THE DIAPASON DECEMBER, 2007
The Brick Presbyterian Church New York City Cover feature on pages 30–32
Dec 07 Cover.indd 1 11/8/07 8:39:21 AM
a total cleaning and releathering. Given siderably smaller than the Trinity organ the prices that have been bandied about (about 100 ranks). St. John the Divine THE DIAPASON for the “temporary” instrument, it prob- (another historic Aeolian-Skinner from A Scranton Gillette Publication ably would have cost the same or less to the 1950s, 150 ranks) is being rebuilt for Ninety-eighth Year: No. 12, Whole No. 1177 DECEMBER, 2007 restore this legendary organ with up-to- about $5 million after the disastrous gift date retrofi tting and new consoles in the shop fi re. Established in 1909 ISSN 0012-2378 Skinner tradition. My advice would be to store the his- An International Monthly Devoted to the Organ, 5) Dr. Burdick will not be at Trin- toric Aeolian-Skinner intact for many the Harpsichord, Carillon, and Church Music ity forever. Given the prestige of Trin- years, with the intention of reinstalling it ity Wall Street, when a replacement is at a later date with upgrades. It would be hired, I am sure the new director of a shame to sell it piecemeal, as the organ music will want a real pipe organ to had its own integrity and worked as an CONTENTS Editor & Publisher JEROME BUTERA [email protected] replace the current digital organ. New integrated musical unit. 847/391-1045 pipe instruments (even with some digi- I have worked with many organ com- FEATURES tal voices because of space or budgetary panies in sales, construction and consult- In celebration of the 100th birthday, concerns) are being installed around the ing for the last 35 years. There is a time October 27, of Helmut Walcha: Associate Editor JOYCE ROBINSON city for an average of $26,000 per rank. and place for digital organs. Trinity is not Artist-Teacher—Part 3 [email protected] This would put the cost of the Trinity’s one of them. by Paul Jordan 21 847/391-1044 real organ (with two consoles and chan- Regarding St. Paul’s Chapel, the The University of Michigan cel/gallery divisions) at about $4.5 mil- Schlicker organ was really never satisfac- Historic Organ Tour 54 Contributing Editors LARRY PALMER lion in today’s money. A new Casavant tory. Perhaps a new mechanical-action by Jeffrey K. Chase 24 Harpsichord at Brick Church, NYC of 118 ranks was pipe organ built in the early American recently installed at about $2.5 million; style to suit the building historically or a Stylistic Features of Frescobaldi and Froberger in St. James, Madison Ave. has a $5 million pipe organ with some digital voices could Buxtehude’s Ciacona in C minor, BuxWV 159 JAMES MCCRAY by Marijim Thoene 27 Choral Music Schoenstein under contract ($3 million be installed there. for the organ, $2 million for the case Frederick A. Tripodi BRIAN SWAGER and structural work), which will be con- Greenwich, Connecticut NEWS & DEPARTMENTS Carillon Letters to the Editor 3 Here & There 3, 4, 5, 6, 8, 10, 12 HERBERT L. HUESTIS OrganNet Forum Nunc Dimittis 8 Osiris Organ Archive Carillon News by Brian Swager 12 www.mdi.ca/hhuestis/osiris Here & There In the wind . . . by John Bishop 12 e-mail: [email protected] On Teaching by Gavin Black 14 Watch for The Diapason’s 2008 Re- Ohnstad. For information: REVIEWS Prepress Operations DAN SOLTIS source Directory, which will be mailed
DECEMBER, 2007 3
Dec 07 pp. 2-20.indd 3 11/8/07 8:40:47 AM The fourth annual Workshop on Sa- ten double-spaced pages of text. Propos- mation: Association des Grandes Orgues graphed by Christoph Sandig. The image cred Music will take place January 19 als will be read for originality, clarity, and de Chartres, 22 Cloître Notre Dame, is used with the permission of the Stadt- at the University of Texas at Austin, appropriateness for oral presentation. 28000 Chartres, France; geschichtliches (State Historical) Muse- where Judith and Gerre Hancock are co- The proposal should include a cover let-
Olena Bratishko, Martha Stiehl, Kevin P. Monteith, Daniel E. West, and Patricio Amerena
University of Wisconsin-Milwau- Krebs, Albinoni and Callahan, and con- Cathedral of St. John Choir at Canterbury Cathedral kee students of Martha Stiehl’s studio cluded with Bach’s Toccata in D-mi- presented a program for a convocation nor, BWV 565, played by the instruc- The Cathedral Choir of St. John’s cies at St. George’s Chapel, Windsor and of the University’s Peck School of the tor, Ms. Stiehl, in honor of Halloween. Cathedral, Albuquerque, New Mexico Canterbury. Music for the tour included Arts on Friday, October 26. Pictured The recital was performed on the A. O. (Iain Quinn, director of cathedral music Gerald Near’s Missa Orbis Factor and here (l to r) are Olena Bratishko, Mar- Smith Memorial Pipe Organ (Austin and cathedral organist; Maxine Thevenot, The Lord Is My Light by Peter Hallock tha Stiehl, Kevin P. Monteith, Daniel 1928, Buzard 2002, IV/59) at Kenwood associate organist-choir director) under- (a former lay clerk at Canterbury Ca- E. West and Patricio Amerena. The United Methodist Church, adjacent to took their fi rst tour to the UK in August thedral). Services were directed by Iain program included works by Bach, the UWM campus. 2007. They sang for weeklong residen- Quinn and Maxine Thevenot.
4 THE DIAPASON
Dec 07 pp. 2-20.indd 4 11/8/07 8:41:14 AM and was recitalist/faculty member for the “Deep River” with trumpeter Brent Ghi- Oundle Summer School, UK. Dr. Fishell glione. The two new works for organ and was a faculty member for the Richmond, trumpet are available from Jazzmuze, Virginia Pipe Organ Encounter. Inc. Scores may be seen on the Jazzmuze website:
thth ConcertArtistCooperative 20ANNIVERSARY
Colin Andrews Cristina Garcia Banegas Emanuele Cardi Shin-Ae Chun Maurice Clerc Organist/Lecturer/ Organist/Harpsichordist/Conductor Organist/Lecturer/ Organist/Harpsichordist/ Interpreter/Improviser/ Recording Artist Organ Faculty and Chair Recording Artist Recording Artist Recording Artist Lecturer, Organ Performance University of the Republic Organ and Soprano with Director of Music and Organist Titular Organist & Sacred Music Studies Conductor, De Profundis Polina Balva (St. Petersburg) Redeemer Lutheran Church St. Benigne’s Cathedral East Carolina University Vocal/Instrumental Ensemble Titular Organist St. Clair Shores, Michigan Faculty School of Music Director, International Organ Festival St. Maria della Speranza National Conservatory Greenville, North Carolina Montevideo, Uruguay Battipaglia, Italy Dijon, France
Leon Couch Laura Ellis Faythe Freese Johan Hermans Michael Kaminski Organist/Lecturer Organist Organist/Lecturer Organist / Lecturer / Organist College Organist Associate Professor of Associate Professor of Organ Recording Artist Director of Music Ministries Assistant Professor of Organ Organ and Carillon School of Music Conservatory of Music Saint Francis Xavier Church and Music Theory University of Florida University of Alabama St. Quintinus Cathedral Brooklyn College Faculty Converse College Gainesville, Florida Tuscaloosa, Alabama Organ Concert Series St. Francis College Faculty Spartanburg, South Carolina Civic Organist Brooklyn, New York Hasselt, Belgium
Angela Kraft Cross William Kuhlman Tong-Soon Kwak David K. Lamb Maija Lehtonen Organist/Pianist/Composer/ Organist Organist Organist/Choral Conductor/ Organist/Pianist/ Recording Artist Professor of Music Emeritus Professor of Organ Oratorio Accompanist Recording Artist Organist Luther College College of Music Director of Music/Organist Senior Lecturer, Organ Faculty Congregational Church Decorah, Iowa Yonsei University First United Methodist Church Oulu Polytechnic San Mateo, California Artistic Director Columbus, Indiana Organ and Violin Torch International Organ Academy with Manfred Grasbeck Seoul, Korea Helsinki, Finland
www.ConcertArtistCooperative.com Beth Zucchino, Founder and Director 7710 Lynch Road, Sebastopol, CA 95472 PH: (707) 824-5611 FX: (707) 824-0956 Established in 1988
DECEMBER, 2007 5
Dec 07 pp. 2-20.indd 5 11/8/07 8:41:32 AM King Lutheran Church, Houston, Texas, is Ernst Pepping’s Wie soll ich dich emp- of their new CD (No: 8.559337) of his the program includes works by Buxte- fangen, Vorspiel I, available in MP3 and Symphony of Seasons (Symphony No. 1), hude, Scheidemann, Böhm, Bruhns, Lü- streaming audio formats at Concerto for Harp and Orchestra, Lairs beck, Bach, and Mendelssohn (Sonata
“We seek to give musical and theological flesh and bone to those who are called to serve the church as leaders of the people’s song.”
– Dr. Paul Westermeyer, Director
Celebrating the new Wicks organ at St. Robert Bellarmine Church are (front) David Spicer of First Church of Christ (Wethersfi eld, Connecticut), and Veronica Fareri of the host church; and (rear, left to right) Mark Wick of Wicks Organ Company (Highland, Illinois), Gerald Oehring of Gerald Oehring & Associates (Lincoln, Nebraska), Father Donald Shane of the host church, and Steve Kehm of Oehring Associates. (Photo by Dana Spicer)
David Spicer played the dedication digital voices controlled by a 3-manual recital of the new Wicks organ at St. console. The program included works by Armstrong Aspaas Ferguson Rodland Westermeyer Robert Bellarmine Church in Omaha, Bach, Beethoven, Yon, Elmore, Haydn, Nebraska, on June 21. Wicks Opus 6397 Scull, Wagner, and Reubke. has 52 ranks of pipes and a package of
6 THE DIAPASON
Dec 07 pp. 2-20.indd 6 11/8/07 8:41:50 AM P C bttjpo pvout/!Cfshibvt!Pshbo!Dpnqboz!jt!mppljoh!gps!tfwfsbm!! joejwjevbmt!xjui!fyqfsjfodf!up!ßmm!uif!gpmmpxjoh!ofxmz!dsfbufe!qptjujpot/!Jo!bmm!dbtft-!uif!! xpsl!jt!efnboejoh!boe!sfrvjsft!b!usvf!tfotf!pg!dpnnjunfou!boe!efejdbujpo/!! Kpc!tqfdjßd!fyqfsjfodf!jt!qsfgfssfe-!cvu!tljmmt!jo!sfmbufe!ßfmet!xjmm!cf!tuspohmz!dpotjefsfe/
pjo!b!dpnqboz! Tusvduvsbm!Eftjhofs!0!Esbgutqfstpo K Bqqmjdbout!tipvme!cf!qspßdjfou!jo!uif!vtf!boe!bqqmjdbujpo!pg! BvupDBE!jo!uif!eftjho!pg!efdpsbujwf!boe!tusvduvsbm!fmfnfout! efejdbufe!up!! pg!qjqf!pshbot/!Bqqmjdbout!xjui!efnpotusbcmf!BvupDBE!tljmmt-! cvu!xjuipvu!qjqf!pshbo!fyqfsjfodf!nbz!bmtp!bqqmz/!Uif!tvddftt. gvm!dboejebuf!xjmm!xpsl!jo!b!dsfbujwf!fowjsponfou!pwfstffo!cz! uif!qbttjpo!pg!! uif!Tusvduvsbm!Eftjho!Ejsfdups/ pshbocvjmejoh/ Dbcjofu!Nblfs Bqqmjdbout!tipvme!cf!ijhimz!tljmmfe!jo!bmm!bsfbt!sfmbufe!up!uif!bsu! boe!dsbgu!pg!ßof!dbcjofunbljoh/!Uif!tvddfttgvm!dboejebuf!xjmm! Cfshibvt!pggfst!bo!fydfmmfou!dpnqfotbujpo!! cf!ijhimz!fyqfsjfodfe-!efubjm!psjfoufe!boe!ibwf!uif!bcjmjuz!up! qsphsbn!uibu!jodmveft!qbje!wbdbujpo-!dpnqsfifotjwf!! xpsl!xfmm!jo!b!ejtdjqmjofe!bunptqifsf/!Gbnjmjbsjuz!xjui!DOD! ifbmui!jotvsbodf!boe!dpnqboz!nbudife!JSB/!! njmmjoh!ufdiojrvft!jt!b!qmvt/! Cfshibvt!jt!bo!frvbm!pqqpsuvojuz!fnqmpzfs/! Xppexpslfs!0!Dsbgutqfstpo Qmfbtf!ejsfdu!dpwfs!mfuufs!boe!sftvnf!d0p!! Bqqmjdbout!tipvme!cf!bcmf!up!efnpotusbuf!fydfmmfou!xppexpsl. Mpsff!Bsntuspoh!bu!uif!qptubm!ps!! joh!tljmmt!boe!cf!xjmmjoh!up!qbsujdjqbuf!jo!hfofsbm!pshbocvjmejoh! f.nbjm!beesftt!mjtufe!cfmpx; bdujwjujft/!Joejwjevbmt!ijsfe!jo!uijt!dbqbdjuz!xjmm!cf!usbjofe!jo!bmm! tusvduvsbmmz!sfmbufe!qspdfttft/ Mpsff!Bsntuspoh! Tpmje.Tubuf!Ufdiojdjbo Cfshibvt!Pshbo!Dpnqboz! Bqqmjdbout!tipvme!cf!fyqfsjfodfe!jo!uif!eftjho!boe!jotubm. 3262!Nbejtpo!Tusffu-!Cfmmxppe-!Jmmjopjt-!71215! mbujpo!pg!b!wbsjpvt!tpmje.tubuf!lfz!boe!tupq.bdujpo!tztufnt/! mbsntuspohAcfshibvtpshbo/dpn Joejwjevbmt!ijsfe!jo!uijt!dbqbdjuz!xjmm!xpsl!jo!uboefn!xjui!uif! ofx!pshbo!boe!tfswjdf!efqbsunfout/!Uiftf!joejwjevbmt!nvtu!cf! efubjm!psjfoufe!boe!ibwf!uif!bcjmjuz!up!ejbhoptf!tfswjdf!sfmbufe! Uif!Efßojujpo!pg!Mfhbdz/ qspcmfnt/!Joejwjevbmt!xjui!hfofsbm!fmfduspojdt!boe!xjsjoh!! fyqfsjfodf!xjmm!bmtp!cf!dpotjefsfe/ Wpjdjoh!Ufdiojdjbo Fyqfsjfodfe!àvf!boe!sffe!wpjdfst!boe!uiptf!xjtijoh!up!foufs! uif!wpjdjoh!qspgfttjpo!bsf!vshfe!up!bqqmz/!Cfshibvt!nbjoubjot! tusjdu!wpjdjoh!tuboebset!xijmf!fohbhjoh!jo!bo!fyqbotjpo!pg!pvs! usbejujpobm!qbsbnfufst/! Tfswjdf!Ufdiojdjbo Pvs!fyqboejoh!tfswjdf!efqbsunfou!offet!fyqfsjfodfe!ufdioj. djbot!gps!bmm!bsfbt!pg!qjqf!pshbo!tfswjdf-!sfqbjs!boe!uvojoh/!! Qspkfdut!Dvssfoumz!Voefs!Dpotusvdujpo; Xf!qsfgfs!bqqmjdbout!xjui!b!xpsljoh!lopxmfehf!pg!tfwfsbm!lfz! bdujpo!nfdibojtnt!jodmvejoh!usbdlfs-!fmfdusjd!0!qofvnbujd! Gjstu!Vojufe!Nfuipejtu!Divsdi!Ñ!Hbjoftwjmmf-!Gmpsjeb tmjefs-!fmfdusp.qofvnbujd!boe!ejsfdu.wbmvf!fmfdusjd/!Uvofst! Tu/!KpioÖt!Fqjtdpqbm!Divsdi!Ñ!Difwz!Dibtf-!Nbszmboe tipvme!cf!dbqbcmf!pg!tfuujoh!ufnqfsbnfout/!Usbjojoh!jt!! Mb!Dbtb!ef!Dsjtup!Mvuifsbo!Divsdi!Ñ!Tdpuutebmf-!Bsj{pob bwbjmbcmf!gps!joejwjevbmt!xjui!mjnjufe!fyqfsjfodf/ Tu/!Kfspnf!Dbuipmjd!Divsdi!Ñ!Pdpopnpxpd-!Xjtdpotjo Gjstu!Mvuifsbo!Divsdi!Ñ!Nbojupxpd-!Xjtdpotjo
