High Speed Trains – a Second Golden Age for Railways? Murray Hughes, Chief Editor (Currently Consultant Editor), Railway Gazette International
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
SSpecialpecial featurefeature articlearticle 12th JR East R&D Symposium High Speed Trains – a Second Golden Age for Railways? Murray Hughes, Chief Editor (Currently Consultant Editor), Railway Gazette International. Murray Hughes holds a BA (Hons) degree in Applied Language Studies, and after spending a year with Swiss Federal Railways, he worked for the International Union of Railways in Paris before joining Modern Railways as Foreign Editor. He moved to Railway Gazette International as News Editor, where he later became Assistant Editor and then Deputy Editor. Appointed as Editor in 1991, he stepped down in April 2006 to become Consultant Editor. From 1995 to 2006 he was also Editor-in-Chief of the fortnightly newsletter devoted to Britain's privatised railway industry, Rail Business Intelligence, originally launched as Rail Privatisation News. He was also responsible for Railway Gazette International's related publications Metro Report and Railway Directory. He is the author of Rail 300 - The World High Speed Train Race, which has been published in England, Spain, Sweden, Japan and Germany. Railway Gazette International contains technical and business articles relating to railways around the world and is read by managers and engineers in over 135 countries. Railway Gazette International website: www.railwaygazette.com you all know far more than I do about the world’s premier high speed railway, but the Shinkansen will be the starting point of my presentation. When the Tokaido Shinkansen opened in 1964, it sparked a fresh interest in railways across the world. At the time, in Europe and North America, there was a school of thought that held railways to be old-fashioned and doomed to extinction. The future, they thought, lay exclusively with jet aircraft and private cars. How wrong they were! That famous opening of the Shinkansen in October 1964 was a milestone in world railway history – and indeed world history. Since then the concept of high speed train travel has spread to at least 15 countries, with many others building, planning or proposing high speed railways. 1 Introduction Good afternoon, Ladies & Gentlemen. I am deeply honoured to be addressing you today. I am especially honoured because I have been asked to talk about high speed trains in the country where the high speed train was born. I shall begin by looking briefly at some key events in the history of high speed railways. I shall then invite you to join me on a tour of Europe to review recent progress with high speed railway developments. I will also touch on plans and projects outside Europe. Finally, I shall look ahead to future plans and briefly discuss the challenges that face high speed train operators in the years to come. The theme of today's symposium is "Aiming for Further Progress for the Shinkansen". I shall not say a great deal about the Shinkansen, as 42 JR EAST Technical Review-No.8 Special feature article At this point, it is important to define high speed. High speed is a On October 27 1903, one of the railcars set a world rail speed record relative term, but generally, this is taken to mean 200 km/h or more. of 210.2 km/h. That momentous feat was over 100 years ago. That speed is practised on historic infrastructure in many countries, Today we take it for granted that we can simulate what happens if with Portugal touching 220 km/h and Amtrak in the USA 240 km/h engineering is pushed beyond accepted limits. But back in the early – although only on short sections of route. 1900s, that was entirely impossible. And because the engineers did But in most cases speeds higher than 200 km/h demand their own not know what would happen, the trials came close to disaster. dedicated tracks. During one test, a bogie on one of the railcars actually lifted off the There are at least 12 countries where purpose-built high speed rails. But fortunately, it landed back on the track in the same railways are under construction. alignment, avoiding tragedy. Today, the benchmark speed for high speed lines is 300 km/h. But We’ll fast forward now for 50 years or so towards the present day to one railway already touches 320 km/h, and over the next 10 years we an event that was even more daring. In March 1955, the French shall see at least two more operators exceed the 300 km/h threshold. Railways, SNCF, staged a series of tests on the main line south of And one of them, of course, will be JR East. Bordeaux. Two locomotives were regeared, given new pantographs and fitted with monobloc wheels, and 2 trains were prepared by attaching passenger coaches. Every component was checked to ensure that it was in perfect working order for what was to follow. The objective was simply to see how fast the locomotives could go. The test site featured a long straight section – although there was a curve at the far end. This curve was a critical limiting factor, and to ensure the train would slow down in time for the curve, staff were on board just to lower the windows to assist with braking. Word of the trials had spread to the surrounding area, and when the tests started there was quite a crowd at the line side. These observers were rewarded with a stunning display of what we would today term as raw railway research. 2 Major Events in High Speed Rail I would ask you now to travel back in time to look at some early speed records. Our time machine will land over a century ago in Germany, just south of Berlin, where engineers were exploring what was then a new technology. It was called electric traction. Using a 23 km military railway, they were investigating the potential for speed, and in 1901 they accelerated an electric locomotive up to 162.5 km/h. These early trials were followed by tests with two electric railcars, during which the 200 km/h barrier was breached for the first time. In a whirlwind of noise and dust, the trains flashed past, flinging ballast into the air and trailing clouds of smoke as the pantographs dissolved into shards of red-hot metal. One of the locomotives touched 326 km/h, and the other recorded 331 km/h. This was a truly astounding achievement. But this exploit also came within a hair’s breadth of catastrophe. Look carefully at the picture on the right, and you will see that the track was seriously bent by the hunting of the bogies (trains). The lesson was that the dynamic forces exerted on the track by high speed trains had to be fully controlled. This critical factor was fully understood here in Japan when the Tokaido Shinkansen opened between Tokyo and Osaka just nine JR EAST Technical Review-No.8 43 Special feature article years later. The trains were lightweight with low axle loads. This On May 18 1990, TGV Set 325 roared into railway history with a policy has been followed to this day in successive generations of record-breaking speed for a passenger-carrying train of 515·3 km/h. Shinkansen rolling stock. This has also been true for other high Excluding magnetic levitation vehicles, that record still stands today. speed trains besides the Shinkansen. But achieving one-off world records is comparatively easy. It is less Let us stay in France for the moment and move on again to 1981. easy to do it every day in commercial service with real passengers on This was a landmark year for France and for Europe. Not only did board. Let’s glance at the history of world speed records in relation to SNCF open the first section of Europe’s first high speed line between the highest average speeds attained in day-to-day service. Paris and Lyon, but its engineers proved to the rest of the world that they had truly mastered high speed technology. Their creation was the TGV or Train à Grande Vitesse, developed after a long programme of research begun in the early 1970s. TGV was a trend- setting train, and the letters TGV have become a household name in France and across Europe. In terms of railway technology, the TGV broke with tradition. This train had articulated trailer coaches, long wheelbase bogies and the lineside signals were moved into the cab. Maximum speed in commercial service was initially 260 km/h. As part of the preparations for opening the new line between Paris and Lyons, tests were carried out with a specially-modified TGV. SNCF's tests culminated on February 26 1981 when SNCF grabbed the attention of the world’s media. The TGV test train crushed the 1955 world The individual speed exploits are shown above the line. In many speed record with a spectacular dash that peaked at 380 km/h. It was cases, these were standard trains that had been specially prepared for proof that high speed rail travel was safe and that the engineers were the occasion, but some were experimental vehicles that were never in full control. Not only that, but there were suggestions that even going to carry fare-paying passengers. The red line on the graph higher speeds were attainable. shows the highest average point-to-point speed in a public timetable Nine years later, in 1990, French railway engineers hit the headlines from the earliest days of railways to the present day. In 2005 the once again. By now they had amassed plenty of experience with high fastest scheduled service in the world is a TGV between Lyon and speed rail, and they again set out to test the limits of wheel-on-rail Aix-en-Provence, attaining a start-to-stop average speed of 263·3 technology.