (3000-4000) 263 - MA200A-2a R4 PCGS MS63 BN Nice toning. Dunn & Co. Oyster House, Charlestown Massachusetts with Bunker Hill monument on reverse. Current research indicates that Dunn was actually from Charlestown rather than Boston as previously thought. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1414. Data: 350°, 42.3 grains, 19.1 mm. (200-300)

264 276 281 264 - MA200A-3a R8 PCGS MS66 BN Attractive toning, obverse nearly Proof Like. Dunn & Co. Oyster House, Boston Massachusetts with Bunker Hill monument on reverse. Rare obverse die, we sold an NGC MS64 BN for $795 in our June 2011 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1414. Data: 0°, 38.1 grains, 19.1 mm. (750-1000) 265 - MA760A- 6a R8 NGC MS65 BN Trace Red and very well struck. J. A. Bolen 1864, Springfield Massachusetts self-portrait with Liberty Cap reverse. Thought to be one of just 25 struck. Musante JAB- 9. We sold a Raw MS65 that was nearly Proof Like that realized $2,050 in our January 2015 auction. From the Tim Gabriele and Henry South collections. (1500-2000) 266 - MA760A- 7a R7 NGC MS64 BN 10% Red. J. A. Bolen 1864, Springfield Massachusetts self-portrait with Stamp Cutter Die Sinker And Medalist reverse. Thought to be one of just 25 struck. Musante JAB-12. We sold a Raw MS63 in our January 2015 sale that brought $700. From the Tim Gabriele collection. (750-1000) 267 - MI060aA-2a R8 PCGS MS64 BN A bit weakly struck opposite the shield. Wm. Brooks, Battle Creek & Elkhart Indiana. Very rare and desirable variety with Indiana Primitive reverse and a Childs obverse. Brooks may have retained possession of the Childs die after the striking of -3a, -4a and -5a and then at a later date had Higgins strike -1a, -2a and -6a. We sold an NGC XF40 for $189 in our January 2015 sale. From the Dave Bowers, Steve Tanenbaum and Ron Vore collections December 1978. Reverse Die: 1202. (750-1000) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 268 - MI085C-2a R5 NGC MS65 60% Red. W. H. Naylor Cutlery, Brighton. Underrated town and merchant. An EF+ of the more available -1a variety brought $206 in our June 2005 sale. From the Tampa, Frank Toth, Steve Tanenbaum, Robert Williams, David Brock, John Canfield and George Fuld collections. From our December 2012 sale where it brought $700. This is the Fuld Plate specimen in the 2nd and 3rd editions of the Store Card book. Reverse Die: 1042. (750-1000) 269 - MI135A-1a R8 NGC AU50 BN Boyd & Bradley Wholesale & Retail Groceries, Cassopolis Michigan 1863. A rare single variety town particularly in nice undamaged condition. We sold a Raw EF+ example in our December 2017 auction that brought $1,600. From the Tampa collection. Reverse Die: 1003. (1500-2000) 270 - MI225 A-6a R7 PCGS MS64 BN 30% Red nearly all on the obverse. W. J. Adderly Grocer, Detroit Michigan 1863. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1042. Data: 30.2 grains, 19.3 mm. (200-300) 271 - MI225 P-3a R7 PCGS MS66 RB 40% Red. G. & W. Clark Butchers, Detroit Michigan 1863. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1042. (400-500) 272 - MI225AV-2a R9 PCGS MS65 RD 80% Red. Martin Bro's Cheap Boot & Shoe Store, Detroit Michigan 1864. Rare merchant, a Raw AU Details retoned example of the equally rare -1b variety sold for $373.56 in our June 2005 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1047. Data: 48.5 grains, 19.1 mm. (1500-2000) 273 - MI225AY-3d R9 NGC MS65 70% Bright with very nice cartwheel luster. Messmore & Lucking Butchers, Detroit Michigan 1864 struck in Copper Nickel and thought to be one of just two struck. From the Tampa and Cliff Temple collections. Reverse Die: 1047. (1000-1500) 274 - MI225AZ-1a R4 NGC MS64 BN 10% Red with nice toning. Robt. Millar Grocer & Liquor Dealer, Detroit 1863. Rare in Uncirculated condition. From the Tampa collection. Reverse Die: 1025. (200-300) 275 - MI225BI-2i R9 NGC MS65 70% Bright with full Tin plating. Joseph Riggs Groceries, Provisions & Flour, Detroit 1863 struck in Tin Plate. Very rare as are nearly all Tin Plated tokens, this is the only example of this variety we have seen offered. We sold an NGC MS64 example of the equally rare MI225C-2i for $575 in our January 2015 auction. From the Cliff Temple collection. Reverse Die: 1042. (750-1000) 276 - MI225BL-2a R6 PCGS MS64 BN Or nearly so. Dr. L. C. Rose Treats All Chronic Female & Venereal Diseases, Detroit Michigan 1863. Always popular. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1039. Data: 57.8 grains, 19.3 mm. (1500-2000) 277 - MI225BS-1a1 R9 PCGS MS65 BN Nice toning and luster. E. B. Smith Book Seller, Detroit Michigan 1863. Very rare variety, only the second we have seen offered. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1025. Data: 58.8 grains, 19.6 mm. (400-500) 278 - MI225CD-2b R8 PCGS MS64 30% Bright. I. & C. Taylor Grocers & Provision Dealers, Detroit Michigan 1863 struck in Brass. Rare merchant, a Raw AU+ example of the more available -2a variety brought $170.50 in our March 2003 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1042. Data: 56.4 grains, 19.3 mm. (400-500) 279 - MI225CN-1a R7 NGC MS64 RB 50% Red. Wilkins & Martins Celebrated Ink & Blacking Depot, Detroit 1863. Rare variety, the second example we have recorded. Reverse Die: 1042. (300-400) 280 - MI250B-3a R8 NGC MS64 BN Trace Red all on the obverse. Andrews & Cooper Family Groceries & Provisions, Dowagiac Michigan 1864. Rare variety one of only four we have seen offered and probably the finest known likely by a considerable margin. From the Steve Tanenbaum, Dale Cade, John Canfield and George Fuld collections. This is the Fuld Plate specimen for both the 2nd and 3rd editions of the Store Card book. Reverse Die: 1107. (750-1000) 281 - MI300E-1a R5 PCGS MS64 RB 20% Red. A. Mester & Co. Marble Works, Eaton Rapids Michigan. A very scarce and popular token featuring Tombstone reverse die 1340. A NGC MS63 RB example sold for $1,500 in our January 2016 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1340. Data: 10°, 54 grains, 19.4 mm. (2000-3000)

282 289 291 282 - MI370F-3b R9 NGC MS63 30% Bright more so on the reverse. C. Kusterer City Brewery Lager Beer Stock & Cream Ale, Grand Rapids Michigan struck in Brass with 1211 reverse previously unlisted. Popular token with horse drawn beer wagon. This had been unlisted until recently despite being in Cliff Temple's collection for over 50 years and being correctly identified as Brass in his notes. We have not seen an example of this die combination offered in Copper. It is quite possible that this piece is Unique and the Copper variety does not exist. In fact the reverse of the listed -3a was corrected from 1214 in the first edition of the Store Card book and not listed in H&G in 1924. A VF+ example of the R4 -1a variety brought $488.88 in our July 2009 sale. From the Rick Irons and Cliff Temple collections earlier from James Kelly December 1941 and believed to be from the Virgil Brand collection. Reverse Die: 1211. (2000-3000) 283 - MI450F-4a R9 PCGS MS65 BN Nicely toned. J. Gottlieb Clothier Hillsdale Michigan 1863 struck in Copper with reverse die 1183. The VF+ in our February 2014 sale realized $262. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1183. Data: 56.3 grains, 19.5 mm. (1000-1500) 284 - MI450H-4a R9 NGC MS62 BN Trace Red. E. C. Keating Grocer and Produce Dealer, Hillsdale Michigan. One of just two known with exceedingly rare and newly listed reverse die 1185A. We sold a Raw MS62 with some light planchet flaws on reverse that realized $1,800 in our July 2009 auction. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection earlier from Don Boller August 1991. Reverse Die: 1185A. (2000-3000)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 285 - MI527A-1a R7 NGC MS64 BN 10% Red. C. C. Blakeslee Druggist, Jonesville Michigan 1863 struck by Alexander Gleason of Hillsdale with tiny Mortar and Pestle on the obverse. Rare merchant this nice and likely one of the finest known. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection earlier in Spink America sale of the Western Reserve Historical Society October 1998. Reverse Die: 1187. (1000-1500) 286 - MI580B-2a R9 NGC MS64 BN 10% Red all on the reverse with attractive toning. Hatch & Craw, Lowell Michigan 1863. The finest of just two known. Very rare obverse die shared with -1a an R8. From the Steve Tanenbaum, Dale Cade, John Canfield and George Fuld collections. This is the Fuld Plate specimen for the 2nd edition of the Store Card book. Reverse Die: 1105. (1000-1500) 287 - MI610C-3a R4 NGC AU50 BN L. H. Robinson, Marshall Michigan 1863. (50-75) 288 - MI660B-3a R8 NGC MS64 RB 40% Red. Richards & Co. Hardware, Morenci Michigan. Very rare variety, just the third example we have seen offered. We sold a Raw AU+ Details with light staining for $148.50 in our July 2006 sale. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection earlier from John Danfield. Reverse Die: 1205. (500-750) 289 - MI700C-3a R5 PCGS MS65 BN Attractive toning. E. S. Parker Hats, Caps & Furs, Niles Michigan 1864. Popular tokens with vintage cap and hat pictured. Surprisingly rare in Uncirculated condition. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1046. Data: 45°, 53.3 grains, 19.1 mm. (500-750) 290 - MI770A-1a R9 PCGS MS64 BN Trace Red all on the reverse with nice toning but weakly struck on obverse opposite the Childs head. Fox & Smith Dealer In Plaster, Pontiac Michigan Union 1863. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1105. Data: 54.7 grains, 19.9 mm. (400-500) 291 - MI770C-1a R8 PCGS MS64 RB Or nearly so, 50% Red with great luster but some light spotting here and there. A. Parker Drugs, Pontiac Michigan struck in Copper. Popular token picturing bottle of French's Hair Restorative For Restoring Gray Hair. From the Dave Bowers collection. Called MI700C-1a on PCGS's holder. Data: 61.5 grains, 20.9 mm. (750-1000) 292 - MI855A-3a R5 PCGS MS64 BN Gallagher & Hess Druggists, Salina Michigan Union 1863. Scarce single merchant town, rare in Uncirculated condition. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1211. Data: 180°, 51.8 grains, 19.9 mm. (400-500) 293 - MI900A-1a R9 PCGS AU58 I. Allen & Son Stoves & Hardware, Schoolcraft Michigan 1863. Rare town and only the second example of this variety we have seen offered. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1094. Data: 180°, 50.4 grains, 19.8 mm. (400-500) 294 - MI915A-1b R7 PCGS MS64 Trace Bright. G. W. Stephenson Drugs and Medicines, St. Johns Michigan with Mortar and Pestle struck in Brass. Scarce town and rare variety. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1310. Data: 120°, 56 grains, 19.3 mm. (500-750) 295 - MI920B-1a R6 PCGS MS66 BN 10% Red. Dr. E. Hause Dentist, Tecumseh Michigan 1863. An NGC MS65 RB sold for $425 in our July 2012 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1094. Data: 330°, 52.4 grains, 19.7 mm. (500-750) 296 - MI960B-2a R4 NGC MS63 BN Nicely toned. Showerman & Bro. Clothing, Ypsilanti Michigan 1863. Rare this nice. (200-300) 297 - MN720A-4a R8 NGC MS65 RB 50% Red. F. W. Andrews Dry Goods & c., Rochester Minnesota 1863. Very rare variety from a very scarce town and state. One of just three examples which we are aware of. A Raw MS62 example of the more available R7 -3a variety sold for $770 in our June 2005 sale. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection earlier from Herman Aqua and so noted on the NGC holder. Reverse Die: 1224. (2000-3000)

