Steve Hayden

STEVE HAYDEN PO Box 1863 Goose Creek SC 29445 (843) 973-4556 (Voice Mail or FAX) - Email [email protected] Web Site CivilWarTokens.com Please note new address MAIL BID SALE - #43 Closing January 31st, 2016 Sunday (online) First Lot at 7:00 PM EST until Last Lot just before 10:00 PM EST

TERMS OF SALE:

1. There are NO buyer's fees in this sale. What you bid is the most you will pay.

2. Bids are reduced to one increment over the second highest bid. Bidding increments are: for bids up to $50 the increment is $2, from $50 to $100 the increment is $5, from $100 to $250 the increment is $10, from $250 to $500 the increment is $25, from $500 to $2,500 the increment is $50, from $2,500 to $5,000 the increment is $250, from $5,000 to $10,000 the increment is $500, from $10,000 to $25,000 the increment is $1,000 and over $25,000 the increment is $2,500.

3. Postage and insurance will be added to all invoices with a minimum charge of $1.00 per item. Free shipping to those who pay by check. When you get your invoice simply send a check for the total before shipping.

4. Invoices for delivery within South Carolina must pay 6% for South Carolina sales tax unless a resale number is supplied. Bidders from other states are responsible for paying any sales / use tax that may be required.

5. This sale has Live Online Bidding. You can view and bid on all lots online at civilwartokens.com. If you plan to bid online you will need to register so don’t delay. As always let us know if you have any difficulty. Although the auction is staggered many lots will close within seconds so plan ahead and bid accordingly.

6. If you choose, you may still bid by Mail, Fax, Phone and Email but those bids should be received at least one day before the closing date of the sale to assure they are properly recorded. We will enter these bids and act as your agent. These bids will be reflected in the online bidding with the User Name “xxmailbid”. If you bid in this manner please do not also bid online.

7. Bids for each lot can be entered at any time until that item closes as noted in online description with possible bidding extensions as noted below. There are no hidden reserves; the opening bid is the consignor’s reserve.

8. Closing time for a lot is automatically extended for 3 minutes if that lot receives a bid within its last 3 minutes. This continues in 3 minute increments until no further bids are received for that item. If you bid with 4 minutes left the closing will still be in 4 minutes. But if you bid with 2 minutes left the closing will be in 5 minutes. And if you bid with one second left the closing will be in 3 minutes and one second.

9. Estimates which appear after the description are only a guide and lots will often be sold above and below those amounts.

10. You may FAX your bids to our regular number. When we are out of the office our phone will be set to receive FAX's or voice mail. Again these bids should be received at least one day before the closing date of the sale to assure they are properly recorded.

11. Returns will be accepted on any lots incorrectly described, however, since the majority of this material is consigned all sales will be considered final 14 days after lot delivery.

12. The auctioneer reserves the right to reject any bid or withdraw any lot.

13. Placing a bid in this sale constitutes acceptance of the above terms.

My web site civilwartokens.com, has Enlarged Photos of EVERY LOT. Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Patriotic Tokens 1 - 1/436 a R5 Raw Unc Details Retoning from cleaning. 1863 United Country with scarce reverse die. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 2 - 5/288 a R2 Raw AU+ Trace Red on reverse. God Protect The Union. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 3 - 6D/310 b R9 PCGS MS62 10% Bright. 1863 Army & Navy struck in Brass. Very unusual as this is the only variety listed in the 6, 7 and 8 die family in anything other than Copper. A raw AU sold for $230 in our January 2015 sale. (400-500) 4 - 9/405 a R6 NGC AU55 BN With some light obverse stains. The Constitution Must And Shall Be Preserved 1863. Indiana Primitive. A NGC XF45 example brought $80 in our August 2015 sale. (150-200) 5 - 9/407 a R6 PCGS MS63 BN Trace Red mostly on the reverse. Proclaim Liberty Through Out The Land Lincoln 1863. Rarely seen this nice, a NGC MS62 BN sold for $350 in our August 2015 auction. From the Henry South collection, earlier from our January 2015 sale. (400-500) 6 - 9/407 a R6 Raw VF Proclaim Liberty Through Out The Land Lincoln 1863. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 7 - 14/297 a R5 NGC MS62 BN 1863 Army & Navy. Very scarce obverse die, an EF+ example sold for $72.67 in our July 2014 sale. (100-150) 8 - 16/300 a R3 NGC MS64 BN With attractive toning and nice luster. 1863 Army & Navy. (100-150) 9 - 34/276 a R6 PCGS MS62 BN With large reverse die cud. Union 1863 Our Card. From the Ed Rosen collection, earlier from our January 2015 sale. (100-150) 10 - 35/277 a R5 NGC MS63 BN With attractive toning and nice luster. Union 1864 Our Card. Scarce variety particularly this nice, an AU+ sold for $80 in our August 2015 auction. (150-200) 11 - 36/271 a R3 NGC MS64 BN Liberty and No Slavery. Rarely seen this nice, a raw 40% Red MS63 realized $137 in our December 2012 sale. (200-300) 12 - 36/340 a R2 Raw MS62 10% Red mostly on the reverse. 1863 Liberty and No Slavery. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 13 - 37/256 a R2 Raw VF Horrors of War Blessings Of Peace 1863 For Public Accommodation. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (25-50) 14 - 46/335 a R2 NGC MS66 BN Very nice Cartwheel luster. Liberty 1864 Our Army. (200-300) 15 - 48/299 a R1 Raw MS64 20% Red. United We Stand Divided We Fall 1863. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 16 - 51/333 a R6 NGC AU50 BN Indian Princess Our Army. Rare and underrated reverse die. A raw EF brought $213 in our August 2015 sale. (300-400) 17 - 54/296 a R5 Raw MS63 50% Red. Indian Princess Army & Navy. Rarely seen this nice. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 18 - 56/161 a R5 Raw VF+ 1864 Indian Princess Our Army with two scarce dies. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 19 - 58/439 a R3 Raw FINE+ Popular Odd Fellows reverse die. Another FINE+ brought $66 in our December 2008 auction. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 20 - 59/453 b R8 NGC AU55 Sharply struck. Crude Indian Head 1863 dated 10 Cent piece struck in Brass. Rare reverse die that is usually found in worn condition often with problems. An EF+ brought $386.10 in our July 2000 sale. From the Mark Glazer, Steve Tanenbaum and Paul Koppenhaver collections. (500-750) 21 - 68/355 a R4 NGC MS63 BN Or a bit better with 10% Red. 1863 Not One Cent. A raw AU+ realized $79.20 in our December 2008 sale. From the Steve Tanenbaum and Cindy Wibker collections. (150-200)

022 023 024 22 - 69/69 a R10 NGC MS62 BN With traces of mint red all on the normally struck side. Unique single die doubleheader of a 1863 Indian Head. Mark Glazer is fascinated by mint errors and built an impressive collection of overstrikes and other interesting pieces. Most have been sold over the years but as with his other Patriotics, he retained the Best of the Best. Single die doubleheaders are certainly the rarest errors in the entire Civil War token field with only a dozen or so known of all varieties. These tokens were struck using a single die one side at a time. This resulted in the side struck first being slightly wavy. This particular piece is prototypical, note the slightly sunk in area at the center of the initial strike. A NGC XF45 example of 87/87 a brought $1,485 in our July 2014 sale. From the Mark Glazer collection acquired from Steve Tanenbaum and earlier part of the "Found In Wall" contemporary hoard of Civil War tokens found hidden in the wall of a New York City building being renovated. This would seem to indicate it is a "real" error rather than a mint concoction or something made specially for collectors. (2000-3000) 23 - 71/148 a Unlisted NGC MS64 BN Attractively toned with nearly Proof Like reverse. 1863 Indian Head with a balding bearded man thought to be John Stanton on the reverse. Stanton manufactured the vast majority of Indian Head Civil War tokens. From an image supplied by the president of the firm's current incarnation, Long-Stanton Manufacturing, it seems clear this is Stanton. See the link http://www.longstanton.com/About.aspx. There is a more complete version on the company’s home page but you need to wait for it to cycle to the front. Very rare obverse die and unlisted variety, the die combination is currently listed only in Tin Plate which we have never seen offered publicly. An EF example of the much more available R7 84/148 a brought $1,105.50 in our June 2005 sale. From the Mark Glazer and Henry South collections. (4000-6000) 24 - 75/459 a R8 NGC MS65 RB 50% Red more so on the reverse. 1863 Indian Head with rare A Business Card reverse die. A raw MS64 in our December 2012 auction brought $1,415. From the Mark Glazer collection earlier from a Kreisberg sale. (1500-2000) 25 - 76/523 a R4 NGC AU55 BN 1864 Grindstone Flagging & Building Stones. Two very scarce dies. An EF brought $175 in our June 2013 auction. (200-300) 26 - 77/331 a R4 Raw AU 1863 Indian Chief Army & Navy. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Patriotic Tokens 27 - 85/431 a R8 Raw VF 1863 Indian Head with Value Me As You Pleas spelling error. A similar example sold for $577.50 in our March 2010 sale. (500-750) 28 - 87/356 a R1 Raw VF Struck 30% Off Center with a tiny rim clip. Indian Head 1863 Not One Cent. Double mint error with unusually large off center strike. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 29 - 93/93 a R9 Raw VF 1863 Indian Head with full brockage mint error reverse. These dramatic errors are created when a struck token sticks to the die and fails to eject. A subsequent token is then struck with one normal die and an incused image from the previous token acting as a die. If the first token stays stuck, each subsequent strike's incused side is less distinct. An exaggerated example of this is 107/107 which can come quite blurry. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection earlier from Jerry Schaeper June 1985. (750-1000) 30 - 93/362 a R2 NGC MS64 BN Attractively toned with very nice luster, normal weak date. 1863 Indian Head Not One Cent signed H on the obverse for die sinker Charles D. Horter and signed on the reverse JGW thought to be engraver James Wilson or Horter neighbor and book seller John G. Wells. It is fairly unusual to have the combination of two differently signed dies. (75-100)

031 032 037 31 - 96/129 a R9 NGC MS65 BN Nicely toned and nearly Proof Like. Popular Lincoln / Indian Head double header struck in Copper. Rare die combination that when found is frequently weakly struck. A weakly struck NGC MS64 of the more available Brass composition realized $1,127 in our March 2010 auction. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III and Ken Bauer collections. (1500-2000) 32 - 96A/131A a R8 NGC MS63 BN Obverse nearly Proof Like. Rare Lincoln / Indian doubleheader struck in Copper with very rare obverse die. A more red raw MS64 brought $1,760 in our September 2010 auction. From the Mark Glazer and Larkin Wilson collections. (1500-2000) 33 - 97/389 a R2 Raw AU+ Trace Red and well struck. Millions For Contractors Fort Lafayette Not One Cent For The Widows. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 34 - 99/292 a R3 NGC MS64 BN 10% Red a bit weakly struck as usual for this variety. Union And Liberty 1863 One Country. Very rarely seen in any degree of Uncirculated. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (200-300) 35 - 105/355 a R3 Raw AU George Washington in Star Not One Cent. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 36 - 110/442 a R1 NGC MS64 RB 40% Red. George Washington New York. From the Steve Tanenbaum and Cindy Wibker collections. (100-150) 37 - 113/294 a R9 NGC MS64 RB 50% Red and boldly struck. Exceedingly rare muling of George Washington Pater Patriae with Freedom reverse normally only seen on Lincoln tokens. The only example we have seen offered, a MS64 example of the more available 113/114A a brought $1,700 in our February 2014 auction. From the Mark Glazer and Andrew Zabriskie collections, earlier from Sotheby's June 1999 sale. (3000-4000) 38 - 115/115A d R9 NGC MS63 40% Bright. George and Martha Washington struck in Copper-Nickel with a Plain edge. Though not noted in Fuld, these come in both Plain and Reeded edge. From the Larry Dziubek collection. (500-750) 39 - 117/420 b R4 Raw MS63 30% Bright. 1863 George Washington Exchange struck in Brass. From an early die state without die crack or cud that is often seen on Copper examples. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 40 - 118/418 a R2 NGC MS63 RB 50% Red. 1863 George Washington Peace For Ever with hands labeled North and South shaking. (75-100) 41 - 123/0 f R5 Raw MS63 20% Bright. A restrike struck in Silver from an original die with blank reverse. George Washington in a large Capitol Plastic holder stating it was struck from the original die and 350 were struck. A MS63 brought $220 in our March 2010 sale. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (200-300) 42 - 125/294 a R7 NGC XF45 BN Abraham Lincoln President 1864 Freedom. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (150-200) 43 - 125/432 ao R8 Raw EF Details With some short old scratches on each side. Struck over another token likely 107/432. 1864 Lincoln No Compromise With Traitors. Very rare Patriotic struck over another Patriotic. This piece was mis-struck in some way resulting is six obverse stars where Lincoln would normally be spelled out. Opposite on the reverse is an arc shaped blank area though traces of a leaf and berry can be seen with effort. We suspect the under type is a 107/432 because of the oddly shaped crude stars that match those used on die 107 and little else; the planchet stock is the same as that used on 107/432 and of course the combinations share the reverse and were made at the same mint. This die combination is unlisted with any under types and all Patriotics over Patriotics are very rare. A normally struck VF brought $231 in our June 2011 sale. (500-750) 44 - 127/177 j R4 Raw MS62 10% Bright, a bit weakly struck as usually seen with nice luster for variety. 1864 Lincoln First In War, First In Peace 1863 struck in German Silver. Note the two different dates used. A VF sold for $165 in our July 2009 auction. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (300-400) 45 - 127/201 a R4 Raw EF Normal very weak strike at centers. Lincoln 1864 with Our Union shield. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 46 - 127/248 a R4 Raw EF 1864 Abraham Lincoln OK. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 47 - 127/248 b R3 Raw AU Details Trace Bright mostly on the reverse with a few light hairlines mostly on the obverse fields. 1864 Abraham Lincoln OK struck in Brass. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 48 - 127/248 j R7 NGC MS62 Or a bit better with 20% original bright mint luster. 1864 Lincoln OK struck in German Silver. Very rare variety and though called R7 this is one of just three examples we have seen offered. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III, Steve Tanenbaum, Dave Bowers and Sandy Feddema collections. (500-750) 49 - 128/289 b R3 Raw EF Lincoln and Union 1864. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 50 - 128/289 b R3 Raw MS63 30% Bright. Lincoln and Union 1864. Ex. Herman Aqua. (300-400) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Patriotic Tokens 51 - 128/290 b R4 Raw EF 10% Bright. Lincoln and Union 1864 struck in Brass. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 52 - 130/349 a R9 Raw VF With traces of Gilt plating primarily on the reverse, unlisted as such. Abraham Lincoln 1864 with canon, drums, rifles and flags on reverse. A bisecting obverse die crack accounts for its rarity in all combinations and compositions. One of the keys to a Lincoln die set. A MS60 with mottled obverse toning sold for $866.80 in our July 2009 sale. Dewitt AL 1864-78 From the Ed Rogalski collection. (300-400)

053 059 060 53 - 130/349 f R9 NGC MS63 10% Bright lightly toned and nearly Proof Like. Abraham Lincoln 1864 with canon, drums, rifles and flags on reverse struck in Silver. A bisecting obverse die crack accounts for its rarity in all combinations and compositions. One of the keys to a Lincoln die set and the only example we have seen offered in Silver. We sold a raw MS63 Gilt example of this die combination in July 2009 for $1,705. Dewitt AL 1864-78 From the Dave Bowers collection earlier from the Western Reserve. (2000-3000) 54 - 132/149 a R5 Raw EF+ For President Abraham Lincoln / For Vice President Andrew Johnson. Popular token signed RL under each bust. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (200-300) 55 - 133/458 b R5 Raw VF Details Holed as usual, dark and a bit porous. Lincoln and Liberty Good For Another Heat with ax in log. Dewitt AL 1864-43 From the Bob Miller collection. (75-100) 56 - 133/458 b R5 NGC MS61 Trace Bright, holed as usual and well struck from an early die state. Lincoln and Liberty Good For Another Heat with ax in log. Dewitt AL 1864-43 From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (200-300) 57 - 136/397 a R1 Raw AU Trace Red. Beware "Copper Head" 1863 with coiled snake. Always popular. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 58 - 141/307 a R1 Raw MS62 Trace Red mainly on the obverse. Crude General George B. McClellan Army & Navy. Very scarce in Uncirculated condition. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 59 - 146/283 e R9 Raw MS61 50% Bright with nice cartwheel luster and some minor tin pest on obverse. Rare and popular combination of Eagle and Anchor and General Burnsides dies in White Metal. This Eagle and Anchor die like its more famous Hunting Dogs cousin has horizontal lines that add to the luster and beauty of the design. We sold an example of the R8 German Silver variety in MS63 for $947.10 in our April 2000 auction. From the Dave Bowers collection. (1500-2000) 60 - 147/227 a fp R6 NGC AU58 Or a bit better, toned with 60% or more original Silvering. Popular Am I Ready 1861 pilgrim token. This plated version has been removed from the current book and replaced by a footnote. This is the normal composition for this die combination, over 60% by our count. It is very hard to find a Brass example that isn't very worn or still has traces of silvering. An NGC AU55 that was brighter with a bit more silvering brought $951 in our July 2012 sale. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (1000-1500) 61 - 155/400 a R4 Raw VF Tiny rim clip mint error. 1863 Union with crude eagle. Scarce Indiana Primitive die combination. (100-150) 62 - 155/431 a R4 NGC AU55 BN Very nice with some traces of red on the reverse. Indiana Primitive with Value Me As You Peas reverse. A raw AU+ with trace red realized $247.50 in our March 2010 auction. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (300-400) 63 - 160/417 a R4 Raw AU+ Liberty For All 1864 with eagle perched on cannon. Struck by Mossin and Marr of Milwaukee. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 64 - 164/312 a R1 NGC MS64 RB 50% Red. Union shield Army & Navy. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection earlier from J. J. Teaparty March 1973. (75-100) 65 - 165/400 a R5 Raw AU+ The Union Must and Shall be Preserved Jackson with shield reverse. The reverse is Higgin's Indiana Primitive version of Scovill's Union shield die 163. The present specimen is unusually well struck and reveals that Union is not spelled out with letters, but is only represented by a series of thick vertical lines. An EF brought $130 in our July 2009 sale. (200-300) 66 - 167/318 a R5 Raw VF+ Union 1863 Army & Navy. Two scarce dies. (75-100) 67 - 168/311 a R1 Raw EF Cannon and cannon balls 1863 Army & Navy. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 68 - 169/213 a R2 Raw EF+ Popular Peace Maker cannon 1863. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 69 - 172/429 a R5 Raw EF Military Necessity with crossed cannons. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 70 - 174/272 a R1 NGC MS64 RB 30% Red. First In War First In Peace 1863 with Washington on horseback. (100-150) 71 - 175/232 a R6 NGC MS64 BN Trace Red, well struck for variety with full but weak date. 1863 First In War First In Peace Our Country. Very scarce Indiana Primitive reverse die. A raw MS62 sold for $173 in our January 2015 sale. (400-500)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Patriotic Tokens

072 076 098 72 - 177/177 a R8 Raw MS63 Trace Red and nicely toned. First In Peace, First In War 1863 with George Washington on horseback with full mirror brockage mint error reverse. From the Dave Bowers collection. (1500-2000) 73 - 178/267 a R1 Raw MS64 60% Red. The Federal Union It Must And Shall Be Preserved 1863. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 74 - 180/343 a R4 Raw MS63 30% Red obverse motto missing as always. Union Forever 1864 with caped rider on horseback signed F. Sigel and Hero Of Pea Ridge motto missing as usual with this die combination. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 75 - 180/343 e R9 Raw MS63 Error 70% Bright struck on a large planchet. Union Forever 1864 with caped rider on horseback signed F. Sigel and Hero Of Pea Ridge motto missing as usual with this die combination. Struck in White Metal on a 23mm untrimmed planchet, a very impressive mint error. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III and Walter Ott collections, earlier from our August 1994 sale where it realized $121. (400-500) 76 - 184/427 a R9 NGC MS66 RD 80% Red. Hunting Dogs with Union 1863 reverse struck in Copper. The obverse is the famous Hunting Dogs die, though it might just as easily be known as Running Dogs or Pointing Dogs. Either way it is a fascinating die, so much so that the late Bret Palser made it literally his calling card. In 2004 he sold this very token for $20,000 with much fanfare and publicity in Coin World. More recently we sold a NGC MS66 BN paired with Burnside on our web site for $6,250 in April 2015. (8000-12000) 77 - 188/384 a R3 Raw AU+ Industry 1863 Beehive. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 78 - 189/399 a R1 Raw MS63 10% Red. Union 1863 with Jewish Star of David on reverse. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 79 - 191/443 a R1 NGC MS65 BN 10% Red with nice luster and toning. Pro Bono Publico 1863 New York. (100-150) 80 - 191/443 a R1 Raw MS63 Trace Red. Pro Bono Publico 1863 New York. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 81 - 197/380 a R2 NGC MS66 BN Trace Red with attractive toning. United States of America 1863 with eagle on shield. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (300-400) 82 - 209/414 a R2 Raw AU Popular Shoot Him on the Spoot error. Rarely seen this nice. From the Bob Miller collection. (50-75) 83 - 212/415 a R2 NGC MS63 RB 40% Red. The Flag Of Our Union Shoot Him On The Spot. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 84 - 214/416 a R1 Raw MS63 40% Red. The Flag Of Our Union Shoot Him On The Spot. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 85 - 225/327 a R1 Raw MS63 20% Red. The Federal Union It Must And Shall Be Preserved Army & Navy. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 86 - 233/312 a R1 Raw MS63 20% Red. Capitol Building Army & Navy. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 87 - 234/431 a R6 Raw MS63 Trace Red. United States Capital 1863 with Value Me As You Pleas spelling error. Indiana Primitive version of Scovill's 233 die to which Higgins added the word Capital, another spelling error making this a double error; a subject near and dear to our hearts. The only Patriotic use of this obverse die. A Trace Red EF+ sold for $410 in our August 2015 sale. Very rare in Uncirculated condition, particularly this well struck. (750-1000) 88 - 236/426 a R1 Raw AU+ Liberty 1863 Union. From the Bob Miller collection. (25-50) 89 - 237/423 a R1 Raw MS61 20% Red. Our Little Monitor 1863. From the Bob Miller collection. (150-200) 90 - 237/423 a R1 Raw MS63 30% Red. Our Little Monitor 1863. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (200-300) 91 - 238/405 a R3 Raw MS62 Scarce Indiana Primitive version of the Our Little Monitor obverse die. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection from M. Fiedler September 1975. (750-1000) 92 - 240/337 a R1 NGC MS64 BN 10% Red. 1863 Our Navy Monitor. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (150-200) 93 - 240/341 a R1 Raw MS62 Struck from worn die as usually seen. 1863 Monitor Union For Ever. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 94 - 243/247 a R3 Raw MS63 20% Red with two obverse rim cuds as often seen. Erinnerung an 1863 Constitution Forever. An unusual Civil War token with a legend in German. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 95 - 247/379 a R3 Raw MS63 10% Red. Constitution For Ever Not One Cent. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 96 - 250/437 a R5 Raw MS62 Trace Red. Popular North Star and Argyle Stocking token much nicer than normally seen. A MS62 10% Red example brought $436 in our December 2012 sale. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (400-500) 97 - 252/271 b R5 Raw AU With normal weakness and obverse cuds usually seen on this variety. Masonic Union For Ever struck in Brass. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 98 - 253/295 mp R9 NGC MS63 Trace Bright with nearly full Tin Plating. Exceedingly rare muling of 1864 Yngenio Ecuador with Freedom reverse die normally seen only with Lincoln obverses. The obverse was original used to make tokens here in the US for use in Cuba, but was muled during the war with six different Civil War token dies, each exceedingly rare. The only example of this die we have seen offered was a NGC MS63 BN 125/253 a in the John Ford collection that realized $3,818.75 in Stack's Bowers September 2013 sale...bought of course by Mark Glazer who thought he got a bargain. From the Mark Glazer and Larkin Wilson collections. (3000-4000) 99 - 257/311 a R3 Raw AU Marching soldier with sword and tiny Monitor in background. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 100 - 259/445 a R2 Raw MS62 30% Red. Coppers 20% Premium Trade And Commerce with sailing ship. From the Bob Miller collection. (100-150) 101 - 259/445 a R2 Raw AU+ Coppers 20% Premium Trade And Commerce with sailing ship. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Patriotic Tokens 102 - 260/447 a R7 NGC MS62 BN Constitution 1861 Concession Before Secession struck in Copper. A very popular token. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (500-750)

