In Search of the Scottish Royal Mausoleum at the Benedictine

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

In Search of the Scottish Royal Mausoleum at the Benedictine In Search of the Scottish Royal Mausoleum at the Benedictine Abbey of Dunfermline, Fife: Medieval Liturgy, Antiquarianism, and a Ground-Penetrating Radar Pilot Survey, 2016-19 by Michael Penman and Erica Carrick Utsi 1 © Copyright Michael Penman and Erica Carrick Utsi Stirling and Ely 2020 Cover: Composite of GPR scans of sections of lost choir of Dunfermline Abbey, 2016-17 – 1a, 1b from 2016 [© Atlas Geophysical] 2 Summary Today, visitors to the Benedictine Abbey of Dunfermline, Fife, find a church of two halves. To the west the surviving medieval Catholic abbey nave which also served as the original parish church of Dunfermline; to the east the modern Protestant Abbey Church of Dunfermline, built in 1818-21 atop the ruins of the abbey’s medieval choir. The lost east-end of this great church had been the focus of the cult shrine of Queen/St Margaret (d.1093) and the site of multiple royal and aristocratic burials down to 1420 before it was sacked at the Reformation of 1560. Thereafter it fell into successive generations of neglect and reuse as a town stone-source and then burial ground, the ‘Psalter churchyard’. As a result, little to no evidence survives – either written or material – to enable us to recreate the overall evolving layout and spiritual life of the lost abbey choir, not least the position and form of the many royal burials within this mausoleum and cult church. What discussion there has been of these important features has been dominated by a focus on the tomb and remains of King Robert Bruce/I (1306-29) whose grave was believed to have been found in 1818 when the choir ruins were cleared to make way for the new Abbey Church build. Medieval Scottish chroniclers had briefly reported Bruce as being buried at the abbey ‘in the middle of the choir.’ However, such evidence that this grave and skeleton did indeed belong to Bruce remains, in several important ways, quite ambivalent and open to differing interpretation. Nor does a focus on the 1818 grave tell us anything of the larger living medieval church. It was in this context that the project outlined in the following report sought to apply Ground- Penetrating Radar [GPR] to the lost choir site. We planned to scan down both through the modern interior floor of the Abbey Church to the medieval depths, and in search of similar archaeology beneath accessible exterior ground atop the choir ruins. We hoped this would provide some fresh evidence which could in turn be used to reassess the surviving medieval written and material evidence, in combination with the many antiquarian finds and observations about the abbey, its choir and tombs reported in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. Once brought together, this evidence might allow us to paint a fuller picture of the architectural and liturgical nature of the choir with a focus on the period from c.1250-1, when St Margaret was moved to her new east-end shrine and the choir expanded, down to c.1560. Our pilot stage GPR scans of 2016, 2017 and 2019 can be said, cautiously, to have been successful thanks to the application of a tailored method of scanning for buried and overbuilt medieval ecclesiastical remains. This report (and its three accompanying technical field reports by GPR expert Erica Utsi) will summarise those scans’ key findings of: - Multiple potential elite burials at the likely medieval depths in the northern Transept/Lady aisle area of the choir, perhaps in pairs down the east-west axis of that aisle adjacent to the fourteenth-century Lady Chapel extension. - Potential evidence for a large north-south architectural feature running across the overbuilt choir presbytery space, perhaps the medieval sanctuary steps. - Evidence for multiple potential burials beneath the floor of the Abbey Church’s east- end vestry, thus beneath the sanctuary pavement and ambulatory of the mid-thirteenth- century feretory shrine extension for St Margaret. As these burials lie west of the surviving fossiliferous marble base of Margaret’s shrine they may, however, also belong to the period of ‘Psalter’ churchyard interments of Protestant townsfolk c.1560- c.1818. 