298 311 313 298 - MO910A-2i R9 NGC MS63 40% Bright with nearly full original Tin plating. Drovers Hotel, St. Louis Missouri 1862 featuring a steer head on the obverse struck in Tin Plate. Very rare variety, the three examples in Newman were the first we had seen offered. One of those examples, also an NGC MS63, sold for $1,200 in our December 2016 sale. From the Eric Newman collection and so noted on NGC's holder. Reverse Die: 1009. (1500-2000) 299 - MO910A-3a R6 NGC MS63 RB 20% Red. Drovers Hotel, St. Louis Missouri 1863. Popular token with steers head pictured. A raw EF+ sold for $388.88 in our November 2004 sale. From the Tampa, Steve Tanenbaum, Ed Rosen and George Fuld collections with Tanenbaum and prior pedigrees are on the NGC holder. Reverse Die: 1038. (1000-1500) 300 - MO910B-3a R9 NGC MS63 BN 10% Red. Lallemand's Specific Rheumatism Gout & Neuralgia Specific 1863. Rare merchant and one of just three examples of the variety we have seen offered. A Raw MS62 example of the more available R8 -1a variety sold for $1,200 in our July 2012 sale. From the Tampa and Eric Newman collections with the Newman pedigree noted on the holder. Reverse Die: 1018. (1500-2000) 301 - NJ220A-3a R3 NGC MS64 BN 10% Red mostly on the obverse. John Engel Merchant Tailor, Elizabeth Port New Jersey IOU One Cent Pure Copper. We sold a Raw MS63 example for $155 in our June 2013 auction. From the Bob Shalowitz collection. Reverse Die: 1265. (150-200) 302 - NJ555A-8a R3 NGC MS64 RB 40% Red. J. L. Agens & Co. Newspapers, Newark New Jersey. From the Bob Shalowitz collection. Reverse Die: 1269. (150-200) 303 - NJ555B-1a R3 NGC MS64 RB 20% Red. Charles Kolb Restaurant, Newark New Jersey. From the Bob Shalowitz collection. Reverse Die: 1014. (150-200) 304 - NJ555C-10e R8 NGC MS63 50% Bright. J. Wightman Newark New Jersey Not One Cent struck in White Metal. Very rare, the first we have recorded. From the Bob Shalowitz collection. Reverse Die: 1253. (400-500) 305 - NJ555C-11j R9 NGC MS64 40% Bright. J. Wightman Newark New Jersey IOU 1 Cent struck in German Silver. Very rare, the first we have recorded. From the Bob Shalowitz collection. Reverse Die: 1267. (500-750) 306 - NJ690A-2a R4 NGC MS63 RB 30% Red. Coutts & Bro., Perth Amboy New Jersey. An example in AU sold for $90 in our December 2012 sale. From the Bob Shalowitz collection. Reverse Die: 1269. (200-300)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 307 - NY105Q-2a R9 NGC MS63 BN Or a bit better, 20% Red and very original. Sohm & Rohmann Butchers Buffalo New York 1863. Very rare variety, just the second we have recorded. Rare merchant and one of the keys to a Buffalo set. A Raw EF example of the more available -3a variety that was a bit dark brought $475 in our sale July 2012 sale. Reverse Die: 1042. (1000-1500) 308 - NY105S-1a R5 PCGS MS65 BN Attractive toning with very nice cartwheel luster. Webster & Co. Grocers, Buffalo New York 1863 with crude Indian Head. From the Dave Bowers collection. (200-300) 309 - NY145A-2a R8 NGC MS64 RB 20% Red. Bingham & Jarvis Drugs, Cooperstown New York. Very scarce merchant. We sold a Raw MS63 example in our June 2005 auction that realized $247.50. Reverse Die: 1236. (300-400) 310 - NY630 K-7e R9 NGC MS62 30% Bright. T. Brimelow Druggist, New York struck in White Metal and Good For One Glass of Soda with Benjamin Franklin portrait. We sold a Raw MS63 example of the more available R8 -7b variety for $275 in our March 2008 sale. From the Virgil Brand collection and so noted on the holder. (200-300) 311 - NY630 W-1do R8 NGC MS65 20% Bright. Felix Kosher Dining Saloon, New York struck over an 1862 Copper Nickel Indian Cent with much of the under type visible. Very popular token with Kosher spelled out in Hebrew. From the Roger Merritt collection from Steve Tanenbaum. With the Tanenbaum pedigree so noted on NGC's holder. Reverse Die: 1015. (1500-2000) 312 - NY630AG-3ao R8 NGC MS62 BN 10% Red mostly on the obverse. John P. Gruber, New York 1863 with apothecary scales. Struck over Felix Kosher Dining Saloon Civil War store card NY630W-1a. From the Tampa collection. Reverse Die: 1015. (300-400) 313 - NY630AMa-1b R7 NGC MS66 70% Bright. H. & M. Kayser & Co., New York with No North, No South, One Flag, One Union reverse die. Rare merchant, a Raw AU brought $890 in our March 2010 auction. Reverse Die: 1190. (2000-3000) 314 - NY630AW-1e R8 NGC MS62 50% Bright. H. B. Melville Jeweler, New York struck in White Metal. A Raw MS62 sold for $180 in our July 2007 sale. From the Tampa collections. (300-400) 315 - NY630BG-2b R7 PCGS MS64 20% Bright. John Quinn Grocer, New York 1863 struck in Brass with George Washington reverse die From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1137. Data: 45°, 42.7 grains, 20.8 mm. (200-300) 316 - NY630BN-1b R5 PCGS MS64 30% Bright more so on the obverse. Geo. D. Schmidt First Avenue Hall, New York 1863 struck in Brass. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 170°, 40.7 grains, 19.2 mm. (150-200) 317 - NY630BP-2h R6 NGC MS64 S. H. Scripture Redeemable in Currency 4 Cents struck in Hard Rubber. Rare merchant, we sold a Raw AU for $543.40 in our December 2005 sale. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection earlier from Rich Hartzog and so noted on the NGC holder. (1000-1500) 318 - NY630BU-2a R3 PCGS MS65 RB 30% Red with nice cartwheel luster. S. Steinfeld French Cognac Bitters, New York. From the Dave Bowers collection. (100-150) 319 - OH005A-7j R9 NGC MS63 20% Bright. Stoner & Shroyer Dry Goods, Adamsville struck in German Silver with rare broken neck eagle reverse die. Very rare variety, just the third we have seen offered. An NGC MS62 example of the equally rare -7e variety brought $715 in our June 2011 auction. From the Alan Bleviss collection and so noted on the holder. Reverse Die: 1193. (750-1000) 320 - OH074A- 7a R8 NGC MS64 RB 40% Red. D. E. Stearns, Berea Ohio. Rare variety, just the forth we have seen offered. We sold a Raw MS63 in our February 2014 auction that brought $252. Reverse Die: 1042. (300-400) 321 - OH115A-7a R9 NGC AU55 BN A. C. Cochran Hardware Dealer, Cambridge Ohio with Padlock. Very rare Store Card brockage mint error. These dramatic errors are created when a struck token sticks to the die and fails to eject. A subsequent token is then struck with one normal die and an incused image from the previous token acting as a die. As a class, brockages of Store Cards are much rarer than Patriotic and within Store Cards Ohio examples are much rarer than New York or even Wisconsin. (1000-1500) 322 - OH150B-1a R7 NGC MS64 BN 30% Red with nice toning. Miles & Sperry Dealers in Dry Goods, Groceries & c., Chesterville Ohio 1864. Rare town and merchant, particularly this nice. Reverse Die: 1046. (500-750) 323 - OH165 T-8a R9 NGC MS64 BN Nicely toned. J. Campbell Provision Dealer, Cincinnati Ohio muled with C. G. Bruce Authorized War Claim Agent 1863, Cleveland Ohio. Very rare two merchant mule with each merchant coming from a different city. Even though there are two merchants listed it is only listed under Cincinnati where it comes first alphabetically by state then city. Of interest to the collectors of both locations. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection earlier George Fuld, Don Schramm and Arthur Fritz and so noted on NGC's holder. (1000-1500) 324 - OH165AB-1a R8 PCGS MS65 RB 60% Red with very nice Cartwheel luster. Connecticut Mutual Life Insurance Company Capital Over 6,000,000 1864. Very rare merchant, an NGC MS64 RB brought $1,800 in our January 2015 sale. From the Dave Bowers and Steve Tanenbaum collection from a Dorge auction Lot 549. Reverse Die: 1047. (2000-3000)

325 331 334 325 - OH165BJ-27a R10 NGC AU58 BN Or a bit better with 20% Red. Carl Haas, Cincinnati obverse muled with J. F. Resta Sausage Maker, Cincinnati Ohio obverse. Unique two merchant mule one with Bunny Rabbit pictured. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection earlier Herman Aqua and William Fayerweather so noted on NGC's holder. Called OH165EU-9a, possibly a proposed attributing that was change to alphabetical in the Store Card 3rd edition. (750-1000) 326 - OH165BO-4b R8 NGC MS64 70% Bright. M. Hartzel Grocer & Commission Merchant, Cincinnati Ohio struck in Brass. Reverse Die: 1042. (300-400) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 327 - OH165BS-3a R7 NGC MS64 RB 50% Red struck from a clashed obverse die. J. Helmig Grocer, Cincinnati Ohio 1863 struck in Copper. Rare merchant. Reverse Die: 1042. (300-400) 328 - OH165BWa-4a R10 PCGS AU53 $5.00 Hill muled with F. W. Lutz Artist. A Unique and very unusual muling, the Hill refers to William Hill an African-American Barber located at 32 Central in Cincinnati Ohio while William W. Lutz was an Artist and Engraver working for token maker Lanphear. Hill also issued tokens for a Shave and a Hair Cut but exactly what the $5.00 token was good for is as yet unknown. From the Dave Bowers, Steve Tanenbaum, Ed Rosen and George Fuld collections. (1500-2000) 329 - OH165CV-3a R8 PCGS MS65 BN 10% Red almost all on the reverse. H. Kreber Grocer, Columbia between Rowe & Mill, Cincinnati Ohio with North Star reverse die 1242. Very rare reverse die in the Store Card series. A Raw MS64 brought $550 in our March 2010 auction. From the Dave Bowers and Henry South collections. Reverse Die: 1242. (750-1000) 330 - OH165EH-5b R8 NGC MS64 60% Bright. O'Reilly Bros. Dry Goods, Cincinnati Ohio struck in Brass. Reverse Die: 1042. (300-400) 331 - OH165FXa- 9a R8 NGC MS64 BN 10% Red and nicely toned. Steamer Lancaster No. 4, Cincinnati Ohio muled with 1860 dated No Submission to the North reverse . This ship had a short but interesting life, launched in January 1861 for the Cincinnati - New Richmond trade. It was later used in April 1862 to ferry wounded soldiers from the battle of Pittsburg Tennessee. Beginning in June 1864 it ran troops and supplies from New Orleans to Vicksburg and in August came under attack near Natchez Mississippi. It snagged and sunk in just ten feet of water south of Portland Missouri on November 18, 1864. Formerly TN600E-9a now listed under Cincinnati as the location of David Gibson & Co. its owner and original base of operations. Very rare, the first we have seen offered, made all the more desirable with the Confederate related reverse. From the Tampa collection. Reverse Die: 1426. (2000-3000) 332 - OH175S- 4do R10 PCGS MS63 Struck on 1862 Indian Cent. Geo. Worthington Hardware, Cleveland Ohio featuring a large padlock struck in Copper Nickel over Cent and Unique as such. The only Lanphear known over a Copper Nickel Cent. From the Dave Bowers, Steve Tanenbaum, Rudolf Mudrock, George Fuld, Don Schramm and Arthur Fritz collections. Reverse Die: 1474. (2000-3000) 333 - OH175S-14a R10 NGC MS64 RB 10% Red more so on the reverse. Geo. Worthington Hardware, Cleveland featuring a large pad lock with rare Phoenician head reverse die. Believed to be Unique. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection earlier from Herman Aqua and so noted on the NGC holder. Called OH175S-17a on the holder, likely a proposed designation that was modified for the 3rd edition of the Store Card book. Reverse Die: 1131. (500-750) 334 - OH190A-3a R5 NGC MS64 RB 50% Red with nice toning a cartwheel luster. Icenhour & Co. Dealers In Drugs, Hardware & Saddlery, Columbiana Ohio with reverse die 1313 featuring mortar and pestle. A Raw VF+ sold for $102.30 in our March 2010 sale. Reverse Die: 1313. (400-500) 335 - OH250A-3a R9 PCGS MS64 BN Trace Red nicely toned. J. W. Hunt Druggist & Express Agent, Delphos Ohio 1864. Very rare variety, just the second example we have seen offered and missing from the Tanenbaum collection. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1047. Data: 49.3 grains, 19.1 mm. (400-500) 336 - OH300aA-1a R7 NGC MS63 BN 10% Red more so on the reverse. E. Bacher Union Saloon Good For Five Cents In Refreshments struck in Copper. Formerly listed under Cincinnati as OH165I-1a, current research shows that Ernst Bacher owned the Union Eating Saloon at 232 South Main St. in Findlay Ohio and consequently is listed there in the 3rd edition. (500-750) 337 - OH330B-1b R8 PCGS MS64 20% Bright. Dr. E. Dillon & Son Druggists, Fremont Ohio with Mortar and Pestle reverse die. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1310. Data: 340°, 52.1 grains, 19.3 mm. (500-750) 338 - OH360B-3a R7 NGC MS64 BN 20% Red mostly on the obverse. T. P. Turpen Grocer & Tobacco, Greenville Ohio struck in Copper. From the Charles Thobaben collection. Reverse Die: 1042. (400-500) 339 - OH385A-2b R8 PCGS MS65 40% Bright. John Deinzer Family Grocery, Hamilton Ohio 1863 struck in Brass. Rare variety, the third we have recorded. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1042. Data: 53 grains, 19.1 mm. (300-400) 340 - OH440C-3a R6 PCGS MS64 BN Trace Red on the obverse. Chas. Pairan Grocer and Liquor Dealer, Lancaster Ohio 1863 with flying eagle. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1166. Data: 66.7 grains, 19.3 mm. (400-500)

