Case of High-Speed Ground Transportation Systems

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Case of High-Speed Ground Transportation Systems MANAGING PROJECTS WITH STRONG TECHNOLOGICAL RUPTURE Case of High-Speed Ground Transportation Systems THESIS N° 2568 (2002) PRESENTED AT THE CIVIL ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT SWISS FEDERAL INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY - LAUSANNE BY GUILLAUME DE TILIÈRE Civil Engineer, EPFL French nationality Approved by the proposition of the jury: Prof. F.L. Perret, thesis director Prof. M. Hirt, jury director Prof. D. Foray Prof. J.Ph. Deschamps Prof. M. Finger Prof. M. Bassand Lausanne, EPFL 2002 MANAGING PROJECTS WITH STRONG TECHNOLOGICAL RUPTURE Case of High-Speed Ground Transportation Systems THÈSE N° 2568 (2002) PRÉSENTÉE AU DÉPARTEMENT DE GÉNIE CIVIL ÉCOLE POLYTECHNIQUE FÉDÉRALE DE LAUSANNE PAR GUILLAUME DE TILIÈRE Ingénieur Génie-Civil diplômé EPFL de nationalité française acceptée sur proposition du jury : Prof. F.L. Perret, directeur de thèse Prof. M. Hirt, rapporteur Prof. D. Foray, corapporteur Prof. J.Ph. Deschamps, corapporteur Prof. M. Finger, corapporteur Prof. M. Bassand, corapporteur Document approuvé lors de l’examen oral le 19.04.2002 Abstract 2 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to extend my deep gratitude to Prof. Francis-Luc Perret, my Supervisory Committee Chairman, as well as to Prof. Dominique Foray for their enthusiasm, encouragements and guidance. I also express my gratitude to the members of my Committee, Prof. Jean-Philippe Deschamps, Prof. Mathias Finger, Prof. Michel Bassand and Prof. Manfred Hirt for their comments and remarks. They have contributed to making this multidisciplinary approach more pertinent. I would also like to extend my gratitude to our Research Institute, the LEM, the support of which has been very helpful. Concerning the exchange program at ITS -Berkeley (2000-2001), I would like to acknowledge the support of the Swiss National Science Foundation. This experience has been important since it provided a very significant basis for this research, thanks to the case studies achieved at ITS-Berkeley. I acknowledge also Prof. Martin Wachs and Prof. William Garrison, who provided me guidance in this research on innovative transportation systems in the USA, as well as Prof. Robert Bea for his advises in risk management. Additionally, I would like to thank Dr. Michele Mossi and Monsieur Philippe Pot, in charge of the Swissmetro Project Management, for the interaction we had, as well as M. Rodolphe Nieth, inventor of the Project and Dr.Vincent Bourquin for the HISTAR R&D project. I acknowledge also those who contributed to commenting my research through the PhD seminars: “Management of Technology & Change”, of Prof. D. Teece & Prof. D. Mowery (Haas-School, Berkeley 2000), and “Managing Organization”, of Prof. A. Bergmann and Prof. G. Cestre (HEC-Lausanne 2000 & 2001). Finally, much gratitude is owed to my wife Beatrice, who supported me all along this work, as well as to my parents and family, especially Monsieur Christian Faessler, for the review of this document. Lausanne, February 28, 2002 Guillaume de Tilière EPFL / ILEMT Abstract 3 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Managing the launch of new technological trajectories is a complex task, especially in the case of High- Speed Ground Transportation (HSGT) Systems. For instance, Maglev systems are now developed since 40 years, and none of these technologies has been implemented until the first Transrapid contract for Shanghai (which could lead to a 1250 km track between Beijing and Shanghai). What are the future challenges for cutting-edge technologies such as Swissmetro or the Japanese MLX- 01? Behind such a question stands the problem of managing technological rupture. This brings us beyond the engineering field since it implies leading change and innovation through organizations, institutions