Garzweiler II’”, and the Legiti- Generation in the Near Future Have Contributed to This Image
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
INVESTIGATIVE DESIGN - PROJECt THE WANDERING HOLE » THE LARGEST MAN-MADE HOLES IN THE WORLD « , AND THEIR CONSEQUENCES 1km N The hole : Lake(2090) 2045 2015 1995 Master thesis by Hannah Hiecke, Information Design (M.A.), Design Academy Eindhoven, June 2015 Mentors : Simon Davies, Nikki Gonnissen, Joost Grootens, Jennifer Pettersson, Arthur Roeloffzen and Gert Staal Supply (RWE Power AG); Activists; Demand; Politics; Pro-Resettlement; Contra-Resettlement; Community; Critic; Research ABSTRACT To the current day, Germany counts worldwide as a model The broad range of research sources regarding this topic in- for the utilisation of and investment in renewable energy. dicates multifaceted perspectives from which to question the Measures such as the exit from stone coal and nuclear power necessity, sustainability of “‘Garzweiler II’”, and the legiti- generation in the near future have contributed to this image. macy of each of the interest groups involved. This research But these decisions have consequences and are becoming a was implemented in form of the design project “The wande- tangible reality in projects such as the brown coal strip mine ring hole”, which shows the interwoven multitudes of cont- “‘Garzweiler II’”. “‘Garzweiler II’” is a migratory brown coal rasts and dimensions. Looking in detail at the complexity at strip mine moving steadily through the landscape of North hand highlights the dynamic movements around and diffe- Rhine-Westphalia in Germany in order to provide a constant ring understandings of its various elements. Each position supply of energy from brown coal. “The wandering hole” exa- reacts differently to the economic realities. “The wandering mines the effects and reactions triggered by the mechanisms hole” creates transparency, sensitivity and an opportunity to and dynamics regarding “‘Garzweiler II’”. The “‘Garzweiler bring the viewer closer to the various perspectives involved in II’” situation is representative of a number of economically “‘Garzweiler II’”. utilised areas in Germany. Beyond that, similar conditions appear worldwide, where the interests of a community colli- de with individual circumstances. The present research is based on studies on village sociology, geography, and environmental psychology. These studies in the context of “‘Garzweiler II’” show a range of local, social, ecological as well as global effects of human interference with nature. Consequences can be shown to be expected for the near as well as distant future. “The wandering hole” visuali- ses the relationship between the energy revolution, the large German utility corporation RWE, political as well as global decisions and their influence on long-standing structures, systems and relatively small seeming elements like families, communities, and the notion of home. PHOTO : Open brown coal pit in Germany 1990 03 04 LEGEND GEOGRAPHICAL ENERGY SOURCE Farmland Nuclear energy Brown coal Open brown coal pit Field Natural gasoline Ground water Mineral oil Park Renewable energy Sand or ‚excavation material ‘ Biogas Lake Sun Forest Wind Water Other energy sources INFRASTRUCTURE Opencast lignitic coal pit Thermal power station Autobahn (highway) Hydroelectric power plant Railroad Gas pipe Oil pipe OtHER Motorway Street Cultivation Water Digger Inner harbour City ( < 100.000 population) Airport Large city ( > 100.000 population) Leisure time Megacity (> 1.000.000 population) Industry House or block of buildings Pumps Opencast pit ‘Garzweiler II’ Stock farming INTEREST GROUPS The present research and design project „The wandering hole“ is used to represent and raise awareness of the individual involved interest groups. OtHER RESOURCES For this purpose the different interest groups are distinguished in the course of the thesis : Iron Fluorite Supply by energy company (RWE Power AG) Tin Asbestos Activists (From non-governmental, environmental and nature Copper Talc protection till voluntary committed organizations) Zinc Phosphor Demand ( From local, national till global users) Nickel Gypsum Politics (Governing parties in NRW) Chrome Titanium Resettler Manganese Pro-resettlement (Unanchored-to-home) Aluminium Contra-resettlement (Anchored-to-home ) Lead Community (Example : Rifle assoication Gold Borschemich) Silver Audience : Critiv (Example UN Climate Change Conference) Salt Audience : Designer (Positioning of the narrative Potassium and investigative research) Sulphur Spar 05 CONTENT 03 ABSTRACT 22 COMMUNICATION 05 LEGEND 23 Social Networks 23 Criticism 10 INTRODUCTION 24 GARZWEILER 12 [ Opencast pit in Germany 1968 – 2050 ] 24 Quality of the Brown Coal from the Garzweiler Strip Mine 15 RESEARCHQUESTION 24 BORSCHEMICH 15 RESEARCHMETHOD 15 Problem 25 