<<

COVER BUL-128 11/9/06 3:45 PM Page 1 www.esa.int

number 128 - november 2006

Member States Etats membres

Austria Allemagne Belgium Autriche Denmark Belgique Finland Danemark France Espagne Germany Finlande Greece France Ireland Grèce Italy Irlande Luxembourg Italie Netherlands Luxembourg Norway Norvège Portugal Pays-Bas SPACE FOR EUROPE Spain Portugal Sweden Royaumi-Uni Switzerland Suède Suisse

IXV Prepares for Reentry ESA bulletin 128 - november 2006

ESA Publications Division ESTEC, PO Box 299, 2200 AG Noordwijk, The Netherlands Tel: +31 71 565-3400 Fax: +31 71 565-5433 Visit ESA Publications at http://www.esa.int INSIDE COVER-B128 11/10/06 1:40 PM Page 2

Editorial/Circulation Office ESA Publications Division ESTEC, PO Box 299, The European Space Agency was formed out of, and took over the rights and obligations of, the two earlier European space organisations – the 2200 AG Noordwijk European Space Research Organisation (ESRO) and the European Organisation for the Development and Construction of Space Vehicle Launchers The Netherlands (ELDO). The Member States are Austria, Belgium, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Italy, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Norway, Tel: +31 71 565-3400 Portugal, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland and the United Kingdom. Canada is a Cooperating State. Editors Andrew Wilson In the words of its Convention: the purpose of the Agency shall be to provide for and to promote for exclusively peaceful purposes, cooperation among Carl Walker European States in space research and technology and their space applications, with a view to their being used for scientific purposes and for operational space applications systems: Design & Layout Isabel Kenny (a) by elaborating and implementing a long-term European space policy, by recommending space objectives to the Member States, and by concerting Jules Perel the policies of the Member States with respect to other national and international organisations and institutions; Advertising (b) by elaborating and implementing activities and programmes in the space field; Lorraine Conroy (c) by coordinating the European space programme and national programmes, and by integrating the latter progressively and as completely as possible into the European space programme, in particular as regards the development of applications satellites; The ESA Bulletin is published by the European Space (d) by elaborating and implementing the industrial policy appropriate to its programme and by recommending a coherent industrial policy to the Agency. Individual articles may be reprinted provided the credit line reads ‘Reprinted from ESA Bulletin’, plus Member States. date of issue. Signed articles reprinted must bear the author’s name. Advertisements are accepted in good The Agency is directed by a Council composed of representatives of the Member States. The Director General is the chief executive of the Agency and faith; the Agency accepts no responsibility for their its legal representative. content or claims.

The ESA HEADQUARTERS are in Paris. Copyright © 2006 European Space Agency Printed in the Netherlands ISSN 0376-4265 The major establishments of ESA are: THE EUROPEAN SPACE RESEARCH AND TECHNOLOGY CENTRE (ESTEC), Noordwijk, Netherlands. THE EUROPEAN SPACE OPERATIONS CENTRE (ESOC), Darmstadt, Germany. ESRIN, Frascati, Italy. Chairman of the Council: S. Wittig Director General: J.-J. Dordain

agence spatiale européenne

L’Agence Spatiale Européenne est issue des deux Organisations spatiales européennes qui l’ont précédée – l’Organisation européenne de recherches spatiales (CERS) et l’Organisation européenne pour la mise au point et la construction de lanceurs d’engins spatiaux (CECLES) – dont elle a repris les droits et obligations. Les Etats membres en sont: l’Allemagne, l’Autriche, la Belgique, le Danemark, l’Espagne, la Finlande, la France, la Grèce, l’Irlande, l’Italie, le Luxembourg, la Norvège, les Pays-Bas, le Portugal, le Royaumi-Uni, la Suède et la Suisse. Le Canada bénéficie d’un statut d’Etat coopérant.

Selon les termes de la Convention: l’Agence a pour mission d’assurer et de développer, à des fins exclusivement pacifiques, la coopération entre Etats européens dans les domaines de la recherche et de la technologie spatiales et de leurs applications spatiales, en vue de leur utilisation à des fins The Intermediate eXperimental Vehicle (IXV) is helping to scientifiques et pour des systèmes spatiaux opérationnels d’applications: build Europe's expertise in atmospheric reentry technology

(a) en élaborant et en mettant en oeuvre une politique spatiale européenne à long terme, en recommandant aux Etats membres des objectifs en matière spatiale et en concertant les politiques des Etats membres à l’égard d’autres organisations et institutions nationales et internationales; (b) en élaborant et en mettant en oeuvre des activités et des programmes dans le domaine spatial; (c) en coordonnant le programme spatial européen et les programmes nationaux, et en intégrant ces derniers progressivement et aussi complètement que possible dans le programme spatial européen, notamment en ce qui concerne le développement de satellites d’applications; (d) en élaborant et en mettant en oeuvre la politique industrielle appropriée à son programme et en recommandant aux Etats membres une politique industrielle cohérente.

L’Agence est dirigée par un Conseil, composé de représentants des Etats membres. Le Directeur général est le fonctionnaire exécutif supérieur de l’Agence et la représente dans tous ses actes.

Le SIEGE de l’Agence est à Paris. Les principaux Etablissements de l’Agence sont: LE CENTRE EUROPEEN DE RECHERCHE ET DE TECHNOLOGIE SPATIALES (ESTEC), Noordwijk, Pays-Bas. LE CENTRE EUROPEEN D’OPERATIONS SPATIALES (ESOC), Darmstadt, Allemagne. ESRIN, Frascati, Italy. Président du Conseil: S. Wittig Directeur général: J.-J. Dordain

www.esa.int ContentsB128 11/9/06 4:00 PM Page 3

8 10 26

Agenda 2011 Unveiling the Universe MELFI Ready for Science Setting the Agenda for Europe’s Space Two Missions Revealing the Cold ESA’s Cryogenic Freezer Begins Work Agency Universe Aboard the International Space Station

42 52 62 Taking the Measure of Earth Healing the Earth IXV in Radar Altimetry Supporting Environmental Conventions The Intermediate eXperimental Vehicle

bulletin 128 - november 2006 Contents

Agenda 2011 8 Healing the Earth 52 Earth Observation Supporting International Unveiling the Universe 10 Environmental Conventions Two Missions to Unlock the Secrets of the Cold Cosmos Olivier Arino, Diego Fernandez-Prieto & Espen Volden Gerald Crone et al. IXV: the Intermediate eXperimental Vehicle 62 Cannibalism in Space: A Star Eats its Companion 18 Europe Among the World Players in Atmospheric Reentry A (Typical?) Observation of the High-Energy Sky Giorgio Tumino & Yves Gerard Christoph Winkler et al. Delta-DOR 68 MELFI Ready for Science 26 A New Technique for ESA’s Deep Space Navigation ESA’s –80ºC Freezer Begins Work in Space Roberto Maddè et al. Maria De Parolis et al.

Preparing for Space 32 Programmes in Progress 76 EVA Training at the European Centre Hans Bolender et al. News – In Brief 92

Taking the Measure of Earth 42 Publications 102 15 Years of Progress in Radar Altimetry Jérôme Benveniste & Yves Ménard

www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 1 Pages 8-9 Agenda 2011 20/11/06 14:47 Page 8

ESA Agenda 2011

Agenda 2011 The next step is to 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 enable new services by Agenda 2011 CMINCMIN 08 08 EU Budget Revision CMINCMIN 11 11 exploiting several systems, space and Preparation of Major decisions on: programme proposals – Level of Resources Complementary non-space, acting in Implementation of for CMIN 08 – Exploration decisions on: Major decisions on: A Document by the Director General and Directors CMIN 05 programmes – Technology – GMES Preparation of – Level of Resources concert as a ‘system of Decision on GMES – GMES segment 2 – GNSS programme proposals – Launchers systems’. The potential Preparatory activities for phase 2 of segment 1 – Launchers for CMIN 11 – Telecom and integrated applications – ISS Exploitation Implementation of Navigation is immense in many – Preparatory Prog on CMIN 08 programmes The Agency’s Agenda 2011, released in monitoring, acted as a catalyst for members and a new relationship with the integrated applications important areas, such October 2006, presents an evolving European space telecommunications and EU. The first step should be taken within European Space Policy as civil security, air

framework of action for achieving the is jointly developing new applications 2 years, to adapt accordingly the Review and Update of Convention: traffic management wide-ranging objectives of Member ( and Global Monitoring for industrial policy rules and procedures, assessment of ESA Action plan for ESA – Decision making New Member States and maritime surveill- Evolution evolution – Funding mechanisms States and for adapting ESA to a Environment and Security/GMES) with decision-making, funding mechanisms Implementation of New Financial ance. This will make Propose new Council Improved coordination Review of industrial updated Convention Management System changing environment. Agenda 2007, the EU. The objective now is to develop and coordination between ESA and meetings set-up with National policy space an indispensable presented in mid-2003, led to significant beyond this, to make ESA a model for national programmes, resources and Programmes tool for European advances in less than 3 years, including underpinning the use of space in the industrial policy. It is expected that, policies. The challenge

a successful Ministerial Council at the world today and specifically in the following such adaptation, there will be Agenda 2011 New competences for New Human is to change from the integrated applications Resources Policy Adaptation of Agenda 2015 end of 2005. context of Europe’s growing needs. at least 22 Member States by 2011. A High Level Space organisation single system (often The plan of actions supporting In order to reach this objective, three longer-term goal is for ESA to evolve Advisory Committee Enhanced Corporate Reinforced “One ESA” satellite-centred) to a (HISAC) Control Agenda 2011 will be detailed and key priorities will drive ESA’s actions: towards the EU by 2014. user-centred approach formalised in the ESA Long-Term Plan ESA Internal operations Evolution of ESA Programmes and Budgets exploiting a network of 2007–2016, updated by the Council Consolidation of steps taken at the 2005 Programmes CMIN: Ministerial Council; GNSS: Global Navigation Satellite System; other abbreviations as in text capabilities. annually. Agenda 2011 is defined within Ministerial Council towards discoveries Core activities to be proposed to the 2008 For example, there the framework of the European Space and competitiveness Ministerial Council include: are significant synergies Policy (ESP); indeed, it is an important The absolute priority in the coming Life and physical sciences: focus on basic gradually become operational as to be exploited between civil security input to that policy. In turn, its years is to consolidate the capabilities Space science: opening the door to new and applied research in life and space assets are integrated into the and defence. Disaster relief and crisis implementation will take into account and competitiveness of European missions by introducing flexibility; physical sciences using the ISS, coordinated data stream. The first management missions include civil and the ESP as endorsed in mid-2007. industry. Without space manufacturers astronomy missions in deep-space sounding rockets and other oppor- services will be pre-operational in military elements (transport, medical and service-providers, Europe cannot orbits; exploiting the synergies of tunities; support future exploration 2008, while full operational capacity treatment, food supply, temporary Overall Objectives and Priorities serve any of its ambitions. Significant Solar System missions with explora- initiatives. will emerge from 2012 as dedicated accommodation), requiring close The ESP will provide a European Union investments in new and advanced tion (see below), and of fundamental Launchers: consolidate Ariane-5 and GMES missions are launched. coordination and coherent information. (EU) dimension to the space path technologies have to be made urgently. physics missions with the ISS. start exploiting and Vega; Meteorology: the Meteosat Third Common communications equipment followed for 30 years by ESA Member Earth science: focus on global change; Ariane-5 and Vega to evolve with Generation will be available in 2015, providing secure links is a clear demand. States. Conversely, this new policy will Development and promotion of integrated one mission per year; increase coopera- family modularity; prepare technolo- followed by MetOp’s successor in For such applications, ESA will take introduce a space dimension into the applications (space & non-space) and tion with international partners and gies for next-generation launchers; 2019. the role of promoter of the space political ambitions of Europe as a integration of security in the ESP technology programmes; preparation international cooperation based on Telecommunications: the Small GEO element of the overall system, which will global actor. The overall objectives of New concepts, new capabilities and a of applications programmes. mutual dependence, with guaranteed and AlphaSat geostationary platforms be the responsibility of a dedicated the next 5 years will serve these new new culture have to be developed in Exploration: begin development of access to space. will be developed to satisfy the small- operator. ESA is beginning pilot dimensions and must therefore order to respond to a multitude of needs ExoMars follow-on mission; choose and large-size satellite market projects to help the proposal for an consolidate “ESA as a global space from users who are not yet familiar with scenario to make Europe an Current applications programmes will demands, respectively, in partnership Integrated Applications Preparatory agency, instrumental for Europe in space systems. The strong coordination indispensable partner: orbit continue with emphasis on: with industry and telecom operators. Programme in 2008, promoting space serving the policies of its Member States and efficient exploitation of synergies infrastructure (telecommunications, systems and demonstrating their role in and the EU, developing a competitive have to be organised between national, navigation), participation in human Galileo: once the system is deployed, the Integrated Applications a wider system. Examples include civil economy, and indispensable to the world intergovernmental and EU resources transportation (in conjunction with challenge will be to make the transition The submissions for the 2008 Ministerial protection, disaster management, flight in contributing to global policies and to and capabilities, as well as between civil the launcher programme), synergy to a full operational system, with a Council will emphasise new integrated safety, human security, health, early- the increase of knowledge”. security and defence applications. with space science missions; stimulate commercial operator and services, applications pro-grammes, based on a warning systems, maritime surveillance ESA is recognised as a globally- international cooperation taking into followed by preparations for a second- multi-disciplinary approach, paving the and education in developing countries. important agency in its core activities of Evolution of ESA account the lessons learned from the generation system. Operational way for security-related programmes. e science and exploration, human space- The Agency’s evolution must be ISS partnership. exploitation is planned to start in 2011. Operational space systems such as flight and partnership in the International accelerated in order to improve our : based around the GMES: as services require data from navigation and communications are The full Agenda 2011 is planned for publication in the Space Station (ISS), and launchers. It has global effectiveness, reinforce the ISS, optimising the benefit for space and other sources, GMES is the part of our daily lives. They integrate coming months. Agenda 2007 is available as ESA already developed important operational motivations for Member States to invest Member States through efficient use typical case for the integrated applica- space and ground elements, but are BR-213 (cost 10 Euro) from ESA Publications or at http://www.esa.int/esapub/br/br213/br213.pdf capabilities in meteorology and climate in space, and prepare ESA for new of research activities and applications. tions approach. GMES services will based on mainly a single type of system.

8 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 9 Pages 8-9 Agenda 2011 20/11/06 14:47 Page 8

ESA Agenda 2011

Agenda 2011 The next step is to 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 enable new services by Agenda 2011 CMINCMIN 08 08 EU Budget Revision CMINCMIN 11 11 exploiting several systems, space and Preparation of Major decisions on: programme proposals – Level of Resources Complementary non-space, acting in Implementation of for CMIN 08 – Exploration decisions on: Major decisions on: A Document by the Director General and Directors CMIN 05 programmes – Technology – GMES Preparation of – Level of Resources concert as a ‘system of Decision on GMES – GMES segment 2 – GNSS programme proposals – Launchers systems’. The potential Preparatory activities for phase 2 of segment 1 – Launchers for CMIN 11 – Telecom and integrated applications – ISS Exploitation Implementation of Navigation is immense in many – Preparatory Prog on CMIN 08 programmes The Agency’s Agenda 2011, released in monitoring, acted as a catalyst for members and a new relationship with the integrated applications important areas, such October 2006, presents an evolving European space telecommunications and EU. The first step should be taken within European Space Policy as civil security, air

framework of action for achieving the is jointly developing new applications 2 years, to adapt accordingly the Review and Update of Convention: traffic management wide-ranging objectives of Member (Galileo and Global Monitoring for industrial policy rules and procedures, assessment of ESA Action plan for ESA – Decision making New Member States and maritime surveill- Evolution evolution – Funding mechanisms States and for adapting ESA to a Environment and Security/GMES) with decision-making, funding mechanisms Implementation of New Financial ance. This will make Propose new Council Improved coordination Review of industrial updated Convention Management System changing environment. Agenda 2007, the EU. The objective now is to develop and coordination between ESA and meetings set-up with National policy space an indispensable presented in mid-2003, led to significant beyond this, to make ESA a model for national programmes, resources and Programmes tool for European advances in less than 3 years, including underpinning the use of space in the industrial policy. It is expected that, policies. The challenge

a successful Ministerial Council at the world today and specifically in the following such adaptation, there will be Agenda 2011 New competences for New Human is to change from the integrated applications Resources Policy Adaptation of Agenda 2015 end of 2005. context of Europe’s growing needs. at least 22 Member States by 2011. A High Level Space organisation single system (often The plan of actions supporting In order to reach this objective, three longer-term goal is for ESA to evolve Advisory Committee Enhanced Corporate Reinforced “One ESA” satellite-centred) to a (HISAC) Control Agenda 2011 will be detailed and key priorities will drive ESA’s actions: towards the EU by 2014. user-centred approach formalised in the ESA Long-Term Plan ESA Internal operations Evolution of ESA Programmes and Budgets exploiting a network of 2007–2016, updated by the Council Consolidation of steps taken at the 2005 Programmes CMIN: Ministerial Council; GNSS: Global Navigation Satellite System; other abbreviations as in text capabilities. annually. Agenda 2011 is defined within Ministerial Council towards discoveries Core activities to be proposed to the 2008 For example, there the framework of the European Space and competitiveness Ministerial Council include: are significant synergies Policy (ESP); indeed, it is an important The absolute priority in the coming Life and physical sciences: focus on basic gradually become operational as to be exploited between civil security input to that policy. In turn, its years is to consolidate the capabilities Space science: opening the door to new and applied research in life and space assets are integrated into the and defence. Disaster relief and crisis implementation will take into account and competitiveness of European missions by introducing flexibility; physical sciences using the ISS, coordinated data stream. The first management missions include civil and the ESP as endorsed in mid-2007. industry. Without space manufacturers astronomy missions in deep-space sounding rockets and other oppor- services will be pre-operational in military elements (transport, medical and service-providers, Europe cannot orbits; exploiting the synergies of tunities; support future exploration 2008, while full operational capacity treatment, food supply, temporary Overall Objectives and Priorities serve any of its ambitions. Significant Solar System missions with explora- initiatives. will emerge from 2012 as dedicated accommodation), requiring close The ESP will provide a European Union investments in new and advanced tion (see below), and of fundamental Launchers: consolidate Ariane-5 and GMES missions are launched. coordination and coherent information. (EU) dimension to the space path technologies have to be made urgently. physics missions with the ISS. start exploiting Soyuz and Vega; Meteorology: the Meteosat Third Common communications equipment followed for 30 years by ESA Member Earth science: focus on global change; Ariane-5 and Vega to evolve with Generation will be available in 2015, providing secure links is a clear demand. States. Conversely, this new policy will Development and promotion of integrated one mission per year; increase coopera- family modularity; prepare technolo- followed by MetOp’s successor in For such applications, ESA will take introduce a space dimension into the applications (space & non-space) and tion with international partners and gies for next-generation launchers; 2019. the role of promoter of the space political ambitions of Europe as a integration of security in the ESP technology programmes; preparation international cooperation based on Telecommunications: the Small GEO element of the overall system, which will global actor. The overall objectives of New concepts, new capabilities and a of applications programmes. mutual dependence, with guaranteed and AlphaSat geostationary platforms be the responsibility of a dedicated the next 5 years will serve these new new culture have to be developed in Exploration: begin development of access to space. will be developed to satisfy the small- operator. ESA is beginning pilot dimensions and must therefore order to respond to a multitude of needs ExoMars follow-on mission; choose and large-size satellite market projects to help the proposal for an consolidate “ESA as a global space from users who are not yet familiar with scenario to make Europe an Current applications programmes will demands, respectively, in partnership Integrated Applications Preparatory agency, instrumental for Europe in space systems. The strong coordination indispensable partner: Moon orbit continue with emphasis on: with industry and telecom operators. Programme in 2008, promoting space serving the policies of its Member States and efficient exploitation of synergies infrastructure (telecommunications, systems and demonstrating their role in and the EU, developing a competitive have to be organised between national, navigation), participation in human Galileo: once the system is deployed, the Integrated Applications a wider system. Examples include civil economy, and indispensable to the world intergovernmental and EU resources transportation (in conjunction with challenge will be to make the transition The submissions for the 2008 Ministerial protection, disaster management, flight in contributing to global policies and to and capabilities, as well as between civil the launcher programme), synergy to a full operational system, with a Council will emphasise new integrated safety, human security, health, early- the increase of knowledge”. security and defence applications. with space science missions; stimulate commercial operator and services, applications pro-grammes, based on a warning systems, maritime surveillance ESA is recognised as a globally- international cooperation taking into followed by preparations for a second- multi-disciplinary approach, paving the and education in developing countries. important agency in its core activities of Evolution of ESA account the lessons learned from the generation system. Operational way for security-related programmes. e science and exploration, human space- The Agency’s evolution must be ISS partnership. exploitation is planned to start in 2011. Operational space systems such as flight and partnership in the International accelerated in order to improve our Human spaceflight: based around the GMES: as services require data from navigation and communications are The full Agenda 2011 is planned for publication in the Space Station (ISS), and launchers. It has global effectiveness, reinforce the ISS, optimising the benefit for space and other sources, GMES is the part of our daily lives. They integrate coming months. Agenda 2007 is available as ESA already developed important operational motivations for Member States to invest Member States through efficient use typical case for the integrated applica- space and ground elements, but are BR-213 (cost 10 Euro) from ESA Publications or at http://www.esa.int/esapub/br/br213/br213.pdf capabilities in meteorology and climate in space, and prepare ESA for new of research activities and applications. tions approach. GMES services will based on mainly a single type of system.

8 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 9 Passvogel 11/9/06 4:09 PM Page 10

Herschel/

Gerald Crone, Anders Elfving & Thomas Passvogel Science Projects Department, Directorate of Unveiling the Universe Science Programme, ESTEC, Noordwijk, The Netherlands

Göran Pilbratt & Jan Tauber Astrophysics Missions Division, Research & Scientific Support Department, Directorate of Science Programme, ESTEC, Noordwijk, The Netherlands

n 2008, an Ariane-5 will lift off from French Guiana carrying ESA’s two pioneering IHerschel and Planck deep space observatories to explore previously unknown regions of the Universe. Their target is the ‘bright’ part of the far-infrared spectrum that has tantalised scientists for decades. Until now, the technology has not existed to make precise observations of a distant domain that touches the very beginning of time. Introduction Herschel, detecting light emitted in the Two Missions to sub-millimetre and far-infrared range of the spectrum that is blocked from reaching Earth by our atmosphere, will Unlock the Secrets reveal phenomena previously obscured from view, such as the very earliest galaxies and stars. of the Cold Cosmos The Planck telescope, observing in a different part of the far-infrared spectrum with the highest precision ever, will investigate cosmic background radiation – the remnants of the radiation that filled the Universe immediately after the Big Bang some 14 billion years ago. Two pioneering missions: Herschel Extreme sensitivity is needed to (left) and Planck (inset) measure the faint heat signatures of this

esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 11 Passvogel 11/9/06 4:09 PM Page 10

Herschel/Planck

Gerald Crone, Anders Elfving & Thomas Passvogel Science Projects Department, Directorate of Unveiling the Universe Science Programme, ESTEC, Noordwijk, The Netherlands

Göran Pilbratt & Jan Tauber Astrophysics Missions Division, Research & Scientific Support Department, Directorate of Science Programme, ESTEC, Noordwijk, The Netherlands

n 2008, an Ariane-5 will lift off from French Guiana carrying ESA’s two pioneering IHerschel and Planck deep space observatories to explore previously unknown regions of the Universe. Their target is the ‘bright’ part of the far-infrared spectrum that has tantalised scientists for decades. Until now, the technology has not existed to make precise observations of a distant domain that touches the very beginning of time. Introduction Herschel, detecting light emitted in the Two Missions to sub-millimetre and far-infrared range of the spectrum that is blocked from reaching Earth by our atmosphere, will Unlock the Secrets reveal phenomena previously obscured from view, such as the very earliest galaxies and stars. of the Cold Cosmos The Planck telescope, observing in a different part of the far-infrared spectrum with the highest precision ever, will investigate cosmic background radiation – the remnants of the radiation that filled the Universe immediately after the Big Bang some 14 billion years ago. Two pioneering missions: Herschel Extreme sensitivity is needed to (left) and Planck (inset) measure the faint heat signatures of this

esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 11 Passvogel 11/9/06 4:09 PM Page 12

Science Herschel/Planck

‘cold’ part of the cosmos, so the point, just like circling a planet, with a The infrared sky background showing the frequency ranges targeted by Herschel and Planck detectors on both Herschel and Planck period of about 6 months. have to operate at very low and stable The thermally benign L2 environment temperatures. The spacecraft therefore offers stable radio links to Earth and Probe (WMAP) spacecraft, both of cool their detectors close to absolute unbroken observing time, making it a which detected temperature fluctuations zero, ranging from 20K (–253ºC) to only preferred location in the coming years in the CMB radiation, leading to strong a few tenths of a degree above the for international observatories of this support of what is known as the –273ºC of absolute zero. kind. ‘inflationary’ Big Bang model to explain The 3-axis stabilised Herschel fits the the origin and evolution of the Universe. traditional notion of an observatory by Herschel and Planck Science In spite of the importance of the pointing at specific targets on request or Herschel will look deep into the far- COBE and WMAP measurements, according to a flexible schedule agreed infrared and sub-millimetre range that however, many fundamental cosmo- by scientists. bridges the gap between what can be logical questions remain open. Planck’s Herschel achieves its low cryostat observed from ground or airborne main objective takes it beyond its temperatures by employing a ‘thermos facilities and earlier space missions, such predecessors: measuring the CMB bottle’ technique, boiling off helium at a as ESA’s Infrared Space Observatory fluctuations with far greater precision. controlled rate to keep the telescope (ISO) of 1995–1998. This will allow scientists to address receivers cool. The spin-stabilised Radiation in this part of the spectrum fundamental questions, such as the Planck, on the other hand, uses passive not only passes through interstellar gas initial conditions for evolution in the cooling complemented by a series of and dust but it is also emitted by the Universe’s structure, the origin of three active refrigerators. very same gas and dust. That means structure in the Universe, the nature and To provide the necessary cold and ‘cold’ objects, invisible to other types of amount of dark matter and the nature stable environment, the observatories telescopes, can be viewed. to radiate in visible light are often Planck, on the other hand, will of dark energy (see box). Planck will will be positioned at the second Herschel’s targets include clouds of hidden behind vast dust clouds that continuously map the whole sky at a also set constraints on theories involving Lagrange point (commonly known as gas and dust where new stars are being absorb the energy and reradiate it at wide range of frequencies, enabling the high-energy particle physics that cannot The Herschel spacecraft is 7.5 m high and 4x4 m across, with a L2), Herschel for its nominal mission born, discs that may form planets, and Herschel’s wavelengths. separation of the galactic and extra- be reached by experiments on Earth. launch mass of 3.3 t. The Payload Module consists of the lifetime of some 3.5 years and Planck the atmospheres of packed with There is a lot to see at these galactic foreground radiation from the The mission’s main observational telescope (a mirror mass-dummy is seen here at ESTEC) and an for up to about 2 years. L2 is a virtual complex organic molecules. wavelengths, and much of it has been primordial background. Its ultimate result will be an all-sky map of the optical bench carrying the parts of the instruments that need to point in space, some 1.5 million km Two-thirds of Herschel’s observation virtually unexplored. Previous space- goal is to produce a map of the tiny temperature fluctuations in the CMB. be cooled. A sunshield protects the telescope and cryostat from heating and prevents stray light from Earth entering the beyond the Earth as viewed from the time will be available to the world based infrared telescopes have had irregularities known to exist in the To achieve this, Planck will survey the telescope; it also carries solar cells to generate the spacecraft’s Sun, where their gravitational forces of scientific community, with the neither the sensitivity of Herschel’s large Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) sky at nine frequencies that bracket the power are balanced. Spacecraft can orbit this remainder reserved for the spacecraft’s mirror nor the ability of Herschel’s three field. ‘peak’ of the CMB infrared spectrum. science and instrument teams. instruments to do such a comprehensive Work in this area began with NASA’s These maps will include not only the Herschel’s far-infrared and sub- job of sensing this important part of the Cosmic Background Explorer (COBE) CMB itself but also all the foreground millimetre wavelengths are considerably spectrum. and Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy emissions, whether galactic or longer than the rainbow of colours extragalactic in origin. All nine maps familiar to the human eye. This is a will be combined by careful processing ‘Dark matter’ is a term coined to describe matter that does not emit or reflect enough critically important portion of the electromagnetic radiation (such as light or X-rays) to be detected directly, but whose to create a single map of the CMB spectrum to scientists because it is here presence may be inferred from its gravitational effects on visible matter. Observed variations (see box). where a large part of the Universe phenomena hinting at dark matter include the rotational speeds of galaxies, the orbital radiates its energy. velocities of galaxies in clusters, and the temperature distribution of hot gas in galaxies and A Common Heritage Much of the Universe consists of gas clusters of galaxies. It has been suggested that such objects, and the Universe as a whole, The Herschel and Planck spacecraft are contain far more matter than is directly observable, indicating that the remainder is dark. Its and dust that is far too cold to radiate in composition is unknown but may include elementary particles. broadly similar in that they have clear visible light or at shorter wavelengths separations between the Service Module such as X-rays. However, even at The hypothetical ‘dark energy’ permeates all of space and has a strong negative (housing all the electronics for space- temperatures well below the most frigid pressure. According to the Theory of Relativity, the effect of such a negative pressure is craft and instrument command and spot on Earth, they do shine in the far- similar to a force acting in opposition to gravity at large scales. Invoking this effect is control) and the Payload Module, which currently the most popular method for explaining recent observations that the Universe infrared and sub-millimetre. Stars and appears to be expanding at an accelerating rate, as well as accounting for a significant carries the sensitive detectors and other cosmic objects that are hot enough portion of the energy in the Universe. cryogenic telescopes. Although the Payload Modules are Discovered in 1965, the Cosmic Microwave Background was produced in the quite different, the Service Modules Universe’s infancy and now fills it entirely. Most cosmologists consider it to be one of the feature many common aspects, with fundamental pieces of evidence for the Big Bang model of the Universe. Planck is 4.2 m high and has a maximum diameter of 4.2 m, almost identical electrical and avionic with a launch mass of 1.8 t systems.

12 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 13 Passvogel 11/9/06 4:09 PM Page 12

Science Herschel/Planck

‘cold’ part of the cosmos, so the point, just like circling a planet, with a The infrared sky background showing the frequency ranges targeted by Herschel and Planck detectors on both Herschel and Planck period of about 6 months. have to operate at very low and stable The thermally benign L2 environment temperatures. The spacecraft therefore offers stable radio links to Earth and Probe (WMAP) spacecraft, both of cool their detectors close to absolute unbroken observing time, making it a which detected temperature fluctuations zero, ranging from 20K (–253ºC) to only preferred location in the coming years in the CMB radiation, leading to strong a few tenths of a degree above the for international observatories of this support of what is known as the –273ºC of absolute zero. kind. ‘inflationary’ Big Bang model to explain The 3-axis stabilised Herschel fits the the origin and evolution of the Universe. traditional notion of an observatory by Herschel and Planck Science In spite of the importance of the pointing at specific targets on request or Herschel will look deep into the far- COBE and WMAP measurements, according to a flexible schedule agreed infrared and sub-millimetre range that however, many fundamental cosmo- by scientists. bridges the gap between what can be logical questions remain open. Planck’s Herschel achieves its low cryostat observed from ground or airborne main objective takes it beyond its temperatures by employing a ‘thermos facilities and earlier space missions, such predecessors: measuring the CMB bottle’ technique, boiling off helium at a as ESA’s Infrared Space Observatory fluctuations with far greater precision. controlled rate to keep the telescope (ISO) of 1995–1998. This will allow scientists to address receivers cool. The spin-stabilised Radiation in this part of the spectrum fundamental questions, such as the Planck, on the other hand, uses passive not only passes through interstellar gas initial conditions for evolution in the cooling complemented by a series of and dust but it is also emitted by the Universe’s structure, the origin of three active refrigerators. very same gas and dust. That means structure in the Universe, the nature and To provide the necessary cold and ‘cold’ objects, invisible to other types of amount of dark matter and the nature stable environment, the observatories telescopes, can be viewed. to radiate in visible light are often Planck, on the other hand, will of dark energy (see box). Planck will will be positioned at the second Herschel’s targets include clouds of hidden behind vast dust clouds that continuously map the whole sky at a also set constraints on theories involving Lagrange point (commonly known as gas and dust where new stars are being absorb the energy and reradiate it at wide range of frequencies, enabling the high-energy particle physics that cannot The Herschel spacecraft is 7.5 m high and 4x4 m across, with a L2), Herschel for its nominal mission born, discs that may form planets, and Herschel’s wavelengths. separation of the galactic and extra- be reached by experiments on Earth. launch mass of 3.3 t. The Payload Module consists of the lifetime of some 3.5 years and Planck the atmospheres of comets packed with There is a lot to see at these galactic foreground radiation from the The mission’s main observational telescope (a mirror mass-dummy is seen here at ESTEC) and an for up to about 2 years. L2 is a virtual complex organic molecules. wavelengths, and much of it has been primordial background. Its ultimate result will be an all-sky map of the optical bench carrying the parts of the instruments that need to point in space, some 1.5 million km Two-thirds of Herschel’s observation virtually unexplored. Previous space- goal is to produce a map of the tiny temperature fluctuations in the CMB. be cooled. A sunshield protects the telescope and cryostat from solar heating and prevents stray light from Earth entering the beyond the Earth as viewed from the time will be available to the world based infrared telescopes have had irregularities known to exist in the To achieve this, Planck will survey the telescope; it also carries solar cells to generate the spacecraft’s Sun, where their gravitational forces of scientific community, with the neither the sensitivity of Herschel’s large Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) sky at nine frequencies that bracket the power are balanced. Spacecraft can orbit this remainder reserved for the spacecraft’s mirror nor the ability of Herschel’s three field. ‘peak’ of the CMB infrared spectrum. science and instrument teams. instruments to do such a comprehensive Work in this area began with NASA’s These maps will include not only the Herschel’s far-infrared and sub- job of sensing this important part of the Cosmic Background Explorer (COBE) CMB itself but also all the foreground millimetre wavelengths are considerably spectrum. and Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy emissions, whether galactic or longer than the rainbow of colours extragalactic in origin. All nine maps familiar to the human eye. This is a will be combined by careful processing ‘Dark matter’ is a term coined to describe matter that does not emit or reflect enough critically important portion of the electromagnetic radiation (such as light or X-rays) to be detected directly, but whose to create a single map of the CMB spectrum to scientists because it is here presence may be inferred from its gravitational effects on visible matter. Observed variations (see box). where a large part of the Universe phenomena hinting at dark matter include the rotational speeds of galaxies, the orbital radiates its energy. velocities of galaxies in clusters, and the temperature distribution of hot gas in galaxies and A Common Heritage Much of the Universe consists of gas clusters of galaxies. It has been suggested that such objects, and the Universe as a whole, The Herschel and Planck spacecraft are contain far more matter than is directly observable, indicating that the remainder is dark. Its and dust that is far too cold to radiate in composition is unknown but may include elementary particles. broadly similar in that they have clear visible light or at shorter wavelengths separations between the Service Module such as X-rays. However, even at The hypothetical ‘dark energy’ permeates all of space and has a strong negative (housing all the electronics for space- temperatures well below the most frigid pressure. According to the Theory of Relativity, the effect of such a negative pressure is craft and instrument command and spot on Earth, they do shine in the far- similar to a force acting in opposition to gravity at large scales. Invoking this effect is control) and the Payload Module, which currently the most popular method for explaining recent observations that the Universe infrared and sub-millimetre. Stars and appears to be expanding at an accelerating rate, as well as accounting for a significant carries the sensitive detectors and other cosmic objects that are hot enough portion of the energy in the Universe. cryogenic telescopes. Although the Payload Modules are Discovered in 1965, the Cosmic Microwave Background was produced in the quite different, the Service Modules Universe’s infancy and now fills it entirely. Most cosmologists consider it to be one of the feature many common aspects, with fundamental pieces of evidence for the Big Bang model of the Universe. Planck is 4.2 m high and has a maximum diameter of 4.2 m, almost identical electrical and avionic with a launch mass of 1.8 t systems.

12 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 13 Passvogel 11/9/06 4:09 PM Page 14

Science Herschel/Planck

As a result, Herschel and Planck are both designed for minimal ground intervention during normal operations, functioning independently of ground control by following an onboard timeline programme that contains all the commands necessary to carry out the regular operations of the day. During the daily periods of contact, lasting about 3 hours, science data recorded during the previous day are downloaded and the commands for the next autonomous period uploaded. Each spacecraft is also programmed to continue nominal science operations in the event of a single onboard Herschel and Planck will orbit L2, a virtual point in equipment failure, when a spare unit space some 1.5 million km from Earth diametrically would automatically switch on to take opposite the Sun. Here, they avoid Earth’s infrared The Focal Plane Units of PACS, SPIRE and HIFI are mounted above Herschel’s cryostat at the telescope’s focus radiation and benefit from stable communications and over. unbroken observing time However, failures of more complex functions (perhaps within the design with a primary mirror diameter Both direct-detection instruments, the 12 separate petals, thus becoming the computers) or combinations of failures of 3.5 m (the largest ever built for space) Photodetector Array Camera and first segmented space mirror as well as The main functional difference satisfy the specific thermal-mechanical leading to unspecified situations will not to focus light on three supercooled Spectrometer (PACS) and the Spectral the largest to date, weighing 240 kg with between the two spacecraft is in attitude requirements of the instruments. have autonomous recovery. If that instruments. and Photometric Imaging Receiver an average thickness of about 20 cm and measurement and control. Herschel uses happens, the effects are contained as far In order to have the sensitivity to (SPIRE), incorporate cameras. The a front face thickness of 2–3 mm. reaction wheels for 3-axis stabilisation, Mission control as possible and the spacecraft detect far-infrared and sub-millimetre third instrument, the Heterodyne Although the main technical while Planck carries small thrusters for ESA’s single ground station for reconfigured automatically into its safe radiation, parts of the instruments have Instrument for the Far-Infrared (HIFI), challenges were in the instruments’ accurately reorienting its spin axis. controlling both missions is in New mode until ground controllers can to be cooled almost to absolute zero. is a complementary very high-resolution focal-plane units (such as the optics, Even so, the observatories have a Norcia, Australia. The L2 orbital restore operations. The shared optical bench that carries all spectrometer. detectors and mechanisms), low-noise significant number of identical units, parameters mean that contact with each of the instruments is contained within The size of Herschel’s mirror meant readout electronics and coolers, similar such as the star trackers which use the spacecraft occurs for just a few hours The Herschel Payload the cryostat to maintain the low that it could not be built in a single piece issues had to be faced within the same hardware but different software to every night (daytime in Europe). The Herschel telescope is a Cassegrain temperature. Some 2300 litres of liquid but instead had to be constructed from spacecraft itself. accommodate for the varying require- helium (at 1.7 K) will be used during the ments of each mission. mission for primary cooling. To achieve The propulsion systems of both the very lowest temperatures, individual Service Modules also employ identical By space standards, Herschel's 3.5 m-diameter detectors are equipped with additional, The Focal Plane Unit of Herschel’s HIFI being mirror is a giant, the largest ever sent into space prepared for cryogenic vibration testing at 20K components. Planck has three propellant and a technological challenge. In comparison, the specialised cooling systems. tanks for adjusting its injection into L2 Hubble Space Telescope has a 2.4 m-diameter main The elaborate cooling system after release by Ariane-5 and to feed the mirror maximises the overall cooling power, main push into the tighter orbit around providing just the right amount at L2, while two tanks are sufficient for different temperature stages to satisfy Herschel’s injection corrections. Ariane-5 local needs. Around 180 gm of helium is will release the two into a direct transfer used per day, allowing the 3.5-year orbit that means they would naturally mission lifetime. circle L2 without further propulsion. The whole cryostat assembly is Though the same thrusters are used, protected from direct sunlight by a fixed they are laid out differently to cater for shade, which also doubles as a solar the specific directional requirements and panel to generate the 1500 W required unique attitude restrictions of the two to operate the entire satellite. The shield spacecraft. also significantly reduces any stray light The structure of each Service Module and heat from the Earth and Moon in is essentially the same, although the the orbit around L2. majority of the equipment panels differ International teams have developed in their detailed designs in order to Herschel’s three scientific instruments.

14 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 15 Passvogel 11/9/06 4:09 PM Page 14

Science Herschel/Planck

As a result, Herschel and Planck are both designed for minimal ground intervention during normal operations, functioning independently of ground control by following an onboard timeline programme that contains all the commands necessary to carry out the regular operations of the day. During the daily periods of contact, lasting about 3 hours, science data recorded during the previous day are downloaded and the commands for the next autonomous period uploaded. Each spacecraft is also programmed to continue nominal science operations in the event of a single onboard Herschel and Planck will orbit L2, a virtual point in equipment failure, when a spare unit space some 1.5 million km from Earth diametrically would automatically switch on to take opposite the Sun. Here, they avoid Earth’s infrared The Focal Plane Units of PACS, SPIRE and HIFI are mounted above Herschel’s cryostat at the telescope’s focus radiation and benefit from stable communications and over. unbroken observing time However, failures of more complex functions (perhaps within the design with a primary mirror diameter Both direct-detection instruments, the 12 separate petals, thus becoming the computers) or combinations of failures of 3.5 m (the largest ever built for space) Photodetector Array Camera and first segmented space mirror as well as The main functional difference satisfy the specific thermal-mechanical leading to unspecified situations will not to focus light on three supercooled Spectrometer (PACS) and the Spectral the largest to date, weighing 240 kg with between the two spacecraft is in attitude requirements of the instruments. have autonomous recovery. If that instruments. and Photometric Imaging Receiver an average thickness of about 20 cm and measurement and control. Herschel uses happens, the effects are contained as far In order to have the sensitivity to (SPIRE), incorporate cameras. The a front face thickness of 2–3 mm. reaction wheels for 3-axis stabilisation, Mission control as possible and the spacecraft detect far-infrared and sub-millimetre third instrument, the Heterodyne Although the main technical while Planck carries small thrusters for ESA’s single ground station for reconfigured automatically into its safe radiation, parts of the instruments have Instrument for the Far-Infrared (HIFI), challenges were in the instruments’ accurately reorienting its spin axis. controlling both missions is in New mode until ground controllers can to be cooled almost to absolute zero. is a complementary very high-resolution focal-plane units (such as the optics, Even so, the observatories have a Norcia, Australia. The L2 orbital restore operations. The shared optical bench that carries all spectrometer. detectors and mechanisms), low-noise significant number of identical units, parameters mean that contact with each of the instruments is contained within The size of Herschel’s mirror meant readout electronics and coolers, similar such as the star trackers which use the spacecraft occurs for just a few hours The Herschel Payload the cryostat to maintain the low that it could not be built in a single piece issues had to be faced within the same hardware but different software to every night (daytime in Europe). The Herschel telescope is a Cassegrain temperature. Some 2300 litres of liquid but instead had to be constructed from spacecraft itself. accommodate for the varying require- helium (at 1.7 K) will be used during the ments of each mission. mission for primary cooling. To achieve The propulsion systems of both the very lowest temperatures, individual Service Modules also employ identical By space standards, Herschel's 3.5 m-diameter detectors are equipped with additional, The Focal Plane Unit of Herschel’s HIFI being mirror is a giant, the largest ever sent into space prepared for cryogenic vibration testing at 20K components. Planck has three propellant and a technological challenge. In comparison, the specialised cooling systems. tanks for adjusting its injection into L2 Hubble Space Telescope has a 2.4 m-diameter main The elaborate cooling system after release by Ariane-5 and to feed the mirror maximises the overall cooling power, main push into the tighter orbit around providing just the right amount at L2, while two tanks are sufficient for different temperature stages to satisfy Herschel’s injection corrections. Ariane-5 local needs. Around 180 gm of helium is will release the two into a direct transfer used per day, allowing the 3.5-year orbit that means they would naturally mission lifetime. circle L2 without further propulsion. The whole cryostat assembly is Though the same thrusters are used, protected from direct sunlight by a fixed they are laid out differently to cater for shade, which also doubles as a solar the specific directional requirements and panel to generate the 1500 W required unique attitude restrictions of the two to operate the entire satellite. The shield spacecraft. also significantly reduces any stray light The structure of each Service Module and heat from the Earth and Moon in is essentially the same, although the the orbit around L2. majority of the equipment panels differ International teams have developed in their detailed designs in order to Herschel’s three scientific instruments.

14 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 15 Passvogel 11/9/06 4:09 PM Page 16

Science Herschel/Planck

The telescope’s line-of-sight is inclined satellite in early 2007 at Astrium in at 85º to the spin axis so that the Friedrichshafen (D). These parallel instruments scan a ring of the celestial programmes are approaching their final sphere once per spacecraft revolution, integration and test period before the and the whole sky in half a year. In launch in 2008. order to view the celestial poles, the spin axis can be moved up to 10º away from Conclusion the anti-Sun direction. Engineers from numerous European The Payload Module is dominated by space companies have worked together three conical radiators that thermally on the design, construction and testing insulate the two reflectors, the detector of ESA’s Herschel and Planck observa- Planck's LFI, an array of radiometers, under calibration testing focal plane and the surrounding black tories, overcoming many challenges that baffle from the Service Module. have pushed technology to new limits. thousandths of a millimetre. Equally The black baffle is a powerful radiator Credit must also go to the hundreds of important, it has to be strong enough to for passively precooling the active three- scientists from specialist institutions withstand harsh conditions. At launch it stage cooling chain to around 60K. across Europe and the United States for Planck’s cryocooling chain will be shaken with a force several times Further cooling of the detectors is designing and developing the suite of that of Earth gravity before going performed via a cascade: 20K by a highly sensitive instruments that will Herschel’s cryostat design was Other technical issues that had to be through drastic temperature changes, continuous hydrogen sorption cooler, operate to the tightest of tolerances at inherited from ESA’s successful ISO overcome during manufacture included from about 20ºC at launch to an average 4K by a mechanical cooler and 100mK temperatures close to absolute zero. mission, but it was still a major the mass-optimised carbon-fibre face of –200ºC in space. by mixing normal helium with a rare Infrared astronomy itself is still a challenge to design capable instruments sheets, which had to be re-manufactured The mirror segments are built from helium isotope. young and exciting science, but with very low heat demands on the several times to find the best silicon carbide, a stable material with the Planck’s two scientific instruments are astronomers studying this part of the cryogenic cooling system in order to compromise between flatness, strength combined advantages of metal and the Low Frequency Instrument (LFI), spectrum have already unveiled tens of reach the mission’s desired lifetime. and mass. glass. It is light and easily polishable, an array of radio receivers using high thousands of new galaxies and made The lightweight carbon-fibre The design requirements on the resists stress and fatigue, and withstands electron mobility transistor mixers, and surprising discoveries. sunshield was difficult to build and, primary mirror were also demanding. It low and high temperatures without any the High Frequency Instrument (HFI), Yet scientists know there is still much owing to the high operating temperature has to be light enough to be placed into notable changes of mechanical and an array of highly sensitive microwave more to find and processes such as the (140–170ºC) of the solar cells, its triple- a distant orbit 1.5 million km from thermal properties. detectors known as bolometers. They growth of structure in the early Universe junction gallium arsenide cells had to be Earth but have an extremely smooth share the off-axis aplanatic telescope, and consequent birth of galaxies and further qualified beyond their standard surface, polished to make it so uniform The Planck Payload which has a primary mirror measuring other objects can best be studied with usage of 80–100ºC. that its bumps are smaller than a few The overall design of Planck’s Payload 2.0x1.5 m. Herschel (top) and Planck will be launched jointly by the most (far-) infrared telescopes situated in deep Module emerged from a design process Verifying the cryogenic performance powerful version of Ariane-5 into a direct transfer orbit to L2 space, well away from the restrictions that had to satisfy competing needs: of Planck under realistic conditions was imposed by the Earth and its shielding the sensitive radiometers from a true challenge. A dedicated test centre atmosphere. the heat of the satellite and microwave demonstrated the performance of the Planck will be able to find and map ESA’s Herschel and Planck observa- radiation from the Sun, Earth and passive radiators at about 60K by regions where the temperature varies tories will help to provide answers to Moon, while generating an all-sky map cooling the facility’s inner surfaces to from the average by a few parts in a some of the most vexing questions now by slowly spinning once every minute below 20K with liquid helium. million. These tiny differences in the being asked in modern science: how did around an axis pointing directly away Equally challenging was the veri- CMB are like the marks in a fossil, the Universe begin, how did it evolve to from the Sun. fication of the alignment and radio- revealing details about the organism what we see today, and how will it evolve Planck’s highly sensitive detectors frequency performance at the they come from – in this case, the in the future? They will be throwing new have to work at temperatures very close operational 60K. Measurement at the physical processes at the beginning of light on an old story. to absolute zero, or else their own heat Planck frequencies and in cryogenic the Universe. emissions would spoil the measurements. conditions is not possible on Earth, so Planck’s baseline mission calls for two Acknowledgement The satellite therefore has a sophisticated verification has to be done by complete scans of the sky during an The authors express their thanks to system of coolers. combining analyses and test results. initial 15 months of observations. Clive Simpson (www.simcomm-europe. Planck’s detectors will convert the com) for his contribution in writing the strengths of the microwave signals into Status article. e Planck’s off-axis aplanatic telescope combines a clear optical path units of temperature. The average Planck’s flight instruments are now with compactness. The eccentricity and tilt of the secondary temperature of the CMB is well known being integrated into the satellite at Detailed information on Herschel and Planck can be mirror and the off-axis angle allow a large focal plane detector at –270.3ºC but there are variations of Alcatel Alenia Space in Cannes (F). found at www.esa.int/science array, while minimising the polarisation introduced by the Scientific information is available at telescope. The telescope is seen here being prepared for thermal- roughly one part in 100 000 around the Herschel’s instruments will closely sci.esa.int/herschel & sci.esa.int/planck vacuum testing at ESTEC sky. follow: they will be integrated into the

16 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 17 Passvogel 11/9/06 4:09 PM Page 16

Science Herschel/Planck

The telescope’s line-of-sight is inclined satellite in early 2007 at Astrium in at 85º to the spin axis so that the Friedrichshafen (D). These parallel instruments scan a ring of the celestial programmes are approaching their final sphere once per spacecraft revolution, integration and test period before the and the whole sky in half a year. In launch in 2008. order to view the celestial poles, the spin axis can be moved up to 10º away from Conclusion the anti-Sun direction. Engineers from numerous European The Payload Module is dominated by space companies have worked together three conical radiators that thermally on the design, construction and testing insulate the two reflectors, the detector of ESA’s Herschel and Planck observa- Planck's LFI, an array of radiometers, under calibration testing focal plane and the surrounding black tories, overcoming many challenges that baffle from the Service Module. have pushed technology to new limits. thousandths of a millimetre. Equally The black baffle is a powerful radiator Credit must also go to the hundreds of important, it has to be strong enough to for passively precooling the active three- scientists from specialist institutions withstand harsh conditions. At launch it stage cooling chain to around 60K. across Europe and the United States for Planck’s cryocooling chain will be shaken with a force several times Further cooling of the detectors is designing and developing the suite of that of Earth gravity before going performed via a cascade: 20K by a highly sensitive instruments that will Herschel’s cryostat design was Other technical issues that had to be through drastic temperature changes, continuous hydrogen sorption cooler, operate to the tightest of tolerances at inherited from ESA’s successful ISO overcome during manufacture included from about 20ºC at launch to an average 4K by a mechanical cooler and 100mK temperatures close to absolute zero. mission, but it was still a major the mass-optimised carbon-fibre face of –200ºC in space. by mixing normal helium with a rare Infrared astronomy itself is still a challenge to design capable instruments sheets, which had to be re-manufactured The mirror segments are built from helium isotope. young and exciting science, but with very low heat demands on the several times to find the best silicon carbide, a stable material with the Planck’s two scientific instruments are astronomers studying this part of the cryogenic cooling system in order to compromise between flatness, strength combined advantages of metal and the Low Frequency Instrument (LFI), spectrum have already unveiled tens of reach the mission’s desired lifetime. and mass. glass. It is light and easily polishable, an array of radio receivers using high thousands of new galaxies and made The lightweight carbon-fibre The design requirements on the resists stress and fatigue, and withstands electron mobility transistor mixers, and surprising discoveries. sunshield was difficult to build and, primary mirror were also demanding. It low and high temperatures without any the High Frequency Instrument (HFI), Yet scientists know there is still much owing to the high operating temperature has to be light enough to be placed into notable changes of mechanical and an array of highly sensitive microwave more to find and processes such as the (140–170ºC) of the solar cells, its triple- a distant orbit 1.5 million km from thermal properties. detectors known as bolometers. They growth of structure in the early Universe junction gallium arsenide cells had to be Earth but have an extremely smooth share the off-axis aplanatic telescope, and consequent birth of galaxies and further qualified beyond their standard surface, polished to make it so uniform The Planck Payload which has a primary mirror measuring other objects can best be studied with usage of 80–100ºC. that its bumps are smaller than a few The overall design of Planck’s Payload 2.0x1.5 m. Herschel (top) and Planck will be launched jointly by the most (far-) infrared telescopes situated in deep Module emerged from a design process Verifying the cryogenic performance powerful version of Ariane-5 into a direct transfer orbit to L2 space, well away from the restrictions that had to satisfy competing needs: of Planck under realistic conditions was imposed by the Earth and its shielding the sensitive radiometers from a true challenge. A dedicated test centre atmosphere. the heat of the satellite and microwave demonstrated the performance of the Planck will be able to find and map ESA’s Herschel and Planck observa- radiation from the Sun, Earth and passive radiators at about 60K by regions where the temperature varies tories will help to provide answers to Moon, while generating an all-sky map cooling the facility’s inner surfaces to from the average by a few parts in a some of the most vexing questions now by slowly spinning once every minute below 20K with liquid helium. million. These tiny differences in the being asked in modern science: how did around an axis pointing directly away Equally challenging was the veri- CMB are like the marks in a fossil, the Universe begin, how did it evolve to from the Sun. fication of the alignment and radio- revealing details about the organism what we see today, and how will it evolve Planck’s highly sensitive detectors frequency performance at the they come from – in this case, the in the future? They will be throwing new have to work at temperatures very close operational 60K. Measurement at the physical processes at the beginning of light on an old story. to absolute zero, or else their own heat Planck frequencies and in cryogenic the Universe. emissions would spoil the measurements. conditions is not possible on Earth, so Planck’s baseline mission calls for two Acknowledgement The satellite therefore has a sophisticated verification has to be done by complete scans of the sky during an The authors express their thanks to system of coolers. combining analyses and test results. initial 15 months of observations. Clive Simpson (www.simcomm-europe. Planck’s detectors will convert the com) for his contribution in writing the strengths of the microwave signals into Status article. e Planck’s off-axis aplanatic telescope combines a clear optical path units of temperature. The average Planck’s flight instruments are now with compactness. The eccentricity and tilt of the secondary temperature of the CMB is well known being integrated into the satellite at Detailed information on Herschel and Planck can be mirror and the off-axis angle allow a large focal plane detector at –270.3ºC but there are variations of Alcatel Alenia Space in Cannes (F). found at www.esa.int/science array, while minimising the polarisation introduced by the Scientific information is available at telescope. The telescope is seen here being prepared for thermal- roughly one part in 100 000 around the Herschel’s instruments will closely sci.esa.int/herschel & sci.esa.int/planck vacuum testing at ESTEC sky. follow: they will be integrated into the