103 109 110 103 - 281/468 b R9 NGC MS62 20% Bright. Eagle with Good For 1 Loaf of Bread reverse struck in Brass. Two rare dies, though a bit overrated at R9, when encountered, it is usually VF at best more often than not with problems. The last problem free piece we sold at auction was a FINE+ that realized $505 way back in April 1996. From the Mark Glazer and Steve Tanenbaum collection. (1500-2000) 104 - 295/432 a R4 Raw EF Better than normal strike for this die combination. Freedom No Compromise With Traitors. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 105 - 332/336 a R4 NGC MS62 BN Our Army / Our Navy. Scarce die combination, particularly this nice. (100-150) 106 - 337/350 a R1 Raw EF Details With flattened rim, struck 10% off center. Our Navy with drum, flags and crossed cannons. Rare off center mint error, unusual for this particular mint. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (25-50) 107 - 427/480A b R9 Raw VF+ Union C 1863 with Eureka Good For 10. Two rare dies particularly the reverse. Very rarely seen above VF and most have some sort of problem, mainly stray counterstamps. We sold a similar piece in our August 2015 auction which realized $450. (500-750) 108 - 450/471 a R1 Raw MS63 10% Red. United We Stand Divided We Fall. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 109 - 451A/532 b R9 NGC XF45 Small beer mug with Good For 4 Cents reverse. Two very rare Patriotic dies. With the obverse and possibly the reverse being current Fuld plate tokens. From the Mark Glazer, Henry South and Spencer Randich collections, earlier from our October 1999 sale where it brought $1,650. (2000-3000) 110 - 498/499 Iron R8 Raw AU 10% Bright with nice luster. The First Ironclad 1862 Made From the Armor Plate Of The Merrimac. The Iron from the Merrimac was not recovered until well after the Civil War and consequently it has been delisted, however, it is still collected along with the series as an important war relic. A bit dark, slightly granular EF realized $1,550 in our August 2015 sale. This example, the finest we have seen offered, is from our July 2006 sale where it realized $3,550 in very spirited bidding (dueling phone bids long before we accepted internet bids). (4000-6000) 111 - 500/505A b Delisted Raw EF Decatur with eagle struck in Brass. Delisted as it is believed to predate the Civil War and was actually part of a series of Whist counters listing personages from the War of 1812 though Monroe is misspelled on one piece. An AU brought $150 in our December 2008 auction. From the Bob Miller collection. (100-150)

112 113 114 112 - 506/511 a R8 NGC MS64 RB 60% Red. For President Abraham Lincoln of Illinois muled with The Wealth of the South featuring rice, tobacco, sugar and cotton struck in Copper. One of the more absurd mulings made to sell to collectors during the Civil War, this one also quite rare (or tightly held) as it is one of just two we have seen offered. We sold a raw MS64 example with the more frequently seen Presidents House reverse for $1,559 in our December 2012 sale. (3000-4000) 113 - 508/510A a R8 NGC MS65 RB 80% Red. John Breckinridge / Presidents House struck in Copper. A NGC MS64 sold for $1,000 in our December 2012 sale. (1500-2000) 114 - 509A/510A b R9 NGC MS61 Trace Bright. John Bell of Tennessee / Presidents House struck in Brass. Very scarce obverse die, rare variety particularly this nice and without a hole as the Fuld plate specimen of both dies. (750-1000)

115 116 123 115 - 511/516 mp R5 NGC XF45 Trace Bright with 10% or more original Tin Plating. Wealth of the South / No Submission to the North. An EF holed example brought $300 in our December 2008 sale. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (750-1000) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Sutler Tokens 116 - DT-FL-50C R7 NGC MS62 BN S. E. Ward Sutler, Fort Laramie Dakota Territory Good For 50c In Sutlers Goods. A very nice example for a rare state often seen with planchet clips or stains. An AU Details with spots sold for $500 in our August 2015 auction. Formerly DT A-50C. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III and John Ford collections, earlier from Clay Feilden September 1963 and Stack's Bowers August 2013 where it realized $1,057.50. (1500-2000) 117 - IL-97-05B R6 NGC AU58 S. Whited & Co. Sutlers 97th Illinois Volunteers Good For 5 Cents In Goods. An EF sold for $400 in our August 2015 sale. Formerly IL P-5B. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (500-750) 118 - IL-MB-05B R7 NGC MS62 H. Rice Sutler M'Clernands Brigade Illinois Volunteers. Rare this nice, an AU brought $750 in our December 2006 auction. Formerly IL T-05B. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III and John Ford collections, earlier from H. J. Forman November 1961. (750-1000) 119 - IN-36-25Ba R8 PCGS MS62 20% Bright. G. Davidson 36th Indiana Volunteers. We sold a similar raw example in our February 2014 sale for $600. Formerly IN G-25B. (750-1000) 120 - IT-FS-05Bb R10 Raw VF Details With many old scratches. Sutler Check Redeemed by Rice & Byers 5 Cents Fort Still, Indian Territory. Unlisted variety in First Edition and though listed as Unique in the Second Edition this is the third example. An EF+ sold for $1,350 on our June 2015 fixed price list. (750-1000) 121 - IT-FS-10Bb R9 Raw VF With flatness opposite counterstamp. Sutler Check Rice & Byers Redeemed in Goods to Soldiers Only Fort Still, Indian Territory. The denomination on this piece was reduced by counterstamping a 0 over the 5 in the struck 15 Cents reverse. Formerly NL U-10Bb and at that time the now considered Unique 15 Cent variety was unknown. It is interesting to compare this and the following reduced denominations tokens with the Garman pieces to follow where the worry was denominations being increased. (750-1000) 122 - IT-FS-10Bc Unlisted Raw EF Details With some areas of roughness from burial and expected flatness opposite counterstamp. Sutler Check Rice & Byers Redeemed in Goods to Soldiers Only Fort Still, Indian Territory. The denomination on this piece was reduced by counterstamping a 1 over the 5 in the struck 50 Cents reverse. Unlisted in both editions of the Sutler book. Apparently the 10 Cent denomination proved more useful to the Sutler and at least some 15 and 50 pieces were devalued. It will be interesting to see if any adjusted 25 Cent or less likely One Dollar tokens from this Sutler are ever discovered. (750-1000) 123 - KY-01-10C R8 NGC MS63 BN 20% Red more so on the obverse. Simmonds Battery, J. M. Kerr Sutler 10 Cents. This Sutler is now attributed to the First Kentucky Independent Battery. Formerly NL M-10C. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (1000-1500) 124 - MA-23-10C R6 NGC AU53 BN Harvey Lewis Sutler 23rd Massachusetts Regiment. A VF brought $310 in our June 2013 auction. Formerly MA B-10C. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (400-500) 125 - MA-23-50C R6 Raw EF+ Harvey Lewis Sutler 23rd Massachusetts Regiment 50 Cents. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (400-500) 126 - NY-1-25C R6 NGC XF45 BN J. J. Benson Sutler 1st New York Mounted Rifles. A VF+ sold for $269 in our February 2014 auction. Formerly NY A-25C. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (300-400) 127 - NY-158-10B R8 NGC MS64 40% Bright. William Vanderbeek Sutlers Check 10 Cents struck in Brass. Research has shown that Vanderbeek was the Sutler for the 158th New York Volunteers. Formerly NL AD-10B. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (1000-1500) 128 - NY-158-50B R6 NGC AU53 Trace Bright. William Vanderbeek Sutlers Check 50 Cents struck in Brass. Research has shown that Vanderbeek was the Sutler for the 158th New York Volunteers. Formerly NL AD-50B. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (400-500) 129 - OH-34-5C R6 NGC XF45 BN Zouave 34th Regiment Ohio Volunteer Militia. Popular, Zouave style uniforms consisted of short jackets, baggy trousers and ornamental headgear. An AU brought $775 in our December 2012 auction. Formerly OH O-5C. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III and John Ford collections, earlier from the Capitol Coin Company January 1962. (500-750) 130 - OH-50-25B R9 NGC AU55 Trace Bright with some light spotting. M. H. Sullivan Sutler 50th Regiment Ohio Volunteers. Rare 25 Cent denomination, a NGC AU58 example of the much more available 5 Cent denomination brought $560 in our January 2015 sale. Formerly OH T-25B. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III and John Ford collections, earlier from Harmer Rooke's May 1970 sale. (750-1000) 131 - OH-55a-50C R8 NGC AU55 BN Or nearly so. J. B. Spitzer Sutler, 55th Ohio Volunteer Infantry 50 Cents with Mercury Head reverse die 1122 in the Store Car series. Formerly OH V-50C. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (500-750) 132 - OH-55b-50Bb R7 NGC XF45 M. Sullivan Sutler 55 Regiment Ohio Volunteer Militia 50 Cents. Formerly OH W-50Bb. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (400-500)

133 140 143 133 - OH-81a-05C R7 PCGS MS62 BN Trace Red all on the obverse. J. W. Cruikshank 81st Regiment Ohio Volunteer Infantry with Civil War token reverse die 1290 that features a sea monster of some type. We sold the first edition Schenkman plate, a raw 40% Red MS63, off our web site for $1,650 in August 2012. Formerly OH AG-5C. (1000-1500) 134 - PA-02-25C R6 NGC XF45 BN Wm. E. Wood Sutler 2nd Pennsylvania Artillery with crossed cannons. A raw EF+ sold for $425 in our July 2014 auction. Formerly PA B-25C. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (500-750) 135 - PA-54-003B R5 NGC MS63 20% Bright. J. A. Garman Sutler 54th Pennsylvania Volunteers 3 Cents. This is the smallest denomination for this prolific issuer. There is an example known with just a 2 stamped which is presumed to have been intended as 25. A raw MS62 brought $395 in our October 2011 auction. Formerly PA I-003B. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (500-750) 136 - PA-54-010Ba R6 NGC MS61 10% Bright. J. A. Garman Sutler 54th Pennsylvania Volunteers 10 Cents. Formerly PA I-010Ba. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (400-500) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Sutler Tokens 137 - PA-54-025B R5 NGC AU58 J. A. Garman Sutler 54th Pennsylvania Volunteers 25 Cents. Formerly PA I-025B. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (300-400) 138 - PA-54-050B R7 NGC AU58 10% Bright. J. A. Garman Sutler 54th Pennsylvania Volunteers 50 Cents. Called PA I-5Bb on holder in error. Formerly PA I-050B. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (400-500) 139 - PA-54-100Bb R8 NGC MS63 30% Bright. J. A. Garman Sutler 54th Pennsylvania Volunteers 100 Cents. This is the largest denomination for this prolific issuer, though there is a "Blank Check" example with no stamp. On this variety the last zero is presumed to have been added for nefarious reasons resulting in the need for this Sutler to add Xs to 5 and 10 Cent varieties to prevent alteration. On this variety the first two digits are usually too far to the right to easily accommodate the final number. More definitively the Zeros are from different punches, the first having an oval interior while the second is more squarish. A fascinating piece with a great story. A raw MS62 brought $395 in our October 2011 auction. Formerly PA I-100B. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (750-1000) 140 - PA-72-05B R8 PCGS AU58 A. W. H. Baxter's Fire Zouaves Sutler's Ticket. The Pennsylvania 72nd Volunteers were popularly known as Baxter's Fire Zouaves because its soldiers were drawn from Philadelphia Fire Companies. They were organized and led by DeWitt Clinton Baxter and wore the unusual Zouave style uniforms with short jackets, baggy trousers and ornamental headgear. A raw AU example realized $1,050 in our December 2005 sale. Formerly NL H-5B. (1000-1500) 141 - UI-A-25B R8 NGC AU53 Good For 25 Sutlers Goods At Frank's. This Sutler has yet to be firmly identified though Julius Frank, the Sutler for the 20th Connecticut Volunteers, has been suggested. Formerly NL F-25B. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III, Steve Tanenbaum and Richard Ulbrich collections. This is the current Sutler book Plate Specimen. (750-1000) 142 - UI-J-50B R7 NGC MS62 20% Bright. H. V. Keep Good For 50 Cents Cash Check Redeemable In US Currency. Long considered a Sutler token it was likely issued by Henry Keep (1818-1869) from Watertown New York, a banker who specialized in currency exchange between the US and Canada. Formerly NL L-50B. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (500-750) Civil War Soldiers ID Tags 143 - Civil War Soldiers ID Tag Raw EF Holed for suspension with 10% original gilt remaining mostly on the struck side. War of 1861 United States with M. F. Moore Co. K. 13th Reg. N.H. V. Portsmouth punched into the blank reverse. Listed as stock tag Eagle 5A in Maier and Stahl's book on Identification Discs of Union Soldiers in the Civil War. Brass 28mm. Martin F. Moore enlisted August 21st 1862 at the age of 18 and was the regimental musician for Company B of the 13th NH Volunteer Infantry and later for Company K beginning on June 20th 1864. He mustered out June 21st, 1865. It is interesting to note that the K in Co. K on this tag is struck over a B indicating this diligent soldier kept his information up to date. An internet search also turned up sales records for his personal diaries for 1864 and 1865. A fascinating piece of history. (1000-1500) 144 - Civil War Soldiers ID Tag Raw AU+ Details With a few light marks. Maj. General McClellan // The War Of 1861 '62 & '63 with area for entering soldiers vital statistics. Listed as stock tag McClellan 1J in Maier and Stahl's book on Identification Discs of Union Soldiers in the Civil War and called Extremely Rare. White Metal 34mm. DeWitt/Sullivan GMcC 1864-8B. From the Bob Miller collection. (150-200) 145 - Civil War Soldiers ID Tag Raw VF Details Holed and corroded from burial. C. CATE / A12NH / ALTON counterstamped on the planed down reverse of an 1863 McClellan Patriotic Civil War token. The first line is double and triple struck and the second line is weak making precise reading difficult, there could be more to the left on the second line. An interesting piece worthy of additional investigation. From the Bob Miller collection. (75-100) Civil War Encased Postage Stamps 146 - Ayers 3c Raw VF Mica is sound with a number of small dents and stamp a bit faded as usual. Ayer's Sarsaparilla To Purify The Blood. From the Bob Miller collection. (200-300) 147 - Ayers 3c Raw EF With traces of original Silvering. Mica is nice and stamp, while a bit faded, is better than average. Ayer's Sarsaparilla To Purify The Blood. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (300-400) 148 - Gault 5c Raw VF+ With nice mica and stamp. J. Gault, Pat. Aug. 12 1862. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (300-400) Civil War Store Cards

149 163 164 149 - CT250A-1b(fp) R8 NGC MS62 Trace Bright with full Silvering. Arch Saloon No. 10 O. Rudd Montville Connecticut with Lincoln Redeemed reverse die struck in Silvered brass and has the odd cross hatching on the edge as noted in new Store Card book. Formerly attributed to Willimantic and has been moved in the new Store Card book to Montville where Orrind Rudd was a saloon keeper based on more current research. A very rare town and very likely the finest known. An NGC AU50 sold for $1,800 in our January 2015 sale. (3000-4000) 150 - IL150 J-18a R5 Raw VF+ Childs' Manufacturer of Advertising Coin, Chicago. Formerly IL150K-4a. From the Fred Ball collection. (50-75) 151 - IL150 Z-1a R4 Raw MS64 30% Red most on the obverse. G. E. Gerts & Co. Brush Factory, Chicago Illinois. From the Fred Ball collection. (150-200) 152 - IL150AH-1a R6 Raw MS63 20% Red and nicely toned. Judd & Corthell Boots & Shoes, Chicago Illinois. Very scarce merchant, a similar example brought $241 in our August 2015 auction. From the Dave Bowers and George Fuld collections. (300-400)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 153 - IL150AI-1b R8 Raw EF O. Kendall's Sons & Co. Bread Good For One Loaf 1863 Chicago Illinois. A FINE+ from our December 2006 auction sold for $137.50 (200-300) 154 - IL150BG-1a R4 NGC MS62 BN Or a bit better, 20% Red. Struck with usual roughness of rim, possibly accounting for the grade assigned. C. Winsauer Gunsmith, Chicago with very scare reverse die 1345 featuring rifles, pistols and accessories. Popular token, an EF+ brought $192.50 in our March 2008 auction. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (400-500) 155 - IL215A-2a R8 Raw VF+ J. Hayes & Bro. 1 Drink 1863 with Flying Eagle. Rare town formerly listed as OH165BP-2a, based on current research it has been moved to Du Quoin Illinois in the new Store Card book. From the John Ostendorf collection earlier from our September 2010 sale where it brought $440 while still considered a rare Cincinnati merchant. (750-1000) 156 - IL225A-1a R3 NGC MS63 BN 30% Red. H. L. Mosely, Durand Illinois. Scarce town, we sold an AU for $70.40 in our March 2010 sale. (150-200) 157 - IL690D-2a R8 Raw EF Penoyer & Larkin Provision Dealers, Paris Illinois 1863. Rare variety from very scarce merchant and scarce town. From the Dave Bowers collection. (200-300) 158 - IL692A- 3a R4 Raw EF Yankee Robinson The Great Comedian with pictorial of Robinson in top hat with rifle. Robinson operated a traveling Circus and traditionally was listed under Cincinnati Ohio. In the third edition of the Store Card book he has been relocated to Peoria Illinois where his base of operations was located at the time these Civil War tokens were issued. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 159 - IL692A-14a R4 Raw EF+ Big Show 1869 dated with Yankee Robinson portrait. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (25-50) 160 - IL700A-1a R5 Raw FINE+ Dehner & Maples Crockery, Pontiac Illinois. (100-150) 161 - IL890B-2a R5 Raw EF J. L. Loveday & Co., Waukegan Illinois with George Washington reverse. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 162 - IN230B-1a R5 Raw VF Details With short reverse scratches. Craddick & Homan Dealers In Books, Danville Indiana. (50-75) 163 - IN230C-2a R9 NGC MS65 RD 80% Red. S. A. Russell Merchant, Danville Indiana 1864. Rare merchant particularly this nice, also very rare variety. A NGC MS63 RB sold for $750 in our December 2008 auction. From the Steve Tanenbaum, Ed Rosen and George Fuld collection. (1500-2000) 164 - IN260B-2a R9 Raw AU+ Very well struck for merchant. J. Davenport & Son, Elkhart Indiana. Very rare Indiana Primitive merchant and variety. An EF with tiny clip realized $750 in our February 2014 sale. (1500-2000)

165 166 182 165 - IN260D-1a R5 NGC MS65 BN 30% Red mostly on the obverse. John Guipe (shoe & boot) Dealer, Elkhart Indiana Union 1863. An obtainable variety in circulated condition, but this is the only Uncirculated example we have seen offered. An EF+ realized $122.10 in our July 2009 sale. From the Steve Tanenbaum, Don Schramm and Ray Haggenjos collections. (750-1000) 166 - IN305A-2a R8 NGC MS66 RB 70% Red. G. W. Follett Boots & Shoes, Fremont Indiana 1864. Very scarce single merchant town, particularly this nice. A raw example of the R8 Brass variety of this die combination realized $825 in our March 2008 sale. From the Steve Tanenbaum, Ed Rosen and George Fuld collection. (1000-1500) 167 - IN350B-1a R6 NGC MS62 RB Or a bit better with 30% Red luster. Hascall, Alderman & Brown Dry Goods, Goshen Indiana 1861. Very rare variety and merchant in Uncirculated condition, the first we have seen offered of either variety. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection. (300-400) 168 - IN460Ba-3a R5 NGC AU55 BN Or nearly so. Frost's Medicine Sold By Druggists, Indianapolis. Formerly attributed to Cincinnati as OH165AZ-3a, current research shows that J. W. Frost managed a sales force marketing patent medicines from Indianapolis. An EF brought $60.50 in our July 2006 sale when it was still believed to be from Cincinnati. (100-150) 169 - IN460M-3a R8 Raw MS64 60% Red. Moritz, Bro. & Co., Indianapolis Indiana 1864. Very scarce merchant, very rare variety. From the Steve Tanenbaum, Ed. Rosen and George Fuld collections. (500-750) 170 - IN460N-1a R5 Raw EF R.R. Parker, Indianapolis Indiana. Nice pictorial of man modeling one of Parkers shirts. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 171 - IN500H-1a R8 Raw MS64 40% Red. J. H. Gotsch Dealer in Clocks, Watches & Jewelry, Kendallville Indiana. A very rare merchant only the tenth example of any of its varieties we have recorded and much nicer than the current plate token. We sold a somewhat porous EF in our July 2000 sale for $248.50. From the Steve Tanenbaum and Richard Coslet collections. (750-1000) 172 - IN500O-1a R6 NGC MS63 RB 10% Red. F. W. Mesing, Kendallville with rare reverse die 1335 featuring Wine Barrel. Very scarce and popular merchant. A more red but raw MS63 sold for $550 in our December 2008 sale. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (500-750) 173 - IN510B-1a R6 NGC AU53 BN Haskett & Co., Kokomo Indiana. Rare town and merchant, we sold a VF with residue traces in our July 2006 auction for $160. (200-300) 174 - IN550F-1a R8 Raw MS64 70% Red. Geo. C. Nill Drug and Medicines, Ligonier Indiana 1863. Just the second Uncirculated example we have seen offered. A similar grade example of the more available -2a variety brought $450 in our January 2015 sale. From the Steve Tanenbaum, Don Schramm and Ray Haggenjos collections. (750-1000) 175 - IN550H-1a R6 Raw EF+ E. Reeve Crockery and Glassware, Ligonier Indiana. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 176 - IN550K-2a R5 NGC MS63 BN 10% Red. J. C. Zimmerman Dry Goods, Ligonier Indiana 1863. We sold a similar raw example for $176.77 in our June 2013 auction. From the Henry South collection. (200-300)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 177 - IN600A-1a R7 NGC XF45 BN Elliott & Swain, Mechanicsburg Indiana. Rare merchant, exceedingly rare in AU or Uncirculated. A FINE+ brought $255 in our July 2007 auction. (300-400) 178 - IN630A- 5a R3 Raw VF+ With tiny rim clip mint error. H. D. Higgins Optician, Mishawaka. Popular token with reverse die 1328 with Periscopic Spectacles. (100-150) 179 - IN630A- 6a R3 Raw VF+ H. D. Higgins Jeweler & Optician, Mishawaka Indiana. (50-75) 180 - IN630A-13a R5 Raw EF H. D. Higgins Jeweler & Optician, Mishawaka Indiana. Popular token with scarce reverse die 1329 featuring a pair of Periscopic Spectacles. (200-300) 181 - IN630A-13a R5 Raw AU H. D. Higgins Jeweler & Optician, Mishawaka Indiana. Popular token with scarce reverse die 1329 featuring a pair of Periscopic Spectacles. An AU+ realized $310 in our June 2013 auction. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (300-400) 182 - IN715A-1a R7 Raw MS64 40% Red. John Wenzel Stoves, North Vernon Indiana. Very scarce town particularly this nice. A MS63 brought $559 in our December 2008 auction. From the Steve Tanenbaum, Don Schramm and Ray Haggenjos collections. (750-1000) 183 - IN800C-1a R6 Raw EF Details Obverse retoned from cleaning. E. F. Hirst Watch Maker & Jeweler, Richmond Indiana. A VF sold for $100 in our June 2013 auction. (100-150) 184 - IN880A-1a R6 Raw MS63 30% Red. D. H. Haines & Bro., Swan Indiana. Very scarce town, a NGC MS64 RB realized $800 in our December 2008 sale. From the Steve Tanenbaum, Don Schramm and Ray Haggenjos collections. (750-1000)

