Table Tennis History Journal 87 Excellent Research for Historians, Collectors February and All Lovers of Our Great Sport 2019
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Table Tennis History Journal 87 Excellent research for Historians, Collectors February and all Lovers of our Great Sport 2019 Chinese poster for Rong Guotuan, who won the 1959 World Singles title, China’s first World Championship in any sport. See pages 33-40 From the Editor Table Tennis Dear Friends, -30C at this writing! Welcome to issue 87 of the Table Tennis History Journal, for History historians, writers, collectors, and all lovers of our sport. We are sorry to learn of the passing of long time collector Bob Op de Journal Beeck of Belgium. In the new issue your editor reports on several interesting New Discoveries, Old Treasures, also a summary of Chinese Table Tennis posters, and the usual Auction Action. Alan Duke (ENG) continues his in-depth research into early newspaper articles, and reports on the oft-told story of Mr EC Goode and the pharmacy change mat. He also shows some images from the Foley porcelain Ping Pong patent. Jorge Arango (COL) presents his 6�� installment on early pirated images, and Gerald Gurney (ENG) sends an article about the Xylonite works in Brantham, Essex. More Barna rackets to share, thanks to Fabio Marcotulli (VEN) and Bruno Lancon (FRA). Our Philatelic Update introduces 2 new blue meters, a postmark No. 87 from India, and a French personalized stamp. Auction Action, features some surprises, including a rare early February 2019 candy box, Table Tennis art, and a ticket for the 1936 World Ch. Hope you enjoy the new issue. Feedback always welcomed. Next edition scheduled for June 1, 2019. Editor and Publisher: For our sport, Table Tennis for All, For Life. Chuck Hoey, Honorary Curator Chuck ITTF Museum & China TT Museum [email protected] I have received the 2018 attendance statistics from Shanghai, for the new Table Tennis Museums. From April to December there Publishing Schedule: were 73,823 visitors, an average of 8,200 per week! Also there were 50,000 visitors for 9 traveling exhibitions throughout China. June 1 Submit articles by May 15 Congratulations to the talented and dynamic museum team in Oct 1 Submit articles by Sep 15 Shanghai - very impressive stats! Keep up the great work. Feb 1 Submit articles by Jan 15 In this issue … Cover: World Ch. New Discoveries, Old Treasures Research Rong Missing Silver bat 4 Silver bowl 5 EC Goode 14-17 Guotuan Scores Szabados bats 6 Kimono 9 Barna bats Foley porcelain 27 poster 3 16mm film 8 10-12 Newspapers 42-54 33 Alan Duke Brantham Pirated 1935 Coleman Chinese Back Page: Xylonite Images Clark article Posters World Ch. Philatelic Auction Part 6 Works 28-32 33-40 Budapest Update 17-25 26 Action 72 Jorge Arango Gerald Gurney 41 55-69 2 World Championships Scores This is a periodic update about the important World Championship Scores project. We made steady progress, thanks to the help of several diligent readers, but unfortunately there is no progress to report in over a year. We are tantalizingly close to completing the Men’s Singles, but in the other Individual Events, many scores are missing from the 1940s and ‘50s, even one from the 1965 Worlds! I encourage our readers to dive in and help preserve the historical record and find those scores. Please contact the Editor if you find any. Go for it! Chuck World Championships - Missing Game Scores, Individual events: MS: 1936: Rd/16 WS: 1934: Rd/16: wins by Kettnerova & Berry 1936: Rd/16 (wins by Smidova, Gal & Koudelova 1947: Rd/16 (wins by Hruskova, Farkas, Abou Heif, Pritzi) 1949: Rd/16 MD: 1936: Rd/16: all except wins by McClure/Blattner, Soos/Hazi, Haguenauer/Bedoc 1949: Rd/16 1950: Rd/16 1955: Rd/16 WD: 1936: Rd/16: Kleinova/Holoubkova won 3-0; Medyanszky/Gal won 3-0 Votrubcova/Depetrisova won 3-1 need game scores 1947: Rd/16 1950: Rd/16, + Farkas/Rozeanu winning Semifinal scores 1965: Rd/16: need only Liang Li-chen/Li Ho-nan 3-0 scores XD: 1933: Rd/16 (all except: Glancz/Gal, Barna/Sipos, & Kelen/Mednyanszky) 1936: Rd/16: wins by Hamr/Kleinova, Ehrlich/Braunova, Tereba/Kettnerova 1947: Rd/16 1949: Rd/16; QF: Leach / Franks 3-2 scores 1950: Rd/16 (I have the British player scores, missing the others) 1955: Rd/16 (I have wins by Simons/Elliot, and Tanaka/Narahara, missing the others) 1957: Rd/16 (I have Leach/Rowe & Haydon/Andreadis wins, missing the others) 1959: Rd/16: Berczik/Lantos 3-0; Murakami/Matsuzaki 3-0; Wang C/Sun 3-1; Sung/Choe 3-1 Ogimura/Eguchi 3-0 3 New Discoveries - Old Treasures Silver Bat 1901 Hallmarks 4 New Discovery - Old Treasure The John Sanders Challenge Cup, presented by Mrs.L. W. Rouse Silver hallmarks date the bowl to 1903. On ebay for $190 5 New Discoveries - Old Treasures Szabados Bats It’s a rare occasion when any Szabados signature bats surface. This fine pair was found in their original box, with photo of the 1931 World Singles Champ. These are shown in the accompanying Slazenger advertisement. They are definitely an old treasure! 