DOCSLIB.ORG

Planning for Wind Power: a Study of Public Engagement in Uddevalla, Sweden

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Planning for Wind Power: a Study of Public Engagement in Uddevalla, Sweden Planning for Wind Power: A Study of Public Engagement in Uddevalla, Sweden by Michael Friesen A Thesis submitted to the Faculty of Graduate Studies of The University of Manitoba In partial fulfilment of the requirements of the degree of MASTER OF CITY PLANNING Faculty of Architecture, Department of City Planning Winnipeg, MB Copyright © 2014 by Mike Friesen Abstract Despite seemingly widespread support, wind power initiatives often experience controversial development processes that may result in project delays or cancelations. Wind power planning – often derided for ignoring the concerns of local residents – is ideally positioned to engage citizens in determining if and where development may be appropriate. Following the process of a dialogue based landscape analysis in Uddevalla, Sweden, the research endeavours to better understand the ties between landscape and attitudes towards wind power, how concerned parties express these attitudes, and how these attitudes may change through public engagement. In contrast to many existing quantitative studies, the research uses one-on-one interviews with participants of the planning processes to provide a rich qualitative resource for the exploration of the topic. Five themes emerging from the interviews and their analysis, are explored in depth. These themes include: landscape form and function; the expression of public attitudes; changing attitudes; frustration with politicians and processes; and engagement and representation. Consideration is also given to landscape analysis as a method, wind power and planning in the Canadian context, and planning theory. The research indicates that attitudes towards wind power development are tied to planning processes, specifically: that the collective landscape shapes values and attitudes, is developed through discourse, and is composed of competing visions; that when formal avenues of discourse are closed, citizens will self-organize to exert political pressure with potentially damaging side-effects on relationships within the community; and that planning, when directed towards recognising and addressing concerns, can generate positive outcomes concerning attitudes towards wind power. Through engagement processes that embrace the multifaceted nature of landscape, value qualitative factors, are fair and transparent, better localize the benefits of development, and generate unique place-based policies, it is possible to acknowledge and address local concerns while still achieving global renewable energy goals. The research findings and recommendations are expected to be of interest to municipalities, citizens, and renewable energy developers to help form a shared and democratic sustainable energy future. Key words: landscape planning, renewable energy, community engagement, public attitudes, sustainability, landscape character assessment (LCA), NIMBY (Not In My Back Yard). i Acknowledgements This endeavour would not have been possible without a great deal of help. To the University of Manitoba, and particularly to the Department of City Planning, thank you for the excellent program, wonderful teachers and financial support you have provided. Thank you also to the Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences for the opportunity to participate in an exchange and broaden my planning horizons. Thank you to my advisors – David, Ian and Karin – without whom this thesis would have been an inferior product. Your insight, patience, and suggestions have helped me to develop as a researcher and as a professional. Many thanks to the people of Uddevalla for inviting me into your beautiful municipality and helping to enlighten the issues surrounding wind power. I am hopeful that your municipality, and wind power planning in general, will be better for it. To my family: thank you for all of your support (both financial and emotional) and for accepting that sometimes after sitting in front of a computer for work and then for writing I simply did not have the energy for emails. Gerry and Lori, thank you for welcoming me into your home and letting me experience the joys of being able to see my extended family every day. Kyle, thesis weekends made writing more than bearable; it was great having a friend with whom I could overcome this challenge. Finally, Christel: thank you for everything. This thesis would not have been possible without you. Having someone to share a coffee and a chat with helped me to persevere. You drove me across your country and dealt with my whining and procrastination with love and consideration. You kept me going and pushed me to be better. Jag älskar dig, alltid. ii Table of Contents Abstract ................................................................................................................................................................ i Acknowledgements............................................................................................................................................. ii Table of Contents ............................................................................................................................................... iii Figures and Tables .............................................................................................................................................. v Chapter 1 - Introduction ....................................................................................................................... 1 1.1 Preamble ....................................................................................................................................................... 1 1.2 Introduction .................................................................................................................................................. 1 1.3 Key Terms .................................................................................................................................................... 3 1.4 Problem Statement ........................................................................................................................................ 4 1.5 Purpose of the Thesis .................................................................................................................................... 4 1.6 Scope of the Thesis ....................................................................................................................................... 