3 - Evidence for potential burials or, more likely, the foundations of architectural or liturgical fittings to the east of the 1818 ‘Bruce grave’ and thus around the likely site of the medieval high altar of the abbey and its chancel/altar screens. - Evidence for the footings of the walls of the east and west ends of the northern Lady Chapel extension of the choir and, perhaps, of some liturgical fittings or tombs within that Chapel’s interior which can be scanned through the ground outside the Abbey Church’s North Transept. - Likely evidence for a southern choir chapel dedicated to St John the Baptist and of a shape and scale matching that of the northern Lady Chapel. This possible finding will require testing and verification in drier weather better suited to GPR work but, if confirmed, allows us to envisage a full symmetrical form for the late medieval choir at Dunfermline and its pilgrimage cult ambulatory and evolving royal mausoleum. The report then combines these initial GPR findings with previously unnoticed or overlooked medieval and antiquarian evidence to make the case for: - A focus for royal and aristocratic burials in the Lady aisle as well as in the northern Lady Chapel in the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries, with a likely concentration of couples, perhaps as double tombs; earlier royal burials would have been focussed in the central monks’ choir/presbytery area. - A second possible location for the tomb of Robert Bruce. This was reported by an antiquarian investigator as lying a ‘few yards to the south west’ of the site of six slabs within the Lady Chapel long believed by locals to cover royal burials, and thus within the northern edge of the medieval presbytery or along its boundary with the Lady aisle (perhaps between columns). - A reassessment of our understanding of the cruciform axes of this great church as running both east-west and north-south, not simply east-west with a focus on the high altar. This should mean that a wider and larger central ‘presbytery’ space in the choir could be the site of royal burials like that of Bruce and his queen, Elizabeth de Burgh, alongside the shrine of Margaret’s son, David I (1124-53), who had elevated the house to a full abbey and, like both his parents, was believed by the monks to be a saint. - A possible double tomb for Robert Bruce and Elizabeth, like such royal couples’ marble monuments to be found in the French royal mausoleum in the contemporary Benedictine abbey of St Denis, outside medieval Paris. - Recreating the position and basic physical form of the medieval high altar and eastern sanctuary/chancel of the choir, and thus to question both the dating of the 1818 ‘Bruce grave’ as pre-Reformation and that it did actually belong to that king. Recreating the high altar and sanctuary space also provides possible evidence for the nature of the access points into the post-1250 shrine chapel of St Margaret. - A growing interest after the Reformation among local families in securing ‘Psalter churchyard’ burial close to the shrine of St Margaret, particularly in the retro- choir/vestry area. - The potential existence of a matching south-side transept aisled chapel, dedicated to St John the Baptist, thus confirming both the accuracy of the ground-plan of the surviving medieval walls recorded by the Abbey Church’s architect-builder in 1818, William Burn (but one which modern heritage plans of the abbey have ignored since then), and 4 the fully symmetrical cruciform shape of the late medieval choir thus with an extensive circuitous pilgrimage ambulatory. - The possibility that for liturgical reasons Alexander III (1249-86) was buried in this St John aisle or chapel. - The possibility that the previously overlooked evidence of both the anthropomorphic (body-shaped) lead coffin and the crude, shallow stone crypt of the 1818 ‘Bruce grave’ actually point to this being a late sixteenth/seventeenth century burial and thus perhaps a post-Reformation rescue burial of a medieval body or a later ‘Psalter’ intrusion. - The lost late medieval choir with all its key chapels, altars, tombs and inter-related liturgical spaces can be cautiously reimagined in all its evolving complexity as very much a Scottish mirror-image of the English and French royal mausoleums at Westminster and St Denis (both also Benedictine houses dedicated to the Trinity and royal saints) and with its own unique liturgical setting and meanings. The report closes with some proposals for further GPR and allied research which could make an important contribution to the fresh (re-)interpretation of Dunfermline Abbey planned for the immediate future. Not least, this closes with the possibility of locating evidence for further potential royal graves and liturgical settings within the central (and western) choir/presbytery and aisles/chapels of the Abbey’s lost east end. 5 Contents Page Partners 2 Summary 3 Acknowledgements 7 Map – key ecclesiastical sites in Scotland mentioned in the main text 10 List of Abbreviations 11 List of Figures 13 i. Introduction Dunfermline Abbey c.1093-c.2020 21 The ambivalence of the medieval chroniclers 33 ii. A Ground-Penetrating Radar pilot survey (2016-19) 42 William Burn and the building of the Abbey Church, c.1817-22 44 Pilot Survey 1: 13-14th June 2016 a. The North Transept 51 b. The Vestry 56 Pilot Survey 2: 12th-14th June 2017 a. The Central area between Vestry and Dais (including the ‘Bruce grave’) 58 b. The East End of the Lady Chapel, exterior to the Abbey Church North Transept 64 c.
