'To Use Our Talents and Improve Them' Women's Careers in the London Art World 1820—1860

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

'To Use Our Talents and Improve Them' Women's Careers in the London Art World 1820—1860 1 “To use our talents and improve them” Women’s careers in the London art world, 1820-1860 2 Declaration of authorship I, Johanna Holmes, hereby declare that this thesis and the work presented in it is entirely my own. Where I have consulted the work of others, this is always clearly stated. All illustrations are reproduced with the kind permission of copyright holders. Signed:………… ……………….. Date:…………25 July 2020.……………………………….. 3 Abstract This study investigates women’s access to work opportunities, and management of their subsequent working careers, in the London art world between 1820 and 1860. As markets became more buoyant, in the 1820s, giving way to a tide of consumerism and mass production from the 1830s onward, the workplace associated with art diversified and grew, yielding new opportunities for training and work in illustration and reproduction, design of commodities, art-teaching and art- historical study to both men and women who, in many cases, also pursued careers as practising artists. Nevertheless, when Emily Mary Osborn’s painting ‘Nameless and Friendless’ was exhibited in 1857, it followed a tradition established in the early 1840s of presenting a demure young woman, clearly vulnerable and insecure in the commercial world, attempting unsuccessfully to earn some much-needed income from her paintings. The narrative of her ‘plight’ in seeking an income from an inadequate education has persisted to the present day, but it is argued here that this did not literally reflect the experience, either of the painting’s female creator, or of other women working in this and associated occupations at the time. Research into women’s working lives in four aspects of the London art business in this period - water-colour painting, wood-engraving, art-teaching and art-writing – provides the opportunity to examine the construction of workplace institutions which stabilised and conferred status on practitioners. The role and impact of bodies which offered occupational status, qualifications and intellectual stimulus are considered through the examination of both cohorts of women and individual case studies. Conclusions are drawn concerning women’s exclusion, not from participation, but from the benefits of these bodies, and the continuation of their precarious tenure in the workplace. To Emily Mary Osborn’s generation of feminists, existing female professionals presented no acceptable model of career success. 4 Table of contents Page Declaration of authorship ......................................................................................... 2 Abstract ................................................................................................................... 3 Chapter 1 Introduction ........................................................................................................... 8 A context of change ........................................................................................................... 10 Shifting values and language ............................................................................................. 15 Constraints on women’s agency ........................................................................................ 24 Professional women at work in the first half of the nineteenth century: a review of literature ............................................................................................................................. 28 The construction of this study ............................................................................................ 36 Chapter 2 Professional inclusion: women painters in water-colour ............................. 41 Introduction......................................................................................................................... 41 The ‘Old’ Water-colour Society: cultivating the image of the professional man ................. 43 An exclusive profession ..................................................................................................... 45 A more masculine style of water-colour ............................................................................. 49 Eliza Sharpe: professional “Artist Painter in Water-Colour” ............................................... 53 Margaret Gillies: public, but not professional, recognition ................................................. 64 Elizabeth Rigby: the talented amateur ............................................................................... 72 “A true professional” ........................................................................................................... 83 Female ambition and industry: managing contradiction .................................................... 89 Chapter 3 “An honourable, elegant and lucrative employment”: wood-engraving and commerce ............................................................................................................................. 95 Introduction......................................................................................................................... 95 Evidence of women’s participation in the wood-engraving business ................................. 