185 192 200 185 - IA560A-3a R7 NGC AU55 BN Wm. Flemming & Bro. Lumber Lath & Shingles, Lansing Iowa. An EF+ example sold for $850 in our March 2010 auction. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (750-1000) 186 - IA930A-1a R7 NGC XF Details Improperly Cleaned. Quite nice without noticeable hairlines and nearly completely retoned. H. & G. Goodhue Lumber, Waterloo Iowa. Scarce town and state, a VF with residues sold for $750 in our July 2012 sale. (750-1000) 187 - KY150D-2a R5 Raw AU V. C. Engert Germania Saloon, Covington Kentucky 1863. An AU+ brought $68.50 in our November 2004 auction. (400-500) 188 - KY480B-4a R8 NGC AU55 BN John W. Lee Confectioner, Lexington Kentucky One Pint of Milk. Called a KY480B-6a on holder. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (400-500) 189 - KY510D-1b R7 Raw EF George Brucklacher with H. Miller & Co., Louisville Kentucky. The reverse features a pictorial of a hand holding a beer mug. Miller was the die sinker for this token which had been listed under him and designated KY510A-2b. (750-1000) 190 - KY640C-3a R3 Raw VF+ H. B. Xelar Wine & Beer Saloon. Formerly listed under Cincinnati Ohio, current research places the Saloon in Newport Kentucky. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 191 - ME100A-2a R3 NGC MS63 BN R. S. Torrey Bee Hive, Bangor Maine. An AU+ brought $276 in our August 2015 sale. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (400-500) 192 - MA115E-1a R4 NGC MS66 RB 40% Red more so on the Dog side with very nice cartwheel luster. Jos. H. Merriam Die Sinker, Boston Massachusetts with very popular Good For A Scent reverse die featuring a dogs head. The NGC MS62 in our January 2015 sale realized $1,815. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (4000-6000) 193 - MA115Fb-1h bla R6 Raw AU Stimson, Valentine & Co. 36 India Street Boston Manufacturers Of Varnishes And Japans struck in Black Hard Rubber. This along with a number of other hard rubber tokens have been added to the third edition of the Store Card book. Earlier from PCAC's May 1997 auction. (300-400) 194 - MA115G-3a R6 Raw VF Tuttle's Restaurant, Boston Good For 25 Cents In Refreshments. Popular token with obverse Steer's head pictorial. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (150-200) 195 - MA200A-2a R4 Raw AU Dunn & Co. Oyster House, Charlestown Massachusetts. Current research indicates that Dunn was actually from Charlestown rather than Boston as previously thought. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 196 - MA260A-2e R9 Raw MS62 60% Bright with small planchet clip. E. P. Francis City Hotel Billiard Room, Fall River Massachusetts struck in White Metal. This very rare variety is the first we have seen offered. Formerly listed as a separate merchant as RI700B-1e, this is its current designation in the new Civil War Store Card book because it combines the reverse of the E. P. Francis -1a with a reverse die 1374 formally thought of as an exclusively Rhode Island die. A MS64 example of the equally rare -2d brought $804 in our December 2012 auction. From the Ed Rosen and George Fuld collections. (500-750) 197 - MA760A- 1b R7 NGC MS61 Or a bit better with 30% Bright luster. J. A. Bolen Die Sinker, Springfield Massachusetts struck in Brass with the 1862 dated Young America reverse. (500-750) 198 - MA970A-1a R4 NGC MS63 BN Trace Red with nice luster. Charles Lang Die Sinker and Engraver, Worcester Massachusetts. A MS62 brought $350 in our July 2014 auction. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (400-500) 199 - MA970B-1h bro R8 Raw AU A. P. Ware & Co. Clothing, Worcester Massachusetts struck in Brown Hard Rubber. From the Steve Tanenbaum and George Fuld collections. (300-400) 200 - MI 40A-2do R8 Raw MS63 30% Bright struck over an 1862 Copper Nickel Indian Head Cent with under type details including strong date and Indian. Philip Bach Dry Goods, Ann Arbor Michigan 1863. (1500-2000)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 201 - MI 40D-3a R2 Raw AU Stebbins & Wilson Druggists, Ann Arbor Michigan. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75)

202 206 213 202 - MI 60B-1a R8 Raw AU+ J. B. Leonard Boot & Shoe Maker, Battle Creek Michigan. Rare merchant and one of the key merchants in a set of the products of Hillsdale diesinker Alexander Gleason. A NGC MS61 BN sold for $1,187.77 in our December 2008 sale. From the Wayne Stafford and Don Thoms collections. (1000-1500) 203 - MI160A-1b R7 Raw AU C. Cummings Groceries, Charlotte Michigan struck in Brass. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III and Alan Bleviss collections. (150-200) 204 - MI225 H-1a R5 NGC MS64 BN Trace Red H. W. Beeson Ship Stores, Detroit Michigan. Rare variety in Uncirculated condition. From the Cliff Temple collection. (150-200) 205 - MI225 Q-1a R5 NGC MS65 BN Very attractively toned. S. Cohen Clothing, Detroit. Only the third Uncirculated example we have seen offered, a raw MS62 brought $151.80 in our November 2004 auction. From the Cliff Temple collection. (300-400) 206 - MI225 V-6d R10 NGC MS65 60% Bright. Detroit City Flour Mills, Detroit Michigan 1864 struck in Copper Nickel and thought to be Unique. From the Cliff Temple collection earlier from C. Verhoeven in March 1946. Per Cliff's own notes on his collection: "C. Verhoeven was a collector in Monroe, Michigan. He sent me a group of Copper Nickel cards (un-asked and without notice) offering them at $2.50 each. I bought them, of course." (1000-1500) 207 - MI225AS-2b R8 NGC MS64 40% Bright. Lapham & Thayer New & Second Hand Furniture, Detroit Michigan 1861 struck in Brass. Very scarce merchant and rare variety. A raw MS64 example of the R7 Copper variety realized $397.10 in our July 2007 auction. From the Cliff Temple collection purchased from James Kelly for $0.35 in May 1943. (400-500) 208 - MI225BM-3b R8 NGC MS63 30% Red. M. Rosenberger, Detroit Michigan 1863 struck in Brass. A raw MS62 of the R7 Copper variety sold for $378.40 in our July 2007 auction. From the Cliff Temple collection. (400-500) 209 - MI225CH-1b R8 NGC MS63 20% Bright. C. C. Tyler & Co. Will Pay One Cent In Goods, Detroit Michigan struck in Brass. Rare large size Detroit token. One of just three we have seen offered. An AU+ brought $222.52 in our May 2004 sale. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III and Cliff Temple collections earlier from our July 2014 sale. (400-500) 210 - MI225CJa-1a R6 Raw AU Wards Lake Superior Line Steamer Planet, Cleveland, Detroit and Lake Superior. Very scarce and popular token. An EF realized $330 in our January 2015 sale. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (400-500) 211 - MI225CS-1a R3 NGC MS63 BN Henry Wolff Trunk Manufactory, Detroit. From the Cliff Temple collection. (100-150) 212 - MI280A-2a R5 NGC XF45 BN Charles W. Bernacki Druggist, East Saginaw Michigan with Mortar and Pestle. A similar example in our August 2015 sale sold for $120. (100-150) 213 - MI300E-1a R5 NGC MS63 RB Or a bit better with 60% original Red luster. A. Mester & Co. Marble Works, Eaton Rapids Michigan. A very scarce and popular token featuring Tombstone reverse die 1340. A similar example sold for $1,600 in our December 2012 sale. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (2000-3000) 214 - MI370C-2e R8 NGC MS61 30% Bright or a bit better. Foster & Metcalf, Grand Rapids Michigan 1861 struck in White Metal. A very unusual White Metal Michigan token and just the third we have seen offered. From the Dave Bowers and Robert Williams collections. (500-750) 215 - MI370D-2b R4 Raw AU Goodrich & Gay 1862, Grand Rapids Michigan struck in Brass with Good Samaritan Stove Pictured. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 216 - MI370H-2b R2 NGC MS65 40% Bright and nearly Proof Like. J. W. Peirce, Grand Rapids Michigan struck in Brass. While it is fairly common in worn condition it is quite rare Uncirculated. Certainly one of the finest known. From the Cliff Temple collection. (150-200) 217 - MI440A-1a R7 NGC MS63 BN Nicely toned. D. C. Hawley, Hastings Michigan. The scarcest of the four collectable Hastings varieties the -5a being exceedingly rare. Rare city in Uncirculated condition. From the Cliff Temple collection. (300-400) 218 - MI450C-2a R6 Raw EF+ Card, Pearce & Co. Agricultural Instruments, Hillsdale Michigan. Rare above VF. From the Wayne Stafford collection earlier from our May 2004 auction where it realized $418. (400-500) 219 - MI450G-7a R2 NGC MS66 BN Attractively toned. A. Gleason Die Sinker, Hillsdale. Very scarce this nice, a NGC MS63 BN brought $132 in our January 2015 sale. From the Wayne Stafford collection. (200-300) 220 - MI450H-3a R7 Raw EF E. C. Keating, Hillsdale Michigan. Scarce merchant rarely seen above EF. From the Wayne Stafford collection. (150-200) 221 - MI450O-2a R4 Raw VF Geo. W. Underwood Druggist, Hillsdale Michigan 1861. (50-75) 222 - MI480B-1a R6 Raw EF Usual weakness at centers. A. H. Bowen Baker, Hudson Michigan. Very scarce merchant rarely seen this nice. We sold a EF+ for $304.70 in our May 2001 sale. From the Wayne Stafford collection. (300-400) 223 - MI495A-1a R2 NGC MS65 BN Trace Red and very nicely toned. James Kennedy Exchange Insurance War Claim Office, Ionia Michigan. A raw MS63 realized $210 in our August 2015 sale. (300-400) 224 - MI525C- 6a R2 NGC MS65 BN Trace Red with very nice toning. Wm. Jackson Groceries, Jackson Michigan. From the Cliff Temple collection. (100-150) 225 - MI527D-1a R7 Raw AU J. S. Lewis Hardware, Jonesville Michigan 1863. Very scarce merchant. A VF+ brought $194.19 in our March 2010 auction. From the Wayne Stafford collection. (400-500) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 226 - MI530E-3a R5 NGC MS63 BN Nicely toned. Kellogg & Co. Lumber, Kalamazoo Michigan. Rare above EF, the Tanenbaum example was a VF. From the Cliff Temple collection. (300-400) 227 - MI530G-1a R4 Raw EF+ L. W. Perrin Dry Goods Groceries, Kalamazoo. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 228 - MI610B-3a R5 NGC MS64 BN C. M. Brewer, Marshall Michigan. A NGC MS62 sold for $110 in our June 2011 auction. From the Cliff Temple collection. (200-300) 229 - MI660A-1a R5 NGC MS64 BN J. M. Page & Co. Hardware, Morenci Michigan. Scarce merchant struck by Gleason of Hillsdale, rare in Uncirculated condition. From the Wayne Stafford, Steve Tanenbaum and Robert Williams collections. (400-500) 230 - MI700C-2a R5 Raw MS64 Trace Red attractively toned with great cartwheel luster. E. S. Parker Hats, Caps and Furs, Niles Michigan. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (200-300) 231 - MI960B-3a R7 Raw EF+ Showerman & Bro. Hats & Caps, Ypsilanti Michigan. Very scarce variety and likely one of the finest known. From the Cliff Temple collection. (75-100) 232 - MN760A-1a R5 NGC MS62 RB D. C. Greenleaf Watch Maker, St. Paul Minnesota counterstamped 52 for use as a Watch Check. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (500-750) 233 - NH120A-1a R4 NGC MS63 BN A. W. Gale Restorator At Depot, Concord New Hampshire. Scarce state, this is its only Civil War token variety. Most higher grade examples came from a hoard that was dispersed in the 1960s through the 1970s. Unfortunately most had minor to more severe spotting; this being a happy exception. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (300-400) 234 - NJ 20A-1a R3 NGC MS64 BN Nice cartwheel luster and attractive toning. Extensive obverse die cracks as often seen. Smick's Neptune House, Atlantic City New Jersey. (150-200) 235 - NJ555C- 2a R3 Raw MS64 10% Red. J. Wightman, Newark New Jersey 1863. A 70% Red MS64 sold for $165 in our December 2012 auction. (100-150) 236 - NY105R-1a R5 Raw FINE+ C. R. Walker Watsons Neuralgia King, Buffalo New York. Popular token, an EF+ sold for $196.42 in our June 2011 auction. (50-75) 237 - NY270A-1a R2 NGC MS64 RB 40% Red more so on the reverse. Harvey & Co. General Store, Fort Edward New York. (100-150) 238 - NY630 D-1a R1 Raw MS63 10% Red. H. J. Bang Restaurant, New York with grapes and grape vine. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 239 - NY630 F-2a R3 Raw MS63 Or a bit better with attractive toning and nice cartwheel luster. V. Benner & Ch. Bendinger Wine & Liquors, New York with a bottle of wine pictured. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 240 - NY630 H-1a R2 Raw AU+ Trace Red. J. L. Bode Birdstuffer, New York with a deer head and antlers. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 241 - NY630 I-1b R5 ICG MS62 20% Bright. Jas. Brennan Postage Stamps, New York struck in Brass with McClellan reverse. Scarce merchant and variety, an AU+ brought $116.60 in our July 2007 sale. (150-200) 242 - NY630 K-2a R4 Raw MS62 Trace Red T. Brimelow Druggist, New York with George Washington pictured on the reverse. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 243 - NY630 K-6a R8 NGC MS64 RB 40% Red weakly struck at centers as usual. T. Brimelow Druggist, New York with Franklin and mortar and pestle pictured. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection earlier from our July 2012 sale. (300-400) 244 - NY630 Ka-2h mar R8 Raw AU+ Details But holed for suspension. Broadway Rubber Emporium 603 Broadway, New York struck in Maroon hard rubber. Apparently the rarer of the two die varieties from this merchant and not illustrated in the new Store Card book. Another holed AU+ brought $111.10 in our October 2003 sale. From the Bob Miller collection. (150-200) 245 - NY630 L- 4e R5 NGC MS63 60% Bright more so on the obverse. Broas Brothers with popular Ben Franklin reverse die 1149 struck in White Metal. Rarity for this variety was changed in error in the Third Edition Store Card book, the original R7 is more correct. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (200-300) 246 - NY630 L- 7a R2 Raw MS62 Struck from clashed and shattered dies. Broas Pie Baker, New York. A very dramatic and popular mint error. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 247 - NY630 L-18a R1 NGC MS66 BN 10% Red. Broas Brothers Pie Bakers, New York with 1863 United We Stand George Washington reverse. (150-200)

248 249 250 248 - NY630 Sa-1a R8 Raw MS65 70% Red. John K. Curtis Watch-Maker and Manufacturing Jeweler 83 Bleecker St and 882 Broadway New York 1861 with George Washington The Cincinnatus of America reverse die. A MS64 in our July 2014 sale realized $825. From the Jon Harris collection from Max Schwartz January 1976. (1000-1500) 249 - NY630 W-1a R4 NGC MS65 RB 30% Red with attractive toning. Felix Kosher Dining Saloon, New York. Very popular and underrated token with Kosher spelled out in Hebrew. A MS63 brought $325 in our March 2010 sale. (750-1000) 250 - NY630 W-1do R8 NGC MS63 Or a bit better with 20% original bright mint luster. Felix Kosher Dining Saloon, New York struck over an 1859 Copper Nickel Indian Cent with so much of the under type visible at times it is difficult to see the token design. Very popular and underrated token with Kosher spelled out in Hebrew. (1500-2000) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 251 - NY630 Z-1a R2 Raw AU+ Fr. Freise Undertaker, New York with coffin pictured, a somewhat morbid advertising message to send during a war. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 252 - NY630AC-1a R2 NGC MS64 RB 40% Red with attractive toning. Charles Gentsch Cafe, New York. (100-150) 253 - NY630AG-6b R7 Raw MS63 20% Bright and nicely toned. John P. Gruber Gold Weight Troy 2 Pennyweight, New York struck in Brass. A similarly graded example of the R8 -6j variety realized $246.09 in our December 2012 auction. (300-400) 254 - NY630AK-1a R1 Raw MS65 50% Red with very nice cartwheel luster. Hussey's Special Message Post Time is Money 1863 Exigency with rider on horse. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150)

255 261 287 255 - NY630AK-2a R3 NGC MS64 BN 40% Red more so on the obverse. Hussey's Special Message Post Time is Money 1863 Expediency with Steam Locomotive pictured. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (400-500) 256 - NY630AP- 2a R6 NGC MS64 BN With nice luster and toning. H. M. Lane Kerosene Oil Lamps 1863. Rarely seen this nice. (75-100) 257 - NY630AP-10a R4 Raw AU+ 20% Red. H. M. Lane Lamps Kerosene Oil, New York Erinnerung an 1863. Interesting token with reverse legend in German for Remembrance of 1863. (50-75) 258 - NY630AQ-3a R3 NGC MS64 BN Trace Red. Gustavus Lindenmueller, New York with beer mug pictured along with the proprietors portrait. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 259 - NY630AQ-3e R8 NGC MS62 50% Bright. Gustavus Lindenmueller, New York struck in White Metal. Beer mug pictured along with the proprietors portrait. A NGC MS63 sold for $374 in our June 2011 sale. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (300-400) 260 - NY630AQ-4j R8 NGC MS62 20% Bright. Gustavus Lindenmueller, New York struck in German Silver. Beer mug pictured along with the proprietors portrait. Very rare variety, the first we have seen offered. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (300-400) 261 - NY630AR-1do R7 NGC MS64 30% Bright with considerable under type visible including full eagle and date. Charles A. Luhrs Pike Slip Shades, New York struck in Copper Nickel over an 1858 Flying Eagle Cent. An impressive token. (3000-4000) 262 - NY630AV-1a R4 NGC MS65 BN Trace Red. John Matthews Soda Water Apparatus, New York. Popular large size pictorial token featuring a swimming fish. A raw but more red MS63 sold for $325 in our July 2014 auction. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (400-500) 263 - NY630AY-3a R6 NGC AU55 BN A bit unevenly struck as usual. Use L. Miller's Hair Invigorator, New York. Very scarce variety and formerly one of the keys to a New York merchant set. It has been combined with the struck varieties under the AY merchant in the new Store Card book. Called NY630AZ-1a on the holder, a prior designation. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (200-300) 264 - NY630BB-13e R9 NGC MS64 70% Bright. Monk's Metal Signs, New York struck in White Metal with George Washington reverse. A raw MS63 sold for $215 in our July 2007 auction. Baker 470 From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (300-400) 265 - NY630BB-14a R6 NGC MS65 BN Trace Red with nice luster. Monk's Metal Signs, New York struck in Copper with George Washington obverse and I O. U. 1 Cent on the reverse. A very impressive mint error. Baker 469 From the John Dettinger collection. (100-150) 266 - NY630BB-14e R9 Raw MS62 30% Bright struck on a very large untrimmed 24mm planchet. Monk's Metal Signs, New York struck in White Metal with George Washington obverse. A very impressive mint error. Baker 469 From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (300-400) 267 - NY630BE- 6e R8 NGC MS65 70% Bright on a slightly larger than normal planchet. G. Parsons Fire Works, New York 1863 struck in White Metal with Eagle on reverse. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (300-400) 268 - NY630BE-2a R3 Raw MS63 10% Red. G. Parsons Fire Works with 1863 Indian Head reverse. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 269 - NY630BH-2a R3 Raw MS63 20% Red. Christian Rauh Confectioner, New York with bouquet of flowers and Rooster reverse. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 270 - NY630BO-2a R1 Raw MS63 20% Red. Edward Schulze's featuring deer with antlers. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 271 - NY630BQ-1b R1 Raw MS63 30% Bright. Ph. J. Seiter's with bulls head with horns. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 272 - NY630BS-2a R1 Raw MS63 40% Red. Staudinger's, New York. The small size token from a merchant who issued nearly identical Cent and Quarter sized tokens. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 273 - NY630BT-1a R3 Raw MS62 Trace Red. St. Charles Billiard Rooms New York with undated Indian Head reverse. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 274 - NY630BV- 1a R3 Raw MS64 30% Red with interesting die cracks. Story & Southworth, New York with coin/token press. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 275 - NY630BV- 4e R9 NGC MS62 20% Bright. Story & Southworth, New York 1863 struck in White Metal with Indian Head reverse. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (200-300) 276 - NY630BV- 4j R8 NGC MS64 50% Bright and well struck for this merchant. Story & Southworth, New York 1863 struck in German Silver with Indian Head reverse. Called NY630BV-4C on holder, a prior designation. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection earlier from our February 2014 sale. (300-400) 277 - NY630BV- 9j R8 Raw MS63 60% Bright and well struck for this merchant. Story & Southworth, New York 1863 struck in German Silver with Eagle on Shield reverse. (300-400)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 278 - NY630BV-21b R8 Raw MS63 40% Bright struck from misaligned dies. Story & Southworth, New York with 1863 Eagle and Shield reverse struck in Brass. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (200-300) 279 - NY630CC-4a R2 Raw MS63 30% Red. Washington Market Exchange, New York with Turkey, vegetables and seemingly anti war motto Live And Let Live. Very nice with much more red than normally seen. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (150-200) 280 - NY630CE-2e R9 NGC MS62 Or a bit better, 50% Bright struck with slightly misaligned dies. John Watson Union Tea Store, New York struck in White Metal with eagle reverse. Scarcer merchant and rare variety, just the third we have seen offered. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (200-300) 281 - NY630CI-1a R3 NGC MS63 BN 20% Red. Willard & Jackson Oyster House, New York. Very scarce this nice. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 282 - NY695A-1a1 R6 Raw EF M. L. Marshall's Fishing Tackle, Oswego New York. Popular large size token with scene of fly fisherman casting into mountain stream. With partially reeded edge. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (150-200) 283 - NY760A-1d R5 NGC AU55 Trace Bright. Eastman National Business College, Poughkeepsie New York struck in Copper Nickel. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (150-200) 284 - NY890C-1h R4 Raw EF Fred A. Plum Goodyear India Rubber Depot, Troy New York struck in Hard Rubber. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 285 - NY905A-1a R5 Raw MS63 10% Red. Dickinson Comstock & Co. Druggists, Utica New York. Very scarce merchant particularly in grades above EF. A raw AU+ sold for $155 in our July 2006 auction. (200-300) 286 - OH 60D-1a R7 Raw MS63 10% Red all on the obverse. E. B. Winans & Co. Drugs and Medicines, Bellaire Ohio. Very scarce merchant, we sold an EF with typical weakness and planchet roughness for $91 in our March 2010 sale. (200-300) 287 - OH 70A-1a R8 NGC VF20 BN O. C. Metcalf Dry Goods, Belmont Ohio. Very rare town and when seen are usually in very low grade and or damaged. A raw VF+ sold for $2,475 in our June 2011 sale. From the Al Cipra collection. (2000-3000) 288 - OH125A-2a R7 Raw MS63 30% Red all on the obverse. J. A. Meyer Watches, Clocks & Jewelry, Canton Ohio 1863. An AU retoning from cleaning brought $90.84 in our October 1999 sale. (300-400) 289 - OH165 N- 7a R5 Raw AU+ Trace Red. 200,000 Families Now Use Dr. Bennett's Medicines, which reputedly cured sickness and pain. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 290 - OH165 N-13a R6 Raw MS62 500,000 Person Annually Cured By Dr. Bennett's Medicines. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 291 - OH165 O-2a R5 Raw MS63 Nicely toned. C. H. Bennett Steam Bakery, Cincinnati Ohio with pictorial of a wheat sheaf. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 292 - OH165 T-5b R8 Raw MS62 Trace Bright and nicely toned. J. Campbell Provision Dealer, Cincinnati Ohio 1863 struck in Brass. From the John Dettinger collection. (150-200) 293 - OH165AS-1a R5 Raw EF F. Fischer, Cincinnati Ohio 1863. From the Dave Bowers collection earlier through us via want list. (50-75) 294 - OH165CN-2a R2 NGC MS62 BN Or nearly so. B. Kittredge & Co. Guns and Pistols, Cincinnati Ohio 1863. A raw AU+ sold for $86.05 in our July 2012 auction. (100-150) 295 - OH165CY-38a R5 Raw EF Well struck for issue. W. K. Lanphear Manufacturer of Metallic Cards, Cincinnati with popular Bully For You reverse die 1348. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 296 - OH165CZ-1b R3 Raw MS62 10% Bright. Lanphear's Good For 5 Cents In Cigars Or Tobacco. Struck uniface on a thin Brass, Sutler style, planchet. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 297 - OH165DE-3a R4 NGC MS63 BN 10% Red with some reverse planchet flaw as is often seen with token from this manufacturer. M. Lindermann Check Maker, Cincinnati with star reverse. Rarely seen this nice. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 298 - OH165DF-8b R7 Raw MS62 10% Bright. H. Loewenstein Butcher, Cincinnati Ohio 1863 struck in Brass. From the John Dettinger collection. (150-200) 299 - OH165EJ-5a R7 Raw AU Peebles Groceries, Cincinnati Ohio 1863. From the Dave Bowers and James Holtel collections. (75-100) 300 - OH165FX-11a R8 NGC MS63 RB 40% Red. John Stanton Manufacturer of Store Cards, Stencils, Stamps & Brands Cincinnati Ohio with reverse bust believed to be of Stanton himself. Stanton was one of the most prolific minters of Civil War tokens, most of which feature an Indian Head reverse to mimic regular US Mint Cents and consequently increase acceptance. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III, Francis Toth and Henry South collections, earlier from PCAC October 1970 and our February 25th 2014 weekly auction where is realized $625. (750-1000) 301 - OH165GC-10a1 R8 Raw AU Van Wunder Meat Market with Bull reverse die 1288. A MS62 sold for $341 in our December 2005 auction. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (200-300) 302 - OH165GS-19a R8 Raw EF Robert Wright Dry Goods, Cincinnati Ohio 1863. From the Dave Bowers and Charles Urquhart collections. (75-100) 303 - OH165GY-31a R7 NGC MS64 BN Trace Red all on the obverse with nice cartwheel luster and attractive toning. John E. Zeltner National Hall, Cincinnati Ohio 1863. (100-150) 304 - OH175O-1a R2 Raw MS63 Trace Red. Chas. W. Stearns, Cleveland with grindstone pictured. (75-100) 305 - OH270A-4a R6 Raw VF+ D. Farnham & Co. Dealer in Dry Goods, Edgerton Ohio. Very scarce town. (100-150) 306 - OH330H-1a R6 Raw EF Thompson & Spicer, Fremont Ohio. Reverse features vintage stove labeled Peace Maker 1863. Very scarce merchant. (150-200) 307 - OH345B-1a R5 Raw EF+ J. J. Cadot & Bro. Grocers, Gallipolis Ohio with Mercury head reverse. (150-200) 308 - OH485A-1d R10 Raw EF+ F. Schuch Dealer in Groceries, Loudenville Ohio 1863 struck in Copper Nickel and believed to be Unique. From the Dave Bowers collection. (750-1000) 309 - OH555A-1a R5 Raw AU P. L. Potter Queensware, Middletown Ohio. Scarce single merchant town, a VF+ sold for $110.13 in our August 2015 auction. (200-300)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 310 - OH557A-2b R8 NGC MS64 10% Bright. John Frank 1 Pint Of Milk struck in Brass. Long attributed to Cincinnati Ohio as OH165AY-2b (holder marked as such), current research has placed the Frank dairy in Mill Creek Township of rural Hamilton County, Ohio. We sold an UNC Details with stains and hairlines for $480 in our February 2014 sale. From the Alan Bleviss collection. (750-1000) 311 - OH585A-1a R4 Raw VF With old reverse mark on cheek. D. Giaugue Dealer In Provisions, Mt. Eaton Ohio. Very scarce single merchant town, a VF brought $133.10 in our September 2010 sale. (75-100) 312 - OH645B-1a R6 Raw EF Some light marks on reverse. G. W. McLean, North Hampton Ohio 1863. Rare merchant and very scarce town. (100-150) 313 - OH690B-2a R6 Raw EF Frank Hendry Man'fr of Spectacles & Eye Glasses, Oberlin Ohio. Rare and popular merchant. (200-300) 314 - OH730B-1a R5 Raw FINE+ French & Swonger Dairy Meat Market, Piqua. Very scarce merchant. From the Fred Ball collection. (100-150) 315 - OH735B-2a R6 Raw VF+ J. P. Tou Grocer, Pomeroy Ohio 1863. Very scarce town. (100-150)

