Sogn og Fjordane, Møre og Romsdal, Sør-Trøndelag, Nord-Trøndelag og Nordland Fullstendige områdebeskrivelser
Norsk institutt for naturforskning, stiftelsen Siste Sjanse og Miljøfaglig utredning AS har beskrevet 70 potensielle naturvernområder med tanke på vern av skog på Statskog SFs arealer. Det er skrevet en egen rapport (Heggland, A. (red)) som sammenfatter metode og hovedmønsteret i resultatene for de undersøkte områdene. I tillegg omfatter rapporten et sammendrag (faktaark med kart) for hvert område. De fullstendige områdebeskrivelsene presenteres nå i fire separate deler som kun foreligger digitalt som pdf filer. Lokaliteter fra Hedmark og Oppland presenteres i hver sin del, Buskerud, Telemark og Aust-Agder i en del og Sogn og fjordane, Møre og Romsdal, Sør-Trøndelag, Nord-Trøndelag og Nordland i en del.
Lokalitetene er sortert i følgende rekkefølge:
Sogn og Fjordane Flensmarka Luster Vestre Statsallmenning Bjørkåsen Bymarka (utvidelse) Møre og Romsdal Tekssjøen Barsteintjernet Nordland Sør-Trøndelag/Nord-Trøndelag Holmvassdalen Grytdalen (utvidelse)
Siste Sjanse -Stiftelse for bevaring av biologisk mangfold
Oversiktsrapport Heggland, A. (red). Naturfaglige registreringer i forbindelse med vern av skog på Statskog SFs eiendommer, del 1 (2004). Årsrapport for registreringer utført i 2004. – NINA Rapport 44. 210 s inkl. vedlegg. Sogn og Fjordane
Gloppen Stryn
Jølster
Luster
Førde
Balestrand Sogndal
Årdal
Leikanger
Luster Vestre Statsallmenning
Vik Lærdal
Aurland
Verneforslag Nasjonalpark Fylkesgrense Vann ± Kommunegrense Skog 0102030 Kilometer /XVWHU9HVWUH6WDWVDOOPHQQLQJ
5HIHUDQVHGDWD )\ONH 6RJQRJ)MRUGDQH 3URVMHNWWLOK¡ULJKHW 6WDWVNRJ'3 .RPPXQH /XVWHU ,QYHQW¡U **$%+/ .DUWEODG ,,,,, 'DWRIHOWUHJ 870 1 $UHDO GDD +RK PRK 9HJHWDVMRQVRQH 6¡UERUHDO 9HJHWDVMRQVHNVMRQ 2&2YHUJDQJVVHNVMRQ
6DPPHQGUDJ /XVWHU9HVWUH6WDWVDOOPHQQLQJOLJJHULLQGUH6RJQSnYHVWVLGHQDY/XVWUDIMRUGHQRJJUHQVHUPRW6RJQGDONRPPXQHLYHVW $OOPHQQLQJHQEHVWnUDYHLJDQVNHEUDWWRJMHYQIMRUGOLVRPEDUHKDUVYDNHJUDGLHQWHULHNVSRVLVMRQPHOORPQRUG¡VWRJ V¡U¡VW$QRUWKRVLWWHQVRPGRPLQHUHUEHUJJUXQQHQJLUJUXQQODJIRUHQOLWHNDONNUHYHQGHRJQ¡\VRPNDUSODQWHYHJHWDVMRQ 7HUUHQJRJNOLPDI¡UHUVDPWLGLJWLODWGHWHUPHVWW¡UUHVNRJW\SHUVRPE UO\QJVNRJRJGnUOLJXWYLNOHWOnJXUWVNRJ)XUXVNRJ GRPLQHUHUPHQGHWHURJVnHQGHOERUHDOODXYVNRJPHGEM¡UNRJRVSVDPWLQQVODJDYQRHHGHOODXYVNRJPHGOLQGRJKDV VHO,WLOOHJJHUGHWHWDYJUHQVHWEHVWDQGPHGHOGUHVHOYIRU\QJHWJUDQLQRUG6NRJDWHLJHQVRPEOHVNRJUHVHUYDWDOOHUHGH L 1RUJHVI¡UVWH %RUWVHWWIUDQRHQPLQGUHJUDQSODQWHIHOWQ UVM¡HQHURPUnGHWXWHQQ\HUHLQQJUHSDYEHW\GQLQJ 'HULPRWE UHUGHWSUHJDYnKDY UWJDQVNHMHYQWRJGHOVKDUGWJMHQQRPKRJGWLGOLJHUH(QNHOWHNUDYIXOOHRJGHOVU¡GOLVWHGH DUWHUHUSnYLVWEODHLGLUHNWHWUXHWMRUGVWMHUQHQ\IRU6RJQRJ)MRUGDQH /RNDOLWHWHQYXUGHUHVVRPUHJLRQDOWYHUQHYHUGLJ ,SRVLWLYUHWQLQJWUHNNHUHQJRGDUURQGHULQJJDQVNHVWRUWDUHDOLQNOXGHUW HQJRGGHOVNRJLV¡UERUHDOYHJHWDVMRQVVRQHRJIUDY UDYQ\HUHLQQJUHS,QHJDWLYUHWQLQJWUHNNHUGHQVYDNHYDULDVMRQV EUHGGHQRYHUYHLHQGHIDWWLJYHJHWDVMRQInU¡GOLVWHDUWHURJEHJUHQVHWSRWHQVLDOHIRUVOLNHVDPWGnUOLJNRQWLQXLWHWLG¡GW WUHYLUNHRJJDPOHWU U,IRUKROGWLOPDQJHODQDO\VHQ )UDPVWDGHWDO IDQJHURPUnGHWEDUHRSSHQNHOWHDYGHSnSHNWH PDQJOHQHRJGDLI¡UVWHUHNNHLQQVODJHWDYODYHUHOLJJHQGHV¡UERUHDOVNRJ'HULPRWKDUGHWGnUOLJPHGULNHVNRJW\SHUHOOHU DQVYDUVW\SHUPDQJOHUVWRUHIRUHNRPVWHUDYOLWHSnYLUNHWVNRJRJKDUInYLNWLJHIRUHNRPVWHUDYU¡GOLVWHDUWHU,HQUHJLRQDO VDPPHQKHQJNRPPHURPUnGHWPLGGHOVJRGWXW'HWKDUHQYLVVUHSUHVHQWDWLYYHUGLVDPWLGLJVRPGHWHUVWRUWPHGJRGH K¡\GHJUDGLHQWHURJJRGDUURQGHULQJ'HULPRWHUGHWÀHUHDQGUHVWRUHRPUnGHULLQGUH6RJQVRPKDUHWNODUWK¡\HUHLQQVODJ DYULNHVNRJW\SHUPLQGUHSnYLUNHWVNRJÀHUHU¡GOLVWHDUWHUVDPWEHGUHVSHQQYLGGHLVNRJW\SHU9HVWUH/XVWHUVWDWVDOOPHQ QLQJIDQJHUPHGDQGUHRUGRSSHQGHOVNRJOLJHNYDOLWHWHUIRUUHJLRQHQPHQVLNUHULNNHYDULDVMRQVEUHGGHQHOOHUGHWELROR JLVNHPDQJIROGHW%RUWVHWWIUDIRUHNRPVWHQDYJUDQVNRJWLOI¡UHUGHWOLWHQ\WWLIRUKROGWLOKYDDQGUHVWRUHVNRJRPUnGHUJM¡U %nGHLV¡URJLQRUGJUHQVHUDOOPHQQLQJHQRSSPRWIMRUGOLHUPHGQDWXUVNRJVWRUWVHWWXWHQVW¡UUHQ\HUHLQQJUHS
)HOWDUEHLG (WWGDJVYHUNEOHEHQ\WWHW9LKDGGHPHGHQOLWHQEnWRJNM¡UWHLQQLRPUnGHWIUD0DQQKLOOHUIHUMHOHLHLV¡U**DEOHVDWWSn ODQGYHG+HOJMDRJJLNNIMRUGOLDV¡URYHULJMHQRJEOHKHQWHWRSSOLNHV¡UIRU6YDUWKLOOHU%+/IRUWVDWWHYLGHUHPRW)XUHQHVHW RJJLNNHQUXQGHLGHQGHOHQDYRPUnGHW,WLOOHJJEHWUDNWHWYLRPUnGHWIUDIMRUGHQPHGEUXNDYNLNNHUW
7LGVSXQNWRJY UHWVEHW\GQLQJ 9 UIRUKROGHQHYDUJRGHPHGVWLOOHRJNODUWK¡VWY U7LGVSXQNWHWYDUWUROLJJRGWHJQHWIRUnIDQJHRSSJUXSSHUVRPPRVHU VRSSRJODYRJDQWDVKHOOHULNNHnKDSnYLUNHWQHJDWLYWNDUSODQWHÀRUDHQLQRHQJUDG+HNNHQGHIXJOHDUWHUORWVHJGHULPRW LNNHUHJLVWUHUHVnVHLQWSnVHVRQJHQ
8WYHOJHOVHRJXQGHUV¡NHOVHVRPUnGH 8QGHUV¡NHOVHVRPUnGHWXWJM¡UHQJDQVNHVWRUVDPPHQKHQJHQGHHLHQGRPVHQKHWGRPLQHUWDYVNRJPHGDQGUHHLHUHSn DOOHNDQWHU(WPLQGUHVNRJEHVWDQGKDUWLGOLJHUHEOLWWYHUQHWVRPQDWXUUHVHUYDW'HWKDULWLOOHJJIRUHOLJJHWHQNHOWHUHJLVWUH ULQJHUVRPLQGLNHUHUYHUGLHUIRUVW¡UUHGHOHUDYHLHQGRPPHQ MIU*DDUGHU1DWXUEDVHQ
7LGOLJHUHXQGHUV¡NHOVHU 7LGOLJHUHELRORJLVNNXQQVNDSRPNULQJRPUnGHWHUEHJUHQVHW6NRJDWHLJHQQDWXUUUHVHUYDWOLJJHULQRUGUHGHODYRPUnGHW RJEOHVRP1RUJHVI¡UVWHVNRJUHVHUYDWYHUQHWDOOHUHGHL'HWKDUY UWVMHNNHWRJRPWDOWÀHUHJDQJHUDYIDJIRONVH LNNHPLQVW%¡UVHW RJ0RH 'HWIRUHOLJJHURJVnGDWDIUDHQEHIDULQJJMHQQRPP\HDYRPUnGHWPHGIRNXVSn IXJOHOLYHW *DDUGHU %¡UVHW KDUHQOHQJUHRPWDOHDY6NRJDWHLJHQGHUKDQVSHVLHOWJMHQQRPJnURJGLVNXWHUHUVNRJKLVWRULHQLNNHPLQVW QnURJKYRUGDQJUDQDHWDEOHUWHVHJ+DQQHYQHURJVnÀHUHHOGUHNLOGHUVRPKDUWDWWIRUVHJGHWWHWHPDHW+DQUHJLVWUHUWH IRU¡YULJNDUSODQWHÀRUDYHJHWDVMRQRJIXJOHOLYHW 0RH QHYQHUEODDW6NRJDWHLJHQKDURYHUYHLHQGHYDQOLJJUDQVNRJYHJHWDVMRQDYEOnE URJVPnEUHJQHW\SHU+DQ DQJLUYLGHUHDWGHWHUVWRUWVHWWVDPPHQKHQJHQGHJUDQVNRJPHOORPRJPRKRJDWHOGVWHPnOWHJUDQWUHYDUnU (WDEOHULQJHQDYJUDQDRPWDOHVPHGJUXQQODJLGLVNXVMRQKRV%¡UVHW 'HWQHYQHVGHUDWJUDQYDUHWDEOHUWLGLVWULNWHW DOWSnWDOOHWPHQDWHQLNNHHUVLNNHUSnIRUHNRPVWDYJUDQLQQHQIRUUHVHUYDWHWI¡USnPLGWHQDYWDOOHW0RH PHQHURJVnDWGDJHQVEHVWDQGVELOGHYLWQHURPDWGHWGUHLHUVHJRPI¡UVWHWUHJHQHUDVMRQ+DQYXUGHUHURJVnXWYL GHOVHUDYUHVHUYDWHWRJVNULYHUGDEOD³PHQOHQJHUQHGHHUGHWLNNHUHJLVWUHUWJUDQ+HUGRPLQHUHUHQIXUXVNRJVRPHU VWHGIYLVP\HRSSEODQGHWPHGRVSRJEM¡UN'HWHUHQK¡\UHWWVWDPPHWRJWHWWEHVWRNNHWIXUXVNRJVRPYLWQHURPJRGJMHQ YHNVWHWWHUDWOLHQVDQQV\QOLJYLVKDUY UWNUDIWLJDYYLUNHWWLGOLJHUH(QUHNNHVWXEEHUYLVHUGHWWHVDPWLGLJVRPWU UQHLNNHHU V UOLJJDPOH$OGHUVPnOLQJHQSnnUHUUHSUHVHQWDWLYWIRUGHMHYQJDPOHWU UQHPHGHQGLDPHWHUSnFDFP'HWWHHU HWYDQOLJVNRJELOGHODQJVIMRUGHQHLLQGUH6RJQKYLONHWEHW\UDWHQXWYLGHOVHDYUHVHUYDWHWPHGQHGHQIRUOLJJHQGHIXUXVNRJ LNNHNDQSULRULWHUHVV UOLJK¡\W´6RPNRQNOXVMRQKDU0RH VNUHYHWDW³6NRJDWHLJHQHUGHWVW¡UVWHJUDQRPUnGHWL LQGUH6RJQIUHGHWDOOHUHGHL'HWHUHQNRPSDNWJUDQVNRJPHGWU ULXOLNHDOGHUVJUXSSHUVDPWJDGGRJO JHUVRP JLUVNRJHQHWRSSULQQHOLJSUHJ8WYLNOLQJHQKDUQHSSHSnJnWWLPHUHQQHWSDUKXQGUHnURJGHWHUWUROLJI¡UVWHJHQHUDVMRQ PHGJUDQVRPGRPLQHUHULGDJ2YHUJDQJHQPRWWLOVW¡WHQGHVNRJHUSnIDOOHQGHVNDUSWLOWURVVIRUJRGIRU\QJHOVHLQQHQIRU UHVHUYDWHW6NRJDWHLJHQKDUY UWEHQ\WWHWWLOIRUVNQLQJVRPUnGHYHGU¡UHUHQGHJUDQHQVKLVWRULHSn9HVWODQGHWRJVRPHQ LVROHUWIRUHNRPVWE¡UUHVHUYDWHWKDVWRUYHUGLVRPJHQEDQN9HUQHYHUGLHQHUVY UWK¡\ ´ *DDUGHU KDUI¡OJHQGHJHQHUHOOHNRPPHQWDUHUWLOVNRJRPUnGHQHSnYHVWVLGDDY/XVWUDIMRUGHQ RJVnLQNOXGHUWVNRJ SDUWLHUUHWWV¡URJYHVWIRUSODQRPUnGHW ³(WVW¡UUHIXUXVNRJVGRPLQHUWRPUnGHOLWHEHU¡UWDYLQQJUHSLQ\HUHWLG6NRJHQHU DOOLNHYHOMHYQWSUHJHWDYKRJVWWLGOLJHUH'HQRUGOLJVWHGHOHQDYGHWXQGHUV¡NWHRPUnGHWKDGGHHQGHOHOGUHODXYVNRJXWHQ DWGHQXWPHUNHWVHJVSHVLHOW(WVSXUYHXJOHSDUEOHREVHUYHUWXQGHUIRUKROGVRPW\GHWSnKHNNLQJQRHVRPHUVMHOGHQWSn 9HVWODQGHW2JVnGXHWURVWEOLUVMHOGHQWVHWWSn9HVWODQGHW7HWWKHWHQHDYVSHWWHUYDULNNHXYDQOLJVWRUPHQORNDOLWHWHUEnGH DYNYLWU\JJVSHWWRJGYHUJVSHWWHULQWHUHVVDQW$QWDJHOLJHUKHNNHSODVVHUDYK¡QVHKDXNRJVnEUD7RWDOWVHWWHW¿QWRJ LQWHUHVVDQWVNRJVRPUnGHPHQWUROLJ¿QQHVGHWÀHUHVNRJVRPUnGHUDYOLJQHQGHRJWLOGHOVVW¡UUHYHUGLL,QGUH6RJQ´ )RU¡YULJNDQQHYQHVHWHQNHOWQ\HUHQRWDWIUDRPUnGHWDY$QRQE\ GHUKDQKDUHLSODQWHOLVWHIUD6NRJDWHLJHQPHG IXQQDYEODQDWW¿RORJNQHURW
