Markle Foundation

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Markle Foundation Implementing a Trusted Information Sharing Environment Using Immutable Audit Logs to Increase Security, Trust, and Accountability A PAPER BY THE MARKLE TASK FORCE ON NATIONAL SECURITY IN THE INFORMATION AGE zoë baird, james barksdale chairmen M A R K L E F O U N D A T I O N TASK FORCE ON NATIONAL SECURITY IN THE INFORMATION AGE MEMBERS AND ASSOCIATES, 2006 Chairmen Eric H. Holder, Jr. Richard Falkenrath Covington & Burling The Brookings Institution Zoë Baird Markle Foundation Jeff Jonas David Gunter IBM Microsoft Corporation Jim Barksdale Barksdale Management Corporation Arnold Kanter Drew Ladner The Scowcroft Group JBoss, Inc. Members Tara Lemmey Randolph D. Moss Robert D. Atkinson LENS Ventures Wilmer Cutler Pickering LLP Progressive Policy Institute Gilman Louie Bill Neugent Eric Benhamou Alsop Louie Partners MITRE 3Com Corporation, Palm, Inc., Benhamou Global Ventures, LLC John O. Marsh, Jr. Daniel Prieto Marsh Institute for Government and Public Kennedy School of Government, Harvard Jerry Berman Policy, Shenandoah University University Center for Democracy & Technology Judith A. Miller Clay Shirky Robert M. Bryant Bechtel Group, Inc. Writer and Consultant National Insurance Crime Bureau James H. Morris Peter Swire Ashton B. Carter Carnegie Mellon University Moritz College of Law, The Ohio State University Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University Craig Mundie Kim Taipale Microsoft Corporation Center for Advanced Studies in Science and Wesley Clark Technology Policy Wesley K. Clark & Associates Jeffrey H. Smith Arnold & Porter LLP Mel Taub William P. Crowell Independent Consultant Security and Intelligence Consultant Abraham D. Sofaer Hoover Institution, Stanford University Richard Wilhelm Bryan Cunningham Booz Allen Hamilton Morgan & Cunningham LLC James B. Steinberg Lyndon Johnson School of Public Affairs, Director , National Security Program Sidney D. Drell University of Texas at Austin Stanford Linear Accelerator Center, Stanford Linda Millis University Paul Schott Stevens Markle Foundation Investment Company Institute Esther Dyson Markle Foundation Staff CNET Networks Rick White former Member of Congress Karen Byers Amitai Etzioni Managing Director and Chief Financial Officer The George Washington University Associates Kim Hogg David J. Farber Laura Bailyn Assistant to the President Carnegie Mellon University Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP Michelle Maran John Gage Rand Beers Manager, Public Affairs Sun Microsystems, Inc. Coalition for American Leadership and Security Danielle Petras John Gordon Project Assistant, Task Force on National Security United States Air Force, Retired Bruce Berkowitz in the Information Age Hoover Institution, Stanford University Slade Gorton Stuart Schear Preston Gates & Ellis LLP Scott Charney Director of Communications, Health and National Microsoft Corporation Security Programs Morton H. Halperin Open Society Institute Bob Clerman Stefaan Verhulst Mitretek Systems Chief of Research Margaret A. Hamburg Nuclear Threat Initiative Jim Dempsey Visualization Producer Center for Democracy & Technology John J. Hamre Sean Dolan Center for Strategic and International Studies Mary DeRosa LENS Ventures Center for Strategic and International Studies Implementing a Trusted Information Sharing Environment Using Immutable Audit Logs to Increase Security, Trust, and Accountability* February 2006 A Project of The Markle Foundation New York City * The Markle Foundation Task Force on National Security in the Information Age acknowledges and thanks Jeff Jonas and Peter Swire as lead authors of this monograph, as well as Daniel Prieto for initial editing. Executive Summary policies and laws. The resulting lack of trust in institutional compliance can lead to a situation in which reasonable and desirable uses of information are Widespread adoption of a trusted information sharing blocked for fear that privacy and civil liberties environment (ISE) requires that users have confidence in protections may be violated, or that data could be the security of the system. To promote confidence and misused. As such, IALs may represent an intermediate trust in the ISE and to help govern information sharing, solution between public communication and total the ISE should incorporate robust security and audit secrecy. features, including immutable audit logs (IALs). The ability to maintain tamper-resistant logs of user activity on This paper seeks to provide insight