DOCSLIB.ORG

The Genpei Jōsuiki and the Historical Narration of the Genpei War

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Genpei Jōsuiki and the Historical Narration of the Genpei War CHAPTER ONE THE GENPEI jōsuiki AND THE HISTORICAL NARRATION OF THE GENPEI WAR On the second month of the first year of Hōgen, a rebellion broke out in the Japanese realm, and from this moment the age of the warrior began. (Jien, 1221) As the Japanese court thinker Jien (1155–1225) observed in the political his- tory Gukanshō (1221), the latter half of the twelfth century was a period of historical turmoil. Three conflicts—the Hōgen Rebellion (1156), the Heiji Rebellion (1159–1160), and the Genpei War (1180–1185)—shook the polity as numerous elite and non-elite institutional players, including emperors and retired emperors, temples and shrines, military aristocrats and local strongmen, jockeyed for power. The last of these conflicts, the Genpei War, led to the birth of the shogunate, or government run by warriors. The historical record shows that the emergence of warrior power was the culmination of two centuries of institutional and social change. Yet, the hundred-odd variant texts of the Heike monogatari (Tales of the Heike; hereafter Heike) imagine a world at a critical turning point. As imperial authority declines in this world, bitterly opposed religious and political factions plunge the realm into war; peace returns to the realm only after the timely intervention of the future shogun Minamoto Yoritomo. Echoing Jien’s remark about epochal shift, the Heike presents the transition from a courtly era to the musa no yo (age of the warrior) as a fait accompli. These tales, though begun around Jien’s time, were completed dur- ing the fourteenth century as new political struggles were unfolding. In 1336, for example, the warrior Ashikaga Takauji (1305–1358) drove out the sitting Emperor Go-Daigo (1288–1339) from the capital of Kyoto to estab- lish the Muromachi shogunate. For the next sixty years of the Nanbo- kuchō (Northern and Southern Courts, 1336–1392) period, the shogunate remained at the helm of a polity divided between the Northern court established by Ashikaga Takauji and the Southern court established by his rival Go-Daigo. The political turmoil of the fourteenth century functioned as a crucible for the creation of multiple accounts of shogunal rule in texts such as the Baishōron (Discourse of Plums and Pines, 1352–1388) and 2 chapter one Gen’ishū (Tales of Minamoto Authority, 1387–1389), and painting scrolls like the Gosannen kassen emaki (Illustrated Tale of the Latter Three Years War, 1347), Yasuhira seibatsu-e (Illustrated Tale of the Defeat of Yasuhira, 1359?), and Suwa daimyōjin ekotoba (Suwa Shrine Scroll, 1356) (see chapter 6 of this volume). In many of these texts, the twelfth-century past became a foundational moment—an origin imbued with significance—from which subsequent Japanese history could be narrated. The impulse to re-narrate the Genpei War in the Heike was an integral part of this historiographical enterprise, designed to provide shape to a chaotic past such that it legiti- mated the present and underwrote a future for shoguns. The Heike corpus is thus frequently characterized as the ‘charter myth of warrior order.’ To scholars who read the English translation of the Heike, this aphorism has always been confusing, since the canoni- cal Kakuichibon variant (1371) does very little to valorize the first shogun Minamoto Yoritomo. More critically, readers lack an understanding of the iconography used to narrate this historic shift. This book tackles our misconception of Yoritomo’s small textual footprint by showing that the mythicization of warrior power is clearest in the last and longest vari- ant, the Genpei jōsuiki (late fourteenth c.). I suggest, by extension, that the twelfth-century past was subject to ongoing interpretation in the retrospective glance of the Heike corpus, creating ever more detailed accounts of shogunal power. With respect to the second problem—that of the iconographic construction of warrior power—I contend that the Heike incorporates symbolic frames rooted in ritual and material culture to contain violence, and to evoke social and political order. These frames, often overlooked when the text is treated as an autonomous whole, reveal that texts