Recommended publications
  • 126613853.23.Pdf
    Sc&- PUBLICATIONS OF THE SCOTTISH HISTORY SOCIETY VOLUME LIV STATUTES OF THE SCOTTISH CHURCH OCTOBEK 190' V STATUTES OF THE SCOTTISH CHURCH 1225-1559 Being a Translation of CONCILIA SCOTIAE: ECCLESIAE SCOTI- CANAE STATUTA TAM PROVINCIALIA QUAM SYNODALIA QUAE SUPERSUNT With Introduction and Notes by DAVID PATRICK, LL.D. Printed at the University Press by T. and A. Constable for the Scottish History Society 1907 CONTENTS INTRODUCTION— i. The Celtic Church in Scotland superseded by the Church of the Roman Obedience, . ix ir. The Independence of the Scottish Church and the Institution of the Provincial Council, . xxx in. Enormia, . xlvii iv. Sources of the Statutes, . li v. The Statutes and the Courts, .... Ivii vi. The Significance of the Statutes, ... lx vii. Irreverence and Shortcomings, .... Ixiv vni. Warying, . Ixx ix. Defective Learning, . Ixxv x. De Concubinariis, Ixxxvii xi. A Catholic Rebellion, ..... xciv xn. Pre-Reformation Puritanism, . xcvii xiii. Unpublished Documents of Archbishop Schevez, cvii xiv. Envoy, cxi List of Bishops and Archbishops, . cxiii Table of Money Values, cxiv Bull of Pope Honorius hi., ...... 1 Letter of the Conservator, ...... 1 Procedure, ......... 2 Forms of Excommunication, 3 General or Provincial Statutes of the Thirteenth Century, 8 Aberdeen Synodal Statutes of the Thirteenth Century, 30 Ecclesiastical Statutes of the Thirteenth Century, . 46 Constitutions of Bishop David of St. Andrews, . 57 St. Andrews Synodal Statutes of the Fourteenth Century, vii 68 viii STATUTES OF THE SCOTTISH CHURCH Provincial and Synodal Statute of the Fifteenth Century, . .78 Provincial Synod and General Council of 1420, . 80 General Council of 1459, 82 Provincial Council of 1549, ...... 84 General Provincial Council of 1551-2 ...
    [Show full text]
  • Talking Gothic! What Do We Mean by Gothic Architecture and How Can We Identify It?
    Talking Gothic! What do we mean by Gothic architecture and how can we identify it? ‘Gothic’ is the name we give to a style of architecture from the Middle Ages. It is usually thought to have begun near Paris in the middle of the 1100s and, from there, it spread throughout Europe and continued into the 16th century. There are many marvellous examples of Gothic buildings throughout Scotland: from Elgin Cathedral in Moray, through amazing buildings like Glasgow Cathedral, Paisley Abbey and Edinburgh St Giles, down to Melrose Abbey in the Scottish Borders. All of these, and more, are well worth a visit! Gothic architecture developed from an earlier style we call Romanesque. Buildings made in the Romanesque style often have rounded arches on their (usually comparatively small) windows and doors, thick columns and walls, lots of ornamental patterns, and shorter structures than the buildings which came later. Dunfermline Abbey is a great example of a Romanesque building in Scotland. The people who paid for the earliest Gothic buildings expressed a wish to transport worshippers to a kind of Heaven on Earth by building higher and brighter churches. What emerged is what we now describe as Gothic. Fashions changed throughout the time that Gothic was the predominant style, and it also varied from place to place. However, the Classical revival made popular as part of the Italian Renaissance largely replaced the Gothic style, and it wasn’t fashionable again until the 19th century. During the Romantic Movement Medieval literature, arts and crafts enjoyed renewed popularity. As a result, Glasgow Cathedral was begun in the Gothic elements can be seen today in the churches, public buildings, and late 12th century and was at the hub of the Medieval city.
