DOCSLIB.ORG

Leonardo and Architecture in the Critical Views of Giuseppe Bossi (1808-1810)

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Leonardo and Architecture in the Critical Views of Giuseppe Bossi (1808-1810) _full_alt_author_running_head (neem stramien B2 voor dit chapter en nul 0 in hierna): 0 _full_alt_articletitle_running_head (oude _articletitle_deel, vul hierna in): Leonardo and Architecture in the Critical Views of Giuseppe Bossi _full_article_language: en indien anders: engelse articletitle: 0 280 Mara Chapter 11 Leonardo and Architecture in the Critical Views of Giuseppe Bossi (1808-1810) Silvio Mara Was Leonardo really an architect? Among the first scholars to pose themselves this question, the primacy seems to belong to the artist-connoisseur Giuseppe Bossi.1 In April 1807 he had been entrusted by the viceroy Eugène de Beauhar- nais with the task of producing a faithful copy of The Last Supper. Soon, how- ever, he realized that it was necessary to undertake a systematic study of Leonardo so as to enter into sympathy with his work. Bossi carefully gathered information and collected as much as he could, both from primary sources and from recent bibliography. In May 1808 he fi- nally decided that he would write a volume entirely dedicated to the topic of The Last Supper. At first he did not have a clear idea of how he would structure his monograph, because the material he had collected exceeded the theme, but in the end, after long and profound reflection, in the first months of 1811 he decided on the title Del Cenacolo di Leonardo da Vinci (On The Last Supper of Leonardo da Vinci).2 The volume collects, in a historical and philological frame- work, all the evidence on the artist’s masterpiece and all the copies made of it, with a final chapter entitled Opinioni di Leonardo intorno alle proporzioni del corpo umano (Opinions of Leonardo regarding the proportions of the human body), which resulted from a study undertaken by Bossi to understand the can- ons of proportionality in Leonardo. This fourth chapter, which includes print reproductions of drawings in Venice of the Vitruvian Man (Fig. 11.1) and of the Bust of a man with a pattern of proportions (Gallerie dell’Accademia di Venezia, inv. 236), constitutes a stand-alone dissertation, and as such it was published in 1811 with the title Delle opinioni di Leonardo da Vinci intorno alla simmetria de’ corpi umani (On the opinions of Leonardo da Vinci regarding the symmetry of human bodies).3. 1 This primacy has recently been acknowledged in Paola Cordera, L’architettura, le feste, gli ap- parati. Disegni di Leonardo dal Codice Atlantico, (Milan: De Agostini, 2010), 19–21. 2 Giuseppe Bossi, Del Cenacolo di Leonardo da Vinci libri quattro (Milan: Stamperia Reale, 1810). 3 Giuseppe Bossi, Delle opinioni di Leonardo da Vinci intorno alla simmetria de’ corpi umani. Discorso di Giuseppe Bossi pittore dedicato al celeberrimo scultore Antonio Canova (Milan: Stamperia Reale, 1811). © koninklijke brill nv, leiden, 2019 | doi:10.1163/9789004398443_013 _full_alt_author_running_head (neem stramien B2 voor dit chapter en nul 0 in hierna): 0 _full_alt_articletitle_running_head (oude _articletitle_deel, vul hierna in): Leonardo and Architecture in the Critical Views of Giuseppe Bossi _full_article_language: en indien anders: engelse articletitle: 0 Leonardo And Architecture In The Critical Views Of Giuseppe Bossi 281 Figure 11.1 Giuseppe Bossi, copy from the Vitruvian Man for the print reproduction in Del Cenacolo (1810). Busto Arsizio, Carnaghi Collection In the initial stages of his research, Bossi began exploring scarcely known sectors of Leonardo’s activity; among these, he was interested in the possible involvement of Leonardo in some architectural building sites in Milan. In the documentation by Giuseppe Bossi preserved at the Biblioteca Ambrosiana in Milan, among the autograph papers that the painter used to prepare his vol- ume, there is a curious unnamed notebook. In its initial lines, Bossi annotated his intention of writing “a separate article” (“un articolo a parte”) that was to be entitled “Dell’architettura del Cenacolo e delle opinioni di Leonardo intorno all’architettura in generale” (“On the architecture of The Last Supper and the opinions of Leonardo regarding architecture in general”).4 For this reason it 4 The folder is at Biblioteca Ambrosiana in Milan, henceforth cited as BAMi, shelf mark ms. & 239 sup.; it was transcribed with various inaccuracies that alter its meaning in Stephanie Bai, .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • De Divino Errore ‘De Divina Proportione’ Was Written by Luca Pacioli and Illustrated by Leonardo Da Vinci
