DOCSLIB.ORG

On the Trail of Comets

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text

Load more

Issue 10 – March 2006 On the trail of comets The frontispiece to Hevelius’ great work on comets, the Cometographia (published in Danzig in 1668) showing rival theories about the origin and motion of comets. On the left Aristotle demonstrates his theory that comets are terrestrial exhalations that have ascended to the upper atmosphere. On the right Kepler suggests that comets move in straight lines. Seated in the middle Hevelius expounds his own theory that comets are expelled from the turbulent atmospheres of Jupiter and Saturn and move in curved paths. The history of the study of comets was discussed at the start of the recent RAS Discussion Meeting on Comets: From Antiquity to the Present Day. This meeting had been arranged to celebrate the tercentenary of the publication of Edmond Halley’s Synopsis of the Astronomy of Comets in 1705. A report appears inside. (Illustration courtesy of the Library of the Royal Observatory Edinburgh). Editorial Clive Davenhall Issues of the Newsletter do not King George V, recently ascended articles for publication. usually have a theme. However, to the throne following the death of Contributions are always welcome more by chance than design, two of Edward VII. The Jamaican dockers and details of how to submit them the articles in this issue are about were convinced that the change was are included on the back page, and comets. Comets have long been a portent that the new King’s reign are also on the Society’s Web site. considered harbingers of doom, would be marked by war. Since We look forward to hearing from though in Classical Antiquity they George V ruled from 1910 to 1936 you. were also thought to mark the soul this prediction, however accidental, of a departed prince rising to proved only too accurate. Heaven (an idea consistent with notions of eschatology in later pagan In this issue Bruce Harper describes Antiquity). Ever the skilled the rather more rational welcome propagandist, Augustus Caesar that the 1910 apparition of comet interpreted the comet of 44 BC as Halley received from the inhabitants the ascendant soul of Julius Caesar, of Ipswich, Queensland and we also thus legitimising his own rule and carry a report on the historical deflecting concern that it augured ill. aspects of the recent RAS Ironically enough, Augustus’ Discussion Meeting about comets. eventual murder in AD 14 was heralded by a blood-red comet. Issue 2 of the Society’s journal, the Antiquarian Astronomer, was Such superstitions might seem far distributed in December and has from our own time. However, as been very well received. Also, some recently as 1910 comet Halley members have been kind enough to The obverse of a silver denarius issued by Augustus Caesar around 19-18 BC caused a similar scare. Dock compliment recent issues of the showing the comet of the ‘Divine Julius’ workers in Bermuda saw the Newsletter. The success and, indeed, (reproduced from The Star of Bethlehem comet’s tail briefly turn red during a continuance, of both publications by Michael R. Molnar, 1999, Rutgers 101-gun salute to honour the new depends on us continuing to receive Univ. Press) Society news Stuart Williams and Clive Davenhall February Council meeting in this very productive meeting, which meeting should contact the London sat from 1pm – 5.30pm. Chairman, Gilbert Satterthwaite. A meeting of the Council of the SHA Council meetings in Society events and SHA was held on 11 February 2006. 2006 meetings for 2006 Thanks to the kind permission of Mr David Elliott, Executive Secretary of Following the February Council As usual, the SHA has an excellent the Royal Astronomical Society, and meeting, future SHA Council programme of meetings and events the helpful assistance of RAS meetings will take place as follows: for the remainder of 2006, Librarian and SHA Councillor Peter 20 May AGM at IOA Cambridge; comprising the Spring Conference Hingley, the meeting took place in 29 July 1pm Yorkshire Museum and and AGM, Summer Picnic and the Herschel Room on the historic 25 November 1pm Sir Robert Ball Autumn Conference. The theme of premises of the Royal Astronomical Library, Birmingham. the Spring Conference is Women in Society in Burlington House, Astronomy and that of the Autumn Piccadilly, London. Apart from the AGM, space is very Conference Instruments and limited at these meetings, which are Imaging. Before the meeting, Council was not general Society meetings, so if able to view a number of fine any member wishes to present a The Summer Picnic will be held at original books and documents from matter to Council in person, they ‘Farthings,’ the home and the RAS Library, including works should apply in advance to the observatory of SHA Honorary Vice by Cassini and Huygens, and notes Secretary, Stuart Williams. Anyone President Sir Patrick Moore. The made by William