96 The wood-engraving trade ................................................................................................. 99 Promoters of women’s participation in commercial wood-engraving ............................... 106 Mary Byfield (1795-1871): a cultivator of her connections .............................................. 114 Ladies seeking a “lucrative” occupation ........................................................................... 122 ‘Graduates’ of the class in wood-engraving ..................................................................... 131 Conclusions ...................................................................................................................... 135 Chapter 4 “Doubt of a lady’s ability to teach”: women teachers of art ....................... 141 Introduction....................................................................................................................... 141 The “obscure individual” ................................................................................................... 143 Female artists and teaching ............................................................................................. 146 5 Government involvement and new opportunities ............................................................. 151 The ‘reform’ of the Female School of Design ................................................................... 152 Teaching ‘drawing’ to the children of working people ...................................................... 154 Structured advanced training of art teachers ................................................................... 156 Art mistresses in training .................................................................................................. 160 Promoting the Employment of Ladies as Teachers of Fine Art: Eliza Mills .................... 167 “Ruling well and wisely”: Louisa Gann’s school of art ..................................................... 172 Conclusions ...................................................................................................................... 182 Chapter 5 “More than ‘colleges’ can do”: art-writing and the working-day world ...... 192 Introduction....................................................................................................................... 192 The history of art takes academic substance ................................................................... 194 The boundaries of female attainment: Anna Jameson experiences a setback .............. 200 Louisa Twining finds a purpose for her talents ................................................................ 209 Jameson and Twining: a working partnership.................................................................. 222 Work, training and professional purpose for women ....................................................... 224 A logical response to a “cruel inconsistency” ................................................................... 225 Louisa Twining’s realisation of her ambitions .................................................................. 228 Conclusions ...................................................................................................................... 231 Chapter 6 “Every wise woman buildeth her house”: Conclusions.............................. 234 The changing nature of the workplace ............................................................................. 236 Professional women’s presence and status ..................................................................... 238 Public perception of the female professional ................................................................... 240 Potential further recoveries .............................................................................................. 245 Resilience and adaptability: treacherous virtues ............................................................ 246 Career objectives and the “adaptive woman” .................................................................. 248 Appendix A: Female wood-engravers active between 1820 and 1860 ................. 254 Appendix B: Women employed in various capacities around mid-century by the Department of Science and Art ........................................................... 257 Abbreviations .......................................................................................................
Recommended publications
  • 2010-2011 Newsletter
    Newsletter WILLIAMS G RADUATE PROGRAM IN THE HISTORY OF A RT OFFERED IN COLLABORATION WITH THE CLARK ACADEMIC YEAR 2010–11 Newsletter ••••• 1 1 CLASS OF 1955 MEMORIAL PROFESSOR OF ART MARC GOTLIEB Letter from the Director Greetings from Williamstown! Our New features of the program this past year include an alumni now number well over 400 internship for a Williams graduate student at the High Mu- going back nearly 40 years, and we seum of Art. Many thanks to Michael Shapiro, Philip Verre, hope this newsletter both brings and all the High staff for partnering with us in what promises back memories and informs you to serve as a key plank in our effort to expand opportuni- of our recent efforts to keep the ties for our graduate students in the years to come. We had a thrilling study-trip to Greece last January with the kind program academically healthy and participation of Elizabeth McGowan; coming up we will be indeed second to none. To our substantial community of alumni heading to Paris, Rome, and Naples. An ambitious trajectory we must add the astonishingly rich constellation of art histori- to be sure, and in Rome and Naples in particular we will be ans, conservators, and professionals in related fields that, for a exploring 16th- and 17th-century art—and perhaps some brief period, a summer, or on a permanent basis, make William- sense of Rome from a 19th-century point of view, if I am al- stown and its vicinity their home. The atmosphere we cultivate is lowed to have my way.