and policy. HSGT innovations with strong technological rupture are complex to manage, involving industry, operators, institutions and politicians. The structure of public/private investments and the long lead-life of such projects (much longer than many industrial ones) require from decision-makers a good understanding of the management of complex systems. This presupposes a good technology assessment, in order to identify technological lock-ins, performances and benefits. However only assessing the intrinsic and extrinsic projects’ value without the ability to introduce change wouldn’t be enough: The ability to lead changes in cultures, organizations, and processes is a determinant of the successful development and diffusion of such technologies. Therefore, the aim of this research is to examine the role of industry, operators and institutions in the implementation of innovative transportation networks and in the diffusion of innovations. Depending on the national context, experiences have been different depending on the countries. Innovative projects have sometimes been successful; other times they have failed, with millions of dollars wasted. Decision-making is a hard task, especially when it concerns R&D investments in projects that imply strong technological rupture. The assessment of risks and uncertainties is not an easy task, as decision-making unfolds in design, construction and operation phases. Therefore, the importance of integrating structural and organizational factors into the analysis seems to be necessary to provide pertinent recommendations for the management of such projects. For this purpose, this research provides a methodological approach with a view to understanding the impact of the technological rupture on project management, leading to a set of recommendations. Those ones are based on case studies, as well as the elaboration of Two HSGT Innovation Models, whose understanding is also enlightened by the development of several conceptual Models. The methodology can be described as follow: 1. Case studies: identification of critical factors of success/failure: - Related to the structure of the market and its evolution - Related to the notion of innovation and rupture 2. Elaboration of innovation models for HSGT technologies: - Modeling innovation processes : main existing models - Modeling diffusion processes of innovations, and decision-making - Elaboration of 2 HSGT innovation models - Putting into perspective the critical factors identified Guillaume de Tilière EPFL / ILEMT Abstract 4 3. Modeling the influence of institutional & organizational factors 4. Developing an approach centered on the notion of risk/opportunity - Defining a methodological approach in order to identify the risks related to the rupture - Identifying the impacts of the technological rupture on risks and uncertainties 5. Providing recommendations on project management Recommendations related to the critical factors underlined by the case studies and the conceptual models. This constitutes the important steps of this research, leading to a better understanding of innovation processes and how to manage them. The identification of critical factors in the management of such projects as well as recommendations are embodied in a Project Management Assessment Tool (PMAS), which is presented in annex. The originality of this research is to analyze, in a multi-perspective approach, innovation processes in the development of new technological trajectories characterized by strong technological rupture. The value of this research also resides in the international perspective of experiences through the case studies: This led to better take into account market and political contexts for recommendations on how to manage the rupture. This being said, this approach also provides a good basis for analyzing innovations in large technical systems in general, the nature of which go beyond private interests and