International Conference on Information, Business and Education Technology (ICIBIT 2013)

Chinese Companies and Their Quest for Globalization

Harlan D. Whatley1 1Swiss Management Center, Zurich, Switzerland

Abstract players in the technology market (Sun, 2009). Chinese internet companies have seen an This qualitative research paper unprecedented growth over the past explores the quest for globalization of decade. However, very few are two successful Chinese internet recognized brands outside of while companies: and Holdings. some seek to develop their brands in In this case study, the focus is on the foreign markets. This paper analyzes the marketing strategies of these expanding marketing strategies of two internet multinational enterprises and the companies: Baidu and Tencent and their challenges they face to become quest for globalization. recognized as global brands. All of the firms in this study were founded as Keywords: Baidu, Tencent, internet, private enterprises with no ownership ties branding, marketing, globalization, China to the Chinese government. Furthermore, an analysis of the countries and markets 1. Introduction targeted by the firms is included in the study. In addition to a review of the Innovation efforts by technology current academic literature, interviews companies in China are driven by adding were conducted with marketing and significant value to imported foreign strategy professionals from the technologies or by developing new perspective firms as well as journalists products to satisfy specific domestic that closely follow Chinese internet firms demands (Li, Chen & Shapiro, 2010). and the technology sector. This study on Firms in the emerging market of China do the globalization of Chinese internet not possess the R&D resources that their firms will contribute to marketing developed Western counterparts have. research on this region and sector. However, this is changing as Sino internet enterprises extend their reach 2. Baidu globally into foreign markets. Boisot and Meyer (2012) argued that it is easier for Co-founded in 2000 by , who Chinese firms to develop their business in dropped out of a PhD program at the foreign markets as opposed to the State University of New York at Buffalo, government controlled domestic market and Eric Xu, a Silicon Valley venture in mainland China. More attention is capitalist, Baidu is China’s most popular being directed towards Chinese (Rabkin, 2012). Also, it is multinational corporations as they have the world’s leading risen from humble beginnings to search engine and is ranked as the becoming recognized as international world’s fifth most popular web site (Alexa.com, 2012). The firm is publicly

© 2013. The authors - Published by Atlantis Press 229 traded on the stock exchange strategy is in its very early stages of and has a market capitalization of $41.6 execution now. We appreciate how billion (Jiang, 2012). Baidu is ranked dynamic the situation is in all emerging 25th on the BrandZ list of the Top 100 internet markets, and we'll have to be Most Valuable Global Brands adaptable, responsive, and opportunistic” (MillwardBrown.com, 2012). The name, (personal communication, September 5, Baidu, translates from Chinese to English 2012). as “hundreds of times” and comes from a Song Dynasty poem (ir.Baidu.com, 2012). 2.3 Partnerships Frank (2012) emphasized that 2.1 Baidu’s partnerships are valuable for two reasons: Baidu’s primary revenue streams come companies will get more market value from advertising via Pay per Click (PPC) and gain the trust of its clients and it can and search engine optimization via Pay provide better services to regular for Placement (P4P). In 2009, Baidu consumers. One of Baidu’s strongest revamped its business model to provide partnerships is with the Chinese better targeting and a new pricing site, , which structure that calculated ad values based has over 300 million users and is China’s on competitors' blind bids (Greenberg, Jie answer to . The partnership is in & Hardy, 2009). In essence, they response to Baidu’s shuttering of their comingle paid search results with natural microblogging product, Baidu Talk, and ones. Baidu Union, where Baidu’s search provides cooperation between the two box field is used on partnering web sites, firms in the areas of search, content, generates shared revenue with hundreds platform, technology, and resources (Lau, of thousands of sites. Recently, Baidu 2012). planned to generate revenue through In the fall of 2011, Baidu released online marketing on its , its mobile popular online forum, which built around Android OS. Lee (2012) will allow clients to market products to reported that Baidu partnered with the forum's users (Investor’s Business Computer to include Baidu Yi on Dell Daily, 2012). handsets and tablets. Baidu Yi has been rebranded as Baidu Cloud and was 2.2 Marketing strategies recently launched on a TCL Baidu’s marketing strategy includes (Millward, 2012). Other partnerships for effective market segmentation and a Baidu include web-based travel services focus strategy in order to raise its click companies Qunar and . These rate and increase site traffic (Kotler, partnerships are in with ’s Keller & Lu, 2009). Jiang (2012) recent acquisition of Frommer’s, a U.S. stressed that “Baidu benefited travel services company (Olanoff, 2012). tremendously from its early-mover status, 2.4 International efforts a carefully crafted ‘China’ brand image, and its aggressive (and sometimes Cooper (2010) observed that “language is questionable) marketing tactics that have an important in ensuring a involved paid search ranking, site consistent brand culture” (p. 13). Baidu blocking, and paid removal of negative announced its intentions to enter the results” (p. 16). According to Kaiser Kuo, Japanese search market in December Director of International Communications 2006 and began server testing in in at Baidu, “our international growth March 2007 with an official launch in

