Masada Vol I + Copertina
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
€ documentation of Masada cultural heritage sites. has didactic aspects as well. The project, consisting project in the aspects, research the Beyond a Pavia. of University the proposal of Engineering for digital of the University of Florence and the Department of Architecture Shenkar and College Civil of Design and Engineering, the Department of Architecture between the Department of Interior Building The and Masada Environment project Design was of developed as an on-going research collaboration A program of International cooperation Italy-Israel 18.00 - I MASADA NOTEBOOKS REPORT OF THE RESEARCH PROJECT 2013 REPORT OF THE RESEARCH PROJECT 2013 REPORT MASADA NOTEBOOKS S TEFANO DIGITAL SURVEY IN ARCHEOLOGY SURVEY DIGITAL B ERTOCCI S ANDRO VOL. I P ARRINELLO R E B EKA V ITAL DIGITAL SURVEY IN ARCHEOLOGY STEFANO BERTOCCI SANDRO PARRINELLO REBEKA VITAL MASADA NOTEBOOKS REPORT OF THE RESEARCH PROJECT 2013 VOL. I This publication is realized with the contribution of several istitutions that sponsor the research project. In particular, the support has been provided by: University of Florence, Italy University of Pavia, Italy Shenkar Collage, Israel & Autodesk Copyright © Edifir-Edizioni Firenze 2013 Copyright © Stefano Bertocci 2013 Copyright © Sandro Parrinello 2013 Copyright © Rebeka Vital 2013 Managing Editor Simone Gismondi Design and Production Editor Elena Mariotti Editing Sara Bua Graphic design proiect Sara Bua Photocopies for reader’s personal use are linited to 15% Printed by of every book/issue of periodical and with payment to Pacini Editore Industrie Grafiche, SIAE of the compensation foreseen in art. 68, codicil Ospedaletto (Pisa) 4, of Law 22 April 1941 no. 633 and by the agreement of Decenber 18, between SIAE, AIE, SNS and CNA, ISBN 978-88-7970-640-7 ConfArtigianato, CASA, CLAAI, ConfCommercio, ConfEsercenti. Reproductions for different purposes from the previously mentioned one may be made only On cover: General view of the point cloud after specific authorization by those holding copyright about Herod’s Palace area. the Publisher. ORGANIZERS University of Florence, Italy University of Pavia, Italy Shenkar Collage, Israel Department of Architecture Laboratory of Landscape Department of Civil University of Florence, Survey & Design Engineering and Architecture Italy University of Florence, Italy University af Pavia, Italy PARTNERSHIP Israel Nature and Parks Mabat Leica Authority 3D Technologies Itd Geosystems Autodesk PATRONAGE Embassy of Italy Tel Aviv SCIENTIFIC COMMITTEE Ferdinando Auricchio University of Pavia, Italy Benedetta Adembri Director of Archaeological Area of Villa Adriana, Tivoli, Italy Stefano Bertocci University of Florence, Italy Marco Bini University of Florence, Italy Elena Calandra Superintendent for Archaeological Heritage of Lazio, Italy Eitan Cambell Director of Masada Archaeological Site, Israel Vittorio Casella University of Pavia, Italy Carlo Ciaponi University of Pavia, Italy Riccardo Galletto University of Pavia, Italy Maria Elena Gorrini University of Pavia, Italy Eri Goshen Shenkar College of Design and Engineering, Israel Maria Teresa Grassi University of Milan, Italy Maurizio Harari University of Pavia, Italy Shraga Kirshner Shenkar College of Design and Engineering, Israel Stefano Maggi University of Pavia, Italy Saverio Mecca University of Florence, Italy Roberto Parenti University of Siena, Italy Sandro Parrinello University of Pavia, Italy Anna Spalla University of Pavia, Italy Rebeka Vital Shenkar College of Design and Engineering, Israel INDEX INTRODUCTION 9 PRESENTATIONS 15 YULI TAMIR, President of Shenkar School of Design and Engineering 16 SHRAGA KIRSHNER, Head of Interior building and Environment Design - Shenkar 17 SAVERIO MECCA, Director of the Department of Architecture-University of Florence 18 FERDINANDO AURICCHIO, Director of the Department of Civil Engineering and Architecture, University of Pavia 19 EITAN CAMBELL, Director of Masada, Israel Nature and Parks Authorities 20 JONATHAN SEROUSSI, Director – AutoCAD Web and Mobile, Autodesk 21 REPORTS 23 Stefano Bertocci A project for the archaeological survey of the site of Masada, Israel 25 Rebeka Vital What does laser scanning has to contribute to conventional methods of documenting a cultural heritage site: From the Yigal Yadin excavations to the digital documentation of Masada 45 Sandro Parrinello The action program for Masada documentation 53 Sara Porzilli The metrics database management for the development of the research project 63 Sandro Parrinello The integrated survey and laser scanner methodology 77 Sara Bua The survey of the Palace of Herod, from the point cloud to the two-dimensional drawings 117 Rebeka Vital, Eyal Nir Using laser scanning and Autodesk tools