7 1.7 Importance of Study ..................................................................................................................................... 8 1.8 Research Methods and Analysis ................................................................................................................... 9 1.9 Assumptions ............................................................................................................................................... 10 1.10 Limitations ................................................................................................................................................ 11 1.11 Theoretical Approaches ............................................................................................................................ 11 1.12 Outline of Chapters ................................................................................................................................... 13 Chapter 2 - Putting Landscapes and Attitudes in Context .............................................................. 15 2.1 Introduction ................................................................................................................................................ 15 2.2 Background ................................................................................................................................................. 16 2.2.1 History of Wind Power ........................................................................................................................ 16 2.2.2 Wind Power Trends ............................................................................................................................. 17 2.2.3 Canadian Wind Power Context ........................................................................................................... 19 2.3 Project Context ........................................................................................................................................... 21 2.3.1 Swedish Wind Power .......................................................................................................................... 21 2.3.2 Uddevalla Municipal Context .............................................................................................................. 24 2.3.3 Original Uddevalla Wind Power Plan ................................................................................................. 25 2.3.4 Ramböll ............................................................................................................................................... 27 2.3.5 Uddevalla Project Description ............................................................................................................. 27 2.4 Public attitudes............................................................................................................................................ 32 2.4.1 NIMBY (Not In My Back Yard) ......................................................................................................... 34 2.4.2 The Attitude-Behaviour Gap in Relation to Wind Power ...................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Final Report
    The Senate Select Committee on Wind Turbines Final report August 2015 Commonwealth of Australia 2015 ISBN 978-1-76010-260-9 Secretariat Ms Jeanette Radcliffe (Committee Secretary) Ms Jackie Morris (Acting Secretary) Dr Richard Grant (Principal Research Officer) Ms Kate Gauthier (Principal Research Officer) Ms Trish Carling (Senior Research Officer) Mr Tasman Larnach (Senior Research Officer) Dr Joshua Forkert (Senior Research Officer) Ms Carol Stewart (Administrative Officer) Ms Kimberley Balaga (Administrative Officer) Ms Sarah Batts (Administrative Officer) PO Box 6100 Parliament House Canberra ACT 2600 Phone: 02 6277 3241 Fax: 02 6277 5829 E-mail: [email protected] Internet: www.aph.gov.au/select_windturbines This document was produced by the Senate Select Wind Turbines Committee Secretariat and printed by the Senate Printing Unit, Parliament House, Canberra. This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Australia License. The details of this licence are available on the Creative Commons website: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/au/ ii MEMBERSHIP OF THE COMMITTEE 44th Parliament Members Senator John Madigan, Chair Victoria, IND Senator Bob Day AO, Deputy Chair South Australia, FFP Senator Chris Back Western Australia, LP Senator Matthew Canavan Queensland, NATS Senator David Leyonhjelm New South Wales, LDP Senator Anne Urquhart Tasmania, ALP Substitute members Senator Gavin Marshall Victoria, ALP for Senator Anne Urquhart (from 18 May to 18 May 2015) Participating members for this inquiry Senator Nick Xenophon South Australia, IND Senator the Hon Doug Cameron New South Wales, ALP iii iv TABLE OF CONTENTS Membership of the Committee ........................................................................ iii Tables and Figures ............................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Global Wind Report Annual Market Update 2012 T Able of Contents
    GLOBAL WIND REPORT ANNUAL MARKET UPDATE 2012 T able of contents Local Content Requirements: Cost competitiveness vs. ‘green growth’? . 4 The Global Status of Wind Power in 2012 . 8 Market Forecast for 2013-2017 . 18 Australia . .24 Brazil . .26 Canada. .28 PR China . .30 Denmark . .34 European Union . .36 Germany. .38 Global offshore . .40 India . .44 Japan . .46 Mexico . .48 Pakistan . 50 Romania . 52 South Africa . 54 South Korea . 56 Sweden . .58 Turkey . 60 Ukraine . .62 United Kingdom. .64 United States . 66 About GWEC . 70 GWEC – Global Wind 2012 Report FOREWORD 2012 was full of surprises for the global wind industry. Most As the market broadens, however, we face new challenges, surprising, of course, was the astonishing 8.4 GW installed in or rather old challenges, but in new markets. Our special the United States during the fourth quarter, as well as the fact focus chapter looks at the impact of increasing local content that the US eked out China to regain the top spot among global requirements and trade restrictions in some of the most markets for the first time since 2009. This, in combination with promising new markets, and the consequences of that a very strong year in Europe, meant that the annual market trend for an industry which is still grappling with significant grew by about 10% to just under 45 GW, and the cumulative overcapacity and the downward pressure on turbine prices market growth of almost 19% means we ended 2012 with that result. 282.5 GW of wind power globally. For the first time in three years, the majority of installations were inside the OECD.