into the use of the network can increase security, build trust among IALs for the ISE by exploring the technical, policy, and users, ensure compliance with relevant policies and security issues relating to IALs. The paper explores guidelines, and improve transparency and the ability to some of the technical issues relating to IALs, including perform oversight by appropriate stakeholders outside of what can be logged effectively, the differences between the system. mutable and immutable logs, and institutional barriers to deployment of IALs. It analyzes some of the Audit logs will record activity that takes place on the potential benefits to the ISE of deploying IALs. At the information sharing network, such as, for example, same time, the paper recognizes some drawbacks, queries made by users, the information accessed, including the possibility that IALs may introduce new information flows between systems, and date- and time- vulnerabilities. Finally, the paper offers policy markers for those activities. Making such logs immutable recommendations. builds confidence that they accurately reflect actual activity and have not been altered. By providing thorough The paper intentionally does not examine or discuss recordkeeping on the activities that occur within the ISE, other potential and beneficial functions of a officials can use IALs to demonstrate that sharing comprehensive logging system, which might include: behavior complies with applicable laws and policies, and monitoring system and network functionality, or to detect violations. IALs will be a critical component for system self-awareness (for example, to discover the ISE since improved and innovative sharing behavior common interests among users, inform resource will represent a marked departure from the current decisions, or improve analysis and reporting by business and behavioral models typical within contributing to a planning process). government. ISE managers should ensure that IALs do not create their A. Benefits of using IALs own security vulnerability by using encryption, ensuring that logs are never stored in a single location, strictly Any audit—whether based on mutable or immutable limiting access to logs, and subjecting everyone reviewing logs—provides benefits, including the ability to deter, logs to audit. detect, and prove policy violations. The ability to perform audits within a system serves as a deterrent because system users will know in advance that logging Discussion and Analysis and auditing are being used to identify policy violations. The perception that a system is effectively logged and It is essential to put in place effective safeguards and will be audited may thus reduce violations by users. security measures to accompany greater sharing of Detection occurs when an actual policy violation is sensitive information within the ISE. The Markle uncovered after the fact. Detection may occur as a Foundation Task Force on National Security in the result of sampling, when one of the transactions Information Age recommended a number of such selected for random audit reveals a violation. Detection measures in its 2003 report, Creating a Trusted Information may also occur in the context of a specific Network for Homeland Security (available at investigation, when the actions of a suspect are www.markle.org). One powerful component of the ISE examined carefully and a violation is detected. Finally, should be the ability to record system activity in IALs. audits can be used to create evidence of a violation. If there is a credible recordkeeping system in place, then IALs are especially important for systems where there is records from the system can be convincing to those limited transparency, such as the ISE, which contains investigating and judging a case. classified government information. Without logging of user activity in such systems, there is no way to Typically, audit logs are maintained in the custody of a demonstrate clearly for oversight and accountability highly privileged system user, for example, a system purposes that there is compliance with established administrator with authorized access. Logs are typically MARKLE FOUNDATION 1 mutable—that is, the system administrator (or others with missing transaction is physically apparent appropriate privileges) can add, change, and delete log entries. from a gap in the paper roll. Traditional mutable logs are also vulnerable to unauthorized tampering by a malicious party other than the system In the shift to computerized administrator. Indeed, changing logs is a standard procedure recordkeeping, there are techniques for for both inside and outside hackers in order to hide evidence essentially reproducing the functionality of that would reveal their unauthorized activity. the continuous roll of paper. Electronic records can be digitally date- and time- To address deficiencies of trust in mutable logs, immutable stamped, to assure the integrity of the logs require either that log information cannot be altered by stamped record. In addition, records can anyone regardless of access privilege (true immutability) or