Quality Pipe Organ Building & Maintenance Since 1967 studied music at the University of Nige- Tournemire, was published in issue no. was named for the donor of the organ, ria, Nsukka, Guildhall School of Music 278–279 of L’Orgue. Dr. Friauff is or- the late Mrs. Gladys H. G. Wiedemann and Drama, London, and the Queen’s ganist and music director at St. Andrew’s of Wichita. They read: “Professor Rob- University in Belfast, Ireland, where he Episcopal Church in Ann Arbor, and ert Town, whose dedicated effort re- obtained his Ph.D. in ethnomusicology presently adjunct professor in organ at sulted in the acquisition of The Great under John Blacking. This monograph Eastern Michigan University. Marcussen Organ and the creation of examines the socio-cultural factors that Wiedemann Hall.” most infl uenced Uzoigwe’s creative thought, inspiration and imagination. Uzoigwe’s life and music explicate the imprint of two cultural worlds, Western and African—Igbo/Yoruba. William Whitehead and assisting John Eliot Gardiner with the famed Monteverdi Choir. Whitehead won fi rst prize at the Odense International Organ Compe- tition in Denmark in 2004 and holds many other awards and honors. He has performed in South Africa, France, Den- mark Russia, Scotland, as well as exten- sively in England at major venues and festivals including those in Litchfi eld, Cheltenham, and Hampstead and High- gate. He is a graduate of University Col- lege, Oxford, where he was organ scholar, Robert Town and Lynne Davis and of the Royal Academy of Music, with a further graduate degree from King’s Robert Town, Professor Emeritus of Vernet Duo College London. His organ teachers Organ at Wichita State University, Wich- have included Dame Gillian Weir, Naji ita, Kansas, was honored at the Sep- French organist Olivier Vernet has Hakim, David Sanger, David Hill, James tember 18 Rie Bloomfi eld Organ Series established a performance duo with his O’Donnell, and David Titterington. recital. On behalf of the School of Mu- sister, the French opera star Isabelle His most recent of seven compact disc sic in the College of Fine Arts, his suc- Vernet, which will be represented in releases, Dances of Life and Death on Timothy Tikker cessor, Lynne Davis, gave a synopsis of North America by Phillip Truckenbrod the Chandos label, won fi ve stars from the events leading up to the installation Concert Artists. Miss Vernet, a mezzo- the magazine BBC Music, the Diapa- Timothy Tikker gave the fi rst Ameri- of the Marcussen and Son organ (IV/84 soprano, is a veteran of many oper- son Découverte award in France, and can performance of Debout sur le Soleil: ranks) and the opening of the Wiede- atic roles at leading opera companies was his fi rst entirely solo recording. His Chant de Résurrection (“Standing on the mann Recital Hall in 1986. Town and throughout Europe as well as in South next solo CD was released by Herald in Sun: Song of Resurrection”) by Jean- the recognition of his students played an America, Canada and the United States, 2007 and coincided with a feature article Louis Florentz on September 30 dur- integral role in realizing the dream of a where she appeared most recently in on the artist in the international journal ing the 47th annual conference on organ new recital hall built specifi cally for an Chicago with Plácido Domingo. She also Choir & Organ. music of the University of Michigan. Tik- organ of recital proportions. does a good deal of recital work and has ker presented the work in a lecture-recit- Town was organ instructor at WSU appeared as soloist with numerous Eu- al, playing the 124-rank Aeolian-Skinner from 1965 until his retirement from the ropean orchestras. She has recorded for organ at Hill Auditorium. Deborah Fri- faculty in 2006. During his tenure, three Ligia Digital, Decca, and EMI. Nunc Dimittis auff served as console assistant, which new organs were installed on the cam- Olivier Vernet is organist of Monaco role included not just page-turning and pus, including the Marcussen, as well as a Cathedral, professor of organ at the registration, but actually joining in play- Reuter practice organ (1970) and a Law- French Regional Conservatory in Nice, Lucien Deiss, C.S.Sp., died on Oc- ing some of the most complex passages. rence Phelps and Associates two-manual and a performer of international reputa- tober 9. His funeral was celebrated on Debout sur le Soleil, composed 1989– tracker for his new studio in Wiedemann tion. Writing of their work as a duo, the October 13 at Seminaire des Missiones 91, is Florentz’s longest single-move- Hall (1986). There are now fi ve organs French newspaper Dernieres Nouvelles in Larue, France. Best known to Roman ment organ work, a symphonic poem on the campus, including a two-manual d’Alsace says of Miss Vernet: “She can Catholics in the U.S. through his scrip- inspired by the book of the same title M. P. Möller (1956), which was installed overlay the bursts of the organ without tural songs such as “All the Earth,” “Keep by Fr. Jean Leclercq of Notre-Dame in the just-completed School of Music effort [and] rise above full organ like a in Mind,” and “Grant to Us, O Lord,” Fr. Cathedral, Paris, as well as by Florentz’s complex within the Duerksen Fine Arts tornado, launching a surge of thrills.” Deiss was also widely known in Europe ethnomusicological study of Ethiopian Center, and a Casavant (II/15 stops, and the United States as a scholar in the Orthodox liturgy and chant. The perfor- 1965, designed by Lawrence Phelps) in The young English organist William fi elds of sacred scripture and patristics. mance commemorated the 60th anni- Grace Memorial Chapel. Robert Town Whitehead, who will be represented He was selected by Pope Paul VI to co- versary this year of the birth of Florentz, has recently pledged an endowment for in North America by Phillip Trucken- ordinate the Lectionary psalter following as the conference celebrated Marilyn the maintenance of campus organs. brod Concert Artists, is organ professor the Second Vatican Council. His Biblical Mason’s 60th year of teaching organ at The Rie Bloomfi eld Organ Series was at Trinity College of Music and music Hymns and Psalms was one of the fi rst the University of Michigan. endowed in 1994, and the Ann and Den- director at St. Mary’s Church, Bourne collections of congregational music for Timothy Tikker is college organ- nis Ross Faculty of Distinction in Organ Street, both in London. Previous posi- Roman Catholics. For this he was given an ist at Kalamazoo College and organist professorship was endowed in Professor tions included seven years teaching at honorary doctorate in sacred music from at St. Thomas the Apostle Church in Town’s honor in 2005. Two plaques were the Royal Academy of Music in London, Duquesne University. An advocate of the Ann Arbor, Michigan. His essay on the presented, one for Robert Town and one service on the music staff of Westminster reforms of Vatican II, Fr. Deiss dedicated Symphonie-Choral, op. 69 of Charles to be placed in Wiedemann Hall, which Abbey and later of Rochester Cathedral, much of his life to liturgical catechesis
RONALD CAMERON BISHOP Consultant Pipe Organs Digital Enhancements All-digital Instruments 8608 RTE 20, Westfield, NY 14787-9728 Tel 716/326-6500 Fax 716/326-6595
Robert I. Coulter Organbuilder Atlanta, GA 404.931.3103 Coulterorgans.com
8 THE DIAPASON
Dec 07 pp. 2-20.indd 8 11/8/07 8:42:47 AM www.ioti.com VirtuosoPIPE ORGAN CONTROL SYSTEM 877 462 4684
The World’s Great Spivey Hall Chose Organists Choose The Virtuoso Pipe The Ruɲatti Organ Organ Control At Spivey Hall. System. through workshops and the well-known Fantasia for Viola and Organ Rorate Coeli, on to found the Helicon Foundation, a 1982. “Deiss days” sponsored by WLP (then Landscapes of Patmos (organ and percussion), New York-based ensemble whose rep- Here & There World Library of Sacred Music). 1984. ertoire included music by Mendelssohn, Tres iubilationes (brass and organ), 1987. Schumann, and Brahms. Two Invocations for Trombone and Organ, Bärenreiter announces the release 1987. Rudolf “Rudy” O. Inselmann died of the complete edition of the organ and Sunday Music, 1957–59. July 6 in Newport Beach, California at piano works by Louis Vierne, with an Laudes, 1964. the age of 72. He majored in piano at editorial team headed by Helga Schau- Ten Chorale Preludes, 1971. Wartburg College, Waverly, Iowa, then erte-Maubouet. The edition will include Two Chorale Fantasias, 1972. Small Chorale Partita, 1978. attended Capital Bible Seminary and works published during Vierne’s lifetime, Faust, 1979–80. became an ordained Lutheran minister. those previously unpublished, and those Mutationes, 1980. He received an MA in organ from Indi- attributed to him. This will be an Ur- Versetti, 1982. ana University and a doctorate in sacred text edition, based on an evaluation of A Festive Voluntary (On Good King Wences- music from the University of Southern all available autographs, fi rst prints, and las), 1986. California in Los Angeles. After teach- hitherto unpublished letters. The fi rst Hommage à Buxtehude, 1987. ing music at the University of El Paso, three volumes of the edition will be pub- Job (organ), 1987. he joined the faculty of Christ College, lished in January 2008. Each volume will Two Festive Preludes, 1990, 1992. Biblical Dances, 1990–91. now Concordia University, Irvine, Cali- include a critical commentary (in Ger- Petr Eben Amen, es werde wahr, 1993. fornia. He served as organist at Church man, English, and French), with details Momenti d’organo, 1994. of the Good Shepherd in Arcadia; St. on editorial methods, sources, as well Czech composer Petr Eben died Oc- Hommage à Henri Purcell, 1994–95. Clement’s Episcopal Church, San Cle- as a preface with performance sugges- tober 25 at his home in Prague at the age mente; St. Kilian Catholic Church, tions. The complete organ works will be of 78. Born January 22, 1929, in Zam- Mission Viejo; and Our Lady Queen of available at a special subscription price berk, Eben began piano study at age six Angels, Newport Beach. Dr. Inselmann (€255). For information: and organ at nine. At 10, he composed was dean of the Orange County AGO
Call us: 1 (413) 773-0066 9-5 EST FAX 1 (413) 773-0166 organmastershoes.com
10 THE DIAPASON
Dec 07 pp. 2-20.indd 10 11/8/07 8:43:17 AM
Rhenen on March 29, 2008. The winning piece(s) and a selection of the other en- tries will be performed that day. All the composers of the performed pieces will be informed in advance. Two (good readable) copies must be sent (please no originals!). The date on the envelope will be used to determine the timely receipt. Send them to Freek Bakker, the secretary of the jury (address below). Participants must write their name, address, the title of the submit- ted piece(s), and a short curriculum vitae in a letter that accompanies the entry or entries. Also, every participant agrees to the publication and performance in the scope of the competition. The prize- Allen theatre organ winning composition(s) and a selec- tion of other interesting entries will be with blue side panels and outlined in published and distributed by the Dutch gold leaf trim. The console interior is a Carillon Guild and the Cunera Carillon contrasting fl at black with a satin varnish. Association after the competition. The organ’s audio system consists of 25 The deadline for entries is Tuesday, speaker cabinets, housed in three cham- January 1, 2008. For further informa- Ruffatti organ for Johns Creek Baptist Church, Alpharetta, Georgia (Photo credit: bers in Dr. Scott’s music room. tion, contact the secretary of the jury: Nancy Daley) The new Allen replaces a four-manual Freek Bakker, Van Kluyvelaan 14, electronic organ that Scott built himself 3862 XG Nijkerk, The Netherlands; on October 14. Ruffatti also completed in the late ’70s, which now has a new phone: +31 (33) 245 90 53; e-mail: a fi ve-manual organ for the new 2200- home with the Free State Theatre Organ
12 THE DIAPASON
Dec 07 pp. 2-20.indd 12 11/8/07 8:43:43 AM LAVISH APPOINTMENTS ~ EXCEPTIONAL TONALITY ~ ARTISTIC INTEGRITY OPUS I OPUS II
PEDAL CHOIR 32 Contre Bourdon 16 Contra Viole 16 Diapason 8 Viola 16 Bourdon 8 Viola Celeste 16 Lieblich Bourdon (Sw) OPUS III 8 Gedackt 16 Contra Violone (Ch) 8 Erzähler 16 Salicional (Ec) 8 Erzähler Celeste 16 Violone (Gt) Allen Organ is proud to announce the commission 4 Prinzipal 8 Octave of yet another Allen Elite™ organ. After consideration 4 Koppelflöte 8 Gamba (Gt) 4 Viole 8 Flauto Dolce (Ec) of other builders, the church’s decision for Opus III 4 Erzähler 8 Gedackt was based on three key areas of Allen superiority: 2 2/3 Nasat 4 Choralbass 2 Blockflöte 4 Flute sound, service and voicing capabilities. 