C O N T E N T 4. Leased lines ...... 39 4.1. Market players...... 39 4.2. Market volume and market players ...... 39 4.3. Prices for the “leased lines” service ...... 40

4. Leased lines 4.1. Market players Besides the incumbent operator, BTC AD, individual licenses for carrying out through telecommunications network for provision of the leased lines service have the mobile operators (MOBILTEL EAD, COSMO MOBILE EAD, RADIOTELECOMMUNICATIONS COMPANY EOOD), some of the big cable operators (EUROCOM CABLE MANAGEMENT BULGARIA EOOD) and data transfer operators ( COMMUNICATIONS AD, NETERRA EOOD, NOVATEL EOOD). In 2006 there were no new individual licenses issued for carrying out telecommunications through telecommunications network for provision of the leased lines service. By CRC decisions No 2218 of 14.12.2006 and No 877 of 11.05.2006 the licenses of CABLETEL AD and EUROCOM CABLE EAD are transferred respectively to GLOBAL COMMUNICATION NET EAD and EUROCOM CABLE MANAGEMENT BULGARIA EOOD. At the end of the year the total number of operators licensed to provide the leased lines service amounts to 14. In 2006, besides BTC, leased lines have provided 10 more operators: BULGARTEL EAD, VESTITEL BG AD, EST AD, CABLETEL AD, COSMO BULGARIA MOBILE EAD, MEMOREX TELEX COMMUNICATIONS BULGARIA EOOD, NETERRA EOOD, NOVATEL EOOD, PANTEL BULGARIA EAD and SOFIA COMMUNICATIONS AD. 4.2. Market volume and market shares The revenues from provision of the service in 2006 amount to 127, 7 mln BGN, which represents increase of 20,3% compared to the preceding year. This is both due to the greater number of alternative operators carrying out activities in the market (10 in 2006 compared to 7 in 2005), as well as to the growth in the revenues of the incumbent operator BTC AD. The relative share of the ex-monopolist in the market structure is 95%, which represents decrease of 2 points compared to 2005, while the share of the competing operators has increased to 5% (Figure 38).

Breakdown of the revenues from leased lines of BTC AD and the alternative operators in 2006

alternative operators 5%

BTC AD 95%

Source: Data submitted to CRC Figure 38 Having in mind the significant market share of BTC in the market for provision of leased lines amounting to 97% for 2005, the competition development on this market segment depends to great extent on regulating and imposing obligations on the operator with significant market power. By Decision No 1315 of 20.06.2006 CRC for a third consecutive year has designated BTC AD as an operator with significant market power on the market of provision of the “leased lines” service, based on analysis of information for the net revenues realized by the operators for the previous year, the total volume of the “leased lines” market segment and the market shares of each of the market participants (in accordance with the provisions of the Methodology on conditions and procedure for designation of operators with significant market power)1. As SMP operator, BTC AD continued to fulfil the obligations with regard to the leased lines service stipulated

1 The high market share of the incumbent operator is due to the restricted definition for the leased lines service used for the analysis in accordance with the TA in force and the 1998 EU Regulatory framework. The market definitions and analyses in compliance with the new Electronic communications law probably will show higher market share of the alternative operators.

39 by the TA and the individual license issued for carrying out telecommunications through telecommunications network for provision of the leased line service, including international leased lines. 4.3. Prices for the leased line service The prices for the minimum set of leased lines, provided through the BTC network are in the range of the prices regulated by CRC. They shall be public and orientated towards the costs of the operator providing them. In 2005 there was no change in the prices of the Reference Offer for the leased lines service approved by the CRC Decision No 1486 of 15.07.2004. The figures 39-42 present the average retail prices per year (calculated on the basis of the monthly subscription for 12 months) for national leased lines provided by the incumbent operators in Bulgaria and the rest of the countries in South Eastern Europe2. The EU averages are also marked on the charts. The prices are presented in euro, excluding VAT and any kind of discounts resulting from individual negotiations. The EU prices are as of September 2006, the SEE ones – as of July 2006.

