News from Egypt Unfolded During Panel
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THE MONTHLY NEWSLETTER OF THE OVERSEAS PRESS CLUB OF AMERICA, NEW YORK, NY • July/August 2012 News From Egypt Unfolded During Panel EVENT RECAP: JUNE 19 log, filling in the audience by Aimee Vitrak on the breaking Egypt’s first election in 7000 news of the day years was held on June 17 and 18. and leveraging But if this election was long in the his familiar- making, so too were the results with ity of a Muslim both candidates claiming victory as country from the military seized control and re- his time as a re- ports surfaced that the deposed dicta- porter for The tor Hosni Mubarak was brain dead. New York Times All of this news was breaking right Sonya K. Fry in Jakarta. up to start of the program on June 19 During the at the Ford Foundation and injected From left, panelists Bazzi, Sennott and Sims. program, the the discussion with a sense of im- election results were looking favor- of this election contain everything mediacy and an urging for American able for the Muslim Brotherhood, Americans believe in is on the line. media to cover Egypt and for the which in many countries can be “Do we support democracy or sta- public to learn more about the U.S. construed as a terrorist organization. bility?” The question was about involvement with Egypt. However, Sennott said terrorism was the $1.3 billion in funding the U.S. Panelists included Mohamad too pat a conception for the Brother- gives to Egypt, largely to support the Bazzi who is a senior fellow for hood in Egypt, which has wanted to military and status quo. In the past, Middle Eastern studies at the Coun- rule in that country since its found- the U.S. has supported the military, cil on Foreign Relations and former ing in 1928. Sennott said the results Middle East bureau chief for News- (Continued on Page 2) day. Charles M. Sennott, executive editor and co-founder of GlobalPost Russia’s Top Cop Denies Threat, Then Apologizes who covered the Egyptian revolts by Larry Martz and the Muslim Brotherhood in A rare shaft of daylight pierced his Frontline/WGBH documentary the hermetically sealed world of the “Revolution in Cairo,” which was Kremlin this week with the unfolding excerpted at the event to fill in the of the bizarre case of Aleksandr Bas- picture of the Muslim Brotherhood. trykin, the head of Russia’s equiva- Calvin Sims, Program Officer, lent of the FBI. Accused of threat- Freedom of Expression Unit of the ening to kill a prominent Russian Ford Foundation facilitated the dia- reporter, Bastrykin first blustered Novaya Gazeta’s editor-in-chief that the story was “outright lies,” Dmitry Muratov in October 2011. In Inside. “stupidities and innuendo.” Then he the background is an image of Anna Politkovskaya who was killed in 2006. called a press conference and issued OPC Election Slate......................3-6 an apology — without admitting the The letter said Bastrykin, angered by Cruise Lecture Circuit......................6 facts or even explaining what he was a story the paper had published, had apologizing for. its deputy editor for investigative People........................................7-10 The story broke when Dmitry reporting, Sergei Sokolov, driven to Muratov, editor in chief of the cru- a section of forest outside Moscow, Journalists in Mexico.....................11 sading newspaper Novaya Gazeta, where Bastrykin threatened to kill New Books....................................12 published an open letter to Bastrykin. (Continued on Page 2) Egypt Event: Continued From Page 1 experience, so far, has and indirectly Mubarak, for the return of an ally in the been a failure.” Middle East and stability. Now however, if the Brother- The panel revealed hood was elected in a fair election, then democracy must how intertwined the prevail, even if the candidate is not preferred by the U.S. Egyptian economy Sennott underscored that the repression in Egypt has and military have be- come at the hands of the Mubarak-led government, not come. For example, President Morsi in July. the Muslim Brotherhood. “America needs to have a so- when an officer serves phisticated reponse...if we fear the Muslim Brotherhood, his time in the army and is ready for retirement, he is we lose that moment.” given, by the government, a business, like a shopping Bazzi said that there are other manifestations of the center or grocery chain as part of the retirement package. Brotherhood, with Hamas in Palestine and Syria. “I’d Sennott said, that if Mubarak died soon, it would be a be worried if Egypt’s Brotherhood were like Syria’s,” metaphor for the collapse of his regime, “in the end, even he said. “The best way to expose any weakness in these his death is an injustice because he is getting away with groups is to give them a chance to govern. The limited murder.” Russia Threat: Continued From Page 1 was to call a meeting at the offices of the Interfax news Sokolov and joked that he personally would lead the in- agency. With the most prominent journalists