Journal of Field Ecology 2009
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Journal of Field Ecology 2009 FOREST DYNAMICS Species-independent, Scale-invariant self-similarity in the Daniel Poon 7 allometry of branches and trunks within a heterogeneous forest Disturbance and fire refugia: deviations from invariant scaling Jane Remfert 14 relations across plant communities Looking for a DBH power function in Cassandra Bog Woods Elizabeth Hood 20 Testing for self thinning in oaks and comparing results in the Melissa Brady 25 presence of Gayluccacia Biases in spatial sampling for size frequency distributions Theresa Ong 31 Neutral theory and the predictions of the species distribution of an Melissa Brady 43 edge habitat Seedling establishment over a disturbance gradient exposes a Daniel Poon 47 species dominance shift within an oak-hickory forest SPATIAL PATTERN FORMATION Examining ant mosaic in the Big Woods of the E.S. George Hyunmin Han 55 Reserve Adventures in self-organization: spatial distribution of Japanese Amanda Grimm 63 Barberry in the E.S. George Reserve Distribution of Sarracenia purpurea clusters in Hidden Lake Hyunmin Han 68 Bog of the E.S. George Reserve BOTANY A survey of host-liana relationships in a Michigan oak-hickory Jane Remfert 74 forest: specificity and overwhelmedness Vine distribution and colonization preferences in the Big Woods Alexa Unruh 81 Examining the relationship between growth and reproduction in Megan Banka 88 perennial forbs Ramets and rhizomes: trade-offs in clonal plants in relation to Elizabeth Hood 96 water availability Hybridization among Quercus veluntina and Quercus rubra is Semoya Phillips 100 evident but a pattern of organization is not COMMUNITY COMPOSITION The halo of life: patterns in ant species richness in a Michigan Leslie McGinnis 105 scrubland The effect of an environmental gradient on species abundance in Jane Skillman 111 Cassandra Bog Stands of Typha sp. Support a different composition of benthic Semoya Phillips 117 macroinvertebrates than other types of vegetation in experimental ponds at E.S. George Reserve Distribution and abundance of organisms inhabiting pitcher plant Evan Childress 122 inquilines HABITAT SELECTION Nesting preferences in Elaeagnus umbellate Jane Skillman 130 Colony size in Formica obscuripes as an indicator of habitat John Berini 136 stability: a positive feedback loop favoring the occupation of stable habitat types by large colonies Habitat preference by Peromyscus leucopus in the E.S. George Alexa Unruh 144 Reserve Exogenous factors influencing chipmunk (Tamias striatus) Evan Childress 150 burrow distribution OAK HERBIVORY AND PARASITISM The leaf-miner paradox: a tradeoff between parental preferences Theresa Ong 157 and larval success Distribution patterns of the Cynipid gall-maker Amphibolips Colin Donihue 166 cooki on oak seedlings in three habitats Dispersal patterns and leaf-preference of the Cynipid gall-maker Colin Donihue 172 Amphibolips cooki on oak seedling in three habitats Untangling the oak-gall system: plant stress influences the Daniel Katz 179 impacts of Cynipid wasps on oaks A preliminary study of chemical-mediated plant-herbivory Hsun-Yi Hsieh 186 interaction in E.S. George reserve: interactions between huckleberry, leafminers and oaks Insect herbivory prevalence and type on white oak and red/black Aaron Iverson 192 oak tress and saplings in the E.S. George Reserve PARASITISM AND DISEASE A test for Janzen-Connell effect: relationship between proportion Yi Hou 201 of Hamamelis virginiana seeds inviable or parasitized and clump area Is one really the loneliest number? Can density and distances Hsun-Yi Hsieh 209 from clump center be proxies of severities of studied American Elm and Red Maple diseases? Dogwood anthracnose in the E.S. George reserve: the rise of Elizabeth Hood 221 Discula destructive Prediction of Discula distructive severity in distinct Cornus Hyunmin Han 227 florida patches Patterns and effects of Sitochroa palealis herbivory on Daucus Serge Fariñas 234 carota in early stage invasion The temporal evasion of intense Sitochroa palealis herbivory by Serge Fariñas 243 late blooming Daucus carota APPLIED ECOLOGY Using Macroinvertebrates to test the effects of dam removal on Mairin Balisi 250 water quality Re-evaluation of dam removal: using benthic macroinvertebrates Mairin Balisi 254 to assess stream recovery Use of the fractal dimension of leaf area for leaf identification Daniel Katz 261 Forest biomass estimates for three different land cover types on John Berini 266 the Edwin S. George Reserve, Livingston County, Michigan Human-mediated seed dispersal in two landscapes and their Megan Banka 271 adjacent roads INVASION ECOLOGY Tetramorium: is the invasion complete? Melissa Brady 279 Infestation of biological control agents in response to the spatial Aaron Iverson 284 distribution and height of plant host Centaurea maculosa A method to predict zebra mussel (Dreissena polymorpha) body Yi Hou 292 length from shell fragment: the relationship between body length and umbonal length The alien advantage: use of novel weapons by Centaurea stoebe, Amanda Grimm 300 an invasive forb OTHER TOPICS Differential