    De Divino Errore ‘De Divina Proportione’ was written by Luca Pacioli and illustrated by Leonardo da Vinci. It was one of the most widely read mathematical books. Unfortunately, a strongly emphasized statement in the book claims six summits of pyramids of the stellated icosidodecahedron lay in one plane. This is not so, and yet even extensively annotated editions of this book never noticed this error. Dutchmen Jos Janssens and Rinus Roelofs did so, 500 years later. Fig. 1: About this illustration of Leonardo da Vinci for the Milanese version of the ‘De Divina Proportione’, Pacioli erroneously wrote that the red and green dots lay in a plane. The book ‘De Divina Proportione’, or ‘On the Divine Ratio’, was written by the Franciscan Fra Luca Bartolomeo de Pacioli (1445-1517). His name is sometimes written Paciolo or Paccioli because Italian was not a uniform language in his days, when, moreover, Italy was not a country yet. Labeling Pacioli as a Tuscan, because of his birthplace of Borgo San Sepolcro, may be more correct, but he also studied in Venice and Rome, and spent much of his life in Perugia and Milan. In service of Duke and patron Ludovico Sforza, he would write his masterpiece, in 1497 (although it is more correct to say the work was written between 1496 and 1498, because it contains several parts). It was not his first opus, because in 1494 his ‘Summa de arithmetic, geometrica, proportioni et proportionalita’ had appeared; the ‘Summa’ and ‘Divina’ were not his only books, but surely the most famous ones. For hundreds of years the books were among the most widely read mathematical bestsellers, their fame being only surpassed by the ‘Elements’ of Euclid.
    [Show full text]
  • Simple Rules for Incorporating Design Art Into Penrose and Fractal Tiles
    Bridges 2012: Mathematics, Music, Art, Architecture, Culture Simple Rules for Incorporating Design Art into Penrose and Fractal Tiles San Le SLFFEA.com [email protected] Abstract Incorporating designs into the tiles that form tessellations presents an interesting challenge for artists. Creating a viable M.C. Escher-like image that works esthetically as well as functionally requires resolving incongruencies at a tile’s edge while constrained by its shape. Escher was the most well known practitioner in this style of mathematical visualization, but there are significant mathematical objects to which he never applied his artistry including Penrose Tilings and fractals. In this paper, we show that the rules of creating a traditional tile extend to these objects as well. To illustrate the versatility of tiling art, images were created with multiple figures and negative space leading to patterns distinct from the work of others. 1 1 Introduction M.C. Escher was the most prominent artist working with tessellations and space filling. Forty years after his death, his creations are still foremost in people’s minds in the field of tiling art. One of the reasons Escher continues to hold such a monopoly in this specialty are the unique challenges that come with creating Escher type designs inside a tessellation[15]. When an image is drawn into a tile and extends to the tile’s edge, it introduces incongruencies which are resolved by continuously aligning and refining the image. This is particularly true when the image consists of the lizards, fish, angels, etc. which populated Escher’s tilings because they do not have the 4-fold rotational symmetry that would make it possible to arbitrarily rotate the image ± 90, 180 degrees and have all the pieces fit[9].