16 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 17 Winkler 11/9/06 4:12 PM Page 18

Integral

Christoph Winkler Astrophysics and Fundamental Physics Missions Division, Research and Scientific Support Cannibalism in Space: Department, Directorate of Scientific Programmes, ESTEC, Noordwijk, The Netherlands

Peter Kretschmar A Star Eats its Astronomy Science Operations Division, Research and Scientific Support Department, Directorate of Scientific Programmes, ESAC, Villafranca, Spain

Michael Schmidt Companion Mission Operations Department, Directorate of Technical and Operational Support, ESOC, Darmstadt, Germany

he work of ESA’s Integral high-energy tobservatory usually follows a long-term Ttplan that is established every year by selecting only the very best of the numerous observing proposals from the scientific community. However, nature does not always follow the same plan, so Integral and the people who keep it running have to react to unforeseen and sudden ‘Targets of Opportunity’. The case here is neutron star IGR J00291+5934, an incredibly dense object with a mass similar to that of our Sun’s compressed into a rapidly spinning sphere only a few kilometres across. Not only that, but it is busy swallowing its stellar companion. Introduction The Integral mission The scientific research with ESA’s Integral (INTErnational Gamma-Ray Astrophysics Laboratory), launched on 17 October 2002, focuses on celestial A (Typical?) Integral objects that radiate in the energy band between 10 000 and 10 million electron volts (eV). On average, these gamma- Observation of the rays are 10 000 to 10 million times more energetic than the photons reaching our eyes from the Sun and stars. They are High-Energy Sky generated by the most energetic and

esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 19 Winkler 11/9/06 4:12 PM Page 18

Integral

Christoph Winkler Astrophysics and Fundamental Physics Missions Division, Research and Scientific Support Cannibalism in Space: Department, Directorate of Scientific Programmes, ESTEC, Noordwijk, The Netherlands

Peter Kretschmar A Star Eats its Astronomy Science Operations Division, Research and Scientific Support Department, Directorate of Scientific Programmes, ESAC, Villafranca, Spain

Michael Schmidt Companion Mission Operations Department, Directorate of Technical and Operational Support, ESOC, Darmstadt, Germany

he work of ESA’s Integral high-energy tobservatory usually follows a long-term Ttplan that is established every year by selecting only the very best of the numerous observing proposals from the scientific community. However, nature does not always follow the same plan, so Integral and the people who keep it running have to react to unforeseen and sudden ‘Targets of Opportunity’. The case here is neutron star IGR J00291+5934, an incredibly dense object with a mass similar to that of our Sun’s compressed into a rapidly spinning sphere only a few kilometres across. Not only that, but it is busy swallowing its stellar companion. Introduction The Integral mission The scientific research with ESA’s Integral (INTErnational Gamma-Ray Astrophysics Laboratory), launched on 17 October 2002, focuses on celestial A (Typical?) Integral objects that radiate in the energy band between 10 000 and 10 million electron volts (eV). On average, these gamma- Observation of the rays are 10 000 to 10 million times more energetic than the photons reaching our eyes from the Sun and stars. They are High-Energy Sky generated by the most energetic and

esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 19 Winkler 11/9/06 4:12 PM Page 20

Science Integral

violent events in the Universe. Integral data are downlinked in real-time to the detects these high-energy photons using ground stations and then forwarded to two main gamma-ray instruments: the the Integral Science Data Centre in SPI spectrometer provides precise Versoix (CH), where they are processed Gamma-ray bursts are the spectral information, and the IBIS and archived before being dispatched to most powerful explosions in camera images the objects with high the proposers for scientific analysis. the Universe accuracy. They are supplemented by two Usually, therefore, the observing monitoring instruments covering the programme follows a sequence planned soft X-ray range below 10 000 eV for the entire year, until a new set of (JEM-X) and the optical wavelength proposals is solicited and selected. band (OMC). For a detailed description At this point, readers may conclude of Integral, its instruments, performance that operating Integral is a routine and ground segment, see the set of matter, with very little to be done on the articles in Bulletin 111, August 2002. ground after the observing programme The celestial objects of interest to the has been established and sent to the Integral views electron-positron annihilation at the centre of our scientists using Integral include black spacecraft. Galaxy (J. Knödleseder et al., Astron. Astrophys., vol 441, p513, holes in our Galaxy and local galaxies, However, this is far from the truth. 2005) neutron stars, X-ray binary stars, pulsars, remnants of supernova The variable high-energy sky astronomy). This means that the data explosions and gamma-ray bursts. A key characteristic of the high-energy can be easily analysed and exciting new Studying the gamma-ray emission lines sky is that a large majority of the scientific results are obtained almost from the radioactive decay of excited gamma-ray sources vary with time. every time. This is what makes these heavy atomic nuclei or from the Some previously regarded as steady observations so exciting. annihilation of electrons with their display sudden outbursts on every Most of these events are positron anti-matter equivalents is also intensity scale. Others have regular unpredictable by their very nature, so important. outbursts. Sky areas supposed to be they are commonly called ‘Targets of empty suddenly reveal new sources; Opportunities’ (ToOs). Any mission The observing programme these often turn out to be previously exploring this energy regime should be Integral is operated like a ground-based undetected persistent but weak sources prepared to react rapidly to such observatory, with the vast majority of its that suddenly burst into life for an dramatic events. The Integral observing time used by astronomers at large. arbitrary period. Some sources may programme, stored in a database, Proposals by the scientific community vary with a quite regular pattern, known already contains a number of accepted for Integral observations are solicited by from observations before Integral was ToO observation proposals that can be ESA once a year and assessed by the launched. activated if the unique event described Time Allocation Committee. Then, The reason for all this variability lies in the proposal really happens. In that scientists at the Integral Science in the nature of these sources. Many are respect, we are not totally unprepared. Why Observe Gamma-rays? Operations Centre (ISOC) in ESA’s in binary stellar systems, and material The entire ground network needs to European Space Astronomy Centre from the companion star is accreted be prepared because an alert could be Light, or electromagnetic radiation, glows in radio waves, infrared, For example, some chemical elements (ESAC, E) create a long-term observing onto the compact object. This accretion received from either the external science comes in many forms. There are radio ultraviolet and X-rays. Some objects are created during explosions in plan. This is an optimised sequence of process, which releases large amounts of community or ISDC at any time waves, microwaves, infrared light, emit only radio waves or X-rays. This which individual stars blow visible light, ultraviolet light, X-rays is why it is important to study the themselves to pieces. The new observations (targets, pointings and energy, can appear to be highly variable – 7 days a week, 24 hours a day. In the and gamma rays, all of which form Universe with various kinds of space chemicals leave gamma-ray exposure durations), taking into for a range of reasons: the radiation may case of Integral, the call could come the ‘electromagnetic spectrum’. Oddly observatories. fingerprints in the fireball for account all the scheduling constraints, be temporarily blocked from view by the from the astronomers at ISDC enough, visible light – to which astronomers to find. By studying Integral is concentrating on the such as spacecraft pointing avoidance companion, nuclear explosions on the monitoring the data as they are received, human eyes are sensitive – is the these, Integral is piecing together how gamma-rays. These are produced by zones and observations that have to be surface of the compact object, pointing out that something strange is smallest band of all. To our eyes, these chemicals are created. spectacular events such as stars what we see seems like the entire performed at particular times. The reconnections of intense twisted going on in the sky right now – an exploding, matter falling into black Integral is also studying the Universe, but there is much more out Mission Operations Centre (MOC) in magnetic fields, or the continuous fast opportunity not to be missed! holes and celestial objects colliding. mysterious blasts known as gamma- there. ESA’s European Space Operations rotation of the dense object (a ‘pulsar’). Such an alert was received by the By collecting gamma-rays, ray bursts. These explode at random Different types of objects in the astronomers can see these violent in distant realms and are probably Centre (ESOC, Darmstadt, D) translates In other words, the high-energy sky Integral team on 5 December 2004, Universe emit different types of events and judge how they shape the caused by the collision of neutron this plan into a sequence of spacecraft looks like a Christmas tree, with candles when Maurizio Falanga from the radiation. Our Sun is a rather obvious Universe. stars or perhaps the explosion of commands for uplinking to Integral flickering at every time scale imaginable. Commissariat à l’Energie Atomique source of visible light. But it also large stars. from one of the ground stations, in Many of these outbursts are relatively (CEA), Saclay (F) requested that the Redu (B) or Goldstone (USA). bright and provide plenty of photons spacecraft be repointed towards a When a target has been observed, the (which are rather scarce in gamma-ray powerful new source as soon as possible.

20 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 21 Winkler 11/9/06 4:12 PM Page 20

Science Integral

violent events in the Universe. Integral data are downlinked in real-time to the detects these high-energy photons using ground stations and then forwarded to two main gamma-ray instruments: the the Integral Science Data Centre in SPI spectrometer provides precise Versoix (CH), where they are processed Gamma-ray bursts are the spectral information, and the IBIS and archived before being dispatched to most powerful explosions in camera images the objects with high the proposers for scientific analysis. the Universe accuracy. They are supplemented by two Usually, therefore, the observing monitoring instruments covering the programme follows a sequence planned soft X-ray range below 10 000 eV for the entire year, until a new set of (JEM-X) and the optical wavelength proposals is solicited and selected. band (OMC). For a detailed description At this point, readers may conclude of Integral, its instruments, performance that operating Integral is a routine and ground segment, see the set of matter, with very little to be done on the articles in Bulletin 111, August 2002. ground after the observing programme The celestial objects of interest to the has been established and sent to the Integral views electron-positron annihilation at the centre of our scientists using Integral include black spacecraft. Galaxy (J. Knödleseder et al., Astron. Astrophys., vol 441, p513, holes in our Galaxy and local galaxies, However, this is far from the truth. 2005) neutron stars, X-ray binary stars, pulsars, remnants of supernova The variable high-energy sky astronomy). This means that the data explosions and gamma-ray bursts. A key characteristic of the high-energy can be easily analysed and exciting new Studying the gamma-ray emission lines sky is that a large majority of the scientific results are obtained almost from the radioactive decay of excited gamma-ray sources vary with time. every time. This is what makes these heavy atomic nuclei or from the Some previously regarded as steady observations so exciting. annihilation of electrons with their display sudden outbursts on every Most of these events are positron anti-matter equivalents is also intensity scale. Others have regular unpredictable by their very nature, so important. outbursts. Sky areas supposed to be they are commonly called ‘Targets of empty suddenly reveal new sources; Opportunities’ (ToOs). Any mission The observing programme these often turn out to be previously exploring this energy regime should be Integral is operated like a ground-based undetected persistent but weak sources prepared to react rapidly to such observatory, with the vast majority of its that suddenly burst into life for an dramatic events. The Integral observing time used by astronomers at large. arbitrary period. Some sources may programme, stored in a database, Proposals by the scientific community vary with a quite regular pattern, known already contains a number of accepted for Integral observations are solicited by from observations before Integral was ToO observation proposals that can be ESA once a year and assessed by the launched. activated if the unique event described Time Allocation Committee. Then, The reason for all this variability lies in the proposal really happens. In that scientists at the Integral Science in the nature of these sources. Many are respect, we are not totally unprepared. Why Observe Gamma-rays? Operations Centre (ISOC) in ESA’s in binary stellar systems, and material The entire ground network needs to European Space Astronomy Centre from the companion star is accreted be prepared because an alert could be Light, or electromagnetic radiation, glows in radio waves, infrared, For example, some chemical elements (ESAC, E) create a long-term observing onto the compact object. This accretion received from either the external science comes in many forms. There are radio ultraviolet and X-rays. Some objects are created during explosions in plan. This is an optimised sequence of process, which releases large amounts of community or ISDC at any time waves, microwaves, infrared light, emit only radio waves or X-rays. This which individual stars blow visible light, ultraviolet light, X-rays is why it is important to study the themselves to pieces. The new observations (targets, pointings and energy, can appear to be highly variable – 7 days a week, 24 hours a day. In the and gamma rays, all of which form Universe with various kinds of space chemicals leave gamma-ray exposure durations), taking into for a range of reasons: the radiation may case of Integral, the call could come the ‘electromagnetic spectrum’. Oddly observatories. fingerprints in the fireball for account all the scheduling constraints, be temporarily blocked from view by the from the astronomers at ISDC enough, visible light – to which astronomers to find. By studying Integral is concentrating on the such as spacecraft pointing avoidance companion, nuclear explosions on the monitoring the data as they are received, human eyes are sensitive – is the these, Integral is piecing together how gamma-rays. These are produced by zones and observations that have to be surface of the compact object, pointing out that something strange is smallest band of all. To our eyes, these chemicals are created. spectacular events such as stars what we see seems like the entire performed at particular times. The reconnections of intense twisted going on in the sky right now – an exploding, matter falling into black Integral is also studying the Universe, but there is much more out Mission Operations Centre (MOC) in magnetic fields, or the continuous fast opportunity not to be missed! holes and celestial objects colliding. mysterious blasts known as gamma- there. ESA’s European Space Operations rotation of the dense object (a ‘pulsar’). Such an alert was received by the By collecting gamma-rays, ray bursts. These explode at random Different types of objects in the astronomers can see these violent in distant realms and are probably Centre (ESOC, Darmstadt, D) translates In other words, the high-energy sky Integral team on 5 December 2004, Universe emit different types of events and judge how they shape the caused by the collision of neutron this plan into a sequence of spacecraft looks like a Christmas tree, with candles when Maurizio Falanga from the radiation. Our Sun is a rather obvious Universe. stars or perhaps the explosion of commands for uplinking to Integral flickering at every time scale imaginable. Commissariat à l’Energie Atomique source of visible light. But it also large stars. from one of the ground stations, in Many of these outbursts are relatively (CEA), Saclay (F) requested that the Redu (B) or Goldstone (USA). bright and provide plenty of photons spacecraft be repointed towards a When a target has been observed, the (which are rather scarce in gamma-ray powerful new source as soon as possible.

20 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 21 Winkler 11/9/06 4:12 PM Page 22

Science Integral

criteria were indeed Winkler, who has the last word on the The Integral control room at ESOC. From left to right: Orlane Bergogne (Spacecraft Operations Engineer, SOE), checking the met and the location planning of scientific observations. So The discovery of IGR J00291+5934 by Integral’s instrument configuration; Michael Schmidt (Spacecraft Operations IBIS camera. The image is 3º high and 6.25º of the source did not now his Sunday afternoon was also Manager, SOM) supervising the replanning activities; Salma across; pixel size is 5 arcmin. (M. Falanga et al., violate any spacecraft interrupted. The two scientists discussed Fahmy (Mission Planner) performing the replanning; Paolo Lippi Astron. Astrophys., vol 444, p15, 2005) pointing constraints. the case and Christoph evaluated the (Analyst) checking the consistency of the database; Atef Soliman The next question was impact of accepting the ToO, both (SPACON) loading the new timeline; Federico di Marco (Attitude & Orbit Control System Operations Engineer) checking the slew the requested reaction scientifically and operationally. Finally, sequence time: this turned out the decision was clear: the requested to be rather short, observation should be done as soon as within a day, if possible. comments (“Oh, not another ToO!”), possible. This meant MOC contacted ISOC to discuss the that the planning for Reshuffling the programme proposed replanning. the current 3-day orbit By now it was nearly 16:00. Quickly, In the planning process, ISOC provides around the Earth Erik informed the lucky observer that a set of data files, including the Preferred would have to be his observation would be scheduled and Observation Sequence (POS), which changed, always a called colleagues at MOC in Darmstadt, defines the required science operations delicate task for the whose weekend routine was also to be and provides the information that MOC MOC, who have to upset as the observing programme was needs to generate the spacecraft merge the old and new about to be reshuffled. First, a suitable commands. The problems with this ToO planning seamlessly. slot within the ongoing observation was that the operations of the affected Finally, the long-term programme had to be found, keeping in revolution were already taking place. The Changing Plans planning for the current and upcoming mind both the pressure to start this ToO official lead time for the replanning was It was a quiet Sunday in December. Erik orbits was reviewed to see which as soon as possible and the requirement 8 hours, including a small margin. Kuulkers, the ISOC duty scientist was observations could be shifted to later in to give Darmstadt enough time for the The feedback from ISOC was: “We enjoying the weekend and a nice Sunday order to accommodate the imminent necessary checks and verifications on have the approval by the Project Scientist lunch at home. Suddenly, at 13:37, the ToO, if accepted. The current main their side. And there was an additional observations of the ToO would begin on were scheduled for Wednesday night as that the ToO is so important that we peace was interrupted by a familiar target was supernova remnant Cas A, a complication: a short calibration Monday afternoon, less than 24 hours part of the next orbit.) should override the planned observations beep: a text on his mobile phone. Most very long observation that had not been observation that could not be moved from the time of planning, but late and we have sent a revised POS.” of the time this means work ahead. A easy to fit into the overall available time. around freely. enough so that MOC’s main activities Getting Integral Ready “Well”, MOC told ISOC, “we hope quick check confirmed that a request to With all the facts collected, Erik called Evaluating all the constraints, Erik could be performed on Monday morning. Monday started as any other day during that a RWB [Reaction Wheel Bias to trigger a ToO observation of the Integral Project Scientist, Christoph settled for a plan in which the first Trying to create the changed planning Integral’s routine operations phase. The offload the wheels] has been introduced IGR J00291+5934 had indeed just been files, Erik encountered another difficulty: Spacecraft Controllers (SPACONs) before the first slew.” received by the Integral helpdesk a strange problem with inserting the performed the shift hand-over, the It was at this point that the Flight computers. Abandoning his plans for a necessary ‘Reaction Wheel Bias’ (more Spacecraft Operations Manager (SOM) Dynamics (FD) team got involved. The calm pre-Christmas Sunday, Erik went on this below). Cursing his luck at arrived and talked to the SPACON on Mission Planner informed the on-call off to work. running up against such an issue on a shift to get the latest news, and the rest of FD staff, and warned him that a Sunday, he tried several options but the Flight Control Team of Analysts and replanned POS (RPOS) had arrived and Checks and balances finally sent the planning files as they Spacecraft Operations Engineers (SOEs) had to be processed. Some parts of the Upon arrival at the ISOC, the first task were to MOC to give his colleagues a arrived one after the other. During the processing are automated, but there is was clear: verify that the request was chance to evaluate the new slews and status checks, the need for replanning the still a considerable amount of manual justified. In many cases, there is already pointing positions on the sky. By 18:15, ongoing orbit was identified because effort. Therefore, everyone met in the an accepted observation proposal with all the files had been sent, the observer there was fresh input from ISOC over the control room. specific criteria to activate it. Of course, had been informed about the intended weekend. Since there was no The RPOS file is imported manually, the astronomers know the criteria that schedule of his first observations, the accompanying alert for an immediate as opposed to the fully automatic they or the Time Allocation Committee scientific community at large using process and since the automatic import for the routine POS files. The FD have set. But in the excitement to get Integral had been informed about the processing of the planning file did not and the Flight Control Team checked their chance, astronomers frequently try change in the observing programme, reveal any urgency, the replanning was the file by eye, in particular to verify that to trigger an observation without and the duty scientist could leave to postponed to later on Monday morning. all the RPOS rules were met. “Uh-oh!” checking these criteria, reacting enjoy what was left of his weekend. The The activities at MOC started again There was no RWB before the first slew. prematurely. But not in this case – the current observations did not cover all of when SOM Michael Schmidt contacted “Well, the time of divergence is in about the requested time, but the rest could be Mission Planner Salma Fahmy with a 4 hours and luckily there was an RWB planned more calmly, after the results call along the corridor: “We’ve got a planned in about 2 hours. If we can get Erik Kuulkers, Operations Scientist on duty at ISOC, studies the from the first observation had been Target of Opportunity that requires some the RPOS processed by then, there should target visibility map for the ToO observation evaluated. (The remaining observations replanning”. After the usual round of be no problem.”

22 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 23 Winkler 11/9/06 4:12 PM Page 22

Science Integral

criteria were indeed Winkler, who has the last word on the The Integral control room at ESOC. From left to right: Orlane Bergogne (Spacecraft Operations Engineer, SOE), checking the met and the location planning of scientific observations. So The discovery of IGR J00291+5934 by Integral’s instrument configuration; Michael Schmidt (Spacecraft Operations IBIS camera. The image is 3º high and 6.25º of the source did not now his Sunday afternoon was also Manager, SOM) supervising the replanning activities; Salma across; pixel size is 5 arcmin. (M. Falanga et al., violate any spacecraft interrupted. The two scientists discussed Fahmy (Mission Planner) performing the replanning; Paolo Lippi Astron. Astrophys., vol 444, p15, 2005) pointing constraints. the case and Christoph evaluated the (Analyst) checking the consistency of the database; Atef Soliman The next question was impact of accepting the ToO, both (SPACON) loading the new timeline; Federico di Marco (Attitude & Orbit Control System Operations Engineer) checking the slew the requested reaction scientifically and operationally. Finally, sequence time: this turned out the decision was clear: the requested to be rather short, observation should be done as soon as within a day, if possible. comments (“Oh, not another ToO!”), possible. This meant MOC contacted ISOC to discuss the that the planning for Reshuffling the programme proposed replanning. the current 3-day orbit By now it was nearly 16:00. Quickly, In the planning process, ISOC provides around the Earth Erik informed the lucky observer that a set of data files, including the Preferred would have to be his observation would be scheduled and Observation Sequence (POS), which changed, always a called colleagues at MOC in Darmstadt, defines the required science operations delicate task for the whose weekend routine was also to be and provides the information that MOC MOC, who have to upset as the observing programme was needs to generate the spacecraft merge the old and new about to be reshuffled. First, a suitable commands. The problems with this ToO planning seamlessly. slot within the ongoing observation was that the operations of the affected Finally, the long-term programme had to be found, keeping in revolution were already taking place. The Changing Plans planning for the current and upcoming mind both the pressure to start this ToO official lead time for the replanning was It was a quiet Sunday in December. Erik orbits was reviewed to see which as soon as possible and the requirement 8 hours, including a small margin. Kuulkers, the ISOC duty scientist was observations could be shifted to later in to give Darmstadt enough time for the The feedback from ISOC was: “We enjoying the weekend and a nice Sunday order to accommodate the imminent necessary checks and verifications on have the approval by the Project Scientist lunch at home. Suddenly, at 13:37, the ToO, if accepted. The current main their side. And there was an additional observations of the ToO would begin on were scheduled for Wednesday night as that the ToO is so important that we peace was interrupted by a familiar target was supernova remnant Cas A, a complication: a short calibration Monday afternoon, less than 24 hours part of the next orbit.) should override the planned observations beep: a text on his mobile phone. Most very long observation that had not been observation that could not be moved from the time of planning, but late and we have sent a revised POS.” of the time this means work ahead. A easy to fit into the overall available time. around freely. enough so that MOC’s main activities Getting Integral Ready “Well”, MOC told ISOC, “we hope quick check confirmed that a request to With all the facts collected, Erik called Evaluating all the constraints, Erik could be performed on Monday morning. Monday started as any other day during that a RWB [Reaction Wheel Bias to trigger a ToO observation of the Integral Project Scientist, Christoph settled for a plan in which the first Trying to create the changed planning Integral’s routine operations phase. The offload the wheels] has been introduced IGR J00291+5934 had indeed just been files, Erik encountered another difficulty: Spacecraft Controllers (SPACONs) before the first slew.” received by the Integral helpdesk a strange problem with inserting the performed the shift hand-over, the It was at this point that the Flight computers. Abandoning his plans for a necessary ‘Reaction Wheel Bias’ (more Spacecraft Operations Manager (SOM) Dynamics (FD) team got involved. The calm pre-Christmas Sunday, Erik went on this below). Cursing his luck at arrived and talked to the SPACON on Mission Planner informed the on-call off to work. running up against such an issue on a shift to get the latest news, and the rest of FD staff, and warned him that a Sunday, he tried several options but the Flight Control Team of Analysts and replanned POS (RPOS) had arrived and Checks and balances finally sent the planning files as they Spacecraft Operations Engineers (SOEs) had to be processed. Some parts of the Upon arrival at the ISOC, the first task were to MOC to give his colleagues a arrived one after the other. During the processing are automated, but there is was clear: verify that the request was chance to evaluate the new slews and status checks, the need for replanning the still a considerable amount of manual justified. In many cases, there is already pointing positions on the sky. By 18:15, ongoing orbit was identified because effort. Therefore, everyone met in the an accepted observation proposal with all the files had been sent, the observer there was fresh input from ISOC over the control room. specific criteria to activate it. Of course, had been informed about the intended weekend. Since there was no The RPOS file is imported manually, the astronomers know the criteria that schedule of his first observations, the accompanying alert for an immediate as opposed to the fully automatic they or the Time Allocation Committee scientific community at large using process and since the automatic import for the routine POS files. The FD have set. But in the excitement to get Integral had been informed about the processing of the planning file did not and the Flight Control Team checked their chance, astronomers frequently try change in the observing programme, reveal any urgency, the replanning was the file by eye, in particular to verify that to trigger an observation without and the duty scientist could leave to postponed to later on Monday morning. all the RPOS rules were met. “Uh-oh!” checking these criteria, reacting enjoy what was left of his weekend. The The activities at MOC started again There was no RWB before the first slew. prematurely. But not in this case – the current observations did not cover all of when SOM Michael Schmidt contacted “Well, the time of divergence is in about the requested time, but the rest could be Mission Planner Salma Fahmy with a 4 hours and luckily there was an RWB planned more calmly, after the results call along the corridor: “We’ve got a planned in about 2 hours. If we can get Erik Kuulkers, Operations Scientist on duty at ISOC, studies the from the first observation had been Target of Opportunity that requires some the RPOS processed by then, there should target visibility map for the ToO observation evaluated. (The remaining observations replanning”. After the usual round of be no problem.”

22 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 23 Winkler 11/9/06 4:12 PM Page 24

Science Integral

A quick call was made to ISOC to let consisting of neutrons. Often, they are photons from these spots, finding they system is very small: the stars are so it cannibalises its companion. Over them know and check that this approach also rapidly spinning pulsars. Discovered account for most of the emission at close that they would fit into the radius about 100 000 years, the spin will speed was acceptable; the rest of the by radio astronomers about 50 years ago, energies above 30 000 eV. The key of the Sun. The observations support up by 0.6%, from 1.67 millisec to processing got underway. All aspects of pulsars beam electromagnetic radiation observation behind this result was the the theory that the two stars are close 1.66 millisec. the POS were checked, some visually from their polar regions, like a fact that Integral measured gamma-ray enough for accretion: material is flowing such as the instrument mode parameters lighthouse sweeping its beam across the pulsed emission from IGR J00291+5934 from the companion into a disc around Conclusions and telemetry bandwidth allocation, Earth at regular intervals. The extreme up to energies of 150 000 eV exactly in the neutron star before falling to its The observations of this ToO show that and some by the FD software, such as regularity of the pulse intervals makes phase with the 1.6 millisec X-ray surface. If this process continues, the nature always has surprises and new attitude constraints. them the most precise clocks in the pulsations recorded by RXTE. This companion will be completely consumed questions to offer. Space observatories About an hour later, the RPOS had A neutron star pulsar consumes material from its close stellar Universe – much better than even proves that the observed high-energy by the much smaller star. This such as Integral, with their dedicated been processed, the Enhanced POS companion atomic clocks on Earth. emission must be connected with the conclusion can be drawn once a change operational staff, are ideally suited to (EPOS) and the corresponding timeline polar regions emitting the lighthouse- in the spin period is observed. Neutron providing the right tools to find the had been generated, and it was time to The ToO Observations of IGR J00291+5934 The fastest accreting millisecond-pulsar beam radiation. Before this, such high- stars – spinning rapidly at birth – answers. Over its first 3.5 years of make the switch to the new timeline. It This ‘new’ source was serendipitously On 3 December 2004, using Integral’s energy photons had never been seen in gradually slow down after a few operations, Integral has observed 29 was important to find a gap in the discovered by Integral within its wide data of the discovery made the day the pulsed emission from these objects. hundred thousand years. Neutron stars Targets of Opportunity for a total of timeline when there was no commanding field-of-view during a routine short before, and 2 days before the Integral in binary systems, however, can do the almost 8 million seconds. x e in order to stop the Autostack on the observation around the constellation alert was submitted, scientists observed Cannibals at work opposite, accelerated by the angular control system, abort the old timeline Cassiopeia, in the outer reaches of the the object with NASA’s Rossi X-ray Using the timing information on IGR momentum of the in-falling material and load the new one. (Of course, before Milky Way, when it suddenly flared on Timing Explorer (RXTE), a satellite J00291+5934, it was found that the from the companion. For the first time, Detailed information on Integral and its mission can applying the new timeline the 2 December 2004. It was designated as specialised in high-precision X-ray companion star is perhaps as small as 40 this speeding up was observed directly in be found at http://www.esa.int/SPECIALS/Integral/ paperwork had to be completed. All the IGR J00291+5934, where IGR denotes timing measurements. These revealed Jupiter masses. The two stars orbit one high-energy data. This is direct evidence and http://integral.esac.esa.int/ planning products were cross-checked an ‘Integral Gamma-Ray’ source, and that it was a pulsar, or more precisely an another in only 2.5 hours. The binary for the star spinning faster and faster, as and signed by the various people the numbers give the coordinates on the ‘X-ray millisecond pulsar’. IGR responsible.) With about 4000 commands sky. On this day, the source proved to be J00291+5934 emits around 600 pulses a in one timeline, the loading took a few bright enough to warrant a dedicated, second, one of the fastest known. This minutes. In addition, the running FD longer Integral observation for in-depth corresponds to a rotational period of software tasks had to be stopped and investigation. Normally these sources this solar-mass object of only 1.67 new ones scheduled for the new timeline. stay bright for a few days, but some millisec (37 500 rpm!). This is much So a window of at least 10 minutes was transient sources unexpectedly fade in faster than most other pulsars in binary needed. Owing to the observational less than a day without warning. So it is systems, which rotate every few seconds. pattern of a slew every 30 minutes always exciting to await the outcome of (For comparison, the Sun takes about followed by a period of stable pointing the observation and analysis of the data. 25 days.) Only a few isolated (radio) with no commanding, finding a slot was In this case, the observations were highly pulsars are known to spin even faster. not a problem. It was decided to upload successful and the results were rapidly So, IGR J00291+5934 could be the the new timeline after the next slew. published in the leading scientific ‘missing link’ between the relatively slow The Mission Planner, SPACON and journal Astronomy and Astrophysics (see accreting pulsars in binary systems and FD observed the end of the slew and also the ESA news release at the very fast isolated pulsars, having waited for the FD job to run to update http://www.esa.int/esaSC/SEM finally lost their companions in their old the parameters for the next slew. “Ding- WSAA5QCE_index_2.html). age. dong!” This was the notification by the What did we learn from these control system that the update had observations? Photons from polar regions arrived. “Action!” Many neutron stars have strong The SPACON aborted the timeline, Neutron stars and pulsars magnetic fields, which were frozen in FD rescheduled the jobs, the new Pulsars are rotating neutron stars, which during the collapse of their progenitors. timeline was loaded, the updated Task are created during stellar explosions. This can create incredibly strong Parameter File was applied to the new They are the remnants of stars of 8–10 magnetic fields for a small, city-sized timeline, all associated documents were times the Sun’s mass that ended their neutron star. Charged particles in the updated – and the job was done. lives in supernova explosions. These accreting flow are channelled along Everyone resumed their routine work remnants still contain about the mass of these magnetic field lines onto the polar as Integral’s instruments observed the our Sun but concentrated in a 10–20 km regions of the neutron star (like solar new target. The data were routed within diameter! The extreme pressure forces particles in Earth’s field generating our a few seconds to the Science Data electrons to combine with protons to polar aurorae) where they finally hit the Centre, where a preliminary check of the form neutrons; the entire star is surface close to the poles, creating hot results was made. essentially one big atomic nucleus spots. Integral directly observed the

24 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 25 Winkler 11/9/06 4:12 PM Page 24

Science Integral

A quick call was made to ISOC to let consisting of neutrons. Often, they are photons from these spots, finding they system is very small: the stars are so it cannibalises its companion. Over them know and check that this approach also rapidly spinning pulsars. Discovered account for most of the emission at close that they would fit into the radius about 100 000 years, the spin will speed was acceptable; the rest of the by radio astronomers about 50 years ago, energies above 30 000 eV. The key of the Sun. The observations support up by 0.6%, from 1.67 millisec to processing got underway. All aspects of pulsars beam electromagnetic radiation observation behind this result was the the theory that the two stars are close 1.66 millisec. the POS were checked, some visually from their polar regions, like a fact that Integral measured gamma-ray enough for accretion: material is flowing such as the instrument mode parameters lighthouse sweeping its beam across the pulsed emission from IGR J00291+5934 from the companion into a disc around Conclusions and telemetry bandwidth allocation, Earth at regular intervals. The extreme up to energies of 150 000 eV exactly in the neutron star before falling to its The observations of this ToO show that and some by the FD software, such as regularity of the pulse intervals makes phase with the 1.6 millisec X-ray surface. If this process continues, the nature always has surprises and new attitude constraints. them the most precise clocks in the pulsations recorded by RXTE. This companion will be completely consumed questions to offer. Space observatories About an hour later, the RPOS had A neutron star pulsar consumes material from its close stellar Universe – much better than even proves that the observed high-energy by the much smaller star. This such as Integral, with their dedicated been processed, the Enhanced POS companion atomic clocks on Earth. emission must be connected with the conclusion can be drawn once a change operational staff, are ideally suited to (EPOS) and the corresponding timeline polar regions emitting the lighthouse- in the spin period is observed. Neutron providing the right tools to find the had been generated, and it was time to The ToO Observations of IGR J00291+5934 The fastest accreting millisecond-pulsar beam radiation. Before this, such high- stars – spinning rapidly at birth – answers. Over its first 3.5 years of make the switch to the new timeline. It This ‘new’ source was serendipitously On 3 December 2004, using Integral’s energy photons had never been seen in gradually slow down after a few operations, Integral has observed 29 was important to find a gap in the discovered by Integral within its wide data of the discovery made the day the pulsed emission from these objects. hundred thousand years. Neutron stars Targets of Opportunity for a total of timeline when there was no commanding field-of-view during a routine short before, and 2 days before the Integral in binary systems, however, can do the almost 8 million seconds. x e in order to stop the Autostack on the observation around the constellation alert was submitted, scientists observed Cannibals at work opposite, accelerated by the angular control system, abort the old timeline Cassiopeia, in the outer reaches of the the object with NASA’s Rossi X-ray Using the timing information on IGR momentum of the in-falling material and load the new one. (Of course, before Milky Way, when it suddenly flared on Timing Explorer (RXTE), a satellite J00291+5934, it was found that the from the companion. For the first time, Detailed information on Integral and its mission can applying the new timeline the 2 December 2004. It was designated as specialised in high-precision X-ray companion star is perhaps as small as 40 this speeding up was observed directly in be found at http://www.esa.int/SPECIALS/Integral/ paperwork had to be completed. All the IGR J00291+5934, where IGR denotes timing measurements. These revealed Jupiter masses. The two stars orbit one high-energy data. This is direct evidence and http://integral.esac.esa.int/ planning products were cross-checked an ‘Integral Gamma-Ray’ source, and that it was a pulsar, or more precisely an another in only 2.5 hours. The binary for the star spinning faster and faster, as and signed by the various people the numbers give the coordinates on the ‘X-ray millisecond pulsar’. IGR responsible.) With about 4000 commands sky. On this day, the source proved to be J00291+5934 emits around 600 pulses a in one timeline, the loading took a few bright enough to warrant a dedicated, second, one of the fastest known. This minutes. In addition, the running FD longer Integral observation for in-depth corresponds to a rotational period of software tasks had to be stopped and investigation. Normally these sources this solar-mass object of only 1.67 new ones scheduled for the new timeline. stay bright for a few days, but some millisec (37 500 rpm!). This is much So a window of at least 10 minutes was transient sources unexpectedly fade in faster than most other pulsars in binary needed. Owing to the observational less than a day without warning. So it is systems, which rotate every few seconds. pattern of a slew every 30 minutes always exciting to await the outcome of (For comparison, the Sun takes about followed by a period of stable pointing the observation and analysis of the data. 25 days.) Only a few isolated (radio) with no commanding, finding a slot was In this case, the observations were highly pulsars are known to spin even faster. not a problem. It was decided to upload successful and the results were rapidly So, IGR J00291+5934 could be the the new timeline after the next slew. published in the leading scientific ‘missing link’ between the relatively slow The Mission Planner, SPACON and journal Astronomy and Astrophysics (see accreting pulsars in binary systems and FD observed the end of the slew and also the ESA news release at the very fast isolated pulsars, having waited for the FD job to run to update http://www.esa.int/esaSC/SEM finally lost their companions in their old the parameters for the next slew. “Ding- WSAA5QCE_index_2.html). age. dong!” This was the notification by the What did we learn from these control system that the update had observations? Photons from polar regions arrived. “Action!” Many neutron stars have strong The SPACON aborted the timeline, Neutron stars and pulsars magnetic fields, which were frozen in FD rescheduled the jobs, the new Pulsars are rotating neutron stars, which during the collapse of their progenitors. timeline was loaded, the updated Task are created during stellar explosions. This can create incredibly strong Parameter File was applied to the new They are the remnants of stars of 8–10 magnetic fields for a small, city-sized timeline, all associated documents were times the Sun’s mass that ended their neutron star. Charged particles in the updated – and the job was done. lives in supernova explosions. These accreting flow are channelled along Everyone resumed their routine work remnants still contain about the mass of these magnetic field lines onto the polar as Integral’s instruments observed the our Sun but concentrated in a 10–20 km regions of the neutron star (like solar new target. The data were routed within diameter! The extreme pressure forces particles in Earth’s field generating our a few seconds to the Science Data electrons to combine with protons to polar aurorae) where they finally hit the Centre, where a preliminary check of the form neutrons; the entire star is surface close to the poles, creating hot results was made. essentially one big atomic nucleus spots. Integral directly observed the

24 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 25 deParolis.qxd 11/9/06 4:15 PM Page 26

MELFI MELFI Maria N. De Parolis & Giorgio Crippa System Support Office, ESA Directorate of Human Spaceflight, Microgravity Ready for Science and Exploration, ESTEC, The Netherlands Jean Chegancas & Frederic Olivier EADS-Astrium, Toulouse, France

Jerome Guichard L’Air Liquide, DTA, Sassenage, France

ESA’s –80ºC Freezer Begins Work in Space fter a 4-year wait, ESA’s ‘MELFI’ freezer rack is now installed and working in the AInternational Space Station (ISS). It provides researchers with a unique cold- storage facility important, for example, for biology and human physiology investigations. Originally designed for frequent return trips, a major shift in Station requirements meant that a major effort had to be made before launch aboard Shuttle mission STS-121 in July to prepare it for permanent residence in space. The first science samples have been successfully frozen, before the first European samples were added in September.

Introduction The ‘Minus Eighty-degree Laboratory Freezer for ISS’ (MELFI) allows the fast-freezing and storage of life sciences and biological samples aboard the International Space Station. Developed by ESA on behalf of NASA and the Aerospace and Exploration Agency (JAXA) under various bilateral barter agreements, the Agency has delivered three flight units to NASA and one to JAXA. A flight-standard Engineering Model, a Training Model MELFI is loaded into its carrier module ready for launch aboard the on 4 July 2006 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 27 deParolis.qxd 11/9/06 4:15 PM Page 26

MELFI MELFI Maria N. De Parolis & Giorgio Crippa System Support Office, ESA Directorate of Human Spaceflight, Microgravity Ready for Science and Exploration, ESTEC, The Netherlands Jean Chegancas & Frederic Olivier EADS-Astrium, Toulouse, France

Jerome Guichard L’Air Liquide, DTA, Sassenage, France

ESA’s –80ºC Freezer Begins Work in Space fter a 4-year wait, ESA’s ‘MELFI’ freezer rack is now installed and working in the AInternational Space Station (ISS). It provides researchers with a unique cold- storage facility important, for example, for biology and human physiology investigations. Originally designed for frequent return trips, a major shift in Station requirements meant that a major effort had to be made before launch aboard Shuttle mission STS-121 in July to prepare it for permanent residence in space. The first science samples have been successfully frozen, before the first European samples were added in September.

Introduction The ‘Minus Eighty-degree Laboratory Freezer for ISS’ (MELFI) allows the fast-freezing and storage of life sciences and biological samples aboard the International Space Station. Developed by ESA on behalf of NASA and the Japan Aerospace and Exploration Agency (JAXA) under various bilateral barter agreements, the Agency has delivered three flight units to NASA and one to JAXA. A flight-standard Engineering Model, a Training Model MELFI is loaded into its carrier module ready for launch aboard the Space Shuttle on 4 July 2006 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 27 deParolis.qxd 11/9/06 4:15 PM Page 28

Human Spaceflight MELFI

Brief Description The samples are stored in four identical Dewar enclosures. Each Dewar can be set to cool to below three different temperatures: –80ºC, –26ºC and +4ºC. The centralised cooling system is based on a reverse Brayton cycle using very pure nitrogen as the working fluid. The basic machine was developed under FU1 (left) and FU2 at the Florida launch site ESA’s Technology Research Programme (TRP), and then modified to satisfy with simulation capabilities and a MELFI’s specific and stringent Laboratory Ground Model are installed requirements. The Brayton expander at NASA’s Johnson Space Center (JSC) and compressor wheels are mounted on in Houston and have been used the same shaft, running at up to extensively by the ground and space 96 000 rpm. At that speed, the system MELFI is carefully manoeuvred into position in Destiny crews to prepare for utilisation. In produces 90 W of cooling power at addition, ESA is providing spares and –97ºC. sustaining engineering to maintain all The cooling distribution to the baseline utilisation had to be modified. fewer Shuttle flights now and the MELFI hardware for up to 10 years of Dewars is via vacuum-insulated MELFI begins its journey to the ISS The original plan was to cycle the three retirement in 2010, a new route for operations. nitrogen lines running from the MELFI units between orbit and Earth, cooled samples needs to be found. At machine. A distribution valve on each fast cooling, the samples must be held with ground maintenance shorter than the moment, the only possibilities are ...and ready for use The prime contractor is EADS- Dewar stabilises the temperature within against the Dewar trays and have a large, 2 years between missions. The plan now the Shuttle’s small middeck freezers Astrium in Toulouse (F), with main the required range by modulating the conductive surface. Conversely, samples is to launch only two MELFIs before (such as Merlin), or thermal bags lined subcontractors: cold nitrogen flow. The valves can also requiring slow cooling need small, the Shuttle retires in 2010 – and keep with phase-change materials (PCMs). Into Orbit isolate each Dewar independently, isolating interface surfaces. them in space. Of course, the middeck freezer path will STS-121 delivered tonnes of equipment – L’Air Liquide (F), for the core cooling shutting down one or more enclosures MELFI’s cooling system provides a At NASA’s request, ESA assessed this be lost with Shuttle’s retirement. And and supplies to the ISS following system; when the storage capacity is not needed. quite remarkable performance. It can proposal. The study showed that the thermal bags can hold the required docking on 6 July, including MELFI – Linde (D), for the cold-volume chain; Within the Dewars, trays and boxes cool about 300 litres in 2 days to less MELFI’s very robust design will allow it temperature for only a few hours. FU-1. After attaching MPLM to the – Kayser-Threde (D), for the electrical accommodate basic samples shapes. than –90ºC using only 900 W and hold it to remain in space, with additional This problem of returning hardware Station using Shuttle’s robotic arm, the system and some rack components; Users can design their own accommoda- there with less than 800 W. It also meets maintenance using dedicated tools and and, in particular, experiments results transfer of racks and supplies could – ETEL (CH), for the motor and tion hardware, based on defined the Station’s stringent noise require- spares provided by European industry. from the Station is probably the most begin. MELFI’s move was particularly motor-drive electronics; interface requirements and their cooling ments (less than 40 dB). For The consequences for the Station’s work critical for using the ISS to its full interesting because it is one of the – DAMEC (DK), for the utilisation needs. MELFI is a ‘contact freezer’ to comparison, similar systems on Earth schedule have still to be discussed and potential. largest and heaviest payload racks concept and hardware. allow selection of the cooling speed. For use about double the power with noise agreed between the two agencies. ESA has studied retrievable capsules aboard the Station. Commander Pavel levels around 60 dB (100 times higher), This has also changed how the and freezers that could fit in them. This Vinogradov and Flight Engineers Jeff A single Brayton machine provides cooling for MELFI and could never handle 15 Shuttle samples are delivered to Earth. The includes both active freezers and Williams and had to launches! original scenario used MELFI as a passive, long-term storage containers. move the bulky item with great care The first MELFI flight unit (FU-1) transportation freezer, up/ downloading However, the lack of funding and through the ISS to its final position in was ready in October 2002 for a planned frozen materials and processed samples support from the stakeholders has so far the Destiny laboratory. There was flight on Shuttle in March 2003. every 3–12 months. But given the far prevented their procurement. always the risk of damage to the rack However, the Columbia disaster in itself and to the many items stored en February 2003 halted all launches for The control panel shows the two active Dewars at –98ºC; the others remain at the ambient +15ºC route. several years. FU-1 had to be Once all the connectors were locked, deintegrated from its Multi-Purpose the rack was powered up on 19 July and Logistics Module (MPLM) host and commissioning began. First, there was a maintained for the next 3 years. This general check-out of all the subsystems, work included simple routine mainten- and then the ‘MELFI On-Orbit Cooling ance, such as briefly running the system Experiment’ (MOOCE) began to test and changing the operating fluids, and a performance. more extensive effort to increase the Starting up the cooling machine was time it can spend in orbit. particularly important. It was qualified In fact, the change in the Station on the ground for up to 15 launches and logistics scenario meant that MELFI’s retrievals, but its behaviour after a real

28 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 29 deParolis.qxd 11/9/06 4:15 PM Page 28

Human Spaceflight MELFI

Brief Description The samples are stored in four identical Dewar enclosures. Each Dewar can be set to cool to below three different temperatures: –80ºC, –26ºC and +4ºC. The centralised cooling system is based on a reverse Brayton cycle using very pure nitrogen as the working fluid. The basic machine was developed under FU1 (left) and FU2 at the Florida launch site ESA’s Technology Research Programme (TRP), and then modified to satisfy with simulation capabilities and a MELFI’s specific and stringent Laboratory Ground Model are installed requirements. The Brayton expander at NASA’s Johnson Space Center (JSC) and compressor wheels are mounted on in Houston and have been used the same shaft, running at up to extensively by the ground and space 96 000 rpm. At that speed, the system MELFI is carefully manoeuvred into position in Destiny crews to prepare for utilisation. In produces 90 W of cooling power at addition, ESA is providing spares and –97ºC. sustaining engineering to maintain all The cooling distribution to the baseline utilisation had to be modified. fewer Shuttle flights now and the MELFI hardware for up to 10 years of Dewars is via vacuum-insulated MELFI begins its journey to the ISS The original plan was to cycle the three retirement in 2010, a new route for operations. nitrogen lines running from the MELFI units between orbit and Earth, cooled samples needs to be found. At machine. A distribution valve on each fast cooling, the samples must be held with ground maintenance shorter than the moment, the only possibilities are ...and ready for use The prime contractor is EADS- Dewar stabilises the temperature within against the Dewar trays and have a large, 2 years between missions. The plan now the Shuttle’s small middeck freezers Astrium in Toulouse (F), with main the required range by modulating the conductive surface. Conversely, samples is to launch only two MELFIs before (such as Merlin), or thermal bags lined subcontractors: cold nitrogen flow. The valves can also requiring slow cooling need small, the Shuttle retires in 2010 – and keep with phase-change materials (PCMs). Into Orbit isolate each Dewar independently, isolating interface surfaces. them in space. Of course, the middeck freezer path will STS-121 delivered tonnes of equipment – L’Air Liquide (F), for the core cooling shutting down one or more enclosures MELFI’s cooling system provides a At NASA’s request, ESA assessed this be lost with Shuttle’s retirement. And and supplies to the ISS following system; when the storage capacity is not needed. quite remarkable performance. It can proposal. The study showed that the thermal bags can hold the required docking on 6 July, including MELFI – Linde (D), for the cold-volume chain; Within the Dewars, trays and boxes cool about 300 litres in 2 days to less MELFI’s very robust design will allow it temperature for only a few hours. FU-1. After attaching MPLM to the – Kayser-Threde (D), for the electrical accommodate basic samples shapes. than –90ºC using only 900 W and hold it to remain in space, with additional This problem of returning hardware Station using Shuttle’s robotic arm, the system and some rack components; Users can design their own accommoda- there with less than 800 W. It also meets maintenance using dedicated tools and and, in particular, experiments results transfer of racks and supplies could – ETEL (CH), for the motor and tion hardware, based on defined the Station’s stringent noise require- spares provided by European industry. from the Station is probably the most begin. MELFI’s move was particularly motor-drive electronics; interface requirements and their cooling ments (less than 40 dB). For The consequences for the Station’s work critical for using the ISS to its full interesting because it is one of the – DAMEC (DK), for the utilisation needs. MELFI is a ‘contact freezer’ to comparison, similar systems on Earth schedule have still to be discussed and potential. largest and heaviest payload racks concept and hardware. allow selection of the cooling speed. For use about double the power with noise agreed between the two agencies. ESA has studied retrievable capsules aboard the Station. Commander Pavel levels around 60 dB (100 times higher), This has also changed how the and freezers that could fit in them. This Vinogradov and Flight Engineers Jeff A single Brayton machine provides cooling for MELFI and could never handle 15 Shuttle samples are delivered to Earth. The includes both active freezers and Williams and Thomas Reiter had to launches! original scenario used MELFI as a passive, long-term storage containers. move the bulky item with great care The first MELFI flight unit (FU-1) transportation freezer, up/ downloading However, the lack of funding and through the ISS to its final position in was ready in October 2002 for a planned frozen materials and processed samples support from the stakeholders has so far the Destiny laboratory. There was flight on Shuttle in March 2003. every 3–12 months. But given the far prevented their procurement. always the risk of damage to the rack However, the Columbia disaster in itself and to the many items stored en February 2003 halted all launches for The control panel shows the two active Dewars at –98ºC; the others remain at the ambient +15ºC route. several years. FU-1 had to be Once all the connectors were locked, deintegrated from its Multi-Purpose the rack was powered up on 19 July and Logistics Module (MPLM) host and commissioning began. First, there was a maintained for the next 3 years. This general check-out of all the subsystems, work included simple routine mainten- and then the ‘MELFI On-Orbit Cooling ance, such as briefly running the system Experiment’ (MOOCE) began to test and changing the operating fluids, and a performance. more extensive effort to increase the Starting up the cooling machine was time it can spend in orbit. particularly important. It was qualified In fact, the change in the Station on the ground for up to 15 launches and logistics scenario meant that MELFI’s retrievals, but its behaviour after a real

28 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 29 deParolis.qxd 11/9/06 4:15 PM Page 30

Human Spaceflight MELFI

Jeff Williams removes the frozen 5 ml MOOCE sample MOOCE sample frozen in the ground model MOOCE hardware installed on Dewar-2 Jeff Williams inserts the POEMS sample container into Dewar-2: the first operational user of MELFI

launch and in weightlessness was acquisition systems. Cooling-speed the samples were inserted into the Observatories for Experimental on STS-121, the European Modular the technologies and to provide the somewhat uncertain. A very careful reference tests were performed on the freezer, and to the design of the Microbial Systems’ (POEMS), a US Cultivation System (EMCS), completed Station and the science community with procedure was thus followed, ground for later comparison with packaging. experiment devoted to microbial commissioning in August and began more transportation freezers and commanded remotely by ground on-orbit runs. ESA will provide NASA and the user research, had the honour of being the operations in September with the passive containers to be used after the operators. The Station crew began configuring community with the ‘1 g-to-0 g tool” first real sample cooled in Dewar-2, TROPI plant experiment. TROPI then Shuttle’s retirement and for the Much to their relief, all went the MOOCE hardware on 20 July. A correlated with the on-orbit data. Users while a number of PCM packages were became a guest of MELFI in the Exploration programmes to come. smoothly and the various speed steps slight problem arose when the computer will be able to design different sample accommodated in Dewar-1. autumn and will profit from the return Indeed, life sciences research is of were all taken flawlessly up to the was switched on and the procedure packaging, test them in the MELFI These PCM packs (ICEPAC©) are route, together with IMMUNO and paramount importance for ensuring maximum 96 000 rpm. This was initiated, but a complete blank screen Engineering Model and predict the essential for downloading processed CARD, on STS-116 in December 2006. human health and performance on these followed by individual activation of all appeared. Since the complete data on-orbit performance. samples to Earth. They were developed MELFI FU-2 will be launched in exploration missions. the Dewar valves. The full functionality stream, including video, was available by NASA for the various temperature 2008 and installed in Japan’s Kibo MELFI may be operating in orbit for of the cold system had now been on Earth, the ground team could see First Samples levels and require a long time for module. a very long time. With a robust logistics demonstrated. In particular, Dewar-2 what was happening and could help the Given the positive results from the cooling, owing to their very high system for up/downloading samples, it reached –97ºC in about 12 hours. crew very efficiently in troubleshooting. commissioning phase, NASA decided to thermal inertia. Conclusion will help scientists to get the best This allowed the problem to be solved in activate another Dewar at the lowest The thermal bags are filled with the MELFI was a very challenging samples they need for making advances MOOCE less than half an hour; the experiment temperature to prepare for the first ICEPACs just before insertion into the development for European industry. The in life sciences for space and ground MOOCE has now measured MELFI’s was started by inserting the first sample. insertion of science samples. ‘Passive Shuttle middeck lockers before reentry. advanced technology of the Brayton applications. cooling characteristics in orbit. The There were no other mishaps and all A large number of ICEPACs have to be machine and its cold box required a main reason behind it is the need the planned runs were completed in ICEPAC inserted in a MELFI storage box used in order to stay safely within the great deal of resourcefulness. Highly Acknowledgements expressed by some scientists to cool about a week. All the data were allowed temperature range for up to dedicated engineers in the companies Thanks must be made to all the samples very quickly from ambient downloaded for evaluation and 2 days. The bags are removed and ESA spent months on designing, individuals who have contributed to the temperature in order to avoid damage correlation with the ground data and immediately upon opening of the manufacturing and verifying all the success of the MELFI. The authors wish to tissue or cell structures. analytical models. Shuttle hatch as ‘early retrieval’ elements of the cold chain and to thank the development companies The experiment hardware was defined Complete analysis requires at least payloads. Logistics were developed by developing the sophisticated control (EADS-Astrium, L’Air Liquide, Kayser- by the ESA Project staff and designed 3 months, but some preliminary conclu- NASA, with some Ground Support software to command them. The results, Threde, LINDE, ETEL, CRYSA, and manufactured at ESTEC, within sions can be drawn at the time of writing Equipment provided by ESA, to ensure however, show that it was all definitely DAMEC) and their staff, NASA Project the Thermal Control Section of the (September 2006). As expected, there the specimens are delivered to the well worth the effort. Once again, staff and ESA D/HME, D/TEC and Directorate of Technical & Quality are differences in the cooling times. The scientists in the best possible conditions. European industry has shown its D/RES staff for their invaluable Management. The hardware was on-orbit curves show a slower rate, The first European experiments to capability for being highly innovative support over many years. e qualified at ESTEC and extensively owing to the lack of natural convection, profit from MELFI were the SAMPLE, and producing world-class payloads for tested at NASA’s Kennedy Space but there are also differences between IMMUNO and CARD physiology science. More information about MELFI and its use on-orbit will Center launch site to verify its the various runs. Those differences are experiments in September 2006. In the In order to get the full benefit from be posted at http://spaceflight.esa.int/users after the MOOCE data are fully evaluated behaviour with the Station’s data- most probably due to the way in which meantime, another ESA facility launched MELFI, it is important to capitalise on