are by nature dependent on public and political interests. Guillaume de Tilière EPFL / ILEMT Abstract 5 VERSION ABRÉGÉE Gérer le lancement d’une nouvelle trajectoire technologique est une tâche compliquée, surtout dans le cas des systèmes de transport terrestre à grande vitesse. C’est le cas des systèmes Maglev, maintenant développés depuis plus de 40 ans et dont la première implémentation commerciale à été signée en Chine pour la desserte de l’aéroport de Shanghai (avec comme objectif une possible ligne de 1250 km entre Pékin et Shanghai si le système fait ses preuves). Quels sont les défis pour des technologies avant-gardistes comme le Swissmetro ou le MLX-01 japonais ? Une telle question renvoie à la difficulté de gérer la rupture technologique : Une telle rupture dépasse le domaine de l’ingénierie puisqu’elle implique d’introduire le changement et l’innovation dans les organisations, les institutions et la politique. De tels projets d’innovation à forte rupture technologique sont d’une grande complexité à gérer, impliquant l’industrie, les opérateurs, les institutions et les politiques. La structure des investissements publics-privés et la longue durée de vie de tels projets (bien plus long que les projets industriels classiques) nécessitent de la part des décideurs une bonn e compréhension du management des systèmes complexes. Cela présuppose une bonne évaluation de la technologie, afin d’identifier les verrous technologiques et de marché, ainsi que ses performances et bénéfices. Cependant, l’évaluation intrinsèque ou extrinsèque du projet de rupture technologique sans prendre en compte la capacité de conduire le changement n’est pas suffisante : Introduire le changement dans les cultures, les organisations et les processus chez les acteurs clé est un élément déterminant pour la réussite du lancement et du développement de telles technologies. L’objectif de cette recherché est donc d’examiner le
Recommended publications
  • Mezinárodní Komparace Vysokorychlostních Tratí
    Masarykova univerzita Ekonomicko-správní fakulta Studijní obor: Hospodářská politika MEZINÁRODNÍ KOMPARACE VYSOKORYCHLOSTNÍCH TRATÍ International comparison of high-speed rails Diplomová práce Vedoucí diplomové práce: Autor: doc. Ing. Martin Kvizda, Ph.D. Bc. Barbora KUKLOVÁ Brno, 2018 MASARYKOVA UNIVERZITA Ekonomicko-správní fakulta ZADÁNÍ DIPLOMOVÉ PRÁCE Akademický rok: 2017/2018 Studentka: Bc. Barbora Kuklová Obor: Hospodářská politika Název práce: Mezinárodní komparace vysokorychlostích tratí Název práce anglicky: International comparison of high-speed rails Cíl práce, postup a použité metody: Cíl práce: Cílem práce je komparace systémů vysokorychlostní železniční dopravy ve vybra- ných zemích, následné určení, který z modelů se nejvíce blíží zamýšlené vysoko- rychlostní dopravě v České republice, a ze srovnání plynoucí soupis doporučení pro ČR. Pracovní postup: Předmětem práce bude vymezení, kategorizace a rozčlenění vysokorychlostních tratí dle jednotlivých zemí, ze kterých budou dle zadaných kritérií vybrány ty státy, kde model vysokorychlostních tratí alespoň částečně odpovídá zamýšlenému sys- tému v ČR. Následovat bude vlastní komparace vysokorychlostních tratí v těchto vybraných státech a aplikace na český dopravní systém. Struktura práce: 1. Úvod 2. Kategorizace a členění vysokorychlostních tratí a stanovení hodnotících kritérií 3. Výběr relevantních zemí 4. Komparace systémů ve vybraných zemích 5. Vyhodnocení výsledků a aplikace na Českou republiku 6. Závěr Rozsah grafických prací: Podle pokynů vedoucího práce Rozsah práce bez příloh: 60 – 80 stran Literatura: A handbook of transport economics / edited by André de Palma ... [et al.]. Edited by André De Palma. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar, 2011. xviii, 904. ISBN 9781847202031. Analytical studies in transport economics. Edited by Andrew F. Daughety. 1st ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1985. ix, 253. ISBN 9780521268103.
