ARTICLE
Received 11 Jun 2016 | Accepted 24 Nov 2016 | Published 10 Jan 2017 DOI: 10.1038/ncomms14083 OPEN High power rechargeable magnesium/iodine battery chemistry
Huajun Tian1,2,*, Tao Gao1,*, Xiaogang Li1, Xiwen Wang1, Chao Luo1, Xiulin Fan1, Chongyin Yang1, Liumin Suo1, Zhaohui Ma1, Weiqiang Han2,3 & Chunsheng Wang1
Rechargeable magnesium batteries have attracted considerable attention because of their potential high energy density and low cost. However, their development has been severely hindered because of the lack of appropriate cathode materials. Here we report a rechargeable magnesium/iodine battery, in which the soluble iodine reacts with Mg2 þ to form a soluble intermediate and then an insoluble final product magnesium iodide. The liquid–solid two- phase reaction pathway circumvents solid-state Mg2 þ diffusion and ensures a large inter- facial reaction area, leading to fast reaction kinetics and high reaction reversibility. As a result, the rechargeable magnesium/iodine battery shows a better rate capability (180 mAh g 1 at 0.5 C and 140 mAh g 1 at 1 C) and a higher energy density (B400 Wh kg 1) than all other reported rechargeable magnesium batteries using intercalation cathodes. This study demonstrates that the liquid–solid two-phase reaction mechanism is promising in addressing the kinetic limitation of rechargeable magnesium batteries.
1 Department of Chemical and Biomolecular Engineering, University of Maryland, College Park, College Park, Maryland 20740, USA. 2 Ningbo Institute of Materials Technology and Engineering, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Ningbo 315201, China. 3 School of Materials Science and Engineering, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou 310027, China. * These authors contributed equally to this work. Correspondence and requests for materials should be addressedto H.T. (email: [email protected]) or to W.H. (email: [email protected]) or to C.W. (email: [email protected]).
NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | 8:14083 | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms14083 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications 1 ARTICLE NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms14083
igh abundance (1.5 wt% in earth crust and 0.13 wt% in sea concept is Li/S batteries where a solid–liquid–solid reaction water), high volumetric energy density (3,833 mAh cm 3), pathway takes place during the reduction of sulfur18. For Mg Hvery negative reduction potential ( 2.37 V versus Stan- batteries, iodine (I2) serves as a perfect cathode material for dard Hydrogen Electrode) and, most importantly, highly reversible illustrating this concept. This is because I2 and its partial dendrite-free deposition, have made magnesium (Mg) metal an reduction product, Mg(I3)2, have high solubility in ether-based 1,2 ideal anode material for post lithium ion battery chemistries .The electrolytes, but its final reduced product, MgI2, is insoluble key to a high-performance rechargeable magnesium battery (RMB) (Table 1). Thus, an I2 cathode is expected to have faster redox lies in high voltage electrolytes and high voltage/capacity cathodes. reaction kinetics than intercalation cathodes. In addition, I2 is In the past decades, although significant advances have been made able to provide a much higher voltage (2.1 V) and capacity 3–5 1 in electrolyte development , little progress has been achieved (211 mAh g ) than Mo6S8 (Fig. 1a and Supplementary Table 1, in the cathode material study. The hurdle is the clumsy Mg2 þ see Calculation section). intercalation because of the sluggish solid-state diffusion of the Herein, we demonstrate a rechargeable Mg/I2 battery that divalent Mg2 þ and the slow interfacial charge transfer. Compared is able to provide capacity close to the theoretical value with monovalent cations (Li þ ,Naþ ,Kþ and so on), the high (B200 mAh g 1) with an average voltage of 2.0 V at C/4, charge density of Mg2 þ (twice as high as Li þ ) inevitably raises the corresponding to an energy density of 400 Wh kg 1. Prolonged energy barriers for breaking its