Nearshore Waters of the Great Lakes 1996
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
State of the Lakes Ecosystem Conference 1996 Background Paper NEARSHORE WATERS OF THE GREAT LAKES Thomas A. Edsall Great Lakes Science Center National Biological Service Ann Arbor, Michigan U.S.A. Murray N. Charlton Aquatic Ecosystem Research Branch National Water Research Institute Burlington, Ontario Canada December 1997 ISBN 0-662-26031 EPA 905-R-97-015a Cat. No. En40-11/35-1-1997E ii SOLEC 96 - Nearshore Waters of the Great Lakes Table of Contents 1.0 Introduction .................................................................. 1 2.0 The Nearshore Waters as a Significant Natural Element of the Great Lakes Basin Ecosystem ....................................................................... 1 2.1 A Definition of Nearshore Waters ............................................ 1 2.2 Areas and Volumes of the Nearshore Waters ................................... 11 3.0 The Nearshore Waters as an Element of the Surface-Water Continuum ..................... 13 4.0 The Nearshore Waters as Fish and Wildlife Habitat .................................... 13 5.0 Human Use of the Nearshore Waters ............................................... 14 6.0 Stressors Operating in the Nearshore Waters ......................................... 15 6.1 Definition of Stressor .................................................... 15 6.2 Power Production ....................................................... 15 6.2.1 Thermal-electric ................................................ 16 6.2.2 Hydropower ................................................... 17 6.3 Marine Transportation and Recreational Boating ................................ 19 6.3.1 Vessel Passage Effects ........................................... 19 6.3.2 Level and Flow Regulation ........................................ 20 6.3.3 Dredging and Disposal of Dredged Material ........................... 21 6.4 Shoreline Modification ................................................... 24 6.5 Sand and Gravel Mining .................................................. 24 6.6 Pollution .............................................................. 25 6.6.1 Discharges and Spills ............................................ 25 6.6.2 Agricultural Runoff .............................................. 26 6.7 Extraction of Renewable Resources ......................................... 27 6.8 Exotic Species ......................................................... 28 7.0 Status and Trends ............................................................. 32 7.1 Fish and Wildlife Habitat ................................................. 32 7.1.1 Fish Habitat Features of the Nearshore ............................... 33 7.1.1.1 Depth ................................................ 33 7.1.1.2 Temperature ........................................... 33 7.1.1.3 Vegetation ............................................. 33 7.1.1.4 Substrate .............................................. 34 7.1.2 The Significance of Water-level Fluctuations ........................... 35 7.1.3 Types of Nearshore Habitats ....................................... 36 7.1.3.1 Wetlands .............................................. 36 7.1.3.2 Embayments ........................................... 37 7.1.3.3 Connecting Channels ..................................... 37 7.1.3.4 Tributaries ............................................. 38 7.1.3.5 Exposed Coastline and Offshore Shoals ....................... 38 7.1.4 Problems and Issues ............................................. 38 7.1.4.1 Shoreline Modification .................................... 38 7.1.4.2 Water-quality Degradation ................................. 39 SOLEC 96 - Nearshore Waters of the Great Lakes iii 7.1.5 Fish Habitat Policy and Current Initiatives ............................ 39 7.1.5.1 Department of Fisheries and Oceans (Canada) Policy for the Management of Fish Habitat .......................................... 39 7.1.5.2 Current Initiatives ....................................... 42 7.1.5.3 New Initiatives for Improving Management .................... 43 7.1.5.4 Restoration Examples .................................... 44 7.1.6 Nutrient Enrichment and Algae ..................................... 45 7.1.7 Nearshore Nutrients ............................................. 45 7.1.8 Persistant Toxic Contaminants in Water, Sediment, and Biota .............. 58 7.1.8.1 Status ................................................ 58 7.2 Fish and Wildlife ....................................................... 61 7.2.1 Zooplankton ................................................... 61 7.2.2 Benthic Invertebrates ............................................. 63 7.2.2.1 Nearshore Benthic Communities of the Great Lakes .............. 