DOCSLIB.ORG

A Discussion Guide for Faithful Americans on Immigration Policies and Practices Table of Contents

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
A Discussion Guide for Faithful Americans on Immigration Policies and Practices Table of Contents OFFERING REFUGE: A DISCUSSION GUIDE FOR FAITHFUL AMERICANS ON IMMIGRATION POLICIES AND PRACTICES TABLE OF CONTENTS PREFACE Welcome from the Executive Director of Religions for Peace USA.............................................1 Welcome from the Moderator of Religions for Peace USA.........................................................2 Introduction from the Editors of “Offering Refuge”......................................................................3 About Religions for Peace USA...................................................................................................5 A Joint Statement from U.S. Religious Leaders and Communities Regarding U.S. Immigration and Refugee Policies and Practices............................................................................................8 Member Religious Communities of Religions for Peace USA...................................................10 ORIENTATION Week 1 Background and Definitions of Immigration Terms....................................................................11 Key United States Agencies That Deal With Immigration..........................................................14 Creating Some Ground Rules for Respectful Dialogue..............................................................15 Discerning the Sources That We Use........................................................................................17 THE DISCUSSION GUIDE Week 2 | Introduction..................................................................................................................21 Week 3 | The State of the Global Migration Crisis......................................................................23 Week 4 | Migration is a Matter of Faith.......................................................................................26 Week 5 | Closing the U.S.’s Golden Door.................................................................................. 28 Week 6 | Refugee Resettlement Reductions and Bias.............................................................. 31 Week 7 | Terrorism, Violence, and Hate Crimes.........................................................................35 Week 8 | On the Wall and Deportations......................................................................................38 COVID-19 and Immigration........................................................................................................41 Conclusion and Commitments...................................................................................................42 Resources for Learning More....................................................................................................43 FRONT COVER: The French photographer and street artist JR created this artwork along the border fence in the Mexican city of Tecate in 2017, about an hour southeast of San Diego. The smiling toddler it depicts peeking out of his crib to the US side is named Kikito. BACK COVER: A cross-border picnic takes place on French photographer and street artist JR’s “Giant Picnic” table. The long strip photo that makes the table’s design is meant to depict the eyes of Mayra, a DACA “Dreamer.” It appeared over the U.S.-Mexico border in Tecate, Mexico in October 2017. Attendees from both sides of the border shared a meal across the border and through the fence. Cover photos are ©JR Photographer. See: https://www.jr-art.net/projects/migrants-picnic-across-the-border and the video explaining the project: https://vimeo.com/410614239. October 2020 Dear Reader, Thank you for picking up this booklet and works to engage Americans to join with one considering these matters. another across lines of difference, religious and The U.S. is a nation of immigrants. Except for otherwise. We are our nation’s broadest coalition the indigenous peoples that were here before St. of religious communities and leaders working Augustine, Jamestown, or Plymouth, and those together for peace. brought as slaves, every one of us is an immigrant This booklet is designed to serve as a helping or the child of immigrants. I know, because guide for Americans of faith willing to engage I am one. in respectful discussions about immigration. In I am a proud American. I am a faithful these pages, persons in intentional community Sikh. I am a thankful leader in the movement for with one another can thoughtfully explore interfaith cooperation and care deeply about how together faithful responses to refugees, asylum we approach immigration. seekers, and displaced persons. Immigration is repeatedly listed in surveys as We are non-partisan, so we aren’t trying to being amongst the top five issues Americans want have you decide on any specific political position. to talk about and address. We are still struggling At the same time, we are faith-committed, so we to understand what it means to keep open that believe that each of our respective faiths calls us golden door of hospitality. Differing ideas about to act from our shared values – such as hospitality, how we should approach immigration issues can family, and dignity. This fact compels us to act in divide neighbor against neighbor. loving ways towards our neighbors. Religions for Peace USA, where I have the With appreciation for your willingness to privilege of serving as the Executive Director, discern and discuss these matters with your neighbors, I am, Yours sincerely, Dr. Tarunjit Singh Butalia Executive Director Religions for Peace USA 1 October 2020 Dear Reader, Assalamu alaikum. Greetings of peace to each of you. Like my colleague Tarunjit, I, too, am a proud faith. Trust takes time to develop and is shaped by American. I am a faithful