    [Show full text]
  • Attendee Conference Pack
    Wind Energy Conference 2021 Rising to the Challenge 12 May 2021, InterContinental Hotel, Wellington, New Zealand Programme Joseph, aged 9 We would like to thank our sponsors for their support 2021 Wind Energy Conference – 12th May 2021 Wind Energy Conference Programme 12 May 2021 InterContinental, Wellington Rising to the Challenge Welcome and Minister’s The energy sector and renewables Presentation ▪ Hon Dr Megan Woods, Minister of Energy and Resources 8.30 – 9.00 Session 1 Facilitator: Dr Christina Hood, Compass Climate Decarbonising the New Zealand’s journey to net zero carbon energy sector ▪ Hon James Shaw, Minister of Climate Change 9.00 to 10.45 Infrastructure implications of decarbonisation ▪ Ross Copland, New Zealand Infrastructure Commission The industrial heat opportunity ▪ Linda Mulvihill, Fonterra Panel and Audience Discussion – testing our key opportunities and level of ambition ▪ Ross Copland, New Zealand Infrastructure Commission ▪ Linda Mulvihill, Fonterra ▪ Briony Bennett (she/her), Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment ▪ Matt Burgess, The New Zealand Initiative ▪ Liz Yeaman, Retyna Ltd Morning Tea Sponsored by Ara Ake 10.45 to 11.15 Session 2 Waipipi, Delivering a wind farm during a global pandemic Jim Pearson, Tilt Renewables Building new wind Australian renewables and wind development update 11.15 -1.00 ▪ Kane Thornton, Clean Energy Council DNV’s Energy Transition Outlook what it means for wind energy ▪ Graham Slack, DNV A changing regulatory landscape and implications for wind and other renewables ▪ Amelia
    [Show full text]
  • The Role of Law in Responding to Climate Change: Emerging Regulatory, Liability and Market Approaches
    THE ROLE OF LAW IN RESPONDING TO CLIMATE CHANGE: EMERGING REGULATORY, LIABILITY AND MARKET APPROACHES NICOLA ANNA MAY DURRANT BSc (Env)/LLB (Hons)(GU); Grad DipLP (ANU) Thesis submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Faculty of Law/Institute for Sustainable Resources Queensland University of Technology Brisbane 2008 1 KEYWORDS Climate Change, Climate Law, Climate Liabilities, Carbon Trading, Environmental Governance, Environmental Law, Environmental Policy, International Law. 2 ABSTRACT Climate change presents as the archetypal environmental problem with short-term economic self-interest operating to the detriment of the long-term sustainability of our society. The scientific reports of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change strongly assert that the stabilisation of emissions in the atmosphere, to avoid the adverse impacts of climate change, requires significant and rapid reductions in ‘business as usual’ global greenhouse gas emissions. The sheer magnitude of emissions reductions required, within this urgent timeframe, will necessitate an unprecedented level of international, multi-national and intra-national cooperation and will challenge conventional approaches to the creation and implementation of international and domestic legal regimes. To meet this challenge, existing international, national and local legal systems must harmoniously implement a strong international climate change regime through a portfolio of traditional and innovative legal mechanisms that swiftly transform current behavioural practices in emitting greenhouse gases. These include the imposition of strict duties to reduce emissions through the establishment of strong command and control regulation (the regulatory approach); mechanisms for the creation and distribution of liabilities for greenhouse gas emissions and climate- related harm (the liability approach) and the use of innovative regulatory tools in the form of the carbon trading scheme (the market approach).