1 1/3 Quintflöte Mixture IV Mixture III 16 Bombarde With a tonal scheme reminiscent of the great 8 Clarinet 16 Trompette (Sw) Harp–(Skinner) 8 Trumpet E. M. Skinner, Elite Opus III is a three-manual, Celesta 4 Clarion 73 stop instrument with a floating Echo Division 8 Festival Trumpet (nc) 8 Festival Trumpet and 36 audio channels. When compared with Tremulant SWELL the French Romantic specification of Opus II, ECHO (Floating Division) 16 Lieblich Bourdon the stop list of this newest Elite confirms the 16 Salicional 8 Geigen 8 Flauto Dolce 8 Salicional individuality and uniqueness of every Opus. 8 Flute Celeste 8 Voix Celeste 8 Muted Strings II 8 Flute Celeste II 8 Vox Angelica 8 Rohrbourdon 4 Orchestral Flute 4 Geigen Octave Chimes 4 Traverse Flute Tremulant 2 2/3 Nasard 4 Antiphonal 2 Piccolo 1 3/5 Tierce COUPLERS & GENERALS Fourniture IV TM 8 Great to Pedal 16 Trompette 4 Great to Pedal 8 Trompette 8 Swell to Pedal 8 Oboe 4 Swell to Pedal 4 Clarion 8 Choir to Pedal 8 Festival Trumpet (nc) 4 Choir to Pedal Tremulant MIDI on Pedal 8 Swell to Great GREAT 8 Choir to Great 16 Violone MIDI on Great 8 Diapason THE GOLD STANDARD OF ORGAN BUILDING 8 Swell to Choir 8 Metalgedackt Choir Unison Off 8 Harmonic Flute for discerning customers MIDI on Choir 8 Gamba MIDI on Swell 4 Octave 4 Spitzflöte KEY CHEEK PISTONS Pedal Divide 2 2/3 Twelfth Echo on Swell 2 Fifteenth Echo On Great Mixture IV Echo On Choir 8 Trumpet Allen Organ Company LLC All Swells to Swell 8 Festival Trumpet (nc) 150 Locust Street, P.O. Box 36, Macungie, PA 18062-0036 Echo Expression Swell Tremulant Phone: 610-966-2202 • Fax: 610-965-3098 Echo Expression Great Chimes E-mail: [email protected] • Web site: www.allenorgan.com Echo Expression Choir several hundred organbuilders. These passed from console to chamber using a ees, and most companies employ fewer lectures in a large conference room at the are the people who say, “I didn’t know single wire. In my memory, multiplexing than ten people. In this environment, convention hotel. Those lectures were on there were any of you left.” I’m feeling was the fi rst scary leap. Simply put, the the importance of the supply house is in- subjects as diverse as rebuilding and re- pretty good, how about you? system is based on a clock that scans all creased as we can decide independently pairing Möller pitman chests, recovering Any convention has an exhibit hall in the console outputs a prescribed num- whether or not to build pedalboards “in keyboards, and confl ict resolution. which vendors show their wares to mem- ber of times per second and sends a code house,” or which solid-state control sys- Patrick Murphy, whose organbuilding bers of the trade. There were almost 25 along the wire to the chamber where it tem best fi ts the design and function of workshop is in Stowe, Pennsylvania, was fi rms exhibiting at the AIO convention, is “unscrambled” by another clock. For the console we design. the chair of the convention, and the staff including companies that provide leath- someone who started with trackers, it I thank the people from the compa- of his company was present through- er, specialty tools and hardware, key- was hard to imagine that it would work nies who exhibited at the AIO conven- out answering questions, guiding us as board restoration, organ pipes, console or that it could be reliable. At about that tion. I appreciate the hard work you’ve sheep on and off the buses on schedule, parts, and of course, solid-state control time, there was a Star Trek movie dur- done developing new products. The and providing a cheerful and welcoming systems. The exhibits hall is open for sev- ing which the USS Enterprise was under American organ industry is strengthened presence. Randall Dyer (Randall Dyer eral hours each day, especially in the eve- reconstruction and the famous Trans- by your efforts. The fees you paid for ex- & Associates of Jefferson City, Tennes- ning when it becomes the locus for the porter was malfunctioning. When a crew hibition space helped make this valuable see) is the chair of the AIO’s Convention convention’s social life. After dinner peo- member was “beamed” up or down, the experience possible. And thanks for the Overview Committee. These folks de- ple swirl through the exhibits, run into machine failed to unscramble the mol- candies, wine, keychains, and door prizes serve the gratitude of America’s pipe or- old friends, make new friends, and head ecules accurately, resulting in horrible you provided! gan community for their contribution to off to the hotel bars in small groups. scrambling of human tissue. Would this Earlier this year I wrote a two-part the education, celebration, and advance- One benefi t of this tradition is the dis- happen to our organ music? essay about the new life of the famous, ment of American organbuilders. pelling of myth—I’ve been doing busi- At fi rst bad things did happen. One enormous, and almost indescribable I have always thought that organ- ness with suppliers to the organbuilding system I worked with had a clock that organ in the former Wanamaker’s De- builders are a collegial bunch. Although trade for 30 years, and it’s fun to meet was going too slow, resulting in herky- partment Store (May and June 2007, we are competing with each other in those with whom you’ve spent countless jerky organ music. And lightning strikes “Size Matters”). In it, I wrote that Phila- a small market, we are typically will- telephone hours. You get to form a per- were death. I was caring for a couple delphia boasts an unusual array of very ing to assist each other with advice and sonal connection with the person who an- large organs that had new multiplexing large organs. The Wanamaker organ exchange of ideas, and even by sharing swers the phone at the order desk, and to systems, and I sweated out thunder- (6/462), the Austin organ (4/167) at Ir- workers when projects get larger than a discuss technical problems in detail with storms with good reason. vine Auditorium of the University of small staff can handle. But during most the engineers who design and build the Now we are getting used to software- Pennsylvania, and the Dobson organ of the working year, we are buried in or- equipment. Over the years I have found based systems in which the organbuilder (4/124) at the Kimmel Center (home of gan chambers in our own areas, seem- great value in knowing the people I talk connects the console controls (key- the Philadelphia Orchestra) add up to ingly out of touch with what our col- with on the phone. These relationships boards, stop knobs, piston buttons, swell 753 ranks in three organs that are within leagues are doing. In King of Prussia, are unspeakably valuable when I’m call- shoes) to rows of pins, and using software a few miles of each other. The Wana- Pennsylvania, we came out of our holes ing from a job site where wedding limos determines which pin does what. After maker Store and the Kimmel Center blinking in the sunlight, and shared a are showing up outside and the organ is the organ is fi nished, you could decide to are within walking distance. The partici- wonderful week of professional growth acting up. change divisional pistons into generals by pants in the AIO convention had a won- and companionship. Nice to see you all. I got active in organbuilding in the late updating the software through e-mail. derful opportunity to hear these three See you in Knoxville next year. Q 1970s just as solid-state controls for pipe It’s fun to think back a few generations giant and wildly diverse instruments in organs were entering the market. I had to the time when electro-pneumatic two successive days. my start in workshops that specialized in combination actions and pitman chests While organ-people will no doubt al- tracker-action organs, and my immature were introduced. Any good modern or- ways refer to the Wanamaker Store in understanding didn’t allow much space gan builder knows the symptoms of trou- Philadelphia, credit must be given to On Teaching for digital equipment. I knew many peo- ble in a pitman chest. But when those Macy’s Department Store, now the pro- by Gavin Black ple who resisted or ignored using it. I was chests were fi rst being perfected, techni- prietor of this most grand of retail spac- fortunate to work for several years along cians must have sweated out mysterious es. Robin Hall is an executive vice-presi- side an old-timer who had worked per- problems the way I have with solid-state dent in charge of Macy’s Department of Pedal playing, part II: sonally next to Ernest Skinner (in fact, I gremlins. Annual Events, the group that produces opening exercises assumed the care of two Skinner organs In the exhibit hall of the AIO con- the Thanksgiving Day Parade and July Last month I closed by stating that he had helped install in the 1920s and vention, I was most impressed by the Fourth Fireworks along with numerous there are three reliable ways of fi nding had maintained ever since!) who said, sophistication of new developments in fl ower shows and musical reviews. There notes at the pedal keyboard with accu- “that stuff is for you young guys.” solid-state pipe organ controls, and even can be no division of a modern American racy, namely: 1) fi nding notes absolutely, In the ensuing generation, many if more impressed by the sophistication of corporation more enthusiastic or better in relation only to your position on the not most organbuilders have had at my colleagues, the organbuilders, who in equipped for the care of this most sin- bench; 2) fi nding the next note that a least some experience with solid-state the last 30 years have worked hard to un- gular of pipe organs. In the brief period given foot has to play in relation to where equipment, and many use it exclusively. derstand the function, uses, and benefi ts since their occupation of the store, they the other foot just was; and 3) fi nding the Years ago, I remember being easily be- of this equipment. I joined in conversa- have funded extensive and expensive next note that a given foot has to play in wildered. I would stand trembling with tions in which organbuilders were sug- long-needed repairs, provided a large relation to where that foot last was or my hand on the switch before turning gesting improvements, offering solutions amount of space in the building dedi- what that last foot just did. I also said that on a system for the fi rst time and would to problems, and describing innovative cated to an organbuilding workshop, and while all three of these are useful and be looking for smoke, unfairly (to both ways they’ve found to use existing con- established a collegial relationship with necessary, it is the last one that is actually the supplier and myself) assuming that trols. I saw an institutional comfort level Curt Mangel, curator of the organ, and the most useful and the best source of there would be smoke to see. I handled that can only be to the benefi t of our cli- Peter Conte, Grand Court organist. To really secure, comfortable pedaling. This the circuit boards as though they were ents. We’ve come a long way, baby. hear Peter and Curt talk about the people month I want to elaborate on that idea, poisonous, and while I understood what Because I’ve been involved in some of Macy’s is to hear a gushing exceeded and then to describe a beginning exer- they were supposed to do, I had no idea very large organ projects in recent years, only by the amazing sounds of the organ cise based on this third approach. how they did it. I’ve noted an important way in which or- itself. (Please refer to this column in the For the moment, we are concerned Enough time has passed that we’ve gan organbuilding industry has changed. May and June issues of The Diapason only with the use of the toes in pedaling. been through generations of solid-state Seventy-fi ve years ago, when American for more about the Wanamaker Organ.) This is emphatically not because I believe equipment. Looking back, the earli- organbuilders were producing thousands Anyone who has attended an organ in eliminating the use of the heel or in est systems seem pretty primitive. The of organs each year, there were a num- convention knows the bus rides—hun- restricting it in principle—as noted last companies offering them went to great ber of companies that had hundreds of dreds of like-minded people rattling month, I consider every part of the foot trouble to make the pin-boards (rows employees. It was much easier for such across the countryside on a tight sched- to be fair game for playing pedal keys. of pins where you connect the wires a large company to marshal the forces to ule to hear and see organs. Along with Rather it is because the gesture of point- from the console controls to the system) erect a 32-foot Principal, or just to trans- the organ demonstrations, there were ing with the toe is more natural and basic look as much like traditional pipe organ port an organ of 100 ranks or more. They workshop tours (Patrick J. Murphy & As- as a way of using the foot, and therefore equipment as possible. Later, multiplex- had people employed in experimental sociates and Nelson Barden at Longwood should be the beginning and the basis of ing was introduced—logic-based sys- roles, developing combination actions, Gardens), workshop seminars on mount- pedal technique. In fact, although “toes- tems that reduce organ music to data relays, and new types of voices. Today it’s ing toe-studs, stenciling façade pipes, and only” pedaling is quite rightly linked to streams that allow the information to be rare to fi nd a company with 100 employ- rebuilding Spencer organ blowers, and older repertoire and performance prac- tice (17th and 18th century, approximate- ly), even in the 19th and 20th centuries, David Petty & Associates without any specifi cally “historical” in- Organbuilders tent, it was often recognized that the toes were the logical place to start in teaching pedal playing. For example, the infl uen- 27 Marlboro Lane • Eugene, OR 97405 tial and often reprinted organ method (541) 521-7348 [email protected] of Sir John Stainer begins its pedal play- ing work with the toes alone. Once any student is fully profi cient at fi nding note patterns at the pedal keyboard with his or her toes—given that the technique is fl uid and comfortable—it will be easy and natural to use the heel for some or even many notes. Playing with the heel is, in a way, a special case of fi nding a note with a foot in relation to what that foot just did, and it can be very reliable. Of course, there are musical and histori- cal considerations that might argue for or against the use of heel in any given situation, and I will discuss these at some length in a later column. It is more natural and intuitive for a person to judge or know how far he or she has just moved one foot than to
14 THE DIAPASON
Dec 07 pp. 2-20.indd 14 11/8/07 8:44:09 AM WHY
Because it’s the organ built for you.