341 350 360 341 - OH440D-1a R5 PCGS MS64 BN Trace Red and nicely toned. Andrew Reid Dry Goods & Shoes, Lancaster Ohio 1863. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1273. Data: 56.6 grains, 19.3 mm. (400-500) 342 - OH445A-2b R8 PCGS MS64 20% Bright. Geo. D. Riegel Dry Goods and Groceries, Laurelville Ohio 1863 struck in Brass. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1083. Data: 42.6 grains, 19.4 mm. (300-400) 343 - OH505B-6bo R10 PCGS MS63 Struck over another variety from the same merchant OH505B-1b. F. B. Orr Dealer In Hardware, Mansfield Ohio struck in Brass. An interesting error from a merchant with a number of overstrikes. An NGC MS64 example of the R8 -5bo (mistakenly dropped from the 3rd Edition) brought $240 in our July 2012 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1268. Data: 44 grains, 20.9 mm. (500-750) 344 - OH555A-4b R8 NGC MS64 40% Bright with nice cartwheel luster. P. L. Potter Queensware, Middletown Ohio 1863 struck in Brass. Scarce single merchant town, a Raw VF+ example of the more available R5 -1a variety sold for $110.13 in our August 2015 auction. Reverse Die: 1042. (500-750)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 345 - OH557A-1i R8 NGC MS64 40% Bright with full Tin plating. John Frank One Half Pint Of Milk struck in Tin Plate. Long attributed to Cincinnati Ohio as OH165AY-1i current research has placed the Frank dairy in Mill Creek Township of rural Hamilton County, Ohio. We sold an NGC MS64 example of the equally rare -2b variety for $950 in our January 2016 sale. Called OH165AY-1i on NGC's holder a prior designation. Reverse Die: 1463. (1000-1500) 346 - OH830G-1a R5 PCGS MS65 BN 10% Red with great cartwheel luster. C. Runyon Groceries, Springfield Ohio. Popular Spingfield spelling error. From the Dave Bowers and Wayne Liechty collections. (400-500) 347 - OH920A-2a R9 NGC MS63 RB 50% Red. John Tresler Grocery Store, West Jefferson 1863 with Anchor reverse die 1346. Very rare variety, just the second we have seen offered. A similar Raw example brought $385 in our December 2005 sale. Reverse Die: 1346. (750-1000) 348 - PA013C-2a R6 PCGS MS64 BN Trace Red. Gregg & Dalzell National Planing Mill, Allegheny City Pennsylvania. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 58 grains, 19.2 mm. (200-300) 349 - PA013E-4a R3 PCGS MS65 BN 10% Red. R. & W. Jenkinson, Alleghany Pennsylvania with popular reverse featuring tobacco paraphernalia including cigar box and humidor. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1331. Data: 58.1 grains, 19.3 mm. (200-300) 350 - PA013F-1a R8 PCGS MS65 BN 10% Red mainly on the obverse, nicely toned. John Sherer Tobacco Dealer, Allegheny City Pennsylvania 1863. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1124. Data: 58.5 grains, 19.3 mm. (300-400) 351 - PA464A-3d R8 PCGS MS64 40% Bright. Petersen's Jewelers Honesdale, Scranton & Pittston Pennsylvania with General McClellan reverse struck in Copper Nickel. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1152. Data: 340°. (400-500) 352 - PA525A-1b R6 NGC MS63 50% Bright. S. H. Zahm Coin Dealer, Lancaster Pennsylvania struck in Brass with Ben Franklin reverse die 1148. A raw AU+ brought $300 in our December 2010 sale. From the Mark Cramer collection. (500-750) 353 - PA535A-2a R4 PCGS MS66 BN 10% Red. Wm. Smith Grocer, Lawrenceville Pennsylvania 1863 with eagle. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1180. Data: 22 grains, 19.3 mm. (400-500) 354 - PA750A-1b R3 PCGS MS65 10% Bright and attractively toned. Adams Ton Hall, Philadelphia. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 58.9 grains, 20.6 mm. (100-150) 355 - PA750B-1d R5 PCGS MS63 Or a bit better, 60% Bright. M. B. Allebach Watch Maker & Jeweler, Philadelphia Pennsylvania struck in Copper Nickel. From the Dave Bowers and John Dettinger collections. Reverse Die: 1093. Data: 20°, 64 grains, 19.2 mm. (200-300) 356 - PA750B-2a R9 NGC MS62 BN 10% Red mostly on the obverse. M. B. Allebach Watch Maker & Jeweler, Philadelphia Pennsylvania struck in Copper with very rare 1867 dated reverse featuring General George B. McClellan. The only Uncirculated example we have seen offered and just the second overall. From the Mark Cramer and Henry South collections. (750-1000) 357 - PA750C-2a R5 PCGS MS63 BN Amon Bakery Philadelphia Pennsylvania 1863 with wheat sheaf pictured. A merchant that is rarely seen in Uncirculated condition. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 20°, 60 grains, 20.6 mm. (200-300) 358 - PA750D-1a R4 PCGS MS65 BN Nicely toned. Baltz & Stilz Importers of Wines, Philadelphia with Grapes on the vine. Quite rare in Uncirculated condition. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1381. Data: 20°, 54.7 grains, 20.5 mm. (150-200) 359 - PA750E-1a R2 PCGS MS65 BN 10% Red. M. F. Beirn Magnolia Hotel, Philadelphia. Reverse die signed RL for maker Robert Lovett. From the Dave Bowers and John Dettinger collections. Reverse Die: 1093. (200-300) 360 - PA750H-1b R8 NGC MS63 Or a bit better with 50% Bright luster. Chestnut & Walnut Passenger Railroad Company One Fare struck in Brass with 1861 dated Benjamin Franklin reverse die 1148. Very rare merchant and likely the finest known, high R8 with at least two examples being quite low grade. The current plate token is an AU58 from the Bleviss collection that realized $6,325 in Stack's September 2009 sale. We have been in the auction business 22 years and have never had the pleasure of offering this merchant before. From the Mark Cramer, Steve Tanenbaum, Ray Bryne, Jon Harris and George Fuld collections. In an NGC Tanenbaum holder. The Fuld Plate token in the second edition of the Store Card book. (8000-12000) 361 - PA750Lb-1d R7 NGC MS65 30% Bright. Wm. Idler Coin Dealer 111 N. Ninth Street, Philadelphia struck in Copper-Nickel with reverse die 1093 engraved and signed by Robert Lovett. Only recognized as a Civil War token in the last 30 years and now officially included in the new Store Card book. We sold a raw MS62 for $1,000 in our December 2006 sale. From the Mark Cramer collection. Called PA750La-1d on the NGC holder, a prior designation. (2000-3000)

362 368 371 362 - PA750Lc-1f R9 PCGS MS63 Attractive toning and nearly Proof Like. E. Ivins Metal Trimmings, Philadelphia Pennsylvania with George Washington reverse struck in Silver. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 160°, 150.2 grains, 25.1 mm. (1000-1500) 363 - PA750N-1a R4 PCGS MS62 BN Nice toning. A. Lambert, Philadelphia Pennsylvania. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1092. Data: 160°, 46.6 grains, 19.5 mm. (150-200) 364 - PA750O-2b R6 NGC MS64 Or nearly so with 10% Bright luster. H. Mulligan Watches and Jewelry, Philadelphia struck in Brass with portrait of the owner. Rare in Uncirculated condition. We sold an NGC MS63 for $565 in our September 2012 weekly auction. From the Mark Cramer collection. (750-1000) 365 - PA750P-1a R5 PCGS MS64 BN 10% Red, reverse weakly struck opposite Milk Can as usual. F. P. Rogers Manufacturer Of Milk Cans, Philadelphia Pennsylvania. Nice pictorial of a milk can. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 21.5 grains, 18.8 mm. (300-400)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 366 - PA750Q-1a R3 PCGS MS65 BN 10% Red. G. J. Ruelius, Philadelphia Pennsylvania 1863 City Hotel. From the Dave Bowers and James Holtel Collections. Data: 10°, 53.7 grains, 21.4 mm. (150-200) 367 - PA750S-1a R3 PCGS MS65 BN Trace Red nicely toned. Steppacher Agent Orleans House, Philadelphia Pennsylvania 1863 with crossed flags. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1381. Data: 10°, 50.8 grains, 20.6 mm. (150-200) 368 - PA750T-1d R10 PCGS MS65 40% Bright with very nice cartwheel luster. Granville Stokes Merchant Tailor, Philadelphia Pennsylvania 1862 struck in Copper Nickel and Unique as such. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 149.7 grains, 31.5 mm. (1000-1500) 369 - PA750U-1j R7 PCGS MS63 50% Bright. A. B. Taylor 1861 Soda Water and Denticrete For The Teeth, Philadelphia struck in German Silver. Very scarce single variety merchant, a Raw MS64 brought $475 in our September 2010 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 10°, 38.1 grains, 19.2 mm. (400-500) 370 - PA750W-1a R5 PCGS MS65 BN 10% Red. Union Volunteer Refreshment Saloon Second Annual Fair 1863. Popular Sanitary Fair. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 190°, 45.8 grains, 19.3 mm. (150-200) 371 - PA765A-2a R8 PCGS MS65 RD 80% Red. Allegheny Valley Railroad Hotel, Pittsburgh Pennsylvania. The rarest of the Pittsburgh merchants particularly in Uncirculated condition. We sold a Raw MS62 RB that brought $467.50 in our June 2011 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1042. Data: 61.8 grains, 19.1 mm. (1000-1500) 372 - PA765D-5a R9 PCGS MS64 RB 20% Red all on the obverse. J. A. Eckert Butcher, Pittsburgh Pennsylvania with tobacco scene on reverse. Very rare variety, just the second we have recorded. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1331. Data: 0°, 62.6 grains, 19.2 mm. (500-750) 373 - PA765E-4a R7 PCGS MS65 BN 30% Red. Jos. Fleming Druggist, Pittsburgh Pennsylvania 1863. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1042. Data: 135°, 61.2 grains, 19.2 mm. (400-500) 374 - PA765H-2a R6 PCGS MS64 BN Trace Red. J. W. Hannah, Pittsburgh Pennsylvania with eagle on shield. Rare this nice, just the second Uncirculated example we have seen offered. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1177. Data: 135°, 55.7 grains, 19.2 mm. (300-400) 375 - PA765I-3a R8 PCGS MS65 BN Trace Red all on the obverse with attractive reverse toning. J. C. & W. H. Lippincott Grocers, Pittsburgh Pennsylvania with eagle on shield. Rare variety. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1177. Data: 60 grains, 19.3 mm. (300-400) 376 - PA765K-1a R5 PCGS MS64 BN Attractive toning. J. W. McCarthy Bill Poster, Pittsburgh Pennsylvania 1863. Very scarce merchant. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1026. Data: 315°, 55.2 grains, 19.1 mm. (300-400) 377 - PA765M-1b R5 PCGS MS64 30% Bright. Henry Miner News Dealer, Pittsburgh Pennsylvania struck in Brass. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1364. Data: 190°, 45.3 grains, 19.4 mm. (100-150) 378 - PA765M-5a R6 PCGS MS64 BN Trace Red. Henry Miner News Dealer, Pittsburgh Pennsylvania 1863 with eagle. Rare this nice. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1180. Data: 240°, 53.7 grains, 19.2 mm. (200-300) 379 - PA765O-2a R8 PCGS MS65 RD 70% Red. A. C. Pentz, Pittsburgh Pennsylvania 1863. Rare merchant without the 2 in address canceled as it is on almost all known examples of the R5 -1a variety. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1042. Data: 60.7 grains, 19.1 mm. (400-500) 380 - PA765P- 5a R6 PCGS MS64 BN Attractive toning. Pittock's News Depot, Pittsburgh Pennsylvania 1863. Note the early variation on the spelling of the town. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1124. Data: 270°, 54.2 grains, 19.2 mm. (200-300) 381 - PA765P-15a R7 PCGS MS66 BN Attractive toning. Pittock's News Depot, Pittsburgh Pennsylvania 1863 with eagle. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1180. Data: 315°, 54.1 grains, 19.2 mm. (200-300) 382 - PA765S-3a R4 PCGS MS65 BN Nice cartwheel luster. Pittsburgh Gazette 84 Fifth Street with eagle on shield. One of a number of businesses who issued Civil War tokens who are still operating today. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1177. Data: 90°, 52.4 grains, 19.3 mm. (200-300) 383 - PA765T-1a R5 PCGS MS65 BN Trace Red nicely toned. Reymer & Bros. Confectioners, Pittsburgh Pennsylvania. Very scarce merchant, particularly this nice. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1177. Data: 0°, 60.6 grains, 19.2 mm. (200-300) 384 - PA765U-1a R5 PCGS MS65 BN Nicely toned. Sinclair & Wilson Clothing Store, Pittsburgh Pennsylvania. Another Pittsburgh merchant that is rare in Uncirculated condition. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1177. Data: 60 grains, 19.2 mm. (300-400) 385 - RI700C-5b R8 NGC MS65 30% Bright. Charnley, Providence Rhode Island muled with Frank L. Gay obverse struck in Brass. We sold a Raw MS64 of the similarly rare -5e variety for $660 in our June 2005 auction. From the Tampa collection. (750-1000) 386 - RI700D-5j R8 NGC MS64 30% Bright. H. Dobson, Providence Rhode Island struck in German Silver with very rare eagle and anchor die. The reverse die is by the same die sinker and in the same unique style as the equally rare but more promoted Running Dogs die 1285. We sold a Raw UNC Detail with some Tin Pest of the equally rare -5e variety that realized $655 in our December 2017 sale. From the Tampa collection. Reverse Die: 1191. (1500-2000)