    [Show full text]
  • Alta Velocidade Ferroviária Em Portugal
    Nuno Filipe Ramos Maranhão Alta Velocidade Ferroviária em Portugal Viabilidade económica do transporte de passageiros nos eixos prioritários Dissertação de Mestrado em Economia apresentada à Faculdade de Economia da Universidade de Coimbra para cumprimento dos requisitos necessários à obtenção do grau de Mestre janeiro de 2014 Nuno Filipe Ramos Maranhão Alta Velocidade Ferroviária em Portugal Viabilidade económica do transporte de passageiros nos eixos prioritários Dissertação de Mestrado em Economia, na especialidade de Economia Industrial, apresentada à Faculdade de Economia da Universidade de Coimbra para obtenção do grau de Mestre Orientador: Prof. Doutor Daniel Murta Coimbra, 2014 Agradecimentos Se o trabalho de projeto é, pela sua finalidade académica, um trabalho individual, há contributos de natureza diversa que não podem e nem devem deixar de ser realçados. Por essa razão, expresso os meus agradecimentos: Aos meus pais José e Maria e ao meu irmão César, pelo inestimável apoio e compreensão que preencheram as diversas falhas que fui tendo, e pela paciência revelada ao longo destes anos. Ao Professor Daniel Murta, meu orientador, pela competência científica e acompanhamento do trabalho, cujas críticas, correções e sugestões valorizei muito. Mas, sobretudo, pela relação de amizade e de proximidade, que espero ter sabido corresponder na dimensão que uma pessoa com a profundidade intelectual do Professor merece. Foi um privilégio. À Professora Adelaide Duarte, professora de Seminário de Investigação, porque genuinamente admiro o interesse que deposita na orientação da cadeira e pela agilidade de compreensão que consegue emprestar à multiplicidade de temas que os alunos tratam nos trabalhos de projeto. Um exemplo de nobreza e de entrega à causa da nossa Faculdade.
    [Show full text]
  • East Japan Railway Company Shin-Hakodate-Hokuto
    ANNUAL REPORT 2017 For the year ended March 31, 2017 Pursuing We have been pursuing initiatives in light of the Group Philosophy since 1987. Annual Report 2017 1 Tokyo 1988 2002 We have been pursuing our Eternal Mission while broadening our Unlimited Potential. 1988* 2002 Operating Revenues Operating Revenues ¥1,565.7 ¥2,543.3 billion billion Operating Revenues Operating Income Operating Income Operating Income ¥307.3 ¥316.3 billion billion Transportation (“Railway” in FY1988) 2017 Other Operations (in FY1988) Retail & Services (“Station Space Utilization” in FY2002–2017) Real Estate & Hotels * Fiscal 1988 figures are nonconsolidated. (“Shopping Centers & Office Buildings” in FY2002–2017) Others (in FY2002–2017) Further, other operations include bus services. April 1987 July 1992 March 1997 November 2001 February 2002 March 2004 Establishment of Launch of the Launch of the Akita Launch of Launch of the Station Start of Suica JR East Yamagata Shinkansen Shinkansen Suica Renaissance program with electronic money Tsubasa service Komachi service the opening of atré Ueno service 2 East Japan Railway Company Shin-Hakodate-Hokuto Shin-Aomori 2017 Hachinohe Operating Revenues ¥2,880.8 billion Akita Morioka Operating Income ¥466.3 billion Shinjo Yamagata Sendai Niigata Fukushima Koriyama Joetsumyoko Shinkansen (JR East) Echigo-Yuzawa Conventional Lines (Kanto Area Network) Conventional Lines (Other Network) Toyama Nagano BRT (Bus Rapid Transit) Lines Kanazawa Utsunomiya Shinkansen (Other JR Companies) Takasaki Mito Shinkansen (Under Construction) (As of June 2017) Karuizawa Omiya Tokyo Narita Airport Hachioji Chiba 2017Yokohama Transportation Retail & Services Real Estate & Hotels Others Railway Business, Bus Services, Retail Sales, Restaurant Operations, Shopping Center Operations, IT & Suica business such as the Cleaning Services, Railcar Advertising & Publicity, etc.