%HOLJJHQKHW 2PUnGHWOLJJHUSn9HVWODQGHWLLQGUH6RJQSnYHVWVLGHQDY6RJQHIMRUGHQGHUGHQQHGHOHUVHJRJKRYHGJUHLQDGDQQHU /XVWUDIMRUGHQ)UD0DQQKLOOHULV¡UWLO6ROYRUQLQRUGHUGHWHLYHJO¡VIMRUGVWUHNQLQJSnUXQGWNPQHVWHQXWHQQ\HUHLQQJUHS GHU6WDWVDOOPHQQLQJHQRPIDWWHUGHPLGWUHSDUWLHQH HLVWUHNQLQJSnFDNP
1DWXUJUXQQODJ
7RSRJUD¿ 7HUUHQJHWHUJDQVNHKRPRJHQW'HWRPIDWWHUHLEUDWWRYHUYHLHQGHVNRJNOHGWIMRUGOLVRPLKRYHGVDNHU¡VWYHQGW'HEUDW WHVWHSDUWLHQHOLJJHULV¡U¡VWRJLQRUGRJKHUHUGHWRJVnQRHEHUJRJUDVPDUN,QRUGKDULWLOOHJJHWSDUEHNNHU VSHVLHOW 6W¡OVVNUHGDRJ/LQGHWRL GDQQHWQRHQVNDUSHRJEUDWWHEHNNHGDOHU)ODWHSDUWLHUPDQJOHUWRWDOWLRPUnGHWRJGHWHURJVnL OLWHQJUDGVODNHSDUWLHU6DPPHQPHGNOLPDHWI¡UHUGHWWHWLOWRWDOWIUDY UDYP\URJVHOYIXNWNUHYHQGHDUWHURSSWUHUVY UW VSDUVRPW%ODEHNNHGDOHQHI¡UHUWLODWHQNHOWHDUHDOHULQRUGEOLUV¡U¡VWYHQGWHPHQVGHWLV¡UHUVW\NNHUVRPHURYHUYHL HQGHQRUG¡VWYHQGW
*HRORJL %HUJJUXQQHQVHURYHUQHVWHQKHOHRPUnGHWXWWLOnY UHDQRUWKRVLWW /XWUR 7YHWHQ ERUWVHWWIUDOHQJVWLV¡UGHUGHW NRPPHULQQHWIHOWPHGJUDQRGLRULWW%HJJHW\SHUJLULDOOKRYHGVDNEDUHJUXQQODJIRUHQQ¡\VRPÀRUDRPWUHQWXWHQLQQVODJ DYEDVHNUHYHQGHDUWHU
9HJHWDVMRQVJHRJUD¿ 9HJHWDVMRQVHNVMRQ2&2YHUJDQJVVHNVMRQYHJWDVMRQVRQHV¡UERUHDO FDGDD PHOORPERUHDO FDGDD QRUGERUHDO FDGDD DOSLQ FDGDD ,I¡OJHNDUWHWWLO0RHQ OLJJHURPUnGHWLKRYHGVDNLV¡UERUHDORJGHOVPHOORPERUHDOYHJHWDVMRQVVRQHPHQVVQDXIMHO OHWNRPPHULDOSLQVRQH'HWHUJUXQQWLOnDQWDDWHLVPDOVNRJVRQHRSSPRWVQDXIMHOOHW RYHUFDPRK" EHVWNDQ SODVVHUHVLQRUGERUHDOVRQH,WLOOHJJHUGHWHQNHOWHERUHRQHPRUDOHWUHNNLDUWVPDQJIROGHWLQHGUHGHOHUDYOLD
.OLPD .OLPDHWHUJMHQQRPJnHQGHJDQVNHW¡UWLNNHPLQVWL9HVWODQGVVDPPHQKHQJ2VHDQLVNHDUWHUPDQJOHURJGHWEOHXQGHU IHOWDUEHLGHWKHOOHULNNHSnYLVWVXERVHDQLVNHDUWHUVHOYRPHQLNNHNDQXWHOXNNHDWHQNHOWHVOLNHNDQRSSWUHNDQVNMHV UOLJL K¡\HUHOLJJHQGHRPUnGHU'HQEUDWWHOLDRYHUYHLHQGHMHYQHWRSRJUD¿HQOLWHRJPHVWJURYHO¡VPDVVHUHURJVnDOOHIDNWRUHU VRPI¡UHUWLODWIXNWLJKHWVNUHYHQGHDUWHULOLWHQJUDGRSSWUHU(NVSRVLVMRQHQPRW¡VWI¡UHUSnGHQDQGUHVLGHQWLODWGHWLNNH EOLUGHDOOHUPHVWW¡UNHVWHUNHYHJHWDVMRQVW\SHQHVRPGRPLQHUHU
NRORJLVNYDULDVMRQ 'HQYHUWLNDOHYDULDVMRQHQWLORPUnGHWHUVWRUVLGHQRPUnGHWVSHQQHUIUDKDYQLYnWLOVQDXIMHOOHWPDRKDUVNRJGHNQLQJIUD WLOPRK'HULPRWHUGHWGnUOLJYDULDVMRQLHNVSRVLVMRQHURJKHOOQLQJVJUDGHU/LDHULDOOKRYHGVDN¡VWYHQGWPHGEDUH JUDGLHQWHUPHOORPV¡U¡VWRJQRUG¡VWPHQVUHLQWQRUGYHVWRJV¡UYHQGWHSDUWLHUPDQJOHU6DPWLGLJKDURPUnGHWJDQVNH MHYQEUDWWKHOOLQJRJGHUHUQ UPHVWWRWDOPDQJOHSnÀDWHNRQYHNVHRJNRQNDYHWHUUHQJIRUPDVMRQHU'HWHUOLWWYDULDVMRQL VNRJW\SHU)RUGHOLQJHQSnWUHVODJHUUHODWLYWJRGPHGGRPLQDQVDYIXUXPHQPHGLQQVODJDYHQJRGGHOERUHDOHODXYWU U VDPWOLWWHGHOODXYVNRJPHGOLQGRJKDVVHORJORNDOWRJVnJUDQ6LVWQHYQWHHULWLOOHJJUHJLRQDOWVMHOGHQW'HULPRWYLUNHUYDULD VMRQHQLIURGLJKHWRJEDVHULNKHWVYDNHUHGDGHWHULDOOKRYHGVDNJDQVNHW¡UUHRJEDVHIDWWLJHVNRJW\SHU 9HJHWDVMRQRJWUHVODJVIRUGHOLQJ )XUXVNRJGRPLQHUHUPHQGHWHURJVnHQGHOLQQVODJDYERUHDOODXYVNRJ9DQOLJVWHODXYWU UHURVSRJEM¡UNPHQVVHOMHRJ URJQRSSWUHUVSUHGWRJJUnRURJKHJJORNDOWWLONQ\WWHWIXNWLJHVLJ,WLOOHJJHUGHWHWJDQVNHNODUWDYJUHQVHWJUDQVNRJVEHVWDQG LQRUG6NRJDWHLJHQVRPDOWHUYHUQHWVRPQDWXUUHVHUYDW VHNMHUQHRPUnGHQU *UDQIRUHNRPPHURJVnVSUHGWODQJV IMRUGHQQRUGIRU)XUHQHVHW$YHGHOODXYWU U¿QQHVGHWHQNHOWHEHVWDQGVRPLQQHKROGHUHQGHOOLQGRJKDVVHO$YDOPEOHGHW EDUHUHJLVWUHUWHWSDUWU UV¡UIRU6YDUWKLOOHURJDYVYDUWRUHQKnQGIXOOWU ULHWIXNWLJEHVWDQGQ UVM¡HQLVDPPHRPUnGH 2PUnGHWVHUXWWLOnKDHQIDWWLJWLOGHOVRYHUUDVNHQGHDUWVIDWWLJYHJHWDVMRQ3nWURVVDYHQGHOLQQVODJDYYDUPHNM UHDUWHU VRPOLQGRJKDVVHOPDQJOHUNUDYIXOOHDUWHULIHOWVMLNWHWQ UPHVWWRWDOW%DUHP\VNHEOHIXQQHWGHUDYHGHOODXYVNRJVDUWHURJ VHOYGHQYDUVY UWVSDUVRP2JVnYHOXWYLNOHWOnJXUWYHJHWDVMRQRJK¡JVWDXGHYHJHWDVMRQVHUXWWLOnY UHVY UWVMHOGHQHOOHU PDQJOHQGHVHOYRPGHWHUPXOLJHQNHOWHLNNHXQGHUV¡NWHUDVPDUNHULRYHUJDQJHQPRWVQDXIMHOOHWNDQKDIURGLJHUHYHJHWD VMRQ2JVnIXUXVNRJVW\SHQHHUIDWWLJHPHQGHWWHYDUPHUIRUYHQWHW *URYWVHWWVHUVNRJYHJHWDVMRQHQXWWLOnKDHQWHQGHQVWLOVRQHULQJHU,ODYHUHOLJJHQGHGHOHUHUORNDONOLPDHWW¡UUHVWRJKHU GRPLQHUHUE UO\QJVNRJ3nOLWWEHGUHPDUNNRPPHUGHQVYDNWXWYLNOHGHOnJXUWVNRJHQLQQHOOHUORNDOWDOPOLQGHVNRJ(WWHU KYHUWVRPHQNRPPHUK¡\HUHRSSRJInUPHUKXPLGHIRUKROGRYHUWDUEOnE UVNRJGRPLQDQVHQPHQPHGHQGHOU¡VVO\QJ IXUXVNRJSnIDWWLJPDUNRJLQQVODJDYVPnEUHJQHVNRJSnVWHGHUPHGQRHYDQQVLJRJEHGUHMRUG
6NRJVWUXNWXURJSnYLUNQLQJ 6NRJVWUXNWXUHQLQHGUHRJPLGWUHGHOHUDYOLDYDULHUHUQRHPHQVNRJHQKDUJMHQQRPJnHQGHHWJDQVNHnSHQWSUHJRJHU HQVMLNWHWWLOWRVMLNWHW'HWWHEU\WHVHQGHORSSDYnSQHUHSDUWLHUPHGEHUJRJUDVPDUNVSHVLHOWLV¡QGUHRJQRUGUHGHOHUGHU WHUUHQJHWHUEUDWWHVW'LPHQVMRQHQHSnIXUXWU UQHYDULHUHUJMHQQRPJnHQGHJDQVNHOLWHQRHVRPLQGLNHUHUOLWHQDOGHUV VSUHGQLQJ7UROLJHUP\HDYIXUXDXQGHUnUJDPPHORJKDUNRPPHWRSSHWWHUHQPHJHWKDUGJMHQQRPKRJVWÀDWHKRJVW IRUYHOnUVLGHQ'HWWHHUHWVNRJELOGHVRPHUW\SLVNIRUVWRUHGHOHUDYGHIXUXVNRJVNOHGWHIMRUGOLHQHLLQGUH6RJQMIU RJVn0RH 'HWHUVSDUVRPWPHGG¡GWWUHYLUNHDYIXUXRJGHWVRP¿QQHVHUYDQOLJYLVJDQVNHIHUVNWRJOLWHQHGEUXWW VDPWDYVPnWLOPLGGHOVVWRUHGLPHQVMRQHU*DPOHVWXEEHUIRUHNRPPHUJDQVNHYDQOLJRYHUKHOHRPUnGHW/RNDOWLQHGUH GHOHU¿QQHVRJVnVSRUHWWHUQ\HUHKRJVWHUWUROLJIUDXOLNHWLGVURPSnI¡UVWHKDOYGHODYWDOOHW +HOOHULNNHODXYVNRJHQYLUNHUVSHVLHOWJDPPHOPHQGHWHUYDQVNHOLJHUHnYXUGHUHSnYLUNQLQJVJUDGHQRYHUHWOHQJUHWLGVURP IRUGHQQH6SHVLHOWJDPOHWU USnRYHUnUVHUOLNHYHORJVnXWWLOVWRUWVHWWnY UHIUDY UHQGHEODQWODXYWU UQH0XOL JHQVKDUGHUIRURJVnGHWPHVWHDYODXYVNRJHQY UWXWVDWWIRUGHQKDUGHKRJVWHQVDPWLGLJPHGIXUXD(QUDVNHUHYHNVWRJ RPO¡SVWLGV UOLJSnWUHVODJVRPRVSRJJUnRUI¡UHUOLNHYHOWLODWLQQVODJHWDYG¡GWWUHYLUNHVWHGYLVHUHQJRGGHOK¡\HUH RJDWGHWRJVnIRUHNRPPHUJDQVNHJURYHRJPRUNQHO JHU7\GHOLJHVDPPHQEUXGGVIDVHUHUGHULPRWIRUWVDWWPDQJHOYDUH LGHQODXYGRPLQHUWHVNRJHQ 7LONQ\WWHWNO¡IWHQHQRUGLRPUnGHW VRP/LQGHWRLRJ6W¡OVVNUHGD KDUVNUHG SULP UWVQ¡VNUHG I¡UWWLOQRNVnEUHGHPHUHOOHU PLQGUHSHUPDQHQWHEHOWHUPHGXQJVNRJRJODXYNUDWWLRJLQQWLONO¡IWHQH VHRJVnELOGHUWDWWIUDGLVVHRPUnGHQH
.MHUQHRPUnGHU ,GHWI¡OJHQGHOLVWHVLQIRUPDVMRQRPGHDYJUHQVHGHNMHUQHORNDOLWHWHQHLRPUnGHW/XVWHU9HVWUH6WDWVDOOPHQQLQJ1XPPH UHULQJHQUHIHUHUWLOLQQWHJQLQJHUYLVWSnNDUWHW
+HOJMD 1DWXUW\SH 1DWXUEHLWHPDUN 870 1 %09(5', & +RK PRK $UHDO GDD
%HVNULYHOVHLQQODJWDY**DEDVHUWSnHJHWEHV¡N /RNDOLWHWHQHUHQQHGODJWOLWHQSODVV VRPPHUVW¡O" LGHQEUDWWHIMRUGOLDSnYHVWVLGHQDY/XVWUDIMRUGHQL9HVWUH/XVWHU6WDWVDOOPHQQLQJ%DUH JUXQQPXUHQHVWnUQnWLOEDNHDYKXVHQHPHQGHWHUIRUWVDWWVPnnSQHHQJHUKHURJUHVWHUHWWHUIUXNWWU UPP(QJHQHHUIULVNHWLOJDQVNH W¡UUHPHGQDWXUHQJSODQWHUVRPVPDONMHPSHMRQVRNNROORJJXODNVVDPWDQGUHW\SLVNHHQJDUWHUVRPU¡GNO¡YHUHQJNYHLQKXQGHJUDVRJ U¡GNQDSS(QGHOEHLWHPDUNVVRSSEOHIXQQHWXQGHUEHV¡NHWPHGDUWHUYRNVVRSS VNM¡UYRNVVVRSS+\JURF\EHFHUDFHDNMHJOHYRNVVRSS +FRQLFDJU¡QQYRNVVRSS+SVLWWDFLQDP¡QMHYRNVVRSS+FRFFLQHDRJOLWHQYRNVVRSS+LQVLSLGD HQU¡GVNLYHVRSS EOHLNVNLYHWU¡GVNL YHVRSS(QWRORPDLQIXOD RJHLKHWWH HOIHQEHQVKHWWH0\FHQDÀDYRDOED DOOHYDQOLJHRJUHODWLYWWULYLHOOHDUWHU /RNDOLWHWHQInUYHUGLVRPORNDOWYLNWLJ & VLGHQORNDOLWHWHQHUOLWHQXWHQVSHVLHOOHDUWHURJLODQJVRPJMHQJURLQJ 6NM¡WVHORJKHQV\Q 1RHQNRQNUHWHWUXVOHUIRUHOLJJHUQHSSHERUWVHWWIUDGHQJUDGYLVHJMHQJURLQJHQ(QJHQHHUQRNVnSDVVW¡UUHRJPDJUHDWIHNVVOnWWKYHUW DQQHWnURJOLWWU\GGLQJDYEXVNHURJNUDWWLNDQWHQHnURPDQQHWYLOOHY UWWLOVWUHNNHOLJWLOnEHYDUHNYDOLWHWHQH
+HOJMD¡VW 1DWXUW\SH *DPPHOODXYVNRJ*DPOHRVSHKROW 870 1 %09(5', % +RK PRK $UHDO GDD