    [Show full text]
  • Il Fondo Giuseppe Bossi Della Biblioteca Ambrosiana
    IL FONDO GIUSEPPE BOSSI DELLA BIBLIOTECA AMBROSIANA Note introduttive di Angelo Colombo A conclusione della catalogazione informatica1 del Fondo Giuseppe Bossi, ho ritenuto utile raccogliere alcune notazioni sia per illustrare la sua articolata composizione,2 sia per segnalare ‘documenti’ che ancora attendono di essere adeguatamente valorizzati. Queste note introduttive non vogliono perciò essere una presentazione esauriente delle carte del Bossi, ma solo l’indicazione di un percorso. Il necessario rimando è alle relative schede catalografiche, ora inserite nel Catalogo Unico, che presentano in modo dettagliato e analitico tutto il contenuto del Fondo.3 1 La catalogazione informatica del Fondo Giuseppe Bossi è stata realizzata dal dr. Angelo Colombo, responsabile della catalogazione della Biblioteca Ambrosiana, ed è consultabile on-line sul sito dell’Ambrosiana (www.ambrosiana.eu) 2 “I fogli del Fondo Bossi si presentano allo studioso come un insieme disorganico e privo di una vera e propria caratterizzazione” (Rosalba Antonelli, Il cartone del Cenacolo di Giuseppe Bossi. Tracce per lo studio dei caratteri figurativi e filologici di un originale ritrovato e qualche indicazione sul Fondo Bossi dell’Ambrosiana, in Tra i fondi dell’Ambrosiana. Manoscritti italiani antichi e moderni, a cura di Marco Ballarini, Gennaro Barbarisi, Claudia Berra, Giuseppe Frasso, II, Milano, Cisalpino, 2008, p. 849) 3 Link di accesso diretto al Fondo Giuseppe Bossi: http://ambrosiana.comperio.it/manoscritti/advanced?value_2=fondo+giuseppe+bossi&field_2=title&submit=Cerca
    [Show full text]
  • Leonardo Universal
    Leonardo Universal DE DIVINA PROPORTIONE Pacioli, legendary mathematician, introduced the linear perspective and the mixture of colors, representing the human body and its proportions and extrapolating this knowledge to architecture. Luca Pacioli demonstrating one of Euclid’s theorems (Jacobo de’Barbari, 1495) D e Divina Proportione is a holy expression commonly outstanding work and icon of the Italian Renaissance. used in the past to refer to what we nowadays call Leonardo, who was deeply interested in nature and art the golden section, which is the mathematic module mathematics, worked with Pacioli, the author of the through which any amount can be divided in two text, and was a determined spreader of perspectives uneven parts, so that the ratio between the smallest and proportions, including Phi in many of his works, part and the largest one is the same as that between such as The Last Supper, created at the same time as the largest and the full amount. It is divine for its the illustrations of the present manuscript, the Mona being unique, and triune, as it links three elements. Lisa, whose face hides a perfect golden rectangle and The fusion of art and science, and the completion of the Uomo Vitruviano, a deep study on the human 60 full-page illustrations by the preeminent genius figure where da Vinci proves that all the main body of the time, Leonardo da Vinci, make it the most parts were related to the golden ratio. Luca Pacioli credits that Leonardo da Vinci made the illustrations of the geometric bodies with quill, ink and watercolor.
    [Show full text]
  • Leonardo Da Vinci's Study of Light and Optics: a Synthesis of Fields in The
    Bitler Leonardo da Vinci’s Study of Light and Optics Leonardo da Vinci’s Study of Light and Optics: A Synthesis of Fields in The Last Supper Nicole Bitler Stanford University Leonardo da Vinci’s Milanese observations of optics and astronomy complicated his understanding of light. Though these complications forced him to reject “tidy” interpretations of light and optics, they ultimately allowed him to excel in the portrayal of reflection, shadow, and luminescence (Kemp, 2006). Leonardo da Vinci’s The Last Supper demonstrates this careful study of light and the relation of light to perspective. In the work, da Vinci delved into the complications of optics and reflections, and its renown guided the artistic study of light by subsequent masters. From da Vinci’s personal manuscripts, accounts from his contemporaries, and present-day art historians, the iterative relationship between Leonardo da Vinci’s study of light and study of optics becomes apparent, as well as how his study of the two fields manifested in his paintings. Upon commencement of courtly service in Milan, da Vinci immersed himself in a range of scholarly pursuits. Da Vinci’s artistic and mathematical interest in perspective led him to the study of optics. Initially, da Vinci “accepted the ancient (and specifically Platonic) idea that the eye functioned by emitting a special type of visual ray” (Kemp, 2006, p. 114). In his early musings on the topic, da Vinci reiterated this notion, stating in his notebooks that, “the eye transmits through the atmosphere its own image to all the objects that are in front of it and receives them into itself” (Suh, 2005, p.
