DOCSLIB.ORG

History: India Ww2: Essay Question

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
History: India Ww2: Essay Question HISTORY: INDIA WW2: ESSAY QUESTION Question: how accurate is it to say that the Second World War was the most significant factor driving Indian nationalism in the years 1935 to 1945. (20) One argument for why the Second World War was the most significant factor in driving Indian Nationalism from 1935 to 1945 is because Britain spent vast amounts of money on the Indian army, £1.5 million per year, which made the Indian army feel a boost of self-worth and competence. This would have had a significant effect of Indian nationalism as competence and self- belief are essential in nationalism. Furthermore, Britain paid for most of the costs of Indian troops who fought in North Africa, Italy and elsewhere. This allowed the Indian government to build up a sterling balance of £1,300 million in the reserve Bank of India. This gave Indians freedom of how to spend it which could be spent on new Indian businesses or on infrastructure. This in turn, boosted nationalism as it showed India was becoming less reliant on Britain. However, while India did benefit economically in some aspects from the war, the divisions between Congress and the Muslim League grew. One example of how this occurred could be because the 1937 elections marginalised the Muslim League which made them seem like true nationalists. Once WW2 started these divisions grew as Jinnah returned as a stronger leader wanting better protection of Muslims. As a result, World War Two drove nationalism because of the financial effects on India but increased Muslim nationalism by driving a wedge between the Muslims and Hindus. As a result, this argument is accurate but fails to look deeper into the types of nationalism. A second argument for why the Second World war was the most significant factor in driving Indian nationalism was that USA had put pressure on Britain in 1941 to let India have self-government or Independence as Roosevelt believed all people should have self- determination. Vinayak Savarkar was president of the All- Hindu Mahasabha appealed directly to Roosevelt asking him to guarantee India’s post war freedom. This shows that the USA had a large influence on Indian nationalism as Britain would be forced to acknowledge India’s right for independence if they wanted the USA to help in WW2. Roosevelt believed that in order to defeat the Axis powers India needed to be fully behind the war effort as Japan was a threat to India who had thousands of troops on many fronts. The USA committed troops to Asia to prompt Britain to follow to show India they had not been forgotten. This was a significant factor in driving nationalism as it made Indian’s feel that the west did care about them and they were seen as capable enough by one of the most powerful country’s in the world to govern themselves. However, there is evidence to suggest that the Second World War was not the most significant factor in driving Indian nationalism. One major factor was the Bengal famine in which from 1943 to 1944. This caused the annual death rate to increase from 1.2 million per year to 1.9 million. Many people died from diseases associated with malnutrition. It is estimated between 1 million and 3 million people died. What angered Indian nationalists was the lack of response from Britain in which Viceroy Wavell requested 1 million tons of grain to combat the famine, yet only received 450,000 tons. This gave Bose an opportunity to recruit for his Indian National Army (INA) by guaranteeing food for those who joined. As a result, it can be argued that the Bengal famine drove Indian nationalism but because the poor response from the British made Indian’s feel angry and tired of the repeated failures of Britain. Finally, events in India drove Muslim nationalism and their call for an independent Muslim state. The Second World War was not a main factor for this, instead the Quit India campaign failed to inflict any damage to British rule and increased support for the Muslim League. By the end of the war Muslims were calling for an independent state for themselves in mass and it was becoming a reality. As a result, WW2 did not increase Muslim nationalism that much but more Hindu nationalism. This leaves the conclusion that WW2 was the most significant factor in driving Hindu nationalism, not Indian nationalism. Many events from 1935 to 1945 drove a wedge between Hindus and Muslims which meant they, although both Indian, did not feel they belonged to the same country. The most significant factor in driving Indian nationalism was likely from India becoming less dependent on the British for resources. Frankie, year 12 .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Realignment and Indian Air Power Doctrine
    Realignment and Indian Airpower Doctrine Challenges in an Evolving Strategic Context Dr. Christina Goulter Prof. Harsh Pant Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed or implied in the Journal are those of the authors and should not be construed as carrying the official sanction of the Department of Defense, Air Force, Air Education and Training Command, Air University, or other agencies or departments of the US government. This article may be reproduced in whole or in part without permission. If it is reproduced, the Journal of Indo-Pacific Affairs requests a courtesy line. ith a shift in the balance of power in the Far East, as well as multiple chal- Wlenges in the wider international security environment, several nations in the Indo-Pacific region have undergone significant changes in their defense pos- tures. This is particularly the case with India, which has gone from a regional, largely Pakistan-focused, perspective to one involving global influence and power projection. This has presented ramifications for all the Indian armed services, but especially the Indian Air Force (IAF). Over the last decade, the IAF has been trans- forming itself from a principally army-support instrument to a broad spectrum air force, and this prompted a radical revision of Indian aipower doctrine in 2012. It is akin to Western airpower thought, but much of the latest doctrine is indigenous and demonstrates some unique conceptual work, not least in the way maritime air- power is used to protect Indian territories in the Indian Ocean and safeguard sea lines of communication. Because of this, it is starting to have traction in Anglo- American defense circles.1 The current Indian emphases on strategic reach and con- ventional deterrence have been prompted by other events as well, not least the 1999 Kargil conflict between India and Pakistan, which demonstrated that India lacked a balanced defense apparatus.