%HVNULYHOVHLQQODJWDY**DEDVHUWSnHJHWEHV¡N /RNDOLWHWHQOLJJHUUXQGWRJRYHQIRUGHQYHVOHQHGODJWHSODVVHQ+HOJMD'HQEHVWnUEnGHDYHOHPHQWHUIUDULNHGHOODXYVNRJRJIUDJDPPHO ODXYVNRJPHQGLVVHRYHUODSSHUHQGHORJGHQHUGHUIRUVHWWSnVRPHQHQKHW 5XQGW+HOJMDRJORNDOWRJVnQRHOHQJUHRSSHLOLDPRWQRUGYHVWHUGHWQRHOLQGHVNRJ'HQQHVNRJHQPnEHWHJQHVVRPPLGGHODOGUHQGH PHGOLWHLQQVODJDYG¡GWWUHYLUNH6SHVLHOWJURYHHOOHUKXOHOLQGHWU UEOHLNNHIXQQHW'HWHULQQVODJDYQRHKDVVHONUDWW)HOWVMLNWHWHUIDWWLJ RJWULYLHOWPHGP\VNHVRPHQHVWHREVHUYHUWHHGHOODXYVNRJVDUWRJVHOYGHQRSSWUnGWHVSDUVRPWRJORNDOW'HPHVWNUDYIXOOHDQGUHNDUSODQ WHQHVRPEOHIXQQHWYDUNQROOHUWHNQDSSRJVWRUQHVOHVRPEHJJHYDUVMHOGQH'HWEOHLNNHUHJLVWUHUWVSHVLHOWNUDYIXOOHPDUNOHYHQGHVRSSL HGHOODXYVNRJHQRJSRWHQVLDOHWYXUGHUHVVRPQRNVnVYDNW6YRYHOPXVVHURQJ7ULFKRORPDVXOSKXUHXPYDUGHQPHVWNUDYIXOOH /LWWRSSRYHULOLDRJL¡YUHGHODYORNDOLWHWHQNRPPHUGHWLQQPHUVWRUYRNVWERUHDOODXYVNRJPHGEODHQGHOQRNVnVWRURVS+HUHUGHW RJVnPHUG¡GWWUHYLUNHV UOLJDYXOLNHODXYWU U3nGLVVHRSSWUnGWHHQNHOWHUHJLRQDOWVMHOGQHU¡GOLVWHDUWHUVSDUVRPW JU¡QQVNR%X[EDXPLD YLULGLV'0SnHQRVSHOnJ 870 RJHQJUnRUOnJ 870 EHJHU¿QJHUVRSS&ODYLFRURQDS\[LGLDWD'&SnHQ RVSHOnJ 870 3nODXYWU UQHV UOLJRVSIRUHNRPGHWRJVnHQNHOWHDUWHULOXQJHQHYHUVDPIXQQHWVRPOXQJHQHYHU/R EDULDSXOPRQDULDVNUXEEHQHYHU/VFURELFXODWDN\VWnUHQHYHU3HOWLJHUDFROOLQDJU\QYUHQJH1HSKURPDSDULOHRJYHGHWWWLOIHOOHRJVnROLYHQ ODY)XVFRSDQQDULDPHGLWHUUDQHD 870 VDPWEUXQEO UHJO\H&ROOHPDQLJUHVFHQVRJN\VWYUHQJH1ODHYLJDWXP(QNHOWH NQDSSHQnOVODYNQ\WWHWWLOJDPPHOVNRJEOHRJVnIXQQHWVRPU¡GKRGHQnO&DOLFLXPVDOLFLQXPGYHUJJXOOQnO&KDHQRWKHFDEUDFK\SRGDRJSn HQVHOMHJDGGPXOLJHQVRJVnWDLJDQnO&KFIODHYLJDWD 870 )RU¡YULJEOHSXVOHGUDXJPRVH$QDVWURSK\OOXPKHOOHULDQXP IXQQHWSnPRUNQHO JHURJHQKYLWU\JJVSHWWEOHREVHUYHUWSnQ ULQJVV¡N *HQHUHOWHUGHWDYJUHQVHGHRPUnGHWGRPLQHUWDYIXUXPHQPHGEHW\GHOLJLQQVODJDYOLQGEM¡UNRJRVSVDPWQRHKDVVHORJLQQVODJDY URJQVHOMHRJJUnRU9HJHWDVMRQVW\SHQHHUGHOVOnJXUWVNRJ SULP UWODXYGRPLQHUWHSDUWLHU RJGHOVE UO\QJIXUXVNRJLQHGUHGHOHUPHQV GHWEOLURYHUJDQJPRWU¡VVO\QJIXUXVNRJRJW¡UUEOnE UVNRJLIDWWLJHUHSDUWLHUOHQJUHRSSHRJVPnEUHJQHVNRJSnOLWWIULVNHUHPDUN2PUnGHW KDUXWYLOVRPWY UWJMHQQRPKRJGÀHUHJDQJHUWLGOLJHUH6WXEEHUDYIXUXYDUYDQOLJHRJGHWYLUNHWGnUOLJPHGIXUXWU URYHUnURJHOOHU GEKRYHUFP /RNDOLWHWHQKDUWLGOLJHUHY UWUHJLVWUHUWRJOLJJHULQQHL'1VLQQDWXUEDVH NDOW³+HOJMD´ EDVHUWSnXQGHUV¡NHOVHUXWI¡UWDY*HLU*DDUGHU *DDUGHU (WGDDVWRUWRPUnGHPHGDQWDWWJDPPHOIDWWLJOLQGHVNRJEOHGDDYJUHQVHW'HQ\HXQGHUV¡NHOVHQHIUD HUVWDWWHUEnGHDYJUHQVQLQJYHUGLYXUGHULQJRJORNDOLWHWVRPWDOHDYGHQQHORNDOLWHWHQ$YLQWHUHVVHNDQQHYQHVDWHQGYHUJVSHWWEOH K¡UWRJGXHWURVWK¡UWRJVHWWL¡YUHGHODYORNDOLWHWHQGHQ /RNDOLWHWHQInUXQGHUOLWWWYLOEDUHYHUGLYLNWLJ % VHOYRPGHQHUPLGGHOVVWRULQQHKROGHUOLQGHVNRJRJIXQQDYHWSDUU¡GOLVWHDUWHU9HJH WDVMRQHQHUOLNHYHOVnSDVVIDWWLJSRWHQVLDOHWIRUVSHVLHOWNUDYIXOOHDUWHUVYDNWRJWLGOLJHUHSnYLUNQLQJVJUDGVnSDVVK¡\DWGHQLQQWLOYLGHUH LNNHInUEHGUHYHUGL'HWNDQOLNHYHOLNNHXWHOXNNHVDW\WWHUOLJHUHXQGHUV¡NHOVHUJLUJUXQQODJIRUHQK¡\HUHYHUGLVHWWLQJ 6NM¡WVHORJKHQV\Q 6NRJHQE¡UInVNM¡WWHVHJVHOYXWHQQRHQIRUPHUIRULQQJUHSLQNOXGHUWKRJVW6 UOLJKRJVWDYODXYWU UDQVHHVVRPQHJDWLYW
6YDUWKLOOHUV¡U 1DWXUW\SH 5LNHGHOODXYVNRJ$OPOLQGHVNRJ 870 1 %09(5', $ +RK PRK $UHDO GDD
%HVNULYHOVHLQQODJWDY**DEDVHUWSnHJHWEHV¡N /RNDOLWHWHQOLJJHULGHQEUDWWHIMRUGOLDOLNHV¡UIRU6YDUWKLOOHUHLYLNSnYHVWVLGDDY/XVWUDIMRUGHQLV¡UOLJHGHODY9HVWUH/XVWHU6WDWVDOOPHQ QLQJ+HUHUGHWP\HXURJIDWWLJW¡UUIXUXVNRJPHQGHQDYJUHQVHGHORNDOLWHWHQGRPLQHUHVDYOLQG/LQGHWU UQHHUWLOGHOVJDQVNHK¡\HRJ JURYHRJGHWHURJVnHQNHOWHG¡GHWU UPHQGDVRPJDQVNHIHUVNHO JHU)RUXWHQOLQGHUGHWP\HIXUXVDPWLQQVODJDYRVSKDVVHOEM¡UN RJJUnRU,WLOOHJJEOHWRDOPHWU UIXQQHW)HOWVMLNWHWHUGnUOLJXWYLNOHWPHQLQQHKROGHUVSUHGWPHGOnJXUWRJGHOVK¡JVWDXGHDUWHUVDPWDUWHU NQ\WWHWWLOXURJUDVPDUN VRPVNRJ¿ROJDXNV\UHOLQWRUVNHPXQQOXQGUDSSKXQGHNYHNHJMHUGHYLNNHJXODNVEUXQURW ,HWYDVVVLJEOHGH QRHEDVHNUHYHQGHDUWHQHJXOVLOGUHRJIMHOOWLVWHOIXQQHWHOOHUVJDYNDUSODQWHÀRUDHQInLQGLNDVMRQHUSnULNPDUN$YVRSSEOHGHWJMRUWHWSDU IXQQDYJXOÀXHVRSS$PDQLWDPDSSDRJHWWDYIXUXPDWULVNH'HWPHVWHLQWHUHVVDQWHYDUOLNHYHOIXQQDYWR DQWDWW P\FHODYGHQGLUHNWH WUXHGHSUHVWHMRUGVWMHUQD*HDVWUXPWULSOH[ 870 $UWHQVWRGLHWJDQVNHW¡UWRJnSHQWSDUWLUHWWRYHQIRUIMRUGHQQ UHWSDU VPnKDVVHONUDWW3UHVWHMRUGVWMHUQHHUWLGOLJHUHLNNHIXQQHWLI\ONHWRJIUD9HVW1RUJHHOOHUVEDUHNMHQWIUDHQORNDOLWHWSn6XQQP¡UH /RNDOLWHWHQInUYHUGLVY UWYLNWLJ $ 'HWWHHUEHJUXQQHWLIRUHNRPVWHQDYHQGLUHNWHWUXHWVRSSDUWVRPLWLOOHJJHUUHJLRQDOWVY UWVMHOGHQ 8WHQGHQQHYLOOHGHWYLUNHWPHVWVDQQV\QOLJnJLORNDOLWHWHQYHUGLVRPYLNWLJ % VLGHQGHQHUJDQVNHOLWHQRJIRU¡YULJXWHQDWVSHVLHOW NUDYIXOOHDUWHUHUSnYLVW 6NM¡WVHORJKHQV\Q 6NRJHQVNM¡WWHUVHJEHVWVHOYXWHQQRHQIRUPHUIRULQQJUHS
)XUHQHVHW 1DWXUW\SH 5LNHGHOODXYVNRJ$OPOLQGHVNRJ 870 1 %09(5', % +RK PRK $UHDO GDD
%HVNULYHOVHLQQODJWDY%+/EDVHUWSnHJHWEHV¡N /RNDOLWHWHQOLJJHUUXQGWRJRYHQIRU)XUHQHVHWKYRUGHWVWnUHLK\WWHRJHUQRHHQJYHJHWDVMRQSnGHnSQHNQDXVHQHPRWVM¡HQ'HQDY JUHQVHGHORNDOLWHWHQEHVWnUDYHQYHNVOLQJPHOORPOLQGHVNRJPHGHWWHWWEXVNVMLNWDYKDVVHO LQRUGRJV¡U RJPHUnSHQRVSHVNRJPHGQRH KDVVHORJLQQVODJDYIXUX1DWXUW\SHHUULNHGHOODXYVNRJPHGHOHPHQWHUDYJDPPHOHGHOODXYVNRJ,OLQGHEHVWDQGHWLV¡QGUHGHOYDUGHWHQ JRGGHOG¡GYHGHOOHUVYDUGHWVSDUVRPWPHGG¡GYHGSnORNDOLWHWHQRJVNRJHQEDUSUHJDYWLGOLJHUHLQWHQVLYXWQ\WWHOVH /LQGHVNRJHQYDUPLGGHODOGUHQGHRJGHWEOHLNNHUHJLVWUHUWVSHVLHOWJURYHHOOHUKXOHWU U.DUSODQWHÀRUDHQYDURUGLQ URJGHQHQHVWH HGHOODXYVNRJVDUWHQVRPEOHUHJLVWUHUWYDUP\VNHVRPORNDOWYDUYDQOLJ VSHVLHOWLGHWV¡QGUHEHVWDQGHW )RU¡YULJIRUHNRPNQROOHUWHNQDSS KYLWEODGWLVWHOW\ULKMHOPEOnNQDSSOXQGUDSSRJWHLHE U'HWEOHLNNHUHJLVWUHUWVSHVLHOWNUDYIXOOHPDUNOHYHQGHVRSSLHGHOODXYVNRJHQRJ SRWHQVLDOHWYXUGHUHVVRPQRNVnVYDNW'HQPHVWNUDYIXOOHDUWHQVRPEOHIXQQHWYDUJXOÀXHVRSS$PDQLWDPDSSD 5HWWQRUGIRUGHWQHGODJWHEUXNHWYDUGHWPLGGHODOGUHQGHWLOJDPPHORVSHVNRJKHOWQHGWLOIMRUGHQPHGVSUHGWHKDVVHONUDWWLEXVNVMLNWHW+HU EOHGHWREVHUYHUWHWPDWV¡NHQGHKYLWU\JJVSHWWSDU 9 ,GHWWHEHVWDQGHWYDUGHWQRHG¡GVWnHQGHYHGPHQOLWHO JHU *HQHUHOWEHVWnUGHWDYJUHQVHGHRPUnGHWDYODXYVNRJYHVHQWOLJOLQGRJRVSPHGQRHLQQVODJDYIXUXEM¡UNVHOMHJUnRURJJUDQ9HJHWD VMRQVW\SHQHHUGHOVDOPOLQGHVNRJRJGHOVE UO\QJVNRJRJVPnEUHJQHVNRJ LRVSRJIXUXGRPLQHUWHSDUWLHU /RNDOLWHWHQInUYHUGLYLNWLJ % PHVWSJDGHWROLQGHEHVWDQGHQHVRPKDUQRHSRWHQVLDOHIRUNUDYIXOOHDUWHUVDPWDWORNDOLWHWHQVDQQV\QOLJ YLVLQQJnULHWWHUULWRULXPIRUHWKYLWU\JJVSHWWSDU9HJHWDVMRQHQHULNNHVSHVLHOWULNRJWLGOLJHUHSnYLUNQLQJVJUDGVnSDVVK¡\DWGHQLNNHInU EHGUHYHUGLVHOYRPOLQGHVNRJLXWJDQJVSXQNWHWVNDOKDYHUGLVY UWYLNWLJ'HWNDQOLNHYHOLNNHXWHOXNNHVDW\WWHUOLJHUHXQGHUV¡NHOVHUJLU JUXQQODJIRUHQK¡\HUHYHUGLVHWWLQJ 6NM¡WVHORJKHQV\Q 6NRJHQE¡UInVNM¡WWHVHJVHOYXWHQQRHQIRUPHUIRULQQJUHSLQNOXGHUWKRJVW6 UOLJKRJVWDYODXYWU UDQVHVVRPQHJDWLYW
,QGUH)XUHQHVHWV¡U 1DWXUW\SH 5LNHGHOODXYVNRJ$OPOLQGHVNRJ 870 1 %09(5', % +RK PRK $UHDO GDD
%HVNULYHOVHLQQODJWDY%+/EDVHUWSnHJHWEHV¡N /RNDOLWHWHQOLJJHUPHOORPWREHNNHULGHQEUDWWHOLDV¡UIRU,QGUH)XUHQHVHWRJEHVWnUDYHWIRUKROGVYLVVWRUWOLQGHEHVWDQG+RYHGVDNHOLJ XWJM¡UHVEHVWDQGHWDYXQJHWLOPLGGHODOGUHQGHWU UPHQQRHQInHOGUHWU U¿QQHV,QQVODJHWDYG¡GWWUHYLUNHHUVWRUWPHQNXQIHUVNHRJ DYVPnGLPHQVMRQHU/DQJVEHNNHQHHULQQVODJDYJUnRUPDUNDQW/RNDOLWHWHQRPJLVDYIXUXVNRJPHGQRHEM¡UNRJRVSHLQQEODQGLQJ 9HJHWDVMRQHQYDULNNHVSHVLHOWULNRJInNUDYIXOOHDUWHUEOHQRWHUW(QGHOOnJXUWRJK¡JVWDXGHDUWHUNQ\WWHWWLOUDVPDUNEOHUHJLVWUHUWVOLN VRPEUXQURWNUDWWKXPOHEORPJMHUGHYLNNHKXQGHNYHNHRJVNRJ¿RO'HWEOHIXQQHWOLWHPDUNOHYHQGHVRSS EODEOHNSLJJVRSS RJLQJHQ V UOLJNUDYIXOOH /LQGHVNRJVNDOQRUPDOWJLYHUGLVY UWYLNWLJPHQL,QGUH6RJQHUOLQGVnYDQOLJDWGHWEOLUPLVYLVHQGHnJLDOOHORNDOLWHWHUPHGOLQGHVNRJ GHQQHYHUGLHQ'HWWHHUHQLNNHVSHVLHOWULNORNDOLWHWVRPYXUGHUHVnLNNHKDV UOLJSRWHQVLDOHIRUNUDYIXOOHRJU¡GOLVWHGHDUWHUPHQVW¡U UHOVHQJM¡UDWYHUGLYLNWLJNDQIRUVYDUHV 6NM¡WVHORJKHQV\Q 6NRJHQE¡UInVNM¡WWHVHJVHOYXWHQQRHQIRUPHUIRULQQJUHSLQNOXGHUWKRJVW
6W¡OVVNUHGD 1DWXUW\SH 5LNHGHOODXYVNRJ$OPOLQGHVNRJ 870 1 %09(5', % +RK PRK $UHDO GDD
%HVNULYHOVHLQQODJWDY%+/EDVHUWSnHJHWEHV¡N /RNDOLWHWHQOLJJHULRJQRUGIRUQHGUHGHODY6W¡OVVNUHGD'HQEHVWnUEnGHDYHOHPHQWHUIUDULNHGHOODXYVNRJRJIUDJDPPHOODXYVNRJPHQ GLVVHRYHUODSSHUHQGHORJGHQHUGHUIRUVHWWSnVRPHQHQKHW 3nU\JJHQQRUGIRUVHOYH6W¡OVVNUHGDHUGHWULNHKDVVHONUDWWPHGVYDNWXWYLNOHWWUHVMLNWDYDQGUHODXYWU U+HULQQJLNNDUWHUVRPWUROOXUWRJ VNRJVDODWRJGHWEOHIXQQHWQRHQPLGGHOVNUDYIXOOHDUWHUDYPDUNOHYHQGHVRSSVOLNVRPJXOÀXHVRSS$PDQLWDPDSSDRJDPHW\VWVRSS /DFFDULDDPHWK\VWLQD/DQJV6W¡OVVNUHGDRJV UOLJSnQRUGVLGDHUGHWRVSHVNRJPHGKDVVHORJNRUVYHGLEXVNVMLNWHW1HGPRWIMRUGHQ YHG5HWWDUKDPQ HUGHWXVWDELOPLQHUDOMRUGLQQWLOEHNNHQRJKHUHUGHWVWHGYLVJRGWXWYLNOHGHHQJVDPIXQQPHGDUWHUVRPVPnHQJNDOO WLULOWXQJH¿UNDQWSHULNXPIMHOOPDULNnSHKHVWHVSUHQJIMHOOV\UHNDWWHIRWRJJXODNV ,RYHUJDQJHQPHOORPKDVVHOVNRJHQRJRVSHVNRJHQEOHGHWREVHUYHUWHQKYLWU\JJVSHWW 9 KXQQSnQ ULQJVV¡N 'DORNDOLWHWHQVDQQV\QOLJYLVLQQJnULHWWHUULWRULXPIRUU¡GOLVWHDUWHQKYLWU\JJVSHWW VRPQRUPDOWLNNHEHYHJHUVHJXWDYWHUULWRULHWSnK¡VWHQ InUORNDO 6NM¡WVHORJKHQV\Q 6NRJHQE¡UInVNM¡WWHVHJVHOYXWHQQRHQIRUPHUIRULQQJUHSLQNOXGHUWKRJVW