Prices for national 64 Kbit/s, 2 km leased lines

2 500

1 947 EU average 2 000 1 677 1 491 1 500 1 227 1 227 1 104 920 1 000 824 876 600 576 422 500

0 AL BA BА BА BG HR XM RO XS XK MK TR (bh) (ts) (ht)

The countries and regions are coded as follows: AL - Albania, BA - Bosnia & Herzegovina (bh) - BH Telecom , (ts) - Telekom Srpske, (ht) - Hrvatske Telekomunikacije, BG - Bulgaria, HR - Croatia, RO- , Mon - Montenegro, Ser - , Kos - Kosovo, MK - Macedonia, TR - Source: Cullen International, 3rd Country Comparative Report SEE, 2007; EC, 12th Implementation Report, 2007; BTC tariffs Figure 39

Prices for national 64 Kbit/s, 200 km leased lines

9 000 7 788 8 000 7 129 7 000 6 168 5 798 6 000 5 521 5 521 EU average 5 000 4 479 4 000 3 374 3 396 2 793 3 000 1 506 2 000 1 200 1 000 0 AL BA BА BА BG HR XM RO XS XK MK TR (bh) (ts) (ht)

Source: Cullen International, 3rd Country Comparative Report SEE, 2007; EC, 12th Implementation Report, 2007; BTC tariffs Figure 40

2 The prices of the three incumbent operators active in the different regions of Bosnia & Herzegovina are presented as follows: BH Telecom (BH), active in the Federation of Bosnia & Herzegovina, the only operator in some cantons and sharing the market with Hrvatske Telekomunikacije Mostar (HT) in other cantons; Telekom Srpske (TS ) active in the Republic of Serbia and Hrvatske Telekomunikacije Mostar (HT) - active in the Federation of Bosnia & Herzegovina, the only operator in some cantons and sharing the market with BH Telecom in other cantons.

40 Prices for national 2 Mbit/s, 2 km leased lines

14 000 12 190 12 000

10 000 8 153 7 362 7 362 7 454 8 000 6 748 EU average 6 000 4 418 3 300 3 397 3 408 4 000 2 726 2 927 2 000

0 AL BA BА BА BG HR XM RO XS XK MK TR (bh) (ts) (ht)

Source: Cullen International, 3rd Country Comparative Report SEE, 2007; EC, 12th Implementation Report, 2007; BTC tariffs Figure 41

Prices for national 2 Mbit/s, 200 km leased lines

80 000 67 099 70 000 60 000 53 686 50 879 50 000 41 104 41 104 40 000 33 742 28 905 EU average 30 000 20 844 19 872 14 294 20 000 11 682 10 000 6 600 0 AL BA BА BА BG HR XM RO XS XK MK TR (bh) (ts) (ht)

Source: Cullen International, 3rd Country Comparative Report SEE, 2007; EC, 12th Implementation Report, 2007; BTC tariffs Figure 42 In all the countries from the SEE region the prices for national 64 Kbit/s, 2 km leased lines are lower than the average for the EU, while the prices for the rest of the categories of leased lines vary across the countries and the regions. The lowest prices have the incumbent operators in Romania and Turkey (for 64 Kbit/s, 2 km), in Montenegro and Serbia (for 64 Kbit/s, 200 km) and in Albania and Montenegro (for the high-speed lines - 2 Mbit/s). Except for the 2 Mbit/s 200 km lines, the BTC AD prices remain respectively by 92% (for 64 Kbit/s, 2 km), 29% (for 64 Kbit/s, 200 km) and 74% (for 2 Mbit/s, 2 km) lower than the average ones in the EU. The average prices per year (the monthly subscription for 12 months) for international leased lines provided by the incumbent operators in Bulgaria and the rest of the countries from South Eastern are presented on the following charts (Figure 43-46). The prices to the United Kingdom represent the prices to distant country.