387 392 393 387 - RI700D-8d R9 NGC MS66 70% Bright with great cartwheel luster. Arcade House, Providence Rhode Island Union 1863 struck in Copper Nickel. Very rare variety. From the Tampa collection. Noted as RI700A-3d a prior designation on holder. Reverse Die: 1374. (1500-2000) 388 - RI700F-1a R6 NGC MS64 BN Trace Red on both sides, strike is a bit weak as usual opposite Mug. H. Y. Lefevre Empire Saloon, Providence Rhode Island with popular reverse die 1294 featuring large beer tankard. This crude token, with backwards N's, S's and even a backwards 1, is rarely seen in high grades. A Raw AU sold for $200 in our July 2014 auction. From the Tampa collection. Reverse Die: 1294. (750-1000) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 389 - RI700G-2e R7 NGC MS65 70% Bright with great cartwheel luster and nicer than usual strike. City Fruit Store By Phillips, Providence Rhode Island 1864 struck in White Metal with reverse die 1159 showing a nice portrait of Ambrose Burnside and his famous side burns. We sold a Raw MS62 which brought $495 in our June 2011 auction. From the Tampa collection. Reverse Die: 1159. (1000-1500) 390 - RI700I-1a R7 PCGS MS64 BN 10% Red. F. W. Shattuck Burnside Fruit Store, Providence Rhode Island 1864 struck in Copper. Rare merchant, a Raw AU+ brought $440 in our June 2010 sale. From the Dave Bowers, Steve Tanenbaum and Francis Cady collections. (1000-1500) 391 - TN180A-5a R8 NGC MS63 BN 10% Red. N. O. Underwood Good For 5 Cents, Dedham Tennessee 1863. Rare town and state, very rare this nice. We sold a Raw, somewhat more red MS63 that realized $1,760 in our June 2011 auction. From the Tampa collection. Reverse Die: 1168. (2000-3000) 392 - TN600B- 9a R8 NGC MS64 BN Elliott, Vinson & Co., Memphis Tennessee with No Submission to the North reverse featuring Palmetto tree and Cannon struck in Copper. This Wealth of the South reverse die is quite rare in the Store Card series. From the Tampa collection. Reverse Die: 1426. (1500-2000) 393 - TN600C-4a R8 PCGS MS65 BN Trace Red and nicely toned. B. F. Hammar & Co. Drayage 25 Cents, Memphis Tennessee 1862. A Raw VF+ brought $777.23 in our June 2005 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1401. Data: 150°, 49.2 grains, 19 mm. (1500-2000)

394 398 405 394 - TN690C-1d R10 NGC MS66 60% Bright with very nice cartwheel luster. D. L. Lapsley & Co., Nashville Tennessee 1864 struck in Copper Nickel. Very rare town and merchant and one of only a handful of Civil War tokens known to have been issued by African-Americans. Per the Store Card book the merchants were Barbers and Daniel L. Lapsley in particular was heavily involved in politics during Reconstruction and the early Civil Rights movement. By the 1870 census he was listed as a justice of the peace. We sold an NGC MS63 example of the R9 -1a variety for $4,400 in our June 2011 sale. Reverse Die: 1047. (4000-6000) 395 - WV890A- 2b R8 NGC MS63 20% Bright. Bassett's Cheap Dry Goods, Wheeling 1863 struck in Brass. Very rare die combination, particularly in Uncirculated condition. The whole state of West Virginia is rare for Uncirculated Civil War tokens. We sold an NGC MS62 example of the more available R7 -12a variety for $550 in our August 2015 auction. From the Tampa collection. Reverse Die: 1089. (1000-1500) 396 - WV890D-4a R6 NGC XF45 BN R. C. Graves Periodical and News Dealer, Wheeling West Virginia with open book pictured on reverse. From the Tampa collection from our January 2016 sale where it brought $180. Reverse Die: 1322. (200-300) 397 - WV890G-2a R6 NGC MS63 RB 10% Red mostly on the obverse. C. E. Stifel Tin and Sheet Iron, Wheeling West Virginia. Very tough state to find in high grade. From the Tampa collection. Reverse Die: 1178. (750-1000) 398 - WI235A-1a R8 NGC AU55 BN Well struck and free of the problems that are often encountered with this town. D. L. Edwards Dry Goods & Groceries, Genesee Station Wisconsin Union 1864. Very rare single variety town that went undiscovered for nearly 100 years. We sold the finest known, an NGC MS62, that realized $7,000 in our January 2015 sale. From the Henry South collection. Reverse Die: 1107. (4000-6000) 399 - WI250B-1b R9 NGC MS64 30% Bright. Hoffman & Lewis Tailors, Green Bay Wisconsin 1863 struck in Brass. Though listed as R9, this is the only example we have ever seen offered. From the Mike Tramte, Robert Kraft, Rich Hartzog, Doug Watson and George Fuld collections. Reverse Die: 1127. (750-1000) 400 - WI250F-1b R9 NGC MS63 40% Bright. F. R. Schuttler Dealer In Hardware, Green Bay Wisconsin 1863 struck in Brass. Very rare variety, one of just two examples in our data base. From the Mike Tramte, Robert Kraft, Rich Hartzog, Doug Watson and George Fuld collections. Reverse Die: 1085. (500-750) 401 - WI250F-4a R5 NGC MS63 RB 20% Red. F. R. Schettler Dealer In Hardware, Green Bay Wisconsin 1864. Very rare in Uncirculated condition. From the Mike Tramte and Steve Tanenbaum collections earlier from PCAC's December 1970 sale. The Tanenbaum pedigree in noted on the holder. This is the current Fuld Plate Specimen for reverse die 1228. Reverse Die: 1228. (300-400) 402 - WI250I-3a R8 NGC MS63 20% Red. J. J. St. Louis, Green Bay Wisconsin with Masonic reverse die 1387. One of just three Uncirculated examples we have seen offered, another NGC MS63 sold for $375 in our June 2013 auction. From the Mike Tramte and Henry South collections. The South pedigree is on NGC's holder. Reverse Die: 1387. (400-500) 403 - WI250I-6b R9 NGC MS64 40% Bright. Z.Z. St. Lewis, Green Bay Wisconsin. Very rare variety with Masonic reverse die 1387 and merchant name spelling error. Although called R9, this is the only example we have ever seen offered. From the Mike Tramte, Robert Kraft, Rich Hartzog, Doug Watson and George Fuld collections. Reverse Die: 1387. (750-1000) 404 - WI300C-4a R6 PCGS MS66 BN Trace Red all on the obverse with attractive toning. Chapmans One Price Store, Janesville Wisconsin Union 1861 with eagle. A Raw MS64 realized $585 in our March 2010 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1207. Data: 180°, 52.5 grains, 19.6 mm. (500-750) 405 - WI410G-2a R6 NGC MS62 BN J. Rodermund Lager Beer Stock & Cream Ale, Madison Wisconsin. Popular token with horse drawn beer wagon. A raw AU in our June 2011 sale realized $941.60. (1500-2000) 406 - WI410H-1a R6 PCGS MS65 BN 10% Red. Buy Your Meat of E. Newcomb, Madison Wisconsin 1863 with flying eagle. Scarce single variety merchant. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1169. Data: 290°, 58.3 grains, 19.3 mm. (300-400)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 407 - WI410K-1a R5 PCGS MS64 BN J. Rodermund Dealer In Dry Goods & Groceries, Madison Wisconsin Union 1863. Rare in Uncirculated condition. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1105. Data: 180°, 51.3 grains, 19.7 mm. (300-400) 408 - WI420B-4a R2 PCGS MS66 RB 50% Red. Stucke & Co. Produce, Manitowoc Wisconsin. A fairly common variety and merchant but both quite scarce in Uncirculated condition. A Raw MS64 brought $247.50 in our March 2010 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1194. Data: 63.3 grains, 19.8 mm. (300-400) 409 - WI435A-1a R7 PCGS AU58 I. Livingston Dry Goods Marshall Wisconsin 1863 with eagle. Rare merchant from a very scarce town. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1194. Data: 180°, 62.9 grains, 19.8 mm. (400-500) 410 - WI510 K-3a R5 PCGS MS66 BN Great cartwheel luster and attractive toning. Joseph Fischbein Provisions, Milwaukee Wisconsin 1863. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 180°, 58.3 grains, 20 mm. (400-500)

411 412 413 411 - WI510 M-1a R4 PCGS MS66 BN 10% Red more so on the reverse. Struck slightly off center. Goes & Falk Malt House and Bavaria Brewery, Milwaukee Wisconsin 1863 with three stacked beer barrels on obverse. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 64.6 grains, 19.1 mm. (500-750) 412 - WI510 Q-1a R7 NGC XF45 BN A nice well struck and problem free example. T. W. Hart Supt. M. W. M. Plank Road Company. Ray Callan's research published in The Civil War Token Journal shows that the Madison, Watertown & Milwaukee Plank Road Company had its office in Milwaukee at the corner of Main and Mason. Although Mr. Hart was from Wauwatosa, the President, Secretary and Treasurer of the company were all Milwaukee businessmen while he was Superintendent. Very rare single variety merchant, a Raw EF Details with a short scratch and light hairlines realized $800.01 in our December 2017 auction. (1000-1500) 413 - WI510 R-3d R9 PCGS MS64+ 70% Bright with very nice cartwheel luster. Ch. Hermann & Co. Broom and Stone Ware Factory, Milwaukee Wisconsin 1863 with picture of crossed brooms and jug labeled H & Co. and Naked Amazon Warrior reverse struck in Copper Nickel. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1220. Data: 61.8 grains, 19.7 mm. (750-1000) 414 - WI510 S-1a R6 PCGS MS62 BN Geo. Kane Fine Family Groceries, Milwaukee Wisconsin 1863 with eagle. Very scarce single variety merchant. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1194. Data: 180°, 61.4 grains, 19.7 mm. (200-300) 415 - WI510AA-5d R8 PCGS MS65 60% Bright. A. Miller & Co. Produce & Commission, Milwaukee Wisconsin with America reverse struck in Copper Nickel. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1272. Data: 63.5 grains, 19.7 mm. (500-750) 416 - WI510AB-1a R4 PCGS MS65 BN Trace Red with nice toning. Friedrich Miller Plankroad Brewery, Milwaukee Wisconsin 1863 with barrel and brewing tools. Always popular. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 59.3 grains, 19.9 mm. (400-500)