230 January of 2008 with web, image, video who touts their browser as and search services (Baidu.com, being more convenient coupled with 2012). Like eBay’s attempt to crack the superior /anti-virus capabilities, Japanese market, this has been a difficult despite Baidu’s superior content and task for Baidu. From 2008 to 2011, resources (Zhang, 2012). Baidu lost 700 million RMB as search engine titans Yahoo! and Google 3. Tencent Holdings dominate the Japanese market (Hopkins, 2012). Founded by “Pony” Huateng and four In May of 2012, Baidu launched an college students in in 1998, office in Australia aimed at helping local Tencent’s QQ service offers a chat firms tap into the potential of China's program, a search engine, an e-commerce internet space. Baidu formed a joint marketplace and some of the most venture with a Sydney-based firm, China popular online games in China (Einhorn Search International, and recruited some & Stone, 2011). Wu and Frantz (2012) seasoned talent from Telstra and stated that "the mission of the company is NineMSN to spearhead the initiative to enhance the quality of life through (Apostolou, 2012). internet value added services" (p. 95). In 2012, Baidu formed BIRC, a joint Tencent Holdings is publicly traded on research lab in with I2R, to the Stock Exchange and is focus on natural language processing ranked 37th on the BrandZ list of the Top technologies, allowing Baidu to research 100 Most Valuable Global Brands Thai and Vietnamese language (MillwardBrown.com, 2012). In Chinese, capabilities (Wee, 2012). This will give Tencent means, roughly, "galloping Baidu a better idea of their customer base message", which is in line with its core in these countries, where they already product known as “QQ” have launched products such as the (Tencent.com, 2012). web directory, Baidu Tieba and Tra Da Quan (social networking service) 3.1 Tencent’s business model (Russell, 2012). Unfortunately, Hopkins Tencent segments its business into the (2012) shared that Baidu has encountered following groups: Corporate some operating license issues with the Development Group (CDG), Interactive Vietnamese government. Wee (2012) Entertainment Group (IEG), Mobile noted that Baidu is doing quite well in Internet Group (MIG), Online Media due to the large Chinese ex-pat Group (OMG), Social Network Group community there. (SNG), Technology and Engineering 2.5 Competition Group (TEG) and Tencent E-Commerce Holding Company (ECC) (Tencent.com, Baidu faces stiff competition from 2012). Recently, Tencent announced that English language search engines Google it would adopt an open platform business and Yahoo! but has managed to form an model, a major strategic shift for the alliance with ’s Bing. With company (Shen, 2012). Google’s exit from China to Hong Kong Tencent entered into a partnership with in 2010, this created an even better , the US game maker best known stronghold for Baidu, which now controls for games like FarmVille, which it 80% of the Chinese search engine market created for . China Economic (Greenberg, Jie & Hardy, 2009). In China, Review (2012) affirmed that the breadth Baidu is continually being challenged by of Tencent’s games business includes