Why settle for someone else’s idea of the right organ for your church? A better idea just came along - yours. Trillium Masterpiece Series RUJDQVDUHEXLOWWRIXO¿OO your unique vision for worship. • Unprecedented tonal design ability • Hundreds of registration possibilities • Customized console design, from the trim style to the toe studs • 7ZRWR¿YHPDQXDOV • Each organ created LQGLYLGXDOO\OLNHD¿QHSLSH
organ “THE KING” FOUR MANUAL TRILLIUM MASTERPIECE The Trillium Masterpiece SERIES TOURING ORGAN Series organ. It doesn’t WITH CUSTOM FRENCH SPECIFICATION come out of a box. It comes BUILT FOR HECTOR OLIVERA out of your dreams. CONTACT US FOR A MASTERPIECE SERIES BROCHURE AND CD
Rodgers Instruments LLC A Member of the Roland Group 1300 NE 25th Avenue * Hillsboro, Oregon 97124 503.648.4181 * fax: 503.681.0444 America’s Most Respected Organ Builder Email: [email protected] * www.rodgersinstruments.com know spontaneously how far one foot is sented by the note-surface of pedal lines, Once a student is seated comfortably the note based on the approach de- from the other or how far one foot will be in which of course there are all sorts of on the bench I suggest the following: scribed in 2) above. It is important that from the other after it has been moved. intervals and all sorts of patterns as to 1) Find the lowest “A” on the pedal the student keep everything very slow It is this intuitive judgment that makes which foot is playing what. (For a couple keyboard. It is fi ne to do this by looking, so as to have plenty of time between it possible for us to drive cars knowing of classic cases of this, see the two long for now. each two notes to think about all the de- that we will hit the brake when we need pedal solos from the Bach F-major Toc- 2) Play that note with the left foot, us- tails, without any need to panic. to. In order to tell how far one foot is cata and the pedal part from the Widor ing whatever part of the foot can most 5) Once this scale seems comfort- from the other foot it is necessary to link Toccata). It makes sense for an organist comfortably push the key down fairly able—slow, light, even, accurate, and the two feet together by creating some to pick any pedal line apart, to see which close to the nearest raised keys but with- feeling easy to the student—the next sort of juxtaposition of the legs, for ex- foot is playing what and to look for sim- out touching them. This will (essentially) step is to play an A major scale in exactly ample by keeping the knees more or less ple, memorable, or useful patterns. I will always be part of the toe region of the the same way. This, of course, introduces together or by keeping the upper legs return later to this idea as it applies to foot, and will be the outside of the foot less regularly spaced one-step intervals. more or less parallel and roughly a con- experienced organists hoping to improve for some players and the inside for some. and so is more challenging. It is normal, stant distance apart. All such constraints their happiness with their level of pedal (For a very few students with quite small in fact nearly universal, for a student to on the position that a player assumes on mastery. However, this approach makes feet it will be the very tip of the foot.) land in between e and f coming down the organ bench are perhaps acceptable even more sense for a beginning organ The question of which particular part of from f-sharp, for example. The way to or even comfortable and good for some student. A simple set of exercises will the foot can most comfortably address correct this is again simply to say, on the students or players. But they are also the enable a new student to take the intui- the key will depend on the angle at which next time through that moment, “I must main source of the discomfort—initially tive sense of where a foot is in relation the foot is approaching the key, which move my foot a tiny bit farther.” This physical but then increasingly mental as to where it has just been, train it to be will in turn depend on the student’s pos- works remarkably well. well—that many organists and prospec- increasingly precise, and tie it in solidly ture on the bench. The more the student tive organists feel with the instrument. to the particular logistics of the pedal tends to keep his or her knees together, This simple, basic scale-based exer- In fact they are the reason that a steady keyboard. One important benefi t of the more likely it is that the inside of the cise is extraordinarily effective in train- stream of interested students end up giv- learning pedal playing this way is that foot will be the most comfortable for ing the sense of what it feels like to ing up the organ, as I mentioned in last after only a very few exercises that feel playing this A; the more the student lets move one foot the distance of one step. month’s column. Of course some of the like exercises, any student is able to use his or her knees drift apart the more like- This is the foundation of secure pedal physical constraints that are suggested essentially any pedal line as practice ma- ly it is that the outside of the foot will be facility. Next month I will introduce as ways of orienting the two feet to each terial. This makes it easy to keep things more comfortable. Neither one is right exercises that train that same sense in other are intended only for the begin- interesting for the student and for the or wrong; there is no reason to favor one more complicated musical contexts, and ning of study and are meant to be modi- teacher, and allows the student to have a over the other. It is very important to let expand the scope of what we are asking fi ed or dropped later on. However, they satisfying sense of being connected from the student fi gure out, starting from an each foot to do. Q are still often damaging to the process of the very beginning to the world of real individually comfortable posture, what a student’s becoming comfortable with music and to the tradition of great organ- details are right for that student as to foot Gavin Black is the director of the Princeton the instrument initially, and the success ists through the ages. position for playing particular notes. Early Keyboard Center in Princeton, New that students have moving past this dis- In keeping with all of the above, the (Note: by the time the student has Jersey. He is at work on a pedal-playing meth- od that will probably be available in the fall comfort varies considerably. Organizing fi rst thing that I ask a new student to played and released the A once or twice, of 2008. He welcomes feedback by e-mail at the learning of pedal facility and tech- do in preparing to work on pedal play- he or she should quit looking at the pedal
Specialists in Choral ANNUAL AND ONE-TIME COPYRIGHT and Organ Music
2209 Crestmoor Road, Suite 220 Nashville, TN 37215 PERMISSIONS WITH THE 615-386-3542 § 800-851-9023 § 615-297-4291 Fax www.loisfyfemusic.com CLICK OF A MOUSE
• EASY—online permission and reporting • ECONOMICAL—based on average weekend attendance • THOROUGH—your favorite songs • CONVENIENT—includes a growing list of publishers
LOG ON TODAY! WWW.ONELICENSE.NET
16 THE DIAPASON
Dec 07 pp. 2-20.indd 16 11/8/07 8:44:38 AM 20 years ago, and the use of multi-move- Missa pro defunctis (Requiem), Franz lines, always with solid instrumental sup- chestra version, making the work much ment choral settings during a church von Suppé (1819–1895). SATB, SATB port. It is not clear why Villa-Lobos calls more accessible. This huge work has service has become so rare that creat- soli, and large orchestra, Carus-Ver- this a mass-oratorio and this edition has frequent choral divisi and extended vo- ing this column of reviews on them may lag, 40.085/03, €99.00 (D-). no commentary. It is an interesting work cal ranges, especially in the soprano and seem a waste of time for many readers. There are 13 movements in this Latin and one that merits attention from con- tenor. The organ adapts the original or- Furthermore, although there are excep- Requiem. The large orchestra has paired ductors, probably for concert purposes. chestral timbre so that it retains the color tions, the average size of church choirs winds and includes a huge brass section The ending “dona nobis pacem” is more and character of the music. The organ is far smaller. So, in all this malaise, including four horns. The music is very of a demand than a prayer, as the setting part, on three staves, is somewhat chal- where is church music heading? dramatic with a colorful orchestration. ends with a dynamic of fff. lenging. There are extended solo pas- This writer is aware of one church in Full voice ranges are employed for the sages and this diffi cult music will require the area that lost over half of its popula- choir and they have very expressive lines, Truro Eucharist, David Briggs. SATB outstanding singers. This work is beyond tion over the decision to install a new or- divisi passages, and an extended section and organ, Chestnut Music (Ameri- most church choirs, and will need a large gan in the sanctuary. People did not want where they sing antiphonally with the can distributor, 70 LaSalle St. #128, chorus of very competent singers, but it “to see money wasted on purchasing a solo quartet. This setting will require a New York, NY 10027), $8.45 (M). is great music. new organ.” After lengthy debate over a big choir and orchestra and is about 70 This mass, by British composer period of several years, the decision was minutes’ duration. The orchestral parts Briggs, is in a lovely edition and clearly Te Deum, Johann Nepomuk Hummel fi rmly in place that the organ, which had are €74.00 and choral parts €16. marked. The organ part, on three staves, (1778–1837). SATB, orchestra and served that church for almost 50 years, has some registration suggestions and, organ, Cantate Music Press, CAN would indeed be replaced. As a result of Vidapura (Missa-Oratorio), Heitor except for a few brief right-hand fl owing 9002.01, full score $22.95 (D-). that decision families changed churches, Villa-Lobos. SATB, SATB soloists, or- lines, is relatively easy. The choral parts This is a fi rst edition of Hummel’s 15- the population of the church dropped by gan (or orchestra), Editions Max Es- have some soprano divisi, and a few brief minute Te Deum, which has a large or- almost half, and, in fact, a new church chig (France), M.E. 9010 (Theodore solo passages. Although the Kyrie is in its chestra; an alternate reduced instrumen- was formed by those who left; it became Presser Co.), $46.75 (M). traditional Greek, the other movements tation is available from the publisher. one in which there is no choir. This 22-minute setting is a Latin mass are in English. There is some dissonance, The organ part is not soloistic, usually The decline of church music has be- that contains all of the major movements but generally very attractive music. doubling the low strings as a single line. come so acute that there are numerous including the Credo. It dates from 1919 The choral parts are not diffi cult, pri- books and articles about its erosion. and follows traditional tonal relation- Te Deum marily in a syllabic four-part chordal set- Certainly one of the most widely read ships. The organ reduction, made by ting with minimal melismas. The large books on it is Marva Dawn’s Reaching the composer, is curious in that the fi rst Te Deum, Anton Bruckner (1824– orchestra is used throughout and has an Out Without Dumbing Down, which has page of the Kyrie uses three staves then 1896). SATB, SATB soli, and organ, important role in the total impact of the sparked considerable interest. Her com- stops; there is no pedal indication for the Bärenreiter, BA 7524, €12.95 (D). music, with several dramatic effects to mentary on the culture of church today two staves, which are used for almost Bruckner’s famous Te Deum has been enhance the Latin choral text. should be required reading for all who all the remaining music except for one arranged for organ by Andreas Kohs. are involved in church music at any lev- brief soloistic section where the pedals This setting is another one of Bären- Festival Te Deum, John Leavitt. el. The book is published by William B. are clearly marked. The choral parts are reiter’s large-scale works that has been SATB, brass choir, percussion, Eerdmans Publishing Company, Grand not diffi cult but often have contrapuntal adapted for organ from the original or- organ or piano, Concordia Pub- Rapids, Michigan, and is available in a soft cover, ISBN 0-8028-4102-3 (www. eerdmans.com). The day of full-time church work for musicians has already become a memory. The number of churches where a full- time musician is employed is embarrass- ingly small. Some of the reasons for this are fi nancial, of course, but there also may be an attitude issue. A great many of us have reached the age of retirement. The ... a voice for my soul changing culture of church music is in part because many of us who have tried to champion the traditions of today’s wor- ship services through the use of music by such giants as Bach, Buxtehude, Britten, and others are now reaching retirement age. Newer generations are becoming the leaders, but unfortunately many lack a broad view of church music history. As we retire from our church careers it is a good idea to heed the words of Anne Lamott, an author of such books as Grace (Even- tually) and Plan B, Further Thoughts on Faith. One’s job or career tends to be how we are defi ned to others and to our- selves. When that is no longer the driv- ing force of daily routines, there is a huge sense of loss that is oppressive, and that is why so many people who have retired go back to work. So, for all of you who are about to stop being church musicians, please consider staying in the battle. Your background, commitment, and expertise are needed now more than ever. In some ways, the future of church music depends on people who have this experience and interest. We must be as proactive about church music as those people who were against it and left the church. So instead of that easy formula-based anthem, give some thought to bringing to your choir and congregation an extended work that will challenge them. As the wonderful American composer Ernest Bloch (1880–1959) said, “Only that art can live which is an active mani- festation of the life of the people. It must be a necessary and essential portion of that life, and not a luxury.” The Mass
Missa Brevis, McNeil Robinson. SATB and organ, C. F. Peters Corp., #68154, $5.75 (M). There is no Credo in this Latin Missa www.johannus.com Brevis, which has the organ part on three staves with registration suggestions. Both choral and organ parts are well crafted yet simple in design, making the music very useful. There is limited contrapun- tal writing for the voices, which tend to move syllabically and primarily in similar rhythms. There is a brief soprano solo, and the opening of the Kyrie, which has a moderately high tessitura, would work the JOHANNUS revolution well as a soprano solo, although that is not indicated.