coexist with a range of phenomena that form a culture’s signifi- cative systems. The rituals, customs, and objects taken up in this study are not “deposits” of an anterior historical reality; they are expressive devices through which historical change is explained. These symbolic strategies, alternately celebratory and domesticating, reveal that the scripting of sho- gunal power in the Heike corpus was not just concerned with the legiti- mation of a new polity, as the term ‘charter myth’ might indicate. Writing about warrior power was equally about domesticating and regulating war- rior violence. The Late Heian World and the Genpei War Fictional portrayals of the Genpei War frequently dramatize the con- flict as the settling of scores between two families, the Taira and the .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Heike Legacies
    Mikael Adolphson, Anne Commons, eds.. Lovable Losers: The Heike in Action and Memory. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press, 2015. 284 pp. $55.00, cloth, ISBN 978-0-8248-4675-6. Reviewed by Naama Eisenstein Published on H-Buddhism (January, 2016) Commissioned by Erez Joskovich (Department of Philosophy Ben-Gurion University of the Negev) The close relationship of religion and politics and had the power to give new life to fgures al‐ in medieval Japan is well known and studied. In most forgotten by history. this new publication several scholars examine the Lovable Losers is the result of a four-year calculated combination of religious politics and process, beginning with an international confer‐ faith in Taira no Kiyomori’s (1118-81) rise to pow‐ ence in 2011 focusing on the Heike family and er. Due to its interdisciplinary nature, this book their cultural legacy. The discussions from that may not seem relevant to scholars of Japanese conference echo in the book even for those who, Buddhism at frst, but it is precisely that nature like me, were not lucky enough to participate in it. that exposes just how deeply embedded was Bud‐ The common ground of the chapters is laid out in dhism in premodern Japan. Kiyomori has been a well-written introduction, which surveys the immortalized as a temperamental and selfish chapters and clarifies the intentions and aims of tyrant, but from Lovable Losers he emerges a the writers, unifying twelve different papers into sharp leader, who understood well the religious, one coherent book. The book has two parts: the political, and social workings of his time, as well first focuses on the Heike and their activities dur‐ as how to use and adapt them.
    [Show full text]
  • Local Legends of the Genpei War: Reflections of Mediaeval Japanese History
    Local Legends of the Genpei War: Reflections of Mediaeval Japanese History By B a r b a r a L. A r n n Historians have characterized the twelfth century in Japan as a period of significant change, marked by political and military disturb­ ances, shrinkage of the landholdings and economic base of the ruling aristocracy, the emergence of new styles and genres in art and literature, and, symbolic of all the other changes and conflicts of the period, the Genpei War of 1180-1185, a civil war between adherents of two warrior families. The winning side, the Minamoto, established itself as the de facto political authority in the country and consolidated landholdings and civil power at the expense of the upper aristocracy, while the losing side, the Taira, were effectively destroyed as an independent political force. The Genpei War provided the subject matter for much of mediae­ val history and literature, which offer innumerable accounts of the lives of the nobles, priests, warriors and ladies who figured in the conflict. Mediaeval written sources are consistent in ignoring the commoners who were contemporary with these same warriors and nobles, but the commoners themselves could hardly be untouched by such momentous events, and they had their own versions to recount. An extensive body of local legends about the Genpei War arose in rural areas throughout Japan. These legends have persisted, or continued to be invented, into the present century, and they provide interesting evidence for the exist­ ence of a large audience with interests different from those expressed in written historical and fictional works treating the same period and the same characters.