    [Show full text]
  • Annual Report 2018-19
    GOVENMENT OF INDIA MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS ANNUAL REPORT 2018-19 CONTENTS Chapter - 1 1-5 Mandate and Organisational Structure of the Ministry of Home Affairs Chapter - 2 6-33 Internal Security Chapter - 3 34-50 Border Management Chapter - 4 51-55 Centre-State Relations Chapter - 5 56-63 Crime Scenario in the Country Chapter - 6 64-69 Human Rights and National Integration Chapter - 7 70-109 Union Territories Chapter - 8 110-147 POLICE FORCES Chapter - 9 148-169 Other Police Organizations and Institutions Chapter - 10 170-199 Disaster Management Chapter - 11 200-211 International Cooperation Chapter - 12 212-231 Major Initiatives and Schemes Chapter - 13 232-249 Foreigners, Freedom Fighters’ Pension and Rehabilitation Chapter - 14 250-261 Women Safety Chapter - 15 262-274 Registrar General and Census Commissioner, India (RG&CCI) Chapter - 16 275-287 Miscellaneous Issues Annexures 289-337 (I-XXIII) Annual Report 2018-19 Annual Report 2018-19 Chapter - 1 Mandate and Organisational Structure of The Ministry of Home Affairs 1.1 The Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) Organisational Chart has also been given discharges multifarious responsibilities, at Annexure-II. the important among them being - internal 1.3 The list of existing Divisions of the security, border management, Centre- Ministry of Home Affairs indicating major State relations, administration of Union areas of their responsibility are as below: Territories, management of Central Armed Police Forces, disaster management, etc. Administration Division Though in terms of Entries 1 and 2 of List II – ‘State List’ – in the Seventh Schedule 1.4 The Administration Division is responsible for handling all administrative to the Constitution of India, ‘public order’ matters and allocation of work among and ‘police’ are the responsibilities of various Divisions of the Ministry.
    [Show full text]
  • Technical Graduate Course (Tgc-134) (Jan 2022)
    INDIAN ARMY www.joinindianarmy.nic.in 134TH TECHNICAL GRADUATE COURSE (TGC-134) (JAN 2022) 1. Applications are invited from eligible unmarried Male Engineering Graduates for 134th Technical Graduate Course (TGC-134) commencing in Jan 2022 at Indian Military Academy (IMA), Dehradun for Permanent Commission in the Indian Army. 2. Eligibility (a) Nationality. A candidate must either be : - (i) A citizen of India, or (ii) a subject of Nepal, or (iii) a person of Indian origin who has migrated from Pakistan, Burma, Sri Lanka and East African countries of Kenya, Uganda, the United Republic of Tanzania, Zambia, Malawi, Zaire and Ethopia and Vietnam with the intention of permanently settling in India. Provided that a candidate belonging to categories (ii) and (iii) above shall be a person in whose favour a certificate of eligibility has been issued by Government of India. Certificate of eligibility will however not be necessary in the case of candidates who are Gorkha subjects of Nepal. A candidate in whose case a certificate of eligibility is necessary, will attach such certificate alongwith the application. (b) Age Limit. 20 to 27 years as on 01 Jan 2022. (Candidates born between 02 Jan 1995 and 01 Jan 2002, both dates inclusive). Note. The date of birth recorded in the Matriculation/ Secondary School Examination Certificate or an Equivalent Examination Certificate on the date of submission of application will only be accepted. No other document relating to age will be accepted and no subsequent request for its change will be considered or granted. (c) Educational Qualification for Applying. Candidates who have passed the requisite Engineering Degree course or are in the final year of Engineering Degree course are eligible to apply.
