Understanding Lead-Free Alloys by Karl Seelig

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Understanding Lead-Free Alloys by Karl Seelig Understanding Lead-Free Alloys By Karl Seelig One result of the push to find lead-free solder alternatives is that there are now many options available to the board assembler. Much development, patterning and research has gone into finding viable solutions for those who want to eliminate lead from their process. However, each of these alloys is different in significant ways and background information is necessary. January 1998 The Alternatives: Many of the new products are rich in tin with a variety of At first glance, the bismuth-bearing alloys appear to offer other elements added to enhance different high tensile strength, but in peel strength tests they are characteristics. The most basic solders are binary prone to failure due to poor fatigue resistance. The alloys that have been used for years in non-electronic same can be said for indium-based lead-free applications. Tin-lead has been a suitable standard alternatives. alloy for many years simply because it meets most of Tin/silver as a 96/4 alloy is fairly common and the requirements for electronics assembly. However, has a long history in the hybrid circuit industry. with the urgent need for controlled recycling and Unfortunately, with a spike temperature of 260°C, this reduction of hazardous waste related to finished alloy’s melting point is too high for many surface mount products, the greater use of lead-free solders has led to applications. the discovery of some of their noteworthy characteristics. For example, high joint strength, better Ternary tin/copper/silver alloys comprise a family fatigue resistance, improved high temperature life and of lead-free alternatives that show high promise. harder solder joints are among the features seen in Sources of supply are sufficient and the alloys exhibit some of the newer materials. Nevertheless, it is good wetting, fatigue resistance and good overall joint important to remember that these benefits are very strength. One form * is doped with antimony and much dependent on the specific alloy. Not all lead-frees exhibits an advantage: It does not grow intermetallics are created equally and each should be thoroughly with copper when soaked at 125°C (see chart). investigated before implementation into production. Antimony has been known to stop gray tin transformation at low temperatures and historically, the military required As a general rule, most lead-free solders melt at 0.2 to 0.5 percent antimony to enhance the thermal temperatures higher than those of tin-lead. The cycling properties of tin-lead alloys. exceptions are alloys containing indium or bismuth, which tend to lower the melting point. The main Ternary (with antimony) Alloy on Various Substrates “problem” with indium is its cost, with prices currently in Rate of Intermetallic Growth At 125º C the area of $150/lb. With approximately only 200 tons 10 of indium produced globally each year, the supply is 9 8 quite easily depleted and prone to drastic price 7 6 fluctuation. Typically, choosing an indium-based lead- 5 4 free alloy makes the most sense with temperature- 3 sensitive components that do not require high joint 2 Thickness (µm) 1 strength and where the end product will not be 0 50 100 150 200 250 subjected to harsh or high stress environments. Time (days) As for bismuth-based lead-free alloys, a lower Copper Brass Nickel Alloy42 melting temperature than that of tin-lead is offered together with a cost similar to that of tin (in the area of $3/lb.) Unfortunately, bismuth in soldering alloys tends However, the issue of the toxicity of antimony arises. As to create embrittlement, and if a bismuth-based alloy with most metals, salts, oxides and organo-metallic picks up any lead, the melting temperature will drop compounds of antimony are typically the most toxic again, causing joint embrittlement. forms of the element. 1 -2 Understanding Lead-Free Alloys They, however, do not form in standard soldering processes. Antimony has been approved for use in potable water systems as well as in food containers. In pewter tableware, which is commonly used in the preparation of food, antimony is often found at levels of 7 to 9 percent, and copper at levels of 1 to 3 percent. Further the antimony-doped alloy has been environmentally tested to confirm that it will not leach silver or copper into ground water. The accepted reason is that the two elements tied in the tin and antimony reduce their solubility. Lead-free solders are available in paste, bar and cored-wire form, although the latter’s manufacturability remains an issue for alloys that contain high levels of bismuth or indium, which tend to inhibit their drawing ability. Lead-free solders typically need higher soldering temperatures and successful implementation involves resolution of several critical issues. · The physical (thermal and mechanical) needs of the joint. · The temperature requirements of the components to be soldered. Most parts and board materials can take up to a 240°C spike, but some specialized exceptions remain. · The field environment (temperature, acceleration and shear) of the end product. · The phase-in period for a complete transition to a lead-free regime. (How long will tin-lead components and tin-coated PWB’s be used during the transition period?) · Repairs on in-field products. This may militate against using bismuth or indium-based lead-free alloys for assembly since lead significantly affects their melting points. With a great number of ongoing and completed studies on lead-free soldering alloys available to the end-user, there is a wealth of information entering the public domain. Preliminary results suggest that the tin/silver/copper-based alternatives offer superior long- term reliability and joint strength for most applications and that antimony as an additive brings good high Karl Seelig is V.P. of Technology at AIM in Cranston, RI temperature soak characteristics.¤ E-mail: [email protected] This article may also be found in the November ’97 issue *CASTIN of SMT 2 -2 Understanding Lead-Free Alloys.