solvation sheath or ion-ligand cycling shows an excellent stability at C/2 with capacity retention pair upon interfacial charge transfer6,7. It also induces strong of 94.6% for 120 cycles. A liquid–solid two-phase reaction Coulombic interactions with the host upon ion insertion and mechanism (Fig. 1b) was validated using spectroscopic and hopping8 and causes difficulty for the host to accommodate microscopic characterizations. Because of the fast Mg2 þ diffusion electrons8,9. As a result, most reported cathode materials show in the electrolyte, the ready electron access of iodine species and inferior kinetics and poor reversibility, except for Chevrel phase large interfacial reaction area, the Mg/I2 battery shows superior 10 1 1 (Mo6S8) . However, Mo6S8 only provides a limited energy density rate capability (180 mAh g at 0.5 C and 140 mAh g at 1 C). 1 B (o126 Wh kg ) because of its low operation voltage ( 1.2 V) This proof-of-concept Mg/I2 battery demonstrates the feasibility and low specific capacity (110 mAh g 1)10. of using a liquid–solid two-phase reaction route to address the Extensive efforts have been conducted to improve the reaction challenging intercalation kinetics of RMB cathodes. The chemical kinetics and cycling stability of RMBs. The most successful insights obtained here can be beneficial for realizing an optimized þ strategy is to couple Li intercalation cathodes (for example, system, a Mg/I2 flow battery or other kinds of two-phase reaction 2 þ þ TiS2, LiFePO4 and so on) with a Mg anode in a hybrid Mg /Li RMB cathodes. electrolyte so that the clumsy Mg2 þ intercalation can be partially or even completely replaced by fast Li þ intercalation11–14. However, the energy density of such a hybrid battery is restricted Results by the Li salt concentration of the electrolyte that limited its Material preparation. Because of the electronic insulating nature practical application. There are also studies reporting that of I2, it was intentionally impregnated into the pores of active water can stimulate Mg2 þ intercalation and thus drama- carbon cloth (ACC) through a melt-diffusion method to enhance tically enhance the intercalation kinetics by shielding the charge its electron access following previous reported method19,20. of Mg2 þ via a solvent co-intercalation mechanism15–17, yet the compatibility of Mg anode with water remains a problem. Up until now, there has been no facile strategy that could Table 1 | Solubility of different iodine species in tetraglyme. effectively tackle the Mg2 þ intercalation issue. A conversion cathode that undergoes two-phase (solid–liquid or liquid–solid) Solubility I2 Mg(I3)2 MgI2 reaction pathway during an electrochemical reaction that Mass of solute per 100 ml solvent (g) 475 4100 0.1 2 þ o does not rely on solid-state Mg diffusion is considered a Molarity of atomic iodine (mol l 1) 45.9 47.6 o0.007 promising direction9. The most successful demonstration of this
abDischarge e –
Electrolyte separator
100 200 300 400 500 Wh kg–1 3 ) I2 2
2 MoS2 AgCl MgCoSiO4 α-MnO 2 Mgl
Voltage (V) Mo X 2 Fullerenes 6 8 MgFeSiO4 Mg metal anode Cathode (ACC/l 1 l2 TiS3 V2O5 l3–
Mg2+ 0 0 100 200 300 400 Capacity (mAh g–1) Figure 1 | Schematic illustration of the rechargeable magnesium/iodine battery. (a) The capacity and voltage of the iodine cathode compared with reported rechargeable magnesium batteries cathodes. (b) Schematic of rechargeable Mg/I2 batteries.
2 NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | 8:14083 | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms14083 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms14083 ARTICLE
a ACC ACC/I2 Iodine in the ACC
Melt-diffusion
bc
I
d Fresh ACC ACC/I2 mixture ACC/I2 heated at 135 °C Intensity (a.u.)
20 30 40 50 60 70 80 2
Figure 2 | Material characterization of the active carbon cloth/iodine cathode. (a) Procedure for preparing the ACC/I2 electrode. (b) Scanning electron microscopy images of the ACC/I2 cathode, scale bar: 1 mm. (c) Energy-dispersive spectroscopy mapping of I in the ACC/I2 cathode. (d) X-ray diffraction pattern of the ACC/I2 cathode.