Muslim. The issue context and conditions. By even considering using of faith and immigration is one of grave this resource in a faithful community, you have importance to Muslims across the globe, already taken some of the first vulnerable steps and to myself. The Islamic tradition speaks in trust and relationships that can create change. clearly of the right to seek refuge in the face Thank you for doing so. of persecution, as well as to the duty of providing Thank you for making the space to discuss asylum. Thank you for considering this resource the matters of immigration with your neighbor. and for taking seriously the issues surrounding May a spirit of generosity come between you in immigration. We hope you will be intentional seeking to understand together. in taking time to participate in using this guide with others in your faith or interfaith community. In Peace, We trust that God will be with you in the process of your learning together and discernment. Change takes time and faith. Change happens at the speed of relationships. Mr. Naeem Baig Relationships take time and faith. Relationships Moderator move at the speed of trust. Trust takes time and Religions for Peace USA 2 October 2020 Dear Reader, Good, decent, and well-meaning people can have differences, even sharp ones, about what the best course of action is in handling any political or religious matter. Each of us too easily tends to speak past one another, stay in our bubbles, or avoid talking about difficult matters altogether. It is our very human tendency towards fight, freeze, or flight to protect ourselves. It is the belief that neither religion or politics are supposed to be talked about in polite company. So we must be crazy to think religious people should talk together about the political matter of immigration. It is contentious. A recipe for disaster, right? No. Actually, we believe it is a necessity and the only path forward is through talking about it openly, listening to each other deeply, and discerning faithful positions on the matter together. We have to talk about difficult matters and lean in. Immigration is a moral matter. As Beyond Conflict1 has recently shown with their research (see illustration to the left),2 Americans are actually much closer to agreements on positions about immigration than we think we are. Reality is likely far better than our perceptions. This guide was designed to be used in small study cells within communities of faith. It was created to provide you with: 1. Some suggested ground rules, 2. Short introductions to some key issues on immigration, 1 “America’s Divided Mind: Understanding the Psychology That Drives Us Apart,” by Beyond Conflict, June 2020. Accessed September 15, 2020: https://beyondconflictint.org/americas-divided-mind. 2 Actual vs. Perceived illustration is from p.16 of “America’s Divided Mind: Understanding the Psychology That Drives Us Apart,” by Beyond Conflict, June 2020. Accessed September 15, 2020: https://beyondconflictint.org/americas-divided-mind. 3 3. Thought provoking questions and stories for your discussions, 4. Good resources to look for more and dig deeper, and 5. Compelling stories that provide windows into faith actors working on immigration. It assumes that you might have up to an hour per week to look at each section with your peers, and it is designed to be used over several weeks. Thank you for taking time to engage these resources and consider starting a conversation in your community. If you have questions or want to share insights, drop us a note at [email protected]. We would love to hear from you. In Peace, Alisa Roadcup Bud Heckman President CEO Chicago Refugee Coalition Interfaith Funders Group 4 MISSION The mission of Religions for Peace USA (RFPUSA) is to inspire and advance common actions for peace through multi-religious cooperation among our nation’s religious communities. VISION
Load more

Recommended publications
  • A Reading List for Refugee Week 2020
    Living in Limbo: a reading list for Refugee Week 2020 Cover illustration: 'LandEscape' created by Jal Kong age 15 from South Sudan, currently living in Kakuma refugee camp. Contents Fiction for Younger Readers ...................................................................................................... 2 Fiction for Young Adults ............................................................................................................. 7 Adult Fiction ............................................................................................................................. 12 Non-Fiction ............................................................................................................................... 16 1 | P a g e Fiction for Younger Readers Nadine Dreams of Home by Bernard Ashley Age recommendation 7+ A touching yet serious story with an ultimately uplifting ending. Nadine doesn't like her new life. She doesn't speak the language, she can't understand what's going on, and more than anything, it's just not home. Especially since her father isn't here with them in the UK. But it just wasn't safe in Goma anymore, not with the uprising and the violence of the rebel soldiers. So, Nadine tries to find something in her new life that will remind her of the happy memories of Africa. Particularly suitable for struggling, reluctant and dyslexic readers aged 7+ Give Me Shelter edited by Tony Bradman Age recommendation 9+ The phrase 'asylum-seeker' is one we see in the media all the time. It stimulates fierce and controversial debate, in arguments about migration, race and religion. The movement of people from poor or struggling countries to those where there may be opportunities for a better life is a constant in human history, but it is something with particular relevance in our own time. This collection of short stories shows us people who have been forced to leave their homes or families to seek help and shelter elsewhere.