231 mobile applications, social games, online connection to the media or content shooters and massively multiplayer role- business are looking to get in. playing games (MMORPGs). In 2011, Tencent set up a 500 million RMB online games accounted for 5.3 billion investment fund in April of 2011 focused RMB or 55% of Tencent’s revenue (Shen, on online entertainment content that 2012). Tencent faces fierce competition included a 4.4% stake in Huayi Brothers in the online games market in China from Media, producer and distributor of some , Netease and ChangYou (Olsen, of China's most popular film and 2011), although China Economic Review television productions (Coonan, 2012). (2012) argued that online games are Gaopeng is a fledgling joint venture waning in popularity in China. The open between Tencent and and is the platform approach may in part be a eighth largest daily deal site in China response to heated competition, such as (Ollier, 2011). Another joint venture is the Twitter-like micro-blogging service, with Tencent, Alibaba and Ping An or weibo, introduced by Sina, a Tencent Insurance, which is risky, as the three competitor, in 2009. Leveraging its firms are looking to insure online buyers enormous reach, Tencent launched its against internet fraud in China (Young, own weibo in 2010 (Rapoza, 2012). 2012). In May of 2011, Tencent invested in the Asian travel portal, eLong.com, 3.2 Marketing strategies mimicking the online travel strategies of Wu and Frantz (2012) asserted that Baidu and Google (Tencent.com, 2012). Tencent‘s marketing approach includes 3.3 International efforts forward orientation, independent innovation and national brands creation. As part of their international strategy, Tencent strongly utilizes strategic Tencent launched an English language partnerships with leading domestic and version of their website called ImQQ.com. foreign brands. Some of Tencent’s iPhone and Android users can download partnerships include Vinagame (Vietnam), English versions of QQ to their LevelUp (Singapore), (USA), at no cost to the end user. Activation Blizzard (USA) and Zynga The style of QQ's English version is in (USA). In 2011, Tencent partnered with line with the aesthetic of Westerners and Sky-mobi Limited, the leading mobile is very user friendly (Wu & Frantz, 2012). application store in China, to promote Outside of China, Tencent has Tencent’s QQ mobile browser via Sky- penetrated , Singapore, and mobi’s Maopao application store product Vietnam. In India, Tencent signed a (Worldwide Telecom, 2011). licensing and franchise agreement with In addition to online games, other MIH in 2008 and owns a 20% stake in the forms of media and entertainment are of gaming platform, Ibibo (Wu & Frantz, interest to Tencent. Flannery and Chen 2012). Like China, India has a rapidly (2011) contended that: developing internet culture that is Internet and mobile communications- migrating to smartphone applications. related companies are looking to add new Tencent’s new mobile social networking forms of online entertainment application, Weixin (WeChat in English) content. And with China's government is available via the iOS, Android, easing rules on the content business and Windows operating systems and "cultural" industry of late, companies and delivers text, voice and video in nine that previously had no major languages including Arabic, English, Portuguese, Thai and Vietnamese

232 (Hopkins, 2012). In 2010, Tencent company seeking to partake in the global invested in Sanook, Thailand’s most economy. (Yong, 2005). popular web portal (Tencent, 2012). In Li, Chen and Shapiro (2011) Indonesia, Tencent released a localized observed that “the stronger a firm's cross-platform chat application called marketing efforts, the stronger the Qute, which has some Facebook-like positive effect of exporting activities on features and has over 1 million its product innovation” (p. 13). Friedman downloads since its June 2012 launch (2012) argued that the key to China’s (Hopkins, 2012). S. Millward reported global business reach is a new generation that there are currently some 3 million of Chinese innovators who are low cost, QQ International users in Indonesia and but high skilled. Global brands must that Qute is one of the fastest growing strive for superiority on basics like the technology products since Facebook brand’s price, performance, features and (personal communication, September 11, imagery and must learn to manage brands’ 2012). global characteristics (Holt, Quelch & Taylor, 2004, p. 73). 3.4 Competition The research in this case study The Instant Messenger (IM) market is shows that Baidu’s scale of Chinese dominated by language customers has given them the with a 64% share followed by Microsoft- ability to move into other Asian countries, owned with an 18.6% share. but without English language capabilities, Yahoo! Messenger has a 7.2% share and they still have a long way to go in other Tencent’s QQ has a 2.9% share with regions. Tencent, via an aggressive tailing behind with a 1.9% acquisition agenda, has made its presence share (OPSWAT, 2012). For social known in the online games world and, networking, Facebook is the worldwide unlike Baidu, offers English language player while Tencent’s opportunity in products and services. America is with online games, where they Chinese technology firms have built show no signs of slowing down. up large cash reserves over the past two decades, allowing them to form joint ventures and acquire firms related to their 4. Conclusion business in foreign countries, despite Vaughn (2012) asserted that “China is cultural, political and regulatory barriers. actively seeking to export more than just In the rapidly developing world of the rest of the world’s manufactured technology, Chinese internet firms have goods and to develop strong brands that leveraged their popularity and scale in can hold their own both at home and on China and are positioned to become the world stage” (p. 3). Shelly Lazarus of global market leaders. Ogilvy & Mather stated: Chinese brands are facing the same 5. References issues that national brands from other countries must address when they go [1] Alexa.com (2012). Baidu. overseas. Like their international [2] Apostolou, N. (2012). Baidu sets up counterparts, Chinese brands have to shop in Australia: China Google- establish and maintain an 'emotional' slayer wants your searches. The bond with local consumers, no matter the Register. market. This is a challenging goal for any [3] Baidu Investor Relations (2012). About Baidu