    [Show full text]
  • FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE August 18, 2015
    FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE August 18, 2015 MEDIA CONTACT Emily Kowalski | (919) 664-6795 | [email protected] North Carolina Museum of Art Presents M. C. Escher, Leonardo da Vinci Exhibitions and Related Events Raleigh, N.C.—The North Carolina Museum of Art (NCMA) presents two exhibitions opening in October 2015: The Worlds of M. C. Escher: Nature, Science, and Imagination and Leonardo da Vinci’s Codex Leicester and the Creative Mind. The Worlds of M. C. Escher features over 130 works (some never before exhibited) and will be the most comprehensive Escher exhibition ever presented in the United States. The Codex Leicester is a 500-year-old notebook handwritten and illustrated by inventor, scientist, and artist Leonardo da Vinci—the only manuscript by Leonardo in North America—that offers a glimpse into one of the greatest minds in history. “This is going to be an exciting fall at the Museum—an incredibly rare opportunity for our visitors to see not only centuries-old writings and sketches by Leonardo da Vinci, but also the work of M. C. Escher, another observer of nature and a perfect modern counterpart to Leonardo,” says NCMA Director Lawrence J. Wheeler. “These exhibitions will thrill art lovers and science lovers alike, and we hope that all visitors leave with a piqued curiosity, an ignited imagination, and a desire to more closely observe the world around them.” The Worlds of M. C. Escher: Nature, Science, and Imagination October 17, 2015−January 17, 2016 Comprising over 130 woodcuts, lithographs, wood engravings, and mezzotints, as well as numerous drawings, watercolors, wood blocks, and lithographic stones never before exhibited, The Worlds of M.
    [Show full text]
  • On the Exhibition Policies for Raphael's Masterpieces
    Renaissance 3/2015 - 1 /lessandra Galiz6i Kroegel “3a.e space #or the great Raphael9& :n the ;*hibition Policies #or Raphael1s 3asterpieces Fig. 1= >iew of the current installation of the 2istine 3adonna in the +emäldegalerie /lte 3eister ?resden @0erbert -oswan., ?resden, 2taatliche 8unstsammlungen ?resdenA. “Raphael, or Ingres, or Picasso are meant Raphael in German and Italian museums during to be meditated upon. !" In order to med- the nineteenth centur) and up to the #irst hal# o# itate on a painting, it is essential to present the t%entieth century.[2] ,his stud) %as inspired it in a #avorable location and %ithin a calm b) (laudia -rin. and /ndreas 0enning1s care#ul atmosphere.& reconstruction o# the various hangings o# the 'e (orbusier[1] 2istine 3adonna #rom 1455, %hen the altarpiece arrived in 2a*on) a#ter its removal #rom the In this essa) I %ill discuss the e*hibition policies church o# 2an 2isto in Piacenza, to the present that %ere developed #or a #e% altarpieces b) day in its current location in the Gem7ldegalerie /lessandra +ali66i 8roegel 3a.e space #or the great Raphael9 .unstte*te.de 3/2015 - 2 <ig. 2= /dol# von 3en6el, Plat6 #Br den groβen Raf#ael9, Raphael in ?resden 1D55/5E, +ouache and pastel on paper, 5F * F2 cm, +er- manisches Gationalmuseum Gurnberg, 'oan o# the cit) of Gurnberg, @3oni.a Runge, +ermanisches Gationalmuseum “3ake space #or the great Raphael9&= a #amous Gurnberg). gouache b) /dolph 3en6el bearing this title (1D55/1D5EA @#ig. 2A illustrates an anecdote %hich ma) have circulated at the court o# 2a*on) #rom /lte 3eister in ?resden, %here it is e*hibited as the middle o# the eighteenth century, and %hich the clima* o# the %estern %ing1s stunning en#i- became %ell-.no%n not onl) in +erman) but to lade o# Italian galleries @#ig.