Recommended publications
  • Leaving Reality Behind Etoy Vs Etoys Com Other Battles to Control Cyberspace By: Adam Wishart Regula Bochsler ISBN: 0066210763 See Detail of This Book on Amazon.Com
    Leaving Reality Behind etoy vs eToys com other battles to control cyberspace By: Adam Wishart Regula Bochsler ISBN: 0066210763 See detail of this book on Amazon.com Book served by AMAZON NOIR (www.amazon-noir.com) project by: PAOLO CIRIO paolocirio.net UBERMORGEN.COM ubermorgen.com ALESSANDRO LUDOVICO neural.it Page 1 discovering a new toy "The new artist protests, he no longer paints." -Dadaist artist Tristan Tzara, Zh, 1916 On the balmy evening of June 1, 1990, fleets of expensive cars pulled up outside the Zurich Opera House. Stepping out and passing through the pillared porticoes was a Who's Who of Swiss society-the head of state, national sports icons, former ministers and army generals-all of whom had come to celebrate the sixty-fifth birthday of Werner Spross, the owner of a huge horticultural business empire. As one of Zurich's wealthiest and best-connected men, it was perhaps fitting that 650 of his "close friends" had been invited to attend the event, a lavish banquet followed by a performance of Romeo and Juliet. Defiantly greeting the guests were 200 demonstrators standing in the square in front of the opera house. Mostly young, wearing scruffy clothes and sporting punky haircuts, they whistled and booed, angry that the opera house had been sold out, allowing itself for the first time to be taken over by a rich patron. They were also chanting slogans about the inequity of Swiss society and the wealth of Spross's guests. The glittering horde did its very best to ignore the disturbance. The protest had the added significance of being held on the tenth anniversary of the first spark of the city's most explosive youth revolt of recent years, The Movement.
    [Show full text]
  • The Task Force Report
    THE MARKLE FOUNDATION TASK FORCE ON NATIONAL SECURITY IN THE INFORMATION AGE Chairmen John Gage Participating Experts Sun Microsystems, Inc. (Non-government) Zoë Baird Markle Foundation Slade Gorton Bruce Berkowitz Preston Gates & Ellis RAND Corporation James L. Barksdale The Barksdale Group Morton H. Halperin Robert Clerman Open Society Institute Mitretek Executive Director Margaret A. Hamburg Mary DeRosa Philip Zelikow Nuclear Threat Initiative Center for Strategic and International Miller Center of Public Affairs Studies University of Virginia John J. Hamre Center for Strategic and International Lauren Hall Members Studies Microsoft Alexander Aleinikoff Eric Holder James Lewis Georgetown University Law Center Covington & Burling Center for Strategic and International Studies Robert D. Atkinson Arnold Kanter Progressive Policy Institute The Scowcroft Group Gilman Louie In-Q-Tel Stewart A. Baker Robert Kimmitt Steptoe & Johnson AOL Time Warner, Inc. Douglas McDonald Abt Associates Eric Benhamou Michael O. Leavitt 3Com Corp. and Palm, Inc. Governor of Utah Daniel Ortiz University of Virginia Jerry Berman Tara Lemmey School of Law Center for Democracy and Project LENS Technology Michael Vatis Judith A. Miller Institute for Security and Technology Robert M. Bryant Williams & Connolly Studies National Insurance Crime Bureau Dartmouth College James H. Morris Ashton Carter Carnegie Mellon University Task Force Staff Harvard University Craig Mundie Mary McKinley Wesley Clark Microsoft Associate Director Stephens Group, Inc. Jeffrey H. Smith Ryan Coonerty Wayne Clough Arnold & Porter Government Affairs Counsel Georgia Institute of Technology Abraham D. Sofaer Peter Kerr William P. Crowell Hoover Institution Markle Foundation Cylink Corporation Stanford University Laura Rozen Sidney D. Drell James B. Steinberg Senior Associate Stanford University The Brookings Institution Tara Sonenshine Esther Dyson Paul Schott Stevens Advisor EDventure Holdings Dechert Stefaan Verhulst Amitai Etzioni Rick White Markle Foundation The George Washington University TechNet David J.