    [Show full text]
  • Reliability Impacts of Increased Wind Generation in the Australian National Electricity Grid
    Reliability Impacts of Increased Wind Generation in the Australian National Electricity Grid Mehdi Mosadeghy B.Sc., M.Sc. A thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy at The University of Queensland in 2015 School of Information Technology and Electrical Engineering Abstract Wind power penetration has been consistently growing and it has been rapidly becoming a significant generation technology in many countries. However, the intermittent and variable nature of wind energy is a major barrier in wind power commitment. Wind speed fluctuations and unpredictability can affect the operation and reliability of power systems. Therefore, the impact of integrating large volume of wind generators on the system reliability needs to be carefully investigated and the reliability contributions of wind farms require to be evaluated for better integration of wind energy sources. Because of intermittency and variability of wind energy, conventional reliability evaluation methods are not applicable and different techniques have been developed to model wind generators. However, most of these methods are time-consuming or may not be able to capture time dependency and correlations between renewable resources and load. Therefore, this research intends to improve the existing reliability methods and proposes a faster and simpler approach. In this approach, wind power and electricity demand are being modelled as time-dependent clusters, which not only can capture their time-dependent attributes, but also is able to keep the correlations between the data sets. To illustrate the effectiveness of this framework, the proposed methodology has been applied to the IEEE reliability test system. In addition, the developed technique is validated by comparing results with the sequential Monte Carlo technique.
    [Show full text]
  • Renewables Rising
    ©iStockphoto.com/gmcoop Renewables rising Here comes the sun – the wind, hydro and the rest Industry focus — renewables November 2014 Published by Edison Investment Research Renewables rising Sector primer Here comes the sun – the wind, hydro and the rest Industrials 1 With regard to renewables, those lyrics, “Here Comes the Sun”, finally 24 November 2014 seem to be coming to fruition, as evidenced by the recent performance of many companies in the alternative energy/renewables sector. The recent plethora of yield company spin-offs, as well as similarly missioned “total Companies in this report return” companies, has provided visibility to the sector, validating it Abengoa Yield (ABY) further, and offering investors a unique way to play the alternative Brookfield Renewable Energy Partners (BEP) energy/renewables space in terms of both yield and growth potential. Capstone Infrastructure (CSE.TO) While volatility is likely to be high, overall, we are bullish on the alternative Hannon Armstrong Sustainable Infrastructure (HASI) energy/renewables sector, and believe the “total return” concept offers NextEra Energy Partners (NEP) investors the potential for diversification, higher yield and more secured cash flows associated with renewable assets. In this report, we initiate NRG Yield (NYLD) coverage of the alternative energy/renewables sector, and present an Pattern Energy Group (PEGI) overview of climate change, snapshots of the main subsectors and TransAlta Renewables (RNW.TO) spotlights on select “yieldco/total return” companies in the space. TerraForm Power (TERP) Bluefield Solar Income Fund (BSIF.L) We need more… Greencoat UK Wind (UKW.L) Energy and electricity. Despite some progress with energy efficiency, long-term population growth, increased demand for energy as developing countries further Analysts industrialize their economies and finite supplies of fossil fuels will ultimately drive Cynthia Motz, CFA +1 646 653 7026 demand for alternative and renewable sources.