6NRJDWHLJHQQDWXUUHVHUYDW 1DWXUW\SH 8UVNRJJDPPHOVNRJ*UDQVNRJ 870 1 %09(5', +RK PRK $UHDO GDD
%HVNULYHOVHLQQODJWDY**DEDVHUWSnXOLNHOLWWHUDWXUNLOGHU ,'LUHNWRUDWHWIRUQDWXUIRUYDOWQLQJVLQQDWXUEDVH SU VWnUI¡OJHQGHRPRPUnGHW³'HQVW¡UVWHQDWXUOLJHJUDQIRUHNRPVWHQ GDD L,QGUH6RJQVRPLEOHIUHGHWVRPODQGHWVI¡UVWHVNRJUHVHUYDW2PUnGHWOLJJHUSnYHVWVLGDDY/XVWUDIMRUGHQRSSPRW6WRUH +DXJPHOHQ0RHPÀ NDUDNWHULVHUHURPUnGHWVRPHQNRPSDNWVNRJPHGUHODWLYWJDPOHWU USnVQDXWnUPHGJDGGRJO JHU LXOLNHQHGEU\WQLQJVIDVHUVRPJLUHWYLVVWXUVNRJVSUHJ2PUnGHWKDUY UWEHQ\WWHWWLOIRUVNQLQJYHGU¡UHQGHJUDQDVKLVWRULHSn9HVWODQGHW ) JUL+DIVWHQ RJGHQDQWDVnKDY UWLRPUnGHWLnU9HJHWDVMRQHQHUHQWUDGLVMRQHOOEOnE UVNRJYHVHQWOLJDYVPnEUHJ QHW\SHQ1RHPHUNUDYIXOOHDUWHUVRPKHQJHDNVVNRJ¿RORJOLOMHNRQYDOOSnWUHIIHVVSUHGW0RH VHWWHUYHUQHYHUGLHQWLOVY UWK¡\ PHQXWIUDNULWHULHQHL'1KnQGERNDIRUNDUWOHJJLQJDYELRORJLVNPDQJIROGNRPPHUORNDOLWHWHQLNNHRSSLPHUHQQYLNWLJ-RKDQQHV$QRQE\ EHV¡NWHORNDOLWHWHQRJIDQWIHPRUNLGHDUWHU EODQDWW¿ROVNRJPDULKDQG VDPWP\VNHJUDV6WDWXVHQVRPQDWXUUHVHUYDW VLNUHUDWGHWWHXQLNHJUDQVNRJVEHVWDQGHWInUXWYLNOHVHJQDWXUOLJRJDWQDWXUYHUGLHQHEOLULYDUHWDWW´ %¡UVHW KDUHQPHUGHWDOMHUWEHVNULYHOVHDYRPUnGHWEnGHNDUSODQWHÀRUDUHJLVWUHUWHIXJOHDUWHUYHJHWDVMRQVW\SHUVNRJKLVWRULHRJ VNRJVWUXNWXU+HUJMHQJLVLNNHGLVVHUHVXOWDWHQHQ UPHUHPHQKDQVJMHQQRPJDQJHUPHGSnnXQGHUVWUHNHORNDOLWHWHQVLQYHUGLVRPEOD IRUVNQLQJVREMHNWGHUGHWKDUY UWXUHJHOPHVVLJRSSI¡OJLQJLOHQJUHWLG 3nEDVLVDYGHWWHHUYHUGLHQVDWWWLOYLNWLJ % 1%3nPDQJHNDUWEODGHVRPSXEOLVHUHVL0VHULHQHUORNDOLWHWHQLQQODJWSnIHLOU\JJ LIMRUGOLDRJVNDOHJHQWOLJY UHSODVVHUWYHONPOHQJUHQRUG,'1VLQQDWXUEDVHVnOLJJHUEnGHGHQULNWLJSODVVHUWHORNDOLWHWHQRJGHQ WLGOLJHUHIHLOSODVVHUWHORNDOLWHWHQEHJJHPHGEHVNULYHOVHU
$UWVPDQJIROG 3nYLVWDUWVPDQJIROGYDUUHODWLYWVSDUVRPWLNNHPLQVWVHWWLVDPPHQKHQJPHGRPUnGHWVVW¡UUHOVHRJVSHQQYLGGHIUDIMRUG WLOIMHOO2JVnSRWHQVLDOHWYXUGHUHVVRPJDQVNHVYDNW $YNDUSODQWHUEOHLQJHQVSHVLHOWVMHOGQHHOOHUNUDYIXOOHDUWHUSnYLVWXQGHUYnUWIHOWDUEHLGRJVOLNHHUKHOOHULNNHIXQQHWWLGOL JHUH6SHVLHOOLQWHUHVVHNQ\WWHUVHJWLOGHWJDPOHPXOLJHQVQDWXUOLJHJUDQEHVWDQGHWLQQHQIRU6NRJDWHLJHQQDWXUUHVHUYDWVH Q UPHUHRPWDOHKRV0RH 2JVnIRUHNRPVWHQHDYOLQGRJKDVVHOKDULQWHUHVVHVHOYRPDUWHQHHUXWEUHGWLUHJLRQHQ HUGHWRIWHPDQJHDQGUHNUDYIXOOHDUWHUNQ\WWHWWLOGHP)RU¡YULJNDQRPUnGHWKDHWVYDNWSRWHQVLDOHIRUUHJLRQDOWVMHOGQH ¡VWOLJHDUWHUVRPVNRJMDPQH GHQQHDUWHQHUSnYLVWUHWWSnDQGUHVLGDDYIMRUGHQVH/DUVHQ YDQLOMHURWP\VNHPDXUH ROPHQWUROLJHUGHWInVOLNHDUWHUVRPIRUHNRPPHUKHURJGDEDUHLVPnEHVWDQGHU 1nUGHWJMHOGHUVRSSVnEOHGHWSnYLVWHQYHGERHQGHU¡GOLVWHDUWSnPRUNHQRVS EHJHU¿QJHUVRSS'& RJGHWHUNODUWSR WHQVLDOHIRUÀHUHU¡GOLVWHDUWHUSnPRUNQHRVSHO JHUDQWDJHOLJRJVnSnDQGUHODXYWUHO JHU'HWHUOLNHYHOLQJHQLQGLNDVMRQHU SnVSHVLHOWJRGHHOOHUWHWWHEHVWDQGHUDYVOLNHDUWHU,QJHQVSHVLHOWNUDYIXOOHDUWHUEOHIXQQHWSnG¡GIXUXRJSRWHQVLDOHW YXUGHUHVVRPGnUOLJHUHSnGHWWHWUHVODJHW2JVnSnJUDQLQQHQIRU6NRJDWHLJHQQDWXUUHVHUYDWHUGHWEDUHIXQQHWJDQVNH YDQOLJHRJYLGWXWEUHGWHDUWHU$YPDUNOHYHQGHVRSSVnEOHGHWSnYLVWHQGLUHNWHWUXHWDUWSUHVWHMRUGVWMHUQH)RU¡YULJEOH LQJHQU¡GOLVWHGHDUWHUIXQQHWSnEDNNHQRJEDUHHWSDUVYDNHVLJQDODUWHUVRPJXOÀXHVRSSRJIXUXPDWULVNH$QGUHDUWHU EHJUHQVHWVHJWLOVOLNHVRPEOHLNSLJJVRSSU¡GÀXHVRSSDPHW\VWVRSSUDEDUEUDVRSSVNMHJJULVNHUHGLNNVRSSRJU¡GQHQGH ÀXHVRSS6HOYRPVRSSVHVRQJHQYLUNHWQRHPLGGHOPnGLJPnGHWWHEHWHJQHVVRPHWGnUOLJVLJQDOLIRUKROGWLORPUnGHWVLWW SRWHQVLDOHIRUNUDYIXOOHRJU¡GOLVWHGHPDUNOHYHQGHVRSS1RHQÀHUHDUWHUE¡UIRUHNRPPHPHQGHWHULNNHLQGLNDVMRQHUSn DWGHW¿QQHVHWVWRUWPDQJIROGHOOHUVWRUHNRQVHQWUDVMRQHUDYVOLNH 0RVHÀRUDHQHUPDQJHOIXOOWNMHQW,QJHQVSHVLHOOHPDUNOHYHQGHHOOHUHSLI\WWLVNHDUWHUHUSnYLVWPHQVOLNHHUGHWRJVnLEH JUHQVHWJUDGV¡NWHWWHU)OHUHYDQOLJHUnWHYHGPRVHUHUIXQQHWVDPWVLJQDODUWHQSXVOHGUDXJPRVHRJU¡GOLVWHDUWHQJU¡QQ VNR'HWRVLVWQHYQWHEDUHVSDUVRPW3RWHQVLDOHWIRUÀHUHNUDYIXOOHRJU¡GOLVWHGHDUWHUYXUGHUHVLNNHVRPV UOLJJRGW 1nUGHWJMHOGHUODYVnHUOXQJHQHYHUVDPIXQQHWWLOVWHGHPHQLNNHVSHVLHOWJRGWXWYLNOHW'HYDQOLJVWHDUWHQHLVDPIXQQHW HUIXQQHWLVSDUVRPPHPHQJGHULWLOOHJJWLOHWWIXQQDYGHQQRHPHUXYDQOLJHDUWHQROLYHQODY)RU¡YULJIRUHNRPPHUDUWHUIUD DQGUHVDPIXQQWLOGHOVK\SSLJIHNVLQQHQIRUNYLVWODYVDPIXQQHWPHQGHWHULNNHSnYLVWVSHVLHOWNUDYIXOOHDQGUHDUWHUDY EXVNRJEODGODY$YVNRUSHODYVnEOHGHWIXQQHWHQNHOWHDUWHUDYNQDSSHQnOVODYPHQK\SSLJKHWHQDYNUDYIXOOHDUWHULQQHQ GHQQHJUXSSDYLUNHUODY3RWHQVLDOHWIRUNUDYIXOOHRJU¡GOLVWHGHODYYXUGHUHVGHUIRUKHOOHULNNHVRPV UOLJJRGW 'HWHULOLWHQJUDGOHWWHWWHUYLUYHOO¡VHG\ULQQHQIRURPUnGHWRJSRWHQVLDOHWIRUVOLNHHURJVnLEHJUHQVHWJUDGYXUGHUW6SDU VRPIRUHNRPVWDYYLNWLJHHOHPHQWHUVRPG¡GWWUHYLUNHYDUPHNM UODXYVNRJRJULNHHQJVDPIXQQJM¡UOLNHYHODWSRWHQVLDOHW LNNHYLUNHUVSHVLHOWORYHQGH
7DEHOO$UWVIXQQL/XVWHU9HVWUH6WDWVDOOPHQQLQJ.RORQQHQ7RWDOWDQWDOODYDUWVXPPHUHURSSDQWDOOIXQQLQQHQIRURPUn NRORQQHQ)XQQHWLNMHUQHRPUnGHKHQYLVHUWLOKYLONHNMHUQHRPUnGHUDUWHQHUIXQQHW'HWOLOOHWDOOHWDQJLUKYRUPDQJHIXQQ VRPHUJMRUWLKYHUWNMHUQHRPUnGHEHW\UWHNVWOLJNYDQWL¿VHULQJ6PnWDOOXWHQNMHUQHRPUnGHQXPPHUDQJLUIXQQXWHQIRU NMHUQHRPUnGHU
*UXSSH 9LWHQVNDSHOLJQDYQ 1RUVNQDYQ 5¡GOLVWH 7RWDOWDQWDOO )XQQHWLNMHUQHRP VWDWXV DYDUW UnGH QU
+DXNHIXJOHU $FFLSLWHUQLVXV 6SXUYHKDXN
+DOLDHHWXVDOELFLOOD +DY¡UQ '&
8JOHU *ODXFLGLXPSDVVHULQXP 6SXUYHXJOH
6XUQLDXOXOD +DXNXJOH
6SHWWHIXJOHU 'HQGURFRSRVOHXFRWRV +YLWU\JJVSHWW 9 3
'HQGURFRSRVPDMRU )ODJJVSHWW
'HQGURFRSRVPLQRU 'YHUJVSHWW '&
3LFRLGHVWULGDFW\OXV 7UHWnVSHWW
3LFXVYLULGLV *U¡QQVSHWW 6 6
6SXUYHIXJOHU 7XUGXVYLVFLYRUXV 'XHWURVW
%ODGPRVHU %X[EDXPLDYLULGLV *U¡QVNR '0
/HYHUPRVHU $QDVWURSK\OOXPKHOOHULDQXP 3XVOHGUDXJPRVH
%XVNRJEODGODY &ROOHPDQLJUHVFHQV %UXQEO UHJO\H
)XVFRSDQQDULDPHGLWHUUDQHD 2OLYHQODY
/REDULDSXOPRQDULD /XQJHQHYHU
/REDULDVFURELFXODWD 6NUXEEHQHYHU
1HSKURPDODHYLJDWXP .\VWYUHQJH
1HSKURPDSDULOH *U\QYUHQJH
3DQQDULDFRQRSOHD *U\Q¿OWODY
3HOWLJHUDFROOLQD .\VWnUHQHYHU
6NRUSHODY &DOLFLXPVDOLFLQXP 5¡GKRGHQnO
&KDHQRWKHFDEUDFK\SRGD 'YHUJJXOOQnO
6RSSPDUNERHQGH $PDQLWDPDSSD *XOÀXHVRSS
(QWRORPDLQIXOD %OHNVNLYHWU¡G VNLYHVRSS *UXSSH 9LWHQVNDSHOLJQDYQ 1RUVNQDYQ 5¡GOLVWH 7RWDOWDQWDOO )XQQHWLNMHUQHRP VWDWXV DYDUW UnGH QU
*HDVWUXPWULSOH[ 3UHVWHMRUGVWMHUQH (
+\JURF\EHFHUDFHD 6NM¡UYRNVVRSS
+\JURF\EHFRFFLQHD 0¡QMHYRNVVRSS
+\JURF\EHFRQLFD .MHJOHYRNVVRSS
+\JURF\EHLQVLSLGD /LWHQYRNVVRSS
+\JURF\EHSVLWWDFLQD *U¡QQYRNVVRSS
0\FHQDÀDYRDOED (OIHQEHQVKHWWH
6RSSYHGERHQGH $QWURGLD[DQWKD 5XWHW¡PPHUVRSS
&HULSRULRSVLVUHVLQDVFHQV
&ODYLFRURQDS\[LGDWD %HJHU¿QJHUVRSS '&
$YJUHQVLQJRJDUURQGHULQJ 2PUnGHWHUDYJUHQVHWSnEDVLVDYHLHQGRPVIRUKROGHQH'HWWHLQQHE UHULSUDNVLVHQUHODWLYWQDWXUOLJJUHQVHHWWHUK¡\HVWH GHODYIMHOOU\JJHQPRWYHVW VRPGHOVJnURYHUVQDXIMHOORJGHOVLIMHOOVNRJ 2JVnPRW¡VWHUGHWHLQDWXUOLJJUHQVHLIRUPDY /XVWUDIMRUGHQ%nGHPRWV¡URJQRUGIRUWVHWWHUGHULPRWVWRUHQDWXUVNRJVDUHDOHUODQJVIMRUGVLGDPHGXOLNHXWIRUPLQJHUDY IXUXVNRJHURJODXYVNRJHU1DWXUIDJOLJVHWWPnGHUIRUDYJUHQVQLQJHQEHWHJQHVVRPQRHWLOIHOGLJ 2PUnGHWHUUHODWLYWVWRUWPHGHWWRWDODUHDOSnRYHUNPKYRUDYHQEHW\GHOLJDQGHONDQEHWUDNWHVVRPVOXWWHWSURGXNWLY VNRJ $UURQGHULQJHQHUJRGVLGHQGHWHUVQDNNRPHLVDPPHQKHQJHQGHIMRUGOLIUDVM¡HQRJRSSWLOVQDXIMHOOHWIMHOOU\JJHQ
$QGUHLQQJUHS 6RPQHYQWXQGHUVNRJVWUXNWXUVnE UHUVNRJHQW\GHOLJSUHJDYnKDY UWJMHQQRPHQPHJHWKDUGJMHQQRPKRJVWRJNDQ VNMHRJVnÀDWHKRJVWIRUYHOnUVLGHQ)UDY UDYJURYHVWXEEHURJJURYHJDPOHO JHUDYIXUXYLVHULWLOOHJJWLODWGHW VDQQV\QOLJYLVKDUY UWKRJGJDQVNHKDUGWKHURJVnHQGDOHQJUHWLOEDNHLWLG'HVLVWHKXQGUHnUHQHPnGHULPRWLQQJUHSHQH KDUY UWPHUEHJUHQVHW(QNHOWHRPUnGHUQ UVM¡HQKDUOLNHYHORJVnLQ\HUHWLGKDWWQRHLQQJUHS(WSDUPLQGUHSODQWHIHOW PHGJUDQSn)XUHQHVHWYLWQHURPKRJVWKHUKHOVWOLWWHWWHUVLVWHNULJ$QWDJHOLJKDUQRHDYGHQUDVNHVWYRNVHQGHIXUXVNRJHQ GDEOLWWÀDWHDYYLUNHWSnQ\RJVDPWLGLJWUHVODJVVNLIWHWWLOJUDQ2JVnOHQJVWLV¡UQ U6YDUWKHOOHUEOHGHWIXQQHWKRJVWVSRU VRPEDUHYDUQRHQWLnUJDPOHDQWDJHOLJHWWHUHQPLQGUHRPIDWWHQGHW¡PPHUKRJVW3DUWLYLV\QJUHVNRJUXQGW+HOJMDNDQ VN\OGHVYHGXWWDNWLONQ\WWHWEUXNDYSODVVHQGHU)RU¡YULJVWnUGHWLJMHQQRHQKXVWXIWHUSn+HOJMDHLK\WWHSn)XUHQHVHWRJHL DQQDK\WWHRSSPRWVQDXIMHOOHW -$QRQE\SHUVPHGG 6¡UIRU,QGUH)XUHQHVHWHUGHWRJVnVSRUHWWHUWLGOLJHUHEUXNPHG JMHQYRNVWNXOWXUPDUNRJUHVWHUHWWHUHQWDXEDQH(OOHUVHURPUnGHWXWHQLQQJUHSDYEHW\GQLQJRJPDQJOHUIHNVKHOWYHJHU RJNUDIWOLQMHU%HLWHSUHVVHWIUDKXVG\UVHUKHOOHULNNHXWWLOnKDY UWV UOLJRPIDWWHQGHLODQJWLGRJGHWHUSULP UWKMRUWVRP VWnUIRUGHWWHQn $QQHQLNNHPHQQHVNHOLJSnYLUNQLQJ(WVW¡UUHOLQGHEHVWDQGODQJVQHGUHGHODY/LQGHOYL KRYHGVDNHOLJSnV¡UVLGD KDUEOLWW WDWWDYVQ¡VNUHGIRUInnUVLGHQ