Recommended publications
  • Critical Mineral - Antimony
    Critical Mineral - Antimony Listed as one of the 35 critical minerals by the U.S. Government, antimony strengthens metal in munitions, is used in batteries, solar panels, and wind turbines, and therefore plays an important role in our defense and energy industries. Today, China and Russia control the world’s supply of antimony, leaving the U.S. without a direct source of this mineral which is important to our national, economic, and environmental future. Perpetua Resources is developing the only commercially viable antimony mine in the U.S. to source supply for new battery and solar technologies, as well as alloys critical for national security products. CRITICAL TO THE GREEN ECONOMY Critical minerals are vital to national and economic security, as well as the future green economy. Domestic sourcing and production of all critical minerals has bi-partisan political support. Antimony is critical in the use of bearings for wind turbines, glass clarifcation for solar energy projects, and cable sheathing for wiring and as an important component in many electrical and solid state circuitry components. For defense, antimony use is critical in fame retardants, primers, and ammunition. Antimony has current and projected widespread use for the U.S. green energy sectors. Recent studies point to antimony playing a substantial role in the development of large-scale, safe, affordable battery storage technology. A limited supply of antimony and lack of advanced new antimony development projects are considered key risks to this technology moving forward. SUPPLY Currently, 92% antimony Based on the 2020 Feasibility Study the Stibnite Gold production is dominated by Project is expected to produce enough antimony to supply approximately 30% of U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Atomic Order in Non-Equilibrium Silicon-Germanium-Tin Semiconductors
    Atomic Order in Non-Equilibrium Silicon-Germanium-Tin Semiconductors S. Mukherjee1, N. Kodali1, D. Isheim2, S. Wirths3, J. M. Hartmann4, D. Buca3, D. N. Seidman2, and O. Moutanabbir1,* 1 Department of Engineering Physics, École Polytechnique de Montréal, Montréal, C. P. 6079, Succ. Centre-Ville, Montréal, Québec H3C 3A7, Canada. 2 Department of Materials Science and Engineering and Northwestern University Center for Atom-Probe Tomography, Northwestern University, Evanston, IL 60208-3108, USA. 3 Peter Grünberg Institute 9 and JARA - FIT, Forschungszentrum Juelich, Juelich 52425, Germany. 4 CEA, LETI, Minatec Campus, 17 rue des Martyrs, Grenoble 38054, France. The precise knowledge of the atomic order in monocrystalline alloys is fundamental to understand and predict their physical properties. With this perspective, we utilized laser-assisted atom probe tomography to investigate the three-dimensional distribution of atoms in non-equilibrium epitaxial Sn-rich group IV SiGeSn ternary semiconductors. Different atom probe statistical analysis tools including frequency distribution analysis, partial radial distribution functions, and nearest neighbor analysis were employed in order to evaluate and compare the behavior of the three elements to their spatial distributions in an ideal solid solution. This atomistic-level analysis provided clear evidence of an unexpected repulsive interaction between Sn and Si leading to the deviation of Si atoms from the theoretical random distribution. This departure from an ideal solid solution is supported by first principal calculations and attributed to the tendency of the system to reduce its mixing enthalpy throughout the layer-by-layer growth process. PACS: 68.35 bd, 38.35 bg, 34.20 Gj, 68.35 Dv 1 The assumption that the arrangement of atoms within the crystal lattice is perfectly random is a broadly used approximation to establish the physical properties of semiconductor alloys.