    [Show full text]
  • Amarnath Yatra
    AMARNATH YATRA Yatris entering the shrine TEXT: SHYAMOLA KHANNA t was the month of July and I was standing on the threshold, gazing at the deity of Shri Amarnathji inside the cave at 14,000 ft, cold, wet and not a little FINDING Ibewildered. And then the chants of “Har Har Mahadev!” rang out! I looked back and saw the band of Shiva worshippers calling out to their Lord, saffron bands around their heads and dressed in the barest CrowdsMY in front FAITH minimum, a loin cloth and another orange of the shrine bit draped around their shoulders – men, women and young adolescents all calling out with the same fervor! The ambient temperature would have been between five and six degrees centigrade and yet these people were not cold! So is this what the burning fire of faith was all about? While I watched, I also noticed that the people were generally in the age group of fifty and sixty. There were younger ones and definitely even older ones too—they 8 Miles to go before they sleep a lone sadhu trudges on were the ones who were clad in loads of again. By the time March comes around seeps back into the mountains and flows woolens, shawls, sweaters, caps and woolen and the first nargis (daffodil) starts out in places through the mountainside. socks (probably a couple of pairs!), in the flowering through the snow blankets, then Some of this water flows into Amarnath vanyaprastha or sanyas stages of life. you can start stepping out again. Slowly, the cave and over a period of two to three poppies and irises start to flower and entire weeks, forms an ice mound in the cave, due The Cave hillsides become covered in red, yellow and to the freezing of water drops that fall from When winter sets in the Jammu and blue.
    [Show full text]
  • Curriculum Vitae
    Curriculum Vitae Dr. Krishnamurty V. Padgalwar Registrar IIIT Bhagalpur. Email : [email protected] ; [email protected] Mobile No : +919823663974 Date of Birth : 23rd July 1971 Address for communication : Registrar Indian Institute of information Technology Sabour, Bhagalpur – 813210 (Bihar) Permanent Address : “OM SATYAM”, PLOT NO 7, S. No 51, BHAIRAV NAGAR, DHANORI LANE NO 10, PUNE – 411015 (MS) Educational Qualification : S. Courses University/institution/ Year of Subjects taken Result with No. Passed Board Passing Division/Class 1 SSC Maharashtra State Board Marathi, Hindi, English, 61 % (First of Secondary and Higher Science, Maths, etc Class) Secondary Education Aurangabad 1986 2 HSC Maharashtra State Board 1988 Hindi, English, 69 % (First of Secondary and Higher Physics, Chemistry, Class) Secondary Education Maths, Biology Aurangabad 3 BSc Marathwada University 1991 English, Physics, 77 % Aurangabad Chemistry & (Distinction) Electronics 4 MSc Marathwada University 1993 Physics (Electronics) 73.3 % (First Aurangabad Class) 5 PhD Swami Ramanand Tirth 2008 Environmental Science Degree Marathwadad University, (Global Warming & Awarded Nanded Climate Change) PhD Thesis : “Searching Signals of Climatic Change in Marathwada & Telangana Region of Peninsular India” 1 Professional Training : Organization Period Details of Training From To India Meteorological 1996 1997 Ab Initio Meteorologist Gr – II Department (Forecasting Training) Employment records : Name and address Period Designation of Nature of work and level of of
    [Show full text]
  • British Indian Army: Role of Punjab in the World War I
    201 B. Singh & B. Singh: British Indian Army British Indian Army: Role of Punjab in the World War I Bhupinder Singh and Bawa Singh Central University of Punjab, Bathinda ________________________________________________________________ The British Indian Army evolved out of the three presidencies of Bengal, Madras and Bombay, which had come under the control of the East India Company in the second-half of the eighteenth century. With the outbreak of the Sepoy mutiny 1857, both the administration and the Indian army were radically restructured. The Punjab’s strategic location, the onset of the ‘Great Game,’ and what was believed to be the martial character of local people played an important role in placing this region in the center of British planning. This paper examines the role of Punjab in providing soldiers as well as generous politico-economic support to the British Empire during the World War I. ___________________________________________________________________________________ The origins of the British Indian Army were modest. It began in the 17th century as the East India Company’s irregular force guarding a group of four factories with a few hundred men. A pioneer scholar of military history, Roy (2009), claims that with the passage of time, the colonial army became one of the largest employers in India. In the beginning, the presidencies of Bengal, Bombay and Madras contributed significantly to the building of the colonial army. This first phase was popularly known as Bengalization of the British Indian Army, owing to Bengalʹs substantial contribution. The prominence of Punjab and Punjabis in this Army began with the annexation of Punjab in 1849 and was reinforced by onset of the Great Game in general and World War I in particular.