    [Show full text]
  • Tessellations Hardscape Creations Inspired by the Works of M.C
    Tessellations Hardscape Creations Inspired by the works of M.C. Escher © Chris Belthoff CSB Enterprises, 2013 December 2013 Proprietary 1 Contents Origin What inspired the efforts to produce my hardscape designs Construction How I created the first examples of pavers based on the designs December 2013 2 The Inspiration Ever since I was a child I’ve been fascinated by mathematics In particular, I was always interested in symmetry and patterns…. © Chris Belthoff Enterprises, 2013 December 2013 Proprietary 3 Symmetry and Patterns Have Existed Since Before Man Nature exhibits them all the time: © Chris Belthoff Enterprises, 2013 December 2013 Proprietary 4 ….and Humans Have Creatively Employed Symmetry and Patterns for Centuries © Chris Belthoff Enterprises, 2013 December 2013 Proprietary 5 So what is ‘Tessellation’ A tessellation is the tiling of a plane using one or more geometric shapes, with no overlaps and no gaps Tessellation or tiling is the branch of mathematics that studies how shapes, known as tiles, can be arranged to fill a plane without any gaps. More formally: a tessellation or tiling is a partition of the Euclidean plane into a countable number of closed sets called tiles, such that the tiles intersect only on their boundaries. These tiles may be polygons or any other shapes. Many tessellations are formed from a finite number of prototiles; all tiles in the tessellation are congruent to one of the given prototiles. If a geometric shape can be used as a prototile to create a tessellation, the shape is said to be able to tessellate or to “tile the plane”. Mathematicians have found no general rule for determining if a given shape can tile the plane or not, which means there are many unsolved problems concerning tessellations.
    [Show full text]
  • Leonardo Da Vinci
    LEONARDO DA VINCI 105. Studies for the Christ Child (recto) Slight Diagramatic Sketches (verso) Red chalk, brush and red wash (head at center), small traces of Pedretti and Clark :1983, p. 46, fig. 35, p. 5:1; Marani :1987a, p. 240, white gouache highlights over traces of stylus, on ocher-red pre­ fig. 16;; Kemp :199:1, p. 37; Martin Clayton in Palazzo Grassi :1992, pared paper (recto); pen and brown ink (verso), 285 x 198 mm pp. 250-5:1, nos. 25-25a; Popham 1994- no. :185; Caroline Lanfranc 1 (n% x 7 :Y16 in.) de Pan thou in Musee Conde :1995, pp. 94-95, no. 23; Tordella 1995, Inscribed in red chalk on recto, in right-to-left script, toward cen­ p. 4:15; Arasse :1998, pp. 452-55, fig. 3:13; Annalisa Perissa Torrini in ter of upper border: anbroso; in pen and black ink toward lower Nepi Scire and Torrini 1999, pp. 92-95, no. 28. right, by a later hand: di Leonardo; on verso in pen and brown ink, by the artist in right-to-left script, toward bottom of sheet: Se io so co[n] certezza lospatio che e dal [pun to] e fall o[g]chio. g. che his delicately rendered sheet in red chalk on ocher-red qui lometto 1500 miglia I Ia qua{n]tita c d che meincognita p[er] Tprepared paper offers several studies of gradually magnitudine e p{er] distantia m[iglia] 10 Ia misuro tal I quale elle increased scale for the figure of the infant Jesus as he is repre­ e poi Ia re movo quella medesima unaltro spatio incognito e I I sented in the extant Louvre painting of the Virgin and Child c[i]oe in a b, e lla trovo diminuta e 4l5 della prima qua{n]to giu­ dichero io ch ella I sia piu remota dallochio che essa p[rima] in with Saint Anne and a Lamb (fig.