    [Show full text]
  • Growth and Characterization of Silicon-Germanium-Tin Semiconductors for Future Nanophotonics Devices" (2018)
    University of Arkansas, Fayetteville ScholarWorks@UARK Theses and Dissertations 12-2018 Growth and Characterization of Silicon- Germanium-Tin Semiconductors for Future Nanophotonics Devices Bader Saad Alharthi University of Arkansas, Fayetteville Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.uark.edu/etd Part of the Electromagnetics and Photonics Commons, and the Semiconductor and Optical Materials Commons Recommended Citation Alharthi, Bader Saad, "Growth and Characterization of Silicon-Germanium-Tin Semiconductors for Future Nanophotonics Devices" (2018). Theses and Dissertations. 3012. https://scholarworks.uark.edu/etd/3012 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by ScholarWorks@UARK. It has been accepted for inclusion in Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of ScholarWorks@UARK. For more information, please contact [email protected], [email protected]. Growth and Characterization of Silicon-Germanium-Tin Semiconductors for Future Nanophotonics Devices A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Engineering with a concentration in Electrical Engineering by Bader Saad Alharthi King Saud University Bachelor of Science in Physics, 2003 King Fahd University of Petroleum and Minerals Master of Science in Physics, 2009 University of Arkansas Master of Science in Electrical Engineering, 2018 December 2018 University of Arkansas This dissertation is approved for recommendation to the Graduate Council. Hameed A. Naseem, Ph.D. Shui-Qing (Fisher) Yu, Ph.D. Dissertation Director Dissertation Co-Director Simon Ang, Ph.D. Zhong Chen, Ph.D. Committee Member Committee Member Hugh Churchill, Ph.D. Committee Member Abstract The bright future of silicon (Si) photonics has attracted research interest worldwide. The ultimate goal of this growing field is to develop a group IV based Si foundries that integrate Si-photonics with the current complementary metal–oxide–semiconductor (CMOS) on a single chip for mid- infrared optoelectronics and high speed devices.
    [Show full text]
  • FS Heavy Metals and Metalloids Final
    DETOX Program Fact Sheet – Heavy Metals and Metalloids DETOX Program Hazardous Substances Fact Sheet Heavy Metals and Metalloids 1 DETOX Program Fact Sheet – Heavy Metals and Metalloids Content 1 Background .................................................................................................................... 3 2 Definition ........................................................................................................................ 3 3 Legal Aspects ................................................................................................................. 4 4 Hazardous Properties and Exposure .............................................................................. 4 4.1 Hazardous Properties .............................................................................................. 4 4.2 Exposure ................................................................................................................. 5 5 Sources for Heavy Metals and Metalloids in production of textiles .................................. 6 6 Alternative and Substitute Substances ........................................................................... 7 2 DETOX Program Fact Sheet – Heavy Metals and Metalloids 1 Background Heavy metals and metalloids are constituents of specific dyes and pigments, tanning chemicals for leather, catalysts in fiber production, printing pastes, as part of flame retardants and many more. They can also be found in natural fibers due to absorption by plants through soil or from fertilizers. Metals
    [Show full text]
  • Tin/Lead Reflow Profile Supplement
    TIN/LEAD ALLOYS REFLOW PROFILE GUIDELINES The information provided is a guideline only. Your profile will depend upon many factors including customer requirements, component limitations, oven characteristics, board layout, etc. Ultimately, quality requirements should drive the process, not adherence to these guidelines. Ideally, profile measurements are to be collected on a populated assembly with the reflow profile recorded for each product being processed. It is common for the same profile settings to be used for multiple assemblies. Reflow profile data should be collected, analyzed and recorded for each assembly part number at the beginning of individual production runs. There are two basic profile types: Ramp-Soak-Spike (RSS) and Ramp-To-Spike (RTS). RTS profiles are suitable for use in most applications for enhanced solder performance. RSS profiles are appropriate when the assembly has a large thermal mass or large ∆T. Typical RTS Profile Typical RSS Profile Profile Length: 3-4.5 minutes from Profile Length: 3-4.5 minutes from 40°C to peak 205-235°C 40°C to peak 205-235°C Ramp Rate: 1-3°C per second Soak: 130-180°C for 30-90 seconds Time Above Liquidus: 30-90 seconds Ramp Rate: 1-3°C per second Cool Down Rate: < 4°C per second Time Above Liquidus: 30-90 seconds Cool Down Rate: < 4°C per second Wetting Improvement Wetting issues, whether component (lead-free) or substrate related can be improved through profiling. If the wetting issue is global, it can often be improved with proper profiling technique. If the wetting issue is component specific, it is likely a plating issue with the component/substrate.