30 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 31 deParolis.qxd 11/9/06 4:15 PM Page 30

Human Spaceflight MELFI

Jeff Williams removes the frozen 5 ml MOOCE sample MOOCE sample frozen in the ground model MOOCE hardware installed on Dewar-2 Jeff Williams inserts the POEMS sample container into Dewar-2: the first operational user of MELFI

launch and in weightlessness was acquisition systems. Cooling-speed the samples were inserted into the Observatories for Experimental on STS-121, the European Modular the technologies and to provide the somewhat uncertain. A very careful reference tests were performed on the freezer, and to the design of the Microbial Systems’ (POEMS), a US Cultivation System (EMCS), completed Station and the science community with procedure was thus followed, ground for later comparison with packaging. experiment devoted to microbial commissioning in August and began more transportation freezers and commanded remotely by ground on-orbit runs. ESA will provide NASA and the user research, had the honour of being the operations in September with the passive containers to be used after the operators. The Station crew began configuring community with the ‘1 g-to-0 g tool” first real sample cooled in Dewar-2, TROPI plant experiment. TROPI then Shuttle’s retirement and for the Much to their relief, all went the MOOCE hardware on 20 July. A correlated with the on-orbit data. Users while a number of PCM packages were became a guest of MELFI in the Exploration programmes to come. smoothly and the various speed steps slight problem arose when the computer will be able to design different sample accommodated in Dewar-1. autumn and will profit from the return Indeed, life sciences research is of were all taken flawlessly up to the was switched on and the procedure packaging, test them in the MELFI These PCM packs (ICEPAC©) are route, together with IMMUNO and paramount importance for ensuring maximum 96 000 rpm. This was initiated, but a complete blank screen Engineering Model and predict the essential for downloading processed CARD, on STS-116 in December 2006. human health and performance on these followed by individual activation of all appeared. Since the complete data on-orbit performance. samples to Earth. They were developed MELFI FU-2 will be launched in exploration missions. the Dewar valves. The full functionality stream, including video, was available by NASA for the various temperature 2008 and installed in Japan’s Kibo MELFI may be operating in orbit for of the cold system had now been on Earth, the ground team could see First Samples levels and require a long time for module. a very long time. With a robust logistics demonstrated. In particular, Dewar-2 what was happening and could help the Given the positive results from the cooling, owing to their very high system for up/downloading samples, it reached –97ºC in about 12 hours. crew very efficiently in troubleshooting. commissioning phase, NASA decided to thermal inertia. Conclusion will help scientists to get the best This allowed the problem to be solved in activate another Dewar at the lowest The thermal bags are filled with the MELFI was a very challenging samples they need for making advances MOOCE less than half an hour; the experiment temperature to prepare for the first ICEPACs just before insertion into the development for European industry. The in life sciences for space and ground MOOCE has now measured MELFI’s was started by inserting the first sample. insertion of science samples. ‘Passive Shuttle middeck lockers before reentry. advanced technology of the Brayton applications. cooling characteristics in orbit. The There were no other mishaps and all A large number of ICEPACs have to be machine and its cold box required a main reason behind it is the need the planned runs were completed in ICEPAC inserted in a MELFI storage box used in order to stay safely within the great deal of resourcefulness. Highly Acknowledgements expressed by some scientists to cool about a week. All the data were allowed temperature range for up to dedicated engineers in the companies Thanks must be made to all the samples very quickly from ambient downloaded for evaluation and 2 days. The bags are removed and ESA spent months on designing, individuals who have contributed to the temperature in order to avoid damage correlation with the ground data and immediately upon opening of the manufacturing and verifying all the success of the MELFI. The authors wish to tissue or cell structures. analytical models. Shuttle hatch as ‘early retrieval’ elements of the cold chain and to thank the development companies The experiment hardware was defined Complete analysis requires at least payloads. Logistics were developed by developing the sophisticated control (EADS-Astrium, L’Air Liquide, Kayser- by the ESA Project staff and designed 3 months, but some preliminary conclu- NASA, with some Ground Support software to command them. The results, Threde, LINDE, ETEL, CRYSA, and manufactured at ESTEC, within sions can be drawn at the time of writing Equipment provided by ESA, to ensure however, show that it was all definitely DAMEC) and their staff, NASA Project the Thermal Control Section of the (September 2006). As expected, there the specimens are delivered to the well worth the effort. Once again, staff and ESA D/HME, D/TEC and Directorate of Technical & Quality are differences in the cooling times. The scientists in the best possible conditions. European industry has shown its D/RES staff for their invaluable Management. The hardware was on-orbit curves show a slower rate, The first European experiments to capability for being highly innovative support over many years. e qualified at ESTEC and extensively owing to the lack of natural convection, profit from MELFI were the SAMPLE, and producing world-class payloads for tested at NASA’s Kennedy Space but there are also differences between IMMUNO and CARD physiology science. More information about MELFI and its use on-orbit will Center launch site to verify its the various runs. Those differences are experiments in September 2006. In the In order to get the full benefit from be posted at http://spaceflight.esa.int/users after the MOOCE data are fully evaluated behaviour with the Station’s data- most probably due to the way in which meantime, another ESA facility launched MELFI, it is important to capitalise on

30 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 31 Bolender.qxd 11/9/06 4:18 PM Page 32

EVA Training

Hans Bolender, Hervé Stevenin, Loredana Bessone & Antonio Torres Astronaut Training Division, European Astronaut Centre, Directorate of Human Spaceflight, Microgravity and Exploration, Cologne, Germany Preparing for Space EVA Training at the European Astronaut Centre

he European Astronaut Centre has developed an Extra Vehicular Activity T(EVA) training course for ESA to bridge the gap between their scuba diving certification and the spacesuit qualification provided by NASA. ESA astronauts André Kuipers and have already completed this ‘EVA Pre-Familiarisation Training Programme’ before their training at NASA. In June 2006, an international crew of experienced EVA astronauts approved the course as good preparation for suited EVA training; they recommended that portions of it be used to help maintain EVA proficiency for astronauts. Introduction During Extra Vehicular Activities (EVAs – spacewalks), astronauts venture from their protective spacecraft in autonomous spacesuits to work on, for example, the International Space Station (ISS) or the Hubble Space Telescope. EVAs are among the most challenging tasks of an astronaut’s career. They are complex and demanding, placing the astronauts in a singular, highly stressful environment, requiring a high level of

esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 33 Bolender.qxd 11/9/06 4:18 PM Page 32

EVA Training

Hans Bolender, Hervé Stevenin, Loredana Bessone & Antonio Torres Astronaut Training Division, European Astronaut Centre, Directorate of Human Spaceflight, Microgravity and Exploration, Cologne, Germany Preparing for Space EVA Training at the European Astronaut Centre

he European Astronaut Centre has developed an Extra Vehicular Activity T(EVA) training course for ESA astronauts to bridge the gap between their scuba diving certification and the spacesuit qualification provided by NASA. ESA astronauts André Kuipers and Frank De Winne have already completed this ‘EVA Pre-Familiarisation Training Programme’ before their training at NASA. In June 2006, an international crew of experienced EVA astronauts approved the course as good preparation for suited EVA training; they recommended that portions of it be used to help maintain EVA proficiency for astronauts. Introduction During Extra Vehicular Activities (EVAs – spacewalks), astronauts venture from their protective spacecraft in autonomous spacesuits to work on, for example, the International Space Station (ISS) or the Hubble Space Telescope. EVAs are among the most challenging tasks of an astronaut’s career. They are complex and demanding, placing the astronauts in a singular, highly stressful environment, requiring a high level of

esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 33 Bolender.qxd 11/9/06 4:19 PM Page 34

Human Spaceflight EVA Training

situational awareness and coordination while working at peak performance. Careful and intensive preparation of the astronaut is key to safe, smooth and successful EVAs. Water is the best environment for EVA training on Earth, substituting neutral buoyancy for microgravity. Preparation is therefore centred on special facilities such as the Neutral Buoyancy Laboratory (NBL) at NASA’s Johnson Space Center (JSC, Houston), the Hydrolab at the Gagarin Cosmonaut Training Centre (GCTC, Moscow) and now also at the Neutral Buoyancy Facility (NBF) of ESA’s European Astronaut Centre (EAC, Cologne). During their Basic Training, all astronauts undergo a scuba diving course as a prerequisite to EVA training. For NASA and ISS partner astronauts undergoing Shuttle Mission Specialist training, this is followed by a general EVA skills programme at JSC that also ESA Astronaut takes a photograph during a break from servicing the Hubble Space Telescope helps to identify the most suitable EVA crewmembers. “Together with NASA astronaut Mike Foale, I effective transition to the demands of The training flow of ESA’s EVA An ESA astronaut (white suit) performing the EV1 dive in EAC’s tank. He is equipped with SSDS and a mockup of the life-support backpack Unfortunately, it is becoming was privileged to perform EVA-2 during the training in the NBL. Pre-Familiarisation course at EAC increasingly difficult for ESA astronauts Hubble Space Telescope Servicing Mission “The preparation training provided at to undergo this NASA training. With 3A in December 1999. As an ESA astronaut EAC’s Neutral Buoyancy Facility will nicely The objectives of the course are for courses, briefings and in-water exercises, strategies. This training is in the NBF the last Shuttle launch in 2010, the assigned to JSC for 20 years by then, my fill that gap. Although without a spacesuit, it the trainees to become able to: scripted to challenge the trainees to tank led by an instructor to agreement for ESA Shuttle Mission situation was not common: EVA training and exposes the trainees to enough of the EVA think and perform as if they were demonstrate various methods of Specialist training will come to an end. discussions had almost become part of daily challenges to be excellent preparation for – explain and demonstrate the correct conducting actual EVAs. performing translations in different Moreover, the intense period of Station life as one of the major disciplines that had NBL runs. Translation techniques, tether use of a set of tools and equipment, The main elements of the programme body postures, changing attitude and assembly flights means that NASA’s to be mastered for assembly of the ISS, in protocols, working under limited visibility and including the transportation and are: adjusting body orientations around NBL is significantly overbooked for addition to a couple of anticipated Hubble properly communicating with other installation of Orbital Replaceable confining structures; operational testing and mission-related visits. crewmembers or the capcom/instructor can Units (ORUs) and the manipulation – a description of the EVA course – a briefing and hands-on training on EVA training. And work for future “In the future, European crewmembers will be exercised. It will give our astronauts a of connectors; leading up to the EMU Suit deck describing the EVA tool exploration missions will only add to the be less exposed to JSC’s EVA culture than flying start in subsequent phases of EVA – perform translation, rotation, passing Qualification in the NBL, to give an operations and interfaces to specific burden. we were. Training in the Neutral Buoyancy training, whether using the US of obstacles in a typical EVA overview of the programme and wet equipment that will be used in the So EVA skills training will not be fully Laboratory will not always be as extensive as Extravehicular Mobility Unit or the Russian translation path, while wearing EVA- general expectations during the underwater exercises; available to international astronauts. Yet it was, so preparation and preconditioning of Orlan spacesuit.” like equipment, using safety tethers or training exercises to follow; – the Surface Supplied Diving System assignment to an EVA depends on astronauts from partner nations beyond the Claude Nicollier waist tether protocol (Russian-like); – an overview of the EMU suit, (SSDS) qualification, required for evaluating astronauts’ skills early in US and Russia are going to be a must for – perform a worksite assessment, secure describing its biomechanics and voice communications between the their training, and it is important for oneself at the worksite and perform, constraints in water and space; trainee and the instructor in the assigning Station crews and tasks. psychomotor and behavioural skills equipment and tools. Cognitive skills are alone or with a partner, a defined task – a briefing on ‘moving in space’, Control Room (for details see the EAC therefore took the initiative to ahead of the NASA training. as important, and range from navigating including ORU exchange; providing recommendations on the ‘NBF Characteristics’ box); develop the ‘EVA Pre-Familiarisation around the Station despite the very – handle tether operations, as in exiting best strategies for moving in the suit – a second session underwater, the ‘EV1 Training Programme’ to bridge the gap EVA Pre-Familiarisation Training limited field of view, to applying from an ; without fighting it, for moving along Run’, to highlight the fundamental between scuba training and NASA’s A successful EVA requires psychomotor, tethering and operational rules. – plan a typical EVA as a ‘buddy’ team, and around the Station structure skills of a typical EVA. It is performed EVA skills training. It better prepares cognitive and behavioural skills. Behavioural skills include situation and and carry it out in cooperation with a while allowing for suit limitations and fully equipped for SSDS and wearing ESA astronauts in their initial Psychomotor skills range from the spatial awareness, decision-making and crewmember inside the craft. the Station constraints (obstacles, a low-fidelity mini-work station qualification for using the Shuttle/ISS ability to move in the suit, move along problem-solving, workload management keep-out zones); strapped to the chest to carry EVA spacesuit (the Extravehicular Mobility the Station using handrails (translation) and efficiency, teamwork and The course is spread over 1–2 weeks, – a practical session of underwater tools, a backpack representing the Unit, or EMU), and to provide cognitive, and pass obstacles, to operating communication. consisting of a series of classroom exercises to apply the movement EMU’s Primary Life Support System,

34 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 35 Bolender.qxd 11/9/06 4:19 PM Page 34

Human Spaceflight EVA Training

situational awareness and coordination while working at peak performance. Careful and intensive preparation of the astronaut is key to safe, smooth and successful EVAs. Water is the best environment for EVA training on Earth, substituting neutral buoyancy for microgravity. Preparation is therefore centred on special facilities such as the Neutral Buoyancy Laboratory (NBL) at NASA’s Johnson Space Center (JSC, Houston), the Hydrolab at the Gagarin Cosmonaut Training Centre (GCTC, Moscow) and now also at the Neutral Buoyancy Facility (NBF) of ESA’s European Astronaut Centre (EAC, Cologne). During their Basic Training, all astronauts undergo a scuba diving course as a prerequisite to EVA training. For NASA and ISS partner astronauts undergoing Shuttle Mission Specialist training, this is followed by a general EVA skills programme at JSC that also ESA Astronaut Claude Nicollier takes a photograph during a break from servicing the Hubble Space Telescope helps to identify the most suitable EVA crewmembers. “Together with NASA astronaut Mike Foale, I effective transition to the demands of The training flow of ESA’s EVA An ESA astronaut (white suit) performing the EV1 dive in EAC’s tank. He is equipped with SSDS and a mockup of the life-support backpack Unfortunately, it is becoming was privileged to perform EVA-2 during the training in the NBL. Pre-Familiarisation course at EAC increasingly difficult for ESA astronauts Hubble Space Telescope Servicing Mission “The preparation training provided at to undergo this NASA training. With 3A in December 1999. As an ESA astronaut EAC’s Neutral Buoyancy Facility will nicely The objectives of the course are for courses, briefings and in-water exercises, strategies. This training is in the NBF the last Shuttle launch in 2010, the assigned to JSC for 20 years by then, my fill that gap. Although without a spacesuit, it the trainees to become able to: scripted to challenge the trainees to tank led by an instructor to agreement for ESA Shuttle Mission situation was not common: EVA training and exposes the trainees to enough of the EVA think and perform as if they were demonstrate various methods of Specialist training will come to an end. discussions had almost become part of daily challenges to be excellent preparation for – explain and demonstrate the correct conducting actual EVAs. performing translations in different Moreover, the intense period of Station life as one of the major disciplines that had NBL runs. Translation techniques, tether use of a set of tools and equipment, The main elements of the programme body postures, changing attitude and assembly flights means that NASA’s to be mastered for assembly of the ISS, in protocols, working under limited visibility and including the transportation and are: adjusting body orientations around NBL is significantly overbooked for addition to a couple of anticipated Hubble properly communicating with other installation of Orbital Replaceable confining structures; operational testing and mission-related visits. crewmembers or the capcom/instructor can Units (ORUs) and the manipulation – a description of the EVA course – a briefing and hands-on training on EVA training. And work for future “In the future, European crewmembers will be exercised. It will give our astronauts a of connectors; leading up to the EMU Suit deck describing the EVA tool exploration missions will only add to the be less exposed to JSC’s EVA culture than flying start in subsequent phases of EVA – perform translation, rotation, passing Qualification in the NBL, to give an operations and interfaces to specific burden. we were. Training in the Neutral Buoyancy training, whether using the US of obstacles in a typical EVA overview of the programme and wet equipment that will be used in the So EVA skills training will not be fully Laboratory will not always be as extensive as Extravehicular Mobility Unit or the Russian translation path, while wearing EVA- general expectations during the underwater exercises; available to international astronauts. Yet it was, so preparation and preconditioning of Orlan spacesuit.” like equipment, using safety tethers or training exercises to follow; – the Surface Supplied Diving System assignment to an EVA depends on astronauts from partner nations beyond the Claude Nicollier waist tether protocol (Russian-like); – an overview of the EMU suit, (SSDS) qualification, required for evaluating astronauts’ skills early in US and Russia are going to be a must for – perform a worksite assessment, secure describing its biomechanics and voice communications between the their training, and it is important for oneself at the worksite and perform, constraints in water and space; trainee and the instructor in the assigning Station crews and tasks. psychomotor and behavioural skills equipment and tools. Cognitive skills are alone or with a partner, a defined task – a briefing on ‘moving in space’, Control Room (for details see the EAC therefore took the initiative to ahead of the NASA training. as important, and range from navigating including ORU exchange; providing recommendations on the ‘NBF Characteristics’ box); develop the ‘EVA Pre-Familiarisation around the Station despite the very – handle tether operations, as in exiting best strategies for moving in the suit – a second session underwater, the ‘EV1 Training Programme’ to bridge the gap EVA Pre-Familiarisation Training limited field of view, to applying from an airlock; without fighting it, for moving along Run’, to highlight the fundamental between scuba training and NASA’s A successful EVA requires psychomotor, tethering and operational rules. – plan a typical EVA as a ‘buddy’ team, and around the Station structure skills of a typical EVA. It is performed EVA skills training. It better prepares cognitive and behavioural skills. Behavioural skills include situation and and carry it out in cooperation with a while allowing for suit limitations and fully equipped for SSDS and wearing ESA astronauts in their initial Psychomotor skills range from the spatial awareness, decision-making and crewmember inside the craft. the Station constraints (obstacles, a low-fidelity mini-work station qualification for using the Shuttle/ISS ability to move in the suit, move along problem-solving, workload management keep-out zones); strapped to the chest to carry EVA spacesuit (the Extravehicular Mobility the Station using handrails (translation) and efficiency, teamwork and The course is spread over 1–2 weeks, – a practical session of underwater tools, a backpack representing the Unit, or EMU), and to provide cognitive, and pass obstacles, to operating communication. consisting of a series of classroom exercises to apply the movement EMU’s Primary Life Support System,

34 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 35 Bolender.qxd 11/9/06 4:19 PM Page 36

Human Spaceflight EVA Training

a representative helmet, a pair of Neutral Buoyancy Facility Characteristics unpressurised EMU gloves and boots suitable for foot restraints. There is a NBF Hall, Rooms and Equipment very limited set of tethers, along with • 48 m long, 24 m wide and 14.4 m high dummy tethers deliberately to increase • NBF control room, scuba equipment room, EVA equipment room, electrical the likelihood of tethers snagging and mechanical repair shop, scuba during translation. The trainee has to filling station, technical rooms for pool perform an end-to-end EVA including maintenance, water airlock egress/ ingress, ORU payload filtration/purification, control and transportation to/from a worksite, heating, showers/dressing rooms and sauna translation using waist tethers • Remote air compressor with storage (Russian protocol) and operation of tank assembly including high-pressure ISS connectors. The trainee must feedline connection to multiple filling always comply with the EVA rules: station in NBF hall items and body must be tethered at all • Overhead girder crane with 5 t capacity times, touch handrails only for translation, use only D-rings or Water Tank Mockups handrails for attaching safety tethers, • 22 m long, 17 m wide and • Modified Columbus wet and avoid keep-out zones. An ESA astronaut works with ISS connectors while standing in a portable foot restraint 10 m deep, volume mockup with ISS handrails 3 Disturbances are introduced during 3747 m , temperature range and EVA workstations 27–29°C • Russian airlock mockup the scripted run to exercise situational • Submersible platform • deployable solar panel awareness, communication skills and leading the EVA operations and have been defined and conducted to 5x3.5 m for 0–9.5 m depths, mockup decision-making; supervised by the Test Conductor. Both evaluate and (re-)certify the NBF and 250 kg loading capacity at are in the Control Room, with a Medical EVA infrastructure and equipment. 0m – the third and final ‘EV1+2 Run’ Doctor and a Safety Officer, responsible A Test Readiness Review process has • Continuous monitoring of water quality (e.g. pH value, underwater consists of a two-member for the well-being of the crew and the been developed to ensure safety and chlorine, temperature) EVA designed to emphasise teamwork safety of the operations, and an readiness of the test operations, facility, and team situational awareness, crew Audio/Video Operator to ensure the equipment and personnel. It is called on Scuba and SSDS Diving Equipment communication and workload distribution and recording of all for each diving campaign, for new or • 20 complete sets of scuba equipment (tanks, regulators, suits etc) management, in an even more realistic required signals. The Dive Supervisor modified equipment and for changes in • 3 SSDS sets composed of: – full-face mask with microphone and earphones for 2-way communications between SSDS divers and challenging scenario. The trainees directs and monitors on-deck the pre- procedures, rules or operations. and on-deck personnel; are paired and encouraged to develop and post-dive activities of the Trainees, An end-to-end test of the emergency – buoyancy jacket including inflator, with 6 litre/300 bar reserve air tank, pressure gauge and dive their own timeline and to define the Safety, Utility and Camera Divers, rescue chain was run in June 2006, computer; sharing of their EVA tools. The SSDS operator and deck support including external support from medical – 60 m umbilical hose connected to deck air supply and for communication cables. equipment is the same as for the EV1 personnel. operations, onsite security, the water • SSDS cart on-deck hosting umbilicals, air tanks, pressure-monitoring devices and video and audio monitoring Run, except that the US safety tether A study guide and DVD package with rescue team of the fire brigade, and protocol is used and the life-support the course material, videos of the EVA rescue helicopter teams. backpack cannot be used owing to runs at EAC and additional reference space limitations in the airlock. More documentation and EVA skill Training Runs for ESA Astronauts EVA Tools NBF Control Room • ISS handrails mounted on • Video: 8 channels, including tethers are also worn. The rules of demonstration videos, as well as Two ESA astronauts with no EMU airlock and Columbus switching matrix for observation engagement include all those of the computer-based training material, is experience were scheduled to start their mockups and multiple recording of EV1 Run plus additional constraints given to the trainees upon course EVA training in Houston in late 2005, as • Portable Foot Restraints underwater and deck operations for an ORU change-out requiring completion. part of their ISS crewmember training (PFRs) mounted on EVA • Additional monitor with switching specific tools from a toolbox at a During the past 2 years the Neutral programme: Frank De Winne and worksites on Columbus matrix for deck personnel in NBF mockup hall second work site. The Test Buoyancy Facility and its operations André Kuipers. Both had done scuba • EMU-like boots for use • Audio: 2 audio loops for bi- Conductor/instructor, who also plays have been constantly upgraded and training at EAC, and André had already with PFR directional communications the onboard crew role, inserts adapted for the programme. Around 20 undergone Russian Orlan suit training • EMU Primary Life Support between deck personnel and unexpected equipment failures and certified staff are available for NBF and in the Hydrolab at the Gagarin System backpack, helmet between deck personnel and unplanned activities, adjusting the EVA operations, many with cross- Cosmonaut Training Centre. and gloves (unpressurised) divers (including private loops with • Mini Work Stations SSDS divers) script’s intensity to the crewmembers’ certification for multiple operational To help them, development of the • limited sets of EVA and • Underwater loudspeakers for performance. functions. Operations documents, training programme was accelerated in dummy tethers unidirectional communication with processes, checklists and dive plans have early 2005, and tested by experienced • EVA connectors (electrical all divers These last two activities are controlled been developed to support smooth and spacewalkers Claude Nicollier and and fluid) • Wireless headsets for deck by a Test Director, responsible for safe diving operations. Safety processes Gerhard Thiele. • ORU box and EVA tool box personnel

36 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 37 Bolender.qxd 11/9/06 4:19 PM Page 36

Human Spaceflight EVA Training

a representative helmet, a pair of Neutral Buoyancy Facility Characteristics unpressurised EMU gloves and boots suitable for foot restraints. There is a NBF Hall, Rooms and Equipment very limited set of tethers, along with • 48 m long, 24 m wide and 14.4 m high dummy tethers deliberately to increase • NBF control room, scuba equipment room, EVA equipment room, electrical the likelihood of tethers snagging and mechanical repair shop, scuba during translation. The trainee has to filling station, technical rooms for pool perform an end-to-end EVA including maintenance, water airlock egress/ ingress, ORU payload filtration/purification, control and transportation to/from a worksite, heating, showers/dressing rooms and sauna translation using waist tethers • Remote air compressor with storage (Russian protocol) and operation of tank assembly including high-pressure ISS connectors. The trainee must feedline connection to multiple filling always comply with the EVA rules: station in NBF hall items and body must be tethered at all • Overhead girder crane with 5 t capacity times, touch handrails only for translation, use only D-rings or Water Tank Mockups handrails for attaching safety tethers, • 22 m long, 17 m wide and • Modified Columbus wet and avoid keep-out zones. An ESA astronaut works with ISS connectors while standing in a portable foot restraint 10 m deep, volume mockup with ISS handrails 3 Disturbances are introduced during 3747 m , temperature range and EVA workstations 27–29°C • Russian airlock mockup the scripted run to exercise situational • Submersible platform • deployable solar panel awareness, communication skills and leading the EVA operations and have been defined and conducted to 5x3.5 m for 0–9.5 m depths, mockup decision-making; supervised by the Test Conductor. Both evaluate and (re-)certify the NBF and 250 kg loading capacity at are in the Control Room, with a Medical EVA infrastructure and equipment. 0m – the third and final ‘EV1+2 Run’ Doctor and a Safety Officer, responsible A Test Readiness Review process has • Continuous monitoring of water quality (e.g. pH value, underwater consists of a two-member for the well-being of the crew and the been developed to ensure safety and chlorine, temperature) EVA designed to emphasise teamwork safety of the operations, and an readiness of the test operations, facility, and team situational awareness, crew Audio/Video Operator to ensure the equipment and personnel. It is called on Scuba and SSDS Diving Equipment communication and workload distribution and recording of all for each diving campaign, for new or • 20 complete sets of scuba equipment (tanks, regulators, suits etc) management, in an even more realistic required signals. The Dive Supervisor modified equipment and for changes in • 3 SSDS sets composed of: – full-face mask with microphone and earphones for 2-way communications between SSDS divers and challenging scenario. The trainees directs and monitors on-deck the pre- procedures, rules or operations. and on-deck personnel; are paired and encouraged to develop and post-dive activities of the Trainees, An end-to-end test of the emergency – buoyancy jacket including inflator, with 6 litre/300 bar reserve air tank, pressure gauge and dive their own timeline and to define the Safety, Utility and Camera Divers, rescue chain was run in June 2006, computer; sharing of their EVA tools. The SSDS operator and deck support including external support from medical – 60 m umbilical hose connected to deck air supply and for communication cables. equipment is the same as for the EV1 personnel. operations, onsite security, the water • SSDS cart on-deck hosting umbilicals, air tanks, pressure-monitoring devices and video and audio monitoring Run, except that the US safety tether A study guide and DVD package with rescue team of the fire brigade, and protocol is used and the life-support the course material, videos of the EVA rescue helicopter teams. backpack cannot be used owing to runs at EAC and additional reference space limitations in the airlock. More documentation and EVA skill Training Runs for ESA Astronauts EVA Tools NBF Control Room • ISS handrails mounted on • Video: 8 channels, including tethers are also worn. The rules of demonstration videos, as well as Two ESA astronauts with no EMU airlock and Columbus switching matrix for observation engagement include all those of the computer-based training material, is experience were scheduled to start their mockups and multiple recording of EV1 Run plus additional constraints given to the trainees upon course EVA training in Houston in late 2005, as • Portable Foot Restraints underwater and deck operations for an ORU change-out requiring completion. part of their ISS crewmember training (PFRs) mounted on EVA • Additional monitor with switching specific tools from a toolbox at a During the past 2 years the Neutral programme: Frank De Winne and worksites on Columbus matrix for deck personnel in NBF mockup hall second work site. The Test Buoyancy Facility and its operations André Kuipers. Both had done scuba • EMU-like boots for use • Audio: 2 audio loops for bi- Conductor/instructor, who also plays have been constantly upgraded and training at EAC, and André had already with PFR directional communications the onboard crew role, inserts adapted for the programme. Around 20 undergone Russian Orlan suit training • EMU Primary Life Support between deck personnel and unexpected equipment failures and certified staff are available for NBF and in the Hydrolab at the Gagarin System backpack, helmet between deck personnel and unplanned activities, adjusting the EVA operations, many with cross- Cosmonaut Training Centre. and gloves (unpressurised) divers (including private loops with • Mini Work Stations SSDS divers) script’s intensity to the crewmembers’ certification for multiple operational To help them, development of the • limited sets of EVA and • Underwater loudspeakers for performance. functions. Operations documents, training programme was accelerated in dummy tethers unidirectional communication with processes, checklists and dive plans have early 2005, and tested by experienced • EVA connectors (electrical all divers These last two activities are controlled been developed to support smooth and spacewalkers Claude Nicollier and and fluid) • Wireless headsets for deck by a Test Director, responsible for safe diving operations. Safety processes Gerhard Thiele. • ORU box and EVA tool box personnel

36 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 37 Bolender.qxd 11/9/06 4:19 PM Page 38

Human Spaceflight EVA Training

Frank and André completed the Frank De Winne in the SSDS mask at EAC ESA-NASA-JAXA Crew Review course in three slots. The first two, in The success of the workshop raised the June and September 2005, covered “This training really helped me in preparing interest of the NASA Crew Office, who everything up to the EV1 Run so that for the first EVA runs I had to do at JSC. decided to perform an official Crew they could gain their EMU Suit During my first runs in the NBL, I was really Review, to assess the suitability of ESA’s Qualification at JSC. Feedback from amazed to see how much I had learned course for inexperienced EVA them and their NASA instructors from these first simulations. This EVA crewmembers, and the suitability of the confirmed that the ESA programme had precursor training is, for me, the first step in EV1+2 run for maintaining the significantly contributed to their acquiring European expertise in proficiency of experienced EVA crew performances during the first training operational training, beyond the normal during long periods of non-EVA run in Houston. They also provided system training that is already performed at training. valuable suggestions for improvement. EAC.” The following astronauts took part as The training concluded in March 2006 Frank De Winne trainees to evaluate the course: before Frank and André resumed their EVA training at JSC, and focused on the – Scott Parazynski, NASA (former EV1+2 Run. Both asked to perform it Chief of the NASA Astronaut Office again some time as a refresher, because EVA Branch, has logged 20 hours of it appeared to be useful for proficiency could improve the preparation of Europeans had received such training at EVA); training. European astronauts for future EVA JSC. In cooperation with the NASA – Koichi Wakata, Japan Aerospace Frank and André’s EVA Pre- training at the NBL. This led to the instructors, objectives were identified, Exploration Agency (JAXA; two The participants in the ESA-NASA-JAXA Crew Review, June 2006 Familiarisation Training was fully signature of a Framework of Cooperation requirements defined and the new spacewalks); coordinated with NASA’s chief EVA between the NASA EVA Office, NASA course developed, tested and in place at – , ESA (working for the inspection, and the preparation and outstanding feedback, including detailed instructor. Following this success, the Neutral Buoyancy Laboratory (NBL), EAC in less than a year. NASA Astronaut Office EVA execution at EAC of a joint NASA-ESA recommendations to improve the NASA EVA office decided to have NASA EVA Operations and the ESA In December 2005 an ESA-NASA Branch). Test Readiness Review to ensure that quality even further. As a close-out of international and experienced EVA Neutral Buoyancy Facility (NBF) for the EVA Pre-Familiarisation Workshop took both parties had a common agreement this Crew Review, all of them delivered crewmembers perform an official review preparation of European Astronauts to place at EAC over a week to They were supported by a NASA on the safety and operational readiness reports to a NASA EVA Crew Consensus to validate the training. EVA Pre-Familiarisation. demonstrate the ESA course to NASA delegation that included representatives of the programme before the the crew Memorandum for Validation of the As a result of this agreement, NASA EVA experts, including the supporting from the EVA office, the NBL and arrived. European Astronaut Centre EVA Pre- Cooperation with NASA provided 40 hours of EVA training to NBF operations and EAC’s safety set- NASA Safety. Stephen Doering, Head This event was followed by an intense Familiarisation Training Program issued This programme was developed through ESA instructors Loredana Bessone and up. NASA feedback and recommend- of the NASA EVA Office, also attended week of training for the three by Dave Wolf, Head of the EVA Branch very fruitful cooperation, first proposed Hervé Stevenin, including a 4-hour ations were integrated and ESA and the training at EAC. The first week astronauts, who went through the in the NASA Crew Office. in 2002, between EAC and the EVA EMU Suit Qualification at NBL. It was NASA jointly developed the EV1+2 consisted of a thorough safety complete course. They provided training experts at JSC. the first time that non-astronaut Run. Conclusion As a first step, NASA-NBL and ESA- ESA Astronaut Paolo Nespoli (left) and NASA Astronaut Scott Parazynski prepare for a dive The ESA EVA Pre-Familiarisation NBF in 2004 jointly agreed on a Diving ESA instructors Loredana Bessone and Hervé Stevenin work in JSC’s Neutral Buoyancy Laboratory to gain their NASA Suit Qualification Training Programme has proved to Certification Protocol for ISS Crew benefit ESA astronauts who have not Members and Training Specialists to yet been through EVA training at JSC or harmonise the requirements for scuba GCTC (“EAC personnel are to be diving proficiency training and commended for their innovation and hard certification. The logical next step was work preparing this excellent course”said to extend the cooperation to the NASA Dave Wolf). It will also be of great value EVA Office to identify jointly how EAC to the new ESA astronaut candidates, who will begin Basic Training at EAC Claude Nicollier undertakes the pre-familiarisation training at EAC within the next 2–3 years. The programme not only prepares ESA astronauts for assignment to ISS EVA crews. As reported in the Crew Consensus Memorandum, “it has also considerable potential to aid current ESA astronauts in general proficiency maintenance of EVA operations and situational awareness while not assigned to training at JSC or GCTC”. The memorandum also states “other

38 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 39 Bolender.qxd 11/9/06 4:19 PM Page 38

Human Spaceflight EVA Training

Frank and André completed the Frank De Winne in the SSDS mask at EAC ESA-NASA-JAXA Crew Review course in three slots. The first two, in The success of the workshop raised the June and September 2005, covered “This training really helped me in preparing interest of the NASA Crew Office, who everything up to the EV1 Run so that for the first EVA runs I had to do at JSC. decided to perform an official Crew they could gain their EMU Suit During my first runs in the NBL, I was really Review, to assess the suitability of ESA’s Qualification at JSC. Feedback from amazed to see how much I had learned course for inexperienced EVA them and their NASA instructors from these first simulations. This EVA crewmembers, and the suitability of the confirmed that the ESA programme had precursor training is, for me, the first step in EV1+2 run for maintaining the significantly contributed to their acquiring European expertise in proficiency of experienced EVA crew performances during the first training operational training, beyond the normal during long periods of non-EVA run in Houston. They also provided system training that is already performed at training. valuable suggestions for improvement. EAC.” The following astronauts took part as The training concluded in March 2006 Frank De Winne trainees to evaluate the course: before Frank and André resumed their EVA training at JSC, and focused on the – Scott Parazynski, NASA (former EV1+2 Run. Both asked to perform it Chief of the NASA Astronaut Office again some time as a refresher, because EVA Branch, has logged 20 hours of it appeared to be useful for proficiency could improve the preparation of Europeans had received such training at EVA); training. European astronauts for future EVA JSC. In cooperation with the NASA – Koichi Wakata, Japan Aerospace Frank and André’s EVA Pre- training at the NBL. This led to the instructors, objectives were identified, Exploration Agency (JAXA; two The participants in the ESA-NASA-JAXA Crew Review, June 2006 Familiarisation Training was fully signature of a Framework of Cooperation requirements defined and the new spacewalks); coordinated with NASA’s chief EVA between the NASA EVA Office, NASA course developed, tested and in place at – Paolo Nespoli, ESA (working for the inspection, and the preparation and outstanding feedback, including detailed instructor. Following this success, the Neutral Buoyancy Laboratory (NBL), EAC in less than a year. NASA Astronaut Office EVA execution at EAC of a joint NASA-ESA recommendations to improve the NASA EVA office decided to have NASA EVA Operations and the ESA In December 2005 an ESA-NASA Branch). Test Readiness Review to ensure that quality even further. As a close-out of international and experienced EVA Neutral Buoyancy Facility (NBF) for the EVA Pre-Familiarisation Workshop took both parties had a common agreement this Crew Review, all of them delivered crewmembers perform an official review preparation of European Astronauts to place at EAC over a week to They were supported by a NASA on the safety and operational readiness reports to a NASA EVA Crew Consensus to validate the training. EVA Pre-Familiarisation. demonstrate the ESA course to NASA delegation that included representatives of the programme before the the crew Memorandum for Validation of the As a result of this agreement, NASA EVA experts, including the supporting from the EVA office, the NBL and arrived. European Astronaut Centre EVA Pre- Cooperation with NASA provided 40 hours of EVA training to NBF operations and EAC’s safety set- NASA Safety. Stephen Doering, Head This event was followed by an intense Familiarisation Training Program issued This programme was developed through ESA instructors Loredana Bessone and up. NASA feedback and recommend- of the NASA EVA Office, also attended week of training for the three by Dave Wolf, Head of the EVA Branch very fruitful cooperation, first proposed Hervé Stevenin, including a 4-hour ations were integrated and ESA and the training at EAC. The first week astronauts, who went through the in the NASA Crew Office. in 2002, between EAC and the EVA EMU Suit Qualification at NBL. It was NASA jointly developed the EV1+2 consisted of a thorough safety complete course. They provided training experts at JSC. the first time that non-astronaut Run. Conclusion As a first step, NASA-NBL and ESA- ESA Astronaut Paolo Nespoli (left) and NASA Astronaut Scott Parazynski prepare for a dive The ESA EVA Pre-Familiarisation NBF in 2004 jointly agreed on a Diving ESA instructors Loredana Bessone and Hervé Stevenin work in JSC’s Neutral Buoyancy Laboratory to gain their NASA Suit Qualification Training Programme has proved to Certification Protocol for ISS Crew benefit ESA astronauts who have not Members and Training Specialists to yet been through EVA training at JSC or harmonise the requirements for scuba GCTC (“EAC personnel are to be diving proficiency training and commended for their innovation and hard certification. The logical next step was work preparing this excellent course”said to extend the cooperation to the NASA Dave Wolf). It will also be of great value EVA Office to identify jointly how EAC to the new ESA astronaut candidates, who will begin Basic Training at EAC Claude Nicollier undertakes the pre-familiarisation training at EAC within the next 2–3 years. The programme not only prepares ESA astronauts for assignment to ISS EVA crews. As reported in the Crew Consensus Memorandum, “it has also considerable potential to aid current ESA astronauts in general proficiency maintenance of EVA operations and situational awareness while not assigned to training at JSC or GCTC”. The memorandum also states “other

38 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 39 Bolender.qxd 11/9/06 4:19 PM Page 40

Human Spaceflight

knowledge at EAC for Europe on the challenges of EVAs, which can only be beneficial for future human spaceflight exploration.

Acknowledgements Numerous individuals and organisa- tions made this course possible through their expertise, support and dedication. Our gratitude goes to all of them, but since it is impossible to name them all, the authors thank the organisations they represent: NASA-NBL, NASA EVA Office and EVA Operations, NASA JAXA and ESA Astronaut Offices, NASA and EAC Safety. The diving team from SDT&S, DLR Technische Dienste, DLR Institut für Luft- und Thomas Reiter during his ISS spacewalk on 3 August 2006 Raumfahrtmedizin and EAC Medical Support Office, Berufsfeuerwehr Koeln and Taucherrettungsgruppe der International Partner astronauts not in space hardware underwater. The first Berufsfeuerwehr Koeln, ADAC full time training at JSC or GCTC might underwater test of Eurobot is scheduled Luftrettung ‘Christoph-Rheinland’, find this program beneficial prior to before the end of 2006. Polizeifliegerstaffel West. A special commencing suited EVA training”. This Last but not least, this programme has mention goes to the divers and EAC innovative ESA programme is an open provided ESA with valuable expertise in team members involved in the door to extend current EVA cooperation developing and performing spacewalk NBF/EVA operations. e to the other ISS partners. training. Combined with the EVA Besides crew training, the NBF experience acquired by the ESA Further information on the European Astronaut Centre and its activities can be found at infrastructure (including the EVA astronauts through their space missions, www.esa.int/eac expertise available at EAC) can also test it is helping to build operational

40 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int benveniste 11/9/06 4:25 PM Page 42

Radar Altimetry

Jérôme Benveniste Science and Applications Department, Directorate of Earth Observation Programmes, Taking the Measure ESRIN, Frascati, Italy Yves Ménard Centre National d’Études Spatiales, Toulouse, of Earth France Fifteen Years of Progress in Radar Altimetry

adar altimetry is about to enter a new era. It is becoming an indispensable tool R for oceanography as a new generation of radar altimeters providing higher resolution and precision is poised to begin service. Remarkable progress has been made since the launch of the pioneering ERS-1 in 1991.

Introduction The ERS-1 European Remote Sensing satellite, launched in 1991, was ESA’s first Earth-observation research satellite. Its comprehensive payload included an imaging synthetic-aperture radar, a radar altimeter and other powerful instruments to measure the sea-surface temperatures and wind characteristics. ERS-2 followed in 1995 and, remarkably, is still operating. At the time, the ERS twins were the most sophisticated Earth- observation satellites ever developed and launched by Europe. They have collected a wealth of valuable data on Earth’s land surfaces, oceans and polar caps, and have been called upon to monitor natural disasters such as severe flooding or earthquakes in remote parts Wave heights measured by ERS-2 during the northern summer. Red/pink shows rougher seas during the southern winter of the world.

esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 43 benveniste 11/9/06 4:25 PM Page 42

Radar Altimetry

Jérôme Benveniste Science and Applications Department, Directorate of Earth Observation Programmes, Taking the Measure ESRIN, Frascati, Italy Yves Ménard Centre National d’Études Spatiales, Toulouse, of Earth France Fifteen Years of Progress in Radar Altimetry

adar altimetry is about to enter a new era. It is becoming an indispensable tool R for oceanography as a new generation of radar altimeters providing higher resolution and precision is poised to begin service. Remarkable progress has been made since the launch of the pioneering ERS-1 in 1991.

Introduction The ERS-1 European Remote Sensing satellite, launched in 1991, was ESA’s first Earth-observation research satellite. Its comprehensive payload included an imaging synthetic-aperture radar, a radar altimeter and other powerful instruments to measure the sea-surface temperatures and wind characteristics. ERS-2 followed in 1995 and, remarkably, is still operating. At the time, the ERS twins were the most sophisticated Earth- observation satellites ever developed and launched by Europe. They have collected a wealth of valuable data on Earth’s land surfaces, oceans and polar caps, and have been called upon to monitor natural disasters such as severe flooding or earthquakes in remote parts Wave heights measured by ERS-2 during the northern summer. Red/pink shows rougher seas during the southern winter of the world.

esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 43 benveniste 11/9/06 4:25 PM Page 44

Earth Observation Radar Altimetry

The accuracy of global geodetic In the Indian and, particularly, Pacific altimeters is also used in near-realtime measurements has increased from a few The Principle of Radar Altimetry oceans, the trends in both sea level and jointly with sea-surface temperature and hundred metres at the beginning of the Radar altimetry measures the distance temperature are still dominated by the models to investigate how the upper- satellite era to a few centimetres now. between a satellite and the surface below large changes associated with the large ocean thermal structure is involved in using radar echoes bounced back from the Though a highly complex problem, it El Niño Southern Oscillation of strengthening hurricanes. surface, whether ocean, ice cap, sea-ice, recently became possible to exploit desert, lake or river. The characteristics of the 1997–1998. Fresh water brought by rain, radar altimetry to monitor inland water echoes contain further information on the snow, melting sea-ice, ice sheets and Understanding the Cryosphere levels; the accuracy over these difficult roughness of the surface, wave heights or glaciers complicate our understanding Glaciologists had to wait until the terrains is improving rapidly. wind speeds over the ocean. of the rise in sea levels. It can be advent of ERS-1 to see a polar altimeter After many years of development and Altimetry measurements become scientific- expected that the next decade of flying over sea-ice and the ice sheets. The data exploitation, radar altimetry is ally more useful when the satellite’s position is altimetry will provide fundamental new instrument proved to be a very powerful accurately known. Many satellites, including becoming operational in oceanographic insights into these important features. tool for glaciology, with three major Envisat and CryoSat, carry the DORIS applications. A new generation of high- (Doppler Orbitography and Radiopositioning scientific objectives: ice-sheet modelling resolution and high-precision instruments Integrated by Satellite) radio receiver for Tsunamis and dynamics, ice-sheet mass balance is entering service using techniques such precise orbit determination. DORIS calculates The Sumatran tsunami of December and sea-ice thickness. There are also as ‘delay-Doppler’ and interferometry. the orbit to an accuracy of a few centimetres 2004 was the first to be observed by numerous secondary uses. We now know much more about our by measuring the Doppler shift on signals altimeters in space, which has allowed Earth, ocean dynamics and the cryo- broadcast from a network of more than 50 scientists to improve our understanding Ice sheets beacons spread around the world. sphere than we would without altimetry, of how tsunamis propagate. This is The mass changes in ice sheets has been and we have laid the foundations for invaluable for helping to avoid disasters, studied from space, ranging from the The kinetic energy of eddies in the North Atlantic calculated from sea-level data along the Topex-Poseidon and ERS groundtracks. Red fully operational 3-D oceanography. in addition to being of great interest for largest sheets in Antarctica and highlights the greatest energy. (Le Traon & Dibarboure) science. One of the main components of Greenland, to smaller ones such as the Understanding the Ocean building propagation models is the Austfonna (in Svalbard, the world’s Radar altimetry has made an important underwater equivalent to altimetry: third largest icecap and the largest contribution to oceanography by bathymetry. This is the measurement of glacier in Europe). Overall, the investigating the high-frequency the depth contours of the soil, rock or Greenland and Antarctica sheets are variability in sea-surface height from sand at the bottom of a body of water found to be almost in equilibrium, global to basin scales, and its impact on such as an ocean or a lake. Deriving sea- losing as much ice as they gain, but local the oceans’ general circulation. It Sea levels floor topography from radar altimetry is data suggest a loss that could accelerate highlights the importance of eddies in Altimeter observations from satellites improving the accuracy of these models in the near future. shaping and controlling the flows of show that the global mean sea level has because the nature of the floor influences Radar altimeters are not only able to major current systems such as the risen over the past decade at a rate of how tsunamis move and build. map the global trend but can also catch Antarctic circumpolar current and about 3 mm each year, well above the local imbalances. However, discrepancies western boundary currents (Gulf rate of 1.8 mm per year over the Marine meteorology between some studies may be explained Stream and Kuroshio), and the previous 100 years. This is despite large Radar altimeters are indispensable for by the behaviour of radar waves influence of eddies on the vertical geographical variations, including broad observing the sea state in a variety of interacting with packed snow. This is mixing in the ocean. The results from 15 areas of falling sea level. Consistent applications. Wave climatology, a well- why Envisat’s dual-frequency altimeter years of altimeter data on eddy increases in both sea level and sea- established altimeter application, is is helping to improve our knowledge of variability in the oceans are outstanding surface temperatures have been found in continuously enriched by new data as how radar waves penetrate the snow. and are certainly a major accomplish- most parts of the Atlantic Ocean over they become available; the longer the ment. Altimetry has proved unique in the past 15 years. record, the more consistent and reliable Altimetry over Land and Inland Water The variability of sea-surface height from Topex-Poseidon and ERS data in the southern Pacific Ocean. Box 1 highlights the variability of the South Equatorial Counter Current. Box 3 shows the variability of the South Tropical Counter Current. (Qiu &Chen) dramatically improving our tide models, the results. Correlation of wave-height The potential of satellite radar altimeter in observing internal tides and The rise in sea level during the 20th century appears to be variations with climatological phenom- data for applications over land and understanding the of climatic accelerating. Satellite measurements for the last 15 years are ena such as the North Atlantic inland water is now well known, as data By 1992, the unique results from ERS common goals, and the different events such as El Niño and the North shown in green. (Cazenave et al.) Oscillation has been observed – and has from Topex-Poseidon, Jason, ERS-1, and the CNES/NASA Topex-Poseidon geodesy, geophysics and oceanography Atlantic or North Pacific Oscillations. opened a whole new area of science. ERS-2 and Envisat have extensively had provided a strong foundation for scientific communities had to learn to Now it is the interaction between Wave modelling, a traditional applica- shown. Initially developed to make the future of satellite altimetry and the work closely together. Cryosphere phenomena such as planetary waves, tion, has greatly improved recently precise measurements of sea surfaces, missions then in development, such as researchers benefited by adapting the eddies, tides and mean flow, and their thanks to the assimilation of altimeter radar altimeters rapidly proved able to Jason (CNES and NASA/Jet Propulsion technology and data-processing impact on coastal regions, that must be data in near-realtime, and is now provide information over the continents. Laboratory), Envisat and Geosat progress made by oceanographers, to investigated. These new studies will generating accurate sea-state predictions, Their development to monitor Follow-On (US Navy). Countries with monitor the ice caps and sea-ice. benefit greatly from the higher to the enormous benefit of the shipping continental water surfaces provides a different cultures, especially Europe and Over several decades, new technologies resolution sampling provided by the industry. In addition, sea-surface powerful tool for studying regional the USA, learned to work towards with improved accuracy were developed. upcoming altimeter missions. topography measured by radar hydrological systems.

44 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 45 benveniste 11/9/06 4:25 PM Page 44

Earth Observation Radar Altimetry

The accuracy of global geodetic In the Indian and, particularly, Pacific altimeters is also used in near-realtime measurements has increased from a few The Principle of Radar Altimetry oceans, the trends in both sea level and jointly with sea-surface temperature and hundred metres at the beginning of the Radar altimetry measures the distance temperature are still dominated by the models to investigate how the upper- satellite era to a few centimetres now. between a satellite and the surface below large changes associated with the large ocean thermal structure is involved in using radar echoes bounced back from the Though a highly complex problem, it El Niño Southern Oscillation of strengthening hurricanes. surface, whether ocean, ice cap, sea-ice, recently became possible to exploit desert, lake or river. The characteristics of the 1997–1998. Fresh water brought by rain, radar altimetry to monitor inland water echoes contain further information on the snow, melting sea-ice, ice sheets and Understanding the Cryosphere levels; the accuracy over these difficult roughness of the surface, wave heights or glaciers complicate our understanding Glaciologists had to wait until the terrains is improving rapidly. wind speeds over the ocean. of the rise in sea levels. It can be advent of ERS-1 to see a polar altimeter After many years of development and Altimetry measurements become scientific- expected that the next decade of flying over sea-ice and the ice sheets. The data exploitation, radar altimetry is ally more useful when the satellite’s position is altimetry will provide fundamental new instrument proved to be a very powerful accurately known. Many satellites, including becoming operational in oceanographic insights into these important features. tool for glaciology, with three major Envisat and CryoSat, carry the DORIS applications. A new generation of high- (Doppler Orbitography and Radiopositioning scientific objectives: ice-sheet modelling resolution and high-precision instruments Integrated by Satellite) radio receiver for Tsunamis and dynamics, ice-sheet mass balance is entering service using techniques such precise orbit determination. DORIS calculates The Sumatran tsunami of December and sea-ice thickness. There are also as ‘delay-Doppler’ and interferometry. the orbit to an accuracy of a few centimetres 2004 was the first to be observed by numerous secondary uses. We now know much more about our by measuring the Doppler shift on signals altimeters in space, which has allowed Earth, ocean dynamics and the cryo- broadcast from a network of more than 50 scientists to improve our understanding Ice sheets beacons spread around the world. sphere than we would without altimetry, of how tsunamis propagate. This is The mass changes in ice sheets has been and we have laid the foundations for invaluable for helping to avoid disasters, studied from space, ranging from the The kinetic energy of eddies in the North Atlantic calculated from sea-level data along the Topex-Poseidon and ERS groundtracks. Red fully operational 3-D oceanography. in addition to being of great interest for largest sheets in Antarctica and highlights the greatest energy. (Le Traon & Dibarboure) science. One of the main components of Greenland, to smaller ones such as the Understanding the Ocean building propagation models is the Austfonna (in Svalbard, the world’s Radar altimetry has made an important underwater equivalent to altimetry: third largest icecap and the largest contribution to oceanography by bathymetry. This is the measurement of glacier in Europe). Overall, the investigating the high-frequency the depth contours of the soil, rock or Greenland and Antarctica sheets are variability in sea-surface height from sand at the bottom of a body of water found to be almost in equilibrium, global to basin scales, and its impact on such as an ocean or a lake. Deriving sea- losing as much ice as they gain, but local the oceans’ general circulation. It Sea levels floor topography from radar altimetry is data suggest a loss that could accelerate highlights the importance of eddies in Altimeter observations from satellites improving the accuracy of these models in the near future. shaping and controlling the flows of show that the global mean sea level has because the nature of the floor influences Radar altimeters are not only able to major current systems such as the risen over the past decade at a rate of how tsunamis move and build. map the global trend but can also catch Antarctic circumpolar current and about 3 mm each year, well above the local imbalances. However, discrepancies western boundary currents (Gulf rate of 1.8 mm per year over the Marine meteorology between some studies may be explained Stream and Kuroshio), and the previous 100 years. This is despite large Radar altimeters are indispensable for by the behaviour of radar waves influence of eddies on the vertical geographical variations, including broad observing the sea state in a variety of interacting with packed snow. This is mixing in the ocean. The results from 15 areas of falling sea level. Consistent applications. Wave climatology, a well- why Envisat’s dual-frequency altimeter years of altimeter data on eddy increases in both sea level and sea- established altimeter application, is is helping to improve our knowledge of variability in the oceans are outstanding surface temperatures have been found in continuously enriched by new data as how radar waves penetrate the snow. and are certainly a major accomplish- most parts of the Atlantic Ocean over they become available; the longer the ment. Altimetry has proved unique in the past 15 years. record, the more consistent and reliable Altimetry over Land and Inland Water The variability of sea-surface height from Topex-Poseidon and ERS data in the southern Pacific Ocean. Box 1 highlights the variability of the South Equatorial Counter Current. Box 3 shows the variability of the South Tropical Counter Current. (Qiu &Chen) dramatically improving our tide models, the results. Correlation of wave-height The potential of satellite radar altimeter in observing internal tides and The rise in sea level during the 20th century appears to be variations with climatological phenom- data for applications over land and understanding the genesis of climatic accelerating. Satellite measurements for the last 15 years are ena such as the North Atlantic inland water is now well known, as data By 1992, the unique results from ERS common goals, and the different events such as El Niño and the North shown in green. (Cazenave et al.) Oscillation has been observed – and has from Topex-Poseidon, Jason, ERS-1, and the CNES/NASA Topex-Poseidon geodesy, geophysics and oceanography Atlantic or North Pacific Oscillations. opened a whole new area of science. ERS-2 and Envisat have extensively had provided a strong foundation for scientific communities had to learn to Now it is the interaction between Wave modelling, a traditional applica- shown. Initially developed to make the future of satellite altimetry and the work closely together. Cryosphere phenomena such as planetary waves, tion, has greatly improved recently precise measurements of sea surfaces, missions then in development, such as researchers benefited by adapting the eddies, tides and mean flow, and their thanks to the assimilation of altimeter radar altimeters rapidly proved able to Jason (CNES and NASA/Jet Propulsion technology and data-processing impact on coastal regions, that must be data in near-realtime, and is now provide information over the continents. Laboratory), Envisat and Geosat progress made by oceanographers, to investigated. These new studies will generating accurate sea-state predictions, Their development to monitor Follow-On (US Navy). Countries with monitor the ice caps and sea-ice. benefit greatly from the higher to the enormous benefit of the shipping continental water surfaces provides a different cultures, especially Europe and Over several decades, new technologies resolution sampling provided by the industry. In addition, sea-surface powerful tool for studying regional the USA, learned to work towards with improved accuracy were developed. upcoming altimeter missions. topography measured by radar hydrological systems.