    [Show full text]
  • Understanding Samurai Disloyalty
    New Voices Volume 2 To link to this article: http://dx.doi.org/10.21159/nv.02.05 Understanding Samurai Disloyalty Joshua Archer The University of Sydney Abstract Prevailing notions of samurai loyalty remain largely unopposed by Western scholarly literature. This should not be so. Minor efforts in recent scholarship have plainly shown that the stereotypical notion of samurai loyalty is fallacious. However, despite these assertions the myth remains a powerful and popular misconception. Clearly a greater scholarly undertaking is required. Through an in-depth historical analysis of samurai disloyalty, a more realistic conception of samurai behaviour may be achieved. This article seeks to provide a foundation for further research, arguing that disloyalty was favoured among samurai to further their personal ambitions or interests. Disloyalty between medieval samurai was not always considered morally deplorable, nor was it considered divergent to ‘normal’ samurai behaviour. Moreover, it is erroneous to argue that the majority of samurai were ‘loyal,’ when in fact many were often being coerced or manipulated by those in power. Logic suggests that loyalty must be voluntary, thus the use of coercion undermines assertions of samurai loyalty. Further scholarship should not merely seek to establish the frequency of samurai disloyalty, nor should it condemn such occurrences. It must endeavour to understand how and why disloyalty occurred. Keywords Samurai, Loyalty, Betrayal, Bakufu, Zanshin (残 心) Introduction In 1914, Takagi Takeshi, a scholar in Japanese literature, compared ‘Western Chivalry’ to ‘Japanese Bushidō,’ summarising bushidō into twenty rather broad doctrines.1 He wrote that in Western Chivalry, bravery was the highest virtue. Takagi argued that 1 Takagi, A Comparison of Bushi-do and Chivalry, pp.
    [Show full text]
  • Powerful Warriors and Influential Clergy Interaction and Conflict Between the Kamakura Bakufu and Religious Institutions
    UNIVERSITY OF HAWAllllBRARI Powerful Warriors and Influential Clergy Interaction and Conflict between the Kamakura Bakufu and Religious Institutions A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED TO THE GRADUATE DIVISION OF THE UNIVERSITY OF HAWAI'I IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY IN HISTORY MAY 2003 By Roy Ron Dissertation Committee: H. Paul Varley, Chairperson George J. Tanabe, Jr. Edward Davis Sharon A. Minichiello Robert Huey ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Writing a doctoral dissertation is quite an endeavor. What makes this endeavor possible is advice and support we get from teachers, friends, and family. The five members of my doctoral committee deserve many thanks for their patience and support. Special thanks go to Professor George Tanabe for stimulating discussions on Kamakura Buddhism, and at times, on human nature. But as every doctoral candidate knows, it is the doctoral advisor who is most influential. In that respect, I was truly fortunate to have Professor Paul Varley as my advisor. His sharp scholarly criticism was wonderfully balanced by his kindness and continuous support. I can only wish others have such an advisor. Professors Fred Notehelfer and Will Bodiford at UCLA, and Jeffrey Mass at Stanford, greatly influenced my development as a scholar. Professor Mass, who first introduced me to the complex world of medieval documents and Kamakura institutions, continued to encourage me until shortly before his untimely death. I would like to extend my deepest gratitude to them. In Japan, I would like to extend my appreciation and gratitude to Professors Imai Masaharu and Hayashi Yuzuru for their time, patience, and most valuable guidance.
    [Show full text]
  • Discourses on Religious Violence in Premodern Japan
    The Numata Conference on Buddhist Studies: Violence, Nonviolence, and Japanese Religions: Past, Present, and Future. University of Hawaii, March 2014. Discourses on Religious Violence in Premodern Japan Mickey Adolphson University of Alberta 2014 What is religious violence and why is it relevant to us? This may seem like an odd question, for 20–21, surely we can easily identify it, especially considering the events of 9/11 and other instances of violence in the name of religion over the past decade or so? Of course, it is relevant not just permission March because of acts done in the name of religion but also because many observers find violence noa, involving religious followers or justified by religious ideologies especially disturbing. But such a ā author's M notion is based on an overall assumption that religions are, or should be, inherently peaceful and at the harmonious, and on the modern Western ideal of a separation of religion and politics. As one Future scholar opined, religious ideologies are particularly dangerous since they are “a powerful and Hawai‘i without resource to mobilize individuals and groups to do violence (whether physical or ideological of violence) against modern states and political ideologies.”1 But are such assumptions tenable? Is a quote Present, determination toward self-sacrifice, often exemplified by suicide bombers, a unique aspect of not violence motivated by religious doctrines? In order to understand the concept of “religious do Past, University violence,” we must ask ourselves what it is that sets it apart from other violence. In this essay, I the and at will discuss the notion of religious violence in the premodern Japanese setting by looking at a 2 paper Religions: number of incidents involving Buddhist temples.