316 321 331 316 - OH830G-2d R10 NGC MS65 60% Bright with very nice cartwheel luster. C. Runyon Groceries, Springfield Ohio 1864 struck in Copper Nickel and thought to be Unique. Popular Springfield spelling error. (1500-2000) 317 - OH835G-2a R6 Raw VF D. McConville, Steubenville Ohio. Very scarce merchant. From the Fred Ball collection. (75-100) 318 - OH845A-1a R5 Raw VG H. Bartels Boots & Shoes, Syracuse Ohio 1864. Very scarce town. (50-75) 319 - OH855A-1a R6 Raw EF E. C. Saylor Daily Meat Market, Tippecanoe Ohio. Very scarce variety, much scarcer than -2a. From the Fred Ball collection. (100-150) 320 - OH860C-1b R2 NGC MS63 40% Bright. Ketcham & Barker Stoves, Toledo Ohio with Good Samaritan stove reverse. (100-150) 321 - OH905C-1i R8 NGC XF45 Trace Bright with 30% of original Tin Plating remaining. Memento Of The Sanitary Fair Of Wapakoneta Ohio struck in Tin plated Brass with reeded edge. Rare merchant and the key to a Sanitary Fair set. These fairs were held across the North to raise money to aid soldiers. (1000-1500) 322 - OH905D-1a R5 Raw FINE+ J. H. Timmermeister, Wapakoneta Ohio. Scarce town, single variety merchant. From the Fred Ball collection. (50-75) 323 - OH925A-1a R5 Raw VF C. M. Coffin Dry Goods, West Newton Ohio 1863. (75-100) 324 - OH975A-1a R4 Raw MS63 Trace Red. P. E. Beach, Wooster Ohio with top hat pictorial. Scarce merchant, particularly this nice. From the Fred Ball collection. (150-200) 325 - OH975L-1a R5 Raw EF+ C. Roth Boots and Shoes, Wooster Ohio. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 326 - OH995C-2a R4 NGC MS64 RB 30% Red more so on obverse. Joseph Crosby Tea Dealer, Zanesville Ohio 1863. We sold a raw 20% Red MS63 for $82.50 in our July 2006 auction. (150-200) 327 - OH995D-1a R5 Raw VF+ Everich & Barton, Zanesville Ohio. Single variety merchant. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 328 - PA 13A-1a R6 Raw EF+ Small planchet clip. Wm. Carson Leather Merchant, Allegheny City Pennsylvania. From the Fred Ball collection. (75-100) 329 - PA 13C-2a R6 Raw MS63 40% Red or a bit better. Gregg & Dalzell National Planing Mill, Allegheny City Pennsylvania. (200-300) 330 - PA 13F-6a R4 Raw AU 10% Red. John Sherer Tobacco Dealer, Alleghany City Pennsylvania. With tobacco related reverse including scales, humidor and box labeled Cigars. (100-150) 331 - PA464A-1do R9 NGC MS64 30% Bright struck over a Flying Eagle cent, though not so noted on holder and we could find no visible date. Petersen's Jewelers, Honesdale, Scranton and Pittston Pennsylvania struck over a Copper Nickel Flying Eagle Cent. While we could see no date the bottom outline of the eagle, his talons and tale are visible on the obverse with some study when viewed turned 180 degrees. On the reverse the inner outline of the wreath is visible along with the CEN of Cent, all with some study required. Pennsylvania Civil War tokens over Indian Head Cents are quite unusual let alone one struck over a Flying Eagle, A raw MS63 -2do over an 1863 Cent brought $1,009 in our December 2012 sale. From the Steve Tanenbaum, Herman Aqua and Ray Byrne collections. (1500-2000) 332 - PA525A-1e R5 ICG VF30 S. H. Zahm Dealer in Coins, Tokens and Medals, Lancaster Pennsylvania struck in White Metal. Popular 1861 dated token with Benjamin Franklin reverse die 1148 signed Lovett. (200-300) 333 - PA750F-1a R4 ANACS MS60 BRN Or a bit better. M. C. Campbell's Dancing and Skating Academy, Philadelphia Pennsylvania. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 334 - PA750I-1a R5 Raw EF+ Coombs Second St. Exchange, Philadelphia Pennsylvania. Scarce single variety merchant. From the Fred Ball, Henry South and Jack Detwiler collections. (75-100) 335 - PA750L-1k R6 Raw Unc Details 30% Bright with nearly full Gilt plating and a few light scratches. Great Central Fair, Philadelphia Pennsylvania. Popular Sanitary Fair token. A MS62 brought $232.10 in our September 2010 sale. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 336 - PA750Lc-1e R9 Raw AU Details Tin Pest. E. Ivins Metal Trimmings, Philadelphia struck in White Metal. Very scarce merchant, we sold a VF+ example of the R6 -1b variety for $120 in our January 2015 sale. This is much rarer and the only example we have seen offered. From the Dave Bowers collection. (200-300)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 337 - PA750P-1a R5 Raw VF+ F. P. Rogers Manufacturer Of Milk Cans, Philadelphia Pennsylvania. Nice pictorial of a milk can. A VF sold for $72.60 in our March 2010 sale. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 338 - PA750V-1a R4 ANACS MS62 BRN N. & G. Taylor Co., Philadelphia Pennsylvania. Popular large size token with portrait of Washington. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 339 - PA750V-5e R7 NGC MS62 20% Bright. N. & G. Taylor Co. Stamped & Japanned Ware Metals. Another large size token with George Washington, this struck in White Metal. Very difficult to find this nice, the Tanenbaum example was a MS61 and an AU with a couple light marks realized $195.57 in our July 2009 auction. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III and John Ford collections, earlier from F. C. C. Boyd Estate February 1972 and our April 27th 2014 weekly auction where it brought $375. (500-750) 340 - PA765A-3a R9 Raw MS63 20% Red mostly on the obverse. Allegheny Valley Railroad Hotel, Pittsburgh Pennsylvania 1864. The rarest of the Pittsburgh merchants and very rare variety. From the Dave Bowers collection. (500-750) 341 - PA765C-1a R3 Raw AU+ Trace Red. Buffums Mineral Water, Pittsburgh Pennsylvania. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 342 - PA765J-1a R4 Raw EF A. Ludewig Snuff and Cigars, Pittsburgh Pennsylvania with detailed pictorial of man in fancy clothes. Very popular. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 343 - PA765P- 8a R5 Raw AU+ Trace Red with tiny planchet clip. Struck from rusted reverse die as normally seen. Pittock's News Depot, Pittsburg with popular Sea Serpent reverse die 1290. A similar example brought $215 in our February 2014 auction. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (200-300) 344 - PA765P-16a R5 Raw MS64 20% Red. Pittock's News Depot, Pittsburg with book reverse die 1324. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (150-200) 345 - RI700D-2a R9 Raw MS62 Lightly toned with full Silver plating, unlisted as such. H. Dobson Union 1864, Providence Rhode Island. Very rare die combination with rare East Boston 1837 reverse die 1428. We sold a spotted AU example of the -2b variety for $600 in our October 2011 sale. From the Ed Rosen and George Fuld collections. (750-1000) 346 - RI700F-1a R6 Raw AU With strong strike on a thicker than normal 2.3mm planchet. Some light planchet flaws on the reverse near the date. H. Y. Lefevre Empire Saloon, Providence with popular reverse die 1294 featuring large beer tankard. This crude token, with backwards N's, S's and even a backwards 1, is rarely seen in high grades. A normally weak AU sold for $200 in our July 2014 auction. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (200-300) 347 - RI700G-2a R2 NGC MS62 BN With normal weak spot opposite the head. City Fruit Store, Providence Rhode Island 1864. Reverse die 1159 with nice portrait of Ambrose Burnside and his famous side burns. (200-300)

348 358 359 348 - TN600B- 9b R9 Raw VF+ With traces of original Tin Plating on the reverse. Elliott, Vinson & Co., Memphis with No Submission to the North reverse featuring Palmetto tree and Canon struck in Brass. This Wealth of the South reverse die is quite rare in the Store Card series. (750-1000) 349 - WI220J-2a R6 Raw AU+ Perkins & Smith Stoves, Fond du Lac Wisconsin. An AU sold for $110 in our March 2008 auction. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (150-200) 350 - WI250A-1a R5 Raw EF+ A. Detrich Provisions, Green Bay Wisconsin. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 351 - WI250F-1a R2 NGC MS63 BN 20% Red mostly on the obverse. F. R. Schettler, Green Bay Wisconsin. A raw but more red MS63 brought $181 in our October 2011 auction. From the Mike Tramte collection earlier from Kurt Krueger's April 1990 sale. (200-300) 352 - WI320A-1a R7 Raw VF+ S. H. Coleman, Juneau Wisconsin. Very scarce town. A slightly porous VF+ brought our $192.50 in our June 2011 auction. (300-400) 353 - WI410E-1a R3 Raw EF Details Retoning from cleaning. Huntley & Steensland Crockery, Madison with bisecting obverse die crack as usual. A nice EF sold for $92.50 in our May 2004 auction. (50-75) 354 - WI435B-1a R5 Raw MS62 Trace Red. G. W. Vosburgh Hardware, Stoves & Tin, Marshall Wisconsin 1863. Very scarce town, an EF brought $193.60 in our June 2011 auction. From the Mike Tramte collection. (300-400) 355 - WI510 A-1a R4 Raw EF+ E. Aschermann Cigars & Tobacco, Milwaukee with pictorial of Indian on a charging horse. Popular time, an AU sold for $210.01 in our December 2012 auction. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (150-200) 356 - WI510 C-1a R3 Raw AU Details Retoning from cleaning. Philip Best Lager Beer Empire Brewery, Milwaukee with picture of foaming beer mug. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 357 - WI510 E-1a R3 Raw EF+ V. Blatz Lager Beer City Brewery & Malt House, Milwaukee with picture of King lifting a glass of beer. An EF brought $100 in our February 2014 auction. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 358 - WI510 E-2a R9 Raw MS62 Trace Red with very nice cartwheel luster even on the brockage side. V. Blatz Lager Beer City Brewery & Malt House 1863, Milwaukee full mirror brockage mint error. One of just two known, the other impounded in the ANS's collection. This is the Fuld Plate token for the second edition. From the Steve Tanenbaum, Bob Kraft, Doug Watson and George Fuld collections. (1500-2000) 359 - WI510 R-5a1 R8 Raw MS63 Trace Red. Ch. Hermann & Co., Milwaukee Wisconsin 1863. Very rare obverse die. The token exhibits extensive obverse die cracks likely accounting for its great rarity. One of just three examples we have seen offered. A more red MS62 brought $1,155 in our March 2010 auction. From the Steve Tanenbaum, Bob Kraft and Len Roosmalen collections, earlier from World Exonumia's September 1991 and PCAC's May 1979 sales. (1500-2000) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Civil War Store Cards 360 - WI510 V-1a R4 Raw EF+ Chas. Kleinsteuber Mechanic, Milwaukee Wisconsin. An unusually large size Mossin & Marr token with the portrait of the proprietor signed Marr. Another EF+ sold for $99 in our June 2011 auction. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 361 - WI510AD-1a R4 Raw EF Mossin & Marr Engraver, Milwaukee with naked Amazon reverse die 1220. The maker of many Wisconsin Civil War tokens. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 362 - WI510AG-1a R5 NGC AU58 BN J. Pritzlaff & Co. Glass, Milwaukee Wisconsin 1863 with vintage stove pictured. A raw AU in our March 2008 sale sold for $77.33. (75-100) 363 - WI510AP-1a R3 Raw EF H. Upmeyer Jeweler, Milwaukee with Stephen Douglas reverse. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 364 - WI510AM-1a R5 Raw EF+ D. Stoffel Provisions, Milwaukee Wisconsin 1863. (50-75) 365 - WI520B-1a R6 Raw UNC Details 10% Red with a couple of light marks on reverse. There are also a few obverse planchet flaws. C. W. Leavens & Co., Neenah Wisconsin. An EF+ sold for $115 in our March 2010 auction. The is the current Fuld Plate token. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection. (200-300) 366 - WI540B-1a R7 Raw EF Details Some reverse residues and short old scratch near nose. L. C. Wescott Agricultural Implements, New Lisbon Wisconsin. Rare merchant, an EF+ brought $294.80 in our March 2008 sale. From the Fred Ball and Henry South collection earlier from Walt Korzick December 1986. (150-200) 367 - WI620K-1a R5 Raw EF+ A. Neff Hardware, Oshkosh Wisconsin 1863 with Peace Maker stove reverse die. From the Mike Tramte collection. (75-100) 368 - WI700H-1a R8 Raw MS63 10% Red. D. H. Jones Staple & Fancy Dry Goods, Racine Wisconsin 1863. Rare variety, one of just four examples we have seen offered. From the Mike Tramte collection earlier from our October 2003 sale where it realized $171.04. More recently a similar example sold for $277 in our June 2011 auction. (300-400) 369 - WI700J-1a R7 Raw EF Thelen & Dieterich Dry Goods, Racine Wisconsin. The key to a Racine merchant set. Another EF brought $250 in our June 2011 auction. From the Fred Ball collection. (200-300) 370 - WI720A-6a R8 Raw VF Details A bit porous with some light reverse marks and residues. Greenway's Immense Concert Hall, Ripon Wisconsin. Very scarce single merchant town. A retoned VF brought $297 in our June 2011 auction. From the Mike Tramte collection. (150-200) 371 - WI770A-1a R4 Raw EF+ C. Nebel Steam Mills, Sauk City Wisconsin. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75)

372 375 376 372 - WI920D-3d R8 NGC MS66 70% Bright and quite attractive. T. Devin Clothing, Watertown Wisconsin with Naked Amazon reverse die 1220 struck in Copper Nickel. We sold a NGC MS65 RB example of the R6 -3a variety for $1,900 in our February 2014 auction. From Stack's June 1996 sale. (1500-2000) 373 - WI920L-2b R4 Raw MS63 30% Bright. T. Racek Good For One Glass Beer, Watertown struck in Brass. Once a very rare merchant, a small hoard of generally high grade examples came to the market a number of years ago and is now more properly considered an R4. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (150-200) 374 - WV890D-4a R6 NGC XF45 BN R. C. Graves Periodical and News Dealer, Wheeling West Virginia with open book pictured on reverse. An EF sold for $126 in our March 2008 auction. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (150-200) 375 - LU M-1b R9 Raw VF+ Robin's Garden Union with Childs style eagle on reverse. Most certainly a Civil War token made in Chicago likely for a beer garden, but where was the commissioning merchant located. It may end up being Chicago but to date directory research has yielded no results. A very rare merchant seeming destined to one day find a home. (3000-4000) 376 - SNL-10b1 Unlisted Raw MS62 Trace Bright. Pittsburgh Landing 10 Camp Shiloh April 6th & 7th 1862 signed by Die Sinker H. Miller of Louisville Kentucky. A very interesting and popular token yet difficult to classify. Is it a Patriotic or is it a Store Card? Why and when was it issued? A mystery awaiting discovery. The present example is one of the nicest we have encountered, perhaps second only to another somewhat brighter NGC MS62 in our January 2015 sale that brought $2,280. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection. (1500-2000) 377 - NC-OH-V 2a ANACS MS64 BRN Trace Red all on the obverse. Albert Ross Druggist, Cincinnati struck in Copper. It has been shown that these tokens were issued after the Civil War and consequently now listed in the Non-Contemporary section of the Store Card book. Formerly OH165FA-2a. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 378 - NC-WI-D 2½ao Raw VF Details With some light marks. Struck over a Patriotic Civil War token. Wood Co. Bridge Company 2½. A VF with more under type detail visible brought $142 in our July 2012 sale. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) Counterstamped Coins 379 - IB on the obverse of an 1819 Large Cent. Raw VF Coin VG but porous. The identity of IB is still unknown but is now considered to be from Quebec Canada. (25-50) 380 - W. BROWN on the obverse of 1848 Large Cent. NGC AU55 BN Coin VF. Rulau lists as Pennsylvania silversmith and watchmaker William Brown active 1823-37 and consequently assigns him to the Hard Times era as HT-A401. This is apparently later, Rulau states that from 1845-49 he may have been from Albany New York. Brunk 1215. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 381 - COCKO on the reverse of an 1807 Large Cent. Raw VF Coin VG with some marks. The final O appears to be a design rather than a letter and may hold the key to identifying the issuer. (25-50) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Counterstamped Coins 382 - DEVINS / & / BOLTON / --- / MONTREAL on the obverse of an 1856 Large Cent. Raw VF Coin FINE with tiny obverse rim bump. From the Dave Bowers reference set. (25-50) 383 - J. V. GEIGER on the obverse of 1854 Cent. Raw VF Coin VF. J. V. Geiger known as Boss Geiger was a gunsmith in Towanda Pennsylvania beginning in 1858 when he took over the business from his father John E. Geiger. From the Dave Bowers collection. (200-300) 384 - (Anchor) HOPE SILVER Co on the obverse of 1888 Cent. Raw VF Coin VG. This was the hallmark for silver-plated items by G. W. Parks Company of Providence Rhode Island, active from 1904 to 1915. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection. (50-75) 385 - A. RODICK on both sides of 1854 Large Cent. Raw VF Coin FINE. The first initial is off the coin on one side and indistinct on the other. The consignor saw it as L. and we see as A. but perhaps neither is right. (25-50) 386 - L. D. S. on the obverse of an 1837 Centre Market Hard Times token. Raw FINE Token VG but damaged. (0-25) 387 - SINGLETON / MONTROSE on the obverse of an 1851 Cent. Raw VF Coin VG+. A Singleton from Montrose Pennsylvania has been suggested but in need of more research and a more solid attribution. From the Dave Bowers collection. (50-75) 388 - L. S. WHITE PATENTED JAN 31 1854 in a circular punch on the reverse of an 1848 Cent. Raw VF Coin EF but a bit flattened and apparently pressed into another Cent. A Le Roy S. White of Chicopee Massachusetts received patent number 10438 on January 31, 1854 for a furniture caster. From the Dave Bowers collection. (200-300) 389 - WILCOX & Co / N. HAVEN on the reverse of an 1820 Cent. Raw FINE+ Coin AG. Presumably a Wilcox & Co. from New Haven Connecticut. All we could find with an admittedly quick internet search was an A. Wilcox & Co. of Wethersfield Connecticut, a tool maker listed in an 1840 Journal of the American Institute. From the Dave Bowers collection earlier from Bob Moffatt August 1989. (200-300) 390 - WISS / NEWARK N.J. / U.S.A within a shield shaped design on the reverse of a 1912-D Half Dollar Raw VF Coin GOOD+. This was the logo of the J. Wiss & Son Company who were makers of scissors and other cutlery from 1848 to 1976. From the Steve Tanenbaum and Michael Kolman collections, earlier from Kurt Krueger's Spring 1992 sale. (50-75) 391 - J. F. Whitaker / H'tf'd. Ct. on the obverse on an 1864 Two Cent Piece. Raw VF Coin VF. J. F. Whitaker is listed as a cabinetmaker in Hartford city directories of the 1880's and 1890's. Rulau CT Ha 80. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection. (100-150) 392 - YATES on the obverse of a Draped Bust Large Cent. Raw VF Coin POOR. (25-50) Hard Times Tokens