44 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 45 benveniste 11/9/06 4:25 PM Page 46

Earth Observation Radar Altimetry

Satellite altimetry is improving the Global Digital Elevation Model and our knowledge of sea floor topography. (Berry et al.)

46 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 47 benveniste 11/9/06 4:25 PM Page 46

Earth Observation Radar Altimetry

Satellite altimetry is improving the Global Digital Elevation Model and our knowledge of sea floor topography. (Berry et al.)

46 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 47 benveniste 11/9/06 4:25 PM Page 48

Earth Observation Radar Altimetry

gravity models. Subtraction of this new measurements by altimetry. Scientists about equal to North America, is a model from an altimeter-derived sea are delighted that ESA is rebuilding the broad part of the ocean floor lifted up surface reveals the dynamic ocean satellite. between two major tectonic plates. The topography, at a resolution nearly The laser altimeter aboard NASA’s Louisville Ridge lies to the west of this, sufficient to resolve the western ICESat has provided new gravity and is a chain of large underwater boundary currents. information in those parts of the Arctic volcanoes discovered in 1972 using depth These models are an improvement Ocean where permanent sea-ice closely soundings collected along random ship over the EGM96 combined model and conforms to the shape of the geoid. crossings of the South Pacific. Six years thus will provide an improved reference Further improvements in the accuracy later, the full extent of this chain was for higher-resolution marine gravity and resolution of marine gravity would revealed by a radar altimeter aboard models derived from altimetry. The new provide important contributions in both NASA’s Seasat. Recent data collected by The ground track of Envisat’s radar altimeter over the basin, using a 35-day repeat Envisat altimeter measurements (circles) of the river levels in the Amazon Basin compare well with global-scale geoid models also serve as a scientific and practical studies such as Geosat and ERS-1 show the Pacific- cycle. The height readings over the rivers were used to produce the accompanying graph of in situ readings from gauges (line). (Berry et al.) global vertical reference system. locating 50 000 uncharted seamounts in Antarctic Rise and the Louisville Ridge river levels since 2002 (Berry et al.) Scientists are preparing for the GOCE the deep oceans and exploring the in unprecedented detail. mission, which will provide improved offshore sedimentary basins for oil. Although monitoring inland waters is with ESA. There are different scientific exploiting today’s missions (ERS-2, spatial resolution (about 100 km), Other applications include mapping the Progress in Ocean Integrated Systems rapidly developing, the potential of and technical challenges to be overcome Envisat, Jason-1, Geosat Follow-On) sufficient to resolve western boundary details of plate tectonics, planning In 15 years there has been a wide range multi-mission altimetry is only now in such missions. One is the need to map and on the future CryoSat, Jason-2 and currents such as the Gulf Stream fully. shipboard surveys in remote areas and of activities: synergies between remote being realised. One such mission is river basins in two dimensions, inferring Sentinel-3 missions for studying inland improved inertial navigation of aircraft sensing and in situ data, development of WatER, proposed both to ESA in 2005 the slopes as well as the levels of rivers. waters. Marine gravity and ships. operational oceanography systems, as a response to the second call for While WatER would need several Although no new non-repeating orbit model validation and studies of the Earth Explorer core missions and to years to be developed, if selected, Gravity and Marine Geoid Modelling radar altimeter data have been available Bathymetry impact of the integrated approach on NASA as a possible partnership mission scientists are meanwhile focusing on Geodesy since the ERS-1 geodetic phase in Ocean bathymetry is currently best research and applications. The After years of slow progress, two 1994–1995, reprocessing the raw measured by sonars aboard ships, but international Global Ocean Data missions – CHAMP (2000) and altimeter waveforms has produced a only a small fraction of the global ocean Assimilation Experiment (GODAE) is a GRACE (2002) – are providing exciting near-40% improvement in the accuracy basins have been surveyed; it is practical demonstration of near- The WatER interferometric radar altimeter concept uses two antennas to create a 2-D image of surface height. The results in global geodesy, and GOCE of the gravity field. Comparisons with estimated that it will take 125 ship-years realtime global ocean data assimilation mission was proposed for ESA’s Earth Explorer programme (2007) will soon join them. Geodesy shipborne gravity measurements over to survey all of the deep oceans. The that supports operational oceanography, (Mognard et al.) primarily concerns positioning and the the deep ocean show the accuracy is now need for improved global bathymetry is seasonal-to-decadal climate forecasts gravity field and geometrical aspects of 3–5 mGal and the shortest half- critical because it forms the basic data and oceanographic research. their variations, and it can include the wavelength resolved is approaching the for many fields, including tsunami The main integrated systems study of Earth’s magnetic field. Gravity altimeter track spacing of 8 km from propagation, hydrodynamic tide models/ developed as part of GODAE cover anomalies reflect mass variations inside ERS-1. tidal friction, ocean circulation, seafloor high-resolution (eddy-resolving) systems the Earth, offering a rare window on the The Cryosat launch failure was a tectonics, identification of volcanic that focus on the forecasting of ocean interior. The geoid is the shape of an major setback for the marine gravity chains, defining the 2500 m isobath for mesoscale conditions, and lower resolu- ideal global ocean at rest, and it is used and geophysics communities because the law of the sea, and fisheries tion systems for climate applications. as the reference surface for mapping all that mission would have provided a new management. Such applications require a precise and topographic features, whether they are global altimeter dataset with dense track For example, the Pacific-Antarctic dynamically consistent description of on land, ice or ocean. The geoid’s shape spacing and, more importantly, it would Rise and Louisville Ridge were the ocean state. Use of advanced data depends solely on Earth’s gravity field, have demonstrated the technology for unknown features 30 years ago. The assimilation techniques allows diagnostic so its accuracy benefits from improved the next generation of marine gravity Pacific-Antarctic Rise, covering an area studies such as heat balance. A major gravity mapping. Measuring sea-level changes, ocean circulation and ice movements, for example, need an Improvement in our knowledge of sea floor topography from Seasat (1978, right) to the Geosat and ERS-1 geodetic missions. (Smith & Sandwell) accurate geoid as a starting point. Heat Louisville Ridge and mass transport by oceans are important elements of climate change, Pacific Antarctic Rise but they are still poorly known and await measurement of ocean surface circulation. The new EIGEN04 gravity model derived from these missions and terrestrial gravity data eliminates much of the ‘meridional striping’ seen in

48 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 49 benveniste 11/9/06 4:25 PM Page 48

Earth Observation Radar Altimetry

gravity models. Subtraction of this new measurements by altimetry. Scientists about equal to North America, is a model from an altimeter-derived sea are delighted that ESA is rebuilding the broad part of the ocean floor lifted up surface reveals the dynamic ocean satellite. between two major tectonic plates. The topography, at a resolution nearly The laser altimeter aboard NASA’s Louisville Ridge lies to the west of this, sufficient to resolve the western ICESat has provided new gravity and is a chain of large underwater boundary currents. information in those parts of the Arctic volcanoes discovered in 1972 using depth These models are an improvement Ocean where permanent sea-ice closely soundings collected along random ship over the EGM96 combined model and conforms to the shape of the geoid. crossings of the South Pacific. Six years thus will provide an improved reference Further improvements in the accuracy later, the full extent of this chain was for higher-resolution marine gravity and resolution of marine gravity would revealed by a radar altimeter aboard models derived from altimetry. The new provide important contributions in both NASA’s Seasat. Recent data collected by The ground track of Envisat’s radar altimeter over the Amazon basin, using a 35-day repeat Envisat altimeter measurements (circles) of the river levels in the Amazon Basin compare well with global-scale geoid models also serve as a scientific and practical studies such as Geosat and ERS-1 show the Pacific- cycle. The height readings over the rivers were used to produce the accompanying graph of in situ readings from gauges (line). (Berry et al.) global vertical reference system. locating 50 000 uncharted seamounts in Antarctic Rise and the Louisville Ridge river levels since 2002 (Berry et al.) Scientists are preparing for the GOCE the deep oceans and exploring the in unprecedented detail. mission, which will provide improved offshore sedimentary basins for oil. Although monitoring inland waters is with ESA. There are different scientific exploiting today’s missions (ERS-2, spatial resolution (about 100 km), Other applications include mapping the Progress in Ocean Integrated Systems rapidly developing, the potential of and technical challenges to be overcome Envisat, Jason-1, Geosat Follow-On) sufficient to resolve western boundary details of plate tectonics, planning In 15 years there has been a wide range multi-mission altimetry is only now in such missions. One is the need to map and on the future CryoSat, Jason-2 and currents such as the Gulf Stream fully. shipboard surveys in remote areas and of activities: synergies between remote being realised. One such mission is river basins in two dimensions, inferring Sentinel-3 missions for studying inland improved inertial navigation of aircraft sensing and in situ data, development of WatER, proposed both to ESA in 2005 the slopes as well as the levels of rivers. waters. Marine gravity and ships. operational oceanography systems, as a response to the second call for While WatER would need several Although no new non-repeating orbit model validation and studies of the Earth Explorer core missions and to years to be developed, if selected, Gravity and Marine Geoid Modelling radar altimeter data have been available Bathymetry impact of the integrated approach on NASA as a possible partnership mission scientists are meanwhile focusing on Geodesy since the ERS-1 geodetic phase in Ocean bathymetry is currently best research and applications. The After years of slow progress, two 1994–1995, reprocessing the raw measured by sonars aboard ships, but international Global Ocean Data missions – CHAMP (2000) and altimeter waveforms has produced a only a small fraction of the global ocean Assimilation Experiment (GODAE) is a GRACE (2002) – are providing exciting near-40% improvement in the accuracy basins have been surveyed; it is practical demonstration of near- The WatER interferometric radar altimeter concept uses two antennas to create a 2-D image of surface height. The results in global geodesy, and GOCE of the gravity field. Comparisons with estimated that it will take 125 ship-years realtime global ocean data assimilation mission was proposed for ESA’s Earth Explorer programme (2007) will soon join them. Geodesy shipborne gravity measurements over to survey all of the deep oceans. The that supports operational oceanography, (Mognard et al.) primarily concerns positioning and the the deep ocean show the accuracy is now need for improved global bathymetry is seasonal-to-decadal climate forecasts gravity field and geometrical aspects of 3–5 mGal and the shortest half- critical because it forms the basic data and oceanographic research. their variations, and it can include the wavelength resolved is approaching the for many fields, including tsunami The main integrated systems study of Earth’s magnetic field. Gravity altimeter track spacing of 8 km from propagation, hydrodynamic tide models/ developed as part of GODAE cover anomalies reflect mass variations inside ERS-1. tidal friction, ocean circulation, seafloor high-resolution (eddy-resolving) systems the Earth, offering a rare window on the The Cryosat launch failure was a tectonics, identification of volcanic that focus on the forecasting of ocean interior. The geoid is the shape of an major setback for the marine gravity chains, defining the 2500 m isobath for mesoscale conditions, and lower resolu- ideal global ocean at rest, and it is used and geophysics communities because the law of the sea, and fisheries tion systems for climate applications. as the reference surface for mapping all that mission would have provided a new management. Such applications require a precise and topographic features, whether they are global altimeter dataset with dense track For example, the Pacific-Antarctic dynamically consistent description of on land, ice or ocean. The geoid’s shape spacing and, more importantly, it would Rise and Louisville Ridge were the ocean state. Use of advanced data depends solely on Earth’s gravity field, have demonstrated the technology for unknown features 30 years ago. The assimilation techniques allows diagnostic so its accuracy benefits from improved the next generation of marine gravity Pacific-Antarctic Rise, covering an area studies such as heat balance. A major gravity mapping. Measuring sea-level changes, ocean circulation and ice movements, for example, need an Improvement in our knowledge of sea floor topography from Seasat (1978, right) to the Geosat and ERS-1 geodetic missions. (Smith & Sandwell) accurate geoid as a starting point. Heat Louisville Ridge and mass transport by oceans are important elements of climate change, Pacific Antarctic Rise but they are still poorly known and await measurement of ocean surface circulation. The new EIGEN04 gravity model derived from these missions and terrestrial gravity data eliminates much of the ‘meridional striping’ seen in

48 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 49 benveniste 11/9/06 4:25 PM Page 50

Earth Observation Radar Altimetry

are often small-scale, rapidly changing For the GMES core marine services, filling the possible service gap after map rivers, lakes and wetlands at a and highly turbulent events calling for the operational Sentinel-3 mission will Envisat and complementing Jason-2 for spatial scale over 100 m with a height combined satellite and in situ data (such deliver key information on sea-surface the resolution of ocean mesoscale accuracy of 5–10 cm. as from tide gauges and buoys) to ensure topography, sea-surface temperature variability. It will increase accuracy and Finally, higher resolution is needed adequate resolution and coverage, as and water quality, for example. The sampling capabilities in coastal regions not only for progress in mapping ocean close as possible to the shore-line. operational phase of Sentinel-3 is and improve continental ice-sheet mesoscale and coastal variability and Future altimetry systems will also have planned for around 2011–2015. monitoring, though with the possible hydrological systems, but also to make to meet these requirements, either by For the near future, the main reduction of observing capability under the next advances in geodetic and employing constellations of satellites or operational mission will be Jason-2, exceptional rain and cloud conditions. bathymetric signals using space by developing new wide-swath radar developed by NASA and CNES to be Considerable scientific progress is altimetry. Studies have shown that these concepts. operated by the US National Oceanic & expected from wide-swath interfero- advances could be realised in a highly Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) metric altimetry, not only by resolving cost-effective manner with a high- The Future of Altimetry and Eumetsat. It extends the Topex- smaller-scale ocean variability, but also resolution radar altimeter (as carried by The European Commission-funded Poseidon and Jason-1 series and by providing a truly 2-D sampling of CryoSat) aboard a microsatellite. GAMBLE (Global Altimeter Measure- enhances the current altimetry services hydrological systems. In August 2005, a ments By Leading Europeans) project for climate monitoring and operational consortium with over 150 participants Acknowledgements brought together European experts in oceanography. In the longer term, from the wider hydrological community This article is based on a report of the 2002–2003 to consider future develop- Eumetsat is offering its capability as a submitted the WatER mission proposal Symposium ‘15 Years of Progress in issue for effective data assimilation is to The main conclusion is that major ments in satellite altimetry. The aim was leading European operational organisa- to ESA’s Earth Explorer programme. To Radar Altimetry’ held on 13–18 March estimate the model ‘error covariance’ advances over the past 5 years have to provide recommendations for tion to run some proposed future be flown after 2010, WatER would 2006 in Venice (I). All abstracts, oral and there has been a significant advance helped to develop an ‘integrated’ research and future altimeter missions missions, such as GMES Sentinel-3 and, contribute to a fundamental under- presentations and posters can be viewed in accounting better for these errors. approach to describe and forecast ocean to support and build on current work in possibly, the Jason-2 follow-on. standing of the global water cycle by at http://earth.esa.int/venice06. The A major contributing project to conditions. Integrated descriptions of operational oceanography and to Scientific developments have seen a providing global measurements of papers are available in the proceedings GODAE is Argo, an array of more than the ocean state are now available and are maintain ocean-monitoring programmes. recent tendency towards Ka-band terrestrial surface water storage changes SP-614 from ESA Publications Division 2000 free-floating floats that provide used to characterise and understand GAMBLE recommended in 2003 that altimetry. In particular, CNES is now and discharge. The main instrument is at http://www.esa.int e temperatures and salinity measurements ocean climate variations better. This is coverage by a single satellite is not proposing its AltiKa mission for a the KaRin wide-swath Ka-band at various depths across the oceans. crucial for the long-term sustainability sufficient to meet both operational and launch around mid-2009, aiming at interferometric altimeter, which could Argo results are scientifically valuable in of the global ocean observing system. scientific user needs. Rather, a their own right but can be combined The use of Argo and altimetry data is constellation of at least three nadir- with altimetry data for enhancing essential for developing an improved viewing altimeters is needed to provide environmental and climate knowledge. understanding of variations in the ocean the sampling required for many Studies on the impact of altimetry and climate. The strong synergies between practical purposes. GAMBLE stressed Argo on seasonal forecasts show they Argo and altimetry will become more or the demonstration of new technology The latest “ESA Achievements” can significantly improve data- more obvious as Argo is expanded. such as wide-swath altimeters and larger assimilation systems. Thanks to these constellations of altimeters aboard book is now available! studies, Argo and altimetry are now A New Challenge: Coastal Monitoring microsatellites. The latter could prove to used in the operational seasonal Altimetry may contribute in many ways be very effective in the timely forecasting systems of the European to the study of coastal phenomena, deliverance of sea-state information and Centre for Medium range Weather especially tides, currents and sea state, in warning of natural hazards. In more than 400 pages, it highlights, Forecasting. that directly affect, for example, offshore An important topic for the future of past, present and approved future Physics and biology can be coupled oil exploration, fishing, marine - altimetry is the ongoing transition through the joint analysis of altimetry, culture and coastal planning and towards operational services. In Europe, a missions of the Agency. sea-surface temperature, ocean colour development. Altimetry can supply leading initiative is the Global and model data. There are now studies direct measurements of sea level and sea Monitoring for Environment and into the different mechanisms that could state, and vital information about Security (GMES) programme to develop Copies of are available at EUR 30 each. Just explain the observation of planetary ‘forcing’ from areas just outside the a coordinated operational environmental waves in altimeter, sea-surface tempera- coastal domain. These include the information service, partly based on fill in the Order Form at the back of this ture and ocean colour data. Horizontal influence of offshore ocean circulation today’s space infrastructures. The issue of the Bulletin and send it in by mail advection is an important mechanism and the inflow of fresh water from land MERSEA ocean science component of but vertical and biological effects cannot masses, closely tied to river and lake GMES involves 50 European partners or fax. If you have any questions, please be ruled out. Other studies have shown levels and to ice extent, all of which can aiming to develop and sustain an the importance of ocean physics on the be observed by altimetry satellites. integrated, operational system to provide send them to [email protected] development of phytoplankton blooms However, coastal monitoring has very analysis and forecasting over the global in the wake of islands. demanding requirements. The phenomena ocean and European seas.

50 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 51 benveniste 11/9/06 4:25 PM Page 50

Earth Observation Radar Altimetry

are often small-scale, rapidly changing For the GMES core marine services, filling the possible service gap after map rivers, lakes and wetlands at a and highly turbulent events calling for the operational Sentinel-3 mission will Envisat and complementing Jason-2 for spatial scale over 100 m with a height combined satellite and in situ data (such deliver key information on sea-surface the resolution of ocean mesoscale accuracy of 5–10 cm. as from tide gauges and buoys) to ensure topography, sea-surface temperature variability. It will increase accuracy and Finally, higher resolution is needed adequate resolution and coverage, as and water quality, for example. The sampling capabilities in coastal regions not only for progress in mapping ocean close as possible to the shore-line. operational phase of Sentinel-3 is and improve continental ice-sheet mesoscale and coastal variability and Future altimetry systems will also have planned for around 2011–2015. monitoring, though with the possible hydrological systems, but also to make to meet these requirements, either by For the near future, the main reduction of observing capability under the next advances in geodetic and employing constellations of satellites or operational mission will be Jason-2, exceptional rain and cloud conditions. bathymetric signals using space by developing new wide-swath radar developed by NASA and CNES to be Considerable scientific progress is altimetry. Studies have shown that these concepts. operated by the US National Oceanic & expected from wide-swath interfero- advances could be realised in a highly Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) metric altimetry, not only by resolving cost-effective manner with a high- The Future of Altimetry and Eumetsat. It extends the Topex- smaller-scale ocean variability, but also resolution radar altimeter (as carried by The European Commission-funded Poseidon and Jason-1 series and by providing a truly 2-D sampling of CryoSat) aboard a microsatellite. GAMBLE (Global Altimeter Measure- enhances the current altimetry services hydrological systems. In August 2005, a ments By Leading Europeans) project for climate monitoring and operational consortium with over 150 participants Acknowledgements brought together European experts in oceanography. In the longer term, from the wider hydrological community This article is based on a report of the 2002–2003 to consider future develop- Eumetsat is offering its capability as a submitted the WatER mission proposal Symposium ‘15 Years of Progress in issue for effective data assimilation is to The main conclusion is that major ments in satellite altimetry. The aim was leading European operational organisa- to ESA’s Earth Explorer programme. To Radar Altimetry’ held on 13–18 March estimate the model ‘error covariance’ advances over the past 5 years have to provide recommendations for tion to run some proposed future be flown after 2010, WatER would 2006 in Venice (I). All abstracts, oral and there has been a significant advance helped to develop an ‘integrated’ research and future altimeter missions missions, such as GMES Sentinel-3 and, contribute to a fundamental under- presentations and posters can be viewed in accounting better for these errors. approach to describe and forecast ocean to support and build on current work in possibly, the Jason-2 follow-on. standing of the global water cycle by at http://earth.esa.int/venice06. The A major contributing project to conditions. Integrated descriptions of operational oceanography and to Scientific developments have seen a providing global measurements of papers are available in the proceedings GODAE is Argo, an array of more than the ocean state are now available and are maintain ocean-monitoring programmes. recent tendency towards Ka-band terrestrial surface water storage changes SP-614 from ESA Publications Division 2000 free-floating floats that provide used to characterise and understand GAMBLE recommended in 2003 that altimetry. In particular, CNES is now and discharge. The main instrument is at http://www.esa.int e temperatures and salinity measurements ocean climate variations better. This is coverage by a single satellite is not proposing its AltiKa mission for a the KaRin wide-swath Ka-band at various depths across the oceans. crucial for the long-term sustainability sufficient to meet both operational and launch around mid-2009, aiming at interferometric altimeter, which could Argo results are scientifically valuable in of the global ocean observing system. scientific user needs. Rather, a their own right but can be combined The use of Argo and altimetry data is constellation of at least three nadir- with altimetry data for enhancing essential for developing an improved viewing altimeters is needed to provide environmental and climate knowledge. understanding of variations in the ocean the sampling required for many Studies on the impact of altimetry and climate. The strong synergies between practical purposes. GAMBLE stressed Argo on seasonal forecasts show they Argo and altimetry will become more or the demonstration of new technology The latest “ESA Achievements” can significantly improve data- more obvious as Argo is expanded. such as wide-swath altimeters and larger assimilation systems. Thanks to these constellations of altimeters aboard book is now available! studies, Argo and altimetry are now A New Challenge: Coastal Monitoring microsatellites. The latter could prove to used in the operational seasonal Altimetry may contribute in many ways be very effective in the timely forecasting systems of the European to the study of coastal phenomena, deliverance of sea-state information and Centre for Medium range Weather especially tides, currents and sea state, in warning of natural hazards. In more than 400 pages, it highlights, Forecasting. that directly affect, for example, offshore An important topic for the future of past, present and approved future Physics and biology can be coupled oil exploration, fishing, marine aqua- altimetry is the ongoing transition through the joint analysis of altimetry, culture and coastal planning and towards operational services. In Europe, a missions of the Agency. sea-surface temperature, ocean colour development. Altimetry can supply leading initiative is the Global and model data. There are now studies direct measurements of sea level and sea Monitoring for Environment and into the different mechanisms that could state, and vital information about Security (GMES) programme to develop Copies of are available at EUR 30 each. Just explain the observation of planetary ‘forcing’ from areas just outside the a coordinated operational environmental waves in altimeter, sea-surface tempera- coastal domain. These include the information service, partly based on fill in the Order Form at the back of this ture and ocean colour data. Horizontal influence of offshore ocean circulation today’s space infrastructures. The issue of the Bulletin and send it in by mail advection is an important mechanism and the inflow of fresh water from land MERSEA ocean science component of but vertical and biological effects cannot masses, closely tied to river and lake GMES involves 50 European partners or fax. If you have any questions, please be ruled out. Other studies have shown levels and to ice extent, all of which can aiming to develop and sustain an the importance of ocean physics on the be observed by altimetry satellites. integrated, operational system to provide send them to [email protected] development of phytoplankton blooms However, coastal monitoring has very analysis and forecasting over the global in the wake of islands. demanding requirements. The phenomena ocean and European seas.

50 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 51 Arino 11/9/06 4:30 PM Page 52

Healing the Earth Environment Olivier Arino, Diego Fernandez-Prieto & Espen Volden Earth Observation Supporting International Earth Observation Science, Applications and Future Technologies Department, Directorate of Earth Observation Programmes, ESRIN, Environmental Conventions Frascati, Italy

SA is building long-term relationships with several user communities that can benefit Elfrom the Agency’s Earth observation programmes. Since 2000, ESA has been working in close collaboration on three international environmental conventions. Here we see how its Earth observation activities are benefiting these conventions.

Introduction Dramatic environmental problems affecting our planet have mobilised governments, scientists, private com- panies and environmental organisations over the whole world. As a result, several multilateral environmental agreements (MEAs) have been signed that aim at reducing environmental degradation. An example is the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (UNCED), also known as The Medspiration project maps the sea-surface temperature in the ‘Earth Summit’, held in Rio de the Mediterranean at 2 km resolution in near-realtime; Janeiro, Brasil, in 1992. It resulted in the 21 June 2006 is shown definition of the ‘Agenda 21’ plan of action and the subsequent signature of different multilateral agreements such as the UN Convention to Combat

esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 53 Arino 11/9/06 4:30 PM Page 52

Healing the Earth Environment Olivier Arino, Diego Fernandez-Prieto & Espen Volden Earth Observation Supporting International Earth Observation Science, Applications and Future Technologies Department, Directorate of Earth Observation Programmes, ESRIN, Environmental Conventions Frascati, Italy

SA is building long-term relationships with several user communities that can benefit Elfrom the Agency’s Earth observation programmes. Since 2000, ESA has been working in close collaboration on three international environmental conventions. Here we see how its Earth observation activities are benefiting these conventions.

Introduction Dramatic environmental problems affecting our planet have mobilised governments, scientists, private com- panies and environmental organisations over the whole world. As a result, several multilateral environmental agreements (MEAs) have been signed that aim at reducing environmental degradation. An example is the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (UNCED), also known as The Medspiration project maps the sea-surface temperature in the ‘Earth Summit’, held in Rio de the Mediterranean at 2 km resolution in near-realtime; Janeiro, Brasil, in 1992. It resulted in the 21 June 2006 is shown definition of the ‘Agenda 21’ plan of action and the subsequent signature of different multilateral agreements such as the UN Convention to Combat

esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 53 Arino 11/9/06 4:30 PM Page 54

Earth Observation Environment

Desertification (UNCCD), the UN Potential contributions of Earth Observation in implementing multilateral environmental agreements measure systematically, globally and globally. Coupling ocean colour with Convention on Biodiversity (UNCBD) homogeneously many of the variables atmospheric aerosol and trace gas Ramsar Convention UNCCD UNFCCC and the UN Framework Convention on essential for understanding and measurements will also yield new Climate Change (UNFCCC). • Understanding wetlands, • Understanding expansion and • Understanding the carbon monitoring the climate system. ESA has insights into the chemical links between e.g. water cycles, vegetation retraction of deserts (by providing global model input The road started in 1992 continued in status • Understanding causes and parameters such as global leaf area initiated several global-scale projects ocean and atmosphere. A long time- • Understanding global consequences of land degradation and vegetation indices, statistics on the World Summit on Sustainable wetlands distribution • Understanding water cycle at global fires) that transform satellite data into series of global ocean-colour Development in Johannesburg, South • Understanding interrelations global scale • Understanding the causes and meaningful parameters to provide information will be provided by the knowledge between wetland areas, the • Understanding the causes and effects of global warming and surroundings and whole effects of drought climate change

Africa in 2002. There, many govern- scientific Improving insight into climate change. GlobColour project. catchment areas ments reinforced their commitment to Important variables that satellites can The polar regions are especially • Improving inventories, e.g. • Improving reliability and • Improving forest and land cover sustainable development at the local, by mapping land cover, land capability of early warning inventory capabilities at national measure over land are daily global sensitive to changes in climate, and use and base information systems of drought by providing scales regional, national and international • Assessing environmental timely information over large • Improving identification and ‘albedo’ (the fraction of sunlight models consistently predict future character, e.g. by estimating regions on agriculture and land estimation of de- and reforestation levels, and recognised MEAs as useful and mapping hydrological cover, temperature, albedo, etc. phenomena reflected back from Earth), vegetation warming to be much more significant for achieving that objective. and vegatation parameters • Improving land degradation • Improving estimation capabilities levels, fires and burnt areas, snow cover, there. Many variables can be observed • Monitoring (continuous assessment and monitoring by of over-ground biomass, Implementing these Conventions mapping of changes in providing timely and continuous greenhouse-gas emissions, carbon elevation of ice-sheet surfaces, glacial from satellite, in particular by exploiting vegetation status, land cover information on land cover and stocks in 1990 (baseline year) by requires the collection, analysis and or water table) use and its dynamics by estimating allowing mapping of forest areas evolution and land cover. Some of these radar’s ability to see through clouds. The vegetation status over large areas and types understanding of a huge amount of and obligations declarations on a regular basis factors are required as inputs for carbon GlobIce project is providing infor- Improving execution of resolutions, execution Improving environmental information, from local • Improving derivation of • Estimating indicators to measure • Improving reliability and cycle models, and others give an mation based on satellite data for the to global scales. This information geo-information and Convention performance based on comparability of reporting immediate view of the impact of climate Portugal’s Diário de Noticias highlights the warming of the polar regions. environmental parameters measurable environmental information provides a better understanding of the required in the Ramsar site phenomena, e.g. increases in forest • Allowing verification by change. Mediterranean Sea between 2 July and 2 August 2006, with the Greenhouse gases and aerosols are the sheets, e.g. base maps, area of improvements in independent bodies of the headline ‘Mediterranean water at 30ºC full of jellyfish’ scientific background of the problems location of wetlands, land vegetation status information reported by parties Vegetation cover, fire location, timing primary agents in forcing climate cover and land use, • Allowing joint reporting to the • Improving capabilities of faced, helps decision-making and hydrology, wetland types Convention Secretariat (e.g. independent bodies to auditing and areas affected, as well as additional change; continuous observations • Producing comparable maps common report of Annex IV Clean Development Mechanism enables environmental plans to be put in and environmental indicators countries) providing comparable projects (e.g. verification of forest information on the vegetation growth of sea-surface temperature (SST) has spatially and temporally homogeneous of Ramsar sites in one information from different extent and state over time) place. It also allows the Convention country, and among different countries cycle, are being estimated globally given scientists a uniquely detailed view are therefore required. Since 2003, the mechanisms Secretariats and related bodies to parties • Improving derivation of geo- within ESA’s GlobCarbon project. of the changing physical characteristics TEMIS consortium has been providing • Creation of a database of information, environmental improve their assessment of the geo-information and a indicators and statistics so They are used as input to carbon- of the surface of the oceans, sampled at measurements of ozone and greenhouse Ramsar information system countries report quantitatively performance of the Conventions and including comparable rather than qualitatively on assimilation models. Worldwide fire a rate impossible with only ship-based gases, including carbon dioxide information for all Ramsar progress towards their objectives apply enforcement procedures if and reporting MEA performance Improving sites locations have been analysed for observations. The Medspiration project (currently a research field) and methane,

necessary. • Illustrating problems • Illustrating problems of • Illustrating effects of global 10 years on a monthly basis: data are combines data measured independently by exploiting satellite data. GlobAerosol Earth observation (EO) technology affecting wetlands worldwide desertification at global, regional, warming at different scales freely accessible in the World Fire Atlas. by several different satellite systems into aims to provide a daily global aerosol and increasing awareness national and sub-national levels to (especially global) to increase can significantly contribute by: increase awareness awareness at http://dup.esrin.esa.it/ionia/wfa/. This a set of products that represent the best product over land and water from • Illustrating problems related to • Deriving statistics and geo- drought at global, regional and information at global level to atlas has been used by more than 70 measure of SST, presented in a form several satellites. national levels to increase prove to policy-makers the urgent – improving the scientific knowledge of process awareness need for action and induce political scientific teams, most of them in that can be assimilated into ocean • Deriving geo-information and support the environmental problems; statistics to quantify the problems atmospheric modelling. A global land forecasting models. Land use and forestry – improving the execution of National the political Broadening and induce political support cover map at 300 m resolution is being Ocean algae absorb thousands of Mankind’s land use and forestry have a Action Plans; developed within the GlobCover project tonnes of carbon, forming one of its significant effect on the net emissions of Deriving common environmental information, such as base maps, land cover maps, land cover maps, change- – improving MEA performance; detection maps, environmental indices, global statistics, for different conventions) using Envisat data from 2005 (see the most important and long-lasting removal carbon. Measuring these activities is a reporting – broadening the political process; Common title spread of this article). routes. By precisely measuring ocean main function of the Kyoto Protocol, – contributing to the creation of The large volume of data acquired colour, we can accurately gauge the which obliges the Annex 1 countries common databases and reporting from 20 years of satellite observations concentrations of phytoplankton (who agreed to cut their 1990-level procedures among different conven- DesertWatch, addressing key needs scales, which can help the implement- tions (see the table for a summary). expressed by different users within the ation of conventions and protocols, and convention communities. This article help the members in their reporting However, today’s limited use of EO focuses on the UNFCCC, the Ramsar duties. In addition to providing technology in implementing MEAs Convention on Wetlands and the adequate satellite data, ESA has begun a contrasts with its large potential. To UNCCD. number of activities to demonstrate how explore the potential, and promote the 0satellite data can support the use of, EO technology in supporting UN Framework Convention on Climate Change UNFCCC objectives. environmental conventions, ESA Climate change is a global issue that launched the ‘Treaty Enforcement must be addressed with global models – Global observations from satellite Services using Earth Observation’ and global data are needed as input to The importance of systematic global (TESEO) initiative in 2001. These these models. Earth observation observation for understanding climate studies have been followed by larger satellites are uniquely able to provide change has always been recognised by implementation projects, such as the such global datasets continuously. They the UNFCCC. Improvements in Kyoto Inventory, GlobWetlands and also provide data at national and local technology have made it possible to

www.esa.int 54 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 55 Arino 11/9/06 4:30 PM Page 54

Earth Observation Environment

Desertification (UNCCD), the UN Potential contributions of Earth Observation in implementing multilateral environmental agreements measure systematically, globally and globally. Coupling ocean colour with Convention on Biodiversity (UNCBD) homogeneously many of the variables atmospheric aerosol and trace gas Ramsar Convention UNCCD UNFCCC and the UN Framework Convention on essential for understanding and measurements will also yield new Climate Change (UNFCCC). • Understanding wetlands, • Understanding expansion and • Understanding the carbon monitoring the climate system. ESA has insights into the chemical links between e.g. water cycles, vegetation retraction of deserts (by providing global model input The road started in 1992 continued in status • Understanding causes and parameters such as global leaf area initiated several global-scale projects ocean and atmosphere. A long time- • Understanding global consequences of land degradation and vegetation indices, statistics on the World Summit on Sustainable wetlands distribution • Understanding water cycle at global fires) that transform satellite data into series of global ocean-colour Development in Johannesburg, South • Understanding interrelations global scale • Understanding the causes and meaningful parameters to provide information will be provided by the knowledge between wetland areas, the • Understanding the causes and effects of global warming and surroundings and whole effects of drought climate change

Africa in 2002. There, many govern- scientific Improving insight into climate change. GlobColour project. catchment areas ments reinforced their commitment to Important variables that satellites can The polar regions are especially • Improving inventories, e.g. • Improving reliability and • Improving forest and land cover sustainable development at the local, by mapping land cover, land capability of early warning inventory capabilities at national measure over land are daily global sensitive to changes in climate, and use and base information systems of drought by providing scales regional, national and international • Assessing environmental timely information over large • Improving identification and ‘albedo’ (the fraction of sunlight models consistently predict future character, e.g. by estimating regions on agriculture and land estimation of de- and reforestation levels, and recognised MEAs as useful and mapping hydrological cover, temperature, albedo, etc. phenomena reflected back from Earth), vegetation warming to be much more significant for achieving that objective. and vegatation parameters • Improving land degradation • Improving estimation capabilities levels, fires and burnt areas, snow cover, there. Many variables can be observed • Monitoring (continuous assessment and monitoring by of over-ground biomass, Implementing these Conventions mapping of changes in providing timely and continuous greenhouse-gas emissions, carbon elevation of ice-sheet surfaces, glacial from satellite, in particular by exploiting vegetation status, land cover information on land cover and stocks in 1990 (baseline year) by requires the collection, analysis and or water table) use and its dynamics by estimating allowing mapping of forest areas evolution and land cover. Some of these radar’s ability to see through clouds. The vegetation status over large areas and types understanding of a huge amount of and obligations declarations on a regular basis factors are required as inputs for carbon GlobIce project is providing infor- Improving execution of resolutions, execution Improving environmental information, from local • Improving derivation of • Estimating indicators to measure • Improving reliability and cycle models, and others give an mation based on satellite data for the to global scales. This information geo-information and Convention performance based on comparability of reporting immediate view of the impact of climate Portugal’s Diário de Noticias highlights the warming of the polar regions. environmental parameters measurable environmental information provides a better understanding of the required in the Ramsar site phenomena, e.g. increases in forest • Allowing verification by change. Mediterranean Sea between 2 July and 2 August 2006, with the Greenhouse gases and aerosols are the sheets, e.g. base maps, area of improvements in independent bodies of the headline ‘Mediterranean water at 30ºC full of jellyfish’ scientific background of the problems location of wetlands, land vegetation status information reported by parties Vegetation cover, fire location, timing primary agents in forcing climate cover and land use, • Allowing joint reporting to the • Improving capabilities of faced, helps decision-making and hydrology, wetland types Convention Secretariat (e.g. independent bodies to auditing and areas affected, as well as additional change; continuous observations • Producing comparable maps common report of Annex IV Clean Development Mechanism enables environmental plans to be put in and environmental indicators countries) providing comparable projects (e.g. verification of forest information on the vegetation growth of sea-surface temperature (SST) has spatially and temporally homogeneous of Ramsar sites in one information from different extent and state over time) place. It also allows the Convention country, and among different countries cycle, are being estimated globally given scientists a uniquely detailed view are therefore required. Since 2003, the mechanisms Secretariats and related bodies to parties • Improving derivation of geo- within ESA’s GlobCarbon project. of the changing physical characteristics TEMIS consortium has been providing • Creation of a database of information, environmental improve their assessment of the geo-information and a indicators and statistics so They are used as input to carbon- of the surface of the oceans, sampled at measurements of ozone and greenhouse Ramsar information system countries report quantitatively performance of the Conventions and including comparable rather than qualitatively on assimilation models. Worldwide fire a rate impossible with only ship-based gases, including carbon dioxide information for all Ramsar progress towards their objectives apply enforcement procedures if and reporting MEA performance Improving sites locations have been analysed for observations. The Medspiration project (currently a research field) and methane,

necessary. • Illustrating problems • Illustrating problems of • Illustrating effects of global 10 years on a monthly basis: data are combines data measured independently by exploiting satellite data. GlobAerosol Earth observation (EO) technology affecting wetlands worldwide desertification at global, regional, warming at different scales freely accessible in the World Fire Atlas. by several different satellite systems into aims to provide a daily global aerosol and increasing awareness national and sub-national levels to (especially global) to increase can significantly contribute by: increase awareness awareness at http://dup.esrin.esa.it/ionia/wfa/. This a set of products that represent the best product over land and water from • Illustrating problems related to • Deriving statistics and geo- drought at global, regional and information at global level to atlas has been used by more than 70 measure of SST, presented in a form several satellites. national levels to increase prove to policy-makers the urgent – improving the scientific knowledge of process awareness need for action and induce political scientific teams, most of them in that can be assimilated into ocean • Deriving geo-information and support the environmental problems; statistics to quantify the problems atmospheric modelling. A global land forecasting models. Land use and forestry – improving the execution of National the political Broadening and induce political support cover map at 300 m resolution is being Ocean algae absorb thousands of Mankind’s land use and forestry have a Action Plans; developed within the GlobCover project tonnes of carbon, forming one of its significant effect on the net emissions of Deriving common environmental information, such as base maps, land cover maps, land cover maps, change- – improving MEA performance; detection maps, environmental indices, global statistics, for different conventions) using Envisat data from 2005 (see the most important and long-lasting removal carbon. Measuring these activities is a reporting – broadening the political process; Common title spread of this article). routes. By precisely measuring ocean main function of the Kyoto Protocol, – contributing to the creation of The large volume of data acquired colour, we can accurately gauge the which obliges the Annex 1 countries common databases and reporting from 20 years of satellite observations concentrations of phytoplankton (who agreed to cut their 1990-level procedures among different conven- DesertWatch, addressing key needs scales, which can help the implement- tions (see the table for a summary). expressed by different users within the ation of conventions and protocols, and convention communities. This article help the members in their reporting However, today’s limited use of EO focuses on the UNFCCC, the Ramsar duties. In addition to providing technology in implementing MEAs Convention on Wetlands and the adequate satellite data, ESA has begun a contrasts with its large potential. To UNCCD. number of activities to demonstrate how explore the potential, and promote the 0satellite data can support the use of, EO technology in supporting UN Framework Convention on Climate Change UNFCCC objectives. environmental conventions, ESA Climate change is a global issue that launched the ‘Treaty Enforcement must be addressed with global models – Global observations from satellite Services using Earth Observation’ and global data are needed as input to The importance of systematic global (TESEO) initiative in 2001. These these models. Earth observation observation for understanding climate studies have been followed by larger satellites are uniquely able to provide change has always been recognised by implementation projects, such as the such global datasets continuously. They the UNFCCC. Improvements in Kyoto Inventory, GlobWetlands and also provide data at national and local technology have made it possible to

www.esa.int 54 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 55 Arino 11/9/06 4:30 PM Page 56

Earth Observation Environment

a means to achieving sustainable agencies and scientists to wetland Earth Observation potential contributions to the Ramsar Convention

development throughout the world’. managers and local communities. Scope End-user User requirements where EO can contribute The wise-use concept is understood to However, the type of information Global Ramsar Bureau, UN Global extent of wetlands and their temporal variations be ‘the sustainable utilisation for the required varies significantly. agencies, international non- (seasonal, multi-year) as an input for global environment governmental organisations models (carbon, methane production, etc.); global benefit of humankind in a way The table shows the different geo- (NGOs) and international monitoring of wetlands with respect to global environmental research organisations, changes; global inventory of wetlands. compatible with the maintenance of the information products that can be scientific community

natural properties of the ecosystem’. derived from EO data for the Ramsar Regional Regional policy makers Inventories and maps of: This complex and challenging task community. The community has been (e.g. European • wetland boundaries, e.g. size and variation; Community), regional • land cover/use of wetland site and catchment area; requires all national and international categorised according to the scope of developing agencies • digital elevation model of site and catchment area; (e.g. African Development • water regime, e.g. periodicity, extent of flooding; agencies involved to: the organisation: global, regional, Bank), regional • water chemistry, e.g. colour, transparency; environmental agencies • biota (vegetation zones and structure); national or local. User requirements are (e.g. European • location of potential threats to the wetland (at site and in Enviroment Agency) catchment area); – better understand wetland areas, their split into two groups: global and local. • additional information, e.g. infrastructures internal processes and their signifi- For global needs, the nature of EO National National focal points, related national ministeries, Assessment activities such as: estimation of biological cance in the global environment; data makes it a unique tool for implementing agencies (e.g. vegetation condition) physical (e.g. water table) and national NGOs chemical (e.g. chlorophyll) parameters that characterise the – manage wetland areas efficiently so providing global information to users on ecological condition of a wetland. Local Scientific community, local that they may yield the greatest a regular basis. For local needs, EO authorities, local wetland Monitoring activities such as: identifying and monitoring managers, local basin changes in biological, physical and chemical condition of continuous benefit to present and provides an efficient source of authorities, local NGOs, wetland site, threats in the wetland site and the land owners, local corresponding catchment area, which may affect the wetland future generations; continuous and synoptic information communities, farming and condition (e.g. alien species, overgrazing, urban expansion, A dedicated Kyoto Protocol land-use map of Switzerland was completed in the Kyoto Inventory Project and is being refined in the GSE – inform the general public and policy not only for wetland sites, but also for fishing associations agricultural activities, industrial pollutants). Forest project makers of the importance of wetlands entire basins supplying the wetlands. Rapid reaction to catastrophic events, such as floods and pollution emergencies. and promote their conservation and This provides a novel capability to EO Implementation of management (e.g. rehabilitation) plans, protection worldwide. users, for instance, to extend inventory such as: • basic information for inventories and as a basis for greenhouse-gas emissions by an average countries (those not obliged to cut information and monitor activities planning and decision-making (e.g. base maps); of 5.2% by 2008–2012) to report on greenhouse gases) on their national Existing and future EO technology through catchment areas of wetlands to • change analysis to monitor the efficiency of the taken actions and impact assessment. them during the first commitment communications under the UNFCCC. plays an important part in providing identify and monitor threats upstream period of 2008–2012 and to establish the Forest projects under the Kyoto reliable and cost-effective synoptic that could potentially damage the baseline for 1990. ESA began working Protocol’s Clean Development Mechan- information to monitor and assess these wetland site. with the UNFCCC Secretariat in 2001 ism can also be supported by satellite critical ecosystems worldwide. In some cases, managing large to produce the required maps and images by, for example, identifying sites, wetlands and the corresponding statistics, based on satellite images establishing baseline scenarios and How can EO support Ramsar? catchment areas involves the inventory- combined with ground measurements verifying plantation evolution. ESA is Parties implementing the Ramsar ing, assessment and monitoring of a and other data. working in Uganda and Paraguay to Convention and taking advantage of huge geographic area, such as the So far, more than a 100 million demonstrate the usefulness of such EO technology range from international Okavango Delta. In these cases, and hectares have been mapped, and the services. even though in the table it is mentioned same amount will be added by ESA’s Currently, avoiding emissions from as local information, this actually Global Monitoring for Environment deforestation and forest degradation in requires collecting and analysing and Security Services Element Forest developing countries is a priority for the information at national and even Monitoring (GSE-FM) service by 2008. UNFCCC. ESA, through GSE-FM, has regional scales, which often can only be All of Switzerland and The Netherlands started to address this. Satellite images done by using EO technology. was mapped for the baseline year of can be used both in establishing a 1990 and two other years, in addition to historical deforestation baseline and in The GlobWetland project large parts of Italy, Germany, Spain, continuously monitoring deforestation As a large-scale demonstration of these France, Greece, Denmark and Poland. and degradation. Pilot cases to assist in capabilities, ESA launched the The changes in land use and forestry policy formulation for this issue are GlobWetland project in 2003. It is between these years were also mapped. being developed. This is an example of developing and demonstrating an EO- Standards and best-practices have EO influencing the policy-making been established, and all the maps were process. verified using aerial photos, forest The ‘jewel of the Kalahari’: Botswana’s Okavango Delta is inventory data and other field Ramsar Convention on Wetlands highlighted in the lower left corner of this Envisat MERIS image, measurements, and their utility assessed The objective of the Ramsar acquired on 2 July 2006. The world’s largest inland delta is a by the ministry or agency in charge of Convention on Wetlands, signed in 1971 labyrinth of lagoons, swamps, channels and islands and a home to a vast array of wildlife. The Okavango River flows inland and the Kyoto Protocol reporting of each (in Ramsar, Iran), is ‘the conservation irrigates 15 000 square km of the Kalahari Desert. Such country. and wise use of wetlands by national wetlands are the most biologically diverse ecosystems on Earth, ESA is also working with non-Annex 1 action and international cooperation as more productive even than tropical rainforests

56 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 57 Arino 11/9/06 4:30 PM Page 56

Earth Observation Environment

a means to achieving sustainable agencies and scientists to wetland Earth Observation potential contributions to the Ramsar Convention

development throughout the world’. managers and local communities. Scope End-user User requirements where EO can contribute The wise-use concept is understood to However, the type of information Global Ramsar Bureau, UN Global extent of wetlands and their temporal variations be ‘the sustainable utilisation for the required varies significantly. agencies, international non- (seasonal, multi-year) as an input for global environment governmental organisations models (carbon, methane production, etc.); global benefit of humankind in a way The table shows the different geo- (NGOs) and international monitoring of wetlands with respect to global environmental research organisations, changes; global inventory of wetlands. compatible with the maintenance of the information products that can be scientific community

natural properties of the ecosystem’. derived from EO data for the Ramsar Regional Regional policy makers Inventories and maps of: This complex and challenging task community. The community has been (e.g. European • wetland boundaries, e.g. size and variation; Community), regional • land cover/use of wetland site and catchment area; requires all national and international categorised according to the scope of developing agencies • digital elevation model of site and catchment area; (e.g. African Development • water regime, e.g. periodicity, extent of flooding; agencies involved to: the organisation: global, regional, Bank), regional • water chemistry, e.g. colour, transparency; environmental agencies • biota (vegetation zones and structure); national or local. User requirements are (e.g. European • location of potential threats to the wetland (at site and in Enviroment Agency) catchment area); – better understand wetland areas, their split into two groups: global and local. • additional information, e.g. infrastructures internal processes and their signifi- For global needs, the nature of EO National National focal points, related national ministeries, Assessment activities such as: estimation of biological cance in the global environment; data makes it a unique tool for implementing agencies (e.g. vegetation condition) physical (e.g. water table) and national NGOs chemical (e.g. chlorophyll) parameters that characterise the – manage wetland areas efficiently so providing global information to users on ecological condition of a wetland. Local Scientific community, local that they may yield the greatest a regular basis. For local needs, EO authorities, local wetland Monitoring activities such as: identifying and monitoring managers, local basin changes in biological, physical and chemical condition of continuous benefit to present and provides an efficient source of authorities, local NGOs, wetland site, threats in the wetland site and the land owners, local corresponding catchment area, which may affect the wetland future generations; continuous and synoptic information communities, farming and condition (e.g. alien species, overgrazing, urban expansion, A dedicated Kyoto Protocol land-use map of Switzerland was completed in the Kyoto Inventory Project and is being refined in the GSE – inform the general public and policy not only for wetland sites, but also for fishing associations agricultural activities, industrial pollutants). Forest project makers of the importance of wetlands entire basins supplying the wetlands. Rapid reaction to catastrophic events, such as floods and pollution emergencies. and promote their conservation and This provides a novel capability to EO Implementation of management (e.g. rehabilitation) plans, protection worldwide. users, for instance, to extend inventory such as: • basic information for inventories and as a basis for greenhouse-gas emissions by an average countries (those not obliged to cut information and monitor activities planning and decision-making (e.g. base maps); of 5.2% by 2008–2012) to report on greenhouse gases) on their national Existing and future EO technology through catchment areas of wetlands to • change analysis to monitor the efficiency of the taken actions and impact assessment. them during the first commitment communications under the UNFCCC. plays an important part in providing identify and monitor threats upstream period of 2008–2012 and to establish the Forest projects under the Kyoto reliable and cost-effective synoptic that could potentially damage the baseline for 1990. ESA began working Protocol’s Clean Development Mechan- information to monitor and assess these wetland site. with the UNFCCC Secretariat in 2001 ism can also be supported by satellite critical ecosystems worldwide. In some cases, managing large to produce the required maps and images by, for example, identifying sites, wetlands and the corresponding statistics, based on satellite images establishing baseline scenarios and How can EO support Ramsar? catchment areas involves the inventory- combined with ground measurements verifying plantation evolution. ESA is Parties implementing the Ramsar ing, assessment and monitoring of a and other data. working in Uganda and Paraguay to Convention and taking advantage of huge geographic area, such as the So far, more than a 100 million demonstrate the usefulness of such EO technology range from international Okavango Delta. In these cases, and hectares have been mapped, and the services. even though in the table it is mentioned same amount will be added by ESA’s Currently, avoiding emissions from as local information, this actually Global Monitoring for Environment deforestation and forest degradation in requires collecting and analysing and Security Services Element Forest developing countries is a priority for the information at national and even Monitoring (GSE-FM) service by 2008. UNFCCC. ESA, through GSE-FM, has regional scales, which often can only be All of Switzerland and The Netherlands started to address this. Satellite images done by using EO technology. was mapped for the baseline year of can be used both in establishing a 1990 and two other years, in addition to historical deforestation baseline and in The GlobWetland project large parts of Italy, Germany, Spain, continuously monitoring deforestation As a large-scale demonstration of these France, Greece, Denmark and Poland. and degradation. Pilot cases to assist in capabilities, ESA launched the The changes in land use and forestry policy formulation for this issue are GlobWetland project in 2003. It is between these years were also mapped. being developed. This is an example of developing and demonstrating an EO- Standards and best-practices have EO influencing the policy-making been established, and all the maps were process. verified using aerial photos, forest The ‘jewel of the Kalahari’: Botswana’s Okavango Delta is inventory data and other field Ramsar Convention on Wetlands highlighted in the lower left corner of this Envisat MERIS image, measurements, and their utility assessed The objective of the Ramsar acquired on 2 July 2006. The world’s largest inland delta is a by the ministry or agency in charge of Convention on Wetlands, signed in 1971 labyrinth of lagoons, swamps, channels and islands and a home to a vast array of wildlife. The Okavango River flows inland and the Kyoto Protocol reporting of each (in Ramsar, Iran), is ‘the conservation irrigates 15 000 square km of the Kalahari Desert. Such country. and wise use of wetlands by national wetlands are the most biologically diverse ecosystems on Earth, ESA is also working with non-Annex 1 action and international cooperation as more productive even than tropical rainforests