    [Show full text]
  • Samurai Life in Medieval Japan
    http://www.colorado.edu/ptea-curriculum/imaging-japanese-history Handout M2 (Print Version) Page 1 of 8 Samurai Life in Medieval Japan The Heian period (794-1185) was followed by 700 years of warrior governments—the Kamakura, Muromachi, and Tokugawa. The civil government at the imperial court continued, but the real rulers of the country were the military daimy class. You will be using art as a primary source to learn about samurai and daimy life in medieval Japan (1185-1603). Kamakura Period (1185-1333) The Kamakura period was the beginning of warrior class rule. The imperial court still handled civil affairs, but with the defeat of the Taira family, the Minamoto under Yoritomo established its capital in the small eastern city of Kamakura. Yoritomo received the title shogun or “barbarian-quelling generalissimo.” Different clans competed with one another as in the Hgen Disturbance of 1156 and the Heiji Disturbance of 1159. The Heiji Monogatari Emaki is a hand scroll showing the armor and battle strategies of the early medieval period. The conflict at the Sanj Palace was between Fujiwara Nobuyori and Minamoto Yoshitomo. As you look at the scroll, notice what people are wearing, the different roles of samurai and foot soldiers, and the different weapons. What can you learn about what is involved in this disturbance? What can you learn about the samurai and the early medieval period from viewing this scroll? What information is helpful in developing an accurate view of samurai? What preparations would be necessary to fight these kinds of battles? (Think about the organization of people, equipment, and weapons; the use of bows, arrows, and horses; use of protective armor for some but not all; and the different ways of fighting.) During the Genpei Civil War of 1180-1185, Yoritomo fought against and defeated the Taira, beginning the Kamakura Period.
    [Show full text]
  • Japanese Didactic Gunsho Commentaries in the Edo Period: a Study of the 17Th C
    WRITTEN MONUMENTS OF THE ORIENT. Vol. 6, No. 2 (12), 2020, p. 93–113 93 Alexey Lushchenko Japanese Didactic Gunsho Commentaries in the Edo Period: A Study of the 17th c. Commentary on the Heike Monogatari DOI 10.17816/wmo56802 Abstract: The Heike monogatari hyōban hidenshō is an anonymous 17th c. commentary on the medieval Heike monogatari. As a military studies text (gunsho) written for Edo-pe- riod warriors, the commentary differs substantially from the Heike monogatari in content and purpose. It consists of didactic essays that critically evaluate passages from the Heike monogatari and also includes fi ctional stories that expand and reinterpret the content of the Heike monogatari. The commentary’s content focuses on topics of governance, strategy, and ethics. In the 17th c., such gunsho commentaries functioned as educational texts with advice and admonition addressed to daimyo lords and warriors in general. As a didactic military studies text, the Heike monogatari hyōban hidenshō reveals a new facet of recep- tion of the Heike monogatari in the Edo period. Key words: Japan, Edo period, gunsho, didactic commentaries, gunki monogatari, Heike monogatari hyōban hidenshō, intellectual history, education Introduction The Tale of the Heike (Heike monogatari 平家物語, 13th c. CE), a well- known medieval Japanese “war tale” (gunki monogatari 軍記物語), narrates events of the late 12th c. with a focus on the Genpei 源平 confl ict (1180– 1185 CE) and the rise and fall of the Heike 平家 clan. For many centuries this major historical and literary text has infl uenced Japanese arts and culture. Studies of reception history of this text tend to examine visual arts, theatrical performances, and literary texts intended for entertainment.