    [Show full text]
  • THE SCIENCE and ART DEPARTMENT 1853-1900 Thesis
    THE SCIENCEAND ART DEPARTMENT 1853-1900 Harry Butterworth Thesis submitted for the degree of Ph. D. Department of Education University of Sheffield Submitted July 1968 VOLUMELWO Part Two - Institutions and Instruments PART TWO INSTITUTIONS AND INSTRUMENTS CHAPTER SIX The development of facilities for the teaching of Science CHAPTER SEVEN The South Kensington Science complex CHAPTER EIGHT The development of facilities for the teaching of Art CHAPTER NINE The South Kensington Art complex CHAPTER TEN The Inspectors CHAPTER ELEVEN The Teachers CHAPTER TWELVE Students, Scholarships and Text-books. CHAPTER SIX THE DEVELOPMENT OF FACILITIES FOR THE TEACHING OF SCIENCE a) Schemes before 1859 i) The basic difficulties ii) A separate organizational scheme iii) A meagre response b) Provincial institutions in the early days i) Trade Schools ii) Mining Schools iii) Navigation Schools iv) Science Schools v) The arrangements for aid c) The Science subjects : general development i) Major divisions ii) A "newt' subject: Physiography iiz. 3 yS iii) Other "new" subjects: Agriculture and Hygiene iv) Relative importance of the "divisional' d) The machinery of payments on results in Science i) The general principles ii) Specific applications iii) The Departmental defence e) The organisation of the system of examining f) Abuses of the examinations system i) The question of "cram"" ii) The question of "security" g) The Science Subjects : "Pure" or "Applied"" ? i) Basic premises ii) Reasons for reluctance to aid "trade teaching" iii) criticisms of the "pure"
    [Show full text]
  • 'This Will Be a Popular Picture': Giovanni Battista Moroni's Tailor and the Female Gaze
    ‘This will be a popular picture’: Giovanni Battista Moroni’s Tailor and the Female Gaze Lene Østermark-Johansen In October 1862, when Charles Eastlake had secured the purchase of Giovanni Battista Moroni’s The Tailor (c. 1570) for the National Gallery (Fig. 1), he noted with satisfaction: Portrait of a tailor in a white doublet with minute slashes — dark reddish nether dress — a leather belt [strap & buckle] round the end of the white dress. He stands before a table with scissors in his rt hand, & a piece of [black] cloth in the left. Fig. 1: Giovanni Battista Moroni, The Tailor, c. 1570, oil on canvas, 99.5 × 77 cm, National Gallery, London. CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. 2 The hands excellent — the head low in tone but good (one or two spotty lights only too much cleaned) the ear carefully & well painted — All in good state — The lowness of the tone in the face the only objection — Background varied in darkness — light enough to relieve dark side of face & d. air — darker in left side & below — quite el.1 Eastlake’s description, focusing on the effects of colour, light, and the state of preservation, does not give away much about the charismatic qualities of the painting. With his final remark, ‘quite eligible’, he recognizes one of the most engaging of the old master portraits as suitable for purchase by the National Gallery. Eastlake’s wife Elizabeth immediately perceived the powerful presence of the tailor and made the following entry in her journal: ‘It is a celebrated picture, called the “Taglia Panni.”2 The tailor, a bright-looking man with a ruff, has his shears in his beautifully painted hands, and is looking at the spectator.
    [Show full text]
  • John Stuart Mill and Harriet Taylor : Their Correspondence
    UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA LIBRARIES Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2011 with funding from LYRASIS Members and Sloan Foundation http://www.archive.org/details/johnstuartmillhaOOmill JOHN STUART MILL AND HARRIET TAYLOR ERRATA On the title page instead of Their Correspondence read Their Friendship On p. 25, line 14, instead of given as a frontispiece to read reproduced opposite page 128 of On p. 35, line 8, instead of form read from On p. 60, line 16, instead of morally read morality On p. 140, line 6, instead of his read this On p. 218, line 26, instead of Avignon, read Avignon- On p. 236, line 11, instead of of Antinous read or Antinous On p. 240, line 19, instead of Molo read Molos On p. 246, line 11, instead of clothers read clothes On p. 249, line 23, instead of Galiagni s read Galignani's On p. 264, lines 13 and 14, instead of malherreux read malheureux On p. 266, line 21, instead of on opposite page read on the opposite page On p. 284, line i, insert is before given On p. 294, line 4, instead of on typed envelope read on a typed enve- lope On p. 294, line 14, instead of at least, read at least as a note. On p. 301, line 31, instead of Chateuroux read Chateauroux On p. 311, line 6, instead of {1791-1892) read {1791-1862) JOHN STUART MILL AND HARRIET TAYLOR JOHN STUART MILL AND HARRIET TAYLOR Their Correspondence and Subsequent Marriage BY F. A. HAYEK THE UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO PRESS CHICAGO ILLINOIS [40.