    [Show full text]
  • Television Academy Awards
    2021 Primetime Emmy® Awards Ballot Outstanding Music Composition For A Series (Original Dramatic Score) The Alienist: Angel Of Darkness Belly Of The Beast After the horrific murder of a Lying-In Hospital employee, the team are now hot on the heels of the murderer. Sara enlists the help of Joanna to tail their prime suspect. Sara, Kreizler and Moore try and put the pieces together. Bobby Krlic, Composer All Creatures Great And Small (MASTERPIECE) Episode 1 James Herriot interviews for a job with harried Yorkshire veterinarian Siegfried Farnon. His first day is full of surprises. Alexandra Harwood, Composer American Dad! 300 It’s the 300th episode of American Dad! The Smiths reminisce about the funniest thing that has ever happened to them in order to complete the application for a TV gameshow. Walter Murphy, Composer American Dad! The Last Ride Of The Dodge City Rambler The Smiths take the Dodge City Rambler train to visit Francine’s Aunt Karen in Dodge City, Kansas. Joel McNeely, Composer American Gods Conscience Of The King Despite his past following him to Lakeside, Shadow makes himself at home and builds relationships with the town’s residents. Laura and Salim continue to hunt for Wednesday, who attempts one final gambit to win over Demeter. Andrew Lockington, Composer Archer Best Friends Archer is head over heels for his new valet, Aleister. Will Archer do Aleister’s recommended rehabilitation exercises or just eat himself to death? JG Thirwell, Composer Away Go As the mission launches, Emma finds her mettle as commander tested by an onboard accident, a divided crew and a family emergency back on Earth.
    [Show full text]
  • Bell Ringers for the Week of October 28, 2019 UNIT 3: Cultural Patterns
    Bell Ringers for the week of October 28, 2019 UNIT 3: Cultural Patterns and Processes (Halloween, GenDer, Toponymy) PrepareD by Ken Keller [email protected] *Students should always be prompted, probed, so to speak, to answer the WHY question when responding to geographic inquiry J Question #1: What criteria are useD to Determine the quality of life of women in a country? With those variables in minD, preDict the best anD worst places in the world for women to live. ID variables Elaboration of quality of life variables The Best and Worst places to be a woman, 2019@ https://www.nationalgeographic.com/culture/2019/10/peril-progress-prosperity-womens-well-being- around-the-world-feature/ One geographic theme here is the battle between local/indigenous cultural traditions and modern/global cultural values. What role, if any, do global forces and interactions have on traditional societies with respect to women? From March 2018. Saudi women unveiled. How Saudi society has changed in relation to the life of women @ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/saudi-women-unveiled/ From June, 2018. Six things that Saudi women still can’t do @? http://www.theweek.co.uk/60339/things-women-cant-do-in-saudi-arabia Saudi Women unveiled. How life is changing for women in Saudi Arabia from 60 Minutes, 2018 @ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZNFNxFlLzrc (7:41) The countries where Muslim women can’t wear veils (2017) @ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/women/life/burka-bans-the-countries-where-muslim-women-cant-wear- veils/ From May, 2015. Eight Things Women Are Banned From Wearing Around the World: http://www.theweek.co.uk/63244/seven-things-women-are-banned-from-wearing-around-the-world Different Hijab styles for Muslim women in different parts of the world: http://www.hijabiworld.com/different-hijab-styles-for-muslim-woman-around-the-world/ Ex.
    [Show full text]
  • A STUDY GUIDE by Robert Lewis
    A STUDY GUIDE BY ROBERT LEWIS http://www.metromagazine.com.au http://www.theeducationshop.com.au OVERVIEW OF FILM The series of three 54-minute episodes immigration program. Migrants from charts how the dream soon became war-torn Europe arrived en masse. It At the dawn of the twentieth century a nightmare for some. The insecuri- was social engineering on the grand- Australia was a social laboratory. ties of those at the helm meant that est of scales. The country would be A great experiment was underway at the start of the twentieth century fundamentally transformed forever. But to make this new country the most immigration policy was driven by fear the gatekeepers to the nation’s borders progressive and egalitarian nation in and racism, as well as by a vision had to take Australia and its people the world. of being a ‘British’ Australia. As the with them on this radical journey of White Australia Policy was developed change. The new arrivals had to be The country was busy initiating radical and enforced, many of the non-white white, and the dream was kept alive reforms, born of noble ideals, that residents were deported and barred through stealth and propaganda. The enshrined basic political freedoms and from entry. Vibrant communities were message was clear: ‘You’re welcome the rights of fairness and opportunity fractured and the Chinese population but on our terms and only if you adopt for all. At Federation in 1901, Australia dwindled dramatically. this country as your own.’ It was the seemed to stand as a beacon to the age of assimilation.