    [Show full text]
  • St John the Evangelist Scottish Episcopal Church
    St John the Evangelist Scottish Episcopal Church Forres General Data Protection Compliance Statement St John’s Forres is an incumbency within the Scottish Episcopal Church. It is established exclusively for charitable purposes, primarily for the advancement of religion and to provide public benefit. (The expression “charitable purposes” shall mean a charitable purpose as defined in section 7 of the Charities and Trustee Investment (Scotland) Act 2005 as amended from time to time (“the 2005 Act”) which is also regarded as a charitable purpose in relation to the application of the Taxes Acts from time to time in force.) In order to progress its charitable purposes, the Clergy and Vestry of St John’s Forres collects and processes information from congregation members on the legal basis of informed consent. This information supports the following activities: 1. Pastoral care for the congregation 2. Financial security for the incumbency, its employees and its assets 3. Charitable giving 4. Communication with congregation members about the worship pattern and other activities of the church. 5. Enabling St John’s to provide a voluntary service for the benefit of the wider community. Vestry is responsible for the privacy, security, retention of this information within legal limits, and destruction/deletion of the same when appropriate. It undertakes to audit this information and to assess for risk on an annual basis, to enable subject access appropriately if so requested, and to ensure that congregation members are made aware of exactly what use is intended from the information which is requested and processed. Sharing of your data Your personal data is confidential and will be shared only as set out here.
    [Show full text]
  • The Gazetteer for Scotland Guidebook Series
    The Gazetteer for Scotland Guidebook Series: Stirling Produced from Information Contained Within The Gazetteer for Scotland. Tourist Guide of Stirling Index of Pages Introduction to the settlement of Stirling p.3 Features of interest in Stirling and the surrounding areas p.5 Tourist attractions in Stirling and the surrounding areas p.9 Towns near Stirling p.15 Famous people related to Stirling p.18 Further readings p.26 This tourist guide is produced from The Gazetteer for Scotland http://www.scottish-places.info It contains information centred on the settlement of Stirling, including tourist attractions, features of interest, historical events and famous people associated with the settlement. Reproduction of this content is strictly prohibited without the consent of the authors ©The Editors of The Gazetteer for Scotland, 2011. Maps contain Ordnance Survey data provided by EDINA ©Crown Copyright and Database Right, 2011. Introduction to the city of Stirling 3 Scotland's sixth city which is the largest settlement and the administrative centre of Stirling Council Area, Stirling lies between the River Forth and the prominent 122m Settlement Information (400 feet) high crag on top of which sits Stirling Castle. Situated midway between the east and west coasts of Scotland at the lowest crossing point on the River Forth, Settlement Type: city it was for long a place of great strategic significance. To hold Stirling was to hold Scotland. Population: 32673 (2001) Tourist Rating: In 843 Kenneth Macalpine defeated the Picts near Cambuskenneth; in 1297 William Wallace defeated the National Grid: NS 795 936 English at Stirling Bridge and in June 1314 Robert the Bruce routed the English army of Edward II at Stirling Latitude: 56.12°N Bannockburn.
    [Show full text]
  • Scotland: Bruce 286
    Scotland: Bruce 286 Scotland: Bruce Robert the Bruce “Robert I (1274 – 1329) the Bruce holds an honored place in Scottish history as the king (1306 – 1329) who resisted the English and freed Scotland from their rule. He hailed from the Bruce family, one of several who vied for the Scottish throne in the 1200s. His grandfather, also named Robert the Bruce, had been an unsuccessful claimant to the Scottish throne in 1290. Robert I Bruce became earl of Carrick in 1292 at the age of 18, later becoming lord of Annandale and of the Bruce territories in England when his father died in 1304. “In 1296, Robert pledged his loyalty to King Edward I of England, but the following year he joined the struggle for national independence. He fought at his father’s side when the latter tried to depose the Scottish king, John Baliol. Baliol’s fall opened the way for fierce political infighting. In 1306, Robert quarreled with and eventually murdered the Scottish patriot John Comyn, Lord of Badenoch, in their struggle for leadership. Robert claimed the throne and traveled to Scone where he was crowned king on March 27, 1306, in open defiance of King Edward. “A few months later the English defeated Robert’s forces at Methven. Robert fled to the west, taking refuge on the island of Rathlin off the coast of Ireland. Edward then confiscated Bruce property, punished Robert’s followers, and executed his three brothers. A legend has Robert learning courage and perseverance from a determined spider he watched during his exile. “Robert returned to Scotland in 1307 and won a victory at Loudon Hill.