B 2 Meanwhile, ACC can also inhibit the migration of dissolved I2 of the ACC/I2 disk in the electrochemical tests is 1.0 mg cm towards the Mg anode because of the strong adsorption of I2 in and the electrolyte volume is 100 ml. A typical discharge/charge the ACC pores (Supplementary Fig. 1), thus mitigating the curve of the Mg/I2 cell in 0.5 M Mg-HMDS electrolyte is shown in expected shuttle effect. The synthesis of the ACC/I2 cathode is Supplementary Fig. 5. The open-circuit voltage of the Mg/I2 cell is schematically shown in Fig. 2a. In brief, a mixture of ACC and I2 2.25 V. During discharge, the ACC/I2 cathode experiences a quick was first sealed into an argon-filled container, and then heated to potential drop, and then reaches a plateau at B1.95 V. The first B 1 135 °C for 12 h. At this temperature, the fluid I2 will be infiltrated discharge shows a capacity of 310 mAh g , corresponding to B into the pores of the ACC through the capillarity effect an I2 utilization of 94.7%, excluding the contribution from the (the melting point of I2 is 113.7 °C). The weight ratio of I2 in ACC (the charge/discharge curve of a blank ACC is shown in the composite electrode can be evaluated with thermogravimetric Supplementary Fig. 6). The Coulombic efficiency is B75%, 2 analysis. For an electrode with I2 loading 2.8 mg cm , the mass suggesting the presence of shuttle effect during charging. As I2 ratio of I2 is B27% (Supplementary Fig. 2). Scanning electron and Mg(I3)2 are highly soluble in the electrolyte, it is inevitable to microscopy (SEM) images of the ACC/I2 cathode demonstrates have I2 loss during charge/discharge that causes the shuttle effect no residual I2 on the surface (Fig. 2b,c), and a very uniform and results in low Coulombic efficiency. To mitigate the shuttle distribution of I2 in carbon can be observed in the energy- effect, an electrolyte with a high salt concentration (2 M Mg- dispersive spectrum of I (Fig. 2c). X-ray diffraction shows that the HMDS) was used in the Mg/I2 battery as concentrated electrolytes 22 I2 peak disappears after impregnation (Fig. 2d), suggesting that I2 were proven effective for this purpose. The discharge curves of loses its long range order structure and is uniformly dispersed the ACC/I2 cathode in this concentrated electrolyte show a inside the pores of the carbon fiber. discharge behaviour similar to that in the low concentration electrolyte: a short plateau at 2.2 V followed by a long plateau at 1.9 V (Fig. 3a). However, a remarkable difference can be observed Electrochemical performance. The electrolyte was synthesized by for the charge curves. In the high concentration electrolyte reacting magnesium bis(trimethylsilyl)amide ((HMDS)2Mg) with (2 M Mg-HMDS), the ACC/I2 cathode shows a clear charge B aluminum chloride (AlCl3) and magnesium chloride (MgCl2)in plateau at 2.5 V with a potential spike at the end of the charge tetraglyme (TEGDME) in situ. The preparation procedure is (Fig. 3a), whereas the ACC/I2 cathode in the low concentration given in the Methods section. For convenience, the electrolyte is electrolyte (0.5 M Mg-HMDS) does not show any potential rising abbreviated as Mg-HMDS. The deposition/striping process of the at the end of charge even when the capacity exceeded the electrolyte was measured by three-electrode cell and coin cell theoretical value. The shuttle effect of polyiodide was thus (Supplementary Figs 3 and 4) and a Coulombic efficiency of close effectively mitigated as evidenced from the significantly increased to 100% can be obtained, consistent with previous work.21 Coulombic efficiency (close to 100%). To understand the The electrochemical stability window of the electrolyte was also reaction mechanism of the Mg/I2 chemistry, we performed measured (Supplementary Fig. 3) and the electrolyte starts to cyclic voltammetry with the Mg/I2 battery at a slow scan rate of show observable decomposition when voltage exceeds 2.7 V but 0.1 mV s 1 (Fig. 3b). Two cathodic peaks at B2.2 and B1.8 V vigorous oxidation did not happen until 3.0 V. The Mg/I2 battery can be observed, corresponding to I2/I3 redox couple and was assembled by coupling an ACC/I2 disk, a glass fiber separator I3 /I redox couple, respectively. Two anodic peaks at 2.2 and and an Mg foil anode into a Swagelok cell. The typical I2 loading 2.7 V can also be observed. Both the charge/discharge curve and
NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | 8:14083 | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms14083 | www.nature.com/naturecommunications 3 ARTICLE NATURE COMMUNICATIONS | DOI: 10.1038/ncomms14083
ab3.0 0.10
2.5 0.05
2.0 0.00 Voltage (V) 1.5 Current (mA) –0.05
1.0 –0.10 0 50 100 150 200 250 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 Voltage (V) Capacity (mAh g–1) cd 120 200 Mo6S8¨nSen ) ) MgFePO F
–1 4 100 –1 400 FGSs 80 150 Mo6S8 60 VOx 100 MgCoSiO4 200 40 Iodine loading: ~1 mg cm–2 TiS2
Capacity (mAh g MoS Electrolyte:0.5 M Mg-HMDS 20 Capacity (mAh g 2 50 Current density: C/2 Coulombic efficiency (%) This work 0 0 0 50 100 0 50 100 150 200 Cycle number Current density (mA g–1)
Figure 3 | Electrochemical performance of the rechargeable Mg/I2 battery. (a) A typical discharge/charge curve of the Mg/I2 battery with ACC/I2 1 cathode. (b) Cyclic voltammogram of the Mg/I2 battery with ACC/I2 cathode. Scan rate: 0.1 mVs .(c) Cycling stability of the Mg/I2 battery at 0.5 C 1 (105.5 mA g ) with ACC/I2 cathode. (d) Rate capability of Mg/I2 battery with ACC/I2 cathode. The rate capabilities of other cathode materials are also plotted for comparison.