    [Show full text]
  • Creating a Trusted Information Network for Homeland Security Second Report of the Markle Foundation Task Force
    Creating a Trusted Network for Homeland Security Second Report of the Markle Foundation Task Force zoë baird, james barksdale chairmen michael a. vatis executive director Copyright © 2003 Markle Foundation All rights reserved. ISBN 0-9747809-0-1 markle foundation task force on national security in the information age Chairmen Slade Gorton James Dempsey Preston, Gates & Ellis Center for Democracy and Technology Zoë Baird Markle Foundation Morton H. Halperin Mary DeRosa Open Society Institute Center for Strategic and International James L. Barksdale Studies The Barksdale Group Margaret A. Hamburg Nuclear Threat Initiative Lara Flint Executive Director Center for Democracy and Technology John J. Hamre Michael A. Vatis Center for Strategic and International Lauren Hall Markle Foundation Studies Microsoft Members Eric Holder Jeff Jonas Covington & Burling Systems Research & Development Alexander Aleinikoff Georgetown University Law Center Arnold Kanter James Lewis The Scowcroft Group Center for Strategic and International Robert D. Atkinson Studies Progressive Policy Institute Michael O. Leavitt Governor of Utah Terrill D. Maynard Stewart Baker Steptoe & Johnson Tara Lemmey Mary McCarthy Project LENS Center for Strategic and International Eric Benhamou Studies 3Com Corporation Gilman Louie In-Q-Tel Patrick J. Sullivan, Jr. Jerry Berman Cherry Creek Schools Center for Democracy and Technology Judith A. Miller Williams & Connolly Winston Wiley Robert M. Bryant Booz Allen Hamilton National Insurance Crime Bureau James Morris Carnegie Mellon University Associate Director Ashton Carter Harvard University Craig Mundie Mary McKinley Microsoft Markle Foundation Wesley P. Clark Wesley P. Clark & Associates Jeffrey H. Smith Task Force Staff Arnold & Porter Wayne Clough Nancy Boursiquot Georgia Institute of Technology Abraham D.
    [Show full text]
  • Azer Bestavros Biographical Sketch
    Azer Bestavros Biographical Sketch Azer Bestavros is Warren Distinguished Professor of Computer Science and Founding Director of the Hariri Institute for Comput- ing at Boston University (BU), which was set up in 2011 as an incu- bator for high-risk, high-reward multidisciplinary collaborations. Notable efforts that he incubated at the Institute, which matured into multi-million-dollar projects, include the $25M+ Mass Open Cloud, $10M NSF Cloud Security Frontier project, $5M Red Hat Collaboratory for open-source innovation, and the $1M+ SCOPE cloud platform for smart-city applications. Under his leadership, the Institute served as an anchor for a number of university pro- grams, including the Data Science Initiative (DSI), the Digital Health Initiative, the Digital Learning Initiative (DLI), the AI Research Initiative (AIR), the Cyber Security, Law, and Society Alliance, the Software & Application Innovation Lab (SAIL), and BU Spark! for student-driven innovation. Prior to his inaugural role at the Hariri Institute, Professor Bestavros chaired the BU Computer Science Department from 2000 to 2007, having joined it in 1991 after completing his PhD in Computer Science at Harvard University. He holds affiliated appointments in the Department of Electrical & Computer Engineering, the Division of Systems Engineering, and a number of research centers at BU. He held visiting professorships at Harvard University, Institut Eur´ecomin France, KTH Royal Institute of Technology in Sweden, and the American University in Cairo. A distinguished educator and scholar, Professor Bestavros teaches and pursues research in networking, distributed computing, cybersecurity, and high-assurance systems. His semi- nal contributions include pioneering studies of web push caching through content distribution networks, self-similar Internet traffic characterization, game-theoretic cloud resource manage- ment, and safety certification of networked systems and software.