9XUGHULQJRJYHUGLVHWWLQJ 2PUnGHWHUGHOYLVUHSUHVHQWDWLYWIRUGHW¡UUHIXUXGRPLQHUWIMRUGOLHQHSnDQRUWKRVLWWLLQGUHGHOHUDY6RJQ'HQHQVDUWHGH HNVSRVLVMRQHQJM¡UDWGHWLNNHIDQJHURSSGHPHVWW¡UUHRJVROHNVSRQHUWHXWIRUPLQJHQHRJPXOLJHQVRJVnQRHGnUOLJGH PHUIXNWLJHQRUGHNVSRQHUWH2PUnGHWKDUHQYLVVVSHQQYLGGHLVNRJW\SHUSnIDWWLJPDUNPHQPDQJOHUHOOHUKDUOLWHDY VNRJW\SHUSnULNHUHPDUN%RUWVHWWIUDHQVWRUVSHQQYLGGHLK¡\GHUHUGHQWRSRJUD¿VNHVSHQQYLGGHQGnUOLJPHQVGHWHU EHGUHYDULDVMRQLWUHVODJVIRUGHOLQJ)RUXWHQP\HIXUXVNRJRJHQGHOERUHDOODXYVNRJ¿QQHVGHWRJVnKHUOLWWHGHOODXYVNRJ RJHWVW¡UUHEHVWDQGPHGJUDQVNRJ6LVWQHYQWHHUGHWPHVWVMHOGQHWUHNNHWYHGRPUnGHWRJGHWHUEDUHSn9RVVL+RUGD ODQGDWVW¡UUHJUDQVNRJVEHVWDQGNRPPHWRSSHWWHUHJHQIRU\QJHOVHHUNMHQWSn9HVWODQGHW'HWHUSnYLVWQRHQNUDYIXOOHRJ U¡GOLVWHGHVNRJVDUWHULRPUnGHW(QNHOWHRSSWUHULJDQVNHJRGHEHVWDQGHUVRPKYLWU\JJVSHWWRJDQGUHHUUHJLRQDOWVMHOGQH WLOPHJHWVMHOGQHVRPSUHVWHMRUGVWMHUQH3RWHQVLDOHWIRUNUDYIXOOHRJU¡GOLVWHGHDUWHUYXUGHUHVOLNHYHOEDUHVRPPLGGHOV VDPOHWVHWW2PUnGHWKDUInQ\HUHLQQJUHSDYEHW\GQLQJERUWVHWWIUDPLQGUHJUDQSODQWHIHOWRJPDQJOHUIHNVKHOWYHLHURJ NUDIWOLQMHU'HULPRWE UHUGHWSUHJDYRPIDWWHQGHWLGOLJHUHJMHQQRPKRJVWHURJNRQWLQXLWHWLG¡GWWUHYLUNHRJJDPOHWU U YXUGHUHVVRPJDQVNHGnUOLJ$UURQGHULQJHQHUJRGVLGHQGHWHUHWVDPPHQKHQJHQGHRPUnGHPHGQDWXUOLJHJUHQVHUPRW IMRUGRJIMHOOL¡VWRJYHVW'HULPRWJUHQVHUGHWWLOQDWXUVNRJLJURYWVHWWVDPPHODQGVNDSVW\SHEnGHPRWV¡URJQRUG ,IRUKROGWLOPDQJHODQDO\VHQ )UDPVWDGHWDOV IDQJHURPUnGHWRSSHQNHOWHDYGHSnSHNWHPDQJOHQH'HWWHJMHOGHU LI¡UVWHUHNNHEHKRYHWIRUnGHNNHRSSODYHUHOLJJHQGHVNRJLERUHRQHPRUDORJV¡UERUHDOVRQH6SHVLHOWVLVWQHYQWHVRQHHU JDQVNHJRGWUHSUHVHQWHUWLQQHQIRURPUnGHW2PUnGHWHUPLGGHOVVWRUWPHQXWJM¡UVDQQV\QOLJYLVHQGHODYHWVWRURPUnGH 3nGHQPHUQHJDWLYHVLGHQHUGHWGnUOLJPHGULNHVNRJW\SHUWLGOLJHUHSnYLUNQLQJKDUY UWRPIDWWHQGHRJRPUnGHWVHUXWWLO nY UHXWHQV UOLJHNRQVHQWUDVMRQHUHOOHUEHVWDQGHUDYU¡GOLVWHDUWHU 2JVnSnHWUHJLRQDOWQLYnPnRPUnGHWVLHVnNRPPHQRHPLGGHOPnGLJXW3nGHQSRVLWLYHVLGHQHURPUnGHWUHODWLYWVWRUW PHGJRGDUURQGHULQJRJXWHQQ\HUHLQQJUHS'HULPRWHUGHWNMHQWÀHUHDQGUHVNRJRPUnGHULLQGUH6RJQPHGEHW\GHOLJ EHGUHUHSUHVHQWDVMRQDYULNHVNRJW\SHUU¡GOLVWHDUWHUPLQGUHSnYLUNQLQJVJUDG LGHWPLQVWHLGHOHUDYRPUnGHQH RJEHGUH YDULDVMRQVEUHGGH(QNHOWHDYGLVVHHURJVnLVDPPHVW¡UUHOVHVRPGHWWHRPUnGHW'RNXPHQWHUWHHNVHPSOHUSnVOLNHRP UnGHUPHGP\HIXUXVNRJHUEnGH 7DEHOO.ULWHULHURJYHUGLVHWWLQJIRUNMHUQHRPUnGHURJWRWDOWIRU/XVWHU9HVWUH6WDWVDOOPHQQLQJ,QJHQVWMHUQHU EHW\UDW Y NDSLWWHOHW .MHUQHRPUnGH 8U¡UW '¡GYHG '¡GYHG *DPOH *DPOH *DPOH 7UHVODJV 9DULD 5LN $UWHU 6W¡U $UURQ 6DPOHW KHW PHQJGH NRQW EDUW U O¡YWU U HGHO IRUGHOLQJ VMRQ KHW UHOVH GHULQJ YHUGL O¡YWU U +HOJMD +HOJMD¡VW 6YDUWKLOOHUV¡U )XUHQHVHW ,QGUH)XUHQHVHWV¡U 6W¡OVVNUHGD 6NRJDWHLJHQQDWXU UHVHUYDW 7RWDOWIRU/XVWHU9HV WUH6WDWVDOOPHQQLQJ 5HIHUDQVHU $QRQE\-5DSSRUWIUnKHOJHV\QIDULQJL6NRJDWHLJHQQDWXUUHVHUYDWL/XVWHUMXOL8SXEOQRWDWV %¡UVHW$,QYHQWHULQJDYVNRJUHVHUYDWHUSnVWDWHQVJUXQQ,QVWIRUQDWXUIRUYDOWQLQJ1/+1)UDSS )UDPVWDG(NODQG%%HQGLNVHQ(%DNNHVWXHQ9%ORP+ %UDQGHUXG7(/LVWHRYHUSULRULWHUWHPDQJOHUYHGVNRJYHUQHW 1,1$RSSGUDJVPHOGLQJSS *DDUGHU*1DWXUUHJLVWUHULQJHUL6RJQRJ)MRUGDQHRJ0HGKRYHGYHNWSnRUQLWRORJL)\ONHVPDQQHQL6RJQRJ)MRUGDQH PLOM¡YHUQDYG1RWDWV *DDUGHU*1DWXUYHUGLHUSn)LPUHLWHnVHQ6RJQGDONRPPXQH6RJQRJ)MRUGDQH6LVWH6MDQVHQRWDWVYHGOHJJ +RIWRQ7+%LRORJLVNHYHUGLHUL'U JQLVPRUNL 1172 Jensagjelet Lindetoi 6791000 K Sleipegjelet Stølsskreda 6 Kvalen 6790000 Lustrafjorden Kvalagjelet Majorho 5 Ulvenes u Våtera 6789000 Trondskogen Trondskogg Fureneset 4 r 6788000 2 Helgja 1 6787000 Kvarven 6786000 Svartheller 3 nordre 6785000 716 Sorgi Verneforslag Tidligere registreringer Målestokk 1:33 000 Blåfjell Ombandsnes Alternativ grense Omr. for vurdering (DN 2004) Rutenett 1km Ekvidistanse 20m ± 6784000 Kjerneområder Eksisterende verneområder 01.05.2005 409000 410000 411000 412000 413000 414000 Bilder fra området Luster Vestre Statsallmenning Luster Vestre Statsallmenning, sett fra sørøst. Bildeutsnittet Prestejordstjerne Geastrum triplex, fotografert innenfor dekker praktisk talt hele området, men heller ikke så mye annet, kjerneområdet ved Svarthiller. Dette er eineste kjente lokalitet for med unntak av helt i nord. Foto: Geir Gaarder arten i fylket, og en av to kjente lokaliteter i Vest-Norge. Foto: Geir Gaarder Typisk furuskogsinteriør fra området. Bildet viser ei bratt liside litt Ganske storvokst lindeskog innenfor kjerneområdet ved sør for Svarthiller (rett utenfor kjerneområdet der). Lia er bratt, Svarthiller. Her er det også innslag av dødt trevirke, furuskogen nokså enssjiktet og ensaldret, selv om det akkurat her hovedsakelig som følge av rasaktivitet. Foto: Geir Gaarder er sparsomt med død ved, og det er tørre, fattige vegetasjonstyper (bærlyngskog) Foto: Geir Gaarder Møre og Romsdal Averøy Tustna Eide Kristiansund Fræna Averøy Frei Tingvoll Fræna Eide Gjemnes Aukra Barsteintjernet Molde Nesset Midsund Vestnes Rauma Verneforslag Nasjonalpark Fylkesgrense Vann ± Kommunegrense Skog Ørskog01020 Kilometer Stordal %DUVWHLQWMHUQHW 5HIHUDQVHGDWD )\ONH 0¡UHRJ5RPVGDO 3URVMHNWWLOK¡ULJKHW 6WDWVNRJ'3 .RPPXQH 0ROGH1HVVHW ,QYHQW¡U )*2 .DUWEODG ,7LQJYROO,9(LGH 'DWRIHOWUHJ ,,,cQGDOVQHV 870 1 $UHDO GDD +RK PRK 9HJHWDVMRQVRQH 1RUGERUHDO 9HJHWDVMRQVHNVMRQ 2.ODUWRVHDQLVN 6DPPHQGUDJ %DUVWHLQWMHUQHWOLJJHUSnPLGWUHGHODY5RPVGDOVKDOY¡\DSnJUHQVDPHOORP0ROGHRJ1HVVHWNRPPXQHU8QGHUV¡NHOVHQH LKDURPIDWWHWWUHGHORPUnGHUUXQGWHWWLGOLJHUHHWDEOHUWEDUVNRJVUHVHUYDWPHGWRPLQGUHVNRJWHLJHU KYHUSnFD GDD LQRUG¡VWRJV¡U¡VWVDPWHWVW¡UUHODQJVWUDNWEHOWH SnFDGDD PRWYHVW8QGHUV¡NHOVHVRPUnGHQHOLJJHULHW QRHVPnNXSHUWODQGVNDSSUHJHWDYIXUXVNRJRJVPnP\URPUnGHUPHQRJVnPHGLQQVODJDYQRHODXYVNRJ2PUnGHQHOLJ JHULPHOORPERUHDORJQRUGERUHDOVRQHPHGHWN\VWQ UWKXPLGNOLPD6NRJHQHUJMHQQRPJnHQGHJDPPHOPHQXWHQJRG NRQWLQXLWHWLG¡GWWUHYLUNHWUROLJVRPI¡OJHDYKDUGHJMHQQRPKRJVWHULWLGOLJHUHWLGHU'HWHURYHUYHLHQGHIDWWLJHWLOPLGGHOV ULNHYHJHWDVMRQVW\SHURJEHJUHQVHWPHGIURGLJK¡JVWDXGHVNRJ(QNHOWHU¡GOLVWHGHRJNUDYIXOOHJDPPHOVNRJVDUWHURSSWUHU GHOVLJDQVNHJRGHEHVWDQGHUPHQWHWWKHWRJGLYHUVLWHWDYVOLNHDUWHUHULNNHVSHVLHOWK¡\ 'HORPUnGHQHRJHNVLVWHUHQGHUHVHUYDWYXUGHUHVVDPOHWVHWWnY UHDYQDVMRQDOYHUQHYHUGL 'HWWHIRUGLGHWHUHWUHOD WLYWVWRUWRPUnGHPHGP\HJDPPHOVNRJÀHUHNUDYIXOOHRJGHOVU¡GOLVWHGHDUWHURSSWUHUHQNHOWHRJVnLEUXNEDUHEHVWDQGHU GHWHUHQYLVVYDULDVMRQVEUHGGHRJRPUnGHWHUSnÀHUHPnWHUW\SLVNIRUGHK¡\HUHOLJJHQGHVNRJVPLOM¡HQHLUHJLRQHQ'HWWH VDPVYDUHUVDPWLGLJPHGWLGOLJHUHYHUGLYXUGHULQJ,VROHUWVHWWKDUGHXOLNHGHORPUnGHQHODYHUHYHUGLRJInUKYHUIRUVHJ VWMHUQHU,QQHQIRUGHWQRUG¡VWUHRJGHWYHVWUHGHORPUnGHWJLULQQJUHSVVLWXDVMRQDUURQGHULQJRJQDWXUNYDOLWHWHUYDULDVMRQ LHJQHWKHWIRUYHUQGHUHQNHOWHSDUWLHUYXUGHUHVVRPEHGUHHJQHWHQQDQGUHGHOHU'HWV¡U¡VWUHGHORPUnGHWHUGHULPRW YHVHQWOLJPHUHQKHWOLJLVnPnWH 'HXQGHUV¡NWHGHORPUnGHQH RJHNVLVWHUHQGHUHVHUYDW YXUGHUHVVRPJDQVNHUHSUHVHQWDWLYHIRUGHKXPLGHOLWWK¡\HUHOLJ JHQGHRJIXUXGRPLQHUWHVNRJHQHLUHJLRQHQ(WJRGWLQQVODJDYHOGUHRVSHVNRJRJQRUGYHQGWHVNRJVOLHUHUSRVLWLYHWUHNN PHQVGnUOLJIRUHNRPVWDYODYHUHOLJJHQGHVNRJYDUPHNM UHHOHPHQWHURJW¡UUHV¡UYHQGWHVNRJVOLHUHUQHJDWLYHWUHNN 'HWQRUG¡VWOLJHGHORPUnGHWKDUÀHVWLQQJUHSPHGLQQVODJDYSODQWHIHOWNUDIWOLQMHPPPHQVGHWYHVWUHGHORPUnGHWSn GHQDQGUHVLGHQJUHQVHUPRWVWRUHJUDQSODQWHIHOW6¡U¡VWUHGHORPUnGHKDUGHULPRWInLQQJUHSRJHUGHOYLVRPJLWWDYHOGUH QDWXUVNRJ'HWHUPHVWVNRJSnIDWWLJRJPLGGHOVULNPDUNRJVSDUVRPWPHGIURGLJHK¡\SURGXNWLYHVNRJVPLOM¡HU2PUnGHW VLQEHW\GQLQJIRUU¡GOLVWHGHRJNUDYIXOOHDUWHUNQ\WWHWWLOJDPPHOVNRJHUEDUHPLGGHOVJRG9HUQHRPUnGHWRJGHORPUnGHQH OLJJHUKHOWHOOHUGHOYLVLQQHQIRUÀHUHVPnQHGE¡UIHOW$UURQGHULQJHQDYHNVLVWHUHQGHUHVHUYDWHULNNHV