    [Show full text]
  • Monarchy in Scotland | the Edinburgh Legal History Blog
    Edinburgh Research Explorer Monarchy in Scotland Citation for published version: Cairns, JW, Monarchy in Scotland, 2013, Web publication/site, Edinburgh Legal History Blog. <http://www.elhblog.law.ed.ac.uk/2013/07/23/monarchy-in-scotland/> Link: Link to publication record in Edinburgh Research Explorer Document Version: Publisher's PDF, also known as Version of record Publisher Rights Statement: © Cairns, J. (Author). (2013). Monarchy in Scotland. Edinburgh Legal History Blog. General rights Copyright for the publications made accessible via the Edinburgh Research Explorer is retained by the author(s) and / or other copyright owners and it is a condition of accessing these publications that users recognise and abide by the legal requirements associated with these rights. Take down policy The University of Edinburgh has made every reasonable effort to ensure that Edinburgh Research Explorer content complies with UK legislation. If you believe that the public display of this file breaches copyright please contact [email protected] providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim. Download date: 24. Sep. 2021 Monarchy in Scotland | The Edinburgh Legal History Blog http://www.elhblog.law.ed.ac.uk/2013/07/23/monarchy-in-scotland/ The Edinburgh Legal History Blog Monarchy in Scotland Posted on 23/07/2013 by John Cairns The birth of a Prince to the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge on 22 July calls for some reflection in a Legal History Blog, particularly one based in Scotland, with which our British Royal family has such close links, both ancient and recent. Of course, the Duke’s and Duchess’s studies at the University of St Andrews are well known; less well known is that the Duchess’s sister, “Pippa” Middleton, studied at your blogger’s University of Edinburgh.
    [Show full text]
  • OFFICE-BEARERS and MEMBERS ELECTED SINCE May 5. 1823
    ( 457 ) LIST OF THE OFFICE-BEARERS AND MEMBERS ELECTED SINCE MARCH 3. 1823. May 5. 1823. MEMBERS ELECTED. ORDINARY. Capt. THOMAS DAVID STEWART, Hon. E. I. Comp. Service. ANDREW FYFE, M. D. ROBERT BELL, Esq. Advocate. June 2. 1823. MEMBERS ELECTED. ORDINARY. Capt. NORWICH DUFF, R. N. WARREN HASTINGS ANDERSON, Esq. LISCOMBE JOHN CURTIS, Esq. Ingsdon House, Devonshire. ALEXANDER THOMSON, Esq. of .Banchory, Advocate. 4 3 M2 458 LIST OP OFFICE-BEARERS AND MEMBERS November 24. 1823. OFFICE-BEARERS. Sir WALTER SCOTT, Bart. President. VICE-PEESIDENTS. Right Hon. LORD CHIEF BARON. Dr T. C. HOPE. Lord GLENLEE. Professor RUSSELL. Dr BREWSTER, General Secretary. THOMAS ALLAN, Esq. Treasurer. JAMES SKENE, Esq. Curator of the Museum. PHYSICAL CLASS. ALEXANDER IRVING, Esq. President. JOHN ROBISON, Esq. Secretary. Counsellors from the Physical Class. Sir JAMES HALL, Bart. ROBERT STEVENSON, Esq. Dr KENNEDY. Sir. W. ARBUTHNOT, Bart. Rev. Dr MACKNIGHT. JAMES JARDINE, Esq. LITERARY CLASS. HENRY MACKENZIE, Esq President.. P. F. TYTLER, Esq. Secretary. Counsellors from the Literary Class. THOMAS THOMSON, Esq. Professor WILSON. GEORGE FORBES, Esq. Sir W. HAMILTON, Bart. Lord MEADOWBANK. Rev. Dr LEE. ELECTED SINCE 1823. 459 December 1. 1823. MEMBERS ELECTED. FOREIGN. M. THENARD, Member of the Institute, and Professor of Chemistry in the College of France. ORDINARY. ROBERT KNOX, M. D. ROBERT CHRISTISON, M. D. Professor of Medical Juris- prudence. GEORGE KELLIE, M. D. Leith. January 19. 1824. MEMBERS ELECTED. HONORARY. The Rev. JOHN BRINKLEY, D. D., F. R. S., and President of the Royal Irish Academy. W. H. WOLLASTON, M. D., F. R. S. &c. &c* FOREIGN. WILLIAM HAIDINGER, Esq.