    [Show full text]
  • Railroad (UP) BNSF Railway (BNSF)
    Union Pacific Railroad (UP) BNSF Railway (BNSF) September 3, 2014 Sacramento, California 1 Help inform planning for near, mid, and long-term planning horizons. ◦ Sustainable Freight Plan ◦ State Implementation Plan ◦ Scoping Plan, etc Identify current state of advanced technologies that provide opportunities for emission reductions. 2 3 Background on North American Freight Rail Operations Historical Evolution of Technology and Operations Framework for Technology Assessment Assessment of Technologies to Reduce Locomotive Emissions 4 5 Seven Class I (Major) Freight Railroads in US Operating on 160k miles of track with Chicago as a major hub. UP and BNSF National Fleet of ~15,000 locomotives. ◦ 10,000 interstate line-haul and 5,000 regional and switch locomotives 6 Courtesy of GE ~4,400 hp Diesel engine powers electric alternator which provides electricity to the locomotive traction motors/wheels. Two Domestic Manufacturers: General Electric (GE) and Electro-Motive Diesel (EMD) 7 Interstate Line Haul (4,400 hp) ◦ Pull long trains across the country (e.g., Chicago to Los Angeles) ◦ Consume ~330,000 gallons of diesel annually. ◦ Operate 5-10% of time within California Medium Horsepower (MHP) (2,301-4,000 hp) ◦ Regional, helper, and short haul service. ◦ Consume ~50,000-100,000 gallons of diesel annually. ◦ Most operations in California or western region. Switch (Yard) (1,006-2,300 hp) ◦ Local and rail yard service. ◦ Consume ~25,000-50,000 gallons of diesel annually. ◦ Most operations in and around railyards. 8 Cajon Junction Colton • UP Cajon / Palmdale (8 trains per day) BNSF Transcon (66 trains per day) UP Cajon / Cima (9 trains per day) UP Coastal (1 train per day) Northern UP, Metrolink Valley Sub (9 trains per day) Alameda Corridor (UP and BNSF: UP Sunset (40 trains per day) 45 trains per day) 10 50% improvement in efficiency since 1980 (~1.8%/year) ◦ Due to operational and technology improvements ◦ FRA and rail roads project continued fuel efficiencies of about 1% per year.
    [Show full text]
  • About Suspension of Some Trains
    About suspension of some trains Some trains will be suspended considering the transport of passengers due to the outbreak of the Novel Coronavirus. *Please note that further suspension may be subject to occur. 【Suspended Kyushu Shinkansen】 (May 11 – 31) ○Kumamoto for Kagoshima-Chūō ※Service between Kumamoto and Shin-Osaka is available. Name of train Kumamoto Kagoshima-Chūō Day of suspension SAKURA 545 10:34 11:20 May 11~31 SAKURA 555 15:23 16:10 May 11~31 SAKURA 409 12:18 13:15 May 11~31 ○Kagoshima-Chūō for Kumamoto ※Service between Kumamoto and Shin-Osaka is available. Name of train Kagoshima-Chūō Kumamoto Day of suspension SAKURA 554 11:34 12:20 May 11~31 SAKURA 562 14:35 15:20 May 11~31 SAKURA 568 17:18 18:03 May 11~31 MIZUHO 612 18:04 18:48 May 11~31 【Suspended Hokuriku Shinkansen】 (May 1 – 31) ○Tōkyō for Kanazawa Name of train Tōkyō Kanazawa Day of suspension KAGAYAKI 521 8:12 10:47 May 1~31 KAGAYAKI 523 10:08 12:43 May 2. 9. 16. 23. 30 KAGAYAKI 525 10:48 13:23 May 1~4. 9. 16. 23. 30 KAGAYAKI 527 11:48 14:25 May 2. 3. 5. 6 KAGAYAKI 529 12:48 15:26 May 2~6 KAGAYAKI 531 13:52 16:26 May 1. 3~6. 8. 15. 22. 29. 31 KAGAYAKI 533 14:52 17:26 May 1. 8~10. 15~17. 22~24. 29~31 KAGAYAKI 535 17:04 19:41 May 2~6 KAGAYAKI 539 19:56 22:30 May 1~6.