    [Show full text]
  • Traces Volume 4, Number 4 Kentucky Library Research Collections Western Kentucky University, [email protected]
    Western Kentucky University TopSCHOLAR® Traces, the Southern Central Kentucky, Barren Kentucky Library - Serials County Genealogical Newsletter 1-1977 Traces Volume 4, Number 4 Kentucky Library Research Collections Western Kentucky University, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.wku.edu/traces_bcgsn Part of the Genealogy Commons, Public History Commons, and the United States History Commons Recommended Citation Kentucky Library Research Collections, "Traces Volume 4, Number 4" (1977). Traces, the Southern Central Kentucky, Barren County Genealogical Newsletter. Paper 63. https://digitalcommons.wku.edu/traces_bcgsn/63 This Newsletter is brought to you for free and open access by TopSCHOLAR®. It has been accepted for inclusion in Traces, the Southern Central Kentucky, Barren County Genealogical Newsletter by an authorized administrator of TopSCHOLAR®. For more information, please contact [email protected]. SOUTH CENTRAL KENTUCKY HISTORICAL QUARTERLY VOL 4 GLASGOW. KENTUCKY^ JANUARY 3977 NO 4 CONTENTS PAGE DIARY OF LITTLEBERRY J HALEY, DD 80 OFFICERS AND MEN IN LORD DUNMORE'S WAR 84 CLINTON COUNTY KENTUCKY VITAL STATISTICS 1856-57-53 - 87 SMITHS GROVE, KENTUCKY CEMETERY RECORDS - 92 1976 MEMBERSHIP 96 NEWS - NOTES - NOTICES 100 LOCKE FAMILY ASSOCIATION 100 HAPPY 105TH BIRTHDAY LUCY A WARD lOl QUERIES 102 BOOKS ^ BOaCS - BOOKS - , . 1.05 Membership Dues $5.00 Per Calendar Year Includes Issues Published January - April - July - October. Members Joining Anytime During The Year Receive The Four Current Year Issues Only. Queries Are Free to Members. Dues Are Payable January. Back Issues As Long As Available Are $1.50 Each. SEND CHECK TO ADDRESS BELOW South Central Kentucky Historical and Genealogical Society, Inc.
    [Show full text]
  • The Looking-Glass World: Mirrors in Pre-Raphaelite Painting 1850-1915
    THE LOOKING-GLASS WORLD Mirrors in Pre-Raphaelite Painting, 1850-1915 TWO VOLUMES VOLUME I Claire Elizabeth Yearwood Ph.D. University of York History of Art October 2014 Abstract This dissertation examines the role of mirrors in Pre-Raphaelite painting as a significant motif that ultimately contributes to the on-going discussion surrounding the problematic PRB label. With varying stylistic objectives that often appear contradictory, as well as the disbandment of the original Brotherhood a few short years after it formed, defining ‘Pre-Raphaelite’ as a style remains an intriguing puzzle. In spite of recurring frequently in the works of the Pre-Raphaelites, particularly in those by Dante Gabriel Rossetti and William Holman Hunt, the mirror has not been thoroughly investigated before. Instead, the use of the mirror is typically mentioned briefly within the larger structure of analysis and most often referred to as a quotation of Jan van Eyck’s Arnolfini Portrait (1434) or as a symbol of vanity without giving further thought to the connotations of the mirror as a distinguishing mark of the movement. I argue for an analysis of the mirror both within the context of iconographic exchange between the original leaders and their later associates and followers, and also that of nineteenth- century glass production. The Pre-Raphaelite use of the mirror establishes a complex iconography that effectively remytholgises an industrial object, conflates contradictory elements of past and present, spiritual and physical, and contributes to a specific artistic dialogue between the disparate strands of the movement that anchors the problematic PRB label within a context of iconographic exchange.