    [Show full text]
  • In Search of Dunfermline Abbey's Lost Medieval Choir
    History Scotland (Sep/Oct 2020) 20.5, pp. 20-26 Part 1: In Search of Dunfermline Abbey’s lost medieval choir: history, liturgy and ground-penetrating radar. Michael Penman The many visitors to Dunfermline Abbey and Palace in Fife typically encounter a church of two halves. To the west stands the medieval nave and, until 1821, parish church. Stripped of its post-Reformation pews and lofts and re-presented as a stunning Romanesque-Gothic stone shell, it still coveys much of the misty spirituality of its Benedictine monastery dedicated to the Holy Trinity. Its elegant columns speak to its former scale and status and its strong links with Benedictine Durham Cathedral Priory through the 11th and 12th centuries. Fig 1: Dunfermline Abbey’s buttressed medieval nave (west) and modern Abbey Church (east) [© Robert Cutts, CC BY 2.0] However, of the later medieval monastic choir to the east (and the cloisters) little remains. The great east-end of this church was left ruinous by the iconoclasm of the Reformation. Like its nave, it had been home to successive royal and aristocratic burials and the cult of the queen of Malcolm III, St Margaret (d.1093), canonised in 1249. Long used after the Reformation as a romantic burial ground by local townspeople, known as the ‘Psalter’ churchyard, the choir ruins were eventually cleared and overbuilt c.1817-21 to make way for a new Presbyterian ‘Abbey Church’ of Dunfermline parish, conjoined to the nave. Fig 2: The fossiliferous marble base of St Margaret’s feretory shrine within her east-end chapel, outside the Abbey Church vestry [Author’s photograph].
    [Show full text]
  • Man in Moray
    10 0 I w! Fig.2.1 Moray. MANIN MORAY 5,000 years of history Ian Keillar Synopsis The extent of Moray is defined and the physical conditions briefly described. Traces of Mesolithic man have been found in the Culbin, and later Neolithic peoples found Moray an attractive place to settle. As metal working became established, trades routes followed and Moray flourished. As the climate deteriorated, so, apparently, did the political situation and defensive sites became necessary. The Romans came and went and the Picts rose and fell. The Vikings did not linger on these shores and MacBeth never met any witches near Forres. The Kings of Scots divided and ruled until they themselves set a pattern, which still continues, that if you want to get on you must go south to London. In distant Moray, brave men like Montrose and foolish men like Prince Charles Edward, fought for their rightful king. The Stuarts, however, ill rewarded their followers. Road makers and bridge builders half tamed the rivers, and the railways com­ pleted the process. With wars came boom years for the farmers, but even feather beds wear out and Moray is once more in apparent decline. However, all declines are relative and the old adage still has relevance: 'Speak wee] o the Hielans but live in the Laich.' Physical The name Moray is now applied to a local authority administrative District extending from west of Forres and the Findhorn to Cullen and stretching down in an irregular triangle into the highlands of the Cairngorms (Fig.2. l ). In Medieval times, Moray reached as far as Lochalsh on the west coast and there has always been some difficulty in defining the bound­ aries of the province.