    [Show full text]
  • Interrelation Between Gold And
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Springer - Publisher Connector Interrelation Introduction The occurrence of tin in certain historical gold objects has Between Gold been reported in the literature. Also, there is available a historical literary reference of Indian origin which mentions the occurrence of gold in tin mini-ingots. It is most unlikely and Tin: that either gold in tin or tin in gold were added intentionally in antiquity. It appears that they were present in each other naturally. In the present paper the archaeological and literary A Historical evidence related to gold objects containing tin, and tin mini–ingots containing gold have been reviewed. The Perspective reasons for the natural presence of tin and gold in each other have been discussed. The word “historical” has been used in a wider sense in this paper. RK Dube Department of Materials and Metallurgical The Occurrence of Tin in Gold Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology, There are several references discussing gold objects and Kanpur-208016, India pieces found from archaeological excavations, which inform us about the presence of tin in historical gold objects. The chemical analysis, based on emission spectroscopy, of about Abstract 3300 European gold artifacts dating from the Bronze Age to The historical evidence for the occurrence of some tin the beginning of the Christian era indicates that these in gold objects and some gold in tin mini-ingots from contain tin, and in some cases platinum too1. Gold objects various parts of the world has been discussed. It has belonging to the close of the Bronze Age in Central Europe, been shown that their presence in each other is not i.e.
    [Show full text]
  • Zinc-Nickel Zinc-Iron Tin-Zinc Zinc Alloy Finishes
    Modern Plating is a Publication No. Modern Plating Corporation MPC 5-11-06 certified ZinKlad 500 zinc-iron & ZinKlad 1000 zinc-nickel Zinc Alloy Finishes applicator! Zinc-Nickel ●● Zinc-Iron ●● Tin-Zinc Modern Plating specializes in the application of high performance zinc-alloy finishes. These alloy finishes provide superior corrosion protection and offer an environmentally friendly alternative to cadmium due to the toxicity of cadmium and the cyanide used in the cadmium plating process. The demand for higher quality, longer lasting, more corrosion resistant coatings in industries such as automotive and electrical components has driven the devel- opment of these finishes. Modern currently offers all of the alloy finishes with either a clear and/or a black trivalent finish. Hexavalent chromates are being eliminated by the automotive industry due to the carcinogenic nature of Chrome VI and are being replaced by trivalent chromates. ZinKlad 1000 Zinc-Nickel— Zinc-nickel offers the greatest corrosion resistance of all the alloy finishes. It is often used as a substitute for cadmium although it Zinc-Nickel does not offer the lubricity of cadmium nor its cosmetic appearance. It does offer high resistance to heat and UV light and does not promote galvanic corrosion when in contact with aluminum. It is considered a hard finish with good resistance to abrasion. Zinc-Iron— Zinc-iron offers good weldability and ductility making it a good choice for components that will undergo subsequent manufacturing operations. It is often used on parts that are to be painted. It is the least ZinKlad 500 expensive. Zinc-iron clear offers a good cosmetic appearance.