DECEMBER, 2007 17
Dec 07 pp. 2-20.indd 17 11/8/07 8:44:56 AM lishing House, 97-6895, full score Not unlike William Dowd, Frank denwoche’,” by Axel Unnerbäck (“From 1637–1641”). Despite the fact that Franz $20.00 (M+). Hubbard, Wallace Zuckermann and ‘Schnitger Week’ to ‘Sweden Week’”) de- Tunder and Dieterich Buxtehude played Brass choir includes three C trumpets, David Way in the world of harpsichord scribes Vogel’s role in the establishment this organ more than 50 years, this Stell- two trombones, one bass trombone, building, he gave himself over complete- of Swedish organ culture. How much wagen opus was entirely replaced in and tuba; timpani and small percussion ly to the vision of organ building in the better this article would have been if 1851. The disposition of that organ, un- are also needed. Leavitt’s setting is in antique style. His infl uence was seminal provided in English translation! fortunately, is a matter of conjecture. English with some divisi singing for the in the development of the artisan or- Chapters 5 through 9 are entirely on 18. “Eine Lütticher Quelle zur Ver- women. The music is syllabic, without gan building we know and even take for compositional techniques. breitung des gleichstufi gen 19tönigen contrapuntal vocal lines, often in block- granted today. 5. “Gleichwie sich fein ein Vöglein . . . Stimmungssystems in der ersten Hälfte chord rhythms. It is very exciting music These 21 essays in honor of Vogel’s Zu den Choralbicinien Johann Pachel- des 17. Jahrhunderts,” by Paul Peeters that will need a large choir, although 65th birthday range from remembrances bels,” by Michael Belotti (“The Chorale (“A Liege Source on the Dissemination the vocalists rarely have to try and to articles of musicological signifi cance Bicinia of Johann Pachelbel”). of Equal Nineteen-Note Temperament oversing to be heard since the brass has in organ building, composition and per- 6. “Anmerkungen zu Stil und Satz- in the First Half of the Seventeenth minimal areas where they play with the formance practice. They cover every- technik in Samuel Scheidts Görlitzer Century”). An excursion into the rather choir, usually having bursts of sound thing from congregational singing to sty- Tabulaturbuch,” by Konrad Brandt bizarre world of equal temperament be- between choral phrases. This is a work lus phantasticus. In the realm of organ (“Remarks on Style and Compositional yond 12 semitones! that singers and audience will greatly building they touch upon the organs of Technique in Samuel Scheidt’s Görlitzer 19. “Modernism, Mexico, and Musi- enjoy and one that could be done by Tannenberg in America to the restora- Tabulaturbuch”). cal Instrument Restoration,” by Edward solid church choirs. tion of antique organs in Mexico. This 7. “The Enigma of the stylus phantas- Charles Pepe. Four notions of mod- wide range of topics is a little confusing ticus and Dietrich Buxtehude’s Praeludi- ernism are visited: those of innovation, Te Deum, Douglas Coombes. SATB, at fi rst and is aggravated by the lack of um in G Minor (BuxWV 163),” by Pieter universality, reduction of non-western S solo, brass quintet and keyboard, English translations of several articles in Dirksen. This musicological exposition cultures, and individualism. These are Lindsay Music (Theodore Presser German. How handy it would have been demonstrates that the fantasia style was compared to historicism in the revival- Co.), $13.95 (M+). to have side-by-side translations instead carefully through-composed rather than ist organ culture and the nostalgia that The brass parts are available only of summaries! However, the content is of improvisational. created a yearning for artisan expression on rental; this choral score uses piano, suffi ciently high quality to warrant mul- 8. “Zusammenhänge zwischen den in organ building as opposed to indus- which has a very independent part with tiple readings. Vokal- und Orgel-Magnifi cats von Hie- trial production of the pipe organ. Pepe soloistic passages. The English text is set This 400-page volume includes 21 ronymus Praetorius,” by Frederick K. points out how modernist notions are at primarily in syllabic chordal fashion, with chapters, which are divided into four Gable (“Correlations between the Vocal tremendous odds with historical con- limited contrapuntal vocal lines. The so- areas: and Organ Magnifi cats of Hieronymus cepts in organ building and the work of prano solo is not extensive, sometimes • Harald Vogel, with essays by John Praetorius”). the old masters. He also makes an excel- singing alone but more often above a Brombaugh, Elizabeth Harrison, Ma- 9. “A Late-Romantic Motet Intabu- lent case for the inclusion of Spanish ele- choral background. This is a work that sakata Kanazawa and Axel Unnerbäck. lation: Sigfrid Karg-Elert’s Organ Tran- ments in the organs of Mexico. will challenge but will be attractive to the • Keyboard Literature, with articles scription of J. S. Bach’s Singet dem Herrn 20. “David Tannenberg: Remnant of listener and singer. by Michael Belotti, Konrad Brandt, Piet- ein neues Lied,” by Sverker Jullander. a Lost European Organ Culture?” by er Dirksen, Frederick Gable and Sverker These musicological articles appear Bruce Shull. The organs of David Tan- Jullander. to deviate tremendously from the main nenberg are described, and the restora- • Performance, with essays by Klaas theme of the book. This is a complicated tion of the Home Moravian Church in Book Reviews Bolt, Wim Kloppenburg, Keith Hill, situation for the English reader, given Salem, North Carolina is documented. Marianne Ploger and William Porter. that only summaries are provided for ar- Shull’s article explores fascinating as- • Organs, Organists, and Organbuild- ticles in the German language. pects of restoration in the areas of origi- Orphei Organi Antiqui—Essays in ers, with articles by Laurence Libin, 10. “Congregational Singing in a Cri- nal voicing and construction practices. Honor of Harald Vogel, edited by Lynn Edwards Butler, Gregory But- sis Situation,” by Klaas Bolt. This is a Shull cites the theories of Kristian Weg- Cleveland Johnson. Westfi eld Cen- ler, Felix Friedrich, Ibo Ortgies, Paul reprinted article that brings the reader scheider that “Tannenberg organs more ter, P.O. Box 505, Orcas, WA 98280. Peeters, Edward Pepe, Bruce Shull and back to Vogel’s concept of organ cul- correctly appear to stem from a branch $74.95 non-members, $64.95 mem- Joel Speerstra. ture and the need for studying antique of organbuilding that has once been bers,
18 THE DIAPASON
Dec 07 pp. 2-20.indd 18 11/8/07 8:45:14 AM some cases this means, of course, of the performance of Keith Chapman’s excit- and mysterious clunks. This CD is no ex- tre, etc., well played by Mr. Carpenter, edition used. ing arrangement of “Bring a Torch, Jea- ception to that principle; the fl ip side is who makes the most of the gentle and The organ was built by Rieger in 1992, nette, Isabella.” Richard Elliott’s rhyth- that there is an immediacy and presence, lovely sounds of this small organ. Seven a three-manual of 57 stops (about 82 mically charged and technically precise which often shows how it really sounded. anthems and songs appropriate to the ranks). The Positive (fi rst manual) seems playing brings Chapman’s creative writ- The choir is well balanced and expres- Christmas season are sung expressively to me very successful with a useful cho- ing to life. The featured vocal soloists sive. Preces are by Craig Phillips, chants and harmoniously by the Winston-Salem rus based on the Principal 4′ and quite perform arrangements of traditional by David Hurd and Stephen G. Schaef- Children’s Chorus, ably accompanied by “baroque” reeds. All of the instrument’s carols (as in Frederica von Stade’s stir- fer (Psalms 111, 112, 113 sung continu- David Pulliam. This large group of young reeds are very fi ne, and the pedal organ ring performance of “The First Noel”) as ously), the Magnifi cat and Nunc dimittis people encompasses ages 8–18. is impressive with 14 stops including two well as traditional secular favorites (An- from Howells’ Collegium Regale. The The Christmas music of the Mora- 32′s. Actually, this instrument, a bit of a gela Lansbury reprises her Tony award Psalms are beautifully rendered, and the vian tradition is a chief interest of this sensation in Great Britain in 1992, is not winning role as “Mame” in “We Need discreet organ accompaniment never in- recording. All the examples should be unusual for North America, and there a Little Christmas”). The incredible trudes. This is a large parish of over 4000 better known. Karl Gottfried Lowe’s “O are many organs by Rieger and others of voices of Bryn Terfel, Audra McDonald, members and obviously is beautifully Most Gracious, Welcome Child” can very similar makeup. The Swell contains and Renée Fleming are also featured in served by the cathedral musicians. Dr. only be described as gorgeous music, as a number of mutations in addition to traditional Christmas tunes and spiritu- Schaeffer plays the fi nal hymn, “All My is “Morning Star, O Cheering Sight” by reeds, and the number of solo possibili- als. The exceptional recording quality Hope on God Is Founded” and the excit- Francis Florentine Hagen. Boeringer’s ties is considerable. The organ acquits enhances the joyful listening experience ing Trumpet Tune of Craig Phillips as the “In Natali Domini” is marred by intona- itself well in all of the pieces on the disc. offered by this gifted musical cast. fi nal voluntary. This estimable group has tion problems occasionally. Ah, volun- I would have liked a more piquant sound —Steven Young sung Evensong in seven English cathe- teers! Bless ’em. in the Böhm partita, and I found the Bridgewater State College drals. It is easy to hear why. —Charles Huddleston Heaton fl utes dull in the slow movement of the Bridgewater, Massachusetts Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania Bach concerto, but these are objections An Old Salem Christmas. Moramus to the registration, not to the organ. Chorale, James Bates, director; One pleasant rediscovery for me was Evensong at The Advent. Cathedral Winston-Salem Children’s Chorus, Sigfrid Karg-Elert: The Complete Or- the Hollins work, which, despite a less Church of The Advent, Birming- Barbara C. Beattie, director; Scott gan Works—Volume 2. Stefan Engels, than promising title, is a fi ne organ ham, Alabama; Stephen G. Schaef- Carpenter, organ. 1800 Tannenberg organ; the Skinner organ of Toledo mood piece well worth resurrecting. fer, organist and director of music; Organ, 13 ranks, restored by Taylor Cathedral, Ohio, USA. Priory Records Walton’s march, in Sir William McKie’s Timothy S. Tuller, organist; Möller & Boody. Raven OAR-860, $14.98; PRCD819,
of Saxony, he seems to me less happy in DYERCASAVANT FISK GARLAND GOULDING & WOOD HENDRICKSON FRERES DOBSON R. the baroque pieces than elsewhere. The accompanying booklet contains information about organ, music, and performer in English, French, and
German. BOODY A well-played interesting mixed pro- gram on a good organ. You will enjoy it! —W. G. Marigold Urbana, Illinois
The Wonder of Christmas. Live per- formances of the Mormon Taberna- cle Choir and Orchestra at Temple Square featuring Renée Fleming, Angela Lansbury, Audra McDonald, Frederica von Stade, and Bryn Ter- fel. Mormon Tabernacle Choir, 2006.
DECEMBER, 2007 19
Dec 07 pp. 2-20.indd 19 11/8/07 8:45:33 AM Elert, recorded on the Späth organ of gan in a way evocative of the overwhelm- a selection of pieces popular in Anglo- leaps, and a plethora of ornamentation. the St. Georgskirche in Riedlingen, ing waves of the sea, and then drops back American society. It is a unique source Of considerable interest is the written- Germany, in the February 2007 issue to a whisper on the celeste in an epilogue for early American keyboard music. out cadenza by Pelham, which contains of the The Diapason. Stefan Engels based on the Kyrie at the end. This is an Of the 19 pieces in this volume, seven the only fi ngering indications in the MS. has recorded the second volume of the extremely well-crafted piece that de- are vocal pieces including a four-move- The fi nal keyboard piece is a setting of series on the 4/76 1930 E. M. Skinner serves to be better known and which ment cantata Alexis by Johann Pepusch, “Bonny Jean, a Scotch Tune,” in similar organ, Op. 820, at Our Lady of the Most might well, both because of its nature as with arias and recitatives and plenty of vein to “Through the Wood Laddie.” Holy Rosary Cathedral in Toledo, Ohio. a “storm” piece and because of its associ- Alberti bass work for the LH. Also in- Two further pieces in appendices in- While this would not have been ex- ations with the Titanic, appeal to a wide cluded is “A song set to Musick,” one of clude a treble line only to a minuet by actly the sort of instrument Karg-Elert audience of the general public. only three pieces known to be by Karl Pelham, and a Bass Minuet by Pachel- would have been used to in Germany, The fi nal three tracks on the compact Pachelbel; moving mainly in quarters bel, complete with fi ngering, taken from he would undoubtedly have approved disc are taken up with Karg-Elert’s Three or eighth notes, it is one of only two a MS of 1739. The preface gives a most the choice, since he was a good friend New Improvisations, op. 142. These pieces in the minor key. It would have valuable detailed introduction to Pel- of Mr. Skinner and a great admirer of represent Karg-Elert at his most impres- been helpful if the opening ritornello ham’s life (also to his descendants), to his instruments. This particular Skinner sionistic. As the notes inform us, they had actually been printed in full after bar the MS, and also to the ornamentation. organ is an outstanding example, both were originally written for the theatre 67 rather than the MS indication of two Pelham’s own table included just the because of its fi ne tonal qualities and organ—an instrument whose colors fas- bars followed by “etc.” names and signs without any explanation, because of the meticulous way that it cinated Karg-Elert—as Five Pastels for Other vocal pieces include the short but the editor has included facsimiles of has been restored, even down to retain- Cinema Organ. Two of the fi ve, “Iberian” “The Modest Question” set by Mr. the explanations from Purcell’s Rules for ing its original electro-pneumatic com- and “A Jolly Fellow,” have unfortunately Russell, who was a prolifi c composer Graces and Prelleur’s ornament table bination action and relays. not survived. The surviving three were of songs; two examples of song in the and fi ngering illustration from 1731. The recording begins with the Three arranged for classical organ and post- Masque of Comus by Thomas Arne, the This edition presents pieces of varying Impressions, op. 108, entitled “Sun- humously published in 1936. They are fi rst of which includes LH eighth-note quality and diffi culty (the simpler dances set,” “Starlight,” and “Elegiac Poem.” entitled “Stimmen der Nacht,” “Valse runs in octaves in the fi nal appearance are typical of those found in so many All three might be taken together to as mignonne,” and “Romantisch.” These of the opening bars that rounds off the publications in England in the early 18th evidence for the claim that Karg-Elert works are full of color, both in their chro- piece; “A Song on a Lady of Quality” set century), but the quantity of ornaments was Germany’s leading impressionist matic textures and in their spacious use to music by Mr. Marchant, which con- in some of the pieces will need careful composer. The fi rst two, gently sug- of the Skinner organ’s multi-hued pal- tains some fl orid vocal passagework in practice. The volume is an essential pur- gestive of the beauties of the natural ette. In the second of the Three Impro- 16th-note runs and dotted rhythms; and chase for all who are seriously interested world, are very different from the third, visations, the spirited “Valse mignonne,” “The Happy Shepherd,” a short ditty by in the development of keyboard music in originally subtitled Feuerbestattung the origins of the piece as a work for Doctor Greene. It is interesting that key- the 18th century in America. There are (“Cremation”) and apparently intended theatre organ are unmistakable. It has of board-style ornaments are written in the two facsimiles. The editing and printing to be evocative of soaring fl ames. The late become one of the composer’s most vocal part. All these pieces are on two are excellent; it is very much to be hoped Three Impressions are followed by one popular works. staves only and the performer must de- that other early American MS may be of Karg-Elert’s better-known works, Ca- Those who enjoyed the fi rst compact cide whether to double the vocal line or made available in the future. thedral Windows, a series of six pieces, disc will probably enjoy this one even treat the bass as an unfi gured bass to be —John Collins some of which are based on Gregorian more. I thoroughly recommend it. used for improvising an accompaniment. Sussex, England chants and others on familiar Christmas —John L. Speller There is, of course, no reason why these carols such as Resonet in Laudibus and St. Louis, Missouri pieces should not also be considered for Adeste fi deles. In several of the indi- performance on keyboard alone. vidual pieces effective use is made of The instrumental pieces vary consid- New Handbell Music repeated short motifs sounding like the erably in quality and standard. The fi rst tolling of a bell, while there is a lucidity New Organ Music one is a simple setting of “King George’s and brilliance in the compositions that March,” originally found in Handel’s op- Be Still My Soul, arranged for 3–7 evokes the light of stained glass. Ac- era Rinaldo, that is similar to the march- octaves of handbells by Cynthia cording to a surviving letter of the com- The Peter Pelham Manuscript of es of Jeremiah Clarke. The second piece, Dobrinski. Agape (Hope Publishing poser, Cathedral Windows was written 1744—An Early American Keyboard a minuet mainly in two voices, may well Company), code #2412, $4.50, level in a single day and was the result of the Tutor. Edited by H. Joseph But- have been composed by Pelham himself. 3 (M+). enthusiasm Karg-Elert felt when fi rst ler; published by Wayne Leupold The next piece is an almand originally Here is an ambitious arrangement of introduced to liturgical chant in Turin as American Classic and Romantic from a ballet produced by Campra and the beautiful tune Finlandia. With the Cathedral by one of his students, the Organ and Keyboard Music no. 7, Danchet, but in bars 12–13 Pelham has full complement of bells, this reharmoni- Baroness Ricci de Ferres. WL600204, $23.75;