417 423 424 417 - WI510AP-3a R9 NGC MS64 RB Trace Red all on the struck side. H. Upmeyer Jeweler, Milwaukee Wisconsin obverse brockage combined with a normal Stephen Douglas reverse. Most brockages have a struck and incused image of the same die, very rarely does a very strange set of coincidences or mint mischief create a piece such as this. Though called an R9 this is the only example we have seen offered. The description in the Store Card books second edition was incorrect and was carried forward to the latest edition. From the Matt Westphal, Robert Kraft, Rich Hartzog, Doug Watson and George Fuld collection. This is the Fuld Plate Specimen for the 2nd edition of the Store Card book. Reverse Die: 1155. (3000-4000) 418 - WI510AP-4a R5 PCGS MS63 BN Attractive toning. H. Upmeyer Jeweler, Milwaukee with Stephen Douglas reverse. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1155. Data: 58 grains, 19.7 mm. (150-200) 419 - WI510AP-6a1 R9 PCGS AU55 H. Upmeyer Jeweler, Milwaukee Wisconsin with rare S.A.D. (Stephen A. Douglas) reverse die 1156. Somewhat overrated and we have yet to personally examine the R8 Plain Edge variety; perhaps the rarities should be reversed. An NGC AU58 sold for $351 in our January 2015 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1156. Data: 66.6 grains, 19.7 mm. (400-500) 420 - WI520B-1a R6 PCGS MS63 BN C. W. Leavens & Co. Groceries, Neenah Wisconsin 1863 Drugs And Medicines with Mortar and Pestle. Very scarce single variety town. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1316. Data: 59.3 grains, 19.3 mm. (300-400) 421 - WI540B-1a R7 PCGS AU58 Nice luster on the obverse. L. C. Wescott Agricultural Implements, New Lisbon Wisconsin. Rare merchant. An EF+ brought $294.80 in our March 2008 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1107. Data: 48.5 grains, 19.4 mm. (400-500) 422 - WI550A-1a R6 PCGS MS66 BN 20% Red more so on the obverse. W. H. Bogardus Dealer In Dry Goods, Groceries. Hardware, North Prairie Wisconsin 1863 with eagle. Very scarce town. We sold a very nice NGC MS63 RB example that realized $817 in our December 2012 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1194. Data: 64.2 grains, 19.8 mm. (1000-1500)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards

423 - WI550C-1a R8 PCGS MS64 BN Nice luster and toning. J. Smart Steam Flouring & Planning Mills, North Prairie Wisconsin Union 1863 with eagle. Rare merchant in exceptional condition as most examples are VF to EF with problems. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1205. Data: 190°, 54.6 grains, 19.8 mm. (1500-2000) 424 - WI590A-1a R8 PCGS XF Details Surfaces smoothed but still fairly attractive. Mrs. J. Tate Milliner, Oconomowoc Wisconsin 1864. Very rare single variety town and the key to a Wisconsin town set. Also one of just a handful of Civil War tokens known to have been issued by female merchants. The Bleviss specimen was NCS Genuine with what appears to be EF Details with some porosity and sold for $12,650 in Stack's January 2010 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. This is the current Fuld Plate specimen. Reverse Die: 1174. Data: 57.2 grains, 19.8 mm. (12000-16000) 425 - WI600A-1a R5 PCGS MS66 BN 10% Red nearly all on the obverse. Stiles Gang Mills Dealer in Lumber, Lath and Shingles, Oconto County Wisconsin 1863 with eagle. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1194. Data: 61.5 grains, 19.9 mm. (750-1000) 426 - WI620F-1a R5 PCGS MS65 BN Trace Red with attractive toning and luster. Hay & Clark Dealers In Hardware, Oshkosh Wisconsin 1863 with eagle. Scarce merchant particularly this nice. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1179. Data: 56.1 grains, 19.3 mm. (300-400) 427 - WI620H-1a R6 PCGS MS65 BN 10% Red. Kellogg & Hughes Dry Goods, Oshkosh Wisconsin 1863. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1127. Data: 57 grains, 19.3 mm. (300-400) 428 - WI620J-1a R6 PCGS MS65 BN 10% Red all on the obverse with great toning and luster on reverse. Lines & Russell Harness Makers, Oshkosh Wisconsin with Saddlery Hardware reverse. We sold an NGC MS64 RB for $375 in our December 2012 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Data: 190°, 60.2 grains, 19.3 mm. (400-500) 429 - WI660A-1a R7 PCGS MS62 BN T. M. McMillan Groceries & Crockery, Portage City Wisconsin Union 1863. Very scarce single variety town, very rare above EF. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1205. Data: 47.9 grains, 19.4 mm. (750-1000) 430 - WI700C-3a R5 PCGS MS65 BN Trace Red all on the reverse with nice toning. John Elkins Dealer In Watches, Jewelry, Pianos & c., Racine Wisconsin 1863 Union. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1106. Data: 53.4 grains, 19.9 mm. (300-400) 431 - WI700D-1a R4 PCGS MS64 BN 10% Red. F. Elmlinger Tailor, Racine Wisconsin. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1106. Data: 56.9 grains, 19.9 mm. (100-150) 432 - WI700E-3a R6 PCGS MS65 BN Trace Red all on the obverse. J. W. English Trunk & Harness Dealer, Racine Wisconsin Union 1861 with eagle. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1207. Data: 50.7 grains, 19.6 mm. (300-400) 433 - WI700G-1a R6 PCGS MS64 BN Thos. Falvey Manufacturer Of Reapers & Mowers, Racine Wisconsin 1863. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1101. Data: 52.6 grains, 19.8 mm. (300-400) 434 - WI700H-1a R8 PCGS MS65 BN Nice toning and luster. D. H. Jones Staple & Fancy Dry Goods, Racine Wisconsin 1863. Rare variety, A Raw MS63 sold for $277 in our January 2016 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1105. Data: 54 grains, 19.9 mm. (400-500) 435 - WI700J-1a R7 PCGS MS63 BN Thelen & Dieterich Dry Goods, Racine Wisconsin. The key to a Racine merchant set. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1108. Data: 53.3 grains, 19.8 mm. (500-750) 436 - WI720A-7d R9 PCGS MS65 50% Bright. Greenway's Immense Concert Hall Seats 1,000 People, Ripon Wisconsin 1864 struck in Copper Nickel. Very scarce single merchant town, an NGC MS64 example of the much more available R7 -1a variety sold for $700 in our June 2013 auction. From the Dave Bowers and Bob Kraft collections from World Exonumia's September 1991 auction. Reverse Die: 1047. Data: 340°, 62.6 grains, 19.4 mm. (1500-2000) 437 - WI770A-1a R4 PCGS MS64 BN Nice toning and luster. C. Nebel Steam Mills, Sauk City Wisconsin 1863 with eagle. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1194. Data: 61.7 grains, 19.7 mm. (300-400)

438 444 446 438 - WI790A-2a1 R8 PCGS MS65 RB 50% Red with nice cartwheel luster. Trowbridge's Watch, Clock & Jewelry Store, Sheboygan Wisconsin with pocket watch pictured on reverse. Rare single merchant town and one of the keys to a Wisconsin town set. We sold an NGC MS64 RB that realized $2,650 in our October 2011 sale. From the Dave Bowers and Bob Kraft collections from World Exonumia's September 1991 auction. Reverse Die: 1319. Data: 110°, 66.8 grains, 19.2 mm. (3000-4000) 439 - WI830B-1a R6 PCGS MS64 BN Nice toning and luster. W. S. Newton Dealer In Hardware & Stoves, Sparta Wisconsin Union 1864. Very scarce town and merchant. An AU realized $412.50 in our December 2008 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1107. Data: 51.1 grains, 19.5 mm. (750-1000) 440 - WI860A-1a R7 PCGS MS64 BN Trace Red on the obverse. T. P. Camp Watch Maker, Stoughton Wisconsin 1863 with Pocket Watch reverse. Very scarce merchant, a Raw MS62 RB brought $522.50 in our September 2010 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1320. Data: 65.6 grains, 19.3 mm. (750-1000) 441 - WI860C-1a R5 PCGS MS65 BN 20% Red mostly on the obverse. H. Peterson Dry Goods, Clothing, Boots, Shoes & c., Stoughton Wisconsin with eagle. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1181. Data: 67.7 grains, 19.4 mm. (400-500) 442 - WI890B-1a R5 PCGS MS64 BN Obverse nearly Proof Like. Wm. Runkel Dealer In Dry Goods & C., Tomah & New Lisbon Wisconsin 1863 with eagle. Rare in Uncirculated condition. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1194. Data: 180°, 64.8 grains, 19.6 mm. (300-400)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 443 - WI900A-1a R4 PCGS MS66 BN 10% Red obverse nearly Proof Like. R. Suettinger Stoves Manufacturers & Dealers In Stoves, Tin & Sheet Iron Ware, Two Rivers Wisconsin 1863 with eagle. Scarce single variety town, we sold an NGC MS64 RB that realized $442 in our December 2012 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1194. Data: 58 grains, 19.8 mm. (500-750) 444 - WI920B-1a R6 PCGS MS62 BN Or a bit better 10% Red. Bertram & Co. Sign of the Mammoth Boot, Watertown Wisconsin. Very scarce single variety merchant, we sold an NGC MS63 RB that brought $487 in our June 2013 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1317. Data: 180°, 61.1 grains, 19.4 mm. (400-500) 445 - WI920C-1a R6 PCGS MS64 BN 20% Red all on the obverse. Cordes & Platz Dry Goods Groceries & Liquors, Watertown Wisconsin 1863. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1085. Data: 54.7 grains, 19.3 mm. (200-300) 446 - WI920D-1a R8 PCGS MS66 BN 10% Red nicely toned with great cartwheel luster particularly on the reverse. T. Devin Clothing, Watertown Wisconsin 1864 Liberty For All with eagle on cannon. Rare variety, a Raw MS63 sold for $230 in our June 2013 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1174. Data: 60.1 grains, 19.9 mm. (750-1000) 447 - WI920D-1b R8 PCGS MS65 Trace Bright and nicely toned. T. Devin Clothing, Watertown Wisconsin 1864 Liberty For All with eagle on cannon struck in Brass. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1174. Data: 63.6 grains, 20.1 mm. (400-500) 448 - WI920D-4d R8 PCGS MS65 60% Bright. T. Devin Clothing, Watertown Wisconsin with America reverse struck in Copper Nickel. Just the fifth example we have seen offered. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1272. Data: 60.9 grains, 19.7 mm. (400-500) 449 - WI920F-1a R5 PCGS MS62 BN Nice toning with luster. Fischer & Rohr Clothiers, Watertown Wisconsin 1863 with eagle. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1194. Data: 200°, 60 grains, 19.9 mm. (150-200) 450 - WI920G-1a R6 PCGS MS66 BN Trace Red. W. C. Fountain Drugs, Watertown Wisconsin 1863 with Mortar and Pestle reverse. We sold an NGC MS64 RB example in our July 2012 sale that brought $387. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1316. Data: 66.6 grains, 19.4 mm. (500-750)