393 395 396 393 - LOW 1 / HT-1 R6 Raw FINE+ Andrew Jackson The Bank Must Perish. One of the classics in the Hard Times series. From the Maurice Shepherd and Sara Hinckley collections earlier from PCAC's November 2006 sale where it brought $3,450. (4000-6000) 394 - LOW 3 / HT-5 R3 Raw VF Details But planchet very slightly bent. Andrew Jackson President 1832. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (200-300) 395 - LOW 6 / HT-14 R5 NGC XF45 Trace Bright. For The Constitution Hurrah!, Whig Victorious April 1834. Very scarce this nice, a raw EF+ sold for $600 in our March 2008 auction. From the Maurice Shepherd collection earlier from Chuck Kirtley's sale number 83. (750-1000) 396 - LOW 7 / HT-15 R6 NGC VF35 BN The Glorious Whig Victory Of 1834. A very nice example worthy of the most advanced collection. From the Maurice Shepherd and Gilbert Steinberg collections, earlier from our May 2004 auction where it realized $1,750. (2000-3000) 397 - LOW 8 / HT-9 R1 NGC MS63 BN With nice luster. My Substitute For The US Bank with running boar pictured. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (300-400) 398 - LOW 8A / HT-9A Unlisted Raw AU Details But cleaned with nearly full Gilt plating. My Substitute For The US Bank with running boar pictured in Gilt and unlisted as such. Difficult to determine if it is original due to cleaning, but suffice it to say that Steve Tanenbaum thought enough of this piece to keep it in his collection for over 30 years. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection earlier from Bill Panitch October 1977. (200-300) 399 - LOW 9 / HT-10 R3 Raw FINE+ Jackson with Running Boar 1834 struck in Brass. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 400 - LOW 10 / HT-11 R2 Raw VF+ My Substitute For The US Bank. Down With the Bank 1834 with running Boar. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 401 - LOW 11 / HT-12 R5 Raw FINE+ Details But with a large spot in front of running boar. Running Boar our Currency our Glory struck in Brass. Very scarce in any grade, a VF with a number of light marks and small rim bumps brought $302 in our July 2014 auction. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (200-300) 402 - LOW 12B / HT-25B R7 Raw EF Struck slightly off center on a large 29.4mm planchet. The Constitution As I Understand It Roman Firmness LLD 1834 A Plain System Void Of Pomp. A satirical anti Andrew Jackson piece picturing a donkey or jackass and Jackson with sword and bag of money. We sold an AU example for $300 on a tie bid in our May 2004 sale. From the Maurice Shepherd collection earlier from Chuck Kirtley's October 1997 sale. (200-300) 403 - LOW 13 / HT-26 R4 NGC XF45 William Seward Our Next Governor. Very scarce variety particularly this nice and problem free. A VF with light scratches brought $321.20 in our June 2011 sale. From the Maurice Shepherd collection earlier from PCAC's November 1999 sale. (500-750) 404 - LOW 14 / HT-27 R5 Raw VF+ William Seward Our Next Governor. Very scarce variety, an EF brought $792 in our July 2006 auction. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (750-1000)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Hard Times Tokens 405 - LOW 15 / HT-28 R3 Raw FINE+ William Seward Our Next Governor. Rarely seen this nice, another FINE+ but porous with residues and two thin planchet cracks brought $525 in our February 2014 sale. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (300-400) 406 - LOW 16 / HT-30 R2 NGC AU50 Gulian Verplanck Our Next Governor. An AU realized $302.50 in our March 2010 auction. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (300-400) 407 - LOW 17 / HT-31 R3 Raw VF+ I Follow in the Foot Steps of our Illustrious Predecessor. The scarcest by far of the HT-31 to 34 series and often misattributed. A FINE sold for $127.50 in our June 2011 sale. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (200-300) 408 - LOW 18 / HT-32 R1 Raw AU I Follow in the Foot Steps of our Illustrious Predecessor. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 409 - LOW 19 / HT-33 R1 NGC MS64 BN Attractively toned with very nice cartwheel luster. Turtle carrying Sub Treasury with Jackass on reverse. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (300-400) 410 - LOW 23 / HT-37 R4 Raw FINE+ Details NOT smoothed and a few light marks. 1837 Millions For Defense Not One Cent For Tribute. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (75-100) 411 - LOW 29 / HT-44 R3 Raw FINE+ Weak opposite head as usual. 1837 Millions For Defense. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (50-75) 412 - LOW 33 / HT-48 R1 NGC MS61 RB Or a bit better 30% Red. Millions for Defense Not One Cent For Tribute. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (150-200) 413 - LOW 36 / HT-51 R2 Raw VF Liberty Head Not One Cent 1837. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (50-75) 414 - LOW 38 / HT-62 R1 Raw VF Mint Drop Brentonian Currency 1837. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (25-50) 415 - LOW 39 / HT-52 R1 Raw EF Liberty / Millions For Defense. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (50-75) 416 - LOW 40 / HT-65 R2 Raw VF+ Liberty Head Specie Payment Suspended May Tenth 1837. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (50-75) 417 - LOW 44 / HT-69 R1 Raw AU+ I Take The Responsibility with Jackson in strong box with sword and bag of money. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 418 - LOW 45 / HT-56 R1 Raw EF Phoenix rising from flames Substitute For Shin Plasters. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (50-75) 419 - LOW 46 / HT-57 R1 Raw VF+ Substitute For Shin Plasters 1837. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (25-50) 420 - LOW 47 / HT-66 R1 NGC MS62 Trace Red. Substitute For Shin Plasters with Phoenix rising. A MS62 sold for $148.50 in our March 2010 sale. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (150-200) 421 - LOW 48 / HT-67 R1 Raw AU Substitute For Shin Plasters 1837 with Phoenix rising. (75-100) 422 - LOW 51 / HT-70 R1 NGC MS62 BN The Constitution As I Understand It Roman Firmness Veto with Jackass labeled LLD. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (150-200) 423 - LOW 52 / HT-71 R3 Raw FINE+ Details With some light obverse marks. The Constitution As I Understand It Roman Firmness Veto with Jackass labeled LLD struck in Brass. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (25-50) 424 - LOW 53 / HT-72 R2 Raw EF+ Nicely struck for variety. I Take the Responsibility. Very scarce this nice, an EF+ sold for $137 with tie bids in our September 2010 auction. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 425 - LOW 54 / HT-81 R1 Raw VF+ The 8 in reverse date is quite weak as usual. Very popular 1838 Anti Slavery token that pictures a woman in chains with the legend Am I Not A Woman And A Sister. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (200-300) 426 - LOW 55 / HT-63 R1 Raw EF Popular Loco Foco Benton Experiment Mint Drop 1838. Very scarce above EF, a VF+ sold for $220 in our June 2011 auction. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (150-200)

427 448 462 427 - LOW 57 / HT-76 R6 Raw FINE+ Details Slightly porous with a few light marks. Holed for suspension as always. Martin Van Buren The Peoples Choice with strongbox guarded by dog, his paw sitting on the key. Very difficult to find in nice problem free condition. We sold a nice VF+ for $1,650 in our January 2015 sale. Dewitt MVB 1840-7 From the Maurice Shepherd and Sara Hinckley collections earlier from PCAC's November 2006 sale where it realized $1,265. (1000-1500) 428 - LOW 58 / HT-16 R1 Raw EF+ Webster Credit Current 1841 with ship labeled Constitution sailing on calm seas. (50-75) 429 - LOW 59 / HT-17 R1 NGC MS63 BN Trace Red. Webster ship labeled Constitution sailing smoothly. A somewhat underrated variety, particularly in Uncirculated condition. An AU brought $80 in our July 2012 sale. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (200-300) 430 - LOW 60 / HT-18 R1 NGC MS62 BN Van Buren Metallic Currency with ship labeled Experiment being hit by storm. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (200-300) 431 - LOW 61 / HT-19 R5 Raw AU Details Quite sharp but slightly porous. Daniel Webster Lightning inside wreck 1841. Quite rare in Uncirculated condition. From the Maurice Shepherd collection, earlier from Bowers and Merena's June 1985 sale. (400-500) 432 - LOW 62 / HT-20 R1 Raw AU+ Van Buren Metallic Current 1837 with ship labeled Experiment crashing on the rocks in a lightning storm. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 433 - LOW 63 / HT-21 R2 Raw EF Webster Credit Currency Constitution 1841. Scarcer variety particularly this nice. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (75-100) 434 - LOW 65 / HT-23 R4 Raw VF+ Liberty 1837 and Webster Credit Current 1841. Rarely seen variety without problems, another problem free VF+ sold for $155 in our July 2012 sale. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (150-200)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Hard Times Tokens 435 - LOW 66 / HT-24 R3 NGC XF40 BN Nice for variety with two tiny Ds counterstamped on reverse. A Friend To The Constitution Agriculture and Commerce. The counterstamped D's indicate it was once part of the William Forrester Dunham collection. He counterstamped his entire collection, including his 1804 Dollar! From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (300-400) 436 - LOW 67 / HT-68 R1 Raw EF Specie Payments Suspended May Tenth 1837. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (50-75) 437 - LOW 68 / HT-64 R1 Raw EF+ Bentonian Currency Mint Drop 1837. Rarely seen this nice. (75-100) 438 - LOW 69 / HT-58 R1 Raw EF+ Millions For Defense Not One Cent For Tribute. (50-75) 439 - LOW 72 / HT-175 R6 Raw VF Details With a few light marks. Francis L. Brigham Cheapside, New Bedford Massachusetts. Very scarce an EF with a hairline scratch sold for $427 in our October 2011 sale. From the Maurice Shepherd collection, earlier from Bowers and Merena's March 1990 auction. (300-400) 440 - LOW 73 / HT-176 R3 Raw EF Well struck for issue. Francis L. Brigham Cheapside, New Bedford Massachusetts. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (300-400) 441 - LOW 74 / HT-428 R1 Raw AU+ Ephriam A. Hathaway City Coal Yard, Providence Rhode Island. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 442 - LOW 76 / HT-153 R1 Raw AU Details With small verdigris spot. Robinson's Jones & Co. Naval Buttons, Attleboro Massachusetts. (25-50) 443 - LOW 77 / HT-348 R5 Raw VF Details With some light marks and scratch. But with very sharp strike for variety with nearly full legends. Bucklin's Interest Tables, Troy New York 1834. A exceptionally detailed example, so much so it was chosen as one of the two Adams plate tokens for this variety. From the Maurice Shepherd collection earlier from the April 1997 EAC sale. (300-400) 444 - LOW 79 / HT-361 R4 Raw FINE With a couple tiny rim bumps. W. P. Haskins, Troy New York. Very scarce variety, particularly this nice. An EF+ brought $346 in our July 2012 auction. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (50-75) 445 - LOW 83 / HT-150 R2 Raw MS62 With very nice cartwheel luster. H. M. & E. I. Richards, Attleboro Massachusetts. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (200-300) 446 - LOW 84 / HT-158 R1 Raw EF S. B. Schenck 1834 Planing Machine Attleboro, Massachusetts. (50-75) 447 - LOW 86 / HT-174 R1 Raw FINE+ S. L. Wilkins Furs, Lowell Massachusetts. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (50-75) 448 - LOW 87 / HT-347 R7 PCGS XF40 Struck on a clipped planchet. Oliver & Phardice Boutwell Bakers & Confectioners, Troy New York 1835. Signed *T beneath Wheat Sheaf for engraver True of Albany. This issue seems to have been issued in very modest numbers, years later Oliver Boutwell was one of the most prolific issuers of Civil War tokens. One of the classic rarities of the Hard Times series. Thought to be one of just ten or so known and usually only available in lower grades, more often than not with problems. The Dice & Hicks, Zeddies, Brand specimen, a sharp EF with cleaned and lacquered obverse brought $7,475 in Stack's July 2008 sale. From the Gilbert Steinberg collection earlier Stack's October 1989 sale, where it realized $5,775. (8000-12000) 449 - LOW 89 / HT-349 R5 Raw FINE+ Somewhat weakly struck as usual but much better than usual with nearly all stars and profile complete. Bucklin's Interest Tables, Troy New York. One of the nicest examples of this variety we have offered in many years. From the Maurice Shepherd collection earlier from Bowers & Merena's November 1998 sale. (300-400) 450 - LOW 92 / HT-353 R1 Raw VF Partial brockage mint error. Typical weak strike and even more so due to error striking. Bucklin's Book Keeping, Troy New York 1835. Nice tab off center partial brockage with incused denticles and O from Book clearly visible. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (100-150) 451 - LOW 92 / HT-353 R1 Raw VG Details But holed. Full mirror brockage mint error. Bucklin's Book Keeping, Troy New York 1835. The last in a series of Hard Times token Brockages from the Steve Tanenbaum collection; it may be many years before another is offered. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection from Mike Ringo November 1994. (500-750) 452 - LOW 93 / HT-355 R4 Raw VF With a few light marks. 1835 Bucklin's Book Keeping, Troy weakly signed TRUE ALB under date. Very scarce variety. From the Maurice Shepherd and Gilbert Steinberg collections, earlier from Bowers and Merena's November 2002 auction where it brought $345. (500-750) 453 - LOW 95 / HT-291 R1 Raw MS62 Trace Red. Merchants Exchange Wall Street New York. Very scarce this nice. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (150-200) 454 - LOW 97 / HT-293 R1 Raw MS62 Trace Red and a bit weakly struck. Merchants Exchange Wall Street, New York. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (150-200) 455 - LOW 98 / HT-294 R1 NGC MS65 BN 10% Red more so on reverse and well struck for variety. Merchants Exchange New York Joint Stock Exchange. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (300-400) 456 - LOW 99 / HT-216 R1 Raw EF+ Walsh's General Store, Lansingburgh New York with plow pictured. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 457 - LOW 101 / HT-218 R1 Raw EF Details With some light silvery staining or poorly mixed copper planchet. Walsh's General Store, Lansinburg New York 1835. Town spelling error. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (50-75) 458 - LOW 103 / HT-154 R3 Raw VF R. & W. Robinson Sporting Buttons, Attleboro Massachusetts. Very scarce variety. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (50-75) 459 - LOW 104 / HT-155 R1 Raw AU+ Trace Red. R. & W. Robinson Military Buttons, New York. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 460 - LOW 105 / HT-156 R4 Raw FINE+ R. & W. Robinson Military Buttons American Institute, New York. By far the scarcest of the Low 103 to 105 series. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (75-100) 461 - LOW 107 / HT-219 R2 Raw MS62 Trace Red. Henry Anderson Mammoth Boot, New York 1837 picturing a large boot. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (200-300)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Hard Times Tokens

462 - LOW 108 / HT-430 R7 NGC AU50 R. L. Baker Good For 1 Glass Soda Water, Charleston South Carolina 1837 struck in German Silver. Very rare and much nicer than normally seen. Rulau states that only seven examples are in collectors hands and while this may be a bit over stated it has long been considered one of the classic rarities of the series. An EF+ with two small stains sold for $6,655 in our March 2008 sale. From the Maurice Shepherd, Dice & Hicks and Julian Leidman collections. (8000-12000) 463 - LOW 111 / HT-240 R1 Raw MS62 Centre Market Accommodations, New York. Scarce this nice. Another MS62 brought $210 in our February 2014 sale. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (150-200) 464 - LOW 113 / HT-244 R2 Raw EF+ H. Crossman (Umbrella) Manufacturer, New York 1837 with Eagle. An EF brought $105.01 in our February 2014 auction. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 465 - LOW 116 / HT-172 R3 NGC XF45 Maverick Coach 1837, East Boston Massachusetts struck in German Silver. A VF brought $391.60 in our December 2008 sale. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (500-750)

466 467 477 466 - LOW 117 / HT-262 R3 NGC EX45 Feuchtwanger's Composition 1837 Three Cents, New York. A raw VF+ realized $1,100 in our March 2010 auction. From the Maurice Shepherd collection from Benj Fauver. (1500-2000) 467 - LOW 118 / HT-263 R5 Raw FINE+ Feuchtwanger's Composition Three Cent Piece 1837 with Eagle struck in German Silver. A very nice example of the popular large size Feuchtwanger piece, a VF+ brought $2,112 in our March 2010 sale. From the Maurice Shepherd collection earlier from PCAC's October 2000 sale. (2000-3000) 468 - LOW 120 1-A / HT-268 R4 Raw VF Feuchtwanger's Composition 1837 One Cent, New York. A VF+ brought $450 in our August 2015 auction. From the James Higby collection. (300-400) 469 - LOW 120 2-A / HT-268 R5 Raw VG+ With some reverse spotting. Feuchtwanger's Composition 1837 One Cent, New York. Rare in Uncirculated condition, a VF+ sold for $231 in our December 2008 sale. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (100-150) 470 - LOW 120 3-B / HT-268 R3 Raw EF Feuchtwanger's Cent, New York. Very scarce and underrated variety, another EF brought $166 in our August 1996 sale and more recently an AU+ sold for $500 in our July 2014 auction. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (200-300) 471 - LOW 120 3-D / HT-268 R7 Raw VF Details With some small dents and marks. Feuchtwanger's Cent, New York. Very rare variety, its reverse die not used in any other combinations. This is the only example we have been able to offer. From the Maurice Shepherd and Gilbert Steinberg collections, earlier from Bowers and Merena's November 2002 sale where it realized $575. (750-1000) 472 - LOW 120 3-E / HT-268 R3 Raw VF+ Feuchtwanger's Composition 1837 One Cent, New York. From the James Higby collection. (150-200) 473 - LOW 120 3-G / HT-268 R6 Raw FINE With a few light marks on reverse. Later reverse die state as usual. Feuchtwanger's Cent 1837, New York. Rare variety, a VF sold for $365 in our July 2009 sale. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (200-300) 474 - LOW 120 4-E / HT-268 R3 Raw EF+ Feuchtwanger's Composition 1837 One Cent. A somewhat underrated variety, an AU+ brought $551 in our February 2014 auction. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (300-400) 475 - LOW 120 5-G / HT-268 R2 Raw VF+ Feuchtwanger's Composition One Cent 1837 struck in German Silver. Another VF+ sold for $140 in our December 2010 sale. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (150-200) 476 - LOW 120 5-H / HT-268 R1 PCGS MS63 10% Bright more so on reverse with nice luster. Feuchtwanger's One Cent 1837 struck in German Silver. Precise variety not noted on the holder. We sold a NGC AU58 in our January 2015 sale for $215. From the Bob Miller collection. (400-500) 477 - LOW 120 6-G / HT-268 R1 NGC MS63 20% Bright. Feuchtwanger Composition One Cent 1837 struck in German Silver. Very underrated variety and examples in Uncirculated condition are quite rare, an NGC MS65 sold for $1,850 in our June 2013 auction. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (500-750) 478 - LOW 120 6-I / HT-268 R1 Raw EF+ Feuchtwanger's One Cent 1837 struck in German Silver. From the James Higby collection. (200-300) 479 - LOW 123 / HT-284 R1 Raw VF George A. Jarvis Wine & Tea Dealer, New York. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (50-75) 480 - LOW 126 / HT-290 R1 Raw EF+ Struck nearly 10% off center. S. Maycock & Co. Everpointed Pencil Case, New York. Nice mint error. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (75-100)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Hard Times Tokens

481 482 487 481 - LOW 128 / HT-309 R5 Raw FINE+ With some tiny planchet cracks and minor surface roughness. R. E. Russell IOU 12½ Cent Token 1837 Columbia South Carolina struck in German Silver. Long assumed to be from New York City due to its association with the Feuchtwanger pieces. Ground breaking research by Aaron Packard shows it was actually issued by Robert E. Russell of Columbia South Carolina. Russell operated a Botany Garden which included a Public Bath. Long one of the most desirable Hard Times tokens and rare, particularly so problem free. Demand is certain to increase due to its new more exotic location and fascinating story. We sold a problem free VF for $2,115 in our June 2011 auction. From the Maurice Shepherd collection earlier from PCAC May 1997 sale. (1000-1500) 482 - LOW 130 / HT-105 R3 NGC MS62 BN J. M. L. & W. H. Scovill, Waterbury Connecticut. Scovill was the maker of many Hard Times and other tokens. A NGC AU55 BN from our January 2015 sale brought $375. From the Maurice Shepherd collection from Steve Tanenbaum. (500-750) 483 - LOW 131 / HT-192 R2 Raw VF+ A. C. Smith and Haselton & Palmer, Dover New Hampshire. Scarce and underrated merchant, a VF brought $55 in our June 2005 sale. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 484 - LOW 133A / HT-312B R7 Raw AU Details With a few light marks and 30% or more of original silvering remaining mostly on the clock face side. Smiths Clock Establishment, New York. An EF example of the non silvered variety sold for $350 in our December 2012 sale. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (300-400) 485 - LOW 135 / HT-314 R1 Raw AU Smiths Clock Time Is Money, New York. An EF+ realized $184.80 in our June 2011 sale. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (200-300) 486 - LOW 136 / HT-315 R1 Raw EF Smiths Clock Time Is Money, New York. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 487 - LOW 139 / HT-464 R6 Raw VF+ S S B 1837 struck in Brass. Rare and enigmatic, a VF brought $1,400 in our June 2014. From the Maurice Shepherd and Robert Schonwalter collections, earlier from New Netherlands and Stack's January 2004 sale where it sold for $1,275. (1500-2000) 488 - LOW 141 / HT-335 R3 Raw VF Ezra B. Sweet, Stoves & Kitchen Furniture, New York 1837. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection earlier from our July 2014 auction. (100-150) 489 - LOW 142 / HT-205 R2 Raw EF Bergen Iron Works 1840, Lakewood New Jersey struck in Brass. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (150-200) 490 - LOW 143 / HT-206 R4 Raw VF Large die crack, though earlier die state than most. Bergen Iron Works 1840, Lakewood New Jersey struck in Copper. From the Bob Miller collection. (150-200) 491 - LOW 143 / HT-206 R4 Raw EF+ Large die crack, though earlier die state than most. Bergen Iron Works 1840, Lakewood New Jersey struck in Copper. Rarely seen this nice. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (300-400) 492 - LOW 145 / HT-356 R2 Raw VF+ With tiny planchet clip. Very well struck for issue with just the tops of a few letters indistinct. Bucklin's Book Keeping, West Troy New York. (100-150) 493 - LOW 148 / HT-204 R1 Raw VF With scattered planchet flaws as often seen on this variety. T. Duseaman Butcher, Belleville New Jersey. (50-75) 494 - LOW 151 / HT-272 R6 Raw VF Details With slightly porous surfaces. Very well struck for variety. W. Gibbs Agriculturist, New York. Rare and exceedingly difficult to find unimpaired. From the Maurice Shepherd, Sara Hinckley and Wurtzbach collections, earlier from PCAC's November 2006 sales where it brought $575. (500-750) 495 - LOW 153 / HT-305 R1 Raw EF+ Abraham Riker, New York with boots and shoes pictured. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III and Don Boller collections earlier from our July 2012 sale. (100-150) 496 - LOW 162 / HT-77 R5 Raw EF Details Holed as always with some porosity. Martin Van Buren Independent Treasury July 4, 1840. A VF+ example from our June 2011 sold for $660. From the Maurice Shepherd and Gilbert Steinberg collections, earlier from Bowers and Merena's November 2002 sale. (400-500) 497 - LOW 163 / HT-201 R3 Raw FINE The middle three letters of Token are very weak but visible at the right angle, typical if not above average for this variety and amount of wear. Howell Works Garden, Allaire New Jersey with rose pictured. From the Maurice Shepherd collection from Bowers and Ruddy's January 1983 auction. (200-300) 498 - LOW 164 / HT-151 R2 Raw EF Details With a number of light marks. H. M. & E. I. Richards, Attleboro Massachusetts. Very scarce and underrated variety. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (50-75) 499 - LOW 171 / HT-70A R3 Raw EF+ Trace Bright with 40% or more original Gilt plating remaining. I Take The Responsibility. Very scarce and underrated variety with Gilt plating. From the Maurice Shepherd collection from Steve Tanenbaum April 1997. (200-300) 500 - LOW 175 / HT-433 R5 Raw EF Crudely struck and slightly off center on an oval planchet. Where struck, it is quite sharp for variety with a readable date. Gustin & Blake, Chelsea Vermont. Distinguishing between Low 175 and 176 is difficult and we believe a Low 175 illustrates both varieties in Rulau. Refer to lot 318 in the Ford Hard Times sale for a well struck Low 176 and note the base of the T's in Stoves and Tin and base of E in Ware. We sold a VF+ that was better centered but unevenly struck for $1,342 in our December 2006 sale. From the Maurice Shepherd and Gilbert Steinberg collections, earlier from Bowers and Merena's November 2002 sale where it realized $575. (1500-2000) 501 - LOW 190 / HT-78 R4 Raw AU 10% Bright holed as always. Martin Van Buren Democracy and Our Country struck in Brass. Very scarce this nice, another AU brought $777 in our December 2010 sale. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection earlier from our July 2014 auction. (500-750) 502 - LOW 192 / HT-79 R2 Raw FINE WE missing from reverse as often seen. Henry Clay United We Stand. (50-75) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Hard Times Tokens 503 - LOW 192 / HT-79 R2 Raw VF Or a bit better with WE missing from reverse as often seen. Henry Clay United We Stand. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 504 - LOW 201 / HT-221 R7 Raw EF Details With a few small dents. Atwood's Railroad Hotel 3 Cents signed Bale & Smith NY with George Washington on horseback. Rare variety often seen porous or with other problems, an EF+ sold for $1,655 in our October 2011 auction. From the Maurice Shepherd collection from Catherine Bullowa's June 1997 sale. (500-750)