for digital documentation of cultural heritage sites 133 Francesca Picchio Data acquisition and automatic processing by 123D Catch 143 Filippo Fantini The use of reality based models for the interpretation of ancient architecture: experiences of reverse modeling at Masada 155 BIBLOGRAPHY 175 CREDITS AND PHOTO REPORTS OF INTERNATIONAL WORKSHOP FOR SURVEY IN ARCHAEOLOGY 181 INTRODUCTION 10 INTRODUCTION A program of International cooperation Italy-Israel The Masada project was developed as an on-going research collaboration between the Department of Interior Building and Environment Design of Shenkar College of Design and Engineering, the Department of Architecture of the University of Florence and the Department of Architecture and Civil Engineering of the University of Pavia. Beyond the research aspects, the project has didactic aspects as well. The project, consisting in a proposal for digital documentation of Masada cultural heritage sites, is directed by Stefano Bertocci, Sandro Parrinello and Rebeka Vital. Methodology This project is part of our research in the field of three-dimensional digital documentation and mapping of sites of cultural importance. A team of professors, research scholars and students works together to document the selected site through laser scanning. The equipment that was used is a Leica Scanstation C-10. The cloud of points that comes from the scanning, was compiled as raw data and was part of the documentation database. Further, the team is processed the cloud of points and extract information to make 2D as- built drawings (plans, sections and elevations), 3D renderings and 2D and 3D details of building elements of interest. The aims of these projects are: t To create a comprehensive digital documentation of the existing state of important sites. t To create an opportunity for collaborative work between Israeli and Italian academic institutions. 11 t To create learning opportunities for Israeli and Italian students in the latest advancements of architectural and archaeological documentation. t Such databases can serve as a base for further historic preservation and actual restoration done by companies or academic institutions. Masada Project The general aim of the project is to create a comprehensive digital documentation of the archaeological site of Masada. The data acquisition is done through laser scanning and photogrammetry. This methodology will give us a data base of accurate three-dimensional geometrical information in the form of a point cloud and extensive photographic imagery, which can be used to create textured three-dimensional geometry. Once all raw data is collected, 2D architectural drawings and 3D models of the site can be produced. The 3D models can represent the site “as-is” and can further serve as a basis for o digital reconstruction that can illustrate the state of our knowledge about the site, for different time periods. The didactic aspect of the project was in the form of a workshop. The workshop focused on digital documentation of historical sites and the use of 3D laser scanning in the research and analysis of built environments. During the workshop the participants were shown the methodology and strategies related to the acquisition and management of three-dimensional data from the site. Further, the possibilities of using acquired data for the construction of two-dimensional drawings and three-dimensional models were explained. The participants had the opportunity to use the site of Masada as a laboratory for applying all steps of the methodology: they were familiarized with the laser scanning equipment and the digital acquisition of three-dimensional data, they were acquainted with the laser scanning software used for the registration of the various laser scans acquired on-site and they took active part both in collecting the information on-site and in the post-processing the cloud of points and extracting architectural drawings. 12 Further, the workshop created an international collaborative framework for working with students, lecturers and professors from around the world. Within the framework of the signed collaboration between Shenkar College of Design and Engineering, the University of Florence and the University of Pavia, two workshops on digital documentation of cultural heritage sites have taken place: t Urban Archaeology in the Center of Florence – 3D laser scanning survey and 3D modeling, Florence, Italy; October 2012 t Masada International Workshop – How we document a heritage site digitally? Masada, Israel; February 2013 Stefano Bertocci, Sandro Parrinello, Rebeka Vital 13 PRESENTATIONS ĕėĔďĊĈęċĔėęčĊĆėĈčĆĊĔđĔČĎĈĆđĘĚėěĊĞĔċęčĊĘĎęĊĔċ ĆĘĆĉĆǡ ĘėĆĊđ !"#$%&'()#*"'++, Introduction Architect and Antiques The scholar of architecture is undoubtedly interested in the study of the ancient world,