451 458 465 469 451 - WI920H-3d R10 PCGS MS66 70% Bright. Chas. Goeldner Musical Instruments, Watertown Wisconsin with Saddles, Bridles & C. saddle reverse die struck in Copper Nickel and believed to be Unique. From the Dave Bowers, Bob Kraft, Rich Hartzog, Johnson and Green collections. Reverse Die: 1341. Data: 180°, 66.8 grains, 19.4 mm. (1500-2000) 452 - WI920H-4a R5 PCGS MS66 BN 20% Red more so on the obverse. Chas. Goeldner Manufacturer Of Harness, Children's Carriages & C., Watertown Wisconsin with Saddles, Bridles & C. reverse die 1341 struck in Copper. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1341. Data: 52.4 grains, 19.3 mm. (750-1000) 453 - WI920J-1a R5 PCGS AU58 Daniel Kusel Hardware, Watertown Wisconsin 1863 with eagle. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1194. Data: 180°, 62.2 grains, 19.7 mm. (150-200) 454 - WI920K-1d R10 PCGS MS65 60% Bright. J. Moulton Groceries, Flour & Feed, Watertown Wisconsin 1863 struck in Copper Nickel and thought to be Unique. From the Dave Bowers, Bob Kraft, Rich Hartzog, Johnson and Green collections. Reverse Die: 1088. Data: 10°, 65.8 grains, 19.4 mm. (1000-1500) 455 - WI920L-2b R4 PCGS MS66 20% Bright. T. Racek Good For One Glass Beer, Watertown struck in Brass. Once a very rare merchant when a small hoard of generally high grade examples came to the market a number of years ago. A Raw MS63 sold for $151.50 in our January 2016 sale. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1356. Data: 45.6 grains, 19.6 mm. (300-400) 456 - WI930A-1a R7 PCGS MS65 RB 20% Red mostly on the obverse. Charles Cork Crockery, Waukesha Wisconsin 1863. The rarest of the three very scarce Waukesha merchants in Uncirculated condition, just the second recorded. An NGC MS64 RB example sold for $600 in our February 2014 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1127. Data: 135°, 53.4 grains, 19.3 mm. (1000-1500) 457 - WI930C-1a R6 PCGS MS66 BN Trace Red on the obverse with nice toning on the reverse. H. W. Sherman Dry Goods, Hats, Caps And Groceries, Waukesha Wisconsin with boot on the reverse. Very scarce town, the NGC MS63 from our December 2012 sale realized $475. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1317. Data: 250°, 56.2 grains, 19.3 mm. (750-1000) 458 - WI960C-1d R10 PCGS MS66 60% Bright. J. T. Smith Jeweler, Whitewater Wisconsin 1863 with pocket watch reverse die struck in Copper Nickel and thought to be Unique. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1320. Data: 63.6 grains, 19.4 mm. (1500-2000) 459 - WI960D-1a R6 PCGS MS65 RB 40% Red. Dr. Van Valkenburgh Druggist and Grocer, Whitewater Wisconsin with Mortar and Pestle reverse. In our July 2012 sale we sold an NGC MS64 RB example of the similarly rare -2a variety for $351. From the Dave Bowers collection. Reverse Die: 1310. Data: 58.9 grains, 19.3 mm. (500-750) Counterstamped Coins 460 - A. KNIGHT'S / MINERAL / WATER SALOON / 99 / BALTo STREET on the obverse of a dateless Spanish Two Real NGC AG Details Coin POOR with two light reverse scratches, counterstamp is VF. Attributed to Baltimore Maryland and dated to 1856-1860. We sold another VF on a holed GOOD 1779 Two Real for $249.70 in our July 2006 sale. Rulau Md 85B. From the John J. Ford collection Stack's Bowers August 2013. (150-200)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate

Counterstamped Coins 461 - PARISIAN / VARIETIES / 16. St & B'WAY. N. Y. on the obverse of an 1874 Arrows Seated Half Dollar NGC XF45 BN Coin EF, counterstamp EF. According to Rulau, Parisian Varieties was an erotic show of nubile young ladies in 1875 and 1876. This counterstamp is known on a number of different Half Dollars making for a challenging collection by date and mint mark. Very choice coin and stamp. Miller 627 Rulau NY NY 230 From the John J. Ford collection Stack's Bowers August 2013. (400-500) 462 - PARISIAN / VARIETIES / 16. St & B'WAY. N. Y. on the obverse of an 1874 Arrows Seated Half Dollar NGC F15 Coin VG, counterstamp VF. According to Rulau, Parisian Varieties was an erotic show of nubile young ladies in 1875 and 1876. This counterstamp is known on a number of different Half Dollars making for a challenging collection by date and mint mark. A raw EF example of the more available 1875 Half in EF with light reverse scratches brought $222 in our February 2014 sale. Called a 1874-CC in error on NGC holder. Miller 627 Rulau NY NY 230. From the John J. Ford collection Stack's Bowers August 2013. (200-300) 463 - PARISIAN / VARIETIES / 16. St & B'WAY. N. Y. on the obverse of an 1875 Seated Half Dollar NGC FINE Details Coin VG with some light scratches, counterstamp VF. According to Rulau, Parisian Varieties was an erotic show of nubile young ladies in 1875 and 1876. This counterstamp is known on a number of different Half Dollars making for a challenging collection by date and mint mark. A raw EF example on a EF coin with light reverse scratches brought $222 in our February 2014 sale. Miller 627 Rulau NY NY 230. From the John J. Ford collection Stack's Bowers August 2013. (200-300) 464 - PARISIAN / VARIETIES / 16. St & B'WAY. N. Y. on the obverse of an 1875 Seated Half Dollar NGC VG10 Coin VG, counterstamp EF. According to Rulau, Parisian Varieties was an erotic show of nubile young ladies in 1875 and 1876. This counterstamp is known on a number of different Half Dollars making for a challenging collection by date and mint mark. A raw EF example on a EF coin with light reverse scratches brought $222 in our February 2014 sale. Miller 627 Rulau NY NY 230. From the John J. Ford collection Stack's Bowers August 2013. (200-300) 465 - PARISIAN / VARIETIES / 16. St & B'WAY. N. Y. on the obverse of an 1875-CC Seated Half Dollar NGC VG8 Coin VG, counterstamp VF. According to Rulau, Parisian Varieties was an erotic show of nubile young ladies in 1875 and 1876. This counterstamp is known on a number of different Half Dollars making for a challenging collection by date and mint mark with just a precious few bearing the CC mint mark of Carson City Nevada as this example does. A raw VF example on the much more available 1874 Half in AG brought $210 in our January 2015 auction. Miller 627 Rulau NY NY 230. From the John J. Ford collection Stack's Bowers August 2013. (1500-2000) 466 - ADMIT / TO / WOOD'S / MINSTRELS / 444 Bd WAY / NY on the obverse and reverse of a 1773 Spanish Two Real NGC AG3 Coin AG, counterstamp is a nice VF. These counterstamped 2 Reals were used as 25 Cent admission tickets to H. Wood's minstrels and Ethiopian band that performed at 444 Broadway from 1855 to 1857 when they moved to 561 & 563 Broadway and instead issued struck silver tokens to serve as admission. Listed on NGC holder as Rulau NY 964D which Rulau describes as a latter type while this is an earlier type, perhaps NY 964E would be a better designation. Regardless a rare and apparently unlisted type. From the John J. Ford collection Stack's Bowers August 2013. (200-300) 467 - ADMIT / TO / WOOD'S / MINSTRELS / 444 Bd WAY / NY on the obverse and reverse of a 1777 Lima Peru Spanish Two Real NGC VG Details Coin VG but bent and straightened, counterstamp VF. These counterstamped 2 Reals were used as 25 Cent admission tickets to H. Wood's minstrels and Ethiopian band that performed at 444 Broadway from 1855 to 1857 when they moved to 561 & 563 Broadway and instead issued struck silver tokens to serve as admission. Rulau NY 964B. From the John J. Ford collection Stack's Bowers August 2013. (200-300) 468 - ADMIT / TO / WOOD'S / MINSTRELS / 444 Bd WAY / NY on the obverse and reverse of a 1778 Spanish Two Real NGC G6 Coin GOOD, counterstamp a bold EF. These counterstamped 2 Reals were used as 25 Cent admission tickets to H. Wood's minstrels and Ethiopian band that performed at 444 Broadway from 1855 to 1857 when they moved to 561 & 563 Broadway and instead issued struck silver tokens to serve as admission. Rulau NY 964B. From the John J. Ford collection Stack's Bowers August 2013. (300-400) 469 - FREE TICKET TO / YANKEE / ROBINSONS / QUADRUPLE - SHOW on the obverse of an 1854-O Arrows Half Dollar NGC VG8 Coin VG, counterstamp EF. This traveling Circus also issued a large number of Civil War tokens. A raw VF on a VG 1854-O Half brought $429 in our July 2012 auction. From the John J. Ford collection Stack's Bowers August 2013. (500-750) Hard Times Tokens 470 - LOW 8 / HT-9 R1 NGC MS64 BN With nice cartwheel luster. My Substitute For The US Bank with running boar pictured. From the Bob Shalowitz collection. (400-500) 471 - LOW 19 / HT-33 R1 NGC MS63 BN Trace Red with very nice cartwheel luster. Turtle carrying Sub Treasury with Jackass on reverse. From the Bob Shalowitz collection. (300-400) 472 - LOW 21 / HT-35 R2 NGC VF30 BN 1837 Liberty head Millions For Defense Not One Cent For Tribute. From the Bob Shalowitz collection. (150-200) 473 - LOW 38 / HT-62 R1 NGC MS63 BN Trace Red on both sides. Mint Drop Brentonian Currency 1837. From the Bob Shalowitz collection. (300-400) 474 - LOW 49 / HT-73 R2 NGC MS64 BN Half Cent Worth Of Pure Copper 1837. Listed in the Half Cent section of the Red Book and always popular. A raw AU+ sold for $331 in our October 2011 sale. From the Bob Shalowitz collection. (750-1000) 475 - LOW 51 / HT-70 R1 NGC MS65 BN Trace Red with nice cartwheel luster. The Constitution As I Understand It Roman Firmness Veto with Jackass labeled LLD. An NGC MS64 BN brought $375 in our December 2016 auction. From the Bob Shalowitz collection. (400-500) 476 - LOW 53 / HT-72 R2 PCGS MS62 BN Unusually well struck for issue. The Constitution As I Understand It Roman Firmness Veto with Jackass labeled LLD. A cruder version of the normally encountered variety, likely from a different maker. A Raw AU, quite well struck, sold for $290 our October 2011 auction. (400-500)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate

Hard Times Tokens

477 482 484 477 - LOW 60 / HT-18 R1 NGC MS63 BN 20% Red. Van Buren Metallic Currency with ship labeled Experiment being hit by storm. A variety rarely seen with any original red. From the Bob Shalowitz collection. (300-400) 478 - LOW 64 / HT-22 R1 PCGS MS64 BN Trace Red, nicely toned with very nice cartwheel luster. Webster Credit Currency with sailing ship on calm waters. From the Bob Shalowitz collection. (400-500) 479 - LOW 97 / HT-293 R1 NGC MS63 BN Very sharp strike. Merchants Exchange Wall Street, New York. From the Bob Shalowitz collection. (200-300) 480 - LOW 98 / HT-294 R1 NGC MS65 BN Well struck with very nice cartwheel luster. Merchants Exchange New York Joint Stock Exchange. A similar example brought $375 in our January 2016 sale. From the Bob Shalowitz collection. (400-500) 481 - LOW 104 / HT-155 R1 NGC MS64 BN Trace Red on both sides. R. & W. Robinson Military Buttons, New York. (300-400) 482 - LOW 107 / HT-219 R1 NGC MS62 BN Or a bit better 10% Red. Henry Anderson Mammoth Boot, New York 1837 picturing a large boot. From the Bob Shalowitz collection. (300-400) 483 - LOW 109 / HT-104 R3 NGC AU58 BN Benedict & Burnham Buttons, Waterbury Connecticut. From the Bob Shalowitz collection. (300-400) 484 - LOW 117 / HT-262 R3 PCGS XF40 A nice well struck and problem free example. Feuchtwanger's Composition 1837 Three Cents, New York. A raw VF+ realized $1,100 in our March 2010 auction. From the Bob Shalowitz collection. (1500-2000) 485 - LOW 120 6-G / HT-268 R1 NGC MS61 Feuchtwanger Composition One Cent 1837 struck in German Silver. Very underrated variety, we sold a Raw EF example for $235 in our December 2016 sale. From the Bob Shalowitz collection. (300-400) 486 - LOW 120 6-I / HT-268 R1 NGC MS63 Trace Bright. Feuchtwanger's One Cent 1837 struck in German Silver. A Raw EF+ sold for $300 in our January 2016 auction. From the Bob Shalowitz collection. (400-500) 487 - LOW 141 / HT-335 R3 NGC AU55 BN Strong even strike. Ezra B. Sweet, Stoves & Kitchen Furniture, New York 1837. A raw EF brought $235 in our December 2012 sale. From the Bob Shalowitz collection. (200-300) 488 - LOW 143 / HT-206 R4 NGC XF45 BN Nicely struck on a slightly larger than normal planchet. Bergen Iron Works 1840, Lakewood New Jersey struck in Copper. (150-200) 489 - LOW 158 / HT-377 R7 NGC FINE Details Porous environmental damage. A. Loomis Liquor Dealer 1843, Cleveland Ohio. Very rare token that when encountered is usually low grade with problems. From the Dice and Hicks collection earlier from Stack's July 2008 sale where it realized $4,312.50. (3000-4000) 490 - LOW 180 / HT-205A R4 NGC XF45 BN Bergen Iron Works Store, Lakewood New Jersey. Struck in Copper and somewhat underrated, particularly this nice. (300-400) 491 - LOW 205 / HT-224A R8 NGC VF20 Atwood's Railroad Hotel 3 Cents signed Bale & Smith NY with George Washington on horseback struck in Silver with reeded edge. Very rare. Listed for years by Russ Rulau with the caveat "May not exist" and may very well be Unique. Measured at 25.4mm and 4.19 grams. From the John Ford Collection. From Stacks Bowers August 2013 sale where it realized $5,581.25. (6000-8000)