    [Show full text]
  • Mercury and Mercury Compounds
    United States Office of Air Quality EPA-454/R-97-012 Environmental Protection Planning And Standards Agency Research Triangle Park, NC 27711 December 1997 AIR EPA LOCATING AND ESTIMATING AIR EMISSIONS FROM SOURCES OF MERCURY AND MERCURY COMPOUNDS L & E EPA-454/R-97-012 Locating And Estimating Air Emissions From Sources of Mercury and Mercury Compounds Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards Office of Air and Radiation U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Research Triangle Park, NC 27711 December 1997 This report has been reviewed by the Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, and has been approved for publication. Mention of trade names and commercial products does not constitute endorsement or recommendation for use. EPA-454/R-97-012 TABLE OF CONTENTS Section Page EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ................................................ xi 1.0 PURPOSE OF DOCUMENT .............................................. 1-1 2.0 OVERVIEW OF DOCUMENT CONTENTS ................................. 2-1 3.0 BACKGROUND ........................................................ 3-1 3.1 NATURE OF THE POLLUTANT ..................................... 3-1 3.2 OVERVIEW OF PRODUCTION, USE, AND EMISSIONS ................. 3-1 3.2.1 Production .................................................. 3-1 3.2.2 End-Use .................................................... 3-3 3.2.3 Emissions ................................................... 3-6 4.0 EMISSIONS FROM MERCURY PRODUCTION ............................. 4-1 4.1 PRIMARY MERCURY
    [Show full text]
  • Urine Toxic Metals
    URINE TOXIC METALS LAB#: U000000-0000-0 CLIENT#: 12345 PATIENT: Sample Patient DOCTOR: SEX: Female Doctor's Data, Inc. AGE: 48 3755 Illinois Ave. St. Charles, IL 60174 POTENTIALLY TOXIC METALS RESULT REFERENCE WITHIN VERY METALS µµµg/g CREAT RANGE REFERENCE RANGE ELEVATED ELEVATED Aluminum < dl < 35 Antimony < dl < 5 Arsenic 89 < 100 Beryllium < dl < 0.5 Bismuth < dl < 30 Cadmium 0.5 < 2 Lead 0.9 < 15 Mercury 21 < 3 Nickel < dl < 12 Platinum < dl < 2 Thallium 0.4 < 14 Thorium < dl < 12 Tin 11 < 6 Tungsten 0.7 < 23 Uranium 0.1 < 1 CREATININE RESULT REFERENCE mg/dL RANGE 2SD LOW 1SD LOW MEAN 1SD HIGH 2SD HIGH Creatinine 22 60- 160 SPECIMEN DATA Comments: Date Collected: 9/20/2002 Method: ICP-MS Collection Period: timed Date Received: 9/25/2002 <dl: less than detection limit Volume: 3675 ml Date Completed: 9/26/2002 Provoking Agent: DMPS Provocation: POST PROVOCATIVE Toxic metals are reported as µg/g creatinine to account for urine dilution variations. Reference ranges are representative of a healthy population under non-challenge or non-provoked conditions. No safe reference levels for toxic metals have been established. V10.00 ©2000-02 DOCTOR’S DATA, INC. yyy ADDRESS: 3755 Illinois Avenue, St. Charles, IL 60174-2420 yyy CLIA ID NO: 14D0646470 yyy MEDICARE PROVIDER NO: 148453 TOLL FREE: 800.323.2784 yyy TEL: 630.377.8139 yyy FAX: 630.587.7860 yyy EMAIL: [email protected] yyy WEBSITE: WWW.doctorsdata.com Reproduced with permission of Doctor’s Data, Inc. Lab number: U000000-0000-0 Urine Toxics Page: 1 Patient: Sample Patient Client: 12345 INTRODUCTION This analysis of urine elements was performed by ICP-Mass Spectroscopy following acid digestion of the specimen.
    [Show full text]
  • Periodic Table of the Elements Notes
    Periodic Table of the Elements Notes Arrangement of the known elements based on atomic number and chemical and physical properties. Divided into three basic categories: Metals (left side of the table) Nonmetals (right side of the table) Metalloids (touching the zig zag line) Basic Organization by: Atomic structure Atomic number Chemical and Physical Properties Uses of the Periodic Table Useful in predicting: chemical behavior of the elements trends properties of the elements Atomic Structure Review: Atoms are made of protons, electrons, and neutrons. Elements are atoms of only one type. Elements are identified by the atomic number (# of protons in nucleus). Energy Levels Review: Electrons are arranged in a region around the nucleus called an electron cloud. Energy levels are located within the cloud. At least 1 energy level and as many as 7 energy levels exist in atoms Energy Levels & Valence Electrons Energy levels hold a specific amount of electrons: 1st level = up to 2 2nd level = up to 8 3rd level = up to 8 (first 18 elements only) The electrons in the outermost level are called valence electrons. Determine reactivity - how elements will react with others to form compounds Outermost level does not usually fill completely with electrons Using the Table to Identify Valence Electrons Elements are grouped into vertical columns because they have similar properties. These are called groups or families. Groups are numbered 1-18. Group numbers can help you determine the number of valence electrons: Group 1 has 1 valence electron. Group 2 has 2 valence electrons. Groups 3–12 are transition metals and have 1 or 2 valence electrons.