    [Show full text]
  • REPORT Wind Power in Cold Climate
    Wind power in cold climate, Appendix – R&D-projects REPORT Wind Power in cold climate 5 September 2011 By: Elin Andersen, Elin Börjesson, Päivi Vainionpää & Linn Silje Undem Revised by: Christian Peterson Approved by: Eva-Britt Eklöf Assignment ref.: 10152935 Dated: 5 September 2011 Wind power in cold climate Revised: Christian Peterson Representative: Eva-Britt Eklöf Status: Final Report REPORT Wind power in cold climate Client Nordic Energy Research Stenbergsgatan 25 N-0170 Oslo NORGE Consultant WSP Environmental Box 13033 402 51 Göteborg Visitors: Rullagergatan 4 Phone: +46 31 727 25 00 Fax: +46 31 727 25 01 WSP Environment & Energy Sweden Corporate identity no.: 556057-4880 Reg. office: Stockholm www.wspgroup.se Contacts Eva-Britt Eklöf Phone: +46 31 727 28 93 Email: [email protected] 0 . 1 r e v 2 (77) Assignment ref.: 10152935 Dated: 5 September 2011 Wind power in cold climate Revised: Christian Peterson Representative: Eva-Britt Eklöf Status: Final Report Table of Contents 1 EXECUTIVESUMMARY............................................................................6 2 INTRODUCTION.....................................................................................10 2.1 Background ......................................................................................................... 10 2.2 Objectives and scope of work .............................................................................. 10 2.3 Methodology ......................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Realizing British Columbia's Second Renewable Electricity Revolution
    Realizing British Columbia’s Second Renewable Electricity Revolution An Outlook 2020 Topic Paper prepared by OnPoint Consulting Inc. for the Business Council of British Columbia March 2010 Sponsored by The opinions expressed in this document are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of the Business Council of British Columbia. Permission to use or reproduce this report is granted for personal or classroom use without fee and without formal request provided that it is properly cited. Copies may not be made or distributed for profit or commercial advantage. Executive Summary A renewable electricity revolution is sweeping across the globe. Many jurisdictions are accelerating the development of renewable electricity in response to concerns about climate change, energy security and supporting economic development. The United States is now the fastest growing jurisdiction for renewable electricity; however, China and India are both beginning to make a significant shift toward renewable electricity generation. The growth in renewable electricity is being supported by the rapidly evolving renewable electricity technology. As technology continues to rapidly improve, the cost of renewable electricity is also falling. British Columbia is already a renewable electricity leader, with more than 87% of the province’s generating capacity coming from renewable sources. Much of the province’s renewable electricity generation is based on a massive wave of large hydroelectric facilities constructed between the 1960’s and 1980’s to support the development of electricity‐intensive industries in the province. There is now an opportunity to create a second renewable electricity wave based on smaller renewable electricity (wind, small hydro, geothermal, ocean and biomass).
    [Show full text]
  • Community Wind in Alberta
    Status of Social Economy Provision of Wind Electric Energy in Alberta Photo: Wind turbines at Pincher Creek, AB Julie MacArthur BALTA B6 Researcher January 4, 2010 Wind electricity in Canada and Alberta Wind power is one of the fastest growing energy sources in the world and Canada is no exception to this. 2009 was a record year for the development of wind power in Canada and it now occupies the 11th country spot in total installed capacity according to the World Wind Energy Association 2009 report. Total installed capacity in Canada is now at 3,319MW (CanWEA, 2009a1), which is up from 2,370MW at the end of 2008 (40% increase) and 1,770MW in 2007 (StatsCan, 2009). Every province now has some installed capacity (with the opening of Bear Mountain Wind Park in Dawson Creek, BC). In fact, using the CanWEA numbers, installed capacity from 2000 to 2009 grew at an average of 40% every year. According to a CanWEA press release “current provincial targets and policy objectives would result in a further quadrupling of installed wind energy capacity in the next six years” (CanWEA, 2009a). While this growth is impressive, it is important to keep in mind that Canada still has one of the most underdeveloped wind resources in the world. Germany, for example, which is 28 times smaller than Canada has 10 times more installed wind capacity (Valentine 2009, p.3). Only 0.6 per cent of Canada’s total electricity production in 2008 was from wind and tidal sources (NEB, Source: CanWEA 2009(http://www.canwea.ca/farms/index_e.php) 2009, p.43- see table 1).