    [Show full text]
  • Television Academy Awards
    2021 Primetime Emmy® Awards Ballot Outstanding Sound Editing For A Nonfiction Or Reality Program (Single Or Multi-Camera) All In: The Fight For Democracy All In: The Fight For Democracy follows Stacey Abrams’s journey alongside those at the forefront of the battle against injustice. From the country’s founding to today, this film delves into the insidious issue of voter suppression - a threat to the basic rights of every American citizen. Allen v. Farrow Episode 2 As Farrow and Allen cement their professional legacy as a Hollywood power couple, their once close-knit family is torn apart by the startling revelation of Woody's relationship with Mia's college-aged daughter, Soon-Yi. Dylan details the abuse allegations that ignited decades of backlash, and changed her life forever. Amend: The Fight For America Promise Immigrants have long put their hope in America, but intolerant policies, racism and shocking violence have frequently trampled their dreams. American Masters Mae West: Dirty Blonde Rebel, seductress, writer, producer and sexual icon -- Mae West challenged the morality of our country over a career spanning eight decades. With creative and economic powers unheard of for a female entertainer in the 1930s, she “climbed the ladder of success wrong by wrong.” American Murder: The Family Next Door Using raw, firsthand footage, this documentary examines the disappearance of Shanann Watts and her children, and the terrible events that followed. American Oz (American Experience) Explore the life of L. Frank Baum, author of The Wonderful Wizard of Oz. By 1900, Baum had spent his life in pursuit of success.
    [Show full text]
  • IRC Ambassador Book List
    IRC Ambassador Book List Refugee by Alan Gratz Young Adult (8+) All three young people will go on harrowing journeys in search of refuge. All will face unimaginable dangers–from drownings to bombings to betrayals. But for each of them, there is always the hope of tomorrow. And although Josef, Isabel, and Mahmoud are separated by continents and decades, surprising connections will tie their stories together in the end. The Lightless Sky: A Twelve-Year-Old Refugee’s Harrowing Escape from Afghanistan and His Extraordinary Journey Across Half the World by Gulwali Passarlay Young Adult (8+) A gripping, inspiring, and eye-opening memoir of fortitude and survival—of a twelve-year-old boy’s traumatic flight from Afghanistan to the West—that puts a face to one of the most shocking and devastating humanitarian crises of our time. Escape From Aleppo by N.H Senzai Young Adult (8+) It is December 17, 2010: Nadia’s twelfth birthday and the beginning of the Arab Spring. Soon anti-government protests erupt across the Middle East and, one by one, countries are thrown into turmoil. As civil war flares in Syria and bombs fall across Nadia’s home city of Aleppo, her family decides to flee to safety. Inspired by current events, this novel sheds light on the complicated situation in Syria that has led to an international refugee crisis, and tells the story of one girl’s journey to safety I Lived on Butterfly Hill by Marjorie Agosín Young Adult (8+) Celeste Marconi is a dreamer. She lives peacefully among friends and neighbors and family in the idyllic town of Valparaiso, Chile, until the time comes when even Celeste, with her head in the clouds, can”t deny the political unrest that is sweeping through the country.
    [Show full text]
  • Asian American Pacific Islander Booklist
    Bank Street College of Education Educate The Center for Children's Literature 5-2021 Asian American Pacific Islander Booklist Children's Book Committee. Bank Street College of Education Follow this and additional works at: https://educate.bankstreet.edu/ccl Part of the Children's and Young Adult Literature Commons Recommended Citation Children's Book Committee. Bank Street College of Education (2021). Asian American Pacific Islander Booklist. Bank Street College of Education. Retrieved from https://educate.bankstreet.edu/ccl/14 This Book is brought to you for free and open access by Educate. It has been accepted for inclusion in The Center for Children's Literature by an authorized administrator of Educate. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Recently-Published Recommended Books by and/or about the AAPI Community Arranged by Age Published from 2015 to early 2021 May 2021 Background A month ago, we formed a subcommittee to produce a short list of recommended books, from our Best Books List archives, centered on AAPI characters, authors, and illustrators. This was in direct response to spikes in unprovoked anti-Asian violence in the past year. That process sparked many debates over which ones to include. After that experience, the subcommittee returned to our archives for a closer inspection. We wanted to create a larger resource for readers from infancy to age 18.We also wanted to be able to deliver it within a reasonable timeframe, so here is how we created the list you see below. Methodology 1. First, we combed our recent Best Books list (BBL) archives for books that we have recommended, from our most recently published list (2020) back to the 2016 edition (meaning, books published from 2015 to 2019).