492 496 503 492 - LOW 206 / HT-226 R8 NGC AU55 10% Bright. Bailly Ward & Co. No. 41 Maiden Lane New York Jewelry Perfumery, Engravings, Stationery & French And English Fancy Articles struck in White Metal. Incredibly, Ford had three examples (one damaged) of this very rare merchant, this being the finest in our opinion, though one was called AU58 by NGC. All others seen have been low grade and / or damaged, missing from the Dice-Hicks offering. Refer to the Rulau plate specimen for a more typical example. A nice FINE+ but with scratched reverse sold for $1,650 in Bowers and Merena's November 1990 sale. The aforementioned NGC AU58 sold for $2,400 in our February 2014 auction. From the John J. Ford collection Stack's Bowers August 2013. (4000-6000) 493 - LOW 239 / HT-247 R6 NGC AU58 BN Day, Newell & Day Manufacturer of Locks, Bolts & Hinges, New York. Very scarce variety particularly this nice. We sold an NGC AU55 BN that brought $475 in our January 2015 sale. From the Steve Dabney collection. (500-750) 494 - LOW 261 / HT-286 R2 NGC AU55 BN H. Law Baker English Bread, Twist & Fancy Cakes, New York. From the Bob Shalowitz collection. (200-300)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Hard Times Tokens 495 - LOW 264 / HT-122 R5 NGC AU53 John A. Merle & Co. Bienville Street, New Orleans. Very scarce in any grade and Rare in EF or better. Another NGC AU53 brought $1,060 in our August 2015 auction. From the Steve Dabney collection. (750-1000) 496 - LOW 268 / HT-302 R7 NGC AU50 Edwin Parmele Bowling Saloon with well-dressed gentleman holding a wine glass on the reverse with his motto Quite Comfortable. Very rare merchant with most of the five known examples damaged. One of the nicer damaged examples is a nice VF by wear but with a large punch mark. It sold for $4,400 in PCAC's June 1996 sale, was sold again by PCAC in November 2006 for a fairly shocking $21,850 and finally failed to sell in Stacks sale of the Dice & Hicks collection in July 2008 with a starting bid of $13,800. This example is much nicer and is the finest certified. From the John J. Ford collection Stack's Bowers August 2013. (12000-16000) 497 - LOW 279B / HT-319 R7 NGC XF45 BN Squire & Merritt Ship Chandlers and Rope Makers (175) South St., New York. With 175 of address counterstamped as usual for this scarce variety. Die combination 1-A. We sold a Raw VF+ that sold for $320 in our July 2014 auction. From the Steve Dabney collection. (400-500) 498 - LOW 300 / HT-181 R1 NGC MS62 BN John J. Adams, Taunton Massachusetts with running boar pictured. An NGC MS61 in our December 2012 auction realized $180. From the Bob Shalowitz collection. (200-300) 499 - LOW 321 / HT-295 R2 NGC MS63 BN Trace Red on both sides. James G. Moffet Brass Founder, New York with charmingly crude die work featuring a backwards N and S in E Pluribus Unum. A Raw MS62 sold for $270 in our August 2015 sale. From the Bob Shalowitz collection. (300-400) 500 - LOW 365 / HT-339 R8 NGC XF45 BN Richard Williams Union Hall New York Good For Refreshment At The Bar with Odd Fellow heart in hand symbol on obverse and signed Bale on reverse. A very rare merchant. We can only account for six, including the EF Rulau plate specimen that realized $8,050 in the July 2008 Stacks Dice & Hicks sale and Ford's NGC AU58 that brought $9,400 in an August 2013 Stack's Bowers sale. From the John J. Ford collection Stack's Bowers August 2013. (4000-6000) 501 - LOW 371 / HT-299 R6 NGC VF20 New York & Harlaem Rail Road Company struck in German Silver counterstamped with Rosette and vintage carriage signed B & S NY for the maker Bale and Smith. From the Steve Dabney collection. (750-1000) 502 - LOW 398A / HT-385A R6 NGC MS62 20% Bright. Isaac Barton & Co., Philadelphia Pennsylvania. Vary scarce variety with reeded edge, but rare in Uncirculated condition. Another NGC MS62 example brought $600 in our December 2017 auction. From the Virgil Brand collection. (750-1000) 503 - LOW 400B / HT-141 R4 NGC XF40 Coin EF, with bold EF counterstamp unusual with this issue. HOUCK'S / PANACEA / BALTIMORE in raised letters within an oblong depression on the obverse of an 1830 Capped Bust Half Dollar. An unusually nice example all the way around. From the John J. Ford collection Stack's Bowers August 2013. (1000-1500) 504 - LOW 403A / HT-147A R5 NGC MS62 Trace Bright with interesting die cracks. Randall & Co. Baltimore Maryland struck in German Silver. From our February 2014 sale where it realized $450. From the Steve Dabney and John Ford collections. (500-750) 505 - HT-214 R4 NGC AU53 BN W. A. Thomson, Buffalo New York picturing a large anvil and Tea Pot. Unlisted in Low. Very scarce this nice, we sold a Raw EF in our December 2017 sale that realized $185.15. (200-300) 506 - HT-C417 R7 NGC XF45 Snyder & Shankland Drapers & Tailors, Philadelphia Pennsylvania struck in White metal with a Plain edge with Cupid drawing back bow. The obverse is signed with a B between Cupid's feet. From our July 2014 sale where it brought $600. From the Steve Dabney and John Ford collections. (500-750) Merchant Tokens

507 512 517 507 - MILLER CT 7 NGC MS64 Nicely toned and nearly Proof Like. Alfred Robinson Banker, Hartford Connecticut 1861 struck in Silver with Value Me As You Please Higley Three Pence reverse. Long planned to be added as a Civil War token in the new Third Edition of the Store Card book, it has recently been shown that they were included in auctions that took place shortly before the Civil War began. The NGC holder lists with the proposed Fuld number CT210A-1f. A raw MS63 example of the much more available Copper variety realized $275 in our December 2017 sale. From the Steve Tanenbaum, John Ford and F. C. C. Boyd collections earlier from Stack's May 2006 sale at $977.50. (2000-3000) 508 - MILLER MA 50B NGC AU55 R. M. & CO. on both sides counterstamped 55 struck in White Metal with Plain edge 33mm. This previously unlisted token is thought to be related to the R. Marston & Co. token listed as Miller MA 50. That token is listed as a Possible Civil War Store Card in the current book as they were listed in city directories from 1857 to 1866 and beyond. Rare and thought to be Unique, even the listed example is not pictured in Rulau. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection earlier from Robert Moffatt February 1990. (150-200) 509 - MILLER MA 70 NGC MS61 30% Bright. W. W. Messer 212 Washington Street, Boston Massachusetts Families Supplied With Fresh Cream & French Chocolate struck in White Metal. Wesser has been listed as a Possible Civil War Store Card in the current edition because they were listed in city directories from 1858 to 1862. Quite rare regardless of time period. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection earlier from Harmer Rooke March 1991. (200-300) 510 - MILLER MO 21 NGC MS63 RB 40% Red. Fitzgibbon Daguerreotype Gallery, St. Louis Missouri struck in Copper with Plain edge. (150-200) 511 - RULAU NJ Gb 16 NGC MS63 40% Bright. Whitney Brothers, Glassboro New Jersey 1869 One Cent struck in White Metal with Plain edge. Very rare variety with Benjamin Franklin reverse. From the Bob Shalowitz collection. (300-400)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate

Merchant Tokens 512 - MILLER NY 59 NGC MS64 PL Proof Like. American Museum P. T. Barnum Proprietor New York with building and bust of Barnum and list of attractions, Admission To The Whole Only 25 Cents struck in White Metal. This die combination has been included in the Civil War Store Card book as a possible Civil War Token based on an April 1862 auction appearance though there is currently no proof it was not struck before the War. We sold a Raw MS63 PL White Metal example for $750 in our August 2015 auction. Rulau NY-NY 11. From the James McClure collection. (1000-1500) 513 - MILLER NY 474A NGC MS65 RB 40% Red more so on the obverse. Loder & Co. 130 Broadway, New York struck in Copper with Plain edge. We have yet to see the two address mules listed by Adams, Miller and Rulau as NY 474 and NY 475, these listings are likely in error. This example is called NY 478 by NGC and should have an "&" rather than "AND"; this is likely an erroneous duplicate listing. From the James McClure collection. (200-300) 514 - MILLER NY 815 NGC MS62 20% Bright. Jas. S. Smith & Co. Military Goods, New York with a military hat struck in Silvered Brass with Plain edge. Only listed in Silvered Copper but all we have seen appear to be Brass. (100-150) 515 - MILLER NY 832 NGC MS63 Trace Bright toned. Lewis L. Squire & Sons Ship Chandlers, New York struck in Silver with Plain edge. Silver merchant tokens in general are quite rare. From the John Ford collection. (400-500) 516 - MILLER NY 923 NGC AU58 Trested Fecit Six Cents struck in Brass with Reeded edge. Very rare merchant, particularly this nice. From the Steve Dabney and John Ford collections earlier from Stack's Bowers February 2014 sale where it realized $587.50. (500-750) 517 - RULAU NY NY 395B NGC MS64 PL 30% Bright and Proof Like. 1877 US Grant Civis Londiniensis token designed by Isaac F. Wood with die by George Hampden Lovett struck in Brass with Plain edge. The Londiniensis reverse die is known with and without designers initials I. F. W., this is the without version. (200-300) 518 - MILLER PA 30 NGC MS62 10% Bright. Bailey & Co. Silver Ware, Philadelphia Pennsylvania struck in Silvered Brass with Plain edge. From the Mark Cramer collection. (100-150) 519 - MILLER PA 89 NGC MS64 RB 40% Red and nearly Proof Like. Edward Cogan Dealer In Books, Coins, Medals and Engravings 1859, Philadelphia struck in Copper with Reeded edge. Struck and signed by Lovett on George Washington on the reverse. A raw AU+ realized $195 in our February 2014 auction. Baker 527 From the Mark Cramer collection. (500-750) 520 - MILLER PA 90A NGC MS63 BN Trace Red. Edward Cogan Coin Dealer, Philadelphia 1860 struck in Copper with Plain edge. A similar example brought $145 in our December 2012 sale. From the Mark Cramer collection. (150-200) 521 - MILLER PA 90B NGC MS63 50% Bright. Edward Cogan Coin Dealer, Philadelphia 1860 struck in Brass with Reeded edge. A raw MS62 brought $110 in our February 2014 auction. From the Mark Cramer collection. (150-200) 522 - MILLER PA 90F NGC MS64 Toned. Edward Cogan Coin Dealer, Philadelphia Pennsylvania 1860 struck in Silver with Reeded edge. An NGC MS63 realized $535 in our October 2011 sale. From the Mark Cramer collection. (750-1000) 523 - MILLER PA 145 NGC AU58 Trace Bright with most of original Silvering remaining. Evan's & Watson Makers Dickeson's Coin & Medal Safe, Philadelphia with Robert Lovett's George Washington Security on reverse struck in Silvered White Metal with Plain edge. Apparently scarcer than the Copper variety and known in Silvered as well as Non Silvered White Metal. In NGC holder as Rulau Pa Ph 33. Baker 530D From the Mark Cramer collection. (150-200) 524 - MILLER PA 151 NGC MS65 BN 20% Red. Evan's & Watson Makers Dickeson's Coin & Medal Safe, Philadelphia with Sommer Islands Shilling and Hog on reverse struck in Copper with Plain edge. Very popular, a raw MS64 sold for $561.99 in our June 2013 auction. In an NGC holder as Rulau Pa Ph 50. From the Mark Cramer collection. (750-1000) 525 - MILLER PA 217 NGC MS66 BN Trace Red. W. Idler Dealer In Coins & Medals, Philadelphia. Made to resemble a 1659 Lord Baltimore Penny struck in Copper with Plain edge. Listed on the NGC holder as PA-223/PA-217 an understandable choice given Rulau's confusing listings and poorly placed photos for this merchant; we choose to use Adams and Millers listings. We sold an NGC MS62 RB in our January 2016 sale for $115. From the Mark Cramer collection. (500-750) 526 - MILLER PA 230 NGC MS62 10% Bright toned with full silver plating. W. Idler Dealer In Coins, Minerals, Shells, Antiques, 111 N. 9th St., Philadelphia struck in Silvered White Metal with Plain Edge and George Washington reverse. This variety comes in both Silvered (unlisted) and Non Silvered White Metal, so far by our count they are of similar rarity. We sold an MS62 Unlisted Silvered White Medal for $185 in our December 2012 sale. Baker 545D From the Mark Cramer collection. (200-300) 527 - MILLER PA 230 NGC UNC Details 40% Bright and nearly Proof Like but with a few light marks. W. Idler Dealer In Coins, Minerals, Shells, Antiques, 111 N. 9th St., Philadelphia struck in White Metal with Plain Edge and George Washington reverse. This variety comes in both Silvered and Non Silvered White Metal, so far by our count they are of similar rarity. Baker 545D From the Mark Cramer collection. (75-100) 528 - MILLER PA 230B NGC MS64 20% Bright. W. Idler Dealer In Coins, Minerals, Shells, Antiques, 111 N. 9th St., Philadelphia struck in Nickel with Plain edge and George Washington reverse. A raw MS62 brought $150 in our February 2014 sale. Baker 545C From the Mark Cramer collection. (400-500) 529 - MILLER PA 230F NGC UNC Details 30% Bright. The NGC holder notes Obverse Damage and while there are a few small spots and a few light marks none seem serious to call Damage. We would grade MS62 W. Idler Dealer In Coins, Minerals, Shells, Antiques, 111 N. 9th St., Philadelphia with Continental Paper Money, Autographs, Engravings & c. Bought and Sold reverse struck in Brass with Plain edge. From the Mark Cramer and Dave Bowers collections. In an NGC Bowers holder. (100-150) 530 - MILLER PA 332 NGC MS64 60% Bright and nearly Proof Like. Robert Lovett Jr. Die Sinker, Philadelphia Pennsylvania with Stephen Girard reverse struck in Brass with Plain edge. A raw MS63 in our January 2015 auction sold for $140.15. From the Mark Cramer collection. (300-400) 531 - MILLER PA 334 NGC MS62 BN With attractive toning and nearly Proof Like surfaces. Robert Lovett Jr. Die Sinker, Philadelphia Pennsylvania struck in Copper with Plain edge and Stephen Girard reverse. A raw MS62 brought $162.65 in our February 2014 sale. From the Mark Cramer collection. (150-200) 532 - MILLER PA 339 NGC MS62 30% Bright. Robert Lovett Jr. Die Sinker, Philadelphia Pennsylvania struck in Brass with Reeded edge and George Washington on horseback on reverse. Baker 556B From the Mark Cramer collection. (150-200)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Merchant Tokens 533 - MILLER PA 355 NGC MS62 20% Bright. R. Lovett Jr. Engraver & Die Sinker 1860, Philadelphia struck in Copper Nickel with Plain edge. Popular token due to its association with and similarity to the Confederate Cent made just one year later by the same firm. Though the most available composition for this die combination, it enjoys added demand as it more closely mimics the Confederate Cent. An MS62 brought $190 in our February 2014. From the Mark Cramer collection. (200-300) 534 - MILLER PA 382 NGC MS62 40% Bright with nice cartwheel luster. Partridge & Richardson Dress Trimmings, Philadelphia with beehive and women riding horseback sidesaddle pictured struck in Brass with Reeded edge. (100-150) 535 - MILLER PA 504 NGC MS61 20% Bright. A. B. Taylor Orilote And Denticrete For The Teeth Soda Water 1860, Philadelphia Pennsylvania struck in Nickel with Plain edge. Incorrectly called PA 507B on NGC's holder. A raw MS62 in our July 2012 auction brought $123. From the Mark Cramer collection. (100-150) 536 - MILLER PA 506C NGC AU Details With rough obverse and notches in the rim. NGC holder notes Removed From Jewelry but more likely mounted for display like Louis Kaufman who had similar items among his Civil War token display. A. B. Taylor Soda Water 1860, Philadelphia Pennsylvania with heraldic eagle reverse, struck in White Metal with Plain edge. Very rare variety only listed by Adams in Copper; Miller added White Metal and Silver but Rulau replaced White Metal with Brass. From the Mark Cramer collection. (200-300) 537 - MILLER PA 507 NGC UNC Details 20% Bright with a number of very light hairlines. A. B. Taylor Druggist & Apothecary, Denticrete For The Teeth, Philadelphia Pennsylvania struck in Copper Nickel with Plain edge. From the Mark Cramer collection. (100-150) 538 - MILLER PA 508 NGC MS65 BN Or nearly so. A. B. Taylor Druggist & Apothecary The Best Preparations For Teeth, Philadelphia struck in Copper with a Plain edge. A raw MS63 sold for $152 in our February 2014 sale. From the Mark Cramer collection. (300-400) 539 - MILLER PA 509 NGC MS64 50% Bright. A. B. Taylor Druggist & Apothecary Full Assortment of Drugs Always on Hand, Philadelphia Pennsylvania struck in Copper Nickel with Plain edge. An MS62 brought $110 in our July 2012 sale. From the Mark Cramer collection. (300-400) 540 - MILLER PA 510 NGC MS62 RB 50% Red. A. B. Taylor Druggist & Apothecary, Philadelphia Pennsylvania with Drugs and Medicines reverse struck in Copper with Plain edge. A raw MS63 realized $165 in our February 2014 auction. From the Mark Cramer collection. (150-200) 541 - RULAU Pa Ph 298 NGC UNC Details 30% Bright with a few marks including a fairly large nick in the field right of Franklin on the reverse. NGC holder noted Obverse Damage while we would grade MS61. Mason & Co. 1870 Coin & Stamp Dealer 139 No. 9th St., Philadelphia with Benjamin Franklin reverse struck in White Metal with Plain edge. Very rare and said to be one of just two struck. Unlisted die combination in Adams and Miller. From the Mark Cramer and Dave Bowers collections. In an NGC Bowers holder. (500-750) 542 - MILLER TN 12 NGC MS65 70% Bright. Francisco & Co. Hatters, Memphis Tennessee struck in Brass with a Reeded edge. (300-400) 543 - MILLER TN 13 NGC MS65 60% Bright. Francisco & Co. Hatters, Memphis Tennessee struck in Silvered Brass with a Plain edge. This example brought $390 in our January 2015 sale. (300-400) Political Tokens

544 546 548 544 - FP 1852-1 WM NGC MS63 PL Proof Like. General. F. Pierce (around military bust left signed Leonard F.) // United We Stand, Divided We Fall (around shield inscribed Our Country Right Or Wrong surrounded by eagle, flags and swords). White Metal 41mm. We sold a Raw VF+ holed example in our July 2014 sale for $325. (500-750) 545 - WS 1852-05 CU NGC MS63 RB 40% Red. General Winfield Scott The Peoples Choice (around bust left) // Nominated By The Baltimore Convention 1852 Queenstown Churubusco Chapultepec (around and within wreath). Copper 33mm. (400-500) 546 - WS 1852-07 CU NGC MS64 RB 30% Red more so on the obverse. Major Gen: Win: Scott (around bust left) // United We Stand Divided We Fall (around fasces surrounded by rays). Copper 32mm. From the John Ford Collection. From Stacks Bowers September 2013 sale where it realized $528.75. (500-750) 547 - GMcC 1864-02 CU NGC MS63 BN Maj. Gen. Geo. B. McClellan (around bust left signed Lovett for maker George Lovett of New York) // Nec Querere Nec Spernere Honorem. Copper 35mm with a bronzed appearance as are most if not all. An impressive item. (400-500) 548 - GMcC 1864-89 WM NGC MS63 30% Bright holed for suspension as issued. Antietam Sep. 17th 1862 (around bust left) // Cheat Mountain Yorktown Williamsburg Fir Oaks Gaines Mill Malvernhill South Mountain. White Metal 39mm. A large and impressive piece that was sometimes used as a soldier's dog tag with the pertinent information added to the outer ring. Maier & Stahl McClellan 1G and called Extremely Rare. (400-500) So-Called Dollars 549 - HK-013 R5 NGC MS63 Toned, sharp strike and nearly Proof Like surfaces. 1870 Pilgrim Jubilee Memorial with scene of Pilgrim Landing struck in Silver Plated Brass. (300-400) 550 - HK-169 R4 NGC MS63 20% Bright. 1893 Columbian Exposition Chicago Facts Dollar struck in Aluminum with Plain edge. (100-150) 551 - HK-238 R6 NGC MS64 RB 40% Red more so on the reverse with nice cartwheel luster. 1893 World's Columbian Exposition Columbus Statue Dollar struck in Copper. Very scarce and very attractive. (400-500) 552 - HK-274 R4 NGC MS64 60% Bright with nice cartwheel luster. 1897 Tennessee Centennial Exposition Nashville with US Mint Building struck in Brass. The official medal struck at the Mint exhibit on the Exposition grounds. We sold a similar Raw example for $165 in our July 2009 sale. (200-300)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate So-Called Dollars 553 - HK-319 R5 NGC MS63 DPL Deep Mirror Proof Like. 1904 Louisiana Purchase Exposition St. Louis Missouri Palace of Electricity Dollar struck in Aluminum. (200-300) 554 - HK-320 R5 NGC MS63 DPL Deep Mirror Proof Like. 1904 Louisiana Purchase Exposition St. Louis Missouri Palace of Machinery Dollar struck in Aluminum. (200-300) 555 - HK-321 R5 NGC MS63 PL Proof Like. 1904 Louisiana Purchase Exposition St. Louis Missouri Palace of Varied Industries (for whatever reason this reminds me of Sir Not-Appearing-In-This-Film) Dollar struck in Aluminum. (150-200) 556 - HK-414 R5 NGC MS62 Or a bit better with 50% Bright luster and nearly Proof Like surfaces. 1915 Panama-Pacific Exposition California State Dollar struck in Gilt Brass. (100-150) 557 - HK-867 R6 NGC MS64 Lightly toned. 1933 Colorado's Century of Progress Dollar struck in Silver. One of just 300 issued. (400-500) Bashlow Restrike Set 558 - Bashlow NGC MS68 RD All three exceptional condition and quite bright. Housed together in a custom NGC holder. Circa 1961 Bashlow restrikes of Confederate Cent from copy dies in Copper, Goldine (Brass) and Silver. From the Mark Cramer collection. (750-1000) Bolen Tokens 559 - Bolen JAB-06 Cu NGC MS64 RB 20% Red. Avoid the Extremes of Party Spirit struck in Copper 28mm with bust of George Washington signed J. A. Bolen. One of just 75 Struck in Copper (Oreide). An UNC Details with spots sold for $350 in our December 2010 auction. Baker 258A From the Tim Gabriel and Neil Musante collections. (750-1000) 560 - Bolen JAB-23 Cu NGC MS63 BN Trace Red. Springfield Antiquarians Massachusetts 1866 struck in Copper 27.9mm, 2.5mm thick. One of just 14 said to have been struck by Bolen. We sold a Raw MS63 in our July 2009 sale for $610. From the Tim Gabriel collection. (500-750) Washingtonia 561 - Douglas 22 R3 NGC AU55 Trace Bright and holed for suspension as were most if not all. George Washington bust right signed Lovett with Federal Hall on reverse struck in White Metal 32mm. From the Mark Cramer collection. (75-100)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #46 Closing April 22nd 2018

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com