PRAKARSA Issue 6 / April 2011
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Journal of the Indonesia Infrastructure Initiative PRAKARSA Issue 6 / April 2011 Urban Mobility • A Mobility Overview • Freeing Jakarta from Gridlock • Solutions in Surabaya • Strategies for Bogor’s Angkot ! "-,1&,10! !!(D!'DK,E./0K1ED!KE!2,87D!5E8161K7! !"H"9G&5FCIB,&H-9&.CF/,&0519&G"2"/5F&GHFI33/9G&."H-&HF500"1&1CB39GH"CB&5B,&49-"1I/5F&5C//IH"CBR&.5GH& 5HH925HG&HC&GC/49&H-9&5FC8/92&-549&CB/9&25,9&"H&.CFG9P&8IH&B9.9F&555FC51-9G&C009F&",95G&H-5H&259&-549& F9/945B19&HC&'B,CB9G"5R&-"%$%a& % !!8,991D:!(7A7,K7!=,EC!%,1.6E0A! %F95H9F&(5?5FH5SG&HF5BG5CFH5H"CB&G9GH92&-5G&899B&GI8@91H&HC&25B9&0CF19G&C49F&H-9&/5GH&,915,9R&0HFCB3& 5C/"H"15/&1C22"H29BH&"G&B99,9,&0CF&H-9&3C49FB29BH&HC&299H&H-9&,925B,&0CF&IF85B&2C8"/"H9R&-"%$%g& & !!1@9!0/,78777!0KE,7A!.,E869CC!7D.!0E6/K1EDC!=E,!'CD,EE1D:!2,87D!5E8161K7! B519,&."H-&H-9&G529&5FC8/92G&5/53I"B3&25B9&'B,CB9G"5B&1"H"9GP&0IF58595&G-C.G&5CH9BH"5/&HC&51-"949& 3F95H9F&IF85B&2C8"/"H9&5B,&EI5/"H9&C0&/"09R&-"%$%_e& & !!0E6E1D:! E:E,GC!H(D:AEK!.,E869CI! DB&C49FGI55/9&C0&5B3?CH&-5G&1F95H9,&1CB39GH"CB&5B,&G509H9&5FC8/92G&"B& C3CFP&8IH&90091H"49&GC/IH"CBG&5F9& 89"B3&5,C5H9,R&-"%$%*_& ! !!&.1KE,GC!59CC7:9A%E,-.%*! !!'D=,7CK,/0K/,9!87!K@9!,/C89,CA%E,-.%*! !!J9KK9,C!KE!'9)2)9:)A%E,-.%*e! !!1@9!&OD9,K!319NA%E,-.%*f! !!-/K0EC9CA%E,-.%a0! !!'D!-/,!,9OK!'CC/9A%E,-.%a0! ! 1@1C!N/7,K9,67!OE/,D76!1C!D/861C@9.!87!K@9!'D.ED9C17!'D=,7CK,/0K/,9!'D1K17K1E9P!7D!(/CK,7617D!%EE9,DC9DK!=/D.9.!D,EO90K!.9C1:D9.!KE! D,ECEK9!90EDEC10!:,ENK@!1D!'D.ED9C17!87!9D@7D01D:!K@9!,969E7D09P!N/761K7!7D.!N/7DK/C!E=!1D=,7CK,/0K/,9!1DE9CKC9DKX!1@9!E19NC! 9OD,9CC9.!1D!K@1C!OE/,D76!.E!DEK!D909CC7,167!,9=690K!K@9!E19NC!E=!K@9!(/CK,7617!'D.ED9C17!.7,KD9,C@1D!E,!K@9!(/CK,7617D!%EE9,DC9DKX! .697C9!.1,90K!7D7!0ECC9DKC!E,!N/9CK1EDC!KE!K@9!"ECC/D107K1EDC!197C!7K!'D.''P!K96X!Rso!aonb!opmZsmspP!=7O!Rso!aonb!pnvmZovvqP!E,!9Z C716!.123454.6741844T8DT48X!498C1K9A!LLLT41844T8DT48% ! .,7A7,C7!]!'CC/9!_s!]!(D,16P!omnn!]!.,1DK9,Z8,19D.67!&.1K1ED!]!.7:9!o!E=!pm! !! Editor’s Message! Infrastructure! 1@1C!1CC/9!E=!'9)2)9:)!@7C!K@9!K@9C9!H/,87D!CE8161K7IX!8E,!C7D7! ,97.9,C! _! 