Herschel. Much of wishing to table an agenda item at Society is extremely grateful to Sir the following news originates from the AGM or any other Council Patrick for his continuing generous SHA Newsletter – Issue 10 Page 2 March 2006 and practical support. Further details of all the events can be found in Forthcoming Meetings and Events on p22. A flyer for the Spring Conference and AGM should be enclosed with this Newsletter. Thanks for early renewals SHA Treasurer Ken Goward announced at February’s Council meeting that subscriptions were being renewed at a much more satisfactory rate this year, and thanks are offered to those members who have done so, as well as encouragement to those who have not! It is essential that members renew as soon as possible each year Councillors inspect material from the RAS Library before the recent Council meeting. in order that the Society may From left to Right: Martin Lunn, Ken Goward, Roger Jones, Reg Withey, Gilbert balance its cash-flow. If you have Satterthwaite and Peter Hingley not paid your 2006 subscription yet, please remember your membership has been renamed the Survey of up to date, and although this can will lapse at the end of March. Astronomical History, following the sometimes be difficult, it is hoped to February Council meeting, where it do so in more timely fashion in Publications success was decided that a more concise future, as and when new information appellation would be beneficial. is generated. SHA Secretary Stuart Thanks to excellent editorial Another benefit of this shorter title Williams was also recently teamwork combined with the is that it opens the Survey to approached to provide a profile of assistance of our printers, Parchment overseas members. A corner of the the SHA for the popular magazine of Oxford, and mailing organised by Sir Robert Ball Library at the BBC Sky at Night, and it is hoped Peter Hingley, the second issue of Birmingham & Midland Institute that this will highlight the Society in The Antiquarian Astronomer and has now been set up as the HQ of the March issue. ninth edition of the Newsletter were the Survey. A number of county sent out promptly before Christmas, binders have been filled with the SHA publicity leaflet which was a great present to all current data collection by SHA those members whose postmen were Councillor Roger Jones, organiser of A new publicity leaflet bearing an on the ball over the festive season! the Survey. The original Windows endorsement from Sir Patrick Moore Good progress is already being PC donated by the BMI will be together with a photograph of him made with issue three of The primarily dedicated to SHA Survey and details of various Society Antiquarian Astronomer edited by work. Members interested in joining activities has been designed by Reg Withey and Kevin Johnson. the Survey should contact Roger Stuart Williams and is aimed at Jones directly (contact details on the recruiting new members across the Our highly acclaimed publications back page). UK. It is hoped to make the new have become one of the most leaflet, which is being printed in important reasons for joining the SHA publicity colour, available for download from SHA, and Council is delighted that the SHA Web site shortly. production is now both timely and Since the last issue of the of a high standard. If you think that Newsletter, SHA Councillor Martin Temporary closure of RAS you are missing any copies of Lunn has been working busily as our apartments Society publications please contact new Publicity Officer. Several items the Secretary Stuart Williams have appeared in recent magazines SHA Councillor and RAS Librarian (contact details on the back page). as a result, but Martin is still keen to Peter Hingley has reported that the emphasise the need to continue to apartments of the RAS, including Survey renamed and publicise our existence and the Library, will be closed later this facilities enhanced activities, and all members are year for about twelve months for encouraged to tell their friends, complete refurbishment and The SHA’s Survey of the colleagues and societies about the rearrangement of the interior. See Astronomical Geography of the UK, SHA and its work. It is also essential p22 for further details. one of our most important projects, the our Web site be kept regularly SHA Newsletter – Issue 10 Page 3 March 2006 London Planetarium to Commander Antony Compass Observatory (ACO) at close Fanning MBE, DSC, FRAS Slough and was soon promoted to Deputy Director. Commander With deep regret we report the death Fanning became an accomplished on 29 December 2005 of SHA practical astronomer and historian, founder member Commander and wrote several books, most Antony Fanning. Commander notably Steady as She Goes (1986), Fanning had a distinguished record a history of the ACO.
Recommended publications
  • Imaginative Geographies of Mars: the Science and Significance of the Red Planet, 1877 - 1910