    [Show full text]
  • Melania G. Mazzucco
    Mamoli Zorzi and Manthorne (eds.) FROM DARKNESS TO LIGHT WRITERS IN MUSEUMS 1798-1898 Edited by Rosella Mamoli Zorzi and Katherine Manthorne From Darkness to Light explores from a variety of angles the subject of museum ligh� ng in exhibi� on spaces in America, Japan, and Western Europe throughout the nineteenth and twen� eth centuries. Wri� en by an array of interna� onal experts, these collected essays gather perspec� ves from a diverse range of cultural sensibili� es. From sensi� ve discussions of Tintore� o’s unique approach to the play of light and darkness as exhibited in the Scuola Grande di San Rocco in Venice, to the development of museum ligh� ng as part of Japanese ar� s� c self-fashioning, via the story of an epic American pain� ng on tour, museum illumina� on in the work of Henry James, and ligh� ng altera� ons at Chatsworth, this book is a treasure trove of illumina� ng contribu� ons. FROM DARKNESS TO LIGHT FROM DARKNESS TO LIGHT The collec� on is at once a refreshing insight for the enthusias� c museum-goer, who is brought to an awareness of the exhibit in its immediate environment, and a wide-ranging scholarly compendium for the professional who seeks to WRITERS IN MUSEUMS 1798-1898 proceed in their academic or curatorial work with a more enlightened sense of the lighted space. As with all Open Book publica� ons, this en� re book is available to read for free on the publisher’s website. Printed and digital edi� ons, together with supplementary digital material, can also be found at www.openbookpublishers.com Cover image:
    [Show full text]
  • Artists' Perception of the Use of Digital Media in Painting
    Artists' Perception of the Use of Digital Media in Painting A dissertation presented to the faculty of The Patton College of Education of Ohio University In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree Doctor of Philosophy Cynthia A. Agyeman December 2015 © 2015 Cynthia A. Agyeman. All Rights Reserved. 2 This dissertation titled Artists' Perception of the Use of Digital Media in Painting by CYNTHIA A. AGYEMAN has been approved for the Department of Educational Studies and The Patton College of Education by Teresa Franklin Professor of Educational Studies Renée A. Middleton Dean, The Patton College of Education 3 Abstract AGYEMAN, CYNTHIA A., Ph.D., December 2015, Curriculum and Instruction, Instructional Technology Artists' Perception of the Use of Digital Media in Painting (pp. 310) Director of Dissertation: Teresa Franklin Painting is believed to predate recorded history and has been in existence for over 35,000 (Ayres, 1985; Bolton, 2013) years. Over the years, painting has evolved; new styles have been developed and digital media have been explored. Each period of change goes through a period of rejection before it is accepted. In the 1960s, digital media was introduced to the art form. Like all the painting mediums, it was rejected. It has been over 50 years since it was introduced and yet, it has not been fully accepted as an art form (King, 2002; Miller, 2007; Noll, 1994). This exploratory study seeks to understand the artist’s perception on the use of digital media as an art tool and its benefit to the artists and art education. Grounded theory was used as a methodological guide for the study.
    [Show full text]
  • CRIT 150 (Spring 2018) Histories of Art, Design, and Visual Culture
    CRIT 150 (Spring 2018) Histories of Art, Design, and Visual Culture MW 4:00-5:20 Andy Campbell [email protected] 213.743.1858 Office Hours: W 1:00-3:00pm TA: Allison Littrell ([email protected]) and by appointment IFT 113F This course is a thematic and issues-based, loosely chronological survey of art, visual culture, design, and critical theory from the early modern period through Modernism (roughly 1300 – 1959). We will privilege the interrelationship between these diverse fields, as well as interrogate the formation of these histories as “canon.” This course’s argument is that “Art” and “Design” are categories of production and experience deeply informed (and created) by the colonial and imperial projects of the Global West and North. We will bounce between lecture and discussion formats, as we seek to understand the Western canon of art and design, while also interrogating and expanding upon its limits. Every two weeks or so students will take an open-note quiz comprised of identifications and short essays to assess their progress in the course. Throughout the semester students will be introduced to the process of academic research. The two major assignments in this class focus on research (finding, synthesizing, citing). Rather than a means of arriving at a uniform output (e.g. an end-of-year paper), the goal is to deepen and improve basic research and writing skills, giving equal weight to digital and analogue methods of research— browsing both databases and shelves. This course’s content has been partially constructed by former students; for the final assignment, you will propose a course session for potential inclusion in a future version of this course.