505 506 510 505 - LOW 207 / HT-227 R7 Raw VF Details A bit dark and porous. Bale & Smith Engravers & Die Cutters New York with George Washington on horseback signed Bale & Smith NY. Exceedingly rare in any grade, just the fifth we have seen offered. (1000-1500) 506 - LOW 217 / HT-394 R7 Raw AU Bender's Eating Saloon Good For 38 Cents, Philadelphia Pennsylvania. Even though there are many different denominations each is exceedingly rare. We sold an MS62 example of the 13 Cent variety for $2,276 in our July 2012 auction. From the Maurice Shepherd, Dice & Hicks and Ray Byrne collections, earlier from Steve Tanenbaum August 2003 and Stack's July 2008 auction. (1500-2000) 507 - LOW 220 / HT-235 R6 Raw EF Details Retoning from cleaning with some light marks and short scratches. 10% of original Gilt plating remains. J. & L. Brewster, New York and New Orleans. Rare merchant, many with problems. An AU with a few tiny digs and two hairline scratches brought $800 in a tie bid in our July 2007 auction in a time when most bids came by the US mail and it was necessary to note that tie bids were won by the earliest post mark. (750-1000) 508 - LOW 234 / HT-182 R3 Raw VF+ With a few light marks, very well struck for variety. Crocker, Brothers & Co., Taunton Massachusetts. Very scarce and underrated variety, particularly in higher grades. An EF+ with a few tiny marks brought $421 in our July 2012 sale. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (200-300) 509 - LOW 245 / HT-258 R4 NGC AU55 10% Bright. Doremus, Suydam & Nixon, New York. With 37 & 39 Nassau Street address and signed Bale N.Y. This would appear to be Gilt plated making it HT-258C. We sold a NGC MS62 for $500 in our July 2014 sale. From the Maurice Shepherd collection earlier from Bowers and Merena's November 1989 sale. (300-400) 510 - LOW 249 / HT-269 R7 NGC AU55 BN W. Field Manufacturer of Hats, Caps and Fancy Furs, New York. Very rare merchant. Superior to the AU with minor problems that brought $7,500 in our December 2012 auction. Also in our opinion the finest of the Ford examples, though NGC called it AU58. From the John Ford collection earlier from F. C. C. Boyd March 1958. (8000-12000) 511 - LOW 253 / HT-277 R4 NGC AU55 Trace Bright. Hallock Dolson & Bates, New York. A NGC MS61 with some minor stains brought $295 in our August 2015 auction. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (200-300)

512 517 519 512 - LOW 256 / HT-279 R3 NGC MS64 RB 40% Red. Dr. J. G. Hewett Bone Setter Practice Confined to Dislocations, Sprains, Contractions, Rheumatism, White Swellings, Weakness of the Limbs and etc., New York. Interestingly this variety is almost always found in Uncirculated condition while Low 255 / HT-278 is almost always found in worn condition. Another MS64 RB sold for $673.20 in our March 2008 sale. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (750-1000) 513 - LOW 261 / HT-286 R2 Raw EF A bit weak near rims as usual, much better than average. H. Law Baker English Bread, Twist & Fancy Cakes, New York. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (200-300) 514 - LOW 266 / HT-164 R1 Raw EF Wm. H. Milton Tailor, Boston Massachusetts. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (50-75) 515 - LOW 271 / HT-363 R1 Raw EF Well struck for issue, though still somewhat uneven. J. & C. Peck Tin Machines, Troy New York with one of their machines pictured. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 516 - LOW 273 / HT-307 R1 Raw VF+ Robert B. Ruggles Dentists Gold, New York. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 517 - LOW 275 / HT-441 R3 Raw FINE+ Richmond is missing a number of letters as often seen. Beck's Public Baths, Richmond Virginia with picture of a nude female bather on the reverse. The FINE+ with very light scratches brought $872 in our September 2010 auction. From the Maurice Shepherd collection earlier from us April 2002. (1000-1500) 518 - LOW 279A / HT-318A R4 Raw AU Squire & Merritt Ship Chandlers and Rope Makers, New York. This is die combination 1-A with a Plain edge and 175 counterstamp. Rarely seen this nice. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection earlier from our July 2014 sale were it realized $426. (500-750)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Hard Times Tokens 519 - LOW 283 / HT-324 R6 NGC MS61 BN Squire & Merritt Ship Chandlers and Rope Makers, New York. A very confusing merchant to attribute with many die and sub varieties. Adding to the confusion, Rulau's listing and spacing where the descriptions of the varieties proceed the listing rather than follow it as in other sections of his book. This is die combination 3-B with a Reeded edge and no counterstamp. Quite rare in Uncirculated condition, a NGC MS62 sold for $750 in our February 2014 sale. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (500-750) 520 - LOW 284 / HT-368 R2 Raw VF+ Long die crack as usual. Well struck for issue, though still somewhat uneven. N. Starbuck & Son, Troy New York with plow and large screw. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 521 - LOW 291 / HT-102 R2 Raw VF Fobes & Barlow Veneers, New Haven Connecticut. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 522 - LOW 293 / HT-440 R4 Raw VF+ S. N. Botsford Clock & Watch Maker, Norfolk Virginia. Underrated variety, and very rarely seen above VF. A VF brought $453 in our October 2011 auction. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (500-750) 523 - LOW 300 / HT-181 R1 NGC MS62 BN 10% Red with nice luster. John J. Adams, Taunton Massachusetts with running boar pictured. A NGC MS61 in our December 2012 auction realized $180. (200-300)

524 532 541 524 - LOW 313A / HT-376A R7 NGC AU53 10% Bright with 30% or more original Gilt plating. P. Evens Draper & Tailor, Cincinnati Ohio. Rare merchant. This is the Rulau plate specimen. We sold a raw AU with some light hairlines for $1,210 in our March 2008 sale. From the Maurice Shepherd and Hick & Dice collections, earlier from Stack's July 2008 auction. (1000-1500) 525 - LOW 317 / HT-344 R7 Raw EF Henderson & Lossing Watch Maker, Poughkeepsie New York. Rare merchant, we sold an AU for $838.20 in our March 2008 auction. From the Maurice Shepherd collection earlier from Benj Fauver. (750-1000) 526 - LOW 318A / HT-346 R4 Raw FINE+ Hiram Judson Silver Smith, Syracuse New York struck on a Thick Plain edge planchet. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 527 - LOW 320 / HT-381 R5 Raw FINE+ A nice problem free example. A. Loomis Foreign Liquors and Wines, Cleveland Ohio. From the Maurice Shepherd collection earlier from our May 2001 sale. (400-500) 528 - LOW 321 / HT-295 R2 Raw EF+ James G. Moffet Brass Founder, New York with charmingly crude die work featuring a backwards N and S in E Pluribus Unum. An AU+ sold for $160.75 in our February 2014 sale. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 529 - LOW 323 / HT-297 R2 Raw AU+ With sharp strike. James G. Moffet Brass Founder, New York with charmingly crude die work featuring backwards N's and S's and Pluribus spelled incorrectly. A similar example realized $330 in our December 2012 auction. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (300-400) 530 - LOW 324 / HT-212 R4 Raw VF+ Very well struck for merchant. Patterson Bros., Buffalo New York. This is the much scarcer Plain edge variety, a VF with a few light marks sold for $165 in our March 2008 auction. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (150-200) 531 - LOW 326 / HT-160 R2 Raw VF S. B. Schenck Planing Machine, Attleboro Massachusetts. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (50-75) 532 - LOW 327 / HT-170 R7 Raw VF+ Well struck and nicely centered on a large nearly 30mm planchet. William Rutter Songs and Ballads Boston Massachusetts. Rare variety usually seen in lower grades and/or damaged, this example is a happy exception. The best one of our prior sales could offer was a slightly porous VF with residues and short scratches in our June 2005 sale that realized $312. From the Maurice Shepherd collection earlier from PCAC's June 2015 sale and one of the last pieces added to Maurice's collection. (750-1000) 533 - LOW 328 / HT-171 R1 Raw EF Alfred D. Willard, Boston Massachusetts with vintage comb pictured. (50-75) 534 - LOW 348 / HT-210 R4 Raw EF Details With a few light marks. N. Safford Temperance House, Albany New York. An EF realized $302.50 in our June 2013 auction. From the Maurice Shepherd and Gilbert Steinberg collections, earlier from Bowers and Merena's November 2002 sale where it sold for $173. (200-300) 535 - LOW 358 / HT-418 R4 Raw VF+ Spering, Mixsell & Innes Dry Goods, Philadelphia Pennsylvania. A very scarce merchant, particularly problem free. An EF retoning from an old cleaning brought $314.60 in our September 2010 sale. From the Maurice Shepherd collection earlier from Charles Kirtley. (400-500) 536 - LOW 364 / HT-M17 R4 Raw UNC Details Obverse stain near mouth. Wm. J. Mullen Gold Dial Manufacturer, New York with a detailed reverse scene featuring angels. Struck by Charles Cushing Wright from die cut by Louisa Lander apparently in 1847. From the David Litrenta collection. (150-200) 537 - LOW 364 / HT-M17 R4 Raw EF+ Wm. J. Mullen Gold Dial Manufacturer, New York with a detailed reverse scene featuring angels. An EF sold for $200.64 in our September 2010 sale. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection, earlier from our December 2012 sale. (200-300) 538 - LOW 366 / HT-M19 R2 Raw AU C. D. Peacock Jeweler, Chicago with displaying Peacock and Time Is Money reverse. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (75-100) 539 - LOW 367A / HT-M21 R2 Raw AU+ C. D. Peacock Jeweler, Chicago with displaying Peacock and Time Is Money reverse. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 540 - LOW 368 / HT-M23 R2 Raw MS62 30% Red. C. D. Peacock Jeweler, Chicago with displaying Peacock and Time Is Money reverse. Rarely seen this nice. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (200-300) 541 - LOW 370 / HT-298 R6 NGC AU53 New York & Harlaem Rail Road Company struck in German Silver with vintage carriage signed B & S NY for Bale and Smith. An example in NGC AU50 brought $1,200 in our February 2014 sale. From the Maurice Shepherd collection earlier from PCSC's December 2004 auction. (1500-2000) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Hard Times Tokens

542 544 547 542 - LOW 383 / HT-410 R4 NGC MS61 70% Bright and nearly Proof Like. Samuel & Joseph Harvey Cutlery, Philadelphia Pennsylvania. Rarely seen this nice. From the Maurice Shepherd collection earlier from Bowers and Merena's June 1996 sale. (500-750) 543 - LOW 386B / HT-417B R8 NGC VF30 Trace Bright more than 10% original Gilt remaining. Smith & Brothers Cutlery, Philadelphia. A raw EF brought $354 in our June 2013 auction. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III and John Ford collections. (200-300) 544 - LOW 398A / HT-385A R8 NGC MS62 40% Bright. Isaac Barton & Co., Philadelphia Pennsylvania. Vary scarce variety with reeded edge (overrated at R8), but rare in Uncirculated condition. Another NGC MS62 example brought $1,056 in our March 2010 auction. From the Maurice Shepherd collection earlier from Bowers and Merena's June 1996 sale. (1000-1500) 545 - LOW 403A / HT-147A R5 Raw VF+ Early die state without usual die cracks. Randall & Co. Baltimore Maryland struck in German Silver. A similar example sold for $346.50 in our September 2010 auction. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (300-400) 546 - LOW 406 / HT-402B R7 Raw FINE With traces of original Gilt plating around some of the letters. Buehler's & Smith Cutlery, Philadelphia Pennsylvania. A rare and underrated merchant and variety. A similar example but with more Gilt remaining brought $363 in our June 2011 auction. From the Maurice Shepherd collection, earlier from us and still earlier Charles Litman. (200-300) 547 - HT-A168 R9 Raw VF Coin VG holed and plugged with rim bump. W. D. Phyfe Pure Silver Coin Boston counterstamped on a 1813 Italian 5 Lire. William Phyfe was a silversmith in Boston Massachusetts in the 1830's. Thought to be Unique and the Rulau plate specimen. From the Maurice Shepherd and Gregory Brunk collections, earlier from World Exonumia's November 2006 sale. (750-1000) 548 - HT-213 R5 Raw EF Details With a number of light marks. W. A. Thomson, Buffalo New York popular large size token picturing a large anvil and hammer. Unlisted in Low. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 549 - HT-214 R4 Raw EF Details With some short scratches. W. A. Thomson, Buffalo New York picturing a large anvil and Tea Pot. Unlisted in Low. Scarce, an EF with light reverse scratches sold for $144 in our June 2013 sale. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 550 - HT-415B R4 Raw VF Coin GOOD. H. REES on the obverse of an 1802 Large Cent. Rees was a Philadelphia blacksmith in the late 1830's. From the Maurice Shepherd collection earlier from PCAC's December 2004 sale. (100-150) 551 - HT-C420 R7 Raw VF Coin VG with some light marks. F. A. VACHE on the obverse of an 1831 Large Cent. Francis A. Vache was listed as a Philadelphia machinist. From the Maurice Shepherd collection earlier from PCAC's December 2004 sale. (150-200) 552 - HT-E464A R7 Raw VF Coin VG. W. H. SCOTT twice intersecting on the obverse of an 1828 Half Cent. Rulau attributes this stamp to William H. Scott a dry goods merchant from Philadelphia. We sold a similar example of the more available Large Cent planchet for $121 in our January 2015 sale. From the Maurice Shepherd and Gregory Brunk collections, earlier from World Exonumia's November 2006 sale. (200-300) 553 - HT-488 R6 Raw VF+ Tiny obverse rim bump. Dickson, White & Co. Watches, Philadelphia. Rare merchant. From the Maurice Shepherd collection earlier from our May 2001 auction where it realized $385. (500-750) 554 - HT-545 R5 Raw EF Coin VF. O & G with one star above and two below counterstamped on the obverse of an 1835 Half Cent. A mystery maverick awaiting identification. From the Maurice Shepherd and Gregory Brunk collections, earlier from World Exonumia's November 2006 sale. (100-150) 555 - HT-580A R5 Raw VF Chamberlain Woodruff & Scranton, Fair Haven Connecticut. This is the Reeded edge variety; we have yet to see the Plain edge version. Underrated and underpriced in Rulau. Particularly difficult to find problem free. A cleaned AU brought $362.40 in our September 2010 auction. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (400-500) 556 - HT-A800 R3 Raw EF Details Holed as always with some flattening near rim. Martin Van Buren 1840 with balance scale showing Democrats out weighing Whigs. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (50-75) 557 - HT-807 R3 Raw MS62 30% Bright, holed for suspension as are all. Henry Clay The Ashland Farmer 1844 Born April 12 1777 with an 1840 set of scales favoring Whigs over Democrats. Brass 24mm. DeWitt HC 1844-36. (150-200) 558 - HT-811 R3 Raw VF+ Holed for suspension as usual. Traces of original Gilt plating. Maj. Gen W. H. Harrison 1841 Go It Tip, Come It Tyler. Dewitt WHH 1840-28. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (50-75) 559 - HT-812 R4 Raw AU Holed for suspension as usual, 10% Bright with 40% original Gilt plating. Maj. Gen W. H. Harrison 1841 Go It Tip, Come It Tyler. Dewitt WHH 1840-37. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 560 - HT-815 R4 Raw AU+ Holed for suspension as usual, 30% Bright with 60% original Gilt plating. Maj. Genl W. H. Harrison The Peoples Choice In The Year 1840. Very rare this nice. A very similar example brought $160 in our December 2006 sale. Dewitt WHH 1840-50. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (150-200) 561 - HT-815E R4 Raw AU+ Holed for suspension as usual, 20% Bright with 60% original Gilt plating. Maj. Genl W. H. Harrison The Peoples Choice In The Year 1841. A variant of the listed piece with different date and three stars on epaulet. Dewitt WHH 1840-57. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (150-200) 562 - HT-815G R4 Raw AU Trace Bright, holed as always. Maj. Genl W. H. Harrison The Peoples Choice In The Year 1840. A variant of the listed piece with no stars on epaulet. An AU realized $82.50 in our December 2006 sale. Dewitt WHH 1840-53. From the Maurice Shepherd collection. (100-150) 563 - HT-820 R4 Raw EF Details Holed as always with small obverse spot. Maj. Genl W. H. Harrison The Peoples Choice The Hero Of Tippecanoe. Larger size 29mm. Dewitt WHH 1840-25. (50-75) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Hard Times Tokens 564 - HT-905 R7 Raw VF Coin VG but holed. W. LEVIS counterstamped in raised letters within a ribbon shaped depression on the obverse of a 1789 Mexico City Two Real. Rulau attributes this piece to Philadelphia silversmith William Levis and since 1836 is the latest dated coin he counterstamped, includes them in the Hard Times period. We sold a similar example in our February 2012 auction for $525. (500-750) Merchant Tokens 565 - MILLER CA 6 Raw AU 20% Red with light reverse planchet flaw. Joseph Brothers Watch Makers, Jewelers and Opticians, San Francisco California struck in Copper with Reeded edge. Very scarce early California token, 1854-1860. An EF example sold for $101 in our June 2013 sale. From the Ron Ward collection. (100-150) 566 - MILLER CT 14 Raw MS62 40% Red. J. E. Bassett & Co., New Haven Connecticut. (75-100)