    [Show full text]
  • Designing Learning Futures Digital Media & Learning Conference
    DESIGNING LEARNING FUTURES DIGITAL MEDIA & LEARNING CONFERENCE MARCH 3-5, 2011 // LONG BEACH, CALIFORNIA SPONSORS OVERVIEW About the Theme: Designing Learning Futures Conference Chair and Committee Keynotes and Plenary Session Panelists CONFERENCE SCHEDULE [9] Overview [10] March 3, 2011 [11] March 4, 2011 [11] March 5, 2011 CONFERENCE INFORMATION Wireless and Social Media at DML2011 Conference Receptions and Gatherings CONFERENCE PROGRAM ABSTRACTS [15] March 3, 2011 [28] March 4, 2011 [51] March 5, 2011 CONFERENCE PROGRAM DEMOS AND EXHIBITS March 3, 2011: Mozilla Science Fair March 4, 2011: Demos & Exhibits Sponsored by the Pearson Foundation MAPS Conference Venue Maps Map of Local Area GENERAL INFORMATION About Long Beach Travel and Accommodation Local Cuisine SUPPLEMENTS RoadTrip Nation DMLcentral DML Competition DESIGNING LEARNING FUTURES DIGITAL MEDIA & LEARNING CONFERENCE Hilton Conference & Meeting Center // Long Beach, CaliforniaMarch 3-5, 2011 CONFERENCE CHAIR Katie Salen CONFERENCE COMMITTEE Kimberly Austin Student Volunteers Chair danah boyd Emerging Platforms and Policies Chair Sheryl Grant DML Competition Liason Chair Heather A. Horst Local Organizing Committee Chair Trebor Scholz Social Media Chair Mark Surman New Collectives Chair S. Craig Watkins Youth, Digital Media and Empowerment Chair KEYNOTE PRESENTERS Alice Taylor Muki Hansteen-Izora The Digital Media and Learning Conference is an annual event supported by the MacArthur Foun- dation and organized by the Digital Media and Learning Research Hub at University of California, Irvine. The conference is meant to be an inclusive, international and annual gathering of scholars and practitioners in the field, focused on fostering interdisciplinary and participatory dialog and linking theory, empirical study, policy, and practice. SPONSORS UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA UC HUMANITIES RESEHRARCH INSTITUTEI DML hub CONFERENCE OVERVIEW The Digital Media and Learning Conference 2011 is the second annual event organized by the Digital Media and Learning Hub at the University of California, Irvine.