    [Show full text]
  • The Tjhivbrsitt Op Oklahom Graduate College
    THE TJHIVBRSITT OP OKLAHOM GRADUATE COLLEGE THE PRE-RAPHAELITES AHD THEIR CRITICS: A TENTATIVE APPROACH TOWARD THE AESTHETIC OP PRE-RAPHAELITISM A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED TO THE GRADUATE FACULTY in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OP PHILOSOPHY BY WILLIAM EVAN PREDEMAN Norman, Oklahoma _________ l â 5 6 __________ THE PEE-EAPHABLITBS AND THEIR CRITICS A TENTATIVE APPROACH TOWARD THE AESTHETIC OP PRE-RAPHAELITISM APPROVED BT Æ", ~hi. I DISSERTATION COMMITTEE PEBPAOE The purpose of this study is to exsimine the view­ points of a sufficient number of critics of the Pre- Eaphaelite Movement to arrive at a tentative definition and to place the movement in its proper historical per­ spective. The primary emphasis will be literary. But since ,the Pre-Raphaelite Movement began as a movement in painting and so expanded in its later phase that its influence spread to furniture making, interior decoration, tapestry and wall paper design, and book making and illustration, a completely literary study of the movement would be as inadequate as one dealing solely with the painting. Numerous studies have been made of the indi­ vidual Pre-Raphaelites and of the movement in general. Most of these, however, are devoted to relating biographi­ cal facts and to tracing the history of the movement. Critical studies of the aesthetic underlying the movement and motivating the individual members are few in number. Although Pre-Eaphaelitism is well documented, no universal agreement concerning the historical facts of the movement exists. Por this reason, the first part of the study is essentially historical, tracing the successive Phases through which Pre-Ranhaelitism progressed.
    [Show full text]
  • Converts to Rome
    C O N V E R T S T O R O M E . A L I S T O F A B O U T FO UR TH O US A N D PR OTE S TA N TS WH O HA V E R E CE N T LY BE C O M E R M A N A T H LI O C O CS . C OM PILE D BY R N G R M A N W. G D O O O , “ ’ O T W LA E DIT IO OM IT S E DIT R O F T H E O S T N S O F R E S R ECR U . S E C O N D E D I T I O JV . LO NDO N W . S W A N S O N N E N S C H E I N A N D C O . , PA T E RNO S TE R S QUA RE . 1 88 5 . PREFA CE T O T HE SE CON D E DIT ION . C O NSIDERING the reception which has been accorded to the “ of C R in new issue onverts to ome, and bearing mind the m of P 1 k it m k few co ments the ress, thin necessary to a e a observations on points which will interest my readers . As r D seve al reviewers , notably those connected with issenting O re I rgans , have been under the imp ssion that have been honoured by the assistance of the Premier in the compilation of k t f my wor , it will be as well to state tha the ollowing e M r G E of letter, writt n by .
    [Show full text]
  • Newsletter April 2020 Friends of Highgate Cemetery Trust Contents
    NEWSLETTER APRIL 2020 FRIENDS OF HIGHGATE CEMETERY TRUST CONTENTS President Editor Chair’s note ....................................3 The Lord Palumbo of Walbrook Ian Dungavell A mother’s sacrifice .......................4 Vice Presidents With thanks to A garden of remembrance for the Derek Barratt Martin Adeney, Frank Cano, John outcast dead ..................................6 Ian Kelly Constable, James Stevens Curl, John Murray Victor Herman, Russ Howells, Penny An unfortunate end for the largest Linnett, Katy Nicholls, Robin Oakley, airplane in the world ......................8 Chair Stuart Orr, Nick Powell, Max Reeves, The Loudon and cemeteries ....... 10 Martin Adeney John Shepperd. The lost Dickens .......................... 12 Trustees The August 2020 issue will The new Cedar of Lebanon .......... 13 Doreen Aislabie be posted on 17 July 2020. Katy Baldwin Contributions are due by 11 June News roundup .............................. 14 April Cameron 2020. Charles Essex Historic cemeteries news............ 16 Nicola Jones Registered Office Steve Kennard Highgate Cemetery Lucy Lelliott Swain’s Lane, London N6 6PJ Stuart Orr Telephone 020 8340 1834 Teresa Sladen Web www.highgatecemetery.org Nigel Thorne Eve Wilder Company Number 3157806 Charity Number 1058392 Protectors Dr Tye Blackshaw Richard Morris Philip Williams Staff Dr Ian Dungavell FSA Chief Executive Frank Cano Head Gardener Justin Bickersteth Registrar Claire Freston Deputy Head Judith Etherton Archivist Gardener Nikki Druce Volunteering Manager Gardeners Victor Herman Sexton Zurab Gogidze Sally Kay Bookkeeper & Membership Adam Howe Nick Powell Visitor Experience Przemyslaw Talaga Manager Lucy Thompson Operations Manager Cover photograph The grieving widow on a memorial near Comforts’ Corner in Highgate Cemetery West. 2 Highgate Cemetery Newsletter Chair’s note First of all a big thank you.
    [Show full text]