    Imaginative Geographies of Mars: the Science and Significance of the Red Planet, 1877 - 1910

    Copyright by Kristina Maria Doyle Lane 2006 The Dissertation Committee for Kristina Maria Doyle Lane Certifies that this is the approved version of the following dissertation: IMAGINATIVE GEOGRAPHIES OF MARS: THE SCIENCE AND SIGNIFICANCE OF THE RED PLANET, 1877 - 1910 Committee: Ian R. Manners, Supervisor Kelley A. Crews-Meyer Diana K. Davis Roger Hart Steven D. Hoelscher Imaginative Geographies of Mars: The Science and Significance of the Red Planet, 1877 - 1910 by Kristina Maria Doyle Lane, B.A.; M.S.C.R.P. Dissertation Presented to the Faculty of the Graduate School of The University of Texas at Austin in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy The University of Texas at Austin August 2006 Dedication This dissertation is dedicated to Magdalena Maria Kost, who probably never would have understood why it had to be written and certainly would not have wanted to read it, but who would have been very proud nonetheless. Acknowledgments This dissertation would have been impossible without the assistance of many extremely capable and accommodating professionals. For patiently guiding me in the early research phases and then responding to countless followup email messages, I would like to thank Antoinette Beiser and Marty Hecht of the Lowell Observatory Library and Archives at Flagstaff. For introducing me to the many treasures held deep underground in our nation’s capital, I would like to thank Pam VanEe and Ed Redmond of the Geography and Map Division of the Library of Congress in Washington, D.C. For welcoming me during two brief but productive visits to the most beautiful library I have seen, I thank Brenda Corbin and Gregory Shelton of the U.S.
  • AST101 Lecture 17 Barsoom

    AST101 Lecture 17 Barsoom

    AST101 Lecture 17 Barsoom There are 4 Terrestrial Planets • Mercury • Venus • Earth • Mars Mercury From the Messenger Orbiter, March 2011. Rayed crater: Debussy Venus From the Venus Express, 2007. H2SO4 clouds Earth (Terra) Apollo 17 Mars Hubble Space Telescope Barsoom A world like our own? Populated by aliens? Telescopic Observations Mars is dynamic • Polar caps wax and wane • Surface features change shape regularly • Clouds obscure the surface Giovanni Schiaparelli Published a map of Mars in 1877 Identified surface features he called “canali” Schiaparelli’s Mars Percival Lowell Mistranslated “canali” (channels) as canals Established Lowell Observatory on Mars Hill, Flagstaff AZ Lowell’s map of Mars (excerpt) Lowell’s Mars Canals imply • intelligent life, and • deliberate construction Lowell created a Mars that is • a dying planet, • whose intelligent denizens built canals – to collect the melting polar ice, and – to distribute the water among the oases Camille Flammarion (1884) Chesley Bonestell: Surface of Mars © Bonestell Space Art No one would have believed in the last years of the nineteenth century that this world was being watched keenly and closely by intelligences greater than man's and yet as mortal as his own; that as men busied themselves about their various concerns they were scrutinised and studied, perhaps almost as narrowly as a man with a microscope might scrutinise the transient creatures that swarm and multiply in a drop of water. H. G. WELLS THE WAR OF THE WORLDS Illusions of Mars. I. This mythos arose from two optical illusions. 1. The human brain tends to connect the dots, which results in apparent linear features.
  • Call to Let the People Decide New Place Names on Mercury and Pluto 20 April 2015, by Alice Gorman

    Call to Let the People Decide New Place Names on Mercury and Pluto 20 April 2015, by Alice Gorman