    [Show full text]
  • “There Are Many Things to Love About Connecting for Health
    Nation At Risk: Policy Makers Need Better Information to Protect the Country The Markle Foundation Task Force on National Security in the Information Age March 2009 THE MARKLE FOUNDATION TASK FORCE ON NATIONAL SECURITY IN THE INFORMATION AGE Zoë Baird, Co-Chair* Jim Barksdale, Co-Chair The Markle Foundation Barksdale Management Corporation MEMBERS: Robert D. Atkinson Jim Dempsey* Slade Gorton* Judith A. Miller* Information Technology and Center for Democracy & K&L Gates Bechtel Group, Inc. Innovation Foundation Technology Morton H. Halperin James H. Morris Rand Beers** Mary DeRosa** Open Society Institute Carnegie Mellon University National Security Network Senate Committee on the Judiciary Margaret A. Hamburg** Craig Mundie Eric Benhamou Nuclear Threat Initiative Microsoft Corporation 3Com Corporation, Palm, Inc., Sidney D. Drell Benhamou Global Ventures, LLC Stanford Linear John J. Hamre Jeffrey H. Smith* Accelerator Center, Center for Strategic and Arnold & Porter LLP Jerry Berman Stanford University International Studies Center for Democracy & Abraham D. Sofaer* Technology Esther Dyson Eric H. Holder, Jr.** Hoover Institution, CNET Networks Covington & Burling Stanford University Robert M. Bryant National Insurance Crime Bureau Amitai Etzioni Jeff Jonas* James B. Steinberg** The George Washington IBM Lyndon Johnson School of Public Ashton B. Carter** University Affairs, University of Texas at Kennedy School of Government, Arnold Kanter Austin Harvard University Richard Falkenrath The Scowcroft Group New York Police Department Kim Taipale Wesley Clark Tara Lemmey* Center for Advanced Studies in Wesley K. Clark & Associates David J. Farber LENS Ventures Science Carnegie Mellon University and Technology Policy William P. Crowell* Gilman Louie Security and Intelligence John Gage Alsop Louie Partners Rick White* Consultant Kleiner Perkins Caulfield & Byers former Member of Congress John O.
    [Show full text]
  • Solving the Dilbert Paradox
    Solving the Dilbert Paradox Richard Adler Rapporteur Communications and Society Program Charles M. Firestone Executive Director Washington, D.C. 2011 To purchase additional copies of this report, please contact: The Aspen Institute Publications Office P.O. Box 222 109 Houghton Lab Lane Queenstown, Maryland 21658 Phone: (410) 820-5326 Fax: (410) 827-9174 E-mail: [email protected] For all other inquiries, please contact: The Aspen Institute Communications and Society Program One Dupont Circle, NW Suite 700 Washington, DC 20036 Phone: (202) 736-5818 Fax: (202) 467-0790 Charles M. Firestone Patricia K. Kelly Executive Director Assistant Director Copyright © 2011 by The Aspen Institute This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution- Noncommercial 3.0 United States License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/us/ or send a letter to Creative Commons, 171 Second Street, Suite 300, San Francisco, California, 94105, USA. The Aspen Institute One Dupont Circle, NW Suite 700 Washington, DC 20036 Published in the United States of America in 2011 by The Aspen Institute All rights reserved Printed in the United States of America ISBN: 0-89843-545-5 11-006 1816CSP/11-BK Contents FOREWORD, Charles M. Firestone ...............................................................v SOLVING THE DILBERT PARADOX, Richard Adler Defining the Dilbert Paradox ......................................................................... 3 Defining Talent ...............................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Mobilizing Information to Prevent Terrorism Accelerating Development of a Trusted Information Sharing Environment
    Mobilizing Information to Prevent Terrorism Accelerating Development of a Trusted Information Sharing Environment Third Report of the Markle Foundation Task Force ZOË BAIRD, JAMES BARKSDALE CHAIRMEN M ARKLE F OUNDATION TASK FORCE ON NATIONAL SECURITY IN THE INFORMATION AGE MEMBERS AND ASSOCIATES, 2006 Chairmen John Gage Richard Wilhelm Sun Microsystems, Inc. Booz Allen Hamilton Zoë Baird Markle Foundation John Gordon Associates United States Air Force, Retired Jim Barksdale Bruce Berkowitz Barksdale Management Slade Gorton Hoover Institution, Stanford University Corporation Preston Gates & Ellis LLP Fred Cate Members Morton H. Halperin Indiana University School of Law Open Society Institute Bloomington Robert D. Atkinson Information Technology Margaret A. Hamburg Scott Charney and Innovation Foundation Nuclear Threat Initiative Microsoft Corporation Rand Beers John J. Hamre Bob Clerman Coalition for American Leadership Center for Strategic and International Mitretek Systems and Security Studies David Gunter Eric Benhamou Eric H. Holder, Jr. Microsoft Corporation 3Com Corporation, Palm, Inc., Benhamou Covington & Burling Global Ventures, LLC Drew Ladner Jeff Jonas JBoss, Inc. Jerry Berman IBM Center for Democracy & Technology Bill Neugent Arnold Kanter MITRE Robert M. Bryant The Scowcroft Group National Insurance Crime Bureau Daniel B. Prieto Tara Lemmey Reform Institute Ashton B. Carter LENS Ventures Kennedy School of Government, Clay Shirky Harvard University Gilman Louie Writer and Consultant Alsop Louie Partners Wesley Clark Peter Swire Wesley K. Clark & Associates John O. Marsh, Jr. Moritz College of Law, The Ohio State Marsh Institute for Government and University William P. Crowell Public Policy, Shenandoah University Security and Intelligence Consultant Mel Taub Judith A. Miller Independent Consultant Bryan Cunningham Bechtel Group, Inc.