    [Show full text]
  • Uredas, URGENT EARTHQUAKE DETECTION and ALARM SYSTEM, NOW and FUTURE
    13th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering Vancouver, B.C., Canada August 1-6, 2004 Paper No. 908 UrEDAS, URGENT EARTHQUAKE DETECTION AND ALARM SYSTEM, NOW AND FUTURE Yutaka NAKAMURA 1 SUMMARY UrEDAS, Urgent Earthquake Detection and Alarm System, can realize the real-time early earthquake detection and alarm system in the world. There is a local government that has realized a tsunami warning system using real-time estimated earthquake parameters as magnitude and location, distributed by UrEDAS. On 26th May 2003, the Miyagiken-Oki Earthquake was occurred. It was so large that the maximum acceleration of about 600 Gal was observed along the Shinkansen line and 23 columns of the rigid frame viaducts (RC) were severely cracked. This earthquake occurred on the business hours of the Shinkansen. As expected, coastline “Compact UrEDAS” along the Shinkansen took out the early P-wave alarm before the destructive earthquake motion and the validity of this system was proved for the first time. INTRODUCTION UrEDAS is the only real time P-wave alarm system over the world on practical use. It is characterized to be able to process digitized waveform step by step without saving. Amount of procedure does not differs either earthquake occurs or not, so failure because of over load will not occur. The 2003 Miyagiken-Oki earthquake (Mj 7.1) occurred on 26th May, Compact UrEDAS worked as expected. It was for the first time that the validity of the early warning system was verified under circumstances of big earthquake such as rigid frame viaducts of Shinkansen were damaged. In this paper, the present condition of P-wave early detection system UrEDAS will be viewed referring to cases at work, also result of test observation where faults exists will be reported.
    [Show full text]
  • Modell Des THALYS PBKA
    Modell des THALYS PBKA 37791 Inhaltsverzeichnis Seite Sommaire Page Informationen zum Vorbild 4 Informations concernant la locomotive réelle 5 Hinweise zur Inbetriebnahme 6 Indications relatives à la mise en service 6 Sicherheitshinweise 10 Remarques importantes sur la sécurité 14 Allgemeine Hinweise 10 Informations générales 14 Funktionen 10 Fonctionnement 14 Schaltbare Funktionen 11 Fonctions commutables 15 Parameter / Register 26 Paramètre / Registre 26 Wartung und Instandhaltung 27 Entretien et maintien 27 Ersatzteile 33 Pièces de rechange 33 Table of Contents Page Inhoudsopgave Pagina Information about the prototype 4 Informatie van het voorbeeld 5 Notes about using this model for the first time 6 Opmerking voor de ingebruikname 6 Safety Notes 12 Veiligheidsvoorschriften 16 General Notes 12 Algemene informatie 16 Functions 12 Functies 16 Controllable Functions 13 Schakelbare functies 17 Parameter / Register 26 Parameter / Register 26 Service and maintenance 27 Onderhoud en handhaving 27 Spare Parts 33 Onderdelen 33 2 Indice de contenido Página Innehållsförteckning Sida No tas para la puesta en servicio 6 Anvisningar för körning med modellen 6 Aviso de seguridad 18 Säkerhetsanvisningar 22 Informaciones generales 18 Allmänna informationer 22 Funciones 18 Funktioner 22 Funciones posibles 19 Kopplingsbara funktioner 23 Parámetro / Registro 26 Parameter / Register 26 El mantenimiento 27 Underhåll och reparation 27 Recambios 33 Reservdelar 33 Indice del contenuto Pagina Indholdsfortegnelse Side Avvertenza per la messa in esercizio 6 Henvisninger
    [Show full text]
  • About Suspension of Some Temporary Trains(Translation:PDF76KB)