41 Prices for international leased lines - 64 Kbit/s, near country

35 000 28 779 30 000

25 000

20 000 18 481 14 921 15 000 12 834 12 424 11 043 9 255 10 000 6 600 6 960 7 328 4 661 EU average 5 000 1 800

0 AL BA BА BА BG HR XM RO XS XK MK TR (bh) (ts) (ht)

Note: The prices of Bulgaria and Romania for international leased lines, as well as the price of Macedonia for international leased lines – 64Kbit/s, near country refer to „single routing”. For the rest of the countries the prices refer to „double routing”. International circuits are often provided in the form of double routing, i.e. include an additional element of redundancy in case of technical failure. Source: Cullen International, 3rd Country Comparative Report SEE, 2007; EC, 12th Implementation Report, 2007; BTC tariffs Figure 43

Prices for international leased lines - 64 Kbit/s, distant country

40 000 35 135 35 000 29 345 30 000 23 250 25 000 22 362 20 000 17 613 13 500 14 092 15 000 11 400 11 653 10 910 8 316 10 000 EU average 5 000 1 800 0 AL BA BА BА BG HR XM RO XS XK MK TR (bh) (ts) (ht)

Source: Cullen International, 3rd Country Comparative Report SEE, 2007; EC, 12th Implementation Report, 2007; BTC tariffs Figure 44

Prices for international leased lines - 2 Mbit/s, near country

300 000 281 650

250 000 213 559 210 886 192 748 200 000

150 000 110 429 101 879 105 020 100 000 80 173 EU average 55 93454 816 50 000 30 000 9 900 0 AL BA BА BА BG HR XM RO XS XK MK TR (bh) (ts) (ht)

Source: Cullen International, 3rd Country Comparative Report SEE, 2007; EC, 12th Implementation Report, 2007; BTC tariffs Figure 45

42 Prices for international leased lines - 2 Mbit/s, distant country

450 000 417 793

400 000 361 405 350 000

300 000 273 357 263 724 245 399 250 000 200 000 176 750 138 483 139 836 150 000 99 712 EU average 100 000 71 316 45 600 50 000 9 900 0 AL BA BА BА BG HR XM RO XS XK MK TR (bh) (ts) (ht)

Source: Cullen International, 3rd Country Comparative Report SEE, 2007; EC, 12th Implementation Report, 2007; BTC tariffs Figure 46 The BTC AD prices for international leased lines (quoted in Special Drawing Rights, SDRs) keep their levels of 2004 and 2005; while the difference in their values is due only to exchange rates differences3. Their levels are close to the averages for the EU Member States. The lowest prices in the SEE region are those of the incumbent operators of Montenegro, while the highest prices are of one of the incumbent operators in Bosnia & Herzegovina (BH Telecom) and those of the operators in Macedonia and Albania. Figure 47 illustrates the average annual price for national leased lines of the incumbent operators in Bulgaria and the countries from the Organisation for economic cooperation and development (OECD), calculated based on the OECD price basket. The prices are in euro and are as of November 2006, the values exclude VAT and the initial charges for service activation. The price basket comprises national lines of 64 Kbit/s, 2 Mbit/s и 34 Mbit/s. The incumbent operators in Finland, , and Switzerland do not publish leased line tariffs any more, therefore, the price basket does not include data for these countries. The incumbent operator in Sweden also does not publish tariffs and the last available data for this country are used for the basket. Full description of the price basket can be found on the web page of Teligen Ltd4.

National leased lines price basket - incumbents in Bulgaria and the OECD countries

400000

national leased lines - 34 Mbit/s 350000 national leased lines - 2 Mbit/s national leased lines - 64 Kbit/s

300000

250000

200000

150000

100000

50000

0 UK Italy USA Spain Japan Korea Ireland Poland Turkey Iceland Mexico Austria Belgium Canada Portugal Norway Bulgaria Sweden Denmark Australia Czech Rep. Luxembourg New Zealand

Source: Teligen T-Basket (version November 2006); prices of BTC AD

3 The BTC AD prices are quoted in currency of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) – special drawing rights (SDR), the values are converted to US dollars (USD) according to data in the International Monetary Funds (IMF) special bulletins. The USD value is converted to BGN according to the USD-SDR and USD-BGN exchange rates announced by the Bulgarian National Bank for the relevant period. 4 http://www.teligen.com/publications/oecd.pdf

43 Figure 47 It could be expected that trend of entrance of more new telecommunications operators on the leased lines market will be kept for the next years. The planned for 2007 investment for construction, maintenance and usage of leased lines networks amounting 22,4 mln BGN give grounds to forecast revenue growth for this type of telecommunications activity and increasing competition.

44