    Call to let the people decide new place names on Mercury and Pluto 20 April 2015, by Alice Gorman choose the new place-names. Mapping our celestial neighbours How do places in the solar system get named? We already use the names of gods and goddesses given by the Romans, over 2,000 years ago, to the most visible planets: Mercury, Venus, Mars, Jupiter and Saturn. The existence of Pluto, Uranus and Neptune wasn't known until much later; but they were similarly Artist’s impression of NASA’s New Horizons spacecraft named after classical deities. encountering Pluto and its largest moon, Charon. Credit: NASA/Applied Physics Laboratory/Southwest Research Planetary geography really kicked off with the Institute invention of telescopes in the 17th century. Celestial places were being mapped by European astronomers at the same time as places on the Earth, in the era of European colonial expansion. Do you think a place on Pluto should be named after the sinister tentacle-faced monster Cthulhu The lunar maria ("seas"), mountains and craters from the novels of horror writer H.P. Lovecraft? Or familiar to us today were mapped by the first real a crater on Mercury after iconic opera singer Dame selenographer (charter of the moon), the Dutch Nellie Melba? astronomer Michael van Langren, in 1645. (Incidentally, he also made the first known Mercury and Pluto are at the opposite ends of the statistical graph). solar system, but this year, as a result of two extraordinary space missions, some of their newly His place names were mostly European royalty and observed topographical features will receive notable scientists of the time.
  • Schiaparelli and His Legacy. TABLE of CONTENTS

    Schiaparelli and His Legacy. TABLE of CONTENTS

    MEMORIE DELLA SOCIETA` ASTRONOMICA ITALIANA Vol.82 n.2 2011 Schiaparelli and his legacy. Milan, 19-20 October, Turin 21 October 2010 editors: G. Trinchieri, and A. Manara TABLE OF CONTENTS Index 203 Foreword 206 Session I: Life and science of Schiaparelli A. Manara, G. Trinchieri Schiaparelli and his legacy 209 G. Giorello, L. Guzzardi G.V. Schiaparelli: from scientific observations to scientific imagination 219 G. Berlucchi Some historical crossroads between astronomy and visual neuroscience 225 A. Ferrari Between two Halley’s comet visits 232 P. Tucci The Diary of Schiaparelli in Berlin (26 October 1857-10 May 1859): a guide for his future scientific activity 240 Victor K. Abalakin Some remarks on preparations for Giovanni Virginio Schiaparelli’s journey to Russia 248 S. Bianchi, D. Galli, A. Gasperini G. V. Schiaparelli and the Arcetri Observatory 253 S. Maffeo, S.J G.V. Schiaparelli and Fr. A. Secchi, S.J. 259 S. Debarbat´ Schiaparelli and French astronomers 268 204 A. Manara, A. Wolter Mars in the Schiaparelli−Lowell letters 276 E. Antonello Schiaparelli and the dawn of astronomy 280 S. De Meis A few aspects of Schiaparelli’s studies 290 Session II: Modern planetary science A. Cellino and A. Dell’Oro Minor bodies: small actors in Solar System’s history 300 T. J. Jopek Meteoroid streams and their parent bodies 310 A. Coradini and R. Orosei The exploration of Mars: past and future 321 C.R. Perotti and M. Rinaldi Mars and Earth topography: a preliminary comparative analysis 334 D. Lupishko,V. Kaydash and Yu. Shkuratov Global dust storms and highly polarizing clouds on Mars 341 V.
  • 02. Solar System (2001) 9/4/01 12:28 PM Page 2