    About suspension of some temporary trains Some temporary trains will be suspended considering the transport of passengers due to the outbreak of the Novel Coronavirus. *Please note that further suspension may be subject to occur. 【Suspended Sanyo Shinkansen】 (April 1 – May 6) ○Tōkyō for Hakata Name of train Tōkyō Hakata Day of suspension NOZOMI 135 7:12 12:14 May 6 NOZOMI 137 7:21 12:19 May 3. 4 NOZOMI 139 8:12 13:14 May 3 NOZOMI 145 9:12 14:14 May 3. 6 NOZOMI 149 10:12 15:14 May 3 NOZOMI 151 10:42 15:47 May 2. 4 NOZOMI 155 11:42 16:47 May 3 NOZOMI 159 12:42 17:47 May 2 NOZOMI 163 13:42 18:47 May 2. 6 NOZOMI 169 14:42 19:47 May 4 NOZOMI 173 15:21 20:19 May 2. 3. 5. 6 NOZOMI 181 16:42 21:46 May 6 NOZOMI 183 17:12 22:14 May 1. 6 NOZOMI 185 17:21 22:19 May 4 NOZOMI 189 18:12 23:14 May 1. 5 ○Hakata for Tōkyō Name of train Hakata Tōkyō Day of suspension NOZOMI 136 7:58 13:03 May 3 NOZOMI 138 8:31 13:33 May 1 NOZOMI 140 8:58 14:03 May 2. 3. 5. 6 NOZOMI 144 9:58 15:03 May 2. 3. 5. 6 NOZOMI 150 11:31 16:33 May 2. 5 NOZOMI 152 11:58 17:03 May 4 NOZOMI 156 12:58 18:03 May 3 NOZOMI 160 13:31 18:33 May 4 NOZOMI 170 15:31 20:33 May 2.
    [Show full text]
  • Railroad Postcards Collection 1995.229
    Railroad postcards collection 1995.229 This finding aid was produced using ArchivesSpace on September 14, 2021. Description is written in: English. Describing Archives: A Content Standard Audiovisual Collections PO Box 3630 Wilmington, Delaware 19807 [email protected] URL: http://www.hagley.org/library Railroad postcards collection 1995.229 Table of Contents Summary Information .................................................................................................................................... 4 Historical Note ............................................................................................................................................... 4 Scope and Content ......................................................................................................................................... 5 Administrative Information ............................................................................................................................ 5 Controlled Access Headings .......................................................................................................................... 6 Collection Inventory ....................................................................................................................................... 6 Railroad stations .......................................................................................................................................... 6 Alabama ...................................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Rail Accident Report
    Rail Accident Report Fatal collision between a Super Voyager train and a car on the line at Copmanthorpe 25 September 2006 Report 33/2007 September 2007 This investigation was carried out in accordance with: l the Railway Safety Directive 2004/49/EC; l the Railways and Transport Safety Act 2003; and l the Railways (Accident Investigation and Reporting) Regulations 2005. © Crown copyright 2007 You may re-use this document/publication (not including departmental or agency logos) free of charge in any format or medium. You must re-use it accurately and not in a misleading context. The material must be acknowledged as Crown copyright and you must give the title of the source publication. Where we have identified any third party copyright material you will need to obtain permission from the copyright holders concerned. This document/publication is also available at www.raib.gov.uk. Any enquiries about this publication should be sent to: RAIB Email: [email protected] The Wharf Telephone: 01332 253300 Stores Road Fax: 01332 253301 Derby UK Website: www.raib.gov.uk DE21 4BA This report is published by the Rail Accident Investigation Branch, Department for Transport. Fatal collision between a Super Voyager train and a car at Copmanthorpe, 25 September 2006 Contents Introduction 5 Summary of the report 6 Key facts about the accident 6 Immediate cause, contributory factors, underlying causes 7 Severity of consequences 7 Recommendations 7 The Accident 8 Summary of the accident 8 The parties involved 8 Location 9 External circumstances 9 Train