    [Show full text]
  • W. Stanford Reid 1286·1370
    W. Stanford Reid THE ENGLISH STIMULUS TO SCOTTISH NATIONALISM, 1286·1370 Wherever a Scot goes in this world, he usually organizes a Burns Society, establishes a curling rink:, and perhaps opens a bank and a Presby, terian church. To those less fortunate individuals who are not Scots or who can claim no Scottish connection, these actions are manifestations of a rather silly but typical Scottish idiosyncrasy, for the Scot is above all other things almost uniquely nationalistic. Most people, even the Scots themselves, take this nationalism very much for granted, failing to realize that it is the result of a long process of his~ory which began in the thirteenth century. Moreover, they fail to recognize that had it not been for Englishmen such as the early Plantagenets, there might have been no Scottish national consciousness and feeling at all, for it was in response to their challenge that the Scots first came to look upon themselves as a nation. Although some historians have maintained that there was a strong Scottish national consciousness, particularly in the Highlands, before the thirteenth century, this seems to be an overstatement of the situation. 1 It is true that from the days of William the Lion (1165-1214) the monarchy had been generally recognized throughout the country without much controversy, but this recognition hardly guaranteed a feeling of nation' ality. The relationships of the barons to the crown were, as in most other countries of the time, primarily personaLz Indeed, in Scotland the feel­ ing of personal loyalty largely based upon the prefeudal clan system seems to have been particularly strong, not infrequently leading to violent and prolonged inter-tribal feuds and conflicts.
    [Show full text]
  • Holyrood Abbey Statement of Significance
    Property in Care (PIC) ID: PIC223 Designations: Scheduled Monument (SM13031) Taken into State care: 1906 (Ownership) Last reviewed: 2014 STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE HOLYROOD ABBEY We continually revise our Statements of Significance, so they may vary in length, format and level of detail. While every effort is made to keep them up to date, they should not be considered a definitive or final assessment of our properties. Historic Environment Scotland – Scottish Charity No. SC045925 Principal Office: Longmore House, Salisbury Place, Edinburgh EH9 1SH © Historic Environment Scotland 2019 You may re-use this information (excluding logos and images) free of charge in any format or medium, under the terms of the Open Government Licence v3.0 except where otherwise stated. To view this licence, visit http://nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open- government-licence/version/3/ or write to the Information Policy Team, The National Archives, Kew, London TW9 4DU, or email: [email protected] Where we have identified any third party copyright information you will need to obtain permission from the copyright holders concerned. Any enquiries regarding this document should be sent to us at: Historic Environment Scotland Longmore House Salisbury Place Edinburgh EH9 1SH +44 (0) 131 668 8600 www.historicenvironment.scot You can download this publication from our website at www.historicenvironment.scot Historic Environment Scotland – Scottish Charity No. SC045925 Principal Office: Longmore House, Salisbury Place, Edinburgh EH9 1SH HOLYROOD ABBEY SYNOPSIS The Augustinian Abbey of Holyrood was founded by David I in 1128 as a daughter-house of Merton Priory (Surrey). By the 15th century the abbey was increasingly being used as a royal residence – James II was born there in 1430 - and by the time of the Protestant Reformation (1560) much of the monastic precinct had been subsumed into the embryonic Palace of Holyroodhouse.
    [Show full text]
  • THE HOME of the ROYAL SOCIETY of EDINBURGH Figures Are Not Available
    THE HOME OF THE ROYAL SOCIETY OF EDINBURGH Figures are not available Charles D Waterston The bicentennial history of the Royal Society of Edinburgh1, like previous accounts, was rightly concerned to record the work and achievements of the Society and its Fellows. Although mention is made of the former homes and possessions of the Society, these matters were incidental to the theme of the history which was the advancement of learning and useful knowledge, the chartered objectives of the Society. The subsequent purchases by the Society of its premises at 22–28 George Street, Edinburgh, have revealed a need for some account of these fine buildings and of their contents for the information of Fellows and to enhance the interest of many who will visit them. The furniture so splendidly displayed in 22–24 George Street dates, for the most part, from periods in our history when the Society moved to more spacious premises, or when expansion and refurbishment took place within existing accommodation. In order that these periods of acquisition may be better appreciated it will be helpful to give a brief account of the rooms which it formerly occupied before considering the Society's present home. Having no personal knowledge of furniture, I acknowledge my indebtedness to Mr Ian Gow of the Royal Commission on the Ancient and Historical Monuments of Scotland and Mr David Scarratt, Keeper of Applied Art at the Huntly House Museum of Edinburgh District Council Museum Service for examining the Society's furniture and for allowing me to quote extensively from their expert opinions.
    [Show full text]