    [Show full text]
  • Air Power in Joint Operations: a Game Changer in a Limited Conflict with China
    JUNE 2020 ISSUE NO. 374 Air Power in Joint Operations: A Game Changer in a Limited Conflict with China ARJUN SUBRAMANIAM ABSTRACT Any future limited conflict between India and the People’s Republic of China (PRC) will primarily be fought in a high-altitude environment along parts of the 4,000-km- long Line of Actual Control (LAC). With the Indian Army likely to be constrained by the terrain and numerical parity to fight a largely positional battle with limited mobility and offensive options, air power offers several asymmetric opportunities to create operational advantages on the ground. To leverage the IAF’s current qualitative advantage, India must keep an eye on the future and ensure that the rapid modernisation of China’s air force does not erode the IAF’s competitive advantage. This is possible only if India steps up on the induction cycle of cutting-edge platforms, sensors and weapon systems, and improves the jointness and integration of its air and land operations. Attribution: Arjun Subramaniam, “Air Power in Joint Operations: A Game Changer in a Limited Conflict with China,” ORF Issue Brief No. 374, June 2020, Observer Research Foundation. Observer Research Foundation (ORF) is a public policy think tank that aims to influence the formulation of policies for building a strong and prosperous India. ORF pursues these goals by providing informed analyses and in-depth research, and organising events that serve as platforms for stimulating and productive discussions. ISBN: 978-93-90159-49-9 © 2020 Observer Research Foundation. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, copied, archived, retained or transmitted through print, speech or electronic media without prior written approval from ORF.
    [Show full text]
  • Arming Without Aiming: India's Military Modernization
    chapter one Restraint and Affluence One of the most remarkable attributes of India as an independent nation has been its longstanding restraint in military strategy. Reticence in the use of force as an instrument of state policy has been the dominant political condition for Indian thinking on the military, including military modernization. From the initial delay in sending troops to defend Kashmir in 1948 to the twenty-four-year hiatus in testing nuclear weapons, India has used force mainly in response to grave provocation and as an unwelcome last resort. The country’s greatest strategic success, the victory of 1971, occurred in response to a Pakistan Army crackdown on rebel Bengalis, which killed tens of thousands and forced millions of refugees to flee to India. It is notable that New Delhi did not press its military advantage in the west to resolve the Kashmir problem. Similarly, India’s nuclear weapons program, the military capacity that could have transformed India’s strategic position, remained in limbo for twenty-four years after India tested its first atomic device in 1974. There are exceptions to Indian restraint as well as questions about whether it was driven by capacity or intention. Of course, Pakistan has never been persuaded of Indian restraint. We discuss these issues below as part of our investigation in this chapter into whether India’s new affluence and access to advanced weapons technology will end the pattern of strategic restraint, turning India into a traditional great power with clear strategic objectives and the military means to achieve them. The answer is not self-evident.
    [Show full text]
  • Voices of Change.Pdf
    LADAKH, Jammu and Kashmir SUNDARBANS, West Bengal Ladakh in Jammu and Kashmir and the Indian Sundarbans in West Bengal are two of WWF’s priority conservation sites. The increasingly threatening environment in these regions increases the vulnerability of their fragile ecosystems and the indigenous communities that live there. Map prepared by IGCMC, WWF-India © WWF-India, 2010 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced in any form or by any means without prior permission of WWF-India 5 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS INTRODUCTION This report has come a long way to become what you hold in your Environmental change coupled with resource degradation and poverty is hand. Tireless research, meticulous surveys and personal interviews creating situations of extreme adversity in several parts of India. As the conducted by the WWF-India team reflects in every page, as you travel impacts of climate change become unequivocal, nature and ecosystems, through to reach out to stories that would have otherwise, never natural resources and the people who depend on them will become more been heard. vulnerable during this century. This will imply less or uncertain availability of food and water, increased variability in the frequency and intensity For their support, Mr. Ravi Singh, Secretary General & CEO, of natural disasters, loss or migration of species, significant changes in Dr. Sejal Worah, Programme Director and Ms Archana Chatterjee, ecosystems and tremendous risk to human populations and their livelihoods. Head, Regional Programme for Himalayan Glaciers, Rivers and High Altitude Wetlands, WWF-India are to be thanked. Impacts of climate change are likely to be felt more in developing countries such as India, given the greater reliance of its people on natural resources We thank our scientific advisory panel – Prof.
