Durham E-Theses
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Durham E-Theses Iran, Persian Gulf and Relations with the United States: The Myth of Hegemony (1968-75) RIAZ, ADNAN,SHEIKH How to cite: RIAZ, ADNAN,SHEIKH (2014) Iran, Persian Gulf and Relations with the United States: The Myth of Hegemony (1968-75) , Durham theses, Durham University. Available at Durham E-Theses Online: http://etheses.dur.ac.uk/9510/ Use policy The full-text may be used and/or reproduced, and given to third parties in any format or medium, without prior permission or charge, for personal research or study, educational, or not-for-prot purposes provided that: • a full bibliographic reference is made to the original source • a link is made to the metadata record in Durham E-Theses • the full-text is not changed in any way The full-text must not be sold in any format or medium without the formal permission of the copyright holders. Please consult the full Durham E-Theses policy for further details. Academic Support Oce, Durham University, University Oce, Old Elvet, Durham DH1 3HP e-mail: [email protected] Tel: +44 0191 334 6107 http://etheses.dur.ac.uk 2 Iran, Persian Gulf and Relations with the United States: The Myth of Hegemony (1968-75) Submitted by Mr. Adnan Riaz Sheikh (Doctoral Candidate) School of Government and International Affairs and The Institute for Middle Eastern and Islamic Studies, Ustinov College, University of Durham. Page 1 of 450 Declaration “This thesis is the result of my own work. Material from the published or unpublished work of others which is used in the thesis is credited to the author in question in the text.” ………………………………………………………….Mr. Adnan Riaz Sheikh, SGIA-IMEIS, University of Durham. 31st May 2011 Page 2 of 450 Table of Contents IRAN, PERSIAN GULF AND RELATIONS WITH THE UNITED STATES: THE MYTH OF HEGEMONY (1968-75) ............................................................................................... 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS ................................................................................................................... 3 ABSTRACT .......................................................................................................................................... 8 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ...................................................................................................................... 9 INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................................... 10 Project Background: Discourse anomalies of Iran’s diplomatic posture towards of the Gulf and western Asian security, academic prejudices and possibilities for neo-revisionism................................................... 10 Core research questions and Auxiliary assumptions ....................................................................................... 13 Research Issues, preliminaries and project perimeters ................................................................................ 18 Central Aims of Research.............................................................................................................................. 27 Methodology, Case studies and Data analysis ................................................................................................ 31 Project Outline .............................................................................................................................................. 32 Chapter 1: Theoretical Framework .................................................................................................................... 32 Chapter 2: .......................................................................................................................................................... 35 The Persian Gulf-Arabian Peninsula axis (1956-75): External threats, regional hegemony and the politics of security, resources and ideology ....................................................................................................................... 35 Empirical Chapters 3-9: ...................................................................................................................................... 37 American interests in the Indian Ocean (1968-75): The Iran-Saudi strategic competition under the Soviet- radical Arab threat and the politics of arms, islands and oil trade .................................................................... 37 CHAPTER 1: ....................................................................................................................................... 41 Theoretical Framework ................................................................................................................................... 41 1.1. Introduction ................................................................................................................................................ 41 1.2. Preliminary Hypothesis ............................................................................................................................... 43 1.3. The Melian Fallacy: Morality, alliance or self-help in International relations? ......................................... 44 1.4. Neo-realism: Systemic influences, the structure and the paradox of the (Three) ‘Statist’ interests .......... 46 1.4.1: Balance of Power: Counter-coalitions, band-wagonning and cooperation ............................................. 48 1.4.2. Systemic Shifts: Bipolar systemic “stability”, rise of contenders and allies ............................................. 51 1.4.3. Systemic Transformation: Structural change and rise of revisionist state .............................................. 53 1.4.4. Regional hegemony, deterrence and power ........................................................................................... 56 Page 3 of 450 1.4.5. Defensive Realism: State expansionism, restraint and ‘structural modifiers’ ......................................... 58 1.5. International System and the Regional Security Complexes: A ‘sectoral’ analytical approach .................. 62 1.5.2. RSCs: ‘Autonomous, Overlaid, Penetrated and non-Security’ ................................................................ 69 1.5.3. Conclusion ............................................................................................................................................... 72 1.6. Security Communities: Shared interests, non-security and structure-agency transformation .................. 73 1.6.2. ‘Values are what actors make of’: the politics of security, identity and development of norms ............ 77 1.6.3. Power and Community: the realist contribution ...................................................................................... 79 1.6.4. Security Communal phases: ‘Nascent, Ascendant, Mature and Disintegrating’ ...................................... 81 1.7. Conclusion ............................................................................................................................................... 84 CHAPTER 2: ....................................................................................................................................... 88 THE PERSIAN GULF AND EXTERNAL POWERS, NATIONALISM, HEGEMONY AND SECURITY COMMUNITY: A NEO-HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE (1956-75) ..................... 88 2.1. The Strategic context of Soviet and regional powers’ interests in the Middle East: .................................. 89 2.1.1. Some geopolitical generalizations and region-specific Soviet interests .................................................. 89 2.2.2. The Soviet-Conservative Epoch 1962-80: The strategic Space between the two Détentes: ................... 94 2.1.2. Soviet interests in the Mediterranean and engagements with Turkey, Egypt and Syria (1956-70) ........ 97 2.1.3. Power Transition in the Middle East and new sub-security systems (1967-72) .................................... 101 2.1.4. The case for Soviet “intervention” in the Persian Gulf (1968-79) ......................................................... 105 2.1.5. The reality of Soviet-Iraqi collaboration and the Communist-Kurdish link (1958-75) ......................... 110 2.2. The political economy of islands, ideology and security: Intra- Gulf pre-emptions and collaborations ......................................................................................................................................................................114 2.2.1. Introduction ........................................................................................................................................... 114 2.2.2. The Upper Persian Gulf islands: politics of resources, nationalism and the legacy of modern Irano-Arab rivalry (1950-75) .............................................................................................................................................. 117 2.2.3. Territorial rivalries in the lower Gulf (1968-74): politics of resources or pretentious Nationalism? ..... 128 2.2.4. Bahrain: Resources, Hegemony and the “pride complex”? ................................................................... 133 2.2.5. Conclusion ............................................................................................................................................. 137 2.3. ‘Independent Nationalism’ in the post-1956 phase: Cooperative Security, the British- Egyptian threat to Gulf and security discourses ..........................................................................................................................140