UOLJJRGRJGHPX OLJHXWYLGHOVHVRPUnGHQHE¡WHUEDUHLEHJUHQVHWJUDGSnGHWWHGHUGH¡VWUHGHORPUnGHQHHUYLNWLJVW,IRUKROGWLOPDQJOHQH YHGHNVLVWHUHQGHVNRJYHUQVnYLOGHXQGHUV¡NWHGHORPUnGHQHNXQQH¡NHLQQVODJHWDYVNRJPHGRYHUYHLHQGHQDWXUOLJ G\QDPLNNRJGHUPHGI¡UHWLODW%DUVWHLQWMHUQHWQDWXUUHVHUYDWVW\UNHUVLQEHW\GQLQJLVnPnWH5HVHUYDWHWNDQRJVnIn¡NW VLQHDUHDOHUPHGIXNWLJN\VWEM¡UNHVNRJHQGHO )HOWDUEHLG )HOWDUEHLGHWEOHXWI¡UWSnWRGDJHUGHQRJGHQDXJXVWWRWDOWQ UPHUHGDJVYHUN'HQEOHGHWR¡VWUH SULYDWHWHLJHQHXQGHUV¡NW9LJLNNVDPOHWLQQLRPUnGHWIUDULNVYHJHQSnQRUGVLGHQDY*DPPHOVHWHUYDWQHWRJGHOWHGHQ QRUGUHWHLJHQPHOORPRVV)UDYHVWHQGHQDYGHQQHWHLJHQ YHG%DUVWHLQWMHUQHW JLNNYLGLUHNWHPRW¡VWWLOGHQV¡QGUHWHLJHQ RJIXOJWHGHQIUDYHVWPRW¡VW )*2XQGHUV¡NWHQRUGUHGHOGYVQHGUHGHODYOLDPRW*DPPHOVHWHUYDWQHWPHQV**D XQGHUV¡NWHV¡QGUHGHOGYV¡YUHGHODYOLD 'HQEOHYHVWUHVWDWVHLGHGHOXQGHUV¡NW9LJLNNLQQLRPUnGHWIUDVNRJV YHJHQV¡UIRU6RWnD)*2XQGHUV¡NWH¡VWUHKDOYGHOGYVDUHDOHQHV¡UIRU 7LGVSXQNWRJY UHWVEHW\GQLQJ 9 UHWYDUEHJJHGDJHUJUnWWRJRYHUVN\HW6 UOLJGHQYDUGHWHQGHOUHJQPHQVGHWEDUHYDUOLWW\UGHQ9 UHW YDUOLNHYHOLNNHGnUOLJHUHHQQDWGHWLNNHDQWDVnKDKHPPHWDUEHLGHWLV UOLJJUDG7LGVSXQNWSnnUHWYDUJRGWHJQHWIRUn IDQJHRSSODYPRVHUNDUSODQWHURJYHGERHQGHVRSS'HWEXUGHRJVnY UWHJQHWIRUPDUNOHYHQGHVRSSPHQVHVRQJHQ YDUIRUGnUOLJWLOGHWWH GHWYDUJHQHUHOWUHODWLYWGnUOLJPHGVRSSLVNRJHQHLUHJLRQHQSnWLGVSXQNWHW )RUIXJOVnEOHGHWJMRUW LQWHUHVVDQWHUHJLVWUHULQJHUPHQWLGVSXQNWHWYDUGnUOLJHJQHWWLOnIDQJHRSSKHNNHIXJOIDXQDHQ 8WYHOJHOVHRJXQGHUV¡NHOVHVRPUnGH 'HNDUWODJWHDUHDOHQHRPIDWWHUWUHGHORPUnGHUORNDOLVHUWUXQGWHWHWDEOHUWEDUVNRJVUHVHUYDW %DUVWHLQWMHUQHWQDWXUUHVHUYDW ,¡VWHUGHWVQDNNRPWRPLQGUHVNRJWHLJHU V¡URJQRUGYHVWIRU*DPPHOVHWHUYDWQHW GHUGHUHVSHNWLYHJUXQQHLHUHQH 2OD 7MHOOHRJ6YHUUH7MHOOH KDUPHOGWLQQGLVVHVNRJSDUWLHQHIRUYXUGHULQJWLOIULYLOOLJYHUQ,YHVWHUGHWHLODQJVWULSH DYJUHQVHW LYHVWDY%RUGDOHQ PHGJMHQVWnHQGHQDWXUVNRJRSSPRWVQDXIMHOOHWVRPOLJJHUSnVWDWVJUXQQGHUYHUQHYHUGLHQHVNDOYXU GHUHV 7LGOLJHUHXQGHUV¡NHOVHU %DUVWHLQWMHUQHW QDWXUUHVHUYDW EOH YHUQHW VRP I¡OJH DY UHJLVWUHULQJHU IRUHWDWW L .RUVPR 6YDODVWRJ 'HUHV UHJLVWUHUWHRPUnGHDYYHNHQGHOIUDGHWVRPEOHHQGHOLJYHUQHW5HVHUYDWHWEOHXWYLGHWQRHLYHVWRJLQQVNUHQNHWHQGHOL ¡VWVDPPHQOLJQHWPHGGHUHVIRUVODJ)RUGHDUHDOHQHVRPQnKDUEOLWWYXUGHUWIRUYHUQLQQHE UHUGHWWHDWVNRJWHLJHQIRU IULYLOOLJYHUQSnV¡UVLGHQDY7MHOOHYDWQHWYDULQNOXGHUWL.RUVPR 6YDODVWRJ VLQHXQGHUV¡NHOVHUVDPWYHVWUHGHOHUDY VNRJWHLJHQSnQRUGYHVWVLGHQDY7MHOOHYDWQHW,WLOOHJJEOHGHOHUDYGHVDPPHVNRJWHLJHQHXQGHUV¡NWLIRUELQGHOVHPHGSOD QHURPQ\NUDIWOLQMHIUD6XQQGDOV¡UDXWSn\WUHGHOHUDY5RPVGDOVKDOY¡\D *DDUGHU 6WHQEHUJ 8WRYHUGHWWHKDUGHW L¡VWUHGHORPUnGHULNNHEOLWWIRUHWDWWQ\HXQGHUV¡NHOVHUIHNVLIRUELQGHOVHPHGGHQNRPPXQDOHNDUWOHJJLQJHQDYELRORJLVN PDQJIROG -%-RUGDOSHUVPHGG ,0ROGHHU0L6NDUWOHJJLQJLNNHVWDUWHWRSSHQGDPHQVGHQHUVOXWWI¡UWL1HVVHW,QJHQ 0L6¿JXUHUOLJJHULQQHQIRUGHYXUGHUWHGHORPUnGHQH ,YDU6NMHUY¡\6NRJHLHUIRUHQLQJD1RUGSHUVPHGG ,YHVWUHGHORPUnGHKDUGHWY UWI UUHXQGHUV¡NHOVHU0ROGHYDUSU¡YHNRPPXQHIRUELRORJLVNPDQJIROGNDUWOHJJLQJPHQ GHWEOHGDLNNHXWI¡UWQ\WWIHOWDUEHLGLQQHQIRURPUnGHWDYEHW\GQLQJ MIU-RUGDO *DDUGHU +HOOHULNNHYHGGHQVXS SOHUHQGHNRPPXQDOHNDUWOHJJLQJHQIRU0ROGHVRPEOLUDYVOXWWHWLKDUGHWY UWXWI¡UWHJHWIHOWDUEHLGKHU $&RQQRU SHUVPHGG %HOLJJHQKHW +HOHRPUnGHWOLJJHUJDQVNHVHQWUDOWSODVVHUWL0¡UHRJ5RPVGDOI\ONHSnLQGUHGHOHUDY5RPVGDOVKDOY¡\D'HWR¡VWUH GHORPUnGHQHOLJJHULQRUGYHVWUHGHODY1HVVHWNRPPXQHPHQVGHWYHVWUHOLJJHULV¡U¡VWUHGHODY0ROGHNRPPXQH,SUDN VLVVnRPIDWWHUGHORPUnGHQHPHGGHWHWDEOHUWHQDWXUUHVHUYDWHWLPHOORPP\HDYGHQLQGUHGHOHQDY6NnODKDOY¡\D'HQQH VWUHNNHUVHJYHVWRYHUXWPRW5RPVGDOVIMRUGHQPHG/DQJIMRUGHQSnV¡UVLGHQRJ)DQQHIMRUGHQSnQRUGVLGHQRJPHGIMHOO PDVVLYHW6NnOD K¡\HVWHSXQNWHUPRK VRPHWJDQVNHPDUNHUWODQGHPHUNH 1nUGHWJMHOGHUGHHQNHOWHGHORPUnGHQHVnOLJJHUGHQQRUG¡VWUHWHLJHQVRPHLVPDO¡VWYHVWYHQGWVWULSHLQQWLOHNVLVWH UHQGHQDWXUUHVHUYDW'HWRPIDWWHUHQOLWHQWDQJHL*DPPHOVHWHUYDWQHWOHQJVW¡VWRJKDUMHYQEUHGGHLQQWLO%DUVWHLQWMHUQDL YHVW'HQV¡U¡VWUHWHLJHQKDUHQPHU¿UNDQWHWIRUPRJLQQHE UHUHQPLQGUHIRUOHQJHOVHDYQDWXUUHVHUYDWHWPRW¡VWODQJV V¡UVLGHQDY*DPPHOVHWHUYDWQHW'HWYHVWUHGHORPUnGHWHUGHULPRWHWÀHUHNLORPHWHUODQJW RJVWRUWVHWWEDUHHWSDUKXQGUH PHWHUEUHGW EHOWHVRPJnUIUD 1DWXUJUXQQODJ 7RSRJUD¿ 7RSRJUD¿HQLGHWWHODQGVNDSHWSnPLGWUHGHOHUDY5RPVGDOVKDOY¡\DHULHQYHVWODQGVVDPPHQKHQJEDUHVPnNXSHUW'HW SUHJHVDYJDQVNHVPnGDOI¡UHUODYHRJQRNVnUXQGHIMHOOVSUHGWHWMHUQRJVPnLQQVM¡HURJHQGHOP\URPUnGHULPRVDLNN PHGVNRJNOHGWHOLVLGHU7UDQJHIMRUGHUVWXSEUDWWHOLHUK¡\HIMHOORJUROLJHVWUDQGÀDWHODQGVNDSPPHUHOHPHQWVRP¿QQHV DQGUHVWHGHULUHJLRQHQPHQVRPPDQJOHULRJQ UXQGHUV¡NHOVHVRPUnGHW 1nUGHWJMHOGHUGHHQNHOWHGHORPUnGHQHVnKDUGHWQRUG¡VWUHGHWVODNHVWHWHUUHQJHW8WPRW*DPPHOVHWHUYDWQHWHUGHW ÀHUHODYHnVNROOHUPHQVGHWLQQPRW%DUVWHLQWMHUQDHUHQVODNVNRJNOHGWnVU\JJ6PnP\UÀHNNHU¿QQHVVSUHGWKHOHYHLHQ 'HWV¡U¡VWUHGHORPUnGHWEHVWnUDYHLPHUHOOHUPLQGUHVDPPHQKHQJHQGHQRUGYHQGWVNRJVOLQHGPRW*DPPHOVHWHUYDWQHW (WSDUVPnGDOHUIUDWRSSHQRJQHGOLDEU\WHURSSWHUUHQJHWOLWW,GHWYHVWUHGHORPUnGHWVNDSHUQRUGYHVWVLGHQDY6RWnGDOV U¡UDRJ%OnKDPPDUHQ KHOWXWPRW%RUGDOHQ HQQRHPHUVNDUSRJGUDPDWLVNWRSRJUD¿3nEHJJHVWHGHUHUGHWLQQVODJDY QRHVW¡UUHEHUJYHJJHURJUDVPDUNSnQHGVLGHQ)RU¡YULJHUGHWRJVnKHUPHVWMHYQHQRUGYHQGWHOLVLGHUPHQPHG6RWn GDOHQRJ%RUGDOHQVRPVPnGDOI¡UHUVRPNRPPHUQHGIUDV¡U0\URSSWUHUMHYQWEnGHLIXNWLJHOLVLGHURJSnÀDWHSDUWLHURJ GDQQHUQRHVW¡UUHDUHDOUXQGW%RUGDOVYDWQHW *HRORJL *HRORJLHQLXQGHUV¡NHOVHVRPUnGHWHULXWJDQJVSXQNWHWJDQVNHVnHQVDUWHWRJYLUNHULNNHORYHQGHPKSÀRUDHQ+HOH 6NnODKDOY¡\DRJLHWEUHGWEHOWHYLGHUH¡VWRYHUHUGRPLQHUWDYJUDQLWW 7YHWHQHWDO 'HWJHRORJLVNHNDUWHWJLULQJHQ LQGLNDVMRQHU Sn QRH EHGUH EHUJJUXQQ (QNHOWH SODQWHIXQQ LQQHQIRU GH XQGHUV¡NWH RPUnGHQH VDPW ÀHUH UHJLVWUHULQJHU LQQHQIRUDQGUHGHOHUDYGHWWHJUDQLWWRPUnGHW MIU*DDUGHU 6WHQEHUJ YLVHUOLNHYHODWGHWRJVnKHUORNDOWPnY UH HQGHOYHVHQWOLJPHUQ ULQJVULNHEHUJDUWHU,NNHPLQVWYLVHUÀHUHUHJLVWUHULQJHUDYVWRUHRJJDQVNHYHOXWYLNOHGHULNP\UHU GHWWH'HWGRPLQHUHQGHLQQWU\NNHWLNNHPLQVWLQQHQIRUXQGHUV¡NHOVHVRPUnGHWHUOLNHYHOHQRYHUYHLHQGHQ ULQJVIDWWLJ EHUJJUXQQVRPEDUHJLUJUXQQODJIRUQ¡\VRPPHYHJHWDVMRQVW\SHU 9HJHWDVMRQVJHRJUD¿ 9HJHWDVMRQVHNVMRQ2.ODUWRVHDQLVNYHJWDVMRQVRQHQRUGERUHDO FDGDD PHOORPERUHDO FDGDD 8QGHUV¡NHOVHVRPUnGHW OLJJHU L VLQ KHOKHW LQQHQIRU ERUHDOH YHJHWDVMRQVVRQHU 2JVn V¡URERUHDO VRQH PDQJOHU LQQHQIRU RPUnGHWVHOYRPGHWORNDOW¿QQHVVYDNHYDUPHNM UHWUHNNLÀRUDHQ%nGHGHQN\VWQ UHEHOLJJHQKHWHQRJWRSRJUD¿HQJM¡U VNLOOHWPHOORPPHOORPERUHDORJQRUGERUHDOVRQHXNODUPHQWUROLJHUVWRUHGHOHUDYVNRJHQLPHOORPERUHDOVRQHPHQVEDUH GHPHVWK¡\WOLJJHQGHVNRJSDUWLHQHE¡UI¡UHVWLOQRUGERUHDOVRQH .OLPD 0HGHQnUVQHGE¡UPHOORPRJRJRYHUYHLHQGHK¡\HUHOLJJHQGHVNRJVLHUGHWVHJVHOYDWNOLPDHWEOLUJMHQQRPJn HQGHIXNWLJRJKXPLGHWUHNNLYHJHWDVMRQHQHUW\SLVNH6PnEDNNHP\UHUHUXWEUHGWVHOYLJDQVNHEUDWWHQRUGYHQGWHOLVLGHU 3nOLWWEHVN\WWHGHVWHGHUPRWYHVWDY UHWVRPLRPUnGHQHUXQGW%DUVWHLQWMHUQHWRJ*DPPHOVHWHUYDWQHWSUHJHVVNRJHQ DYHQULNHSLI\WWÀRUD*DPOHIXUXWU ULJOLVVHQVNRJNDQY UHJDQVNHQHGOHVVHWPHGJXEEHVNMHJJLWLOGHOVVMHOGHQWVWRUH PHQJGHU3nIURGLJHUHVWHGHUPHGULNWIHOWVMLNWRJHQYDULHUWWUHVODJVVDPPHQVHWQLQJDYODXYWU UNDQGHWY UHHQGHOPRVHU RJP\HODYIUDOXQJHQHYHUVDPIXQQHWODQJWRSSRYHUWUHVWDPPHQHRJGHOVXWRYHUW\QQHJUHLQHU7\SLVNHUHJQVNRJVODYHU LNNHSnYLVWLHOOHUQ UXQGHUV¡NHOVHVRPUnGHWPHQGHORNDONOLPDWLVNPHVWIXNWLJHVWHGHQHOLJJHUQRNLJUHQVHODQGIRUn NXQQHKDVOLNH6XERVHDQLVNHDUWHUEnGHDYNDUSODQWHURJODYHUGHULPRWVY UWNDUDNWHULVWLVNHIRURPUnGHW NRORJLVNYDULDVMRQ 'HHQNHOWHGHORPUnGHQHHULVROHUWVHWWLNNHVSHVLHOWYDULHUWH'HWQRUG¡VWUHRPUnGHWHUVODNWWLOVPnNXSHUWGHUWHUUHQJHWKDU IRUOLWHQVNDODWLOnVNLOOHJRGWPHOORPXOLNHHNVSRVLVMRQHU'HWHUHQW\GHOLJJUDGLHQWIUDGHQPHVWIDWWLJHVNRJHQLV¡UYHVWWLO PHUPLGGHOVULNVNRJL¡VWRJQRUG'HWV¡U¡VWUHRPUnGHWKDUOLWWVW¡UUHVSHQQYLGGHEnGHPKSK¡\GHODJRJWHUUHQJ'HW HUJMHQQRPJnHQGHQRUGYHQGWPHQLQQHKROGHUHWSDUVPnGDOHURJV¡NNVDPWGHWVODNHUHSDUWLHWQHGPRW*DPPHOVHWHU YDWQHW'HWYHVWUHGHORPUnGHWHUVW¡UUHRJKDUHQVW¡UUHVSHQQYLGGH6SHVLHOWJLU%RUGDOHQHWYLNWLJXWVODJLYDULDVMRQHQ VLGHQGHWKHUHUPDUNHUWH¡VWYHQGWHRJYHVWYHQGWHOLVLGHUGHOVPHGEHUJYHJJHURJUDVPDUNVDPWHQGDOEXQQPHGHWWMHUQ RJWLOK¡UHQGHXWO¡SVEHNN 