9CD9017667! K@EC9! N@E! =1:@K! (7A7,K7! K,7==10! ED! 7! .7167! by the Numbers! 87C1C! _! 1K! NE/6.! 89! 97C7! KE! 7CC/C9! K@7K! K@1C! 9.1K1ED! C/CK! 89! D,1C7,167!78E/K!0ED:9CK1ED!1D!K@9!D7K1EDGC!07D1K76X! ! ! _c00%BDID58N8A.6R%% 1@7K! 7CC/CDK1ED! NE/6.! 89! 1D0E,,90KX! H2,87D! CE8161K7I! 1C! DEK! C7DED7CE/C!N1K@!H0ED:9CK1ED!,9619=I!7D.!(7A7,K7!1C!DEK!K@9!ED67! c00%,3IDBDC4A.6% 01K7!1D!'D.ED9C17!K@7K!=709C!CE8161K7!0@7669D:9CX!(C!.9K9,!51.:697! .9C0,189C!1D!H(D!'DK,E./0K1ED!KE!2,87D!5E8161K7I!aD7:9!pbP!/,87D! 1E.%13BC.5%DF%BDID5%G.E48A.6% D67DD9,C!@7E9!697,D9.!87!9OD9,19D09!K@7K!7!C1D:69ZC1D.9.!=E0/C! C.41-%,88.8%ID%(,I,5I,U6%5D,86%.G.5N%8,NT% ED! ,9./01D:! 0ED:9CK1ED! @7C! 7! K9D.9D07! KE! 697.! KE! /DN7DK9.! % E/K0EC9CA! 8/16.! CE,9! ,E7.CP! 7D.! CE,9! D,1E7K9! E9@1069C! N166! N/10A67! =166! K@9C! /DX! 'DCK97.P! K@9! A97! 1C! KE! 7CAA! HaEN! 07D! N9! b0L% 9==1019DK67! CEE9! D9ED69! 7D.! :EE.CP! 7D.! .E! 1K! 1D! 7! N77! K@7K! 1C! 1E.%E.58.1I%DF%I4B.%IE,I%8,56%41%(,I,5I,%,5.% 7==E,.7869P!0EC=E,K7869P!7D.!9DE1,EDC9DK7667!=,19D.67TI!(DCN9,C! C/CK!89!CE/:@K!=,EC!7!8,E7.!0,[email protected],CX! ,8I3,AAN%BDG41-%83541-%IE.45%MD351.N6T%% ! % c1==9,9DK!01K19C!1D!'D.ED9C17!7,9!7K!.1==9,9DK!CK7:9C!E=!7..,9CC1D:! 1CD,EE9C9DKC!KE!/,87D!CE8161K7X!(7A7,K7!1C!K@9!D,9C19,!9O7CD69! *bL% E=! N@7K! 07D! @7DD9D! N@9D! 90EDEC10! :,ENK@! 697.C! KE! C/,:1D:! 1E.%,G.5,-.%AD,8%F,8ID5%FD5%E3CA48% .9C7D.!=E,!@1:@ZN/761K7!K,7DCDE,KP!8/K!7!0EE,.1D7K9.!CK,7K9:7!=E,! D/8610! K,7DC1K! .E9C! DEK! A99D! D709X! c7D7D:! .7,1A9C1KGC! 7,K1069P! I5,16ED5I,I4D1%41%ND-N,I,5I,T%O4-E.5%,G.5,-.% H8,991D:!(7A7,K7!8,EC!%,1.6E0AI!aD7:9!vbP!9OD6E,9C! @EN!(7A7,K7! F4-35.6%8D55.6ED18%-5.,I.5%.FF484.18N% @7C!0EC9!KE!1KC!0/,,9DK!/D@7DD7!CK7K9P!7D.!C7A9C!K@9!DE1DK!K@7K! ,18%5.838.8%8D1-.6I4D1T%%% CK,ED:!DE61K1076!0ECC1KC9DK!N166!89!9CC9DK176!1=!CE6/K1EDC!7,9!KE! % 89!=E/D.X! ! d0L% -K@9,!01K19C!C77!DEK!79K!89!7C!C9E9,967!0@7669D:9.!7C!(7A7,K7P!8/K! QD1I54C3I4D1%DF%IE.%I5,16ED5I%6.8ID5%ID% K@97!D99.!CK,ED:!DE61K1076!0ECC1KC9DK!KEEX!H1@9!0/,78777!0KE,7A! .,E869CC!7D.!0E6/K1EDC!=E,!'CD,EE1D:!2,87D!5E8161K7I!87!416617C! 8,5CD1%84DR48.