    [Show full text]
  • UNITED STATES INTERNATIONAL TRADE COMMISSION Washington, D.C. 20436 Before the Honorable David P. Shaw Administrative Law Judge
    UNITED STATES INTERNATIONAL TRADE COMMISSION Washington, D.C. 20436 Before the Honorable David P. Shaw Administrative Law Judge In the Matter of CERTAIN POINT-TO-POINT NETWORK Investigation No. 337-TA-892 COMMUNICATION DEVICES AND PRODUCTS CONTAINING SAME RESPONDENTS’ IDENTIFICATION OF EXPERT WITNESSES Pursuant to the Procedural Schedule, Respondents AmTRAN Logistics, Inc. and AmTRAN Technology Co., Ltd., LG Electronics, Inc., LG Electronics U.S.A., Inc., and LG Electronics MobileComm U.S.A., Inc., Panasonic Corporation and Panasonic Corporation of North America, Sharp Corporation and Sharp Electronics Corporation, Sony Corporation, Sony Corporation of America, Sony Electronics Inc., Sony Mobile Communications AB, Sony Mobile Communications (USA) Inc., Sony Computer Entertainment, Inc., and Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC, Toshiba Corporation, Toshiba America, Inc., and Toshiba America Information Systems, Inc., and VIZIO, Inc. (collectively “Respondents”) hereby identify the following expert witnesses, including their expertise and curriculum vitae, who may testify on behalf of one or more Respondents at the hearing in this investigation. Respondents will present the testimony of these expert witnesses live, through witness statements, or through depositions. This identification of experts is based on Respondents’ current understanding of the evidence produced thus far during discovery. In as much as discovery is ongoing, Respondents reserve the right to supplement this identification as warranted. 1. Donal O’Mahony Professor Donal E. O’Mahoney received a degree in Engineering and a Ph.D in Computer Science from Trinity College Dublin, where he is presently a professor of Computer Science. Professor O’Mahoney’s areas of expertise include network protocols, security applications, mobility, ad-hoc networking, and the software engineering of networked systems.