56 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 57 Arino 11/9/06 4:30 PM Page 58

Earth Observation Environment

An example of the GlobWetland Information System for Axios, complexity of the phenomena and the Greece interaction between poverty and land degradation. It involves a very complex set of interactions and issues, with few Resolution becomes progressively higher easily identifiable causes or tidy through a wetland region (Level-2), solutions. Moreover, estimates of the wetland complex (Level-3) and wetland areas involved range from a third of the habitat (Level-4). This approach is taken world to close to half; and people in GlobWetlands to maximise the affected from 1-in-6 to 1-in-3. efficient use of geo-information and A better use of EO data is, therefore, reserve the most expensive imagery for becoming more critical to understand- relatively small areas where detailed ing desertification processes and man- assessment is required. made effects on natural ecosystems, and Wetland managers and ecologists use can ultimately contribute to improving many information sources to determine policies. Areas of UNCCD implement- ecological change and to target their ation that could directly benefit from interventions, through negotiation of use of spaceborne EO technology are: land use and water allocations within stakeholder-based catchment planning. – the collection and analysis of short- Combining the strategic use of EO- term and long-term data and derived geo-information with ground information to identify causal factors, Parties in Havana, Cuba, ESA launched main information needs and validating data, for example, local land ownership, both natural and human, contributing DesertWatch in 2004. This project aims the results. Their participation is critical water-gauging information or species to land degradation, desertification to develop a tailored, standardised, to ensure the full integration of the final based information service to help wetland SAR and MERIS, Radarsat, Spot, counts is now considered to be an and/or drought; commonly accepted and operational system into the daily working practices managers and national authorities Landsat, Ikonos, Quickbird, CHRIS/ essential partnership for sustaining these – increased knowledge of the processes information system based on EO of national and regional administra- respond to the requirements of the Proba and ASTER. Observations were vital reservoirs of life and opportunity. leading to land degradation, desertifi- technology. It will support national and tions. The project follows a ‘develop- Ramsar Convention. The project involves tailored to the individual sites, ensuring cation and drought, and better regional authorities of Annex IV operate-transfer’ approach to support 50 wetlands in 21 countries, and relies on maximum coverage of wetland vegeta- UN Convention to Combat Desertification understanding of the interaction countries (the North-Mediterranean the full transition from a research phase the direct collaboration of several tion and capture of the changes in water The international community has, with between climate and desertification Region) in reporting to the UNCCD to an operational phase, where selected regional, national and local conservation extent using SAR data. the UNCCD, launched an innovative and assessment of the effects of and assessing and monitoring national and regional technical centres authorities and wetland managers. The impact of these EO products on initiative to reverse and prevent the drought on desertification; desertification and its trends over time. continue operations, thereby ensuring A set of EO-derived products was the daily work of wetland managers and mismanagement of the world’s drylands. – the systematic observation of the It will help: sustainability. defined based on the requirements of conservation authorities has been Where past ‘Plans of Action to Combat environment to assess qualitative and Based on preliminary user needs, individual wetland managers and significant. It is not possible to isolate Desertification’ ignored the complex quantitative trends in natural – to create standard and comparable DesertWatch information is being national focal points of the convention the management of wetlands from the interplay of socio-economic influences resources, evaluating the causes and national geo-information products on organised in autonomous layers that can (mainly environment ministries). Core land use and water management regime behind dryland over-exploitation, the consequences of desertification, the status and trends in desertifica- be integrated and combined in suitable products include: land-use and land- within their catchment areas. All UNCCD confronts them directly. The notably ecological degradation, and tion; models to derive different thematic cover maps; long- and short-term freshwater wetlands depend upon a net convention suggests a new ‘holistic’ and monitoring the effects of these to – to create a common framework for products on three scales: pan-European, change-detection maps; and water-cycle positive water balance determined by participatory approach aiming for improve the value of combating reporting to the UNCCD for national and sub-national. regime maps. Site-specific products the relative contributions of rainfall, sustainable development of drylands. In strategies; Annex IV countries; The products include some land use include leading-edge EO applications evapotranspiration, abstraction, ground- this respect, the convention has some – the establishment and/or strengthening – to create a common basic infra- indices, derived from Landsat and such as the analysis of biophysical water exchange and surface flows. These unique features compared to other of early warning systems to evaluate structure as a base for further MERIS data, aimed at identifying key parameters within water bodies, coastal in turn (even rainfall) are strongly environmental treaties. By stating that the impacts of natural climate developments where EO plays a key drivers, pressures and impacts on land erosion, subsidence, peatland burned influenced by the land use and land desertification is primarily a problem of variability on regional drought and role; degradation processes, such as areas and digital elevation models. cover in and around the wetland which, sustainable development, it draws desertification, and generate seasonal- – the development of a common meth- deforestation, forest fragmentation, The main products, focusing on along with water management object- attention to the interface between to-interannual climate predictions to odological approach for all Annex IV forest fires, irrigation, urbanisation and wetland land cover and water-table ives, form part of the information base sustainable natural resource manage- improve the efficiency of drought- countries to assess and monitor land abandonment. With additional dynamics, are based on semi-automated of management plans necessary for the ment and economic development issues, mitigation programmes on affected desertification problems and identify socio-economic data and other processing techniques that make use of conservation and wise use of wetlands. notably in poor countries with scarce populations. trends and potential scenarios. information, these indicators form the multiple types of EO data, user-supplied Geo-information is vital to wetland and/or overexploited natural resources. basis for deriving information on the data and field information. Space management. The Convention advises The UNCCD is not an ideal legal The DesertWatch project To this end, the National Committees risk and status of desertification. sources include synthetic-aperture radar that it should be organised at different instrument to combat desertification. Following the TESEO project and the to Combat Desertification of Italy, A second component of the system (SAR) and optical data at various scales. Level-1 is for information on a Desertification remains a poorly consultation with national delegations Portugal and Turkey have helped in the includes a number of biophysical resolutions from Envisat Advanced broad scale, such as a river basin. understood concept – notably the during the 2003 Conference of the preparation of the project, defining the indexes measuring the density of

58 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 59 Arino 11/9/06 4:30 PM Page 58

Earth Observation Environment

An example of the GlobWetland Information System for Axios, complexity of the phenomena and the Greece interaction between poverty and land degradation. It involves a very complex set of interactions and issues, with few Resolution becomes progressively higher easily identifiable causes or tidy through a wetland region (Level-2), solutions. Moreover, estimates of the wetland complex (Level-3) and wetland areas involved range from a third of the habitat (Level-4). This approach is taken world to close to half; and people in GlobWetlands to maximise the affected from 1-in-6 to 1-in-3. efficient use of geo-information and A better use of EO data is, therefore, reserve the most expensive imagery for becoming more critical to understand- relatively small areas where detailed ing desertification processes and man- assessment is required. made effects on natural ecosystems, and Wetland managers and ecologists use can ultimately contribute to improving many information sources to determine policies. Areas of UNCCD implement- ecological change and to target their ation that could directly benefit from interventions, through negotiation of use of spaceborne EO technology are: land use and water allocations within stakeholder-based catchment planning. – the collection and analysis of short- Combining the strategic use of EO- term and long-term data and derived geo-information with ground information to identify causal factors, Parties in Havana, Cuba, ESA launched main information needs and validating data, for example, local land ownership, both natural and human, contributing DesertWatch in 2004. This project aims the results. Their participation is critical water-gauging information or species to land degradation, desertification to develop a tailored, standardised, to ensure the full integration of the final based information service to help wetland SAR and MERIS, Radarsat, Spot, counts is now considered to be an and/or drought; commonly accepted and operational system into the daily working practices managers and national authorities Landsat, Ikonos, Quickbird, CHRIS/ essential partnership for sustaining these – increased knowledge of the processes information system based on EO of national and regional administra- respond to the requirements of the Proba and ASTER. Observations were vital reservoirs of life and opportunity. leading to land degradation, desertifi- technology. It will support national and tions. The project follows a ‘develop- Ramsar Convention. The project involves tailored to the individual sites, ensuring cation and drought, and better regional authorities of Annex IV operate-transfer’ approach to support 50 wetlands in 21 countries, and relies on maximum coverage of wetland vegeta- UN Convention to Combat Desertification understanding of the interaction countries (the North-Mediterranean the full transition from a research phase the direct collaboration of several tion and capture of the changes in water The international community has, with between climate and desertification Region) in reporting to the UNCCD to an operational phase, where selected regional, national and local conservation extent using SAR data. the UNCCD, launched an innovative and assessment of the effects of and assessing and monitoring national and regional technical centres authorities and wetland managers. The impact of these EO products on initiative to reverse and prevent the drought on desertification; desertification and its trends over time. continue operations, thereby ensuring A set of EO-derived products was the daily work of wetland managers and mismanagement of the world’s drylands. – the systematic observation of the It will help: sustainability. defined based on the requirements of conservation authorities has been Where past ‘Plans of Action to Combat environment to assess qualitative and Based on preliminary user needs, individual wetland managers and significant. It is not possible to isolate Desertification’ ignored the complex quantitative trends in natural – to create standard and comparable DesertWatch information is being national focal points of the convention the management of wetlands from the interplay of socio-economic influences resources, evaluating the causes and national geo-information products on organised in autonomous layers that can (mainly environment ministries). Core land use and water management regime behind dryland over-exploitation, the consequences of desertification, the status and trends in desertifica- be integrated and combined in suitable products include: land-use and land- within their catchment areas. All UNCCD confronts them directly. The notably ecological degradation, and tion; models to derive different thematic cover maps; long- and short-term freshwater wetlands depend upon a net convention suggests a new ‘holistic’ and monitoring the effects of these to – to create a common framework for products on three scales: pan-European, change-detection maps; and water-cycle positive water balance determined by participatory approach aiming for improve the value of combating reporting to the UNCCD for national and sub-national. regime maps. Site-specific products the relative contributions of rainfall, sustainable development of drylands. In strategies; Annex IV countries; The products include some land use include leading-edge EO applications evapotranspiration, abstraction, ground- this respect, the convention has some – the establishment and/or strengthening – to create a common basic infra- indices, derived from Landsat and such as the analysis of biophysical water exchange and surface flows. These unique features compared to other of early warning systems to evaluate structure as a base for further MERIS data, aimed at identifying key parameters within water bodies, coastal in turn (even rainfall) are strongly environmental treaties. By stating that the impacts of natural climate developments where EO plays a key drivers, pressures and impacts on land erosion, subsidence, peatland burned influenced by the land use and land desertification is primarily a problem of variability on regional drought and role; degradation processes, such as areas and digital elevation models. cover in and around the wetland which, sustainable development, it draws desertification, and generate seasonal- – the development of a common meth- deforestation, forest fragmentation, The main products, focusing on along with water management object- attention to the interface between to-interannual climate predictions to odological approach for all Annex IV forest fires, irrigation, urbanisation and wetland land cover and water-table ives, form part of the information base sustainable natural resource manage- improve the efficiency of drought- countries to assess and monitor land abandonment. With additional dynamics, are based on semi-automated of management plans necessary for the ment and economic development issues, mitigation programmes on affected desertification problems and identify socio-economic data and other processing techniques that make use of conservation and wise use of wetlands. notably in poor countries with scarce populations. trends and potential scenarios. information, these indicators form the multiple types of EO data, user-supplied Geo-information is vital to wetland and/or overexploited natural resources. basis for deriving information on the data and field information. Space management. The Convention advises The UNCCD is not an ideal legal The DesertWatch project To this end, the National Committees risk and status of desertification. sources include synthetic-aperture radar that it should be organised at different instrument to combat desertification. Following the TESEO project and the to Combat Desertification of Italy, A second component of the system (SAR) and optical data at various scales. Level-1 is for information on a Desertification remains a poorly consultation with national delegations Portugal and Turkey have helped in the includes a number of biophysical resolutions from Envisat Advanced broad scale, such as a river basin. understood concept – notably the during the 2003 Conference of the preparation of the project, defining the indexes measuring the density of

58 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 59 Arino 11/9/06 4:30 PM Page 60

Earth Observation

impacts related to land will provide novel and advanced degradation since 1984. capabilities to monitor the world’s Finally, the system environment on a regular basis. The will provide users with a success of new technologies depends on tool to explore different the parties involved in the space sector future scenarios in land (space agencies, value-added companies use and cover, and and research institutions) developing impacts on land user-driven, cost-effective operational degradation due to applications. different environ- ESA’s Earth observation programmes mental policies and will continue in this direction, supporting management practices. governments, scientists and all those The project must pursuing the goals and targets of include modelling com- environmental conventions. ESA is ponents for poten-tial continuously consulting the international land-use evolution fore- user community via themed workshops casts based on previous and participation in the Conference of land-use maps, socio- the Parties of the different conventions. economic data and a Also, new activities addressing the number of user-defined information needs of other major Example of a land degradation index from MERIS data covering southern Portugal rules. conventions, such as the UN Conven- tion on Biological Diversity, are ready to be launched. They will open the door to vegetation and the soil/rock abundance Conclusion the development of new and more ratio. The former and its trends over Earth observation technology offers efficient EO-based information services, time are key towards a better under- many ways to improve the implement- reinforcing the international community standing of the vegetation status and its ation of multilateral environmental with new tools to deal with the key stress with respect to rainfall and agreements, such as the continuous environmental problems that confront climate variations. The second can be provision of global data, historical data our planet. considered as a substitute for erosion archives, observations of several indices; it is an accurate indication of environmental parameters at global, Acknowledgements the proportion of developed soils and national and local scales, and the The authors wish to thank the UNFCCC, parent material, which provides the provision of synoptic and comparable UNCCD and Ramsar Convention basis for determining the degree of soil information without infringing on Secretariats; the different users who erosion. national sovereignties. actively participated and supported the A Land Degradation Index derived In spite of these benefits, EO support above projects, the industrial teams who from meteorological and Envisat of MEAs is still limited and, in many carried out the work, led by ACRI, MERIS data has been developed to cases, restricted to research and ACS, GAF, GMV, Ifremer, INTECS, highlight the degree of soil degradation. demonstration projects. This is because KNMI, MEDIAS, SARMAP, UCL, The index is relative to the soil type and of several factors in the environmental University of Southampton, VEXCEL, the local conditions: an arid soil can be and EO sectors. The gap between these VITO and VTT; and the colleagues considered as ‘good’ even with only a two worlds has hampered the from SERCO and the Earth Observa- few rainfall episodes because of the integration of this technology into the tion Graphic Bureau who made all this vegetation growth for that type of soil common operational practices of work possible. e and local conditions. environmentalists and governments in The temporal component is a key many fields. However, more integration factor to understanding desertification of related technologies, such as geo- processes today in the Mediterranean information systems and information Useful Links area. The project is investigating the technology, as well as wider awareness www.esa.int/due www.esa.int/gmes variations of the last 20 years through a within the environmental community www.unfccc.int www.unccd.int trend analysis using EO archives. The and the technological developments in www.ramsar.org www.temis.nl above indicators will be generated at the space sector, offer a promising www.medspiration.org www.globaerosol.info www.globcolour.info www.globwetland.org three different dates showing the future. World Fire Atlas http://dup.esrin.esa.it/ionia/wfa/ evolution of the main pressures and The next generation of EO satellites

60 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int Tumino.qxd 11/9/06 4:32 PM Page 62

Reentry Technology

Giorgio Tumino Future Launchers Preparatory Programme, Directorate of Launchers, Paris, France

Yves Gerard Next Generation Launcher Prime S.p.A., Turin, IXV: the Intermediate Italy eXperimental Vehicle

ith the objective of placing Europe Europe Among the among the world’s space players in Wthe strategic area of atmospheric reentry in future international transportation, World Players in exploration and scientific projects, several studies on experimental vehicle concepts and improvements of critical reentry technologies Atmospheric Reentry have paved the way for the flight of an experimental craft. The Intermedidate eXperimental Vehicle is building on previous achievements at the system (such as the Atmospheric Reentry Demonstrator) and technology levels, and providing a unique means of establishing Europe’s autonomous position in this international field.

Introduction Returning to Earth from orbit is still a challenge, as the loss of Space Shuttle Columbia tragically underlined. Braking from 7.7 km/s through the atmosphere to a safe and precise landing calls for a wide range of demanding technologies to be mastered. The number of experimental reentry vehicles studied in recent years by ESA, France, Germany and Italy underlines Europe’s need for flight experience with reentry systems

esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 63 Tumino.qxd 11/9/06 4:32 PM Page 62

Reentry Technology

Giorgio Tumino Future Launchers Preparatory Programme, Directorate of Launchers, Paris, France

Yves Gerard Next Generation Launcher Prime S.p.A., Turin, IXV: the Intermediate Italy eXperimental Vehicle

ith the objective of placing Europe Europe Among the among the world’s space players in Wthe strategic area of atmospheric reentry in future international transportation, World Players in exploration and scientific projects, several studies on experimental vehicle concepts and improvements of critical reentry technologies Atmospheric Reentry have paved the way for the flight of an experimental craft. The Intermedidate eXperimental Vehicle is building on previous achievements at the system (such as the Atmospheric Reentry Demonstrator) and technology levels, and providing a unique means of establishing Europe’s autonomous position in this international field.

Introduction Returning to Earth from orbit is still a challenge, as the loss of Space Shuttle Columbia tragically underlined. Braking from 7.7 km/s through the atmosphere to a safe and precise landing calls for a wide range of demanding technologies to be mastered. The number of experimental reentry vehicles studied in recent years by ESA, France, Germany and Italy underlines Europe’s need for flight experience with reentry systems

esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 63 Tumino.qxd 11/9/06 4:32 PM Page 64

Launchers Reentry Technology

and technologies in order to consolidate The layout of the Intermediate eXperimental Vehicle its position among the world’s space players in this strategic field. Europe must be able to play a more ambitious role in international cooperation in space transportation, exploration and scientific projects. ESA’s Future Launchers Preparatory Programme (FLPP) was conceived by its Member States to provide a framework for, among other technology challenges, the development of the Intermediate eXperimental Vehicle (IXV) by 2010. The IXV trajectory from launch to Mach 2 The current reference trajectory from Kourou to Kiruna

Project Definition and Status ESA and its industrial prime contractor future operational vehicles (this explains protection and hot structures under vehicle, when the air molecules break Next Generation Launcher Prime SpA the Intermediate in the name). realistic flight conditions. These include apart to dissipate the high energies (I), a joint venture between Astrium (F, fall over uninhabited areas and the identified, assessed and mitigated at an IXV is a lifting reentry body, with its advanced ceramic and metallic assem- involved in reentry and the perfect-gas D) and Finmeccanica (I), assisted by experimental vehicle to fly over sparsely early stage in the project. shape resulting from the set of design blies, insulation, attachments, junctions laws are no longer valid. This complex ASI, CNES, DLR and ESTEC, initiated populated regions. A study is therefore under way by requirements, including the need to and seals, as well as advanced guidance situation affects the interaction between the IXV project at the beginning of 2005 The reference mission plans a launch industry as a first step in Phase-B1 to maximise the internal volume for navigation and control techniques. shockwave and boundary-layer flows, by defining the mission objectives and from Kourou (French Guiana) into an assess how the safety requirements carrying experiments. The goal is to get This verification of performance in the interaction between shockwaves, the maturing the design. orbit with a 70º inclination, followed by affect the mission, with a comparison of the most out of the vehicle while flight builds on previous efforts and transition from laminar-to-turbulent The objectives include the complete a landing in the North European all the feasible mission scenarios. The guaranteeing the mass (limited by Vega’s ground verification, and aims at boundary-layer flows, the transitional and deep identification of what Aerospace Test Range at Kiruna (S). landing scenario and area will soon be capacity) and centre-of-gravity location. maturing the technologies for operational boundary-layer separation, the heating experiments Europe needs in reentry The scenario is being refined (see selected by ESA with technical The primary objectives of the IXV space applications. of thermal protection materials by technology, with an optimised plan of below), and backup schemes leading to assistance from ASI, CNES, DLR, project can be grouped into three Reentry technology validation focuses turbulent boundary-layer flows, the flight experiments that trades cost a sea landing are also being considered. ESTEC and recommendations from categories: reentry system demonstra- on gathering representative reentry overheating owing to external cavities, against technology maturity needs. IXV will be delivered into an orbit of industry. tion, technology experimentation and performance data in order to investigate the behaviour of materials’ catalytic A thorough comparison has been 180 x 307.2 km, where Vega’s upper technology validation. aerothermodynamic phenomena and properties, the materials’ oxidation, the performed for all the existing ESA and stage will fire above the Pacific Ocean Reentry System and Technology The first focuses on gaining validate system design tools, evaluating reduction in efficiency of the control national concepts against shared off the coast of Chile to trigger reentry. From experience with ambitious experience in lifting and aerodynamic- the behaviour of air around a lifting surfaces through boundary-layer flow criteria, focusing on: experiment IXV will begin formal reentry 120 km experimental vehicles around the world, ally controlled reentry, which would be a body for atmospheric entry in the separation, and the efficiency of the requirements (technology and systems), above the Atlantic Ocean, at a speed of such as NASA’s series of X-vehicles, significant advance on earlier ballistic hypersonic regime (above Mach 5). The reaction control system. programme requirements (technology 7700 m/s and an angle of 1.19º below there is general consensus within and quasi-ballistic efforts, such as the most interesting phenomena stem from The experiment objectives are being readiness, development schedule and the horizontal. The reentry trajectory Europe’s space community that a step- Atmospheric Reentry Demonstrator the behaviour of the airflow around the translated into the vehicle design via an cost) and risk mitigation (design lasting around 20 minutes will be by-step flight programme is the best capsule flown by ESA in 1998. Europe feasibility, maturity, robustness and controlled by a combination of moving approach. It limits the risks, allows needs to go through the entire design growth potential). aerodynamic surfaces and thrusters stepped costs and ensures that progress- loop for such a complex system, specify The result of the trade-off has led to from hypersonic speeds at 120 km ively more sophisticated developments the entire system development phases in the selection of the slender lifting body altitude down to Mach 2.0, while benefit from the results of relatively low- detail, address the manufacturing and configuration. The baseline design builds travelling a surface distance of 7500 km. cost missions. assembly issues of critical reentry upon the extensive national (CNES/ All the while, it will gather large Since 2002, ESA has focused on an technologies, the integration of these Pre-X) and ESA (AREV: Atmospheric quantities of data to verify the optimised long-term scheme of flight key technologies at the system level Reentry Experimental Vehicle) efforts. performance of several critical reentry experiments. Further consolidation with (during the design, assembly, testing and The contractors are now working on technologies. industry in 2005 confirmed the operations), perform overall system Phase-B1 (preliminary design definition), IXV will then be slowed from Mach 2 Intermediate eXperimental Vehicle as integration and verification for a vehicle targeting a system requirements review by a set of parachutes deployed by the core of this effort. IXV integrates fully loaded with advanced and by mid-2007. drogue ’chutes, before airbags inflate to key technologies at the system level, innovative instrumentation, and conduct soften the landing. including thermal protection and active the flight while ensuring the highest The Reference Mission Even though the end-to-end trajectory aerodynamic control surfaces. This is a safety for the ground below. The IXV baseline mission is driven by lies principally over low-population significant advance on Europe’s The reentry technology experiments using Vega as the launcher, with critical territories, a failure during reentry has previous flying testbeds, although the centre on verifying the performance of safety issues that call for Vega’s stages to risks that need to be thoroughly shape is not necessarily representative of system-integrated advanced thermal The aerodynamic shape of IXV

64 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 65 Tumino.qxd 11/9/06 4:32 PM Page 64

Launchers Reentry Technology

and technologies in order to consolidate The layout of the Intermediate eXperimental Vehicle its position among the world’s space players in this strategic field. Europe must be able to play a more ambitious role in international cooperation in space transportation, exploration and scientific projects. ESA’s Future Launchers Preparatory Programme (FLPP) was conceived by its Member States to provide a framework for, among other technology challenges, the development of the Intermediate eXperimental Vehicle (IXV) by 2010. The IXV trajectory from launch to Mach 2 The current reference trajectory from Kourou to Kiruna

Project Definition and Status ESA and its industrial prime contractor future operational vehicles (this explains protection and hot structures under vehicle, when the air molecules break Next Generation Launcher Prime SpA the Intermediate in the name). realistic flight conditions. These include apart to dissipate the high energies (I), a joint venture between Astrium (F, fall over uninhabited areas and the identified, assessed and mitigated at an IXV is a lifting reentry body, with its advanced ceramic and metallic assem- involved in reentry and the perfect-gas D) and Finmeccanica (I), assisted by experimental vehicle to fly over sparsely early stage in the project. shape resulting from the set of design blies, insulation, attachments, junctions laws are no longer valid. This complex ASI, CNES, DLR and ESTEC, initiated populated regions. A study is therefore under way by requirements, including the need to and seals, as well as advanced guidance situation affects the interaction between the IXV project at the beginning of 2005 The reference mission plans a launch industry as a first step in Phase-B1 to maximise the internal volume for navigation and control techniques. shockwave and boundary-layer flows, by defining the mission objectives and from Kourou (French Guiana) into an assess how the safety requirements carrying experiments. The goal is to get This verification of performance in the interaction between shockwaves, the maturing the design. orbit with a 70º inclination, followed by affect the mission, with a comparison of the most out of the vehicle while flight builds on previous efforts and transition from laminar-to-turbulent The objectives include the complete a landing in the North European all the feasible mission scenarios. The guaranteeing the mass (limited by Vega’s ground verification, and aims at boundary-layer flows, the transitional and deep identification of what Aerospace Test Range at Kiruna (S). landing scenario and area will soon be capacity) and centre-of-gravity location. maturing the technologies for operational boundary-layer separation, the heating experiments Europe needs in reentry The scenario is being refined (see selected by ESA with technical The primary objectives of the IXV space applications. of thermal protection materials by technology, with an optimised plan of below), and backup schemes leading to assistance from ASI, CNES, DLR, project can be grouped into three Reentry technology validation focuses turbulent boundary-layer flows, the flight experiments that trades cost a sea landing are also being considered. ESTEC and recommendations from categories: reentry system demonstra- on gathering representative reentry overheating owing to external cavities, against technology maturity needs. IXV will be delivered into an orbit of industry. tion, technology experimentation and performance data in order to investigate the behaviour of materials’ catalytic A thorough comparison has been 180 x 307.2 km, where Vega’s upper technology validation. aerothermodynamic phenomena and properties, the materials’ oxidation, the performed for all the existing ESA and stage will fire above the Pacific Ocean Reentry System and Technology The first focuses on gaining validate system design tools, evaluating reduction in efficiency of the control national concepts against shared off the coast of Chile to trigger reentry. From experience with ambitious experience in lifting and aerodynamic- the behaviour of air around a lifting surfaces through boundary-layer flow criteria, focusing on: experiment IXV will begin formal reentry 120 km experimental vehicles around the world, ally controlled reentry, which would be a body for atmospheric entry in the separation, and the efficiency of the requirements (technology and systems), above the Atlantic Ocean, at a speed of such as NASA’s series of X-vehicles, significant advance on earlier ballistic hypersonic regime (above Mach 5). The reaction control system. programme requirements (technology 7700 m/s and an angle of 1.19º below there is general consensus within and quasi-ballistic efforts, such as the most interesting phenomena stem from The experiment objectives are being readiness, development schedule and the horizontal. The reentry trajectory Europe’s space community that a step- Atmospheric Reentry Demonstrator the behaviour of the airflow around the translated into the vehicle design via an cost) and risk mitigation (design lasting around 20 minutes will be by-step flight programme is the best capsule flown by ESA in 1998. Europe feasibility, maturity, robustness and controlled by a combination of moving approach. It limits the risks, allows needs to go through the entire design growth potential). aerodynamic surfaces and thrusters stepped costs and ensures that progress- loop for such a complex system, specify The result of the trade-off has led to from hypersonic speeds at 120 km ively more sophisticated developments the entire system development phases in the selection of the slender lifting body altitude down to Mach 2.0, while benefit from the results of relatively low- detail, address the manufacturing and configuration. The baseline design builds travelling a surface distance of 7500 km. cost missions. assembly issues of critical reentry upon the extensive national (CNES/ All the while, it will gather large Since 2002, ESA has focused on an technologies, the integration of these Pre-X) and ESA (AREV: Atmospheric quantities of data to verify the optimised long-term scheme of flight key technologies at the system level Reentry Experimental Vehicle) efforts. performance of several critical reentry experiments. Further consolidation with (during the design, assembly, testing and The contractors are now working on technologies. industry in 2005 confirmed the operations), perform overall system Phase-B1 (preliminary design definition), IXV will then be slowed from Mach 2 Intermediate eXperimental Vehicle as integration and verification for a vehicle targeting a system requirements review by a set of parachutes deployed by the core of this effort. IXV integrates fully loaded with advanced and by mid-2007. drogue ’chutes, before airbags inflate to key technologies at the system level, innovative instrumentation, and conduct soften the landing. including thermal protection and active the flight while ensuring the highest The Reference Mission Even though the end-to-end trajectory aerodynamic control surfaces. This is a safety for the ground below. The IXV baseline mission is driven by lies principally over low-population significant advance on Europe’s The reentry technology experiments using Vega as the launcher, with critical territories, a failure during reentry has previous flying testbeds, although the centre on verifying the performance of safety issues that call for Vega’s stages to risks that need to be thoroughly shape is not necessarily representative of system-integrated advanced thermal The aerodynamic shape of IXV

64 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 65 Tumino.qxd 11/9/06 4:33 PM Page 66

Launchers Reentry Technology

The IXV is Europe’s next logical technology extensive flight-measurement plan that includes thermocouples, heat-flux and Europe has been developing advanced project phasing allows the industrial This will allow a solid commitment on step after the successful flight of ESA’s accommodates: pressure sensors, combined heat-flux, thermal protection systems and hot work to continue smoothly. the schedule and cost-at-completion by Atmospheric Reentry Demonstrator, and the temperature and pressure sensors structures for space transportation systems Today’s budget of about €55 million the time of the Preliminary Design for almost 20 years through a series of ESA important complementary national efforts in – important layer measurements for and/or probes, flush air data system, covers the completion of Phase-B, Review at the latest. It will also allow the Germany on the Phoenix-1, a winged vehicle and national programmes, such as Hermes, IXV’s guidance, navigation and control antennas, reflectometers, catalytic Phase-C and early phase-D, to the industrial activities to ramp up released by helicopter for autonomous Manned Space Transportation Programme runway landings, and on the Shefex-1, a system and for ground controllers to sensors, slip flow and skin friction (MSTP), Future European Space second quarter of 2009. smoothly after Phase-B. sharply pointed body launched by a 2-stage monitor the mission’s progress; sensors, advanced pyrometric tempera- Transportation Programme (FESTIP), The IXV project cost-at-completion Technology Research Programme (TRP), rocket for testing advanced materials, and in – Vehicle Model Identification (VMI) ture and heat-flux sensors, a requires additional funding for ESA Member State Participation General Support Technology Programme Italy on the USV-1, a slender winged measurements for post-flight recon- miniaturised spectrometer/pressure (GSTP), ARD, Ausgewaehlte Systeme und completing Phase-D/E/F, including IXV is supported by 11 Member States: laboratory released from a balloon for struction of IXV’s dynamic behaviour system, an infrared thermography Technologien fuer zukuenftige procurement of the Vega launch and Austria, Belgium, France, Germany, transonic-to-supersonic flights. and environment; system, a combined Rayleigh lidar and Raumtransport-Anwendungen (ASTRA), post-flight evaluation of the performance. Ireland, Italy, Portugal, Spain, Sweden, – IXV’s mandatory core experiments on electron beam fluorescence system, and X-38/ and FLPP-1/2. The additional funding is expected Switzerland and The Netherlands. ESA’s Atmospheric Reentry Demonstrator the reentry enabling technologies; high-resolution temperature-mapping either at the next Ministerial Council, in Although Europe lacks experience in Several thermal protection and hot-structure – complementary passenger experiments systems. assemblies and components have been mid-2008, and/or through additional developing such a complex lifting-body that are not directly necessary for The innovative materials and concepts designed, developed, manufactured and contributions from cooperation with reentry system, the broad participation mission success but will increase the proposals include actively cooled qualified for flight. The final verification of national and/or international agencies. of Member States provides a large and technological return. systems, ceramic nanostructures, their flight performance by IXV will provide efficient industrial organisation with all metallic matrix composites, ultra-high- Europe with advanced and competitive flight- Industrial Organisation the competences to make the project a proven hardware ready for future launchers, The current IXV baseline design is the temperature ceramics, self-healing exploration and science applications. The project is organised with well- success. result of extensive analyses, including oxidation protection, high-performance defined levels of industrial responsibili- mission and trajectories, aeroshape insulation, secondary protection layer ties, reflecting the progressive restruc- National and International Cooperation design optimisation, computational systems, intermetallics, aged ceramics, Electromechanical actuator bearing for flap turing of European industry for the The nominal project planning and fluid dynamics for aerodynamics and borosilicon carbonitride (SiBNC) poly- development and exploitation of next- execution is done within ESA’s FLPP, aerothermodynamics, flying-quality mer ceramic fibre technology, and smart generation launchers. It merges the best which is funding IXV activities up to Phoenix-1 (EADS-ST) assessment for longitudinal/lateral thermal protection. industrial competences and ensures a early 2009. Although the rest of the stability, trimmability and controll- Suggested techniques for guidance, single optimised overall system funding is expected to be agreed upon at ability of the vehicle. Additional navigation and control include realtime structure. the next ESA Council at Ministerial analysis and significant testing, GPS and/or Galileo signal tracking for Under the responsibility of NGL Level in 2008, it is important to increase including thermal, mechanical and wind accurate navigation and attitude Prime, the system activities focus on coordination and harmonisation with and plasma tunnels, are planned for the determination during reentry, realtime project management, planning, costing, national programmes in order to avoid upcoming project phases to help select trajectory control and new autonomous control and system engineering. These wasteful duplication and help to secure the final system and subsystem designs. and highly adaptive guidance software. include technology requirements, budget resources for the following IXV Proposals for structural health technical specifications, subsystem phases as soon as possible. Complementary Passenger Experiments monitoring look at the vibro-acoustic procurement, environments and ESA is fostering cooperation with Shefex-1: ‘Sharp Edge Flight Experiment’ (DLR) In order to maximise the mission’s environment and structural damping. Nosecap assembly (DLR) internal/external interfaces, product national agencies in Europe to stream- technological return, ESA organised ESA and NGL Prime SpA are making assurance and safety. line all the national activities on reentry scientific and industrial workshops in a detailed evaluation of the NGL Prime contracts system support systems and technologies towards the 2005. The impressive response high- compatibility between each passenger and subsystem design and production to common IXV objectives. The Agency is lighted the wide interest in using the experiment and the IXV system to level-1 companies, including Astrium (F, evaluating the benefits and constraints flight for complementary research to assess the technical and programme D) and Alcatel Alenia Space (I), and stemming from project financing by benefit future launchers, exploration impacts, including feasibility, reliability, level-2 subcontracts to European multiple budgetary sources (including and science. More than 50 passenger risk and cost. They are important issues industry and research organisations ESA and national), while maintaining experiment proposals have been received because these passenger experiments from ESA Member States participating its own coherent approach to ensure by ESA from European industry, would be integrated into a system in IXV. The subsystem efforts centre on common industry policy principles for USV-1: ‘Unmanned Space Vehicle’ (CIRA) research centres and universities. They baseline that is already significantly Segments of a leading edge structures, thermal protection and participating Member States. address innovative techniques and loaded with its own functional and VMI control, descent and recovery, guidance, ESA is also exploring cooperation instrumentation for investigating measurements and core experiments. navigation and control, power, data opportunities with international agencies, aerothermodynamic phenomena, handling, telemetry, software, mechan- such as in Russia, to benefit from the innovative materials and concepts for Project Schedule isms, flap control, reaction control, existing expertise in reentry systems in thermal protection and hot structures, The IXV project schedule runs across ground and flight segments and flight order to reduce experiment risks and and additional methods for guidance, the different overlapping FLPP periods, test instrumentation. costs, while maintaining the key navigation, control and structural health with the ESA Councils at Ministerial Today’s industrial team is growing to objectives of Europe’s technology monitoring. Level as milestones for funding include all the required industrial and experiments. e The proposed instrumentation contribution and subscription. The research organisations within Phase-B.

66 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 67 Tumino.qxd 11/9/06 4:33 PM Page 66

Launchers Reentry Technology

The IXV is Europe’s next logical technology extensive flight-measurement plan that includes thermocouples, heat-flux and Europe has been developing advanced project phasing allows the industrial This will allow a solid commitment on step after the successful flight of ESA’s accommodates: pressure sensors, combined heat-flux, thermal protection systems and hot work to continue smoothly. the schedule and cost-at-completion by Atmospheric Reentry Demonstrator, and the temperature and pressure sensors structures for space transportation systems Today’s budget of about €55 million the time of the Preliminary Design for almost 20 years through a series of ESA important complementary national efforts in – important layer measurements for and/or probes, flush air data system, covers the completion of Phase-B, Review at the latest. It will also allow the Germany on the Phoenix-1, a winged vehicle and national programmes, such as Hermes, IXV’s guidance, navigation and control antennas, reflectometers, catalytic Phase-C and early phase-D, to the industrial activities to ramp up released by helicopter for autonomous Manned Space Transportation Programme runway landings, and on the Shefex-1, a system and for ground controllers to sensors, slip flow and skin friction (MSTP), Future European Space second quarter of 2009. smoothly after Phase-B. sharply pointed body launched by a 2-stage monitor the mission’s progress; sensors, advanced pyrometric tempera- Transportation Programme (FESTIP), The IXV project cost-at-completion Technology Research Programme (TRP), rocket for testing advanced materials, and in – Vehicle Model Identification (VMI) ture and heat-flux sensors, a requires additional funding for ESA Member State Participation General Support Technology Programme Italy on the USV-1, a slender winged measurements for post-flight recon- miniaturised spectrometer/pressure (GSTP), ARD, Ausgewaehlte Systeme und completing Phase-D/E/F, including IXV is supported by 11 Member States: laboratory released from a balloon for struction of IXV’s dynamic behaviour system, an infrared thermography Technologien fuer zukuenftige procurement of the Vega launch and Austria, Belgium, France, Germany, transonic-to-supersonic flights. and environment; system, a combined Rayleigh lidar and Raumtransport-Anwendungen (ASTRA), post-flight evaluation of the performance. Ireland, Italy, Portugal, Spain, Sweden, – IXV’s mandatory core experiments on electron beam fluorescence system, and X-38/Crew Return Vehicle and FLPP-1/2. The additional funding is expected Switzerland and The Netherlands. ESA’s Atmospheric Reentry Demonstrator the reentry enabling technologies; high-resolution temperature-mapping either at the next Ministerial Council, in Although Europe lacks experience in Several thermal protection and hot-structure – complementary passenger experiments systems. assemblies and components have been mid-2008, and/or through additional developing such a complex lifting-body that are not directly necessary for The innovative materials and concepts designed, developed, manufactured and contributions from cooperation with reentry system, the broad participation mission success but will increase the proposals include actively cooled qualified for flight. The final verification of national and/or international agencies. of Member States provides a large and technological return. systems, ceramic nanostructures, their flight performance by IXV will provide efficient industrial organisation with all metallic matrix composites, ultra-high- Europe with advanced and competitive flight- Industrial Organisation the competences to make the project a proven hardware ready for future launchers, The current IXV baseline design is the temperature ceramics, self-healing exploration and science applications. The project is organised with well- success. result of extensive analyses, including oxidation protection, high-performance defined levels of industrial responsibili- mission and trajectories, aeroshape insulation, secondary protection layer ties, reflecting the progressive restruc- National and International Cooperation design optimisation, computational systems, intermetallics, aged ceramics, Electromechanical actuator bearing for flap turing of European industry for the The nominal project planning and fluid dynamics for aerodynamics and borosilicon carbonitride (SiBNC) poly- development and exploitation of next- execution is done within ESA’s FLPP, aerothermodynamics, flying-quality mer ceramic fibre technology, and smart generation launchers. It merges the best which is funding IXV activities up to Phoenix-1 (EADS-ST) assessment for longitudinal/lateral thermal protection. industrial competences and ensures a early 2009. Although the rest of the stability, trimmability and controll- Suggested techniques for guidance, single optimised overall system funding is expected to be agreed upon at ability of the vehicle. Additional navigation and control include realtime structure. the next ESA Council at Ministerial analysis and significant testing, GPS and/or Galileo signal tracking for Under the responsibility of NGL Level in 2008, it is important to increase including thermal, mechanical and wind accurate navigation and attitude Prime, the system activities focus on coordination and harmonisation with and plasma tunnels, are planned for the determination during reentry, realtime project management, planning, costing, national programmes in order to avoid upcoming project phases to help select trajectory control and new autonomous control and system engineering. These wasteful duplication and help to secure the final system and subsystem designs. and highly adaptive guidance software. include technology requirements, budget resources for the following IXV Proposals for structural health technical specifications, subsystem phases as soon as possible. Complementary Passenger Experiments monitoring look at the vibro-acoustic procurement, environments and ESA is fostering cooperation with Shefex-1: ‘Sharp Edge Flight Experiment’ (DLR) In order to maximise the mission’s environment and structural damping. Nosecap assembly (DLR) internal/external interfaces, product national agencies in Europe to stream- technological return, ESA organised ESA and NGL Prime SpA are making assurance and safety. line all the national activities on reentry scientific and industrial workshops in a detailed evaluation of the NGL Prime contracts system support systems and technologies towards the 2005. The impressive response high- compatibility between each passenger and subsystem design and production to common IXV objectives. The Agency is lighted the wide interest in using the experiment and the IXV system to level-1 companies, including Astrium (F, evaluating the benefits and constraints flight for complementary research to assess the technical and programme D) and Alcatel Alenia Space (I), and stemming from project financing by benefit future launchers, exploration impacts, including feasibility, reliability, level-2 subcontracts to European multiple budgetary sources (including and science. More than 50 passenger risk and cost. They are important issues industry and research organisations ESA and national), while maintaining experiment proposals have been received because these passenger experiments from ESA Member States participating its own coherent approach to ensure by ESA from European industry, would be integrated into a system in IXV. The subsystem efforts centre on common industry policy principles for USV-1: ‘Unmanned Space Vehicle’ (CIRA) research centres and universities. They baseline that is already significantly Segments of a leading edge structures, thermal protection and participating Member States. address innovative techniques and loaded with its own functional and VMI control, descent and recovery, guidance, ESA is also exploring cooperation instrumentation for investigating measurements and core experiments. navigation and control, power, data opportunities with international agencies, aerothermodynamic phenomena, handling, telemetry, software, mechan- such as in Russia, to benefit from the innovative materials and concepts for Project Schedule isms, flap control, reaction control, existing expertise in reentry systems in thermal protection and hot structures, The IXV project schedule runs across ground and flight segments and flight order to reduce experiment risks and and additional methods for guidance, the different overlapping FLPP periods, test instrumentation. costs, while maintaining the key navigation, control and structural health with the ESA Councils at Ministerial Today’s industrial team is growing to objectives of Europe’s technology monitoring. Level as milestones for funding include all the required industrial and experiments. e The proposed instrumentation contribution and subscription. The research organisations within Phase-B.

66 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 67 Madde 11/9/06 1:40 PM Page 68

Navigation

Roberto Maddè, Trevor Morley, Ricard Abelló, Marco Lanucara, Mattia Mercolino, Gunther Sessler & Javier de Vicente Delta-DOR Ground Systems Engineering Department, Directorate of Operations & Infrastructure, A New Technique for ESA’s Deep Space ESOC, Darmstadt, Germany Navigation

hen ESA’s second deep space antenna nbecame available in late 2005 WtCebreros in Spain, the Agency could begin using a powerful new navigation technique particularly important for inter- planetary craft: delta-DOR. Delta-DOR contributed to the successful orbit insertion of around the planet in April 2006, and it is expected to be a fundamental tool for navigating all of ESA’s current and future interplanetary missions.

Rosetta’s close flyby of Mars in February 2007 will be assisted by the latest addition to ESA’s tracking techniques. ESA’s deep space antenna at Cebreros in Spain (inset) will play a critical role Introduction Routine navigation of a spacecraft around the Solar System relies on two tracking methods: ranging and two-way Doppler. Precisely measuring the time it takes radio signals to travel to and from a spacecraft gives the distance from the ground station (‘two-way range’), while measuring the signal’s Doppler shift provides the craft’s velocity along that line-of-sight (‘range-rate’). The other two position coordinates, against the sky background, are obtained only indirectly from the motion of the ground station as the Earth rotates. This imposes a daily sinewave oscillation

esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 69 Madde 11/9/06 1:40 PM Page 68

Navigation

Roberto Maddè, Trevor Morley, Ricard Abelló, Marco Lanucara, Mattia Mercolino, Gunther Sessler & Javier de Vicente Delta-DOR Ground Systems Engineering Department, Directorate of Operations & Infrastructure, A New Technique for ESA’s Deep Space ESOC, Darmstadt, Germany Navigation

hen ESA’s second deep space antenna nbecame available in late 2005 WtCebreros in Spain, the Agency could begin using a powerful new navigation technique particularly important for inter- planetary craft: delta-DOR. Delta-DOR contributed to the successful orbit insertion of Venus Express around the planet in April 2006, and it is expected to be a fundamental tool for navigating all of ESA’s current and future interplanetary missions.

Rosetta’s close flyby of Mars in February 2007 will be assisted by the latest addition to ESA’s tracking techniques. ESA’s deep space antenna at Cebreros in Spain (inset) will play a critical role Introduction Routine navigation of a spacecraft around the Solar System relies on two tracking methods: ranging and two-way Doppler. Precisely measuring the time it takes radio signals to travel to and from a spacecraft gives the distance from the ground station (‘two-way range’), while measuring the signal’s Doppler shift provides the craft’s velocity along that line-of-sight (‘range-rate’). The other two position coordinates, against the sky background, are obtained only indirectly from the motion of the ground station as the Earth rotates. This imposes a daily sinewave oscillation

esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 69 Madde 11/9/06 1:40 PM Page 70

Operations & Infrastructure Navigation

Measuring the time it takes a radio signal to travel from Earth to the ESA’s second Deep Space Antenna, at Cebreros, Spain Delta-DOR tracking of a deep and a nearby spacecraft and back gives the distance (range, r). The Doppler shift in quasar from DSA-1 (New Norcia) and DSA-2 (Cebreros). the frequency gives the speed along that line (range-rate, vr). But The quasar’s position is already known with great navigating the spacecraft requires knowing the actual velocity (v) precision from astronomical catalogues, so the actual through space. Traditionally, the missing elements were provided by measurements will reveal the distortions added by the measuring the spacecraft’s movement against the sky background ionosphere, for example, allowing them to be removed over several days from the probe’s tracking

ESA's New Norcia Deep Space Antenna, about 150 km north of Perth, Western Australia

on the range and range-rate data related critical stages of a mission. This is The ESA Delta-DOR Concept The quasar is usually within 10º of the longer baselines. Maximising the With the Cebreros DSA-2 antenna to the position of the spacecraft. These especially the case on approaching a The delta-DOR technique for navigating spacecraft so that their signal paths baseline is limited by the need for the coming into operation in September position components, though, can only planet before landing, performing a interplanetary spacecraft is based on a through Earth’s atmosphere are similar. spacecraft and quasar to be mutually 2005, ESA had the potential for making be deduced to much lower accuracy. swingby or insertion into orbit. simple but effective concept. It uses two In principle, the delay time of the visible from both antennas for long delta-DOR measurements for the first Also, when the spacecraft is close to the However, ESA can now augment the widely separated antennas to simul- quasar is subtracted from that of the enough. time. With DSA-1 at New Norcia in celestial equator, the calculations conventional tracking by measurements taneously track a transmitting probe in spacecraft’s to provide the delta-DOR During each scan, signals are sampled Western Australia, the baseline is struggle and the north-south position is known as ‘Delta Differential One-way order to measure the time difference measurement (the Greek symbol ‘delta’ and recorded in the stations. The 11 650 km. However, even with this very poorly determined. The craft’s Range’ (delta-DOR). (‘delay time’) between signals arriving at is commonly used to denote ‘difference’). recorded data are transferred to ESOC, basic infrastructure, the system had to velocity components in the plane-of-sky NASA’s Deep Space Network (DSN) the two stations. The technique of The delay is converted to distance by where they are processed to extract the be upgraded for delta-DOR: modifying are not measured and can only be found has provided delta-DOR data since 1980 measuring this delay is named multiplying by the speed of light. delay. the receivers at each station, a new from how the position changes from day and has aided the navigation of ESA Differential One-way Range (DOR). A complication is that the quasar and A spacecraft signal is normally a architecture for the communication to day. This means that tracking over missions since 1986. Theoretically, the delay depends only spacecraft cannot be measured sequence of frequency-spaced tones links from the stations to ESOC, the several days is necessary and calls for In 1992, the navigational accuracy of on the positions of the two antennas simultaneously. In practice, three scans (either dedicated DOR tones produced development of a ‘correlator’ to extract very high-fidelity modelling of the on its approach to Jupiter was and the spacecraft. However, in reality, are made: spacecraft-quasar-spacecraft by the transponder or harmonics of the the delays from the raw data recorded at spacecraft’s motion. improved by the addition of delta-DOR the delay is affected by several sources of or quasar-spacecraft-quasar, and then telemetry subcarrier), each tone with its each station, and a flight dynamics The tracking system at ESA’s 35 m- measurements. In the second half of error: for example, the radio waves interpolation between the first and third full power contained in a few Hertz of system able to use the measurements. diameter deep space antennas (DSAs), 2003, 56 delta-DOR measurements travelling through the troposphere, converts them to the same time as the bandwidth. In contrast, quasar signals The system upgrade was completed in at New Norcia in Western Australia and from the Goldstone (California, USA)- ionosphere and solar plasma, and clock second measurement, from which the look like noise buried in the antenna’s less than 10 months, driven by the need Cebreros near Madrid provides very Madrid baseline and 49 from the instabilities at the ground station. delta-DOR data point is calculated. overall noise. For this reason, two to have an operating and tested delta- accurate measurements. Typically, the Goldstone-Canberra (Australia) baseline Delta-DOR corrects these errors by As two angles are required to define a different algorithms (based on the DOR capability before the Venus random errors on range are about 1 m were processed at ESOC for Mars ‘tracking’ a quasar in a direction close to direction, full exploitation of delta- signal’s characteristics) are necessary Express launch in November 2005. The and on the two-way range-rate less than Express. For the release of Beagle-2 and the spacecraft for calibration. The chosen DOR calls for measurements from two when extracting the delay in the signal improved system could then help to 0.1 mm/s. Nevertheless, the limitations insertion into Mars orbit, this provided quasar’s direction is already known different baseline orientations, the closer arrival times at the two stations. navigate the craft between the planets described above mean the accuracy of a 7-fold reduction in the navigation extremely accurately by astronomical to 90º the better. The error in the delta- Also, the accuracy improves if the and into the critical orbit insertion. resulting orbit determination may not uncertainty compared with the standard measurements, typically to better than DOR measurement translates into an tones are further apart in frequency. So The Venus Express orbit had to be good enough for navigation during method. 50 billionths of a degree (a nanoradian). angular error that diminishes with a wide bandwidth is important. calculated to very high accuracy, so an

70 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 71 Madde 11/9/06 1:40 PM Page 70

Operations & Infrastructure Navigation

Measuring the time it takes a radio signal to travel from Earth to the ESA’s second Deep Space Antenna, at Cebreros, Spain Delta-DOR tracking of a deep space probe and a nearby spacecraft and back gives the distance (range, r). The Doppler shift in quasar from DSA-1 (New Norcia) and DSA-2 (Cebreros). the frequency gives the speed along that line (range-rate, vr). But The quasar’s position is already known with great navigating the spacecraft requires knowing the actual velocity (v) precision from astronomical catalogues, so the actual through space. Traditionally, the missing elements were provided by measurements will reveal the distortions added by the measuring the spacecraft’s movement against the sky background ionosphere, for example, allowing them to be removed over several days from the probe’s tracking

ESA's New Norcia Deep Space Antenna, about 150 km north of Perth, Western Australia

on the range and range-rate data related critical stages of a mission. This is The ESA Delta-DOR Concept The quasar is usually within 10º of the longer baselines. Maximising the With the Cebreros DSA-2 antenna to the position of the spacecraft. These especially the case on approaching a The delta-DOR technique for navigating spacecraft so that their signal paths baseline is limited by the need for the coming into operation in September position components, though, can only planet before landing, performing a interplanetary spacecraft is based on a through Earth’s atmosphere are similar. spacecraft and quasar to be mutually 2005, ESA had the potential for making be deduced to much lower accuracy. swingby or insertion into orbit. simple but effective concept. It uses two In principle, the delay time of the visible from both antennas for long delta-DOR measurements for the first Also, when the spacecraft is close to the However, ESA can now augment the widely separated antennas to simul- quasar is subtracted from that of the enough. time. With DSA-1 at New Norcia in celestial equator, the calculations conventional tracking by measurements taneously track a transmitting probe in spacecraft’s to provide the delta-DOR During each scan, signals are sampled Western Australia, the baseline is struggle and the north-south position is known as ‘Delta Differential One-way order to measure the time difference measurement (the Greek symbol ‘delta’ and recorded in the stations. The 11 650 km. However, even with this very poorly determined. The craft’s Range’ (delta-DOR). (‘delay time’) between signals arriving at is commonly used to denote ‘difference’). recorded data are transferred to ESOC, basic infrastructure, the system had to velocity components in the plane-of-sky NASA’s Deep Space Network (DSN) the two stations. The technique of The delay is converted to distance by where they are processed to extract the be upgraded for delta-DOR: modifying are not measured and can only be found has provided delta-DOR data since 1980 measuring this delay is named multiplying by the speed of light. delay. the receivers at each station, a new from how the position changes from day and has aided the navigation of ESA Differential One-way Range (DOR). A complication is that the quasar and A spacecraft signal is normally a architecture for the communication to day. This means that tracking over missions since 1986. Theoretically, the delay depends only spacecraft cannot be measured sequence of frequency-spaced tones links from the stations to ESOC, the several days is necessary and calls for In 1992, the navigational accuracy of on the positions of the two antennas simultaneously. In practice, three scans (either dedicated DOR tones produced development of a ‘correlator’ to extract very high-fidelity modelling of the Ulysses on its approach to Jupiter was and the spacecraft. However, in reality, are made: spacecraft-quasar-spacecraft by the transponder or harmonics of the the delays from the raw data recorded at spacecraft’s motion. improved by the addition of delta-DOR the delay is affected by several sources of or quasar-spacecraft-quasar, and then telemetry subcarrier), each tone with its each station, and a flight dynamics The tracking system at ESA’s 35 m- measurements. In the second half of error: for example, the radio waves interpolation between the first and third full power contained in a few Hertz of system able to use the measurements. diameter deep space antennas (DSAs), 2003, 56 delta-DOR measurements travelling through the troposphere, converts them to the same time as the bandwidth. In contrast, quasar signals The system upgrade was completed in at New Norcia in Western Australia and from the Goldstone (California, USA)- ionosphere and solar plasma, and clock second measurement, from which the look like noise buried in the antenna’s less than 10 months, driven by the need Cebreros near Madrid provides very Madrid baseline and 49 from the instabilities at the ground station. delta-DOR data point is calculated. overall noise. For this reason, two to have an operating and tested delta- accurate measurements. Typically, the Goldstone-Canberra (Australia) baseline Delta-DOR corrects these errors by As two angles are required to define a different algorithms (based on the DOR capability before the Venus random errors on range are about 1 m were processed at ESOC for Mars ‘tracking’ a quasar in a direction close to direction, full exploitation of delta- signal’s characteristics) are necessary Express launch in November 2005. The and on the two-way range-rate less than Express. For the release of Beagle-2 and the spacecraft for calibration. The chosen DOR calls for measurements from two when extracting the delay in the signal improved system could then help to 0.1 mm/s. Nevertheless, the limitations insertion into Mars orbit, this provided quasar’s direction is already known different baseline orientations, the closer arrival times at the two stations. navigate the craft between the planets described above mean the accuracy of a 7-fold reduction in the navigation extremely accurately by astronomical to 90º the better. The error in the delta- Also, the accuracy improves if the and into the critical orbit insertion. resulting orbit determination may not uncertainty compared with the standard measurements, typically to better than DOR measurement translates into an tones are further apart in frequency. So The Venus Express orbit had to be good enough for navigation during method. 50 billionths of a degree (a nanoradian). angular error that diminishes with a wide bandwidth is important. calculated to very high accuracy, so an