    [Show full text]
  • Applicable Directivity Description of Railway Noise Sources
    THESIS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY Applicable Directivity Description of Railway Noise Sources XUETAO ZHANG Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering Division of Applied Acoustics, Vibroacoustic Group CHALMERS UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY Göteborg, Sweden 2010 Applicable Directivity Description of Railway Noise Sources XUETAO ZHANG ISBN 978-91-7385-416-0 © Xuetao Zhang, 2010 Doktorsavhandlingar vid Chalmers tekniska högskola Ny serie nr 3097 ISSN 0346-718X Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering Division of Applied Acoustics Chalmers University of Technology SE – 412 96 Göteborg Sweden Tel: +46 (0) 31-772 2200 Fax: +46 (0) 31-772 2212 Cover: 3D directivity pattern of a perpendicular dipole pair, viewed along the axis of the red dipole component which is 4 dB weaker than the blue one. Printed by Chalmers Reproservice Göteborg, Sweden, 2010 ii Applicable Directivity Description of Railway Noise Sources XUETAO ZHANG Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering Division of Applied Acoustics Chalmers University of Technology Abstract For a sound source, directivity is an important parameter to specify. This parameter also reflects the physical feature of the sound generation mechanism. For example, turbulence sound is of quadrupole directivity while fluid-structure interaction often produces a sound of dipole characteristic. Therefore, to reach a proper directivity description is in fact a process of understanding the sound source in a better way. However, in practice, this is often not a simple procedure. As for railway noise engineering, several noise types of different directivity characters are often mixed together, such as wheel and rail radiation, engine and cooling fan noise, scattered fluid sound around bogies and turbulent boundary layer noise along train side surfaces.
    [Show full text]
  • Timetables ALFA Pendular/Intercities from LISBOA SANTA APOLONIA to PORTO CAMPANHA and BRAGA 07/15/2005 05:25 PM
    Timetables ALFA Pendular/Intercities from LISBOA SANTA APOLONIA to PORTO CAMPANHA and BRAGA 07/15/2005 05:25 PM ALFA Pendular/Intercities Trains Timetables ALFA Pendular/Intercities See the terms of use LISBOA - PORTO - BRAGA - GUIMARAES: Train family: Train number: 121 123 521 125 127 523 Services on bord: Observations: [1] [2] [2] [2] [1] [2] LISBOA SANTA 06:55 07:55 08:55 09:55 10:55 12:55 APOLONIA LISBOA - ORIENTE 07:04 08:04 09:04 10:04 11:04 13:04 VILA FRANCA DE --- --- 09:16 --- --- 13:16 XIRA SANTAREM --- 08:43 09:47 10:43 11:43 13:47 ENTRONCAMENTO --- 09:01 10:05 11:01 12:01 14:06 FATIMA --- --- 10:19 --- --- --- CAXARIAS --- --- 10:27 --- --- 14:26 POMBAL --- 09:37 10:44 11:33 12:33 14:46 ALFARELOS --- --- 10:59 --- --- --- COIMBRA-B 08:48 10:01 11:11 11:57 12:57 15:12 PAMPILHOSA --- --- 11:21 --- --- --- MEALHADA --- --- --- --- --- 15:25 AVEIRO 09:11 10:25 11:40 12:22 13:22 15:44 ESTARREJA --- --- 11:50 --- --- 15:53 OVAR --- --- 12:00 --- --- --- ESPINHO --- 10:50 12:13 12:49 13:48 16:14 http://www.cp.pt/horarios/alfa_ic/e_401_2_66_84.html Page 1 of 4 Timetables ALFA Pendular/Intercities from LISBOA SANTA APOLONIA to PORTO CAMPANHA and BRAGA 07/15/2005 05:25 PM GAIA 09:45 11:00 12:25 13:00 14:00 16:25 PORTO 09:50 11:09 12:30 13:05 14:05 16:30 CAMPANHA FAMALICAO --- 11:37 --- --- --- --- BRAGA --- 11:55 --- --- --- --- TROFA --- --- --- --- --- --- SANTO TIRSO --- --- --- --- --- --- VIZELA --- --- --- --- --- --- GUIMARAES --- --- --- --- --- --- Train family: Train number: 129 525 131 133 531 135 Services on bord: Observations:
    [Show full text]