arXiv:physics/0608279v1 [physics.hist-ph] 29 Aug 2006 n he os pcfial,Rsn,Slaoe Luciano, Salvatore, Maria. daughters Rosina, and two specifically, Ettore had sons, they three and the and Corso Majo- of Dorina Massimo member married Fabio a rana Lincei. and dei University Accademia Bologna prestigious experimen- at of physics professor renowned tal brother a younger Majorana the in Inspec- Quirino was Rome of General Majorana in Massimo Communication be Fabio of Majorana, family Ministry to 1928. Italian Massimo influential appointed the Fabio of was and was tor that known father engineer His well an a city. that in of 1906 5th [3]. gust sciences social value and of the physics message on in laws focus readership main statistical its the the of invite with to consider contribution is last to note Majorana’s News this of Europhysics found aim of be The can 2]. that [1, information on in the biographical based The discuss mainly are article. and notes 10th introduce Majorana’s of and points main Majorana Ettore about among known least the probably articles. is 10th his his article specifically This articles, Majorana’s article. in- of directly entitled one Economics” by 17-23 and spired September Physics Tsal- on in C. Laws Course and ”Statistical a Zichichi, Pietronero scheduled A. L. has by Gell-Mann, lis, co-directed M. Italy Benedek, Erice, Scien- G. for of of Centre Culture” Complexity and arti- tific Foundation on the Majorana School of ”Ettore International each will the the on volume Lastly, note The descriptive cles. English. brief a in language contain and includ- original also Italian) the volume cases in a most both of (in articles publication Majorana’s Italiana all the Societ ing concerns the Catania of Fisica in initiative held di Another be 5-6. will October that of on Italy Astronomia century” e Catania, Fisica XXI of di University the ”Ettore Dipartimento of the on Physics by Among Conference organized the and International initiatives. legacy the of Majorana’s is series The there a times. them all triggered of physicists has Italian centenary major the of one rana, h aiymvdt oei 91 toeMajorana Ettore 1921. in Rome to moved family The Au- on Italy Catania, in born was Majorana Ettore details biographical few a sketch briefly we note this In Majo- Ettore of birth the of centenary the is year This 1 iatmnod iiaeTcooi eaie Universit`a Relative, Tecnologie e Fisica di Dipartimento rgnlveso h oeo ttsia asi hsc and physics in laws statistical theo of in role achievements Majo the sciences. exceptional Ettore on of his views birth only elementary the original not of an centenary reconsider of the to level of observed occasion p laws the statistical the a at between hope in analogy determinism atom formal or of a particle lack suggest single This a of level. evolution biographical statistical time few art irreducible the 10th an a describe Majorana’s sketch as of mechanics briefly points quantum we main considers note the this discuss and In introduce times. all of hsya stecneayo h it fEtr aoaa on Majorana, Ettore of birth the of centenary the is year This h et ril fEtr Majorana Ettore of Article Tenth The oai uzoMantegna Nunzio Rosario iPlro il el cez,I918Plro Italy Palermo, I-90128 Scienze, delle Viale Palermo, di mnto rcdr.H hrfr eaepoesrof professor became therefore ex- the He outside namely as procedure. fama”, Majorana ”chiara amination for E. the professor nominate full that should a proposed Education work therefore of the and Minister with candidates comparison other above the and G.of work Persico, outstanding his E. be considered to Lazzarino, unanimously Carelli, O. A. Fermi, and E. Polvani of Commit- The composed of University. tee professor Palermo a of at in position physics an a part theoretical obtain taking showed to by physics again examination during physics national he theoretical theoretical Rome in when in to interest involvement 1937 active return until his his declined 1933 After research of fall where Bohr. Copenhagen the Niels briefly met this inter- and positively he Heisenberg, in he W. work where Lipsia, with his visited act of he the- 1933 to most the In energy produced During his field. all and devoted Fermi. physics he E. 1933 oretical of to 1929 supervision from the years of under physics in 1929 half development graduated Majorana first in the Ettore the century. in last of the physics of period nuclear and heroic mechanics quantum the of professional physicists a as then Et- and of student involvement started. the a the physicist at as time happen that Majorana At did tore Physics En- 1928. of of of School Institute beginning the the from to Majorana Fermi.gineering Ettore Enrico by of led passage physicists convince of The group to Et- the attempted join of to he qualities Ettore meanwhile exceptional and the Segr Majorana Emilio tore about physics, talking Edoardo of often environment example, was new for the In as, such Amaldi. suc- Theo- physicists other by of Italian followed was professor cessful path old) full same years The of 26 position Physics. retical the time to that of nominated (at Institute was Fermi the Enrico to he where Segr Engineering Emilio Engineering Physics of 1926 School of In the Sapienza” from Segr. School moved Emilio ”La with the only interact At to time started Engineering that existed). of (at School University University the his at Rome obtained enrolled of he then He where Tasso” diploma. Torquato and Massimo” Statale ”Istituto schools ”Liceo secondary the at studied toeMjrn a n ftegets theoretical greatest the of one was Majorana Ettore hoybcueteter sntal to able not is theory the because theory npyisadi h oilsine.We sciences. social the in and physics in nohrdsilnssc stesocial the as such disciplines other in eia hsc u lohsfehand fresh his also but physics retical ce nhsatceMjrn explicitly Majorana article his In icle. eieevrneta deterministic a at environment recise aawl eueu ormme and remember to useful be will rana eal bu toeMjrn and Majorana Ettore about details 1 hsclsse oiae i to him motivated system physical ftemjrIainphysicists Italian major the of e 2 theoretical physics at Naples University where he taught same epistemological basis as the modeling of physical a quantum mechanics course during the academic year systems. 