70 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 71 Madde 11/9/06 1:41 PM Page 72

Operations & Infrastructure Navigation

uncertainty of only 1 nanosecond (a Receiver modifications New Norcia and up to 1.4 Gbyte/hour determination soft- billionth of a second) was imposed on The existing Intermediate Frequency from Cebreros, or up to 95% of the ware. These are the delta-DOR time-delay measurements. Modem System (IFMS) receiver had to available bandwidth. delivered to the Flight This corresponds to an angular accuracy be modified for simultaneous reception Dynamics team to of roughly a millionth of a degree – of multiple signals and to synchronise The correlator calculate the space- better than 4 km on the probe’s position the raw data, essential for achieving the The data are finally collected and craft’s orbit. at a distance of 150 million km. required accuracy. processed in a ‘correlator’ explicitly With only two stations available, ESA The IFMS is a multi-mission receiver designed for delta-DOR processing. The can provide delta-DOR tracking with developed by British Aerospace under challenge in this case consisted of The Validation Campaign just one baseline, and can track the ESA contract for a large variety of containing the costs (thus building a with spacecraft only in the portion of space routine tracking purposes – telecommand software correlator instead of the more Testing of ESA’s delta- visible between New Norcia and transmission, telemetry reception, data complex and expensive hardware DOR system began in Cebreros. decoding, ranging and Doppler correlator normally used) and the very late 2005 using Rosetta The ideal case for delta-DOR measurements. In order to support tight schedule. Defining the software and Venus Express. purposes would be to have another deep delta-DOR measurements, the IFMS requirements and identifying the Around the same time, space antenna at American longitudes, was upgraded to receive up to eight interfaces with all the other elements DOR measurements preferably in the southern hemisphere. channels in different portions of the was a demanding task, requiring the were made of pairs of This would provide a baseline almost downlink spectrum with a relative time- analysis of similar processors developed quasars (one of each perpendicular to the current one, tag synchronisation among the channels by NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory pair representing the completely resolving the angular of better than 1 nsec. Remote and radioastronomy systems. The spacecraft) so that the position of the spacecraft. installation of the software (another Department of Aerospace and correlation of the With such a baseline, ESA could be characteristic feature of this receiver) Astronautical Engineering of the quasar signal could be independent of outside help for delta- then allowed a fast upgrade of the The system updated for delta-DOR: the improved receiver, the University of Rome ‘La Sapienza’ Two IFMS receivers were upgraded at each ground station validated. In January DOR tracking. receiving system in both antennas. For storage units at each station, the modified wide-area network developed this software correlator. The and March 2006, test redundancy, two of the three receivers in and the development and installation of a software correlator at host machine is an off-the-shelf server DOR data were ESOC Setting up the System each station were upgraded. with enough computational power to obtained from Mars Express. Creation of the delta-DOR system was Two External Storage Units (ESUs), process the data to meet the 24-hour Delta-DOR Operations Of all these tests, those with Mars done step by step. Several elements of each an off-the-shelf server, were added constraint. The two ground stations are usually Express were the most important. While the existing infrastructure had to be to each station to offload the storage Data transfer remotely operated from the Ground in orbit around Mars, its trajectory is modified and some created ex novo to burden from the receiver. They also Once the data have been stored on the Flight dynamics support Facilities Control Centre in ESOC. determined using only Doppler data, meet the highly demanding require- permit fast formatting and long-term ESUs, they are transferred to the An important role during all phases is Orbit predictions required to point the with a resulting error in its position ments on a very tight schedule. storage of the data. correlator at ESOC for processing. The played by the ESOC Flight Dynamics antennas to the object are delivered to relative to the planet of usually less than quantity is substantial (up to 11 Gbyte) team, who support the planning, the stations on a routine basis. The 200 m. Our knowledge of the position – mainly from the quasar observations. execution and evaluation of delta-DOR unique delta-DOR feature is the of Mars itself has about the same Furthermore, they must reach ESOC observations by: production by the Flight Dynamics accuracy. Mars Express could thus be Areas of mutual visibility (greater than 10º above the horizon) between DSA-1 (New Norcia), DSA-2 (Cebreros) and a hypothetical within 12 hours in order to be used for team of predictions for quasars. The used to evaluate the real accuracy of the station in Paranal (Chile), highlighting the advantage of having a third antenna navigation within 24 hours of the – identifying suitable quasars near to operations of all ground elements delta-DOR measurements. observations. To cope with these the direction of the spacecraft, and supporting delta-DOR (ground stations, The Mars tests revealed a correlator restrictions and to keep the costs down providing visibility information; correlator, Flight Dynamics, communi- problem that caused the delta-DOR (so no dedicated data links), existing – providing accurate orbit predictions to cations, ESOC facilities) are scheduled measurements to be wrong on the order resources had to be used. Both stations the correlator, including derived according to Flight Dynamics of 5 nsec. After this was corrected, are connected to ESOC via a triangular quantities like expected one-way range requirements, which mesh with station processing of the six sets of DOR data network, where each side has a 2 Mbit/s and range-rate values for both the usage by other missions, and in showed that all but one of the delta- capacity. For the delta-DOR data spacecraft and quasar for both coordination with a delta-DOR DOR measurements were accurate to transfer, the capacity is used on a best- stations; observations planning team. The data better than 0.5 nsec (the goal was effort basis, on both the direct line – processing the reduced DOR data recorded at the ground stations are 1 nsec). The other gave 0.7 nsec; this was (single hop) and the indirect line (dual within complex software to generate retrieved offline via the correlator caused by using a quasar 15º from the hop). The busy lines, especially for New the delta-DOR residual (the difference workstation during or just after the spacecraft (the standard is within 10º). Norcia, required special data retrieval between the actual measurement and observation itself. and stacking algorithms. (See also ‘New its value predicted from mathematical Based on the raw data, and on the The Operational Venus Express Campaign Communication Solutions for ESA models) and, together with the prediction files provided by Flight Following these encouraging results, Ground Stations’ in ESA Bulletin 125. processing of the conventional data, Dynamics, the correlator extracts the and although the project was still in its A high throughput was achieved: an to determine the spacecraft orbital delay between the signal arrival times at validation phase, it was decided to make average of up to 1.2 Gbyte/hour from parameters. the two stations required for the orbit delta-DOR measurements of Venus

72 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 73 Madde 11/9/06 1:41 PM Page 72

Operations & Infrastructure Navigation

uncertainty of only 1 nanosecond (a Receiver modifications New Norcia and up to 1.4 Gbyte/hour determination soft- billionth of a second) was imposed on The existing Intermediate Frequency from Cebreros, or up to 95% of the ware. These are the delta-DOR time-delay measurements. Modem System (IFMS) receiver had to available bandwidth. delivered to the Flight This corresponds to an angular accuracy be modified for simultaneous reception Dynamics team to of roughly a millionth of a degree – of multiple signals and to synchronise The correlator calculate the space- better than 4 km on the probe’s position the raw data, essential for achieving the The data are finally collected and craft’s orbit. at a distance of 150 million km. required accuracy. processed in a ‘correlator’ explicitly With only two stations available, ESA The IFMS is a multi-mission receiver designed for delta-DOR processing. The can provide delta-DOR tracking with developed by British Aerospace under challenge in this case consisted of The Validation Campaign just one baseline, and can track the ESA contract for a large variety of containing the costs (thus building a with Mars Express spacecraft only in the portion of space routine tracking purposes – telecommand software correlator instead of the more Testing of ESA’s delta- visible between New Norcia and transmission, telemetry reception, data complex and expensive hardware DOR system began in Cebreros. decoding, ranging and Doppler correlator normally used) and the very late 2005 using Rosetta The ideal case for delta-DOR measurements. In order to support tight schedule. Defining the software and Venus Express. purposes would be to have another deep delta-DOR measurements, the IFMS requirements and identifying the Around the same time, space antenna at American longitudes, was upgraded to receive up to eight interfaces with all the other elements DOR measurements preferably in the southern hemisphere. channels in different portions of the was a demanding task, requiring the were made of pairs of This would provide a baseline almost downlink spectrum with a relative time- analysis of similar processors developed quasars (one of each perpendicular to the current one, tag synchronisation among the channels by NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory pair representing the completely resolving the angular of better than 1 nsec. Remote and radioastronomy systems. The spacecraft) so that the position of the spacecraft. installation of the software (another Department of Aerospace and correlation of the With such a baseline, ESA could be characteristic feature of this receiver) Astronautical Engineering of the quasar signal could be independent of outside help for delta- then allowed a fast upgrade of the The system updated for delta-DOR: the improved receiver, the University of Rome ‘La Sapienza’ Two IFMS receivers were upgraded at each ground station validated. In January DOR tracking. receiving system in both antennas. For storage units at each station, the modified wide-area network developed this software correlator. The and March 2006, test redundancy, two of the three receivers in and the development and installation of a software correlator at host machine is an off-the-shelf server DOR data were ESOC Setting up the System each station were upgraded. with enough computational power to obtained from Mars Express. Creation of the delta-DOR system was Two External Storage Units (ESUs), process the data to meet the 24-hour Delta-DOR Operations Of all these tests, those with Mars done step by step. Several elements of each an off-the-shelf server, were added constraint. The two ground stations are usually Express were the most important. While the existing infrastructure had to be to each station to offload the storage Data transfer remotely operated from the Ground in orbit around Mars, its trajectory is modified and some created ex novo to burden from the receiver. They also Once the data have been stored on the Flight dynamics support Facilities Control Centre in ESOC. determined using only Doppler data, meet the highly demanding require- permit fast formatting and long-term ESUs, they are transferred to the An important role during all phases is Orbit predictions required to point the with a resulting error in its position ments on a very tight schedule. storage of the data. correlator at ESOC for processing. The played by the ESOC Flight Dynamics antennas to the object are delivered to relative to the planet of usually less than quantity is substantial (up to 11 Gbyte) team, who support the planning, the stations on a routine basis. The 200 m. Our knowledge of the position – mainly from the quasar observations. execution and evaluation of delta-DOR unique delta-DOR feature is the of Mars itself has about the same Furthermore, they must reach ESOC observations by: production by the Flight Dynamics accuracy. Mars Express could thus be Areas of mutual visibility (greater than 10º above the horizon) between DSA-1 (New Norcia), DSA-2 (Cebreros) and a hypothetical within 12 hours in order to be used for team of predictions for quasars. The used to evaluate the real accuracy of the station in Paranal (Chile), highlighting the advantage of having a third antenna navigation within 24 hours of the – identifying suitable quasars near to operations of all ground elements delta-DOR measurements. observations. To cope with these the direction of the spacecraft, and supporting delta-DOR (ground stations, The Mars tests revealed a correlator restrictions and to keep the costs down providing visibility information; correlator, Flight Dynamics, communi- problem that caused the delta-DOR (so no dedicated data links), existing – providing accurate orbit predictions to cations, ESOC facilities) are scheduled measurements to be wrong on the order resources had to be used. Both stations the correlator, including derived according to Flight Dynamics of 5 nsec. After this was corrected, are connected to ESOC via a triangular quantities like expected one-way range requirements, which mesh with station processing of the six sets of DOR data network, where each side has a 2 Mbit/s and range-rate values for both the usage by other missions, and in showed that all but one of the delta- capacity. For the delta-DOR data spacecraft and quasar for both coordination with a delta-DOR DOR measurements were accurate to transfer, the capacity is used on a best- stations; observations planning team. The data better than 0.5 nsec (the goal was effort basis, on both the direct line – processing the reduced DOR data recorded at the ground stations are 1 nsec). The other gave 0.7 nsec; this was (single hop) and the indirect line (dual within complex software to generate retrieved offline via the correlator caused by using a quasar 15º from the hop). The busy lines, especially for New the delta-DOR residual (the difference workstation during or just after the spacecraft (the standard is within 10º). Norcia, required special data retrieval between the actual measurement and observation itself. and stacking algorithms. (See also ‘New its value predicted from mathematical Based on the raw data, and on the The Operational Venus Express Campaign Communication Solutions for ESA models) and, together with the prediction files provided by Flight Following these encouraging results, Ground Stations’ in ESA Bulletin 125. processing of the conventional data, Dynamics, the correlator extracts the and although the project was still in its A high throughput was achieved: an to determine the spacecraft orbital delay between the signal arrival times at validation phase, it was decided to make average of up to 1.2 Gbyte/hour from parameters. the two stations required for the orbit delta-DOR measurements of Venus

72 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 73 Madde 11/9/06 1:41 PM Page 74

Operations & Infrastructure

Express and use them operationally. combination of unfavourable geometry Fifteen data points derived from and problems achieving consistent sessions on five occasions in March and modelling of small accelerations from early April 2006 augmented a total of 45 solar radiation pressure and possible NASA measurements obtained at the outgassing from the spacecraft. same time, mainly from the Goldstone- Despite this, the single most Canberra baseline. important navigation parameter, the Pre-launch analysis had shown that, minimum altitude above Venus at under normal circumstances, the arrival, was only 3 km higher than the navigation accuracy needed for insertion predicted 386 km. Even with all the into orbit around Venus could be achieved information available after the event, it with range and Doppler data only. Delta- is not possible to distinguish entirely ESA’s delta-DOR measurements will be important for combining DOR increased confidence, because it between small navigation errors and the with NASA’s information during the Rosetta flyby of Mars in could confirm the basic correctness of small difference between the actual and February 2007 these conventional orbit solutions. expected performance of the orbit Also, delta-DOR covered the insertion. contingency case of the spacecraft stations – a truly complementary switching to its basic safe mode during The Future arrangement between two space the last few days before arrival at Venus. On 25 February 2007, Rosetta will swing agencies. In that case, thrusters would fire by Mars at a planned altitude of Future interplanetary ESA missions autonomously and perturb the orbit 250 km. Errors in the swingby are fuel- will also benefit from this technique. It is with a velocity increment of unknown expensive to correct afterwards, so it is expected that it will help BepiColombo magnitude and direction and planned to make both NASA DSN and to make significant fuel savings in its imprecisely-known timing. Delta-DOR ESA delta-DOR measurements, mostly correction manoeuvres. In preparation, would reveal the orbit much faster than in January and February. a SMART-1 tracking campaign conventional data. In early 2007, Rosetta will appear in validated the capability of the system to Analysis showed that the quality of Earth’s southern sky, at the limit of record and process dedicated DOR these ESA measurements was only simultaneous visibility from Goldstone tones transmitted by the spacecraft. slightly inferior to those obtained using and Madrid for NASA. It is expected Finally, collaboration with NASA and NASA’s 34 m antennas. The most that very few, if any, DOR measure- Japan will be improved by the accurate were obtained with NASA’s ments can be made from this baseline. development of data translators to 70 m dishes. Although the delta-DOR This means that, in order to exploit exchange data and results. This will data substantially reduced the delta-DOR capabilities to obtain greatly extend the number of baselines navigation uncertainties, the improve- complete direction information (that is, available for delta-DOR observations, ment was not as marked as that for use two baselines), one must be of benefiting everyone involved in the Mars Express. This was mainly due to a NASA stations and the other of ESA navigation of deep space probes. e

74 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 75 BP128 11/9/06 4:38 PM Page 76

Programmes In Progress

2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 PROJECT J FMAMJ JASONDJ FMAMJ JASONDJ FMAMJ JASOND J FMAMJ JASONDJ FMAMJ JASOND J FMAMJ JASONDJ FMAMJ JASOND J FMAMJ JASONDJ FMAMJ JASOND COMMENTS SPACE TELESCOPE LAUNCHED APRIL1990 Programmes ULYSSES LAUNCHED OCTOBER 1990 SOHO LAUNCHED DECEMBER 1995

HUYGENS LAUNCHED OCTOBER 1997

XMM-NEWTON LAUNCHED DECEMBER 1999

CLUSTER RE-LAUNCHED MID-2000

INTEGRAL LAUNCHED OCTOBER 2002

MARS EXPRESS LAUNCHED JUNE 2003

SMART-1 LAUNCHED SEPTEMBER 2003 TC-1 LAUNCHED DECEMBER. 2003 SCIENTIFIC in Progress PROGRAMME TC-2 LAUNCHED JULY 2004 ROSETTA LAUNCHED MARCH 2004

VENUS EXPRESS LAUNCHED NOVEMBER 2005

HERSCHEL/PLANCK LAUNCH MAY 2008

LISA PATHFINDER LAUNCH 4TH QUARTER 2009 Status end-September 2006 GAIA LAUNCH END-2011 JWST LAUNCH JUNE 2013

BEPICOLOMBO LAUNCH AUGUST 2013

METEOSAT-5/6/7 M5 LAUNCHED 1991, M6 1993, M7 1997

ERS-2 LAUNCHED APRIL 1995

ENVISAT LAUNCHED MARCH 2002

MSG-1 MSG-2 MSG MSG-3 LAUNCH 2011, MSG-4 LAUNCH 2013

METOP METOP-A LAUNCH OCTOBER 2006, METOP-B 2010, METOP-C 2015 CRYOSAT LAUNCH FAILURE OCTOBER 2005 CRYOSAT-2 LAUNCH MARCH 2009 GOCE LAUNCH SEPTEMBER 2007 PROGRAMME

EARTH OBSERVATION EARTH SMOS LAUNCH SEPTEMBER 2007

ADM-AEOLUS LAUNCH SEPTEMBER 2008

SWARM LAUNCH 2010

EARTHCARE LAUNCH END-2012

ARTEMIS LAUNCHED JULY 2001

ALPHABUS LAUNCH 2009

SMALL GEO SAT. LAUNCH JUNE 2010

COMMS./NAV. GNSS-1/EGNOS OPERATIONS START 2006 PROGRAMME

GIOVE-A GIOVE-B GALILEOSAT GIOVE-A LAUNCHED DEC. 2005 GIOVE-B LAUNCH 2007, IOV END-2008 PROBA-1 LAUNCHED OCTOBER 2001

PROBA-2 LAUNCH SEPTEMBER 2007 PROG.

TECHNOL. SLOSHSAT LAUNCHED FEBRUARY 2005

COLUMBUS LAUNCH OCTOBER 2007

ATV FIRST LAUNCH JUNE-JULY 2007

NODE-2 & -3 & CUPOLA LAUNCHES AUGUST 2007 & JANUARY 2010 CUPOLA WITH NODE-3 ERA LAUNCH NOT BEFORE END-2009

MSG MELFI 1 EDR/EUTEF/SOLAR MELFI 2 ISS SUPPORT & UTIL. EUTEF/SOLAR WITH COLUMBUS

FOTON-MI APCF-6/BIOBOX-5/ MATROSHKA FOTON-M2 TEXUS-42 MAXUS-7/TEXUS-43 PCDF TEXUS-44/45 ARMS/BIOPACK/ MASER-11 EMIR/ELIPS MASER-10 EML-1 EMCS/ MARES FAST-2/ERISTO MAXUS-6 PEMS FOTON-M3 MSL MFC BIO, FSL, EPM with COLUMBUS & EXPLORATION PROGRAMME & EXPLORATION ASTRONAUT FLT. HUMAN SPACEFLIGHT, MICROGRAVITY HUMAN SPACEFLIGHT,

AURORA CORE

EXOMARS LAUNCH MID-2013

ARIANE-5 DEVELOP. OPERATIONAL

ARIANE-5 PLUS AR5-ECA QUALIF. LAUNCHED FEBRUARY 2005

VEGA FIRST LAUNCH DECEMBER 2007 PROG.

LAUNCHER SOYUZ AT CSG READY FOR LAUNCH MAY 2009

DEFINITION PHASE MAIN DEVELOPMENT PHASE STORAGE

LAUNCH/READY FOR LAUNCH OPERATIONS ADDITIONAL LIFE POSSIBLE

76 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 77 BP128 11/9/06 4:38 PM Page 76

Programmes In Progress

2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 PROJECT J FMAMJ JASONDJ FMAMJ JASONDJ FMAMJ JASOND J FMAMJ JASONDJ FMAMJ JASOND J FMAMJ JASONDJ FMAMJ JASOND J FMAMJ JASONDJ FMAMJ JASOND COMMENTS SPACE TELESCOPE LAUNCHED APRIL1990 Programmes ULYSSES LAUNCHED OCTOBER 1990 SOHO LAUNCHED DECEMBER 1995

HUYGENS LAUNCHED OCTOBER 1997

XMM-NEWTON LAUNCHED DECEMBER 1999

CLUSTER RE-LAUNCHED MID-2000

INTEGRAL LAUNCHED OCTOBER 2002

MARS EXPRESS LAUNCHED JUNE 2003

SMART-1 LAUNCHED SEPTEMBER 2003 TC-1 LAUNCHED DECEMBER. 2003 SCIENTIFIC DOUBLE STAR in Progress PROGRAMME TC-2 LAUNCHED JULY 2004 ROSETTA LAUNCHED MARCH 2004

VENUS EXPRESS LAUNCHED NOVEMBER 2005

HERSCHEL/PLANCK LAUNCH MAY 2008

LISA PATHFINDER LAUNCH 4TH QUARTER 2009 Status end-September 2006 GAIA LAUNCH END-2011 JWST LAUNCH JUNE 2013

BEPICOLOMBO LAUNCH AUGUST 2013

METEOSAT-5/6/7 M5 LAUNCHED 1991, M6 1993, M7 1997

ERS-2 LAUNCHED APRIL 1995

ENVISAT LAUNCHED MARCH 2002

MSG-1 MSG-2 MSG MSG-3 LAUNCH 2011, MSG-4 LAUNCH 2013

METOP METOP-A LAUNCH OCTOBER 2006, METOP-B 2010, METOP-C 2015 CRYOSAT LAUNCH FAILURE OCTOBER 2005 CRYOSAT-2 LAUNCH MARCH 2009 GOCE LAUNCH SEPTEMBER 2007 PROGRAMME

EARTH OBSERVATION EARTH SMOS LAUNCH SEPTEMBER 2007

ADM-AEOLUS LAUNCH SEPTEMBER 2008

SWARM LAUNCH 2010

EARTHCARE LAUNCH END-2012

ARTEMIS LAUNCHED JULY 2001

ALPHABUS LAUNCH 2009

SMALL GEO SAT. LAUNCH JUNE 2010

COMMS./NAV. GNSS-1/EGNOS OPERATIONS START 2006 PROGRAMME

GIOVE-A GIOVE-B GALILEOSAT GIOVE-A LAUNCHED DEC. 2005 GIOVE-B LAUNCH 2007, IOV END-2008 PROBA-1 LAUNCHED OCTOBER 2001

PROBA-2 LAUNCH SEPTEMBER 2007 PROG.

TECHNOL. SLOSHSAT LAUNCHED FEBRUARY 2005

COLUMBUS LAUNCH OCTOBER 2007

ATV FIRST LAUNCH JUNE-JULY 2007

NODE-2 & -3 & CUPOLA LAUNCHES AUGUST 2007 & JANUARY 2010 CUPOLA WITH NODE-3 ERA LAUNCH NOT BEFORE END-2009

MSG MELFI 1 EDR/EUTEF/SOLAR MELFI 2 ISS SUPPORT & UTIL. EUTEF/SOLAR WITH COLUMBUS

FOTON-MI APCF-6/BIOBOX-5/ MATROSHKA FOTON-M2 TEXUS-42 MAXUS-7/TEXUS-43 PCDF TEXUS-44/45 ARMS/BIOPACK/ MASER-11 EMIR/ELIPS MASER-10 EML-1 EMCS/ MARES FAST-2/ERISTO MAXUS-6 PEMS FOTON-M3 MSL MFC BIO, FSL, EPM with COLUMBUS & EXPLORATION PROGRAMME & EXPLORATION ASTRONAUT FLT. HUMAN SPACEFLIGHT, MICROGRAVITY HUMAN SPACEFLIGHT,

AURORA CORE

EXOMARS LAUNCH MID-2013

ARIANE-5 DEVELOP. OPERATIONAL

ARIANE-5 PLUS AR5-ECA QUALIF. LAUNCHED FEBRUARY 2005

VEGA FIRST LAUNCH DECEMBER 2007 PROG.

LAUNCHER SOYUZ AT CSG READY FOR LAUNCH MAY 2009

DEFINITION PHASE MAIN DEVELOPMENT PHASE STORAGE

LAUNCH/READY FOR LAUNCH OPERATIONS ADDITIONAL LIFE POSSIBLE

76 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 77 BP128 11/9/06 4:38 PM Page 78

Programmes In Progress

ISO Explanatory Library on the ISO web site. under a different geometry may help to observations to be performed between May HST Support continued to be provided directly to answer this question. 2007 and May 2008 has opened. XMM- users in their exploitation of the ISO data Newton scientific results have been reported A team of US and European astronomers throughout the period. The analysis and interpretation of Huygens in 1188 refereed papers, of which 181 are analysing two of the deepest views of the data continue. The excellent scientific return from 2006. cosmos made with the Hubble Space of Huygens is well illustrated by the movies Telescope has uncovered a gold mine of recently released by the DISR team (available A preliminary version of the second XMM- more than 500 galaxies that existed less than SOHO at http://saturn.esa.int). These give a good Newton serendipitous source catalogue, a billion years after the Big Bang. This account of the work done so far by all the 2XMMp, has been released. The catalogue sample is the most comprehensive SOHO-18 ‘Beyond the Spherical Sun: A New teams to understand and interpret the has been constructed by the XMM-Newton compilation of galaxies in the early Universe, Era in Helio- and Asteroseismology’ was held performance of the probe during the descent Survey Science Centre (SSC) on behalf of researchers said. The discovery is jointly with the annual meeting of the Global and the returned science data. A recent ESA. It contains over 150 000 source scientifically invaluable for understanding the Oscillation Network Group (GONG) detailed interpretation of the Huygens detections, making it the largest catalogue of origin of galaxies, considering that just a 7–11 August at the University of Sheffield, observations by meteorologists astronomical X-ray sources ever produced. decade ago early galaxy formation was UK. Nearly 130 participants discussed over suggests that methane was drizzling down The catalogue is derived from the available largely uncharted territory. Astronomers then 150 papers, which will be published as ESA on the day of the Huygens landing. pointed observations that XMM-Newton has had not seen even one galaxy from when the SP-624. A French-Spanish team reported the made so far, and covers less than 1% of the Universe was a billion years old, so finding detection of g modes in the Sun using sky. 500 in a Hubble survey is a significant leap 10 years of GOLF data. Their results also forward for cosmologists. devoted to these topics was held in This Hubble image shows 28 of the more than 500 young suggest a solar core rotating significantly XMM-Newton XMM-Newton has found evidence linking September to honour him and celebrate his galaxies uncovered in the analysis of two Hubble surveys. faster than the rest of the radiative zone. If stellar remains to the oldest recorded birthday. At that meeting, George Gloeckler, (NASA; ESA; R. Bouwens & G. Illingworth, University of California, confirmed, this could open a new era in the XMM-Newton operations are continuing supernova. The combined image from the Santa Cruz, USA) his Co-PI on the Ulysses Solar Wind Ion study of the dynamical properties of the smoothly, with the spacecraft, instruments Chandra and XMM-Newton X-ray Ulysses Composition instrument (SWICS), noted that central solar interior. and ground segment all performing observatories of a supernova remnant called Johannes Geiss was the first to measure the best use of the legacy provided by the first nominally. The 6th Announcement of RCW 86 shows the expanding ring of debris On 6 October, Ulysses completed its 16th composition of the noble gases in the solar true infrared observatory in space, in close On 9 August a Polish amateur astronomer Observing (AO-6) opportunity for that was created after a massive star in the successful year in orbit. The spacecraft wind when, in the late 1960s, he flew his collaboration with active National Data discovered the 1000th SOHO in the continues its climb to high southern latitudes brilliant foil experiments on five Apollo Centres. Major releases of the ISO Data Kreutz group of Sun-grazing comets. The XMM-Newton full field (left) and Chandra close-up (right) images of the oldest recorded supernova, RCW 86. Both images show low- with all subsystems and science instruments missions to collect solar wind ions on the Archive included: 1185th comet discovered in data from energy X-rays in red, medium energies in green and high energies in blue. (ESA/XMM-Newton; NASA/CXC; Univ. Utrecht, J. Vink) in good health. Science operations are Moon. In recent years, Geiss, together with SOHO’s LASCO and SWAN instruments in currently being conducted according to a his colleagues on the SWICS team, has – the introduction of products derived from total, the faint object is officially designated revised payload power-sharing plan. Largely determined the isotopic and elemental systematic manual processing of data, C/2006 P7 (SOHO) by the Minor Planet as a result of the gradually improving composition of the solar wind under all solar including queryable catalogues and atlases Centre of the IAU. Before the launch of thermal situation as Ulysses gets closer to wind conditions and at all helio-latitudes. (Highly Processed Data Products). ISO will SOHO, only some 30 members of the Kreutz the Sun, several instruments not in the core have about a third of its content populated group were known. All 1000 Kreutz comets payload category have been able to acquire Geiss’ quest to measure and understand the with Highly Processed Data Products; are believed to be fragments of a single data for short periods (typically a month). composition of matter is not limited to the – the adoption of an innovative way to comet observed in about 371 BC by Aristotle These include the gamma-ray burst solar wind, however. He has also played a document quality information for each and Ephorus, and the fragments themselves experiment and the solar wind electron key role in the in situ measurement of observation; continue to fragment, making more sensor. Ground segment performance has molecular ions in comets and the – the characterisation by object type; Sun-grazing comets. been excellent, leading to an overall data interpretation of these data, and in the study – full integration into the Virtual Observatory. return for the period of 98.6%. By the middle of the composition of plasmas in the of November, the spacecraft will have of Earth and Jupiter. On ISO results continue to appear in the refereed reached 70ºS solar latitude, marking the start behalf of the Ulysses team, literature and are clearly used to prepare Cassini-Huygens of the third South Polar Pass. Johannes Geiss ‘many happy returns’ and proposals with other astronomical facilities. many more scientific discoveries. The ISO Science Legacy book was published, The Cassini Orbiter mission continues One of the fathers of the Ulysses mission reviewing the most significant results from smoothly. Regular observations are (and one of its longest-serving Principal papers published until 2005. Over 1380 published on JPL’s web page Investigators), Johannes Geiss, recently refereed papers based on ISO data have been (http://saturn.jpl.nasa.gov). Each Titan flyby celebrated his 80th birthday. Geiss is a ISO published to date. Documentation about the brings new surprises as the radar probes world-leader in the measurement and mission, its instruments and data products new territory. Lakes have been spotted near interpretation of the composition of matter The 5-year ISO Active Archive Phase is due has been published in the 5-volume ISO the north pole but it is not yet known that reveals the history, present state and for completion in December 2006. This is the Handbook. This is accompanied by a legacy whether they are dry or filled with liquid. future of astronomical objects. A symposium last phase of ISO, aiming at ensuring the of around 200 documents organised in the Upcoming observations of the same territory

78 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 79 BP128 11/9/06 4:38 PM Page 78

Programmes In Progress

ISO Explanatory Library on the ISO web site. under a different geometry may help to observations to be performed between May HST Support continued to be provided directly to answer this question. 2007 and May 2008 has opened. XMM- users in their exploitation of the ISO data Newton scientific results have been reported A team of US and European astronomers throughout the period. The analysis and interpretation of Huygens in 1188 refereed papers, of which 181 are analysing two of the deepest views of the data continue. The excellent scientific return from 2006. cosmos made with the Hubble Space of Huygens is well illustrated by the movies Telescope has uncovered a gold mine of recently released by the DISR team (available A preliminary version of the second XMM- more than 500 galaxies that existed less than SOHO at http://saturn.esa.int). These give a good Newton serendipitous source catalogue, a billion years after the Big Bang. This account of the work done so far by all the 2XMMp, has been released. The catalogue sample is the most comprehensive SOHO-18 ‘Beyond the Spherical Sun: A New teams to understand and interpret the has been constructed by the XMM-Newton compilation of galaxies in the early Universe, Era in Helio- and Asteroseismology’ was held performance of the probe during the descent Survey Science Centre (SSC) on behalf of researchers said. The discovery is jointly with the annual meeting of the Global and the returned science data. A recent ESA. It contains over 150 000 source scientifically invaluable for understanding the Oscillation Network Group (GONG) detailed interpretation of the Huygens detections, making it the largest catalogue of origin of galaxies, considering that just a 7–11 August at the University of Sheffield, observations by Titan meteorologists astronomical X-ray sources ever produced. decade ago early galaxy formation was UK. Nearly 130 participants discussed over suggests that methane was drizzling down The catalogue is derived from the available largely uncharted territory. Astronomers then 150 papers, which will be published as ESA on the day of the Huygens landing. pointed observations that XMM-Newton has had not seen even one galaxy from when the SP-624. A French-Spanish team reported the made so far, and covers less than 1% of the Universe was a billion years old, so finding detection of g modes in the Sun using sky. 500 in a Hubble survey is a significant leap 10 years of GOLF data. Their results also forward for cosmologists. devoted to these topics was held in This Hubble image shows 28 of the more than 500 young suggest a solar core rotating significantly XMM-Newton XMM-Newton has found evidence linking September to honour him and celebrate his galaxies uncovered in the analysis of two Hubble surveys. faster than the rest of the radiative zone. If stellar remains to the oldest recorded birthday. At that meeting, George Gloeckler, (NASA; ESA; R. Bouwens & G. Illingworth, University of California, confirmed, this could open a new era in the XMM-Newton operations are continuing supernova. The combined image from the Santa Cruz, USA) his Co-PI on the Ulysses Solar Wind Ion study of the dynamical properties of the smoothly, with the spacecraft, instruments Chandra and XMM-Newton X-ray Ulysses Composition instrument (SWICS), noted that central solar interior. and ground segment all performing observatories of a supernova remnant called Johannes Geiss was the first to measure the best use of the legacy provided by the first nominally. The 6th Announcement of RCW 86 shows the expanding ring of debris On 6 October, Ulysses completed its 16th composition of the noble gases in the solar true infrared observatory in space, in close On 9 August a Polish amateur astronomer Observing (AO-6) opportunity for that was created after a massive star in the successful year in orbit. The spacecraft wind when, in the late 1960s, he flew his collaboration with active National Data discovered the 1000th SOHO comet in the continues its climb to high southern latitudes brilliant foil experiments on five Apollo Centres. Major releases of the ISO Data Kreutz group of Sun-grazing comets. The XMM-Newton full field (left) and Chandra close-up (right) images of the oldest recorded supernova, RCW 86. Both images show low- with all subsystems and science instruments missions to collect solar wind ions on the Archive included: 1185th comet discovered in data from energy X-rays in red, medium energies in green and high energies in blue. (ESA/XMM-Newton; NASA/CXC; Univ. Utrecht, J. Vink) in good health. Science operations are Moon. In recent years, Geiss, together with SOHO’s LASCO and SWAN instruments in currently being conducted according to a his colleagues on the SWICS team, has – the introduction of products derived from total, the faint object is officially designated revised payload power-sharing plan. Largely determined the isotopic and elemental systematic manual processing of data, C/2006 P7 (SOHO) by the Minor Planet as a result of the gradually improving composition of the solar wind under all solar including queryable catalogues and atlases Centre of the IAU. Before the launch of thermal situation as Ulysses gets closer to wind conditions and at all helio-latitudes. (Highly Processed Data Products). ISO will SOHO, only some 30 members of the Kreutz the Sun, several instruments not in the core have about a third of its content populated group were known. All 1000 Kreutz comets payload category have been able to acquire Geiss’ quest to measure and understand the with Highly Processed Data Products; are believed to be fragments of a single data for short periods (typically a month). composition of matter is not limited to the – the adoption of an innovative way to comet observed in about 371 BC by Aristotle These include the gamma-ray burst solar wind, however. He has also played a document quality information for each and Ephorus, and the fragments themselves experiment and the solar wind electron key role in the in situ measurement of observation; continue to fragment, making more sensor. Ground segment performance has molecular ions in comets and the – the characterisation by object type; Sun-grazing comets. been excellent, leading to an overall data interpretation of these data, and in the study – full integration into the Virtual Observatory. return for the period of 98.6%. By the middle of the composition of plasmas in the of November, the spacecraft will have magnetospheres of Earth and Jupiter. On ISO results continue to appear in the refereed reached 70ºS solar latitude, marking the start behalf of the Ulysses team, we wish literature and are clearly used to prepare Cassini-Huygens of the third South Polar Pass. Johannes Geiss ‘many happy returns’ and proposals with other astronomical facilities. many more scientific discoveries. The ISO Science Legacy book was published, The Cassini Orbiter mission continues One of the fathers of the Ulysses mission reviewing the most significant results from smoothly. Regular observations are (and one of its longest-serving Principal papers published until 2005. Over 1380 published on JPL’s web page Investigators), Johannes Geiss, recently refereed papers based on ISO data have been (http://saturn.jpl.nasa.gov). Each Titan flyby celebrated his 80th birthday. Geiss is a ISO published to date. Documentation about the brings new surprises as the radar probes world-leader in the measurement and mission, its instruments and data products new territory. Lakes have been spotted near interpretation of the composition of matter The 5-year ISO Active Archive Phase is due has been published in the 5-volume ISO the north pole but it is not yet known that reveals the history, present state and for completion in December 2006. This is the Handbook. This is accompanied by a legacy whether they are dry or filled with liquid. future of astronomical objects. A symposium last phase of ISO, aiming at ensuring the of around 200 documents organised in the Upcoming observations of the same territory

78 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 79 BP128 11/9/06 4:39 PM Page 80

Programmes In Progress

Milky Way collapsed and exploded. The new downlinked to the ground station at the end demonstrated and the VMC imaging system observations reveal that RCW 86 was created Double Star of the test. Preliminary analysis indicates that provided the first sequences of the by a star that exploded about 2000 years all instruments and the Philae lander are in observations of the cloud movements in the ago. This age matches observations of a new The two spacecraft and their instruments are good health. atmosphere. Most spectacular so far have bright star by Chinese (and possibly Roman) operating nominally. TC-2 has started the been the observations by VIRTIS at the astronomers in 185 AD and may be the eclipse season and TC-1 follows in November. On 29 September the second large Deep different wavelengths in the 1–5 µm range. It oldest known recording of a supernova. Space Manoeuvre was executed to target the clearly showed that we can penetrate to The European Payload Operation System, trajectory for the Mars swingby. The different levels deep in the atmosphere and which coordinates the operations for the manoeuvre was extremely accurate (0.1%) even can relate the observations to distinct seven European instruments, is running and placed Rosetta on its final course surface features. Cluster smoothly. Data are acquired using the towards the Red Planet. VILSPA 2 ground station for 3.8 h/day over an Venus Express is operated from the VEX The four spacecraft and instruments are average of two passes per day. The availability Intense analysis, testing and validation Mission Operations team at ESOC with daily operating nominally and have successfully of the ground station between January and activities are under way at the Control Centre 8 h tracking passes via ESA’s deep space come through the long eclipse season, July 2006 was above 99%. in preparation of the next critical mission antenna in Cerbreros (E). Payload operations including spacecraft-1, which now has very phases: Mars and Earth swingbys in are coordinated by the VEX Science weak batteries. To counteract this, ESOC A study on pulsed magnetic reconnection was February and November 2007, respectively, Operations Centre at ESTEC. defined a new mode of operation called A perspective view of the Cydonia region of Mars based on images from the High Resolution Stereo Camera aboard Mars Express. published in Annales Geophysicae using and the first asteroid (Steins) flyby in ‘decoder only’, where the computer and all Resolution is 13.7 m/pixel; date 22 July 2006. See the ‘In Brief’ news section of this issue for further information. Double Star and Cluster data. It was shown September 2008. The payload is usually other subsystems are switched off. To warm (ESA/DLR/FU Berlin, G. Neukum) that newly reconnected flux tubes (‘flux inactive in this cruise period, with the up spacecraft-1 and recharge the batteries, transfer events’) are observed in the exception of periodic test activities and SMART-1 the instruments were switched off for all the Announcement for Observing proposals longest eclipses. With the craft being equatorial plane by Double Star and at higher occasional scientific opportunities. However, eclipses (15–23 September). The other three (AO-4) are being observed. AO-4 includes a configured for the low-power/aphelion latitude by Cluster. This showed that the payload operations are planned for The operational mission ended on satellites recorded data as usual between pilot key programme observation of the season, payload operations are suspended reconnection site was at least extended over December, when there will be many test and 3 September, at 05:42:22 UT, when the New eclipses. galactic bulge region, which attracted a great (except for radio science during solar 2 h in local time. Furthermore, Double Star calibration activities, including major Norcia ground station in Australia lost radio deal of interest. The scientific community will conjunction) for some 10 weeks. However, could detect these events during one of its onboard software updates. contact with the spacecraft. SMART-1 ended JSOC and ESOC operations continue be invited to propose specific key thanks to excellent support from the full longest observations (about 8 h). its journey in the Lake of Excellence, at nominally. The data return from June 2006 to programmes in AO-5. ground segment, it proved possible to make 34.4ºS/46.2ºW. The ~2 km/s impact took the end of August 2006 was on average two sets of coordinated Mars Express-NASA place on the nearside of the Moon, in a dark 99.8%. The Cluster Active Archive is also Integral scientific results have been reported Rover/CRISM spectrometer observations Venus Express area just near the terminator at a grazing operating nominally. User access is growing in 203 refereed (of which 62 are from 2006) between the low-power/aphelion and the Rosetta angle of 5–10º. The time and location was every month and a total of 256 users were and 355 non-refereed publications. The 6th solar conjunction windows. Insufficient After the successful insertion into Venus planned to favour observations of the event registered at the end of August (more than Integral workshop was held at the Space downlink capacity was available at the time, At the end of its first period of solar orbit on 11 April, the spacecraft and its from ground-based telescopes. This was 80% increase over the last quarter). Research Institute (IKI) in Moscow with the and the data will be downlinked after the end conjunction, lasting March–May 2006, subsystems and the payload passed their achieved by a series of orbit manoeuvres theme ‘The Obscured Universe’. The of the solar conjunction on 5 November. Rosetta was configured in Passive Cruise in-orbit commissioning with flying colours. during the summer, using ingenious An article on magnetic reconnection in the workshop was attended by about 180 Mode during June and July. In this mode, the The spacecraft is functioning well and all combinations of wheel offloading and tail, where Cluster could detect a magnetic scientists from around the world. The topics The latest major Mars Express discovery was craft’s activity level is reduced and ground payload elements, with the exception of the thruster firings to reach an optimum orbit. null for the first time, was accepted by a new discussed covered nearly all the major made by the SPICAM team when they found contact is limited to once per week. Planetary Fourier Spectrometer, show The last manoeuvre was performed on journal: Nature Physics. The article was scientific areas being investigated using the highest clouds above any planetary Nevertheless, at the beginning of July it was nominal performance. During Venus Orbit 1 September. A final adjustment had to be written by a team of Chinese scientists from Integral, including the nature of the high- surface. The results are a new piece in the possible to perform, via time-tagged Insertion, VIRTIS provided spectacular views made as a reanalysis of available lunar data Peking University together with European energy cosmic background, massive black puzzle of how the Martian atmosphere works. commands autonomously executed onboard, of the south pole’s cloud structure. On performed at the University of Nottingham scientists. Magnetic nulls are expected in the holes, and nucleosynthesis and X-ray Until now, scientists had been aware only of measurements of the plasma environment 4 June commissioning concluded and the (UK) suggested that, in the absence of any centre of the reconnection when the two binaries in our own Galaxy. the clouds that hug the Martian surface and with the RPC instruments while Rosetta was nominal science mission started. further manoeuvres, impact would very likely opposite fields cancel each other before lower reaches of the atmosphere. Thanks to crossing the tail of Comet Honda. In August, Management of the mission was transferred occur one orbit earlier if SMART-1 clipped reconnecting. SPICAM, a fleeting layer of clouds was preparation for the Mars swingby of from the Scientific Projects Department to the rim of Clausius crater. discovered at an altitude of 80–100 km, most 25 February 2007 began, with more frequent the Research and Scientific Support Mars Express likely composed of carbon dioxide. tracking from ESA’s New Norcia and NASA’s Department. The impact concluded a highly successful Deep Space Network ground stations. The mission that, in addition to testing innovative Integral In early June, Mars Express celebrated A spectacular set of images covering the fourth periodic payload checkout took place at During the initial science phase the space technology, conducted a thorough 3 years in space. Most of the summer was Cydonia region, and including the famous the end of August, when the scientific instruments already demonstrated that the scientific exploration of the Moon for about a Integral operations continue smoothly, with spent preparing for, and entering, the power- ‘Face on Mars’ and its appearance following instruments were activated in sequence and objectives of the mission can be fulfilled: year and a half, gathering data on the the spacecraft, instruments and ground challenging eclipse/aphelion season. The years of geological processing, were checked out over a period of 5 days outside of preliminary temperature and composition morphology and mineralogical composition segment all performing nominally. Targets special Survival Mode was tested and released, and can be found on ground contact, and the resulting profiles of the atmosphere were derived. The of the surface in visible, IR and X-ray selected in response to the 4th successfully used to sail safely through the http://www.esa.int/marsexpress housekeeping and science telemetry data feasibility of bi-static radar observations was wavelengths.

80 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 81 BP128 11/9/06 4:39 PM Page 80

Programmes In Progress

Milky Way collapsed and exploded. The new downlinked to the ground station at the end demonstrated and the VMC imaging system observations reveal that RCW 86 was created Double Star of the test. Preliminary analysis indicates that provided the first sequences of the by a star that exploded about 2000 years all instruments and the Philae lander are in observations of the cloud movements in the ago. This age matches observations of a new The two spacecraft and their instruments are good health. atmosphere. Most spectacular so far have bright star by Chinese (and possibly Roman) operating nominally. TC-2 has started the been the observations by VIRTIS at the astronomers in 185 AD and may be the eclipse season and TC-1 follows in November. On 29 September the second large Deep different wavelengths in the 1–5 µm range. It oldest known recording of a supernova. Space Manoeuvre was executed to target the clearly showed that we can penetrate to The European Payload Operation System, trajectory for the Mars swingby. The different levels deep in the atmosphere and which coordinates the operations for the manoeuvre was extremely accurate (0.1%) even can relate the observations to distinct seven European instruments, is running and placed Rosetta on its final course surface features. Cluster smoothly. Data are acquired using the towards the Red Planet. VILSPA 2 ground station for 3.8 h/day over an Venus Express is operated from the VEX The four spacecraft and instruments are average of two passes per day. The availability Intense analysis, testing and validation Mission Operations team at ESOC with daily operating nominally and have successfully of the ground station between January and activities are under way at the Control Centre 8 h tracking passes via ESA’s deep space come through the long eclipse season, July 2006 was above 99%. in preparation of the next critical mission antenna in Cerbreros (E). Payload operations including spacecraft-1, which now has very phases: Mars and Earth swingbys in are coordinated by the VEX Science weak batteries. To counteract this, ESOC A study on pulsed magnetic reconnection was February and November 2007, respectively, Operations Centre at ESTEC. defined a new mode of operation called A perspective view of the Cydonia region of Mars based on images from the High Resolution Stereo Camera aboard Mars Express. published in Annales Geophysicae using and the first asteroid (Steins) flyby in ‘decoder only’, where the computer and all Resolution is 13.7 m/pixel; date 22 July 2006. See the ‘In Brief’ news section of this issue for further information. Double Star and Cluster data. It was shown September 2008. The payload is usually other subsystems are switched off. To warm (ESA/DLR/FU Berlin, G. Neukum) that newly reconnected flux tubes (‘flux inactive in this cruise period, with the up spacecraft-1 and recharge the batteries, transfer events’) are observed in the exception of periodic test activities and SMART-1 the instruments were switched off for all the Announcement for Observing proposals longest eclipses. With the craft being equatorial plane by Double Star and at higher occasional scientific opportunities. However, eclipses (15–23 September). The other three (AO-4) are being observed. AO-4 includes a configured for the low-power/aphelion latitude by Cluster. This showed that the payload operations are planned for The operational mission ended on satellites recorded data as usual between pilot key programme observation of the season, payload operations are suspended reconnection site was at least extended over December, when there will be many test and 3 September, at 05:42:22 UT, when the New eclipses. galactic bulge region, which attracted a great (except for radio science during solar 2 h in local time. Furthermore, Double Star calibration activities, including major Norcia ground station in Australia lost radio deal of interest. The scientific community will conjunction) for some 10 weeks. However, could detect these events during one of its onboard software updates. contact with the spacecraft. SMART-1 ended JSOC and ESOC operations continue be invited to propose specific key thanks to excellent support from the full longest observations (about 8 h). its journey in the Lake of Excellence, at nominally. The data return from June 2006 to programmes in AO-5. ground segment, it proved possible to make 34.4ºS/46.2ºW. The ~2 km/s impact took the end of August 2006 was on average two sets of coordinated Mars Express-NASA place on the nearside of the Moon, in a dark 99.8%. The Cluster Active Archive is also Integral scientific results have been reported Rover/CRISM spectrometer observations Venus Express area just near the terminator at a grazing operating nominally. User access is growing in 203 refereed (of which 62 are from 2006) between the low-power/aphelion and the Rosetta angle of 5–10º. The time and location was every month and a total of 256 users were and 355 non-refereed publications. The 6th solar conjunction windows. Insufficient After the successful insertion into Venus planned to favour observations of the event registered at the end of August (more than Integral workshop was held at the Space downlink capacity was available at the time, At the end of its first period of solar orbit on 11 April, the spacecraft and its from ground-based telescopes. This was 80% increase over the last quarter). Research Institute (IKI) in Moscow with the and the data will be downlinked after the end conjunction, lasting March–May 2006, subsystems and the payload passed their achieved by a series of orbit manoeuvres theme ‘The Obscured Universe’. The of the solar conjunction on 5 November. Rosetta was configured in Passive Cruise in-orbit commissioning with flying colours. during the summer, using ingenious An article on magnetic reconnection in the workshop was attended by about 180 Mode during June and July. In this mode, the The spacecraft is functioning well and all combinations of wheel offloading and tail, where Cluster could detect a magnetic scientists from around the world. The topics The latest major Mars Express discovery was craft’s activity level is reduced and ground payload elements, with the exception of the thruster firings to reach an optimum orbit. null for the first time, was accepted by a new discussed covered nearly all the major made by the SPICAM team when they found contact is limited to once per week. Planetary Fourier Spectrometer, show The last manoeuvre was performed on journal: Nature Physics. The article was scientific areas being investigated using the highest clouds above any planetary Nevertheless, at the beginning of July it was nominal performance. During Venus Orbit 1 September. A final adjustment had to be written by a team of Chinese scientists from Integral, including the nature of the high- surface. The results are a new piece in the possible to perform, via time-tagged Insertion, VIRTIS provided spectacular views made as a reanalysis of available lunar data Peking University together with European energy cosmic background, massive black puzzle of how the Martian atmosphere works. commands autonomously executed onboard, of the south pole’s cloud structure. On performed at the University of Nottingham scientists. Magnetic nulls are expected in the holes, and nucleosynthesis and X-ray Until now, scientists had been aware only of measurements of the plasma environment 4 June commissioning concluded and the (UK) suggested that, in the absence of any centre of the reconnection when the two binaries in our own Galaxy. the clouds that hug the Martian surface and with the RPC instruments while Rosetta was nominal science mission started. further manoeuvres, impact would very likely opposite fields cancel each other before lower reaches of the atmosphere. Thanks to crossing the tail of Comet Honda. In August, Management of the mission was transferred occur one orbit earlier if SMART-1 clipped reconnecting. SPICAM, a fleeting layer of clouds was preparation for the Mars swingby of from the Scientific Projects Department to the rim of Clausius crater. discovered at an altitude of 80–100 km, most 25 February 2007 began, with more frequent the Research and Scientific Support Mars Express likely composed of carbon dioxide. tracking from ESA’s New Norcia and NASA’s Department. The impact concluded a highly successful Deep Space Network ground stations. The mission that, in addition to testing innovative Integral In early June, Mars Express celebrated A spectacular set of images covering the fourth periodic payload checkout took place at During the initial science phase the space technology, conducted a thorough 3 years in space. Most of the summer was Cydonia region, and including the famous the end of August, when the scientific instruments already demonstrated that the scientific exploration of the Moon for about a Integral operations continue smoothly, with spent preparing for, and entering, the power- ‘Face on Mars’ and its appearance following instruments were activated in sequence and objectives of the mission can be fulfilled: year and a half, gathering data on the the spacecraft, instruments and ground challenging eclipse/aphelion season. The years of geological processing, were checked out over a period of 5 days outside of preliminary temperature and composition morphology and mineralogical composition segment all performing nominally. Targets special Survival Mode was tested and released, and can be found on ground contact, and the resulting profiles of the atmosphere were derived. The of the surface in visible, IR and X-ray selected in response to the 4th successfully used to sail safely through the http://www.esa.int/marsexpress housekeeping and science telemetry data feasibility of bi-static radar observations was wavelengths.