EVAPorating hoMelanD 16 Design Approach 25 STABILITY 16 Methodology 25 Definition of the Sense of Home 17 Implementation of the Design Approach 26 IDENTITY 17 Positioning 26 The Awareness of Surroundings 18 RESEARCHAREA 26 Orientation & Aesthetics 18 NORTH RHINE WESTPHALIA 27 (Social) Constructivist 18 NRW’s Energy Policy Landscape Research 19 BROWN COAL IN NRW 27 MEMORIES 19 Formation of Brown Coal 27 The Location-Updating Effect 20 The Rhineland Mining District 28 FRICTION 20 RWE ( Rheinisch–Westfälisches Elektrizitätswerk ) 29 ECONOMY & 22 PRESENCE COMMON GOOD 07 28 JUDICIARY 37 TOTAL LOSS 28 APPROVAL 28 THE RIGHT TO A HOME 38 OPEN BROWN COAL PIT IN GERMANY : TOdaY 29 Resistance and Solidarity 38 Inefficiency 38 Future 30 conSEQUenceS 39 CURRENT SITUATION 30 MIGRATION 30 CONSEQUENCES FOR THE LANDSCAPE 40 conclUSion 30 INTERFERENCE WITH NATURE 30 Dewatering 32 Woodland Clearing 32 COMPENSATION 32 Reclamation 32 Final-Cut Pits 35 SOcIAL CONSEQUENCES 43 APPENDIX 35 RESEttLEMENT 35 PROCESS 51 RESOURCES 35 Partial Resettlement 52 REFERENCE – INTERVIEW 36 CONCEPT 52 REFERENCE – BÜCHER 36 Community 54 REFERENCE – PDFS / LINKS 36 COMPENSATION 55 REFERENCE – VIDEOS 37 UPROOTING & 55 REFERENCE – OtHER EXPROPRIATION 57 INDEX 37 Social Changes 08 09 INTRODUCTION FIGURE 01 : Economic use in NRW FIGURE 02 : Urban agglomeration in NRW (dark means high density of agglomeration) FIGURE 03 : Commuter in NRW FIGURE 04 : (Large) cities in NRW Germany as a whole sources almost a quarter of the energy Around 18 Million people live in NRW; it is the most popu- mix it consumes from local brown coal. The industrial utili- lous of the German federal states . In 2014, there were 29 sation of brown coal as a resource has a history of almost 200 cities (see FIG. 04), with a rising tendency for growth1. In no years in Germany and forms the origin of German indust- other area of Germany are population density and industrial rial history (see TABLE 01 on the next page). The locations of activity as high as in NRW2. This makes the area particu- brown coal power plants indicate the areas with the highest larly prone to clashes of economic, social and political inte- industrial activity. The largest industrial region lies in North rest groups. The dynamics and tensions of an industrialised Rhine-Westphalia - NRW (see FIG. 01). country and their consequences become apparent. Economic Economic hubs are not only attractive for companies, but phenomena and proportions particularly stand out: It is a also a magnets for many people (see FIG. 02) working or look- construct of power, money, sacrifices for the greater good, de- ing for work in that industry. A mutual economic dependen- pendency and insecurity, rethinking, trust and distrust. ce becomes evident (see FIG. 03). Over time, industrial history Added to this is a growing awareness for the environment has developed its own mechanism and legitimacy . and sustainability . Climate change causes a change in 1 City with more than 100,000 inhabitants (Source: http://universal_lexikon.deacade- mic.com/35009/Gro%C3%9Fstadt 26 January 2015) 2 „The excellent infrastructure, the central location and the people‘s high qualifications have made the most populous of the German federal states an economic power on an international scale in its own right. North Rhine-Westphalia ranks among the world‘s best in many economic indicators.” (Translated quote) [ Source: http://www.nrwinvest.com/nrwinvest_deutsch/NRW_ im_Ueberblick/Daten_Fakten/Wirtschaftsregion/index.php ( 26 January 2015 ) ] 10 ‚THE WANDERING HOLE‘ FIGURE 05 : History and development of RWE as a monopoly company in the Rhineland many views, and there will be, and will have to be, some res- On the one hand, interest groups form that are primarily in- tructuring. Energy generation from brown coal is inefficient terested in brown coal as a source of energy. (See FIG. 05) For and one of the energy sources causing the most damage to one, in the shape of a large public limited company (in this the environment3. Brown coal strip mines and power plants case, the RWE Power AG) , who makes money by turning attract increasing criticism. The debate on the issue of brown coal into electric energy. This satisfies the majority of harmful emissions gains more and more weight. In contrast Germany’s energy demand. Connected to them is the interest to sustainability-focussed rethinking, lignite strip mining group that determines demand . It ranges from individual continues to stand as a leading element of industrialisation households to big business. The consumers have anexpec - in the Rhineland: After Germany’s exit from stone tation of a stable, affordable electricity price. On the other coal (2006) and nuclear power generation (2011), brown hand we have the interest group of people who are mainly coal is one of the last remaining fossil