    02. Solar System (2001) 9/4/01 12:28 PM Page 2

    01. Solar System Cover 9/4/01 12:18 PM Page 1 National Aeronautics and Educational Product Space Administration Educators Grades K–12 LS-2001-08-002-HQ Solar System Lithograph Set for Space Science This set contains the following lithographs: • Our Solar System • Moon • Saturn • Our Star—The Sun • Mars • Uranus • Mercury • Asteroids • Neptune • Venus • Jupiter • Pluto and Charon • Earth • Moons of Jupiter • Comets 01. Solar System Cover 9/4/01 12:18 PM Page 2 NASA’s Central Operation of Resources for Educators Regional Educator Resource Centers offer more educators access (CORE) was established for the national and international distribution of to NASA educational materials. NASA has formed partnerships with universities, NASA-produced educational materials in audiovisual format. Educators can museums, and other educational institutions to serve as regional ERCs in many obtain a catalog and an order form by one of the following methods: States. A complete list of regional ERCs is available through CORE, or electroni- cally via NASA Spacelink at http://spacelink.nasa.gov/ercn NASA CORE Lorain County Joint Vocational School NASA’s Education Home Page serves as a cyber-gateway to informa- 15181 Route 58 South tion regarding educational programs and services offered by NASA for the Oberlin, OH 44074-9799 American education community. This high-level directory of information provides Toll-free Ordering Line: 1-866-776-CORE specific details and points of contact for all of NASA’s educational efforts, Field Toll-free FAX Line: 1-866-775-1460 Center offices, and points of presence within each State. Visit this resource at the E-mail: [email protected] following address: http://education.nasa.gov Home Page: http://core.nasa.gov NASA Spacelink is one of NASA’s electronic resources specifically devel- Educator Resource Center Network (ERCN) oped for the educational community.
  • The Rosetta Mission: Flying Towards the Origin of the Solar System

    The Rosetta Mission: Flying Towards the Origin of the Solar System

    THE ROSETTA MISSION: FLYING TOWARDS THE ORIGIN OF THE SOLAR SYSTEM KARL-HEINZ GLASSMEIER1, HERMANN BOEHNHARDT2, DETLEF KOSCHNY3, EKKEHARD KUHRT¨ 4 and INGO RICHTER5 1Institut fur¨ Geophysik und extraterrestrische Physik, Technische Universitat¨ Braunschweig, Mendelssohnstrasse 3, D-38106 Braunschweig, Germany 2Max-Planck-Institut fur¨ Sonnensystemforschung, Lindau, Germany 3Research and Scientific Support Department, ESA/ESTEC, Noordwijk, The Netherlands 4Institut fur¨ Planetenforschung, Deutsches Zentrum fur¨ Luft- und Raumfahrt, Berlin, Germany 5Technische Universitat¨ zu Braunschweig, Germany (∗Author for correspondence: E-mail: [email protected]) (Received 16 November 2006; Accepted in final form 12 December 2006) Abstract. The ROSETTA Mission, the Planetary Cornerstone Mission in the European Space Agency’s long-term programme Horizon 2000, will rendezvous in 2014 with comet 67P/Churyumov- Gerasimenko close to its aphelion and will study the physical and chemical properties of the nucleus, the evolution of the coma during the comet’s approach to the Sun, and the development of the in- teraction region of the solar wind and the comet, for more than one year until it reaches perihelion. In addition to the investigations performed by the scientific instruments on board the orbiter, the ROSETTA lander PHILAE will be deployed onto the surface of the nucleus. On its way to comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko, ROSETTA will fly by and study the two asteroids 2867 Steins and 21 Lutetia. Keywords: ROSETTA, solar system, comets, asteroids 1. Introduction The International ROSETTA Mission, approved in November 1993 by the Science Programme Committee of the European Space Agency (ESA), is the planetary cornerstone mission in ESA’s long-term programme Horizon 2000 (Bonnet, 1985).
  • Meet the Planets Table of Contents

    Meet the Planets Table of Contents

    Teaching Activity Guide Meet the Planets Table of Contents 3 How to Use This Activity Guide 4 What Do Children Already Know? 4 Pre-Reading Questions 5 Thinking It Through & Writing Prompts 5 Comprehension Questions 6 Find in the Art 8 People of History in the Art 11 Vocabulary Game 11 Using the Words 12 Silly Sentence Structure Activity 13 Sequence Sentence Strips 15 Word Search 16 Solar System Cards 21 Rotation or Revolution? 22 Science Journal 24 True or False? 25 Which Planet? 26 Temperatures 27 Scale and Distance 30 Coloring Pages 33 Glossary 39 Answers 51 Appendix A—“What Children Know” Cards 52 Appendix B—Venn Diagram 53 Appendix C—Vocabulary Cards Copyright 2011 © Arbordale Publishing These activities may be copied for personal and non-commercial use in educational settings. www.ArbordalePublishing.com Arbordale Publishing formerly Sylvan Dell Publishing by John McGranaghan Mt. Pleasant, SC 29464 illustrated by Laurie Allen Klein How to Use This Activity Guide There are a wide variety of activities that teach or supplement all curricular areas. The activities are easily adapted up or down depending on the age and abilities of the children involved. And, it is easy to pick and choose what is appropriate for your setting and the time involved. Most activities can be done with an individual child or a group of children. Glossary/Vocabulary words: Words may be written on index cards, a poster board, or on a chalkboard for a “word wall.” If writing on poster board or chalkboard, you might want to sort words into nouns, verbs, etc.
  • Encke's Minima and Encke's Division in Saturn's A-Ring