fruit preferences of ground foragers for native and Theresa Ong 305 non-native plants Distribution and behavior of two species of aphid-tending ants Leslie McGinnis 314 A comparison of litter decomposition rates near trees associated Jane Skillman 320 with ecto-mycorrhizal fungi and non-ecto-mycorrhizal fungi FOREST DYNAMICS Species-independent, Scale-invariant self-similarity in the Daniel Poon 7 allometry of branches and trunks within a heterogeneous forest Disturbance and fire refugia: deviations from invariant scaling Jane Remfert 14 relations across plant communities Looking for a DBH power function in Cassandra Bog Woods Elizabeth Hood 20 Testing for self thinning in oaks and comparing results in the Melissa Brady 25 presence of Gayluccacia Biases in spatial sampling for size frequency distributions Theresa Ong 31 Neutral theory and the predictions of the species distribution of Melissa Brady 43 an edge habitat Seedling establishment over a disturbance gradient exposes a Daniel Poon 47 species dominance shift within an oak-hickory forest SPECIES-INDEPENDENT, SCALE-INVARIANT SELF-SIMILARITY IN THE ALLOMETRY OF BRANCHES AND TRUNKS WITHIN A HETEROGENEOUS FOREST DANIEL POON, ALEXA UNRUH, AARON IVERSON, ELIZABETH HOOD, KELVIN HAN, JES SKILLMAN, KARINA LANERI, JOHN BERINI, & JOHN VANDERMEER ABSTRACT We investigated patterns of self-similarity within a Michigan oak-hickory forest undergoing succession. Branch circumference distribution across all trees in the forest were found to follow a power law with exponent approximately equal to the exponent for the power law distribution of DBH across the whole forest, both ~ -2.5. Within each species the branch circumference distribution exponents all differ significantly from the distribution of DBH of that species within the forest, corresponding more closely instead to the distribution of DBH of all species within the forest taken together. The correspondence between the exponents of species-specific branch power laws and the whole-forest DBH power law was species-independent among the understory trees, suggesting the existence of species-independent growth regulation sensitive to forest-wide architecture. INTRODUCTION Any natural distribution network will follow a power law. (West et al. 1999) This tendency is exhibited by vascular systems, bronchial tubes, and tree branches. West et al. (2009) introduced the idea that a forest can be viewed as a vascular system. As a whole, the entire forest behaves like a scaled version of the largest tree. As a vascular system, each tree removes energy and resources from the ecosystem at a fairly uniform rate across the community. The growth of individuals in the system of a given size must be equal to the mortality of individuals of the same size class. However, these models assume that the populations in the system are demographically stable. In systems that are not stable, a power law should not be observed because populations are changing. In these systems, individuals in the largest size classes would be dying at a higher rate than those in the smaller classes. Kéfi et al. (2007) demonstrate that an ecosystem undergoing a change of dominance will deviate from a power law. Therefore, any deviation of the distribution of the sizes of trees from a power law should indicate a change in the dominant species populations of that ecosystem. Enquist and Niklas (2000) found that the number of individuals in a forest plot scales as the -2 power of basal stem diameter, independent of species composition or latitude, and developed a metabolic simulation model that reproduced the effect of this power law. The same authors (1999) found that a single set of power laws relating the allometry of biomass, body size, and growth rate held for photosynthetic organisms across twenty orders of magnitude from unicellular algae to woody dicots. The question therefore arises: down to what size scale does power-law scale-invariance hold within an organism? In particular, does the forest-wide growth pattern inform the growth behavior of a single tree? If one can expect that trunks should show a 7 power law irrespective of the tree species because each trunk is but a single element in a forest- wide vascular system, then one would also expect the same phenomenon to be found in branches, irrespective of the tree species from which the branches come, as branches too are single vascular elements. Indeed, one might expect to see a power law exhibited by the distribution of the sizes of tree individuals in a forest for many reasons. Because the branches, trunks, and roots of trees are all interconnected bifurcating systems, they transport their fluids using the same physical methods. By competing to fill open spaces with the best nutrient and water availability for each individual, individuals will grow at every size scale. Yet there are also many reasons why one might not expect the branch diameter distributions of all the individual tree species in the forest to exhibit the same power law exponent. Different types of trees will allocate different amounts of biomass and resources to their leaves. Root-to- shoot ratios for different species vary.