80 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 81 BP128 11/9/06 4:39 PM Page 82

Programmes In Progress

The Herschel cryostat in the ESTEC cleanroom during preparation Professional and amateur observers from violent mass ejection took place from the for its straylight test South Africa, the Canary Islands, South star about 10 000 years ago. This image was America, the continental USA, Hawaii and taken with the far-IR surveyor instrument at many other locations participated in the 90 µm. is due to complete its first scan campaign. The most impressive observation of the entire sky in October. was the IR impact flash seen by the Canada-France-Hawaii telescope. The Joint ESA’s contributions to the mission are Institute for Very-long Baseline working well: regular and efficient ground For the LTP, all the subsystem PDRs have Interferometry (JIVE) in Europe coordinated station coverage from Kiruna (S) and been held and some CDRs have taken place. a successful joint campaign covering five pointing reconstruction software, developed is operating successfully (JAXA) Good progress is being made despite the radio telescopes. at ESAC, which is already in routine use. The many technical challenges. The most critical ESAC team is in close contact with the Open subsystems are still the inertial sensor In addition to its mission proper, SMART-1 Time users in Europe, to maximise the enhance the scientific outcome of the vacuum enclosure, the electrostatic tested and calibrated parts of the ground overall scientific return of the pointed mission, ESA joined the Hinode team in 2005 suspension front-end electronics and the segment for the Chinese and Indian space observations programme, despite increasing in the form of a coordinated endeavour with caging mechanism. Progress has been made agencies in preparation for their Chang’e-1 operational constraints. Norway. In partnership with the Norwegian on all of these. Breadboard tests confirmed and Chandrayaan lunar missions. Space Centre in Oslo, ESA is providing the difficulty in meeting the extremely ground station coverage through the demanding performance requirements of Svalbard Satellite Station. This is the only these subsystems. Hinode (Solar-B) station in the world that can receive data for Akari (Astro-F) each of Hinode’s 15 daily orbits. As a result, and integration of the instruments and the LTP structural integrity during launch, In the meantime, tests continue on the LTP Solar-B was launched on 22 September at the data rate of Hinode and hence the telescope. The electrical and functional while ensuring the delicate thermoelastic various Engineering Models, both to confirm Akari, Japan’s IR astronomical satellite with 21:36 UT from JAXA’s Uchinoura Space scientific return of the mission will be verification testing is now concentrating on performance during the orbital measurement the basic concept of the electrostatic ESA participation, continues its sky survey Centre and renamed Hinode (‘sunrise’). It is a significantly increased, and scientists from the Planck SVM, and is overall progressing phases. suspension of the inertial sensor in the and its mapping of our cosmos. New exciting Japan-led mission with US and UK ESA’s member states will have access to the nominally. The telescope FM completed its pendulum facility at the University of Trento images recently recorded by Akari depict instrument participation and ESA and data. These will be accessible via the cryogenic testing with the videogrammetry All the subsystem and equipment has now and to measure the magnetic susceptibility of scenes from the birth and death of stars. In Norwegian ground support. It is studying the European Hinode Data Centre, which is being measurement of the displacements. been selected and the contracts kicked off the test mass. The test mass is made from a the IR camera image of the reflection nebula mechanisms that power the solar atmosphere built at the Institute of Theoretical with one only exception: the thermal special alloy (73% gold, 27% platinum by IC1396 at 9 µm and 18 µm (see photo), it is and looking for the causes of violent solar Astrophysics at the University of Oslo. On the Herschel telescope, a Tiger Team hardware is due to be procured in 2007. An mass) designed to minimise this possible to discern new generations of stars eruptions. The Sun-pointing platform carries reviewed the results of the cryo-optical important contract, awarded before the fundamental property, to make the test mass being born in the outer shells of gas and three major instrument packages: testing and confirmed readiness for summer, was the parallel development of the insensitive to the spacecraft magnetic field dust ejected by violent massive star integration with the spacecraft. two European micropropulsion technologies and its gradient. formation at the centre of the nebula. Akari’s – Solar Optical Telescope (SOT), a high- Herschel/Planck (needle indium thrusters and slit caesium superior quality and high-resolution imaging resolution (0.2 arcsec) visual imaging All Herschel and Planck instruments are in thrusters). This additional technology The Ground Segment, consisting of the allowed the clear detection of a shell-like system with a vector magnetograph and The satellite development in industry is the final stages of their acceptance testing development phase was deemed necessary Mission Operation Centre and the Science dust cloud surrounding the old star U Hydrae spectrograph; progressing well, with the completion of the and instrument FM calibration. Planck’s after a previous competitive Invitation to and Technology Operation Centre, has been at a distance of about 0.3 light years from – X-ray Telescope (XRT), for coronal flight hardware. The improvements to the instrument testing was completed and the Tender revealed that no technologies were defined and will undergo its PDR in October. the central star, implying that a short and imaging in a wide temperature range from insulation system of Herschel’s cryostat to instruments are being deliveried for ready for use in LISA Pathfinder. The suitable 1 million K to over 30 million K; recover the full lifetime performance have integration. Herschel’s instruments are close technology will be selected in the second half The launch is expected to take place at the – EUV Imaging Spectrograph (EIS), to been completed, and the cryostat is back in to the start of their final calibration phase. of 2007. end of 2009. Akari reveals stars being born in nebula IC1396 (JAXA) measure temperatures and flows in the ESTEC for another round of cryogenic solar corona. testing. These tests include cryostat lifetime The LISA Pathfinder Engineering Model proof-mass undergoing verification and verification of the cryostat magnetic susceptibility testing at the International Bureau of The satellite is in good health. It was injected internal straylight. The Flight Model (FM) of LISA Pathfinder Weights and Measures (BIPM) in Paris Microscope into an orbit well within the nominal range the Herschel Service Module (SVM) is now and then adjusted into its final Sun- fully assembled and in the final stages of its The SMART-2/LISA Pathfinder The system- and satellite-level PDR was held synchronous polar orbit. Following electrical and functional testing. During the Implementation Phase contract is on 13 February 2006 and closed on 13 April spacecraft commissioning, the three summer, the SVM successfully supported the progressing well. The main system activity 2006 by the CNES Steering Committee. The scientific instruments will be turned on by first System Validation Test (SVT), when the during the reporting period was the approval to proceed with Phase-C/D was not the end of October. First observations are spacecraft was controlled by the mission consolidation of the spacecraft design and given owing to delays in the development of planned for November. control centre, at ESOC. the redefinition of the LISA Technology critical technologies: the field-emission Package (LTP) Central Assembly electric propulsion (FEEP) and T-SAGE Like its predecessor , Hinode started The Planck spacecraft FM was returned to accommodation inside the spacecraft. This inertial sensor. Since the Microscope FEEP out as a Japan/US/UK mission. In order to Alcatel (Cannes, F) for final electrical testing activity was required in order to guarantee development at ESA is closely linked to that

82 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 83 BP128 11/9/06 4:39 PM Page 82

Programmes In Progress

The Herschel cryostat in the ESTEC cleanroom during preparation Professional and amateur observers from violent mass ejection took place from the for its straylight test South Africa, the Canary Islands, South star about 10 000 years ago. This image was America, the continental USA, Hawaii and taken with the far-IR surveyor instrument at many other locations participated in the 90 µm. Akari is due to complete its first scan campaign. The most impressive observation of the entire sky in October. was the IR impact flash seen by the Canada-France-Hawaii telescope. The Joint ESA’s contributions to the mission are Institute for Very-long Baseline working well: regular and efficient ground For the LTP, all the subsystem PDRs have Interferometry (JIVE) in Europe coordinated station coverage from Kiruna (S) and been held and some CDRs have taken place. a successful joint campaign covering five pointing reconstruction software, developed Hinode is operating successfully (JAXA) Good progress is being made despite the radio telescopes. at ESAC, which is already in routine use. The many technical challenges. The most critical ESAC team is in close contact with the Open subsystems are still the inertial sensor In addition to its mission proper, SMART-1 Time users in Europe, to maximise the enhance the scientific outcome of the vacuum enclosure, the electrostatic tested and calibrated parts of the ground overall scientific return of the pointed mission, ESA joined the Hinode team in 2005 suspension front-end electronics and the segment for the Chinese and Indian space observations programme, despite increasing in the form of a coordinated endeavour with caging mechanism. Progress has been made agencies in preparation for their Chang’e-1 operational constraints. Norway. In partnership with the Norwegian on all of these. Breadboard tests confirmed and Chandrayaan lunar missions. Space Centre in Oslo, ESA is providing the difficulty in meeting the extremely ground station coverage through the demanding performance requirements of Svalbard Satellite Station. This is the only these subsystems. Hinode (Solar-B) station in the world that can receive data for Akari (Astro-F) each of Hinode’s 15 daily orbits. As a result, and integration of the instruments and the LTP structural integrity during launch, In the meantime, tests continue on the LTP Solar-B was launched on 22 September at the data rate of Hinode and hence the telescope. The electrical and functional while ensuring the delicate thermoelastic various Engineering Models, both to confirm Akari, Japan’s IR astronomical satellite with 21:36 UT from JAXA’s Uchinoura Space scientific return of the mission will be verification testing is now concentrating on performance during the orbital measurement the basic concept of the electrostatic ESA participation, continues its sky survey Centre and renamed Hinode (‘sunrise’). It is a significantly increased, and scientists from the Planck SVM, and is overall progressing phases. suspension of the inertial sensor in the and its mapping of our cosmos. New exciting Japan-led mission with US and UK ESA’s member states will have access to the nominally. The telescope FM completed its pendulum facility at the University of Trento images recently recorded by Akari depict instrument participation and ESA and data. These will be accessible via the cryogenic testing with the videogrammetry All the subsystem and equipment has now and to measure the magnetic susceptibility of scenes from the birth and death of stars. In Norwegian ground support. It is studying the European Hinode Data Centre, which is being measurement of the displacements. been selected and the contracts kicked off the test mass. The test mass is made from a the IR camera image of the reflection nebula mechanisms that power the solar atmosphere built at the Institute of Theoretical with one only exception: the thermal special alloy (73% gold, 27% platinum by IC1396 at 9 µm and 18 µm (see photo), it is and looking for the causes of violent solar Astrophysics at the University of Oslo. On the Herschel telescope, a Tiger Team hardware is due to be procured in 2007. An mass) designed to minimise this possible to discern new generations of stars eruptions. The Sun-pointing platform carries reviewed the results of the cryo-optical important contract, awarded before the fundamental property, to make the test mass being born in the outer shells of gas and three major instrument packages: testing and confirmed readiness for summer, was the parallel development of the insensitive to the spacecraft magnetic field dust ejected by violent massive star integration with the spacecraft. two European micropropulsion technologies and its gradient. formation at the centre of the nebula. Akari’s – Solar Optical Telescope (SOT), a high- Herschel/Planck (needle indium thrusters and slit caesium superior quality and high-resolution imaging resolution (0.2 arcsec) visual imaging All Herschel and Planck instruments are in thrusters). This additional technology The Ground Segment, consisting of the allowed the clear detection of a shell-like system with a vector magnetograph and The satellite development in industry is the final stages of their acceptance testing development phase was deemed necessary Mission Operation Centre and the Science dust cloud surrounding the old star U Hydrae spectrograph; progressing well, with the completion of the and instrument FM calibration. Planck’s after a previous competitive Invitation to and Technology Operation Centre, has been at a distance of about 0.3 light years from – X-ray Telescope (XRT), for coronal flight hardware. The improvements to the instrument testing was completed and the Tender revealed that no technologies were defined and will undergo its PDR in October. the central star, implying that a short and imaging in a wide temperature range from insulation system of Herschel’s cryostat to instruments are being deliveried for ready for use in LISA Pathfinder. The suitable 1 million K to over 30 million K; recover the full lifetime performance have integration. Herschel’s instruments are close technology will be selected in the second half The launch is expected to take place at the – EUV Imaging Spectrograph (EIS), to been completed, and the cryostat is back in to the start of their final calibration phase. of 2007. end of 2009. Akari reveals stars being born in nebula IC1396 (JAXA) measure temperatures and flows in the ESTEC for another round of cryogenic solar corona. testing. These tests include cryostat lifetime The LISA Pathfinder Engineering Model proof-mass undergoing verification and verification of the cryostat magnetic susceptibility testing at the International Bureau of The satellite is in good health. It was injected internal straylight. The Flight Model (FM) of LISA Pathfinder Weights and Measures (BIPM) in Paris Microscope into an orbit well within the nominal range the Herschel Service Module (SVM) is now and then adjusted into its final Sun- fully assembled and in the final stages of its The SMART-2/LISA Pathfinder The system- and satellite-level PDR was held synchronous polar orbit. Following electrical and functional testing. During the Implementation Phase contract is on 13 February 2006 and closed on 13 April spacecraft commissioning, the three summer, the SVM successfully supported the progressing well. The main system activity 2006 by the CNES Steering Committee. The scientific instruments will be turned on by first System Validation Test (SVT), when the during the reporting period was the approval to proceed with Phase-C/D was not the end of October. First observations are spacecraft was controlled by the mission consolidation of the spacecraft design and given owing to delays in the development of planned for November. control centre, at ESOC. the redefinition of the LISA Technology critical technologies: the field-emission Package (LTP) Central Assembly electric propulsion (FEEP) and T-SAGE Like its predecessor Yohkoh, Hinode started The Planck spacecraft FM was returned to accommodation inside the spacecraft. This inertial sensor. Since the Microscope FEEP out as a Japan/US/UK mission. In order to Alcatel (Cannes, F) for final electrical testing activity was required in order to guarantee development at ESA is closely linked to that

82 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 83 BP128 11/9/06 4:39 PM Page 84

Programmes In Progress

on LISA Pathfinder, CNES decided to been implemented to deal respectively with last two procurements being finalised. The NASA is currently initiating an NRC review to postpone the Phase-C/D until the end of the the specifics of the overall science data flow NIRSpec subsystems CDR campaign is BepiColombo decide on the prioritisation of the Beyond development/qualification phase of the LISA and the radiation characterisation of the starting. Einstein programme elements (LISA, Con-X Pathfinder FEEP, planned for September 2007. CCDs. The BepiColombo mission scenario foresees and the JDEM probes). The target date for Problems were encountered during the a Soyuz-Fregat launch in August 2013 and the final decision is October 2007. The LISA In the period March–June 2006, CNES studied The Gaia Science Team met at regular environmental and operational lifetime arrival at Mercury in August 2019 for a project is well under way in updating the alternative propulsion solutions to the slit intervals to be briefed about the progress of testing of the NASA-provided Micro Shutter nominal 1-year scientific mission. documents that are expected to be required. FEEP. Two backup solutions were analysed: the project, to provide advice as required and Array flight-like devices. During the In parallel, NASA is supporting the mission the needle FEEP being studied within the LISA to discuss scientific matters. random vibration test, shutters remained Proposals from Alcatel Alenia Space and formulation activity. Regular Quarterly Pathfinder parallel FEEP Phase-1 and the stuck in the closed position and wire Astrium were received on 17 May 2006 in Progress Meetings and Technical Interchange micronewton proportional cold-gas thruster bonds and flex mounts broke. However, response to the Invitation to Tender for the Meetings are held to exchange information (based on the technology development for stiction problems remain the biggest Implementation Phase. The Tender and results and jointly to consolidate the Gaia). CNES presented the results of the JWST concern. Evaluation Board, supported by a large team mission design. analysis to their Board on 28 June, which of specialists, performed a detailed The BepiColombo composite: the Mercury Transfer Module recommended focusing on the nominal slit NASA has reached a Technology Readiness The MIRI subsystem CDR campaign was evaluation of the proposals and attached to the MPO and MMO spacecraft FEEP solution and monitoring with ESA Level (TRL) 6 for five out of ten JWST critical concluded before the summer break. The recommended selection of the Astrium support the development of the backup technologies: the Sunshield membrane; the action plan to close all open issues is proposal. Both contenders were informed of GOCE solutions. Primary Mirror Segment Assembly; the consistent with the preparation of the MIRI this result on 6 July. Subsequent Orbiter is awaiting JAXA approval, after which Sidecar ASIC; and the Near-IR and Mid-IR optical system CDR, scheduled to kick-off in negotiations took place to integrate Alcatel it will be submitted to the SPC. Substantial progress has been made with the Phase-B for the T-SAGE accelerometer Focal Plane Assemblies. The last three December. Alenia Space within the core team. The gradiometer instrument over the past few development at ONERA was closed in May, elements are part of the NIRSpec and MIRI contract proposal will be submitted to the The technology demonstration work for months. Three Accelerometer Sensor Head though a delta-Phase-B is required in order to instruments. Following recent problems in Parts and subassemblies for the instrument Industrial Policy Committee at the end of gridded ion thrusters is continuing on the (ASH) Flight Models (FMs) have been implement the recommendations of the PDR vibro-acoustic tests, the NASA-provided Verification Model are being manufactured January 2007. The cost-at-completion will Astrium RIT thruster and the QinetiQ T6 assembled and tested at ONERA. Five ASHs to solve the outstanding issues before NIRSpec Micro Shutter Array will be the last and tested. The MIRI Contamination Control be submitted to the Scientific Programme engine; almost 5000 h of thrust time has been have therefore been completed to date; a starting Phase-C. item to reach TRL-6, in December 2006. Cover was delivered after successful Committee (SPC) for approval in February achieved. sixth is being assembled and is expected to vibration and cryogenic testing. 2007. enter acceptance testing before the end of NASA-provided software platforms and EGSE October. Alcatel Alenia Space has integrated were delivered to the MIRI and NIRSpec Finalisation of the ‘Definition Phase of the The third Science Working Team meeting the three Front-End Electronic Unit FMs, the Gaia instrument developers. European personnel JWST Launch Services’ contract is under was held in Padova (I) 26–28 September. LISA Thermal Control Electronic Unit Proto-Flight also received the training to operate this way. This definition phase will cover activities The instrument design and prototyping is Model (PFM) and the Gradiometer In early July, Gaia passed the System equipment. from now until 3 years before launch, and is proceeding according to plan, but the The Mission Formulation activity with Astrium Accelerometer Interface Electronic Unit PFM Requirements Review, the first major meant to assist NASA and the JWST Prime immediate allocation of funds is of concern GmbH is in its Phase-2 and is proceeding and nearly completed the final functional milestone in the life cycle of a project. The The build-up of the NIRSpec industrial Contractor during the development of the to some Principal Investigators. The project well. Following consolidation of the mission testing. Moreover, the upgrade of the board members declared that it had met all consortium is reaching completion, with the mission. places particular emphasis on model baseline architecture design, some trade-offs Structural Thermal Model of the Gradiometer the objectives; this was very important philosophy, verification and procurement of alternative configurations were performed. Core, which will be used during the satellite because it forms the basis for the start of the schedule for the present work with the These deal with alternative payload concepts, FM test campaign, has also been completed. detailed design activities. JWST: the spacecraft's 6.5 m- Experimenter teams until detailed interface including off-axis telescope, in-field-of-view diameter primary mirror and accommodation work can be started pointing and single proof-mass configuration. On the platform side, there was a severe The competitive selection of subcontractors consists of 18 semi-rigid with the Prime Contractor. The financial setback on 19 July when an anomaly in the hexagonal segments continues according to the rules of the commitment from the Lead Funding The possibility of stable maintenance of the Electrical Ground Support Equipment (EGSE) Agency. At the time of writing, more than a Agencies to support the payload on the triangular constellation, thus removing the triggered a chain of events that ultimately led third of the nearly 80 procurements have been Mercury Planetary Orbiter is being obtained breathing angle, was analysed. The conclusion to an over-voltage on the platform PFM, successfully completed. The progress of this in accordance with the Science Management is that this option cannot be considered any causing the failure of one power converter of activity is critical for the overall schedule Plan. The proposed text of the Multi-Lateral further for two main reasons: the required the Command and Data Monitoring Unit stability of Gaia. The major risks, such as Agreement between ESA and the Lead thrust authority would be far above the FEEP (CDMU) PFM and stress on many electronic flight CCD production, mirror polishing and Funding Agencies has been informally capabilities, and the noise induced by this components of the Power Conditioning and the detailed design work on the payload discussed between all parties and is now active/permanent thrust would severely Distribution Unit (PCDU) PFM. Both units module, are all well in hand and progressing being distributed for final approval. Likewise, degrade the measurement sensitivity of the were demounted and returned to their satisfactorily. No impact on the overall a bilateral agreement between ESA and LISA system. manufacturers for further investigation and schedule for a launch at the end of 2011 has Roskosmos was drafted for the Mercury recovery. The EGSE unit was also returned been identified. Gamma-ray and Neutron Spectrometer. Technology Development Activities Invitations for correction. As a consequence, the to Tender will be released shortly to cover functional testing of the platform PFM had to In agreement with the Gaia Science Team, a The joint Memorandum of Understanding optical mechanisms, optical bench and be stopped, while the closed-loop functional number of dedicated working groups have with JAXA for the Mercury Magnetospheric telescope characterisation. testing of the Drag Free Attitude Control

84 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 85 BP128 11/9/06 4:39 PM Page 84

Programmes In Progress

on LISA Pathfinder, CNES decided to been implemented to deal respectively with last two procurements being finalised. The NASA is currently initiating an NRC review to postpone the Phase-C/D until the end of the the specifics of the overall science data flow NIRSpec subsystems CDR campaign is BepiColombo decide on the prioritisation of the Beyond development/qualification phase of the LISA and the radiation characterisation of the starting. Einstein programme elements (LISA, Con-X Pathfinder FEEP, planned for September 2007. CCDs. The BepiColombo mission scenario foresees and the JDEM probes). The target date for Problems were encountered during the a Soyuz-Fregat launch in August 2013 and the final decision is October 2007. The LISA In the period March–June 2006, CNES studied The Gaia Science Team met at regular environmental and operational lifetime arrival at Mercury in August 2019 for a project is well under way in updating the alternative propulsion solutions to the slit intervals to be briefed about the progress of testing of the NASA-provided Micro Shutter nominal 1-year scientific mission. documents that are expected to be required. FEEP. Two backup solutions were analysed: the project, to provide advice as required and Array flight-like devices. During the In parallel, NASA is supporting the mission the needle FEEP being studied within the LISA to discuss scientific matters. random vibration test, shutters remained Proposals from Alcatel Alenia Space and formulation activity. Regular Quarterly Pathfinder parallel FEEP Phase-1 and the stuck in the closed position and wire Astrium were received on 17 May 2006 in Progress Meetings and Technical Interchange micronewton proportional cold-gas thruster bonds and flex mounts broke. However, response to the Invitation to Tender for the Meetings are held to exchange information (based on the technology development for stiction problems remain the biggest Implementation Phase. The Tender and results and jointly to consolidate the Gaia). CNES presented the results of the JWST concern. Evaluation Board, supported by a large team mission design. analysis to their Board on 28 June, which of specialists, performed a detailed The BepiColombo composite: the Mercury Transfer Module recommended focusing on the nominal slit NASA has reached a Technology Readiness The MIRI subsystem CDR campaign was evaluation of the proposals and attached to the MPO and MMO spacecraft FEEP solution and monitoring with ESA Level (TRL) 6 for five out of ten JWST critical concluded before the summer break. The recommended selection of the Astrium support the development of the backup technologies: the Sunshield membrane; the action plan to close all open issues is proposal. Both contenders were informed of GOCE solutions. Primary Mirror Segment Assembly; the consistent with the preparation of the MIRI this result on 6 July. Subsequent Orbiter is awaiting JAXA approval, after which Sidecar ASIC; and the Near-IR and Mid-IR optical system CDR, scheduled to kick-off in negotiations took place to integrate Alcatel it will be submitted to the SPC. Substantial progress has been made with the Phase-B for the T-SAGE accelerometer Focal Plane Assemblies. The last three December. Alenia Space within the core team. The gradiometer instrument over the past few development at ONERA was closed in May, elements are part of the NIRSpec and MIRI contract proposal will be submitted to the The technology demonstration work for months. Three Accelerometer Sensor Head though a delta-Phase-B is required in order to instruments. Following recent problems in Parts and subassemblies for the instrument Industrial Policy Committee at the end of gridded ion thrusters is continuing on the (ASH) Flight Models (FMs) have been implement the recommendations of the PDR vibro-acoustic tests, the NASA-provided Verification Model are being manufactured January 2007. The cost-at-completion will Astrium RIT thruster and the QinetiQ T6 assembled and tested at ONERA. Five ASHs to solve the outstanding issues before NIRSpec Micro Shutter Array will be the last and tested. The MIRI Contamination Control be submitted to the Scientific Programme engine; almost 5000 h of thrust time has been have therefore been completed to date; a starting Phase-C. item to reach TRL-6, in December 2006. Cover was delivered after successful Committee (SPC) for approval in February achieved. sixth is being assembled and is expected to vibration and cryogenic testing. 2007. enter acceptance testing before the end of NASA-provided software platforms and EGSE October. Alcatel Alenia Space has integrated were delivered to the MIRI and NIRSpec Finalisation of the ‘Definition Phase of the The third Science Working Team meeting the three Front-End Electronic Unit FMs, the Gaia instrument developers. European personnel JWST Launch Services’ contract is under was held in Padova (I) 26–28 September. LISA Thermal Control Electronic Unit Proto-Flight also received the training to operate this way. This definition phase will cover activities The instrument design and prototyping is Model (PFM) and the Gradiometer In early July, Gaia passed the System equipment. from now until 3 years before launch, and is proceeding according to plan, but the The Mission Formulation activity with Astrium Accelerometer Interface Electronic Unit PFM Requirements Review, the first major meant to assist NASA and the JWST Prime immediate allocation of funds is of concern GmbH is in its Phase-2 and is proceeding and nearly completed the final functional milestone in the life cycle of a project. The The build-up of the NIRSpec industrial Contractor during the development of the to some Principal Investigators. The project well. Following consolidation of the mission testing. Moreover, the upgrade of the board members declared that it had met all consortium is reaching completion, with the mission. places particular emphasis on model baseline architecture design, some trade-offs Structural Thermal Model of the Gradiometer the objectives; this was very important philosophy, verification and procurement of alternative configurations were performed. Core, which will be used during the satellite because it forms the basis for the start of the schedule for the present work with the These deal with alternative payload concepts, FM test campaign, has also been completed. detailed design activities. JWST: the spacecraft's 6.5 m- Experimenter teams until detailed interface including off-axis telescope, in-field-of-view diameter primary mirror and accommodation work can be started pointing and single proof-mass configuration. On the platform side, there was a severe The competitive selection of subcontractors consists of 18 semi-rigid with the Prime Contractor. The financial setback on 19 July when an anomaly in the hexagonal segments continues according to the rules of the commitment from the Lead Funding The possibility of stable maintenance of the Electrical Ground Support Equipment (EGSE) Agency. At the time of writing, more than a Agencies to support the payload on the triangular constellation, thus removing the triggered a chain of events that ultimately led third of the nearly 80 procurements have been Mercury Planetary Orbiter is being obtained breathing angle, was analysed. The conclusion to an over-voltage on the platform PFM, successfully completed. The progress of this in accordance with the Science Management is that this option cannot be considered any causing the failure of one power converter of activity is critical for the overall schedule Plan. The proposed text of the Multi-Lateral further for two main reasons: the required the Command and Data Monitoring Unit stability of Gaia. The major risks, such as Agreement between ESA and the Lead thrust authority would be far above the FEEP (CDMU) PFM and stress on many electronic flight CCD production, mirror polishing and Funding Agencies has been informally capabilities, and the noise induced by this components of the Power Conditioning and the detailed design work on the payload discussed between all parties and is now active/permanent thrust would severely Distribution Unit (PCDU) PFM. Both units module, are all well in hand and progressing being distributed for final approval. Likewise, degrade the measurement sensitivity of the were demounted and returned to their satisfactorily. No impact on the overall a bilateral agreement between ESA and LISA system. manufacturers for further investigation and schedule for a launch at the end of 2011 has Roskosmos was drafted for the Mercury recovery. The EGSE unit was also returned been identified. Gamma-ray and Neutron Spectrometer. Technology Development Activities Invitations for correction. As a consequence, the to Tender will be released shortly to cover functional testing of the platform PFM had to In agreement with the Gaia Science Team, a The joint Memorandum of Understanding optical mechanisms, optical bench and be stopped, while the closed-loop functional number of dedicated working groups have with JAXA for the Mercury Magnetospheric telescope characterisation. testing of the Drag Free Attitude Control

84 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 85 BP128 11/9/06 4:39 PM Page 86

Programmes In Progress

System on the platform Engineering Model limited redesign has been necessary to further activities will be undertaken until interfaces were reviewed in the Preliminary Launch of the satellite remains scheduled for Test Bench continue. In order to minimise absorb the impact of the redundant SIRAL 2007. The launch is scheduled for March Mission Analysis Meeting involving ESA, September 2008. impact on the overall schedule, it was decided and to eliminate minor weaknesses found 2009. CNES, Alcatel, Eurockot and Khrunichev. to use the time to recover the CDMU and during the original CryoSat development. In PCDU PFMs to pack and ship the platform three cases the manufacturer is developing a For the overall SMOS ground segment, the PFM and associated EGSE to the satellite new equipment design to replace PDR has been completed. While the elements Swarm prime contractor. Platform PFM transportation obsolescent equipment used in the original SMOS of the flight operations ground segment, took place during the last week of September. CryoSat. Consequently a series of delta- both on the CNES and the ESA side, were Phase-B of the satellite activities with EADS It was agreed that industry will continue to CDRs at equipment level have been held, Delivery of subsystem units for the payload found to be in an adequate development Astrium GmbH is progressing. The Satellite work double shifts until completion of the leading up to the system-level delta-CDR protoflight model continues. All LICEF state, the payload data ground segment, System Requirement Review is completed. assembly, integration and test programme. starting in November 2006. The major lower- receivers have been delivered, and are being including the data processors for level-1 and Feasibility and preliminary mission analysis level delta-CDR for SIRAL was completed in used to populate the arm segments of the -2 data products, were judged to be studies have been initiated with Arianespace, Final acceptance testing of the first of two July. structural model to undergo the ‘on farm’ schedule-critical. Backup solutions were Kosmotras and Eurockot. Launch of MetOp-A from Baikonur Cosmodrome on 19 October identical Ion Thruster Assemblies (ITA FM1) antenna pattern characterisation at the suggested by the Board for investigation and aboard a Soyuz-2/Fregat was successfully completed in September. ITA A 3-month delay in the star tracker delivery Technical University of Denmark. All three eventual implementation by the project. Procurement activities for the satellite units FM2 testing then began and will be followed was announced, which appears to be a arm measurements have been completed; and instruments are well advanced, with Reactivation of the campaign meant that by the integration of ITA FM1 and FM2 on a knock-on effect from damage incurred during still to be measured is the central hub The building refurbishment and preparations subcontractor bids for critical elements of some essential and time-consuming activities panel where the xenon gas feed system and testing of a star tracker in another structure with one adjacent segment of each for the X-band receive antenna are the programme already in the negotiation had to be repeated. These were mainly solar the two Ion Propulsion Control Units have programme. Since the same design is used arm. Once all the antenna characterisation is progressing nominally for installing the ESA- phase and close to kick-off. Other offers are array preparation, instrument cleaning and, already been integrated. Functional tests are in several ESA programmes, the possibility of completed, the LICEF receivers will be part of the ground segment at ESAC (E). in preparation. finally, a satellite functional test. expected to take place throughout October optimising the production sequence and transferred to the FM arm segments that are and November, before final delivery of the full schedule to reduce the delay for CryoSat, under integration with electrical, radio- Phase-B of the Electrical Field Instrument is MetOp was remated with its Fregat upper Ion Propulsion Assembly PFM in December. without introducing delay to the other frequency and optical harness, thermal progressing. Breadboard activities of the stage and reencapsulated to form the ‘Upper programmes, is being investigated. control hardware, and other subsystems ADM-Aeolus critical elements are near completion. Composite’. Unfortunately, during the transfer The Factory Acceptance Test of Version 1 of such as the noise sources of the calibration of the Upper Composite from the integration the ground segment’s Calibration and The process of approving all electronic parts subsystem. The FM platform with tanks, pipework and The Absolute Scalar magnetometer Phase-B facilities to the transport train, a handling Monitoring Facility & Reference Planning has been almost completed during this harness installed was shipped to Astrium is underway with LETI, Grenoble (F), under error caused a mechanical shock. This Facility was completed in July. The pre- reporting period. Platform integration of the recurrent Proteus Friedrichshafen (D) for integration of the the leadership of CNES. The breadboard necessitated an investigation to check the acceptance review of Version 2 of the Level 1 platform has progressed significantly at the flight electronics units. Tests on the flight activities of the instrument are near integrity of the flight hardware, including to Level 2 High Level Processing Facility of Close-out work on the various components Alcatel Alenia Space facilities (Cannes, F). It software using the onboard computer and completion. The manufacturing of the mechanical analysis of the loads induced on the European GOCE Gravity Consortium was of the Payload Data Ground Segment has is interrupted owing to the resumption of the the first platform electronics units are Engineering Model has started. The PDR is the spacecraft and a detailed visual inspection held in July. Development of the Flight finished and the facilities hibernated. No Calypso launch campaign. Rockot launcher showing satisfactory results. The silicon planned for mid-December. that required MetOp’s return to the cleanroom Operations Segment and the Payload Data carbide FM telescope integration is complete and removal from the fairing. The inspection Segment continue according to plan, and and its performance is excellent. All revealed no damage to the satellite, and entry into the Ground Segment Overall Flight Model of the electronic units of the flight instrument complementary analyses from the launcher Validation phase is expected soon. ADM-Aeolus telescope except the laser have been bench-tested MetOp authorities (TsKB, NPO-L and EADS-Casa)) together; their performance is excellent. and the spacecraft industry (Astrium) The planned launch date for MetOp-A of demonstrated that the allowable specifications There have been further thermo-mechanical 17 July could not be kept. After three for MetOp loads were not exceeded. CryoSat-2 problems with the laser. As a result, the consecutive launch attempts, all halted by the thermal-vacuum test of the Qualification Soyuz ground control system through a These additional activities meant that the The Contract for the Phase-C/D/E1 Model will now start in November. variety of relatively minor operational launch date had to be delayed, to 17 October. development of the CryoSat-2 satellite was problems, the launcher’s maximum period Final preparations, formal rehearsals and signed with Astrium GmbH on 26 July 2006. A workshop for potential users was held at allowable in a fuelled condition was exceeded simulations for both the launch and early orbit Almost all of the subcontractor contracts have ESTEC at the end of September. All users and it had to be returned to the manufacturer phase, satellite in-orbit verification and also been negotiated and kicked off. expected a significant impact from the (TskB in Samara) for refurbishment. The routine operations phases of the MetOp Manufacturing is in progress and many items satellite on Numerical Weather Prediction. satellite was returned to the integration mission were completed. Both ESOC and of the flight structure, including composite There will be many other benefits in facilities for storage. Eumetsat Ground Systems are ready for the panels and machined elements, are ready for climatology. There was widespread support satellite launch. The 17 October launch integration. for follow-on missions to avoid a data gap Starsem and its industrial partners analysed attempt was halted by another Soyuz ground before the first post-MetOp satellite. This the causes of the launch interrupts and control system problem and the 18 October Most equipment has seen some design included some suggestions for cooperation identified technical solutions that allowed the attempt was thwarted by high-altitude , evolution (owing to obsolescence of electronic with the US, where there is at present no launch campaign to restart on 30 August but MetOp successfully reached orbit on parts, for example) while in a few cases comparable mission. consistent with a launch on 7 October. 19 October.

86 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 87 BP128 11/9/06 4:39 PM Page 86

Programmes In Progress

System on the platform Engineering Model limited redesign has been necessary to further activities will be undertaken until interfaces were reviewed in the Preliminary Launch of the satellite remains scheduled for Test Bench continue. In order to minimise absorb the impact of the redundant SIRAL 2007. The launch is scheduled for March Mission Analysis Meeting involving ESA, September 2008. impact on the overall schedule, it was decided and to eliminate minor weaknesses found 2009. CNES, Alcatel, Eurockot and Khrunichev. to use the time to recover the CDMU and during the original CryoSat development. In PCDU PFMs to pack and ship the platform three cases the manufacturer is developing a For the overall SMOS ground segment, the PFM and associated EGSE to the satellite new equipment design to replace PDR has been completed. While the elements Swarm prime contractor. Platform PFM transportation obsolescent equipment used in the original SMOS of the flight operations ground segment, took place during the last week of September. CryoSat. Consequently a series of delta- both on the CNES and the ESA side, were Phase-B of the satellite activities with EADS It was agreed that industry will continue to CDRs at equipment level have been held, Delivery of subsystem units for the payload found to be in an adequate development Astrium GmbH is progressing. The Satellite work double shifts until completion of the leading up to the system-level delta-CDR protoflight model continues. All LICEF state, the payload data ground segment, System Requirement Review is completed. assembly, integration and test programme. starting in November 2006. The major lower- receivers have been delivered, and are being including the data processors for level-1 and Feasibility and preliminary mission analysis level delta-CDR for SIRAL was completed in used to populate the arm segments of the -2 data products, were judged to be studies have been initiated with Arianespace, Final acceptance testing of the first of two July. structural model to undergo the ‘on farm’ schedule-critical. Backup solutions were Kosmotras and Eurockot. Launch of MetOp-A from Baikonur Cosmodrome on 19 October identical Ion Thruster Assemblies (ITA FM1) antenna pattern characterisation at the suggested by the Board for investigation and aboard a Soyuz-2/Fregat was successfully completed in September. ITA A 3-month delay in the star tracker delivery Technical University of Denmark. All three eventual implementation by the project. Procurement activities for the satellite units FM2 testing then began and will be followed was announced, which appears to be a arm measurements have been completed; and instruments are well advanced, with Reactivation of the campaign meant that by the integration of ITA FM1 and FM2 on a knock-on effect from damage incurred during still to be measured is the central hub The building refurbishment and preparations subcontractor bids for critical elements of some essential and time-consuming activities panel where the xenon gas feed system and testing of a star tracker in another structure with one adjacent segment of each for the X-band receive antenna are the programme already in the negotiation had to be repeated. These were mainly solar the two Ion Propulsion Control Units have programme. Since the same design is used arm. Once all the antenna characterisation is progressing nominally for installing the ESA- phase and close to kick-off. Other offers are array preparation, instrument cleaning and, already been integrated. Functional tests are in several ESA programmes, the possibility of completed, the LICEF receivers will be part of the ground segment at ESAC (E). in preparation. finally, a satellite functional test. expected to take place throughout October optimising the production sequence and transferred to the FM arm segments that are and November, before final delivery of the full schedule to reduce the delay for CryoSat, under integration with electrical, radio- Phase-B of the Electrical Field Instrument is MetOp was remated with its Fregat upper Ion Propulsion Assembly PFM in December. without introducing delay to the other frequency and optical harness, thermal progressing. Breadboard activities of the stage and reencapsulated to form the ‘Upper programmes, is being investigated. control hardware, and other subsystems ADM-Aeolus critical elements are near completion. Composite’. Unfortunately, during the transfer The Factory Acceptance Test of Version 1 of such as the noise sources of the calibration of the Upper Composite from the integration the ground segment’s Calibration and The process of approving all electronic parts subsystem. The FM platform with tanks, pipework and The Absolute Scalar magnetometer Phase-B facilities to the transport train, a handling Monitoring Facility & Reference Planning has been almost completed during this harness installed was shipped to Astrium is underway with LETI, Grenoble (F), under error caused a mechanical shock. This Facility was completed in July. The pre- reporting period. Platform integration of the recurrent Proteus Friedrichshafen (D) for integration of the the leadership of CNES. The breadboard necessitated an investigation to check the acceptance review of Version 2 of the Level 1 platform has progressed significantly at the flight electronics units. Tests on the flight activities of the instrument are near integrity of the flight hardware, including to Level 2 High Level Processing Facility of Close-out work on the various components Alcatel Alenia Space facilities (Cannes, F). It software using the onboard computer and completion. The manufacturing of the mechanical analysis of the loads induced on the European GOCE Gravity Consortium was of the Payload Data Ground Segment has is interrupted owing to the resumption of the the first platform electronics units are Engineering Model has started. The PDR is the spacecraft and a detailed visual inspection held in July. Development of the Flight finished and the facilities hibernated. No Calypso launch campaign. Rockot launcher showing satisfactory results. The silicon planned for mid-December. that required MetOp’s return to the cleanroom Operations Segment and the Payload Data carbide FM telescope integration is complete and removal from the fairing. The inspection Segment continue according to plan, and and its performance is excellent. All revealed no damage to the satellite, and entry into the Ground Segment Overall Flight Model of the electronic units of the flight instrument complementary analyses from the launcher Validation phase is expected soon. ADM-Aeolus telescope except the laser have been bench-tested MetOp authorities (TsKB, NPO-L and EADS-Casa)) together; their performance is excellent. and the spacecraft industry (Astrium) The planned launch date for MetOp-A of demonstrated that the allowable specifications There have been further thermo-mechanical 17 July could not be kept. After three for MetOp loads were not exceeded. CryoSat-2 problems with the laser. As a result, the consecutive launch attempts, all halted by the thermal-vacuum test of the Qualification Soyuz ground control system through a These additional activities meant that the The Contract for the Phase-C/D/E1 Model will now start in November. variety of relatively minor operational launch date had to be delayed, to 17 October. development of the CryoSat-2 satellite was problems, the launcher’s maximum period Final preparations, formal rehearsals and signed with Astrium GmbH on 26 July 2006. A workshop for potential users was held at allowable in a fuelled condition was exceeded simulations for both the launch and early orbit Almost all of the subcontractor contracts have ESTEC at the end of September. All users and it had to be returned to the manufacturer phase, satellite in-orbit verification and also been negotiated and kicked off. expected a significant impact from the (TskB in Samara) for refurbishment. The routine operations phases of the MetOp Manufacturing is in progress and many items satellite on Numerical Weather Prediction. satellite was returned to the integration mission were completed. Both ESOC and of the flight structure, including composite There will be many other benefits in facilities for storage. Eumetsat Ground Systems are ready for the panels and machined elements, are ready for climatology. There was widespread support satellite launch. The 17 October launch integration. for follow-on missions to avoid a data gap Starsem and its industrial partners analysed attempt was halted by another Soyuz ground before the first post-MetOp satellite. This the causes of the launch interrupts and control system problem and the 18 October Most equipment has seen some design included some suggestions for cooperation identified technical solutions that allowed the attempt was thwarted by high-altitude winds, evolution (owing to obsolescence of electronic with the US, where there is at present no launch campaign to restart on 30 August but MetOp successfully reached orbit on parts, for example) while in a few cases comparable mission. consistent with a launch on 7 October. 19 October.

86 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 87 Programmes

MSG

Meteosat-8/MSG-1 A reset of the Central Data Management Unit (CDMU) resulted in the satellite entering safe mode on 23 September 2006. Although the exact cause is not yet known, it is likely to be a single event upset, as similar situations have been observed on the Spacebus 3000 CDMUs. After nominal reconfiguration, the satellite became the operational satellite again on 10 October 2006. Satellite condition is nominal and the instrument performance remains of excellent quality.

Meteosat-9/MSG-2 After successful commissioning, MSG-2 became the hot standby for Meteosat-8. With Thomas Reiter working in the Destiny laboratory, 10 September Meteosat-8 entering safe mode on 23 September, MSG-2 automatically became the operational satellite for the data delivery the third member of the Expedition-13 ISS the Columbus launch, saving several until the switch back to Meteosat-8 on crew and is carrying out the long-duration hundred kg of structural mass compared to 10 October. The satellite (now renamed Astrolab mission. Also launched, and its US counterpart. Meteosat-9) shows flawless nominal commissioned in the US Lab Destiny, were operations. ESA’s European Modular Cultivation System, Qualification and acceptance of the the –80ºC Freezer (MELFI) and the is now almost MSG-3 Percutaneous Electrical Muscle Stimulator. complete, following the completion of the MSG-3’s flight PROM has been integrated review (Q&AR) with the Board on 21 July. and tested. It is planned to put MSG-3 in On 9 September long-term storage by the end of the year, (STS-115) was launched to the ISS, marking The ATV Jules Verne spacecraft hardware awaiting launch in early 2011. the return to major assembly work on the and software is stable; acoustic and leak Station with the installation of the P3/P4 tests were completed and preparation is MSG-4 truss – the first configuration change for the under way for the final major environmental Preparation activities for MSG-4’s thermal- ISS since November 2002. test, the thermal-vacuum test. The second of vacuum test and optical-vacuum tests have three functional qualification test campaigns been completed. MSG-4 is now waiting for The Space Station Control Board has made has started on the Flight Simulation Facility its test slot at Alcatel Alenia Space in Cannes progress on the scheduling of the remaining (FSF) at Les Mureaux (F), and a number of (F); the thermal-vacuum test is expected to Shuttle flights to the ISS, with the Columbus functional qualification tests were performed, start by mid-November. launch on flight 1E on 17 October 2007. and some major bilateral interface tests were also completed. However, some problems Space Infrastructure Development during functional qualification testing, which The Columbus ground processing Phase-1 at is on the critical path for the programme, are Human Spaceflight, the was completed, still being encountered on test platforms, including the integrated leak test which usually caused by equipment front ends, and Microgravity & demonstrated that the ESA module is the qualification testing will now continue least susceptible Station module in this through into early 2007, resulting in a launch Exploration respect. Columbus is now in storage at the date not earlier than mid-June 2007. KSC until April 2007. Qualification and acceptance of the ATV Highlights A European commercial carrier, the Astrium- Control Centre is almost complete and the Space Shuttle Discovery (STS-121) was built ICC-Lite, has been baselined as the corresponding Q&AR review has started. launched to the ISS on 4 July with ESA payload bay structure to support the SOLAR Operations qualification for the Jules Verne astronaut Thomas Reiter aboard. He became observatory and EuTEF facility payloads on mission is well under way, with many parts

88 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int BP128 11/9/06 4:39 PM Page 88

Programmes In Progress

of the pre-qualification programme MSG completed. The operations product verification review has taken place and the Meteosat-8/MSG-1 Board meeting in October gave the go-ahead A reset of the Central Data Management Unit for the start of the simulations and training (CDMU) resulted in the satellite entering safe programme. mode on 23 September 2006. Although the exact cause is not yet known, it is likely to be The implementation review of the ISS a single event upset, as similar situations operations services contract was completed have been observed on the Spacebus 3000 and plans were agreed with industry for the CDMUs. After nominal reconfiguration, the work up to end-2007. This includes the satellite became the operational satellite Columbus and Jules Verne launches as well again on 10 October 2006. Satellite condition as the final transition from development to is nominal and the instrument performance operations programme. remains of excellent quality. Node-3 functional testing was completed and Meteosat-9/MSG-2 mechanical activities, in preparation for After successful commissioning, MSG-2 acceptance and shipment early next year, are became the hot standby for Meteosat-8. With Thomas Reiter working in the Destiny laboratory, 10 September under way. However, NASA has indicated that Meteosat-8 entering safe mode on it would like to transfer more activities from 23 September, MSG-2 automatically became KSC to Europe; negotiations on these the operational satellite for the data delivery the third member of the Expedition-13 ISS the Columbus launch, saving several activities are under way, for which NASA will until the switch back to Meteosat-8 on crew and is carrying out the long-duration hundred kg of structural mass compared to fund the European prime contractor of 10 October. The satellite (now renamed Astrolab mission. Also launched, and its US counterpart. Alcatel Alenia Space in Turin (I). Meteosat-9) shows flawless nominal commissioned in the US Lab Destiny, were operations. ESA’s European Modular Cultivation System Qualification and acceptance of the Roskosmos has announced to the SSCB that (EMCS), the –80ºC Freezer (MELFI) and the Columbus Control Centre is now almost it is planning on a long delay, to end-2009, MSG-3 Percutaneous Electrical Muscle Stimulator complete, following the completion of the for the launch of its Multipurpose Laboratory MSG-3’s flight PROM has been integrated (PEMS). review (Q&AR) with the Board on 21 July. Module (MLM). This will entail a preparing for his EVA during Shuttle mission STS-116 in December 2006 and tested. It is planned to put MSG-3 in On 9 September Space Shuttle Atlantis corresponding delay for the European long-term storage by the end of the year, (STS-115) was launched to the ISS, marking The ATV Jules Verne spacecraft hardware Robotic Arm (ERA). Plans are already in awaiting launch in early 2011. the return to major assembly work on the and software is stable; acoustic and leak place to store the flight unit, freeze all Facility (PCDF) integration has been Portable Glovebox has been used for the Station with the installation of the P3/P4 tests were completed and preparation is activities in Russia and go into team-keeping concluded and Phase-C/D experiment BIO-2 experiments that were performed MSG-4 truss – the first configuration change for the under way for the final major environmental mode with Dutch Space. development for Increment-16 is under way. during the Soyuz-13S visiting flight. During Preparation activities for MSG-4’s thermal- ISS since November 2002. test, the thermal-vacuum test. The second of The deployment of the first experiments for that flight, A. Ansari, acting as a short-term vacuum test and optical-vacuum tests have three functional qualification test campaigns Utilisation Planning, Payload the Fluid Science Laboratory (FSL) and medical test subject, performed several been completed. MSG-4 is now waiting for The Space Station Control Board has made has started on the Flight Simulation Facility Developments and Preparatory Missions Biolab, as well as the Flywheel Exercise human physiology experiments. The its test slot at Alcatel Alenia Space in Cannes progress on the scheduling of the remaining (FSF) at Les Mureaux (F), and a number of The SURE proposals review (32 proposals, Device, is envisaged for flight 1E, together experiment programme executed by Russian (F); the thermal-vacuum test is expected to Shuttle flights to the ISS, with the Columbus functional qualification tests were performed, four of which are industrial projects) is under with the upload on 1E of various cosmonaut P. Vinogradov (Increment-13) start by mid-November. launch on flight 1E on 17 October 2007. and some major bilateral interface tests were way and the peer review of the 49 bedrest consumables for human physiology was successfully concluded. also completed. However, some problems study proposals (15 science disciplines) is in experiments. Space Infrastructure Development during functional qualification testing, which preparation. ISS Education The Columbus ground processing Phase-1 at is on the critical path for the programme, are Destiny payloads: on-orbit recertification of Preparation of the education programme the Human Spaceflight, the Kennedy Space Center was completed, still being encountered on test platforms, Precursor missions: Maser-11 Phase-A/B the Microgravity Science Glovebox (MSG) is Christer Fuglesang STS-116 mission including the integrated leak test which usually caused by equipment front ends, and studies are almost completed and Phase-C/D almost complete, the Material Science (December 2006) is under way, and filming Microgravity & demonstrated that the ESA module is the qualification testing will now continue will follow directly. The Phase-C/D Laboratory (MSL) flight model pre-ship of the experiment has been approved by least susceptible Station module in this through into early 2007, resulting in a launch Texus-44/45 Request for Quotation is review has started, and development of Principal Investigator. Exploration respect. Columbus is now in storage at the date not earlier than mid-June 2007. starting in 2006, with a launch planned for ANITA, which will be deployed on ATV-1 and KSC until April 2007. end-2007, and Foton-M3 payload accommodated in an Express rack on The ARISS (Amateur Radio on the ISS) radio Qualification and acceptance of the ATV development activities are progressing well Destiny, is approaching completion. contact with the ISS and Thomas Reiter was Highlights A European commercial carrier, the Astrium- Control Centre is almost complete and the for a launch in September 2007. organised in Patras, Greece on 29 July, with Space Shuttle Discovery (STS-121) was built ICC-Lite, has been baselined as the corresponding Q&AR review has started. Following launch on STS-121 (ULF-1.1) and the participation of the Greek Minister of launched to the ISS on 4 July with ESA payload bay structure to support the SOLAR Operations qualification for the Jules Verne Columbus payloads: European Drawer Rack commissioning, MELFI and EMCS are Education. The UTBI experiment (University astronaut Thomas Reiter aboard. He became observatory and EuTEF facility payloads on mission is well under way, with many parts (EDR)/Protein Crystallisation Diagnostics supporting the scientific programme. The of Valencia) was launched on Soyuz-13S.