    [Show full text]
  • Report Download
    Low-Impact Renewable Energy Policy in Canada: Strengths, Gaps and a Path Forward February, 2003 Prepared by: Andrew Pape-Salmon Jonathan Dogterom Carissa Wieler Mark Anielski Pembina Institute About the Pembina Institute The Pembina Institute is an independent, citizen-based organization involved in environmental education, research, public policy development and client-confidential environmental consulting services. Its mandate is to develop and promote policies and practices that lead to environmental protection, resource conservation and environmentally sound and sustainable energy and resource management. The mission of the Pembina Institute is to implement holistic and practical solutions for a sustainable world. Incorporated in 1985, the Institute’s head office is in Drayton Valley, Alberta, with offices in Ottawa and Calgary, and research associates in Edmonton, Vancouver and other locations across Canada. For more information on the Pembina Institute’s work, and details of the capabilities and services offered, please visit www.pembina.org. About the Authors Andrew Pape-Salmon is the Director of Sustainable Energy at the Pembina Institute. He is a professional engineer and resource manager with a focus on sustainable energy policy, low-impact renewable energy technologies and community energy planning. He has led several sustainable energy policy advocacy efforts in Canada and has authored several related reports, including, “A Smart Electricity Policy for Alberta,” available free of charge on the Pembina Institute Web site. (For further information about the report, please contact the author at [email protected].) He has worked extensively on the implementation of low-impact renewable energy and energy efficiency at a community level with First Nations and small municipal government partners in Alberta, British Columbia and the Yukon.
    [Show full text]
  • Preliminary Assessment of the Impact of Wind Farms on Surrounding Land Values in Australia, NSW Valuer
    PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT OF THE IMPACT OF WIND FARMS ON SURROUNDING LAND VALUES IN AUSTRALIA NSW DEPARTMENT OF LANDS PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT OF THE IMPACT OF WIND FARMS ON SURROUNDING LAND VALUES IN AUSTRALIA Prepared for: NSW Valuer General August 2009 RESEARCH REPORT 1 PRP REF: M.6777 PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT OF THE IMPACT OF WIND FARMS ON SURROUNDING LAND VALUES IN AUSTRALIA NSW DEPARTMENT OF LANDS CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY _____________________________________________________________ 2 1. INTRODUCTION ______________________________________________________________ 3 2. CONTEXT ___________________________________________________________________ 4 3. LITERATURE REVIEW _________________________________________________________ 5 4. METHODOLOGY _____________________________________________________________ 12 5. RESULTS ___________________________________________________________________ 16 6. DISCUSSION ________________________________________________________________ 54 7. REFERENCES _______________________________________________________________ 56 RESEARCH REPORT 1 PRP REF: M.6777 PRELIMINARY ASSESSMENT OF THE IMPACT OF WIND FARMS ON SURROUNDING LAND VALUES IN AUSTRALIA NSW DEPARTMENT OF LANDS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The aim of this study was to conduct a preliminary assessment on the impacts of wind farms on surrounding land values in Australia, mainly through the analysis of property sales transaction data. This included consideration of the contribution of various factors (including distance to a wind farm, view of a wind farm, and land use) to
    [Show full text]
  • Review of the National Wind Farm Commissioner Final Report
    h REVIEW OF THE NATIONAL WIND FARM COMMISSIONER FINAL REPORT MAY 2018 2 Published by the Climate Change Authority www.climatechangeauthority.gov.au © Commonwealth of Australia 2018 This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Australia Licence. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/au The Climate Change Authority asserts the right to be recognised as author of the original material in the following manner: © Commonwealth of Australia (Climate Change Authority) 2018. IMPORTANT NOTICE – PLEASE READ This document is produced for general information only and does not represent a statement of the policy of the Commonwealth of Australia. The Commonwealth of Australia and all persons acting for the Commonwealth preparing this report accept no liability for the accuracy of or inferences from the material contained in this publication, or for any action as a result of any person’s or group’s interpretations, deductions, conclusions or actions in relying on this material. FINAL REPORT - REVIEW OF THE NATIONAL WIND FARM COMMISSIONER 3 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The Climate Change Authority would like to thank the many individuals and organisations that contributed time and expertise to this review by making submissions or participating in consultations. These contributions have improved the quality of the review and provided evidence to help inform the Authority’s recommendations. The National Wind Farm Commissioner, the Department of the Environment and Energy and the Clean Energy Regulator also provided information to assist the Authority in its preparation of this review. However, the views in this report are the Authority’s own.
    [Show full text]