6HWWLIRUKROGWLOGHWHNVLVWHUHQGHQDWXUUHVHUYDWHWVnWLOI¡UHUGHPXOLJHXWYLGHOVHVDUHDOHQHOLWHQ\WW%nGHRPUnGHEHVNULYHO VHUIRUUHVHUYDWHWRJDQGUHGDWDW\GHUSnDWGHÀHVWHQDWXUW\SHQHVRPHUSnYLVWRJVnHUUHSUHVHQWHUWLQQHQIRUUHVHUYDWHW 3nGHQDQGUHVLGHQVW\UNHUVDQQV\QOLJYLVÀHUHSDUWLHULGHXQGHUV¡NWHGHORPUnGHQHYLNWLJHNYDOLWHWHULQQHQIRUHNVLVWHUHQGH UHVHUYDW'HWWHJMHOGHULNNHPLQVWIRUHNRPVWHQDYJDPPHOEM¡UNHVNRJRJIXNWLJRJIURGLJODXYVNRJLGHWV¡U¡VWUHGHORPUn GHWVWRUYRNVWRVSHVNRJLQRUGYHVWUHGHORPUnGHVDPWJDPPHOIXUXVNRJLYHVWUHGHORPUnGH 9HJHWDVMRQRJWUHVODJVIRUGHOLQJ 'HQRYHUYHLHQGHQRNVnIDWWLJHEHUJJUXQQHQRJGHWKXPLGHNOLPDHWGHUXQGHUV¡NHOVHVRPUnGHWOLJJHULQRUGYHQGWHWHU UHQJIRUPDVMRQHU JM¡U DW IXNWLJH RJ QRH IDWWLJH VNRJW\SHU GRPLQHUHU %OnE UIXUXVNRJ RJ U¡VVO\QJIXUXVNRJ HU YDQOLJVWH YHJHWDVMRQVW\SHU3nOLWWEHGUHPDUNHUGHWOLNHYHOLNNHVnXYDQOLJPHGVPnEUHJQHVNRJRJLOLWWEUDWWHUHOLHUHUGHWORNDOW JDQVNHVnIURGLJPHGYHOXWYLNOHWK¡JVWDXGHVNRJHOOHUVWRUEUHJQHVNRJ9HOXWYLNOHWVXPSVNRJPDQJOHUPHQLNDQWHUDYP\U RJYDVVGUDJHUGHWWHQGHQVHUWLOIRUVXPSHWVNRJGHOVPHGIXUXRJGHOVPHGODXYWU U EM¡UNJUnRU 0\UHUYDQOLJPHQLDOO KRYHGVDNVRPIDWWLJIDVWPDWWHP\U0MXNPDWWHRJODXVERWQP\U¿QQHVEDUHORNDOWIHNVWLONQ\WWHWWMHUQVRP%DUVWHLQWMHUQD RJ%RUGDOVWMHUQD)OHNNHUPHGLQWHUPHGL URJGHOVULNP\UIRUHNRPPHURJVnKRYHGVDNOLJLQRNVnEUDWWHOLHUPHQHULNNH VnDUWVULNHRJYHOXWYLNOHGHVRPOHQJHU¡VWSn5RPVGDOVKDOY¡\D9HJHWDVMRQHQSnVQDXIMHOOHWHULNNHQ UPHUHXQGHUV¡NW PHQDQWDVnSUHJHVDYIDWWLJHW\SLVNHKHLXWIRUPLQJHU'HWYHVOHVRP¿QQHVDYUDVPDUNHUYLUNHUJURYVWHLQHWHRJJDQVNH WULYLHOOH 1nUGHWJMHOGHUGHHQNHOWHGHORPUnGHQHVnKDUGHWQRUG¡VWUHP\HU¡VVO\QJEORNNHE UVNRJRJGHWWHHUGHQKHOWGRPLQH UHQGHYHJHWDVMRQVW\SHQLV¡UYHVWUHGHOHU,QRUGRJ¡VWHUGHWPHVWEOnE UVNRJLQRHQRPUnGHUPHGJDQVNHVWRUWLQQVODJ DYRVS'HVVXWHQ¿QQHUHQVPnÀHNNHUPHGVPnEUHJQHVNRJRJWHQGHQVHUWLOVWRUEUHJQHVNRJ,WLOOHJJNRPPHUQRHIDWWLJ IDVWPDWWHP\U'HWV¡U¡VWUHGHORPUnGHWHUJMHQQRPJnHQGHIURGLJHUHPHGEOnE UVNRJVRPGRPLQHUHQGHVNRJW\SH+HUHU GHWOLWHU¡VVO\QJVNRJPHQHQGHOVWRUEUHJQHVNRJRJLQQVODJDYVPnEUHJQHVNRJRJK¡JVWDXGHVNRJ'HWHURJVnQRHIDWWLJ IDVWPDWWHP\U2JVnLYHVWUHGHORPUnGHHUEOnE UVNRJWRWDOWVHWWYDQOLJVWHRJGRPLQHUHQGHYHJHWDVMRQVW\SH'HWHUHOOHUV HQGHOU¡VVO\QJVNRJVWRUEUHJQHVNRJK¡JVWDXGHVNRJRJOLWWVPnEUHJQHVNRJVDPWWHQGHQVHUWLOOnJXUWVNRJ L%RUGDOHQ 'HWWHGHORPUnGHWHUULNHVWLYHVWRJJMHQQRPJnHQGHIDWWLJHUHL¡VW 6NRJVWUXNWXURJSnYLUNQLQJ 1DWXUVNRJHQLGHWWHVNRJODQGVNDSHWHUJMHQQRPJnHQGHVYDNWÀHUVMLNWHWPHGSDUWLHUPHGIDWWLJIXUXVNRJVRPNDQY UH GnUOLJHUHVMLNWHWRJIURGLJODXYVNRJPHGJRGVMLNWQLQJ'HWWHJMHOGHURJVnLQQHQIRUGHXQGHUV¡NWHRPUnGHQHGHUGHEUDWWH OLHQHLV¡U¡VWUHRPUnGHWRJSn¡VWVLGHQDY%RUGDOHQKDUEHVWVMLNWQLQJPHQVGHQHUGnUOLJVWLGHÀDWHUHIXUXGRPLQHUWH RPUnGHQHLQRUG¡VW 'HODXYGRPLQHUWHRPUnGHQHHUVDPWLGLJJDQVNHWHWWHPHQVVSHVLHOWRPUnGHUPHGIXUXGRPLQHUWVNRJRSSPRWVQDXIMHOOHW VRPL6RWnGDOHQ HUnSHQ2JVnSnÀDWHUHSDUWLHUVRPLQRUG¡VWHUGHWQRNVnJOLVVHQVNRJGHOVVRPI¡OJHDYDWVPn P\UHUEU\WHURSSVNRJHQ 6HLQWYRNVHQGHJDPPHOIXUXIRUHNRPPHULDOOHGHORPUnGHURJHUHWNDUDNWHULVWLVNRJXWEUHGWLQQVODJLGHWYHVWUHGHORPUn GHW'HWHURJVnHQGHOVHLQWYRNVHQGHIXUXLGH¡VWUHGHORPUnGHQHPHQHOHPHQWHWHUPHVWVSDUVRPWLV¡U¡VWKHOVWVRP I¡OJHDYDWERQLWHWHQKHUHUK¡\HVW1nUGHWJMHOGHUJDPOHODXYWU UHUGHWGHULPRWGHWV¡U¡VWUHGHORPUnGHWVRPKDUEHVW LQQVODJLNNHPLQVWDYJDPPHOEM¡UN2JVnLYHVWL%MRUGDOHQHUGHWLQQVODJDYHQGHOJDPOHODXYWU USULP UWRVSDYWLO GHOVVWRUHGLPHQVMRQHU,GHWQRUG¡VWUHGHORPUnGHWHUGHWHQGHORVSLQNOXGHUWQRHHOGUHWU UPHQJMHQQRPJnHQGHPHU VSDUVRPWPHGJDPPHOODXYVNRJ 1nUGHWJMHOGHUG¡GWWUHYLUNHVnIRUHNRPPHUGHWWHQRUPDOWVSDUVRPW,GHWQRUG¡VWUHGHORPUnGHWHUIRUHNRPVWHQQ UPHVW XEHW\GHOLJRJVWRUWVHWWEHJUHQVHWWLOJDQVNHIHUVNHO JHU.RQWLQXLWHWLG¡GWWUHYLUNHHUGHUIRUEUXWWKHU,GHWV¡U¡VWUHGH ORPUnGHWHUGHWGnUOLJPHGG¡GIXUXPHQQRHEHGUHPHGG¡GWODXYWUHYLUNH2JVnDYODXYWUHYLUNHHUGHWPHVWDYIHUVNHWLO PLGGHOVQHGEUXWWHVWDGLHURJNRQWLQXLWHWHQLG¡GWWUHYLUNHYLUNHUVYDN,YHVWHUGHWRJVnVWRUWVHWWOLWHG¡GWWUHYLUNHPHQ LHQNHOWHSDUWLHUNDQGHWIRUHNRPPHHQGHORJVSHVLHOWLQQHQIRUHQNHOWHNMHUQHRPUnGHUHUGHWWLOGHOVJRGIRUHNRPVWGHU GHWRJVnHULQQVODJDYJURYHRJPRUNQHO JHU'HWWHJMHOGHULNNHPLQVWL%RUGDOHQRJSnQRUGVLGHQDY/DQJU\JJHQGHU GHQJRGHVSUHGQLQJDDYG¡GIXUXLQGLNHUHUODYSnYLUNQLQJRYHUPHJHWODQJWLG6DPOHWVHWWDQWDVGHWWHGHORPUnGHWnKDHQ PLGGHOVJRGNRQWLQXLWHWLG¡GWWUHYLUNHDYIXUX QRHVRPVW¡WWHVDYIXQQDYU¡GOLVWHGHYHGERHQGHVRSSSnIXUXO JHU QRH VRPGHWHUODQJWPHOORPLUHJLRQHQ .MHUQHRPUnGHU ,GHWI¡OJHQGHOLVWHVLQIRUPDVMRQRPGHDYJUHQVHGHNMHUQHORNDOLWHWHQHLRPUnGHW%DUVWHLQWMHUQHW1XPPHUHULQJHQUHIHUHU WLOLQQWHJQLQJHUYLVWSnNDUWHW *DPPHOVHWHUYDWQHWYHVW 1DWXUW\SH *DPPHOODXYVNRJ*DPOHRVSHKROW 870 1 %09(5', % +RK PRK $UHDO GDD %HVNULYHOVHLQQODJWDY**DEDVHUWSnHJHWEHV¡N /RNDOLWHWHQOLJJHUUHWWSnYHVWVLGHQDY*DPPHOVHWHUYDWQHWLQRUGNDQWDYNUDIWOLQMDVRPNU\VVHURPUnGHWRJUHWWQRUGIRUHNVLVWHUHQGH%DU VWHLQWMHUQHWQDWXUUHVHUYDW,HQ¡VWYHQGWVODNVNUnQLQJHUGHWQRHODXYGRPLQHUWVNRJPHGP\HJDQVNHVWRURJGHOVJURYRVS5XQGWHUGHW PHVWIXUX2JVnLQQHLEHVWDQGHWHUGHWHQJRGGHOIXUXOLWWEM¡UNRJVSDUVRPWPHGURJQ6NRJHQHUOLWHVMLNWHW9HJHWDVMRQHQHULNNHVSHVLHOW ULNPHGKRYHGVDNOLJEOnE UVNRJRJEDUHPLQGUHSDUWLHUPHGVPnEUHJQHVNRJ3nIXUXWU UQHHUGHWORNDOWP\HJXEEHVNMHJJ$OHFWRULD VDUPHQWRVD9HUGLHQHVHUOLNHYHOXWWLOLI¡UVWHUHNNHnY UHNQ\WWHWWLOODYVDPIXQQSnRVSRJGHOVURJQ'LVVHKDUPLGGHOVJRGWXWYLNOHWOXQ JHQHYHUVDPIXQQPHGDUWHUVRPOXQJHQHYHU/REDULDSXOPRQDULDN\VWYUHQJH1HSKURPDODHYLJDWXPJU\QYUHQJH/SDULOHN\VWnUHQHYHU 3HOWLJHUDFROOLQDN\VW¿OWODY3DQQDULDUXELJLQRVDYDQOLJEOn¿OWODY'HJHOLDSOXPEHD¿OWKLQQHODY/HSWRJLXPVDWXUQLQXPVWLIW¿OWODY3DUPHOLHOOD WULSWRSK\OODRJ0HJDODULDJURVVD,WLOOHJJEOHVNRUSH¿OWODYHQ)XVFRSDQQDULDLJQRELOLV '& IXQQHWSnWRRVSHWU U /RNDOLWHWHQInUYHUGLVRPYLNWLJ % VLGHQHQU¡GOLVWHDUWHUSnYLVW.YDOLWHWHQHIRU¡YULJ PHQJGHQDQGUHODYIRUHNRPVWHQDYVWRURVS WLOVLHU ORNDOWYLNWLJWLOYLNWLJ *DPPHOVHWHUYDWQHWV¡U¡VW 1DWXUW\SH *DPPHOODXYVNRJ.RQWLQXLWHWVSUHJHWN\VWEM¡UNHVNRJ 870 1 %09(5', % +RK PRK $UHDO GDD %HVNULYHOVHLQQODJWDY**DEDVHUWSnHJHWEHV¡NVDPPHQPHG)LQQ2OGHUYLNVDPWOLWWHUDWXUNLOGHU *DDUGHU 6WHQEHUJ *DDUGHU 6WHQEHUJ ´2PUnGHVNLOGULQJ*HQHUHOW'HQQRUGYHQGWHVNRJVOLDWLO\NMHIMHOOHWKDUWLOGHOVIURGLJODXYRJEODQGLQJVVNRJ 'HWJMHOGRJLQQDIRUGHQDYJUHQVDORNDOLWHWHQVRPJnURYHULIDWWLJDUHP\URJP\UVNRJQHGPRW*DPPHOVHWHUYDWQHW'HWHUIURGLJPHQ LNNMHVnLQWHUHVVDQWVNRJLGHQEUDWWHOLDLV¡URJYHVWRJPRWHNVLVWHUDQGHNUDIWOLQHLDXVW9HJHWDVMRQ,QQDIRUORNDOLWHWHQHUGHWPHVWVPn EUHJQHRJGHOVEOnE UVNRJPHQRJVnOLWWULNDUHK¡JVWDXGHVNRJ'HWVWnUQRNRJURYRJJDPPDORVSKHUVDPWOLWWIXUXEM¡UNURJQJUDQ RJHLWSDUVHOMHWUH'HW¿QVWOLWWJDGGRJO JHU.XOWXUSnYHUNQDG'HWVWnUQRNRJUDQDYXOLNHDOGHULRPUnGHW1RNUHWUHNDQYHUDSODQWDPHQ GHWPHVWHHUWUXOHJVSUHGWIUnHOGUHSODQWLQJHUQ UDUH7MHOOH'HWHUÀHLUHVPnJU¡IWHUJMHQQRPRPUnGHW(OOHVKDUGHWLNNMHYRUHKRJGWUH KHUSnQRNVnODQJWLG$UWVIXQQ6NRJHQOLJJJDQVNHEHVN\WWDRJGHWHUJRGHUnPHWLOK¡YHIRUPDODY)OHLUHDUWDUIUnOXQJHQHYHUVDPIXQ QHWYHNVGDRJVnSnODXYWUHDPDYDUWGHQUDXGOLVWDVNRUSH¿OWOHYHQ3DQQDULDLJQRELOLVIXQQHSnWRRVSHWUH(OOHVI¡UHNRPPDRVHSEO UHJO\H&ROOHPDVXEQLJUHVFHQVOXQJHQHYHU/REDULDSXOPRQDULDEOn¿OWODY'HJHOLDSOXPEHDN\VW¿OWODY3DQQDULDUXELJLQLQRVDVNUXEEHQHYHU /REDULDVFURELGXODWDRJN\VWYUHQJH1HSKURPDODHYLJDWXP$YVNRUSHODYYDNVJDPPHOJUDQODY/HFDQDFWLVDELHWLQDRJYLQÀHNNODY$UWKRQLD YLQRVDYHGEDVLVDYJDPOHEM¡UNHWUHRJSnHLQURJQHJDGGYDUWODQJQnO&KDHQRWKHFDJUDFLOOLPDIXQQH'HWYDUHLQGHOUnWHYHGPRVHUSnHO GUHO JHUPDUDXGOLHVWHDUWHQUnWHÀjN&DO\SRJHLDVXHFLFD9HUGVHWWLQJ2PUnGHWEOLUYHUGVHWWWLO% YLNWLJ SJDI¡UHNRPVWDYWRUDXGOLVWDWD SODQWHDUWDURJDWODXYVNRJHQHUJDQVNHIXNWLJRJJDPPDO6NM¡WVHORJRPV\Q'HWEHVWHHUnODVNRJHQInOLJJHLIUHGIRULQQJUHSLQNOXGHUW DOOHI 1\WWIHOWDUEHLG /RNDOLWHWHQOLJJHULGHQYHVOHGDOHQVRPJnURSSLV¡UYHVWHQGHQDY*DPPHOVHWHUYDWQHW 870VHQWUDOSXQNW04 QRHVRP LQQHE UHUDWGHQOLJJHUSnEHJJHVLGHUDYUHVHUYDWJUHQVD+HUHUGHWVY UWIURGLJK¡JVWDXGHSUHJHWRJODXYGRPLQHUWVNRJ%M¡UNHUYDQ OLJVWHWUHVODJLWLOOHJJWLOQRHJUnRU V UOLJODQJVEHNNHVLJHW URJQRJLQQVODJDYJUDQ PHVWVHNXQG UVSUHGW IXUXRVS LYHVWLQQHQIRU UHVHUYDWHW RJVHOMH'HWHUOLWWG¡GWWUHYLUNHSULP UWDYXOLNHODXYWUHVODJRJJDQVNHIHUVNW*UnRUDRSSQnUEUXNEDUHGLPHQVMRQHUSnRSSWLO FPLGLDPHWHUHOOHUVHULNNHVNRJHQVSHVLHOWJURY'HWPHJHWIURGLJHIHOWVMLNWHWPHGGRPLQDQVDYK¡JVWDXGHYHJHWDVMRQRJHOOHUVQRH