    [Show full text]
  • How a Mathematician Started Making Movies 185
    statements pioneers and pathbreakers How a Mathematician Started Making Movies M i ch e l e e M M e R The author’s father, Luciano Emmer, was an Italian filmmaker who made essentially two—possibly three—reasons. The first: In 1976 I feature movies and documentaries on art from the 1930s through was at the University of Trento in northern Italy. I was work- 2008, one year before his death. Although the author’s interest in films ing in an area called the calculus of variations, in particular, inspired him to write many books and articles on cinema, he knew he ABSTRACT would be a mathematician from a young age. After graduating in 1970 minimal surfaces and capillarity problems [4]. I had gradu- and fortuitously working on minimal surfaces—soap bubbles—he had ated from the University of Rome in 1970 and started my the idea of making a film. It was the start of a film series on art and career at the University of Ferrara, where I was very lucky mathematics, produced by his father and Italian state television. This to start working with Mario Miranda, the favorite student of article tells of the author’s professional life as a mathematician and a Ennio De Giorgi. At that time, I also met Enrico Giusti and filmmaker. Enrico Bombieri. It was the period of the investigations of partial differential equations, the calculus of variations and My father, Luciano Emmer, was a famous Italian filmmaker. the perimeter theory—which Renato Caccioppoli first intro- He made not only movies but also many documentaries on duced in the 1950s and De Giorgi and Miranda then devel- art, for example, a documentary about Picasso in 1954 [1] oped [5–7]—at the Italian school Scuola Normale Superiore and one about Leonardo da Vinci [2] that won a Silver Lion of Pisa.
    [Show full text]
  • Fractals: a Resonance Between Art and Nature
    Fractals: A Resonance between Art and Nature Richard Taylor, Ben Newell, Branka Spehar and Colin Clifford Physics and Psychology Reveal the Fractal Secrets of Jackson Pollock’s Drip Paintings The discovery of fractal patterns was an interesting advance in the understanding of nature [1, 2]. Since the 1970s many natural scenes have been shown to be com- posed of fractal patterns. Examples include coastlines, clouds, lightning, trees, rivers and mountains. Fractal patterns are referred to as a new geometry because they look nothing like the more traditional shapes such as triangles and squares known within mathematics as Euclidean geometry. Whereas these shapes are composed of smooth lines, fractals are built from patterns that recur at finer and finer magnifications, generating shapes of immense complexity. Even the most common of nature’s fractal objects, such as the tree shown in Figure 1, contrast 53 sharply with the simplicity of artificially constructed objects such as buildings. But do people find such complexity visually appealing? In particular, given peo- ple’s continuous visual exposure to nature’s fractals, do we possess a fundamental appreciation of these patterns – an affinity independent of conscious delibera- tion? The study of human aesthetic judgement of fractal patterns constitutes a rela- tively new research field within perception psychology. Only recently has research started to quantify people’s visual preferences for (or against) fractal content. A useful starting point in assessing people’s ability to recognize and create visual pat- ternsistoexaminethemethodsusedbyartists to generate aesthetically pleasing images on their canvases. More specifically, in terms of exploring an intrinsic ap- preciation of certain patterns, it seems appropriate to examine the Surrealists and their desire to paint images which are free of conscious consideration.
    [Show full text]
  • A Mathematical Analysis of Knotting and Linking in Leonardo Da Vinci's
    November 3, 2014 Journal of Mathematics and the Arts Leonardov4 To appear in the Journal of Mathematics and the Arts Vol. 00, No. 00, Month 20XX, 1–31 A Mathematical Analysis of Knotting and Linking in Leonardo da Vinci’s Cartelle of the Accademia Vinciana Jessica Hoya and Kenneth C. Millettb Department of Mathematics, University of California, Santa Barbara, CA 93106, USA (submitted November 2014) Images of knotting and linking are found in many of the drawings and paintings of Leonardo da Vinci, but nowhere as powerfully as in the six engravings known as the cartelle of the Accademia Vinciana. We give a mathematical analysis of the complex characteristics of the knotting and linking found therein, the symmetry these structures embody, the application of topological measures to quantify some aspects of these configurations, a comparison of the complexity of each of the engravings, a discussion of the anomalies found in them, and a comparison with the forms of knotting and linking found in the engravings with those found in a number of Leonardo’s paintings. Keywords: Leonardo da Vinci; engravings; knotting; linking; geometry; symmetry; dihedral group; alternating link; Accademia Vinciana AMS Subject Classification:00A66;20F99;57M25;57M60 1. Introduction In addition to his roughly fifteen celebrated paintings and his many journals and notes of widely ranging explorations, Leonardo da Vinci is credited with the creation of six intricate designs representing entangled loops, for example Figure 1, in the 1490’s. Originally constructed as copperplate engravings, these designs were attributed to Leonardo and ‘known as the cartelle of the Accademia Vinciana’ [1].
    [Show full text]