6 Another type of Szabados bat, originally listed on ebay at £499, but then withdrawn due to ‘an error in the listing’, which often suggests it was privately sold. 7 16mm Dunlop film featuring 5-time World Singles Champion Victor Barna vs 1931 World Singles Champion Miklos Szabados. Directed by Roland Litchfield, £38 8 New Discoveries - Old Treasures Meisen Kimono Meisen antique silk Kimono & Haori. The kimono is 147 cm in length, the haori is 71 cm long, both are 60 cm wide. $450, then lowered to $427 immortalgeisha.com notes that Meisen is a method of flat weaving shiny silk which began in the late Edo period. On ebay for $427 9 Barna Bats from Fabio and Bruno Superb Barna bat with red signature, no red oval, the Dunlop logo in red teardrop, with original Barna testimony. From Fabio Marcotulli 10 11 Jeu de Ping Pong, by Aux Quatre As, with pair of hardbats with Barna signature, underscored. With thanks to Bruno Lancon (FRA) 12 Greeting card with copy of a painting by famous Italian artist Massimo Campigli (1895-1971), kindly sent by another great, Fabio Marcotulli 13 The Tale of E C Goode and the Chemist’s Cash Mat by Alan Duke The Story: This oft-repeated story was featured by Chuck Hoey in a Fact or Fiction article (TTC 46, page 4). The tale of a Mr E C Goode from Putney using a racket covered with a rubber cash mat, spotted by chance in a chemist’s shop, probably originated from Ivor Montagu’s description in his second book on the game, Table Tennis (1936) - written over 30 years after the event, by someone who wasn’t even born at the time! In this version the claim was made that Mr Goode then proceeded to defeat everyone at the next Royal Aquarium tournament, including in the final the then champion of England Mr A C Parker “by the preposterous score of 50 points to 3”. In later versions of the tale, the event had even become the national championships! When and Where: In attempting to verify the origins of this story, assuming that memory wasn’t playing tricks with the venue and that it was at the Aquarium as described, the tournament would have to have been before 10th January 1903. On that night, after 26 years as “a landmark of London as well known as St Paul’s to the average citizen”, the Royal Aquarium closed, and 3 weeks later on 1st February following the sale of props, etc, the Wesleyans took possession. In his farewell speech, “Uncle” Ritchie (manager; and father of M J G Ritchie, organiser and referee of the tournaments held there) stated that he was “proud to say that about thirty million people had paid for admission since the Aquarium was opened” (Sheffield Daily Telegraph, 12 January). Also, if the reference to Arnold Parker were to be believed, that places the event after December 1901. But I have yet to find any reference to Mr Parker losing 50-3 as reported. And although there were a number of candidates named E C Goode in the London area at that time, none ever appear to have entered any of the reported events (let alone win any), and none were from Putney. But there were numerous reports of a Mr Good. And during 1902 there were plenty of tournaments at the Aquarium to choose from, e.g. All-England Championships (8-14 January), Westminster Championships (3-8 February), South London Championships (5-8 March), London Championships (29 October to 1 November), All-England Championships (3-6 December). Earlier Reference?: Checking to see whether Ivor Montagu had made any reference to the story in his (much rarer) earlier book Table Tennis To-Day (1924) gave an important new perspective to the tale! Firstly, the subject was a Mr Good (not the E C Goode as copied and elaborated on in every subsequent re-telling of the events), and secondly there is no reference to Mr Parker (or Putney for that matter, only “a suburb”). The time is some two or three days before the great championship tournament at the Aquarium in 1902. The scene is a suburb, and Mr. Good, one of the competitors, is returning to his home. He has a cold, and, oppressed by a headache, he enters a chemist’s shop and bespeaks a palliative. Then with a suddenness that characterises all great discoveries, he perceives the chemist’s cash mat. A Eureka-stroke of genius, a simple transaction, and the thing is done.