20 THE DIAPASON
Dec 07 pp. 2-20.indd 20 11/8/07 8:45:52 AM In celebration of the 100th birthday, October 27, of Helmut Walcha: Artist-Teacher—Part 3 Paul Jordan
Parts 1 and 2 were published in the and venerable traditions. This context October and November 2007 issues of may help provide the “logic” behind THE DIAPASON, respectively. the postwar decisions of most German Protestant church authorities to remove Improvising and composing most of the Victorian-era hymns from Under the rubric of ‘Performing and the books and—in a sense: artifi cially, by Recording’ I sought to clarify Walcha’s sheer act of will—to replace them with concept of the relative places of the the sorts of older hymns which, e.g., had objective and subjective, the calculated still been in common use when Bach and the spontaneous, the performance included settings of them in his Orgel- for the moment and the recording for büchlein (and elsewhere), but which had the ages. As discussed, these categories long since, by the “organic” processes of pertained mainly to the role of the per- history and changes of taste, gone out of former in interpreting and rendering use (and out of the hymnals). the compositions of other musicians. In I describe these aspects of the broad contrast, say, to a Paul Hindemith, Wal- existential and the related ecclesiastical cha’s primary role and, at least for many situations also as the context in which decades, the main basis of his reputa- Walcha, at the turn of the decade from tion, was as an interpreter. This empha- the 1940s to the 1950s, committed a bold sis may have meanwhile shifted some- act, which was in some sense to haunt what, particularly in the Anglo-Saxon him for the rest of his life. As a respon- worlds of sacred music, where the four sible and already established artist in his volumes of his own Chorale-Preludes, own 40s, he felt self-confi dent and also— as published by Peters Verlag, have be- looking at the world around him—some- come liturgical staples, recognized for how impelled to publish an article, in a their quality, originality and accessibil- widely read sacred music journal, about ity even by younger musicians who may the organ music of Max Reger (who had never have heard Walcha’s performanc- died, in the midst of the fi rst world-con- es as an organist, and in particular his fl agration, in 1916). interpretations of Bach, either live or in In it Walcha made several key points their recorded embodiments. that I recall from my own reading—I It is useful to understand that these had, a decade after its publication, to compositions grew out of Walcha’s ex- seek the article out in the library. He tensive liturgical praxis—for, of the dared to express a less than positive hundreds if not thousands of worship evaluation of the pervasive chromati- services he played, virtually all included cism, grandiosity and hyper-expressiv- improvisations, and in particular of cho- ity of Reger’s idiom—in conversation, rale-preludes in many diverse styles, at least, I recall a comparison with the idioms, textures, durations, and degrees overbearing decadence of the Völker- of “modernity” and complexity. Indeed, schlachtdenkmal (Monument to the these publications are the only form in Battle of the Nations) in Leipzig. More which Walcha allowed his improvisation- importantly, he claimed that Reger’s or- al art to be preserved. At the same time, gan music was not, in the truest sense, as he would be the fi rst to concede, there organ music! It wrote out explicitly, in is a clear line between the spontaneity of mountains of notes, the very octaves improvisation and the fi xed and calculat- and other overtones that the organ ed structures of written compositions. “produces by itself,” by virtue of its Ursula Walcha (photo courtesy Jérôme Do Bentzinger) His wife Ursula—indispensable assis- tonal structure, e.g., in the mixtures of tant in Walcha’s learning of new scores the principal chorus, in the realization to their essences, might prove to be rel- side—evidently expected dyed-in-the- (she played each voice separately as of much simpler, basic notations that in- atively insignifi cant. wool Romanticists to close the book and dictation into his memory), in helping deed have been appropriately reduced, Not leaving it there, Walcha pro- go home, now cured of their Reger addic- to evaluate his registrations (and, when by real organ composers (e.g., Bach), to ceeded, in notational form, to reduce the tion. Or, he didn’t care . . . And he went necessary, pulling stops), and in his trav- the bare contrapuntal and harmonic es- opening strains of one of Reger’s grand- on to unmask the late-Romantic master els (these three roles cited from among sences of the music. Not only the sound, est and most renowned organ opuses to in yet another respect. He quoted lengthy her innumerable contributions to his but even the appearance of Reger’s such essences, to their “actual” musical samples of inner voices from fugues by welfare and success)—was wont to voice music, Walcha implied, was overladen meanings, expressed in plain four-part Reger, voices which were, indeed, distin- her view that her husband’s composi- and pretentious and tended to hide the harmony. Having thus “unmasked” the guished by being undistinguished, if not tions, fi ne as they were, did not quite presence of ideas, which, once reduced reality, the professor—he had his naïve virtually shapeless. He implied that such represent the full glory of his improvisa- tions. Still, we are fortunate to have them for their intrinsic values and as a minimal record of this artist’s most personal—and often moving—manner of conveying the meanings of the tunes and texts of hymns, and of his considerable capaci- ties as a musical thinker within as well as outside of the Bachian “box.” Provocateur for his times (Walcha and Reger) Regardless of whatever preoccupa- tions we may nurture with matters of cosmic order, time (eternity) beyond human or even natural history, peren- nial philosophies and unalterable truths, we are also all children of our own time, embedded in its more or less chaotic his- tory, and subject, with little recourse, to EHGLHQWRUJDQFRP its shifting winds. For Germans the year 1945 marked the “zero hour,” as Hitler and his minions had severely ruptured the integrity of the nation’s spirit and the opposing Allies reduced a large portion of its “physical plant” to rubble—to- gether also leaving virtually no survivors untouched by loss of friends and family. With World War II coming so close on the heels of—and even more destructive than—the earlier “war to end all wars,” the newly traumatized mood was less one of quick fermentations and liberations than of a need to reexamine the bases of one’s existence, to slough off all that was superfl uous, and even to seek renewal in QRZZLWKPXVLFDQGYLGHR a return to long-lost but once well-tried
DECEMBER, 2007 21
Dec 07 pp. 21-23.indd 21 11/8/07 8:47:45 AM voices can be retained only on a short-or- “Good luck, Helmut!,” I thought when der basis—they lack the kind of identity he told me this. (But if anyone could do that would enable them to penetrate to it . . . ) This did not of course mean that the deeper layers of musical appercep- he was going to start learning to play tion. This demonstrated, too—here, the some French music—there seemed coup de grâce—that Reger was writing to be an uncrossable line there; yet at fugues on paper only, fugues that had least he wished to fi nd out more about some visual “earmarks,” but lacked the the language behind it . . . substance of genuine polyphony. Again, the late gentleman is revealed to have Friends, successors been something of a four-fl usher . . . When it came time to think about In a concession, Walcha acknowledged his successors, at school and church, the likelihood that it was not merely ig- Walcha, as might be expected, thought norance that prompted Reger’s lavishly judiciously. While there were several doubled and tripled notation: it was of his former students, on both sides probably made necessary by the relative of the Atlantic, who he believed would lack of overtones in the tonal structure be qualifi ed to succeed him in either of the organs with which Reger had con- or both positions, he also thought it tact, organs built, self-evidently, before wiser—at least in making suggestions the Orgelbewegung (the neoclassicist to the school administration—to move reform movement of the 1920s) had suc- outside of “the family.” The Geneva or- ceeded in bringing back the earlier type ganist and recording artist Lionel Rogg of instruments with their richer overtone and he admired each other’s playing and resources. But this too becomes evidence had exchanged views in letters; on bal- against the continuing credibility—or vi- ance, Rogg seemed a worthy candidate able use—of Reger’s organ compositions: both to carry forth the pedagogical work designed for organs that required the use within a congenial aesthetic tradition of so many fi ngers all at once, they will and to sustain the prestige of the church sound harsh, if not ridiculous, if applied Helmut Walcha at St. Laurens Church, Alkmaar, the Netherlands music division of the Hochschule. Com- to our current instruments that have all ing from Geneva, however, Rogg was un- these overtones already—and properly ing decades and did not necessarily fi nd discipline, structured by his sense of time, derstandably less than enthusiastic about so—built into their tonal structures! No, Walcha unreceptive. There were two was extraordinary; on top of all the organ the contours and ambiance of post-war Reger—Walcha believed—would be possibilities: if the work was to be one and harpsichord music, and the entire Frankfurt as a city; while the chance to found to have not much going for him in that Walcha himself had once played, Lutheran hymnal—including the words preside over the Schuke across the river this newly “essential” world of 1950. he might well take it on, and—relearn- of hymns with thirteen verses—he also just might have been able to persuade And then the consequence. In the ing it quickly from listening—would had his datebook in his head. When I him, Walcha was still yearning for a few light of the foregoing considerations, he soon also even be able to demonstrate once gave him a long-playing album for more years of unencumbered work at his said, “I have decided to strike Max Reger it again at the console . . . If it were a his birthday in October and a few days Dreikönigskirche. In the end, the suc- from the list of composers whose works piece unfamiliar to Walcha, there were later asked if he had heard it, he said, “Oh cessor at school was Edgar Krapp, who, students at the Frankfurt Hochschule other, often quite willing teachers avail- no, I won’t be able to listen to that until it is said, convinced Walcha and the oth- are required to play.” One might ask: If able at the school. [Disclosure: during February—it’s scheduled for the 19th, ers with an especially cogent rendition of students here in New Haven in 2007 are my own Frankfurt time, Armin Schoof after my afternoon nap.” When at my les- the C-minor Passacaglia and Fugue. not required to play Reger, why should studied Reger’s great F-minor work with son on February 20th I remembered to Later, at church, Walcha was suc- students in Frankfurt in 1950 have been Walcha—though it is not specifi cally in- inquire if he’d yet had a chance to listen ceeded by his recent student Renate required to? But those were different cluded in the Coppey-Kunz repertoire to the album (the early Swingle Singers Meierjürgen, who had already been di- times, and in a different country. The ar- list—while I enjoyed learning the much singing Bach), he responded immediate- recting the choir and was something of ticle occasioned “storms” of professorial smaller, but also tellingly “Regerian” Pre- ly, “Oh yes, we listened to it yesterday, as an expert on his Chorale-Preludes. This protest in endless letters of rebuttal in lude in A Minor from Opus 69 with Prof. planned, right after my nap . . .” appointment kept matters at the church, subsequent issues of the journal. Part of Hartmann at the cathedral downtown.] Helmut and Ursula (though I never literally, in the family for the rest of the the trauma was due to a confl ation of “not In wrapping up this episode, which I used those words) made time for quiet Walchas’ lives, inasmuch as Frau Meier- required to” with “forbidden to.” Anoth- have narrated in detail because I believe social events with the students—often jürgen, a single woman, had also agreed er part was a nervous fear of a creeping it to be of interest yet perhaps not read- in their home—and with their friends. to move in with the Walchas on Has- return of the kind of authoritarianism ily accessible to other American organ- There was never an impression that they selhorstweg, where she became instru- and censorship that had characterized ists, my own feelings are that, despite a were rushed, under deadline pressures, mental in helping both of them to cope German cultural life during the “thou- number of inherent misunderstandings, or had not gotten enough sleep. In the with the diffi culties of old age and now sand year empire” from 1933 to 1945. it formed a characteristic, if marginal part summers they loved to take long walks continues to reside. Her successor at the Another element was no doubt simple of the process of cleaning up from the in the Black Forest—and, after a few ex- church became Andreas Köhs, a concert envy of and dislike for Helmut Walcha, vestigial messiness of some Romanticism planations, he had the layout of the land- organist and choral-orchestral conduc- coupled with an outspoken rejection of along with some forms of potential bru- scape memorized (just as he knew, and tor as well as a music editor with a ma- his opinionated outspokenness. Another tality, which that emotional/artistic nexus could give you a guided taxi tour of the jor publisher. Like most German organ- may have been a sense that as the duly had left behind in the political and cultur- Frankfurt cityscape). They also managed ists today, given the slow attrition of the appointed head of the Frankfurt school’s al sphere [the line, say, from Wagner’s to to attend concerts, of his colleagues, or churches’ budgets under the continuing Church Music Institute, Walcha had the Hitler’s anti-Semitism], and that the con- of students such as myself who might system of church fi nancing via state-col- prerogative to make such decisions with- troversy engendered by Walcha’s boldness be performing in other media (e.g., he lected taxes, and with a dwindling con- out enduring such a challenge—but did was needed, or useful, in 1950, as a healthy wanted to hear recorder, he wanted to gregation as almost everywhere, he faces it have to be with that rationale, and that means to help clarify both aesthetic and hear counter-tenor; or, if I happened to an ongoing struggle to maintain, if not provocative publicity?! human rights positions in certain German play an organ concert near where they expand the program—meaning, in this If not already in that written context, musical circles—and this even if perhaps were vacationing, they might show up case, to continue Dreikönigs’ traditional Walcha did eventually offer the addi- there is now no one left who could still unexpectedly and socialize with us after- contributions to the city’s cultural life in tional explanation that while in wartime agree in all specifi cs with either Walcha’s wards—other students have told similar a manner worthy of the memory of the he was memorizing the 48 W.T.C. Pre- or some of his critics’ theses. stories . . .). relatively recent tenures, at this institu- ludes and Fugues in the country retreat, In retrospect, it is hard to imagine how tion, of such stellar historical fi gures as he came to realize that there was not Lifestyle, discipline, personal time, all this was possible, especially inasmuch (the conductor and, later, Thomas-Kan- enough room in his mind to accommo- hobbies as he could read neither words nor music tor) Kurt Thomas and Helmut Walcha. date their highest-density substance and The Walchas’ personal lifestyle was in Braille. They listened to some radio, The Walchas had several concen- still hold on to the discursive Reger organ characterized primarily by modesty and and he alluded to their reading entire tric circles of friends, relatives and as- extravaganzas that he had learned and simplicity, an almost vegetarian diet, books (including novels) together, she sociates. Among their closest friends often played in his younger years; some- herbal teas, regular afternoon naps, an reading to him regularly in the evenings. in their later years, in addition to Frau thing had to give. A related question can- occasional glass of wine; after the inter- He was curious, and the questions he