Alcock & Williams
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
ALCOCK & WILLIAMS, LLC 224 Buena Vista Avenue, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48103 • Telephone 734-747-7400 Real Estate Appraisal of: The Former YMCA Site at 350 South Fifth Avenue Tax Code 09-09-29-404-001 Ann Arbor, Michigan Prepared for: Matthew R. Rechtien, P.E. Senior Assistant City Attorney City of Ann Arbor 301 East Huron Street Ann Arbor, Michigan 48104 Prepared on: April 17, 2018 Valuation on: April 3, 2018 ALCOCK & WILLIAMS, LLC Real Estate Appraisal Services Jay T. Alcock Kirsten Williams Member Member Matthew R. Rechtien, P.E. April 17, 2018 Senior Assistant City Attorney City of Ann Arbor 301 East Huron Street Ann Arbor, Michigan 48104 Re: Appraisal of the Former YMCA Site at 350 South Fifth Avenue, Ann Arbor, Michigan; Tax Code 09-09-29-404-001 Dear Mr. Rechtien: The City of Ann Arbor has contracted Alcock & Williams, LLC, to appraise the referenced property. The purpose of this appraisal is to estimate the market value of the fee simple title to the appraisal property as of a current valuation date in ‘as is’ condition. This appraisal is classified as an Appraisal Report under 2018-19 USPAP. This valuation is subject to the conditions and limitations stated in this report. Further, this valuation is intended to conform to the requirements of the Code of Professional Ethics and Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice of the Appraisal Foundation. This appraisal must be read in its entirety to understand the market value conclusion. It is our opinion that the market value of the subject in ‘as is’ condition as of April 3, 2018, is Eleven Million ($11,000,000) Dollars Hypothetical Condition: Any and all deed restrictions, covenants, options, and time limitations as they relate to the development and use of the subject property between the City of Ann Arbor and Fifth Fourth, LLC, are removed. In other words, the subject property is transferable with a free and clear title and the ‘by-right’ development density and uses as only defined by the D1, Core District, as of the date of valuation. For a complete disclosure, refer to the Assumptions and Limiting Conditions set forth in the eponymously titled section of the report. The attached report is an explanation of the methods of valuation. Respectfully submitted, Alcock & Williams, L.L.C. Jay T. Alcock, Member Michigan Certified General Appraiser 224 Buena Vista Ave., Ann Arbor, MI 48103 ◦ Phone 734‐747‐7400 email: [email protected] ◦ web: alcockwilliams.com TABLE OF CONTENTS TRANSMITTAL LETTER...............................................................................................................................i TABLE OF CONTENTS.................................................................................................................................iii EXECUTIVE SUMMARY .......................................................................................................................... 1 PHOTOGRAPHS OF SUBJECT AND SURROUNDING AREA ........................................................... 3 IDENTIFICATION OF PROPERTY ....................................................................................................... 10 SCOPE OF WORK AND CORE DEFINITIONS ................................................................................... 12 FEE SIMPLE TITLE .................................................................................................................................... 13 MARKET VALUE ....................................................................................................................................... 14 FLOOR-AREA RATIO (FAR) ..................................................................................................................... 14 PROPERTY ANALYSIS ........................................................................................................................... 16 AREA ANALYSIS .................................................................................................................................. 16 WASHTENAW COUNTY PROFILE ................................................................................................ 17 CITY OF ANN ARBOR PROFILE .................................................................................................... 35 NEIGHBORHOOD PROFILE ........................................................................................................... 41 SITE DESCRIPTION ............................................................................................................................. 42 ZONING ANALYSIS ............................................................................................................................. 45 TAX CONSIDERATIONS ...................................................................................................................... 48 ANALYSIS OF VALUE ............................................................................................................................ 50 MARKET CONDITIONS AND TRENDS .............................................................................................. 50 HIGHEST AND BEST USE ANALYSIS ............................................................................................... 51 METHODS OF VALUATION ................................................................................................................ 53 FLOOR-AREA RATIO (FAR) ANALYSIS AND CONCLUSION ........................................................ 54 SALES COMPARISON APPROACH .................................................................................................... 56 RECONCILIATION AND CONCLUSION OF MARKET VALUE ...................................................... 58 MARKETING AND EXPOSURE TIMES .............................................................................................. 59 ASSUMPTIONS AND LIMITING CONDITIONS ................................................................................ 60 REQUIRED STATEMENTS .................................................................................................................... 64 APPRAISER’S CERTIFICATION .......................................................................................................... 65 APPRAISER’S QUALIFICATIONS........................................................................................................ 66 Exhibit Market Data Alcock & Williams, LLC iii EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The subject is a high-density development site one block east of South Main Street in downtown Ann Arbor. City officials are contemplating an option to purchase this site after a redevelopment failed to materialize. The downtown and central campus areas are presently rife with new dense apartment developments, proposals, and speculation following a rezoning of the downtown in 2009 and a national trend to fund and develop urban residential high-rises. Location: The subject property is bounded by East William Street and South Fourth and South Fifth Avenues in downtown Ann Arbor, Washtenaw County, Michigan. Current Use: Vacant land. Site: Rectangular shaped 34,848± net square feet or 0.80± net acre double- corner site; 264± feet on William, 132± feet on Fifth, and 132± feet on Fourth; very gradual slope down to the west. Utilities: Municipal water and sewer, DTE Energy electric and gas, AT&T and Comcast broadband internet-television-VoIP are at the site. According to the DDA, two six-inch water mains are at the subject site. Zoning: D1, Core District Traffic Counts: A 24-hour traffic count at the subject at William east of Main was 8,150 in November, 2001, the latest available. No counts are available on South Fourth and Fifth at the subject. Pedestrian foot and public bus traffic are high at the subject. Flood Hazard: Zone X area of 0.2% annual chance of flood according to the FEMA flood insurance rate map; Panel 263 of 585, Map No. 26161C0263E, effective April 3, 2012. Environmental Conditions: Unknown but appraisal is subject to change if any environmental conditions are found. See ‘Assumptions and Limiting Conditions’ for a complete disclosure. Alcock & Williams, LLC 1 Highest and Best Use: As a dense mixed-use development. Hypothetical Condition: Any and all deed restrictions, covenants, options, and time limitations as they relate to the development and use of the subject property between the City of Ann Arbor and Fifth Fourth, LLC, are removed. In other words, the subject property is transferable with a free and clear title and the ‘by-right’ development density and uses as only defined by the D1, Core District, as of the date of valuation. Market Value: $11,000,000 as of on April 3, 2018, subject to the Assumptions and Limiting Conditions noted at the eponymously titled section of this report as well as the hypothetical condition defined above. The entire appraisal must be read to understand the market value conclusion. Alcock & Williams, LLC 2 PHOTOGRAPHS OF SUBJECT AND SURROUNDING AREA Elevated view of the subject looking east Looking east at the subject from Fourth Avenue Taken on April 17, 2018 by Jay T. Alcock Alcock & Williams, LLC 3 Looking southwest across the subject from Fifth Avenue Looking east at the public transit center with the subject site to the right Taken on April 17, 2018 by Jay T. Alcock Alcock & Williams, LLC 4 Looking north at Fourth Avenue Looking south at Fourth Avenue Taken on April 17, 2018 by Jay T. Alcock Alcock & Williams, LLC 5 Look east at William Street Looking west at William Street Taken on April 17, 2018 by Jay T. Alcock Alcock & Williams, LLC 6 Looking