233 [4] Boisot, M. & Meyer, M.W. (2012). [19] Lau, A. (2012). Baidu partners with It’s easier for small Chinese firms to Sina to reinforce mobile search in go international than national. China. Search Engine Watch. Chinese Management Insights, 1(1), Retrieved from 9 – 11. http://searchenginewatch.com/ [5] China Economic Review (2012). The [20] Lee, M. (2012). Dell and Baidu legend of Tencent: Diversification team up for tablets, mobiles. wins out in a slow market. China .com. Retrieved from Economic Review, 23(9), 20 – 20. http://www.reuters.com [6] Coonan, . (2012). Tencent buys [21]Li, J., Chen, D., & Shapiro, D.M. Huayi Bros. stake. Variety.com. (2010), Product innovations in [7] Cooper, L. (2010). Five strategies for emerging economies: The role of a successful global brand. Marketing foreign knowledge access channels Week. and internal efforts in Chinese firms, [8] Einhorn, B. & Stone, B. (2011). Management & Organization March of the penguins. Bloomberg Review, 6(2), 243-66. Businessweek, 4241, 68 – 73. [22]MillwardBrown.com (2012a). [9] EIU (2010). Deal watch. Business BrandZ Top 100 Most Valuable China, 7. Global Brands. [10] Flannery, R. & Chen, M. (2011). [23]MillwardBrown.com (2012b). China web giant Tencent buys 4.6% BrandZ Top 50 Most Valuable stake in movie studio. Forbes.com. Chinese Brands. [11] Frank, R. (2012). Baidu: Ready to [24] Millward, S. (2012). Baidu still skyrocket on partnerships. Seeking pushing its OS, today launches on Alpha. third phone. TechinAsia.com. [12] Friedman, T.L. (2012). In China we [25]Olanoff, D.(2012). Baidu has chosen (don’t) trust. . Skyscanner as its international flight [13] Greenberg, A., Jie, L. & Hardy, Q. search partner. Insider/The Next Web. (2009). The guy who’s beating [26]Ollier, P. (2011). China business Google. Forbes, 184(6), 82 – 87. sells counterfeit watches. Managing Retrieved from Intellectual Property, 214, 75 – 75. http://www.ebscohost.com [27] Olsen, R. (2011). Tencent jumps [14] Holt, D.B., Quelch, J.A. & Taylor, after earnings surge 61%. E.L. (2004). How global brands Forbes.com. compete. Harvard Business Review, [28]OPSWAT (2012). Instant messenger 82(9), 68 – 75. market share report. [15] Hopkins, J. (2012). Baidu and [29]Rabkin, A. (2012). The Tao of the Tencent set sail. TechRice. sea turtle. FastCompany, 162, 78 – [16] Investor’s Business Daily (2012). 99. Baidu seeks non-search revenue. [30]Rapoza, K. (2012). China’s weibos Investor’s Business Daily. vs. US Twitter: And the winner is?. [17] Jiang, M. (2012). Internet companies Forbes.com. in China: Dancing between the party [31]Russell, J. (2012). Baidu continues line and the bottom line. to eye overseas opportunities as Asie.Visions, 47, 1- 50. Tieba Vietnam launch is confirmed. [18] Kotler, P., Keller, K.L. & Lu, T. The Next Web/. (2009). Marketing management in China. Singapore: Pearson.

234 [32]Shen, A. (2012). Tencent rejigs to [37] Wee, W. (2012) Baidu opens lab in improve reach beyond online games. Singapore to research Thai, Forbes.com, 55 – 55. Vietnamese search know-how. [33]Sun, S.L. & Liang, H. (2010). TechinAsia.com. International value creation through [38] Wu, J.P. & Frantz, T.L. (2012). private equity: Cases of Chinese Largest IM platform in China – outward ventures. LSE Alternative Tencent’s QQ. Journal of Business Investment Research Conference Case Studies, 8(1), 95 – 102. (London). [39] Young, D. (2012). Alibaba, Tencent, [34]Tencent.com (2012). About. Ping An JV: insuring failure. South [35]Vaughn, J. (2012). Remaking ‘made China Morning Post. in China’. JWT Intelligence. [40] Zhang, J. (2012). Baidu vs. Qihoo: [36]Worldwide Telecom (2011). Sky- Search superiority outweighs Mobi/Tencent form strategic convenience. Seeking Alpha. partnership. Worldwide Telecom, 23(3), 1 – 8.

235