    [Show full text]
  • Elizabeth Oyler
    Japanese Journal of Religious Studies 36/2: 295–317 © 2009 Nanzan Institute for Religion and Culture Elizabeth Oyler Tonsuring the Performer Image, Text, and Narrative in the Ballad-Drama Shizuka This essay explores the portrayal of the famous shirabyōshi dancer Shizuka in an illustrated, hand-copied book (nara ehon) dating from the late sixteenth cen- tury. The text for the nara ehon, taken from a somewhat earlier ballad-drama (kōwakamai), describes Shizuka’s capture by her lover’s brother and enemy, the shogun Minamoto Yoritomo. In the tale, Shizuka and her mother are taken from the capital to Kamakura, Yoritomo’s headquarters. Shizuka bravely refuses to reveal her lover’s whereabouts, spending her time in captivity defiantly dem- onstrating her formidable skills and erudition to Yoritomo and his retinue. By contrast, the illustrations of the text provide a counter-narrative stressing the loss and suffering that Shizuka endures during her time in Kamakura, ignor- ing some of the most famous parts of the narrative, including a defiant dance she performs at the Tsurugaoka Hachiman Shrine in front of Yoritomo and his men. I focus on the juxtaposition between text and image in this work, stressing the discontinuities between the two, especially in comparison with other, near- contemporary nara ehon versions whose illustrations more closely follow the text. I argue that the increasing enclosure and control of women during the late medieval period is reflected in the portrayals of Shizuka and her mother, whom we see only in captivity or on forced journeys that could end in death. keywords: shirabyōshi—nara ehon—Kamakura shogunate—Minamoto Yoritomo— Minamoto Yoshitsune—Shizuka Elizabeth Oyler is assistant professor in the Department of East Asian Languages and Cultures at the University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign.
    [Show full text]
  • Visualising the Tales of Genji and Heike on the Folding Screen
    Swarthmore College Works Art & Art History Faculty Works Art & Art History 2009 Unfolding Narratives: Visualising The Tales Of Genji And Heike On The Folding Screen Tomoko Sakomura Swarthmore College, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://works.swarthmore.edu/fac-art Part of the Asian Art and Architecture Commons Let us know how access to these works benefits ouy Recommended Citation Tomoko Sakomura. (2009). "Unfolding Narratives: Visualising The Tales Of Genji And Heike On The Folding Screen". The Golden Journey: Japanese Art From Australian Collections. 78-89. https://works.swarthmore.edu/fac-art/30 This work is brought to you for free by Swarthmore College Libraries' Works. It has been accepted for inclusion in Art & Art History Faculty Works by an authorized administrator of Works. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Enfolding narratives: Visualising the tales of Genji AND HEIKE on the EOLDING SCREEN Ihe celebrated Japanese narratives, The tale of Genji (Genji monogatari) (p. 83) and The tales of Heike (Tleike monogatari) (pp. 76-7) are the subject of three folding screens {bydbu) in the collection of the Art Gallery of South Australia. The tale of Genji, authored around the turn of the eleventh century by Lady Murasaki Shikibu (died C.1014), is a courtly epic of fifty-four chapters which chronicles the life, loves and heirs of the protagonist Genji, an ideal courtier nicknamed the ‘Shining Lord’.^ The tales of Heike, with its best-known variant recorded in the mid-thirteenth century, is a warrior tale of twelve books, which centres around the tragic destruction of the Taira hy the Minamoto during the Genpei War (1180-85).
    [Show full text]
  • Heike-Monogatari-Background-Guide
    Table of Contents Welcome from the Dais ………………………………………………………………………… 1 Introduction …………………………………………………………………………………… 3 Background Info ……………………………………………………………………………… 4 The Tale of the Heike as Text ……………………………………………………………4 How We Got Here ……………………………………………………………………… 4 The Lay of the Land …………………………………………………………………… 5 Topics of Discussion …………………………………………………………………………… 6 Topic One: Authority and Administration ……………………………………………… 6 Topic Two: The Conduct of War ……………………………………………………… 8 Topic Three: Memory and Vendetta …………………………………………………… 10 Topic Four: The Life Well Lived ……………………………………………………… 10 Characters …………………………………………………………………………………… 15 Bibliography …………………………………………………………………………………… 17 Further reading ……………………………………………………………………………… 18 Appendix ……………………………………………………………………………………… 20 Nomenclature and Onomastics ………………………………………………………… 20 Maps ……………………………………………………………………………………. 21 Content Warning: Suicide is mentioned throughout this guide, especially in Honour and Shame, Loyalty and Vassalage, and Memory and Vendetta. Disordered eating is also alluded to in Memory and Vendetta. 1 Welcome from the Dais The Jetavana Temple bells ring the passing of all things. Twinned sal trees, white in full flower, declare the great man’s certain fall.1 The arrogant do not long endure: They are like a dream one night in spring. The bold and brave perish in the end: They are as dust before the wind. —Tale of the Heike, 1:12 Fourth month of Jishō 4, Yamashiro Province Your honours and eminences, For the reigns of countless emperors, the deities of the Kamo Shrine have watched over the capital, but never, even in this degenerate and disordered age, have they seen such turmoil in the realm. Earlier this year, His Majesty the Emperor Takakura abdicated in favour of the young Antoku, an abdication many have whispered of violating hallowed protocol established both in our narrow realm and in the other realm of China, while his Cloistered Eminence languishes without the honour he merits.