    [Show full text]
  • Amsterdam University Press CMS 2014, Vol. 2, No. 1 Www
    CMS 2014, Vol. 2, No. 1 www.comparativemigrationstudies.org Amsterdam University Press CCMS2014-1.inddMS2014-1.indd I 117-03-147-03-14 111:221:22 CCMS2014-1.inddMS2014-1.indd IIII 117-03-147-03-14 111:221:22 Colophon Comparative Migration Studies (CMS) is published as an Open Access e-journal at www.comparativemigrationstudies.org , CMS is an international, peer-reviewed journal for comparative research in the fijield of migration, integration and ethnic studies. Editorial Offfijice Peter Scholten , Erasmus University Rotterdam Sawitri Saharso , University of Twente, VU Amsterdam Karin Milovanovic , Erasmus University Rotterdam Editorial Board Sawitri Saharso , University of Twente, VU Amsterdam Peter Scholten , Erasmus University Rotterdam Ines Michalowski , Wissenschaftszentrum Berlin (WZB) Tiziana Caponio , University of Turin Phil Triadafijilopoulos , University of Toronto Andrew Geddes , University of Shefffijield Advisory Board Julia Szalai , United Nations – Research Institute for Social Development Sieglinde Rosenberger , University of Vienna Ricard Zapata Barrero , University Pompeu Fabra Barcelona Erik Bleich , Middlebury University Ferruccio Pastore , FIERI, Turin Holger Kolb , Institut für Migrationsforschung und Interkulturelle Studien (IMIS) Osnabrück Oliver Schmidtke , University of Victoria Patrick Simon , INED, France Rainer Bauböck , European University Institute Pieter Bevelander , Malmö University Marek Okólski , Warsaw University Joop Hartog , University of Amsterdam Marco Martiniello , Université de Liège Rinus Penninx
    [Show full text]
  • Refugee Children's and YA Literature
    Kathy G. Short, 2021 Children’s & Adolescent Literature on Refugee Experiences Displacement Due to Violence and War Picturebooks Beckwith, Kathy (2005). Playing War. Illus. Lea Lyon. Gardiner, ME: Tilbury House. RF Friends like to play war on the playground until a refugee child tells of losing his family in a real war. Hinojosa, Victor. (2020). A Journey toward Hope. Illus. Susan Guevara. Six Foot Press. RF The paths of four unaccompanied children from Central America through Mexico toward the U.S., and their reasons for their perilous journeys. Kaadan, Nadine (2018). Tomorrow. London: Lantana. RF A young boy in Syria is forced to stay inside due to the war around him. Lord, Michelle (2008). A Song for Cambodia. Illus. Shino Arihara. New York: Lee & Low. Bio True story of a young boy and musician who survives the Khmer Rouge killing fields and work camp. Robinson, Anthony (2009). Hamzat's Journey: A Refugee Diary. Illus. June Allan. London: Frances Lincoln. NF True story of a boy who lost his leg in a land mine during the Russia/Chechyna war and became a refugee. Smith, Icy (2010). Half Spoon of Rice: A Survival Story of the Cambodian Genocide. Illus. Sopaul Nhem. Manhattan Beach, CA: East West HF A boy separated from his family by the Khmer Rouge tries to survive when forced to work in the fields. Vander Zee, Ruth (2008). Always with You. Illus. Ronald Himler. Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans. HF A girl is orphaned when her village in Vietnam is bombed, comforted by her mother’s final words. Chapter Books Anderson, Natalie (2019).