VWRUEUHJQHVNRJJM¡UDWIRU\QJHOVHQHUSUREOHPDWLVNRJSDUWLHUHUXWHQWU U0LOM¡HWHUIXNWLJPHGP\HODYSnWU UQH/XQJHQHYHUVDPIXQ QHWHUJRGWXWYLNOHWPHQEDUHJDQVNHYDQOLJHDUWHULQNOXGHUWVOLNHVRPSXWHJO\H&ROOHPDIDVFLFXODUHRJYDQOLJEOn¿OWODY'HJHOLDSOXPEHD 7LOGHOVHUGHWP\HHSLI\WWLVNHPRVHU)RU¡YULJEOHJDPPHOJUDQODY/HFDQDFWLVDELHWLQDIXQQHWSnEM¡UN$YNDUSODQWHUYDUGHPHVWNUDYIXOOH REVHUYHUWHDUWHQHWUROOE URJP\VNHIRU¡YULJNDQQHYQHVVNRJVWMHUQHEORPWXUWRJP\VNHJUDV /RNDOLWHWHQInUYHUGLYLNWLJ % VHOYRPLQJHQVSHVLHOWVMHOGQHHOOHUNUDYIXOOHDUWHURJVNRJW\SHUHUSnYLVW0LOM¡HWHUOLNHYHOVnIURGLJRJ SRWHQVLDOHWIRUNUDYIXOOHDUWHUJDQVNHJRGW*UDQDLRPUnGHWE¡UKRJJHVQHGUHODWLYWUDVNWPHQXWHQDWGHWJM¡UHVIRUV¡NSnnIUDNWHGHQ YHNNIRUnXQQJnNM¡UHVNDGHU 6HWHUKDXJHQQRUG 1DWXUW\SH *DPPHOODXYVNRJ.RQWLQXLWHWVSUHJHWN\VWEM¡UNHVNRJ 870 1 %09(5', $ +RK PRK $UHDO GDD %HVNULYHOVHLQQODJWDY**DEDVHUWSnHJHWEHV¡N /RNDOLWHWHQOLJJHUUHWWSnV¡UVLGHQDY*DPPHOVHWHUYDWQHWOLWWRSSHLOLDXQGHU6HWHUKDXJHQ+HUHUGHWHWSDUWLPHGJDQVNHJDPPHOEM¡U NHGRPLQHUWVNRJ,WLOOHJJHUGHWHQGHOIXUXRJLQQVODJDYURJQ6MLNWQLQJHQHUJRGRJGHWHUOLWWO JHURJJDGGDYEM¡UNVDPWHQNHOWHDY IXUX%M¡UNDHUGHOVQRNVnJURYPHGWU URSSPRWFPLGLDPHWHU9HJHWDVMRQHQHUOLNHYHOLNNHVSHVLHOWIURGLJPHGPHVWEOnE UVNRJ OLWWVWRUEUHJQHVNRJRJEDUHWHQGHQVHUWLOK¡JVWDXGHVNRJ,WLOOHJJ¿QQHVOLWWIDWWLJIDVWPDWWHP\U'HWEOHLNNHIXQQHWVSHVLHOWJRGWXWYLNOHGH EXVNRJEODGODYVDPIXQQKHUPHQOLWWVWU\ODYRJOXQJHQHYHU/REDULDSXOPRQDULD'HULPRWHUIRUHNRPVWHQDYVNRUSHODYSnGHJDPOH EM¡UNHWU UQHJRG*DPPHOJUDQODYRSSWUHUJDQVNHYDQOLJSnWU UQHYLQÀHNNODY$UWKRQLDYLQRVDEOHIXQQHWÀHUHVWHGHURJSnHWSDUWU U YRNVWHN\VWGRJJQnO6FOHURSKRUDSHURQHOOD3nHQVMHOGHQWJURYEM¡UNHJDGGLHWOLWHKROWXWHSnIDWWLJP\UDYRNVWHRJVnKYLWKRGHQnO&KD HQRWKHFDJUDFLOHQWDRJSUDNWGRJJQnO6FOHURSKRUDDPDELOLV6LVWQHYQWHHUUHJLRQDOWPHJHWVMHOGHQRJWLGOLJHUHLNNHIXQQHWVnODQJWV¡UL ODQGVGHOHQ KDUVLWWQRUVNHNMHUQHRPUnGHL1RUG7U¡QGHODJ )RUHNRPVWHQDYXYDQOLJJDPPHORJJURYEM¡UNRJLNNHPLQVWHWJRGWXWYLNOHWVNRUSHODYVDPIXQQPHGIXQQDYHQUHJLRQDOWPHJHWVMHOGHQ DUWJM¡UDWRPUnGHWYXUGHUHVVRPVY UWYLNWLJ $ /DQJU\JJHQ¡VW 1DWXUW\SH 5LNP\U0LGGHOVULNIDVWPDWWHP\U 870 1 %09(5', & +RK PRK $UHDO GDD %HVNULYHOVHLQQODJWDY**DEDVHUWSnHJHWEHV¡N /RNDOLWHWHQOLJJHUSn¡VWUHGHODY/DQJU\JJHQGHUHQOLWHQNROOHVNDSHUOLWWYDULDVMRQLODQGVNDSHW'HQRPIDWWHUEDUHHWOLWHIXNWLJVLJYHG IRWHQDYOLDI¡UGHQQHJnURYHULHWIXNWGUDJYLGHUHQHGRYHU7UROLJHUGHWQRHPHUPLQHUDODQULNHWYDQQVRPKHUNRPPHUXWIUDEHUJJUXQQ RJMRUGVPRQQRJVNDSHUJUXQQODJIRUHQPHUNUDYIXOOÀRUDHQQGHWVRPHOOHUVHUYDQOLJLGLVWULNWHW$YDUWHUNDQQHYQHVJXOVWDUUWYHERVWDUU EUHLXOOVYDUWWURSSVXPSKDXNHVNMHJJGYHUJMDPQHNYLWEODGWLVWHORJNRUQVWDUU /RNDOLWHWHQInUEDUHYHUGLVRPORNDOWYLNWLJ & 6HOYRPGHQHUJDQVNHLQWDNWVnHULQJHQVSHVLHOWVMHOGQHHOOHUNUDYIXOOHDUWHUSnYLVWVDPW DWGHQHUOLWHQ$QP'HWEOHRJVnIXQQHWHWOLWHSDUWLPHGULNP\UHQGDOHQJUH¡VWPHGRPWUHQWVDPPHDUWVLQYHQWDU /DQJU\JJHQVNRJ 1DWXUW\SH 8UVNRJJDPPHOVNRJ)XUXVNRJ 870 1 %09(5', $ +RK PRK $UHDO GDD %HVNULYHOVHLQQODJWDY**DEDVHUWSnHJHWEHV¡N /RNDOLWHWHQOLJJHUSn/DQJU\JJHQL¡YUHVNRJEHOWHRYHQIRU5¡\UOLD'HWHUJMHQQRPJnHQGHJDPPHOEODQGLQJVVNRJLGHQQHOLDRYHQIRU JUDQSODQWHIHOWHQHPHQGHQDYJUHQVHGHORNDOLWHWHQVNLOOHUVHJOLNHYHOSRVLWLYWXWPHGK¡\HUHLQQVODJDYHOHPHQWHUNQ\WWHWWLOJDPPHOVNRJ )XUXHUGRPLQHUHQGHWUHVODJ,WLOOHJJHUGHWHQGHOEM¡UNVDPWLQQVODJDYURJQVHOMHJUnRURJJUDQ VHNXQG UVSUHGWIUDSODQWHIHOWGHOV RJVnSODQWHWLQHGNDQW 6NRJHQHUPLGGHOVIURGLJPHGPHVWEOnE UVNRJ,WLOOHJJHUGHWHQGHOVWRUEUHJQHRJK¡JVWDXGHVNRJOLWWVPn EUHJQHVNRJRJLYHVWUHRJ¡YUHGHOHURJVnQRHU¡VVO\QJVNRJ,QQVODJHWDYG¡GWWUHYLUNHHUJMHQQRPJnHQGHJRGWRJRPUnGHWVNLOOHUVHJ XWYHGRJVnnKDJURYHRJJDPOHO JHURJJDGGDYIXUX$QVODJVYLVQ UPHUHHQWUHGMHODYVWRNNHQHYDUUHODWLYWJURYH'HWHURJVnHQGHO VWnHQGHJURYIXUXPHGGLDPHWHURYHUFP0\HDYO JUHQHHUQRNJDPOHYLQGIDOOPHQHQGHOKDURJVnVWnWWRJUnWQHWSnURW'HWEOHWDWW ÀHUHEHOHJJDYYHGERHQGHVRSS'HOVYDUGHWWHUHODWLYWWULYLHOOHDUWHUVRP6NHOHWRFXWLVELJXWWXODWD3KOHELHOODSVHXGRWVXJDHRJ5HVLQLFLXP FIIXUIXUDFHXPPHQLWLOOHJJEOHRJVnGHQVnUEDUHJDPPHOVNRJVWLONQ\WWHGHEDUNVRSSHQ3K\VRGRQWLDOXQGHOOLLSnYLVW3RWHQVLDOHWIRUÀHUH NUDYIXOOHRJGHOVU¡GOLVWHGHYHGERHQGHVRSSYXUGHUHVVRPJRGW$YODYHUOXQJHQHYHUVDPIXQQHWPLGGHOVJRGWXWYLNOHWSnURJQHWU UPHG DUWHUVRPOXQJHQHYHU/REDULDSXOPRQDULDVNUXEEHQHYHU/VFURELXODWDYDQOLJEOn¿OWODY'HJHOLDSOXPEHDSXWHJO\H&ROOHPDIDVFLFXODUH PXVOLQJODY1RUPDQGLQDSXOFKHOODN\VW¿OWODY3DQQDULDUXELJLQRVDYUHQJHDUWHU1HSKURPDVVSRJORNDOWRJVnOLWWV¡OYQHYHU/DPSOLVVLPD )RU¡YULJEOHYLQÀHNNODY$UWKRQLDYLQRVDIXQQHWHWWVWHG.DUSODQWHÀRUDHQHUJDQVNHRUGLQ UPHQPHGVSUHGWHIXQQDYNQHURW /RNDOLWHWHQInUYHUGLVY UWYLNWLJ $ IRUGLHQVnUEDUEDUNVRSSHUSnYLVW9HUGLYXUGHULQJHQVW\UNHVDYHWJRGWLQQVODJDYJURYJDPPHORJ G¡GIXUXLNNHPLQVWPHGIRUHNRPVWHQDYJURYHRJJDPOHO JHUQRHVRPHUUHJLRQDOWVMHOGHQW(WDEOHUWJUDQLRJLQQWLOORNDOLWHWHQE¡U IMHUQHV %RUGDOHQ¡VW 1DWXUW\SH 8UVNRJJDPPHOVNRJ)XUXVNRJ 870 1 %09(5', $ +RK PRK $UHDO GDD %HVNULYHOVHLQQODJWDY**DEDVHUWSnHJHWEHV¡N /RNDOLWHWHQOLJJHUSn¡VWVLGHQDY%RUGDOHQLQHGUHGHODYOLD¡VWIRU%RUGDOVWMHUQ,QHGUHGHOHUHUGHWKHUHQGHOODXYGRPLQHUWVNRJGHU VSHVLHOWIRUHNRPVWHQDYWLOGHOVPHJHWJURYRVSHULQWHUHVVDQW/HQJHURSSHEOLUVNRJHQPHUVPnYRNVWLQQVODJHWDYIXUXVW¡UUHVDPWLGLJ VRPGHWEOLUOLWWPHUG¡GWWUHYLUNH%M¡UNHUQRNGHWYDQOLJVWHWUHVODJHWPHQGHWHURJVnP\HRVSRJIXUX,WLOOHJJNRPPHUOLWWURJQHQGHO VHNXQG UVSUHGWJUDQ GHHOGVWHHUWUROLJJRGWRYHUnU VDPWLQQVODJDYJUnRUKHJJRJVHOMH9HJHWDVMRQHQHUWLOGHOVQRNVnIURGLJ PHGHQGHOK¡JVWDXGHRJEUHJQHULNVNRJPHQRJVnEOnE UVNRJHUYDQOLJ'HWHULWLOOHJJWHQGHQVHUWLOOnJXUWVNRJ IHNVPHGOLOMHNRQYDOO RJWHLHE U (QNHOWHDYRVSHWU UQHHUVRPVDJWJURYHPHGGLDPHWHURYHUFPRJRJVnHLJUDQHUUHODWLYWVWRU$YG¡GWWUHYLUNHRSSWUHU RVSHO JHUVSDUVRPWLXOLNHVWDGLHURJVnQRNVnJURYHO JHU'HWVDPPHJMHOGHUIXUXVRPKDUÀHUHJURYHRJPLGGHODOGUHQGHWLOJDPOH O JHURSSHLOLD3nRVSURJQRJLPLQGUHJUDGEM¡UNHUOXQJHQHYHUVDPIXQQHWJDQVNHJRGWXWYLNOHW/XQJHQHYHU/REDULDSXOPRQDULD YDQOLJEOn¿OWODY'HJHOLDSOXPEHDRJYUHQJHU1HSKURPDVVSHUYDQOLJHSXWHJO\H&ROOHPDIDVFLFXODUHPXVOLQJODY1RUPDQGLQDSXOFKHOOD VNUXEEHQHYHU/VFURELFXODWDRJN\VW¿OWODY3DQQDULDUXELJLQRVDPHUVSDUVRPPHPHQVVNRUSH¿OWODY)XVFRSDQQDULDLJQRELOLVLDOWEOHIXQQHW SnHWWLWDOOVRVSHURJ¿QQHVKHUPDRLHQUHODWLYWJRGEHVWDQG'HWEOHVDPOHWLQQHQNHOWHYHGERHQGHVRSSIUDIXUXRJSnHQOnJYRNVWH EnGH6NHOHWRFXWLVOHQLVRJU¡GOLVWHDUWHQEUXQKYLWNMXNH$QWURGLDDOEREUXQQHD '& 6LVWQHYQWHKDUWLGOLJHUHLNNHY UWSnYLVWSn5RPVGDOV KDOY¡\DRJHUUHJLRQDOWVMHOGHQ /RNDOLWHWHQInUXQGHUQRHWYLOYHUGLVY UWYLNWLJ $ VLGHQHWSDUU¡GOLVWHDUWHUHUSnYLVWRJGHWHUHOHPHQWHUEnGHDYPHJHWJURYRVSRJ JDPPHOIXUX6HNXQG UVSUHGWJUDQE¡USnVLNWIMHUQHV *DPPHOVHWHUYDWQHWQRUGYHVW 1DWXUW\SH 8UVNRJJDPPHOVNRJ)XUXVNRJ 870 1 %09(5', $ +RK PRK $UHDO GDD %HVNULYHOVHLQQODY)*2EDVHUWSnIHOWQRWDWHUIUDHJHWEHV¡N/RNDOLWHWHQXWJM¡UHVDYHWOLWHP\UGUDJRJHLJDQ VNHVODNNnVVLGHYHVWIRUQRUGOLJHGHODY*DPPHOVHWHUYDWQHW(WOLWHWMHUQVDPPHQPHGP\UGUDJHWRJGHQQRUGOLJHHNVSRVLVMRQHQJM¡U DWORNDOLWHWHQEOLUUHODWLYWIXNWLJ9HJHWDVMRQHQHUVWRUWVHWWWULYLHOOEOnE UVNRJPHGIRUKROGVYLVVPnYRNVWIXUXPHQRSSPRWHWPLQGUH K¡JGHGUDJYRNVHUGHWRJVnQRHRVS PHGOXQJHQHYHU/REDULDSXOPRQDULD RJJDQVNHJDPPHOJURYEM¡UN1RHG¡GYHGLGHWWHRPUnGHW UXQGW04 3nHWPLGGHOVJURYIXUXYLQGIDOOEOHGHWWDWWEHOHJJDYHWSDUEDUNVRSSHU'HQHQHYLVWHVHJnY UH3KOHELDWULVWLV 5 'HWHUIXNWLJEOnE UIXUXVNRJPHGQRHJURYEM¡UNRJRVSYHG 04 ,GHWVDPPHRPUnGHWEOHGHWRJVnREVHUYHUWWUHWnVSHWW SnPDWV¡N 9HUGLYXUGHULQJ7UROLJHUGHWHQVDPPHQKHQJPHGREVHUYDVMRQDYWUHWnVSHWWSnORNDOLWHWHQRJUHODWLYWJRGWLOJDQJSnG¡GYHG,RJPHG DWGHWEOHIXQQHWVMHOGHQU¡GOLVWHWVRSSVnPnORNDOLWHWHQYHUGVHWWHVWLO6Y UWYLNWLJ$1nUGHWJMHOGHUGHQU¡GOLVWHGHUnWHYHGVRSSHQ 3KOHELDWULVWLVVnNDQGHWWHIXQQHWVDPPHQPHGDQGUHIXQQVRPHUJMRUWLI\ONHWW\GHSnDWDUWHQI¡UVWRJIUHPVWHUIXNWLJKHWVNUHYHQGH GYVGHQNUHYHUUHODWLYWK¡\RJVWDELOIXNWLJKHW/DQJNRQWLQXLWHWLG¡GYHGHOHPHQWHWNDQYLUNHVRPHWVHNXQG UWNUDY 6NM¡WVHORJRPV\Q6NRJHQKHUE¡UInY UHPHVWPXOLJLIUHGXWHQLQQJUHSVRPKRJVWJU¡IWLQJRJOLJQHQGH(YHQWXHOOHJUDQWU UE¡U VHOYVDJWIMHUQHVIHOOHV 6RWnGDOVU¡UDQRUG 1DWXUW\SH 8UVNRJJDPPHOVNRJ)XUXVNRJ 870 1 %09(5', % +RK PRK $UHDO GDD %HVNULYHOVHLQQODY)*2EDVHUWSnIHOWUHIHUDWIUDHJHWEHV¡N/RNDOLWHWHQOLJJHURSSHLGHQEUDWWHOLDV¡UYHVWIRU