%.B4664D16%41%35C,1%,5.,6%DF% 31D09DK!aD7:9!ntb!9O7C1D9C!K@9!0ED.1K1EDC!1D!0/,78777!KE.77!7D.! S18D1.64,T%% C7A9C! K@9! DE1DK! K@7K! 7! 0ECD,9@9DC1E9! CK,7K9:7! K@7K! 7..,9CC9C! % K@9!,9:1ED!1C!0,1K1076X!'D!H0E6E1D:! E:E,GC!e(D:AEK!.,E869CGI!aD7:9! onbP!c7E1.!-E9,1D:KED!.9C0,189C!@EN!K@9!"1K7!E=! E:E,!@7C!C7.9! c% CK,1.9C! 1D! 7..,9CC1D:! K@9! D,E869CC! 0,97K9.! 87! 7D! 9O09CC! E=! 1E.%13BC.5%DF%S18D1.64,1%84I4.6%TC.648.6% 7D:AEKP!8/K!1K!N166!K7A9!0ED09,K9.!9==E,K!87!K@9!01K7!7D.!.1CK,10K! (,I,5I,U%IE,I%L4AA%63FF.5%IDI,A%-548AD8I% KE:9K@9,! KE! 1CD69C9DK! 6ED:ZK9,C! CE6/K1EDC! K@7K! N166! 89! K,/67! 9==90K1E9X! 6DB.I4B.%C.IL..1%*0_c%,18%*0*c%4F%1D% ! .FF.8I4G.%35C,1%BDC4A4IN%EDA48N%46% 1@9!9O7CD69C!E=!(7A7,K7P!0/,78777P!7D.! E:E,!C7A9!1DK9,9CK1D:! 4BEA.B.1I.8T%1E.%84I4.6%,5.% ,1831-W% 7D.!,969E7DK!,97.1D:P!8/K!=E,!K@9!0E/DK,7!E=!'D.ED9C17!K@97!7,9! X,I,66,5W%X.8,1W%035,C,N,W%,18%0.B,5,1-T% ED67! K@9! 89:1DD1D:X! 'D.ED9C17! @7C! 7,E/D.! om! EK@9,! 01K19C! N1K@! DED/67K1EDC!1D!9O09CC!E=!@76=!7!C1661EDX!57D7!E=!K@9C!@7E9!DEK! 79K! CEKE,1C9.! KE! K@9! C7C9! 9OK9DKX! 1@1C! 1C! 7D! 9DE,CE/C! a*0% EDDE,K/D1K7X! '=! K@9C9! 01K19C! 970@! ,9CE6E9! KE! .9E96ED! 0ECD,9@9DC1E9! 6ED:ZK9,C! D67DC! =E,! /,87D! CE8161K7P! K@97! 07D! Z3BC.5%DF%IE.%_db*%C36.6%4BED318.8%41% 7E9,K!D,E869CC!89=E,9!K@97!890EC9!E/K!E=!0EDK,E6X!1@9!,9C/6KC! (,I,5I,%FD5%I5,FF48%G4DA,I4D16%41%*0_0%IE,I%L.5.% N166! 89! 8EK@! 89KK9,! N/761K7! E=! 61=9! =E,! 01K1f9DC! 7D.! 1CD,EE9.! 1DI%5D,8LD5IENW%,88D5841-%ID%(,I,5I,U6%Q4IN% 90EDEC10!:,ENK@X!g!"04! 15,16ED5I,I4D1%"-.18NT% .,7A7,C7!]!'CC/9!_s!]!(D,16P!omnn!]!.,1DK9,Z8,19D.67!&.1K1ED!]!.7:9!p!E=!pm! !! ! An Introduction to Urban Mobility "1K19C! 7,E/D.! K@9! NE,6.! =709! C1C167,! CK,/::69C! N1K@! K,7==10! 0ED:9CK1ED! 7D.! E9@10/67,! DE66/K1EDX! .7CK! 7KK9CDKC! KE! CE6E9! K@9! D,E869C! @7E9! ED67! C7.9! 1K! NE,C9P! 8/K! D9N9,! 7DD,E70@9C!E==9,!1.97C!K@7K!C77!@7E9!,969E7D09!KE!'D.ED9C17X!g! 7!.9K9,!51.:697! ! ! ! ! ! ! "1K19C!7,E/D.!K@9!NE,6.!7,9!0ED09,D9.! ! N1K@!K@9!=6EN!E=!:EE.C!7D.!D9ED69X!1@1C! ! C09D9!C@ENC!.7,1C!K,7==10!7C!C99D!=,EC! ! K@9!(,0!.9!1,1ECD@9X&& ! !CIFH9G9&C0& FC?9B05-9F9&CB&4"?"29,"5& ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 8E,!C7D7!797,CP!