    [Show full text]
  • Stannides and Intermetallic Tin Compounds – Fundamentals and Applications
    Stannides and Intermetallic Tin Compounds – Fundamentals and Applications Rainer P¨ottgen Institut f¨ur Anorganische und Analytische Chemie, Westf¨alische Wilhelms-Universit¨at M¨unster, Corrensstraße 30, D-48149 M¨unster, Germany Reprint requests to R. P¨ottgen. E-mail: [email protected] Z. Naturforsch. 61b, 677 – 698 (2006); received January 19, 2006 Dedicated to Professor Wolfgang Jeitschko on the occasion of his 70th birthday Tin, tin alloys and intermetallic tin compounds play a key role in many technologies and high-tech applications. Many of these intermetallics find application in daily life such as pewterware, bronzes, solders, fusible alloys, superconductors, capsules for wine bottles or tinplate packaging. Many of the applications are directly related to distinct stannides or intermetallic tin compounds. The crystal chemistry and chemical bonding of these materials as well as their applications are briefly reviewed. Key words: Tin, Stannides, Intermetallics Introduction Elemental tin is a fascinating element which has two modifications under ambient pressure conditions. At 13.2 ◦C the tetragonal metallic β-modification (space 3 group I41/amd, ρ = 7.285 g/cm ) transforms to the semi-metallic α-modification with the cubic diamond structure (space group Fd3¯m, ρ = 5.769 g/cm3) [1, 2]. This phase transition proceeds via a translationen- gleiche symmetry reduction [3] and usually proceeds slowly. However, if small nuclei of the α-modification have formed, the transformation proceeds rather fast and destroys the metallic workpiece (tin pest). The two modifications have different near-neighbor coordina- tion. In α-Sn each tin atom has a tetrahedral coordi- nation at a Sn–Sn distance of 281 pm, while the coor- dination number in β-Sn is increased to 4 × 302 + 2 × Fig.
    [Show full text]
  • 60/40 Tin Lead Solder
    TECHNICAL INFORMATION SHEET 60/40 TIN LEAD SOLDER NOMINAL CHEMICAL COMPOSITION%: SPECIFICATION COMPLIANCE: Lead Remainder ASTM B32 Alloy Grade Sn 60 Tin 59.5-61.5 J-STD-006 Sn60Pb40Sb0.4 Antimony 0.20 – 0.50 SAFETY INFORMATION: TYPICAL PHYSICAL PROPERTIES: WARNING: PROTECT yourself and others. Read and understand this Solidus 361ºF (183°C) information. Liquidus 374°F (190°C) FUMES AND GASES can be hazardous to your health. HEAT RAYS, (infrared radiation) from flame or hot metal can injure eyes. SOLDERING PROPERTIES: Before use, read and understand the manufacturer’s instructions, Safety Data Sheets (SDS), and your employer's With some exceptions, the tin lead solders can be used to safety practices. solder copper and most copper alloys, lead, nickel alloys, and Keep your head out of fumes. steel. 60/40 solder is frequently used for electronic or electrical Use enough ventilation, exhaust at the flame, or heat applications. The narrow melting range makes it suitable for dip source, to keep fumes and gases from your breathing zone soldering baths. and the general area. Wear correct eye, ear, and body protection. Tin lead solders are not recommended in high stress or vibration See American National Standard Z49.1, Safety in Welding, joints in the cooling industry due to lack of sufficient elongation Cutting, and Allied Processes, published by the American properties. Heat sources include soldering guns, irons, and air- Welding Society, 8669 Doral Blvd., Doral, Florida 33166; fuel torches. OSHA Safety and Health Standards, available from the U.S. Government Office, Washington, DC 20402. Lead bearing solders are not to be used for potable water STATEMENT OF LIABILITY- DISCLAIMER: plumbing connections.
    [Show full text]