567 578 590 567 - MILLER CT 27A R8 Raw VF Waterbury House 42 Church St N.H. signed WBD 6 Cent denomination struck in Brass. Waterbury house was located in New Haven Connecticut. William B. Dunbar was a diesinker from Waterbury Connecticut. Unlisted denomination in Adams and Miller. This is the Rulau Plate specimen. We mistakenly called Steve Tanenbaum's upgrade in our July 2014 sale the plate token. That NGC XF45 example realized $2,429. Still believed to be one of just three known and Steve owned two! The discovery specimen from the Steve Tanenbaum collection earlier for Charles Kirtley January 1981 and J. L. Hargett. (1500-2000) 568 - RULAU CT Wat 8 Raw MS62 30% Bright. Scovill Manufacturing Company, Waterbury Connecticut with scene of Pilgrims landing at Plymouth Rock 1620 signed J. E. Ellis. From our December 2006 sale where it brought $38.50. (50-75) 569 - MILLER IL 2 Raw MS63 20% Red. John Plane & Co. 1856, Belvidere Illinois struck in Copper with Plain edge. Anvil and stove pictured. (100-150) 570 - MILLER IL 16 NGC MS64 30% Bright with 20% original Silvering remaining all on one side. C. N. Holden Teas in Chests, Chicago Illinois struck in Silvered Brass. In holder labeled IL 14 the unplated Brass variety. (100-150) 571 - MILLER IL 40 Raw MS63 Peter Stumps, Chicago Illinois. Popular token featuring a vintage Fireman's Hat. (100-150) 572 - RULAU IN Unlisted Raw VF+ C. B Crickmore Watchmaker with blank reverse. Brass 26mm. According to Redfield & Logan's 1866 Business Guide Crickmore was a Jeweler, Watchmaker and dealer in Clocks located South Side Main between Washington and Adams in Knightstown Indiana. Rare early Indiana token likely used very near if not during the Civil War. Wright 214 (200-300) 573 - MILLER KY 2 Raw VF+ Brown, Curtis & Vance Louisville Kentucky struck in Copper with Plain edge. Very scarce merchant represented in Rulau by a drawing rather than photograph. (100-150) 574 - MILLER KY 36 NGC MS65 RB 10% Red and attractively toned. S. T. Suit Salt River Bourbon For Medical Use Only Kentucky Currency 1850, Jefferson County Kentucky struck in Copper. (400-500) 575 - MILLER MD 162 Raw MS62 10% Bright. Geo. P. Steinbach, Baltimore struck in Brass with Liberty head and eagle. Quite scarce this nice, a NGC MS62 brought $160 in our February 2014 auction. From the John Ford collection. (150-200) 576 - MILLER MA 30C Raw MS64 60% Red on the obverse, toned on the blank reverse. Not One Cent But Just As Good. Large cent look alike with blank reverse. (200-300) 577 - MILLER MA 56 Raw MS63 10% Bright. Jos. H. Merriam Medalist Die Sinker And Cutter, Boston Massachusetts struck in Brass 27mm with Plain edge with George Washington reverse die signed M for Merriam. A MS64 example of the Copper variety brought $261 in our August 2015 sale. Baker 560 From the Steve Tanenbaum and George Fuld collections earlier from Dorge's October 1975 auction. (200-300) 578 - MILLER MA 65 Raw MS63 30% Red. Jos. H. Merriam Die Sinker Medals Struck In Gold, Silver, Copper Or Tin, Boston Massachusetts with Labor Omnia Vicit reverse thought to be Merriam's self portrait, struck in Copper 31mm. Quite rare. Rulau MA Bo 73 From the Steve Tanenbaum collection and Byron Johnson estate. (300-400) 579 - MILLER MA 68 Raw MS63 With Bronzed like finish. Jos. H. Merriam Die Sinker Medals Struck In Gold, Silver, Copper Or Tin, Boston Massachusetts with Thomas Sayers Champion Of England 1859 reverse struck in Copper 31mm though this example has more of a Bronzed appearance similar to US Mint medals from this period. Sayers was a very popular boxer from an era when it was still illegal and before the use of gloves. He had a famous 37 round fight with John Heenan (also a Merriam subject) in 1860. Later they toured together reenacting their match. Another more traditional Copper MS63 brought $151 in our August 2015 auction. Rulau MA Bo 77 From the Steve Tanenbaum, Charles Litman and Don Miller collections. (150-200) 580 - MILLER MA 68 Raw UNC Details Retoning from cleaning. Jos. H. Merriam Die Sinker Medals Struck In Gold, Silver, Copper Or Tin, Boston Massachusetts with Thomas Sayers Champion Of England 1859 reverse struck in Copper 31mm. Sayers was a very popular boxer from an era when it was still illegal and before the use of gloves. He had a famous 37 round fight with John Heenan (also a Merriam subject) in 1860. Later they toured together reenacting their match. Rulau MA Bo 77 From the Dave Bowers reference set. (50-75) 581 - MILLER MA 69 Raw MS64 10% Red. Jos. H. Merriam Die Sinker Boston Massachusetts with John C. Heenan Champion of America 1859 reverse struck in Copper 31mm. Heenan was a very popular boxer from an era when it was still illegal and before the use of gloves. He had a famous 37 round fight with Thomas Sayer (also a Merriam subject) in 1860. Later they toured together reenacting their match. A MS63 sold for $160 in our August 2015 sale. Rulau Ma Bo 78 From the Steve Tanenbaum, Charles Litman and Don Miller collections. (200-300)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Merchant Tokens 582 - MILLER MA 69 Raw MS63 With Bronzed like finish. Jos. H. Merriam Die Sinker Boston Massachusetts with John C. Heenan Champion of America 1859 reverse struck in Copper 31mm though this example has more of a Bronzed appearance similar to US Mint medals from this period. Heenan was a very popular boxer from an era when it was still illegal and before the use of gloves. He had a famous 37 round fight with Thomas Sayer (also a Merriam subject) in 1860. Later they toured together reenacting their match. A MS63 example of the more traditional Copper sold for $160 in our August 2015 sale. Rulau Ma Bo 78 From the Steve Tanenbaum, Charles Litman and Don Miller collections. (150-200) 583 - RULAU MO StL 8 Raw MS63 Or a bit better with 70% Bright luster. St. Louis Refrigerator & Wooden Gutter Co. Manufacturer of Aluminum Bicycles 1894 with picture of vintage bike and enumeration of the new metals benefits. Aluminum 39mm. (75-100) 584 - MILLER NJ 14 Raw AU 20% Bright. Warrick & Stanger 1872, Glassboro New Jersey struck in White Metal with Plain Edge. Unlisted merchant in Rulau and much rarer than the Brass variety. (150-200) 585 - MILLER NJ 15 Raw MS63 Trace Red. Warrick & Stanger 1872, Glassboro New Jersey struck in Copper with Plain Edge. Unlisted merchant in Rulau and much rarer than the Brass variety. (100-150) 586 - MILLER NJ 16 Raw VF+ S. A. Whitney 1852, Glassboro New Jersey struck in Brass with Plain edge featuring a glass bottle. An EF realized $80 in our July 2012 auction. From the Bob Miller collection. (50-75) 587 - MILLER NJ 16A Raw AU Details With some dents as usual on this thin token. S. A. Whitney 1852, Glassboro New Jersey struck in very thin Brass with the reverse of the proceeding on a thin Brass planchet with incused image on reverse. From the Bob Miller collection. (50-75) 588 - RULAU NJ AC 33 Raw AU Details Holed for suspension. Young's Amusement Co. Merry Go Round, Atlantic City New Jersey struck in Red Vulcanite with Reeded edge (unlisted as such, but the third we have recorded) and view of lighthouse, shoreline and lady on horseback. An unholed AU sold for $74 in our July 2012 auction. From the Bob Miller collection. (50-75) 589 - MILLER NY 32 Raw MS62 20% Bright. James, Clark & Co., Hudson New York muled with the Sailing Ship reverse normally seen on Doremus & Nixon struck in Brass with Plain edge. Very rare. (200-300) 590 - MILLER NY 59A Raw MS63 Toned. American Museum P. T. Barnum Proprietor New York with building and bust of Barnum and list of attractions, Admission To The Whole Only 25 Cents struck in Silvered White Metal and unlisted as such. This die combination has been included in the Civil War Store Card book as a possible Civil War Token based on an April 1862 auction appearance though there is currently no proof it was not struck before the War. We sold a MS63 PL White Metal example for $750 in our August 2015 auction. Rulau NY-NY 11A From the Steve Tanenbaum collection, earlier from PCAC's January 1983 sale. (750-1000) 591 - MILLER NY 147 Raw AU 20% Bright. The Havana Express Carrington & Co., New York struck in White Metal with Reeded edge. Popular token picturing a man carrying a letter on a galloping horse labeled The First Expressman. A MS63 example in our December 2012 sale realized $230. (150-200) 592 - MILLER NY 156 Raw MS63 60% Bright. Chesebrough Stearns & Co. Dr. Sellek, New York struck in Brass with Reeded edge. (75-100) 593 - MILLER NY 178 Raw VF+ John Curtis Jeweler and Watch Maker 1860, New York struck in White Metal with Reeded edge. Johannes Allan reverse by George H. Lovett. (50-75) 594 - MILLER NY 180 Raw MS63 40% Red. John Curtis Jeweler and Watch Maker 1860, New York struck in Copper with Reeded edge. The Antiquary reverse. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection from Dave Schenkman August 1974. (200-300) 595 - MILLER NY 236 Raw MS64 70% Red. Farmers and Mechanics Life Insurance Co., New York struck in Copper with Plain edge. Rulau NY NY 72 (200-300) 596 - MILLER NY 252 Raw MS63 50% Bright. Finck's Hotel 9, struck in Brass with Plain edge. (100-150)

597 611 617 597 - MILLER NY 265 Raw VF With some light planchet striations as struck. Francis Patent Screw & Fancy Boat Establishment New York struck in Brass with Plain edge. Joseph Francis (1801-1893) was a famous boat builder and holder of many patents. On April 23, 1833 he received his first patent for a portable screw boat. It was called that not because it used a screw propeller, but instead because it was made in sections to be portable and was literally screwed together when ready for use. This seemingly places this token solidly within the Hard Times period and even though Rulau himself dates this issue to (1832-33) he still assigns it to the Early American section of his standard catalog. Exceedingly rare, Steve Tanenbaum had noted on his holder that this was the only example he had seen in 35+ years. Unfortunately, fate intervened and he was not able to see Ford's specimen when it was sold a few years ago. These are the only two we have seen offered. This is the Rulau plate specimen from the Steve Tanenbaum and Robert Lindesmith collections, earlier from Bowers and Merena's March 2000 sale where it brought $1,840. (1500-2000) 598 - MILLER NY 389 Raw MS62 10% Bright with some toning streaks and blotchy toning. Jennings, Wheeler & Co. 45 & 47 Chambers St., New York muled with 1860 Abraham Lincoln campaign token struck in Brass with Plain edge. Quite rare. Dewitt AL 1840-41B From the Steve Tanenbaum and Captain Andrew Zabriskie collections, earlier from Sotheby's June 1999 sale. (300-400) 599 - MILLER NY 393A Raw MS64 40% Red. Jennings, Wheeler & Co. 45 & 47 Chambers St., New York muled with N. C. Folger & Son New Orleans Louisiana token featuring Pelican on nest feeding young struck in Copper with Plain edge. Quite rare, a Brass example in MS62 sold for $277 in our August 2015 auction. From the Steve Tanenbaum, Charles Litman and Don Miller collections. (400-500) 600 - MILLER NY 405 Raw AU+ This piece is attributed to the 1820's by Rulau based on the possibility it was produced by Richard Trested, we believe the style is more suggestive of the Clinton Lunch piece that is currently listed in the Hard Times period. A similar example realized $154 in our October 1998 sale. (400-500) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Merchant Tokens 601 - MILLER NY 423 Raw MS61 40% Bright. C. Leighton 1st Premium Shirt Manufacturer, 10 Park Place New York and 5 Royal St. New Orleans struck in White Metal with Plain edge. Quite scarce and said to be one of just 25 struck. A MS63 sold for $223.99 in our July 2012 sale. From the Bob Miller collection. (100-150) 602 - MILLER NY 466 Raw MS64 60% Bright. Loder & Co. Importers 83 Cedar St., New York struck in Brass with Reeded edge. From the Ron Ward collection earlier from our October 2001 sale. (100-150) 603 - MILLER NY 488 NGC MS62 60% Bright and nearly Proof Like. Geo. H. Lovett Medal Die-Sinker, New York with reverse of Cupid being followed by Sea Serpent struck in White Metal with Reeded edge. Popular token, a raw MS62 brought $275 in our August 2015 sale. From the Bob Miller collection. (300-400) 604 - MILLER NY 488A Raw MS63 20% Red. Geo. H. Lovett Medal Die-Sinker, New York with reverse of Cupid being followed by Sea Serpent struck in Copper with Reeded edge. Popular token, a White Metal example in MS63 PL brought $375 in our August 2015 sale. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection earlier from Gilbert June 1976. (300-400) 605 - MILLER NY 502 Raw MS63 40% Bright. J. D. Lovett Wedding & Visiting Cards, Seals, Dies, Jewelry Engraved with New Congress Hall 1860 struck in Brass with Reeded edge. A MS64 brought $236 in our August 2015 sale. (200-300) 606 - MILLER NY 515 NGC MS64 RB 30% Red and nicely toned. Malcolm & Gaul British, French and American Dry Goods, New York struck in Copper with Plain edge. From the Bob Miller collection. (100-150) 607 - MILLER NY 599 Raw EF Moss' Hotel, New York with 3 / - (three shillings and no pence) on reverse struck in Brass with Plain edge. (50-75) 608 - MILLER NY 614 R5 Raw AU Wm. H. Mott Corner of Old Slip & Water Street, New York with Anvil pictured struck in Brass with plain edge. (200-300) 609 - MILLER NY 802 Raw MS64 60% Red. Scovill Manufacturing Company Daguerreotype Materials, New York struck in Copper with Plain edge. A MS63 sold for $160 in our August 2015 auction. From the John Ford collection. (200-300) 610 - MILLER NY 818 Raw MS62 20% Bright. F. B. Smith & Hartmann Die Sinkers, New York struck in Brass with Reeded edge and featuring an Indian Chief in feathered headdress. A NGC MS62 brought $335 in our February 2014 auction. (300-400) 611 - MILLER NY 820G NGC MS61 20% Bright. Young America of the 19th Century, The Brave, Fearless & Generous Hearted Fireman 30mm White Metal. Detailed die work signed S & H for Smith & Hartmann on both sides. Though thought to date from the 1860's when the firm seems most active the Young America die was latter used in the 1890's for an Aluminum striking of the E. Jacobs & Son New York store card. The Young American die is also known muled with a 1860's McClellan Civil War dog tag. A beautiful and intriguing token with many secrets yet to be discovered. From the Bob Miller collection. (750-1000) 612 - MILLER NY B823 Raw AU+ Silvered with 135 engraved on the blank reverse. Smithsonian House 606 Broadway struck in Silvered Brass with blank reverse engraved 135 and Plain edge. Other pieces known from this merchant with engraved numbers are the Rulau listed 15 plus a 40 and 45 in addition to this unlisted piece. All known so far are divisible by 5 indicating a value rather than a room or customer number. An interesting series. From the John Ford collection. (100-150) 613 - MILLER NY 859 Raw AU 10% Bright. Sweeny's Hotel and Sweeny's Dining Saloon, New York struck in German Silver with Plain edge counterstamped 87. (75-100) 614 - MILLER NY 921B Raw AU 10% Bright with 70% of Original Silvering. Tredwell Kissam & Co. Looking Glasses, New York struck in Silvered Brass with reeded edge. Rarely seen this nice. (100-150) 615 - MILLER NY 945 Raw EF+ Uriah Welch Proprietor, St. Nicholas and Richfield Spa New York. Attractive token with pictorial of rooster and a Griffin's head. From the John Ford collection. (100-150) 616 - MILLER NY 971 Raw MS63 80% Bright and Proof Like. Woodgate & Co. Wines, New York 1860 Represtd By J. N. T. Levick struck in White Metal with a reeded edge. From the John Ford collection. (150-200) 617 - MILLER NY 1008 NGC MS64 RB 30% Red and nearly Proof Like. M. L. Marshall's Variety Store 1860, Oswego New York with man fly fishing along a mountain stream struck in Copper with Plain edge. Exceptional quality. A similar raw example sold for $550 in our February 2014 auction. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (500-750) 618 - RULAU NY NY 16A Raw EF 10% Bright. Charles S. Stratton Known As Genl Tom Thumb 25 In High with view of Tom on desk surrounded by books, glass, wine bottle and desk set, signed Allen & Moore F: Birm 1844. Reverse has image of Tom Thumb's chariot with statistics signed Pub. By P. T. Barnum. Struck in White Metal 38.5mm. This version dated 1844 with larger right facing chariot is unlisted in Rulau. A similar example brought $106.88 in our June 2013 sale. From the Bob Miller collection. (100-150) 619 - RULAU NY NY A62 NGC MS63 Holed for suspension and Proof Like. Two Cities As One New York & Brooklyn Souvenir of the Opening of the East River Bridge May 24th 1883 1867-1883, White Metal 37mm. Nicely detailed view of bridge signed C. E. D. From the Bob Miller collection. (100-150) 620 - MILLER PA 129 NGC MS63 RB Or a bit better, 50% Red. W. A. Drown & Co., 246 Market St., Philadelphia 1857 Umbrellas & Parasols struck in Copper with Plain edge. From the Bob Miller collection. (100-150) 621 - MILLER PA 137 NGC MS63 RB 30% Red mostly on the obverse. W. A. Drown & Co. 1857 Philadelphia Pennsylvania with Umbrella pictured struck in Copper with Plain edge. From the Bob Miller collection. (100-150) 622 - MILLER PA 149 Raw AU Evan's & Watson Makers Dickeson's Coin & Medal Safe, Philadelphia with reverse of Sommer Islands Shilling on reverse struck in White Metal with Plain edge. A MS62 in our February 2014 sale brought $545. Rulau Pa Ph 46 (200-300)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Merchant Tokens

623 640 641 623 - MILLER PA 187C NGC MS63 RB 10% Red all on the reverse. Harbach's Original Walnut Candy, Philadelphia struck in Copper with Popular Libertas Americana reverse. Unlisted die combination in Adams and unlisted composition in Miller. A raw MS64 sold for $1,025 in our January 2015 sale. Rulau Pa Ph 930 (750-1000) 624 - MILLER PA 217 NGC MS62 RB 30% Red. W. Idler Dealer In Coins & Medals, Philadelphia. Made to resemble a 1659 Lord Baltimore Penny struck in Copper with Plain edge. Listed on the holder as PA-216/PA-223 an understandable choice given Rulau's confusing listing for this merchant, we choose to use Adams and Millers listings. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (150-200) 625 - MILLER PA 228F NGC AU50 W. Idler Dealer In Coins & Medals 111 N. 9th St., Philadelphia Dealer in Coins, Minerals, Shells, Antiques & c. with the obverse resembling obverse of a 1659 Lord Baltimore Penny struck in Copper Nickel with Reeded edge. Although unlisted as such, this is the third we have offered. A raw EF brought $82.50 in our June 2011 auction. Called the Copper PA228F on the holder. (100-150) 626 - MILLER PA 265 Raw AU+ 30% Bright and nearly Proof Like. Ornamental Medal & Seal Die Sinker & c. & c. 329 Arch St. Phila in small letters within large KEY on obverse and bust of Queen Victoria and Prince Albert with dolphins below on the reverse struck in White Metal with Plain edge. From the Bob Miller collection. (50-75) 627 - MILLER PA 313A Raw MS62 30% Bright. Lingg & Bro. Watches and Jewelry, Philadelphia struck in White Metal with popular Continental Minuteman reverse. Rulau PA Ph 237 From the Bob Miller collection. (50-75) 628 - MILLER PA 351 ICG MS66 80% Bright and nearly Proof Like. R. Lovett Jr. Die Sinker, Philadelphia Pennsylvania struck in German Silver with Plain edge and St. George slaying dragon on reverse. From the Bob Miller collection, earlier from our December 2008 sale. (300-400) 629 - MILLER PA 392½ Raw MS63 40% Bright. Pfaelzer Bros. Wholesale Jewelry Philadelphia Pennsylvania with Independence Hall reverse struck in Brass. Rulau PA Ph 324B. From the Don Boller collection. (100-150) 630 - MILLER PA 398 NGC XF45 BN Philadelphia Museum Charles Wilson Peale Founder Incorporated 1821 Admit The Bearer struck in Copper with Plain edge. Designed by Christian Gobrecht and struck at the US Mint around 1830. Rarely seen this nice. We sold a raw EF for $480 in our August 2015 auction. Julian UN-23 From the Bob Miller collection. (500-750) 631 - MILLER PA 581 Raw MS65 70% Bright and Proof Like. Dr. Williams Anti Dyspeptic Elixir F. G. Williams & Co. Philadelphia with Liberty Bell reverse struck in White Metal. Rare merchant not pictured in Rulau. Rulau Pa Ph 496. (100-150) 632 - RULAU PA Ph 246 Raw MS64 80% Bright and Proof Like. Lingg & Bro. Watches & Jewelry, Philadelphia Independence Hall 1876. Unusual Centennial token on an oval planchet. (150-200) 633 - RULAU PA Unlisted Raw EF Details With some light rim marks. Union Benevolent Association Philadelphia Coal Token Founded 1851. Black Hard Rubber 32mm. Listed as one to four known in the Coal Scrip book. It is also listed as a Possible Civil War token in the new Store Card book. (150-200) 634 - MILLER SC 9 Raw VF+ Details With some light stains and marks. W. W. Wilbur Auction & Commission Merchant 1846, Charleston South Carolina struck in Brass. Obverse 3 with Going At Only A Penny and reverse B with short bushy tree. Popular token featuring an auctioneer holding gavel. Thought to be one of the many auction houses that sold slaves during this period. A VF+ without the issues brought $265 in our July 2012 sale. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (100-150) 635 - MILLER TN 32 Raw EF+ Trace Bright. M. H. Miller & Co. Hatters, Memphis Tennessee struck in Brass with Reeded edge and Liberty head reverse. From the John Ford collection. (100-150) 636 - RULAU VA 103 NGC AU58 BN Very nice and exceeding well struck for issue with sharp date and nice toning. Marshall House 1859, Richmond Virginia. Popular token issued for the hotel where Colonel Ellsworth was shot and killed for removing the Confederate flag in 1861. A raw AU with small spots and normal weak date brought $155.33 in our August 2015 sale. From the Dr. W. Stokes Houck III collection. (200-300) 637 - RULAU Z47 Raw VF J. K. J. Ten Cents. A Civil War era piece that the late Steve Tanenbaum believed might turn out to be a Sutler token. Another example appeared as lot 1525 in Edward Cogan's September 1863 sale serving to limit the possible issue date. Still solving this mystery will likely require some brilliant sleuthing and more than just a little luck. (100-150) 638 - RULAU Y3C Raw MS63 30% Bright. Suspender Buttons 1837 1857 Contrahendo et Solvendo. Brass 19mm. An intriguing and enigmatic token; reading Russ Rulau’s summary of possible explanations for the issue made our head sore. (75-100) 639 - RULAU Y3E Raw MS63 30% Bright. Thursday 1863 Contrahendo et Solvendo. Brass 19mm. Seemingly related to the previous lot as they share a die. Will this make solving the mystery easier or more difficult? (100-150) Political Tokens 640 - PM 1796-1+ Cu NGC MS64 BN Well struck with attractive toning. End Of Pain with Thomas Paine hanging from gallows and Pandoras Breeches with burning pants and snake with man’s head removed with dagger on reverse. Struck in Copper 22mm. A Farthing size version of a type normally seen Half Penny size; in fact no Farthings are listed in Dewitt / Sullivan. Another NGC MS64 BN sold for $700 in our July 2014 sale. D&H-1110 From the Steve Tanenbaum collection. (1000-1500) 641 - PM 1796-2 Cu NGC MS63 Well struck with attractive light toning. End Of Pain May The Knave Of Jacobin Clubs Never Get A Trick with Thomas Paine pictured hanging on gallows. Struck in Copper 29mm on a thick plain edge planchet, unlisted as such. D&H-831 From the Steve Tanenbaum collection earlier from Jim King. (1500-2000)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Political Tokens 642 - AJACK 1824-2 Br Raw AU+ 10% Bright. Jackson Genl. Andrew Jackson (around bust three-quarters right) // Hero Of New Orleans (within wreath). Not holed as were many and exceptionally nice. Brass 25mm. (200-300) 643 - MF 1856-3 WM Raw MS63 50% Bright. Millard Fillmore (around bust right signed F. B. S. & H. N.Y.) // Be Vigilant and Watchful, That Internal Dissensions Destroy Not Your Prosperity. Quite nice and scarce. White Metal 35mm. (200-300)

644 648 649 644 - AL 1860-08 WM Raw AU 30% Bright. Abraham Lincoln Henning & Hymann NY (around bust right) //Thou Art The Man President 1861 A. I. Henning NY. White Metal 40mm. Rare, popular and distinctive Lincoln piece. Every time we see one of these we can't help but remember CRO's "A classy thing to yell at a golf tournament" ad in Coin World. We sold an AU+ example in Brass for $1,457.50 in our September 2010 sale. (1000-1500) 645 - AL 1860-38D Cu Raw VF Details With some small rim bumps. Abraham Lincoln Born Feb. 12. 1809. (around bust right signed Merriam) // Made From Copper Taken From The Ruins Of The Turpentine Works Newbern N.C/ Destroyed By The Rebels March 14. 1862. Copper 32mm. Rare muling, unlisted in Sullivan. An example in MS63 from our June 2013 sale brought $716. From the Bob Miller collection. (150-200) 646 - AL 1860-45F WM Raw MS63 50% Bright Abraham Lincoln Born Feb. 12 1809 (around bust right signed Merriam) Apollo Garden Good For 6 Cents Hess & Speidel. White Metal. Though other Hess & Speidel tokens sharing this die are listed as Civil War tokens, it is believed this was struck after the war. Miller MA 10, Rulau Ma Bo 31 and King 599. From the Henry South collection earlier from PCAC's December 1986 sale. (300-400) 647 - AL 1860-59 Br Raw MS64 50% Bright. Millions For Freedom 1860 Not One Cent For Slavery // Success To Republican Principles (around eagle). Brass 24mm (300-400) 648 - AL 1860-60 Silver NGC MS63 Nicely toned and nearly Proof Like. Millions For Freedom Not One Cent For Slavery // Success To Republican Principles (around eagle) struck in Silver 24mm. This variety is thought to have been struck in 1859 prior to the 1860 dated AL 1860-59 and is much scarcer in all compositions. This silver example is the rarest of all with only 6 examples reportedly struck. From the Mark Glazer and John Ford collections earlier from Stack's Bowers September 2013 sale. (2000-3000) 649 - C 1861-13 Br Raw EF Details With some light marks and minor reverse stains. Anti-Confederate Jefferson Davis 1861. (around man hanging from gallows) // Death To Traitors (counterstamped Becker). Brass 25mm. Quite popular due to the dramatic subject. From the Bob Miller collection. (400-500)