    [Show full text]
  • Samurai in Medieval Japan Through Art and Literature, Consider How Our Understanding of Warrior Culture Compares to the Reality of Their Daily Lives
    Medieval Japan Samurai: Real and Imagined The life and persona of the samurai are alive in popular imagination, but how well do they reflect historical accuracy? By comparing representations of the samurai in medieval Japan through art and literature, consider how our understanding of warrior culture compares to the reality of their daily lives. Samurai (lit. “one who serves”) refers to members of Japan’s warrior class. The origins of the samurai can be traced to the eighth and ninth centuries, when large landholdings moved into the hands of the imperial family and related members of the aristocracy. In the Heian period (794–1185), the Kyoto- based imperial court and nobles depended on the agricultural income from these landholdings, especially large private estates in northern Japan. The need to defend these distant estates from attacks by local chieftains led to the birth of the samurai. Nobles sent from the capital to govern the estates often lacked the skills and authority necessary to maintain security or provide effective administration in such remote districts, so the court appointed deputies from among the local population to assist them. Forerunners of the samurai, these deputies built local and regional power by creating privately controlled militias, called “warrior bands.” Starting as little more than family organizations, warrior bands were initially formed for the duration of a military campaign. Afterward, the group wa disbanded to allow the men to return to farming. By the eleventh century the bands were changing to groups of fighting men not necessarily connected through kinship. Power was beginning to aggregate in the hands of a few elite military families, or clans, whose regional dominance was supported by the fighting abilities of retainers and vassals.
    [Show full text]
  • Arts in the Wind: JICC Kite Collection List and Supplementary Descriptions 2017 6/12-8/18
    Arts in the Wind: JICC Kite Collection List and Supplementary Descriptions 2017 6/12-8/18 Goryokaku: 1 This kite, designed by Hikozo Ohta, originates in Hakodate, Hokkaido and depicts Fort Goryokaku, where loyalists to the Shogunate staged their final resistance when the Meiji Restoration returned power to the Emperor. Today, the remains of the fort, in what is now known as Goryokaku Park, are a special Historical Site and popular cherry blossom viewing spot. Noshiro kite: 2, 3, 8 This type of kite originated in Noshiro, Akita Prefecture. It is unique in that the frame has no diagonal pieces and no bottom. Daruma: 7, 16, 39, 49 Bodhidharma, a Zen Buddhist mystic from the 5th or 6th century, is known as Daruma in Japan. The Daruma doll (left) is used to achieve an important goal. Upon undertaking a task, one eye is filled. The other eye is filled only when the goal is achieved. In one legend, he is said to have sat facing a wall in a cave near the Shaolin Monastery for nine years, neither moving nor speaking, as his legs atrophied. This is why the Daruma doll commonly seen in Japan has neither arms nor legs. “Rashomon”: 11, 69 “Rashomon” is a Noh story which contains a depiction of the battle between a samurai and an oni at Rashomon. The samurai here is Watanabe no Tsuna, who is one of the four champions of Minamoto no Yorimitsu - a revered samurai lord of the Minamoto Clan from the Heian period (794 - 1185.) Kintoro/Sakata Kintoki: 21, 33 Contemporary to Watanabe no Tsuna, this legendary figure was also one of the four champions of Minamoto no Yorimitsu.
    [Show full text]