Meierjürgen, were the late composer not be repressed: Is there anyone alive national success of his recordings—his asked of people were meaningful and Kurt Hessenberg and his wife Gisela; who knows and plays, or was there ever D Minor Toccata and Fugue record- well formulated; it was a pleasure to try harpsichordist Maria Jäger-Jung, who anyone who knew and played—during ing alone, he once told me, fi nanced his to answer to his satisfaction. His main died this year; the organist Karl Köhler, the same period of life—the entire Well- house organ—the couple could have hobby, I think—as well as a way to prac- formerly in charge of much of the litur- Tempered Clavier as well as a set of giant lived in much greater opulence; but they tice—was playing his house organ. In gical organ program at the Hochschule Reger organ works, both from memory? chose not to do so. For one thing, such his retirement he did so purely for fun, and still residing in Frankfurt; the late In any case, the occasional determined a change could have impinged on the ac- telling me, for instance, how nice it felt Berlin painter Gerhard Rechenbach Frankfurt student did propose Reger customed quietude and focus requisite to be freed from the compulsion of al- (who painted the portrait of Helmut for study in the lessons over the ensu- for his ongoing musical attainments. His ways playing for note perfection. Though Walcha that still adorns the living room his harpsichord playing seemed not as on Hasselhorstweg), and the loyal Adolf idiomatic, sensuous, mellifl uous as, say, Kirschner, still living in Frankfurt, with Gustav Leonhardt’s (or as his own organ whom the friendship dated back to the playing), he did enjoy the East German year 1935. In addition it is clear that they cembalo he had at home. enjoyed a close relationship with Chris- In his retirement he turned also to tel North-Wittmann (the oldest daughter other enjoyments—listening to Wag- of Pastor Paulus North), who at one time ner (as he had in his youth)—or learn- directed the church’s choir, and her fam- ing French(!), something he felt he’d ily, as also with Helmut Walcha’s former missed out on throughout his music assistant Agathe Calvelli-Adorno (a niece studies and professional life. Of course of the late eminent philosopher) and her he had to approach this in his own sys- brilliant scientist-husband Rainer Jae- tematic way, starting with the music: nicke. Of course there were important from his tutor he wanted fi rst to fi nd friendships lost to death—I think of the out how to pronounce all the nasal late Erich Thienhaus, who on behalf of word endings, in, en, an, on, un (hard Deutsche Grammophon recorded many enough to distinguish in context . . . ). of Walcha’s early albums, and his com-
22 THE DIAPASON
Dec 07 pp. 21-23.indd 22 11/8/07 8:48:52 AM an endpoint has been reached . . . ) of attending to playing-styles informed by reconsiderations and revisions without the most recent historiography, and which life and history are not possible. even from such seductively looser and But the primary focus of his work and more “casual” kinds of musical gestures teaching was the artist’s obligation to as seem favored among some of the deal responsibly—a path at least as chal- younger artists, I confess that what I do lenging—with the immanent structure fi nd largely missing these days is a sense and character of each individual work, of the deep interpretative responsibility not by subjecting it to a patented solu- to the essence of each individual work, tion, but by minute examination and and the consequent specifi c and lucid analysis—of its specifi c language and be- internal organization of each musical ing and discernible structure and expres- rendition, which characterized and was sive intentions—by the eyes and intellect so widely appreciated half a century ago and heart and (rather than by theories) in the work of Helmut Walcha. Perhaps, via the inner ear informed by these three prompted by his centennial, a broad and human faculties and supplemented by detailed reconsideration of the sound such intriguing general stylistic man- recordings of this artist, in conjunction dates or suggestions as are contempora- with his educational legacy, could facili- neously proffered through the insights or tate a reformulation (resolidifi cation?) opinions of historians. of our interpretative priorities—within I have enjoyed listening to recordings a new hermeneutical cycle of conscious- and performances by some of the bril- ness—and thereby also contribute, in liant young organists entering church and analogy to his work’s earlier direct appeal concert life today. Much of their work beyond the confi nes of the organ world, conveys a fi ne visceral excitement—pas- to bringing our instrument and its reper- Kurt Hessenberg with Helmut Walcha in the mid-1960s (photo credit Paulus North, sion has not been lost! While the gen- toire yet a step closer—as most of us de- courtesy Jérôme Do Bentzinger) erations may be well advised to eschew sire—toward the center of mainstream directly “interfering” with each other, contemporary classical music culture. panion—a couple to whom, in my recol- to good historical research than to sub- empathy and respect for the mysteries It is my hope that, by way of encour- lection, the Walchas referred quite often. jectivity or spontaneity; indeed he knew of new (or old) perceptions and of dif- aging such an undertaking or at least Helmut Walcha and many of his former that, as an intrinsic part of our lives and ferent internally driven emphases need discussion, recollections by others who students, on both sides of the ocean, kept times, it contributed inevitably and often perhaps not preclude some benefi cial re- knew or felt strongly about Helmut in touch with each other, some in more usefully—or usably, for it needs to be ciprocal stimulation and cross-fertiliza- Walcha—along with other relevant com- rigorous, some in looser ways. But the af- used and not worshipped—to change, tion (as another part, indeed, of the in- ments or critiques prompted by this ar- fections from and for the Walchas were via those endless hermeneutic cycles eluctable historical hermeneutic). While ticle—will be forthcoming in the pages and are spread around the planet. No- (no matter how often we like to believe I can—and have tried to—learn from of The Diapason. Q where do his work and person continue to be more revered, for instance, than today in Japan. The organ in the musical world Our instrument is grandly self-con- tained and we are, with few exceptions, not required to interact with other mu- sicians in order to enjoy it; in addition, it usually sits, not portable, in church buildings and liturgical contexts a good step or two removed from the venues and concerns of the larger—and secu- lar—musical world. We congregate less with other musicians than among our- selves, and then with clergy and church people for whom music is often one of several means toward approaching reli- gious goals but rarely an end in itself. In these circumstances it may not be sur- prising that some organists have, over the last seven or eight decades, been drawn to doctrines that advocate simplistic solu- tions to the problems of musical interpre- tation—cries of “everything legato except repeated notes!, everything detached!, everything portato except for occasional couplets!, no Romanticism!, no Clas- sicism!, only Eclecticism is American!, organs without tremulants!, no thumbs!, never legato over the bar-line!, no cases!, no swells!, no electric bellows!, no combi- nations!, no more tracker-action!, choral accompaniment only on British organs!, never play from memory!, always play from memory!, historical temperaments only!, Spanish Renaissance organs to the Johns Creek Baptist Church rescue!”—etc. Is there a reader who has not heard all Alpharetta, Georgia of these cries? Is it a problem that none of them ever crossed the lips of Helmut Five manuals • 103 ranks Walcha? It is a problem, for us—I sub- mit—that almost none of them ever crosses the lips of an oboist or a singer or a violinist or a composer or a pianist . . . For any of these people, to advocate such creeds would soon render them dysfunctional as musicians. For them the issue is, and has to be, the virtually endless variety of means available, and required!, for convincing, communica- tive interpretation of music. How and where have we, do we (through our iso- lation?), go wrong, become so narrow? Out there, also—scratched beneath the surface—even the Harnoncourts and Hogwoods, Herreweghes and Gardin- ers would admit that delving ever deeper into the cave of history, to retrieve from its dim light ever greater jewels of truth, of authentic instructions from the dead (instructions then to be enforced by a kind of Early Music Police, analogous to composers’ Avant-garde Music Police of the 1960s), is not actually the way, not the Distinguished pipe organ builders of Padua, Italy primary way, in which musical interpre- tation evolves (or “improves”)—among www.ruff atti.com Via Facciolati, 166 • 35127 Padua, Italy organs@ruff atti.com people living in a 21st century. Telephone (39-049) 750-666 Telefax (39-049) 850-483 In the United States: 330-867-4370 Helmut Walcha was no more opposed
DECEMBER, 2007 23
Dec 07 pp. 21-23.indd 23 11/8/07 8:49:16 AM The University of Michigan Historic Organ Tour 54 Jeffrey K. Chase
hat a special trip the Marilyn organ (reconstructed by Hoffmann in Mason University of Michigan 1999) on the fourth level. It was to test WHistoric Organ Tour 54 this this organ that Bach came to Arnstadt in past July 9–22 was, tracing the cities 1703. He was so appreciated that he was and churches limning the lives and ca- hired as organist and remained employed reers of J. S. Bach and Buxtehude and, here until 1707, when he took his 200- among others, the organ builders Silber- mile walk to Lübeck to hear and learn mann, Schnitger, Trost and Marcussen! from Buxtehude, a trip that resulted in Entitled “In the Footsteps of Bach and his dismissal and move to Mühlhausen. Buxtehude,” it included visits to historic Marilyn Mason’s friend Gottfried Praller organs in Mühlhausen, Weimar, Eisen- demonstrated this Wender/Hoffmann ach, Arnstadt, Altenburg, Frauenstein, instrument with performances of Buxte- Freiberg, Dresden, Leipzig, Wittenberg, hude’s Ciaconne in d and Bach’s Fugue in Hamburg, Lübeck, Århus, Odense and d. On the third level of this church, now Copenhagen. Much was learned and ex- referred to as the Bachkirche, is a 1913 perienced by its fortunate participants. Steinmeyer organ, also reconstructed by After arriving in Frankfurt at approxi- Hoffmann in 1999. mately 7:30 a.m. and after having collect- Our last stop in Arnstadt was the near- ed all of the participants fl ying in from by New Bach Museum containing, inter various locations, we boarded a beauti- alia, the console Bach played upon in St. ful, very modern bus to commence our Boniface and some historic holographic journey of exploration. music manuscripts. Bach House in Eisenach from the back
Mühlhausen, Weimar, Eisenach, Altenburg, Frauenstein, and and Arnstadt Dresden Our fi rst stop was at St. Blasiuskirche The next day, after breakfast, we de- in Mühlhausen, where Bach had worked parted for Dresden, but with two inter- from 1707–1708 (this year being the mediary stops. The fi rst was in Altenburg 300th anniversary of Bach’s arrival there to view and play the 1735–1739 Tobias from Arnstadt). While there, Bach sub- Heinrich Trost (1673–1759) organ in the mitted plans for rebuilding the organ. castle church (“One of the great organs This organ, however, was replaced in of the world,” says Marilyn Mason). Bach the 19th century with a new instrument. played this organ in September 1738 or But turnabout is fair play, and from 1739 and again in October 1739, when 1956–1958 the 19th-century organ was Bach’s pupil Krebs was the organist, as removed; the Alexander Schuke compa- he was for the last 25 years of his life. ny built a new organ based upon Bach’s This fi ne organ was also played by We- plans, but with the addition of fi ve new ber, Liszt, Agricola and Schütz. Today registers to support the performance of Felix Friedrich, who has edited and pub- modern organ literature. The casework lished several volumes of Krebs’s work, of this Schuke organ exemplifi es the in- is the organist. Altenburg is known as dustrial style of the former East German the playing card capital of the world, be- regime and its banal aesthetic. cause playing cards are made here, and Then on to Weimar where Bach spent the castle museum contains an interest- ten years as a musician to the Grand ing collection of both old and new cards. Duke; where Bach was imprisoned in The second stop was in Frauenstein, 1716 for requesting to resign from his the birth city of the revered organ build- position to take another; and where, in er Gottfried Silbermann (1683–1753) 1717, Bach was fi rst mentioned in print, and the site where Werner Mueller being called “the famous Weimar organ- established the Gottfried Silbermann ist.” After checking into the outstanding Museum, which contains, among other Elephant Hotel, next door to the build- things, a reproduction of a one-manual, ing in which Bach lived from 1708–1717 no-pedal organ in Bremen, and upon and where his sons Wilhelm Friedemann which we each shared playing a theme and Carl Philip Emmanuel were born, and variations by Pachelbel on Was Gott we took a short stroll in the rain to visit thut, das ist wohlgetan. While there, we the Parish Church of Sts. Peter and Paul, learned that the property has recently where, beginning in 1707, Bach’s relative been sold to developers, so most likely and colleague Johann Gottfried Walther the museum will be removed to anoth- was organist. er building. Early the next morning we boarded Now in Dresden, we visited the Dom the bus and departed for Eisenach, or Hofkirche (the Dom was the main where J. S. Bach was born on March 21, church in a town) containing a 1755 1685. He was baptized at St. George’s Silbermann organ, his largest and last, Church, where Luther had sung in the with three manuals and 47 registers, choir and had also preached. That bap- and which was last restored by Jehmlich tismal font, which has a pedestal carved in 1971. Then we walked past the por- like a wooden basket, is still in use today. celain mural of the kings of Saxony on At that church, located on the Market the street leading to the Frauenkirche, Square (that day it was market day), we which, however, we could not visit due were treated to an organ recital (well at- to the late time of day. So on to a fi ne tended by the public) performed by the dinner at one of the outside restaurants. young Denny Philipp Wilke, an organist from Nürnberg, who studied with Latry Freiberg, Leipzig, Rötha, and van Oosten. Wilke performed Bach’s and Stürmthal Prelude and Fugue in D, the Scherzo The next day we traveled to Leipzig Paul Merritt playing the Silbermann organ in the Georgenkirche in Rötha. This from Vierne’s Organ Symphony No. 2 via Freiberg to visit Silbermann’s Opus is the organ on which the “Marilyn Mason” organ at the University of Michigan and the Franck A-minor Choral on the 2 (1714) with three manuals and 44 reg- was based. 1982 Schuke of Potsdam organ. This fall isters and last restored by Jehmlich in Wilke was scheduled to record a recently 1983. We also visited the Jakobikirche, pointed simulated foliage. We played an is not a relic of the days of Bach’s tenure, discovered transcription by Dupré of just outside the old city wall, where we 1862 fi ve-manual Ladegast organ re- but an 1889 Wilhelm Sauer instrument Liszt’s Ad nos, ad salutarem undam. played a two-manual Silbermann. This worked over the years by Sauer and by last restored in 1993. It is here that Bach After lunch we visited the Bach Muse- church is an old, very plain building but Eule. Currently part of its electronic is buried. um (Bach’s birth house), where we heard with an active congregation. The priest, stop action is by Porsche, whose name is No University of Michigan organ tour a talk describing and demonstrating two rather than an organist, let us in and ex- prominently displayed on the beautiful to this area would be complete without small period organs, a spinet, a clavicem- plained that the congregation can’t afford wood of its art deco-like console. From a stop in Rötha to view the 1721 G. Sil- balo and a clavichord, and in which a an organist. Can you imagine: a church the Nikolaikirche it was a short walk to bermann organ in the Georgenkirche, crystal drinking cup, the only item re- with an historic Silbermann organ and the legendary Thomaskirche, originally because this instrument was chosen by maining from the Bach household, is no organist! Any volunteers? part of a 13th-century monastery and the Charles Fisk and Marilyn Mason as the displayed. One of the rooms is set up as In Leipzig we lunched on the Niko- other main city church, and the one at model for what is now known as the Bach’s composition room in Leipzig pre- laistraße before entering the Nikolai- which J. S. Bach was cantor from 1723 “Marilyn Mason Organ” in the Universi- sumed to have looked. kirche, whose congregation was a leader until his death in 1750 and with which he ty of Michigan School of Music, Theatre Then back in the air-conditioned bus in the democratic movement before the is most closely associated. Because this and Dance—Fisk and Mason thought it, for a drive to Arnstadt to visit St. Boni- fall of the Berlin Wall. This church has a church is such a tourist attraction, all we of all known G. Silbermann organs, best face Church, containing a 1703 Wender very ornate interior decorated with sharp could do was look around; the organ here suited to the U-M space.