in Russia vestigation into his death. Muratov said Sokolov had in attendance, Bastrykin issued his apology, shook hands fled the country, and demanded that Bastrykin guarantee with Muratov, and said he had spoken by phone with So- his safety. kolov and offered him a wristwatch as a gesture of con- Novaya Gazeta is no stranger to violence. At least ciliation. Muratov said the matter was settled, and “Ev- erything that I demanded in the letter has been satisfied.” three of its journalists have been killed in the past decade The OPC’s Freedom of the Press Committee has writ- in retaliation for their reporting, including the illustrious ten two letters to Putin in response to this odd case. The Anna Politkovskaya, winner of the OPC’s first Artyom first, before Bastrykin’s apology, demanded that he be Borovik award for investigative reporting in Russia. No suspended from his office while Muratov’s charges were one has been punished for any of the killings. investigated, and that criminal charges must be filed if In an interview with the newspaper Izvestia, Bas- the story was true. The second letter repeated those de- trykin denied the whole story. As head of Russia’s In- mands, explaining that Bastrykin’s threat, if true, “was a vestigative Committee and a university classmate of the crime, which no vague apology can erase.” It would also newly restored President Vladimir V. Putin, he clearly represent “a gross dereliction of duty” undermining the felt no threat from a mere newspaper. What happened to rule of law, and faith in the system could be restored only change his mind may never be known, but his next move with Bastrykin’s prosecution. OVERSEAS PRESS CLUB OF AMERICA • BOARD OF GOVERNORS PRESIDENT SECRETARY Tim Ferguson Toni Reinhold ASSOCIATE BOARD PAST PRESIDENTS David A. Andelman Jane Ciabattari Editor Editor in Charge, MEMBERS EX-OFFICIO Editor Author/Journalist Forbes Asia New York Desk Bill Collins John Corporon World Policy Journal Reuters Director, Public & Allan Dodds Frank ACTIVE BOARD Chrystia Freeland Business Affairs Alexis Gelber FIRST VICE PRESIDENT Ron Allen Global Editor-at-Large Tom Squitieri Ford Motor Company William J. Holstein Marcus Mabry Correspondent Thomson Reuters Freelance Journalist Marshall Loeb Editor at Large NBC News Emma Daly Larry Martz International Herald Tribune Evelyn Leopold Gillian Tett Communications Roy Rowan Rebecca Independent Journalist U.S. Managing Editor Director Leonard Saffir SECOND VICE PRESIDENT Blumenstein United Nations Financial Times Human Rights Watch Larry Smith Michael Serrill Page One Editor Richard B. Stolley Assistant Managing Editor The Wall Street Journal Santiago Lyon Seymour Topping Sarah Lubman Bloomberg Markets Director of Emeritus Partner EXECUTIVE Paul Brandus Photography Professor of Brunswick Group DIRECTOR THIRD VICE PRESIDENT West Wing Report Associated Pess International Sonya K. Fry Arlene Getz Journalism Abi Wright Editor-in-Charge, Media Jonathan Dahl John Martin Columbia University Director EDITOR Thomson Reuters Editor-in-Chief Writer/Editor Alfred I. duPont- Aimee Vitrak Smart Money Joel Whitney Columbia University TREASURER Abigail Pesta Editor Awards OPC Jacqueline Albert- Adam B. Ellick Editorial Director Guernica ISSN-0738-7202 Simon Video and Print Journalist Women in the World Copyright © 2002 U. S. Bureau Chief The New York Times Over seas Press Club of Politique Internationale America 40 West 45 Street, New York, NY 10036 USA • Phone: (212) 626-9220 • Fax: (212) 626-9210 • Website: opcofamerica.org OPC Bulletin • July/August 2012 • Page 2 Asia. She also helped launch the first Asian news bureau 2012 OPC Election Slate for WSJ.com. Before that, she was based in London OFFICERS for Dow Jones Newswires. She has won numerous PRESIDENT journalism awards for her reporting. Michael Serrill has been an OPC member for 19 years. He has Toni Reinhold is one of the editors served several times as a member in charge of Reuters’ Americas of the board, as second and third Desk. Reinhold has worked for Vice President and as Secretary. Reuters for more than 19 years He ran the awards judging panels as a correspondent, editor and for several years. He then became training editor. She also teaches Editor of Dateline, the magazine journalism around the world on distributed in conjunction with behalf of the Thomson Reuters the annual awards dinner. He ran that publication for Foundation. Before joining Reuters, more than a decade, then returned last year to the job Reinhold worked as a general and political reporter of organizing the awards panels. Serrill is Assistant and investigative reporter and as an internationally Managing Editor at Bloomberg Markets magazine. Early syndicated columnist. She is the author of several mass in his career Serrill was the editor of two criminal justice market books, including Untamed — The as-told-to publications underwritten by the Ford Foundation that autobiography of Gunther Gebel Williams and Patient were finalists for National Magazine Awards three times.