66 7.2.3 Fish ......................................................... 69 7.2.4 Birds ......................................................... 79 7.2.4.1 The Importance of the Nearshore Aquatic Zone for Wildlife on the Canadian Great Lakes .................................... 79 7.2.5 Mammals ..................................................... 85 8.0 Human Health ................................................................ 85 8.1 Infectious Organisms as Health Hazards ...................................... 85 8.2 Beach Closures ......................................................... 88 8.3 Drinking Water ........................................................ 93 8.4 Fish Consumption Advisories .............................................. 97 9.0 Emerging Challenges .......................................................... 110 9.1 Sewage Treatment ..................................................... 110 9.2 Aquaculture .......................................................... 110 10.0 Summary and Conclusions .................................................... 111 11.0 Acknowledgments ........................................................... 111 12.0 Glossary .................................................................. 112 13.0 References ................................................................ 112 14.0 Additional Reading List ....................................................... 136 15.0 List of Tables and Figures ..................................................... 137 Appendix A: Common and Scientific Names of Plants and Animals Mentioned in This Report ........................................................................ 140 iv SOLEC 96 - Nearshore Waters of the Great Lakes Notice To Readers This Background Paper is part of a series of Backgournd Papers that are intended to provide a concise overview of the status of the nearshore conditions in the Great Lakes. The information they present has been selected as representative of the much greater volume of data. They therefore do not present all research or monitoring information available. The Papers were prepared with input from many individuals representing diverse sectors of society. The Papers provided the basis for discussions at SOLEC ‘96. Participants were encouraged to provide specific information and references for use in preparing the final post-conference versions of the Papers. Together with the information provided by SOLEC discussants, the Papers will be incorporated into the 1997 State of the Great Lakes report, which provides key information required by managers to make better environmental decisions. SOLEC 96 - Nearshore Waters of the Great Lakes v vi SOLEC 96 - Nearshore Waters of the Great Lakes Nearshore Waters of the Great Lakes 1.0 Introduction In October 1994, the governments of the United States and Canada convened the first State of the Lakes Ecosystem Conference (SOLEC ’94). The conference was designed to further the purpose of the Great Lakes Water Quality Agreement between the United States and Canada, which aims to restore and maintain the chemical, physical, and biological integrity of the waters of the Great Lakes basin ecosystem. Background papers prepared for the conference and discussions that occurred at SOLEC ’94 are summarized in a document prepared by the U.S. and Canadian governments titled “State of the Great Lakes 1995” (EC and EPA 1995). A second, follow-up conference (SOLEC ’96) scheduled for fall 1996 is designed to focus more intensively on the status of the Great Lakes coastal ecosystem, which includes the coastal shorelands, coastal wetlands, and coastal or nearshore waters. A major objective of SOLEC ’96 is to examine the effects of human activity—and particularly land-use practices—on the coastal ecosystem. The present paper is designed to provide background information that will facilitate discussion of the status of the nearshore waters element of Great Lakes coastal ecosystems. 2.0 The Nearshore Waters as a Significant Natural Element of the Great Lakes Basin Ecosystem The Great Lakes basin ecosystem covers about 760,000 km2 (USEPA and GC 1995), spans 9o of latitude and 19o of longitude, and lies halfway between the equator and the North Pole in a lowland corridor that extends from the Gulf of Mexico to the Arctic Ocean (Figure 1). The Great Lakes, which are the most prominent feature of this system, have a combined surface area of about 244,000 km2, a volume of 22,700 km3, and are the largest single collection of fresh water on the surface of the earth, excluding the polar ice caps (TNC 1994). The Great Lakes basin ecosystem has been divided into major elements by TNC (1994), Dodge and Kavetsky (1995), and Edsall (1996). These elements basically include open lake (including nearshore and offshore waters);