    Encke's Minima and Encke's Division in Saturn's A-Ring

    ENCKE’S MINIMA AND ENCKE’S DIVISION IN SATURN’S A-RING Pedro Ré http://astrosurf.com/re When viewed with the aid of a good quality telescope Saturn is undoubtedly one of the most spectacular objects in the sky. Many amateur astronomers (including the author) say that their first observation of Saturn turned them on to astronomy. Saturn’s rings are easily visible with a good 60 mm refractor at 50x. The 3D appearance of this planet is what makes it so interesting. Details in the rings can be seen during moments of good seeing. The Cassini division (between ring A and B) is easily visible with moderate apertures. The Encke minima and Encke division are more difficult to observe and require large apertures and telescopes of excellent optical quality. These two features can be observed in Saturn’s A-Ring. The Encke minima consists of a broad, low contrast feature located about halfway out in the middle of the A-Ring. The Encke division is a narrow, high contrast feature located near the outer edge of the A-Ring. Unlike the Encke minima, the Encke division is an actual division of the ring (Figure 1). Figure 1- Saturn near Opposition on June 11, 2017. D. Peach, E. Kraaikamp, F. Colas, M. Delcroix, R. Hueso, G. Thérin, C. Sprianu, S2P, IMCCE, OMP. The Encke division is visible around the entire outer A ring. Astronomy Picture of the Day (20170617) https://apod.nasa.gov/apod/ap170617.html 1 Galileo Galilei observed the disk Saturn for the first time using one of his largest refractor.
  • Mapping the Planet Mars by Philip Corneille

    Mapping the Planet Mars by Philip Corneille

    Planetary exploration Spaceflight Vol 47 July 2005 Mapping the planet Mars by Philip Corneille Ancient Babylonian clay tablets depicted the Earth as a flat circular disk but both Roman, Greek and Arab empires’ cartographers were more interested in producing celestial globes rather than terrestrial. The first terrestrial globe was produced by Crates of Mallos, around 150 BC, and the earliest surviving Earth globe was produced by Martin Behaim in 1492. However, it lasted until the 20th century when the first photos of Earth from space to produce the most accurate terrestrial globes. Since then mankind’s attention has turned to the planets. Mars before the space age The planet Mars, named after the Roman god of war, is fourth in order of distance from the Sun and seventh in order of size and mass. The astronomical symbol for Mars, represents a shield with a spear. The so- called red planet is slightly more than half the size of Earth but the lack of oceans gives it the same landmass as Earth. Mars has no Lowell observatory – Flagstaff Arizona plate motion and its rotational axis is inclined to the ecliptic, like Earth’s. The planet Mars globe (top) made by completes an elliptical orbit around the Sun Percival Lowell in 1911, in 687 days and spins on its axis with a based on his observations. It period of 24 hours 37 minutes. This period is shows the ‘canals’ in the named a ‘sol’ or Martian solar day. It has two area of Elysium planitia and moons, Phobos (Fear) and Deimos (Terror), Utopia planitia and (above) named after the mythical chariot horses of Mars photo-frames show the Mars.
  • 7 Mapping the Heavens