    [Show full text]
  • Pak Pos and RMS Offices 3Rd Ed 1962
    Instructions for Sorting Clerks and Sorters ARTICLES ADDRl!SSBD TO TWO PosT-TOWNS.-If the address Dead Letter Offices receiving articles of the description re­ 01(an article contains the names of two post-town, the article ferred in this clause shall be guided by these instructions so far should, as a general rule, be forwarded to whichever of the two as the circumstances of each case admit of their application. towns is named last unless the last post-town- Officers employed in Dead Letter Offices are selected for their special fitness for the work and are expected to exercise intelli­ ( a) is obviously meant to indicate the district, in which gence and discretion in the disposal of articles received by case the article should be . forwar ~ ed ~ · :, the first­ them. named post-town, e. g.- A. K. Malik, Nowshera, Pes!iaivar. 3. ARTICLES ADDRESSED TO A TERRITORIAL DIVISION WITH­ (b) is intended merely as a guide to the locality, in which OUT THE ADDITION OF A PosT-TOWN.-If an article is addressed case the article should be forwarded to the first­ to one of the provinces, districts, or other territorial divisions named post-town, e. g.- mentioned in Appendix I and the address does not contain the name of any post-town, it should be forwarded to the post-town A. U. Khan, Khanpur, Bahawalpur. mentioned opposite, with the exception of articles addressed to (c) Case in which the first-named post-town forms a a military command which are to be sent to its headquarters. component part of the addressee's designation come under the general rule, e.
    [Show full text]
  • The Indian Army and Human Rights
    The Indian Army and Human Rights “You are not there to fight the people in the area, but to protect them. You are fighting only those who threaten the people and who are a danger to the lives and properties of the people[1]”. The Indian Army has always been committed to this Special Order of the Day issued by the Chief of the Army Staff (COAS) in 1955. For over 60 years, the Indian Army has participated in Counter Insurgency and Counter Terrorism (CI/CT) operations in different parts of the country including Punjab, Jammu and Kashmir and the Northeastern States. While functioning in civilian areas the forces encounter numerous complexities ranging from gruesome acts of violence carried out by militants and insurgents to unprecedented attacks by some unruly and violent crowd. In such circumstances, the Indian Army is under immense pressure to not only safeguard the territorial integrity of the nation but also to abide by their duty to protect the Human Rights of the innocent civilian population. Irrespective of the difficult CI/CT environment, the Indian Security Forces follow the twin ethics of ‘minimum use of force’ and ‘good faith’ while conducting such operations[2]. In fact, all Indian Army personnel abide by the COAS Ten Commandments for Troops in Counter Insurgency which underscores the need to ‘Respect Human Rights’ and condemns ‘Rape’, ‘Molestation, and ‘Torture’[3]. Actions of soldiers deployed to fight insurgency and terrorism are regulated by three tenets. First, respecting the elders, women and children is of utmost importance. Second, any inconvenience to the public must always be avoided.
    [Show full text]
  • Imperial Influence on the Postcolonial Indian Army, 1945-1973
    University of Vermont ScholarWorks @ UVM Graduate College Dissertations and Theses Dissertations and Theses 2017 Imperial Influence On The oP stcolonial Indian Army, 1945-1973 Robin James Fitch-McCullough University of Vermont Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.uvm.edu/graddis Part of the Military History Commons Recommended Citation Fitch-McCullough, Robin James, "Imperial Influence On The osP tcolonial Indian Army, 1945-1973" (2017). Graduate College Dissertations and Theses. 763. https://scholarworks.uvm.edu/graddis/763 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Dissertations and Theses at ScholarWorks @ UVM. It has been accepted for inclusion in Graduate College Dissertations and Theses by an authorized administrator of ScholarWorks @ UVM. For more information, please contact [email protected]. IMPERIAL INFLUENCE ON THE POSTCOLONIAL INDIAN ARMY, 1945-1973 A Thesis Presented by Robin Fitch-McCullough to The Faculty of the Graduate College of The University of Vermont In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts Specializing in History October, 2017 Defense Date: May 4th, 2016 Thesis Examination Committee: Abigail McGowan, Ph.D, Advisor Paul Deslandes, Ph.D, Chairperson Pablo Bose, Ph.D. Cynthia J. Forehand, Ph.D., Dean of the Graduate College ABSTRACT The British Indian Army, formed from the old presidency armies of the East India Company in 1895, was one of the pillars upon which Britain’s world empire rested. While much has been written on the colonial and global campaigns fought by the Indian Army as a tool of imperial power, comparatively little has been written about the transition of the army from British to Indian control after the end of the Second World War.
    [Show full text]