88 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 89 BP128 11/9/06 4:39 PM Page 90

Programmes In Progress

Development and testing of the CASPER the Descent Module Entry, Descent and (RHUs) of the type developed for the Russian ESA and Roskosmos are discussing an The earthworks at the Soyuz experiment (University of Dublin) is Landing System (EDLS), Descent Module Mars-96 mission. A follow-up technical exchange of letters that will establish the Launch Site proceeding, with the launch targeted for Support Structure and Rover Egress System meeting with BIAPOS, the company that formal basis for conducting the preparatory Progress-23P. (SES) and the Carrier/Orbiter. The Request developed and manufactured these devices, programme as a cooperative undertaking. A for Quotation for the Rover Vehicle was took place in early September with fully-fledged agreement in accordance with Astronaut Activities released. All proposals have been received encouraging results. A meeting is foreseen in the requirements of both agencies will be As part of his mission aboard the ISS, and are being evaluated. the near future to address the possibility of worked out and signed at a later stage. In Thomas Reiter performed an EVA of more broader ESA/Roskosmos cooperation on the parallel, the two parties will discuss and put The qualification test of than 6 hours with NASA astronaut Jeff Industrial activities began in early September rover, airbags, parachute design and in place the necessary measures to launch the Zefiro-23 forward Williams. They completed all the preparation with Galileo Avionica for the Drill and the development. programme activities at both Agency and skirt was successful on activities for the next ISS truss assembly Sample Preparation and Distribution system industrial level. 22 September. The test (installing the motor controller on the (SPDS) design and breadboard, and with Under the Exploration Core programme, the plan at the component radiator joint), deploying the new camera to Aerosekur for the airbag design and overall objectives and strategy for The ESA procurement process for industrial level to characterise the monitor the condition of the Shuttle’s breadboard. The Planetary Protection 2006–2009 were drawn up in line with the activities is being launched so that a contract skirt mechanical carbon-carbon structures, installing two support contract kicked-off at end-August programme proposal resulting from the can be awarded to industry as soon as characteristics is under materials experiments (MISSE-3 and -4) and with SEA/Open University. Berlin Ministerial Council in December 2005. possible. way. performing additional tasks. is not uniform. Instead, the construction Work has progressed on both the baseline For the general exploration technologies and The Zefiro-9 performance recovery plan was company is building a concrete pillar, 8 m in Most Astrolab experiments have been already mission, based on a Soyuz launcher and preparation for lunar exploration, several concluded. A slight modification of the diameter and 8 m deep, to reach the rock initiated by Thomas Reiter and will be relying on a NASA telecommunications activities are under preparation. Habitation Vega propellant formulation and an increase in the ceiling. The impact on the planning is being performed repeatedly. More experiments and orbiter, and an enhanced option requiring an and life-support activities are being proposed expansion ratio were proposed. The analysed and measures will be taken to consumables were uploaded on Soyuz-13S Ariane-5 launch. The latter option would for approval, dealing with further The qualification test campaign for the modifications were reviewed in the Zefiro-9 regain the time needed for this unforeseen and more will follow on Progress-23P. allow an independent European mission with development of Melissa, development of the launcher’s upper composite started at the CDR that began in September. activity. its own telecommunications orbiter and ALISSE advanced life-support system beginning of August in the ESTEC Test Although the plans have not yet been would provide the opportunity for continuing evaluator, further development of the ARES Centre. In September, it passed its vibration The composite structure for the P80 The CDR for the Launch System is scheduled formalised, ESA astronauts Leopold Eyharts Mars Express-type science. A close air-revitalisation system and further definition tests mounted on a shaker while some 400 Demonstration Model firing test arrived in for late October. The next industrial CDR for and Frank De Winne have started to train as examination was made of the overall project of exploration habitation requirements, for accelerometers and 40 strain gauges French Guiana during July, and the propellant the Russian deliveries will be held in three prime and backup for a mini-increment of schedule, which resulted in a critical near-term implementation. measured the movements and deformation casting was successful in August. Integration steps, one for each major industrialist 2–3 months after the launch of Columbus. assessment of the 2011 launch target, which of the structure. Acoustic tests are scheduled of the nozzle, igniters and sensors is involved. The first began in late September, They will be followed by a Canadian during was considered to be very tight. The 2013 System-level studies are being proposed for for mid-October. proceeding according to schedule. The first with the other two before the end of the year. stage 1J/A (with André Kuipers as backup) launch would provide a robust schedule with in situ resource utilisation, better definition of firing test is planned for end-November. and then a JAXA astronaut during stage 1J. several months’ contingency. ISS use for exploration and lunar mission The Vega upper composite is prepared for testing in the Large analysis specifically addressing Lagrange European Acoustic Facility at ESTEC was selected as a On the payload side, a series of instrument orbits. FLPP crewmember aboard Columbus/Shuttle flight interface meetings between ESA, the prime Soyuz at CSG 1E, in addition to Christer Fuglesang (12A.1, contractor and each Pasteur instrument The Mars Sample Return Phase-A2 contract An Authorisation To Proceed (ATP) was December 2006) and Paolo Nespoli (10A, teams allowed good progress in the design kicked off at end-August. Two precursor The construction site has changed awarded to industry in July for the Vinci Node-2 flight in August 2007). and definition of the instrument interfaces. mission definition studies (autonomous considerably in the past few months. Expander Demonstrator first contract, funded An assessment of the Pasteur payload mass rendezvous and soft/precision landing) will Temporary facilities such as offices, changing by FLPP-2. The NGL ELV and Building Blocks The first ESA ATV training was provided to allocation began in early July and continued be performed after a first system design rooms and catering facilities, were erected system concept studies began after national the Expedition-15 crew in September when into August to check whether some of the refinement loop. around the site. The stone crusher was agencies agreed on the Launcher System the Russian prime and backup crewmembers payload instrument requests could be Four tenders for approved planetary erected and put to work, allowing the rock Workshop conclusions. The first set of received ‘ATV Part 1 Training’ at the accommodated. protection/RHU units/radiation-related debris from the flame chute excavation to be industrial activities for the Intermediate European Astronaut Centre (EAC). Some 20 activities of the Core programme were used elsewhere. The foundations of the eXperimental Vehicle (IXV) was completed. weeks of ISS crew training will be The Geophysics and Environment Package issued; proposals were received and are Launch Operation Centre and for the air- The second set began, while IXV activities to implemented at EAC for Columbus, ATV and (GEP) status review activities began with a under evaluation. conditioning facility were laid. Hoisting be funded by FLPP-2 are upcoming, with the payloads during the next 12 months. first meeting in early July and continued equipment is being installed around the Statement of Work being finalised. through August and September. Further Crew Space Transportation System building construction sites. Exploration investigations are ongoing. The Programme Declaration for the CSTS For the consolidated FLPP contract with For ExoMars, now in Phase-B1 under Alcatel preparatory programme and a side document The excavation of the flame chute is NGL, all technical and contractual Alenia Space-Italy as prime contractor, the A preliminary meeting took place with recording statements by participating States proceeding at a good pace, although clarifications were received and contract selection process of the second-level Roskosmos to discuss potential cooperation and ESA’s Director General in connection problems have been encountered. It was signature is planned in October. Pending contractors has progressed with the issue in in ExoMars. Of particular interest is the with subscriptions were finalised on discovered that the rock layer where the finalisation of negotiations, industrial early August of the Invitations to Tender for procurement of Radioisotope Heater Units 29 September. pillars of the launch table would have rested activities were launched by ATP. e

90 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 91 BP128 11/9/06 4:39 PM Page 90

Programmes In Progress

Development and testing of the CASPER the Descent Module Entry, Descent and (RHUs) of the type developed for the Russian ESA and Roskosmos are discussing an The earthworks at the Soyuz experiment (University of Dublin) is Landing System (EDLS), Descent Module Mars-96 mission. A follow-up technical exchange of letters that will establish the Launch Site proceeding, with the launch targeted for Support Structure and Rover Egress System meeting with BIAPOS, the company that formal basis for conducting the preparatory Progress-23P. (SES) and the Carrier/Orbiter. The Request developed and manufactured these devices, programme as a cooperative undertaking. A for Quotation for the Rover Vehicle was took place in early September with fully-fledged agreement in accordance with Astronaut Activities released. All proposals have been received encouraging results. A meeting is foreseen in the requirements of both agencies will be As part of his mission aboard the ISS, and are being evaluated. the near future to address the possibility of worked out and signed at a later stage. In Thomas Reiter performed an EVA of more broader ESA/Roskosmos cooperation on the parallel, the two parties will discuss and put The qualification test of than 6 hours with NASA astronaut Jeff Industrial activities began in early September rover, airbags, parachute design and in place the necessary measures to launch the Zefiro-23 forward Williams. They completed all the preparation with Galileo Avionica for the Drill and the development. programme activities at both Agency and skirt was successful on activities for the next ISS truss assembly Sample Preparation and Distribution system industrial level. 22 September. The test (installing the motor controller on the (SPDS) design and breadboard, and with Under the Exploration Core programme, the plan at the component radiator joint), deploying the new camera to Aerosekur for the airbag design and overall objectives and strategy for The ESA procurement process for industrial level to characterise the monitor the condition of the Shuttle’s breadboard. The Planetary Protection 2006–2009 were drawn up in line with the activities is being launched so that a contract skirt mechanical carbon-carbon structures, installing two support contract kicked-off at end-August programme proposal resulting from the can be awarded to industry as soon as characteristics is under materials experiments (MISSE-3 and -4) and with SEA/Open University. Berlin Ministerial Council in December 2005. possible. way. performing additional tasks. is not uniform. Instead, the construction Work has progressed on both the baseline For the general exploration technologies and The Zefiro-9 performance recovery plan was company is building a concrete pillar, 8 m in Most Astrolab experiments have been already mission, based on a Soyuz launcher and preparation for lunar exploration, several concluded. A slight modification of the diameter and 8 m deep, to reach the rock initiated by Thomas Reiter and will be relying on a NASA telecommunications activities are under preparation. Habitation Vega propellant formulation and an increase in the ceiling. The impact on the planning is being performed repeatedly. More experiments and orbiter, and an enhanced option requiring an and life-support activities are being proposed expansion ratio were proposed. The analysed and measures will be taken to consumables were uploaded on Soyuz-13S Ariane-5 launch. The latter option would for approval, dealing with further The qualification test campaign for the modifications were reviewed in the Zefiro-9 regain the time needed for this unforeseen and more will follow on Progress-23P. allow an independent European mission with development of Melissa, development of the launcher’s upper composite started at the CDR that began in September. activity. its own telecommunications orbiter and ALISSE advanced life-support system beginning of August in the ESTEC Test Although the plans have not yet been would provide the opportunity for continuing evaluator, further development of the ARES Centre. In September, it passed its vibration The composite structure for the P80 The CDR for the Launch System is scheduled formalised, ESA astronauts Leopold Eyharts Mars Express-type science. A close air-revitalisation system and further definition tests mounted on a shaker while some 400 Demonstration Model firing test arrived in for late October. The next industrial CDR for and Frank De Winne have started to train as examination was made of the overall project of exploration habitation requirements, for accelerometers and 40 strain gauges French Guiana during July, and the propellant the Russian deliveries will be held in three prime and backup for a mini-increment of schedule, which resulted in a critical near-term implementation. measured the movements and deformation casting was successful in August. Integration steps, one for each major industrialist 2–3 months after the launch of Columbus. assessment of the 2011 launch target, which of the structure. Acoustic tests are scheduled of the nozzle, igniters and sensors is involved. The first began in late September, They will be followed by a Canadian during was considered to be very tight. The 2013 System-level studies are being proposed for for mid-October. proceeding according to schedule. The first with the other two before the end of the year. stage 1J/A (with André Kuipers as backup) launch would provide a robust schedule with in situ resource utilisation, better definition of firing test is planned for end-November. and then a JAXA astronaut during stage 1J. several months’ contingency. ISS use for exploration and lunar mission The Vega upper composite is prepared for testing in the Large analysis specifically addressing Lagrange European Acoustic Facility at ESTEC Hans Schlegel was selected as a On the payload side, a series of instrument orbits. FLPP crewmember aboard Columbus/Shuttle flight interface meetings between ESA, the prime Soyuz at CSG 1E, in addition to Christer Fuglesang (12A.1, contractor and each Pasteur instrument The Mars Sample Return Phase-A2 contract An Authorisation To Proceed (ATP) was December 2006) and Paolo Nespoli (10A, teams allowed good progress in the design kicked off at end-August. Two precursor The construction site has changed awarded to industry in July for the Vinci Node-2 flight in August 2007). and definition of the instrument interfaces. mission definition studies (autonomous considerably in the past few months. Expander Demonstrator first contract, funded An assessment of the Pasteur payload mass rendezvous and soft/precision landing) will Temporary facilities such as offices, changing by FLPP-2. The NGL ELV and Building Blocks The first ESA ATV training was provided to allocation began in early July and continued be performed after a first system design rooms and catering facilities, were erected system concept studies began after national the Expedition-15 crew in September when into August to check whether some of the refinement loop. around the site. The stone crusher was agencies agreed on the Launcher System the Russian prime and backup crewmembers payload instrument requests could be Four tenders for approved planetary erected and put to work, allowing the rock Workshop conclusions. The first set of received ‘ATV Part 1 Training’ at the accommodated. protection/RHU units/radiation-related debris from the flame chute excavation to be industrial activities for the Intermediate European Astronaut Centre (EAC). Some 20 activities of the Core programme were used elsewhere. The foundations of the eXperimental Vehicle (IXV) was completed. weeks of ISS crew training will be The Geophysics and Environment Package issued; proposals were received and are Launch Operation Centre and for the air- The second set began, while IXV activities to implemented at EAC for Columbus, ATV and (GEP) status review activities began with a under evaluation. conditioning facility were laid. Hoisting be funded by FLPP-2 are upcoming, with the payloads during the next 12 months. first meeting in early July and continued equipment is being installed around the Statement of Work being finalised. through August and September. Further Crew Space Transportation System building construction sites. Exploration investigations are ongoing. The Programme Declaration for the CSTS For the consolidated FLPP contract with For ExoMars, now in Phase-B1 under Alcatel preparatory programme and a side document The excavation of the flame chute is NGL, all technical and contractual Alenia Space-Italy as prime contractor, the A preliminary meeting took place with recording statements by participating States proceeding at a good pace, although clarifications were received and contract selection process of the second-level Roskosmos to discuss potential cooperation and ESA’s Director General in connection problems have been encountered. It was signature is planned in October. Pending contractors has progressed with the issue in in ExoMars. Of particular interest is the with subscriptions were finalised on discovered that the rock layer where the finalisation of negotiations, industrial early August of the Invitations to Tender for procurement of Radioisotope Heater Units 29 September. pillars of the launch table would have rested activities were launched by ATP. e

90 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 91 InBriefB128 11/9/06 3:37 PM Page 92

News In Brief

SMART-1: Crash Scene Investigation Envisat Finds Record Ozone Hole

Early on 3 September, observers structure and mineral Measurements from ESA’s Envisat The ozone hole, first recognised around the world saw a small composition of the surface in satellite have revealed a record in 1985, typically persists until flash illuminate the surface of the visible, infrared and X-ray. loss of ozone over Antarctica: the November or December, when Moon. They had witnessed the 40 million tonnes by 2 October the weakening polar vortex winds final moments of ESA’s tiny Professional and amateur 2006 exceeded the previous allow in ozone-rich air. SMART-1 spacecraft as it observers from South Africa, the record of about 39 Mt in 2000. ESA is backing the Tropospheric In Brief impacted the lunar soil. Canary Islands, South America, The size of this year’s ozone hole Emission Monitoring Internet the continental USA, Hawaii and is 28 million km2, nearly as large Service (TEMIS) to provide SMART-1 scientists and many other locations were as the record hole of 2000; its operational ozone and UV engineers at the European Space watching, hoping to spot the faint depth rivals 1998’s record low. radiation monitoring based on Operations Centre (ESOC), in flash for information about the Infrared images from the Canada-France-Hawaii Telescope show the flash (first Envisat SCIAMACHY and ERS-2 Darmstadt (D), confirmed the impact dynamics and the lunar frame) and the dust cloud that followed the SMART-1 impact “Such significant ozone loss GOME-1 data. The ozone data impact at 05:42:22 UT, when the surface excavated by the requires very low temperatures in from these instruments, spanning New Norcia ground station in spacecraft. the stratosphere combined with 11 years, will be extended by the Australia suddenly lost radio boost the perilune of the reconstruct the ‘movie’ of what year (it was initially planned to sunlight. This year’s extreme loss MetOp satellite series and its contact. SMART-1 ended its The final days of SMART-1 saw penultimate orbit, while happened to the spacecraft and last only 6 months) allowed can be explained by the next-generation GOME-2 for remarkable journey in the Lake of intense activity as controllers maintaining the intended impact the Moon’s surface. For this lunar scientists to use a number of temperatures above Antarctica years to come. Excellence, at 34.4ºS/46.2ºW. shepherded it towards its . time and location. Suddenly, to ‘Crash Scene Investigation’, we innovative observing methods at reaching the lowest recorded Based on estimates that included add to the tension, SMART-1 need all possible Earth witnesses the Moon. This was tough work since 1979,” said ESA “Long-term measurements of The 2 km/s impact occurred in a local topography, impact was due unexpectedly placed itself into and observational facts,” said for the mission planners, but the atmospheric engineer Claus ozone levels are of key dark area near the terminator (the during orbit 2890, at 05:41 UT ‘safe mode’, at 13:09 UT on Bernard Foing, SMART-1 Project lunar data archive we are now Zehner. The ozone layer, found importance for being able to day-night line) at a grazing angle somewhere at mid-southern 1 September with the Scientist. building is truly impressive,” said about 25 km above us, shields life monitor the ozone’s predicted of 5–10º. The time and location latitudes on the near-side. Then, manoeuvres pending. Most Gerhard Schwehm, SMART-1 on Earth from the Sun’s harmful recovery, which is currently were planned via a series of with only a few days to go, the spacecraft functions and payload Extensive data processing is now Mission Manager. ultraviolet rays. Over the last estimated to take place by around corrections during the summer data suggested that, in the operations were suspended. under way to define the site’s decade, the ozone has thinned by 2060,” Zehner said. e – the last on 1 September – to absence of any further topography. From a preliminary “For ESA’s Science Programme, about 0.3% per year globally, favour observations by manoeuvres, impact would very After a tense 6 hours, Spacecraft analysis of the stereo data and SMART-1 represents a great increasing the risk of skin cancer, telescopes on Earth. likely occur one orbit earlier, at Operations Manager Octavio earlier maps built with SMART-1 success and a very good return cataracts and harm to marine life. Space Colloquium 00:38 UT during orbit 2889, if Camino happily reported full data, it should have hit the Moon on investment, both from the The reduction is caused by The impact concluded a SMART-1 clipped the 1600 m- recovery at 17:15 UT. The on the ascending slope of a technological and the scientific pollutants such as man-made spectacularly successful mission high rim of Clausius crater. manoeuvres were successful, mountain about 1.5 km high, point of view. Future scientific chlorofluorocarbons, which have During 19–22 September, the that, in addition to testing boosting perilune by 592 m and above the Lake of Excellence missions will greatly benefit from still not vanished despite being Western European Union (WEU) innovative space technology, had During the night of shifting impact to 05:42 UT. plain. the technological and operational banned under the Montreal Assembly and the European been exploring the Moon for 1–2 September, ESOC controllers experience gained thanks to this Protocol of 1987. A single Interparliamentary Space 16 months, gathering data on the planned to use the thrusters to The impact took place on orbit In the CFHT infrared movie, a small spacecraft, while the molecule of chlorine can break Conference joined forces to hold 2890. SMART-1 sent its last cloud of ejected material and scientific data gathered by down thousands of molecules of a colloquium on ‘Space, Defence signals at 05:42:21:759 UT, and debris was seen moving about SMART-1 are already helping to ozone. and European Security’ in Kourou, the Mount Pleasant Observatory 80 km in 130 sec by Christian update our current picture of the French Guiana, in association radio telescope of the University Veillet, Principal Investigator for Moon,” said David Southwood, The ozone hole of 27 September as measured by with ESA, CNES and Arianespace. of Tasmania in Hobart, lost the the observations at CFHT. To Director of Scientific Envisat’s SCIAMACHY instrument (KNMI/TEMIS) signal at 05:42:22.394 UT. These determine which part of the flash Programmes. The event brought together more times are remarkable agreement came from heated lunar rock or than 100 Members of Parliament with the final predictions and the from the probe’s remaining “The legacy left by the huge from European nations along with coordinates derived from the propellant, it was important to wealth of SMART-1 data, to be Members of the European position of the infrared impact obtain measurements in several analysed in the months and years Parliament and senior executives flash observed by the Canada- optical and infrared wavelengths, to come, is a precious from ESA, CNES, Arianespace France-Hawaii Telescope (CFHT) in addition to the CFHT contribution to lunar science at a and the space industry. The main on Hawaii. observations at 2.12 micron. time when the exploration of the aim of the discussions was to Moon is once again catching the examine the space sector in its “From the various observations “Our decision to extend the world’s interest,” said Bernard application to security and and models, we are trying to scientific mission by a further Foing. e defence and assess industrial

92 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 93 InBriefB128 11/9/06 3:37 PM Page 92

News In Brief

SMART-1: Crash Scene Investigation Envisat Finds Record Ozone Hole

Early on 3 September, observers structure and mineral Measurements from ESA’s Envisat The ozone hole, first recognised around the world saw a small composition of the surface in satellite have revealed a record in 1985, typically persists until flash illuminate the surface of the visible, infrared and X-ray. loss of ozone over Antarctica: the November or December, when Moon. They had witnessed the 40 million tonnes by 2 October the weakening polar vortex winds final moments of ESA’s tiny Professional and amateur 2006 exceeded the previous allow in ozone-rich air. SMART-1 spacecraft as it observers from South Africa, the record of about 39 Mt in 2000. ESA is backing the Tropospheric In Brief impacted the lunar soil. Canary Islands, South America, The size of this year’s ozone hole Emission Monitoring Internet the continental USA, Hawaii and is 28 million km2, nearly as large Service (TEMIS) to provide SMART-1 scientists and many other locations were as the record hole of 2000; its operational ozone and UV engineers at the European Space watching, hoping to spot the faint depth rivals 1998’s record low. radiation monitoring based on Operations Centre (ESOC), in flash for information about the Infrared images from the Canada-France-Hawaii Telescope show the flash (first Envisat SCIAMACHY and ERS-2 Darmstadt (D), confirmed the impact dynamics and the lunar frame) and the dust cloud that followed the SMART-1 impact “Such significant ozone loss GOME-1 data. The ozone data impact at 05:42:22 UT, when the surface excavated by the requires very low temperatures in from these instruments, spanning New Norcia ground station in spacecraft. the stratosphere combined with 11 years, will be extended by the Australia suddenly lost radio boost the perilune of the reconstruct the ‘movie’ of what year (it was initially planned to sunlight. This year’s extreme loss MetOp satellite series and its contact. SMART-1 ended its The final days of SMART-1 saw penultimate orbit, while happened to the spacecraft and last only 6 months) allowed can be explained by the next-generation GOME-2 for remarkable journey in the Lake of intense activity as controllers maintaining the intended impact the Moon’s surface. For this lunar scientists to use a number of temperatures above Antarctica years to come. Excellence, at 34.4ºS/46.2ºW. shepherded it towards its destiny. time and location. Suddenly, to ‘Crash Scene Investigation’, we innovative observing methods at reaching the lowest recorded Based on estimates that included add to the tension, SMART-1 need all possible Earth witnesses the Moon. This was tough work since 1979,” said ESA “Long-term measurements of The 2 km/s impact occurred in a local topography, impact was due unexpectedly placed itself into and observational facts,” said for the mission planners, but the atmospheric engineer Claus ozone levels are of key dark area near the terminator (the during orbit 2890, at 05:41 UT ‘safe mode’, at 13:09 UT on Bernard Foing, SMART-1 Project lunar data archive we are now Zehner. The ozone layer, found importance for being able to day-night line) at a grazing angle somewhere at mid-southern 1 September with the Scientist. building is truly impressive,” said about 25 km above us, shields life monitor the ozone’s predicted of 5–10º. The time and location latitudes on the near-side. Then, manoeuvres pending. Most Gerhard Schwehm, SMART-1 on Earth from the Sun’s harmful recovery, which is currently were planned via a series of with only a few days to go, the spacecraft functions and payload Extensive data processing is now Mission Manager. ultraviolet rays. Over the last estimated to take place by around corrections during the summer data suggested that, in the operations were suspended. under way to define the site’s decade, the ozone has thinned by 2060,” Zehner said. e – the last on 1 September – to absence of any further topography. From a preliminary “For ESA’s Science Programme, about 0.3% per year globally, favour observations by manoeuvres, impact would very After a tense 6 hours, Spacecraft analysis of the stereo data and SMART-1 represents a great increasing the risk of skin cancer, telescopes on Earth. likely occur one orbit earlier, at Operations Manager Octavio earlier maps built with SMART-1 success and a very good return cataracts and harm to marine life. Space Colloquium 00:38 UT during orbit 2889, if Camino happily reported full data, it should have hit the Moon on investment, both from the The reduction is caused by The impact concluded a SMART-1 clipped the 1600 m- recovery at 17:15 UT. The on the ascending slope of a technological and the scientific pollutants such as man-made spectacularly successful mission high rim of Clausius crater. manoeuvres were successful, mountain about 1.5 km high, point of view. Future scientific chlorofluorocarbons, which have During 19–22 September, the that, in addition to testing boosting perilune by 592 m and above the Lake of Excellence missions will greatly benefit from still not vanished despite being Western European Union (WEU) innovative space technology, had During the night of shifting impact to 05:42 UT. plain. the technological and operational banned under the Montreal Assembly and the European been exploring the Moon for 1–2 September, ESOC controllers experience gained thanks to this Protocol of 1987. A single Interparliamentary Space 16 months, gathering data on the planned to use the thrusters to The impact took place on orbit In the CFHT infrared movie, a small spacecraft, while the molecule of chlorine can break Conference joined forces to hold 2890. SMART-1 sent its last cloud of ejected material and scientific data gathered by down thousands of molecules of a colloquium on ‘Space, Defence signals at 05:42:21:759 UT, and debris was seen moving about SMART-1 are already helping to ozone. and European Security’ in Kourou, the Mount Pleasant Observatory 80 km in 130 sec by Christian update our current picture of the French Guiana, in association radio telescope of the University Veillet, Principal Investigator for Moon,” said David Southwood, The ozone hole of 27 September as measured by with ESA, CNES and Arianespace. of Tasmania in Hobart, lost the the observations at CFHT. To Director of Scientific Envisat’s SCIAMACHY instrument (KNMI/TEMIS) signal at 05:42:22.394 UT. These determine which part of the flash Programmes. The event brought together more times are remarkable agreement came from heated lunar rock or than 100 Members of Parliament with the final predictions and the from the probe’s remaining “The legacy left by the huge from European nations along with coordinates derived from the propellant, it was important to wealth of SMART-1 data, to be Members of the European position of the infrared impact obtain measurements in several analysed in the months and years Parliament and senior executives flash observed by the Canada- optical and infrared wavelengths, to come, is a precious from ESA, CNES, Arianespace France-Hawaii Telescope (CFHT) in addition to the CFHT contribution to lunar science at a and the space industry. The main on Hawaii. observations at 2.12 micron. time when the exploration of the aim of the discussions was to Moon is once again catching the examine the space sector in its “From the various observations “Our decision to extend the world’s interest,” said Bernard application to security and and models, we are trying to scientific mission by a further Foing. e defence and assess industrial

92 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 93 InBriefB128 11/9/06 3:37 PM Page 94

News In Brief

Greece photographed by ESA astronaut Thomas of intensive development have Reiter from the International Space Station MetOp-A in Orbit! during his radio contact with ‘Space Camp’ achieved a major step forward in students on 29 July. This year’s ESA Space Camp reducing costs. Not only a major was held in Patras, Greece event for Vega, it also bodes well MetOp-A, the first of three Earth’s surface under similar for future updates to the Ariane-5 meteorological satellites illumination conditions almost on boosters. developed jointly by ESA and a daily basis. MetOp will provide Eumetsat, was successfully a closer view of the atmosphere Now in Kourou, the nozzle is launched from Baikonur from low orbit, delivering data being integrated with the P80 Cosmodrome, Kazakhstan at that will improve global weather motor for the first firing test, 16:28:13 UT on 19 October prediction and enhance our planned for end-November. aboard a Russian Soyuz-2/Fregat understanding of climate change. On the subject of access to Vega’s maiden flight is planned rocket. Some 69 minutes later, space, the Chief Executive Officer for late 2007. e the Fregat upper stage released Following release, the satellite of Arianespace, Jean-Yves the 4093 kg MetOp over the came under the control of ESA’s Le Gall, pointed to the ever- Kerguelen archipelago in the European Space Operations stronger position of European New Goals for Earth Science South Indian Ocean into a circular Centre (ESOC) in Darmstadt, launchers. Ariane-5’s reliability orbit at an altitude of 837 km. Germany, and automatically and regular launches had enabled deployed its solar array. It then Europe to orbit the greatest ESA announced in September a With a slightly retrograde 98.7º underwent the first checkouts of number of commercial satellites new science strategy for the inclination, this orbit enables its systems and deployed its in 2005 and 2006. This had given future direction of its Living MetOp-A to circle the globe from antennas. Handover to Eumetsat Europe a ready, reliable, Planet Programme, addressing pole to pole while always was on 22 October for full capabilities in the light of the Vivier, welcomed the colloquium and implementing a European guaranteed competitive access to the continuing need to further our crossing the equator at the same satellite commissioning and challenges facing Europe. The being held in Kourou, in his view Space Policy, Europeans should space for sovereign missions by understanding of the Earth local time – 9:30 am. This Sun- routine operations. Bulletin 127 participants noted the gulf “not a moment too soon”. If build on present successes. European governments. System and the impact that synchronous orbit allows revisits (August 2006) includes detailed between the strategic ambitions Europe wanted to catch up with There was a need to take human activity is having. to almost each point of the articles on MetOp. e that Europe has for its space its main competitors in space, it feedback from users, consolidate In this respect, the European dimension and the level of funds needed to take the financial technological and industrial launcher programme was a The Changing Earth: New it was prepared to commit to it. decisions that were necessary, capacities, maintain flexibility, model of the success of Scientific Challenges for ESA's Leader Passes Asteroid Honour and quickly. The vital necessity strengthen coordination between European integration in the Living Planet Programme focuses The President of the of the security and defence the parties involved and manage service of security and defence, on the most fundamental Interparliamentary European dimension being discussed at the evolution of space as the launches of 26 military challenge facing humanity at the It is with regret The Minor Planet Security and Defence Assembly the colloquium was something governance by stages. This was a satellites already illustrates. beginning of the 21st century: The Changing Earth (SP-1304; €20, 83pp) can be that ESA notes Center at the (WEU Assembly), Jean-Pierre that parliamentarians must challenge for everyone and one to Finally, the full range of launchers global change. A better ordered using the form at the back of this issue the death of Smithsonian Masseret, emphasised the seriously take on board in order which, with the commitment of in use at Europe’s Spaceport in knowledge of the Earth System Michel Bignier, Astrophysical importance of Europe being able to convince governments to all concerned, and in particular of Kourou from 2008 – Vega, Soyuz and the impact of increasing – provide an infrastructure to on 12 October. Observatory to draw on the full gamut of invest massively in space – an the member states, Europe was and Ariane-5 – would mean that human activity is of crucial allow satellite data to be A leading figure (Harvard, USA), space-based facilities: Earth area that has been far too long quite equal. Europe could independently put a importance in providing the basis quickly and efficiently exploited in the space world and Director under the auspices of the observation, telecommunications, neglected. payload of any given weight into for managing a sustainable for research and applications; General of CNES 1972–1976, he International Astronomical Union, intelligence, navigation and For the President of CNES, any chosen orbit. e environment. – provide a unique contribution was Director of ESA’s has designated minor planet ballistic missile early warning The Director General of ESA, Yannick D’Escatha, space had to global Earth observation programme 1976–1980, and number 10969 as ‘Perryman’, systems, noting further that this Jean-Jacques Dordain, felt that become thoroughly The new strategy aims to assess capabilities, complementing then Director of Space Transport named for Michael Perryman of comprehensive range of messages were being received interdisciplinary, and was thus a Vega Nozzle the most important Earth-science satellites operated by other Systems until 1986. “He has ESA’s Science directorate. capabilities played a crucial part from the conference that would key element of major European questions to be addressed in the agencies and in situ observing been one of the main players in Previously project scientist of the in preventing, managing and constitute important inputs into policies. He emphasised the years to come. It outlines the systems; the long struggle to adopt a Hipparcos and Gaia missions, exiting crises, and would the preparation, by the European special ‘dual’ contribution of A ceremony at Snecma observational challenges that – provide an efficient and cost- balanced European Space and professor at Leiden guarantee genuinely autonomous Commission and ESA, of the space in virtually every field – Propulsion Solide in Bordeaux (F) these raise, and the contribution effective process for science Programme,” said ESA Director University, Michael Perryman was powers of decision and action in European Space Policy, to be military and civil – connected on 14 September marked the that the Agency can make. priorities to be rapidly General Jean-Jacques Dordain, cited for his leadership in the security and defence matters for unveiled at the Fourth Meeting of with people’s security and was formal delivery of the first nozzle Underpinning the strategy is a set translated into space missions, echoing the deep regret of all development of space astronomy. Europe. the Space Council, in May 2007. adamant that Europe must take for the P80 first stage motor of of ambitious objectives, adequately resourced with those at ESA who had the The minor planet was discovered Members of national parliaments advantage of this dual-use ESA’s Vega small launcher. including: associated ground support; opportunity to know Bignier and in May 1971 by C.J. van Houten The President of the European and the European Parliament had aspect, in view of the difference – launch a steady flow of – support the development of appreciate his work and and I. van Houten-Groeneveld on Interparliamentary Space affirmed the strategic importance in levels of investment in Europe The delivery is a milestone for the missions addressing key innovative approaches to commitment to a true European Palomar Schmidt telescope plates Conference, François Roelants du of space for Europe. In defining and the USA (1:6). Vega programme. Several years issues in Earth science; instrumentation. e space policy. e taken by T. Gehrels. e

94 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 95 InBriefB128 11/9/06 3:37 PM Page 94

News In Brief

Greece photographed by ESA astronaut Thomas of intensive development have Reiter from the International Space Station MetOp-A in Orbit! during his radio contact with ‘Space Camp’ achieved a major step forward in students on 29 July. This year’s ESA Space Camp reducing costs. Not only a major was held in Patras, Greece event for Vega, it also bodes well MetOp-A, the first of three Earth’s surface under similar for future updates to the Ariane-5 meteorological satellites illumination conditions almost on boosters. developed jointly by ESA and a daily basis. MetOp will provide Eumetsat, was successfully a closer view of the atmosphere Now in Kourou, the nozzle is launched from Baikonur from low orbit, delivering data being integrated with the P80 Cosmodrome, Kazakhstan at that will improve global weather motor for the first firing test, 16:28:13 UT on 19 October prediction and enhance our planned for end-November. aboard a Russian Soyuz-2/Fregat understanding of climate change. On the subject of access to Vega’s maiden flight is planned rocket. Some 69 minutes later, space, the Chief Executive Officer for late 2007. e the Fregat upper stage released Following release, the satellite of Arianespace, Jean-Yves the 4093 kg MetOp over the came under the control of ESA’s Le Gall, pointed to the ever- Kerguelen archipelago in the European Space Operations stronger position of European New Goals for Earth Science South Indian Ocean into a circular Centre (ESOC) in Darmstadt, launchers. Ariane-5’s reliability orbit at an altitude of 837 km. Germany, and automatically and regular launches had enabled deployed its solar array. It then Europe to orbit the greatest ESA announced in September a With a slightly retrograde 98.7º underwent the first checkouts of number of commercial satellites new science strategy for the inclination, this orbit enables its systems and deployed its in 2005 and 2006. This had given future direction of its Living MetOp-A to circle the globe from antennas. Handover to Eumetsat Europe a ready, reliable, Planet Programme, addressing pole to pole while always was on 22 October for full capabilities in the light of the Vivier, welcomed the colloquium and implementing a European guaranteed competitive access to the continuing need to further our crossing the equator at the same satellite commissioning and challenges facing Europe. The being held in Kourou, in his view Space Policy, Europeans should space for sovereign missions by understanding of the Earth local time – 9:30 am. This Sun- routine operations. Bulletin 127 participants noted the gulf “not a moment too soon”. If build on present successes. European governments. System and the impact that synchronous orbit allows revisits (August 2006) includes detailed between the strategic ambitions Europe wanted to catch up with There was a need to take human activity is having. to almost each point of the articles on MetOp. e that Europe has for its space its main competitors in space, it feedback from users, consolidate In this respect, the European dimension and the level of funds needed to take the financial technological and industrial launcher programme was a The Changing Earth: New it was prepared to commit to it. decisions that were necessary, capacities, maintain flexibility, model of the success of Scientific Challenges for ESA's Leader Passes Asteroid Honour and quickly. The vital necessity strengthen coordination between European integration in the Living Planet Programme focuses The President of the of the security and defence the parties involved and manage service of security and defence, on the most fundamental Interparliamentary European dimension being discussed at the evolution of space as the launches of 26 military challenge facing humanity at the It is with regret The Minor Planet Security and Defence Assembly the colloquium was something governance by stages. This was a satellites already illustrates. beginning of the 21st century: The Changing Earth (SP-1304; €20, 83pp) can be that ESA notes Center at the (WEU Assembly), Jean-Pierre that parliamentarians must challenge for everyone and one to Finally, the full range of launchers global change. A better ordered using the form at the back of this issue the death of Smithsonian Masseret, emphasised the seriously take on board in order which, with the commitment of in use at Europe’s Spaceport in knowledge of the Earth System Michel Bignier, Astrophysical importance of Europe being able to convince governments to all concerned, and in particular of Kourou from 2008 – Vega, Soyuz and the impact of increasing – provide an infrastructure to on 12 October. Observatory to draw on the full gamut of invest massively in space – an the member states, Europe was and Ariane-5 – would mean that human activity is of crucial allow satellite data to be A leading figure (Harvard, USA), space-based facilities: Earth area that has been far too long quite equal. Europe could independently put a importance in providing the basis quickly and efficiently exploited in the space world and Director under the auspices of the observation, telecommunications, neglected. payload of any given weight into for managing a sustainable for research and applications; General of CNES 1972–1976, he International Astronomical Union, intelligence, navigation and For the President of CNES, any chosen orbit. e environment. – provide a unique contribution was Director of ESA’s Spacelab has designated minor planet ballistic missile early warning The Director General of ESA, Yannick D’Escatha, space had to global Earth observation programme 1976–1980, and number 10969 as ‘Perryman’, systems, noting further that this Jean-Jacques Dordain, felt that become thoroughly The new strategy aims to assess capabilities, complementing then Director of Space Transport named for Michael Perryman of comprehensive range of messages were being received interdisciplinary, and was thus a Vega Nozzle the most important Earth-science satellites operated by other Systems until 1986. “He has ESA’s Science directorate. capabilities played a crucial part from the conference that would key element of major European questions to be addressed in the agencies and in situ observing been one of the main players in Previously project scientist of the in preventing, managing and constitute important inputs into policies. He emphasised the years to come. It outlines the systems; the long struggle to adopt a Hipparcos and Gaia missions, exiting crises, and would the preparation, by the European special ‘dual’ contribution of A ceremony at Snecma observational challenges that – provide an efficient and cost- balanced European Space and professor at Leiden guarantee genuinely autonomous Commission and ESA, of the space in virtually every field – Propulsion Solide in Bordeaux (F) these raise, and the contribution effective process for science Programme,” said ESA Director University, Michael Perryman was powers of decision and action in European Space Policy, to be military and civil – connected on 14 September marked the that the Agency can make. priorities to be rapidly General Jean-Jacques Dordain, cited for his leadership in the security and defence matters for unveiled at the Fourth Meeting of with people’s security and was formal delivery of the first nozzle Underpinning the strategy is a set translated into space missions, echoing the deep regret of all development of space astronomy. Europe. the Space Council, in May 2007. adamant that Europe must take for the P80 first stage motor of of ambitious objectives, adequately resourced with those at ESA who had the The minor planet was discovered Members of national parliaments advantage of this dual-use ESA’s Vega small launcher. including: associated ground support; opportunity to know Bignier and in May 1971 by C.J. van Houten The President of the European and the European Parliament had aspect, in view of the difference – launch a steady flow of – support the development of appreciate his work and and I. van Houten-Groeneveld on Interparliamentary Space affirmed the strategic importance in levels of investment in Europe The delivery is a milestone for the missions addressing key innovative approaches to commitment to a true European Palomar Schmidt telescope plates Conference, François Roelants du of space for Europe. In defining and the USA (1:6). Vega programme. Several years issues in Earth science; instrumentation. e space policy. e taken by T. Gehrels. e

94 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 95 InBriefB128 11/9/06 3:38 PM Page 96

News In Brief

These spectacular images of the Cydonia region of the Red Planet were captured by the High Resolution Stereo Camera of Mars Express. Obtained on 22 July and released in September, they include the famous ‘face’ on Mars in unprecedented detail (inset and arrowed).

Cydonia sits in the transition zone between the planet’s southern highlands and the northern plains, a region characterised by wide, debris-filled valleys and isolated remnant mounds of various shapes and sizes. One of these massifs became famous as the ‘Face on Mars’ in an image taken in 1976 by NASA’s Viking-1 orbiter. It was an illusion caused by the angle of the Sun and the shadows giving the impression of eyes, nose and mouth. Other formations seen here in the top left quadrant resembled ‘pyramids’. While the features are not artificial, they are nevertheless of great interest to planetary geologists. Image resolution is about 13.7 m per pixel. (ESA/DLR/FU Berlin; G. Neukum) 10 km N

96 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 97 InBriefB128 11/9/06 3:38 PM Page 96

News In Brief

These spectacular images of the Cydonia region of the Red Planet were captured by the High Resolution Stereo Camera of Mars Express. Obtained on 22 July and released in September, they include the famous ‘face’ on Mars in unprecedented detail (inset and arrowed).

Cydonia sits in the transition zone between the planet’s southern highlands and the northern plains, a region characterised by wide, debris-filled valleys and isolated remnant mounds of various shapes and sizes. One of these massifs became famous as the ‘Face on Mars’ in an image taken in 1976 by NASA’s Viking-1 orbiter. It was an illusion caused by the angle of the Sun and the shadows giving the impression of eyes, nose and mouth. Other formations seen here in the top left quadrant resembled ‘pyramids’. While the features are not artificial, they are nevertheless of great interest to planetary geologists. Image resolution is about 13.7 m per pixel. (ESA/DLR/FU Berlin; G. Neukum) 10 km N

96 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 97 InBriefB128 11/9/06 3:38 PM Page 98

News In Brief

New Zealand’s dramatic landscape is captured by Envisat’s MERIS have attracted attention from film directors: Mt. Ruapehu was The current configuration of the International Space Station, after a Thomas Reiter, who has been working aboard the Station since 6 July, imaging spectrometer on 10 September at a resolution of 300 m. Two transformed into the fiery Mount Doom in ‘Lord of the Rings’, while second pair of 73 m-long solar wings (in shadow) was attached in to Earth. Next year will be a busy time for ESA and its astronauts at of the volcanoes on the North Island are visible as snow-capped Mt. Taranaki served as the setting for ‘The Last Samurai’. As almost all September by Shuttle mission STS-115. The new wings will double the Station: Paolo Nespoli will accompany Node-2 aboard STS-120 in circular features. Mount Ruapehu, the North Island’s tallest peak at volcanoes occur near tectonic plate boundaries, it is no surprise that the Station’s power when they are brought online during the next August, Hans Schlegel is scheduled to fly with the Columbus module 2797 m, is at top centre, while Mount Taranaki is at top left. volcanism has greatly affected New Zealand’s landscape. Volcanoes Shuttle flight, STS-116, planned for launch in December. Part of the on STS-122 in October, and the Agency’s Automated Transfer Vehicle Mt. Ruapehu last erupted in 1995 and 1996; Mt. Taranaki is classed as have claimed more lives in the country than any other form of natural job will be done by ESA astronaut Christer Fuglesang during his two (ATV) will begin its delivery service some time during May–July dormant but it is still considered a risk. Their impressive landscapes disaster. South Island is at bottom left. spacewalks on that mission. STS-116 will also return ESA astronaut following launch by Ariane-5 from Kourou.

98 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 99 InBriefB128 11/9/06 3:38 PM Page 98

News In Brief

New Zealand’s dramatic landscape is captured by Envisat’s MERIS have attracted attention from film directors: Mt. Ruapehu was The current configuration of the International Space Station, after a Thomas Reiter, who has been working aboard the Station since 6 July, imaging spectrometer on 10 September at a resolution of 300 m. Two transformed into the fiery Mount Doom in ‘Lord of the Rings’, while second pair of 73 m-long solar wings (in shadow) was attached in to Earth. Next year will be a busy time for ESA and its astronauts at of the volcanoes on the North Island are visible as snow-capped Mt. Taranaki served as the setting for ‘The Last Samurai’. As almost all September by Shuttle mission STS-115. The new wings will double the Station: Paolo Nespoli will accompany Node-2 aboard STS-120 in circular features. Mount Ruapehu, the North Island’s tallest peak at volcanoes occur near tectonic plate boundaries, it is no surprise that the Station’s power when they are brought online during the next August, Hans Schlegel is scheduled to fly with the Columbus module 2797 m, is at top centre, while Mount Taranaki is at top left. volcanism has greatly affected New Zealand’s landscape. Volcanoes Shuttle flight, STS-116, planned for launch in December. Part of the on STS-122 in October, and the Agency’s Automated Transfer Vehicle Mt. Ruapehu last erupted in 1995 and 1996; Mt. Taranaki is classed as have claimed more lives in the country than any other form of natural job will be done by ESA astronaut Christer Fuglesang during his two (ATV) will begin its delivery service some time during May–July dormant but it is still considered a risk. Their impressive landscapes disaster. South Island is at bottom left. spacewalks on that mission. STS-116 will also return ESA astronaut following launch by Ariane-5 from Kourou.

98 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 99 InBriefB128 11/9/06 3:38 PM Page 100

News In Brief

A new Hubble image of the ‘Antennae’ galaxies is the sharpest yet of the two cores of the original galaxies, and consist mainly of old stars The fourth Ariane-5 success of the year. On 13 October, flight V173 engineering test satellite. The fifth and final Ariane-5 launch of the year this merging pair of spiral galaxies. As they smash together, thousand criss-crossed by filaments of dust. The two galaxies are dotted with from Kourou, French Guiana, delivered two commercial is planned for December. As with the others in 2006, it will use the of millions of stars are born, mostly in groups and clusters. The brilliant blue star-forming regions surrounded by pink hydrogen gas. telecommunications satellites safely into geostationary transfer orbit. ‘ECA’ version to carry two main passengers: the AMC-18 TV- galaxies started to fuse about 500 million years ago, making them the Only about 10% of the new super star clusters will live to see their ten DirectTV-9S will broadcast TV services to the USA, while Optus-D1 distribution satellite for SES Americom, and WildBlue-1 to handle Ka- nearest and youngest example of a pair of colliding galaxies. Nearly millionth birthday – most will disperse into individual stars but about will provide communications and TV services over Australia and New band Internet traffic. Ariane-5 ECA, with its large cryogenic upper half of the faint objects are young clusters containing tens of 100 of the largest will survive to become globular clusters as we see Zealand. The mission also carried Japan’s LDREX-2 to demonstrate stage, is the most powerful of the world’s commercial launchers. thousands of stars. The orange blobs to the left and right of centre are in our Galaxy today. (NASA/ESA/B. Whitmore, STScI) the deployment of a lightweight antenna planned for the ETS-8 (ESA-CNES-Arianespace/Photo Optique Video CSG)

100 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 101 InBriefB128 11/9/06 3:38 PM Page 100

News In Brief

A new Hubble image of the ‘Antennae’ galaxies is the sharpest yet of the two cores of the original galaxies, and consist mainly of old stars The fourth Ariane-5 success of the year. On 13 October, flight V173 engineering test satellite. The fifth and final Ariane-5 launch of the year this merging pair of spiral galaxies. As they smash together, thousand criss-crossed by filaments of dust. The two galaxies are dotted with from Kourou, French Guiana, delivered two commercial is planned for December. As with the others in 2006, it will use the of millions of stars are born, mostly in groups and clusters. The brilliant blue star-forming regions surrounded by pink hydrogen gas. telecommunications satellites safely into geostationary transfer orbit. ‘ECA’ version to carry two main passengers: the AMC-18 TV- galaxies started to fuse about 500 million years ago, making them the Only about 10% of the new super star clusters will live to see their ten DirectTV-9S will broadcast TV services to the USA, while Optus-D1 distribution satellite for SES Americom, and WildBlue-1 to handle Ka- nearest and youngest example of a pair of colliding galaxies. Nearly millionth birthday – most will disperse into individual stars but about will provide communications and TV services over Australia and New band Internet traffic. Ariane-5 ECA, with its large cryogenic upper half of the faint objects are young clusters containing tens of 100 of the largest will survive to become globular clusters as we see Zealand. The mission also carried Japan’s LDREX-2 to demonstrate stage, is the most powerful of the world’s commercial launchers. thousands of stars. The orange blobs to the left and right of centre are in our Galaxy today. (NASA/ESA/B. Whitmore, STScI) the deployment of a lightweight antenna planned for the ETS-8 (ESA-CNES-Arianespace/Photo Optique Video CSG)

100 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 101 PublicationsB128 11/9/06 4:47 PM Page 102

Publications New issues

The Changing Earth – New Scientific Proceedings of the 5th European Workshop on ESA CR(P)-4543 // CD ESA Brochures Challenges for ESA’s Living Planet Programme Thermal Protection Systems and Hot Price: 25 Euro (July 2006) Structures, 17–19 May 2006, Noordwijk, Cassini/Huygens – Uma Sonda para Titã – ESA Earth Observation Mission Science Division The Netherlands (August 2006) SAD-LP – Low Power Solar Array Drive Português (August 2006) (Ed. B. Battrick) K. Fletcher (Ed.) Development – Final Report (June 2005) B. Warmbein & A. Wilson (Eds.) ESA SP-1304 // 83 pp ESA SP-631 // CD Contraves Space ESA BR-228 // 30 pp Price: 20 Euro Price: 50 Euro ESA CR(X)-4537 // CD Price: 5 Euro Price: 25 Euro Proceedings of the First Workshop on Innovative Systems Concepts, 21 February Design Development and Test of a DIAL Laser 2006, Noordwijk, The Netherlands Transmitter – Final Report (December 2005) (August 2006) Galileo Avionica, Italy K. Fletcher (Ed.) ESA CR(P)-4538 // CD ESA SP-633 // 88 pp Price: 25 Euro Publications Price: 20 Euro GASP – Reflector Panel for Ground Station The documents listed here have Antennas Using the Nickel Replication ESA Scientific & Technical Technology – Summary Report (July 2002) been issued since the last Memoranda Media Lario publications announcement in the ESA CR(P)-4398 // 39 pp Price: 10 Euro ESA Bulletin. Requests for copies Service Support Environment Architecture, Model and Standards – White Paper should be made in accordance SkyKit Pre-Phase A – Final Report (2006) (April 2006) OHB System with the Table and Order Form B. Battrick (Ed.) ESA CR(P)-4547 // CD ESA STR-252 // 61 pp Price: 25 Euro inside the back cover Price: 20 Euro FACTS – Observation Techniques and Sensor Concepts for Observation of CO2 from Space ESA History Books – Final Report (2006) La France dans l’Espace 1959-1979 IPSL-LMD, France Proceedings of the Symposium on 15 Years of Contribution à l’effort spatial européen ESA CR(P)-4544 // CD Progress in Radar Altimetry, 13–18 March (June 2006) Price: 25 Euro 2006, Venice, Italy (July 2006) H. Lacoste (Ed.) D. Danesy (Ed.) ESA HSR-37 // 110 pp Ultrafast On-Board Processor for Meshed ESA Special Publications ESA SP-614 // CD Price: 20 Euro Packet Networks – Final Report Price: 60 Euro (January 2006) Biomimetic Engineering for Space Applications EADS Astrium (August 2006) Proceedings of the Second Working Meeting ESA Contractor Reports ESA CR(P)-4542 // CD K. Fletcher (Ed.) on MERIS and AATSR Calibration and Price: 25 Euro ESA SP-1297 // 310 pp Geophysical Validation (MAVT-2006), 20–24 GPS-AODS Demonstrator – Final Report Price: 40 Euro March 2006, ESRIN, Frascati, Italy (July 2006) EADS Astrium Development of a 89.5-litre Helium Pressurant D. Danesy (Ed.) ESA CR(P)-4539 // CD Tank – Final Report (January 2006) ESA SP-615 // CD Price: 25 Euro EADS Space Transportation Price: 30 Euro ESA CR(P)-4540 // CD Satellite Based Alarm and Surveillance Price: 25 Euro Proceedings of SOHO 17 – 10 Years of SOHO System – Executive Summary (March 2006) and Beyond, 7–12 May 2006, Giardini Naxos, MediaMobil, Germany WALOPACK – Final Report (February 2005) Sicily, Italy (July 2006) ESA CR(P)-4546 // CD 3D Plus, France H. Lacoste (Ed.) Price: 25 Euro ESA CR(P)-4545 // CD ESA SP-617 // CD Price: 25 Euro Price: 60 Euro Generic Launch Window Optimisation (GELO) – Executive Summary (February 2006) MMSA – Multiband Multibeam Conformal Proceedings of the 1st EPS/MetOp RAO SciSys, UK Antennas for Vehicular Mobile Satellite Workshop, 15–17 May 2006, ESRIN, Frascati, ESA CR(P)-4548 // CD Systems – Executive Summary Italy (August 2006) Price: 25 Euro Jast Antenna Systems D. Danesy (Ed.) ESA CR(P)-4541 // CD ESA SP-618 // CD L-Band Array – Final Report (January 2006) Price: 25 Euro Price: 30 Euro Rymsa ESA CR(P)-4549 // CD EODIS – Final Report (November 2005) Proceedings of the 3rd MSG RAO Workshop, Price: 25 Euro Telbios 5 June 2006, Helsinki, Finland (August 2006) ESA CR(P)-4536 // 32 pp D. Danesy (Ed.) GAIA – Mirror 5DOF Positioning Mechanism Price: 10 Euro e ESA SP-619 // CD M2M – Final Report (March 2006) Price: 30 Euro Sener

102 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 103 PublicationsB128 11/9/06 4:47 PM Page 102

Publications New issues

The Changing Earth – New Scientific Proceedings of the 5th European Workshop on ESA CR(P)-4543 // CD ESA Brochures Challenges for ESA’s Living Planet Programme Thermal Protection Systems and Hot Price: 25 Euro (July 2006) Structures, 17–19 May 2006, Noordwijk, Cassini/Huygens – Uma Sonda para Titã – ESA Earth Observation Mission Science Division The Netherlands (August 2006) SAD-LP – Low Power Solar Array Drive Português (August 2006) (Ed. B. Battrick) K. Fletcher (Ed.) Development – Final Report (June 2005) B. Warmbein & A. Wilson (Eds.) ESA SP-1304 // 83 pp ESA SP-631 // CD Contraves Space ESA BR-228 // 30 pp Price: 20 Euro Price: 50 Euro ESA CR(X)-4537 // CD Price: 5 Euro Price: 25 Euro Proceedings of the First Workshop on Innovative Systems Concepts, 21 February Design Development and Test of a DIAL Laser 2006, Noordwijk, The Netherlands Transmitter – Final Report (December 2005) (August 2006) Galileo Avionica, Italy K. Fletcher (Ed.) ESA CR(P)-4538 // CD ESA SP-633 // 88 pp Price: 25 Euro Publications Price: 20 Euro GASP – Reflector Panel for Ground Station The documents listed here have Antennas Using the Nickel Replication ESA Scientific & Technical Technology – Summary Report (July 2002) been issued since the last Memoranda Media Lario publications announcement in the ESA CR(P)-4398 // 39 pp Price: 10 Euro ESA Bulletin. Requests for copies Service Support Environment Architecture, Model and Standards – White Paper should be made in accordance SkyKit Pre-Phase A – Final Report (2006) (April 2006) OHB System with the Table and Order Form B. Battrick (Ed.) ESA CR(P)-4547 // CD ESA STR-252 // 61 pp Price: 25 Euro inside the back cover Price: 20 Euro FACTS – Observation Techniques and Sensor Concepts for Observation of CO2 from Space ESA History Books – Final Report (2006) La France dans l’Espace 1959-1979 IPSL-LMD, France Proceedings of the Symposium on 15 Years of Contribution à l’effort spatial européen ESA CR(P)-4544 // CD Progress in Radar Altimetry, 13–18 March (June 2006) Price: 25 Euro 2006, Venice, Italy (July 2006) H. Lacoste (Ed.) D. Danesy (Ed.) ESA HSR-37 // 110 pp Ultrafast On-Board Processor for Meshed ESA Special Publications ESA SP-614 // CD Price: 20 Euro Packet Networks – Final Report Price: 60 Euro (January 2006) Biomimetic Engineering for Space Applications EADS Astrium (August 2006) Proceedings of the Second Working Meeting ESA Contractor Reports ESA CR(P)-4542 // CD K. Fletcher (Ed.) on MERIS and AATSR Calibration and Price: 25 Euro ESA SP-1297 // 310 pp Geophysical Validation (MAVT-2006), 20–24 GPS-AODS Demonstrator – Final Report Price: 40 Euro March 2006, ESRIN, Frascati, Italy (July 2006) EADS Astrium Development of a 89.5-litre Helium Pressurant D. Danesy (Ed.) ESA CR(P)-4539 // CD Tank – Final Report (January 2006) ESA SP-615 // CD Price: 25 Euro EADS Space Transportation Price: 30 Euro ESA CR(P)-4540 // CD Satellite Based Alarm and Surveillance Price: 25 Euro Proceedings of SOHO 17 – 10 Years of SOHO System – Executive Summary (March 2006) and Beyond, 7–12 May 2006, Giardini Naxos, MediaMobil, Germany WALOPACK – Final Report (February 2005) Sicily, Italy (July 2006) ESA CR(P)-4546 // CD 3D Plus, France H. Lacoste (Ed.) Price: 25 Euro ESA CR(P)-4545 // CD ESA SP-617 // CD Price: 25 Euro Price: 60 Euro Generic Launch Window Optimisation (GELO) – Executive Summary (February 2006) MMSA – Multiband Multibeam Conformal Proceedings of the 1st EPS/MetOp RAO SciSys, UK Antennas for Vehicular Mobile Satellite Workshop, 15–17 May 2006, ESRIN, Frascati, ESA CR(P)-4548 // CD Systems – Executive Summary Italy (August 2006) Price: 25 Euro Jast Antenna Systems D. Danesy (Ed.) ESA CR(P)-4541 // CD ESA SP-618 // CD L-Band Array – Final Report (January 2006) Price: 25 Euro Price: 30 Euro Rymsa ESA CR(P)-4549 // CD EODIS – Final Report (November 2005) Proceedings of the 3rd MSG RAO Workshop, Price: 25 Euro Telbios 5 June 2006, Helsinki, Finland (August 2006) ESA CR(P)-4536 // 32 pp D. Danesy (Ed.) GAIA – Mirror 5DOF Positioning Mechanism Price: 10 Euro e ESA SP-619 // CD M2M – Final Report (March 2006) Price: 30 Euro Sener

102 esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 www.esa.int www.esa.int esa bulletin 128 - november 2006 103