    7 Mapping the Heavens

    7 Mapping the Heavens Astronomy rather than natural philosophy was the eighteenth- century science. It was the science that set the standard to which others aspired. The phenomenal success of Newton’s Principia in setting the study of celestial motions on an apparently se- cure and certain mathematical footing had made astronomy the archetypal science. Newton’s triumph in reducing the night sky’s complexities to a simple law set the standard for achievement throughout natural philosophy. There were other reasons for astronomy’s high status as well. As Europe’s maritime nations squabbled over conquered territories in the New World and the Indies, mastery over the seas became crucial. Solving the prob- lem of longitude—to be able to know one’s position on the high seas with precision—was essential and astronomy seemed to be the key.Observatories were founded to map the sky with increas- ing accuracy. Expeditions set out to study celestial phenomena from outposts of empire—with the aim of positioning those out- posts more securely on the terrestrial globe. William Herschel’s discovery of Uranus demonstrated the power of new telescopes to push back the frontiers of the unseen. Herschel’s ambition was to produce a natural history of the heavens—to produce a map of the skies that charted each celestial object and put it securely in its place. Astronomy’s high status and evident utility at the end of the eighteenth century meant that it was one of the few sciences to attract substantial state patronage. As such, it was a 192 Mapping the Heavens 193 fruit ripe for the picking to ambitious young radicals as the new century commenced.
  • Venusians: the Planet Venus in the 18Th-Century Extraterrestrial Life Debate

    Venusians: the Planet Venus in the 18Th-Century Extraterrestrial Life Debate

    MEETING VENUS C. Sterken, P. P. Aspaas (Eds.) The Journal of Astronomical Data 19, 1, 2013 Venusians: the Planet Venus in the 18th-Century Extraterrestrial Life Debate David Dun´er1,2 1History of Science and Ideas, Lund University, Biskopsgatan 7, 223 62 Lund, Sweden 2Centre for Cognitive Semiotics, Lund University, Sweden Abstract. In the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries it became possible to believe in the existence of life on other planets on scientific grounds. Once the Earth was no longer the center of the universe according to Copernicus, once Galileo had aimed his telescope at the Moon and found it a rough globe with mountains and seas, the assumption of life on other planets became much less far-fetched. In general there were no actual differences between Earth and Venus, since both planets orbited the Sun, were of similar size, and possessed mountains and an atmosphere. If there is life on Earth, one may ponder why it could not also exist on Venus. In the extraterrestrial life debate of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, the Moon, our closest celestial body, was the prime candidate for life on other worlds, although a number of scientists and scholars also speculated about life on Venus and on other planets, both within our solar system and beyond its frontiers. This chapter discusses the arguments for life on Venus and those scientific findings that were used to support them, which were based in particular on assumptions and claims that both mountains and an atmosphere had been found on Venus. The transits of Venus in the 1760s became especially important for the notion that life could thrive on Venus.
  • An Abstract of the Dissertation Of

    An Abstract of the Dissertation Of

    AN ABSTRACT OF THE DISSERTATION OF Emily M. Simpson for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in History of Science presented on June 12, 2018. Title: Mars and Popular Astronomy, 1890-1910 Abstract approved: ______________________________________________________________________ Jacob D. Hamblin Beginning in the late-nineteenth century, several dialogues emerged concerning life on Mars. Some supported the notion of an inhabited Mars, citing recent observations of the planet, while others, pointing to a lack of concrete evidence, denied the validity of such a bold hypothesis. The dialogues within and between different groups focused on three primary topics: the existence of artificial canals on Mars, evaluation of scientific values, and methods to contact Mars from Earth. Scientists and science popularizers recognized the power of popular media to legitimate and perpetuate their interpretations of Mars and employed several tools to promote their ideas, especially when those ideas proved controversial. These methods were the use of environmental conditions as scientific authority, the creation of popular public identities, and promotion of the power of technology to discover hidden truths of the universe. Mars and Popular Astronomy draws upon resources in several manuscript and correspondence collections from archives housed at Lowell Observatory, Caltech, Huntington Library, and University of California, Santa Cruz. This study also relies on contemporary newspapers and popular magazines. When pieced together, these documents reveal the tactics that scientists and science popularizers used in their efforts to define, create, and control popular science. They also show how competing interests overlapped and how participants in the debates grappled with definitions of scientific authority and the parameters for responsibility and accountability in science communication.