1937-38. His conclusion was considered as rather peculiar and Ettore Majorana mysteriously disappeared in March was accepted as a general belief by only a minority of 1938 during a trip on the ship connecting Palermo to physicists for several years. For example in the book ”La Naples. His body was never found although the search vita e l’opera di Ettore Majorana” [1], Edoardo Amaldi for Majorana both by government officials and members just wrote a single sentence on this article in a biograph- of the Majorana family continued for a long time. Enrico ical and scientific note of 49 pages. Even today, Ma- Fermi had a very high estimation of him. In the letter jorana’s point of view might indeed still be rather un- he wrote in 1938 to the Italian prime Minister of that popular among mainstream physicists, in spite of more time, Benito Mussolini, asking the government to inten- than 70 years of quantum mechanics and after some ma- sify the support of Ettore’s research, Fermi stated ”I have jor breakthrough in the fields of critical phenomena and no hesitation to state to You, and I am not saying this as chaos theory. an hyperbolic statement, that of all Italian and foreign There is a pioneering nature of this article both from scholars that I have had the opportunity to meet, Majo- the perspective of physics and economics. From the rana is among all of them the one that has most struck physics point of view, Majorana took a clear position me for his deep sharpness” [2]. about the key aspect that quantum mechanics forces sci- Majorana was not a prolific author. He just pub- entists to use a statistical description down to events in- lished 9 articles before his disappearance and a 10th arti- volving single entities. From the point of view of eco- cle, whose manuscript was found by Majorana’s brother nomics and social sciences, there is an emphasis on the among his files, was published in 1942 after his disappear- observation that statistical laws have to be used in eco- ance in the international Italian journal Scientia, through nomic and social modeling. It should be noted this posi- the interest of his friend Giovanni Gentile Jr.. Nine of tion was not that of the majority of scholars working in these articles were written in Italian and one in German. the thirties of the last century in both the disciplines con- Italian is not a widespread language and this limitation sidered. In fact, during the thirties of the last century the has prevented Majorana’s work becoming known and cor- interaction between social sciences and natural scientists rectly evaluated by a vast community of scientists. I have was developed under the paradigm of celestial mechanics translated the 10th article of Majorana ”The value of sta- (the only exception to this approach was the one pur- tistical laws in physics and social sciences” to provide to sued by Louis Bachelier that at that time had no impact a broad audience of physicists the possibility of direct on the academy [4]). This interaction goes back to the access to the article. The translation was recently pub- development of general equilibrium theory pursued by lished in Quantitative Finance 5, 133-140 (2005). Walras, Pareto, Schlesinger and Wald. The emphasis of The article is a rather special article in several respects. Majorana on the intrinsic statistical nature of most of the In the original presentation for Scientia, Giovanni Gen- underlying processes describing natural phenomena sug- tile Jr. wrote that the article was originally written for a gests that statistical laws should be incorporated into a sociology journal. This article was therefore intended to modeling approach to social phenomena. This approach present the point of view of a physicist about the value has eventually found its best achievement in finance with of statistical laws in physics and social sciences to schol- the Black and Scholes modeling of option pricing [5]. ars of a broad spectrum of different disciplines such as The topic considered by Majorana in his article is sociology and economics. In his article, Majorana con- timely today for a series of reasons. First, it should siders quantum mechanics as a fundamental and success- be noted that a cross-disciplinary consensus about the ful theory able to describe the basic processes involving epistemological value of statistical laws in different dis- single particles and atoms. He explicitly considers the ciplines is not easily found today. The major paradigm theory as a statistical theory because the theory is not of the validity of a scientific theory is still based on the able to describe the time evolution of a single particle