Ice Age Animals in Southwest U.S. Rock Art, Part 2
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Pleistocene coalition news VOLUME 5, ISSUE 3 MAY- JUNE 2013 Inside - Challenging the tenets of mainstream scientific agendas - Main story: Continuing with Ray Urbaniak’s Asian or extinct animals in U.S. rock art PAGE 1 Page 4: Trekking from Central Asia to Utah. Click to read » Ice Age animals in Page 5: Calico needs scientific oversight. Click to read » SW US rock art, Prt 2 Ray Urbaniak Page 6: Member news & other information. Click to read » Page 7: Technical paper—Glacial maxima. Click to read » PAGE 4 Page 10 : Textbook evo propaganda 1. Click to read » Straight line travel Page 13: Neanderthal renaissance. Click to read » in the Pleistocene John Feliks Page 16: Textbook evo propaganda 2. Click to read » PAGE 5 Calico renamed Ice Age animals in and emasculated Virginia Steen-McIntyre Southwest U.S. rock art, part 2 PAGE 6 Member News & By Ray Urbaniak that the petroglyphs do not at mals as is commonly done it other information all resemble the tightly -coiled is my belief that the fossil Engineer, rock art photographer, horns of bighorn sheep but record may have holes in it Maggie Macnab, researcher and preservationist clearly show animals with that can be plugged with vari- Vesna Tenodi long sweeping horns over ous animals depicted in rock [Editor’s note: This article is condensed their backs. art if we from a much longer submission. are willing PAGE 7 In Part 1, I provided origi- In Part 2, I to look at nal photographs of South- offer other the evi- Technical paper: petroglyphs Glacial maxima west rock art petroglyphs dence from that support the idea of in Utah and an open- Alan Cannell humans having been in the Arizona minded which de- Americas much longer point of than traditionally taught, pict addi- view. PAGE 10 as they appear to show either tional enig- Propaganda in col- extinct animals or animals matic ani- There are mals (e.g., in fact de- lege textbooks,Prt1 which have never been known from the area even in the Fig. 1). pictions of John Feliks Ice Age fossil record (PCN #22, I believe Fig. 1. Southwest petroglyph of an enig- March-April 2013). matic animal with forward-facing horns animals in that depic- which is clearly not a bighorn sheep. North PAGE 13 The Part 1 petroglyphs were tions of Photo: Ray Urbaniak. America possible A Neanderthal ren- of animals that appear to be which place extinct animals is strong evi- aissance antelope, ibex, or gazelle— Native peoples in North Amer- animals with straight or long dence that people were in the ica much earlier than had Vesna Tenodi sweeping horns—which are Americas around the last ice previously been believed by known from Asia, Europe, and age and most likely much non-native people. longer—just as Native people PAGE 16 Africa. I pointed out that in the U.S. such petroglyphs are have long insisted. A variety of living and ex- tinct animals Propaganda in col- commonly interpreted as be- Rather than viewing every lege textbooks,Prt2 ing “stylized” depictions of unusual or enigmatic animal In the process of working to John Feliks bighorn sheep because big- figure as either a mythologi- preserve Southwest rock art I horn are known from the cal creature or as “stylized” area. This is despite the fact versions of well-known ani- > Cont. on page 2 VOLUME 5, ISSUE 3 PAGE 2 Ice Age animals in Southwest U.S. rock art, part 2 have taken many photo- There is no reason not to graphs in the Southwest U.S. graphs of animal depictions expect that some of these which could possibly repre- which are not sent such ani- easy to identify. mals. A couple of One example is them are shown shown in Fig. 2. in Fig. 1 and As mentioned Fig. 3. above, apart from thinking of For those inter- “There is no such depictions ested in informa- as stylized ver- tion about the reason not to various species expect sions of well- known con- of pronghorn that temporary that were still some of animals or as living in the imaginary Americas when these early people were now ex- animals, I offer a few here see the very tinct ani- possible in- accessible article mals terpretations by Darren Nash, based on 2010, at science- would blogs.com called have been de- animals which are Release the Fossil Pronghorns!! Also picted in the known from the Fig. 2. Upper Left: Southwest U.S. petroglyph of an unidenti- interesting are rock art of fossil record. fied animal; Photo by Ray Urbaniak. Very noticeable character- early Native The Camelops istics of the animal include a long neck or trunk, a relatively Extinct and Ex- large body, long straight legs, and a short tail. For comparison, tant Pronghorns: Americans.” interpretation is based on an I offer a couple of animals