/,87D!K,7DCDE,K!D67DD9,C!@7E9!7KK9CDK9.!KE!,9./09!0ED:9CK1EDX!57D7!K,7DCDE,K! CK/.19C!=,EC!D7CK!797,C!89:1D!N1K@!67D:/7:9!K@7K!,97.CP!H"ED:9CK1ED!1C!ED!K@9!1D0,97C9!7D.!@9,9! 7,9! CK9DC! KE! ,9./09! 1KXI! 'D! CECK! 07C9CP! C/0@! CK/.19C! ,90ECC9D.! EE9,0EC1D:! 0ED:9CK1ED! 87! 1CD,EE1D:!0ED.1K1EDC!=E,!E9@1069CP!D7,K10/67,67!CEKE,1C9.!ED9C!C/0@!7C!K,/0ACP!8/C9C!7D.!D,1E7K9! 07,CX!(/K@E,C!E=!K@9C9!CK/.19C!89619E9.!K@9!CE6/K1ED!N7C!C1CD69A!8/16.!K@9!,E7.C!D909CC7,7!KE! C99K!.9C7D.X! /K! CEC9K@1D:! N9DK! N,ED:X! 1@9! ,E7.C! K@7K! N9,9! 8/16K! CK1C/67K9.! 9E9D! CE,9! :,ENK@! 1D! 07,! END9,C@1D! 7D.! /C7:9X! 1@9! ,9C/6KC! N9,9! 9E9,Z1D0,97C1D:! 0ED:9CK1EDP! 90EDEC10! 1D9==1019D019CP! DE66/K1EDP!7D.!EK@9,!=E,CC!E=!9DE1,EDC9DK76!.9:,7.7K1EDX!"697,67!K@1C!7DD,E70@!@7C!DEK!NE,A9.X! /K!N@7K!1C!K@9!76K9,D7K1E9T!! (C!7!C9D1E,!'D.ED9C17D!K,7DCDE,K!9OD9,K!,909DK67!E8C9,E9.P!H49!@7E9!KE!CKED!K,71D:!KE!,9./09! 0ED:9CK1EDh! N9! @7E9! KE! CK7,K! 1CD,EE1D:! CE8161K7XI! a9! 1C! ,1:@KX! 11C9C! 7,9! 0@7D:1D:P! 7D.! C7D7! 01K19C! K@,E/:@E/K! K@9! NE,6.! 7,9! DEN! =E0/C1D:! ED! 1CD,EE1D:! CE8161K7P! N1K@! 1CD,9CC1E9! ,9C/6KCX! 01D:7DE,9!1C!7!C@1D1D:!9O7CD69!E=!N@7K!07D!89!70@19E9.!87!0ED09DK,7K1D:!69CC!ED!8/16.1D:!,E7.C! 7D.!0ED09DK,7K1D:!CE,9!ED!0@7D:1D:!K@9!N77!D9ED69!/C9!,E7.CP!7C!N966!7C!D,EE1.1D:!7!=1,CK!067CC! 7D.!7==E,.7869!D/8610!K,7DCDE,K!C7CK9CX!! 57D7!01K19C!1D!&/,ED9P! ,7f16P!"E6EC817!7D.!'D.17!7,9! DEN! .9E96ED1D:! CE8161K7! CK,7K9:19C! 7D.! 1CD69C9DK1D:!C97C/,9C!.9C1:D9.!KE!1CD,EE9!CE8161K7!=E,!766!01K1f9DCP!DEK!O/CK!K@EC9!K,7E9661D:!87! D,1E7K9! 07,X! 1@9! 01K7! E=! %/7D:f@E/! 1C! 697.1D:! K@9! N77! 1D! "@1D7P! 7D.! CE8161K7! 1CD,EE9C9DK! .,7A7,C7!]!'CC/9!_s!]!(D,16P!omnn!]!.,1DK9,Z8,19D.67!&.1K1ED!]!.7:9!q!E=!pm! !! C97C/,9C!1CD69C9DK9.!1D!,9N!iE,A!9D7869.!K@9!01K7!KE!N1D!K@9!0/CK71D7869!"1K19C!7N7,.!1D!omnm! aCEC9K@1D:!K@7K!NE/6.!@7E9!899D!1D0ED091E7869!9E9D!=1E9!797,C!7:EbX! 4E,I%S6%V25C,1%XDC4A4INW_% Key Points 'CD,EE1D:! /,87D! CE8161K7! C97DC! =E0/C1D:! Historically, urban transport planners were focused on ED! K@9! CEE9C9DK! E=! D9ED69! 7D.! :EE.C! reducing congestion.