650 652 666 650 - AL 1864-05 Cu Raw MS64 30% Red with very sharp strike. Lincoln & Johnson Union Candidates 1864 (around high relief bust left signed W. H. Key F.) // Freedom To All Men. Union (around star with George Washington's bust). Copper 32mm. Very impressive, a similar example in our June 2013 sale realized $701. Baker 383A (750-1000) 651 - AL 1864-10 Slvd Br Raw MS63 30% Bright with nearly full Silvering. Lincoln Abraham Lincoln For President 1864 (around bust right) // US (on shield with eagle, flags, etc. surrounding). An EF+ example sold for $125 in our July 2009 auction. Silver Plated Brass 31mm. (400-500) 652 - AL 1864-31B NGC MS64 20% Bright and nearly Proof Like. Lincoln Abraham Lincoln 1864 (around bust right) // Chas. K. Warner. Dealer In American & Foreign Coins & Medals. 326 Chestnut St. Phila. Struck in Brass 25mm. King 614 Rulau Unlisted. Very rare. The Rulau listings are a bit confusing but this piece does not appear to be listed, in fact the NGC holder does not list any attribution but only "1864-Dated Phila PA Charles K. Warner, Coins." We sold a White Metal MS62 example for $480 in our July 2007 sale. (1000-1500) 653 - AL 1864-81 Br Raw EF+ Holed for suspension as usual. Traces of original Gilt plating. Lincoln 1864 (with stars around bust left) // Abraham Lincoln Freedom Justice Truth 1865. Brass 14mm. A Silvered Brass example in VF brought $120.51 in our October 2011 auction. From the Bob Miller collection. (150-200) 654 - GMcC 1864-41 Br Raw VF Details Holed for suspension with some old reverse scratches. (stars around bust left of McClellan) // George B. McClellan. Union, Peace, Prosperity. Brass 16mm. From the Bob Miller collection. (50-75) 655 - AJOHN 1866-6 Silver Mule Raw MS63 Toned. Very rare muling of the obverse of AJOHN 1866-6 and obverse of AJACK 1832-4 the obverse signed B for engraver William Barber. Apparently a US Mint medal but not listed in Julian and thought by a prior owner to be Unique. Silver 18mm. (400-500) 656 - USG 1868-30 Slvd Br Raw MS62 20% Bright with nearly full Silvering, holed for suspension. General U.S. Grant 1868 (around bust facing right with J. E. Ellis on truncation) // I Promise To Fight It Out On This Line If It Takes All Summer (around wreath). Rarely seen this nice. Silvered Brass 28mm (100-150)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Political Tokens 657 - USG 1868-35 Cu Raw EF Details Holed for suspension with obverse rim bump. Maj. Gen. U. S. Grant Vicksburg July 4 1863. (around bust right) // The Union Must And Shall Be Preserved Victory (around eagle). Copper 24mm. From the Bob Miller collection. (25-50) 658 - HS 1868-60 Br Shell Raw MS63 20% Bright. Horatio Seymour 1868 (around bust left) // Frank P. Blair Jr. 1868 (around bust right). A choice and visually very impressive example of this fragile campaign item. Embossed Brass shell with Silvered inner portion Brass colored frame 24mm with small loop at top for attaching to ribbon etc. (200-300) 659 - HG 1872-03 WM Raw MS62 40% Bright and nearly Proof Like. Horace Greeley (around bust left) // B. Gratz Brown (around bust right) struck in White Metal 28mm. Rare item with Greeley's running mate. (300-400) 660 - HG 1872-04 WM Raw MS63 60% Bright holed for suspension. Horace Greeley (around bust left) // Liberal Republican Candidate for President of the United States struck in White Metal 28mm. Another Rare Greeley piece. (150-200) 661 - GC 1892-08 Al Raw MS64 60% Bright and nearly Proof Like. Cleveland A Public Office Is A Public Trust. (round large bust right) // Democracy The Party Of The People 1892 (within wreath). Aluminum 38mm. Quite impressive. A MS63 in Copper sold for $205 in our October 2011 sale. (200-300) 662 - WM 1896 WM Raw UNC Details With Tin Pest mostly on the obverse. William McKinley (around bust left) // This Medal Was Struck In Commemoration Of The Patriots Of 1896 Who Voted For An Honest Dollar, Struck in White Metal 38mm. From the Bob Miller collection. (50-75) 663 - MVB-C Raw MS64 40% Bright. Martin Van Buren The Peoples Choice (around bust left) // Martin Van Buren VIII President of the United States. Struck in the 1860's for Philadelphia coin dealer Charles K. Warner and said to be one of just 15 struck. The obverse die by William Key copies that used on the rare Hard Times token Low 57 (MVB 18407). Brass 26mm. (150-200) 664 - WHH-B Lead Raw AU Details Covered with Tin Pest. William H. Harrison (around bust quarter left) // Ninth President of the United States (around log cabin with flag labeled TIP flying above) struck in Lead 45mm. (25-50) So-Called Dollars 665 - HK-020 R4 Raw MS64 Nicely toned and Proof Like. 1876 US Centennial Philadelphia struck in Silver. A toned MS62 sold for $200 in our June 2013 auction. US Mint medal Julian CM-10. (300-400) 666 - HK-086 R7 NGC MS66 1876 US Centennial Philadelphia struck in Red Gutta-Percha with Art Gallery from a different die from HK-083 without W. H. Key. F and different letter placement. Very rare. From the Don Boller collection. (1500-2000)

667 678 688 667 - HK-278A R6 NGC MS64 Nearly Proof Like Bronzed 1897 Grant's Tomb Dedication with bust right and edifice struck in Bronze. (400-500) 668 - HK-279 R6 Raw MS63 20% Bright with nearly full Silvering. 1897 Grant's Tomb Dedication with bust left struck in what appears to us to be a Silvered Brass or Silvered Bronze. This piece is currently listed in White Metal and Bronze; this could then be unlisted or just a difference in terminology. We sold a MS62 Bronze example in our September 2010 auction for $388.50. (400-500) 669 - HK-310 R5 Raw MS63 70% Bright and fully Proof Like. 1904 Louisiana Purchase Exposition St. Louis Missouri Dollar struck in Brass. (100-150) 670 - HK-349 R4 Raw AU+ 30% Bright. 1907 Jamestown Exposition Norfolk Virginia struck in Brass apparently Gilt plated as struck. Varieties exist but this is the variety pictured. (50-75) 671 - HK-354 R4 Raw AU 1909 Alaska-Yukon-Pacific Exposition Seattle Washington Official Medal struck in Bronze. (50-75) 672 - HK-374 R5 Raw AU+ 10% Bright. 1909 Hudson-Fulton Celebration Hendrik Hudson Daalder struck in aluminum. Small 15mm, the Gold Dollar. (50-75) 673 - HK-463 R2 Raw AU+ 1933 Century of Progress Dollar struck in Bronze. (25-50) 674 - HK-834 R5 Raw EF 1897 Bickford Dollar struck in Aluminum with Bronze center. Variety with mound labeled Gold And Silver. (50-75) 675 - HK-852a R4 Raw MS63 Nearly Proof Like. Continental Dollar Restrike struck in Silver. The Bashlow restrike with a small S on reverse, one of 2,000 struck. A similar example brought $191.09 in our January 2015 sale. (150-200) Miscellaneous by Topic 676 - Cent PCGS AU55 A well struck example of a US coin sometimes used as a planchet for Civil War token collector strikes. From the Bob Miller collection. (300-400) 677 - Baker 91B R2 Raw MS63 George Washington Time Increases His Fame. Bronzed 27mm. (50-75) 678 - Baker 240B R7 NGC MS63 60% Bright and nearly Proof Like. First In War, First In Peace And First In The Hearts Of His Countrymen George Washington and Lincoln Reverse. Brass 28mm. Popular token not only due to the presence of Abraham Lincoln but also the controversy surrounding the meaning of the inscription. Is it saying that Lincoln is the opposite REVERSE of Washington or was it just a die sinker misunderstanding that Lincoln should be on the reverse? A MS64 example in Copper sold for $650 in our June 2013 sale. (500-750) 679 - Baker 279 R7 Raw MS64 Toned. The Constitution is Sacredly Obligatory on All US Mint Oath of Allegiance Taken by the Officers and Workmen Sept. 2. 1861 Jas. Pollock, Dir. Struck in Silver 30mm at US Mint signed Paquet and said to be one of just 259 struck. Julian CM-2. (400-500) 680 - Baker 279B R5 Raw MS64 The Constitution is Sacredly Obligatory on All US Mint Oath of Allegiance Taken by the Officers and Workmen Sept. 2. 1861 Jas. Pollock, Dir. Struck in Bronze 30mm at US Mint and signed Paquet. Julian CM-2. (50-75)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Miscellaneous by Topic 681 - Baker 360A R6 Raw MS64 Philadelphia Rifle Club with George Washington bust. Struck in 1871 as an award medal commemorating its 25th anniversary. Bronzed 26mm. (50-75) 682 - Baker 412A R5 Raw AU Centennial Reception Feby. 22nd 1876 Academy of Music NY with portraits of George and Martha Washington struck in Copper 27mm and signed G.H.L. (George H. Lovett). From the Bob Miller collection. (50-75) 683 - Bolen JAB-04 Br Raw MS61 20% Bright mostly on the reverse. US Arsenal, Springfield Massachusetts struck in Brass 28mm. Bolen struck 75 examples in Brass. From the Bob Miller collection. (100-150) 684 - Bolen JAB-04 WM Raw UNC Details 20% Bright with a number of light rim marks. US Arsenal, Springfield Massachusetts struck in White Metal 28mm. Though an unknown number were struck by Edwards in White Metal (Tin) they seem to be much rarer than either the Copper or Brass varieties of which 75 examples of each were made by Bolen. From the Bob Miller collection. (150-200) 685 - Bolen JAB-21 WM Raw AU Moore Brothers Photographic Artists Springfield Massachusetts struck in White Metal 27.9mm, 1.8mm thick. One of 400 struck in White Metal. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection, earlier from Paul Koppenhaver in February 1980. (300-400) 686 - Bolen JAB-23 Cu Raw MS62 Reverse double struck with some rotation between strikes. Springfield Antiquarians Massachusetts 1866 struck in Copper 27.9mm, 2.5mm thick. One of just 14 said to have been struck by Bolen. We sold an MS63 in our July 2009 sale for $610. From the Dave Bowers reference set. (500-750) 687 - Bolen JAB-24 Br Raw MS63 30% Bright. J. A. Bolen 1867 Die Sinker & C. Springfield Mass not signed Bolen struck in Brass 25.4mm, 2.7mm thick. One of just 15 struck. A MS64 example in Copper brought $450 in our August 2015 sale. From the Steve Tanenbaum, John Ford and F. C. C. Boyd collections, earlier from Bowers and Ruddy's October 1982 sale. (300-400) 688 - Bolen JAB-30 Cu Raw MS64 20% Red and nicely toned. Libertas Americana J. A. Bolen 1867 struck in Copper 25.5mm, 2.8mm thick. One of just 16 struck in copper. A MS63 sold for $1,800 in our August 2015 auction. From the Steve Tanenbaum, Charles Litman and Don Miller collections. (1500-2000) 689 - Bolen JAB-30 WM Raw MS60 20% Bright with some minor Tin Pest. Libertas Americana J. A. Bolen 1867 struck in White Metal 25.6mm and 2.6mm thick. Said to be the only example struck in White Metal (3 per AJN). A MS62 example in Brass also thought to be Unique realized $3,300 in our August 2015 auction. From the Steve Tanenbaum and Henry South collections, earlier from Chuck Kirtley's March 1990 sale. (750-1000) 690 - Bolen JAB-35 WM Slvd Raw MS63 Toned and attractively so on the reverse. J. A. Bolen 1869 Die Sinker & C. Springfield Mass struck in Silvered White Metal 25.5mm, 2.2mm thick. Thought to be one of just 50 pieces struck in White Metal. From the Steve Tanenbaum and J. A. Bolen collections, earlier from a Bowers & Merena auction Lot 2262. (200-300)

691 694 698 691 - Bolen JAB-35 Wood Raw MS63 J. A. Bolen 1869 Die Sinker & C. Springfield Mass struck in Wood 24.9mm, 3.0mm thick. Unique and unlisted in Musante. Bolen's own Unique Silver example of this die pair brought $9,050 in our August 2015 sale. From the Steve Tanenbaum collection, earlier from Broadway Coin in May 1987 for $200. (750-1000) 692 - Bolen JAB-41 Cu Raw MS62 30% Red more so on the reverse. Masonic Building, Springfield Massachusetts 1892 struck in Copper 29mm. Thought to be one of just 250 struck in this composition. We sold an AU+ example for $96.59 in our July 2014 auction. From the Bob Miller collection. (150-200) 693 - Bolen JAB-K-08 WM Raw MS63 60% Bright and Proof Like. Recorder of Deeds 1875 David H. Lane with Bolen's Lincoln reverse struck in White Metal struck by Philadelphia coin dealer John Kline. Very rare. Miller NY 416 Rulau NY NY 145 but is actually from Philadelphia. King 610. From the Steve Tanenbaum and Andrew Zabriskie collections, earlier from Sotheby's June 1999 sale (400-500) 694 - Bolen JAB-M/E-12 Br Raw MS63 20% Bright. Mason / Edwards muling of J. A. Bolen, Die Sinker, And Medalist. Springfield, Mass. with Inimica Tyrannis Americana reverse struck in Brass. Very rare, Musante lists just a single auction record in Brass, it more than 100 years ago. From the Steve Tanenbaum, Dave Bowers, Charles Litman, Don Miller and Henry Chapman collections. (1000-1500) 695 - Bolen JAB-W-06 Cu Raw MS60 20% Red with small reverse stain. Woodward muling of Bolen's Washington portrait with Merriam's Apollo Garden store card struck in Copper 27.8mm, 2.4mm thick. Very rare, just 5 struck per Woodward's March 1897 auction catalog. A MS65 example in White Metal brought $750 in our August 2015 auction. Baker 540 and Rulau Ma Bo 37 From the Steve Tanenbaum, Richard Picker and George Parsons collections, earlier from George Fuld November 1973 and Henry Chapman June 1914. (400-500) 696 - Bolen JAB-W-07 WM Raw MS62 49% Bright and nearly Proof Like. Woodward muling of Bolen's The Father Of Our Country with Merriam's Apollo Garden store card struck in White Metal 28.0mm, 1.7mm thick. Very rare, just 5 struck per Woodward's December 1882 auction catalog. An example in MS63 PL sold for $600 in our August 2015 auction. Baker 541 and Rulau Ma Bo 37a From the Steve Tanenbaum and Gilbert Steinburg collections, earlier from Stack's May 1992. (500-750) 697 - Children's Award Medal Raw AU Holed for suspension and engraved to the recipient C. H. Miller. Francis Asbury Centenary of American Methodism 1866 Children's Medal. Brass 30mm. (25-50) 698 - First Steam Coinage NGC MS65 BN Bronzed, nearly Proof Like and quite attractive. United States Mint First Steam Coinage Mar. 23. 1836 struck in Bronze 28mm. One of just 261 originals struck with the corrected date over the first scheduled date of Feb. 22 although a later strike with only traces of the prior date remaining. We sold a raw AU with similar die state for $341 in our December 2010 auction. Julian MT-21 (1000-1500)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Miscellaneous by Topic 699 - Funeral Train Coin Raw EF Coin 1899 Cent is well flattened with the date and a few other details barely visible on obverse; reverse is more visible. MC KINLEYS / FUNERAL / TRAIN. / 9. 18. 1901. From the Bob Miller collection. (25-50) 700 - Funeral Train Coin Raw EF Coin 1901 Nickel unevenly flattened with much detail of an AU or so Coin. MCKINLEY / SEPT / 18. From the Bob Miller collection. (25-50) 701 - Funeral Train Coin Raw EF Coin 1910-D Quarter well flattened with minimal detail on either side. PRES. / W. G. HARDING / 8 - 9 - 23. From the Bob Miller collection. (25-50) 702 - Lincoln and Columbus medal Raw AU 1809 Abraham Lincoln 1865 (around bust right) // 1492 Christopher Columbus 1892 & 3 (around bust right). Copper 45mm with both sides signed H. Zearing. Eglit 85. From the Bob Miller collection. (50-75) 703 - Lincoln Memorial token Raw EF Details With two obverse nicks. Abraham Lincoln In God We Trust Assassinated April 16 1865 (with 25 under bust) // United States of America For Ever Inseparable 1864. Struck in White Metal 24mm. The meaning of 25 on the obverse has long been debated, given the motto In God We Trust being used on coins beginning is 1864 it has been suggested this is a proposal for a new quarter. Alternately, the 25 could represent the number of states still in the Union after the Confederate states succession. From the Bob Miller collection. (75-100) 704 - Lincoln Memorial token Raw EF Details Obverse rim nick. Abraham Lincoln 16 President of the United States Assassinated by the Plotters of Treason Apr. 14 1865 // Martyr of Liberty A. Lincoln Apr. 15. 1865 signed Lewis Joy New York. Brass 21mm. From the Bob Miller collection. (50-75) 705 - Lovett's Adams Residence Raw MS62 The Residence Of John Adams by George H. Lovett of New York struck around 1860 in Copper 35mm. From the Bob Miller collection. (75-100) 706 - Lovett's Old Middle Dutch Church Medal Raw MS63 50% Red and nearly Proof Like. Old Middle Dutch Church Nassau St. N.Y. Founded 1729 Finished 1731 Altered 1764 A Riding School for British Dragoons During the Revolutionary War. Struck in Cooper 34mm. Struck by George H. Lovett. Miller NY 83Jb (100-150) 707 - McClellan Satire by George H. Lovett Raw MS63 60% Bright and nearly Proof Like. General G.(UN) B.(OAT) McClellan Candied-Date For "Anything" Sweet // I Couldn't Be President In 1865 But I'll Be "Big Injun" In 1877 I'll Be Governor Of New Jersey!! Hooray!!! Struck in White Metal 31mm. A MS64 example in Copper sold for $151 in our July 2014 sale. From the Bob Miller collection. (150-200) 708 - Merriam Benjamin Franklin Medal Raw EF+ Benjamin Franklin Born Jan. 17, 1706 Diligence is the Mother of Good Luck Time is Money struck in White Metal 31mm. Obverse is signed by maker Merriam. From the Dave Bowers reference set. (50-75) 709 - Merriam Edwin Forrest Medal Raw MS64 60% Red and nearly Proof Like. Edwin Forrest Born March 9 1806 Just to Opposers and to Friends Sincere Rose by His Own Efforts struck in Copper 31mm. Both sides are signed by maker Merriam Boston. From the Dave Bowers reference set. (75-100) 710 - Merriam Edwin Forrest Medal Raw MS62 30% Red. Edwin Forrest Born March 9 1806 Just to Opposers and to Friends Sincere Rose by His Own Efforts struck in Copper 31mm. Both sides are signed by maker Merriam Boston. From the Dave Bowers reference set. (50-75) 711 - Merriam Thomas Sayers Medal Raw AU+ 20% Bright. Thomas Sayers Champion of England 1859 Heenan & Sayers Fought April 17, 1860 Heenan Victorious struck in White Metal 31mm. Reverse signed M by maker. Sayers was a very popular boxer from an era when it was still illegal and before the use of gloves. He had a famous 37 round fight with John Heenan (also a Merriam subject) in 1860. Later they toured together reenacting their match. From the Dave Bowers reference set. (50-75) 712 - Norse American Centennial Medal 1925 PCGS MS64 With light toning and nice luster. North American Centennial 1825 1925 Authorized by Congress of the United States of America, A.D. 1000. Struck at the US Mint in Philadelphia these were designed by James Earle Fraser of Buffalo Nickel fame and signed Opus Fraser on the reverse. This Thin planchet variety was the first struck and the scarcer of the two thicknesses with just 6,000 originally struck. From the Bob Miller collection. (500-750) 713 - Philadelphia Retail Grocers 1888 Medal NGC MS60 30% Bright and holed for suspension. Retail Grocers Association of Philadelphia Third Annual Jubilee Aug. 9th 1888 struck in White Metal, 38mm though the holder notes 48mm. The obverse features a wonderful design of a grocer behind the counter surrounded by a detailed depiction of his wares. From the Bob Miller collection. (75-100) 714 - Sage's Historical Tokens No. 1a Raw MS63 20% Red. The Old Provost, N.Y. A British Prison During The Revolution. The British "Brison" spelling error. Copper 31mm Plain edge. A similar example realized $161.55 in our August 2015 sale. From the Dave Bowers reference set. (150-200) 715 - Sage's Historical Tokens No. 1a Raw MS62 The Old Provost, N.Y. A British Prison During The Revolution. The British "Brison" spelling error. Copper 31mm Plain edge. A similar example realized $82 in our August 2015 sale. From the Dave Bowers reference set. (100-150) 716 - Sage's Historical Tokens No. 1a Raw AU+ The Old Provost, N.Y. A British Prison During The Revolution. The British "Brison" spelling error. Copper 31mm Plain edge. From the Dave Bowers reference set. (50-75) 717 - Sage's Historical Tokens No. 1a Raw AU Details Retoning from cleaning. The Old Provost, N.Y. A British Prison During The Revolution. The British "Brison" spelling error. Copper 31mm Plain edge. From the Dave Bowers reference set. (25-50) 718 - Sage's Historical Tokens No. 1a Raw AU Details Small obverse spot. The Old Provost, N.Y. A British Prison During The Revolution. The British "Brison" spelling error. Copper 31mm Plain edge. From the Dave Bowers reference set. (25-50) 719 - Sage's Historical Tokens No. 6b Raw MS62 40% Bright. State House, Philadelphia The Patriots Rendezvous In '76 signed G.H.L. on obverse. The corrected spelling of Rendezvous with Z cut over S. White Metal 31mm Plain edge. From the Dave Bowers reference set. (100-150) 720 - Sage's Historical Tokens No. 7 Raw MS62 The Home of Washington Mount Vernon, The Women of American Noble Preservers of Our Father's Home signed G.H.L. on obverse. Copper 31mm Plain edge. A similar example realized $140 in our August 2015 auction. From the Dave Bowers reference set. (100-150) 721 - Sage's Historical Tokens No. 7 Raw AU The Home of Washington Mount Vernon, The Women of American Noble Preservers of Our Father's Home signed G.H.L. on obverse. Copper 31mm Plain edge. From the Dave Bowers reference set. (50-75) 722 - Sage's Historical Tokens No. 8 Raw MS62 Trace Red. The Old Hasbrook House Newburg NY, Washington's Head Quarters 1782-3 signed G.H.L. on obverse. Copper 31mm Plain edge. From the Dave Bowers reference set. (100-150) 723 - Sage's Historical Tokens No. 8 Raw MS62 20% Red. The Old Hasbrook House Newburg NY, Washington's Head Quarters 1782-3 signed G.H.L. on obverse. Copper 31mm Plain edge. From the Dave Bowers reference set. (100-150) 724 - Sage's Historical Tokens No. 8 Raw AU The Old Hasbrook House Newburg NY, Washington's Head Quarters 1782-3 signed G.H.L. on obverse. Copper 31mm Plain edge. From the Dave Bowers reference set. (50-75) Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate Miscellaneous by Topic 725 - Sage's Historical Tokens No. 9 Raw MS62 Richmond Hill House, NY Erected 1760, Washington's Head Quarters May, 1776. Copper 31mm Plain edge. From the Dave Bowers reference set. (100-150) 726 - Sage's Historical Tokens No. 9 Raw AU+ Richmond Hill House, NY Erected 1760, Washington's Head Quarters May, 1776. Copper 31mm Plain edge. From the Dave Bowers reference set. (50-75) 727 - Sage's Historical Tokens No. 10 Raw MS62 Washington's Headquarters At Tappan, Liberty Tree. Copper 31mm Plain edge. From the Dave Bowers reference set. (100-150) 728 - Sage's Historical Tokens No. 10 Raw AU Details Retoning from cleaning with a few tiny spots. Washington's Headquarters At Tappan, Liberty Tree. Copper 31mm Plain edge. From the Dave Bowers reference set. (25-50) 729 - Shell Card Raw AU 20% Bright. Van Amburch & Co. Great Golden Menagerie is coming into Vermont in July or August with 1868 Liberty Head shell and yellow card. This traveling circus wintered at Brewster's Station New York. Bowers NY-840 (200-300) 730 - Shell Card Raw FINE Details Mirror cracked with some silvering missing or disturbed. Pickering's Furnishing House 994 Elm St. Manchester Pat. June 16, 1868 pin cushion mirror. Per an 1875 Manchester NH town history J. W. C. Pickering was the proprietor. Bowers Unlisted (150-200) 731 - Sumner Memorial Token Raw MS64 20% Red mostly on the reverse. Take Care Of My Civil Rights Bill (around bust right) // In Memory Of Chas Sumner Born 1811 Died 1874. Copper 19mm. Sumner was a leader in the Anti Slavery movement and was nearly killed on the Senate floor in 1856 by South Carolina Representative Preston Brooks. Quite a bit scarcer than the White Metal variety usually seen. (150-200)

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com Steve Hayden Mail Bid Sale #43 Closing January 31st, 2016

Lot Description Grade Comments/Estimate

Remember No Buyer’s Fee, every lot pictured and Live Online Bidding all at civilwartokens.com