of the camel family known from the America’s U.S. Pleistocene—Miocene age fossil record, as well as an ex- Pseudo- extinct camel tinct elephant from Asia. Upper Right: Alticamelus or Aepy- which is known antelopes, by camelus, an extinct camel known from the Miocene of Colo- Mark Gelbart, to have been rado, etc. According to the fossil record as presently known it present in the died out before the Pliocene, c. 5 million years ago. Lower 2012; and Prehis- Americas when Left: Camelops, an extinct camel that lived in western North toric Pronghorn: early people America along with early Native Americans until the end of the Ancient Antelope, “The fossil re- were here. The Pleistocene about 10,000 years ago. This animal could very about an exhibit other two inter- certainly have been subject of depiction in Native American at the Arizona cord may have rock art. Lower right: Deinotherium, an extinct elephant from Museum of Natu- holes in it that pretations are the Miocene-Pleistocene of Africa, Europe, and Asia. All com- not as conven- ral History. can be plugged parison images: Wikimedia Commons. ient geographi- One petroglyph with the ani- cally or time-wise but should now extinct animals could panel with a pronghorn-type mals depicted not be automatically ruled have been depicted in the animal or extinct early ante- in rock art.” out. lope which I Pronghorns photographed is high on the There is only rock face one species (approx 15 of pronghorn feet up) at living in the what may American west have been today. How- ground level ever, during thousands of the Pleisto- years ago. On cene and the same Pliocene there panel are were at least other ice age 12-14 differ- Fig. 3. One of the petroglyph panels in Utah with depictions of several animals. different horned or antlered animals in a sequence (Photo: Ray Urba- ent species niak). There appear to be two different types of pronghorn depicted Saiga ante- and some with suggesting at least one before the animal’s extinction. very unusual lope horns. Prong- There is a petroglyph panel rock art of early Native horns had a range stretching in Arizona which could possi- from Florida to California and Americans and I have taken many petroglyph photo- from Mexico to Canada. > Cont. on page 3 PLEISTOCENE COALITION NEWS VOLUME 5, ISSUE 3 PAGE 3 Ice Age animals in Southwest U.S. rock art, part 2 bly include a rare depiction Usuktuk River in northern Next issue of a Saiga Antelope (Fig. 4). Alaska; whereas the latest sur- vivor, also from Alaska, dates In the same valley with the Saigas are presently confined to to about 12,200 years ago. saiga petroglyph is a petro- central Asia. However, during Of the three Canadian speci- glyph of a mountain goat. the Pleistocene—about 2 mil- mens, two from the Baillie Also, on the same highly- Islands, Northwest Terri- patinated panel with prong- tories and Bluefish Cave horn and saiga is a glyph III, Yukon, yielded dates which may well depict a of about 15,000-13,400 Mammoth. It is a very old years ago. The other is panel where the patina of from Old Crow Basin, the pecked area matches the northern Yukon and color of the surrounding pat- dated at about 13,200 inated rock surface. There years ago. (See Dr. are other petroglyphs I have Virginia Steen- photographed that most McIntyre’s report, Early people would dismiss as man in Northern Yukon “fanciful animals.” You de- 300,000 years ago, cide. Pleistocene Coalition From: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/ News #20 for infor- science-environment-18770963 mation on firmly- Editor’s note: This article series Fig. 4. Lower Right: Southwest U.S. petroglyph showing possible depiction dated archaeological is a condensed version of a much of a Saiga antelope extinct from the Americas since about 12,000 years ago. sites proving that peo- longer submission. Petroglyph photo by Ray Urbaniak. Inset: Photoshop-enhanced version of the ple were in the Old petroglyph by Ray Urbaniak. Saiga drawing and photo: Wikimedia Commons. Crow Basin long enough to have seen saiga antelope either from Ray Urbaniak is an engineer by educa- lion to 10,000 years ago— Central Asia a few thousand tion and profession; however, he is an they spread not only as far artist and passionate amateur arche- miles away or while saiga ologist at heart with many years of were still present in systematic field research on Native Alaska.) American rock art, especially as related to archaeoastronomy, equinoxes and http://www.beringia.com/ solstices in Utah. He has noted that research/saiga.html standard archaeological studies com- monly record details of material culture Radiocarbon Dates on Saiga but overlook the sometimes incredible Antelope (Saiga tatarica) celestial archeological evidence.