24 THE DIAPASON
Dec 07 pp. 24-26.indd 24 11/8/07 8:50:18 AM Gale Kramer playing the Ladegast/Eule organ in the Nikolaikirche in Leipzig. Note the Porsche name on the console The bronze doors with Luther’s 95 in the lower right portion of this picture Theses on the Schlosskirche in and the Rollschweller to the left of the Wittenberg two swell pedals.
the church where Buxtehude had worked portative organ with pull-down pedals from 1668 to 1707. Its historic Schnitger and a bird stop, which has been restored organ and the Totentanz organ (named by Ahrend in the Netherlands. after a painting in the church) were de- The design of the 13th-century Ae- stroyed by bombs in 1942. gidiankirche is unusual because its pews The Domkirche, founded by Henry face the preacher and not the altar. It the Lion in 1173, today makes modern has a choir screen from the Renaissance use of space. Its Romanesque towers with eight panels depicting the life of survived the war, but its Gothic portions Christ. Its original organ dated from A portion of the old console of the Jacobikirche in Hamburg showing stops with fell. Its contemporary (1960) stained 1629 and was built by Scherer of Ham- the heads of the donors glass window in the west end is especial- burg. The case, not in baroque style, but ly beautiful. The 1699 Schnitger organ, with small, refi ned details suggestive of Next, an unscheduled visit to Stürm- 32′ stop because he wanted his church to originally built here but burned during earlier times, was created by a famous thal to tour a country church, where a be the only one in town to have a 32′ stop, the war, had been played by Handel, Lübecker carver. This is one of the few funeral was in progress. Zacharias Hil- but Schnitger foiled him by building two Mendelssohn and Mattheson. A 1970 organs built during the Thirty Years debrandt (1688–1757), a protégé of G. 32′s—a Principal and a Posaune. Bach Marcussen instrument now sits on the War, in which the independent north- Silbermann, built this organ, a one-man- applied for the organ post here in 1720, north wall. There are raised auditorium ern German cities were not obliged to ual with pedal, but got into trouble with but he would have had to pay a fee to get seats on the west end where the organ fi ght. Now, the old cabinetry with its Silbermann because of Silbermann’s per- the job. Instead a wealthy man with the used to be and a small positiv organ is in intricate light and dark inlaid wood fi g- ceived competition. Hildebrandt invited money to pay (bribe!) was hired. the choir space. Here also is a charming ures is more interesting than the 1992 Bach to play this bright, high-pitched This was the organ whose pipes were Baggio di Rosa 1777 Italian one-manual Klais instrument it contains. instrument and Bach wrote Cantata 194 removed to safe storage during WWII, for Hildebrandt. thus saving this organ when the church and loft were subsequently destroyed. Wittenberg, Lüneburg, Hamburg, This Schnitger organ, which used to and Neuenfelde hang higher on the wall, was eventually The next day, Saturday, began with a restored by Jürgen Ahrend in 1950 and long drive to Hamburg with a fi rst stop again in 1993. It was Schnitger’s habit “The sound comes from along the way in Wittenberg, birthplace to reuse pipes, so pipes from the 1500s of the Lutheran Reformation, to visit were incorporated by Schnitger. (This in the revered Martin Luther sites. We did contrast to Silbermann, who used only within you.” not play the organ in the castle church, new material.) Its temperament is be- another major tourist attraction and tween meantone and Werckmeister III which now has Luther’s 95 statements (modifi ed meantone). The faces of its immortalized in bronze on its doors (the donors are immortalized on the original doors upon which Luther nailed his 95 stopknobs of the original console, which Theses on 31 October 1517 have long is displayed on a balcony but is not part since been replaced). of the currently functioning instrument. The second stop on the Hamburg Albert Schweitzer has played this organ, journey was in Lüneburg to visit the and Marilyn Mason has proclaimed it Michaeliskirche, where Bach had ma- one of the great organs of the world. triculated in the choir school. This triple- We also visited the Michaeliskirche in naved, Gothic, red-brick hall church with Hamburg, the main city church, a rococo drastically leaning pillars contains an or- room with curved balconies. The gallery gan with a typical North German case organ was built from 1909–1912 by E. F. and with pipes from many eras. This was Walcker of Ludwigsburg. With its fi ve originally the church for a Benedictine manuals and 163 stops, for a time it was monastery, and thus the private church the largest organ in the world. We played and sepulchral vaults for the reigning music including French pieces that work families of the Billungs and Guelphs. well on it. The restored organ in the side Tobias Gravenhorst is the current choir- gallery we did not play, nor did we play master. The organ here consists of an old a small organ in the choir space. There case with new contents last reworked in were many visitors coming and going in 1999–2000 by Sauer, which used to be a this church. large fi rm but now is only a small compa- St. Pankratius, a small church with a ny. One might speculate whether Bach, rural setting in Neuenfelde, is the buri- as a young boy in the choir school gazing al place of Arp Schnitger (1648–1719) up at the organ case, got the idea of put- and was his home church for a number ting “Soli Deo Gloria” at the end of his of years. He built this high baroque- compositions from the “Soli Deo Gloria” style, two-manual, 34-stop organ for this All Saints Episcopal Church, Atlanta, GA inscription at the top of the organ case. church in 1688 and the bulletin board in- Raymond & Elizabeth Chenault, Music Directors Sunday mornings are, of course, the time vites people to worship on Sunday to the Quote overheard during the Dedication Service when churches are fulfi lling their main accompaniment of the Schnitger organ. function as houses of worship for their congregations, so for us Sunday morning Lübeck Member, Associated Pipe Organ is free time. On Monday, our last day in Germany, John-Paul Sunday afternoon we visited the fa- we journeyed to Lübeck, the fi rst Ger- Builders of America mous Jakobikirche in Hamburg, where we man city bombed in World War II (in Buzard 112 West Hill Street were hosted by a friendly female organist response to the Germans’ bombing of Pipe Organ Builders Champaign, Illinois 61820 who knows English well. Reinken was on Coventry, England), where we visited the city committee in 1693 when the or- four important churches. The fi rst was 800.397.3103 • www.Buzardorgans.com gan was built by Arp Schnitger. Reinken the Marienkirche, where Ernst-Erich didn’t want this church’s organ to have a Stender, organist, was our host. This is
DECEMBER, 2007 25
Dec 07 pp. 24-26.indd 25 11/8/07 8:50:38 AM this fi rm celebrated its 200th anniversary last year. Still in the ownership of Mar- cussen’s descendants, it has been in this location in Aabendraa since 1829. Our tour was conducted by a Marcussen rela- tive. We concluded this day in Århus. Århus, Odense, and Copenhagen The fi rst stop the next morning was at the Århus Domkirke, the largest church in Denmark. Originally containing a Schnitger organ, the current instrument is a 1928 Frobenius, which has been placed behind the 1730 Kastens console and is the organ on which Gillian Weir recorded the complete works of Franck, Messiaen and Durufl é. Its 8′ Voix hu- maine is modeled after that in Ste. Clo- tilde in Paris (César Franck’s church). After lunch we left for Odense, the birth city of Hans Christian Andersen, and visited St. Canute’s Cathedral, lo- cated next to a beautiful city park. This cathedral contains three organs: the smallest and oldest is the Jens Gregersen instrument built c. 1843; the second old- est is the main organ built by Marcussen & Søn in 1965 and using the façade of Jerry Jelsema plays the Cavaillé- its 1756 predecessor; and the newest, in Coll organ in the Jesuskirken in the east end of the cathedral, was built Copenhagen by Carsten Lund in 1999. Then on to Copenhagen for a visit to the Church of & Søn dated 1888 set in a Jürgen Hin- the Holy Ghost with its 1986 Marcussen richsen angel façade dated 1790. From & Søn organ; the opulent Jesuskirken, 1864 to 1920 this part of Denmark had built by the Carlsberg brewing family been part of Germany, and during World and containing in front one of the last War II this church’s bells were removed Cavaillé-Coll organs (dated 1890) built to Hamburg to be melted down for mu- and, in the rear, a 1993–1994 Jensen & nitions manufacture, but were fortu- Thomsen instrument; and a city tour. nately rescued just at the end of the war before being melted. Danish churches Roskilde have ships suspended from the ceiling to On the penultimate day we visited as a symbol recalling that human life is the impressive Roskilde Cathedral con- sustained by God; the nave is called the taining a 1991 Marcussen & Søn three- church ship. The patron of this church manual, 33-rank organ. We were granted was the Duke of Augustinborg. special access to the upper gallery from From there we bussed to the Søn- which to view this magnifi cent edifi ce, The organ in the Dorothea Chapel at the royal Sønderborg Castle in Denmark. Note derborg Castle; however, when we ar- which is the burial place of many Danish the stop pulls hanging from the casework. rived the streets were blocked. We soon kings and queens and with its wonderful learned that this was for the security trompe l’oeil paintings of heroic exploits The Jakobikirche is where Hugo Dis- built in 1637 and based upon an anony- of the visiting Queen Margrethe, who on various side chapel walls. tler—who had a good sense of history and mous builder in 1515, was last restored had arrived in her royal yacht to visit From there we visited the environ- resisted romantic modifi cations to the by Brothers Hillebrand in 1978. With this coastal castle. However she left mentally friendly chapel organ, an 1882 great organ, built by Joachim Richborn this organ being 70% original, today one promptly at 2 pm, and we were granted A. H. Busch & Sønner rebuild at Ledre- in 1673 and last restored by Schuke/Ber- hears what would have been the sounds entrance to hear a recital on this recon- borg Castle. The resident organist (from lin in 1984—was the organist from 1931 of 1637 and of 1515. The Werckmeister structed Renaissance organ by its or- Tennessee!) gave a demonstration of this to 1937. This organ contains pipes from a temperament is tuned one step above ganist. Originally there was a 1570 Rot- unusual single-manual instrument to Blockwerk from the 1400s; Schuke added A=440. Distler had this organ in mind tenstein-Pock instrument, which was which the pedal is always coupled, which a Swell as part of his restoration in 1984. when he composed Nun komm, der enlarged to two manuals with nine and has not been electrifi ed and requires an This organ is approximately 20% original Heiden Heiland. fi ve stops, respectively, in 1626; each assistant to work the bellows. We re- and includes an 18th-century pedal divi- manual has a slightly different compass. turned to Copenhagen to give a public sion. Interestingly, there are two match- Ulkebøl, Sønderborg, and The present instrument is a 1996 Mads recital at St. Andreas Church. ing organ cases, north and west, both in Aabendraa Kjersgaard reconstruction set in the On Saturday, our last day together, swallow’s nest design. The main case is in The Ulkebøl Lutheran Church was original 1570 façade; D-sharp and E- many spent the day shopping and en- Renaissance style and the Positiv case is our fi rst stop in Denmark. Although fl at are separate pitches because of the joying the city, while others visited the in Baroque style. this church has housed an organ con- (probably) meantone tuning. Trinity Church with its three-manual, The Jacobikirche three-manual, 31- tinuously since the beginning of the 16th From there we were treated to a Mar- 53-rank, 1956 Marcussen & Søn organ register smaller organ by Stellwagen, century, its current organ is a Marcussen cussen factory tour. Founded in 1806, rebuilt by P. G. Andersen in 1977 and the Garnisonkirche. Our communal din- ner, at an historic local restaurant, was a bittersweet gathering, knowing that the camaraderie created by this tour’s partic- /44/ (%533 /2'!. 0!243 ipants was a unique organism and never to be duplicated. Unlike any other instrument, no two 4RADITION AND 0ROGRESS organs are the same and, to be fully un- derstood and appreciated, should be personally touched and experienced. &OR