    [Show full text]
  • Visioning Justice and the American Jewish Community
    VISIONING JUSTICE and the American Jewish Community by Shifra Bronznick and Didi Goldenhar CREDITS Shifra Bronznick served as principal author and investigator for Visioning Justice and the American Jewish Community, the research and action project launched by the Jewish Life and Values Program of the Nathan Cummings Foundation. Didi Goldenhar, served as co-author of Visioning Justice and the American Jewish Community. Dr. Steven M. Cohen provided scholarly counsel on American Jewish life and social justice. Hillary Leone and Christopher Bugbee offered important intelligence about new technologies and social media. Rabbi Jennie Rosenn, Director of the Jewish Life and Values Program of the Nathan Cummings Foundation, launched this inquiry and served as a wise and insightful partner throughout the process. A complete listing of individuals who generously participated in interviews and conversations can be found in Appendix A. Design: Cabengo LLC We appreciate the support of FJC. To download copies of this report go to www.nathancummings.net/jewish/001081.html The Nathan Cummings Foundation 475 Tenth Avenue, Fourteenth Floor New York, NY 10018 1.212.787.7300 www.nathancummings.org Table of Contents A Letter from the Nathan Cummings Foundation ………………………………… 4 Overview and Key Findings ……………………………………………………………………… 7 The Nathan Cummings Foundation and Jewish Social Justice …………………… 8 Visioning Justice and the American Jewish Community …………………………… 10 What We Have Learned ………………………………………………………………………………… 11 Strategies ……………………………………………………………………………………………………
    [Show full text]
  • Opportunity Rising: Empowering Americans to Flourish in a Global Networked Economy and Revitalizingvisual the Identity American Dream Manual
    ECONOMIC FUTURE INITIATIVE Opportunity Rising: Empowering Americans to Flourish in a Global Networked Economy and RevitalizingVisual the Identity American Dream Manual In recent years, globalization and technology limitless possibilities offered by online have changed our way of life more than platforms, the digital economy can make it anyone could have imagined. While enriching far easier for Americans and businesses of “The America we want us in many ways, these forces also have all sizes to offer skills and services to anyone, eliminated traditionally secure jobs and anywhere—here or abroad. our children to inherit—a eroded economic security for millions. Now country that is strong and we face a great national challenge: finding Through information sharing, online tools, new strategies that help all Americans and innovative forms of credit and finance, inspires opportunity for flourish in today’s economy. people can more easily expand or launch new businesses and hire more workers. all—is at risk. There is Americans can learn and train in innovative “What big gear could we find that ways that can better connect them to good- nothing more important paying jobs. we could grab and move one way than finding ways to or another and make all the little The Initiative is both a catalyst and an ones spin?” advocate for actions that help Americans use advance Americans – Michael Leavitt the transformative forces of technology and Chairman, Leavitt Partners globalization to their advantage in order to at all income levels to Former Governor, State of Utah Former Administrator, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency succeed in a world of constant change.
    [Show full text]
  • Corner Office
    SPECIAL: Breakthrough Ideas for 2005…page 17 www.hbr.org February 2005 The Hole in the 72 Ending the CEO Succession Crisis Ram Charan Corner Office 82 Productive Friction: How Difficult Business Partnerships Can Accelerate Innovation John Hagel III and John Seely Brown 92 Should Nonprofits Seek Profits? William Foster and Jeffrey Bradach 104 Change Through Persuasion David A. Garvin and Michael A. Roberto 114 The HBR Interview Transforming an Industrial Giant Heinrich von Pierer 17 The HBR List Breakthrough Ideas for 2005 59 HBR Case Study Springboard to a Swan Dive? Ajit Kambil and Bruce Beebe 125 Managing Yourself Two Executives, One Career Cynthia R. Cunningham and Shelley S. Murray 132 Best Practice Strategic Sourcing: From Periphery to the Core Mark Gottfredson, Rudy Puryear, and Stephen Phillips …page 72 146 Executive Summaries 152 Panel Discussion TLFeBOOK Allstate High-performance customer service, delivered. To maintain its position as one of the country’s 2004 Accenture. All rights reserved. largest property and casualty insurers—while © also positioning itself to offer a broader range of financial products—Allstate wanted to offer new ways of interacting with customers, and to do it on an aggressive schedule. Building on a long relationship with Allstate, Accenture deployed eight development teams to help design and implement The Good Hands Network,® which adds integrated Internet and call center channels to the existing system of local agents. Deployed in just 18 months, the two new channels enable customers to do business with Allstate 24/7. Already, over 40 percent of the company’s more than 6 million yearly inquiries are made outside of traditional business hours, further extending the company’s standing as a high-performance business.
    [Show full text]