or falsification procedure of a law. It is undisputable that atom in a precise environment at a deterministic level. this approach has been devised having in mind the most As an example of the lack of determinism in the time characteristic laws in physical sciences, i.e. deterministic evolution of a single system he discusses the case of the laws or laws having a deterministic part (as is the case for decay of a radioactive atom. This lack of determinism quantum mechanics when the time evolution of the wave at the level of an elementary physical system motivated function is considered or for random walk theory when him to suggest a formal analogy between statistical laws one considers the statistical description of an ensemble of observed in physics and the social sciences. In his article, walks). During the past years it has been progressively he concludes that there is an ”essential analogy between realized that such an approach might not be the most physics and the social sciences, between which an identity appropriate to other disciplines such as, for example, bi- of value and method has turned out”. These words seem ology. For this important and successful discipline, the to pioneer the view that an investigation of complex sys- nature of the laws (or sometimes theories) is often intrin- tems (indeed this term is literally present in the article) sically related to the prevalence of indeterminacy owing of economic or social origin might be conducted on the to the high frequency of stochastic processes unavoidably 3 involved and moreover a double causality (one related to been performed with tools of statistical physics properly the external conditions and forces and one governed by adapted or extended. For example, one of these models the amount of information inherited at the biological level is the minority game [7, 8] recently investigated within under consideration) is present in most cases [6]. Simi- the new research field of econophysics [9]. lar observations are most probably also valid for social In summary, the 10th article of Majorana raised the ne- sciences. cessity of focusing the attention of several disciplines on Physics might certainly benefit from a deeper under- the value and nature of statistical laws. From physics, to standing of the role, necessity and peculiarity of statis- biology and to social sciences, all the scientific disciplines tical laws in physics. Some of the statistical laws are present statistical laws and scholars of these disciplines eventually reinterpreted in terms of more fundamental need to reflect about their role within each discipline. and deterministic laws. However there are cases when a Majorana noticed that quantum mechanics made clear reduction seems to be impossible. One of these cases is that a scientific description without statistical laws is im- indeed quantum mechanics and other more recent exam- possible. Today there is still a need to assess the status of ples concern the topics of chaos and critical phenomena statistical laws and to consider the validation procedures theory. By somewhat inverting the perspective of the re- that are most appropriate to these sorts of laws. Valida- lations between physics, biology and the social sciences, tion procedures probably need to be different from those it might be worth discussing the possibility that physi- originally devised having in mind deterministic laws. cists should also start to consider as proper to their dis- I hope the occasion of the centenary of the birth of cipline the investigation of systems where the basic ele- Ettore Majorana will be useful to remember and to re- ments composing the system are in possession of a certain consider not only his exceptional achievements in theo- level of internal information and are characterized by a retical physics but also his fresh and original views on certain ability to react to external stimuli by properly the essential aspects, importance and role of statistical processing the available external information with inher- laws in physics and in other disciplines such as the social ited or adaptive rules. Investigations of this kind have sciences.

[1] Edoardo Amaldi, La vita e l’opera di Ettore Majorana, 654 (1973). Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei (Roma, 1966). [6] Ernst Mayr, The autonomy of biology: The position of [2] Erasmo Recami, Il Caso Majorana, Di Renzo Editore biology among the sciences, The Quarterly Review of Bi- (Roma, 2002). ology, 71, 97-106 (1996). [3] Ettore Majorana, Il valore delle leggi statistiche nella fisica [7] Damien Challet, Matteo Marsili, Yi-Cheng Zhang, Minor- e nelle scienze sociali, Scientia, Quarta serie, Febbraio- ity Games : Interacting Agents in Financial Markets, Ox- Marzo 1942 pp. 58-66. English translation in Ettore Ma- ford University Press (2005). jorana, The value of statistical laws in physics and social [8] Anthony C.C. Coolen, The Mathematical Theory of sciences, Quantitative Finance 5, 133–140 (2005). Minority Games : Statistical Mechanics of Interacting [4] Louis Bachelier, Thorie de la spculation, Ph.D. thesis in Agents, Oxford University Press (2005). mathematics, Annales Scientifiques de l’Ecole Normale [9] J. Doyne Farmer, Martin Shubik, and Eric Smith, Is Eco- Suprieure, III-17, 21–86 (1900). nomics the Next Physical Science?, Physics Today 58, 37- [5] Fisher Black and Myron S. Scholes, The Pricing of Op- 42 (2005). tions and Corporate Liabilities, J. Polit. Econ., 81, 637–