    [Show full text]
  • A Mid-March Haggadah
    COLOMBIA SOLIDARITY SEDER HAGGADDAH Letter to those about to begin a Seder in Solidarity with Colombia. Dear Brothers and Sisters, For me it is an honor and a great pleasure for us to be strengthening ties of friendship, solidarity and social commitment to work together for the resistance and sovereignty of the people. Thank you so much for sharing with us this moment in which food converts into symbols, representing the process that we put forward to continue walking together. We will be holding a Seder April 7th from 4-7PM, and it’s good to know that on an international level we will be able to gather, unite, and strengthen each other spiritually. The Seder is a space to share the historic memory of one people with another, which is important in order to not forget what has happened. If one does not know of the past, how can one resolve the present or future? That’s what memory is for. And history is not something dead on the pages of a book, but rather something alive, something living within ourselves. And we must tell it, show it. Just like with art...if I know how to sing but don’t sing, how do I show who I am? Thus memory is something that preserves one’s identity, and also serves to feed movements of resistance. It gives us knowledge, and with that information we can deepen our studies, and begin to understand another reality—the reality that the people live, but which isn’t published— and with that we are able to build a resistance.
    [Show full text]
  • Waiting and the Temporalities of Irregular Migration
    Waiting and the Temporalities of Irregular Migration This edited volume approaches waiting both as a social phenomenon that proliferates in irregularised forms of migration and as an analytical per- spective on migration processes and practices. Waiting as an analytical perspective offers new insights into the complex and shifting nature of processes of bordering, belonging, state power, exclu- sion and inclusion, and social relations in irregular migration. The chapters in this book address legal, bureaucratic, ethical, gendered, and affective dimensions of time and migration. A key concern is to develop more the- oretically robust approaches to waiting in migration as constituted in and through multiple and relational temporalities. The chapters highlight how waiting is configured in specific legal, material, and socio-cultural situa- tions, as well as how migrants encounter, incorporate, and resist temporal structures. This collection includes ethnographic and other empirically based mate- rial, as well as theorizing that cross-cut disciplinary boundaries. It will be relevant to scholars from anthropology and sociology, and others interested in temporalities, migration, borders, and power. Christine M. Jacobsen is a Professor of Social Anthropology and the Direc- tor of the Centre for Women’s and Gender Research (SKOK) at the Univer- sity of Bergen, Norway. Marry-Anne Karlsen is a Researcher in the Centre for Women’s and Gender Research (SKOK) at the University of Bergen, Norway, and heads IMER Bergen (International Migration and Ethnic Relations research unit). Shahram Khosravi is Professor of Social Anthropology at Stockholm University, Sweden. Waiting and the Temporalities of Irregular Migration Edited by Christine M. Jacobsen, Marry-Anne Karlsen and Shahram Khosravi LONDON AND NEW YORK First published 2021 by Routledge 2 Park Square, Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon OX14 4RN and by Routledge 52 Vanderbilt Avenue, New York, NY 10017 Routledge is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group, an informa business ©2021 selection and editorial matter, Christine M.
    [Show full text]
  • Redistricting and the Territorial Community
    University of Chicago Law School Chicago Unbound Journal Articles Faculty Scholarship 2012 Redistricting and the Territorial Community Nicholas Stephanopoulos Follow this and additional works at: https://chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/journal_articles Part of the Law Commons Recommended Citation Nicholas Stephanopoulos, "Redistricting and the Territorial Community," 160 University of Pennsylvania Law Review 1379 (2012). This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Faculty Scholarship at Chicago Unbound. It has been accepted for inclusion in Journal Articles by an authorized administrator of Chicago Unbound. For more information, please contact [email protected]. ARTICLE REDISTRICTING AND THE TERRITORIAL COMMUNITY NICHOLAS 0. STEPHANOPOULOSt As the current redistrictingcycle unfolds, the courts are stuck in limbo. The Supreme Court has held unanimously that politicalgerrymandering can be un- constitutional-butit has also rejected every standardsuggested to date for dis- tinguishing lawful from unlawful districtplans. This Article offers a way out of the impasse. It proposes that courts resolve gerrymanderingdisputes by exam- ining how well districts correspond to organic geographic communities. Dis- tricts ought to be upheld when they coincide with such communities, but struck down when they unnecessarily disrupt them. This approach, which I call the "territorialcommunity test," has a robust theoretical pedigree. In fact, the proposition that communities develop geograph- ically and require legislative representationhas won wide acceptancefor most of American history. The courts have also employed variants of the test (without scholars previously having noticed) in several related fields: reapportionment, racial gerrymandering, racial vote dilution, etc. The principle of district- community congruence thus animates much of the relevant case law already.
    [Show full text]